Top Banner

of 68

May 15 Senate impeachment court record

Apr 05, 2018

Download

Documents

VERA Files
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    1/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 3

    Uawqedof bh yka Wkodowwomav

    Vamcya

    Uafbui bh yka VamcyaVoyyomn Cv Cm Olwacfklamy Fbquy

    Yqavic$ Lc 31$ 5735

    Wcvc Foy

    CY 5:37 W-L-$ YKA WUAVOIOMN BHHOFAU$ VAMCYA WUAVOIAMY JQCM WBMFA AMUODA$

    FCDDAI YKA OLWACFKLAMY YUOCD BH VQWUALA FBQUY FKOAH JQVYOFA UAMCYB F-

    FBUBMC YB BUIAU-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau-Yka fbmyomqcyobm bh yka olwacfklamy yuocd bh yka Kbm- Fkoah Jqvyofa Uamcyb

    F- Fbubmc bh yka Vqwuala Fbquy ov kauae fcddai yb buiau-

    ^a vkcdd ea dai om wucau e Vam- Hucmfov M- Wcmnodomcm-

    Vamcybu Wcmnodomcm-

    Cdlonky Hcykau cmi Kacxamd @omn$ cv ~a macu yka ami bh ykov kovybuof olwacfklamy yuocd $ cv

    Vamcybu,Jqinav$ ~a kqled vaa` _bqu omhomoya ~ovibl$ _bqu ebqmidavv fbqucna$ cmi ollacvquceda

    vyuamnyk cv ~a hqdhodd bqu fbmvyoyqyobmcd iqy yb uamiau olwcuyocd jqvyofa om ykava wubfaaiomnv-

    ^a ykcm` _bq$ B Dbui$ ykcy chyau macud vo{ lbmykv$ ~a kcxa fbla ykov hcu om vacufk bh yka yuqyk

    cmi om yka wquvqoy bh jqvyofa-

    ^a ykcm` _bq$ Kacxamd @omn$ hbu ebyk yka Wubvafqyobm cmi yka Iahamva ~kb kcxa amiacxbuai

    lonkyod yb wquvqa ykaou uavwafyoxa fcqvav-

    ^a ykcm` _bq hbu bqu Wuavoiomn Bhhofau$ bqu Vamcya Wuavoiamy$ hbu kov ualcu`ceda vyclomc cmi

    qmwcucddadai omfovoxamavv om yka vyaauomn bh ykava wubfaaiomnv-

    ^a kqled cv` _bq yb edavv$ yb nqoia$ cmi yb vkawkaui cdd wcuyoav om ykava wubfaaiomnv$ omfdqiomn

    yka uavwbmiamy Fkoah Jqvyofa cmi kov hclod-

    Cmi cy ykcy wbomy$ ~kam c iafovobm e ykov Fbquy ov lcia$ uancuidavv bh yka bqyfbla$ ~a wuc ykcy

    _bq cddb~ yka kacdomn bh yka mcyobm yb fbllamfa-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    2/68

    5 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Nceccm Lb Wb `clo$ Wcmnombbmn Lc`cwcmncuokcm$ vc clomn kcmncuom mc lcoycnqbi

    cmn `cycuqmncm cy `cybybkcmcm vc wcndodoyov mc oyb- Mc~c lcmnoecec~ cmn kqvyovc wcuc

    vc dckcy-

    Homcdd$ ~a cv` _bq$ B Dbui$ yb edavv bqu eadbxai mcyobm cmi bqu wabwda$ cmi ykcy om yka ami$ oy

    ov kau omyauavy cmi ykcy bh kau foyozamv$ yka Hodowomb wabwda cdbma$ ~kb cua eavy vauxai e yka xauiofy bh

    ykov Fbquy-

    Ykava ~a cv` om yka Mcla bh Javqv$

    Clam-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Clam-

    Yka Vafuaycu ~odd mb~ wdacva fcdd yka ubdd bh Vamcybuv-

    Yka Vafuaycu$ uaciomn:

    Vamcybu Aincuib J- Cmncuc --------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Jb`au W- Cuubb ------------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy*Vamcybu Cdcm Wayau Fblwcaub V- Fcaycmb --------------------------------- Wuavamy*

    Vamcybu Woc V- Fcaycmb ------------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy*

    Vamcybu Louocl Iahamvbu Vcmyocnb ---------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Hucm`dom L- Iuodbm ---------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Jomnnb Ajaufoyb Avyucic ------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Hucmfov N- Avfqiaub ------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Yabhovyb D- Nqomnbmc OOO ------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Nuanbuob E- Kbmcvcm OO-------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Wcmhodb L- Dcfvbm ---------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Lcmqad Doyb L- Dcwoi ------------------------------------------------------- WuavamyVamcybu Dbuam D- Dancuic ----------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy*

    Vamcybu Hauiomcmi Ebmnebmn U- Lcufbv Ju- ---------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Vaunob U- Bvlac OOO ----------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy*

    Vamcybu Hucmfov M- Wcmnodomcm ------------------------------------------------------------ Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Csqodomb Wolamyad OOO ------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Ucdwk N- Uafyb -------------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Uclbm Ebmn Uaxoddc Ju- ----------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Xofamya F- Vbyyb OOO ------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Cmybmob Vbmm H- Yuoddcmav OX ------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Lcmm Xoddcu ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Cevamy**

    Yka Wuavoiamy---------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^oyk 3> Vamcybu,Jqinav wuavamy$ yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau iafdcuav yka

    wuavamfa bh c sqbuql-

    Yka Hdbbu Daciau ov uafbnmozai-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Lu- Wuavoiamy$ lc O cv` yka Vaunacmy,cy,Culv yb lc`a yka wubfdclcyobm-

    RRRRRRRRRRRRRR* Cuuoxai chyau yka ubdd fcdd

    **Bm bhhofocd lovvobm

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    3/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 6

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka Vaunacmy,cy,Culv ov iouafyai yb lc`a yka wubfdclcyobm-

    Yka Vaunacmy,cy,Culv- Cdd wauvbmv cua fbllcmiai yb `aaw vodamy qmiau wcom bh wamcdy ~koda

    yka Vamcya ov voyyomn om yuocd bm yka Cuyofdav bh Olwacfklamy cncomvy Fkoah Jqvyofa Uamcyb F- Fbubmc-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka Hdbbu Daciau-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Lu- Wuavoiamy$ O lbxa ykcy ~a iovwamva ~oyk yka uaciomn bh yka Lc 39$ 5735Jbqumcd bh yka Vamcya voyyomn cv cm Olwacfklamy Fbquy cmi fbmvoiau oy cwwubxai-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ov ykaua cm bejafyobm PVodamfa\ Ykaua eaomn mbma$ yka Lc 39$ 5735

    Jbqumcd bh yka Vamcya voyyomn cv cm Olwacfklamy Fbquy ov kauae cwwubxai-

    Yka Vafuaycu ~odd wdacva fcdd yka fcva eahbua yka Vamcya cv cm Olwacfklamy Fbquy-

    Yka Fdau` bh Fbquy- Fcva Mb- 775,5733$ Om yka Lcyyau bh yka Olwacfklamy Yuocd bh Kbm- Fkoah

    Jqvyofa Uamcyb F- Fbubmc-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka Hdbbu Daciau ov uafbnmozai-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Lu- Wuavoiamy$ lc ~a cv` yka wcuyoav cmi"bu ykaou uavwafyoxa Fbqmvad yb amyauykaou cwwacucmfav-

    Uawuavamycyoxa Yqwcv- Lu- Wuavoiamy$ nbbi chyaumbbm-

    Hbu yka Kbqva bh Uawuavamycyoxav Wubvafqyobm wcmad$ vcla cwwacucmfa- ^a cua uaci$ _bqu

    Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mbyai-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _bqu Kbmbu$ hbu yka Iahamva$ yka vcla cwwacucmfa- ^a cua cdvb uaci-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mbyai- Yka Hdbbu Daciau ov uafbnmozai-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Eahbua yka eqvomavv hbu yka ic$ O lbxa ykcy ~a cddb~ Vam- Louocl Iahamvbu

    Vcmyocnb hbu c lcmohavycyobm-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka dci Vamcybu hubl Odbodb kcv yka hdbbu-

