Page 1
1
Medication Management at End of LifeMolly Curran, PharmDFebruary 9, 2016
PGY2 Critical Care Pharmacy ResidentDepartment of Pharmacy, University Health System, San Antonio, TXDivision of Pharmacotherapy, The University of Texas at Austin College of PharmacyPharmacotherapy Education and Research Center, University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio
Disclosures
I acknowledge that I have no actual or potential conflicts of interest or relevant financial relationships with any commercial interest in relation to this CE.
2
3
Pharmacist Learning Objectives:
To describe the role of medication in managing end of life symptoms
To explain medication classes important for medical management during end of life care
To formulate evidence based recommendations for managing patient symptoms at end of life
Pharmacy Technician Objectives:
To recognize the common medications used in end of life patient care
To describe the administration routes for medications used in palliative care
To convert opioid equivalencies for various analgesic medications
Page 2
2
4
Alleviate physical and emotional symptomsAchieve the best possible quality of life (QoL)
Intended effect
Relieves discomfort or suffering
Unintended effect
Hastens death?
Rule of Double Effect
Goals for Patient Care:
Strickland, J.M. (2009) Palliative Pharmacy Care.
Unjustified Fears of Double Effect
Studies evaluating adequate pain control at end of life:
No difference in survival
Studies evaluating the use of sedation at end of life:
No significant differences in survival
One study favored sedation
Use symptom relief as means of evaluation
5
Cancer 1999:86:871‐77.J Palliat Med 1998;1(4)315‐28.Arch Int Med 2003;163:341‐44.
End of Life Decisions
Meet the needs of patient and family
May address multitude of concerns about care:
Stopping unnecessary interventions
Ventilator withdrawal and extubation
Aggressive or unnecessary medical therapy
Nutrition
Provide emotional and spiritual support to prepare or plan for patient death
6
Strickland, J.M. (2009) Palliative Pharmacy Care.
Page 3
3
7
Patient‐Centered
Goals of Care
Plan
Spiritual needs
Family
Caregivers
Considerations
Health Provider Communication
Imminently Dying: Prioritizing Comfort
Prepare for transition to comfort care
Stop non‐essential drugs
Convert medications aimed at comfort to alternative access routes
Subcutaneous, topical, parenteral, rectal
Providing support for family, friends, caregivers
Address symptoms at end of life
Anticipatory medication orders
8
Strickland, J.M. (2009) Palliative Pharmacy Care.
9
What are examples of medications that may be stopped for comfort care
patients?
A. Atorvastatin
B. Lisinopril
C. Phenytoin
D. Estradiol
Page 4
4
Medical Symptom Management
10
End of Life Symptoms
Pain
Delirium and anxiety
Terminal Secretions
Dyspnea
11
End of Life: Pain Management
Many patients die with treatable pain
Up to 80%
Minimize iatrogenic sources of pain
Use patient self‐report or validated tools for assessing
Behavioral Pain Scale in ICU
Critical Care Pain Observational Tool
Nonverbal Pain Scale
12
J Palliat Med. 2010; 13(5):501‐4.J Palliat Med. 2006;9:658‐65.J Pain Symptom Manage. 2007;34:227‐36.
Page 5
5
Pain Scale Assessment
13
Am J Crit Care 2006; 15(4):420‐7.
14
Pain?
Present
Controlled?
Continue current regimen
Add PRN order to anticipate increasing
pain
Uncontrolled?
If Opioid naïve:Start PRN Morphine 2‐4mg q 15 min to assess
usage
If Opioid tolerant: Review current analgesia
dosage and increase by 25‐100% depending on severity of pain
Give PRN doses as symptoms occur
Absent
Prescribe morphine as
needed (up to a 1x/hour)
Review 24 hour use and consider Infusion if >3‐4 doses needed
Adapted from Liverpool Care Pathway
Strategy for Pain Management
BMJ 2013;346:f2174.
Properties of Common Opioids
IV EquivDosing
Onset to Peak Effect, mins
Duration of Effect, hrs
Typical Adult Dose
Morphine 10 mg 20‐30 3‐4 2‐10 mg
Fentanyl 100 mcg 2‐5 0.5‐2 0.5‐2 mcg/kg
Hydromorphone 1.5 mg 20‐30 3‐4 0.5‐2 mg
15
Crit Care Med 2008;36(3)953‐63.
