THE UNITED REPUBLIC OF TANZANIA MINISTRY OF WATER Artesian well drilled at Kahe village, Moshi Rural August 2012
THE UNITED REPUBLIC OF TANZANIA
MINISTRY OF WATER
Artesian well drilled at Kahe village, Moshi Rural
August 2012
ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PREFACE ................................................................................................................................. IX
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................................................................................ 1
1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................. 13
1.1 BACKGROUND .......................................................................................................................................... 13 1.2 THE 2012 WATER SECTOR STATUS REPORT ............................................................................................ 14
1.2.1 Scope and Purpose of the Report ........................................................................................................ 14 1.2.2 Structure of the Report ........................................................................................................................ 14
2 SECTOR FINANCING .................................................................................................... 15
2.1 FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE FOR JULY 2011 - JUNE 2012 .......................................................................... 15 2.2 STATUS OF DISBURSEMENTS BY COMPONENTS FOR FY 2011/2012 ......................................................... 16 2.3 SECTOR FINANCING TRENDS .................................................................................................................... 17 2.4 FUNDS FROM OTHER SOURCES INCLUDING IAS‟ OWN REVENUES ........................................................... 17 2.5 WSDP EXPENDITURE PERFORMANCE BY COMPONENTS .......................................................................... 19 2.6 RESULTS FROM AUDIT TRAILS ................................................................................................................. 19 2.7 FINANCING AND SUSTAINABILITY ............................................................................................................ 20
3 STATUS ON IMPLEMENTATION OF PROCUREMENT PLAN ............................ 21
3.1 OVERVIEW OF WSDP PROCUREMENT MANAGEMENT STANDARDS ......................................................... 21 3.2 STATUS OF MEASURES FOR RISK MITIGATION IN WSDP PROCUREMENT ................................................ 21 3.3 STATUS OF IMPLEMENTATION OF THE WSDP PROCUREMENT PLAN ........................................................ 21 3.4 IMPLEMENTATION OF PROCUREMENT PLAN BY WSDP COMPONENTS ..................................................... 22 3.5 CHALLENGES ON THE PROCUREMENT PROCESSES ................................................................................... 26
4 STATUS OF WATER RESOURCES IN THE COUNTRY ......................................... 27
4.1 WATER AVAILABILITY ............................................................................................................................. 27 4.2 WATER STATUS IN BASINS ....................................................................................................................... 28 4.3 LESSON LEARNT ...................................................................................................................................... 32 4.4 WAY FORWARD ....................................................................................................................................... 32
5 STATUS ON IMPLEMENTATION OF WSDP PLANNED ACTIVITIES AGAINST
TARGETS ................................................................................................................................. 33
5.1 COMPONENT 1: WATER RESOURCES MANAGEMENT ................................................................ 33 5.1.1 Strengthening Basin Level Water Resources Management ................................................................. 34 5.1.2 Integrated River and Lake Basin Management and Development Plans ............................................ 41 5.1.3 Priority Water Resources Infrastructure Investments ......................................................................... 41 5.1.3 Management of Trans-Boundary Waters ............................................................................................ 42 5.1.4 Water Quality Compliance and Strengthening Water Laboratories ................................................... 49 5.1.5 Achievements vs Planned (MKUKUTA) Targets ................................................................................ 51 5.1.6 Water Resources Management Challenges ......................................................................................... 52
5.2 COMPONENT 2: RURAL WATER SUPPLY AND SANITATION ..................................................... 52 5.2.1 Local Government Authorities Management Support Subcomponent ................................................ 53 5.2.2 Implementation of National Sanitation Campaign and School – WASH ............................................ 56
iii
5.2.3 Investments in RWSS Subprojects ....................................................................................................... 58 5.2.4 Achievements vs. Planned (MKUKUTA II) Targets ............................................................................ 60 5.2.5 Assessment against MDG Targets ...................................................................................................... 62 5.2.6 Challenges in RWSS ............................................................................................................................ 63
5.3 COMPONENT 3: URBAN WATER SUPPLY AND SANITATION ..................................................... 64 5.3.1 Urban Water Supply and Sanitation Authorities Management Support ............................................. 65 5.3.2 Investments in UWSS Sub-projects ..................................................................................................... 66 5.3.3 Progress on Output and Estimated Outcomes against MKUKUTA II Targets ................................... 71 5.3.4 Challenges in the UWSSAs ................................................................................................................. 74
5.4 COMPONENT 4: INSTITUTIONAL STRENGTHENING AND CAPACITY BUILDING ................. 75 5.4.1 Support for Operationalization of the New Role of the Ministry of Water ......................................... 76 5.4.2 TA for Strengthening of Sub-Sector Planning and Operational Capacities ....................................... 79 5.4.3 Support Sector Coordination and Performance Monitoring .............................................................. 80 5.4.4 Support for Sector Capacity Building ................................................................................................. 81 5.4.5 Challenges .......................................................................................................................................... 83
6 IMPLEMENTATION OF SAFEGUARDS POLICIES AND GUIDELINES ............ 84
6.1 SAFEGUARDS MANAGEMENT OF SUBPROJECTS ....................................................................................... 85 6.2 SCREENING OF PROJECTS ......................................................................................................................... 85 6.3 ACHIEVEMENTS ....................................................................................................................................... 86 6.4 CHALLENGES ........................................................................................................................................... 88
7 WATER SECTOR MONITORING SYSTEMS ............................................................ 89
7.1 IMPORTANCE OF THE FUNCTIONAL MIS LINKED TO AN EFFECTIVE M&E FRAMEWORK ......................... 89 7.2 THE WATER POINT MAPPING ................................................................................................................... 89 7.3 IMPORTANCE OF CENSUS AND SURVEY .................................................................................................... 91 7.4 SECTOR PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENTS AND PROGRAMME EVALUATION ................................................. 91
8 STATUS ON THE USE OF WATER AND SANITATION FACILITIES AS
ANALYZED BY NATIONAL SURVEYS ............................................................................. 92
8.1 RURAL WATER SUPPLY SERVICES IMPROVEMENT ................................................................................... 92 8.2 URBAN WATER SUPPLY SERVICES DELIVERY SUSTAINABILITY .............................................................. 92 8.3 REASONS FOR DECLINING WATER SUPPLY SERVICES DELIVERY ............................................................. 93 8.4 SANITATION SERVICES ............................................................................................................................. 93
9 STATUS ON IMPLEMENTATION OF 6TH JWSR UNDERTAKINGS FOR FY
2011/2012 ................................................................................................................................... 94
10 PROPOSED UNDERTAKINGS FOR 2012 AND ROADMAP FOR THE WSDP
PHASE II ................................................................................................................................... 96
ANNEXES ................................................................................................................................. 99
ANNEX 1: CATEGORIES OF UWSSAS, SMALL TOWNS AND NATIONAL PROJECTS ............................................... 99 ANNEX 2: STATUS OF SOCIAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL SAFEGUARDS .................................................................. 100 ANNEX 3: STATUS OF PROJECTS IN CATEGORY A REQUIRING EIA .................................................................... 101 ANNEX 4: STATUS OF IMPLEMENTATION OF UNDERTAKINGS .......................................................................... 102
iv
REFERENCES ....................................................................................................................... 109
v
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1: WSDP Commitments Vs Disbursements ................................................................ 15
Table 2: WSDP Approved Budgets Vs Actual Disbursements ............................................ 15
Table 3: Status of Disbursement by Components for 2011/2012 ......................................... 16
Table 4: Actual Disbursement Performance as at June 2012 ............................................... 16
Table 5: Funds from Other Sources including Implementing Agencies' Own Revenues .. 18
Table 6: Revenue Generated for Regional UWSAs in million Tshs .................................... 18
Table 7: WSDP Expenditure Performance by Components ................................................ 19
Table 8: Planned Contracts, Awarded Contracts and Uninitiated Contracts up to June
2012 ............................................................................................................................................ 22
Table 9: Planned Contracts, Awarded Contracts and Uninitiated Contracts up to June
2012 for Component 1 .............................................................................................................. 22
Table 10: Planned Contracts, Awarded Contracts and Uninitiated Contracts up to June
2012 for Component 2 .............................................................................................................. 24
Table 11: Planned Contracts, Awarded Contracts and Uninitiated Contracts up to June
2012 for Component 3 .............................................................................................................. 25
Table 12: Planned Contracts, Awarded Contracts and Uninitiated Contracts up to June
2012 for Component 4 .............................................................................................................. 26
Table 13: General Characteristics of Mtera, Kidatu and Kihansi Dams ............................ 29
Table 14: Summary on Status of Water Point Mapping Survey ......................................... 55
Table 15: Number of People with Access to Water Supply Service in Rural Areas from
Year 2009 to 2011 .......................................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
Table 16: Screened Sub-Projects for Component 2 .............................................................. 87
Table 17: Summary of Implementation of the 6th Agreed Undertakings for 2011/2012 .. 95
Table 18: Action Plan for the Preparation of WSDP Phase II ............................................. 97
vi
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1: Actual Disbursement Performance as at June 2012 ............................................. 17
Figure 2: Water Level at Nyumba ya Mungu Dam ............................................................... 29
Figure 3: Water Situation at Mtera Dam ............................................................................... 30
Figure 4: Water Situation at Kidatu Dam ............................................................................. 31
Figure 5: Water Situation at Kihansi Dam ............................................................................ 31
Figure 6: Water Use Permits Issued ....................................................................................... 36
Figure 7: Water Use Conflicts Reported and Resolved from FY 2008/2009 to 2011/2012 38
Figure 8: Status of Hydrological Investigations for Five Years ........................................... 40
Figure 9: Water Quality Compliance ..................................................................................... 49
Figure 10: Water of Unacceptable Quality ............................................................................ 50
Figure 11: Efficacy of Water Treatment Chemicals ............................................................. 51
Figure 12: Trends in Rural Water Supply Coverage based on Functioning Water
Facilities ..................................................................................................................................... 62
Figure 13: Rural Water Supply Service Coverage in Regions of Tanzania Mainland by
December 2011 .......................................................................................................................... 63
Figure 14: Regional UWSSAs Categories .............................................................................. 65
Figure 15: Implementation of Immediate Works in Utilities ............................................... 68
Figure 16: Status of Water Supply Coverage in the 19 UWSSAs ........................................ 72
Figure 17: Trend of Household Water Connections ............................................................. 72
Figure 18: Trends in Sewerage Connections .......................................................................... 73
Figure 19: Trends in the Length of Water Supply and Sewerage System Infrastructure in
19 UWSSAs ............................................................................................................................... 73
Figure 20: Water Point Collection Status for the year 2012 ................................................ 90
Figure 21: Summary of Implemented Undertakings ............................................................ 95
vii
ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS
AFD - French Development Agency
AfDB - African Development Bank
BADEA - Arab Bank for Economic Development in Africa
BTC - Belgium Development Agency
BWB - Basin Water Boards
BWO - Basin Water Offices
CAG - Controller and Auditor General
CBOs - Community Based Organizations
CD Plans - Capacity Development Plans
CIA - Chief Internal Auditor
COWSOs - Community Owned Water Supply Organisations
CPD - Chief Parliamentary Draftsman
CQS - Cost and Quality Selection
CSOs - Civil Society Organizations
CWSSP - Community Water Supply and Sanitation Programme
DAWASA - Dar es Salaam Water and Supply and Sanitation Authority
DAWASCO - Dar es Salaam Water Supply and Sanitation Company
DDCA - Drilling and Dam Construction Agency
DFID - Department for International Development
DFTs - District Facilitation Teams
DPs - Development Partners
DSS - Decision Support System
DUWS - Division of Urban Water Supply
DUWSAs - District Urban Water and Sanitation Authorities
DUWSAs - Districts Urban Water Authorities
DWR - Division of Water Resources
DWSTs District Water and Sanitation Teams
EAC - East African Community
EIB - European Investment Bank
ESAMI - Eastern and Southern Africa Management Institute
ESIA - Environmental and Social Impact Assessment
ESMF - Environmental and Social Management Framework
EU/ GTZ - European Union/ Deutsche Gesellschaft fuer Technische Zusammenarbeit.
EWURA - Energy and Water Utilities Regulatory Authority
FM - Financial Management
GEF - Global Environmental Fund
GIS - Geographical Information System
GoT - Government of Tanzania
GPS - Global Positioning System
HBS - Household Budget Survey
HICTU - Head Information Communication Technology Unit
HTM - Handeni Trunk Main
viii
IAs - Implementing Agencies
IC - Individual Consultancy
ICB - International Competitive Bidding
ICT - Information and Communication Technology
IDA - International Development Agency
IDB - Internal Drainage Basin
IE - Impact Evaluation
IEs - Implementing Entities
IFR - Interim Financial Report
IMTC - Inter-Ministerial Technical Committee
IT - Information Technology
IUCN - International Union for Conservation of Nature
IWRM - Integrated Water Resources Management
JICA - Japan International Cooperation Agency
JSM - Joint Supervision Mission
JWC - Joint Water Commission
JWSR - Joint Water Sector Review
KASHWASA - Kahama Shinyanga Water Supply and Sanitation Authority
KfW - Kreditanstait Fur Wiederaufbau (German Development Bank)
KOICA - Korea International Cooperation Agency
LGAs - Local Government Authority
LVEMP - Lake Victoria Environmental Management Programme
M&E - Monitoring and Evaluation
MCC - Millennium Challenge Corporation
MCS - Maji Central Stores
MDGs - Millennium Development Goals
MIS - Management Information System
MKUKUTA - Mkakati wa Kukuza Uchumi na Kuondoa Umasikini
MoF - Ministry of Finance
MoU - Memorandum of Understanding
MoW - Ministry of Water
MoWI - Ministry of Water and Irrigation
MTB - Ministerial Tender Board
MTEF - Medium Term Expenditure Framework
MTR - Medium Term Review
NAO - National Audit Office
NAWAPO - National Water Policy
Tshs Tanzanian Shilling
USD United States Dollar
ix
Preface
The Government of Tanzania instituted water sector reforms in early 2000s as articulated in the
National Water Policy (2002). The overall objective of the reforms, as being coordinated by the
Water Sector Development Programme, is to strengthen sector institutions for integrated water
resources management and improve access to clean and safe water supply and sanitation
services. There are a number of instruments which have been established since then in order to
facilitate efficient and effective implementation of the reforms. Keys among them include; the
National Water Sector Development Strategy (2006 – 2015), Water Resources Management
Act No. 11 of 2009, Water Supply and Sanitation Act No. 12 of 2009, to mention, just a few.
The collaborative efforts between the Government and the DPs have by June 2012, attracted to
water sector the total commitments of about USD 1,299 million, an increase of USD 348
million, equivalent to 36% of the initial planned investment portfolio of the Programme‟s Phase
I amounting to USD 951 million. In the same period, the actual disbursements have reached
USD 789 million which is equivalent to financial performance of about 61%.
In the medium term, WSDP is set to achieve the Millennium Development Goals (2000 - 2015)
and MKUKUTA II (2010 - 2015) target at increasing access in rural areas from 57.8% in 2010
to 65%; regional capitals from 84% in 2010 to 95%; Dar es Salaam from 55% in 2010 to 75%;
district, small towns and national projects from 53% in 2010 to 57% by 2015. All water basin
institutions to be strengthened and fully operational and have integrated basin water resources
management and development plans approved by basin stakeholders by 2015. On sanitation,
the targets include increasing the coverage of sewerage services from 18% in 2010 to 22% in
2015; and increasing basic sanitation from 86% in 2010 to 95% in 2015. In the long-term
WSDP is set to achieve the Tanzania Development Vision (2025) targets at increasing access to
clean and safe water in rural areas to 90% and universal access in urban areas by 2025.
In implementation of the WSDP, the GoT and DPs agreed to use a number of instruments and
tools as reflected in the revised MOU, revised dialogue mechanism and revised PIM in order to
facilitate effective coordination and decision making, monitoring and evaluation, learning and
accountability. Key among them is for the GoT to prepare water sector status reports on annual
basis in order to facilitate discussion by the water sector stakeholders on key sector issues and
challenges facing implementation of WSDP, share experiences between stakeholders, and
suggest options for improved implementation of WSDP in the future.
x
In response to the jointly agreed arrangement as described above, MoW in collaboration with
other line ministries, prepared and shared the Water Sector Status Report 2012 with the key
water sector stakeholders in September, 2012, for discussion during these two days.
It is our hope that you had enough time to go through the report and the GoT is open for
discussion on water sector issues, and considers the comments that you may have with regard
to improved performance of WSDP in the future.
Eng. Christopher N. Sayi
Permanent Secretary
Ministry of Water
1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Water Sector Status Report 2012 (the Report) presents the status of the water sector for the
Programme components and sector financing as at 30th
June, 2012. The Report also highlights
challenges and constraints encountered and suggest remedial measures for improved
performance of the Programme in the future. Inputs for the Report were derived from the
Programme implementation progress reports, Joint supervision Mission Aide Memoires and
other water sector analytical documents.
SECTOR FINANCING
The Government of Tanzania (GoT) in collaboration with Development Partners (DPs)
committed funds to finance the WSDP in the first phase of five years period from 2007/2008 to
2011/2012 at an estimated cost of USD 951 million. The GoT committed to contribute USD
251 million, which is equivalent to 26%; and DPs USD 700 million, which is equivalent to
74%.
After the Programme restructuring in 2011, it was found that the implementation of some
investment projects would go beyond June 2012. It was jointly (GoT and DPs) agreed to extend
the implementation of Phase I of WSDP (phase I) for two years period to June 2014. During the
implementation of phase I, more commitments have been received from DPs. By the end of
March 2012, the total amount committed reached USD 1,299 million, an increase of USD 348
million, equivalent to 36% of the original estimates.
Total disbursements from both GoT and DPs as at 30th
June, 2012, reached USD 789million
against total revised commitments of USD 1.2billion, equivalent to 61%. Disbursements for
WRM component reached USD 35million against revised commitments of USD 69million,
equivalent to 52%; disbursements for RWSS component reached USD 241million against
revised commitments of USD 463million, equivalent to 52%; disbursements for UWSS
component reached USD 420million against revised commitments of USD 698million,
equivalent to 60%; Disbursements for IS & CD reached USD 40million against revised
commitments of USD 69million, equivalent to 59%.
Of the total amount disbursed (USD 789million), USD 658million had been reported to be
spent, equivalent to 83%, and the remaining balances were still in the Holding Account (USD
51million) and in the accounts of some LGAs, Small Towns, District Head Quarters and WBOs
due to delays in procurement of consultants.
The major challenge faced in the course of implementation is how to expedite procurement
processes in IAs, especially, the Basins and Small Towns, as well as strengthening the
monitoring and evaluation capabilities of LGAs to enable effective contract administration and
management.
WATER RESOURCES MANAGEMENT
Freshwater is a basic natural resource, which sustains life and provides for various social and
economic needs. Tanzania has experienced widespread shortages in its surface and
2
groundwater in many areas. The water shortages result from a number of factors including
reduced and delayed rains, increasing mult-sectoral demands, degradation of water catchments
due to pollution, over abstraction, poor land use practices, and encroachment of land for
agriculture, urbanization and industrial development.
Growing Water Resources Development and Management Concerns include inadequate water
storage infrastructure that is impeding the nation‟s ability to deal with climate variability and it
is impact to food, energy, water and environmental security. Climate change is going to further
stress the nation‟s water resources.
Lesson Learnt from Basin Water Boards reports presented to the BWBs Annual General
meeting in July 2012 shows that, in the past three consecutive years, many parts of the country
were faced with shortage of water supplies for various uses due to shortage of rainfall during
the short and long rain seasons. Water levels in all major hydropower dams are low and
declining, the case of Mtera and Nyumba ya Mungu where power generation has been affected
resulting in economic instability. The issues of data collection, rehabilitation and construction
of water resources monitoring stations as well as management information system have been
noted as important requirement for all BWBs.
Inadequate investments in reliable water infrastructure and the low capacity of water resources
management institutions are contributing to water insecurity and stress, perpetuating local and
regional water use conflicts, and imposing losses to the economy.
As a way forward, for basins to manage water resources efficiently and to address issues of
water resources availability as well as to improve water security for the country, several
initiatives are been undertaken by the government in collaboration with Development Partners
and other stakeholders under WSDP. The initiatives include preparation and implementation of
Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM) plans which will address issues of
sustainable allocation and conservation of water resources, Strengthening of BWBs to carry out
their mandated tasks through provision of equipment for data collection and monitoring for
informed decision making, rehabilitation and building of Basins Water and Laboratory offices
and , Implementation of water Pollution control strategy, and Strengthening of Water resources
management institutions and formation of new ones according to the WRMA 2009 .
Status on Implementation of WSDP Planned Activities under Water Resources Management
The objectives of the WRMD component of WSDP is to develop a sound water resources
management and development framework in all nine water basins, for optimizing the utilization
of the water resources in a sustainable manner for the various competing uses. The WRMD
component comprises of three main sub-components, namely; Basin Level Water Resources
Management, Integrated River and Lake Basin Management and Development plans, and
Priority water resources infrastructure investment. Major achievements made in
3
implementation of planned activities include, commencement of preparation of IWRMD Plans
for Pangani, Ruvuma, Lake Tanganyika, Lake Rukwa and Lake Nyasa basins,
operationalization of the Water Pollution Control Strategy in all nine (9) water basins, the
inauguration of National Water Board (NWB)) on 26 July 2012 and the inauguration and
commencement of Songwe River Basin Development Program.
Strengthening of Basin Water Resources Management include implementation of the Water
Resources Management Act 11, 2009, which became effective in August 2009, whereby three
regulations have been prepared and gazetted. Basin Water Boards for 8 out of 9 Basins water
Offices are in place except for Lake Tanganyika BWB whose tenure expired in May 2012.
Process is underway to form a new Board. The process to form Water user Association
(WUAs) is ongoing in all the 9 Water Basins and up to June 2012, a total of 53 WUAs have
been formed. Basin Water Boards have continued to grant water use permits according to new
WRMA and re-register old water rights and a total of 605 water use permits granted. Process of
protecting and conserving water sources is a continuous activity implemented by in all BWBs.
In order to conserve water sources from pollution, Basin water offices in collaboration with
other actors, made a close follow up of activities which are potential sources for pollution and
where necessary, directions are drawn. Water use conflicts among users have been experienced
in almost all basins. A total of 27 water use conflicts were reported in 2011/2012, of which 26
were resolved. Water resources monitoring and exploration equipment have been secured and
are ready for installation and use in data collection. All Basins continued to carry out water
abstractions inspection to make sure that all users comply with their water permit conditions. A
total of 5,107 water samples from boreholes, water supply networks, lakes, rivers and dams,
were collected and analyzed out of 8,000 water samples targeted Monitoring of effluents
discharged to the environment (water bodies) has been carried out to ensure that waste water
returned to the environment is within the allowable limit. A total of 612 wastewater samples
out of 1,000 targeted were collected and analyzed.
In this financial year, most of the planned activities have not been implemented due to
inadequate operational funds. Basin Water Boards still depend to a large extent on the funds
disbursed from the Ministry of Water for implementation of all development activities and in
meeting some of the recurrent costs for supporting staff, conducting minor repairs of the basin
data collection stations and buildings and for office management. Dependency of the Boards is
attributed to poor fee structures that do not reflect actual value for water being abstracted by
various users. A study for Water Resources Management-Financing Options is being
undertaken and expected to be accomplished in the FY 2012/2013.
To enable efficient planning and allocation of Water Resources Basin Water Boards are in a
process to prepare IWRMDPs . Preparation and implementation of Integrated Water Resources
4
Management (IWRMD) plans will address issues of sustainable allocation and conservation of
water resources.
Several Transboundary Water Management Initiatives are ongoing, with various
accomplishments made in transboundary water resources management nitiatives under Lake
Victoria, Lake Tanganyika, Lake Chala/Jipe and Umba River, Zambezi River and Songwe
River.
WRM Challenges
The growing WRM concerns and challenges include; acute water use conflicts experienced in
many parts of the country especially in Pangani, Internal drainage, Rufiji and Lake Rukwa
Basins, illegal water abstractions, encroachment and degradation of water sources as a result of
growing human development activities in water catchments and inadequate funding of the
Basin Water Boards.
Rural Water Supply and Sanitation (RWSS)
During the financial year 2011/2012, Component 2 made a significant development towards
increasing people's access to clean and safe water and basic sanitation services. This has been
done through Local Government Authorities Management Support, National Sanitation
Campaign and Investments in RWSS Subcomponents.
The status of implementation and sub-strategic intervention include; Monitoring
implementation of WSDP implementation at LGAs level, preparation of WSDP Reports were
prepared including first quarter, second quarter, semi-annual, third quarter and annual progress
reports from LGAs, RSs and MoW .In order to have non-conflicting data on the number of
water points available and the rural population served, it was planned to carry out a water point
mapping. From September 2011 to April 2012, data collection was done in 19 LGAs and
prototype web based monitoring system developed.
To enhance implementation of the Capacity Development of RWSTs, CWSTs and BWOs, The
water sector has been implementing a Rural Water Supply and Sanitation Capacity
Development (RUWASACAD) phase 2 by support of JICA, preparation, submission and
discussion of inception report were done while consultant has carried out baseline survey.
The component is also in a process to develop rural water supply Sustainability Strategy to be
followed by implementation action plan.
National Sanitation Campaign and School – WASH
In response to issues raised during the restructuring plan, MoHSW, MoEVT and PMO-RALG
launched the National Sanitation Campaign (NSC). 42 LGAs from 12 regions for
implementation of National Sanitation Campaign have been selected; National WASH Strategy
5
has been prepared and approved by management. The campaign has started in 42 LGAs as the
point of start, which then will expand proportionately into the remaining LGAs.
School - Water, Sanitation and Hygiene (School - WASH) Campaign
The importance of school WASH has been recognized in national policy debates. The new
MKUKUTA II, for example, has included a specific target that 100% of schools should have
adequate sanitation.
The MoEVT has performed various activities as a way of implementing the Sanitation
Campaign, and include; completion and approved the National Strategic Plan for School Water
Sanitation and Hygiene, training of Regional Education Officers for ten regions, training of
National facilitators (83), training of District Education Officers from 42 LGAs, Mapping of
SWASH actors, Developing of SWASH Guideline, Formation of SWASH Clubs in schools in
some LGAs.
Investments in RWSS Subprojects
The sub- component consist of several activities which include; construction, drilling of wells,
boreholes and installation of hand pumps, piped systems using pumped water from boreholes or
gravity fed water from springs or rivers.
The status of implementation as of June 2012, 130 LGAs out of 132 had procured and signed
contracts with consulting firms for provision of the technical and facilitation of service delivery
in their respective jurisdiction.
The status of implementation sub projects in 10 selected villages in each LGA is; 62 LGAs
have attained “no objection” from MoW to start construction of water sub projects in some of
the villages. 53 LGAs have attained “no objection” from MoW to advertise tenders for
construction of water projects and they are in various stages of implementation, remaining
LGAs are at different stages of implementation.
Construction and rehabilitation of medium size dams in dry areas continued through
construction and rehabilitation of Dams of medium size dams in semi arid areas such as
Wegero (Musoma) dam constructed; and construction /rehabilitation of other 7 medium sized
dams is ongoing.
Achievements agaist Planned (MKUKUTA II) Targets and MDG Targets
Based on MKUKUTA II, the Rural Water Supply and Sanitation component planned to
increase access to clean and safe water supply from 58.7% in 2009 to 65% in June 2015, which
is equivalent to addition of 2.22 million new beneficiaries in rural areas by 2015. As per
6
December 2011 the trend shows that water coverage is at 56.6%. The decline is due to various
reasons; including drying off of water sources as a result of droughts in various parts of the
country. The sanitation trend shows that in December 2011 improved sanitation at household
level was at 9%. In assessing the implementation against MDG Targets, using routine data
system, the actual trend indicates an increase from 48% in 1990, to 51% in 2000, to 53% in
2003 to 57.1% in 2007, to 57.8% in 2010, to 56.6% in 2011. This is an increase of 8.6% during
the 1990- 2011 period. On the other hand, with more than 90% of the household population in
the rural areas with access to basic sanitation, the country appears to be on track to meet the
sanitation target of the 2015.