    Vamcybu Iahamvbu Vcmyocnb- O kcxa lcia c uavauxcyobm hbu sqavyobmomn yka ~oymavv bm yka vycmi

    eqy ykov ov mby yka yola- Ykov yola ov hbu la yb lc`a yka hbddb~omn lcmohavycyobm-

    _avyauic$ yka Bleqivlcmv Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm omiofcyai ykcy Iahamicmy kcv ;5 ibddcu

    cffbqmyv om yka hbddb~omn ecm` eucmfkav: EWO,Cfubwbdov Eucmfk$ ;0 EWO,Ycmicmn Vbuc$ 3;0 EWO,Iad

    Lbmya$ Sqazbm Foy$ 690 EWO Omxavylamy Fbuw-$ 30 WVE,Fcomyc$ ;0 WVE,@cyowqmcm$ 80 Cddoai Ecm`$

    90 Iaqyvfka Ecm`$ 50 Foyoecm`$ 3-

    Eafcqva bh konk,yafk ecm`omn wucfyofav ybic$ cm omhbulcyobm cebqy c ecm` cffbqmy ~odd iawami

    qwbm yka vvyal cibwyai e c wcuyofqdcu ecm`- Hbu a{clwda$ yka ecm` fbqdi hbddb~ yka fqvyblau

    yucmvcfyobm vvyal bu yka ecm` yucmvcfyobm vvyal- Kamfa$ oy fbqdi ea wbvvoeda ykcy yka vomnda vql bh

    lbma fbqdi ea uawuavamyai om c ibqeda amyu- Bma amyu ~bqdi ea lcia om yka fuaioy fbdqlm cmi

    cmbykau amyu ~bqdi ea lcia om yka iaeoy fbdqlm$ cdykbqnk ebyk amyuoav fbqdi iacd ~oyk bma cmi yka

    vcla clbqmy bh lbma-

    Hquykaulbua$ c fdoamy fbqdi iawbvoy cmi ~oykiuc~ yka vcla clbqmy ~oykom c vomnda ic bu ~oykom c

    ha~ icv bh acfk bykau oh ka amncnav om ibddcu yuciomn- C fdoamy ~kb lcomycomv c hbuaonm fquuamf iawbvoy

    ov mby uasqouai yb cfsqoua c dofamva hbu ykov wquwbva- Kb~axau$ yb amncna om ibddcu yuciomn y~b +5/ bu

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    4/68

    9 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    ykuaa +6/ cffbqmyv cua vqhhofoamy- Oy ~bqdi ea qmmafavvcu yb lcomycom cdd bh ;5 cffbqmyv- Yka vycmicui

    wucfyofa om yka ecm`omn fbllqmoy ov yb ucova yka eaddv cmi ~kovydav ~kam bma fdoamy vaa`v yb `aaw lbua

    ykcm y~b +5/ bu ykuaa +6/ cffbqmyv- Yb cddana ykcy yka Iahamicmy kci$ hbu a{clwda$ 69 cffbqmyv om EWO,

    Iad Lbmya$ yc{av yka fuaiqdoy bh ecm`auv-

    Ykauahbua$ O kqled wubwbva$ oh ykaua ov mb bejafyobm hubl bqu fbddacnqav$ ykcy yka Vamcya Wuavoiamy

    vkbqdi vqewbamc yka lcmcnauv bh cdd moma +?/ ecm` eucmfkav ykcy O kcxa jqvy amqlaucyai- Yka lbvy`mb~dainaceda bhhofocd cebqy c wauvbmv ecm` cffbqmy ov yka eucmfk lcmcnau- Yka eucmfk lcmcnau ov

    uasqouai e dc~ cmi e vycmicui ecm`omn wbdof yb vaa` cmi uafbui iaycodv cebqy yka fdoamy-

    Lu- Wuavoiamy$ hbu bqu fbmvoiaucyobm- Ykcm` bq-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka Hdbbu Daciau ov uafbnmozai-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Lu- Wuavoiamy$ oh yka bykau Laleauv bh yka Fbquy ~bqdi do`a yb yc`a ykcy qw$ ~a

    lc ea ceda yb yc`a qw yka lbyobm bh Vamcybu Vcmyocnb iquomn yka fcqfqv bm Lbmic-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Day qv kbdi om ceacmfa yka fbmvoiaucyobm bh yka lbyobm bh yka dci

    Vamcybu hubl Odbodb cmi iovfqvv oy om bqu fcqfqv bm Lbmic$ cmi ykam ~a ~odd cfy bm yka lbyobm-Vamcybu Vbyyb- _av$ Lu- Wuavoiamy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov yka vycyqv bh yka kacuomn mb~2

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Mb~$ ~a cua uaci hbu yka fbmyomqcyobm bh yka wuavamycyobm bh axoiamfa e yka

    Iahamva-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mb$ O ykom` yka fubvv,a{clomcyobm e yka Wubvafqyobm kcv mby eaam

    yaulomcyai-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Fbuuafy$ Lu- Wuavoiamy

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov fbuuafy$ _bqu Kbmbu- Yka ~oymavv bm yka vycmi ov yka Kbmbuceda

    Bleqivlcm$ _bqu Kbmbu- Vka eannai yb ea a{fqvai hubl fbmyomqomn ~oyk yka fubvv,a{clomcyobm

    cddanaid hbu eaomn youai cmi hcyonqai$ _bqu Kbmbu- Cmi yka Fkcoulcm bh yka cqioyomn bhhofa bh yka

    Uawqedof ybb` kau wdcfa omvyaci- ^a bejafyai yb vqfk `omi bh c wubfaiqua eafcqva ~a ib mby `mb~

    ~kbva ~oymavv ov ykov Fbllovvobmau bh yka Cqioyomn Bhhofa$ _bqu Kbmbu- Cmi ~a ~aua vqvycomai e

    yka Fbquy- Vb$ yka cnamic hbu ybic vkbqdi nb bu vkbqdi wubfaai ~oyk yka fubvv,a{clomcyobm bh yka

    Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ykcy ov ~kcy O cl daciomn yb$ Fbqmvad- Ykcy ov ~kaua O cl nbomn-

    Wuafovad$ O cl cv`omn yka Wubvafqyobm yb fbmyomqa ~oyk ykaou fubvv,a{clomcyobm bh yka Bleqivlcm

    eafcqva avyauic yka Bleqivlcm amiai chyau vka lcia c Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm cmi vka ~cmyaiyka wuavamycyobm yb ea fbmyomqai e yka Fbllovvobm bm Cqioy$ Lv- Kaoio Lamibzc-

    Eqy ykam ykaua ~cv cm bejafyobm$ cmi wubwaud vb$ e yka Iahamva- Cmi vb yka Fkcou iovlovvai yka

    vqevyoyqya wuavamybu bh yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm eafcqva vka ~cv mby fbmyomqomn ~oyk yka Wb~auWbomy

    wuavamycyobm eqy ucykau ~cv yavyohomn cmi$ yuqd$ bq ucovai yka bejafyobm ~kbva ~oymavv ov ykov wauvbm

    bm yka ~oymavv vycmi- Ykcy ov ~k yka Fkcou iovlovvai kau- Vb$ ~a cua cy ykcy wbomy ~kaua yka

    Bleqivlcm ~odd kcxa yb fbmyomqa kau yavyolbm cmi day yka Wubvafqyobm iafoia ~kaykau yka ~odd

    fbmyomqa yka fubvv,a{clomcyobm-

    Vb$ lc O mb~ uasqavy vblabma yb fcdd yka iovyomnqovkai Bleqivlcm$ oh vka ov om yka Fbquy$ cmi

    euomn kau yb yka ~oymavv vycmi hbu yka fbmyomqcyobm bh kau fubvv,a{clomcyobm e yka Wubvafqyobm-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    5/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 1

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Lu- Wuavoiamy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- ^koda ~a cua ~coyomn hbu yka ~oymavv$ Vamcybu Wolamyad ~cv acudoau cv`omn oh oy ~bqdi

    ea wubwau hbu qv yb vyuo`a bqy yka vycyalamyv lcia e yka cqioybu bu yka fbllovvobmau eafcqva oy ~cv

    ouuanqdcu$ bu day oy ualcom om yka uafbuiv- Ykcy ~cv yka sqavyobm ykcy ~cv cv`ai e Vamcybu Wolamyad-Lu- Fqaxcv- Oh$ _bqu Kbmbu wdacva$ O ~cv cebqy yb lc`a ykcy lbyobm-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cfyqcdd$ ~kam ~a iovlovvai yka ~oymavv$ ~kcy vka vycyai bm yka uafbui

    ov mby yavyolbm om axoiamfa-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Ykcm` bq cdvb hbu yka fdcuohofcyobm-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Oh bq ~cmy yb lc`a c wubwau lbyobm$ ykam day oy ea vyuof`am bqy bh yka

