Page 1 of 2 Meeting Minutes TEC 09/09/2020 Regarding Pre Qualification of firms. A meeting of the Technical Evaluation Committee held on 09/09/2020 at 11:00 am in the Office of Manager Supply Chain MTI:KTH under the Chairman ship of Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Head of Orthopedic Department MTI:KTH. Following members attended the meeting; 1. Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar HOD Orthopedic Chairman 2. Account Officer MTI:KTH Member 3. Manager Pharmacy MTI:KTH Member 4. Manager Supply Chain MTI:KTH Member 5. Sub Engineer Maintenance Co-Member 6. In charge IT/MIS Co-Member 7. Bio Medical Engineer MTI:KTH Secretary Agenda: To check and Evaluate the quotations for pre qualification of Contractors for civil work, Medical Gases, IT& Networking, Safety& Security advertised for the f.y 2020- 2021. Decisions: 1. Meeting started in presence of all mentioned members. 2. Manager Supply Chain briefed committee about agenda of the meeting. 3. The committee checked and evaluate the bids in presence of their representative. 4. The decisions made are mentioned below; A. For Civil Work. S.No Name of firm Status 1. Riaz & Sons Pass/Pre-Qualified for Civil Work 2. Royal Builders Private Limited Pass/Pre-Qualified for civil work 3. Zahir Shah & Brothers Swabi Govt. Contractor Pass/Pre Qualified for Civil work 4. Recent Construction Pass/Pre Qualified for Civil Work 5. Sahil Builders Govt. Contractor Pass/Pre Qualified for civil work 6. Sarhad Engineering Pass/Pre Qualified for civil work 7. Mohmand Developers Pass/Pre Qualified for civil work 8. Haji Aurangzeb Khan Gandapur & Sons Pass/Pre Qualified for civil work 9. Jamal Khalil Construction Co. Swat Fail/Not Pre-Qualified 10. Wajid Ali Khan & Son's Govt. Contractor Fail/Not Pre-Qualified 11. New Shah Construction Company Fail/Not pre-Qualified 12. Dawood Construction Pvt. Limited Fail/Not Pre Qualified 13. Shah Brohters Pohan Govt. Contractor Fail/Not pre-qualified 14. Zaheen Kamal Group of Company Fail/Not Pre-Qualified
66
Embed
Meeting Minutes TEC 09/09/2020 Regarding Pre Qualification of … · 2020. 9. 23. · Meeting Minutes TEC 09/09/2020 Regarding Pre Qualification of firms. A meeting of the Technical
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1 of 2
Meeting Minutes TEC 09/09/2020 Regarding Pre Qualification of firms.
A meeting of the Technical Evaluation Committee held on 09/09/2020 at 11:00 am in
the Office of Manager Supply Chain MTI:KTH under the Chairman ship of Prof.Dr.Zahid
Askar Head of Orthopedic Department MTI:KTH.
Following members attended the meeting;
1. Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar HOD Orthopedic Chairman
2. Account Officer MTI:KTH Member
3. Manager Pharmacy MTI:KTH Member
4. Manager Supply Chain MTI:KTH Member
5. Sub Engineer Maintenance Co-Member
6. In charge IT/MIS Co-Member
7. Bio Medical Engineer MTI:KTH Secretary
Agenda: To check and Evaluate the quotations for pre qualification of Contractors for
civil work, Medical Gases, IT& Networking, Safety& Security advertised for the f.y 2020-
2021.
Decisions:
1. Meeting started in presence of all mentioned members.
2. Manager Supply Chain briefed committee about agenda of the meeting.
3. The committee checked and evaluate the bids in presence of their
representative.
4. The decisions made are mentioned below;
A. For Civil Work.
S.No Name of firm Status 1. Riaz & Sons Pass/Pre-Qualified for Civil Work 2. Royal Builders Private Limited Pass/Pre-Qualified for civil work 3. Zahir Shah & Brothers Swabi Govt.
Contractor Pass/Pre Qualified for Civil work
4. Recent Construction Pass/Pre Qualified for Civil Work 5. Sahil Builders Govt. Contractor Pass/Pre Qualified for civil work 6. Sarhad Engineering Pass/Pre Qualified for civil work 7. Mohmand Developers Pass/Pre Qualified for civil work 8. Haji Aurangzeb Khan Gandapur & Sons Pass/Pre Qualified for civil work 9. Jamal Khalil Construction Co. Swat Fail/Not Pre-Qualified 10. Wajid Ali Khan & Son's Govt. Contractor Fail/Not Pre-Qualified 11. New Shah Construction Company Fail/Not pre-Qualified 12. Dawood Construction Pvt. Limited Fail/Not Pre Qualified 13. Shah Brohters Pohan Govt. Contractor Fail/Not pre-qualified 14. Zaheen Kamal Group of Company Fail/Not Pre-Qualified
Page 2 of 2
B. For Medical Gases: No firm Pre –Qualified as per criteria
C. For IT and Networking: No firm Pre-Qualified as per criteria
D. For Safety & Security: No firm Pre-Qualified as per criteria
5. Complete details are mentioned in the concerned Technical Comparative Statement
for Pre-Qualification of Contractors.
Meeting ended with vote of thanks from the Chairman
1. Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar HOD Orthopedic Chairman
2. Account Officer MTI:KTH Member
3. Manager Pharmacy MTI:KTH Member
4. Manager Supply Chain MTI:KTH Member
5. Sub Engineer Maintenance Co-Member
6. In charge IT/MIS Co-Member
7. Bio Medical Engineer MTI:KTH Secretary
S/N Eligibility /Evaluation Criteria PASS/FAIL Riaz & Sons
Jamal Khalil
Construction
Co. Swat
Royal Builders
Private
Limited
Wajid Ali Khan &
Son's Govt.
Contractor
New Shah
Construction
Company
Zahir Shah &
Brothers Swabi
Govt.
Contractor
Recent
Construction
Dawood
Construction
Pvt. Limited
Sahil Builders
Govt.
Contractor
Sarhad
Engineering
Mohmand
Developers
1 MANDATORY REQUIREMENTS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
aValid Registration with PEC with relevant CODE of
specialization.PASS/FAIL
CB
252
C-3/E
4499
C-1
1383
C-4
9420
C-2
1730
CB
277
CA
00116
C-3
4978
C-1
1154
C-B
239
C-1
1302
b
An Affidavit, (that firm is not black listed), prepared
with in the current month of submission of pre-
qualification documents.
PASS/FAIL
Riaz & Sons
(Old)
JV UNIMIX (Ok)
Pass Pass PASS Pass Pass PASS PASS PASS Pass Pass
c
Registration with income tax department (valid KNTN)
And clearance certificate from FBR for the last three
Techncial Comparative Statement for the Pre Qualification of Contractors for Civil Works in F.Y 2020-2021
TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT
15 15 15
Pass Pass Pass
5.33
9.33
9.33 0 5.33
Pass Fail Pass
5 5 5
1515 15
Electrical works carried out during last three years (Total Marks =05)
In hand projects (Total Marks = 10)
Pass Pass Pass
5 5 5
Pass Pass Pass
0 3
0.75 0
0
1.2 1.2 4.8
NA
NA 0.5
NA
0.038 NA 1.8
personal capabilities (Total Marks = 15 )
Enlistment record with Government Organizations & other agencies (Total Marks = 05)
1.99 1.2 10.1
FAIL Fail Pass
20 5 5
20 5 5
Pass Pass Pass
5 5 5
NA NA NA
5 5 5
5 5 5
15 15 15
Pass Pass Pass
FAIL Fail Pass
EQUIPMENT CAPIBILITIES (Total Marks 20)
FINANCIAL CAPIBILTIES (Total Marks = 30)
PASSING WEIGHTAGE/MARKS FOR EACH CATEGORY =70%
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for IT& Networking for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Manager MIS Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
a) General Experience
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
OPTCL Wajid Ali Khan & Sons Sahil Builders Mohmand
Developers
Royal Builders Pvt
Ltd
1. Audit Report Mandatory Bank Statement and Audit Report of Last three
years
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
2. Taxation Mandatory Income Tax Certificate Must be on Active Tax
payer and returns of Income Tax of Last three
years
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
3. KPRA Mandatory Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Revenue Authority and
Must be Active.