Challenges in RWSS
Financing in investment in Rural areas remains low compared to investments made in urban
and small towns. While the sector faces considerable capacity challenge. COWSOs have been
given sustainability responsibilities. However, they lack effective tools and experience in
managing schemes. Another challenge is the increased unit costs in investment due to the shift
in the selection of water supply technologies by communities due to improved level of
development in rural areas. Other challenges are drying up of water sources during dry season
due to Climate change coupled with Low Capacity at LGAs and RSs levels in terms of human
resources, equipment and systems and low capacity of the private sector in executing works.
Urban Water Supply and Sanitation
Component 3 of WSDP provides support to improve utility performance in the DAWASA
service area; 19 regional Urban Water Supply and Sanitation (UWSAs) utilities, a total of 109
small towns and district headquarters, as well as gazetted small towns and 7 national schemes
in the provision of water and sanitation services.
The component has two sub components: (1) Management support for Urban Water and
Sewerage Authorities and (2) Urban WSS investments (works as well as goods and services).
Urban Water and Sewerage Authorities Management Support
Rehabilitation and Construction of UWSSs‟ offices: The target was to continue with
construction of Babati new office and procure works for Sumbawanga UWSS. The
construction progress of new UWSS office in Babati has reached 32%, whereas the detailed
design and tender documents for Sumbawanga are completed. Procurement of works for 3
offices in small towns of Mpwapwa, Utete, and Tunduma is also ongoing at various stages.
Water Supply and Sanitation Studies: On provision of technical advisory services to assist the
Regional UWSSs and Small Towns; the feasibility studies, detailed designs and tender
7
document preparations for all of the seven (7) towns of Bukoba, Musoma, Babati, Lindi,
Sumbawanga, Mtwara and Kigoma, were completed; also design studies for Bunda, Mugumu,
Tarime, Mugango/Kiabakari Water Supply systems and Musoma sewerage were completed;
and Supervisions of Immediate Works in Mtwara, Lindi and Babati are in progress.
Revision of DAWASA Act: MoW submitted the proposed amendments of the DAWASA Act to
the Chief Parliamentary Draftsman (CPD) for vetting, comments received and the draft cabinet
paper presented to the stakeholders for more comments. Thereafter it was re-submitted to the
Cabinet Secretariat for further steps. EWURA Board has approved the lease Contract between
DAWASA and DAWASCO and both entities have signed the document. It is now ready for
use.
Clustering: There are two forms of clusters namely; Model II where category A Regional
Authorities are clustered with district/small towns water authorities and cluster I where small
town‟s water authorities are clustered themselves. The studies on both models raised various
Policy and Legal issues that were required to be addressed before full implementation. The
issues include D by D Policy, Human resources, Institutional set up, Clustering Regulations and
Financial support during transition period and legal issues regarding LGAs and Regional Water
Authorities. A Team of members from MoW, PMO-RALG and EWURA was appointed to
review the issues so as to propose the way forward. The team strongly recommended that the
utilities should ensured continued financial support both from both Local Government and
Central Government until their financial viability is attained and also they should undertake
capacity building for billing and revenue collection. The team also recommended that the
Clustering to start in phases as well as involvement of LGAs and Councils. However the issue
of Board dissolution remain pending. Thereafter the process of clustering will start after
finalizing the Clustering regulation.
Urban Water Supply and Sewerage Investment
A total of 5 DUWSSs of Orkesumet, Maswa, Mwanga, Himo and Karatu implemented
immediate works (quick wins). 18 production boreholes (discharge capacity 3,500m3) were
drilled and installed in Dar es Salaam areas namely, Mbagala Kuu, makangarawe, Tandika,
Mtoni Mashine ya Maji (Temeke); Tandale and Barafu (Kinondoni); and Tabata Kisiwani,
Kiwalani and Kinyerezi (Ilala). Also implementation of expansion of water supply services in
groups I to IV towns, and in district head quarters and small towns (group V), was ongoing
though in varied progress ranging from 50% to 95% in some of the towns.
Feasibility study and design for Kidunda dam has been completed, however, the contract for
Consultant has been amended and extended to August 2012, in order to finalize design of the
dam including hydropower related facilities. Draft ESIA report and RAP for Kidunda dam was
prepared and commented; also the Terms of Reference (TOR) for ESIA (the access road 75
km) has been prepared and commented. The design consultancy for the access road is at the
inception stage. Phase I report on Conceptual Aquifer Model for Kimbiji and a draft Technical
8
specification and bidding document have also been submitted and commented. The Technical
feasibility study and ESIA/RAP for Kidunda dam are under preparation.
The contract for design and supervision of expansion of Upper Ruvu (Water Treatment Plant)
and construction of the Trunk Main/Transmission Line was signed and started in March 2012;
Compensation of the affected people is completed and supervision consultant is already in
place. DAWASA launched Tenders for works, in which construction is expected to commence
soon after receiving No-objection from World Bank. The project will be completed after 15
months.
The targets for urban water supply and sewerage are derived from MKUKUTA II. The targets
were to increase access to water supply in 19 regional water utilities from 84% in 2010 to 95%,
Dar es Salaam from 55% in 2010 to 75%, District and Small Towns from 53% in 2010 to 57%
by 2015. On sanitation the target include the coverage of sewerage service from 18% in 2010 to
22% in 2015. By June 2012, water supply coverage was 86% in the 19 urban regional
headquarters which were defined by MKUKUTA to represent urban sector. The coverage in
district head quarters and small towns was 53% and coverage in Dar es Salaam reached 67%.
MKUKUTA targets could not be realized due to various reasons, including delayed
implementation of planned investment sub projects. Status on various operational indicators
such as number of both water supply and sewerage connections, average hours of services and
length of distribution network is provided in detail in the main report.
Institutional Strengthening and Capacity Building
Overall objective of this component is to provide support to Sector Institutional Strengthening
and Capacity Building. In operationalization of the New Role of the Ministry of Water, the
Ministry client service charter has been revised and now is operational. Phase 1 on
rehabilitation/construction of offices at the Ministry of Water Headquarters has been completed
except for block D for which BoQ and cost estimates have been prepared by the Consultant.
Rehabilitation work under Phase 2, to be financed by Government‟s own funds, is scheduled to
start in the coming FY 2012/13. MoW has decided to officially cancel the contract and restart
the new procurement process for Goods supply contract that was initiated in the year 2009 but
the delivery was not effected.
The Government has installed Water Sector Programme MIS, which became operational in
June 2011 at MoW, BWOs, LGAs, UWSAs, Agencies and National Water Projects. All
contracts and non contract payments under WSDP had been entered into the system. MIS data
also include earmarked projects from UWSAs, BWOs, LGAs and other IAs. The system is
implemented in phases in order to ensure sustainability based on lessons learnt. The Data
verification was done from November 2011 up to June 2012. To tackle noted challenges and to
enhance data management and information dissemination among the WSDP IAs ICT projects
have been developed and are in various stages of implementation. There are other several
noted challenges which are been addressed on continuous basis. The way forward include
9
among others to put in place adequate infrastructure and necessary training required and tools
(standardized tools, applications and procedures) required to support and maintain the sector
MIS environment.
On Components Program Management Support, Four Technical Advisers (TA) contracts for
component I are under procurement process, while TA for water quality management was
approved by MTB on May 14, 2012. The two acts namely; Water Resources Management Act
No. 11 and Water Supply and Sanitation Act No. 12, became effective in August 2009. Six
regulations have been gazetted , three for Water Resources Management Act No. 11 and three
for Water Supply and Sanitation Act No. 12 respectively.
On sector coordination, TWG 4 held an extraordinary meeting in February 2012 and all four
TWGs met in April, 2012. For the first time, the new Steering Committee (SC), held its first
meeting on February 16, 2012 where it was briefed on status of implementation of the program.
MoW conducted the 7th
and 8th
Joint supervision Mission in September 2011 and May 2012
respectively and the 6th Joint Water Sector Review (JWSR) meeting from 18th
-19th
October
2011.
On Support for Sector Capacity Building, no new recruitment and training was implemented
covering only few areas of monitoring and evaluation, record management, sustainable urban
water and sanitation, integrated process, communication, Information technology and
networking. The consultant to conduct training impact assessment is in place and has started
the assignment.
The delivery of library books for Water Development and Management Institute (WDMI) has
been completed and full paid by June 2012. The Institute has also has procured chemicals for
its laboratory, the delivery is 90%. To address the staff shortage and enhance the Institute‟s
management capacity, 31 staff are expected to be recruited through Public Service Recruitment
Secretariat including 3 Directors, the exercise is expected to be completed by September 2012.
Implementation of Safeguards Policies
The Environmental and Social Management Framework provides a strategic guide for the
integration of environmental and social considerations in Programme implementation. To build
the capacity of the IAs in implementation of safeguards, the The World Bank conducted
safeguards training that were attended by 54 staff associated with WSDP implementation. In
the period (July 2011 – June 2012), Screening was conducted for 164 projects from (10)
Regions namely Kigoma Kagera Lindi, Mara, Mbeya, Mtwara , Mwanza , Rukwa, Shinyanga,
and Tabora. Twenty nine (29) projects found to be under category A so need Environment
Impact Assessment (EIA).
Water Sector Monitoring Systems
10
The WSDP monitoring systems are set in such a way that they provide key decision making
information through both routine and survey data. The routine data measures progress on
access to services resulting from investment in water infrastructure throughout the country
while surveys measures the actual use of water infrastructure, thus revealing over- or under-
utilization of infrastructure relative to the installed capacity of the system. Currently, the online
functioning MIS does provide key WSDP operational data to stakeholders accordingly. As the
WSDP operational routine data are regularly uploaded in the MIS, production of quarterly IFRs
has become an easy task.
The Water Point Mapping
Producing accurate and up-to-date data on rural water supply infrastructure is one of the most
urgent challenges facing the sector. The Ministry of Water, together with Development
Partners, have previously made two attempts to solve the mentioned challenge by developing a
rural water supply database and Management Information System (MIS). However, in 2008,
the Joint Water Sector Review agreed that MoW should establish a single harmonized rural
water supply database.
WPM surveys involve collecting and analyzing rural water supply infrastructure data and
presenting it in a visual, easily understandable manner. As of July 2012, data have been
collected in 82 Local Government Authorities. The data from WPM in these districts will be
used for a number of purposes.The consultant has already conducted a water point mapping
survey and adjusted data for 63 LGAs with 2,042 wards and 4,985 villages. 35,641 public
water points were mapped, out of which 23,545 (66.1 %) were found to be functional while
12,096 (33.9%) were non – functional. Furthermore, the pretesting of established web-based
prototype monitoring system is underway including the uploading of data and information for
19 LGAs.
The routine data system, which is coordinated by the Ministry of Water as mentioned above
and national surveys coordinated by the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) are the main data
sources for assessing performance in the water sector.
Performance Assessments
The WSDP implementation effort and performance indicators are assessed once at each end of
financial year. The current rating for the sector performance for implementation of WSDP
based on the financial year 2010-2011 stands as "moderate satisfactory" subject to change when
a new sector performance assessment result is out later before December 2012.
Status on the Use of Water and Sanitation
The water sector continued implementing the global program (WSDP) for the year ending
December 2011 as the effort towards reducing the waterborne diseases risks. Proportion of
11
households in rural settlements with access to clean and safe water from improved/protected
sources was 56.6%; a drop of 1.2 percentage points from the figure in 2010 (57.8%).
As the WSDP implementation continued across Tanzania mainland, specific interventions in
regional urban centers have tremendously increased the physical water supply facilities, though
the access to clean and safe water from improved/protected sources went down slightly to 81%
by December 2011 from the 86% in December 2010. The proportion of households in Dar es
Salaam with access to clean and safe water from improved/protected sources dropped to 51% in
the same period from the 55% in December 2010. Proportion of households in small towns
with access to clean and safe water from improved/protected sources within 30 minutes was
52.5%.
Given all interventions made under WSDP in terms of water supply and sanitation,
environmental and social safeguards. The general performance, especially in water supply
coverage declined due to a number of reasons.
Sanitation Services
The main sources of data on sanitation are household surveys, which report on types of toilets
and latrines used by households in Tanzania mainland. According the Tanzania Human
Development Report (THDR) published by the National Bureau of Statistics in December
2011, the proportion of households with access to a ventilated improved pit (VIP) latrine or a
flush toilet declined from 8% in 2007 to 6% in 2010. Furthermore, the use of traditional toilets
declined from 85% in 2007 to 79% in 2010. More effort is needed such that the target for basic
sanitation under MKUKUTA II is higher as 95% by 2015.
The MKUKUTA target for school sanitation requires that all schools meet the minimum
standard of one latrine for every 20 girls and one latrine for every 25 boys. The most recent
data on school sanitation collected by the Ministry of Education and Vocational Training-
Basic Education Statistics in Tanzania (BEST) and presented in the THDR, 2011, shows that
the national average of pupil to pit latrine ratios (PLR) by region is 53 pupils per latrine.
Implementation of Undertakings
The MoW has been able to implement most of the 2011 JWSR undertakings with the exception
of 2 undertakings (i) Preparation of WSDP phase II (which included preparation of objectives,
targets, activities and work plan).(ii) The harmonization of the work plan at national level to
that of LGA level by including activities funded by donors supporting direct to LGAs. The
status of implementation of the undertakings is that 2 out of 4 undertakings were completed by
component 1; 6 out of 11 by component 2; 4 out of 6 by component 6; and 7 out of 9
undertakings were completed by component 4. The delay in the implementation of 6th JWSR
undertakings for 2011 is due to several reasons among them accumulation of outstanding
12
unpaid certificates which hampers smooth implementation of planned activities. It is
recommended that, DPs and MoW should revert to disbursing funds according to disbursement
projections as far as data verification loaded in the MIS is completed.
Key Areas for WSDP Phase II
Key areas are identified for each programme component to be considered in preparation of
WSDP Phase II. Preparation of the WSDP Phase II will be undertaken on the basis of the whole
programme rather than allowing each component to have its own plan and approach.
13
1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
The Water Sector Development Programme (WSDP 2006 - 2025) with its sector wide approach
to planning arrangement was prepared by the Government of Tanzania, to facilitate the
management and development of the water sector. The program development objective is to
strengthen sector institutions for integrated water resources management and improve access to
water supply and sanitation services. This effort was in line with the National Water Policy
(NAWAPO - 2002) and the National Water Sector Development Strategy (2006), which aim at
developing a comprehensive framework for sustainable development of the country‟s water
resources. The legal and institutional frameworks, which guide sector performance and
development have been is in place since 2009 through enactment of the Water Resources
Management Act and the Water Supply and Sanitation Act. The ultimate objective is to attain
the Millennium Development Goals and targets of the National Strategy for Growth and
Poverty Reduction – MKUKUTA II.
The Programme is financed through two distinct funding mechanisms; a „basket fund‟ that uses
common financing and „earmarked‟ financing arrangements. The programme is coordinated
through four components, namely; (i) Water Resources Management, which is implemented in
all nine Basin Water Offices under the Ministry‟s coordination; (ii) Rural Water Supply and
Sanitation implemented in 132 local government authorities under coordination of Ministry of
Water through Regional Secretariats and the Prime Minister‟s Office – Regional
Administration and Local Government; (iii) Urban Water Supply and Sanitation implemented
in 19 regional headquarters, DAWASA/DAWASCO, 109 districts/small towns‟ utilities and 7
national projects under coordination of the Ministry and under regulation by EWURA; and the
Institutional Strengthening and Capacity Building to support the management of the
Programme through policy formulation, oversight and capacity building roles.
The WSDP restructuring was completed in June 2011, following the recommendations of
Midterm-Review and Restructuring missions in April 2010. In the process, several requisites
were reviewed including the revised Financing Plan, budget allocation, results framework, and
revised institutional arrangements. The WSDP MoU and IDA-Financing Agreement (FA) were
amended in July 2011. There has been significant increase in the level of financial
commitments since the Programme‟s Phase I became operational in July 2007, with an
estimated investment envelope of USD 951 million to the current commitment of USD 1,299
million in June 2012.
The overall WSDP implementation has been making good progress. Most of the water supply
projects are in the construction stages. Following extension of phase I of the programme from
June 2012 to June 2014, the budget, work plan, procurement plan and disbursement projection
14
have been reviewed. The aim is to complete designated works with available budget agreed
upon during the restructuring process.
1.2 The 2012 Water Sector Status Report
The Water Sector Status Report 2012 presents the status of programme implementation during
2011/2012. Also, it highlights challenges and constraints encountered in that particular period
of time. The report provides information and data on the achievements of WSDP
implementation, resulting from concerted efforts made by the Ministry of Water in
collaboration with the Ministry of Finance, Prime Minister‟s Office – Regional Administration
and Local Government, Ministry of Health and Social Welfare, Ministry of Education and
Vocational Training, Development Partners, Implementing Agencies and other stakeholders.
1.2.1 Scope and Purpose of the Report
Inputs for the WSSR 2012 were derived from WSDP implementation progress reports, other
water sector documents and other analytical documents. This report gives analysis of level of
implementation of water projects country wide including constraints and issues that underpin
the programme performance under the SWAp framework. The report proposes remedial
measures to identified challenges faced during programme implementation.
1.2.2 Structure of the Report
The report is arranged in 12 chapters with introductory part giving a brief explanation of the
Programme since its inception. Chapter 2 presents the status of sector financing and financial
performance of the programme including results from audit trails. Chapter 3 presents the status
of implementation of the procurement plan up to June 2012. In chapter 4, the report discusses
status of water resources in the country as summarized from basins‟ reports and studies.
Chapter 5 presents status of implementation of WSDP planned activities in all programme
components for the period from July 2011 to June 2012. Chapter 6 discusses achievements and
challenges of implementation of safeguards policies and guidelines. Chapter 7 elaborates status
on the use of water and sanitation facilities as analyzed by national surveys. Chapter 8 charts
out the sector monitoring system with elaboration of the need to improve reporting through the
functional MIS. Chapter 9 presents the status of implementation of the 2011 Joint Water Sector
Review‟s undertakings. Chapter 10 presents the roadmap for preparation of WSDP Phase II and
introduces draft undertakings for 2012/2013. Chapter 11 is about the way forward for sector
progress.
15
2 SECTOR FINANCING
The Government of Tanzania (GoT) in collaboration with Development Partners (DPs)
committed funds to finance the WSDP in the first phase of five years period from 2007/2008 to
2011/2012 at an estimated cost of USD 951 million. The GoT committed to contribute USD
251 million, which is equivalent to 26%; and DPs USD 700 million, which is equivalent to
74%. After the Programme restructuring in 2011, it was found that the implementation of some
investment projects would go beyond June 2012. It was then jointly (GoT and DPs) agreed to
extend the implementation of phase I of WSDP (phase I) for two years period to June 2014.
During the implementation of phase I, more commitments have been received from DPs. By
the end of June 2012, the total amount committed reached USD 1,299 million, an increase of
USD 348 million, equivalent to 36% of the original estimates (as shown in Table 1).
Table 1: WSDP Commitments Vs Disbursements
Sources Original
Commitment
in USD
Revised
Commitment
Actual
Disbursement as
June 2012
Performance
(%)
GoT 251,000,000 251,000,000 137,110,849.35 55%
Basket
Partners*
330,000,000 374,950,000 273,976,581.02 73%
Earmarked
Partners**
370,000,000 673,976,606 377,916,862.87 56%
Total 951,000,000 1,299,926,606 789,004,293.25 61%
Source: Water Sector MIS: Exchange rate: TShs. 1,500/USD
*Does not include AfDB Commitment which has been re-categorized as Basket under new MoU. AfDB is included under earmarked in this
table.
** This Actual Disbursements reported is as per Implementing Agency record from MIS. It differs from what most Earmarked partners
reported because it does not include administrative costs and other accompanying measures.
2.1 Financial Performance for July 2011 - June 2012
WSDP budget for financial year 2011/2012 totalled USD 284.489 million. The amount
includes USD 27.896 million from GoT and USD 256.593 million from DPs. By the end of
June 2012, a total of USD 149.553 million had been disbursed. This includes USD 15.295
million from GoT and USD 134.258 million from DPs, which is equivalent to budget
performance of 55% and 52% respectively. (See Table 2 below)
Table 2: WSDP Approved Budgets Vs Actual Disbursements
DPs Approved Budget
FY 2011/2012
Actual Disbursement
FY 2011/2012
Performance (%)
16
GoT 27,896,696.67 15,295,243.33 55%
Foreign 256,593,278.67 134,258,656.43 52%
Total 284,489,975.33 149,553,899.76 53%
Source: Water Sector MIS: Exchange rate: TShs. 1,500/USD
2.2 Status of Disbursements by Components for FY 2011/2012
According to the revised commitments, disbursement ratios across components were required
to base on agreed allocation percentages. However, the actual disbursements indicate deviation
from agreed allocation percentages especially for component 2 and component 3 due to various
reasons; such as delayed commencement of works in component 2, which caused the 3%
decrease on its share of actual disbursement percentages in favour of component 3, which had
projects ready for implementation (as shown in Table 3 and 4). Actual works for ten villages
were scaled down to five villages, of which signing of contracts started in 2011/2012 in some
LGAs.
Table 3: Status of Disbursement by Components for 2011/2012
COMPONENT Approved Budget FY
2011/2012
Actual Release
FY 2011/2012
Release %
FY 2011/2012
COMPONENT 1 22,860,744.00 2,274,020.84 10
COMPONENT 2 33,863,417.33 40,745,992.05 120
COMPONENT 3 207,761,997.33 71,191,733.54 34
COMPONENT 4 20,003,816.67 2,301,570.64 12
284,489,975.33 116,513,317.07 41
Source: Water Sector MIS
Table 4: Actual Disbursement Performance as at June 2012
COMPONENT Revised
Commitment
as at June 2012
in US dollars
Revised
Commitment
%
Actual Releases
as at June 2012
in US dollars
Actual
Disbursement
as of June 2012
%
COMPONENT 1 68,862,633 5 35,513,718.82 5
COMPONENT 2 463,410,123 36 241,072,586.39 33
COMPONENT 3 698,267,038 54 420,335,085.26 57
COMPONENT 4 69,386,812 5 40,699,164.65 5
TOTAL 1,299,926,606 737,620,555.14
Funds in Holding
Accounts
0 51,383,738.11
17
1,299,926,606 100 789,004,293.25 100
Source: Water Sector MIS
Figure 1: Actual Disbursement Performance as at June 2012
2.3 Sector Financing Trends
WSDP financing trend shows that GoT actual contribution has continuously been declining
from FY 2007/2008 to FY 2011/2012 from USD 55.8 million to USD 15.2million in FY
2011/2012. However, for the FY 2012/2013 GoT has increased its budget contribution to USD
87 million. The WSDP basket fund partners‟ contribution increased in previous financial years
except in 2011/2012 where a decrease was noted. The basket fund DPs were requested to fulfill
their commitment of disbursing funds based on cash flow projections prepared by MoW in
order to stabilize the financial situation in the sector and enable IAs to implement their
investment plans timely and effectively.
2.4 Funds from Other Sources Including IAs’ Own Revenues
In addition to the funds from basket and earmarked partners, implementation of WSDP used
funds from other sources including own implementing agency revenue; such as, water user fee
and water permit application fee for basins; water and sewerage tariff for UWSAs. For the case
of LGAs, other sources include charity contributions from CBOs and NGOs; local taxes and
other charges levied under local government laws; discretional capital grants from the central
government and community contribution. During the reporting period, a total of TShs. 11.126
billion (approx. USD. 7.417 million) was collected from other sources. Basins collections
amounted to 1.034 billion (approx. USD 0.689 million); UWSAs, TZS 7.080 billion (approx.
USD 4.72 million; and LGAs TShs. 3.012 billion.
18
Basin Water Offices
The collection of water use fee for the nine basins in FY 2011-2012 was Tshs. 1,034,634,856
against the planned amount of Tshs. 1,181,000,000, equivalent to 88%( table 5). Although
Water User Fee (WUF) revenue collection percentage is high, it is comparatively still very low
when compared to the required operational budget. This affects BWOs ability to effectively
manage water resources in their respective basins. As a remedial response, the consultant on
Water Resource Management Financing options has submitted the draft report with
recommendations on how to stabilize the sustainable financing of water resources management
operations in all basins. The proposed actions will be discussed and agreed during JWSR so as
to guide the way forward.
Table 5: Funds from Other Sources including Implementing Agencies' Own Revenues
YEAR BASINS
TOTAL
LGAs OWN
SOURCES
Urban Water Supply
and Sewerages
Authorities
TOTAL
2010/2011 1,323,359,026 10,925,133,181 6,131,232,000 18,379,724,207
2011/2012 1,034,634,856 3,012,123,308 7,080,999,000 11,127,757,164
Local Government Authorities (LGAs)
LGAs‟ sources of income includes funds from charity contributions from CBOs and NGOs;
local taxes and other charges levied under local government laws; funds from projects like
TASAF, discretional capital grants from the central government and community contribution.
During the year under review, Tshs. 3.012 billion was used by LGAs to fund water projects in
their respective areas. (See Table 5). However, community contribution has been declining, and
this may affect O&M plans.
Urban Water Supply and Sewerages Authorities
The main source of revenue of utilities is the sales of water supply and sewerage services,
which constitute their core business. In the FY 2011/2012 total revenue collected by UWSAs
amounted to Tshs. 7.08 billion. Of the total amount, collection for Dar es Salaam accounts for
37% of the total UWSAs collections. Categories B and C collection have increased by 32% due
to new connections. However, the low increase of revenue collection in category A and
DAWASCO is due to the fact that UFW is still high and there is an increase in unpaid debts.
Table 6: Revenue Generated for Regional UWSAs in million Tshs
19
Category 2010/11 2011/12 Percentage increase
A 3,477,979 4,078,588 17%
B& C 279,486 367,617 32%
Dar es Salaam 2,373,767 2,634,794 11%
Total 6,131,232 7,080,999 15%
2.5 WSDP Expenditure Performance by Components
For the past five years of implementation of WSDP, a total of USD 789 million was disbursed,
out of this, USD 658.4 million, equivalent to 83% were spent. Most of unspent balance is still
in Holding Account (USD 51,383,738.11) and other balances are with LGAs, small towns,
district headquarters and basins due to delays in procurement of consultants. (See Table 7
below).
Table 7: WSDP Expenditure Performance by Components
Component Actual Releases as
at June 2012
Actual Expenditure
July 2007 to June
2012
Expenditure
Performance
COMPONENT 1 35,513,718.82 35,022,526.80 99%
COMPONENT 2 241,072,586.39 186,978,781.79 78%
COMPONENT 3 420,335,085.26 396,090,639.68 94%
COMPONENT 4 40,699,164.65 40,308,205.05 99%
Total 737,620,555.14 658,400,153.32 89%
Holding Account
Balance
51,383,738.11
789,004,293.25 658,400,153.32 83%
Source: Sector MIS
2.6 Results from Audit Trails
As per the Public Finance Act 2010, National Audit Act, IPSAs, MoU, PIM and Financial
Management addendum; the MoW has been facilitating and coordinating the conduct of
financial audits, technical audits, in-depth financial management reviews and statement of
expenditure reviews in compliance with good governance standards.
(i) External Audit
External Audit for FY 2011/2012 of WSDP was conducted by NAO as per Public Finance Act
and IPSAs; a qualified opinion was issued mainly because of differences in balances of IAs and
20
MIS. This issue has been dealt with through MIS data verification exercise, which was
conducted for all IAs. Therefore, it is expected that the audit opinion will improve.
(ii) Technical Audit 2010/2011 and 2011/2012
The consultant to conduct Technical Audit for FY 2010/2011 and FY 2011/2012 has been
identified through the procurement process. The exercise was delayed due to the fact that MoW
and DPs agreed to expand the scope of work by including the current financial year, contract
now is for two years i.e 2010/2011 and FY 2011/2012.The report is expected to be ready by
31st December 2012 as per ToR.
(iii) In-depth Financial Review
In-depth FM review was done by the WB in FY 2011/2012, which identified areas that need
improvement. The most notable recommendation includes the need to enhance financial
management and MIS capacity of IAs staff such as accountants and engineers. As a response,
MoW has conducted training of LGAs accountants and internal auditors in using MIS to
improve Financial Management.
2.7 Financing and Sustainability
The Government of Tanzania has been implementing several fiscal stability measures geared at
improving local revenue collection with the aim of increasing the local development budget
allocated to sectors including water sector. This is evidenced by the increasing trend of local
development budget during the last three years from Tshs. 30.7 billion in FY 2010/2011 to
Tshs. 41.6 billion in FY 2011/2012 and Tshs. 140 billion in FY 2012/2013, when the increase
was 35% for FY 2011/2012 and 237% for FY 2012/2013 respectively.