Take Home Point #1: If pain well controlled, consider continuing current regimen orusing equi‐analgesic dose
Page 6
6
Opioid Metabolism: Focus on Morphine
When administered orally, undergoes 1st pass metabolism to produce: Active metabolite
Morphine‐6‐glucoronide
Inactive metabolite Morphine‐3‐glucoronide
Contributes to neurotoxicity
All opioids undergo hepatic metabolism
Metabolites are renally cleared Consider dose
reduction/decreased frequency if side effects
16
Image from: http://intranet.tdmu.edu.ua/Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 1997 Jan;41(1 Pt 2):116‐22.
Alternative Routes: Sublingual Opioids
Advantages: Rapidity of onset
Bypass 1st pass metabolism
Intensity/duration analgesia
Smaller side effect profile
Non‐invasive profile
Ease of administration
Disadvantages Unpalatable
Burning sensation
Need to retain medication for minutes
17
Pharmacol Res Commun 1982;14:369‐80.Am J Hosp Care 1987;4:39‐41.Am J Hosp Care 1988;5:17‐8.
McQuay et al.n = 5
Pannuti et al.n = 8
Weinberg et al.n = 10
Osborne et al.n = 10
Intervention Dose: 10 mgRetained: 5 minPopulation: Chronic opioid use
Dose: 10 mgRetained: 10 minPopulation: Advanced cancer
Dose: 15 mg tabletPopulation: Healthy volunteers
Dose: 11.7 mg tabletRetained: Until dissolutionPopulation: Healthyvolunteers
Outcomes Meanbioavailability:61% (10‐100%)
No statisticallysignificant differences
Mean absorption: 22%Mean bioavailability :9 ± 11.9%
No statistically significant difference from PO morphine (21.9% v. 20.%bioavailability)
Misc Measuredmorphine in expectorant (F = 51%)
Allowed patients to swallow SL dose confounds results
Retention time unknown
Longer Tmax and Cmax
18
Pharmacokinetics: Sublingual Morphine
Page 7
7
Pharmacodynamics: Sublingual Morphine
19
Pannuti et al.n = 8
Engelhardt and Crawford.n = 14
Intervention Dose titrated to effect Interval: Every 4 hours as needed over 5 weeksPopulation: Advanced cancer
Dose: 0.1 mg/kg solutionPopulation: Pediatric surgical patients
Outcomes Mean pain reduction (0‐10 VAS):7.8 to 2.7
Average pain scores (0‐5 rating scale)SL route: 2.3 ± 0.5IV route: 2.5 ± 0.6
Misc Statistically significant advantages:• Rapidity/intensity of analgesia• Nonsignificant reduction in
constipation/vomiting
All patients received concurrent NSAID therapy which may confound results
Alternative Routes: Sublingual Opioids
Other opioids have been studied for sublingual administration:
Methadone
Fentanyl
SL bioavailability reported is highly variable
20
Take Home Point #2: If using SL opioids, avoid doses greater than 2 mL because may leak out of sublingual space
J Palliat Med. 2007;10(2):465‐75.
What is the equivalent dose of 10mg IV morphine in mcg of IV fentanyl?
21
A. 30 mg
B. 30 mcg
C. 100 mcg
D. 1000 mcg
Page 8
8
Alternative Routes: Rectal Opioids
Highly bioavailable absorption in lower rectum bypass 1st pass metabolism
Upper rectum absorption undergoes 1st pass metabolism
Dose similar to oral opioids due to anastomses
Any immediate release tablet or solution can be given rectally
22
Capc.org. Fast Fact #257J Pain Symptom Manage. 1996;11(6):378‐87.
Take Home Point #3: May give IR opioid tablets/solution/parenteral solution (<60 mL) per rectum if PO route compromised
Alternative Routes: Subcutaneous Opioids
May be administered continuously or as needed
Conversion ratio from IV:SubQ not well established
Morphine appears to be 1:1
Adverse effects include skin irritation, itching, site bleeding
Change needle if occurs
23
Capc.org. Fast Fact #28Cancer. 1988;62:407‐11.