Yes Yes Yes Yes yes
4. C&W KPK Mandatory Communication and Works department Khyber
Pakhtunkhwa
NO Yes Yes Yes Yes
5. PEC in
Category C-5
& Above
Mandatory Valid for 2020-2021 having relevant specialization code
ME-06/EE-07/EE-08/EE-09/EE-02
Yes No
PEC Not for IT
(EE07,EE08,EE09)
Yes No
PEC Not for IT
(EE07,EE08,EE09)
Yes
6. Projects of similar nature
and
complexity
Completed in
last 03 years.
15 12 Marks are given if the contractor has completed at least 3 projects of similar nature
in last three years.
For less than 3 projects completed use the
following weightage.
12 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects completed use the following
weightage.
12+ (A/6) x 3
A = No of projects of similar nature Completed in
last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6 projects or
more.
15 00 3.9 00 00
7. Projects of
similar nature
and
complexity
10 8 Marks are given if the contractor has 3
projects of similar nature in-hand.
For less than 3 projects in-hand use the
00 00 00 00 00
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for IT& Networking for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Manager MIS Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
OPTCL Wajid Ali Khan & Sons Sahil Builders Mohmand
Developers
Royal Builders Pvt
Ltd
in-hand
following weightage.
8 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects in-hand use the following weightage.
8+ (A/6) x 2
A = No of projects of similar nature In-hand during
last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6 projects or
more.
8. Electrical/Civ
il/Medical
Gases/IT Networking/S
afety Security
works carried
out during
last three
years (as the
case may be)
5 4 Marks are given if the contractor has
completed at least 3 projects of similar nature
in last three years.
For less than 3 projects completed use the
following weight age.
4 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects completed use the following
weightage.
4+(A/6) x1
A = No of projects of similar nature Completed in
last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6 projects or
more.
05 00 1.3 00 00
9.
Enlistment record with
Government
Organizations
& other
agencies
5 1 Mark for each enlistment up to maximum of
five enlistments.
05 05 05 05 05
Total Marks Allocated
35 Disqualified
Not Registered with
C&W
Disqualified
PEC Not for IT Work
EE-07,EE08,EE09
Disqualified
Obtained
Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
PCE Not for IT
work
EE07,EE08,EE09
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for IT& Networking for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Manager MIS Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
b) Personnel Capabilities
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
OPTCL Wajid Ali Khan &
Sons
Sahil Builders Mohmand Developers Royal Builders Pvt Ltd
i) B.Sc Engineers
registered with
Pakistan Engineering
Council (PEC)
9
Experience (3-Marks) :
3 Marks will be given if the
individual experience of at least
4 no. of B.Sc Engineers
(professional) is equal to 15
years or above.
For less than 4 no of B.Sc
Engineers having individual
experience of 15 years, marks will be given as per
following formulas:
= (A/4) * 3
A = No. of Engineers having
individual experience of 15
years or above.
Strength of Engineers (6 Marks)
6 Marks will be given if the
total no. of Engineers registered
with PEC are 15 nos. or above.
For less than 15 no of B.Sc Engineers registered with PEC
marks will be given as per
following formulas:
= (A/15) * 6
A = No. of Engineers
00
00
00
1.6
2.25
02
2.25
1.6
1.5
1.5
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for IT& Networking for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Manager MIS Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
OPTCL Wajid Ali Khan &
Sons
Sahil Builders Mohmand Developers Royal Builders Pvt Ltd
ii) Associates Engineers
(DAE)
6
Experience (2-Marks) :
2 Marks will be given if the
individual experience of at least
8 no. of Associates Engineers
(DAE) is equal to 10 years
or above.
For less than 8 no of Associates
Engineers (DAE) having
individual experience of 10
years, marks will be given as
per following formulas: = (A/8) * 2
A = No. of DAE Engineers.
Strength of Associate Engineers (4
Marks)
4 Marks will be given if the
total no. of Associate Engineers
(DAE) are 20 nos. or above.
For less than 20 no of Associate
Engineers marks will be given
as per following formulas:
= (A/20) * 4 A = No. of Associate Engineers
00
00
00
1.2
02
04
1.5
2.8
0.75
1.2
Total Marks Allocated 15
Disqualified
Obtained Marks
less than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Qualified
10.25
Qualified
8.15
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less than
50%
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for IT& Networking for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Manager MIS Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
c). Equipment Capability
Critical equipment required for the Project shall be specified by the User/Employer under para 3.2.4 (a). High value equipment should be an option to purchase, lease or hire.
Table B: For IT & Networking
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned
Explanation for Marks
Obtained
OPTCL Wajid Ali Khan &
Sons
Sahil Builders Mohmand Developers Royal Builders Pvt
Ltd
1 Buffer Inventory
Stock
10 Marks for each
equipment are
given if the Contractor meets
the minimum
requirements
given in the
prequalification
document for each
item.
10 00 00 00 00
2 List of Tools /
Equipment for
executing concern
project
10 10 00 00 00 00
Total Marks Allocated
20
Qualified
20
Disqualified
Obtained
Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained
Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks
less than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks
less than 50%
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for IT& Networking for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Manager MIS Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
d) Financial Soundness
- For Financial Status assessment, the Applicants may be required to submit Audited financial statements for the last three years or any other document which verifies their Financial
Status.
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Criteria for Marks Obtained
OPTCL Wajid Ali Khan &
Sons
Sahil Builders Mohmand Developers Royal Builders PVt Ltd
a) Available
Bank Credit
Line
5 3 Marks are given if
the available bank
credit line limit is
equal to 500 Million.
For limit less than 500
Million, use following
weightage 3 x (A/500)
For the limit more
than 50O million but
less than 1000 million
use following
weightage
3 + (A/1000) x 2
A= Available Bank Credit
Line Limit
Full Marks are given
in case of limit is 1000 million or more.
0.14 4.2 2.7 3 0.57
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for IT& Networking for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Manager MIS Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
b) Working Capital in
last 3
years
5 3 Marks are given if the available average
working capital for
last three years is
equal to 500 Million.
For the capital less
than 500 million use
following weightage
3 x (A/500)
For the capital more
than 500 million but
less than 1000 million use following
weightage
3+ (500/A) x 2
A= Average working
capital in last three
years.
Full Marks are given
in case of limit is 1000
million or more.
1.2 0.6 2.7 3 5
c) Registration
with income tax
department
5 No points will be
given if income tax certificate is not
attached and 5 points
will be added in case
of valid certificate.