Apart from national level revenue enhancement strategies, water sector has also been
implementing various sector revenue enhancement strategies including:-
Cost sharing by communities to finance operation and maintenance, and investment
costs;
Private sector involvement as per National Water Policy and Public Private
Partnership in implementation of water projects as per PPP policy;
Securing low interest loans from internal and external sources including commercial
banks; and
Establishment and operation of the National Water Investment Fund, as per section 44
of the Water Supply and Sanitation Act No 12 of 2009. Finances from this investment
will be used to fund priority investments.
21
3 STATUS ON IMPLEMENTATION OF PROCUREMENT PLAN
3.1 Overview of WSDP Procurement Management Standards
WSDP Procurement follows the laws and procedures in the public sector and respective
financing agreements which include, the Public Procurement Act 2004, and the World Bank
Procurement Guidelines. The agreed procedures for the procurement of goods, services and
works under the Programme are outlined in Section 9 of the WSDP Memorandum of
Understanding. The objective is to promote effectiveness and quality assurance in the
procurement transactions and achievement of value for money in the water sector
procurements. The methods detailed in the PIM ensure bidding competitiveness using both the
International Competitive Bidding (ICB) and the National Competitive Bidding (NCB)
methods. ICB is applied with a prior review of the World Bank and issue of No Objection on
related documentations, terms and conditions and decisions for bidding process, contracting
and contract management. NCB is applied for items of small value or moderate transactions
which require a post review of the World Bank and should use the Public Procurement Act
(2004), the Public Procurement Regulations (2005) and the relative standard bidding
documents issued by the PPRA. While in Consultancy Services the use of methods of selection
of Quality and Cost Based Selection (QCBS), Quality and Least Cost Based Selection (LCBS),
Quality and Fixed Budget Selection and the Quality Based Selection (FQBS).
3.2 Status of Measures for Risk Mitigation in WSDP Procurement
Procurement planning for WSDP phase I took into accounts estimated costs and related risks
and their mitigation measures. The risks assessed during the program design have been
modified based on improvement achieved, and the current status of implementation as
summarized below:
Among the risky areas identified during programme design and implementation process in
Procurement management includes:
(i) Weak Procurement management Unit at the MOW;
(ii) Weak procurement management at the LGAs;
(iii) Weak procurement at the Utilities and BWOs.
Mitigation measures which have been taken to address issues of procurement management
include; procurement of Specialist for one year to strengthen the capacity of the PMU,
replacement of three staff by transfer from other ministries, training of two staff in records
management and one staff transferred from the MoW Registry to strengthen the capacity of
PMU. Also two containers have been procured and installed to accommodate procurement
documents.
A Training programme in procurement and procurement plan preparation has been developed
and is ready for implementation when funds are available, for RAS engineers head of PMUs‟
and members of Tender Boards in respective LGAs, utilities and BWOs.
3.3 Status of Implementation of the WSDP Procurement Plan
The status of implementation of the WSDP Procurement Plan is as shown in the Table 8 below.
22
Table 8: Planned Contracts, Awarded Contracts and Uninitiated Contracts up to June
2012
Contracts not Initiated
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
Basket Fund
Goods 89 43.019 70 38.737 7 2.168 12 1.314 62 18.856 8 19.881
Works 318 363.772 151 254.992 16 5.877 151 168.217 118 23.19 33 231.802
Consultancy 236 111.144 194 93.464 13 1.807 29 10.703 13 5.731 176 87.733
Non-Consultancy 4 0.34 3 0.181 1 0.159 0 0 3 0.181 0 0.000
Sub-Total Basket Fund 647 518.275 418 387.374 37 10.011 192 180.234 196 49.958 217 339.416
Earmarked Financing
Goods 7 10.33 4 0.972 0 0.000 3 8.900 4 1.07 0 0.200
Works 17 238.52 12 259.37 0 0.000 5 75 3 68.64 9 191.000
Consultancy 33 53.395 29 51.429 0 0.000 4 0.150 12 18.857 17 32.562
Sub-Total Earmarked
Financing 57 302.245 45 311.771 0 0.000 12 84.2502 19 88.567 26 223.762
GOT Financing
Goods 16 10.476 2 8.922 5 0.52 9 0.143 2 0 1 8.922
Works 55 155.86 23 52.692 10 18.908 22 96.921 5 2.200 18 50.142
Consultancy 24 7.46 12 2.389 1 0.06 11 3.15 2 0.0600 10 2.329
Non Consultancy 7 0.68 0 0 7 0.68 0 0 0 0 0 0.000
Subtotal GOT Funding 102 174.476 37 64.003 23 20.168 42 100.214 9 2.26 29 61.393
Grand total 806 994.996 500 763.148 60 30.179 246 364.698 224 140.785 272 624.571
Contracts in ProgressContracts Initiated
PARTICULARS
Planned Contracts Contracts Awarded Completed Contracts
Source: WSDP PP 2007/2008 to FY 2012/2013
Table 8 above shows that out of 806 planned contracts, 500 were awarded; and out of those
awarded, 224 contracts are completed and 272 contracts are under implementation. 246
contracts have been initiated while 60 have not been initiated. When categorized according to
sources of funding the status is, 547 Contracts are planned under the Basket Funding, 57 under
earmarked funding and 102 under the GOT financing. A further analysis based on the
respective Components is outlined below.
3.4 Implementation of Procurement Plan by WSDP Components
(i) Component 1: Strengthening Water Resources Management and Development
Framework:
The Component is financed by the basket fund, earmarked and GoT with an allocation of USD
35.028 million for procurement of goods, works, consultancy and non-consultancy inputs, with
the highest allocation of USD 15.365 million to consultancy services. The total of 63 contracts
was planned for WSDP phase 1. Up to June 2012, 28 contracts were awarded, out of which 2
contracts were completed. 13 contracts were uninitiated while 22 contracts are under
implementation Table 9 summarizes the status of contracts under component 1:
Table 9: Planned Contracts, Awarded Contracts and Uninitiated Contracts up to June
2012 for Component 1
23
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
Basket Fund
Goods 10 13.871 5 12.351 4 0.841 1 0.308 0 0.000 5 12.351
Works 8 3.703 2 1.575 2 1.697 4 3.86 0 0.000 2 1.575
Consultancy 38 15.365 20 9.356 7 0.967 11 5.652 2 0.211 14 9.145
Non-Consultancy 0 0.000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 0 0.000
Sub-Total Basket Fund 56 32.939 27 23.282 13 3.507 16 5.96 2 0.211 21 23.071
Earmarked Financing
Goods 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Works 0 0.00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Consultancy 1 1.12 1 1.12 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1.120
Sub-Total Earmarked
Financing 1 1.12 1 1.12 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1.12
GOT Financing
Goods 0 0.419 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Works 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Consultancy 6 0.55 0 0 0 0 6 0.55 0 0 0 0
Non Consultancy 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Subtotal GOT Funding 6 0.969 0 0 0 0 6 0.55 0 0 0 0
Grand total 63 35.028 28 24.402 13 3.507 22 6.51 2 0.211 22 24.191
Contracts in ProgressContracts not Initiated
PARTICULARS
Planned Contracts Contracts Awarded Contracts Initiated Completed Contracts
Source: WSDP PP 2007/2008 to FY 2012/2013
The performance reflects that, more contracts were performed before the financial year
2011/2012 as it was expected that phase one of the programme would have been ended in June
2012. Some projects which cannot be implemented in Phase I shall be implemented in Phase II
and hence removed from the procurement plan.
(ii) Component 2: Rural Water Supply and Sanitation
This component is implemented with a relatively high number of implementing agencies and
actors (Local Government Authorities, Regional Secretariats, under the coordination of Prime
Minister‟s Office; Regional Administration and Local Government – PMO-RALG in
collaboration with the Ministry of Water); therefore it requires relatively high initial costs for
preparation and ensuring proper understanding of relative roles, accounting and reporting
procedures.
The Component is allocated a total of USD 243.718 million financed by the basket fund,
earmarked donors and GOT for procurement of good, works, and consultancy services and
non- consultancy services, with the highest allocation of USD 137.452 million to Works
contracts. The total of 462 contracts was planned for WSDP phase 1. Up to June 2012, 278
contracts were awarded, out of which 118 contracts are completed. 26 contracts are uninitiated
While 158 contracts are under implementation Table 10 summarizes the status of contracts
under component II:
24
Procurements Status for WSDP Component 2
Table 10: Planned Contracts, Awarded Contracts and Uninitiated Contracts up to June
2012 for Component 2
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
Basket Fund
Goods 0 0.000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 0 0.000
Works 265 137.452 115 18.739 14 4.18 136 114.533 111 15.270 4 3.469
Consultancy 139 54.762 132 53.650 3 0.430 4 0.682 4 2.005 126 51.645
Non-Consultancy 0 0.000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000
Sub-Total Basket Fund 404 192.214 247 72.389 17 4.862 140 115.215 115 17.275 130 55.114
Earmarked Financing
Goods 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Works 1 2.20 0 0 0 0 1 2.2 0 0 0 0
Consultancy 7 16.705 5 12.038 0 0 1 0.0502 2 4.17 3 7.868
Sub-Total Earmarked
Financing 8 18.905 5 12.038 0 0 2 2.25 2 4.17 3 7.868
GOT Financing
Goods 2 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.143 0 0 0 0
Works 40 30.490 18 22.692 9 4.908 13 6.082 1 2.200 18 20.492
Consultancy 8 2.11 8 2.055 0 0 0 0.000 0 0 7 2.055
Non Consultancy 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000
Subtotal GOT Funding 50 32.599 26 24.747 9 4.908 15 6.225 1 2.200 25 22.547
Grand total 462 243.718 278 109.174 26 9.77 157 123.690 118 23.645 158 85.529
Contracts in ProgressContracts not Initiated
PARTICULARS
Planned Contracts Contracts Awarded Contracts Initiated Completed Contracts
Source WSDP PP 2007/2008 to FY 2012/2013
This performance includes the projects transferred from the Rural Water Supply and Sanitation
Project (before commencement of WSDP). It also includes quick wins and the design of
drilling of boreholes. The complex projects such as construction of dams and water point
mapping were prolonged due to their complexity.
(iii) Component 3: Urban Water Supply and Sewerage - Overall Status
This component is implemented with a relatively high number of implementing agencies and
actors (all Urban Water Authorities and Small Towns, and National Water Projects), whereby
the bulk of financial resources allocated are for infrastructure investments in improving urban
water supply and sanitation services. In the context of capacity building and monitoring, the
PMU of MOW in collaboration with Department of Urban Water Supply and Sewerage
Services has been reviewing procurement processes, documentation and decision made on
various activities.
The Component is allocated a total of USD 647.179 million financed by the basket fund,
earmarked donors and GOT for procurement of good, works, and consultancy services and
non- consultancy services, with the highest allocation of USD 565.083 million to Works
contracts. The total of 196 contracts was planned for WSDP phase 1. Up to June 2012, 164
contracts were awarded, out of which 75 contracts are completed. 1 contract is uninitiated
25
While 80 contracts are under implementation Table 11 summarizes the status of contracts under
component III:
Procurements Status for WSDP Component 3
Table 11: Planned Contracts, Awarded Contracts and Uninitiated Contracts up to June
2012 for Component 3
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
Basket Fund
Goods 51 4.650 48 3.612 0 0 0 0 48 3.612 0 0.000
Works 41 218.833 33 233.746 0 0 8 46.84 7 7.92 26 225.826
Consultancy 38 38.150 31 29.382 0 0.000 7 3.309 4 3.439 29 25.943
Non-Consultancy 0 0.000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000
Sub-Total Basket Fund 130 261.639 112 266.740 0 0 15 50.149 59 14.971 55 251.769
Earmarked Financing
Goods 5 1.13 3 0.772 0 0 0 0 3 1.07 0 0
Works 16 235.32 12 259.37 0 0 5 73 3 68.640 9 191
Consultancy 23 34.32 22 38.181 1 0.800 0 0 9 14.597 13 23.584
Sub-Total Earmarked
Financing 44 270.763 37 298.323 1 0.800 5 73.44 15 84.307 22 214.016
GOT Financing
Goods 3 0.936 0 0 0 0.000 0 0 0 0 0 0
Works 13 110.91 5 30 0 0 8 90.38 0 0 3 29.650
Consultancy 6 2.93 1 0.060 0 0 5 2.6 1 0.060 0 0
Non Consultancy 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Subtotal GOT Funding 22 114.777 6 30 0 0 13 92.98 1 0.06 3 29.65
Grand total 196 647.179 164 595.123 1 0.8 33 216.56 75 99.338 80 495.435
PARTICULARS
Source: WSDP PP 2007/2008 to FY 2012/2013
(iv) Component 4: Institutional Strengthening and Capacity Building:
The Component is allocated a total of USD 67.37 million financed by the basket fund,
earmarked donors and GOT in accordance with the amounts shown in Table 12 below, with
bulk of the allocations to goods.
The performance in Table 14 shows that out of 81 planned contracts, 39 contracts were
awarded; and out of those awarded, only 22 contracts were completed. 20 contracts are
uninitiated contracts.
26
Procurements Status for WSDP Component 4
Table 12: Planned Contracts, Awarded Contracts and Uninitiated Contracts up to June
2012 for Component 4
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million USD
No of
Contracts
Cost in
Million
USD
Basket Fund
Goods 28 24.498 17 22.774 3 1.327 8 1.008 14 15.244 3 7.530
Works 4 3.784 1 0.932 0 0 3 2.984 0 0 1 0.932
Consultancy 21 2.867 11 1.076 3 0.410 7 1.16 4 0.076 7 1.000
Non-Consultancy 4 0.340 3 0.181 0 0 0 0 3 0.181 0 0.000
Sub-Total Basket Fund 57 31.489 32 24.963 6 1.737 18 5.152 21 15.501 11 9.462
Earmarked Financing
Goods 2 9.2 1 0.2 0 ,0 1 8.900 0 0 1 0.200
Works 0 0.00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Consultancy 2 0.13 1 0.09 0 0 1 0.100 1 0.090 0.000
Sub-Total Earmarked
Financing 4 9.33 2 0.29 0 0 2 9 1 0.09 1 0.200
GOT Financing
Goods 7 9.54 2 8.922 5 0.52 0 0 0 0 1 8.922
Works 2 14.46 0 0 1 14 1 0.459 0 0 0 0
Consultancy 4 1.87 3 0.274 1 0.08 0 0 0 0 2 0.274
Non Consultancy 7 0.68 0 0 7 0.68 0 0 0 0 0 0
Subtotal GOT Funding 20 26.551 5 9 14 15.28 1 0.459 0 0 3 9.196
Grand total 81 67.37 39 34.253 20 17.017 21 14.611 22 15.591 15 18.858
Contracts in ProgressContracts not Initiated
PARTICULARS
Planned Contracts Contracts Awarded Contracts Initiated Completed Contracts
Source: WSDP PP 2007/2008 to FY 2012/2013
3.5 Challenges on the Procurement Processes
The major challenge faced in the course of implementation includes:
(i) Slow procurement processes, especially to the new institutions like Basins and Small
Towns;
(ii) Weak contract administration and management; and
(iii) Unreliable flow of funds for monitoring and evaluation and for payments of contracts
certificates.
Recommended measures include:
(i) Sustaining the functional MIS for the Water Sector;
(ii) Strengthen sector M&E;
(iii) Resolve back to the normal disbursement of funds for implementation of WSDP.
(iv) Each works contract be administered by works inspection committee comprised of PMU and
user department staff (3 officers); (v) The accounting officer should appoint the works supervisor who will monitor day to day
progress of the works and shall report to the committee; and
(vi) Strengthen the capacity of PMU staff (Basin) as well as the capacity of PMU at MoW.
This shall be done through training (tailor-made training).
27
4 STATUS OF WATER RESOURCES IN THE COUNTRY
Freshwater is a basic natural resource, which sustains life and provides for various social and
economic needs. In its natural state, water is an integral part of the environment whose quantity
and quality determine how it can be used. Despite its importance to our lives and development,
water is unevenly distributed in time, space, quantity and with great variations in quality; also,
water is a finite and a vulnerable resource.
Tanzania has faced growing water shortage from reduced and delayed rains and increasing
demand for water. Over the past 25 years, these demands have intensified with the increase in
population and concurrent growth of economic activities requiring water as an input such as
hydropower generation, irrigated agriculture, industries, tourism, mining, livestock keeping,
domestic, fisheries, wildlife and forestry activities. Water scarcity is perceived at many places
due to unreliable rainfall, multiplicity of competing uses, degradation of sources and
catchments.
Factors contributing to stress on local water resources include reduced and delayed rains,
increasing multisectoral demands, degradation due to pollution, over abstraction, poor land use
practices, and encroachment of land for agriculture, urbanization and industrial development. .
The water stress being faced in many places in the country is partly due to high rainfall
variability and frequent droughts. Water insecurity is manifested through: (a) shortages for
domestic supply and irrigation; (b) growing conflicts amongst groups of water users (farmers)
and between different sectoral uses of water (irrigators, power generators, industries,
pastoralists and environment) and communities and individuals, (c) water pollution, (d)
destruction/degradation of water sources –watersheds, wetlands, springs, and recharge areas,
and (e) a national power crisis.
About 73% of Tanzania‟s electricity comes from 6 hydropower plants with an installed
capacity of 561 MW. Water levels in all major hydropower dams are low and declining. Both
Nyumba ya Mungu and Mtera dams are abstracting from dead storage to generate power, and
thus increasing the risk of turbine cavitations and long term damage. Water and land use
conflicts in the Pangani, Rufiji, Internal Drainage and Lake Rukwa basins have created volatile
conditions. Over abstraction, pollution and contested borders on transboundary waters are
creating regional tensions and instability.
4.1 Water Availability
Water availability depends on annual rain amount and pattern. Water situation in any area in
the country, depends on availability of rain for a particular zone. Tanzania has been divided
into seven rain zones as follows: Lake Victoria zone which covers Kagera, Mwanza, Shinyanga
and Mara regions together with northern parts of Kigoma; North eastern highlands zone covers
28
Kilimanjaro, Arusha and Manyara regions; northern coast zone covering Coast region, Dar es
Salaam, Tanga regions and northern parts of Morogoro region; Western zone which include
Tabora, Rukwa Kigoma, regions and southern parts of Shinyanga region; Central zone consist
of Dodoma and Singida regions; Southern highlands comprise of Mbeya, Iringa regions and
parts of southern Morogoro and southern coast zone which encompass Ruvuma, Mtwara and
Lindi regions.
Tanzania‟s annual renewable water resources are 89 cubic kilometres or 2,700 cubic meters of
water per person per year (World Resources 2000- 2001) and about 40 Km3 groundwater
reserve; but the resource is unevenly distributed and there are no enough water storage
infrastructures to reserve the water when it is plenty for future use. Based on projected
population from estimated 33 million in the year 2001 to about 59.8 million by the year 2025,
annual average available water per capita which is 2,700 cubic meters, will be reduced by 45%
to about 1,500 cubic meters per person per year which shows that the country will face a water
stress situation, considering that below 1,700 cubic meters per person per year signifies water
scarcity.
More than half of the country receives on the average less than 800mm of rain per year. The
monsoon type of climate prevailing in the country causes extreme temporal variability in
rainfall and even more extreme variability in river flows. The annual mean rainfall shows that
the eastern coastal areas receive well over 1000mm per year while most parts of the drier
interior receive less than 600mm. Water resources in the country include rivers, lakes,
wetlands, springs, natural reservoirs, groundwater aquifers and transboundary rivers that are
shared with neighbouring countries. The drainage areas of these international water bodies
cover over 43.5% of the country‟s land area.
4.2 Water Status in Basins
Water availability is heavily influenced by the amount of rainfall in a particular year. Up to
June, 2012 water availability situation in Basins and Catchments was reported as follows:
Normal in Ruvuma and Southern Coast, Lake Victoria, Lake Tanganyika and Lake Nyasa
Basins, above normal in Wami-Ruvu and Pangani Basins and below normal in Great Ruaha
Catchment in Rufiji Basin. The catchments of Luwegu and Kilombero in Rufiji Basin reported
normal water availability.
Water Situation in Reservoirs for Power Production
Nyumba ya Mungu dam in Pangani Basin: The dam has 140 sq. km, 1.1 billion m3 storage
capacity, regulating body for 3 Hydro Power plants at Nyumba ya Mungu dam (8MW), Hale
(21MW) and New Pangani Falls (68MW). Variation of water levels up to 23rd
week of 2012
(see fig 2).The status of major dams water level is given below.
29
WATER LEVELS AT NYUMBA YA MUNGU DAM
Figure 2: Water Level at Nyumba ya Mungu Dam
Mtera, Kidatu and Kihansi in Rufiji Basin:
There are three major dams for hydropower generation in Rufiji Basin Water Office, which has
potential to produce 464 MW which is equivalent to more than 80% of hydropower production
in the country. The following are characteristics of these three dams. Some general
characteristics of the dams are summarized in Table 13.
Table 13: General Characteristics of Mtera, Kidatu and Kihansi Dams
N
o
Dam Maximum
storage (Mill.
m3)
Maximum water
level (m)
Minimum water
level (m)
Maximum turbine
discharge (m3/s)
1 Mtera 3200.00 698.50 690.00 96.00
2 Kidatu 125.00 450.00 433.00 140.00
3 Kihansi 0.999 1146.00 1127.00 24.90
Water situation at Mtera dam is not good because water level has been receding. The level
recorded on 30th
July 2012, was 690.37 meters above mean sea level (m.a.m.s.l). This level is
minimal compared to the long-term July‟s average (from 2006 to 2012), which is 695.194
m.a.m.s.l. That means, only 0.37 m.a.m.s.l is left for water to reach the dead storage, which is
690.00 m.a.m.s.l. Figure 3 show the trend of water levels from 2006/2012.
30
Figure 3: Water Situation at Mtera Dam
Amount of water at Kidatu dam has also been decreasing following the decrease of water level
in Mtera dam and the amount of water flowing at Lukosi, Mwega and Yovi rivers. Water level
recorded on 30th
July 2012 at Kidatu dam was 445.40 m.a.m.s.l., which is less compared to the
long-term average for July, which is 448.403 m.a.m.s.l. Figure 4 shows water trend in Kidatu
dam from 2006-2012.
Water Situation at Mtera Dam from 2006-2012
686
687
688
689
690
691
692
693
694
695
696
697
698
699
700
1 12 23 34 45 56 67 78 89 100 111 122 133 144 155 166 177 188 199 210 221 232 243 254 265 276 287 298 309 320 331 342 353 364 Days
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
Dead storag e
31
Figure 4: Water Situation at Kidatu Dam
For Kihansi dam, the situation is better compared to other dams where by the amount of water
level recorded on 23rd
June, 2012 was 1144.564 m.a.m.s.l. This level is more or less similar to
the long-term average for July, which is 1144.990 m.a.m.s.l. Figure 5 illustrates water situation
at Kihansi from year 2010 to 2012.
Figure 5: Water Situation at Kihansi Dam
Growing Water Resources Development and Management Concerns
(i) Inadequate water storage infrastructure, which impedes the nation‟s ability to deal with
climate variability and it is impacting food, energy, water and environmental security
and causing huge economic loss. Climate change is going to further stress the nation‟s
water resources. IWRMD plans will provide opportunities for integrating climate
change adaptation.
(ii) Water use conflicts as well as illegal water abstractions are increasing.
(iii) Destruction of water source areas – watersheds, wetlands, springs and recharge areas -
due to encroachments are increasing tensions and impacting water supply and quality.
(iv) Pollution from municipal sewage and mining and industrial activities are increasing.
(v) Low irrigation efficiencies are contributing to sub optimal water use and conflicts.
(vi) Limited hydrological and water use information and data. Available data is not in an
accessible form.
32
4.3 Lesson Learnt
(i) The issue of data collection, rehabilitation and construction of water resources
monitoring stations as well as management information system is a critical need for all
BWBs.
(ii) There is weak enforcement of the WRMA 2009 resulting from slow progress putting in
place water resources management institutions such as WUAs and catchment
committees, and construction/rehabilitation, of monitoring stations and installation of
equipment which are crucial for a sound water resources management.
4.4 Way Forward
(i) Data collection will be given high priority for efficient water resources management.
Rehabilitation of most Water Resources monitoring stations will be done during the
financial year 2012/2013;
(ii) Preparation and implementation of Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM)
plans will address issues of sustainable allocation and conservation of water resources.
(iii) As a measure to mitigate possible climate change impacts and to improve water storage,
7 dams will be rehabilitated in the Internal Drainage Basin (6) and Ruvuma and
Southern Coast Rivers Basin (1) during the FY 2012/2013. Construction of Ndembera
Dam in Rufiji Basin and Farkwa dam in the Internal Drainage Basin planned during the
second phase of WSDP. To enable easy access of water resources data and information,
water resources data and information management system will be established in all
Basin Water Boards.
(iv) Inventory of all water users and water sources in all nine water basins will be conducted
as a basis for improving revenue collection for the basins operations. Staff recruitment
and training will be carried out for the basins to reduce the skills gap as well as devising
mechanism for incentives and motivation.
(v) Inventory of reservoirs in the country will be conducted to reveal their status and
necessary requirements for malfunctioning dams will be established. Potential sites for
dam sites will also be determined.
(vi) All Water Basin Offices will collaborate with other stakeholders at all levels and using
the EMA and WRMA 2009 to arrest catchment degradation and water sources
pollution.
33
5 STATUS ON IMPLEMENTATION OF WSDP PLANNED
ACTIVITIES AGAINST TARGETS
5.1 COMPONENT 1: WATER RESOURCES MANAGEMENT
The objectives of the Water Resources Management and Development component (WRMD) of
WSDP are:
To develop a sound water resources management and development framework in all
nine water basins, for optimizing the utilization of the water resources in a sustainable
manner for the various competing uses;
To promote good governance of water resources through empowering water users,
encouraging participatory and transparent decision-making in the allocation, utilization,
protection and conservation of water resources, devolving ownership to the user level,
and granting secure water rights with responsibilities to the water users, community
groups, local government and basin boards;
To promote economic instruments to encourage wise use of water; and to strengthen the
capacity of basins‟ offices to address trans-boundary and lake basin issues.
WRMD Program sub-components
The WRMD component comprises of three main sub-components, namely:
(a) Sub-component 1 - Basin Level Water Resources Management: is designed to
strengthen institutional capacity for improving the management of water resources in all the
basins including the systems for water resources planning, management and development as
well as intervening in stress-reduction, the establishments of water user associations, water
resources monitoring, assessment, and enforcement, water quality management and pollution
control, protection of important water sources, and water demand management.
(b) Sub-component 2 – Integrated River and Lake basin Management and Development
plans: preparation of five integrated river basin management and development plans for the
Rufiji, Pangani, Wami/Ruvu, Ruvuma, and Internal Drainage basins, and four integrated lake
basin management and development plans for the Lakes Victoria, Tanganyika, Nyasa, and
Rukwa basins. These multi-sectoral plans will provide a roadmap for future investments in
water resources management and development from the medium to long term to be financed
under future water supply, hydropower, irrigation, flood control or multipurpose investment
programmes.
The plans will integrate, build on and extend past sectoral plans (such as the Regional Water
Masterplans, National Irrigation Development Plan and National Energy Masterplan), current
developments under ongoing Programmes (such as Nile Basin Initiative-NBI, Lake Victoria
34
Environmental Management Project-LVEMP2, Lake Tanganyika Basin Commision-LTBC2,
and current priorities and targets defined under MKUKUTA, Agriculture Sector Development
Programme (ASDP), Vision 2025 and other emerging GoT Programmes.
(c) Sub-component 3 - Priority water resources infrastructure investment: - financing of
selected priority water resources (single and multi-purpose) management and development
investments identified by Government.
The status on implementation and progress towards achieving the Program Development
Objective planned activities is detailed below:
Major achievements made in implementation of planned activities are as follows:
(i) Commencement of preparation of IWRMD Plans for Pangani, Ruvuma, Lake
Tanganyika, Lake Rukwa and Lake Nyasa basins.
(ii) Operationalization of the Water Pollution Control Strategy in all nine water basins
(iii) The inauguration of National Water Board (NWB) by the Minister for Water Hon.
Jumanne Maghembe (MP) on 26 July 2012. The board held its second meeting on 27th
July 2012.
(iv) Recruitment of Project Manager and National Project Coordinator for the Songwe River
Basin Development Program , commencement of operations of the Project office and
inauguration of the Project on 16th
July 2012.