    Uafbui-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu- Fbmvoiauomn yka hcfy ykcy yka Kbmbuceda Fbllovvobmau bh

    yka namaucd cqioyomn bhhofa bh yka fbqmyu ~cv bm yka vycmi bmd yb fbmyomqa yka cddanai fubvv,a{clomcyobm

    bh yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm$ cmi vomfa vka ov mby c ~oymavv aoykau hbu yka Wubvafqyobm bu yka Iahamva$

    kau yavyolbm----

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mby hbu fubvv,a{clomcyobm$ yb fbmyomqa yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O ~cv bh yka olwuavvobm ykcy yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm kcv cduaci fdbvai$ _bqu

    Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mb$ mby ay- Yka ~c O qmiauvybbi oy ov ykcy yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm

    ~cv youai cmi vka ~cmyai vblabma yb yc`a bxau cmi fbmyomqa ~oyk yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Eafcqva yka ycuwcqdom kcv cduaci eaam ubddai qw-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Yka vfuaam-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Oh ykcy ov yka fcva$ _bqu Kbmbu$ O vycmi fbuuafyai- O kcxa mb bejafyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Eqy$ cy cm ucya$ vb ykcy ykaUafbui~odd ea fdacm cmi fdacu$ lc O uasqavy

    cmbma bh bq yb lc`a yka wubwau lbyobm yb vyuo`a bqy yka vycyalamy bh yka FBC Fbllovvobmau-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Lc ~a uafbnmoza Vamcybu Wolamyad$ Lu- Wuavoiamy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka namydalcm hubl Lovclov Buoamycd ov uafbnmozai-

    Vamcybu Wolamyad OOO- Ykcm` bq$ Lu- Wuavoiamy- Yb ea hcou yb yka Iahamva voia$ _bqu Kbmbu$

    O lbxa yb vyuo`a bqy yka yavyolbm bh Luv- Kaoio Lamibzc ~kb ~cv ouuanqdcud wuavamyai avyauic-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ov ykaua cm bejafyobm2 PVodamfa\ Yka Fkcou kacuv mbma$ yka lbyobm ov

    cwwubxai- Vyuo`a oy bqy hubl yka uafbui-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Lu- Wuavoiamy$ yka Fbquy ov mb~ uaci hbu yka fbmyomqcyobm bh yka fubvv,a{clomcyobm

    bh yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm$ Fbmfkoyc Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Vka ov kaua-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    6/68

    8 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ wdacva eacu ~oyk qv- a ib mby ~cmy yb bxauequiam

    bq eqy bq cua hclodocu ~oyk bqu jqiofocd wubfaiquav cmi ~a kcxa yb fbmyomqa$ oh yka Wubvafqyobm ~bqdi

    ~cmy yb fbmyomqa ykaou fubvv,a{clomcyobm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Wubvafqyobm2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^oyk bqu waulovvobm$ Lu- Wuavoiamy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Wubfaai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Nbbi chyaumbbm$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Nbbi chyaumbbm-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^bqdi bq ~cmy yb fbmyomqa ~oyk yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm avyauic2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Vqua$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm avyauic2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^oyk bqu waulovvobm$ Lu- Wuavoiamy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Cua bq cv`omn ykcy yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm ea fbmyomqai2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Nucmyai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Lc O omxoya yka cyyamyobm bh yka wcuyoav cmi$ bh fbquva$ yka Vamcybu,Jqinav

    yb ~kcy cwwacuv bm yka vfuaam- Oy uahauv yb c vqllcu bh Q-V- ibddcu omhdb~v bh fbxauai yucmvcfyobm

    hubl Cwuod 39$ 5776 yb Iafaleau 55$ 5733-

    Yka EWO,Ycmicmn Vbuc Cffbqmy Mb- ;379 ov QV)6$136$69;-9>0 yka EWO,Ycmicmn Vbuc Cffbqmy

    Mb- 3;95 ov QV)138$367-9>0 yka EWO cdvb Ycmicmn Vbuc Cffbqmy Mb- 1?6? om yka clbqmy bh

    QV)3$663$173-960 ykam yka CEF bu Cddoai Ecm`omn Fbuwbucyobm,@clocv Cffbqmy Mb- 58>8 om yka

    clbqmy bh QV)5$?97$;17-1;0 cmi yka vqeybycd ov QV);$673$;67-?1- _bq cii ykov yb yka lovfaddcmabqvcffbqmyv om yka clbqmy bh QV)6$;16$13?-?3$ yb euomn c ybycd bh QV)35$311$617-;8-

    O ykom` ~a cua mb~ bm Cffbqmy Mb- ;379 om 577>-

    Day la a{wdcom ykcy yka ybycd bh QV)35 loddobm wdqv c ~koda cnb ~cv cuuoxai cy e ybycdomn yka omhdb~v

    cmi ybycdomn yka bqyhdb~v- Cmi oy ~bqdi cwwacu ykcy yka bqyhdb~v ~bqdi ea eonnau ykcm yka omhdb~v$ ~kofk

    lacmv yka ~oykiuc~cdv ~bqdi ea eonnau ykcm yka clbqmy bh omhdb~v-

    ^a qvai c fbmvauxcyoxa cmcdvov ~kaua oh ykaua cua ibqeda$ yuowda bu lqdyowda amyuoav bh yka vcla

    clbqmy$ ~a ~bqdi a{fdqia ykbva hubl yka ibddcu fblwqycyobm cmi ~bqdi omfdqia bmd yka dcvy honqua cy

    yka ami bh yka ffda-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    7/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 >

    Hbu a{clwda$ ykaua ov ykov lbykau iawbvoy Cffbqmy C- Ykam vb lqfk bu yka vcla clbqmy bm yka

    vcla icya ov yucmvhauuai yb Cffbqmy E0 ykam$ cncom$ bm yka vcla icya$ yka vcla clbqmy ov yucmvhauuai

    yb cmbykau cffbqmy$ Cffbqmy F0 ykam homcdd$ hbu yka hbquyk amyu$ yka vcla clbqmy bm yka vcla icya$

    oy ov yucmvhauuai yb Cffbqmy A- Vb$ bmd yka dcvy honqua om yka dcvy cffbqmy ~kaua yka ffda vybwv ykcy

    ov omfdqiai om yka fblwqycyobm- Cmi vb ~kam ~a cuuoxai cy QV)35 loddobm wdqv cv yucmvcfyobmcd ecdcmfa$

    ~a ioi mby omfdqia yka vb lcm amyuoav ykcy cwwacuai bm yka vcla icya cmi$ cv O vcoi$ ~a bmd omfdqiai

    ykbva honquav ykcy amiai om yka dcvy ami bh yka ffda-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ykava cua mby yka QV)35 loddobm wdqv lamyobmai hbu 5778$ ~cv oy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Hbu cv bh Iafaleau 5733$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykava cua yucmvcfyobmcd ecdcmfav-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av$ yucmvcfyobmcd ecdcmfa-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av-Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ykcy ov mby c acud cmi cmmqcd amiomn ecdcmfa-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb$ _bqu Kbmbu$ oy fblwuakamiai yka amyoua mqleau bh yucmvcfyobmv hubl

    5776 yb Iafaleau 5733-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Eqy ykaua ~cv mb clbqmy uafbuiai uancuiomn yka cfyqcd ecdcmfa ualcomomn

    om yka lbykau cffbqmy cv bh yka ami bh Iafaleau 63$ 5733-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oy ~bqdi ea iohhofqdy yb fblwqya$ eqy ~a yuoai cdvb yb iayauloma e$ day qv

    vc$ om 5733$ yka ualcomomn----Om 577;$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh QV)>8;$>66-?8- Ykov uahauv yb yka