05 05 05 5 05
d) Copy of
Valid
electrical
license from
Sub-
Contractor/
JV Partner
5 No points will be
given if license is not
attached and 5 points
will be added in case
of valid license.
00 00 00 00 00
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for IT& Networking for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Manager MIS Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
e) Litigation History in
which
Decision has
been given
against the
firm(s)
5 In case the firm is involved in any
litigation, no marks
will be given and 5
points will be added in
case affidavit of no
litigation is attached.
05 05 05 5 05
f) Blacklisting
from any
agency
5 In case the firm is
blacklisted, no Marks
will be given and 5
points will be added in
case affidavit by the company that it has
not been black listed is
attached.
05 05 05 05 05
Total Marks Allocated 30 Qualified
16.34
Qualified
19.8
Qualified
20.4
Qualified
21
Qualified
20.57
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for IT& Networking for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Manager MIS Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
a) General Experience
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Zahir Shah & Brothers
sawabi
Haji Aurangzaib Khan
Gandapure & Sons
Riaz & Sons Dawood Construction Pvt Ltd
1. Audit Report Mandatory Bank Statement and Audit Report of
Last three years
Yes Yes Yes Yes
2. Taxation Mandatory Income Tax Certificate Must be on
Active Tax payer and returns of Income
Tax of Last three years
Yes Yes Yes Yes
3. KPRA Mandatory Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Revenue
Authority and Must be Active.
Yes Yes Yes Yes
4. C&W KPK Mandatory Communication and Works department
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
Yes Yes yes Yes
5. PEC in
Category C-5
& Above
Mandatory Valid for 2020-2021 having relevant
specialization code
ME-06/EE-07/EE-08/EE-09/EE-02
Yes Yes Yes Yes
6. Projects of similar nature
and
complexity
Completed in
last 03 years.
15 12 Marks are given if the contractor has completed at least 3 projects of similar
nature in last three years.
For less than 3 projects completed use
the following weightage.
12 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects completed use the following
weightage.
12+ (A/6) x 3
A = No of projects of similar nature
Completed in last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6
projects or more.
00 00 00 00
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for IT& Networking for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Manager MIS Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Zahir Shah & Brothers
sawabi
Haji Aurangzaib Khan
Gandapure & Sons
Riaz & Sons Dawood Construction Pvt Ltd
7. Projects of
similar nature
and
complexity
in-hand
10 8 Marks are given if the contractor has 3
projects of similar nature in-hand.
For less than 3 projects in-hand use the
following weightage.
8 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects in-hand use the following
weightage.
8+ (A/6) x 2
A = No of projects of similar nature In-hand
during last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6
projects or more.
00 00 00 00
8. Electrical/Civ
il/Medical
Gases/IT
Networking/S
afety Security
works carried
out during
last three
years (as the
case may be)
5 4 Marks are given if the contractor has
completed at least 3 projects of similar
nature in last three years.
For less than 3 projects completed use
the following weight age.
4 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects completed use the following
weightage.
4+(A/6) x1 A = No of projects of similar nature
Completed in last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6
projects or more.
00 00 00 00
9.
Enlistment
record with
Government
Organizations
& other
agencies
5 1 Mark for each enlistment up to
maximum of five enlistments.
05 05 05 05
Total Marks Allocated
35 Disqualified
Obtained Marks less than
50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less than
50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less than 50%
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for IT& Networking for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Manager MIS Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
b) Personnel Capabilities
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Zahir Shah & Brothers
Sawabi
Haji Aurangzaib Khan
Gandapure & Sons
Riaz & Sons Dawood Construction Pvt Ltd
i) B.Sc Engineers
registered with
Pakistan Engineering
Council (PEC)
9
Experience (3-Marks) :
3 Marks will be given if the
individual experience of at least
4 no. of B.Sc Engineers
(professional) is equal to 15
years or above.
For less than 4 no of B.Sc
Engineers having individual experience of 15 years,
marks will be given as per
following formulas:
= (A/4) * 3
A = No. of Engineers having
individual experience of 15
years or above.
Strength of Engineers (6 Marks)
6 Marks will be given if the
total no. of Engineers registered
with PEC are 15 nos. or above.
For less than 15 no of B.Sc
Engineers registered with PEC
marks will be given as per
following formulas:
= (A/15) * 6
A = No. of Engineers
03
06
03
4.8
3
2.79
2.25
2
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for IT& Networking for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Manager MIS Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Zahir Shah & Brothers
Sawabi
Haji Aurangzaib Khan
Gandapure & Sons
Riaz & Sons Dawood Construction Pvt Ltd
ii) Associates Engineers
(DAE)
6
Experience (2-Marks) :
2 Marks will be given if the
individual experience of at least
8 no. of Associates Engineers
(DAE) is equal to 10 years
or above.
For less than 8 no of Associates
Engineers (DAE) having
individual experience of 10
years, marks will be given as
per following formulas: = (A/8) * 2
A = No. of DAE Engineers.
Strength of Associate Engineers (4
Marks)
4 Marks will be given if the
total no. of Associate Engineers
(DAE) are 20 nos. or above.
For less than 20 no of Associate
Engineers marks will be given
as per following formulas:
= (A/20) * 4 A = No. of Associate Engineers
02
3.4
0.5
1.8
1
1.2
0.25
0.4
Total Marks Allocated 15
Qualified
14.4
Qualified
10.1
Qualified
7.9
Disqualified
4.9
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for IT& Networking for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Manager MIS Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
c). Equipment Capability
Critical equipment required for the Project shall be specified by the User/Employer under para 3.2.4 (a). High value equipment should be an option to purchase, lease or hire.
Table B: For IT & Networking
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Zahir Shah & Brothers
Sawabi
Haji Aurangzaib Khan
Gandapure & Sons
Riaz & Sons Dawood Construction Pvt Ltd
1 Buffer Inventory
Stock
10 Marks for each equipment
are given if the Contractor
meets the minimum
requirements given in the prequalification document
for each item.
00 00 00 00
2 List of Tools /
Equipment for
executing concern
project
10 00 00 00 00
Total Marks Allocated
20
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks
less than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less than
50%
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for IT& Networking for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Manager MIS Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
d) Financial Soundness
- For Financial Status assessment, the Applicants may be required to submit Audited financial statements for the last three years or any other document which verifies their Financial
Status.
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Criteria for Marks Obtained
Zahir Shah & Brothers Haji Aurangzaib Khan
Gandapure & Sons
Riaz & Sons Dawood Construction Pvt
Ltd
a) Available
Bank Credit
Line
5 3 Marks are given if the available bank
credit line limit is equal to 500 Million.
For limit less than 500 Million, use
following weightage
3 x (A/500)
For the limit more than 50O million but less than 1000 million use following
weightage
3 + (A/1000) x 2
A= Available Bank Credit Line Limit
Full Marks are given in case of limit is
1000 million or more.
1.14
5
1.29
0.89
b) Working
Capital in
last 3
years
5 3 Marks are given if the available
average working capital for last three
years is equal to 500 Million.
For the capital less than 500 million use
following weightage
3 x (A/500)
For the capital more than 500 million
but less than 1000 million use
following weightage
3+ (500/A) x 2
A= Average working capital in last three years.
05
5
1.29
1.6
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for IT& Networking for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Manager MIS Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Full Marks are given in case of limit is 1000 million or more.
c) Registration
with income
tax
department
5 No points will be given if income tax
certificate is not attached and 5 points
will be added in case of valid
certificate.