5.1.1 Strengthening Basin Level Water Resources Management
(a) Water Resources Governance and Institutional Framework
(i) WRM Act and Regulations
Implementation of the Water Resources Management Act 11, 2009, which became effective in
August 2009, is progressing well. Its implementation is dependent on the formulation and the
gazettement of some of the requisite regulations in a number of its provisions. There are 41
sections of the WRM Act that need regulations to be developed. The WRM Act 2009 is now
operational and the process of preparing regulations is ongoing. Three Regulations which cover
14 out of 41 sections of the WRMA have been prepared and in use, draft regulations for 19
sections are under preparation while regulations for 8 sections are waiting for completion of
studies. Sections which are waiting for studies prior to preparation of regulations include;
Water resources classifications and reserve, Water abstraction charges, minimum distances for
sinking or dipping of wells or boreholes, water bodies classifications and financing and
utilization of funds in basin water boards and issuance of water use permits.
Three regulations, which have been prepared and gazetted include:-
35
Water Resources Management (Registration of Water Users Association) Regulations,
2009 (GN No 22 of 22 January 2010) – Made under sections 81(1).
Water Resources management (Water Abstraction, Use and Discharge) Regulations,
2000 (GN No 109 published on 21May 2010) – Made under sections 11(3), 12(2),
72(3) – 75(1)-(2), and 111(1).
Water Resources management (Procedure for Nomination of Board Members)
Regulations, 2000 (GN No 187 published on 21 May 2010) – Made under sections
20(3), 22(4) and 29(3).
MOW in collaboration with stakeholders is in a process to translate the Water Resources
Management Act (2009) into simple easily understandable Kiswahili version for dissemination
to the general public. Rufiji Basin with the assistance of WWF has already translated and
circulated some sections of the WRM Act (2009) in Kiswahili.
(ii) Establishment of Basin Water Boards
Basin Water Boards for 8 out of 9 Basins are in place except for Lake Tanganyika BWB whose
tenure expired in May 2012. The National Water Board is also in place and operational. The
board comprises of 11 members from irrigation, energy, environment and private sectors, while
the Director for Water Resources is the Secretary. Three members are nominated by the Basin
Water Boards through their forum. The National Water Board was inaugurated on 26th
July
2012 and is operational.
(iii) Formation of Water Users Associations and Catchment Committees
The process to form Water User Association (WUAs) is ongoing in all the 9 Water Basins.
WUAs are basic inputs in forming catchment committees. The WUAs have also been observed
to be very effective in water resources management, especially in conflicts management, and
water allocation. Up to June 2012, a total of 53 WUAs have been formed; 38 catchments and
86 sub catchments have been identified; and 8 catchment water committees formed in all 9
basins.
(iv) Granting Water Use and Discharge Permits
Basin Water Offices have continued to grant water use permits according to new WRMA and
re-register old water rights. During the FY 2011/2012, 605 new water use permits were granted
{Ruvuma (294), Lake Nyasa (44), Wami/Ruvu (89) and Lake Victoria basin (20), Rufiji (27)
and Pangani (131)}. 56 Water users were re-registered according to WRMA of 2009 in Lake
Nyasa (21) and Wami/Ruvu (35); 51 water use permits were gazetted on the Government
Gazette on 23rd March 2012 in Ruvuma Basin.
36
A total of 203 applications were processed in Wami/Ruvu (130), Internal Drainage Basin (66)
and Ruvuma (7) Basins, the process for gazettment is ongoing. By June 2012, a total of 5,907
permits have been granted in Pangani (1146), Rufiji(1044), Wami/Ruvu (1135), Lake Victoria
(400), Internal drainage (805), Lake Rukwa (136), Lake Tanganyika (209), Nyasa (308) and
Ruvuma (724).Thirty six applications in IDB are waiting for Board approval. Six discharge
permits were granted in Ruvuma (1), Wami/Ruvu (2), Lake victoria (2), and Lake Rukwa (1)
Basins. Application for two (2) discharge permits received in Wami/Ruvu Basin. All BWBs
continue with review and updating of Water Permits Register in accordance to Section 69(1) of
the WRMA. Recording of unregistered rights continues according to section 51(1) to 51(5), and
52(1) to 52(2). Fig 6. Shows Water Use Permits Issued by BWBs since FY2007/ 2008-
2011/2012.
Figure 6: Water Use Permits Issued
(b) Protection and Conservation of Water Sources
(i) Demarcation of Water Sources in all 9 Basins
Process of protecting and conserving water sources for Umba River, Selian River and Kyanga
spring carried out in Pangani Basin Water Office. Demarcation of Ruvu River is on progress,
which started from Ruvu at the Morogoro Road Bridge to downstream. Spot water quality
monitoring was done in Wami/Ruvu Basin. Orders to gazette Makutupora well field in
Wami/Ruvu Basin and Kawa Dam in Lake Rukwa Basin as protected areas were prepared and
submitted to the Attorney General for review.
37
(ii) Environment and Water Sources Conservation
In order to avoid pollution of water sources, Basin Water Offices in collaboration with other
actors, continued to implement their monitoring programmes through close follow up of
activities, which are potential sources of pollution.
The following have been done:-
Inspection was conducted to the Autrad Mining Company at Chunya District in Lake
Rukwa Basin, to examine the potential risks to the environment, and the owners were
directed to develop the area without polluting water sources.
Pollution control inspection was conducted for 14 industries, 2 hotels and 1 institution
in Rufiji Basin, of which directives were given, aimed at improving the sewerage
facilities. Water sources pollution control inspection conducted around Mtera dam and
Mwega River at Malolo - Kilosa district for checking pollution caused by TAZAMA oil
pipeline, which spread at the river due to pipe bursting.
Twenty five (25) water samples were collected and analyzed (water quality status found
to be within acceptable Tanzania/WHO standard). Monitoring visit was conducted at
Mlandizi River (Wami/Ruvu Basin), which was polluted by leaking fuel from
TAZAMA pipeline and samples were collected on 16th
December 2011 for analysis to
investigate the extent of pollution.
Water sampling from North Mara treatment plant was done in Lake Victoria Basin to
ascertain the efficient of newly installed treatment plant.
(c) Conflicts Resolution
Water use conflicts have been experienced in almost all basins among users. A total of 28 water
use conflicts were reported in 2011/2012, of which 26 were resolved in Pangani (11),
Wami/Ruvu (10), Rufiji (3) and Internal Drainage Basin (2). Two (2) conflicts have been
attended in Ruvuma Basin and resolution process is on progress. To minimize water use
conflicts, Basin Water Boards provide education and conduct awareness programmes in order
to sensitize the public on the importance of forming water user associations and when
necessary use legal authorities. Fig. 7 shows number of water use conflicts resolved since FY
2008/2009 to FY 2011/2012.
38
Figure 7: Water Use Conflicts Reported and Resolved from FY 2008/2009 to 2011/2012
(d) Providing Operational Support to the BWOs
(i) Rehabilitation/Construction of Offices
The plan was to construct/rehabilitate 36 offices including Water Basin Offices, Water
laboratories, and Catchment and Water Users Association offices in all water basins. The aim
was to have at least 9 Basin offices for each Basin completed at the average cost of USD
85,000 for each office. Progress on this activity includes construction of head quarter office for
Lake Nyasa, which started in August 2010 and as of 30th
June 2012; the work had reached 80%
of completion, expected to be completed in March 2013. Rehabilitation of office building to
accommodate JICA study team carrying out IWRM study for Wami/Ruvu Basin was
completed.
(ii) Provision of goods:
Purchase and installation of laboratory equipment have been carried out. Six lots out of 12 of
the laboratory equipment have been delivered. Equipment in the other two lots has partially
been delivered. 50% of the goods delivered have been distributed and installed in different
water quality laboratories in the country.
(e) Water Resources Monitoring
(i) Construction and Rehabilitation of Monitoring stations
Water resources monitoring and exploration equipment have been secured and are ready for
installation and use in data collection. Installation and operationalisation of the equipment will
enable the basins to carry out their mandated tasks of data collection.
39
To ensure that accurate water quality and quantity data are collected, inventory of hydrometric
monitoring stations was conducted and recommended that, 362 hydrometric stations are
required all over the country, out of which 90 are operational while 272 will be either
constructed or rehabilitated in FY 2012/2013. Three groundwater monitoring stations have
been constructed in Wami/Ruvu Basin. During the F/Y 2011/2012, minor rehabilitation was
carried out for 10 hydrometric stations and installation of meteorological facilities in 7 stations
was done in Lake Tanganyika Basin. Also, 13 rainfall stations were inspected in Lake Victoria
Basin and in Lake Rukwa Basin inspection of hydrometric stations was conducted.
Inspection of Abstractions for Compliance
Basins continued to carry out inspection of water abstractions to make sure that all users
comply to water permit conditions. Where conditions found to be violated, re-adjustment was
carried out and some were closed or demolished. Inspection was conducted for 194 abstraction
points in Great Ruaha catchment. It was observed that 45 were unauthorized canals, hence,
identified for water permit and 148 are legal abstractions. 14 canals were closed while 31
authorized canals were regulated. Abstraction points were also inspected in 11 furrows in
Pangani Basin and Kapunga irrigation scheme in Rufiji Basin.
(f) Hydro-geological Investigations and Compliance to Drilling Regulations
Hydro-geological investigations and supervision of drilling activities had been carried out in all
basins. In the F/Y 2011/2012, 563 sites were surveyed in Pangani (56), Wami/Ruvu (68), Rufiji
Basin (42) Ruvuma Basin (80), IDB (245), Lake Rukwa (22), Lake Nyasa (8), Lake
Tanganyika (14), and Lake Victoria (63) Basins. Regulations for controlling drilling activities
are under preparation. Basin Water offices have been provided with 126 equipments for
groundwater investigations. Identification and updating of information on drilling companies
continued. So far there are a total of 126 registered drilling companies operating in the country
whose activities need to be appropriately regulated. Basin Water Offices have been mandated
to monitor for compliance of water drilling permits conditions at their areas of jurisdiction. Fig.
8 shows the Status of hydrological investigations for five financial years.
40
Figure 8: Status of Hydrological Investigations for Five Years
(g) Capacity Building and Retooling
(i) Training
In order to bridge gaps of knowledge and update the technical knowhow of staff, training on
priority areas identified were conducted for a total of 61 staff from Pangani (4), Lake Nyasa
(1), Ruvuma (1), Lake Rukwa (8), Rufiji (44), and Wami/Ruvu (3). The areas covered were;
conflict resolution skills, procurement and contract management, water governance, monitoring
and evaluation, financial management and integrated water resources management (IWRM).
Also, 28 staff were trained on the use of the groundwater equipment received.
(ii) Collection of Water Users Fees
In this financial year, most of the planned activities have not been implemented due to
inadequate operational funds. A sum of Tshs. 3,915,383,824 about 16% of the projected funds
was released for the implementation period starting July 2011 to April 2012. As a result critical
activities such as installation of hydrometric equipment could not be accomplished. Water Use,
Application and other miscellaneous Fees continued to be collected in all Basins Water Offices.
Total collection of TShs. 1,594,030,475 which is 134% of the projected amount of Tshs.
1,181,000,000 has been collected.
(iii) Financial Sustainability of the Basin Water Offices
Basin Water Offices still depend to a large extent on the funds disbursed from the Ministry of
Water for implementation of all development activities and meeting some of the recurrent costs
for supporting staff, conducting minor repairs of the basin data collection stations and buildings
and for office management. In an effort to attain administrative and financial autonomy, Basin
water offices have started to widen revenue base and securing revenue from various water
users. Likewise awareness creation is being done to instil a sense of obligations to users and
41
stakeholders in paying for services received from water resources management done by the
Basin Water Offices.
Dependency of the offices is attributed to poor fee structures that do not reflect actual value for
water being abstracted by various users. For instance, according to the prevailing water use fee
tariffs, large commercial abstractor are charged Tshs. 120 only for 100m3 and small
commercial abstractors are charged Tshs. 90 only for 100m3. Beside this shortcoming, the
revenue base for charging water use is still very narrow and requires further studies.
A study for Water Resources Management - Financing Options is being undertaken and
expected to be accomplished in the FY 2012/2013. Among key outputs of this study is an
efficient and reliable fee structure and proposals for new sources of revenue. In order to
enhance basin sustainability, the Ministry has issued guidance to BWBs to set interim charges
by September 2012 and submit to the Ministry for review and Minister‟s approval by
November 2012.
Despite the low fees and inadequacy of the fees structures, still Water User Fee (WUF) is the
most prominent and reliable sources of revenue for the BWBs, others are Water User Permit
Application Fees and TANESCO Royalty.
5.1.2 Integrated River and Lake Basin Management and Development Plans
To enable efficient planning and allocation of Water Resources Integrated Water Resources
Management and Development (IWRMD) Plans preparations for Rufiji, Wami-Ruvu and
Internal Drainage Basins are at advanced stages and expected to be completed in December
2012. Consultants for preparation of the plans for Pangani, Ruvuma, Lake Nyasa, Lake Rukwa
and Lake Tanganyika have started working between January and April 2012. Procurement of
the consultant to prepare IWRM Plan for Lake Victoria is still is on progress under Lake
Victoria Basin Commission. Preparation of the IWRM Plans will consider the impact of
climate change for water resources assessment and establishing Decision Support Systems, it is
also considered that during the course of preparing IWRMD Plans, MoW and BWOs staff
training will be given a high priority so as to build their capacity as well as sustainability.
5.1.3 Priority Water Resources Infrastructure Investments
The target is to strengthen water resource management by BWOs, through the provision of
Capital Development Grants to finance WRM Subprojects. Progress made includes:-
(a) Drilling of 30 Wells
Fifteen production boreholes drilled in Sanya plains (Hai District) and pumping test done for 13
boreholes. Seven boreholes were drilled in Rombo District but only one was successful .
42
Pangani Basin water office continues to investigate on the suitable power source before
deciding on the specifications of pumps for the wells.
(b) Construction and Rehabilitation of Dams
(i) Ndembera Dam:
A contract for Consultancy service for Preparation of Feasibility Study and Detailed Design of
Lugoda Dam and Maluluma Hydropower on Ndembera River has been signed on 28th
June
2012. Negotiation for Consultancy services for preparation of ESIA studies for Lugoda dam
and Maluluma hydropower has been done
(ii) Environmental Audit for Mchema Dam:
The consultant for the environmental audit for rehabilitation of Mchema dam has been
identified and the contract is ready for signature.
(iii) Environmental Audit for six (6) Dams:
Draft contract for the consultancy services for carrying out environmental audit for the six (6)
dams has been prepared. The six dams are: Itobo, Uchama, Nkiniziwa in Nzega District and
Leken (Elenywe), Enguikument I & II in Monduli District. Rehabilitation of Dams in IDB: 12
dams will be rehabilitated in phase II of the Program. 6 dams (Leken, Enguikument I & II,
Itobo, Uchama and Nkiniziwa). Shortlisting of Consultants for supervision of rehabilitation of
Dams, preparation of RFP and bid documents for Environmental Audit for the 6 dams has been
completed.
(iv) Mandera dam in Wami Ruvu:
Four potential sites have been identified for construction of the dam upstream of Wami River at
Mandera Bridge.
(v) Borehole sites assessment in Lake Victoria Basin:
Ten boreholes sites have been identified for drilling of boreholes to augment water supply at
Ngonwa, Kisesa, Maliza - Buhongwa and Sapiwi.
5.1.3 Management of Trans-Boundary Waters
(a) Trans-boundary Water Management Treaties and Ratified Agreements
Several Transboundary Water Resources Management Initiatives are ongoing, with some
accomplishments made. The important achievements as detailed below include those made on
Lake Victoria Basin Commission, Lake Tanganyika, Lake Chala/Jipe and Umba River,
Zambezi River, and Songwe River and Nile Basin Initiative.
43
(i) Lake Victoria Basin Commission: Lake Victoria New Water Release and Abstraction
Policy
A contract to develop a Release Policy was signed between LVBC Secretariat and the
Consultant. The Consultant has submitted the final report which was discussed by Task Force.
The report was adopted by the task force, but it was noted that the New Water Release and
Abstraction Policy required more upstream abstraction data and additional studies which
include ESIA and SEA for the Policy to be implemented.
(ii) Lake Victoria Watershed Management
The objective of this component seeks to reduce environmental stresses from the lake basin
through the implementation of sustainable soil and water management practices and livelihoods
improvement interventions, using community-driven development approaches. A total of 37
projects with a total cost of USD 706,330 are now under implementation in villages within
Bariadi, Magu, Meatu, Maswa and Kwimba Districts. Within Simiyu catchment on Tanzania
side
(iii) Lake Tanganyika Authority (LTA)
The main concern at the moment is about declining Levels of Lake Tanganyika and Lukuga
River outlet in DRC. The Consultant has been engaged by COMESA, hydrological design and
ESIA studies of Lake Tanganyika and Lukuga River outlet is ongoing. Tanzania through Lake
Tanganyika Authority is making a close follow up on the progress of this project because of
the negative impact experienced on various water related activities, especially navigation for
regional shipping, transport and commerce.
(iv) Joint Cross Border Meeting on IWRM for Lake Chala, Jipe and Umba River
Ecosystem
Final draft Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) to enable the two countries of Tanzania and
Kenya to work together in the eleven areas of cooperation is in place and expected to be signed
before December, 2012. LVBC has contracted a consultant to develop the Lake Chala - Jipe
and Umba river ecosystem programme.
(b) SADC Water Programmes
(i) SADC Ministers Responsible for Water Meeting in Maseru, Lesotho
Tanzania participated in the Ministers responsible for Water from the Southern African
Development Community (SADC) met on 22nd
September 2011 in Maseru, on 23rd
September
2011. The meeting deliberated on the following:-
44
Reviewed the progress on the implementation of the second Regional Strategic Action
Plan (RSAP) on Integrated Water Resources and approved the third phase of the RSAP
as a document that will guide implementation of water related activities in the region.
Approved the Climate Change Strategy for the water sector which was launched during
the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change Conference of Parties
(UNFCC-COP) negotiations.
Reviewed the status of implementation of various projects in the various river Basins in
the SADC Region (Okavango, Limpopo, Orange-Senqu, Buzi, Save, Ruvuma, Zambezi
and Incomati/Maputo) and paid tribute to the various partners supporting the projects in
these basins. Tanzania is beneficiary of 6 community based projects under
implementation in Songea Rural, Tandahimba, Nanyumbu and Mbinga districts with a
total cost of USD 800,000
Recognized the coming into force of the Zambezi Watercourse Commission
(ZAMCOM) agreement of which Tanzania is party after six out of eight countries that
share the Zambezi River Basin completed their ratification processes and successfully
deposited their ratification instruments with the SADC Secretariat.
(ii) Zambezi Watercourse Commission (ZAMCOM)
The objective of the Commission:“is to promote the equitable and reasonable utilization of the
water resources of the Zambezi Watercourse as well as the efficient management and
sustainable development thereof.” The eight countries involved include ; The Republic of
Angola, the Republic of Botswana, the Republic of Malawi, the Republic of Mozambique, the
Republic of Namibia, the United Republic of Tanzania, the Republic of Zambia and the
Republic of Zimbabwe.
Tanzania National Stakeholders Committee (NASCs) according to ZAMCOM guideline was
established and officially since 4th April, 2012. The committee is responsible for coordination
of activities at National level. The status of activities under the commission is:
Shared Watercourse Support Project for Buzi, Save and Ruvuma:
Various projects under SADC to be funded by AfDB; the following have been achieved;
The consultant has been engaged to prepare Monographs for Ruvuma River Basin submitted
the final Monographs report on 17th
April 2012 to Ruvuma Basin and is now doing the studies
on development Scenarios for Ruvuma River.
The project is also funding six Community Based Management Projects (CBMPs) in Ruvuma
River Basin in Tanzanian side. The other two Community Management Projects are: (i) Soil
and Water Conservation for Majimaji and Lelolelo Villages located in Tunduru District and (ii)
45
Soil and Water Conservation for Nandembo and Daraja Mbili Villages located in Tunduru
District.
The two projects will be done by the Communities and Tunduru District Council under the
Supervision of Ruvuma Basin Water Board. The Project has also procured two (2) vehicles for
Ruvuma River Basin Water Board. The project is also expected to fund the drilling of five (5)
monitoring boreholes scheduled to be drilled by December 2012.
Songwe River Basin Development Programme (SRBDP)
The Songwe River, which forms part of the international boundary, between Tanzania and
Malawi has been changing its course as a result of floods rendering the boundary unstable. The
two countries formulated the Songwe River Basin Development Programme to improve the
social and economic development in the basin and stabilize the course of the river.
The program involves 3 Phases: (i) Feasibility study; (ii) Detailed Design and (iii)
Implementation.
Phase I of Feasibility study was completed in 2003 which paved a way to Phase II of the
SRBDP of Detailed Design and Investment Preparation Project from 2004. Several meetings of
the Joint Committee of Officials (JCO), the Joint Team of Experts (JTE) and Joint Steering
Committee (JSC) were held between September, 2009 and March 2011 to prepare a
Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) between the two Countries for the Detailed Design of
Works and Investment Preparations. Tanzania signed the MoU on 8th March, 2011 while
Malawi signed on 5th April, 2011 and the MoU was sent to African Development Bank.
After signing the MoU, Terms of References (TOR) for all Project components were developed
jointly between Malawi and Tanzania and were accepted by the African Development Bank
which is a major financier of the Programme.
Activities performed include:-
Project Manager and National Project Coordinator (NPC) for Tanzania for SRBDP have
been recruited and reported on duty.
Process to procure of a consultant to carry out Detailed Design and Investment
Preparation Project for identified projects under SRBDP is going on.
Projects identified include design of dams for hydropower production, irrigation, water
supply, fishing, navigation, recreation, road development and flood control through
river training which will result in the stabilization of Songwe River.
Inauguration of the project was done on 16th
July 2012.
46
(iv) Negotiation on boundary dispute between Malawi and Tanzania on Lake Nyasa
Tanzania efforts to resolve boundary dispute between Malawi and Tanzania on Lake Nyasa
started after Independence, Records show that Tanzania wrote a letter to Malawi government to
address the issue on January, 1967 but Malawi government did not show a good will to
cooperate. Tanzania did not despair and in 2005 official communication resumed again and
reinforced in 2010. Negotiation between our sister countries is ongoing, by engagement of joint
team of experts, including one from Ministry of Water, Permanent Secretaries from Ministries
of Foreign Affairs and Lands, Housing and Human Settlement and Ministers of Foreign Affairs
and Lands.
(c) Nile Basin Initiative
The Nile Basin Initiative is a partnership among the Nile riparian states that “seeks to develop
the river in a cooperative manner, share substantial socio-economic benefits, and promote
regional peace and security.
(i) Status of Projects under Nile Equatorial Subsidiary Action Progamme
The Nile Equatorial Lakes Subsidiary Action Program (NELSAP) oversees the implementation
of the jointly identified projects and promotes cooperative inter-country and in country
investment projects related to the common use of the Nile Basin water resources. The Program
promotes investments in power development and trade, water resources management,
management of lakes, fisheries and watersheds as well as agricultural trade and productivity.
The following is the status of implementation of agreed projects in the Financial Year
2011/2012.
(ii) Kagera Transboundary Integrated Water Resources Management and Development
Project
The objective of Kagera Transboundary Integrated Water Resources Management and
Development Project (KTIWRMDP) is to develop tools and permanent cooperative
mechanisms for the joint management of the water resources in the Kagera River Basin in order
to prepare for sustainable development investments geared towards the improvement of the
living conditions of the people and to protect the environment.
On-going Implementation: The following activities have been undertaken, namely;
Integrated Watershed Management Feasibility Study; Water Resources Development for
Multipurpose Uses study and ESIA study; The Kagera Basin-wide Development Plan study and
the Assessment of the Climate Change Impacts, Vulnerability and Adaptation in the Kagera
River Basin. The PMU also is supervising a study on Kagera water allocation model and dams
identification study.
Capacity Building: The Kagera PMU has organized several trainings including training
in Climate Change, training on the use of MIKE BASIN Model, which was attended by 18
47
water resources experts from the Basin, training on Integrated Water Resources Management
attended by 23 Kagera riparian officials from water ministries, and a training in Environmental
and Social Impact Assessment which was attended by 32 officers from riparian countries.
Hydrometric network: The second hydrometric equipment lot ordered from M/s OTT
MESSTECHNIK, GmbH & Co comprising of Counter Set OTT Z400 incl. Battery with
velocity calc. and AWLR (Complete) with Data Logger/Accessories have been shipped and
will be distributed to the countries. A consultant has been hired and is in the field carrying out
installation.
(iii) Mara River Basin Integrated Water Resources Management and Development
Project
Mara River Basin Management Project is a Bilateral Agreement between the Republic of
Kenya and the United Republic of Tanzania on joint co-operation for the sustainable
management and equitable utilization of shared water resources of Mara River. The following
is the status of implementation in the FY 2011/12.
Feasibility Study of Small Dams of Norera and Borenga: The hired firm undertook a
topographical survey of the two proposed sites, Norera in Kenya and Borenga in Tanzania.
Also Socio-economic surveys have been conducted for both dam sites and a report complied.
Assessment for irrigation potential and suitable crops for the Mara River Irrigation command
area has been undertaken.
Undertaking Environmental and Social Impact Assessment and Preparation of
Resettlement Action Plan: The consultant held public consultations with communities of
Norera dam site in Kenya and Borenga-Mrito dam site in Tanzania.
Installation of Hydrometric Equipment: The Project procured two individual
consultants, one from Tanzania and the other from Kenya to install hydrometric equipment.
The installation exercise is going on in the Kenyan side while the same has been completed on
Tanzania side and handed over to the Lake Victoria Basin Water Office (LVBWO), Musoma.
Training on operation and maintenance is planned for September 2012 and will involve
technicians from Lake Victoria South Catchment Area (LVSCA), in Mara Basin, Kenya and
LVBWO in Musoma.
Tanzania Irrigation Development and watershed management project: Starting from
July 08, the Consultant commenced their third round of field work. During the field work
program, they undertook the soil and socio-economic surveys for the three proposed sites
(Mara valley, Bugwema, and Ngono). The Consultant has started analysis of soil samples and
other collected data.
NEL Multi Sector Investment Opportunity Analysis: The Consultant has finalized and
submitted the NEL Strategic Social and Environmental Assessment for review. A Situational
Analysis Workshop was held in Kigali on July 25, 2012 to discuss both reports: the Situational
48
Analysis and Strategic Social and Environmental Assessment reports. Comments from the
stakeholders were compiled, and those from the Peer Reviewers are awaited in order to forward
them to the Consultants for consideration in the next reporting period.
Aswa Multipurpose WRD Project Consultancy: A Situational Analysis report on
multipurpose project identification was received on July 16, 2012, and circulated among the
The Consultant is finalizing the Situational Analysis report.
(iv) Regional Rusumo Falls Hydro-Electric and Multi-Purpose Project (RRFP)
Contract with SNC Lavalin Inc. of Montreal Canada: The consultant has completed the study
and submitted draft ESIA and Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) report for the Intermediate
Development Scheme (IDS) as per the agreed revised TOR for the study- from Full
development Scheme (FDS) to IDS. In February, 2012, the three governments recommended
that due to high cost for mitigating the ESIA, Run off River Scheme be studied. TORS for
these studies were developed by NELSAP in February, 2012 and submitted to SNC Lavalin
who submitted technical and financial proposal for carrying out this study.
(v) Lake Victoria Environmental Management Program
Lake Victoria Environmental Management Project Phase Two (LVEMP II) is an 8 years (2009
- 2017) regional project implemented in the 5 East Africa Community partner states of the
Republics of Kenya, Burundi, Rwanda, Uganda and the United Republic of Tanzania. The
project has been designed to address major environmental concerns in Lake Victoria Basin
which have had adverse impact on the LVB ecosystem, as well as the region‟s economy and
livelihoods.
In summary, the following are main achievements;
(i) A total of 37 Community Driven Development Projects (CDD) sub projects with an
estimated cost of USD 706,330 have been approved.
(ii) MoUs to facilitate implementation for 28 CDD sub projects amounting to USD 512,656
have been signed and Bank account opened ready for funding.
(iii) 56 livelihood CDD sub project proposals were prepared and tabled for approval by
NTAC/NPSC.
