Top Banner

of 122

MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

Apr 06, 2018

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    1/122

    11

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    2/122

    897.9$5403

    3,2,88;089,785,550,70/4;074,3308-:7$4:917.,

    $4:917.,38,3/50450,4;079047/070,,720/,3/

    907710/3493431478:700907907,90770897,807007094-030;40398,70907340/04190:3;07809:847070070

    94.436:07,79

    %4:2,39857414:3/8:75780309074190808.03,748,55030/

    3890,/9085:898,990704;0734;07$4:917.,9//349

    .422:3.,9047708543/94011479894.439,.99

    3,,190724398410,90//0-,90,3//0-07,94390

    39073,943,.422:39089,39/0./0/9,990,/94907,4394908594800447,9,838/0,3//090723090

    249;,9438147907570803.043,79

    3.0,90,2410330078,813,,-094.:9907,974:1;0

    100941209,9007084.0/94/8.4;07349,8:57020390039

    ,3/54071:7,.041-038-:97,907,:0545:,94341/08507,90

    ,3/05088,03889,7;3,3//3

    %07007024709,3,24341902$420490,03843-4,7/

    ,/4899070,/0785,3/39003.,574-,-/:094/80,804184203/,3/070540708894709:739407090.,20174247

    2,39,390-,8.300/81479078:7;;,

    3901,.0418:.8:11073,3//08507,9439070,8,34:954:73

    4139073,943,:2,39,7,380392039940590/3,0389,8

    .0,79,9,/0114798.4:/349-0.,770/4:9439085,3/8490

    ,03545:,943,897,3854790/94,3,70,439074:3/3

    4,3308-:707070010114798070.43.0397,90/394,3/41

    701:00.,25,3/-01470903099,/-0.420,8:2%0.,25,8.,0/$%#%

    #0,9438-0900390,038,3/904.,545:,9436:.9:730/

    84:7,2/89,.2,904110,7,.2,909,98443-0.,204:979

    4899%057,38,890,038070.,0/07094:994-0

    ,7088;0,3/;4039,3/,39,037498844307:590/

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    3/122

    %039073,943,.422:39708543/0/-03.48390.,253,

    29,70/-47/07147905:754790/57490.94341-4990,038

    ,3/904.,545:,943%07570803.0.,2094-094:941,8,

    -:7/03,3/9050450414,3308-:7-0,3940907,3990,038

    940907-07024;0/4707,/.,90/

    %4/,897.98.,:9:53,0-41540770,9438%0,038

    ,703090738/03474:98/090,90,70-49-03894-0

    57490.90/,80,810,70/,3/.439,30/974:,0,8890241

    7,.,8070,943;03908:73,970/4190,038-904.,

    545:,943414,3308-:79039073,943,.422:39,834.4.0

    -:994704.,9090,03894897.9,3014720/24/073/,

    ;0784341,.43.0397,943.,25

    %88909088419012897.9,24;0/70.90/-,$4:9

    17.,3120/3$4:917.,,3/8093$4:917.,%04.,94341

    90128349,.43./03.09024;003,.98,7941904.41

    7,.,4907,9439,9,890.4704.41905,790/$89023

    $4:917.,%0,5,790/88902,8,0,7020417,.,

    805,7,9439,9,890/174294

    %0$4:917.,3209,5478:36:0549039-0.,:80984304190

    248905.9.,808419070208417,.82,9904;0732039,0;0

    0707,.,.,90470807003.4/0/3,0;08414;0732039

    897:.9:70147/0.,/08982,0890$4:917.,3.439750147

    ,55.,9439449077,.,.4398-0.,:80:8903897.990

    -:70,:.7,9.88902412,3,02039.70,908,309.,/89,3.39,9

    70/:.0890490794,/8548,-00;003,-3034./0:7

    $,7,4:80!4503,03:83088$.444:3/39077:590/390':307,-941;0789,3,020399954503,7.;0.-8/-98970,2,3/0$,7,*4:80*:75/1806:03.0

    398,90,974.908.,55030//:7390,5,790/7020,8,40/94,550394,70,903/-0.,:8041,9,:2,338570/-0;3,8.,0/247,/89,3.0%7,/943,09.8-,80/43:/0308.4/0847.,.:,9438903/894.70,90247,/89,3.0,3/:3/07230507843,247,9!,707430809,4389,/,3/2499,:2,3430890348%0348,3/249903/898,7:2039,89054394:99,9-:70,:.7,.,48,3/03.4:7,0898025400894

    /0;045,990.,,.,.:,933893.93890,/41,247,3893.9%8247,/89,3.0803/0/3-:70,:.7,9.47,33070/0.843880/427043903/;/:,247,4190025400-:93890,/43850.1.7:0847;79:08/0130/-,2,3,02039,3,02039/0./08,9.43899:908,;79:4:8.,7,.907,3/9:8,44/025400%0474341,5,79.:,7,.94389:8349/0907230/-490,.9472801938,-4:9

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    4/122

    980110.98-:9-98-033.43147299907:08,//43-948044..:5,077,3390-:70,:.7,9.07,7.9034889,3.0-49047,5.,,3/07,7..,8398,1443430809,,897,909,9419030,/9490/8548,41507843,.,70:70,:.7,98,;0944-047/078,9,9208,3/47/078,703496:089430/-,8038041507843,247,,:31708,398;0,.9478,99025994,.0;0247,30:97,9974:-4958.,,3/07,7..,/89,3.0430809,%01,.041904907507843/8,550,780390708,/89,3.03-0900390801,3/904907,3/0,7005480/94,9-49,:2,3,3/0;3,84://03490,8,3011,.020393011,.02039901,.0/8,550,78,3/3/;/:,8,7043

    8003,8.,9047084703990894-02,3,0/%0/0,,-4:9247,/89,3.0.70,90/--:70,:.7,.85:99498

    7020-,:2,34/8.:880849044.,:89,8247,5488-044.,:89147,:2,3890.7:00890,250414,,703:2-074150450.,3-08:-0.90/94,3088039,:99,7,3.,.:,9430709043.43.0738490-08920,38,;,,-0.,32009,5,79.:,703/%0702,7,-06:089431443430809,84-:70,:.7,9.47,3,94382,3,09403.4:7,03472,247,5045094-0,;03,94:/490780-070,7/0/,82247,,8%034870,9089498030,7:089,99,83472,,3/.;0/50450,3/3493;0907,908,/89845,;0/90,147%70-3,%0803472,,3/.;0/50450070473147-:70,:.7,9.47,3,9438%0.4://08974,4050450-8993,9907/088%0348

    ,:317081448983041,7:2039,943990.,29,9-:70,:.7,9.3899:94383:2-4:7247,25:808,3//0:2,30:8%02,0:8147094:780;08347/079470840437:08,3/4-0/03.094,8,3/2,3,02039050798,398,,-:8308809.8-:/43-:70,:.7,9./89,3.07024;0802540081742907507843,8038041247,9398;009.8/40834903.4:7,0247,,.943831,.99:3/0723089-0.,:809814:3/,9437:084:990507843,247,

    7085438-9843,80,.98403.431472997:080,70430,7085438-0-:90,7030;07247,7085438-094:$4:917.,//349050703.0842093,8477-0,89044.,:894790034./08347207:48,;,,3/#,3/,90.7:09083$4:917.,.,3-0.425,70/9490804907.7:0908147-039,7090/88902,9.,,,389,5,79.:,774:54190545:,943%0,-4;02039430/,3,808419044.,:89,3/247,/89,3.0.,390701470,84-0,550/9490,5,790/70203$4:917.,,9,55030/3$4:917.,,8,84,110.90/-,3:2-0/507843,247,9,3/,247,/89,3.0,3/988.,0,8349/:094900397090545:,943-033070390;-:9-0.,:8041,337430,897:.9:70.8:554790/8070,943,8070,943.,8,3/94,,70/070089884/00574490/390504509,90;0390-,.545:,9438:554790/90-,8./0,841908070,94354.,7,;,,3,;0,8494/8947084149007030;0797:08:5547907841,5,790/:9,89,8842093842,35045070:59,3/1472,399446:9084209209470,0,931,.9,/,55030/,

    ;03,890128$4:917.,3.439;0890209,547417,.0,

    54071:54903.,8,84.,7010;0.79.82905078431.,94341

    490730883901:704190,0303,-08901294574;403898

    ,3/.79.,94:9.43.07334:72489-,8.;,:08,3/88:088:.,8

    84.,306:,97,.828070,94303.,2520398.03.0,3/

    29,7829843974:908.03.01.9433,77,9;041,0389,9

    8:.,84.,.796:0.,388:01479

    .,:/

    .,0 ,&$4703$07;.0411.071470,78-014709:7331:92094793 807;0/,8.9305:98889,39$0.709,741$9,90147$.03.0,3/%0.34470.9474190$9,9005,792039811.0 41/;,3.0/ %0.344 389074:38047 147 3;7432039 $.03.0,3/ %0.344 ,9 90207.,32-,883%44,3/,84:380471473;7432039$.03.0,3/%0.344,990207.,32-,883!,78 439,.9903;,9438:74508,3/0,78,-4:93.4:390737,90770897,8 ,90 ..0880/

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    5/122

    9954/8,3/,038.427084:7.08439,.9903;,9438.,0.,:/5/1%%07084343043089,380794906:0894341,9390039,038-00,3/490-0,;094,7/:84:2,334841:8,70850.:,93%,9/40834920,39,90,70-0317;44:8 850.:,9438.,3,;0;,:0:7850.:,9438,70,,41443,94:780;0841

    933,-4:9:2,33/1742,34;0507850.9;0%0.43.05941 7,90770897,39003.003.4:7,08 :8 94 44 ,,3 ,9 90 20,33 41 :2,3 08903.0 5745480/ ,208 789,3 94548450,,39490440,,3949,0,3490744,94:7,84:709.84:723/84:7340/0:7850.:,9438,-4:94907.;,9438,70,,414433944:7431:9:70%0.,38:0890907901:9:70081474:780;0847901:9:709,9010,7.420 10/4349.,304:7,8030050.97,90770897,894-0247,8:50747,3/,97:89.0,704539,90-02470247,,3/,97:89.3901:9:70 8.03-,.5:999070,9 242039 41 .439,.9 2, 825 7023/ :8 9,9 ,9 0 2489 ,39 8 94 13/ , -09907 ;07843 41 4:780;08 :7850.:,9438 ,84 ,70 ,7338 !70/.93 9,9 4907 84.0908 2, ,;0 8:..:2-0/ 94 ,77:3,, 545:,943 749 03;7432039, /,2,0 47 /8,8974:8 050720398 8 , , 41,7334:780;08414029/07,90:2,3,/;039:700302,30,03894-0;.4:8.436:074780,705740.9310,78,-4:9:2,3.431.98:7850.:,9438,705,914728

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

    0,70.43174390/9,8479841,032,084:7/,;08974:

    8.03.01.943%0,03,8039070/3944:7.:9:7,2,3,7,3/

    9889,9:88,89041.43903943,8;,74:8.43.0594387,304;07

    54797,3907.43.059434184.09974:90209,54741,038

    $4203,77,9;0854797,,038,81703/,3/;3,243:88:.,8

    ,14790.43902547,7,32,90/5747,2:990;,892,47941

    ,038.03.01.9437057080398,038,8,907713970,9;893

    5,3090,79147/,7,3/8389075:754808390803,77,9;0890,03890030241:2,33/,3/2:89-0/089740/,3/

    0723,90/,9,.4898

    0/,419803703.:/0,7419047/83/0503/03.0,

    0390%3074381742:907$5,.0908940843,3/

    43%0808.03.01.943705708039,9438,705740.9438414:743

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    6/122

    10,78,3/,309084394,32,3,749074850784310/390

    147241,4890,037,.09420,705072,3039,9,7

    #,.8974:58,3/9029,7,708034/41983,77,9;04190

    0;,03,3/507509:,93,.48:7094,7/84907308839084.,

    2,3,78473:54557088;0/044087,.7$90;037,.57410884741,3974544,947/,39073,943,&3;0789&839031472,94309951:0/:=27,.8&314,09208(

    070,82,35045039078947/903/943907570990&,8,20.,382,37,90770897,85,.08550450390%7/47/474:7947/903/94800934907.4398%04190339075709&-038,84/885798,308/0;,8471,0708$2589.,,3/5,9073,89.,0890737080,7.078,88:209,990,7034982,79034:9470,090,70/0,39,903,90.344.,,/;,3.0/84.093494-02,907,3:98,3/-4984-0.98 :98420&4898,70.423,74:3/949070,,9439,990,03;02,-0,574/:.9414:743:36:014470,3/.:9:70743:543,/09418.03.01.943207.,38,70570/85480/94,88:20,39390/439:3/0789,3/2:89.42017424:90785,.0$420390&7080,7..422:39,70.,701:/0.43897:.9390-4:3/,708-09003&050703.08,3/49073/8410;03987,331742704:8;84388:.,8,92,940,707705479841897,304-0.9839089070,9785,;009.94:2,37080,7.078,3994.43;03039/,9090-03334190&503420343949800280&003.4:39078,;00890/974:4:98947,3/9,9907,90770897,39075709,943417080,7.078704:94190.43941207.,3.:9:70,99,9

    920%0&8002894,;0/85,0/147,43920,7010.9;05745079897,3027747347,39.5,9390050.9,943847-0018419084.090709803.4:39070/30939,9988147.3907080,7.0794/489414.:824700,;4390507.5039,3/0884390507.059!,79 ,3/5,7.0419030:1448,70,,9439,934943/48420&9308808,;02:950.48003.4:39078-:9,849041903,;0,1089471:4149073/841897,305,7,58.44.,5,7,3472,47:3:8:,050703.087,331742549070899505034203,94390710703.0900.9743.06:52039&03.4:390788420920880029497074:9-70,8419080:3:8:,5034203,47,,033841