05 05 05 05
d) Copy of
Valid
electrical
license from
Sub-
Contractor/
JV Partner
5 No points will be given if license is not
attached and 5 points will be added in
case of valid license.
00 00 00 00
e) Litigation History in
which
Decision has
been given
against the
firm(s)
5 In case the firm is involved in any litigation, no marks will be given and 5
points will be added in case affidavit of
no litigation is attached.
05 05 05 05
f) Blacklisting
from any
agency
5 In case the firm is blacklisted, no
Marks will be given and 5 points will
be added in case affidavit by the
company that it has not been black
listed is attached.
05 05 05 05
Total Marks Allocated 30 Qualified
21.14
Qualified
25
Qualified
17.58
Qualified
17.49
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
a) General Experience
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Radiant Medical
PVt Ltd
Total Technology Pvt
Ltd
Pakistan
Oxygen
Eastern Medical
Technology
Zahir Shah &
Brothers
Surrani Construction
1. Audit Report Mandatory Bank Statement and Audit Report of
Last three years
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
2. Taxation Mandatory Income Tax Certificate Must be on
Active Tax payer and returns of Income
Tax of Last three years
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
3. KPRA Mandatory Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Revenue
Authority and Must be Active.
Yes Yes Yes NO Yes Yes
4. C&W KPK Mandatory Communication and Works department
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
NO Yes NO NO Yes Yes
5. PEC in
Category C-5
& Above
Mandatory Valid for 2020-2021 having relevant
specialization code
ME-06/EE-07/EE-08/EE-09/EE-02
Yes Yes NO NO Yes Yes
6. Projects of similar nature
and
complexity
Completed in
last 03 years.
15 12 Marks are given if the contractor has completed at least 3 projects of similar
nature in last three years.
For less than 3 projects completed use
the following weightage.
12 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects completed use the following
weightage.
12+ (A/6) x 3
A = No of projects of similar nature
Completed in last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6
projects or more.
7.9
14.49
3.9
7.9
00
7.9
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Radiant Medical
PVt Ltd
Total Technology Pvt
Ltd
Pakistan
Oxygen
Eastern Medical
Technology
Zahir Shah &
Brothers
Surrani Construction
7. Projects of similar nature
and
complexity
in-hand
10 8 Marks are given if the contractor has 3 projects of similar nature in-hand.
For less than 3 projects in-hand use the
following weightage.
8 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects in-hand use the following
weightage.
8+ (A/6) x 2
A = No of projects of similar nature In-hand
during last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6 projects or more.
5.3
08
00 00 00 2.6
8. Electrical/Civ
il/Medical
Gases/IT
Networking/S
afety Security
works carried
out during
last three
years (as the
case may be)
5 4 Marks are given if the contractor has
completed at least 3 projects of similar
nature in last three years.
For less than 3 projects completed use
the following weight age.
4 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects completed use the following
weightage.
4+(A/6) x1
A = No of projects of similar nature Completed in last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6
projects or more.
04
4.6
1.3
2.6
00 2.6
9.
Enlistment
record with
Government
Organizations
5 1 Mark for each enlistment up to
maximum of five enlistments.
05 05
05 05 05 05
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Radiant Medical
PVt Ltd
Total Technology Pvt
Ltd
Pakistan
Oxygen
Eastern Medical
Technology
Zahir Shah &
Brothers
Surrani Construction
& other
agencies
Total Marks Allocated
35 Disqualified
Not Registered
with C&W
Qualified
32.09
Disqualified
Not registered
with
C&W,PEC
Disqualified
Not Registered
With
C&W,PEC,KPR
A
Disqualified
Obtained
Marks less
than 50%
18.1
Qualified
b) Personnel Capabilities
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Radiant Medical
PVt Ltd
Total
Technology
Pvt Ltd
Pakistan
Oxygen
Eastern Medical
Technology
Zahior Shah & Brothers Surrani
Construction
i) B.Sc Engineers
registered with
Pakistan Engineering Council (PEC)
9
Experience (3-Marks) :
3 Marks will be given if the
individual experience of at least 4 no. of B.Sc Engineers
(professional) is equal to 15
years or above.
For less than 4 no of B.Sc
Engineers having individual
experience of 15 years,
marks will be given as per
following formulas:
= (A/4) * 3
A = No. of Engineers having
individual experience of 15
years or above.
Strength of Engineers (6 Marks)
6 Marks will be given if the
total no. of Engineers registered
with PEC are 15 nos. or above.
00
4.39
00
4.75
00
00
00
1.5
03
06
00
2.4
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Radiant Medical
PVt Ltd
Total
Technology
Pvt Ltd
Pakistan
Oxygen
Eastern Medical
Technology
Zahior Shah & Brothers Surrani
Construction
For less than 15 no of B.Sc
Engineers registered with PEC
marks will be given as per
following formulas:
= (A/15) * 6
A = No. of Engineers
ii) Associates Engineers
(DAE)
6
Experience (2-Marks) :
2 Marks will be given if the
individual experience of at least
8 no. of Associates Engineers
(DAE) is equal to 10 years
or above.
For less than 8 no of Associates
Engineers (DAE) having
individual experience of 10
years, marks will be given as
per following formulas: = (A/8) * 2
A = No. of DAE Engineers.
Strength of Associate Engineers (4
Marks)
4 Marks will be given if the
total no. of Associate Engineers
(DAE) are 20 nos. or above.
For less than 20 no of Associate
Engineers marks will be given
as per following formulas:
02
3.4
0.5
0.8
00
00
0.25
0.4
02
3.4
00
00
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Radiant Medical
PVt Ltd
Total
Technology
Pvt Ltd
Pakistan
Oxygen
Eastern Medical
Technology
Zahior Shah & Brothers Surrani
Construction
= (A/20) * 4
A = No. of Associate Engineers
Total Marks Allocated 15
Qualified
9.79
Dis-Qualified
6.05
No
professional
Engineer
Available
obtained
marks are less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained
Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks
less than 50%
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
c). Equipment Capability
Critical equipment required for the Project shall be specified by the User/Employer under para 3.2.4 (a). High value equipment should be an option to purchase, lease or hire.
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
d) Financial Soundness
- For Financial Status assessment, the Applicants may be required to submit Audited financial statements for the last three years or any other document which verifies their Financial
Status.
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Criteria for Marks Obtained
Radiant Medical
PVt Ltd
Total Technology
Pvt Ltd
Pakistan Oxygen Eastern Medical
Technology
Zahir Shah &
Brothers
Surrani
Construction
a) Available
Bank Credit
Line
5 3 Marks are given if
the available bank
credit line limit is
equal to 500 Million.
For limit less than 500
Million, use following weightage
3 x (A/500)
For the limit more
than 50O million but
less than 1000 million
use following
weightage
3 + (A/1000) x 2
A= Available Bank Credit
Line Limit
Full Marks are given in case of limit is 1000
million or more.
05
0.24
0.04
00
1.14
0.1008
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
b) Working Capital in
last 3
years
5 3 Marks are given if the available average
working capital for
last three years is
equal to 500 Million.
For the capital less
than 500 million use
following weightage
3 x (A/500)
For the capital more
than 500 million but
less than 1000 million use following
weightage
3+ (500/A) x 2
A= Average working
capital in last three
years.
Full Marks are given
in case of limit is 1000
million or more.
05
05
00
00
05
00
c) Registration
with income tax
department
5 No points will be
given if income tax certificate is not
attached and 5 points
will be added in case
of valid certificate.