(iv) Six draft proposals for district-based strategic interventions on Natural Resources
conservation (Kwimba 2, Meatu 1, Maswa 2 and Mwanza City 1) were jointly
reviewed.
(v) Training manuals on 9 thematic modules for CDD implementation have been prepared.
(vi) ToT for DFLTs conducted training to Sub-projects‟ Community Management
Committees.
(vii) Environmental screening of nine (9) CDD sub projects that were approved by NPSC.
49
(viii) Verification of 41 proposed district strategic interventions for all five districts of the
Simiyu catchment.
(ix) Finalisation and polishing of environmental screening reports of the approved CDD sub
projects.
5.1.4 Water Quality Compliance and Strengthening Water Laboratories
(i) Water Quality Compliance
During the reporting period some achievement have been made through monitoring water
quality for domestic uses, water sources and pollution control whereby 6727 water samples out
of 8,000 that targeted were collected and analysed for compliance (as indicated in Figure 9).
Figure 9: Water Quality Compliance
A total of 4,668 water samples analysed were found to be within the recommended limit. 371
water samples indicated not to comply with the required standards due to feacal contamination
thus continuous monitoring was carried out to determine the cause of contamination and
responsible authorities were advice to disinfect water before being supplied. 1,014 water
samples collected in the coastal areas were found to be saline and the advice was to find
alternative water sources of good quality water. 674 water samples collected from lakes and
rivers had high content of nitrates and phosphorous, this indicates the possibility of
eutrophication of our water bodies.(figure 10)
50
Figure 10: Water of Unacceptable Quality
To ensure that effluents discharge to the water bodies are within the allowable limit for
pollution control; wastewater samples were collected on monthly basis from different
wastewater treatment facilities in Dar es salaam, Mwanza, Tanga, Morogoro, Dodoma, Bukoba
and Iringa. A total of 678 wastewater samples out of 1,000 were collected and analysed during
the entire period whereby 525 samples were found to be within recommended limit to be
discharged to the environment while 153 samples were found not to comply with the standard,
advices were given on this matter to the authorities concern.
In order to ensure that the efficacy of the water treatment chemicals is within the required
standards; 57 chemical samples were analysed 22 Aluminum Sulphate, 15 Polyaluminum
Chloride and 20 Calcium Hypochlorite). 52 samples of chemicals were of acceptable quality
for treating water to fit the intended use while 5 chemical samples of Polyaluminum Chloride
indicated to have low strength thus not fit for intended purposes. Advices were given on this
matter to the authorities concern.( figure 11)
51
Figure 11: Efficacy of Water Treatment Chemicals
(ii) Strengthening Water Laboratories
Under WSDP, it is planned to strengthen the Water quality Laboratories through provion of
equipment, training and office building and rehabilitation. About 50% of the procured
equipments have been distributed to 16 Regional Laboratories and installed.
22 laboratories staff have been trained on ISO 17025 (Quality Assurance), this is being one of
requirement for the improving the performance of the water quality laboratories as well as
accreditation processes.
5.1.5 Achievements vs Planned (MKUKUTA) Targets
Goal 2: Reducing income poverty through promoting inclusive,
sustainable, and employment‐enhancing growth and development
Percentage
The operational targets Performance
1. Participatory integrated water
resource development, allocation
and management for productive
use and environmental
sustainability assured
Basin Water Boards for 8 out of 9
Basins water Offices are in place
except for Lake Tanganyika BWB
whose tenure expired in May 2012. A
total of 53 WUAs have been formed;
38 catchments and 86 sub catchments
have been identified; and 8 catchment
water committees formed in all 9
basins
About
56 %
implemented
2. Integrated River and Lake Basin
Management and Development
Plans
in place by 2015
Consultants for preparation of IWRM
plans for 8 basins of Rufiji, Internal
Drainage, Wami/Ruvu, Pangani,
Ruvuma, Rukwa, Nyasa and
Tanganyika are currently in the field
working at various stages.
Consultants for Rufiji, Internal
Drainage and Wami/Ruvu Basins are
at the advance stages expected to
complete by June 2013.
About
30%
implemented
3. Number of monitoring (water and
meteorology) stations regularly
producing reliable data increased
from 83 in 2009 to 438 by 2015
90 hydrometric stations are
reasonably good working condition
and 272 stations require rehabilitation
or upgrading or construction. Minor
rehabilitation were carried out for 10
hydrometric stations at Kalambo,
Karema, Nzubuka at Railway Bridge,
Ipala, Mlawezi at Uvinza Rd Bridge,
Msenguse at Ikola, Luamfi at Masola,
About
25%
implemented
52
Samba at Masola, Igombe and
Utyatya Dam in Lake Tanganyika
Basin
4. Forty five failed dams
rehabilitated and 3 major new
dams built
Consultant for Preparation of
Feasibility Study and Detailed Design
of Lugoda Dam and Maluluma
Hydropower on Ndembera River has
been engaged. Contract signed on
28th June 2012. Negotiation for
Consultancy services for preparation
of ESIA studies for Lugoda dam and
Maluluma hydropower has been done
5. Participatory climate change
adaptation measures at catchment/
water
user association level initiated
Climate change issues are considered
in preparation of IWRM plans for all
basins, Process to engage consultant
to prepare Climate Change
Adaptation Strategy for Water
Resources Management is ongoing
About 10%
implemented
5.1.6 Water Resources Management Challenges
The following are the growing WRM concerns and challenges:
(i) Acute water use conflicts experienced in many parts of the country especially in
Pangani, Internal drainage, Rufiji and Lake Rukwa Basins.
(ii) Illegal water abstractions
(iii) Growing tensions – encroachment and degradation of water sources as a result of
growing human development activities in water catchments.
(iv) Increasing pollution from mining and industrial activities.
(v) Degradation in key catchments and groundwater recharge areas.
(vi) Inadequate funding of the Basin Water Boards and low water Use fees which do not
suffice the operation of basin activities.
5.2 COMPONENT 2: RURAL WATER SUPPLY AND SANITATION
During the financial year 2011/2012, Component 2 made a significant development towards
increasing access to clean and safe water and basic sanitation services. This has been done
through Local Government Authorities Management Support, National Sanitation Campaigns
and Investment in RWSS Sub-components.
53
5.2.1 Local Government Authorities Management Support Subcomponent
This subcomponent provides support to LGAs' management issues aimed at strengthening their
capacity to carry out the planned interventions. The summary of status of implementation is
provided after each sub-strategic intervention under here.
(i) Monitoring implementation of WSDP
It was planned to have a field visits to selected LGAs for follow up of boreholes' drilling
activities, water point mapped areas, financing, contracts data entry into water sector MIS and
operation and maintenance of constructed sub projects both earmarked and quickwin projects.
(ii) Preparation of WSDP Reports
Three types of progress reports namely, quarterly, semi-annually and annually were to be
prepared. The first quarter, second quarter, semi-annual, third quarter and annual progress
reports from LGAs, RSs and MoW were prepared and consolidated into a WSDP report.
(iii) Supervision and Monitoring by CWSTs
It was planned that CWSTs to supervise and monitor consultants in the implementation of
RWSS projects phase I contracts. CWSTs have been supervising and monitoring consultants
and borehole drillers who were part of RWSS subprojects implementation team. One of the key
tasks in CWSTs was the review of consultants' documentations. The approval of payments to
consultants was another key activity. Furthermore, during the implementation period, physical
project inspections were conducted through field visits.
(iv) RSs and PMO-RALG Oversight to LGAs
It was planned that RSs had to provide technical oversight to LGAs by reviewing designs and
tender documents, contracts for drilling and supervision options and construction of sub
projects in some of the ten selected villages in each LGA. Generally, the task was clearly
conducted as per plan; though shortage of finances remained as a potential challenge for their
maximum performance. PMO-RALG consolidated reports from RSs, which normally are
shared with the Ministry of Water.
(v) Promote Private Sector Participation
Due to inadequate participation of the private sector in the water sector, a consultant was
engaged to study the prevailing bottlenecks and recommend the necessary measures required.
A contract was signed between MoW the firm, which won the tender on 10th
April 2012. After
preparation of inception report, the firm has started to gather information from LGAs and
elsewhere for preparation of the final report.
(vi) Preparation and execution of ICT at LGAs and RSs levels
54
Planed activities were identification and procurement of items to be installed in the ICT rooms
in LGAs and RSs. Items were identified, of which its procurement is in progress, expecting to
complete in September 2012 to allow installation to take place later.
(vii) Implementation of CD plans at LGAs and RSs levels
The activity was planned for implementation in the same financial year but since no funds were
released; the task was not executed.
(viii) Provide training and deploy program management support consultant
It was planned to engage a consultant to assist the Rural Water Supply Division on matters of
program management. The contract was signed on 25th
June 2012 and the consultant is
executing the contract activities. ToR is being reviewed to include most of the implementing
challenges facing component 2.
(ix) Rehabilitation and construction of offices
Under this activity, no office was rehabilitated or constructed in the year 2011/2012. This
activity will continue to be implemented in phase II of WSDP.
(x) Provision of goods, such as vehicles, motor cycles, computers and office equipment:
In this FY 2011/2012, it was planned to purchase one vehicle and 6 computers. Specifications
for vehicles and laptops are in place, but no funds were released to facilitate procurement
process.
(xi) Strengthen the capacity of communities to operate and maintain water and sanitation
services
Priority was given to formation and registration of water user entities. 110 LGAs have
appointed registrars of COWSOs according to The Water Supply and Sanitation (Registration
of Community Owned Water Supply Organisations) Regulations, 2009, GN. No. 21 of
22/01/2010.
(xii) Promote sanitation and hygiene in collaboration with line Ministries
It was planned that to participate in national events of promoting sanitation and hygiene such as
Maji Week, International toilet day etc. The Maji week event was conducted though the
International toilet day event did not effect due to lack of funds.
(xiii) Conduct water point mapping
In order to have non-conflicting data on the number of water points available and the rural
population served, it was planned to carry out a water point mapping. The consultant conducted
55
a survey, whereby 63 LGAs with 2,042 wards and 4,985 villages were adjusted. The survey
mapped 35,641 public water points, out of which 23,545 (66.1 %) points were found functional
while 12,096 (33.9%) were non - functional.
From September 2011 to April 2012, data collection was done in 19 LGAs and prototype web
based monitoring system developed. Equipment including server and GPS for LGAs are under
procurement process. As of April 2012, 82 LGAs had been mapped. The contract was
scheduled to end in December 2011 but due to lack of timely fund release, the task was delayed
while extension of the contract is in advanced stage.
Table 14: Summary on Status of Water Point Mapping Survey
S/
N
Region No.
of
LGA
s
No.
of
War
ds
No. of
Villag
es
Physical Status of Water Points
Function
al
Non
Function
al
Total % of
Functio
nal
% of
Non
Function
al
1 Coast 7 187 465 2076 139 2215 93.7 6.3
2 Dodoma 6 272 561 2303 1496 3799 60.6 39.4
3 Iringa 8 371 821 5145 1581 6726 76.5 23.5
4 Kagera 8 310 733 2752 1530 4282 64.3 35.7
5 Mbeya 7 246 554 3727 2418 6145 60.7 39.3
6 Morogo
ro
6 209 560 2335 1290 3625
64.4 35.6
7 Mwanza 7 142 422 2660 1951 4611 57.7 42.3
8 Rukwa 5 66 139 503 675 1178 42.7 57.3
9 Tanga 9 269 730 2044 1016 3060 66.8 33.2
Total 63 2,072 4,985 23,545 12,096 35,641 66.1 33.9
The 33.9% of the non functional mapped water points is due to the following reasons:
Uneasy access of spare parts;
Inadequate design of water supply schemes;
Water supply infrastructures including boreholes getting beyond their service life;
Shortage of funds to conduct monitoring;
Missing, theft and damage to electrical and mechanical components
Breakage in transmission/ distribution network
Community disputes
Low pressure in the distribution system
56
Damaged one of water supply infrastructures due to the fact that the water point or
water source is not protected and more;
Damage due to floods
Financial sustainability: most schemes are financially unsustainable due to poor
collection of water revenues at the potable point;
Absence of pumping machinery at source; and
A lack of beneficiaries‟ sense of ownership on water supply services.
(xiv) RUWASACAD Phase II
The water sector has been implementing a Rural Water Supply and Sanitation Capacity
Development (RUWASACAD) phase 2, with the purpose to enhance implementation of the
Capacity Development of RWSTs, CWSTs and BWOs. The project area includes three regions
(Tabora, Singida and Mwanza) and six LGAs (Sikonge, Uyui, Singida, Manyoni, Kwimba and
Sengerema districts). From July 2011 to April 2012, preparation, submission and discussion of
inception report were done and implementation of the baseline survey by a consultant was
done. Furthermore, excursion of staff for technical training in Japan was conducted while
training of participants from the project areas was done in Mwanza City and Tabora
Municipality.
(xv) Development of Sustainability Strategy
A two days stakeholders‟ forum to discuss and identify sustainability issues and challenges for
the Rural Water Supply projects was conducted to prepare inputs for the sustainability strategy.
The workshop was held from on 3rd
and 4th
of July 2012. The workshop participants included
DPs, NGOs, CBOs, Regional Secretariats, LGAs and selected representatives from water user
entities. A consultation meeting with PMO-RALG on their role in sustainability of Rural Water
Supply Projects will be held on 31st July to 1
st August 2012.
5.2.2 Implementation of National Sanitation Campaign and School – WASH
(a) National Sanitation Campaign
In response to issues raised during the restructuring plan MoHSW, MoEVT and PMO-RALG
launched the National Sanitation Campaign (NSC). This campaign aims at implementing a
household sanitation initiative under the leadership of MoHSW to stimulate and improve
demand and supply through a combination of Community Led Total Sanitation (CLTS),
Sanitation Marketing and other approaches; expanding and accelerating the pace of School
Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene (SWASH) activities focusing on improving school sanitation
infrastructure. Moreover, the two (Household Sanitation and School Water, Sanitation and
57
Hygiene) sub-strategic interventions are implemented jointly by MoHSW, MoEVT, PMO-
RAGL and MOW.
Planned activities in the area were identifying 42 local government authorities where
interventions would take place, prepare National WASH strategy, engaging consultants to
develop training and promotional materials; prepare concepts and messages and advertise in the
TV and Radio.
42 LGAs from 12 regions for implementation of National Sanitation Campaign have been
selected; National WASH Strategy has been prepared and approved by management. MoHSW
coordinates the implementation of the NSC. The campaign has started in 42 LGAs as the point
of start, which then will expand proportionately into the remaining LGAs. The implementation
of the activities stipulated in the Action Plan has started implementation, particularly at national
level. To date the status of implementation is as follows;
(i) The ToR for the consultancy services on Consumer Market Research has been prepared
and submitted to the Ministry of Water and thereafter will be forwarded to the World
Bank for No Objection.
(ii) The ToR for the consultancy service on the Development of Concepts and Messages for
driving the campaign has been prepared and submitted to the Ministry of Water and
later to World Bank for No Objection
(iii) Guidelines (Sanitation Option Manual and CLTS facilitation guidelines) have been
developed and disseminated to District Health Officers, District Education Officers and
Regional Health Officers
(iv) The national sanitation campaign was launched at the World Environment Day in
Moshi Municipality by H. E Dr. Jakaya Mrisho Kikwete; the President of United
Republic of Tanzania.
(v) Training of CLTS facilitators has been conducted, whereby 105 District Health Officers
and Community Development Officers from 42 LGAs were trained on CLTS
facilitation.
(b) School - Water, Sanitation and Hygiene (School - WASH) Campaign
The importance of school WASH is recognized in national policy. The new MKUKUTA II, for
example, has included a specific target that 100% of schools should have adequate sanitation.
The Ministries of Education and Vocation Training (MoEVT), Health and Social Welfare
(MoHSW), Water (MoW) and the Prime Minister‟s Office Regional Administration and Local
Government (PMO-RALG) have emphasized the importance of school WASH. The Ministry
of Education and Vocational Training has been implementing the School Sanitation campaign
58
activities through rehabilitation of sanitation facilities in Schools. 88 schools are targeted for
the first phase. The fund has been incorporated into the Ministry and Local Government
Authorities (LGAs) plans.
(c) Achievements
The MoEVT has performed the following activities as a background of implementing the
Sanitation Campaign.
(i) Complete and approval of National Strategic Plan for School Water Sanitation and
Hygiene.
(ii) Training of Regional Education Officers for ten regions whereby the sanitation
Campaign will be conducted.
(iii) Training of National facilitators (83) who will sensitize the awareness on the sanitation
campaign from school level to teachers‟ training colleges.
(iv) Training of District Education Officers from 42 LGAs.
(v) Mapping of SWASH actors in Tanzania.
(vi) Developing of SWASH Guideline, which was successfully piloted in three districts by
construction of latrines and provision of water systems and hand washing facilities. The
guideline has been distributed to 42 LGAs for implementation of SWASH Campaign.
During Sanitation campaign 88 schools were identified for rehabilitation of WASH
facilities.
(vii) Formation of SWASH Clubs in schools in some LGAs where the campaign will take
place like Makete, Iringa Municipal, Mufindi, Kibondo and Kibaha.
(d) Way Forward
(i) To rehabilitate schools immediately after LGAs received fund from BoT.
(ii) The Ministry to verify the selected schools and create awareness on sanitation
campaign.
(iii) National facilitators to conduct community mobilization of resource for rehabilitation of
latrines.
(iv) Training of school committee and schools by using child to child approach on hand
washing practices and proper use of latrines.
5.2.3 Investments in RWSS Subprojects
The sub-component consist of several activities as; construction, drilled of wells, boreholes and
installation of hand pumps, piped systems using pumped water from boreholes or gravity fed
water from springs or rivers, procurement of the technical and facilitation service providers and
hand pump supply chain. The strategic objective for investments in RWSS subprojects are
59
carried out through earmarked projects (by GoT and DPs) and the construction of 10 selected
village water schemes in the first phase in each LGA under basket fund modality.
Planned activities were to finance and coordinate the implementation of 34 earmarked
contracted works funded by government, implement JICA financed water projects in Mwanza,
Mara and Tabora regions, implement BADEA financed water projects in Same, Mwanga and
Korogwe, implement KfW financed water projects in Moshi rural and Hai Districts. Other
planned activities were implementing LGDG financed water projects in LGAs and construction
of small and medium dams in LGAs. The status of implementation is as follows:
(a) Procurement of technical and facilitation service providers to assist communities in
carrying out designs and supervision of works
By June 2012, 130 LGAs out of 132 had procured and signed contracts with consulting firms
for provision of the technical and facilitation of service delivery in their respective jurisdiction.
Morogoro District Councils is yet to engage a consultant while the Musoma Municipality is
using the consultant engaged Musoma Urban Water Supply and Sewerage Authority.
(b) Implementation status of sub projects in 10 selected villages in each LGA
Up to July 2012, the status of implementation in the LGAs is as follows:
62 LGAs have attained “no objection” from MoW to start construction of water sub
projects in some of the villages. Out of those 62; 26 LGAs already signed contracts with the
supervision consultants and contractors; and construction works have started. The
remaining 28 LGAs have signed contracts with supervision consultants and contractors;
construction works shall start after contractors have mobilized.
The 62 LGAs are Kilolo DC and Iringa MC (Iringa); Ludewa DC, Makete DC and Njombe
DC (Njombe); Biharamulo DC, Bukoba DC, Karagwe DC and Bukoba MC (Kagera); Hai
DC, Mwanga DC and Same DC (Kilimanjaro); Kilwa DC, Lindi MC, Liwale DC, Lindi
DC, Nachingwea DC and Ruangwa DC (Lindi); Babati DC, Babati TC and Mbulu DC
(Manyara); Bunda DC and Serengeti DC (Mara); Mbarali DC, Mbozi DC, Chunya DC,
Mbeya CC, Kyela DC and Rungwe DC (Mbeya); Kilombero DC and Ulanga DC
(Morogoro); Masasi DC, Mtwara MC, Newala DC, Mtwara DC, Nanyumbu DC and
Tandahimba DC (Mtwara); Kwimba DC, Sengerema DC, Misungwi DC and Ukerewe DC
(Mwanza); Kibaha DC, Kibaha TC and Rufiji DC (Pwani); Mpanda DC and Mpanda TC
(Katavi); Tunduru DC and Mbinga DC (Ruvuma); Bukombe DC (Geita); Kahama DC,
Kishapu DC and Shinyanga DC (Shinyanga); Maswa DC and Meatu DC (Simiyu); Iramba
DC, Manyoni DC and Singida DC (Singida); Tabora MC and Nzega DC (Tabora); Kilindi
DC, Mkinga DC and Pangani DC (Tanga).
60
53 LGAs have attained the “no objection” from MoW to advertise tenders for construction
of water projects and at various stages of implementation. Out of those 26 LGAs have
acquired contractors and are waiting for “no objection” for supervision consultants in order
to sign contracts. 16 LGAs have advertised tenders and at various stages of evaluation and
preparation of contracts. The remaining 11 LGAs are in the final processes of advertising
the tenders.
The remaining LGAs are at different stages as follows:
4 LGAs have completed drilling of boreholes and are designing sub projects;
9 LGAs are drilling boreholes as water sources;
In 1 LGA, the consultant is preparing a scoping study;
In 1 LGA, the consultant is gathering information for preparation of inception report;
1 LGA of Musoma MC is implementing sub projects through Musoma UWSA;
Morogoro DC has not yet engaged consultant.
The Morogoro DC received both technical and financial proposals from six shortlisted firms.
After evaluation of technical proposals, it proceeded to open the financial proposals. In the
process of opening the financial proposals, financial proposal from one firm was missing. The
procurement process is to be repeated, whereby a consultant is expected to be in place by
December 2012.
(c) Status on Construction/Rehabilitation of Medium Size Dams in Drought Prone Areas
For the period from July 2011 to June 2012, implementation of construction of dams continued,
from which the following medium size dams in semi arid areas were being implemented:
Wegero (Musoma) dam was completed; and construction /rehabilitation of the other 7 medium
sized dams of Habiya (Bariadi), Seke Ididi (Kishapu), Iguluba (Iringa), Kawa (Nkasi), Sasajila
(Chamwino), Matwiga (Chunya) and Mwanjoro (Meatu) is ongoing.
(d) Hand Pump Supply Chain - Expand the existing supply chain of private retail outlets
to ensure the availability of equipment such as water pumps and spare parts; and
maintenance services for RWSS sub-projects
The original plan was to engage a consultant to study on the hand pump supply chain only.
However, it was later agreed to include other water supply facilities required for construction
and maintenance of water supply schemes. The revised ToR for engaging a consultant to make
studies on the supply chain was submitted to the World Bank on 12th
March 2012 and a
reminder sent on 24th
April 2012 for no objection.
5.2.4 Achievements vs. Planned (MKUKUTA II) Targets
61
Based on MKUKUTA II, the Rural Water Supply and Sanitation component planned to
increase access to clean and safe water supply from 58.7% in 2009 to 65% in June 2015, which
is equivalent to addition of 2.22 million new beneficiaries in rural areas by 2015. On the part of
sanitation, the target was to increase the percentage of population with improved sanitation at
household level from 23% in 2010 to 35% by 2015 and making sure that proportional of
schools with improved sanitation facilities increased.
As per December 2011 the trend shows that water coverage is at 56.6%. The decline is due to
various reasons; including drying off of water sources as a result of droughts in various parts of
the country; poor sustainability of water schemes due to lack of ownership, missing of spare
parts and competent technical personnel to support operations and maintenance and low
investment level compared to the population growth in rural areas.
Table 15: Number of People with Access to Water Supply Service in Rural Areas from
Year 2009 to 2011
Year No. of People with Access to Water Supply in Rural Areas
2009 19,685,659
2010 20,545,945
2011 20,634,227
62
Figure 12: Trends in Rural Water Supply Coverage based on Functioning Water
Facilities
5.2.5 Assessment against MDG Targets
The MDG trajectory for water supply coverage in rural areas was supposed to increase by at
least 1.53% point per annum since the year 2000 (the millennium summit year), which implies
that it was supposed to increase from 48% in 1990 to 51% in 2000, to 55.9% in 2003, to
63.24% in 2008, and to 66.4 in 2010; so as to attain the 74% anticipated MDG service coverage
by 2015. According to the routine data system, the actual trend indicates an increase from 48%
in 1990, to 51% in 2000, to 53% in 2003 to 57.1% in 2007, to 57.8% in 2010, to 56.6% in
2011. This is an increase of 8.6% during the 1990- 2011 period. That means, in order to meet
the MDG target of 74% by 2015; there still remain 17.4% of people without access that are
supposed to be covered with service by 2015. This indicates that attaining MDG target for
water supply service in the rural areas is off track.
According to statistics, more than 90% of the household population in the rural areas have
access to basic sanitation; hence the country appears to be on track to meet the sanitation target
of the 2015. However, it is difficult to conclude on overall sanitation as WASH facilities and
practice in schools and health facilities (facility for client) have no baseline data in MKUKUTA
II.
63
Figure 13: Rural Water Supply Service Coverage in Regions of Tanzania Mainland by
December 2011
5.2.6 Challenges in RWSS
(i) Communication Channels in IAs
Channelling relevant communication to the designated officers in a timely manner in order to
ensure that issues are addressed and participating agencies represented at meetings remains a
major challenge in coordination of component 2 activities. The suggestion made at one of the
TWG meeting to identify focal point officers at MoHSW, MoEVT and PMO-RALG as a
means of improving the coordination to bring a closer follow-up of the RWSS planned
activities.
(ii) Financing
Despite the high population in the rural areas, sector financing remains low compared to
investments made in urban and small towns.
(iii) Water Schemes Sustainability
The sector faces considerable capacity challenge at community level. COWSOs have been
given sustainability responsibilities. However, they lack effective tools and experience in
managing schemes.
(iv) Technology Options
Due to increase in the level of development in rural areas, the major shift in the selection of
water supply technologies by communities from the program preference of hand pump schemes
to piped scheme has resulted in increasing the investment unit costs. More precautions are
required as we move to WSDP II where we need to provide more education on the unit costs of
investments and operational and maintenance costs to communities who have the responsibility
on sustainability.
(v) Climate change
Some of the projects whose sources were providing adequate water services to the communities
have been drying up during dry season. This situation affects coverage and therefore decreasing
service levels. The LGAs are working closely with other stakeholders to carry out mitigation
measures to ensure that the infrastructure have sustainable water supply.
(vi) Low Capacity at LGAs and RSs levels
64
The capacity of LGAs in terms of human resources, equipment and systems is still inadequate
to meet WSDP implementation requirements. More LGAs and RSs are being established and
available facilities are not sufficient to the LGAs and RSs already in place. The developed
capacity development plans are the start points for capacity building but inadequate resources is
the setback that needs special attention.
(vii) Low capacity of the private sector in executing works
There is low capacity of private sector in construction activities. This was evidenced during
construction of small-scale schemes (quick-wins) and boreholes drilling (for 10 villages)
whereby in some LGAs re-advertisement was made to meeting the procurement requirements.
The MoW will continue carrying out awareness creation to make private sector participate in
rural Water supply projects.
5.3 COMPONENT 3: URBAN WATER SUPPLY AND SANITATION
Component 3 of WSDP provides support to improve utility performance in the DAWASA
service area that includes Dar es Salaam, Kibaha, Bagamoyo and some parts of Mkuranga; 19
Regional Urban Water Supply and Sanitation (UWSSs) utilities and a total of 109 and District
and Small Towns, as well as, 7 National schemes in the provision of water and sanitation
services. According to the new Water Supply and Sanitation Act No. 12 of 2009, the 19
regional Urban Water Supply and Sanitation Authorities, are graded under four categories of
AA, A, B and C as follows:
(i) Category „AA‟: Those with water service coverage of more than 85% and meet all
operation and maintenance costs, depreciation and return on investment.
(ii) Category „A‟: Those with water service coverage of more than 75% and meet all
operational and maintenance costs and depreciation.
(iii) Category „B‟: Those with water service coverage of more than 65% and meet all
operational and maintenance costs.
(iv) Category „C‟: Those with water service coverage of less than 65% and meet
operational costs except part of plant electricity costs as shall be determined in the MoU.
Figure 14 shows categories of UWSAs.
65
Figure 14: Regional UWSSAs Categories
Component 3 has two sub-components namely:
(i) Management support for Urban Water Supply and Sanitation Authorities; and
(ii) Urban WSS investments (Works as well as Goods and Services).