    58..549039,8-:94190390144897,30050703.088:.,8570.439;0/70,28470,73897,3034808,80 %031472,943,0,82,/0:2,33/,,709,99080950841050703.08.,3-014:3/3:89,-4:9,3.:9:70-:9490,70/0,99;,708174284.099484.09$420.:9:70870,7/,3/

    ;,:0570.4:8.439,.9899090747/308907384.0904190370098:.050703.089/,34808412039,308847478030939,9,550,7894-0.0,789,9908095084103.4:39078800294574107,903.:9:7089,9,702470,..059341902:992,349-090.,809,990,7024701706:03992,825-09,9504503948084.0908,702470394/08.7-0,3//8.:88:3:8:,050703.08990750078%0.:9:7,25,.943&050703.08,550,7894-0.0,7-:9431:039,98706:7081:79070547,943%4:,4-,:3/0789,3/34190&50342034384898307039.:9:7,2,0,-94190050703.0-98/43920,3948:0899,99070,7039:3;078,80300/94805,7,9090050703.0174290.:9:7,39075709,94389,9504504;07,4394940;07,92,0898574-02,9.89,9905034203439801800289405703147.0948039075709,94380;03708543/894902384205,7,/4.,,0300/944-043/902,31089,943894903307473841905034203433/39738.,98002894-0,.43974889024184203/

    %0&,8,43974$8902%0&,90;0792,-0,550,7894,;090,-994,907.438.4:83088507.05943,3/948420/07002,-00;0385,.0,3/92098010.8'$9,550,7894-0,331472,94383:,79.8002894/7,-98,3/50.084170,9,74:3/9394,3047/07!8.,70,98/894790/3;,74:8,8.,9902:9,9438.745.7.0825,398507.50395844.,.,3088:-8/,7549070895034203,09.398,0:99/40839,550,794-0,397:0,../039,94:7899897,3898974:4:770,98002/0-07,90,2489.4397;0/14.:80/4384208479413907,.9439:8,1-,0/570/.9438,7094/94.439,.9008,-/:.9008,3/,03.,330078,-4:9

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

    :2,3-0389/1107039802,39.897:.9:70814747,33907507.059438 9543989490/7,2,9.,83

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    7/122

    .8.03.0,3/90.344800294-097,38147231:3/,2039,.43.05984105890244,3/43944%020/:28902,88,0',008:089890&1:3.9438,8,3/419072489,9,70:,947.0583,;,904:784.09-,.94,7/908:-90,3/903;8-0,190798-0.42094414.:80/43907488,3/90;8-091:3.9438,8,3/41,:947085438;0.4397488902:93100/-,.94.,03048810/5,7,/2820209.897:.9:708,3/-001889028:990:80418:-90.4397420.,3828.,3349,;0-003489439020341#!42,-039070890/390&90.34414724704;0793/84158.44.,.43974!,7,34,,8439740.,38239020/,,3/545:,7.:9:70,80,890&

    570889,41&3;,843,3/.443,9438002894-0743,9,7090808389077,8:594,1907,

    99070309.8,253.,9902:9,93,3/80.709:3/0774:3/-,80894:,033;,8438,;0-003,89,504124;0883.0,7419047/83;,84341904/$3,9.078,3/444/88,:.071.89800280904890,033;,8432020,8709:730/9,;030,3.039080;04301742904;,-0,031.841908$9,72,3%4803.4:39078945,7,34/2,890750.088:.,83/0503/03.0,,3/%'8488:.,89008,3/,7$08070,34300;034:730-47.,3-0,5,34190,0388389072,89075,3;03;/04,208070,478307/080907,%###0897,3.4:390705100/9829443945:-..438.4:83088399,70,84190,9073,9;020/,29,74:58,3/&74:5889,7984:3/30277472,08410,.49075749089341-,.

    0.4590788:7;0,3.000.9743.,7,882039033,.,3/047/7/078439024;0908:5702,.8974:58,;04990339490,2041107390743;843418:507:2,3-43/7,3!0,/0,38070948,;0:817428,793907,,.9.-,3078,3/5,7,8908#,.029:7099:7384:98:89,34907897,90-90-,/,038940,0390897,3,3/5705,70:81473;,843,890:1,783/7420,37,90770897,;7:814:3/4390%:3:8,20904790/$%,890$,78547078.:990/94,;4/5045013/34:99097:9,-4:990/43,,7901,.98%080,3/49076:08943880029487,74:3/90&10/94/,1,.9,3/1.943-03/380,20889409070,84:9/43902/850.:,9438410,707&7080,7.07870,7/3747.090,808,3/.4;077:5889029,7,80,730/974:4:9894710,78,70,924-074150450,3/,30.00395705,707147,7;03

    190030208,702,3,747907/00/80,07,90/3,307,070904/,7803/34.,390&$29,7147.082,39,39073.70/-054794341903,943,50,3&4898,;02039430/#43,/#0,,386:59,990370,9-,990-0,,389,30302174285,.0!0450,7013/3088,3/0889,990.,3:3909419,,3893:2,3938174285,.029190-6:903.0:.0,70,5438,3/$.,313/,3080.43/,7:891.,943147,7/341174:0,89074/8174285,.02,-00;030;7,84:9949:73:839457490384:540;07/4399398305,7,34/5,80390&$8,/0-07,90.4397;0/-9029,72:920/,.4250,993,8,55030/89,99029,784-808843980.70./8.530,3/897039,850720,90/4:70397084.09,

    3,9:7,708:941;3:3/07,.:9:70413,943,80.:791478443#,9079,3842074907,9.3:80;0,89,790/,9.30,.4907974:4:7.,2.47/0787,/48.,33078,3/,2,90:78506:52039%0&29850720,93903907309,705,79,3/5,7.041,,707897,30703454-,.

    8002894-09,34/3545:,7.438.4:830880,774-8504504190770,843,3/.480890723/8,,38990:33439,.9;,9089024893893.9:,5,7984190:2,323/9480.43.0730/9507843,8:7;;,

    %097:57414:3/93,-4:9897.989,998:-;079898

    3,77,9;0#,9079,3-034890,3/0;90,0383897.9

    ,70,91789/08507,90,3/05088%0,038,7084435,.0/3,8479

    41701:00.,259,9-0.420829,70/,3/4557088;082,79490

    /0,9.,25841,072,3

    %74:98:36:02,3,741,038897.903,.98,.796:041

    904.414907,9439,9708:98390034./0419480/0020/

    /1107039,3/0889,3:2,3897.98.796:0414907,943

    ,5508349:8994,5,790/-:9,8494,41904.84184.,

    ;403.03.:/3&$29,72507,823.:/390,7837,6

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    8/122

    ,3/1,389,390038,;020394117.,38,3/90034./041,

    90504508390207.,84308

    ,990&3;078941,3.08907897.9#0;028947!740.9:809952:80:0/:4:73,812*,3/*8947;430892

    $4-038897.9/70.90/-042,25,3/574/:.0/-%047/4190#38!0907,.8439980,7998 8,8.03.01.943-4.-:89079,9,8,438/0,9.20384:99470.4;07842070850.9,-9147900370,2/8.74541545.473850.9,.08%7,381472078#0;0304190,03%0723,947$,;,943,3/,207.4209423/#0509094-;4:8,:843894$4:917.,8-7:9,8070,90/5,89988,123.8420932:.2470390708938,947-030,9908.14889,33982:950.4:8383/00/9020/,,8/4302:.94574249098,8,129,938420,03,08990894741,5,790/:839090730884198,03894/8.:88$4:917.,87,.,90784170.039/0.,/08%07082:.9390129801948:55479.,289,9905498905488-90814784.,.422039,79,9,703070393908.03.01.943037042394908.7003039703.0/3,8974380380412,383:2,39942,3897.983498,9810/998,:843894,5,790/-:93890,/4482:./0050739490894741909.039:7,3/.4330.9890/498-09003,90:2,3

    .7:09913/803;,3/0070,7384304190,03834994494897.9 9030.,25-:9850.1.,14790;89478908038041:703.,3/4774738;4.00,/8430942,309,93857,9431479084:9439490,03574-0229,;0-003/7,3174290,83,$4:9434790$4;09:,8%080.,25807090280;08-,80/43570.0/0398809-90$5,38/:7390%030,78,790207.,38/:7390!5530207.,3,7,3/90798/:7390407,73$4:917.,9801897.98897.9/7,843,43,3//70,/1::2,3079,04139072039,3/.,89898477478394,3,9442,3,-01:9:70%:890128:08989,9,843,80507.0;058.,/110703.0-09390728417,.047850.0894-0,831074158..,/882,799038:.-7:9,8,94370.:79834940;07438947.,4774789,9,70,40/940207039490129%0:3/0774:3/29,780/05072039,9438904507,90/-908,/4:93,943,&390/3.:888:-0.90/943:2,3.7:09849,931472,943.,3-0,9070/,-4:92/85,824709,3,5,88382,79411:3.943,3/5:7548094:,39,3,24,,3/9084.,0/-,.8908,.7488904-0%01,.99,9,3434;0732039,47,38,9432,3,08984507,94370.,8901,7234:94180.:797085438-90894,.,90747//0340,3/9057419007341,-:7943/:73904343,737,6%4:897.92,0805.9011479894/7,.4330.9438-0900398/8945,31:9:70,3/850.1.8947.,,974.9089,84800894.4220394390.:77039/870,7/147:2,3-038/85,0/3.43902547,7.431.98384/4398:08989,90,705,79414:7438947087050,9390-7:9,9414:75,89,3/10.4393:0:3,-,90/5740.939394,1:9:70070;89478944:75,309-0970,90/32:.908,20,,80,;0970,90/,3/.4393:094970,90,.49073/!,0(%070845040;073901288:089439,990-4:3/,708-09003$01,3/907,7050720,-0:8:3/07408,574.088412:9,943-0.423,3,032801304190;894782,088434:7301742970,9033549039,90774789.443:5,90.344.,/0;.03,//03,-3908:29457490.947,3/8,;4:741900,,3/4:3/0/:89003/418

    97,381472,9430,8-003;03,:2,33,207894507,3/-03894/85,:2,30249438 %,9.805,7,908

    2,31742,03,3/03.07,.017427,.0817,0,3/5078,-090$01,3/90907,70:92,90908,2093%82,78,/7,89..,301742908.03.01.943419081742.9812/7,88989.,%0-:00/,038,3/,39.243890789,989,0/207.,8.302,8.700383902//041909.039:7070349907094-0:3/078944/-:994-0023,90/%04;070232,4790704890,3/39039434:7/0897:.943288:.,83;,8434190$,:.0703,3/%0,7419047/8.,89,038,8770.43.,-/11070391742,3/:3702993970,903394:2,3-038%4:91988420;8:,7010703.0817429080128897.9807;08949:8941,7.302,,8.420-/05.9390:2,3$01,3/90,03907,894,;0841908,2040%02088,09,99012,81479047/98002889,918.03.0

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    9/122

    1.943.302,.,3,-,3/4398,04/-0019,9-44.,,3/03.07,.,/110703.006:,908942,31089/893.94388907089419047/89.:9930,.49074503570:/3430,34907,..47/39483.44:7,3/708543/3,8152039,943070/0893%88,8.03.01.943-4.-:89079,997:9890549039,419820/:294.,0309084.4549.,89,9:86:4

    98984907,9439,989014:3/,94341034./0,3/3:.0,7,33,9434;0!741!4422!8.3890340,38990$9,9041:.0,7%077475%077,943,99,941903-01,874:5843902,7384184.0970;0,89047341,0307,20.,3829,9:3/4:-90/

    .4397-:9083,2,47,949089,-94177,943,,3/4557088;084.,47/0780384.09,8,40877,943,,3/50720,90/9;403.0,3//423,9439030,.3/;/:,93989,3/9439073,0 842041908,20,8047807:3890,:390941507843,/0;045203939073,020,390/0;045203941:3.438.4:8897:.9:70/70,943894907800,.,;0,339073,0397,58..74:54170,9438-0900390,3/909079,984390430,3/6:901,39,89.,3/4:941220/,90.439,.99073,70,904390490788,50/-9,970,9,3/88,50/-939:73$:.8,534..:78974:902039,574.08808.,0/ 39740.94324/0341

    90801-9047/,3/5740.94324/03419047/,..47/39490801%0907-039030,9434190801.,39,0432,3.,7,.90789.844/47-,/%0907907014708-49,74:

    705.,943419044/3088,3/-,/30884190073,47/,80,8,/090723,39419,944/308847-,/3088030.437:,9039474:583.:/39084.09.83907,94908074:589070,94384190730889,043,/0.8;025479,3.0473901472,94341,74:5,3/418599330.088,79,085,.0-0900300203984190907%88599388,50/,-4:990770/:.-01,.9419074:54784.09,3/98/0399190708,74:5903430809073947349742,34907,3074:589,08,50,-4:990/0542039419010034138/030883/43.04308390390702:89-0,34:98/0190708,3207.,903430.,3-0,3207.,3184903,49078-0.420907,3/343207.,38

    471470307849418947,89:730/,74:3/901,.99,990-,8.38/04:98/070,94384174:58,;0.42094-01:80/99044/3088,3/-,/30884190907%03,948038/0-0.42044/,3/,4:98/0-,/%0202-078419074:50,.709:7394-0341905:710/50,8:7004/08.7-0/0,707030070/0;04539034943415,7,34,,3/900307,58.444190.34.7,. 3841,7,890-,/4:98/09,0843,50780.:9476:,99074:59801-0.42085,7,34/9980/110703.0-090039074:5,3/903/;/:,0;09,9903/;/:,5,7,34,.050703.089050780.:943220/,90090202-07419074:5838:,90/-/0391.,94399049078,3/847075,79.5,94339074:5857,.9.0398,905,7,34,8/00,90/949074:5,8,400298,9,99-0.4208/08:-0.910/,3/5,8808-043/9058.440841903/;/:,84190

    74:5%03/;/:,23/702,38:3/07908,4190,11,943419044/9079,9702,3838/074:570,94380,309050780.:947549039,41904:98/078870/:.0/-/0:2,3,943%88450450702,33472,3/;/:,0.4:3903,3.3,3/0;03,.9;0.,7734:9902489034:8,3/77,943,,.9843909310/,3//0:2,30/-4/08414:98/0789908:8,49,-4:947,.4:8,3/3/90$4:9073078.4:/3.,3/.,897,90-,.841444/.0,3011.039072,38.4:/9:7308394,258,/0841487,089907,3.03997,/9434108.425,8843,9030880,730/974:.039:708418:11073.4:/.,.:,90//8548808890!,0893,350450 ,3/41.4:7804901703/207.,38.4:/,33,907482,,3/.:99078,9974:8947

    8,32,3,9;0089:7041,.340/2039,3/.79.,7010.94343

    90894741.443,82,3/,8,.43/023,943419095041;4039

    4907,9432,/005.93908.03.01.9433,77,9;041897.90411079014435,3

    %0&390/$9,9080/07,4;073203984:/-:/,97,3:,7

    243:2039439039073,943,$5,.0$9,943

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    10/122

    :/3,243:2039439039073,943,$5,.0$9,943708543/894

    90.48070,94385419085,.089,9439490.443,039075780

    ;039085,.089,943,-47,94783,20/4:2-:89097,3:,7

    8,507010.989097,3:,7:7450,317.,3207.,83,9:7041

    .443,9437010.939097,3041207.,39,82,3/9097,/.