05
05
05
05
05
05
d) Copy of
Valid
electrical
license from
Sub-
Contractor/
JV Partner
5 No points will be
given if license is not
attached and 5 points
will be added in case
of valid license.
00
00
00
00
05
00
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
e) Litigation History in
which
Decision has
been given
against the
firm(s)
5 In case the firm is involved in any
litigation, no marks
will be given and 5
points will be added in
case affidavit of no
litigation is attached.
05
05
05
05
05
05
f) Blacklisting
from any
agency
5 In case the firm is
blacklisted, no Marks
will be given and 5
points will be added in
case affidavit by the
company that it has not been black listed is
attached.
05
05
05
05
05
05
Total Marks Allocated 30 Qualified
25
Qualified
20.24
Qualified
15.04
Qualified
15
Qualified
26.14
Qualified
15.1
Technical Comparative Statement for Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gas System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
a) General Experience
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Sarhad Engineering
& Electric Company
Wajid Ali
Khan & Sons
Riaz & Sons Royal Builders Haji Aurangzaib Khan
Gandapure & Sons
Dawood
Construction
1. Audit Report Mandatory Bank Statement and Audit Report of
Last three years
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
2. Taxation Mandatory Income Tax Certificate Must be on
Active Tax payer and returns of Income
Tax of Last three years
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
3. KPRA Mandatory Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Revenue
Authority and Must be Active.
Yes Yes Yes yes Yes Yes
4. C&W KPK Mandatory Communication and Works department
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
Yes Yes yes Yes Yes Yes
5. PEC in
Category C-5
& Above
Mandatory Valid for 2020-2021 having relevant
specialization code
ME-06/EE-07/EE-08/EE-09/EE-02
Yes Yes Yes
Yes
Yes Yes
6. Projects of similar nature
and
complexity
Completed in
last 03 years.
15 12 Marks are given if the contractor has completed at least 3 projects of similar
nature in last three years.
For less than 3 projects completed use
the following weightage.
12 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects completed use the following
weightage.
12+ (A/6) x 3
A = No of projects of similar nature
Completed in last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6
projects or more.
3.9
00 00 00 00 00
Technical Comparative Statement for Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gas System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Sarhad Engineering
& Electric Company
Wajid Ali
Khan & Sons
Riaz & Sons Royal Builders Haji Aurangzaib Khan
Gandapure & Sons
Dawood
Construction
7. Projects of similar nature
and
complexity
in-hand
10 8 Marks are given if the contractor has 3 projects of similar nature in-hand.
For less than 3 projects in-hand use the
following weightage.
8 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects in-hand use the following
weightage.
8+ (A/6) x 2
A = No of projects of similar nature In-hand
during last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6 projects or more.
00 00 00 00 00 00
8. Electrical/Civ
il/Medical
Gases/IT
Networking/S
afety Security
works carried
out during
last three
years (as the
case may be)
5 4 Marks are given if the contractor has
completed at least 3 projects of similar
nature in last three years.
For less than 3 projects completed use
the following weight age.
4 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects completed use the following
weightage.
4+(A/6) x1
A = No of projects of similar nature Completed in last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6
projects or more.
2
00 00 00 00 00
9.
Enlistment
record with
Government
Organizations
5 1 Mark for each enlistment up to
maximum of five enlistments.
05 05 05 00 00 00
Technical Comparative Statement for Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gas System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Sarhad Engineering
& Electric Company
Wajid Ali
Khan & Sons
Riaz & Sons Royal Builders Haji Aurangzaib Khan
Gandapure & Sons
Dawood
Construction
& other
agencies
Total Marks Allocated
35 Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained
Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained
Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained
Marks less than
50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less than
50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks
less than 50%
b) Personnel Capabilities
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Sarhad Engineering
& Electric Company
Wajid Ali Khan & Sons Riaz & Sons Royal
Builders Pvt
Ltd
Haji Aurangzaib Khan
Gandapure & Sons
Dawood
Construction Pvt
Ltd
i) B.Sc Engineers
registered with
Pakistan Engineering
Council (PEC)
9
Experience (3-Marks) :
3 Marks will be given if the
individual experience of at least
4 no. of B.Sc Engineers (professional) is equal to 15
years or above.
For less than 4 no of B.Sc
Engineers having individual
experience of 15 years,
marks will be given as per
following formulas:
= (A/4) * 3
A = No. of Engineers having
individual experience of 15
years or above.
Strength of Engineers (6 Marks)
6 Marks will be given if the
total no. of Engineers registered
with PEC are 15 nos. or above.
00
2.4
0.75
1.59
3
2.79
1.5
1.5
03
4.8
2.25
2
Technical Comparative Statement for Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gas System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Sarhad Engineering
& Electric Company
Wajid Ali Khan & Sons Riaz & Sons Royal
Builders Pvt
Ltd
Haji Aurangzaib Khan
Gandapure & Sons
Dawood
Construction Pvt
Ltd
For less than 15 no of B.Sc
Engineers registered with PEC
marks will be given as per
following formulas:
= (A/15) * 6
A = No. of Engineers
ii) Associates Engineers
(DAE)
6
Experience (2-Marks) :
2 Marks will be given if the
individual experience of at least
8 no. of Associates Engineers
(DAE) is equal to 10 years
or above.
For less than 8 no of Associates
Engineers (DAE) having
individual experience of 10
years, marks will be given as
per following formulas: = (A/8) * 2
A = No. of DAE Engineers.
Strength of Associate Engineers (4
Marks)
4 Marks will be given if the
total no. of Associate Engineers
(DAE) are 20 nos. or above.
For less than 20 no of Associate
Engineers marks will be given
as per following formulas:
00
0.4
0.75
1.2
1
1.2
0.75
1.2
0.5
1.8
0.25
0.4
Technical Comparative Statement for Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gas System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Sarhad Engineering
& Electric Company
Wajid Ali Khan & Sons Riaz & Sons Royal
Builders Pvt
Ltd
Haji Aurangzaib Khan
Gandapure & Sons
Dawood
Construction Pvt
Ltd
= (A/20) * 4
A = No. of Associate Engineers
Total Marks Allocated 15
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Qualified
7.99
Disqualified
Obtained
Marks less
than 50%
Qualified
10.1
Disqualified
Obtained Marks
less than 50%
c). Equipment Capability
Critical equipment required for the Project shall be specified by the User/Employer under para 3.2.4 (a). High value equipment should be an option to purchase, lease or hire.
Technical Comparative Statement for Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gas System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
d) Financial Soundness
- For Financial Status assessment, the Applicants may be required to submit Audited financial statements for the last three years or any other document which verifies their Financial Status.
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Criteria for Marks Obtained
Sarhad Engineering &
Electric Company
Wajid Ali Khan &
Sons
Riaz & Sons Royal Builders
PVt Ltd
Haji Aurangzaib
Khan Gandapure &
Sons
Dawood Construction
Pvt Ltd
a) Available
Bank Credit
Line
5 3 Marks are given if
the available bank
credit line limit is
equal to 500 Million.
For limit less than 500 Million, use following
weightage
3 x (A/500)
For the limit more
than 50O million but
less than 1000 million
use following
weightage
3 + (A/1000) x 2
A= Available Bank Credit
Line Limit
Full Marks are given
in case of limit is 1000
million or more.