5.3.1 Urban Water Supply and Sanitation Authorities Management Support
The thrust of this sub-component includes strengthening the capacity of Urban Water and
Sanitation Authorities through the provision of Capacity Building Grants. In this FY
2011/2012 this sub-component was planned to provide support in the following areas:-
(i) Rehabilitation and Construction of UWSSAs offices
The target was to continue with construction of Babati new office and procure works for
Sumbawanga UWSSA. The construction progress of new office in Babati UWSSA has
reached 32%, works are in progress, whereas the detailed design and tender documents for
Sumbawanga are completed. Procurement of works for 3 offices in small towns of Mpwapwa,
Utete, and Tunduma is also ongoing at various stages.
(ii) Provision of Technical Advisory Services to assist the Regional UWSSAs and Small
Towns
The component continued preparation of Design Studies & Supervision in various activities
(Studies /Designs for Water Supply and Sewerage infrastructures). The status is that:
The Feasibility studies, Detailed designs and tender document preparations for all of
the seven (7) towns: of Bukoba, Musoma, Babati, Lindi, Sumbawanga, Mtwara and
Kigoma, were completed in December 2011, in a joint undertaking by MoW with the
coordinated support from EU, KfW and AfD;
Design studies for Bunda, Mugumu, Tarime, Mugango/Kiabakari Water Supply
systems and Musoma sewerage are completed;
Supervision of Immediate Works in Mtwara, Lindi and Babati are in progress.
(iii) Revision of DAWASA Act:
The lease revision for DAWASA-DAWASCO:
66
The lease Contract approved by EWURA Board has been signed by DAWASA and
DAWASCO and a final copy submitted to EWURA on 15th
March 2012. The document is
now ready for use.
The amendment of DAWASA Act:
MoW submitted the proposed amendments to Chief Parliamentary Draftsman (CPD) on
23//11/2011 for vetting and received their comments on 11/01/2012. MoW presented the draft
Cabinet paper to the stakeholders meeting held on 25/04/3012 for more comments, thereafter
submitted the commented draft to the Cabinet Secretariat for further steps.
(iv) Clustering
Clustering is a process of putting together water supply and sanitation utilities to form a
common managerial body for efficient delivery of water supply and sanitation services in order
to obtain commercial viability. There are two forms of clusters namely Cluster model II where
category A Regional Authorities are clustered with district/small town water authorities and
cluster model I where small town water authorities are clustered themselves.
The studies on both models raised various policy and legal issues that were required to
addressed before full implementation. The issues included the D by D policy, Human
resources, Institutional Setup, investment, Clustering regulations, and financial support during
transition period and legal issues regarding LGAs and Regional Water Authorities.
A team of members from MoW, PMO-RALG and EWURA was appointed to review the issues
so as to propose the way forward. The team strongly recommended that the utilities should
ensured of continued financial support both from both Local Government and Central
Government until their financial viability is attained and also they should undertake capacity
building for billing and revenue collection. The team also recommended that the Clustering to
start in phases as well as involvement of LGAs and Councils. However the issue of Board
dissolution remain pending. Thereafter the process of clustering will start after finalizing the
Clustering regulation.
5.3.2 Investments in UWSS Sub-projects
In this sub-component, the aim is strengthening the delivery of water and sanitation services
by Category A, B, C and DUWSSAs, DAWASA area, District Headquarters, Small towns and
National Projects through the provision of Sub-loans and/or Capital Development Grants to
finance investments in UWSS Sub-projects. Implementation of the sub-component has been
progressing reasonably well during this period. Significant progress has been made on sub-
projects implementation on the ground as quite a number of new water supply schemes have
either been completed or are at advanced stages of completion. In the FY 2011/2012 the
activities which were planned to be implemented under this sub-component were divided into
categories as follows:
(i) Investment for Dar-es-Salaam (DAWASA/DAWASCO)
67
This activity deals with expansion and WSS services in Dar es Salaam – construction of
Kidunda dam to regulate Ruvu river, dedicated trunk main to University Reservoir,
augmentation of treatment capacity and expansion of network to un-served areas.
(a) Kidunda dam
The contract was extended to August 2012, the consultant is finalizing design of the dam
including hydropower related facilities, for which MoU between DAWASA and TANESCO
has to be signed. The consultant has also prepared a draft ESIA report and discussed it at a
stakeholders meeting in February 2012. The WB reviewed and provided comments on the draft
ESIA and RAP during the just ended Joint Supervision mission. The design consultancy for the
access road is at the inception stage. The Technical feasibility study and ESIA/RAP for
Kidunda dam are under preparation.
(b) Development of Kimbiji and Mpera groundwater for Dar es Salaam Water Supply:
Consultant for Aquifer Assessment and Modeling Consultancy has prepared a phase I report
on Conceptual Aquifer Model, which has been commented by the World Bank on number and
depth of boreholes. Consultant for Kimbiji submitted to DAWASA an Aquifer design review
and drilling supervision has prepared a draft technical specification and bidding document
which has also been commented by World Bank.
(c) Expansion of Upper Ruvu (Water Treatment Plant) and Construction of the Trunk
Main/Transmission Line from Kibaha to Kimara
The contract involves the design, review for measurement and pumping plan and design for
harmonizing the pipeline. The contract for design and supervision consultancy service was
signed and started in March 2012.
(d) Lower Ruvu Expansion Works (MCC)
This year plans were to continue expansion of Lower Ruvu (Water Treatment Plant). The
contractor has continued with construction of raw water sump, pump house, clarifier, and
clear water tank and pump house. The completion rate of the works for the expansion of the
treatment plant is at 36%. The works is in progress and expected to be completed on March
2013.
(e) Construction of the Lower Ruvu Trunk Main to the University Reservoirs
Compensation of the affected people was completed. Supervision consultant is in place.
DAWASA has launched Tenders for works which are expected to complete in August 2013.
Construction is expected to complete after 15 months.
(f) Community water supply and sanitation systems in peri-urban and low income
settlements of Dar es Salaam project under BTC:
The project aims at improving the living condition of the communities in peri-urban low
income settlements of Dar es Salaam City. In the FY 2011/2012,18 production boreholes with
total discharge capacity 3,500m3 were drilled and installed in Dar es Salaam areas namely,
Mbagala Kuu, Makangarawe, Tandika, Mtoni Mashine ya Maji (Temeke); Tandale and
68
Barafu (Kinondoni); and Tabata Kisiwani, Kiwalani and Kinyerezi (Ilala). Procurement for
contractor for distribution networks is underway.
(ii) Investment in Regional Towns, DUWSSs, Small Towns and National Projects
WSDP planned to implement priority activities in UWSSs, for the purpose of improving water
supply and sewerage services in respective areas. The priority interventions and status is
provided here under:-
(a) Immediate works (quick wins)
In the year 2011/12 a total of 5 DUWSSs implemented immediate works (quick wins) that
could yield quick results in improving water supply services to customers, while preparing the
long term construction works. The towns are Orkesumet, Maswa, Mwanga, Himo and Karatu.
The trend shows that the number of the implemented towns in FY 2011/2012 has decreased
compared to the previous year (2010/2011). This is due to lack of funds. Figure 15 shows
implementation of immediate works in Utilities.
Figure 15: Implementation of Immediate Works in Utilities
(b) Rehabilitation and expansion of WSS services in 7 Group I Towns
These are towns that have very low water supply coverage and previously did not receive
significant assistance therefore urgently required assistance. These are Babati, Bukoba,
Musoma, Lindi, Mtwara, Sumbawanga and Kigoma. The status is as follows:
Sumbawanga: The progress of the immediate works programme is 54% on
rehabilitation works. Construction works to improve water supply systems which involve
drilling of 10 New Boreholes plus power Supply and Collector mains and rehabilitation works
continued. However, the contract duration for both consultant and contractor has already
elapsed. Nevertheless, the outstanding works should be completed by October 2012. Further
upgrading works will be financed under EU/KfW-MDGI project.
Mtwara: The overall completion percentage is 90%. The activities involved
rehabilitation of existing well field, refurbishment of Mtawanya booster pumping station and
transmission main, limited works at Mangamba treatment plant, and providing minor
extension to the existing network. Rehabilitation of 27 km is completed; nine pumps have
69
been delivered to Mtwara and waiting installation. Construction of pump house at Mtawanya
water source for housing 4 booster pumps completed.
Babati: The project involved drilling of 10 boreholes, Construction of three storage
tank, construction of treatment plant, laying of transmission and distribution pipeline. Drilling
of boreholes has been completed and construction of infrastucture is ongoing the construction
progress has reached 50%. The general progress is 76%.
Lindi: The general progress of work is 95%. The activities involved supply and
installation of approximately 47 Km pipeworks (50mm to 250mm diameters), procurement of
power supply to Kitunda well fields, construction of 680m3 storage tank at Kitunda,
construction of four (4) break pressure tanks, supply and installation of 380 bulk meters and
supply 2,650 domestic meters to be installed by LUWASA, replacement of two booster pumps
and development of Kitunda wells. Currently all the pipelines and valves have been installed,
construction of a tank is completed; installation of pump is on progress. Power supply to
Kitunda wellfield is completed. The outstanding works should be completed by October 2012.
Further upgrading works will be financed under the EU/KfW-MDGI project.
Bukoba and Musoma (AfD): Detailed designs and tender documents are completed.
Evaluation report for works in Bukoba and Musoma were submitted to AfD for No-objection.
No objection for Bukoba have been received and awaited for Musoma, implementation is
expected to commence by November 2012.
Lindi, Kigoma and Sumbawanga (EU/KfW-MDGI): Detailed designs and tender
documents are completed. Tender for works has been advertised. Pre-bid meetings are
currently being conducted in the respective towns. These upgrading works are to be financed
under the EU/KfW-MDGI project and implementation is expected to commence by October
2012 following signing of Financing Agreements on works and supervision contracts .
(c) Rehabilitation and expansion of UWSS services in Group II Towns
These are towns that have received limited assistance but still need substantial support to
develop long term solutions. These include Morogoro and Tabora:
Tabora: The Contract for rehabilitation and expansion of water supply infrastructure for
Tabora municipal financed by SECO continues. The scope of works include: Rehabilitation of
27 km distribution line, laying of 500m diameters pipeline (km 2.7) from Igombe dam, supply
and installation of two pumps and transformer, rehabilitation of tanks with total capacity of
5,000 m3; supply of 5,000 water meters and rehabilitation of intake and construction of post
chlorination unit. The contractor has cleared road for 500 mm pipes, post chlorination unit is
30% completed. The contract has procured pipes and fitting arts and verification of network
for rehabilitation which is 36% completed. The construction of foundation for post
chlorination is 20% completed. Overall progress is at 28%.
Morogoro: Rehabilitation of Morogoro Water Supply System (MCC): Rehabilitation of Boma
Road storage tank is 95% completed; Excavation and lying of 1.8 km of DN 500 mm
transmission main /pipes at distance of 1,800 m is 95% complete. Demolition of old
Mambogo water treatment plant and other facilities is complete and the site is now clear for
construction of new Water Treatment Plant (WTP). The overall implementation of the project
is 20% completed.
70
(d) Rehabilitation and expansion of WSS services in Group III Towns
These are towns that have received substantial assistance. These include Arusha, Dodoma,
Moshi and Tanga. Status is as follows:
Dodoma: The Contract for rehabilitation and expansion of water supply infrastructure
for Dodoma municipal financed by SECO is in progress. The scope of works includes: Laying
of a total of 30km pipeline (8.94km pipeline from Kilimani to Kisasa and 21km distribution
network at Kisasa area). Currently the project activities are completed at 90% for Lot I and
75% for Lot II. Procurement of contractor for expansion of water supply (32km), water
storage tanks (12,000 m3) and construction of sewerage infrastructure (waste stabilization
ponds) at Dodoma University is on-going; the WB has given No-objection on the evaluation
report (Prequalification).
Arusha, Moshi and Tanga: Detailed designs and tender documents are completed.
Most of the works for Arusha, Moshi and Tanga will be implemented in the 2nd
phase of
WSDP.
(e) Rehabilitation and expansion of WSS services in Group IV Towns
These are towns that have on-going assisted projects. These include Mbeya, Mwanza, Iringa,
Songea, Shinyanga and Singida. Status is as follows:
Mwanza: The consultants submitted final engineering design report and tender
documents of Mwanza City, towns of Sengerema, Geita, Magu, Nansio, Ngudu and Misungwi
in March 2012.
Iringa: Project for construction of water supply and sewerage in Iringa has been
successful completed and officially inaugurated by the President of United Republic of
Tanzania during Maji Week commemorations on 22nd
March 2012. The contractor is in
defects liability period. Implementation of a pilot NRW project started in May 2012, by
Addendum to the contracts of Consultant and Contractor.
Mbeya: The project for expansion of water supply and sewerage network in Mbeya
completed on 23rd
December, 2011 and it is under defect liability period. It is expected to be
officially inaugurated in July 2012.
Singida: Construction and expansion of water supply continues and it is approximately
62% completed. Currently 63.8 km pipes have been laid out of 81. Storage tanks of capacity
6000 m3
One borehole at Mwankoko was tested with 200 m3/h yield capacity. Total of 500
Water Meters of 20mm diameter (comprising of 453 for house connections and 47 for
Domestics water points (kiosks) were fixed within the Airport and Karakana areas. The
project is scheduled to be completed by December 2012. Boreholes at Irao shall be put to be
drilled in August 2012.
(f) Rehabilitation and expansion of WSS services in District town /Small Towns and
National Projects utilities - Group V Small Towns
These include 93 gazetted townships, 32 un-gazetted small towns and 6 National schemes
which have reached various stages of utility management. Status is as follows:
71
Chalinze: There are nine (9) ongoing construction contracts at Chalinze. Many are
progressing well although some are behind schedule. Lots 1, 2, 3 and package J were
expected to complete on time if the flow of fund was as planned, but only package J was
completed on time. Lots 1, 4, 5, 6 and package F and H have applied for extension. The (9)
Lots/Packages in Chalinze are at various levels of progress. The overall works summary is as
follows: Lot 1 (~66%), Lot 2 (~33%), Lot 3 (~50%), Lot 4 (~42%), Lot 5 (~30%), Lot 6
(~60%); Package F (~70%), Package H (~75%), and Package J: (~ 95%)
Igunga: Rehabilitation and expansion of water supply project phase II is on - going in
which construction of fence, bridge, one guard house and drainage system around the
treatment plant installation of electricity power were completed, Filling filter materials in
filtration unit is on progress. The overall progress of works package is 98% completed.
Bunda : Construction of phase I of water supply works is completed; Construction of
phase II has started whereby the resident engineer house 50% complete and 6000m of trench
excavated.
Ikwiriri: Construction of a Pump house, installation of pump, construction of workshop
security house and office buildings are in progress at 90% completion. Remaining activities
are installation of pump and construction of manhole chambers for valves.
Kibiti: The construction of water supply systems is completed. The four boreholes are
currently operational while one is under power connection.
Mvomero, Gairo, Kilosa , Turiani and Kibaigwa as well as Masasi and Nachingwea: Contractors continue with the construction works for the towns in which general progress of
work is 80%, 84.4%, 75%, 62.4% , 85%and 85% respectively. The main works executed for
the towns were excavation for the footing and foundation of the tanks, trench excavation and
pipe laying, construction of substructure for booster pump station, chlorination room, guard
houses and boreholes drilling.
5.3.3 Progress on Output and Estimated Outcomes against MKUKUTA II Targets
The targets for urban water supply and sewerage are derived from MKUKUTA II. The targets
were to increase access to water supply at regional capitals from 84% in 2010 to 95%, Dar es
Salaam from 55% in 2010 to 75%, District, Small Towns and National Projects from 53% in
2010 to 57% by 2015. On sanitation the target include the coverage of sewerage service from
18% in 2010 to 22% in 2015. By June 2012, water supply coverage was 86% in the 19 urban
regional headquarters which were defined by MKUKUTA to represent urban sector. The
coverage in district head quarters and small towns was 53% and coverage in Dar es Salaam
reached 67%. MKUKUTA targets could not be realized due to various reasons, including
delayed implementation of planned investment sub projects. The brief summary of the
performance attained by Urban Water supply and sewerage authorities for the period from
July 2011 to June 2012 is presented here under:
(i) Trends of Water Supply Service Coverage in the 19 UWSSAs
The population coverage maintained at 86% in 2009/2010, 2010/11 and 2011/2012, this is due
to the fact that population within service areas in various Authorities have increased. Figure
16 shows the status of water supply coverage in the 19 UWSSs.
72
Source: UWSSAs Annual Reports
Figure 16: Status of Water Supply Coverage in the 19 UWSSAs
(ii) Number of household connected to water supply and sewerage systems
The number of household connected to water supply system in UWSSAs has been increasing
from year to year. Currently the number has increased from 254,236 in 2010/2011 to 289,058
in 2011/2012 an increase of 13.7%. In DAWASCO, the increase is from 122,990 in
2010/2011 to 129,672 in 2011/2012 an increase of 5.4%.
Source: Annual UWSSAs Reports
Figure 17: Trend of Household Water Connections
The trend of house connection in general for both UWSSAs and DAWASCO had a positive
increase from 2007/2008 to 2008/2009 and decrease in 2009/2010 was due to removal of
abandoned house connections of DAWASCO.
(iii) Number of household connected to sewerage systems
The number of household connected to sewerage system in UWSSAs has increased from
19,209 in 2010/2011 to 20,910 in 2011/2012. In DAWASCO, number of connections
73
increased from 18,415 in 2010/2011 to 19,200 in 2011/2012. Figure 18 shows trends in
sewerage connections previous years.
Source: UWSSAs Annual Reports
Figure 18: Trends in Sewerage Connections
(iv) Length of water supply and sewerage infrastructure rehabilitated or constructed
The number of water supply and sewerage infrastructure rehabilitated or constructed is
measured by the number of kilometers of network increase. In UWSSAs, the length of water
supply infrastructure network increased from 4,834 in 2010/2011to 5,400km in 2011/2012.
For sewerage, the length of infrastructure network in UWSSAs increased from 414.30km in
2010/2011 to 488.90 in 2011/2012.
Source: UWSSAs Annual Reports
Figure 19: Trends in the Length of Water Supply and Sewerage System Infrastructure in
19 UWSSAs
In DAWASCO, the length of water supply infrastructure network increased from 1658 in
2010/2011 to 1670 Km of water supply network in 2011/2012. Figure 19 shows trends in the
length of water supply system infrastructure per year. In DAWASCO, the length of sewerage
infrastructure increased from 238km in 2009/2010 to 280.
(iv) Number of constructed Kiosks
74
The trends in construction of kiosks in UWSSAs decreased from 1,511 in 2010/2011 to 1,601
in year 2011/2012. In DAWASCO, the number of kiosks was 195 in 2009/2010 to 199. Each
kiosk is designed to serve about 60 beneficiaries.
(v) Number of average hours of service
Average hours of service per day for UWSSAs decreased from 19.85 in 2010/2011 to 18.00 in
2011/2012. Average hours of service for DAWASCO decreased from 9 to 8 in 2010/2011 to
2011/2012 respectively.
(vi) Rate of Non Revenue Water
The average (%) Non Revenue Water in UWSSAs has increased from 32.5% in 2010/2011 to
37% in 2011/2012. The metering ratio has increased from 91.4% in 2010/2011 to 93% in
2011/2012. In DAWASCO, the Non Revenue Water (%) decreased from 49.9% in 2010/2011
to 41.8 in 2011/2012. The metering ratio increased from 86% in 2010/2011 to 91%. The
increase of the Non Revenue Water (NRW) average level for UWSSAs is due to physical
losses caused by leaks arising from bursting of old age pipes in the distribution network. (like
the newly completed Iringa Water Supply Scheme, which caused an increased system
pressures causing leakages in older parts of the network).
5.3.4 Challenges in the UWSSAs
(i) Accumulation of outstanding unpaid certificates still persists across the board. This has
led to interest accumulation and increased cost of contracts and delayed completion of
works. Furthermore, it is painting bad reputation of the program as non-paying and in
future tenders potential service providers (service providers and suppliers) may refrain
to apply. As of July 2012 unpaid certificates valued to Tshs. 36.3 billion while the
interest accumulated to Tshs. 6.8 billion.
(ii) Inadequate qualified staff in small town utilities and national projects led to difficulties
in implementation of immediate works projects. Furthermore, the present vacancies in
the professional positions of the UWSSAs may affect the overall performance of the
utilities, due to gaps in the available expertise. Earmarked funds not captured by
experts in the MIS at Implementing Agencies (IAs) due to donors not inform IAs when
send the fund to contractors
(iii) Procurement procedure in which the time required for the proposal to be processed
between UWSSAs, MoWI and World Bank for No- Objection is often too long causing
delays in the execution of projects, e.g. (i) Construction of Lower Ruvu pipeline is yet
to start apart from Government setting aside funds in 2012/2013 and DAWASA
procurement processes. (ii) Addendum for procurement of Pumps for Lindi has also
delayed completion of immediate works resulting into big shortage of water.
75
(iv) Shortage of funds that led to omitting the implementation of some projects including
projects for the towns that has finished studies example Songea (Namtumbo, Mbinga
and Tunduru) and Tanga (Muheza and Pangani). Delay by UWSSAs in acquiring title
deeds for construction of offices for utilities.
(v) Accumulation of unpaid electricity bills for the category B & C and NPs utilities,
leading to power cut by TANESCO resulting in shortage of water supply to the service.
Measures to be taken:
(i) MoW and DPs have agreed to revert to disbursing funds according to disbursement
projections so that component activities can be done as per annual work plans. During
the 1st Steering Committee held on 16th February 2012, MoW presented its cash flow
projections for 6 months (FY 2011-2012) however; the decision has not been taken into
action todate.
(ii) 4 engineers and 6 technicians have been transferred to some small towns to cover the
hman resource gap as an interim measure. Meanwhile the process to employ new staff
in UWSA is continuing.
(iii) There are a number of stages that requires No-Objection, for example, to get a
consultant requires the following stages:
a) Expression of Interest(EoI)
b) Evaluation Report of EoI
c) Request for Proposal (RFP)
d) Evaluation Report of Proposals
e) Contract preparation.
Mow has proposed to WB to eliminate No - Objection in some stages which are
normally found to be standard, without affecting the relevance of pre-view process.
These stages are (b), (c) and (e).This will substantially reduce the procurement delays
and hence speed up the process.
(iv) The Ministry has requested the Ministry of Finance to set aside special funds for
electricity bills. Also all UWSSs have been instructed to allocate part of funds in their
budget for electricity bills.
5.4 COMPONENT 4: INSTITUTIONAL STRENGTHENING AND CAPACITY
BUILDING
The overall objective of this component is to provide support to Sector Institutional
Strengthening and Capacity Building. It has responsibilities of providing regulatory,
76
coordination and administration support to facilitate sector development and investment; and
strengthening participation of service providers in the water and sanitation services. To realize
this objective, the components activities are divided into four intervention areas:
(i) Support for Operationalization of the new role of the Ministry of Water.
(ii) Technical Assistance for Strengthening of Sub – Sector Planning and Operational
Capacities.
(iii) Support sector coordination and performance monitoring.
(iv) Support for sector capacity building.
This component provides capacity building grants to support efficient implementation of the
Water Sector Development Program. The component focuses on institutional transformation of
the role of the Ministry by strengthening its role in policy formulation, oversight and capacity
building roles to other implementing agencies. The support includes strengthening the legal
framework, provide technical and managerial assistance, support the development of
infrastructures, providing working tools, and assisting in developing human resources,
including skills and knowledge. Status for each intervention area is provided here under:-
5.4.1 Support for Operationalization of the New Role of the Ministry of Water
(i) Technical assistance to facilitate the Ministry’s role (development of the 10-year
corporate strategy, preparation of corporate charter)
Preparation of the revised client service charter has been completed, which consists of activities
of the MoW and excluding the activities of irrigation which currently belong to the Ministry of
agriculture, food and cooperatives and approved in May 2012. The charter is currently in
operational.
(ii) Rehabilitation and construction of office accommodation at Ubungo
Rehabilitation/construction of offices at the Ministry of Water Headquarters was planned to be
implemented in two phases. Phase 1 covers seven building blocks whereas the second phase
covers 11 building blocks. Phase 1 has been completed except for block D for which BoQ and
cost estimates have been prepared by the Consultant. Rehabilitation work under Phase 2, which
is to be financed by Government‟s own funds, is scheduled to start in the coming FY 2012/13.
(iii) Construction of MoW Headquarters Building
During the restructuring of procurement plan for WSDP basket fund, DPs withdrew from
financing construction of the proposed MoW Headquarters Building even though it was among
the planned activities in the WSDP phase I. The ministry is currently seeking funds from other
sources including Government allocations.
(iv) Procurement of Computers, communication and other office equipment for MOW,
RSs, LGAs, BWOs, DUWSAs
77
One (1) Goods contract for the supply of (17) heavy duty photocopiers, (112) medium duty
photocopiers, (175) facsimiles, and (2) digitizers, signed in October, 2009 for delivery in
January, 2010 had not been executed. Based on this information, MoW has decided to officially
cancel the contract and restart the new procurement process. The cancellation of the contract
had been approved by the Ministerial Tender Board (MTB) for submitted to the WB for no
objection.
(v) Installation of Management Information Systems (MIS)
Water Sector Management Information System (MIS):
(a) Current Achievements
The Government has installed Water Sector Programme MIS, which became operational in
June 2011 at MoW, BWOs, LGAs, UWSAs, Agencies and National Water Projects. All
contracts and non contract payments under WSDP had been entered into the system. MIS data
also include earmarked projects from UWSAs, BWOs, LGAs and other IAs. The system is
implemented in phases in order to ensure sustainability based on lessons learnt. To a great
extent, the recorded transactions in MIS are now more complete and in consistence with that of
EPICOR or any other accounting system being operated by a particular IA however, close
monitoring is still needed to ensure that all IAs comply with instructions provided to them
through a mechanism that has been put in place. MoW is really leveraging from the use of this
services. Currently, the functional Water Sector Development Programme MIS covers the
following modules and functionalities:
(i) Planning and Budgeting: This module offers definition of projects, project targets as
well as project activities. It also offers the project planning activity amount, Source
funds commitment and donor disbursement functions.
(ii) Procurement Management: This module offers management of project procurement
activities, annual plans, procurement planning, tenders and tender activities.
(iii) Contract Management: This offers management of contracts that includes suppliers,
contract awards, contract amounts, contract lots, contract payments schedules and
awarded contracts.
(iv) Financial Management: The module offers management of financials. They include
program fund releases, component funds releases, implementing entity funds releases,
contract expenditures, non-contract expenditures and addendum/variations.
(v) Reporting: The reporting capability of this system cuts across all functional areas. The
system reports include project planning related reports such as projects, budget
estimates by components, project and activity budgets. Other reports include
procurement plans, procurement plan activities, contract lists, contract payments and
balances, contract payment schedules, publication of the Awards of Contracts, IFRs,
etc.
Before the Water Sector Programme MIS became operational, the Ministry of Water has been
implementing various systems to support data management and M&E for specific functional
areas. Some of these systems include: the Integrated Financial Management System (IFMS)
and the Strategic Budget Allocation System (SBAS3) both under the Ministry of Finance and
Economic Affairs; HYDATA under the Water Resource Management (MoW); Human Capital
78
Information Database system under PO-Public Service Management; and MaJIS under
EWURA. The Ministry also intends to deploy Water Point Mapping System for LGA‟s in the
financial year 2012/2013. Besides these systems, other tailor made applications also exist in
various divisions/units.
(b) Existing Challenges:
(i) Absence of Information Management/Technology Policy: Even though the country has a
national ICT policy statement, the Ministry of Water currently does not have an
instituted Information Management/Technology Policy tailored sector use.
(ii) The Sector Lacks ICT Training: The Sector lacks adequately trained ICT personnel to
take on the required IT mission. The skill level of the existing staff requires sharpening
in order to stay abreast with technology.
(iii) Inadequate information gathering mechanism: The current method for gathering
information needs improvement. Given the vast geographic location that is covered by
data collection and water supply points, a more realizable means of data collection
should be considered. For example, using GIS technology and portable devices are
needed to collect data on water points and distribution infrastructure.
(c) Strategies to Overcome the Challenges
As an effort to tackle the existing challenges as mentioned and to enhance data management
and information dissemination among the WSDP IAs through an integrated sector MIS, the
following ICT projects are in various stages of initiation or implementation and be completed
as follows:-
(i) The Ministry has started to enhance the existing MIS so that additional new user
requirements are met in order to make the system sustainable. This will be completed
by October 2012.