    897:.9:70412507,828,;07034./0$:.,243:20394:/

    82-4.,3.:.,90,473974:4190894741034./0

    .70,90,.,:943,7573.5014785,.00547,943,,3891:9:70

    .443,89;403.0-4703934:709.894,7/870850.9,3//39

    147,0310,7880

    ,3879:77907,3/4:73,89%00,.414:2-:8043,7/4!740.9:809952:80:0/:4:73,8043,7/4;2,788092;3903,204:2-:89490:7450,3$5,.0,-47,94790:7450,3$5,.003.

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

    98013949,398%0288435,9.14790:7450,385,.0,-47,9474:2-:8848,-:0.7.0,8,82-41475,309,79.74880/-,9030%83089,3/81474:2-:81009

    .74883909,39.17420,8994089,80,814790$5,.0$:990.7488391742089940,899070-97,3854793903024/:0949039073,943,$5,.0$9,943$$%0805.9:708,70944-0,:91:94-097:0%0708349908908939,990,2-:941900,.9,94:2-:8,3/8.43902547,708019147:89448,8190:7450,3/8.4;070788094:9147904.0,385:7094,3340/094574;09,990,79874:3/:99,983499097:9%0,/2,88;00.4342.249;08:7450,397,/3.425,3080700,074431473097,/074:908948,94.4:3907908,2.97,/0784.439740/9097,385479-,3/!479::0808,4780709739484;098574-02-.7.317.,%07,5574,.,550,782470,55.,943470390/438905-8905.9:,9070,.0/900.4342.4,6:.079,34:2-:848094:914790089%8,8,1:3/,2039,30,5574,..5,;0/90,94574;00257.,9,990,7970,,8,4-0390437:399:730/4:994-024708:..0881:0;0330.4342.907284:2-:8/8.4;07-74:9:3570.0/0390/0,994:7450-45033:59097,389,39.97,/0$0,547994380;07544

    789447/0,:477089-488420/38:757838479920-9,3,/;,39,041908030-:83088455479:3908 :94:/4390,813/243:203989,97023/4:414980,9.390437:32,/0,

    90..4250090$$5488-0,8.70,90/%8202478349574:/57080390/347-90700;07-4/.4:/8009988,201://0343,794:.4:/13/9147389,3.043,3:3850.9,.:,797,11.8,3/3,3:3850.9,.:,75,7941,2-:707043;071094:78984%897,3:,78,50/97,11.8,3/84.,90/30,7905,.0070.:77039;03,/897.9.,0/,3/8-00703174394190,3/8-0943,90,/23897,943/0./0/94070.99700-74308.:59:70884325479,39507843,9081742,3/8-085,89%0430..,:80/5:-.57490898840/037.,77,1;43$.2202,3343810920,8.438/070/907.0892,341:745043:20398147$,;0%7,/0789,89084:7.041$.2202,3380,9,3/90,9,82039430/43,30,7-5,909,9.,:80/9057490898'894784190243:2039.4:/70,/9070$.2202,338.438/070/,89014:3/0741,3/8-080.4342.897039&3/07847/8590704314:780/84-0.,:80419084.,0/97,3097,/0.,.4,3/71088,;08

    8:,7.,30,3/.49943-09003:745017.,,3/207.,0,8.438/070/907.0892,341:7450$00%0/8.4;0708414:2-:85,;0/90,1479097,3:,797,/0.3.:/0/8,;083

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    11/122

    :3570.0/0390/3:2-07802,34907.903841,2-:7109,8,20/9,924;0732039070.90/,243:2039147,8,;097,/07:9-01470,79.:,9325749089,390/94342470,-4:9 9897,3097,/00,730/9,99,8,3/413907.4393039,574/:.943.,3,7:,-90178970,4-,-:83088$.2202,334,/0/88583:74509.49943574/:.980.,.47108,3/,.44.,/,-003574/:.0/38432,3:1,.9:708%08044/807097,3854790/9490089.4,894117.,070900700.,30/1478,;08%08,;08070-74:99490,7--0,38,3/8944743$.2202,338435,39,94384794-084/38,;02,70984,/0/98:,7.,30,3/.499431742905,39,94383/!,0(90858039-,.94:7450070908044/8-0.,207,2,907,147$.2202,338

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

    9389825479,399434,-4:99014:3/,94384:,7089,3/3433573.509070834937439243:203981478,;097,/078:9984:/-0/430574507984:/057088,.0,754894343983/41-:83088,3/9825.,9438147905708039,3/901:9:703/507,58248925479,39984:/-0070.90/,9,5745074.,9433174394190,3/8-0943,90$.2202,338.:59:70.8:-806:039,87024;0/-984307290.2-//3493-:905708857/0,3/,5570.,94314790,.0;0203984198-:830882,3%070,834779,930020393499089089394190

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

    ,89743,:98;3,3/473439085,.089,943:9 84203/41243:2039830.088,794:99,85,.0,-47,9479903,20414:2-:84:/349-0.4250900300/842093.0,7;8-09490,89743,:98,80,89450450,9.31742-049,97023/8:89493,0,/-01470

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

    .;,943439485,.00,;0,:36:0455479:3994:57,/04:784.,4507,9388902%070,830;07-003,-0990792094.,3090/70.94341:2,30;4:943:90300/8974382-489405:8941:198034724:89,80300/8:.,82-40850.,43904:2-:824/:0%07084:/-0,5:-./0-,90,-4:94-08994.4220247,9090;.92841:7450,305,3843%489,7990/0-,9057454809,98:.,243:203943-4,7/4:2-:884:/,;0,97,3:,78,50

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    12/122

    897.9857414:3/84.,.796:0.,343-0.,770/4:9974:

    8.03.01.94343974:8.03.01.943.,3901:3/,2039,

    209,58.,84:7.0414907,943,3/;403.0-02,/0,55,7039,3/

    .439089,-090.470418.03.01.94308398390774,94341900,.41.443,82,3/98904317,2047..,30110.9;0

    574-02,90,3/97,3814724:770,94385944:7.443,5,89#,55:3

    7.!7410884741%044,990&3;0789419,4897.9,8!489.443,$.03.0.943995/:30/38.4447/57088.42.302,,8047.8294/897.9,85489.443,8.03.01.9434393:3439904..,843,302,,847.82807080-0/0;3394902:7,907841905489.443,47/

    9,97594897.990;07130/0-:9121742$4:917.,3/70.947042,25574/:.0/-4.,-42,/044/!0907,.843%0128,3,047.,0547,94341904343.489841:7450,3.443,8214717.,,3/98504508%4:3,;07/1107039803809889012,8047.82,;8.07,7,553990489841905,895,79.:,79,941$4:917.,3,5,790/94:842041901282088,082470:3;078,897.9880943,3,9073,9;092030390.9414,3308-:73,9894390.,88.8.03.01.943894741,033;,84390894190,398,:.07,334;0790.90;40898,8/;0780,890123/0503/03.0,,3/904/900;84380708' 90,03;89478,77;043,79349,8.436:07478-:9,889,7;3/0247,80/,3/0,/07088701:008%072,88;085,.0.7,19.,8,1,724701:3.943,449,394800,70:80/9480038,/070.970.894550/4;0790.9349147897,90.70,8438-:9-0.,:809,980709,55030/94-70,/43%0$4:917.,34;0732039,9178950,80/9,990,038,/.4803907.4:397844313/89801924709,3,243,03;8947849007/3949099:,7897.9%03,77,9;041901245038,89057;,90.425,33.,7041,03,11,7890838907,3/,944-00;,-0:93,943,&390/&80984:9940;.9,4190,038,3/24;090294897.9,9039.9:3/70/84142097084:98/04,3308-:79,980;033&80892,90834930889,3,.43.0397,943.,25%4:43908:71,.090128973

    ,3/397:3034:94-0099343994:/-0,70,9/8807;.09470,/9907,34300;09.079,38,8947,-4:9,038;33$4:917.,-:943,349070;098,-4:9842093,940907

    24708074:8,3/8420931,72470:380993%0,3,4-0900390,038,3/90$4:917.,38070,9438954.41,5,790/.411.,,803/0/4338850.1.897.98,900232574;80/09949,9-0,78,/893.970802-,3.094$4:917.,394385890,038850,3,,3:,09,93.:/08..3348089,970.,2,33,9;0$4:917.,3,3:,0890,038,70;038,;03,208-904;073203990411.,54.8418070,943,3/.439,32039,507509:,90/:3/0790:80412,39,3347/07,3/4731479070,90744/%&%0128.796:04190970,920394190,038254;0780/,3/97,550/3,.4:39707090,70-4910,70/,3/,90/03/8,047949870,47/.43907020247084190943858,7089;071708%0128,-4:9,5,790/-:998,84,,3,047.,,-4:9,9,8,55030/,1907,7/834304190128248989732,083,438490800:8,77;3420,1907,7:03/,41807;30;.943349.0890,032490785,334;078.421479,-02//0.,884209,2,88;0:3,.340/0/,2489:3.438.4:809%070,7090128:089897:47713938,334;079047/412030:8450714720/:990777,943,,.9841

    570:/.0,3/3:89.03903,20418,109,3/7,943,90;03,1907,5,790/,8,3411.,54.,803/0/303,20147,34907,5,791479040908947.;403.0415,790/.,3,,8-0970,90/,8,2094323985,89,80,83985708039/;07805,98.43/038,943/85,.020390570884347705708039,943 430.,3,,8/0.507974:9883:,79842,349073/841;403.0434339047/943.05,79.,8:00110.90,250,98,5503307097,38,908,99,085,.0070,,8070070;074308,3/07070;07430448.4808994420313907085438-990701470347089,40/147,314724144/.438.03.0,.6:08

    077/,$50.970841,7;%889017892,4717.,32,/094:42,25850392:.418103,3,/,8.03.01.94312,3/994902,078.70/99,9988,89479,9.4:/-094/43317.,98,84,89479,9.4:/43-094/,88.03.01.943398,2489:3700393/,7;84341

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    13/122

    :2,39897.98,/0058:-;078;012%0/89,3.30110.941901,39,89.0020398418.03.01.9431,89079,3997,;03907890,7.;8,943809.,488.03.01.94394908:./11.:9894708,3/,8/11.:96:0894383,89,92470.,88.,70,8903708418947903.,3349$.03.01.9438,8!0907.4834908-499070,924/073907,9:7041209,547,3/5700230399024/073907,9:703494158.8-:941209,58.8(%405,3/4398945.,-91:79070300/439444,99089:33370-4494190900;84380708,99089,7,,.9.,

    ,34907.43902547,78.03.01.94399,9:808,.,701:.70,90/,04794/0.43897:.9905489.443,89:,943,3/94,8:3809936:089438,-4:990.443,54078390.,8090&390/$9,908;0398,87,3993490898,57414:3/289,09439075709900370907,79341,99089,7,,.9.,874-49.,39,43898904380,7:08%088:08349,9438,70-:9,990705708039(%08,20897:04190,0383897.9.0,99089,7,,.9.,894/3,;8:,,3:,09,920890

    1,39,89.9,799,3/0/6:,8/4.:2039,770,8280,;08003,990,0383897.9705708039702,38,345036:08943-:9901789890594,38073986:0894389470.43090,047.,3,9:7041903,77,9;09801%&%0708507,58,1:7907,7:203994-02,/0,90,899039,9;08.03.01.9438037024898:90/1479035489.443,894708%4:431789,3.092980029,998897:04341903894708,-4:990;.9478390.443,897:0;039,99890;.94784,;09070,9089,..088949090.344.,,55,7,9:884.7:.,948.03.01.94340;0742,25,3/94,088070394470,3/.,708439,99070,70,894;0;4.0949480803.0/3.443,.4398-:83908,200370.43;039438%8892:89-03490/349,303970473,.43.09#0/0731,.9,7:08%090889,9.443,828,831.,398947.,.4391470,7