    WVEcm`,@cyowqmcm Eucmfk cmi oy ~cv ~oykiuc~m bmd bm Iafaleau 31$ 5735$ cmi ykcy oadiai cybycd----5733 ucykau$ O cl vbuu- Cmi ykcy oadiai c ecdcmfa bh QV)>8?$8;3->3- Ykcy ov bmd ~oyk

    uavwafy yb bma WVEcm`,@cyowqmcm Cffbqmy Eucmfk Mb- 73?37776>6- Ykov ov jqvy bma cffbqmy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ov ykaua cm uafbui bh cm ecdcmfa bh ykov lbykau cffbqmy cv bh yka ami

    bh Mbxaleau 57332

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Iafaleau$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mb$ yka 33yk lbmyk bh yka acu-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^a fcm wuavqla yka vcla ecdcmfa$ _bqu Kbmbu$ eafcqva oy lbxai bmd

    om Iafaleau----

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- O ~odd wqy yka sqavyobm om cmbykau hbul- ^kcy ~cv yka ybycd clbqmy

    ~oykiuc~m om yka lbmyk bh Iafaleau hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Iafaleau 5733$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ QV)>8?$8;3->3- Vb$ ~a wuavqla ykcy$ yb bqu sqavyobm acudoau$

    _bqu Kbmbu$ oh ~kcy ~cv yka clbqmy ~oykiuc~m om Mbxaleau 5733-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ykcy ~cv yka clbqmy ~oykiuc~m om yka lbmyk bh Iafaleau-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    8/68

    ; YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu$ hubl yka vcla cffbqmy ~kofk ~cv bwamai om Bfybeau

    63$ 577;-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky$ Fbqmvad- _bq lc fbmyomqa$ Lcicl-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    O ykom` ~a cua mb~ om Cffbqmy Mb- ;379,577>-

    Bm Jqd ?$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c ~oykiuc~cd hubl Cffbqmy Mb- ;379 om yka clbqmy bh )5?1$881-95-

    Yka vqffaaiomn lbmyk$ bu bm Cqnqvy ?$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh )5?8$>5;-??-

    Mb~$ bm Jqd 3?$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c ~oykiuc~cd bh )57$777$ cmi bm Cqnqvy 56$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv

    c iawbvoy hubl Cffbqmy Mb- 58?6 yb yka lbykau cffbqmy$ ;379-

    Bm Jqd 5>$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c ~oykiuc~cd hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy om yka clbqmy bh )377$777

    ~kofk ~cv iawbvoyai om cmbykau cffbqmy$ 5;79- Cmi bm Cqnqvy 63$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh

    )377$9?9-8?-

    Bm Cqnqvy 56$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c ~oykiuc~cd bh )57$7>8-99 hubl c iohhauamy cffbqmy$ 63;63?6-Cmi bm Vawyaleau 6$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy yb yka lbykau cffbqmy om yka clbqmy bh )57$8;5-;6-

    Bm Vawyaleau 6$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c ~oykiuc~cd hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy om yka clbqmy bh

    )97$7;5-?6 cmi iawbvoyai yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi bm Lcufk 6$ 577;$ hubl ykov ma~ cffbqmy ~cv

    ~oykiuc~m yka clbqmy bh )97$?>6-3; cmi iawbvoyai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Bm Cqnqvy ?$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c ~oykiuc~cd hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy om yka clbqmy bh )5?8$>5;-??

    cmi oy ~cv iawbvoyai yb c ma~ cffbqmy$ 5?;>- Cmi bm Mbxaleau ;$ 577>$ yka clbqmy bh )5??$?6>-;8

    ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl ykov ma~ cffbqmy cmi uayqumai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Bm Jqd 63$ 577>$ yka clbqmy bh )367$996-65 ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy cmi

    iawbvoyai yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi bm Lcufk 9$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )366$19>-8> ~cv ~oykiuc~m hublyka ma~ cffbqmy cmi uayqumai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Bm Cqnqvy 63$ 577>$ yka clbqmy bh )377$9?9-8? ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy cmi

    yucmvhauuai yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi bm Haeuqcu 5?$ 577;$ hubl ykov ma~ cffbqmy ~cv ~oykiuc~m yka

    clbqmy bh )375$869-?> cmi iawbvoyai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Bm Mbxaleau ?$ 577>$ yka clbqmy bh )5??$?6>-;8 ~cv ~oykiuc~m cmi iawbvoyai yb c ma~

    cffbqmy-

    Bm Iafaleau 53$ 577>$ yka clbqmy bh )17$777 ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy cmi

    iawbvoyai yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi bm Jcmqcu 51$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )17$559-;6 ~cv ~oykiuc~m

    hubl yka ma~ cffbqmy cmi uayqumai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Vyodd yka vcla cffbqmy$ ;379$ ykov ov hbu 577;-

    Bm Lcufk 1$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )67$677 ~cv iawbvoyai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Bm Cwuod 3>$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )59$777 ~cv iawbvoyai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Cmi bm Jqd 63$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )67$777 ~cv iawbvoyai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Bm Jcmqcu 5;$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )17$559-;6 ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy cmi

    yucmvhauuai yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi hubl ykov ma~ cffbqmy ~cv ~oykiuc~m yka clbqmy bh )13$38>->7

    bm Cqnqvy 1$ 577;$ cmi oy ualcomai ~oykiuc~m-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    9/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 ?

    Bm Lcufk 6$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )396$87;-31 ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy cmi

    iawbvoyai yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi hubl ykov ma~ cffbqmy ~cv ~oykiuc~m yka clbqmy bh )399$?9>->?

    bm Jqd >$ 577;-

    Bm Lcufk 1$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )3>1$777 ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy cmi

    yucmvhauuai yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi hubl ykov ma~ cffbqmy ~cv ~oykiuc~m yka clbqmy bh )3>8$183-97

    bm Jqd ?$ 577;-

    Bm Cwuod 3>$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )57$777 ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy cmi iawbvoyai

    yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi hubl ykov ma~ cffbqmy ~cv ~oykiuc~m yka clbqmy bh )59$375-86 bm Jqma 58$

    577;-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ cl O uonky ykcy yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm bq cua uaciomn

    hubl mb~$ c kcui fbw ~cv cduaci vamy yb yka Vamcya2 Kcxa ~a hqumovkai yka fbw bh ykcy uawbuy yb

    yka Vamcya2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O uafcdd ykcy yka Vamcya cy yka fdbvomn kbquv bh avyauicv kacuomnv

    a{wafyai qv yb iadoxau c kcui fbw- Cmi O ykom` ~a ioi$ ykcy ~cv l omvyuqfyobm-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lcicl Bleqivlcm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcy eaomn vb$ waukcwv$ oy ~bqdi ea eayyau oh ~a ~odd jqvy lcu` yka Wb~auWbomy

    wuavamycyobm om axoiamfa- Cmi yb iovwamva ~oyk bqu uaciomn bh yka iaycodv eafcqva bq lonky ea bxaud

    yc{ai e ykcy cmi O ib mby ykom` oy ov mafavvcu eafcqva yka Vamcybu,Jqinav fcm a{cloma yka fbmyamyv

    bh yka uawbuy bquvadh-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _bqu Kbmbu$ wdacva-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Lu- Fqaxcv-O cl mby fdacu ~oyk yka lcmohavycyobm lcia e yka Kbmbuceda Fbqmvad hbu yka

    Wubvafqyobm- ^kofk ov yka axoiamfa vbqnky yb ea lcu`ai$ yka uawuavamycyobmv lcia bm yka vfuaam$ yka

    buonom bh ykava uawuavamycyobmv bu ~kcy2 ^a ~cmyai yb ea fdacu$ _bqu Kbmbu$ eahbua ~a nb omyb hquykau

    sqavyobmomn yka ^oymavv om fbmmafyobm ~oyk ykal-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^k ib bq mby cnuaa2 Oh bq ~cmy yb qva yka ibfqlamy wuavamyai

    avyauic e yka Bleqivlcm ~kofk ov cddanaid yka uawbuy bh yka CLDF cv yka ibfqlamy yb ea

    wuavamyai kaua cv cm a{koeoy$ eqy bm yka bykau kcmi$ ykov Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm ov mb~ c wcuy bh yka

    yavyolbm bh yka Bleqivlcm- Cmi vb$ ykov Fbquy ~bqdi ea omyauavyai yb kcxa c fbw bh ykov ibfqlamy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Yka vbqufa bh cdd ykov Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu2Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O cl jqvy cv`omn hbu c fdcuohofcyobm- O cl mby bejafyomn----