(ii) The Ministry has prepared short term MIS training programme for users at all levels by
conducting training to more staff including all accountants from LGAs, internal auditors
from IAs, and all procurement staff from WSDP IAs. The execution of this training
programme will be completed by November 2012.
(iii) The Ministry has initiated a process to procure ICT equipments for IAs to implement
MIS and WPM system. This will be completed by January 2013.
(iv) The Ministry has prepared Terms of Reference for Scaling up Water Sector Programme
MIS to enhance M&E functions in the water sector. Terms of Reference has been
submitted to e Government Agency (eGA) to obtain technical inputs to avoid
duplication of efforts. Inputs from eGA will be obtained by September 2012 so that
further steps are taken. It is envisaged that the scaling up of the existing MIS to be
completed by June 2013. While most of the current systems will continue to be operated
in their respective domains, the presence of Water Sector MIS will provide an
opportunity to pool selected sets of information to a single platform (Water sector MIS)
in order to enhance and further support SWAP. This will also enable sector to review
and integrate existing systems, where feasible, by developing relevant models that can
79
support the various applications and further built relevant interfaces for the systems and
users.
(v) The Ministry has prepared Terms of Reference for the preparation of information
security policy and disaster recovery plan and submitted to eGovernment Agency for
sharing and obtaining technical inputs based on the national standards. This will enable
the sector to develop a statement or collection of statements that articulates the sector
wide ICT position along with a directive for field offices to comply with the national
guidelines in order to ensure synergy at the national level. Such guideline shall be
tailored to fit the unique needs of each entity. It is envisaged that this policy will be
prepared based on the national and/or international best practices and be in place by
June 2013.
(vi) The Ministry intends to improve the internal and external communication infrastructure
using ICT by deploying the use of National Optic Fibre Services. The tendering process
started. This will enhance the data and voice transfer and facilitate reliability and
availability of Water Sector MIS and other systems.
(vii) The Ministry will prepare a long term plan for putting in place adequate infrastructure
and the necessary training required and tools (such as standardized tools, applications
and procedures, modern data collection equipments, etc) required to support and
maintain the sector ICT & MIS environment.
(viii) The Ministry will develop an enterprise architecture that will support information flow
from and to all stakeholders appropriately.
5.4.2 TA for Strengthening of Sub-Sector Planning and Operational Capacities
(i) Components Program Management Support
Four Technical Advisers (TA) contracts for (i) operational hydrology, (ii) IWRM, and (iii) dam
safety and (iv) Water Resources Information System (WRIS) have reached an advanced stage
where ToRs prepared are ready for submission to MTB for approval. Technical proposal for
TA for water quality management was approved by MTB on May 14, 2012. MoW is also
considering an additional TA for groundwater management. However, the consultancy services
for Dam safety will be a continuation from the previous contract except that the terms of
references (ToRs) will be modified to suit current needs.
(ii) Development of regulations and sub sector operational procedures and guidelines
(including environmental management monitoring)
The two acts namely; Water Resources Management Act No. 11 and Water Supply and
Sanitation Act No. 12 became effective in August 2009. Regulations on 14 sections out of 41
sections in the Water resources Act have been completed. Three regulations have been gazetted
regarding (i) registration of water users association, (ii) water abstraction, use and discharge
and (iii) procedure for nomination board members for National Water Board and Basin Water
Boards. Whereas 3 out of 11 Regulations in the Water Supply and Sanitation Act have been
completed. The remaining eight (8) regulations require research.
80
5.4.3 Support Sector Coordination and Performance Monitoring
(i) Support for the operations of the Sector Working Group and National Water Board
The TWG 4 held an extraordinary meeting in February 2012 and all the four TWGs met in
April, 2012. For the first time, the new Steering Committee (SC), held its first meeting on
February 16, 2012 where it was briefed on status of implementation of the program, challenges
of implementation and the mitigating majors being taken to minimize deficiencies. The work
plan, the budget and the procurement plan were approved by the SC. The National Water Board
is operational and was officially inaugurated on 26th
July 2012 in Arusha, whereby it held its
second meeting on 27 July 2012.
(ii) Annual sector reviews and stakeholder consultation
MoW has conducted 6th
Joint Water Sector Review (JWSR) meeting from 18th
-19th
October
2011. The meeting involved various water Sector stakeholders; including representation from
MoW, PMO-RALG, MoHSW, MoEVT, MoF, MCDGC, Development Partners (DPs), Civil
Society Organizations (CSOs), Regional Secretariats, Local Government authorities, Urban
Water Supply and Sewerage Authorities, District Urban Water Supply and Sanitation
Authorities, National Projects and the Energy and Water Utilities Regulatory Authority
(EWURA). The meeting discussed various issues, including making follow up on the
implementation of undertakings of the previous 2 and half years, discussing physical progress
for programme implementation and receive various reports from other stakeholders who work
together with the Ministry.
(iii) Annual technical and financial audits
Those responses and Implementation status of the action plans for Financial and Special Audits
were shared with DPs and finally submitted to CAG. There are no outstanding issues from
CAG as far as Special and Financial Audits are concerned. Also most of the financial audit
queries raised in various audits have been cleared by the Auditor (CAG) except for MIS Data
verification audit queries relating to opening and closing balances reported by implementing
agencies. The Audit verification for replies has been done and we are now waiting for the audit
comment from CAG.
(iv) Development and Implementation of Communication Strategy - Strengthening the
Information, Education and Communication Unit
The Government Communication Unit (GCU) was established in 2007 as fully fledged unit.
The unit prepared media materials on NAWAPO, NWSDS and WSDP for dissemination using
simplified languages, documentaries, posters, fliers and pamphlets, radio and TV programmes,
as a way of implementing the WSDP communication strategy. For the year 2011/2012, a total
of 19 radio and TV programmes, advertisements, and comedy and drama series were aired; and
more than 40,000 copies of posters, fliers and cartoon booklets on water sector were
disseminated. WSDP Communication Strategy was developed and booklets disseminated to
LGAs, WSSAs, and Basin Water Offices. The implementation of the strategy is going on at all
81
levels. Presently we are on the process of getting a Consultant to evaluate the impact of the
Communication Strategy and determine gapes if any.
5.4.4 Support for Sector Capacity Building
(i) Recruitment of skilled manpower to fill the gaps in all essential fields
Apart from a total of 628 new employees who were employed up to June 2011, no new
employees were employed.
(ii) Training of Water Sector Staff
Up to June 2012, only a limited number of MoW staff were trained in the fields of monitoring
and evaluation (2), record management (2), communication, Information technology and
networking(1), sustainable urban water and sanitation integrated process (1), and
programmable logic controllers for advanced automation (1). The consultant for conducting
training assessment is in place and has started work.
(iii) Sector Staff Augmentation
A total of 159 staff in former Regional Consulting units (RCUs) and BWOs were identified as
suitable for redeployment to LGAs and small towns. However, due to financial constraints only
six (6) had so far been transferred to Kibiti and Ikwiriri small towns. Also, due to financial
constraints the government has frozen new recruitments in all sectors except for the health and
education sectors. Human resources capacity constraints in IAs (BWOs, LGAs, and small
towns) especially in the fields of financial management, procurement and contract management
and engineering, was inhibiting efficient implementation of the program.
(iv) Capacity Development Framework and Capacity Development Plans
A checklist for monitoring implementation of the CD Plans developed by MoW has been
shared with EWURA, PMO-RALG, LGAs, DPs, and other stakeholders. However, the
implementation has yet started due to inadequate of finance.
(v) Water Sector Governance
Implementation Open Government Partnership (OGP) in the Water Sector
The Open Government Partnership (OGP) is a global initiative that aims at promoting
transparency, empower citizens, fight corruption and encourage use of new technologies to
improve governance. The OGP was formally launched in New York on 20th September, 2011.
The OGP is overseen by a multi-stakeholder International Steering Committee comprised of
Government and civil society representatives. Among the major benefits of OGP is to improve
service delivery and make Governments more responsible and accountable to their citizens.
Given the benefits of this initiative, Tanzania declared its intention to join OGP during the
launching meeting. The country intention to join OGP is to make Government business more
82
open to its citizens in the interest of improving public service delivery, Government
responsiveness, combating corruption and building greater trust. Specifically, Tanzania has
joined OGP in order to:
Promote public integrity and transparency, enhance proper management of public
resources and fight corruption; and
Strengthen mechanisms for citizens engagement and participation in improving public
service delivery systems in their areas.
Through the Country OGP Action Plan, the Government commits itself to promoting increased
access to information about Government operations and publish data on the prioritized sectors
of Health, Education and Water.
To implement the Government commitments to OGP the Ministry of Water has prepared an
Action Plan for the year 2012/2013. The Ministry of Water intends to implement the
commitments that are related to the Water Sector to improve and sustain the aforementioned
good governance efforts in Tanzania. The action matrix for the year 2012/2013 for the Water
Sector has been prepared for action and mainstreamed in the normal annual budgeting system
as well as in the normal government statutory requirements, Medium Term Planning and
Budgeting as well as WSDP dialogue and reporting mechanisms. The purpose is to ensure that
OGP implementation and monitoring becomes part of the measures for effective
implementation of WSDP. This means the OGP intended to improve and sustain the
aforementioned good governance efforts in the water sector. The OGP commitments that will
be implemented in the Water Sector for the periods 2012/2013 include among others the
following:-
Ensure wider participation of the citizens in the running of Government by establishing
a platform for citizens to be able to send comments by mobile phone, emails and other
means, and receive feedback within reasonable time.
Strengthen Ministerial website to post online within one month, all reports, studies,
data, circulars, and other public interest data in machine readable format, except those
which compromise national security.
Establish an open forum in collaboration with civil society to review quality, integrity,
depth and pace of progress against OGP.
Develop and/or review Ministry‟s Client Service Charter and make it accessible to
citizens.
Review/establish complaints register to ensure that complaints received are attended
and feedback on action taken is adequately documented and posted to the Ministry
website quarterly.
Finalize Water Point Mapping System for LGAs and make the disaggregated data
available online and other means of communication.
Strengthen the use of Water Sector Management Information Systems by making
disaggregated data available online in machine readable format, and
83
Publishing of Parastatals Organizations, Executive Urgencies and Regulatory
Authorities revenues and expenditure on websites and news papers.
(vi) Executive Agencies
Drilling and Dam Construction Agency (DDCA) Some of the activities at this period had completed as planed and few are at the final stage. The
procurement process of Drilling machines and equipments has had three Lots whereby Lot 1
Drill rigs and accessories LC has been opened on March 2011 and the contract allowed with
partial shipment. The delivery of the goods started on December 2011 and it is expected to be
completed by August 2012. Lot 2 Support Trucks, goods has been delivered and final payment
made on 5th
June 2012. Lot 3 Support Vehicles payment has been made on February 2011 and
goods have been delivered. The procurement of groundwater exploration equipments, goods
had been received and training has been done. The procurement of the soil laboratory
equipments and procurement of design equipment, goods has been received and final payment
has been done on February 2012. The rehabilitation of drilling machines and earthmoving
machine is the ongoing process.
Water Development and Management Institute (WDMI) The delivery of library books has been completed and full paid by June 2012. The Institute has
also has procured chemicals for its laboratory, the delivery is 90%. The 10% of the expected
chemicals are restricted thus need several procedures. The procurement of Consultant for
detailed design and supervision of rehabilitation and construction new building has been
advertised and the evaluation report sent to WB in order to receive the No objection by July
2012.The procurement of office furniture and 1 generator (250KVA) are on final stage that is
contracting process. The Institute has advertised invitation for bids to procure of 50 computers
and workshop equipments their opening of tender documents is expected early August 2012.To
address the staff shortage and enhance the Institute‟s management capacity, 31 staff are
expected to be recruited through Public Service Recruitment Secretariat including 3 Directors,
the exercise is expected to be completed by September 2012. The curriculum for the Degree in
Water Resources Engineering was completed in July 2011and approved by NACTE. The
accreditation from by NACTE is not yet provided.
Maji Central Stores (MCS) The consultant presented the report to the management in November 2011 with a view of
transforming the MCS to an executive agency by recapitalizing it and restructuring the current
operational status and staff. The ministry management adopted the recommendations. The step
forward has been retarded by the shift of the operational premises from Kurasini to Boko.
During the current financial year 2002/2013the Ministry is expected to technical team from
different disciplines for preparation of operational, statutory and technical requirements.
5.4.5 Challenges
84
(i) The main challenges under component 4 is implementation of CD Plans since the
majority IAs, even some DPs, consider the CD Plans parallel with other activities such
as impact assessment study.
(ii) There is also shortage of office accommodation at MoW Headquarters and Basins.
(iii) PCU need to be strengthened and given mandate to acquire reports to whoever has
received funds for implementation of WSDP.
(iv) PCU should be facilitated to have special monitoring programmes, to identify
implementation challenges and give recommendations for improvement.
(v) To improve efficient in procurement and safeguards management, it is recommended to
have additional staff in those areas, or better safeguard coordination to be under the
PCU.
6 IMPLEMENTATION OF SAFEGUARDS POLICIES AND GUIDELINES
The Environmental and Social Management Framework provides a strategic guide for the
integration of environmental and social considerations in the planning and implementation of
the WSDP activities including issues related to International Waterways.
The Environmental and Social Management Framework and Resettlement Management
Frameworks are frameworks prepared to guide implementation of the Water Sector
development Programme (WSDP). The ESMF is used to provide the project implementers with
an environmental and social screening process to enable them identify, assess and mitigate
potential environmental and social impacts of the priority infrastructure investments.
Safeguard started concurrently with implementation of WSDP as a tool for compliance of water
projects in social and environment. Social and environmental management is mainstreamed in
all 4 WSDP components.
In its course of implementation, WSDP planned to achieve institutional strengthening in
environmental and social perspectives for effective implementation of WSDP and application
of environmental and social management measures (assessed through the environmental
checklists) to the preparation of a comprehensive ESIA and /or RAPs. Progress on the planned
activities is provided here under:-
85
6.1 Safeguards Management of Subprojects
The four WSDP Components carried out various safeguard interventions and the status of
Category A subprojects issues under Component 1 is given in Annex XX and briefly explained
as follows: Lower Ruvu Distribution Network ESIA as well as the RAP has been cleared by the
WB. Also the WB has provided a third round of comments for Kimbiji/Mpera Well Field to be
included by the consultant prior to final review.the consultant is still working on the matter for
submission on 30th
August 2012. The RAP and draft ESIA for Kidunda Dam have been
prepared and Comments provided by World Bank.The consutant has failed to finalise ESIA and
RAP and design of the Hydropower due to financial constrains
The ToR for Ngerengere - Kidunda access Road as a necessary precondition to approval on
Safeguards grounds were submitted to WB comments issued. for rectification. DAWASA are
finalising comments for resubmission.
6.2 Screening of Projects
The Environmental Audit reports can give guide on the status of the source before awarding the
water permit. During the reporting period no screening was submitted from component I.
However Basin water offices continued with assessment of screened forms and environmental
assessment reports submitted to them from LGAs within their Basins.
i) Kidunda dam Project development on environmental/Social compliancy
The ESIA for Kidunda Dam was discussed by stakeholders on 13th
March 2012, comments
raised were taken to the site for verification. The consultant was asked to address them
including the actual valuation report submitted to DAWASA by Morogoro Rural District
administration on 30th
April 2012. So far the all stakeholders are informant about their
entitlements ready for payment.
ii) Kimbiji/Mpera Aquifer Development on environmental/social compliancy
The Consultant signed contract on 15th
March, 2012 for borehole design review, prepare tender
documents and supervise drilling. Final ESIA and RAP both in hard copy and soft copy was
submitted to MoW and World Bank on 4th
April, 2012.The W. Bank raised ESIA comments
which are still being addressed by the consultant before resubmission.
iii) Community Participation
Bawamande and Lyandembera water user council conducted awareness meetings on water
sources protection in Igomaa, Ukelemi, Ugenzi and Isalavami villages. A meeting was held on
23rd
March 2012, regarding a pollution incidence. The Villages representatives and the Ministry
discussed the matter where TAZAMA Pipeline Ltd. was ordered to adhere to the recommended
86
measures i.e. to ensure the environment and the river conditions are restored. Also to provide
the analytical results of samples analysed together with an action plan to complete the
restoration exercise. The Ministry of Heath has comfirmed that no serious healthy effects of
permanent in nature were observed in the impacted villages.
Awareness rising on Water Policy, 2002 and Water Resource Management Act of 2009 and
review of water use permits were done through participation on Nane nane exhibition in Lake
Rukwa Basin. Also Awareness on water allocation was conducted to illegal water users of
Ngerengere River downstream Mindu Dam in Wami/Ruvu Basin.
iv) Water Source Protection
Consultative meeting with Arusha DC Office was done in Pangani Basin to discuss issues
related to protection of Kijenge River from wastewater discharge from Sunflag industry at
Makumira. The industry is discharging water without having a discharge permit. Other
identification of water source for protection and conservation was done in Arusha, Babati and
Bukombe in Internal Drainage Basin and awareness creation on environmental conservation
was conducted to encroachers who are performing mining, agriculture and brick making
activities at Morogoro Municipal, Mvomero and Morogoro District in Wami/Ruvu Basin
Meanwhile conservation workshop was organised by Arusha UWSA in collaboration with
Pangani Basin Water Board in Arusha to explain the intention of the basin to conserve and
protect Ngaramtoni-Magereza and Sokon 1 areas for future groundwater supply of the City.
Tree planting and Bill Board construction at Mtawanya Well Field were done in Ruvuma Basin
during Maji Week by Basin staff, MTUWASA staff and Mtawanya Community. One meeting
were conducted at Mtawanya, between Basin Staff, Mtawanya Village Leader, and Water user
group to enhance community participation in tree planting, and Bill Board installation at
Mtawanya Well Field for source protection during Maji Week.
In Rukwa Basin, awareness rising was conducted at Katuma Irrigation Scheme through
meetings and planting water friendly trees near proposed scheme sites in collaboration with
Sumbawanga Municipal staffs.
6.3 Achievements
(a) Screening of Projects
During the reporting period (July 2011 – June 2012), Screening was conducted for 164 projects
from (10) Regions namely Kigoma Kagera Lindi, Mara, Mbeya, Mtwara , Mwanza , Rukwa,
Shinyanga, and Tabora. Twenty nine (29) projects found to be under category A so need
Environment Impact Assessment (EIA). The EIA four (Kimbiji/Mpera wells drilling, Kidunda
87
dam construction, Lower Ruvu Pipeline Construction and Tanga Urban Water supply project)
out of 29 has been completed while the 25 are under review to ascertain their
comprehensiveness. The remaining 135 projects do not require EIA but need an environment
management checklist. Meanwhile only 12 projects from Mbeya Region were considered of
category B and 609 subprojects mainly from component II are Category C. No new screening
was reported from component I and III. The Category B subprojects were subjected to an
Environmental assessment by consultants who carried out the feasibility study.
Table 16: Screened Sub-Projects for Component 2
Components
Categories Unverified
category
A B C Screened Not
screened
Total RAP
Required
Component 1
Component 2 12 609 0 621 131 752
Component 3
TOTAL 12 609 0 621 131 752
(b) The preparation of ESIA for projects which falls under category A.
Component 1
Technical evaluation for ESIA consultancy subproject of the proposed Lugoda/Ndembera dam
was cancelled due to the fact that the financial figure tendered was much higher than the
planned budget. It is planned to be re- advertised once budget issues are settled.
IDB Dams ESIA preparations
The EOI documents for Consultancy on Environmental Audit for IDB Dams were opened and
preparation of RFP is in progress. While a consultant to carry out ESIA Study for Farkwa Dam
has already been identified and negotiations are in progress.
Component 2
No report submitted as regard to this component (subject for review as the new report is due to
be out after compilation of their annual meeting).
Component 3
88
Mbwiji -Masasi Environmental Audit report
Plans are in progress on the preparation of Mbwiji -Masasi Environmental Audit report. The
ToR have been shared with WB and commented. The revised TOR is been finalised for re-
submission to WB.
UWSAs Audit or ESIA reports
Reports from UWSAs are at various stages of preparation of environmental audit or ESIA for
safeguard compliancy. Feasibility study reports form seven towns (Kigoma, Musoma, Bukoba,
Sumbawanga, Lindi, Babati and Singida) contained a chapter discussing about the EIA, but is
not comprehensive. MoW is undertaking the review of these documents and it is to be
performed thoroughly as per requirement.
(c) Capacity Building
The World Bank conducted safeguards training activities in Dar es Salaam and Arusha in
January 2012 and attended by the 54 staff associated with program implementation.
Participants included staff from MoW Headquarters, LGAS, Regional Secretariats, BWBs
(d) Water Quality Issues
Inspection of sewage discharge into water sources was done in Nzega District in Internal
Drainage Basin. Inspection of Mwega River and collection of water samples to Government
chemist laboratory for analysis (The River was polluted with oil which leaked from TAZAMA
pipeline) were done in Rufiji Basin. In Wami/Ruvu Basin the analysis results of the pollutions
were shared by BIDCO Management, where by the polluters were requested to improve the
waste water quality to the acceptable standards. Also, Mindu dam was inspected to assess the
environmental flow downstream.
6.4 Challenges
(i) The screening is taking a slow pace due to some reasons including delayed or limited
allocation of resources, for DWST to execute field assessments. There is a possibility
that some projects activities might require displacement of people, and hence the need
for compensation.
(ii) Inadequate skilled staff has hampered smooth monitoring of environmental issues,
carrying environmental audits and supervision of implementation of proposed
mitigation measures.
89
7 WATER SECTOR MONITORING SYSTEMS
The WSDP monitoring systems are set in such a way that they provide key decision making
information through both routine and survey data. The routine data measures progress on
access to services resulting from investment in water infrastructure throughout the country
while surveys measures the actual use of water infrastructure, thus revealing over- or under-
utilization of infrastructure relative to the installed capacity of the system. The sector
Management Information System (MIS) specifically provides such a crucial source of
operational information in terms of finance, projects, WSDP implementing agencies, signed
contracts and other necessary actual implementation data. Through the established monitoring
system, the Ministry of Water is linked with the Prime Minister‟s Office – Regional Authorities
and Local Governments, Ministry of Health and Social Welfare, Ministry of Education and
Vocational Training, and other Implementing Agencies.
7.1 Importance of the Functional MIS Linked to an Effective M&E Framework
Currently, the online functioning MIS does provide key WSDP operational data to stakeholders
accordingly. As the WSDP operational routine data are regularly uploaded in the MIS,
production of quarterly IFRs has become an easy task. Hence, the system has established a key
WSDP monitoring information database, from which stakeholders are given an opportunity to
inquire data at specified period. For producing reliable information for WSDP implementation,
there has been a comprehensive data verification/reconciliation exercise and later data
validation, conducted by the MoW financial specialists in collaboration with staff from MoW
and other IAs. Therefore, the current operational WSDP MIS has tremendously improved the
quality of data it stores.
7.2 The Water Point Mapping
(i) The Rationale of Water Point Mapping
Producing accurate and up-to-date data on rural water supply infrastructure is one of the most
urgent challenges facing the sector. Currently, the main source of data is from routine
monitoring by Local Government Authorities, using Village Executive Officers living in each
village or care takers of water schemes.
The Ministry of Water, together with Development Partners, have previously made two
attempts to solve the mentioned challenge by developing a rural water supply database and
Management Information System (MIS). However, the databases did not accommodate the
existing coverage demand nationwide. The Rural Water Supply Database was being improved
to accommodate village attributes while the MIS introduced was implemented in the Rural
Water Supply and Sanitation Project tested in fourteen districts namely Mpwapwa, Kilosa,
90
Mvomero, Morogoro Rural, Handeni, Rufiji, Singida Rural, Manyoni, Iramba, Kilindi,
Kongwa, Kiteto, Igunga and Kondoa after establishment of MIS unit in every Local
Government Authority. Lessons learnt revealed that the two systems were subject to
improvement.
Figure 20: Water Point Collection Status for the year 2012
However, in 2008, the Joint Water Sector Review agreed that MoW should establish a single
harmonized rural water supply database. The database could be developed through
improvement of operational MIS to cover financial issues and water point mapping data on
existence and functionality of rural water supply infrastructure. Hence, the Water Point
Mapping (WPM) is a survey tool developed to produce accurate and timely data on existence
and functionality of rural water supply infrastructures. The tool now can produce user friendly
maps and intends to produce reports as well that can be used for planning new investments and
monitoring the performance of the sub-sector.
91
WPM surveys involve collecting and analyzing rural water supply infrastructure data and
presenting it in a visual, easily understandable manner. Data is collected on all public improved
water points, including their locations, schemes, types (the source, extraction and distribution
systems), functionality and reasons for non-functionality, and ownership and management. A
photograph is taken at each water point.
(ii) Status of the Water Point Mapping Survey
As of July 2012, data have been collected in 82 Local Government Authorities. The data from
WPM in these districts will be used for a number of purposes. The Local Government
Authorities use data to plan for new investments. However, NGOs use these data for planning
their own investments. Data is also used by researchers to increase understanding of
sustainability and equity issues for the water sector in the country.
The difference in achievement of goal in time is resulted from the late payment of certificate
submitted by consultant.
The consultant has already conducted a water point mapping survey and adjusted data for 63
LGAs with 2,042 Wards and 4,985 villages. 35,641 public water points were mapped, out of
which 23,545 (66.1 %) were found to be functional while 12,096 (33.9%) were non -
functional. Currently, the consultant has submitted the water points' interim report.
Furthermore, the pretesting of established web-based prototype monitoring system is underway
including the uploading of data and information for 19 LGAs. The firm is expecting to continue
with data collection activities for the remaining 50 LGAs.
7.3 Importance of Census and Survey
The routine data system, which is coordinated by the Ministry of Water as mentioned above
and national surveys coordinated by the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) are the main data
sources for assessing performance in the water and sanitation sector. Evaluation of WSDP
implementation performance through surveys measures the actual use of water infrastructure,
thus revealing over- or under-utilization of infrastructure relative to the installed capacity of the
system (THDR, 2011). Analysis of these different measurements is essential for making
informed decisions for the water sector effective and efficient performance.
7.4 Sector Performance Assessments and Programme Evaluation
The WSDP implementation effort and performance indicators have been assessed once at each
end of financial year. Both the Government (MoW) and development partners (DPs) sit at a
dialogue table to conduct the exercise based on agreed performance indicators directed to both
parties. The exercise aims at instituting compliance and quality services delivery measures
92
associated with implementation of WSDP. The rating scales start at zero (0) up to the defined
maximum value for each performance indicator (Ordinarily Scaled). The consensus has been
that if no information verifying implementation of specific agreed action is available, rating
must be given a zero (0) points. A maximum value (100 points) is given if a target has been
fully achieved in the following rating scales:
(i) Satisfactory (76 - 100);
(ii) Moderately satisfactory (51 -75);
(iii) Moderately unsatisfactory (26 - 50), and
(iv) Unsatisfactory at (0 -25).
The current rating for the sector performance for implementation of WSDP based on the
financial year 2010-2011 stands as "moderate satisfactory" subject to change when a new sector
performance assessment result is out later before December 2012.
8 STATUS ON THE USE OF WATER AND SANITATION
FACILITIES AS ANALYZED BY NATIONAL SURVEYS
Access to improved sources of water (piped water, protected wells and protected springs) is
vitally important to the health and well-being of the population as the use of un-improved
sources (unprotected wells, rivers or streams, ponds, lakes or dams) is directly related to
transmission of waterborne diseases, such as diarrhea and dysentery (THDR, 2011).
The water sector continued implementing the global program (WSDP) for the year ending
December 2011 as the effort towards reducing the waterborne diseases risks. The trends of
information covered in the subsequent sections of this part of a report are from the MKUKUTA
II water sector performance assessment framework (PAF) progress report as of June 2012.
8.1 Rural Water Supply Services Improvement
Proportion of households in rural settlements with access to clean and safe water from
improved/protected sources was 56.6%; a drop of 1.2 percentage points from the figure in 2010
(57.8%).
8.2 Urban Water Supply Services Delivery Sustainability
As the WSDP implementation continued across Tanzania mainland, specific interventions in
regional urban centers have tremendously increased the physical water supply facilities, though
the access to clean and safe water from improved/protected sources went down slightly to 81%
by December 2011 from the 86% in December 2010. The proportion of households in Dar es
93
Salaam with access to clean and safe water from improved/protected sources dropped to 51% in
the same period from the 55% in December 2010.