    8.03.01.9438349,37,;,,39430(5,3/34398079088.03.01.9430548088420939,9

    .443,8225480840;07.443,8283498259070,99,98.03.01.943289108,234997394,7:09,9.443,8288.03.01.9438//0397:9,3994849,9985,794190037089:70,50788903925479,39.425430394198/85,.0/7010703.089489479803,020393/044.,574/:.943,3/98.43897:.94341905488-0,3/902,3,-0(%:88.03.01.943838420803808/0503/039:543:7450,3.443,821479820,33,3/14798;0708903.0%070.,3-0990/4:-99,98.03.01.943,8034902070/,3/44:943,2-070,3/,7:09,9,7$00834;07,3038903890178947415745078.03.01.943/:73,5074/417,5/

    :7450,305,38433,325479,39803809,8402070/,8,70,.94394,3/,99208,70,.943,,389908,2090.344.,334;,94389,92,/0.443,05,3843,3/,/23897,9435488-039017895,.030,233,3/473974:4:7.425.9390.443,034./,574.08808.,3

    04;07.4205708039/,389,39,9438414907,943,3/034./09,9,70-,80/4390

    4.9,9970,9849078,8;072394-00723,90/053:8949,.0907449.,:8041,

    5708039/,/0897:.9;057,.9.08

    4703

    0030!,3/!74141059!8.44,9!,.1.,7,/:,903899:90$03.0/34384749903$5738!,98940,3390,041443,829957,/.,58.4447;44703,9389202,341948045570880/-90.:9:7,034./08507509:,90/-.443,82,;0470/,7/940,-47,909039073,4:3/89,9.443,82-70/022,,4:194804,;0574190/1742.443,82,;0,//83.039;08947010.9439058.44.,.4770,90841-033;4;0/34557088;0897:.9:7084794803.4433.:9:708.443,/04408,;0.4397-:90/94/884.,9390507843,174290.:9:7,03/3:8,803804139074799,98897,30/8.4330.90/1742.4398947.,,3/.:9:7,030,;084:994:3/0789,3/4:780;082489419033.443,58.44080,;09:730/94397,58..-44.,,3/1,2,05,3,94381474:794:98,3/-0,;478473942,090.:9:7,:3.438.4:8;8-034:7/039908,8-003,//70880/438547,/.,,3/

    3,/06:,909390894741/05958.4494:94433/09,,9903/41.438.4:830889,9,8-003897:.9:70/974:5,79.5,94394557088;070,94380.,33493490

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    14/122

    58.44.,94,3//81:7,943455708843.,:80894803;4;0/393/0,70,3;4;0/3998,894:90708,8.308841.0,70:3,,70%40,902:89-0394050703.09099898;07/11.:93050703.399,985,79419030889843-443.425,8843,90,94:780;08349974:90578241:99,90.,3-03942,04:990.4394:784190,3/8.,500,70;33;0310/4390570889902:95.9419047/8,882,90/-90801;378094,2:95.9930,.41:80800982:95.9/85,0/3902,3.,7,.9078414:7

    39/70,28107010.9430;07/,94:90.,3800902:950,3/41903.4397,/.94739073,/,4:089,9,780,809389:,9438974:47708543/39073,940;0398,3/050703.08$01,3/.422:39,707010.9438410,.4907 &839817,20470.,3,8490/884.,90/47/9,98900,.41.443,8225,.984:758.44.,47,3,943,3/0-034:75,9841/0;0452039%08019,970,90894490730883,33897:2039,,390728414904907.,3807;0908012:8930.088,7-03;4;0/3,809418074:8/884.,94381943384743,/4.9478/08.7-08490801/4:-08347/0794507509:,90;403.0,,38949078

    94:9050703.39,88:.30.,30147902,907,,3/58.44.,-030198.4310770/4390214705397,.,.0,3830034./0,/4.9478:3/07039,859934190280;08394941:3.9433408%0:8.9801,40/294,/,5994,3/,..42588034./,9,88085747801,40/2948002801,8,.,7358.,3:8-,3/,3/1,907$:.,/4:-357490.90/21742

    1003841:9,884.,90/990;4,943419009.,573.5080,8473,.422990/94 39889,904158../;8432:7/07,88003,8.0,38320/.,9479:708,87080,7.904907,8;072334-,,9430,;0,3,3,44:889:,94307057,.9.089,9:3/072304.,0.434208

    ,3/9078:89,3,-99,9,;00/943.70,8354;079,3/2,88;0/84.,943841545:,9438,70.,0//0;0452039443,82889474190907,8310747-,.,7/,3/5729;029,908,,389/70.9507.05943841;403.05075097,90/,,3899,94907%8.,:808,/884.,9439390801-0900390/423,39.:9:7,3,77,9;0,3/,34907025,909.100384797,387088;034389,92:8934-0/0103/0/,,38998398,9,9/884.,943893.:9:7,8947-0.42097,38,90/39458../884.,9438$:./884.,9438706:70030794-08:89,30/%8858.44.,/884.,9438,89,909,98.4330.90/

    930:749.8:11073,3/8259428,80,8.4257428083;9,9.70,9;90748,3/.425,8843%05740.9;010/9,970/:.089050784344/4190907,.98,8,34-8.:73.4:/,4343034994050703.0:2,38:11073%047410,3706:708,83,9414:7438:1107394:9810038,3/507.059438,;0-003/8,550,70/398574.088

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    15/122

    897.9'/04

    !'!

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    16/122

    ,/;,3.084., 549., ,3//044., ,03/,8 974:90 2,30/ ;08,3/57,.9.08 41,/;,3.0/7,90770897,8%04708,-4:9,03841903,703903/0/948:554794907-0018:7850.:,94388:089455479:3908147.40.9;08012574;02039,341:8,3994.,30901:9:70349:89099,550394:80,3994780,-4;04:7.:77039.43/943%06:0891474907,3/-0990714728411084.0990.34409.8,3/,2,34970;0,9,990,70,.9:,0800708:0890/0.-:992,390437:305:8942,0842041902,.9:,43

    ,79 2,33 4907 47/8 ,84 .,3 -0 ,3,5574,. 94 8.03.04-0 !70333 20/.,7080,7.07 !09070/,,7 4-807;0/ 9,9 8.0391. 3;089,943 -038 - 90 3;03943 41 ,5488-047/4741,9317,.943419,947/349074-0!7033070309.897,3.48,.4-3490/9,9289.,94:9-038908,20,%0/0-,90450384:723/894,929-05488-0

    0,70.43174390/9,8479841,032,084:7/,;08974:

    8.03.01.943%0,03,8039070/3944:7.:9:7,2,3,7,3/

    9889,9:88,89041.43903943,8;,74:8.43.0594387,304;0754797,3907.43.059434184.09974:90209,54741,038

    $4203,77,9;0854797,,038,81703/,3/;3,243:88:.,8

    ,14790.43902547,7,32,90/5747,2:990;,892,47941

    ,038.03.01.9437057080398,038,8,907713970,9;893

    5,3090,79147/,7,3/8389075:754808390803,77,9;0890

    ,03890030241:2,33/,3/2:89-0/089740/,3/

    0723,90/,9,.4898

    0/,419803703.:/0,7419047/83/0503/03.0,

    0390%3074381742:907$5,.0908940843,3/

    43%0808.03.01.943705708039,9438,705740.9438414:743

    10,78,3/,309084394,32,3,749074850784310/390

    147241,4890,037,.09420,705072,3039,9,7

    %097:57414:3/93,-4:9897.989,998:-;0798-4941

    9080/423,393,77,9;08#,9079,3-03825-030;4039,3/

    1703/474890,3/0;90,0383897.9,70,91789/08507,90

    ,3/05088%0,038,7084435,.0/3,847941701:00.,259,9-0.420829,70/,3/4557088;082,79490/0,9.,25841,

    072,3

    %74:98:36:02,3,741,038897.903,.98,.796:041

    904.414907,9439,9708:98390034./0419480/0020/

    /1107039,3/0889,3:2,3897.98.796:0414907,943

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    17/122

    ,5508349:8994,5,790/-:9,849490,41904.84184.,

    ;403.03.:/3&$29,72507,823.:/390,7837,6

    ,3/1,389,390038,;020394117.,38,3/90034./041,

    90504508390207.,8897.9.796:08908014907/.49429,989014:3/,943147,82,3/207.,329,72507,82

    4308

    ,990&3;078941,3.08907897.9#0;028947!740.9:809952:80:0/:4:73,812*,3/*8947;430892$4-038897.9/70.90/-042,25,3/574/:.0/-%047/4190#38!0907,.8439980,7998 8,8.03.01.943-4.-:89079,9,8,438/0,9.20384:99470.4;07842070850.9,-9147900370,2/8.74541545.473850.9,.08%7,381472078#0;0304190,03%0723,947$,;,943,3/,207.4209423/#0509094-;4:8,:843894$4:917.,8-7:9,8070,90/5,89988,123.8420932:.2470390708938,947-030,9908.14889,33982:950.4:8383/00/9020/,,8/4302:.94574249098,8,129,938420,03,08990894741,5,790/:8390

    90730884198,03894/8.:88$4:917.,87,.,90784170.039/0.,/08%07082:.9390129801948:55479.,289,9905498905488-90814784.,.422039,79,9,703070393908.03.01.943037042394908.7003039703.0/3,8974380380412,383:2,39942,3897.983498,9810/998,:843894,5,790/-:93890,/4482:./0050739490894741909.039:7,3/.4330.9890/498-09003,90:2,3.7:09913/803;,3/0070,7384304190,03834994494897.9 9030.,25-:9850.1.,14790;89478908038041:703.,3/4774738;4.00,/8430942,309,93857,9431479084:9439490,03574-0229,;0-003/7,3174290,83,$4:9434790$4;09:,8%080.,25807090280;08-,80/43570.0/0398809-90$5,38/:7390%030,78,790207.,38/:7390!5530207.,3,7,3/90798/:7390407,73$4:917.,9801897.98897.9/7,843,43,3//70,/1::2,3079,04139072039,3/.,89898477478394,3,9442,3,-01:9:70%:890128:08989,9,8

    43,80507.0;058.,/110703.0-09390728417,.047850.0894-0,831074158..,/882,799038:.-7:9,8,94370.:79834940;07438947.,4774789,9,70,40/940207039490129%0:3/0774:3/29,780/05072039,9438904507,90/-908,/4:93,943,&390/3.:888:-0.90/943:2,3.7:09849,931472,943.,3-0,9070/,-4:92/85,824709,3,5,88382,79411:3.943,3/5:7548094:,39,3,24,,3/9084.,0/-,.8908,.7488904-0%01,.99,9,3434;0732039,47,38,9432,3,08984507,94370.,8901,7234:94180.:797085438-90894,.,90747//0340,3/9057419007341,-:7943/:73904343,737,6%4:897.92,0805.9011479894/7,.4330.9438-0900398/8945,31:9:70,3/850.1.8947.,,974.9089,84800894.4220394390.:77039/870,7/147:2,3-038/85,0/3.43902547,7.431.98384/4398:08989,90,705,79414:7438947087050,9390-7:9,9414:75,89,3/10.4393:0:3,-,90/

    5740.939394,1:9:70070;89478944:75,309-0970,90/32:.908,20,,80,;0970,90/,3/.4393:094970,90,.49073/!,0(%070845040;073901288:089439,990-4:3/,708-09003$01,3/907,7050720,-0:8:3/07408,574.088412:9,943-0.423,3,032801304190;894782,088434:7301742970,9033549039,90774789.443:5,90.344.,/0;.03,//03,-3908:29457490.947,3/8,;4:741900,,3/4:3/0/:89003/418

    97,381472,9430,8-003;03,:2,33,207894507,3/-03894/85,:2,30249438 %,9.805,7,9082,31742,03,3/03.07,.017427,.0817,0,3/5078,-090$01,3/90907,70:92,90908,2093%82,78,/7,89..,301742908.03.01.943419081742.9812/7,88989.,%0-:00/,038,3/,39.243890789,989,0/207.,8.302,8.700383

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    18/122

    902//041909.039:7070349907094-0:3/078944/-:994-0023,90/%04;070232,4790704890,3/39039434:7/0897:.943288:.,83;,8434190$,:.0703,3/%0,7419047/8.,89,038,8770.43.,-/11070391742,3/:3702993970,903394:2,3-038%4:91988420;8:,7010703.0817429080128897.9807;08949:8941,7.302,,8.420-/05.9390:2,3$01,3/90,03907,894,;0841908,2040%02088,09,99012,81479047/98002889,918.03.0

    1.943.302,.,3,-,3/4398,04/-0019,9-44.,,3/03.07,.,/110703.006:,908942,31089/893.94388907089419047/89.:9930,.49074503570:/3430,34907,..47/39483.44:7,3/708543/3,8152039,943070/0893%88,8.03.01.943-4.-:89079,997:9890549039,419820/:294.,0309084.4549.,89,9:86:4

    897.9857414:3/84.,.796:0.,343-0.,770/4:9974:

    8.03.01.94343974:8.03.01.943.,3901:3/,2039,

    209,58.,84:7.0414907,943,3/;403.0-02,/0,55,7039,3/

    .439089,-090.470418.03.01.94308398390774,9434190

    0,.41.443,82,3/98904317,2047..,30110.9;0

    574-02,90,3/97,3814724:770,94385944:7.443,5,89#,55:3

    7.!7410884741%044,990&3;0789419,4897.9,8!489.443,$.03.0.943995/:30/38.4447/57088.42.302,,8047.8294/897.9,85489.443,8.03.01.9434393:3439904..,843,302,,847.82807080-0/0;3394902:7,907841905489.443,47/