00 4.3 1.29 0.57 5 0.89
Technical Comparative Statement for Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gas System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
b) Working Capital in
last 3
years
5 3 Marks are given if the available average
working capital for
last three years is
equal to 500 Million.
For the capital less
than 500 million use
following weightage
3 x (A/500)
For the capital more
than 500 million but
less than 1000 million use following
weightage
3+ (500/A) x 2
A= Average working
capital in last three
years.
Full Marks are given
in case of limit is 1000
million or more.
0.37 4.5 1.29 5 5 1.6
c) Registration
with income
tax department
5 No points will be
given if income tax
certificate is not attached and 5 points
will be added in case
of valid certificate.
05 05 05 05 05 05
d) Copy of
Valid
electrical
license from
Sub-
Contractor/
JV Partner
5 No points will be
given if license is not
attached and 5 points
will be added in case
of valid license.
00 05 05 00 00 00
Technical Comparative Statement for Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gas System for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
e) Litigation History in
which
Decision has
been given
against the
firm(s)
5 In case the firm is involved in any
litigation, no marks
will be given and 5
points will be added in
case affidavit of no
litigation is attached.
05 05
05 05 05 05
f) Blacklisting
from any
agency
5 In case the firm is
blacklisted, no Marks
will be given and 5
points will be added in case affidavit by the
company that it has
not been black listed is
attached.
05 05 05 05 05 05
Total Marks Allocated 30 Qualified
15.37
Qualified
28.8
Qualified
22.58
Qualified
20.57
Qualified
25
Qualified
17.49
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases system for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
a) General Experience
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Mohmand Developers Sahil Builders
1. Audit Report Mandatory Bank Statement and Audit Report of Last three years Yes Yes
2. Taxation Mandatory Income Tax Certificate Must be on Active Tax payer and
returns of Income Tax of Last three years
Yes Yes
3. KPRA Mandatory Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Revenue Authority and Must be
Active.
Yes Yes
4. C&W KPK Mandatory Communication and Works department Khyber
Pakhtunkhwa
Yes Yes
5. PEC in
Category C-5
& Above
Mandatory Valid for 2020-2021 having relevant specialization code
ME-06/EE-07/EE-08/EE-09/EE-02
Yes NO
ME 06
6. Projects of
similar nature
and
complexity
Completed in
last 03 years.
15 12 Marks are given if the contractor has completed at least 3
projects of similar nature in last three years.
For less than 3 projects completed use the following
weightage.
12 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6 projects completed
use the following weightage.
12+ (A/6) x 3
A = No of projects of similar nature Completed in last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6 projects or more.
00 00
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases system for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Mohmand Developers Sahil Builders
7. Projects of
similar nature
and
complexity
in-hand
10 8 Marks are given if the contractor has 3 projects of similar
nature in-hand.
For less than 3 projects in-hand use the following weightage.
8 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6 projects in-hand use
the following weightage.
8+ (A/6) x 2
A = No of projects of similar nature In-hand during last three
years
Full Marks are given in case of 6 projects or more.
00 00
8. Electrical/Civ
il/Medical Gases/IT
Networking/S
afety Security
works carried
out during
last three
years (as the
case may be)
5 4 Marks are given if the contractor has completed at least 3
projects of similar nature in last three years.
For less than 3 projects completed use the following weight
age.
4 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6 projects completed
use the following weightage.
4+(A/6) x1
A = No of projects of similar nature Completed in last three
years
Full Marks are given in case of 6 projects or more.
00 00
9.
Enlistment
record with
Government Organizations
& other
agencies
5 1 Mark for each enlistment up to maximum of five
enlistments.
00 00
Total Marks Allocated
35 Disqualified
Obtained Marks less than 50%
Disqualified PEC NOT for ME
06
Obtained Marks less than 50%
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases system for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
b) Personnel Capabilities
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Mohmand Developers Sahil Builders
i) B.Sc
Engineers
registered
with Pakistan
Engineering
Council
(PEC)
9
Experience (3-Marks) :
3 Marks will be given if the individual
experience of at least 4 no. of B.Sc
Engineers (professional) is equal to
15 years or above.
For less than 4 no of B.Sc Engineers
having individual experience of 15
years, marks will be given as per
following formulas: = (A/4) * 3
A = No. of Engineers having individual
experience of 15 years or above.
Strength of Engineers (6 Marks)
6 Marks will be given if the total no. of
Engineers registered with PEC are 15
nos. or above.
For less than 15 no of B.Sc Engineers
registered with PEC marks will be given
as per following formulas:
= (A/15) * 6 A = No. of Engineers
2.25
1.6
2.25
02
ii) Associates
Engineers
(DAE)
6
Experience (2-Marks) :
2 Marks will be given if the individual
experience of at least 8 no. of Associates
1.5
02
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases system for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Mohmand Developers Sahil Builders
Engineers (DAE) is equal to 10 years
or above.
For less than 8 no of Associates
Engineers (DAE) having individual
experience of 10 years, marks will be
given as per following formulas:
= (A/8) * 2
A = No. of DAE Engineers.
Strength of Associate Engineers (4 Marks)
4 Marks will be given if the total no. of Associate Engineers (DAE) are 20 nos.
or above.
For less than 20 no of Associate
Engineers marks will be given as per
following formulas:
= (A/20) * 4
A = No. of Associate Engineers
2.8
04
Total Marks Allocated 15
Qualified
8.15
Qualified
10.25
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases system for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
c). Equipment Capability
Critical equipment required for the Project shall be specified by the User/Employer under para 3.2.4 (a). High value equipment should be an option to purchase, lease or hire.
Table B: For Medical Gases
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned
Explanation for Marks
Obtained
Mohmand Developers Sahil Builders
1 Buffer Inventory
Stock
10 Marks for each
equipment are
given if the
Contractor meets the minimum
requirements
given in the
prequalification
document for each
item.
00 00
2 List of Tools /
Equipment for
executing concern
project
10 00 00
Total Marks Allocated
20
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less than 50%
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases system for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
d) Financial Soundness
- For Financial Status assessment, the Applicants may be required to submit Audited financial statements for the last three years or any other document which verifies their Financial
Status.
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Criteria for Marks Obtained
Mohmand Developers Sahil Builders
a) Available
Bank Credit
Line
5 3 Marks are given if
the available bank
credit line limit is
equal to 500 Million.
For limit less than 500
Million, use following weightage
3 x (A/500)
For the limit more
than 50O million but
less than 1000 million
use following
weightage
3 + (A/1000) x 2
A= Available Bank Credit
Line Limit
Full Marks are given in case of limit is 1000
million or more.
3 2.7
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases system for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
b) Working Capital in
last 3
years
5 3 Marks are given if the available average
working capital for
last three years is
equal to 500 Million.
For the capital less
than 500 million use
following weightage
3 x (A/500)
For the capital more
than 500 million but
less than 1000 million use following
weightage
3+ (500/A) x 2
A= Average working
capital in last three
years.
Full Marks are given
in case of limit is 1000
million or more.
3 2.7
c) Registration
with income tax
department
5 No points will be given if income tax
certificate is not
attached and 5 points
will be added in case
of valid certificate.
5 05
d) Copy of
Valid
electrical
license from
Sub-
Contractor/
5 No points will be
given if license is not
attached and 5 points
will be added in case
of valid license.