Proportion of households in small towns with access to clean and safe water from
improved/protected sources within 30 minutes was 52.5%, a drop of about 0.5 percentage
points from the recorded figure in 2010 (53.0%).
8.3 Reasons for Declining Water Supply Services Delivery
Given all interventions made under WSDP in terms of water supply and sanitation,
environmental and social safeguards; as indicated by the figures above, the general
performance, especially in water supply coverage declined due to a number of reasons:
(i) Population increase, which does not match with investments in water infrastructure
projects;
(ii) Dilapidated water supply infrastructures, which have not been rehabilitated for so long
time. Much effort, put in constructing new projects was not enough to surpass
population increase. Hence, water supply coverage declined to figures lower than
baseline data.
(iii) Decrease in availability of water resources due to climate change that cause dry-up of
water sources;
(iv) Expansion of areas to be serviced by water utilities (a good example of the scenario is in
Arusha Municipality).
8.4 Sanitation Services
(i) Household Sanitation
It should be noted that, the main sources of data on sanitation are household surveys, which
report on types of toilets and latrines used by households in Tanzania mainland. Therefore,
information covered on this part is based on the Tanzania Human Development Report
(THDR) published by the National Bureau of Statistics in December 2011. The THDR 2011
remains valid source of sanitation information since; there is no any other current study, which
covers the field. The report shows that, the proportion of households with access to a ventilated
improved pit (VIP) latrine or a flush toilet declined from 8% in 2007 to 6% in 2010.
Furthermore, the use of traditional toilets declined from 85% in 2007 to 79% in 2010. Overall,
the proportion of households with access to basic sanitation has declined from 93% in 2007 to
86% in 2010. Indicating that, almost one in five households in rural areas has no access to a
toilet.
More effort is needed such that the target for basic sanitation under MKUKUTA II is higher as
95% by 2015, which is 9 percent points above the current household basic sanitation coverage
level of 86%.
94
(ii) School Sanitation
The MKUKUTA target for school sanitation requires that all schools meet the minimum
standard of one latrine for every 20 girls and one latrine for every 25 boys. A lack of privacy or
adequate hygiene facilities for girls can reduce school attendance and some girls‟ dropout of
school altogether due to a biological reason as pointed out in the THDR, 2011.
The most recent data on school sanitation comes from Basic Education Statistics in Tanzania
(BEST) data collected by the Ministry of Education and Vocational Training is that presented
in the THDR, 2011, which shows that the national average of pupil to pit latrine ratios (PLR)
by region is 53 pupils per latrine. Disaggregated by sex, girls‟ access to a latrine is marginally
better than boys; the ratio for girls is 51:1, for boys it is 54:1. It has been revealed that access to
school sanitation varies markedly by region, from a PLR of 27:1 in Iringa region to 78:1 in
Shinyanga. Hence, based on the MoEVT target, the current PLR for female students, which is
higher as 2.5 times the recommended ratio impends their school attendance largely if not
putting it at risk.
9 STATUS ON IMPLEMENTATION OF 6th JWSR UNDERTAKINGS
FOR FY 2011/2012
The undertakings for the FY 2011/2012 were derived from various presentations and plenary
discussions during the 6th Joint Water Sector Review meeting scheduled from 18-19 October
2011 and agreed to be implemented within one year period. In the FY 2012, the MoW has been
able to implement most of the undertakings (see Table 18 and Figure 21) with the exception of
(i) Preparation of WSDP phase II (which included preparation of objectives, targets, activities
and work plan). This could not comply with the agreed date due to extension of WSDP Phase I
from June 2012 to June 2014 of the IDA Water Sector Support Project.
The other undertaking which could not be fully implemented was the harmonization of the
work plan at national level to that of LGA level by including activities funded by donors
supporting direct to LGAs, due to lack of funds. This activity will however be done during FY
2012/2013. Also MoW did not prepare implementation action plan for addressing the issues
related with sustainability of Rural Water Supply and sanitation scheme. This activity will also
be implemented in the FY 2012/2013 after identifying all issues related with sustainability.
According to records as shown in Table 18 below, 2 out of 4 undertakings were completed by
component 1; 6 out of 11 by component 2; 4 out of 6 by component 6; and 7 out of 9
undertakings were completed by component 4. The status is therefore summarized as follows:
95
Table 17: Summary of Implementation of the 6th Agreed Undertakings for 2011/2012
Complied (C) In
progress/Partially
complied/(PC)
Not complied
(NC)
Total
Component 1 2 2 0 4
Component 2 6 2 3 11
Component 3 4 1 1 6
Component 4 7 2 0 9
Legend:
C: - Complied with by agreed date.
PC: - Partially complied//In progress and is likely to be substantially complied with.
NC: - Not complied with by agreed date.
Figure 21: Summary of Implemented Undertakings
(a) Challenges/Constraints
This sub-chapter describes the progress vis-a-vis the planned agreed JWSR undertakings to be
implemented within the FY 2011-2012. However, there has been a delay in the implementation
of 6th JWSR undertakings -2011 which can be due to several reasons such as:
(i) Accumulation of outstanding unpaid certificates which hampers smooth implementation
of planned activities;
(ii) Unreliable disbursement of funds due to DPs‟ system of release of funds against the
project‟s contractual obligations only;
(iii) Extension of the WSDP phase I from June 2012 to February 2014 contrary to the
96
original plan has negative impact on the implementation of other programme activities
financed by earmarked financiers and also delays WSDP phase II preparations;
(iv) Inadequate contract and financial management capacity of the staff to carry out their
duties causing delays in the disbursement of funds for certified works and delays in
implementation and postponement of some of the planned activities;
(v) Long procurement processes especially the World Bank prior review/no-objection
process has resulted in delayed completion of most undertakings; and
(vi) Non implementation of the CD Plans also hampers efficient implementation of the
programme especially training of staff.
(b) Recommendations for Improvement
(i) DPs and MoW should revert to disbursing funds according to disbursement projections
as far as data verification loaded in the MIS was completed;
(ii) Operationalisation of MIS to generate an accurate prediction of the cash flow demand
based on time bound contractual commitments will minimize the current bottleneck of
delayed disbursements. MIS will overcome most of the constraints experienced to date
by facilitating data handling and improved analysis of data allowing this progress
reporting to be fed into the performance monitoring and learning system.
(iii) Expedite preparations for WSDP phase II without a bridging gap.
(iv) Expedite implementation of the Capacity Development (CD) Plans concurrently with
the conducting of the scheduled impact assessment study due to the current high
demand of technical staff in most departments.
(v) Reduce some of the stages in the World Bank prior-review to speed up the procurement
process.
10 PROPOSED UNDERTAKINGS FOR 2012 AND ROADMAP FOR THE
WSDP PHASE II
(a) Proposed Undertakings for 2012
The following undertakings were proposed for the year 2012.
(i) Preparation of WSDP Phase II-including its annexes-PIM, implementation guidelines
etc;
97
(ii) Linking the functional MIS with M&E framework for ensuring continuous updating of
data and information;
(iii) Finalise water point mapping, including its mechanism for data updating on
functionality and linking it to the functional MIS to improve infrastructure monitoring
and quality reporting.
Finalise the WRM financing options study and start implementing its recommendations.
(iv) Finalise the new Institutional setup that is more efficient, accountable and transparent to
implement WSDP.
(b) Road Map for Preparation of WSDP Phase II
Preparation of the WSDP Phase II should be undertaken on the basis of the whole programme
rather than allowing each component to have its own plan and approach. The preparation of
WSDP phase II will be carried by GoT in close collaboration with DPs and other stakeholders
by engaging multi-disciplinary consultant who will conduct evaluation study on
implementation of Phase I. The evaluation report will feed into preparation of WSDP phase II.
Implantation of WSDP Phase II is expected to commence in July 2014.
The following matrix summarize the action plan for preparation of WSDP phase II by showing
the proposed actions, the means of execution, proposed activities, time frame for each activity
and expected output.
Table 18: Action Plan for the Preparation of WSDP Phase II
Action Means for
execution
Activities Time Output
Conduct
evaluation of
WSDP Phase I
implementation
GoT and DPs will
facilitate the
evaluation to be
undertaken by
multi-disciplinary
consultant under
ToR that are
acceptable to all
parties
Approval of TOR
Procure and sign
contract with
Consultant
Draft Evaluation
report for stakeholders
meeting
Final Evaluation
report.
31 December
2012
30 January
2013
30 April 201
30 June 2013
The evaluation
report in place
Prepare WSDP
Phase II
GoT and DPs will
facilitate the
preparation of
WSDP Phase II to
Approval of TOR
Procure and sign
contract with
April 2013
30 July 2013
WSDP
Phase II
with all
supporting
98
be undertaken by
multi-disciplinary
consultant under
ToR that are
acceptable to all
parties
Consultant
Draft WSDP Phase 2
Documents available
for stakeholders
meetings
Final Approved
WSDP Phase 2
Documents
31 October 201
31 December
2013
documents
and annexes
are in place
99
ANNEXES
ANNEX 1: Categories of UWSSAs, Small Towns and National Projects
Categor
y
Regional District
Headquarters
Small towns National
Projects
„A‟ Arusha, Mbeya, Morogoro,
Moshi, Tanga, Mwanza,
Iringa, Tabora, Songea,
Dodoma, Mtwara
Shinyanga, Musoma
„B‟ Bukoba, Singida Kigoma,
Babati, Sumbawanga,
„C‟ Lindi and Babati Bariadi,
Biharamulo, Bunda,
Chamwino, Chunya,
Dakawa, Geita,
Handeni, Ifakara,
Igunga, Isikizya,
Kahama, Itumba-
Isongole, Karagwe,
Kasulu, Katesh,
Kibaya, Kibondo,
Kilolo, Kilosa,
Kilwa- Masoko,
Kiomboi, Kisarawe,
Kishapu, Kondoa,
Kongwa, Korogwe,
Liwale, Kyela,
Loliondo, Ludewa,
Lushoto, Mafinga,
Magu, Manyoni,
Mahenge, Makete,
Mbinga, Mbulu,
Misungwi,
Mkuranga, Monduli,
Mpanda, Mugumu,
Muheza, Muleba,
Mwanga,
Namanyere, Nansio,
Ngara, Ngudu,
Kilindoni
Isaka,
(Mafia),
Utete,
Mwanhuzi,
Ilula,
Sikonge,
Tunduru,
Didia, Gairo,
Laela,
Iselamagazi,
Jomutinde,
Kasumulu,
Maganzo,
Magugu,
Makambako,
Mbalizi,
Mombo,
Tunduma,
Bashnet,
Bonga,
Chala,
Dareda,
Gallapo,
Mikumi,
Mlowo,
Chalinze
Handeni Trunk
Main (HTM),
KASHWASA,
Maswa,
Mugango-
Kiabakari,
Wanging‟omb
e Makonde,
Chalinze
100
Njombe, Nzega,
Orkesumet,
Pangani, Rujewa,
Same, Sengerema,
Songe, Tarime,
Tukuyu, Tunduru,
Ushirombo,
Urambo, Vwawa,
Mangaka, Masasi,
Mpwapwa,
Nachingwea,
Namtumbo,
Ruangwa
Annex 2: Status of Social and Environmental Safeguards
Subproject Status of Social Safeguards Status of Environmental
Safeguards
Lower Ruvu Distribution
Network
Draft RAP was submitted to
the WB, comments were
provided. It will be finalized
by Mid June, 2012
ESIA cleared by World Bank.
Document filed in InfoShop
Kimbiji/Mpera Well Field RAP cleared by World Bank
Document filed in InfoShop.
Third round of comments
provided by World Bank.
Upon receipt of response by
consultant, World Bank to
review at project and HQ
level.
Kidunda Dam Comments provided by
World Bank on RAP for dam.
Awaiting revised version.
Comments on Draft ESIA for
dam provided by World
Bank. Awaiting revised
version.
Comments on TOR for
Ngerengere-Kidunda Access
Road provided. Waiting for
revised TOR.
Masasi Nachingwea Water
Supply Project
Unclear. Awaiting TOR for
environmental and social
audit to assess implications of
Unclear. Awaiting TOR for
environmental and social
audit to assess implications of
101
project development without
necessary safeguards work.
project development without
necessary safeguards work.
Annex 3: Status of Projects in Category A requiring EIA
No. NAME OF PROJECT INSTITUTIONS INVOLVED
MoW
(customize) NEMC
(Review) OMR
(VPO)
(Certify)
CATEGOR
Y A
1 Construction of Lower Ruvu
Pipeline
V V V V
2 Drilling of wells for
Kimbiji/Mpera
V V V V
3 Construction of Water treatment
plant for Morogoro urban
V V V V
4 Construction of water supply and
sewerage for Tanga, Muheza,
Pangani.
V V V V
5 Construction of Kidunda dam V V Not yet V
6 Construction of Farkwa dam Not yet Not yet Not yet V
7 Construction of Ndembera dam Not yet Not yet Not yet V
10 Iringa W/SS (Phase II) V V Not yet V
11 Songea W/SS V Not yet Not yet V
12 Mwanza W/SS V Not yet Not yet V
13 Shinyanga W/SS V Not yet Not yet V
14 Mbeya W/SS V Not yet Not yet V 15 Bukoba W/SS V Not yet Not yet V
16 Babati W /SS V Not yet Not yet V
17 Lindi W/SS V Not yet Not yet V
18 Sumbawanga W/SS V Not yet Not yet V
19 Musoma W/SS V Not yet Not yet V
20 Kigoma W/SS V Not yet Not yet V
21 Mtwara W/SS, V Not yet Not yet V
22 Environment for Audit for Mchema
dam
Under
preparation
Not yet Not yet V
23 Construction of Leken Under
preparation
Not yet Not yet V
24 Construction of Leken
Enguikumet I, II dams
Under
preparation
Not yet Not yet V
25 Construction of Itobo dam Under
preparation
Not yet Not yet V
26 Construction of Uchama dam Under
preparation
Not yet Not yet V
102
27 Construction of Nkiniziwa dam Under
preparation
Not yet Not yet V
28 Construction of Farkwa dam Under
preparation
Not yet Not yet V
29 Construction of Ndembera dam Under
preparation
Not yet Not yet V
30 Masasi - Mbwinji Under
preparation
Not yet Not yet V
ANNEX 4: Status of Implementation of Undertakings
N
o
Undertaking Implementation Status Remarks
COMPONENT 1
1 The key outstanding WSDP
Phase I interventions that
consequently will spill over to
WSDP phase II. Identify goods,
works and non-consultancy
which shall not be completed
by 30/06/2013
(i) Three (3) projects for extension - (i)
Construction of Lake Nyasa, Lake Rukwa,
Tanganyika, and Ruvuma office buildings.
(ii) IWRM Plans for all basins (iii)
Rehabilitation of (6) dams in Internal
Drainage and the Mchema dam.
(ii)Four (4) spill over projects (i)
Construction of office buildings to the
remaining basins namely Pangani, IDB,
Wami/Ruvu, Rufiji and Lake Victoria. (ii)
Construction of Farkwa and Ndembera dams.
(iii) Construction of the remaining dams in
IDB (12 dams) (iv) Drilling of the monitoring
wells (60) in all nine (9) basins.
complied
2 Facilitate preparation of WSDP
phase II (including its annexes
– PIM, Implementation
guidelines etc)
(a) preparing objectives, targets,
activities and work plan for
WSDP phase II with lists of
projects to be implemented
including, MOU, bilateral and
Multilateral Financial
agreements and addendums –
basket and earmarked,
The WSDP MoU has been revised, discussed
and signed in August 2011. Draft revised PIM
main document, Volumes e.g. Financial
Management Addendum, Procurement
manual etc and Annexes were complete and
submitted to DP for final comments.
complied
103
procurement arrangement,
dialogue of WSDP phase I
3 Implement immediate measures
for strengthening of contract
management in all
implementing agencies – by
establishing/Strengthening the
Basin Tender Boards and PMUs
in all nine Basis:
The task is in good progress, already Rufiji,
Pangani, Wami/Ruvu, Lake Victoria, and
Ruvuma basins have operational Tender
Boards and PMU. The work is in progress in
the remaining BWOs.
In progress
4 Completion of preparation of
IWRMD plans for all 9 basins -
Signing contract for 5 basins
(Lake Rukwa, Lake Nyasa,
Lake Tanganyika, Pangani and
Ruvuma Basins
Contracts have been signed for (5) Basins of
Pangani (29th November 2011); Lake Nyasa
and Tanganyika (15th February 2012);
Ruvuma and Lake Rukwa (March 2012).
However, the work is yet to start in Pangani
waiting for the Advance payment requested
under in list No. 4 of the outstanding debts;
The consultant (JICA) for preparation of
IWRM plan for Wami/Ruvu Basin continues
with conducting evaluation of water resources
potential; The consultant for preparation of
IWRM plan for Lake Victoria Basin has been
selected and contract will be signed on
August 2012.
In progress
COMPONENT 2
1 Identify key blockages, drivers
for sustainability of water supply
and sanitation and actions to be
taken.
(a) Identify issues related with
sustainability of RWS and
sanitation schemes
Review of WPM to identify issues related
with sustainability of RWS and sanitation
schemes will be done after completion of
WPM exercise. So far, 82 out of 132 LGAs
have been mapped. The WPM is expected to
be completed in November 2012; The ToR
for study of hand pump supply has been
revised and sent to the World Bank on
February 2012 for no objection. The study
which will take three months shall also come
up with issues related with sustainability; A
contract for programme management support
services has been signed in April 2012.
Partially
complied
(b) Prepare implementation
action plan for addressing the
issues
This activity will be implemented after
identification of issues related with
sustainability
Not complied
104
2 Complete the water point
mapping and make it a
monitoring system, and inform
LGAs for planning and
budgeting. Inform and train
LGAs to use it for monitoring,
planning and budgeting.
WPM has been completed in 78 LGAs; A
revised work plan to complete the remaining
LGAs h was submitted to MoW in March
2012, indicating that after approval of the
requested time extension, the consultant
would take six months to complete the
remaining LGAs. The revised work plan was
commented upon by Mow and returned to the
consultant for improvement; The consultancy
assignment includes preparation of an
updating-mechanism; Completion of water
point mapping, including training is expected
to be in November 2012.
In progress
3 Revise mechanism to address
equity for resources allocation
(budget allocation, harmonise
direct specific donor support at
district level with the national
budget, work plan)
(a) Revisit the formula based
allocation of resources to LGAs
to address equity
(b) Harmonise the work plan at
national level to that of LGA
level by including activities
funded by donors supporting
direct to LGAs
The formula based allocation of resources to
LGAs were revisited in April 2012 and shared
with stakeholders in the TWG.
This activity will be implemented in the
2012/2013 budget preparation to commence
in May 2012 and later preparation of work
plan after the approval of the national budget.
complied
Not complied
4 Put in place realistic targets and
indicators for WASH.
Revise the targets and indicators
Disseminate to PMO-RALG,
RSs, LGAs & CSOs
Targets and indicators were revised and shared
with stakeholders during the TWG on
19/03/2012. After sharing the targets and
indicators in the TWG meeting, the indicators
were disseminated to PMO-RALG, RSs,
LGAs and CSOs.
complied
5 Prepare WSDP phase II
(including its Annexes-PIM,
Implementation guidelines, etc)
(a) Prepare objectives, targets,
activities and work plan for
WSDP Phase II including list of
projects to be implemented.
Preparation of objectives, targets, activities
and work plan for WSDP II including its
annexes (PIM), implementation guidelines
and list of projects, were not implemented. It
is planned to implement during the FY
2012/13.
Not complied
105
(b) Provide inputs to the
preparation of MoU, bilateral
and multilateral financing
agreements and addendums-
basket and earmarked project
Inputs provided complied
(c) Review and finalize PIM and
its annexes
PIM main document has been revised but
PIM annexes are at the final stage of review,
including an annex on sanitation, which has
been added recently. The draft revised PIM
and annexes were shared in the TWG meeting
March 2012.
complied
6 Strengthen the coordination unit
of the PMO-RALG and revisit
coordination activities and roles
(staff it with appropriate skilled
manpower).
(a) Review the roles of PMO-RALG
coordination activities.
Meeting between MoW and PMO-RALG to
review roles of PMO-RALG coordination
activities were conducted in April 2012
complied
(b) Identify and deploy
manpower requirement at PMO-
RALG for effective coordination
of water sector matters
Two water engineers have been engaged in
the coordination unit of PMO-RALG for
effective coordination of water sector matters
at the PMO-RALG level.
complied
COMPONENT 3
1 List the key outstanding WSDP
phase I goods, works, services
and non-consultancy contracts
that will spill into FY
2012/2013, and those that risk
spilling over to WSDFP Phase
II, i.e. beyond 30/06/2013.
(a) Identify signed contracts
which shall not be
completed by 30/06/2013
and forecast remaining
contract time and
disbursements.
Five (5) spill over signed projects for
component 3: (i) DSM WSS (ii) Dodoma
WSS (Korean) (iii) Sengerema Geita and
Nansio (LVWATSAN II) (iv) Bukoba and
Musoma (AfD); and (v) Kigoma,
Sumbawanga and Lindi (MDGI).
complied
106
2 Preparation of WSDP phase II
(Including its annexes-PIM,
Implementation guideline M &
E framework etc); To prepare
objectives, targets and activities
/ projects for WSDP Phase II;
Finalize PIM; Identify and list
the projects that can be
procured during 2012/2013
Outline for WSDP Phase-II for Component 3
is available. No further elaborations in view
of Phase-I extension to 2014; Inputs for
revised PIM were submitted to DPCU/PCU
with the respective annex; Four (4) projects
have been identified that can be procured
during 2012/2013 and these are (i) Tabora,
Nzega and Igunga Feasibility and Detailed
design; (ii) Kigoma, Sumbawanga and Lindi
(MDGI); (iii) Extension of KASHWASA to
Kagonwa, Isaka and Tinde and (iv)
Orkesumet W/S.
complied
3 Implement immediate measures
for strengthening of contract
management in all
implementing agencies.
(a) Establishment of PMUs in the
Seven National Projects (NP),
and strengthen the existing
PMUs in the 19 UWSAs.
The NPs do not have adequate qualified staff
for own PMUs. They currently use capacity
existing in their LGAs or regional UWSAs.
All 19 UWSAs which are autonomous and
have PMUs were advised to strengthen these
by recruiting more qualified staff
complied
4 Link M&E framework with the
functional MIS for ensuring
continuous updating of data and
information. To provide inputs
in physical project
implementation monitoring
system in MIS.
Current MIS system does not yet have M&E
capabilities. Staffs of MoW & UWSAs are
well-trained to regularly enter data into MIS
Partially
complied.
5 Preparation and approve
projects write-up template for
use by UWSAs who will be
accessing soft loans from the
Government and commercial
loans from Financial
Institutions. Complete and
finalize preparation of a
template and discuss with MoW
management for approval and
disseminate to IAs for accessing
soft loans from the Government
and commercial loans from
Financial Institutions.
Project write-up with loans guidelines has
been finalized and distributed to 19 UWSAs,
DAWASA/DAWASCO in March 2012.
complied
6 Preparation of WSDP Phase II DPP/DPCU have not yet provided guidelines Not complied
107
support arrangement including,
MoU, bilateral and multilateral
financing agreements and
addendums-basket and
earmarked, procurement
arrangement, dialogue
mechanism etc. based on
experiences of WSDP phase I.
(a) Provide inputs during
preparation of MoU,
bilateral and multilateral
financing agreements and
addendums-basket and
earmarked project
for the preparation of WSDP phase II as no
elaboration have so far been given to them by
DPs especially after extension of WSDP
phase I from June 2012 to February 2014.
Inputs will be provided after receiving
guidelines and formats for the preparatory
process.
COMPONENT 4
1 Prepare phase out plan for
WSDP phase I.
(a) Summarize and prioritize
WSDP phase I outstanding
activities based on the
available budget;
Preparation of Work plan
and review Procurement
Plan; and disseminate the
plan to IAs.
A summary and priority activities based on
the available budget was prepared and shared
with DPs; Work plan and Procurement plan
were completed and approved by Steering
Committee (SC) in February, 2012; and
Dissemination of the plan has been done.
complied
(b) Prepare a list of spill over
outstanding activities of
WSDP phase I to WSDP
phase II
Preparation of list were completed in May,
2012
complied
2 Prepare WSDP Phase II.
List down all carry - over
activities for WSDP phase I and
new activities for Phase II;
Prepare Work plan and
Procurement plan and
financing plan; Prepare
financing plan of WSDP
Components; and Prepare
Multilateral and Bilateral
financing agreements, MoU and
dialogue mechanism for WSDP
Detailed Work plan, disbursement projection
and Procurement plan were completed and
approved by SC in February, 2012; and
Preparation of list were completed in mid
May, 2012;
complied
108
phase II implementation.
3 Completing water point
mapping system, including its
mechanism for data updating on
functionality and linking it to
the functional MIS to improve
infrastructure monitoring and
quality reporting.
(a) Finalize Water point mapping
system development and testing
The development of the system has been
completed. Currently; the system is in testing
mode. Most benchmarks benefit heavily from
making sure the system in use is well
operationalizing.
complied
(b) Hosting Water Point
Mapping System at PMO -
RALG data centre in
Dodoma. (Obtain SSL
Certificates, procure, install
and configure server
hardware and software;
WPM installation and
testing).
Tender process is in good progress, as the
advertisement for procurement of supplier of
servers is completed. Thus, once the supplier is
selected, awarded and signed the contract, the
ICT Equipments will be delivered (server‟s
software and hardware to Dodoma PMO –
RALG Data Center as well as to the Ministry
Head Office in Dar es Salaam.
Note: Once the web server is located either
whether in Dodoma or in Dar Salaam the
Water Point Mapping System would be
installed on a web server instantly.
Partially
complied,
(c) Training of Water Point
Mapping users, operators
and decision makers to be
involved in the data
updating.
Preliminary training for technical support
staff was done and training for other users
and decision makers will be done once the
system is installed and operationalized.
Partially
complied
(d) Finalize ToR for
consultancy services to scale
up functional MIS to
incorporate other M & E
functions (including
integration / linkage with
Water Point mapping
system).
ToR completed complied
(e) Training of users and deploy
/ operationalize the scaled
MIS that incorporates other
M & E functions.
Preliminary training for technical support
staff was conducted as planned
complied
4 Strengthen the coordination rule Mow and PMO RALG agreed to transfer the complied
109
of PMORALG in the water
sector, clarifying functions.
(a) Transfer of the 2013 / 2014
budget preparation
responsibility and
accountability of Rural Water
Supply and Sanitation from
MoW to PMO- RALG; allocate
more funds to PMO RALG to
enhance water sector
coordination; and strengthen
PMO RALG with water
experts.
responsibility and accountability; increased
allocation of funds for Sector coordination to
Tshs.. 100m for FY 2012/2013; and deployed
two (2) water engineers in February 2012 to
the Coordination Unit at PMO-RALG for
water sector and two (2) more were engaged
in June 2012.
REFERENCES
United Republic of Tanzania (URT), 1999. The Tanzania Development Vision 2025,
President‟s Office, Planning Commission, Dar es Salaam
United Republic of Tanzania (URT), 2010. The National Strategy for Growth and Reduction of
Poverty (NSGRP/MKUKUTA) 2010/11-2015/16, Ministry of Finance.
United Republic of Tanzania (URT), 2011. The Tanzania Five Year Development Plan
2011/2012-2015/2016: Unleashing Tanzania‟s Latent Growth Potentials, President‟s Office
Planning Commission, Dar es Salaam, June 2011.
United Republic of Tanzania (URT), 2012. “Speech by the Minister for Water, Hon. Prof.
Jumanne Abdallah Maghembe (MP) on Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure of the Ministry
of Water for the Fiscal Year 2012/2013”, Dodoma, July 2012.
United Republic of Tanzania (URT), 2011. Water Sector Status Report 2011 with a Summary
of Water Sector Progress since 2007, Ministry of Water, Dar es Salaam, August 2011
United Republic of Tanzania (URT), 2011, WSDP Restructuring Plan, Dar es Salaam, June
2011
United Republic of Tanzania (URT), 2011, WSDP 7th
JSM Aide Memoire, September 2011
United Republic of Tanzania (URT), 2012, WSDP 8th
JSM Aide Memoire, May, 2012
Website: www.tanzania.go.tz; www.maji.go.tz