    9,97594897.990;07130/0-:9121742$4:917.,3/70.947042,25574/:.0/-4.,-42,/044/!0907,.843%0128,3,047.,0547,94341904343.489841:7450,3.443,8214717.,,3/98504508%4:3,;07/1107039803809889012,8047.82,;8.07,7,553990489841905,895,79.:,79,941$4:917.,3,5,790/94:842041901282088,082470:3;078,897.9880943,3,9073,9;092030390.9414,3308-:73,9894390.,88.8.03.01.943894741,033;,84390894190,398,:.07,334;0790.90;40898,8/;0780,890123/0503/03.0,,3/904/900;84380708' 90,03;89478,77;043,79349,8.436:07478-:9,889,7;3/0247,80/,3/0,/07088701:008%072,88;085,.0.7,19.,8,1,724701:3.943,449,394800,70:80/9480038,/070.970.894550/4;0790.9349147897,90.70,8438-:9-0.,:809,980709,55030/94-70,/43%0$4:917.,34;0732039,9178950,80/9,990,038,/.4803907.4:397844313/89801924709,3,243,03;8947849007/3949099:,7897.9%03,77,9;041901245038,89057;,90.425,33.,7041,03,11,7890838907,3/,944-00;,-0:93,943,&390/&80984:9940;.9,4190,038,3/24;090294897.9,9039.9:3/70/84142097084:98/04,3308-:79,980;033&80892,90834930889,3,.43.0397,943.,25%4:43908:71,.090128973

    ,3/397:3034:94-0099343994:/-0,70,9/8807;.09470,/9907,34300;09.079,38,8947,-4:9,038;33$4:917.,-:943,349070;098,-4:9842093,94090724708074:8,3/8420931,72470:380993%0,3,4-0900390,038,3/90$4:917.,38070,9438954.41,5,790/.411.,,803/0/4338

    850.1.897.98,900232574;80/09949,9-0,78,/893.970802-,3.094$4:917.,394385890,038850,3,,3:,09,93.:/08..3348089,970.,2,33,9;0$4:917.,3,3:,0890,038,70;038,;03,208-904;073203990411.,54.8418070,943,3/.439,32039,507509:,90/:3/0790:80412,39,3347/07,3/4731479070,90744/%&%0128.796:04190970,920394190,038254;0780/,3/97,550/3,.4:39707090,70-4910,70/,3/,90/03/8,047949870,47/.43907020247084190943858,7089;071708%0128,-4:9,5,790/-:998,84,,3,047.,,-4:9,9,8,55030/,1907,7/834304190128248989732,083,438490800:8,77;3420,1907,7:03/,41807;30;.943349.0890,032490785,334;078.421479,-02//0.,884209,2,88;0:3,.340/0/,2489:3.438.4:809%070,70

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    19/122

    90128:089897:47713938,334;079047/412030:8450714720/:990777,943,,.9841

    570:/.0,3/3:89.03903,20418,109,3/7,943,90;03,1907,5,790/,8,3411.,54.,803/0/303,20147,34907,5,791479040908947.;403.0415,790/.,3,,8-0970,90/,8,2094323985,89,80,83985708039/;07805,98.43/038,943/85,.020390570884347705708039,943 430.,3,,8/0.507974:9883:,79842,349073/841;403.0434339047/943.05,79.,8:00110.90,250,98,5503307097,38,908,99,085,.0070,,8070070;074308

    ,3/07070;07430448.4808994420313907085438-990701470347089,40/147,314724144/.438.03.0,.6:08077/,$50.970841,7;%889017892,4717.,32,/094:42,25850392:.418103,3,/,8.03.01.94312,3/994902,078.70/99,9988,89479,9.4:/-094/43317.,98,84,89479,9.4:/43-094/,88.03.01.943398,2489:3700393/,7;84341:2,39897.98,/0058:-;078;012%0/89,3.30110.941901,39,89.0020398418.03.01.9431,89079,3997,;03907890,7.;8,943809.,488.03.01.94394908:./11.:9894708,3/,8/11.:96:0894383,89,92470.,88.,70,8903708418947903.,3349$.03.01.9438,8!0907.4834908-499070,924/073907,9:7041209,547,3/5700230399024/073907,9:703494158.8-:941209,58.8(%405,3/4398945.,-91:79070300/439444,99089:33370-4494190900;84380708,99089,7,,.9.,

    ,34907.43902547,78.03.01.94399,9:808,.,701:.70,90/,04794/0.43897:.9905489.443,89:,943,3/94,8:3809936:089438,-4:990.443,54078390.,8090&390/$9,908;0398,87,3993490898,57414:3/289,09439075709900370907,79341,99089,7,,.9.,874-49.,39,43898904380,7:08%088:08349,9438,70-:9,990705708039(%08,20897:04190,0383897.9.0,99089,7,,.9.,894/3,;8:,,3:,09,920890

    1,39,89.9,799,3/0/6:,8/4.:2039,770,8280,;08003,990,0383897.9705708039702,38,345036:08943-:9901789890594,38073986:0894389470.43090,047.,3,9:7041903,77,9;09801%&%0708507,58,1:7907,7:203994-02,/0,90,899039,9;08.03.01.9438037024898:90/1479035489.443,894708%4:431789,3.092980029,998897:04341903894708,-4:990;.9478390.443,897:0;039,99890;.94784,;09070,9089,..088949090.344.,,55,7,9:884.7:.,948.03.01.94340;0742,25,3/94,088070394470,3/.,708439,99070,70,894;0;4.0949480803.0/3.443,.4398-:83908,200370.43;039438%8892:89-03490/349,303970473,.43.09#0/0731,.9,7:08%090889,9.443,828,831.,398947.,.4391470,7

    8.03.01.9438349,37,;,,39430(5,3/34398079088.03.01.9430548088420939,9.443,8225480840;07.443,8283498259070,99,98.03.01.943289108,234997394,7:09,9.443,8288.03.01.9438//0397:9,3994849,9985,794190037089:70,50788903925479,39.425430394198/85,.0/7010703.089489479803,020393/044.,574/:.943,3/98.43897:.94341905488-0,3/902,3,-0(%:88.03.01.943838420803808/0503/039:543:7450,3.443,821479820,33,3/14798;0708903.0%070.,3-0990/4:-99,98.03.01.943,8034902070/,3/44:943,2-070,3/,7:09,9,7$00834;07,3038903890178947415745078.03.01.943/:73,5074/417,5/

    :7450,305,38433,325479,39803809,8402070/,8,70,.94394,3/,99208,70,.943,,389908,2090.344.,334;,94389,92,/0.443,05,3843,3/,/23897,9435488-039017895,.0

    8,32,3,9;0089:7041,.340/2039,3/.79.,7010.94343

    90894741.443,82,3/,8,.43/023,943419095041;4039

    4907,9432,/005.93908.03.01.9433,77,9;041897.90411079014435,3

    %0&390/$9,9080/07,4;073203984:/-:/,97,3:,7

    243:2039439039073,943,$5,.0$9,943

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    20/122

    :/3,243:2039439039073,943,$5,.0$9,943708543/894

    90.48070,94385419085,.089,9439490.443,039075780

    ;039085,.089,943,-47,94783,20/4:2-:89097,3:,7

    8,507010.989097,3:,7:7450,317.,3207.,83,9:7041

    .443,9437010.939097,3041207.,39,82,3/9097,/.

    897:.9:70412507,828,;07034./0$:.,243:20394:/

    82-4.,3.:.,90,473974:4190894741034./0

    .70,90,.,:943,7573.5014785,.00547,943,,3891:9:70

    .443,89;403.0-4703934:709.894,7/870850.9,3//39

    147,0310

    ,7880

    ,3879:77907,3/4:73,89%00,.414:2-:8043,7/4!740.9:809952:80:0/:4:73,8043,7/4;2,788092

    ;3903,204:2-:89490:7450,3$5,.0,-47,94790:7450,3$5,.003.$,85:9980139097,/94341:7450,30547078,3/070.90/,8947.,243:2039385,.0:998243:203983.42509083.09347089057.09,9:2,39,85,/147:7450,305,3843185,.00547,943870,,-4:9:2,39439485,.0,3/34943,1090.344.,/0;0450/3,9438,8705708039,9;0841$7050,90//0.,70903,34907243:203984:/-0,//0/9490:7450,3$5,.0,-47,947%03,204178945074:2-:8,8,44/705:9,94339085,.0.422:39547385,.0841903507.0;0/,8,/70.9.4393:,9434190;039:70841:7450,3/8.4;0707841909,3/9.039:708;0789730,2504198.43897:.9434197,/943.,3-08003390288435,9.08419085,.0288439,997,3854790/90:7450,385,.0,-47,9474:2-:89490$$%0$:99028843$%$98018483985,9.4:2-:81,85$,39,,7,/70.9.4330.90/9490$5,.0$:9909,398-970089743030709.3089448,8190$,39,,7,,8:83909,39..0,3,8,7:3,,3/0,338500/9,8.43;0793

    98013949,398%0288435,9.14790:7450,385,.0,-47,9474:2-:8848,-:0.7.0,8,82-41475,309,79.74880/-,9030%83089,3/81474:2-:81009.74883909,39.17420,8994089,80,814790$5,.0$:990.7488391742089940,899070-97,3854793903024/:0949039073,943,$5,.0$9,943$$%0805.9:708,70944-0,:91:94-097:0%0708349908908939,990,2-:941900,.9,94:2-:8,3/8.43902547,708019147:89448,8190:7450,3/8.4;070788094:9147904.0,385:7094,3340/094574;09,990,79874:3/:99,983499097:9%0,/2,88;00.4342.249;08:7450,397,/3.425,3080700,074431473097,/074:908948,94.4:3907908,2.97,/0784.439740/9097,385479-,3/!479::0808,4780709739484;098574-02-.7.317.,%07,5574,.,550,782470,55.,943470390/438905-8905.9:,9070,.0/900.4342.4,6:.079,34:2-:848094:914790089%8,8,1:3/,2039,30,5574,..5,;0/90,94574;00257.,9,990,7970,,8,4-0390437:399:730/4:994-024708:..0881:0;0330.4342.907284:2-:8/8.4;07-74:9:3570.0/0390/0,994:7450-45033:59097,389,39.97,/0$0,547994380;07544

    789447/0,:477089-488420/38:757838479920-9,3,/;,39,041908030-:83088455479:3908 :94:

    /4390,813/243:203989,97023/4:414980,9.390437:32,/0,90..4250090$$5488-0,8.70,90/%8202478349574:/57080390/347-90700;07-4/.4:/8009988,201://0343,794:.4:/13/9147389,3.043,3:3850.9,.:,797,11.8,3/3,3:3850.9,.:,75,7941,2-:707043;071094:78984%897,3:,78,50/97,11.8,3/84.,90/30,7905,.0070.:77039;03,/897.9.,0/,3/8-00703174394190,3/8-0943,90,/23897,943/0./0/94070.99700-74308.:59:70884325479,39507843,9081742,3/8-085,89%0430..,:80/5:-.57490898840/037.,77,1;43$.2202,3343810920,8.438/070/907.0892,341:745043:20398147$,;0%7,/0789,89084:7.041$.2202,3380,9,3/90,9,82039430/43,30,7-5,909,9.,:80/9057490898'894784190243:2039.4:/70,/9070$.2202,338.438/070/,89014:3/0741,3/8-080.4342.897039&3/07847/8590704314:780/84-0.,:80419084.,0/97,3097,/0.,.4,3/71088,;08

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    21/122

    8:,7.,30,3/.49943-09003:745017.,,3/207.,0,8.438/070/907.0892,341:7450$00%0/8.4;0708414:2-:85,;0/90,1479097,3:,797,/0.3.:/0/8,;083:3570.0/0390/3:2-07802,34907.903841,2-:7109,8,20/9,924;0732039070.90/,243:2039147,8,;097,/07:9-01470,79.:,9325749089,390/94342470,-4:9 9897,3097,/00,730/9,99,8,3/413907.4393039,574/:.943.,3,7:,-90178970,4-,-:83088$.2202,334,/0/88583:74509.49943574/:.980.,.47108,3/,.44.,/,-003574/:.0/38432,3:1,.9:708

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

    9389825479,399434,-4:99014:3/,94384:,7089,3/3433573.509070834937439243:203981478,;097,/078:9984:/-0/430574507984:/057088,.0,754894343983/41-:83088,3/9825.,9438147905708039,3/901:9:703/507,58248925479,39984:/-0070.90/,9,5745074.,9433174394190,3/8-0943,90$.2202,338.:59:70.8:-806:039,87024;0/-984307290.2-//3493-:905708857/0,3/,5570.,94314790,.0;0203984198-:830882,3%070,834779,930020393499089089394190

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

    ,89743,:98;3,3/473439085,.089,943:9 84203/41243:2039830.088,794:99,85,.0

    ,-47,9479903,20414:2-:84:/349-0.4250900300/842093.0,7;8-09490,89743,:98,80,89450450,9.31742-049,97023/8:89493,0,/-01470080914494349070,;03-4/08:7703990570;,3,999:/03089073.:9:708002894-094,5440,9073890,/41,8314750728843:99,98349,..059,-0039.42089405473,3/8099385,.0%00,.414:2-:8.439,38,.0,72507,9;0084:/34903907,35,3099,983,-90/:30880,70.0,73;90/;03190,8907841,78.4:/43-080039,2.748.45004:/,;09470850.9902,89043078419075,3091.4:7800,70,/,;0039070/,7894:774-498:9084:/-05705,70/94894590,3/3411:790774-498,3/:2,383.,80003.4:3907109070%,9/40834930.088,720,39,90,;0948945900547,943419084,788902%070,702,3490747/89405470,3/809900.,30;03-:/17001385,.080990203980948003;8430/-07,7/03/41.4:780084:/089,-885,.089,94383,7847-9944-807;0490104398