00 00
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Medical Gases system for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
JV Partner
e) Litigation
History in
which
Decision has
been given against the
firm(s)
5 In case the firm is
involved in any
litigation, no marks
will be given and 5 points will be added in
case affidavit of no
litigation is attached.
5 05
f) Blacklisting
from any
agency
5 In case the firm is
blacklisted, no Marks
will be given and 5
points will be added in
case affidavit by the
company that it has
not been black listed is
attached.
5 05
Total Marks Allocated 30 Qualified
21
Qualified
20.4
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety and Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
a) General Experience
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Sarhad Engineering &
Electric Company
Zahir Shah &
Brothers
Haji Aurangzaib Khan
Gandapure & Sons
Riaz & Sons Royal Builders Dawood Construction
1. Audit Report Mandatory Bank Statement and Audit Report of
Last three years
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
2. Taxation Mandatory Income Tax Certificate Must be on
Active Tax payer and returns of Income
Tax of Last three years
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
3. KPRA Mandatory Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Revenue
Authority and Must be Active.
Yes Yes Yes Yes yes Yes
4. C&W KPK Mandatory Communication and Works department
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
Yes Yes Yes yes Yes Yes
5. PEC in
Category C-5
& Above
Mandatory Valid for 2020-2021 having relevant
specialization code
ME-06/EE-07/EE-08/EE-09/EE-02
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
6. Projects of similar nature
and
complexity
Completed in
last 03 years.
15 12 Marks are given if the contractor has completed at least 3 projects of similar
nature in last three years.
For less than 3 projects completed use
the following weightage.
12 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects completed use the following
weightage.
12+ (A/6) x 3
A = No of projects of similar nature
Completed in last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6
projects or more.
3.9
00 00 00 00 00
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety and Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Sarhad Engineering &
Electric Company
Zahir Shah &
Brothers
Haji Aurangzaib Khan
Gandapure & Sons
Riaz & Sons Royal Builders Dawood Construction
7. Projects of
similar nature
and
complexity
in-hand
10 8 Marks are given if the contractor has 3
projects of similar nature in-hand.
For less than 3 projects in-hand use the
following weightage.
8 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects in-hand use the following
weightage.
8+ (A/6) x 2
A = No of projects of similar nature In-hand
during last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6
projects or more.
00 00 00 00 00 00
8. Electrical/Civ
il/Medical
Gases/IT
Networking/S
afety Security
works carried
out during
last three
years (as the
case may be)
5 4 Marks are given if the contractor has
completed at least 3 projects of similar
nature in last three years.
For less than 3 projects completed use
the following weight age.
4 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects completed use the following
weightage.
4+(A/6) x1 A = No of projects of similar nature
Completed in last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6
projects or more.
2
00 00 00 00 00
9.
Enlistment
record with
Government
Organizations
& other
agencies
5 1 Mark for each enlistment up to
maximum of five enlistments.
05 05 05 05 05 05
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety and Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Sarhad Engineering &
Electric Company
Zahir Shah &
Brothers
Haji Aurangzaib Khan
Gandapure & Sons
Riaz & Sons Royal Builders Dawood Construction
Total Marks Allocated
35 Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained
Marks less than
50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained
Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained
Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
b) Personnel Capabilities
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Sarhad Engineering
& Electric Company
Zahir Shah
& Brothers
Haji Aurangzaib
Khan Gandapure &
Sons
Riaz & Sons Royal Builders Pvt
Ltd
Dawood Construction
Pvt Ltd
i) B.Sc Engineers
registered with
Pakistan Engineering
Council (PEC)
9
Experience (3-Marks) :
3 Marks will be given if the
individual experience of at least
4 no. of B.Sc Engineers (professional) is equal to 15
years or above.
For less than 4 no of B.Sc
Engineers having individual
experience of 15 years,
marks will be given as per
following formulas:
= (A/4) * 3
A = No. of Engineers having
individual experience of 15
years or above.
Strength of Engineers (6 Marks)
6 Marks will be given if the
total no. of Engineers registered
with PEC are 15 nos. or above.
For less than 15 no of B.Sc
Engineers registered with PEC
marks will be given as per
following formulas:
= (A/15) * 6
A = No. of Engineers
00
2.4
03
06
03
4.8
3
2.79
1.5
1.5
2.25
2
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety and Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Sarhad Engineering
& Electric Company
Zahir Shah
& Brothers
Haji Aurangzaib
Khan Gandapure &
Sons
Riaz & Sons Royal Builders Pvt
Ltd
Dawood Construction
Pvt Ltd
ii) Associates Engineers
(DAE)
6
Experience (2-Marks) :
2 Marks will be given if the
individual experience of at least
8 no. of Associates Engineers
(DAE) is equal to 10 years
or above.
For less than 8 no of Associates
Engineers (DAE) having
individual experience of 10
years, marks will be given as per following formulas:
= (A/8) * 2
A = No. of DAE Engineers.
Strength of Associate Engineers (4
Marks)
4 Marks will be given if the
total no. of Associate Engineers
(DAE) are 20 nos. or above.
For less than 20 no of Associate
Engineers marks will be given
as per following formulas: = (A/20) * 4
A = No. of Associate Engineers
00
0.4
02
3.4
0.5
1.8
1
1.2
0.75
1.2
0.25
0.4
Total Marks Allocated 15
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Qualified
14.4
Qualified
10.1
Qualified
7.99
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety and Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
c). Equipment Capability
Critical equipment required for the Project shall be specified by the User/Employer under para 3.2.4 (a). High value equipment should be an option to purchase, lease or hire.
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety and Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
d) Financial Soundness
- For Financial Status assessment, the Applicants may be required to submit Audited financial statements for the last three years or any other document which verifies their Financial Status.
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Criteria for Marks Obtained
Sarhad
Engineering &
Electric Company
Zahir Shah &
Brothers
Haji Aurangzaib
Khan Gandapure
& Sons
Riaz & Sons Royal Builders PVt
Ltd
Dawood Construction
Pvt Ltd
a) Available
Bank Credit
Line
5 3 Marks are given if
the available bank
credit line limit is
equal to 500 Million.
For limit less than 500
Million, use following
weightage
3 x (A/500)
For the limit more
than 50O million but
less than 1000 million
use following
weightage
3 + (A/1000) x 2
A= Available Bank Credit Line Limit
Full Marks are given
in case of limit is 1000
million or more.
00
1.14
5 1.29 0.57 0.89
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety and Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
b) Working Capital in
last 3
years
5 3 Marks are given if the available average
working capital for
last three years is
equal to 500 Million.
For the capital less
than 500 million use
following weightage
3 x (A/500)
For the capital more
than 500 million but
less than 1000 million use following
weightage
3+ (500/A) x 2
A= Average working
capital in last three
years.
Full Marks are given
in case of limit is 1000
million or more.
0.37 05
5 1.29 5 1.6
c) Registration
with income
tax
department
5 No points will be
given if income tax
certificate is not
attached and 5 points
will be added in case
of valid certificate.
05 05 05 05 05 05
d) Copy of
Valid
electrical
license from
Sub-
Contractor/ JV Partner
5 No points will be
given if license is not
attached and 5 points
will be added in case
of valid license.
00 00 00 00 00 00
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety and Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
e) Litigation History in
which
Decision has
been given
against the
firm(s)
5 In case the firm is involved in any
litigation, no marks
will be given and 5
points will be added in
case affidavit of no
litigation is attached.