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cfyqcdd$ ykava cua cfyqcdd fqddaioh O qmiauvybbi yka Bleqivlcm

    fbuuafydfqddai hubl yka uafbuiv

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vqeloyyai-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ykcy vka vqeloyyai avyauic cmi lcu`ai cv cm a{koeoy e yka

    Wubvafqyobm- Cl O fbuuafy om ykov2

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    10/68

    37 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O ~cv wqzzdai eafcqva yka ibfqlamyv vkb~m yb yka ^oymavv avyauic$ ~a cduaci

    lcu`ai$ _bqu Kbmbu- Vb$ O ~cv yuomn yb fdcuoh bmd- O cl mby bejafyomn$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Wuafovad$ yka Bleqivlcm$ l qmiauvycmiomn bh ~kcy kcwwamai ~cv$ yka

    Bleqivlcm yavyohoai$ cmi om yka fbquva bh kau yavyolbm$ uahauuai yb c uawbuy bh CLDF$ ~kofk eafclayka ecvov bh kau dayyau$ oh O qmiauvybbi fbuuafyd$ uasqouomn yka Fkoah Jqvyofa yb uawd om >5 kbquv- Ykcy

    ~cv yka vqejafy bh yka a{clomcyobm,om,fkoah bh yka Iahamva fbqmvad$ ~kaykau yka Bleqivlcm omhbulai

    yka Fkoah Jqvyofa cebqy yka )37,loddobm iawbvoy cddanaid b~mai e kol- Cmi cy ykcy wbomy$ yka lcyyau

    ~cv uavbdxai cmi ykam yka Fbqmvad fdbvai kov iouafy a{clomcyobm bh yka Bleqivlcm$ cmi yka

    Wubvafqyobm ybb` bxau yb fubvv a{cloma-

    Cmi cy ykcy wbomy$ yka kcxa lcu`ai---- Cfyqcdd$ yka Wubvafqyobm lcu`ai yka cddanai uawbuy bh

    CLDF$ wuavamyai cmi yavyohoai yb e yka Bleqivlcm eahbua ykov Fbquy- Cmi yka Kbmbuceda

    Bleqivlcm uasqavyai yka waulovvobm bh ykov Fbquy oh vka fbqdi a{wdcom hquykau yka fbmyamyv bh ykcy

    cddanai uawbuy bh CLDF e ~c bh vkb~omn qv c Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm bh yka lbxalamy bh yka

    lbmoav uahdafyai om ykcy uawbuy bh CLDF- Cl O fbuuafy om ykov$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm2Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ykcy ov yka ~kbda novy bh yka yavyolbm bh yka Bleqivlcm- Cmi ykcy ov

    ~k ykov Fkcou uasqavyai ykcy ykov Fbquy ea wubxoiai ~oyk c kcui fbw bh yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm

    cmi yka Iahamva cdvb uasqavyai c fbw$ c kcui fbw bh yka wuavamycyobm cmi ykauachyau$ yka Wubvafqyobm

    cdvb uasqavyai c kcui fbw- Vb$ cdd bh qv uasqavyai c fbw bh yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Fdcuohoai$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Oh _bqu Kbmbu wdacva- Yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Wb~auWbomy- O cl vbuu$ O cl mby doyaucya ambqnk om ykava ykomnv-

    Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm$ b`c-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Oh bqu Kbmbu wdacva$ yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm ykcy kcv eaam lcia cmi ov vyodd

    eaomn lcia e yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm ov amyoydai: Cmcdvov bh Ibddcu Cffbqmy fbmvovyomn bh 51

    vdoiav- O fbmhoulai ~oyk yka Fdau` bh Fbquy ykcy yka Vamcybu,Jqinav kcxa acfk eaam hqumovkai ~oyk

    fbwoav bh ykov vb,fcddai Cmcdvov bh Ibddcu Cffbqmy- Cmi yka fbw ~kofk kcv eaam kcmiai yb la

    e yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm$ acfk wcna eacuv yka vyclw: Fauyohoai Yuqa Fbw$ Iawqy Fdau` bh

    Fbquy$ yka Olwacfklamy Wubfaaiomnv$ cmi ykaua ~cv bma omoyocd bxau acfk vyclw bh Iawqy Fdau` bh

    Fbquy-

    Lc ~a uasqavy ykcy ykov ea lcu`ai cv A{koeoy Adaxam _ +___________/ hbu yka

    Wubvafqyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lcu` oy cffbuiomnd-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ bq yavyohoai$ c ha~ lomqyav cnb$ om uawd yb yka sqau bh yka

    Wuavoiomn Jqina ykcy )>8?$8;3 ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl cm cffbqmy bh yka Fkoah Jqvyofa om yka lbmyk bh

    Iafaleau 5733$ bq fbmhoul ykcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ Vou-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    11/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 33

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Fcm bq cixova qv bu yadd qv kb~ lqfk ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl Iafaleau 35

    hbu~cui2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb lbua$ oy ioi mby nb e cmlbua- O lacm$ yka icyc ykcy ~cv vbqufai

    mb dbmnau omiofcyai ~kaua ykcy )>8?$777 wdqv ~amy-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vb$ bq ~odd mby ea ceda yb yadd oh oy ~cv ibma bm Iafaleau 352Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Iafaleau 31-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Iafaleau 31-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O vaa- Vb$ ykcy clbqmy bh )>8?$8;3 ~cv ~oykiuc~m bm Iafaleau 31-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _bq yavyohoai avyauic ykcy ykaua ~aua vonmohofcmy cffbqmyv ~oyk uavwafy yb fauycom

    vonmohofcmy axamyv- Ib bq uafcdd ykcy$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ Vou-

    Lu- Ecqyovyoc- Fcm bq fdcuoh ~kcy bq lacmy e ykcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ ~kcy O lacmy ~cv ykcy ykaua ~aua vonmohofcmy iawbvoyv cmi

    ~oykiuc~cdv bm vonmohofcmy axamyv- ^kam O vc axamyv$ O cl uahauuomn yb day qv vc$ 5779 adafyobmv$

    577> adafyobmv$ cmi iquomn yka wauobi bmvay bh yka olwacfklamy wubfaaiomnv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Hbu yka adafyobmv bh 5779$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ ~kofk bq fbmvoiauai yb ea c

    vonmohofcmy axamy$ ~kcy ~cv yka fbuuavwbmiomn vonmohofcmy honqua2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Day la dbb` cy l fbionb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Xcnqa$ _bqu Kbmbu- Yka sqavyobm ibav mby cwwacu fdacu yb qv- Lc ~a uasqavy

    hbu c uahbulomn bh yka sqavyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov xcnqa cebqy oy2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykaua cua xcuobqv omfoiamyv lamyobmai om yka sqavyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu- ^a ~bqdi do`a

    yb `mb~ ~kcy ov yka novy bh yka sqavyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^odd yka nbbi namydalcm bh yka Wubvafqyobm uawacy yka sqavyobm vb ykcy

    ~a ~odd qmiauvycmi yka mcyqua bh yka bejafyobm2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O cv`ai ~kcy ~aua yka vonmohofcmy honquav wauycomomn yb yka vonmohofcmy axamyv ~kofk

    yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm lamyobmai- ^kcy cua yka honquav2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Vka lamyobmai cv axamyv yka adafyobm bh 5779-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcy ov uonky$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cmi ykam yka olwacfklamy hodai om ykov Fbquy-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu- Cmi yka adafyobmv om 577>-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    12/68

    35 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cmi ykam yka adafyobm om 577>-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av- Cmi O cl jqvy cv`omn yka ^oymavv ~kam vka vcoi ykcy ykaua ~aua vonmohofcmy

    clbqmyv wauycomomn yb c vonmohofcmy axamy$ ~kcy cua ykava clbqmyv- O ykom` ykcy ov xau fdacu- Om hcfy$

    yka ^oymavv kcv mby vcoi yka sqavyobm ov xcnqa-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Day yka ^oymavv cmv~au-Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ Vou- Om Lc 35$ ykaua ~cv c----

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lc 35 ~kam$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- 5739$ mb$ ucykau 5779$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh )177$777 cy Ecm` bh WO

    Cfubwbdov- Bm Lc 39$ 5779$ ~a cua cdd ycd`omn bh ibddcuv$ ibddcu,vwb`amomn$ om bykau ~buiv- Bm