    5,3090;4;089920$420/,3901:9:7002,0;030,7394.422:3.,909908010147288490.,313,3;90:8147,;89,9,1,39,89.5740.9147,85,.01,73.;,943439485,.00,;0,:36:0455479:3994:57,/04:784.,4507,9388902%070,830;07-003,-0990792094.,3090/70.94341:2,30;4:943:90300/8974382-489405:8941:198034724:89,80300/8:.,82-40850.,43904:2-:824/:0%07084:/-0,5:-./0-,90,-4:94-08994.4220247,9090;.92841:7450,305,3843%489,7990/0-,9057454809,98:.,243:203943-4,7/4:2-:884:/,;0,97,3:,78,50

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    22/122

    30,233,3/473974:4:7.425.9390.443,034./,574.08808.,3

    04;07.4205708039/,389,39,9438414907,943,3/034./09,9,70-,80/4390

    4.9,9970,9849078,8;072394-00723,90/053:8949,.0907449.,:8041,

    5708039/,/0897:.9;057,.9.08

    4703

    0030!,3/!74141059!8.44,9!,.1.,7,/:,903899:90$03.0/34384749903$5738!,98940,3390,041443,829957,/.,58.4447;44703,9389202,341948045570880/-90.:9:7,034./08507509:,90/-.443,82,;0470/,7/940,-47,909039073,4:3/89,9.443,82-70/022,,4:194804,;0574190/1742.443,82,;0,//83.039;08947010.9439058.44.,.4770,90841-033;4;0/34557088;0897:.9:7084794803.4433.:9:708.443,/04408,;0.4397-:90/94/884.,9390507843,174290.:9:7,03/3:8,803804139074799,98897,30/8.4330.90/1742.4398947.,,3/.:9:7,030,;084:994:3/0789,3/4:780;082489419033.443,58.44080,;09:730/94397,58..-44.,,3/1,2,05,3,94381474:794:98,3/-0,;478473942,090.:9:7,:3.438.4:8;8-034:7/039908,8-003,//70880/438547,/.,,3/

    3,/06:,909390894741/05958.4494:94433/09,,9903/41.438.4:830889,9,8-003897:.9:70/974:5,79.5,94394557088;070,94380.,3349349058.44.,94,3//81:7,943455708843.,:80894803;4;0/393/0,70,3;4;0/3998,894:90708,8.308841.0,70:3,,70%40,902:89-0394050703.09099898;07/11.:93050703.399,985,79419030889843-443.425,8843,90,94:780;08349974:90578241:99,90.,3-03942,04:990.4394:784190,3/8.,500,70;33;0310/4390570889902:95.9419047/8,882,90/-90801;378094,2:95.9930,.41:80800982:95.9/85,0/3902,3.,7,.9078414:739/70,28107010.9430;07/,94:90.,3800902:950,3/41903.4397,/.94739073,/,4:089,9,780,80

    9389:,9438974:47708543/39073,940;0398,3/050703.08$01,3/.422:39,707010.9438410,.4907 &839817,20470.,3,8490/884.,90/47/9,98900,.41.443,8225,.984:758.44.,47,3,943,3/0-034:75,9841/0;0452039%08019,970,90894490730883,33897:2039,,390728414904907.,3807;0908012:8930.088,7-03;4;0/3,809418074:8/884.,94381943384743,/4.9478/08.7-08490801/4:-08347/0794507509:,90;403.0,,38949078

    94:9050703.39,88:.30.,30147902,907,,3/58.44.,-030198.4310770/4390214705397,.,.0,3830034./0,/4.9478:3/07039,859934190280;08394941:3.9433408%0:8.9801,40/294,/,5994,3/,..42588034./,9,88085747801,40/2948002801,8,.,7358.,3:8-,3/,3/1,907$:.,/4:-357490.90/21742

    1003841:9,884.,90/990;4,943419009.,573.5080,8473,.422990/94 39889,904158../;8432:7/07,88003,8.0,38320/.,9479:708,87080,7.904907,8;072334-,,9430,;0,3,3,44:889:,94307057,.9.089,9:3/072304.,0.434208,3/9078:89,3,-99,9,;00/943.70,8354;079,3/2,88;0/84.,943841545:,9438,70.,0//0;0452039443,82889474190907,8310747-,.,7/,3/5729;029,908,,389/70.9507.05943841;403.05075097,90/,,3899,94907%8.,:808,/884.,9439390801-0900390/423,39.:9:7,3,77,9;0,3/,34907025,909.100384797,387088;034389,92:8934-0/0103/0/,,38998398,9,9/884.,943893.:9:7,8947-0.42097,38,90/39458../884.,9438$:./884.,9438706:70030794-08:89,30/%8858.44.,/884.,9438,89,909,98.4330.90/

    930:749.8:11073,3/8259428,80,8.4257428083;9,9.70,9;90748,3/.425,8843%05740.9;010/9,970/:.089050784344/4190907,.98,8,34-8.:73.4:/,4343034994050703.0:2,38:11073%047410,3706:708,83,9414:7438:1107394:9810038,3/507.059438,;0-003/8,550,70/398574.088

    3,2,88;089,785,550,70/4;074,3308-:7$4:917.,

    $4:917.,38,3/50450,4;079047/070,,720/,3/

    907710/3493431478:700907907,90770897,807007094

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    23/122

    -030;40398,70907340/04190:3;07809:847070070

    94.436:07,79

    %4:2,39857414:3/8:75780309074190808.03,748,55030/

    3890,/9085:898,990704;0734;07$4:917.,9//349

    .422:3.,9047708543/94011479894.439,.99

    3,,190724398410,90//0-,90,3//0-07,94390

    39073,943,.422:39089,39/0./0/9,990,894907,4

    394908594800447,9,838/0,3//090723090

    249;,9438147907570803.043,79

    3.0,90,2410330078,813,,-094.:9907,974:1;0

    100941209,9007084.0/94/8.4;07349,8:57020390039

    ,3/54071:7,.041-038-:97,907,:0545:,94341/08507,90,3/05088,03889,7;3,3//3

    %07007024709,3,24341902$420490,03843-4,7/

    ,/4899070,/0785,3/39003.,574-,-/:094/80,8041

    84203/,3/070540708894709:739407090.,20174247

    2,39,390-,8.300/81479078:7;;,

    3901,.0418:.8:11073,3//08507,9439070,8,34:954:73

    4139073,943,:2,39,7,380392039940590/3,0389,8

    .0,79,9,/0114798.4:/349-0.,770/4:9439085,3/8490

    ,03545:,943,897,3854790/94,3,70,439074:3/3

    4,3308-:707070010114798070.43.0397,90/394,3/41

    701:00.,25,3/-01470903099,/-0.420,8:2%0.,25

    ,8.,0/$%#%

    #0,9438-0900390,038,3/904.,545:,9436:.9:730/

    84:7,2/89,.2,904110,79,98443-0.,204:9794899%0

    57,38,890,038070.,0/07094:994-0,7088;0,3/

    ;4039,3/,39,037498844307:590/

    %039073,943,.422:39708543/0/-03.48390.,253,

    29,70/-47/07147905:754790/57490.94341-4990,038

    ,3/904.,545:,943%07570803.0.,2094-094:941,8,

    -:7/03,3/9050450414,3308-:7,3990,038940907-0

    7024;0/4707,/.,90/

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    24/122

    %4/,897.98.,:9:53,0-41540770,9438%0,038

    ,703090738/03474:98/090,90,70-49-03894-0

    57490.90/,80,810,70/,3/.439,30/974:,0,8890241

    7,.,8070,943%0,7024704;07,9,7094129,72,35:,943

    /:094907,/;,3.0/90.344;03908:73,970/4190

    ,038-904.,545:,943414,3308-:79039073,943,

    .422:39,834.4.0-:994704.,9090,03894897.9,

    3014720/24/073/,;0784341,.43.0397,943.,25

    %88909088419012897.9

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    25/122

    %!#

    %03,77,9;041,03889024890110.9;0,94.79.,7010.94384.,897:.9:70841

    5407,3/0.:843

    47.487893047.48!7410884741,,94:8,3,$9,90&3;0789,7.'89894,82,5,309#98

    9,384208.03.01.94312,3/900;84380708174290894908:309955,50788873.42845,5078.12,-897,.9*/$,:9478,;0:80/90,033;,8433,77,9;0,8,574147,90;0784.,0,0.4342.474907970,990.:9:702,10,7902489,990920%0/05.94341,0383,033;,8433,77,9;08-03339,7419047/8,3/.4393:3974:8,,88:.,8',3/1288:.,83/0503/03.0,,8/0.059;0;.4:8,3/83023/0/-0383903943:83,79147907435:754808,48:8945740.9:2,397,9843943430890392,3,7-038,3/0,2309021742,.421479,-0/89,3.017,90770897,1008980,;099070,84394-00;09,9985,79.:,739070890/3,7947,7983,-9,398479,97,90770897,84:/,;0,70390394383890,/3;,843038,;02039,3/0549,943,702470094-0.,7,.90789.41:2,384907572,908473900392,22,89,3417,90770897,8%:82:.$3,03

    3;,8433,77,9;08807;08,8,574147:2,3.,7,.90789.8,3/,3,3,4147970,989,9,702:..480794420470,25034;08,3/128,-4:9,033;,/078574/:.0/3908025,8090/423,3910,7,990920.,89,941,422:3899,04;070907974:,34;079,99,.,:3.0/-90$4;09&34347:-,473

    .43.079990,8889,3.041119.4:23898422:389825,9078390&390/$9,908%08,033;,8433,77,9;08/05.990,038,8:3/0870/:30.420,3/:3825,909.-0381903903;,/3,03838:.3,77,9;080708003,857408147.422:38983/,94/,102,3207.,38070.43.0730/,-4:9/039139480939072/89429,7-473903994,7/904;073203939070,47/-4990.9037,3/00.90/411.,8/02,3/0/4,94,98,3/4907/0243897,9438415,9749820,/394.,8089,9.,030/90.43899:943,9418:.4,98

    89,9:908,3//0243897,943803339,;4790,79,3900;84380708/05.93,038;893,79-0394700.990,033;,843,3/,033197,9433,77,9;0834943419089,9,03830.088,75480,970,994:2,39,907807088:.,8473/03,943,3/7/#4.174290$:33.,038,77;043,79950,.01:4730:97,39039438,3/702,3070.4;079147,303/0/5074/41920903/94025,8090343.4317439,943,3,9:704190,03-038;898,3/90703:3039070893:2,38,81349850.084106:,39003.0,3/5407,90,89850.08418420390708947941,90,89842057490.94347343390710703.0 %0801703/,033,77,9;08:809090.36:0418.03.01.943347/0794.796:084.09,3/0,23035,79.:,788:0841.;7983&390/$9,90884.0939080.43/,14190903909.039:7:990/484-543934:95,7,/4.,9,970,,0382,349548090970,989,98420,;0,,8-00;0/038439074:58907057080393545:,7.:9:702,,84349548090970,988420,;0-00;0/347/0794,..425898705708039,94340;07901703/,033,77,9;02:891,.9,90,30.,3041/0,89390$.43;039439801&83$,4890,:/03.094/8.:8888:08417,.080,3/704394:92,3;0078944:3.421479,-0,-4:9.43174393:2,3/110703.080,07,9390/110703.0841904907390$:3;078090;03,:/03.0.,3903.438/07090790/110703.083207.,3,3/47/84.0957080398:.4-89,.08%88,9900;843807088:.,8,;4790,79,303,943,3//#4.174290$:3,4:894/4

    05473147,0380,70054734:780;08,3/4:75,.0390:3;0780

    ,,,

    43!$03470.9:70705,79203941!4845#;07400%$'&&3$9#'#'&,90..0880/9957;070/:4:73,#$573,,,5/1%

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    26/122

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

    5,507%0708,3:3/073/0,9,9190708104349075,309831,.91907081043,494149075,30989,910834984850.,,93390:3;0780 :790724709,8-003,7:0/9,9;03907020044/9,9907081043,30,7313902:99:/0415,309890398;07574-,-09,94384204190805,3098.8:554791039003910,80;4;0/ 98;0,80570880/ 3 , 1472:, %:8 9 .,3 -0 .43.:/0/ 9,9 0;03 390039 10 8 349 84 850., ,503420343 83.0 9 574-,- 4..:78 974:4:9 90 :3;0780 ,3/ 3 98 , 90 ;,:0 41:2,3103,.48244.,.4398/2380/ %0;09,9:2,3108349850.,,3/9,9,88079438419825479,3.0,7020700,250841:2,39880170,7/,8-0030/-84204190-089343574543039841,92,-0.,0/24/0738.0391./0443.:/30797,3/#:880$90;03,4:/,3/2,349078%08.03,7441,:3;078010/9 10 ,3/ 574/:.3 39003910 ,8 90708:9 41,:942,9. 0;4:943,7 574.08808,8 :39 70.039 /423,90/ 8.0391.933,-4:97,90770897,10,98-033394.,3090933,-4:9904..:7703.0411034:90785,.089,9/08590