05 05 05 05 05 05
f) Blacklisting
from any
agency
5 In case the firm is
blacklisted, no Marks
will be given and 5
points will be added in
case affidavit by the company that it has
not been black listed is
attached.
05 05 05 05 05 05
Total Marks Allocated 30 Qualified
15.37
Qualified
21.14
Qualified
25
Qualified
17.58
Qualified
20.57
Qualified
17.49
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety & Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy `Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
a) General Experience
Sr. No. Description Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Vital
International
New Shah Construction
Company
Wajid Ali Khan &
Sons
Sahil Builders Mohmand
Developers
1. Audit Report Mandatory Bank Statement and Audit Report of
Last three years
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
2. Taxation Mandatory Income Tax Certificate Must be on
Active Tax payer and returns of Income
Tax of Last three years
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
3. KPRA Mandatory Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Revenue
Authority and Must be Active.
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
4. C&W KPK Mandatory Communication and Works department
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
No Yes Yes Yes Yes
5. PEC in Category C-
5 & Above
Mandatory Valid for 2020-2021 having relevant
specialization code
ME-06/EE-07/EE-08/EE-09/EE-02
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
6. Projects of similar nature and
complexity
Completed in last 03
years.
15 12 Marks are given if the contractor has completed at least 3 projects of similar
nature in last three years.
For less than 3 projects completed use
the following weightage.
12 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects completed use the following
weightage.
12+ (A/6) x 3
A = No of projects of similar nature
Completed in last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6
projects or more.
15 00 00 00 00
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety & Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy `Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr. No. Description Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Vital
International
New Shah Construction
Company
Wajid Ali Khan &
Sons
Sahil Builders Mohmand
Developers
7. Projects of similar
nature and
complexity in-hand
10 8 Marks are given if the contractor has 3
projects of similar nature in-hand.
For less than 3 projects in-hand use the
following weightage.
8 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6
projects in-hand use the following
weightage.
8+ (A/6) x 2
A = No of projects of similar nature In-hand
during last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6
projects or more.
10 00 00 00 00
8. Electrical/Civil/Med
ical Gases/IT
Networking/Safety
Security works
carried out during
last three years (as
the case may be)
5 4 Marks are given if the contractor has
completed at least 3 projects of similar
nature in last three years.
For less than 3 projects completed use
the following weight age.
4 x (A/3)
For more than 3 projects but less than 6 projects completed use the following
weightage.
4+(A/6) x1
A = No of projects of similar nature
Completed in last three years
Full Marks are given in case of 6
projects or more.
5 00 00 00 00
9.
Enlistment record
with Government
Organizations &
other agencies
5 1 Mark for each enlistment up to
maximum of five enlistments.
05 05 05 05 05
Total Marks Allocated
35 Disqualified
Not registered
with C&W
Disqualified
Obtained Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks
less than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks
less than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks
less than 50%
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety & Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy `Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
b) Personnel Capabilities
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Vital
International
New Shah
Construction
Company
Wajid Ali Khan &
Sons
Sahil Builders Mohmand
Developers
i) B.Sc Engineers
registered with
Pakistan Engineering
Council (PEC)
9
Experience (3-Marks) :
3 Marks will be given if the
individual experience of at least
4 no. of B.Sc Engineers
(professional) is equal to 15
years or above.
For less than 4 no of B.Sc
Engineers having individual
experience of 15 years,
marks will be given as per following formulas:
= (A/4) * 3
A = No. of Engineers having
individual experience of 15
years or above.
Strength of Engineers (6 Marks)
6 Marks will be given if the
total no. of Engineers registered
with PEC are 15 nos. or above.
For less than 15 no of B.Sc
Engineers registered with PEC
marks will be given as per
following formulas:
= (A/15) * 6
A = No. of Engineers
00
00
1.5
1.2
00
1.6
2.25
02
2.25
1.6
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety & Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy `Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Explanation for Marks Obtained
Vital
International
New Shah
Construction
Company
Wajid Ali Khan &
Sons
Sahil Builders Mohmand
Developers
ii) Associates Engineers (DAE)
6
Experience (2-Marks) :
2 Marks will be given if the
individual experience of at least
8 no. of Associates Engineers
(DAE) is equal to 10 years
or above.
For less than 8 no of Associates
Engineers (DAE) having
individual experience of 10
years, marks will be given as
per following formulas:
= (A/8) * 2
A = No. of DAE Engineers.
Strength of Associate Engineers (4
Marks)
4 Marks will be given if the
total no. of Associate Engineers (DAE) are 20 nos. or above.
For less than 20 no of Associate
Engineers marks will be given
as per following formulas:
= (A/20) * 4
A = No. of Associate Engineers
00
00
00
01
00
1.2
02
04
1.5
2.8
Total Marks Allocated 15
Disqualified
Obtained Marks
less than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained
Marks less
than 50%
Disqualified
Obtained Marks
less than 50%
Qualified
10.25
Qualified
8.15
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety & Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy `Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
c). Equipment Capability Critical equipment required for the Project shall be specified by the User/Employer under para 3.2.4 (a). High value equipment should be an option to purchase, lease or hire.
Table B: For Safety and Security
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned
Explanation for Marks
Obtained
Vital
International
New Shah
Construction
Company
Wajid Ali Khan &
Sons
Sahil Builders Mohmand Developers
1 Buffer Inventory
Stock
10 Marks for each
equipment are
given if the Contractor meets
the minimum
requirements
given in the
prequalification
document for each
item.
10 00 00 00 00
2 List of Tools /
Equipment for
executing concern
project
10 10 10 10 10 10
Total Marks Allocated
20
Qualified Qualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety & Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy `Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
d) Financial Soundness
- For Financial Status assessment, the Applicants may be required to submit Audited financial statements for the last three years or any other document which verifies their Financial Status.
Sr.
No. Description
Marks
Assigned Criteria for Marks Obtained
Vital International New Shah
Construction
Company
Wajid Ali Khan &
Sons
Sahil Builders Mohmand Developers
a) Available
Bank Credit
Line
5 3 Marks are given if
the available bank
credit line limit is
equal to 500 Million.
For limit less than 500
Million, use following
weightage
3 x (A/500)
For the limit more
than 50O million but
less than 1000 million
use following
weightage
3 + (A/1000) x 2
A= Available Bank Credit
Line Limit
Full Marks are given
in case of limit is 1000
million or more.
0.14 4.6 4.2 2.7 3
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety & Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy `Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC
b) Working
Capital in
last 3
years
5 3 Marks are given if
the available average
working capital for
last three years is
equal to 500 Million.
For the capital less
than 500 million use
following weightage
3 x (A/500)
For the capital more than 500 million but
less than 1000 million
use following
weightage
3+ (500/A) x 2
A= Average working
capital in last three
years.
Full Marks are given
in case of limit is 1000
million or more.
03 00 0.6 2.7 3
c) Registration
with income
tax
department
5 No points will be
given if income tax
certificate is not
attached and 5 points
will be added in case
of valid certificate.
05 05 05 05 5
d) Copy of
Valid
electrical
license from
Sub-
Contractor/
JV Partner
5 No points will be
given if license is not
attached and 5 points
will be added in case
of valid license.
00 00 00 00 00
Technical Comparative Statements for the Pre-Qualification of Contractors for Safety & Security for f.y 2020-2021
Prof.Dr.Zahid Askar Account Officer MTI:KTH Manager Supply Chain Manager Pharmacy `Biomedical Engineer Chairman TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC Member TEC