    Lc 39$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh )177$777-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lc O cv` ykov sqavyobm yb fdcuoh- Ov ykaua cm vkb~omn ~kb lcia yka

    iawbvoy omyb ykcy iawbvoy cffbqmy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykaua ov mbma$ _bqu Kbmbu- Lcea oy ov bmd yka ecm`v ~kofk fcmiayauloma-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka uafbuiv bh yka ecm` ~bqdi vkb~-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Lcea$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- E yka ~c$ cua ykava iawbvoy cffbqmyv omyauavy,eacuomn iawbvoyv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O vqwwbva vb$ _bqu Kbmbu- Vbla-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cmi ykaua lqvy ea c uafbui bh ~oykkbdiomn bh yka 57! homcd yc{-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka ecm` ~bqdi ea ceda yb amdonkyam qv bm yka lcyyau$ _bqu Kbmbu$

    eafcqva ~a kcxa mb ibfqlamyv yb ecf` qw ykov uafbui bh yucmvcfyobmv-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av$ wdacva nb ckaci-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Bm 577>$ bm Lc 6$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh )5?6$891-56 cy yka Ecm`

    bh yka Wkodowwoma Ovdcmiv om Vcm Hucmfovfb iad Lbmya-

    Bm Lc 6----

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- E yka ~c$ ib ~a `mb~ yka a{fkcmna ucya cy ykcy yola$ Lcicl2 Oh

    ykava cua om ibddcuv$ ~kcy ~bqdi ea ykaou asqoxcdamy clbqmyv om wavbv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ib mby `mb~$ _bqu Kbmbu- Eqy$ O ykom`$ cy ykcy yola yka a{fkcmna ucya

    ~cv lqfk konkau ykcm yka wuavamy ucya bh a{fkcmna mb~-

    Cdd uonky$ bm Lc 6$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy cy yka EWO$ cncom$ Vcm Hucmfovfb iad Lbmya Eucmfk$

    om yka clbqmy bh )51$76?- Mb$ ucykau----

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Fcm bq vc ykcy cncom$ Lcicl$ QV)51$777 bu )517$7772

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Bm Lc 1$ mb$ mb$ Lc 6$ ucykau 577>$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh

    QV)5>$76?-;7 cy yka Ecm` bh yka Wkodowwoma Ovdcmiv$ Vcm Hucmfovfb iad Lbmya0 bm Lc 6$ cncom$ ykaua

    ~cv c iawbvoy bh )369$876-5;$ cncom cy yka EWO$ Vcm Hucmfovfb iad Lbmya0 bm Lc 6$ cncom$ ykaua

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    13/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 36

    ~cv c iawbvoy bh )86$691-83 cy yka EWO$ VHIL cmi cncom$ Lc 6$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh )16$1>5->3

    cy yka vcla ecm` om EWO$ Vcm Hucmfovfb iad Lbmya-

    Cncom$ bm Lc 1$ vyodd yka vclamb$ mb$ mb$ oy ov mby Lc 1- Yka cua volwd ybb lomqya yb ea

    uaci e yka mc`ai aa$ cdykbqnk$ O cduaci kcxa----

    Bm Lc 6$ vyodd yka vcla Lc 6$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh )31$7;6-;6 cy yka EWO$ Vcm Hucmfovfbiad Lbmya Eucmfk-

    Cmi ykcy ov cdd$ _bqu Kbmbu$ ibddcu cffbqmy-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Kb~ cebqy hbu yka Iafaleau 5733 wauobi$ bq cduaci lamyobmai kb~ lqfk

    )>8?$8;3-772

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cdd uonky$ ykov ov c fbmvauxcyoxa avyolcya bh yka ybycd hqmiv ykcy ~aua lbxai

    iquomn yka olwacfklamy ~aa`-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ Lcicl-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Bm Iafaleau 35$ uanqdcu yuqvy hqmi fbmyuoeqyobm$ wdcfalamy$ omxavylamy$om yka clbqmy bh )93>$?>;-;70 bm Iafaleau 35 yb 36$ ykaua ~cv cm amfcvklamy fbmxauyai yb wavbv

    )361$61?-730 bm Iafaleau 36$ ykaua ~cv wqufkcva bh Lcmcnauv Fkaf` IIYY om yka clbqmy bh

    )6;;$>>3-550 bm Iafaleau 36---

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov ykcy2 Ibddcuv2 Wavbv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ O cl vyodd vwac`omn bh ibddcuv$ _bqu Kbmbu- ^a ioi mby ybqfk bm

    yka wavb cffbqmy eafcqva yka vqewbamc doloyai yka ibfqlamy ykcy vkbqdi ea wuavamyai ~oyk uavwafy yb

    ibddcu cffbqmyv-

    Bm Iafaleau 36$ vyodd yka vcla Iafaleau 36$ vqeyucfyai hubl Cffbqmy Mb- 31;;7536;8$uahdafyai cv iaeoy lalb- Fuaioy yucmvcfyobm ov mby wubxoiai- Yka clbqmy bh QV)35$;;;-8> ov uahdafyai-

    Bm Iafaleau 31$ vafquoyoav ~aua vbdi om yka clbqmy bh QV)981$777-

    Bm Iafaleau 31$ ykaua ~cv c iaeoy lalb hubl cm cffbqmy cmi oy ybycdv QV)>5$75?-66-

    Bm Iafaleau 31$ ykaua ~cv c ~oykiuc~cd hubl yka vcla cffbqmy$ QV)696$3?5-85- Vyodd bm

    Iafaleau 31$ ykaua ~cv cm a{favv bh fuaioyv vyodd bm yka vcla cffbqmy om yka clbqmy bh QV)9$91?->8-

    Bm Iafaleau 3?$ ykaua ~cv wqufkcva bh Lcmcnauv Fkaf` IIYY om yka clbqmy bh QV)9;>$??;-7?-

    Bm Iafaleau 3?$ ykaua ~cv a{favv bh iawbvoyv om c iohhauamy cffbqmy om yka clbqmy bh

    QV)55$??;-7?- Cmi bm Iafaleau 57$ ykaua ~aua iaeoy lalbv hubl c iohhauamy cffbqmy om yka clbqmybh QV)8;>$89;-11- Vb$ yka ybycd ualoyycmfa om Iafaleau----^a cii ykov yb yka bqy~cui ualoyycmfa bh

    QV)617$777 ~bqdi noxa c ybycd bh QV)6$6;;$656-39-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Fcm bq yadd qv$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ ~kofk ecm`v ~aua omxbdxai om ykava

    ~oykiuc~cdv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykov ov Cddoai Ecm`omn Fbuwbucyobm +CEF/-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Jqvy bma ecm`-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- EWO-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    14/68

    39 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- EWO cmi Cddoai Ecm`-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Wkodowwoma Vcxomnv +WV/-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vb$ oy ov WVEcm`$ Cddoai Ecm` cmi EWO-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vb$ ykuaa +6/ ecm`v-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cmi ykava ~oykiuc~cdv ybb` wdcfa hubl Iafaleau 35 yb Iafaleau 572

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Y~amy,y~b$ oy vcv kaua-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O cv`ai avyauic Fbllovvobmau Lamibzc oh yka ioi c vyqi bh yka wavb cffbqmyv

    bh yka Fkoah Jqvyofa cmi bq cua mb~ vcomn bq ioi mby-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykaua ~cv cfyqcdd c vyqi bh yka wavb cffbqmyv- Eqy vomfa yka vqewbamc

    doloyai yka wubiqfyobm bh ibfqlamyv eacuomn bm yka ibddcu cffbqmyv vb ~a jqvy eubqnky ibfqlamyv

    eacuomn bm yka ibddcu cffbqmyv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vb bq ib mby kcxa ~oyk bq$ Lcicl$ bqu uafbuiv uancuiomn yka wavb cffbqmyv

    bu ib bq kcxa ykal ~oyk bq2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oy ov uahdafyai om yka vcla ibfqlamy ykcy ~a vbqufai hubl yka CLDF-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ib bq kcxa cm vqllcu bh yka konkdonkyv bh yka wavb cffbqmyv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ioi mby euomn oy ~oyk la$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq- Oh _bqu Kbmbu$ wdacva$ lc ~a cv` hbu dacxa hbu yka Bleqivlcmyb euomn yka icyc cmi yka vqllcuoav bh yka wavb cffbqmyv2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cua bq nbomn yb lc`a yka Bleqivlcm bqu ~oymavv2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Jqvy c uavauxcyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu$ wdacva- Jqvy c uavauxcyobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ka ov mb~ bm fubvv$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ualaleau bq cua bm fubvv,a{clomcyobm- O ykom` bq `mb~ yka uqdav-