    .4389,3980,7.3147934,.9:,8341104349075,3098,8-003/8.4;070/9:81,7 %490/07009,91087,70390:3;078098831.,3.0,3/;,:0-0.42089,92:.2470,55,7039$4030803/:5,7874;078,3/,,9908497,3828843841/,9,0,703494344394800190708104390#0/!,309 0,704439413/,33/.,943412,33/85,.0390:3;07802,3,943,3/-00137,90770897,8,48:2,3894,;08579:,.439025,943

    ,3/933

    003

    :/,4:73,89147&$%4/,!74-34//841,03;894780&3./0398;0890,294,331390/0-,90700349,4307:8977,943,0808,90..0880/%,8.3,943 9 :3/03910/13 4-0.98 80028:3,-,90/94: 9070,70 29803;07 ;49078 434; 700.90/ , -,4920,8:70 9,9 4:/ ,;0 706:70/ 90 .9 94 /0;045, 57494.4 147 0.423 ,038.,0 $07207 5:-807 41 $059.2,,308,890708349,3-00;/03.041;898174249075,3098%00;/03.08841009384938417,:99:2,3

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

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    27/122

    %0247,8,3/.79.,94:9841:2,38.,3-0-089 ,..0880/9 90-00141,038

    ,3/7,90770897,8

    3.40

    .4,8 ,3 38 ,:947 .79. ,3/ 8.70037907 %0,0384 .44380 4:7 23/8.4,83.4043,3,2-94:889170,89:/9,90,23084:7300/94-00;037,90770897,8 %0 , %007,5 08 08 ,90 ..0880/

    99508308.423,.:,5708:98/4.;0/4.;0/4/4.33/97:078-*%1472,98479#'89,794.4708:98&70*%.8-*%9700,97:09700/9.8/4.4%550,7/ /0243897,9088 8.0391.7,943,820,7 4330298:554809,9-0.,:80 90:3;0780 8 843.42570038-

    ,7090.,3.089,9,038,704:990702:89-06:9089743 550,7/8489,998834930.088,784990259894.43:70:5,2,902,9.,1472:,4794.,.:,90-,.,7/8174290574-,-03:2-07418:3895,3098,-097,147284181:933904509,90,70349,430,3/9,984209382,784:99070!7479470,/39843029,;0-003394 ,7009,9,038 574-,- 0890/ 94:9 .,73 430 , 47,349073/00/43029 ,;0 ,7:0/9,9988570.80,9805,7,908-0013,0381742,-00134/092,-04.,94-00;03,0389,7/8002830.088,794/90548943870;0780/%0702,-0344.,70,84394-00;032-:92,3.42503,7:20398,;0-0032,/0,8 949 830.088,79550,7/ 9044 ,3/,0344 -0.4201,7 247082,70 .79.808 904.031,939070,8438,-0013,03829-0;,:,-040;070,9044-,80/431,9290,/:894070,,7/

    147389,3.0550,7/850,147,0380,/8570993047,-949094:9841030#4//03-077.70,94741$9,7%70980028,3:306:,5:78:9$4470,,7090550,7/;0814:7,38078789,3 39070893,038,8574/:.0/;,74:83/84124/0733899:9431742900;843848,3/12894,8,5740.98038,705,7941901,-7.4124/07310$0.43/-0013,038.,3-0.425,70/942470,3.039-001830;0847/02438474898$:507899438,3307,/.,-05,794190:2,3050703.0,3/4:7

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

    90,73/4390/8.:78;0490730889,98:774:3/890,030,70,-094:8098,..059,3.0,8,570.0/03941494;049078

    0,34/!7410884741!49.,$.03.0,94-,79,3/,2$2990,2,7941$97,3030880389038,3/-/:.943%0473/;03903,9:7,390897,30,3/,030;03,89907,08990&/8.4:780574;/08,20,381477,55399014703:309405,347,3,049073088,,42,990741,2,7..0/47-,3,90,03702,383,-/:.943,..4:39824704;0790.480790,03098902470147039-0.4208 9:8:8090:144.,,0390574/:.941,/8.4:7801,-7.,90/9457490.990.70/-9419480700.90/-90092,93/8.4:7808418.03.0,3/,942,790.43902547,789:,94341207.,390.34549.,100.,:809,550,783545:,7.:9:70,8,3.430.,3..43947:3,5747,241343,882,9430.,3:8090,03944503,3/4943,77,9;089,9

    .394.,284170,843,3/70,90;03,890.439089902

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    28/122

    '$##%'$#0947.410;,0349078.,:808904789;403.0,3/03454-,

    7007$90;0370.947%08.48:70!740.!%$#!%$9958.48:70!740.94708(

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

    902,793,33433908,3/,90790-449,7-/:.9438/4.:20390/9084589.,90/:804100.9743.8#'82,32,/0&44,0.7,19.,0/,0370574/:.943;0.08,3/89,0.7,1994 4,%.439,.90;039814790758.44.,,71,70;,:03/00//4.:20398700,80/94:8:3/07,3/.,550,737,90770897,439,.9%0;/03.0,3/25.,9438,3/8.48:70-49-98,:947/8.:88:8390&2,9907147

    58.44.,,71,705:754808%0,3,/,394580.709/4.:2039--079$291742900,7805,389,990&2,9907890248980.7098:-0.9390&$4;07320390.00/30;039080.70.8:774:3/390/0;04520394190/7403-42-;0390801,.988970,843,-094,..059,897:00;078.,7,..4:39.7.:,933905:-.,3/-,80/438:.9,082,0

    80053570:/.,89,902039870,7/398%7,.0479,902:89:8070897,39,3/.,:94310,7094

    ,;4/-032,35:,90/39490,..059,3.041,349071,80030294:390,74:3/,3/

    19:2074:8803478,/44;073203938/078,;03/0503/039/08.7-0/9420,.43.0790/01147994/831472905:-.,3/.70,90901,802570884341,970,9174285,.0849,90;039:,,2:99743/4,7-:/:5410,5438385,.0-0,..0590/-902,8808$:.5745,,3/,8349330;0729,754079,9,880/941:790703,03,71,70,81789/02430/900302907,3/82343805079/02430/08,50450,3/49078849,9504504:/5,88;0,..0599013,84:943%0;7:03930,9;054797,,418:.74:58,8088039,9490.70,94341,8:55480/030294-0/0,99;4039%4/,08007,.89,550,9438,550/94.079,3,00/%74:58%07,8%0

    #059,38%0%,90308:8904/4398970//795,9,,3 :890705,90847//894741

    :2,37,.82570:/.0,3/03454-,,80-034:717898905894,7/89089,78402:8934902:8970897,34:740710,78,3/9,204:743/02438,3/44990004197:9,990.48248,74:3/:8,3/,84:780;089844:/-0301917428:.10,7842054797,,841%10070298:.,8,/474:58940,/:842:.31472,943-,3/0/,-4:984.,;,07,81,.92,,.9:,-084589.,90/.4:390739003.0/831472,943

    /0830/948490800/841,90,3/10,79:8:89130,5438385,.0%0:8:,8:850.98 9480497;043034724:8.43.0397,90/0,9,3/54074:/094:3909047/-:9349350,.0%0894:390,3/.43974:83491479,944/1:9:709,9,88:70/,,98:2,39#,907 90894.43974974:10,7,3/,7,,7-0900347/89013,2,89075,415407.4384/,943070,41:2,392,-089,250/0/394,:310/455489439484202,-043430%7,.03/-84/43,2,88

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    29/122

    90:92,904-,.43974974:10,78570,/30/170,2438990504507'437,:3438/0,9-0/,730/418:.,5,30,730/:89,9,1907904/,790704:/-074:03,9438,3/3,943841.43.073,3/9,9984:/-01440/-4-,90774782,3/9,9984:/-01440/-,970,9174285,.090:92,9097:25.,7/4110,7070-9003970941:2,39.4:/-0:390/94,89024;03/0503/03.0,5:99.,03-:99%070834,94,88088,3%,03/,94:917897,85390.4;079:2,3,03/,0.,3349/8.073,9870,,3/,9802470,98%,3/,98580:/4%/831472,943:30880503097,9090,8418240,3/2774789,9890;,898,/44;073203985745,,3/,2,.30983490,899,08034724:85,903.050780;07,3.0/03.0,3/.,70:998479914794/4

    49078089499347:39932,004549.8,3,7241905745,,3/,,72,.3002:89/4-099079,39802:8970897,34:710,78,3/570:/.08,3/,;4/90/88023,9434130,9;0,3/10,73/:.38907049508-,80/43,30./49,9,08,3/.4:390739003.05747,2802:893;089,901:9090.344.,,3/58.44.,.,5,-9084194804,70-03/:2,3&80.70.,3/0,7394/8.073901,8017429070,$%%00390714790$9:/417,90770897,39003.0$%47.8905,703947,3,943147%08.48:70!740.98.48:70!740.947,8-003803/3050/9438,74:3/9047/1470,78942,0.439,.99%5045080,;030;07-003,720/0,;030;07-003970,9030/0,;030;07-003,17,/%4:8,3/841504504;0790.4:78041:3/70/841050/9438,;03907,.90/99080&8,3/990-03843-4,7/902%74:,41980,;04314:3/%504504,3994:3/0789,3/,3/05:8%0,70,93147:89443902385,.0,8,50450,950,.0%03,3/43903013/90,728419048248/0450370,/9402-7,.0,50,.01:,3/039030/:2,39.90397,;01700,2439089,78

    %74:902897:8941%00;,030435:84:780;081:7907394,34-;4341

    2897:89,3/:/20390,34/!7410884741!49.,$.03.0,94-,79,3/,2$2990,2,7941$97,3030880389038,3/-/:.943%0473/;0393.030/9490:92,90:3/0./,-941907,943,941905:-.85070,3/03.09490.4,5804198;075488-990,03989425479,39.,7,.90789.84190.43902547,7549.889043;03039%0089,90025,741.43902547,7545:,71,8.3,943990,03574;/08,3/,3/,557457,90.,9.57,808%01789897:8934430%05:-.85070/0,700843,232:24197:8943,90,8990,-994/893:81703/81742030208,3/:81742902%0:144.,,0380,.430574/:.0/974:90.43.0397,90/705.,943419090208412897:89,3/.43857,.7:333

    974:4:9&$8947,3/5,79.:,7507;,8;094/,,9.4330.989085,.0,03990227,398908:554894341,.43857,.:3/07233207.,80507203931700/42,3//024.7,.

    '4.0833,9;89,3/&/8.4:7808,0057088,309,-4:9-700/328.003,943,3/-7/9,-4:990.4,58041/893.9438-0900390,03,3/4:780;0830,./8.4:780,550,7.43.0738,-4:94;0733,-4:90907.431/03.0394800397:890/99057490.94341/024.7,9.1700/4288,77,390/47131,.990944,70.477:595,79418420.4;0795499,9-73:8/43%4/,82897:892,3/.,90,24700307,8:85.4341050798,3/549.,389,3,3,.9:,8:554894341.43857,.#,9079,33/.,93902,73,941.43857,.904740;078:.,/8507843412897:89.70,908,5,79.:,7574-02147/024.7,9.549.839,9850.1.3094784197:89,3/.431/03.0-0.4200;07247017,0,3/903:4:8&1449038430;0784341,707.:9:7,5,990738418:85.43.43857,.,3/2897:89 #057080393410;,038,7003454-.089,95745:529,782,3/,208:947410.4234/8#0:3439$4:7.0,3/0.4234/8..4;0783907/203843,3/,79,308!,309,78.03843&8907738,3/39039438439,.9,3/038478508(

    09:834,//7088909,7%04,8419029,7,70940990340/0,3/90.34494/423,90474;07540749078%03,943,80.:79/0503/8:543-03945/49902489/0897:.9;00,5438,;,,-0%07,03/,8948449902/430990340/0,3/90.34414754074;077,9079,3807;.0%4902908041147/039908,70,970,9;079390/4349:3/0789,3/,3//4349,;054074;078,970,944::3/0789,3/90,70349-03.439,.90/ 44::3/0789,3/90300/94.4;07:59008903.041&8%0,;034.439744;07902%08041147/;89478,708:5074743,0;089.425090

    890,9.,5,-908%0,70.,5,-0413907890,7,3/3907/203843,19 90,5437.,5,-0419:733985,30943988/047394,.3/073,2420394/4089,92,0430100487085438-01474:757490.943":903,/06:,90 90701470902:89.4;07:59008903.041&8,3/.4393:094-,.03300790.7,80/4308070,3/

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    30/122

    9070:3990,;0,24/04190743%8,8,70,/-003/43009987488310747% 0,842:8900590970,9,;0-0.,:80907;0708903.0/0503/8:543,;3,.4389,39970,9 90.,38009:31479:3,908,29,723/

    038,7034907094:8,3705708039,943841038,8;,704.0/3944:7430934.039782..,343-04;07.420-4:709.8414859,9

    4,3/#.,7/!3/80.709,74190.,/02413.,4803.4:3907%07,5898$&%%#%8'#$&$%!#!995,73,.42,9.0789208(

    08907,90770897,843907,.99:2,38,70-030;4039%070,702,47:2,328:3/0789,3/384184207,90770897,8/:094:2,3,3974542475.,.41:3/0789,3/3416:90/1107039.:9:708,3/507843,989088,3974544898,;08433/0,39.:9:7,;07/1107039:2,374:5843,79983.4770.994:/090.:9:7,/1107039:2,374:5-90.:9:7,89,3/,7/841430843.:9:70;033207.,9070,705045045:9/43,34907093.74:5-0.,:80909357,80938-0,;0/11070399,30/4$420%7,.08,700709490,.842007094:/08420940,842094,/;,3.0:8.:9:7,842094,/;,3.0:8-44.,84209489:/:88420945,88;04-807;08420949,08,2508414:7147,