Take Home Point #4: SubQ tissue allows for absorption of up to 3mL/hr, so consider intrinsic potency of opioid if using this route
Alternative Routes: Transdermal Fentanyl
Therapeutic blood levels achieved 13‐24 hours after patch removal
Continue to release drug for up to 24 hours after removal
May not be sufficient means of pain control for patient in last hours
Absorption effected by fevers/cachexia
24
Capc.org. Fast Fact #28J Pain Symptom Manage. 1996;11(6):378‐87.
Page 9
9
What are alternative routes you can consider in patients without IV access?
A. Subcutaneous
B. Sublingual
C. Transdermal
D. Rectal
E. All of the Above
25
End of Life Symptoms
Pain
Delirium and anxiety
Terminal secretions
Dyspnea
26
End of Life: Anxiety and Delirium
State of apprehension and fear
Delirium
Hyper‐ or hypo‐ active
“Terminal agitation”
No reversible causes present
May indicate distress:
Physical
Psychological
Existential
27
Strickland, JM. Palliative Pharmacy Care, 2009.BMJ 2013;346:f2174.Clin Geriatr Med 20(2004)641‐67.
Page 10
10
Considerations in Terminal Delirium
Check medication list:
Anti‐cholinergics
Sedatives
Hypnotics
Opioids
Consider other etiologies
Withdrawal
CNS involvement
Metabolic derangements
Neuroleptics are drugs of choice for treatment:
Haloperidol
Olanzapine
Quetiapine
Risperidone
Scant data for atypical agents
QTc interval‐ consider risks and benefits
Benzodiazepines (BZD) may precipitate paradoxical response
28
Capc.org. Fast Fact #60.Am J Psych. 1996; 153:231‐7.
Anxiety in Imminent Death
Common in patients facing life‐threatening illnesses
Address and identify reversible causes
Drugs: corticosteroids, stimulants, etc.
BZD monotherapy for patients with days to weeks
For patients with months, antidepressants are preferred
Consider adjunctive BZD for first weeks of therapy
Consider rebound anxiety in patients previously on oral BZD
29
J Palliat Med. 2005; 8:453‐9.Capc.org. Fast Fact #145.
30
Practical Considerations: Benzodiazepine
Therapy
Benzodiazepine Equivalent Oral Dose (mg) Half‐life (hr)
Alprazolam 0.5 6‐12
Lorazepam 1 10‐20
Clonazepam 0.25‐0.5 18‐50
Diazepam 5 20‐100
Take Home Point #5: If patient previously on BZD, consider equi‐potent dosing if changing route/drug (PR, IV, SubQ)
http://www.benzo.org.uk/bzequiv.htm
Page 11
11
End of Life Symptoms
Pain
Delirium and anxiety
Terminal secretions
Dyspnea
31
End of Life: Terminal Secretions
Lose ability to clear/swallow oral secretions
Decline of gag reflex/reflexive clearing
Accumulation of tracheobronchial tree secretions
Gurgling, Crackling, Rattling
32
Strickland, JM. Palliative Pharmacy Care, 2009.
Terminal Secretions: Treatment
Repositioning for postural drainage
On side
Semi‐prone
Medication therapy
Anticholinergics
MOA:
Relax bronchial muscles and open airways
Dry mucus secretion and slow ciliary passage
33
Strickland, JM. Palliative Pharmacy Care, 2009.
Page 12
12
Treatment: Anticholinergics
Anticholinergic drugs are divided into:
Tertiary: cross blood brain barrier (BBB)
Quaternary: do not cross BBB
Implications on side effect profile
Bind muscarinic receptors
34
Strickland, JM. Palliative Pharmacy Care, 2009.Am J Hosp Palliat Med 2012;30(5)490‐8.
Anticholinergic Toxicity
AnticholinergicToxicity
Blurred visionMydriasis
Delirium
Dry skin
IleusPsychosisConfusion
Tachycardia
Hypertension
Hyperthermia
35
Am J Hosp Palliat Med 2012;30(5)490‐8.
Treatment Options: Anticholinergics
Medication Dose/Route Titration Clinical Pearls
Atropine 1% eye drops
1‐2 drops SL PRN Every 6 hours PRN
• Crosses BBB• Increased risk of CNS
side effects
Scopalamine patch
1 patch (1.5 mg base delivers 1 mg drug)
Every 72 hours • Crosses BBB• Onset 6 to 8 hours• Steady‐state at 24 hours
Glycopyrrolate (Robinul®)
0.2 to 0.4 mg IV every 8 hours PRN
Up to every 6 hours
• PO absorption erratic• Can be given SubQ
Hyoscyamine 0.125 mg or 0.25 mg PO PRN
• Crosses BBB• Onset 30 min• Available in SL tablets
36
Am J Hosp Palliat Med, 2012;30(5)490‐8.Strickland, JM. Palliative Pharmacy Care, 2009.