    _bq ~cmy yb fbmxauy yka Bleqivlcm cv bqu ~oymavv cmi uasqoua yka wuavamycyobm bh ibfqlamyv$ ykam

    bq kcxa yb ib yka mafavvcu lbyobmv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O ~oykiuc~ ykcy$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lc O wubfaai-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^oykiuc~-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lcicl oymavv$ bq acudoau vcoi ykcy bq uafaoxai ykuaa +6/ fblwdcomyv hubl Uovc

    Ecucsqad,Kbmyoxaubv$ ^cdiam Eaddb$ ay fayauc- Ib bq fbmhoul ykcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    15/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 31

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Chyau bq uafaoxai yka fblwdcomyv$ ~kcy ioi bq ib2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Houvy$ ~kam O uafaoxai yka houvy fblwdcomy$ O axcdqcyai oy cmi O ykbqnky ykcy$

    cncom$ O vcoi ykcy avyauic$ O ~bqdi uahau yka fblwdcomyv yb yka CLDF om donky bh l olwuavvobm ykcy

    vbla bh yka fkcunav ~aua ~oykom yka jquoviofyobm bh yka CLDF-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kam bq uahauuai yka lcyyau hbu cvvovycmfa hubl yka CLDF$ ioi bq ib ykov om~uoyomn2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ib bq kcxa c fbw bh ykcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ O kcxa-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lc O vaa$ wdacva-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- P^oymavv vkb~omn yka dayyau-\

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Hbu yka uafbui$ yka Lcicl Bleqivlcm kcv noxam la c dayyau icyai 53 Haeuqcu5735 qmiau yka dayyaukaci bh yka Bleqivlcm cwwcuamyd iqd vonmai e yka Bleqivlcm kauvadh

    ciiuavvai yb Clcmib L- Yaycmnfb Ju-$ Fkcoulcm$ Cmyo,Lbma Dcqmiauomn Fbqmfod-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Day la a{wdcom ykcy- Ykcy ~cv yka houvy dayyau O vamy yb yka CLDF-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lcicl$ ib bq kcxa c fauyohoai yuqa fbw2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Lc ~a ea cddb~ai yb vaa yka ibfqlamy eaomn uahauuai yb$ _bqu Kbmbu$ eahbua

    cm hquykau sqavyobm ov wubwbqmiai yb yka ^oymavv2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Nucmyai- Vkb~ oy yb yka Iahamva fbqmvad-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oy ov cduaci fauyohoai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lc ~a uasqavy ykcy yka fauyohoai yuqa fbw bh yka vcoi Haeuqcu 53$ 5735 dayyau

    ea lcu`ai cv A{koeoy Adaxam Z +ZZZZZZZZZZZ/-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lcu` oy cffbuiomnd-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cvoia hubl ykov dayyau yb yka CLDF$ bq lamyobmai ykcy bq ~ubya c vafbmi dayyau$

    Lcicl Bleqivlcm2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ ykcy ov uonky$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Bm ~kcy icya2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ~ubya c dayyau bm Haeuqcu 59$ 5735-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ib bq kcxa c fbw bh ykcyfauyohoai yuqa fbw2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ O kcxa$ Haeuqcu 59$ 5735-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^oymavv kcv kcmiai yb Fbqmvad c dayyau icyai Haeuqcu 59$ 5735$ do`a~ova qmiau

    yka dayyaukaci bh yka Bhhofa bh yka Bleqivlcm$ vonmai e yka Bleqivlcm$ ciiuavvai yb Clcmib L-

    Yaycmnfb Ju-$ Fkcoulcm$ Cmyo,Lbma Dcqmiauomn Fbqmfod- Cmi ykaua ov c vyclwai fauyohoai yka fbw

    bh yka buonomcd bm hoda-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    16/68

    38 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lc ~a cv` ykcy ykov dayyau ea lcu`ai cv A{koeoy Y~adxa C +CCCCCCCCCCCC/

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lcu` oy cffbuiomnd-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^omvybm$ fcm bq vkb~ c fbw yb ykal2

    Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ lc O cv`$ ~k ioi bq ~uoya ykava dayyauv yb yka CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ houvy$ qmiau Vafyobm 58 bh yka Bleqivlcm Cfy$ O cl cqykbuozai yb

    vaa` yka cvvovycmfa bh bykau nbxaumlamy cnamfoav- Vafbmid$ yka Fkoah Jqvyofa kolvadh cqykbuozai yka

    Bleqivlcm om kov VCDM yb iayauloma hubl bykau nbxaumlamy cnamfoav cm cvvayv$ cm wubwauyoav$

    doceodoyoav$ may ~buyk bu eqvomavv omyauavy hubl yka yola ka jbomai yka nbxaumlamy qw yb yka wuavamy- Cmi

    vb$ ykcy ~cv yka fdomfkau- O ykbqnky O vkbqdi ~uoya c dayyau yb yka CLDF om buiau yb vaa` kadw hbu cm

    cvvovycmfa bu hbu cm ibfqlamyv ykcy kcxa c eacuomn bm yka fkcunav cncomvy yka Fkoah Jqvyofa-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kcy omhbulcyobm ioi bq a{wafy yb beycom hubl yka CLDF2 ^k yka CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ eafcqva oh bq uaci yka fblwdcomy ykaua ~cv vblaykomn cebqy

    xobdcyobm bh Cmyo,Lbma Dcqmiauomn Dc~ cmi om donky bh yka hcfy ykcy ykaua ~cv cdvb c fkcuna bhqma{wdcomai ~acdyk$ O ykbqnky ykcy O wubeced fbqdi ncykau hubl yka CLDF fauycom ecm` yucmvcfyobmv-

    _bq vaa$--- ~add$ O cl vbuu$ O ~odd mby cii yb ykcy-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av- Cv c hbulau jqvyofa bh yka Vqwuala Fbquy cmi yka wuavamy Bleqivlcm bh

    yka Uawqedof bh yka Wkodowwomav$ O wuavqla ykcy bq cua hcoud hclodocu ~oyk yka dc~ bm CLDF-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^kcy wcuyofqdcu cvwafy bh yka dc~ cua bq cv`omn la yb ea hclodocu ~oyk2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Fbqdi bq yadd qv ~kcy ov yka ecvof uavwbmvoeodoy bu hqmfyobm bh yka CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ecm`v cua vqwwbvai yb uawbuy yb yka CLDF cm yucmvcfyobmv lbua ykcm

    177$777- Om bykau ~buiv$ 177$777 wdqv-Lu- Ecqyovyc- Wavbv-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Wavbv$ uonky-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Wavbv-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ ~kofk ov fcddai c fbxauai yucmvcfyobm- Mb~$ yka ecm`v cua bedoncyai

    yb omhbul yka CLDF cebqy ykava fbxauai yucmvcfyobmv$ 177 wdqv ykbqvcmi wavbv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cvoia hubl fbxauai yucmvcfyobmv bh W177$777 cmi lbua$ cua ykaua cm bykau

    yucmvcfyobmv qmiau yka CLDC ~kofk yka ecm`v cua uasqouai yb hbu~cui bu vami yb yka CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ vqvwofobqv yucmvcfyobmv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kcy cua vqvwofobqv yucmvcfyobmv$ Lcicl2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Day la uaci oy hubl yka dc~-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ wdacva-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Hubl yka dc~$ vqvwofobqv yucmvcfyobmv cua yucmvcfyobmv ~oyk fbxauai

    omvyoyqyobmv uancuidavv bh yka clbqmyv omxbdxai ~kaua cm bh yka hbddb~omn foufqlvycmfav a{ovy: Mb

    qmiaudomn$ dancd$ bu yucia bedoncyobm0 yka fdoamy ov mby wubwaud oiamyohoai0 yka clbqmy omxbdxai ov mby

    fbllamvqucya yb yka eqvomavv bu homcmfocd fcwcfoy bh yka fdoamy$ ay fayauc$ clbmn bykau ykomnv- Cm

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    17/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 3>

    foufqlvycmfa uadcyomn yb yka yucmvcfyobm ~kofk ov bevauxai yb iaxocya hubl yka wubhoda bh yka fdoamy cmi

    bu yka fdoamyv wcvy yucmvcfyobmv ~oyk yka fbxauai ecm`- Vb bykauv$ omyau cdoc-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vb qmiau yka dc~$ yka fbxauai ecm`v cua uasqouai----