    ,3/1,:3,84209489,3/:,7/430,70070943;,/03430,70070943430,7007094392/,903430,7007094.:9:7,9,04;070:2,38,7034990-,/:8-:90,;084200880;4;0/507843834:72/89%,9890,98390:3;0780,800,7094/40;0790/110703.089,9900880;4;0/.:9:7084349075,3098,703495072990/-903907,,.9.0/07,9439474,290,,1700,3/.,:80,;4.43;:307,-05,309,7545:,94388:.,8:8%070,7070,84380,;0-003,8830/90,9.07883.04:70,708992083/57490.9438.079,343041948070,8438%0,-4;0/08.75943832,70/.4397,89990/831472,94350//0/-0430,770/445078,/4-43,7013,3.0/,;/,.4-8,3/907:990,-4;089097:9

    %0,0390770570803984:7:92,90380.:794345033,70,94385990

    4907.,34503-4:3/,7089,9,7009403/,7

    0,34/90,.08549.,9047,94-,79,3/,2$29%0,2,7941$97,3030880389038,3/-/:.943!740.9:8008(

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

    9,94:7,03.,8,3:843:8904:780.:79,3/.079,39%090.344,8-003.439743:8/0;04538570,/3705.,9399843242039:2,242039:23443041:8.,3.4257003/029,;094:99,94:70308,70,0,;0-:983.00.,3970,-08,/944347548808890290.43899:90:847840,7094/9079019-

    ,0382,784:7.4397,/.947,3/,2-:4:870,94385944:743-4.02897%0,03890,8,80.:79030;07,/08.7-390.4250941,-/:.9008024943,;08453805,38009974:105,79-901,.99,90.,370,/,3490781,.00.,370,/907-4/,3:,00.,30984208038041

    024943419480938,70/030/:8/:73.439,.99,038%070870,34,0.,390,990:3/0789,3/,-4:9:8%07:3/0789,3/329-03.70/-8:-9038420,8-:928843842049072,47938%070834,9434302,3;0470/948,3,-/:.9008,/9420://03,889,3/3907099021.4:/,;094:941902,8030208,3/.7,30/2801:59,904:/,;084204,3/0/904093-09907:908,/9,890,2-;,03.041349343,998890949,.431:843%8839,303029839,1703/98349020,989.,3970,/908,/90.431:843,//0/9488038041050883088%0,038890,4:780.:794:7,-994

    901703/17420302%09,0,,4:7.,5,.994089,-8-47/078-4:3/,7081.4:780/005/439080-47/078,;0-003:8438$42093830;0770,19$4098

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    31/122

    4190394:99,990,0389,9.8.425090490790,-/:.943/8.4:78005480890,03,89,9.7023/8:89,934938.4250904907,3/0;079388420,949079,990;07-47/07-090030,3/:308:847

    ,31089/0893,3/90034./04190,9;0207.,38,874490/390:74.0397.

    349439,990:7450,38,7090.039074190:3;0780988,3,4:089490.:77039

    /0-,904;0790,0349074390,11.,3-73,3,,703088,3/70850.9147,803903910

    22072,3.,0,8889,3957410884741704:889:/08$9,3147/&3;07893.4:39073039073088%043.059419047030/#0-0..,$,:3/078,3,2,7,3/0394344808(:89,850450,;0:80//110703.08383.447704303/07.:9:7,57,.9.08,3:,0/044,3/0.4342.894:891;403.0,,3894907:2,3850450,;0,84:80//110703.08-09003:2,38,3/4907101472894:891300/088;403.0,,3895,398,32,8,3/039700.488902847.039:70850450,;0.,20/9,943097,947,349071742944:83943:89.,-9/0243897,908:2,38:5074794;07

    490710%033090039.039:7/4.973041,310890893574.,20/9,9,:390/

    207.,3504509041:7450,3/08.039,8-4:3/94/0;04590.439303983,9:7,7084:7.081742.4,8994.4,894/07398/04441,397454.0397.:2,382.490783,9:70-/05.939840,8,33897:2039147:2,303/80307,908034724:80.44.,574-028370.039/0.,/0890/,78/04124/0739,8.4203147/0807;0/.79.820859098:3/03,-0574-02840;0724/0739,8,842,/05488-070,92574;0203983549.,1700/422,907,0-038.0391.

    340/0,3/:2,31085,3&31479:3,9024/0739801147989400;,90:2,33/94909454190.482.0,5,;00307,.420,9900503804149071014728;031:2,38,7024701:.438.4:8473900399,324894907,32,8981,.9/408349:891380389;0970,920394184.,0/407850.08 %0.,5,.914770,907,,703088-73899,34-,943940-9.,70,3/70850.9147,803903910:89,82,3704:8,3//024.7,9.97,/9438,;0.,0/147,303/94/0:2,33,999:/0814:3/37,.828082,3/03454-.3,943,822,303;7432039,89834:70:2,33/94,.340/0983859,3//0503/03.0

    439070894190770897,10990259894/423,90-493,9:70,3/4907:2,3-038702,3,997,.9;040;075,79-0.,:8090,0;,90,309,-4:9507843,,3/84.,2479,9,3/

    0;$:..0883.:7-390:2,3:7094/423,90/423,943308433.70,80/58.44.,,3/84.,3907,943.0,/83/;/:,8,3/74:58941,.0:5943890,/415740.93907432479,9,3/574.;994,7/0;.43897:.9;0548924/07392,08:.3907,943,94557479

    %0:7450,38970,92039413,9;088,7010.94341:2,3.039070/3088,3/907011479894

    70,88:7090280;08,890.039074190:3;07804390,11.,384;0-0.,:80.439,.9990

    ,03,04://8574;09090889,90,70,990.039074190:3;07802,3:8:3,-094

    .42298:.,.9841;403.0

    22072,3.,0,8889,3957410884741704:889:/08$9,3147/&3;07893.4:39073039073088%043.059419047030/#0-0..,$,:3/078,3,2,7,3/0394344808(

    %017895,794198088,-70189:/084.443,08907307870,.90/9490703.4:39079

    90.344.,310747343:7450,38,3/49480343:7450,3870,.90/9490703.4:390799090.344.,8:50747:7450,380349,93343:7450,38419038:11070/17429,903.4:3907-:9,98088034389003994.:7450,3.:9:7030;076:9070.4;070/174290.:9:7,/0.039073-441.439,.993,9;0504508390047/0;0394:948050450070.4430/,3/41903038,;0/08.,790880,7.147,33/:-9,-014:3/,94314797:9,8249;,90/5,79-90

    8059.829,9,7480,1907/8.4;0741047/5045087:,- 90-7:9,.:9:7,,3/0.44.,57,.9.083;4;0/3089073.443,827010.980890732,385078438(/08507,900114799470,88:70280107801(,-4:9807(43.:9:7,.0397,9,;3970,90/,00/310747:2,349078841074.4:8,10.039:708,4429089073078050.994-0970,90/1/8.4;070/,3/.4430/-90.344.,8:50747

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    32/122

    49078%080.43/5,794190088,3;089,9089003994. 9050342034341,03,-/:.943.,380/943:2,3050703.041901470390490790,03%02547,7-7,.093906:08943419043944.,89,9:8419080,03814.:84390050703.07054790/-,-/:.9008;0318:.050703.08:92,9005.,-03

    9072841.425058.44.,574.08808,3/9:80;03190,0389:734:934994-04-0.9;057080392:..,3-00,730/-0,23390050703.03;4;0/303.4:39073,9,90,8980020/94-07,/.,49074704;0789:/418:.050703.02,8:0899,92,38970,2;084170,92,300/94-0

    05,3/0/0.,:8090,-/:.943050703.08944.425094-089:/0/0,:89;03,3088,419803914.:8434305,79.:,7,850.941990050703.041-03,557003/0/-90,03,0

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    33/122

    $%

    $.03.0.943128;0:8/0,841,98-043/4:7507.05943

    ,883!:39,3/$:72,3.,0!:39,79,,883,;/$:72,3,047089&3;0789043,7/4'4:20:2-070-7:,7

    5579.0:309952:80:0/:4:73,8038:22,7;5:3992

    %85,507,8892:,90/-9012,,":089!,7849..4,5808901.994:8/20384384185,.097,;0394908.0391.507.059434170,85,.097,;0347/079470;0,8420389839490.:9:7,.43897:.9434185,.0398.4,-47,943909700,:9478(36:7039490209,547.,209,58.,,3/209,/8.:78;0,850.984190.344-3907,93,7,30418.4,7,.9;908,3/,2513902974:

    34307,7..,.4,-47,94393,33899:943,03;7432039 (9.42-308907080,7.41,79898122,07854947,5078,3//083078990,241,/;,3.34:7:3/0789,3/3419089474190.344,3/054733024/,90841,.,/02.,3/57,.9.,7080,7.438890399984;07,7.3.43.073985,507/0,8990:2,32,3,943,3/70,7/89,8,277472,04185,.0085,.0902,3,9438,70:334,-0,3/,9,90.,30;078,,-4:99,8,303998-,80/43.430.9:70/7,317424:717,2039,7507.059434190,04198,55,70393139003070,;0.4803,8,2094/449489:/90;8-0708/:04190:2,32,3,943390,7988.03.0,3/90.344,3/94

    7,54,909030947147.089,9800294390780.9,9907389,39,943,,70,909209,90,70/08.7-3,:2,3,3/.:9:7,.43/9437,9079,305,339479874:541,:94784:7.42243543941/05,79:708.302,,90.344.,,3,.743829,939,.,:9905:-.2,3,9433,89,9348.039893;0394790.344890397057030:747842,30;07570/.90/%09.039:7.43:747,3/.302,54300704708FG8,3/,107980..0397.820/:2884203,3/3897:20392,078,705488-00.059438

    $.03.01.94302-7,.088.03.0,3/0,;084503,303970-7,3.41.79.82,3/9047

    -4:3/-7,943,82

    #,-37.$%:73,:!741088474138,3:,0,3/907,9:70,990&3;078941.,3$.03.0.943,3/90:9:704179.82!88:04;4:204

    10,8,98.03.01.943802,13/2,3,38078309,9,;05742:,90/3%0,39,89.3907,9:7089,99890-7,3.411,39,89.907,9:709,9.,285,:8-9,,389,-,.74:3/41 8.03.0:99,98,3,774/0139436:9047,-014790923/0/-:93,/06:,9094,-74,/07.79.8290847941.79.829,98.03.01.9433;908-0.,:808.03.01.9438349290/9498

    :7798349290/948.0391.05,3843980547,943

    #,-37.$%:73,:!741088474138,3:,0,3/907,9:70,990&3;078941.,3$.03.0.943,3/90:9:704179.82!88:04;4:204$.03.01.9433490747/88342470290/948.03.01.943907,9:709,34;08290/944;0099078$.03.01.9438,94:/.,,/,593.:89072,.:9:7,88902,3/901:9:7041.79.8208305473.:9:7,889028%4,7/981:9:708.03.01.94384:/0,/90,3.08:554790/$.03.01.9438:75,880;038.03.0

    #,-37.$%:73,:!741088474138,3:,0,3/907,9:70,990&3;078941.,3$.03.0.943,3/90:9:704179.82!88:04;4:20480-0.4200;072470.4330.90/90.:9:7,889029,988.03.01.943574/:.0,.79.829,980;072470.4,-47,9;0.7488390-4:3/,708413/;/:,.4397-:9478:89,89

  • 8/3/2019 MGW Science Fiction Affirmative and Negative

    34/122

    .748808574/:.9;0/42,3817424:804/,55,3.094549.,/0-,908903:2-0741.4397-:94783.70,808,3/,890-4/418,70,-0340/03.70,808.79.8230;9,-,//6:,39,9;02094/894980;072470.,5,.4:86:,9,9;02094/8

    $.03.0.94345038:55488-90894,9.4:/-0

    ,3,70,

    73089,3,70,&3;078941039:.%07488%0!4,3/%0$3043902547,7$.03.0.943,3/90.44.,2,3,94355,5907:30995-445:25.42-55/1--5/109,34907.79.,002039948.03.01.943825.93$:;3857,80902,3,9;017,2047,9073,9;09490,:94780257.,03;7432039%8,894/499000243.740419034;:20.,:808.03.01.943/;0708831.,3917423,9:7,89.4770,89.1.9439,24893;,7,-3.47547,90839498549897:.9:708420;07843419034;:2907,/.,304734;0808,80034;:28,705424754:8,3/3.:/0,8.43.70900,25088:.0020398,80:38,38-0028803903980,03147/89,.438028.4308,3/824;8,/0984733.425.990.439;034728:3/0738.03.01.94398/01,2,730110.9,3/9000243419034;:2903/94574259903;4;0/70,/079448.,90-0900390,:94782507.,47/,3/900897,30/$47/100/3(-,.3949070,/078435708:55489438,3/.:9:7,3;,7,398

    6:089433902,3/;3207,5488-947.79.,0,23,943$:;38,708:9 8.03.01.943,8.79.,549.,90474190388:083,54071:.796:041089384.,3899:9438.:9:7,34728,3/570;,3897:.9:70841

    5407390574.088945038:5,9073,9;0,84184.,.43897:.9390;0/47/,3//8.483:945,35488-908,90393905708039,3/020703939,9/11070395488-01:9:7080570;,38.0391.57,.9.0,3/90.344.,5488-908,701706:039390774,90/478:-;0790/390574.0888,27035:98935,79-0.,:8098/8.4:780874490/3,8.0391.0589024435,79-0.,:809834;:28,70/7,3944790/94/0;0452039838.03.0902489831.,39$30.088,73;089,9090/423