Page 13
13
Pharmacodynamics: Anticholinergic Therapy
Likar et al, 2008 Hugel et al, 2006
Study (n)
Randomized, no placebon = 13Terminal cancer/cognitive dysfunction
Effectiveness of symptom control in Liverpool Care Pathwayn = 72 (36 in each arm)Advanced cancer
Methods IV glycopyrrolate 0.4 mg every6 hours versus bolus scopalamine HBr 0.5 mg every 6 hours
SubQ glycopyrrolate 0.2 mg versus hyoscine HBr 0.4 SubQ followed by continuous bolus drug infusions
Outcomes Glycopyrrolate superior to scopolamine HBr over 12 hours
*Small sample size
Full response in glycopyrrolate group versus 22% in hyoscine response
*Observer bias, unbalanced populations
37
Wien Klin Wocheneschr 2008;120(21‐22):649‐83.J Palliat Med 2006;9(2):279‐84.
Patient Considerations: Anticholinergics
Contraindications to anticholinergic use:
Closed‐angle glaucoma
Ileus
Caution in patients with pre‐existing delirium
38
Take Home Point #6: When selecting an agent for terminal secretions, glycopyrrolate does not cross BBB and may result in less CNS effects
Am J Hosp Palliat Med, 2012;30(5)490‐8.Strickland, JM. Palliative Pharmacy Care, 2009.
End of Life Symptoms
Pain
Delirium and anxiety
Terminal secretions
Dyspnea
39
Page 14
14
End of Life: Dyspnea
Described as: Short of breath
Suffocating
Choking
Drowning
Due to: Increased respiratory
hindrance
Abnormality of respiratory muscles
Increased ventilatorydemand
40
Strickland, JM. Palliative Pharmacy Care, 2009.
Treatment: Dyspnea
Goal: Decrease discomfort
Non‐pharmacologic strategies:
Improve air circulation
Breathing exercises
Positioning
Medications
Opioids
Anxiolytics if anxiety related
41
Strickland, JM. Palliative Pharmacy Care, 2009.J Palliat Med 2012;15:106‐14.
Opioids for Dyspnea
Improve sensation of breathlessness at low doses
Exact mechanism unknown
Distinct from respiratory depression at high doses
No advantage of inhalation therapy over PO/IV
42
Take Home Point #7: While most opioids may be help with dyspnea, methadone is not effective for this indication
Strickland, JM. Palliative Pharmacy Care, 2009.BMJ 2013;346:f2174.The Cochrane Database System, 2013.
Page 15
15
Anxiolytics for Dyspnea
Second‐line agents for dyspnea
Effective for patients with anxiety disorder
Treatment of anxiety ameliorate dyspnea
Lorazepam may be given PO, SL, or SubQ
43
Strickland, JM. Palliative Pharmacy Care, 2009.BMJ 2013;346:f2174.J Palliat Med 2012;15:106‐14.
Take Home Point #8: Anxiolytics are not first line therapy for patients complaining of breathlessness
Standardizing Symptom Orders
Wide variation exists in the palliative care delivered at End of Life
Recent research has looked at Comfort Care Order Sets (CCOS)
Purpose to facilitate comfort care interventions
BEACON Trial, 2014:
Multimodal approach to end‐of‐life care increased comfort interventions
Impact of Standardized Palliative Care Order Set of End of Life Care, 2011:
Addition of order set significantly improved adherence to accepted end‐of life interventions
44
J Palliat Med 2011;14(3):281‐6.J Gen Intern Med 29(6):836‐43.
Example of CCOS
Acetaminophen 650 mg PO/PR q4h PRN T>101°F
For constant pain, give _____ (suggest Morphine SR) at ___ PO BID
For intermittent pain or shortness of breath give: Morphine sulfate ___ mg PO q 2h PRN (suggest starting at 5mg)
If NPO, give morphine sulfate __ mg IV/SubQ q 2h PRN (suggest starting at 2mg)
For anxiety, give lorazepam 0.5 mg IV/PO q6h PRN
For constipation, senna/docusate 2 tablets PO QHS
For nausea/delirium, haloperidol 1 mg PO/IV q 4h PRN
For excessive secretions hyoscyamine 0.125 mg SL q 4h PRN
45
J Gen Intern Med 29(6):836‐43.
Page 16
16
What are the potential advantages to having an inpatient palliative care order set?
A. Less wait time for medications
B. May anticipate patient needs
C. Allow for focused care on communication
D. All of the above
46
Practical Considerations
47
What’s on formulary?
Opioids BZDs Anticholinergics Neuroleptics
Morphine• Concentrated PO
solution: 20 mg/mL• Injection:
2‐15mg/mL• PO Solution:
2 mg/mL
Hydromorphone• Injection:
2 or 10 mg/mL
Fentanyl• Injection: 0.05 mg/mL• Transdermal: 25, 50
100 mcg
Methadone• PO solution: All floors• Injection: NONE
Lorazepam• Concentrated PO
solution: 2 mg/mL• Injection: 2, 4 mg/mL
Midazolam• Injection: 1 mg/mL• Syrup: 2 mg/mL
Diazepam• Injection: 5 mg/mL
Clonazepam• Suspension:
0.1 mg/mL• Tablet: 0.5,1, 2 mg
Alprazolam• Tablet: 0.25, 0.5, 1 mg
Glycopyrrolate• Injection: 0.2 mg/mL
Atropine• Ophthalmic Soln: 1%
Scopalamine• Patch: 1.5 mg base
Hyoscyamine• Elixir: 0.125 mg/5 mL• Tablet (SL, chewable,
PO): 0.125 mg
Haloperidol• Concentrated PO: 2
mg/mL• Injection (lactate):
5mg/mL• Tablet: 0.5, 1, 2, 5, 10,
20 mg
Olanzapine• Tablet: 2.5, 5, 7.5, 10,
15, 20 mg• ODT: 5, 10, 15, 20 mg
Quetiapine• SR tablets: 25, 50, 100,
200, 300, 400 mg
Risperidone• ODT: 0.5, 1, 2, 3, 4 mg• PO Solution: 1 mg/mL• Tablet: 0.25, 0.5, 1, 2,
3, 4
48
Page 17
17
What’s in my PXYIS?
49
Opioids BZDs Anticholinergics Neuroleptics
Morphine• Concentrated PO
solution: 8ACU • Injection: All floors• PO Solution:
All floors except 9ICU
Hydromorphone• Injection:
All floors
Fentanyl• Injection: All floors
except 5ACU and PSYCH
Methadone• PO solution: 1mg/mL• Injection: 10 mg/mL
Lorazepam• Concentrated PO
solution: None• Injection: All floors
Midazolam• Injection: All floors• Syrup: NONE
Diazepam• Injection: All floors
^ICU
Clonazepam• Suspension:
None• Tablet: All floors
Alprazolam• Tablet: All floors
Glycopyrrolate• Injection: 8ACU, 8ICU
Atropine• Ophthalmic Soln: None
Scopalamine• Patch: 5ICU, 6ACU,
8ACU
Hyoscyamine• Elixir: None• Tablet (SL, chewable,
PO): 8ACU
Haloperidol• Concentrated PO::
NONE• Injection (lactate): All
floors• Tablet: 5ACU, 6ACU,
8ACU, 9ACU, 9ICU
Olanzapine• Tablet: All floors• ODT: All floors except
9WEST
Quetiapine• SR tablets: All floors
Risperidone• ODT: All floors except
5ICU, 9WEST• PO Solution: NONE• Tablet: All floors
Current as of 3‐16‐15
Medication Orders
Anticipatory orders especially important if:
Not stocked in PXYIS
STAT orders to be verified and sent by pharmacy within 1 hours
Do not call unless <1 hour
Routine orders to be verified and sent by pharmacy within 2 hours
50
Final Considerations
End of life is an unpredictable process
Evaluate patient’s comfort level bedside
Medications are one part of the treatment
Anticipating end‐of‐life needs may provide more timely care for patients
51
Page 18
18
Thank You
Dr. Katie Stowers
Laurajo Ryan, PharmD
Bryson Duhon, PharmD
52
53
Questions?
Secret CE Codes
For Pharmacists: WG8i
For Technicians: k8iC
54