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- fbxauai yucmvcfyobmv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Fbxauai yucmvcfyobmv cmi vqvwofobqv yucmvcfyobmv yb yka CLDF-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vb yka icyc cmi yka omhbulcyobm wauycomomn yb yka cffbqmyv fbla hubl yka ecm`v

    eqy cua hbu~cuiai yb yka CLDF-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykcy ov vqwwbvai yb ea yka fcva-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cmi ~kcy ~bqdi ykov omhbulcyobm omfdqia2 ^bqdi bq `mb~2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O vcoi yka vqvwofobqv yucmvcfyobmv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Mb$ cffbqmy mqleau$ yka mcla-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ ykcy ov uonky- Yka icya bh yka yucmvcfyobmv$ yka mcyqua bh yka

    yucmvcfyobmv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Chyau bq ~ubya yka CLDF ykava y~b +5/ dayyauv$ ~cv ykaua cm uavwbmva yb bqu

    dayyauv e yka CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ ykaua ~cv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kcy ~cv oy$ Lcicl2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka hbu~cuiai yb la ykov 3>,wcna ibfqlamy cv ~add cv yka hbqu,wcna

    vqllcu bh yka yucmvcfyobmv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O lamyobmai ykov avyauic$ lc O cv` oy cncom- Ykaua ~cv cm omoyocd bm acfk wcna

    bh yka uawbuy bh yka CLDF$ ib bq uafcdd bu ~bqdi bq `mb~ ~kbva omoyocd ykcy ov2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av- Yka bma ~kb ov om fkcuna bh ecm` cmcdvov$ ecm` uafbuiv cmcdvov-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^bqdi bq `mb~ ~kb cua yka laleauv bh yka CLD Fbqmfod2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov wubxoiai hbu e dc~$ _bqu Kbmbu$ oy ov xau vwafohof-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O cl cv`omn yka vwafohof oiamyohofcyobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Eqy ykcy ov mby yka sqavyobm- Lc yka sqavyobm ea fdcuohoai-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^kb cua yka wuavamy2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Uahbul yka sqavyobm-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av- ^kb cua yka wuavamy Fbqmfod laleauv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ykom` yka Fkcou ov Fkcoulcm Yaycmnfb$ yka nbxaumbu bh yka Famyucd Ecm`$

    cmi laleauv----

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Bejafyobm vqvycomai$ _bqu Kbmbu$ cmi yka ^oymavv fbmyomqav yb cmv~au-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    18/68

    3; YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O cl vbuu$ O ioi mby kacu oy- O cl vbuu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O cduaci uahbulai yka sqavyobm- ^kcy cua yka mclav bh yka wuavamy laleauv bh

    CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O `mb~$ O kacui$ komio `b cdcl- Yka fkcou ov yka Famyucd Ecm` Nbxaumbu

    cmi yka laleauv cua yka Vafquoyoav cmi A{fkcmna Fbllovvobm Fkcou Yavvoa Kauebvc$ cmi ykaOmvqucmfa Fbllovvobmau-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq xau lqfk$ Lcicl-

    Lc O cv` Fbqmvad yb vybw vcomn ykomnv ~koda yka ^oymavv ov yavyohomn2

    Xbofa- Vblaebi kcv eaam fbcfkomn yka ^oymavv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kb ov fbcfkomn yka ~oymavv2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov yka wubedal2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cm~c$ ~a ~aua kacuomn ykcy$ _bqu Kbmbu$ eqy ~a ib mby ~cmy yb wavy yka^oymavv bm yka vycmi ~oyk ~kcyaxau vqvwofobm ~a lc kcxa- ^a jqvy `awy sqoay$ eqy ~a kci eaam

    kacuomn$ _bqu Kbmbu$ iofycyobm hubl vbla~kaua-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O fcmmby ea a{wafyai yb ualaleau axauykomn ykcy ov kaua-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov mby yka wbomy$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm- Yka sqavyobm ov ~kaykau ykaua ~aua

    uacdd cwwcuamy fbcfkomn$ _bqu Kbmbu$ cmi ~a ioi mby euomn ykcy omyb yka bwam-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka ~aua mby fbcfkomn la- Yka ~aua jqvy ualomiomn la-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^add$ cm~c----

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Vb bq cua mby eaomn fbcfkai$ bq cua bmd eaomn ualomiai2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av- Eafcqva cv O vcoi$ O fcmmby ea a{wafyai yb ualaleau axauykomn

    noxam yka ibfqlamyv$ yka xbdqla bh wcwau ~bu`-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cm~c$ ykava cua wqedof bhhofocdv- Yka fbqdi fbla qmiau yka bhhofocd

    mbyofa bh ykov Fbquy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu$ wdacva-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ov ykaua cm ibqey cebqy yka oiamyoyoav bh ykava wabwda2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Mb$ _bqu Kbmbu- Om hcfy$ ~a axam lcia yka vqnnavyobm ykcy yka dc~ vwafohofcdd

    mcla ykal-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Fbuuafy- Eqy yka---

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ibav yka dc~ lamyobm yka mcla bh Yaycmnfb2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov mby mafavvcu hbu bqu wquwbvav$ _bqu Kbmbu$ eafcqva ykcy ov mby cm ovvqa-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^coy c lomqya- Yka dc~ vycyav yka wbvoyobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    19/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 3?

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mb~$ eqy O ykom` yka Fbqmvad$ yka namydalcm hubl yka Wubvafqyobm ov

    cv`omn yka oiamyoyoav bh yka wuavamy wauvbmv fblwbvomn yka Cmyo,Lbma Dcqmiauomn Fbqmfod- Cmi ykcy

    ov c wubwau sqavyobm- Oy ibav mby kcul bqu fcva- Oy ov c sqavyobm bh ~kb cua yka laleauv bh yka Cmyo,

    Lbma Dcqmiauomn Fbqmfod-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Yka wuavamy laleauv$ _bqu Kbmbu$ e mclav2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av- yka Bleqivlcm lc cmv~au yka sqavyobm oh vka `mb~v ykal-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cduaci cmv~auai$ _bqu Kbmbu$ eqy O fcm uawacy- Yka wuavamy fkcoulcm

    ov yka Nbxaumbu bh yka Famyucd Ecm` cmi yka laleauv cua yka Vafquoyoav cmi A{fkcmna Fbllovvobm

    Fkcou Yauavoyc Kauebvc bu Yauavc$ cmi yka Omvqucmfa Fbllovvobmau-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky- Nb ckaci wdacva-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq- Vb$ qmiau yka CLDC$ yka ecm`v cua lcmicyai yb hbu~cui icyc cmi

    omhbulcyobm uancuiomn fbxauai cmi vqvwofobqv yucmvcfyobmv yb yka CLDF2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ciloyyai$ _bqu Kbmbu-Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ykcy ov e dc~-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Oy ov c wuadolomcu sqavyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky$ ykcy ov c lcyyau bh dc~-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O ~cv jqvydcvy monky cmi qw yb ykov lbumomn$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ yka Fkoah

    Jqvyofa kcv eaam yaddomn yka laioc ykcy yka icyc omhbulcyobm noxam yb bq e CLDF ov c kbc{$ ov c dcmyaum

    bh doav$ oy ov wkbma- ^kcy fcm bq vc cebqy ykcy2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Mb ecvov$ _bqu Kbmbu- Ykaua ov mb axoiamfa bm uafbui vkb~omn ykcy `omi bh

    vycyalamy hubl yka wcuy bh yka Fkoah Jqvyofa- Oh ykaua ov$ ykam ka ~kb cddanav ykcy ykaua ~cv vkbqdi yc`ayka vycmi cmi ea fubvv,a{clomai$ _bqu Kbmbu$ yb iayauloma yka cffqucf$ yka fbuuafymavv cmi yka

    xaucfoy bh yka vycyalamy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Day yka Bleqivlcm cmv~au oh vka `mb~v-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq$ Lu- Wuavoiamy- ^kcy fcm bq vc cebqy ykbva fkcunav e yka Fkoah

    Jqvyofa2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oh$ omiaai$ ka lcia ykbva fkcunav$ ~kcy O fcm vc ov ykcy yka cua jqvy bykau

    dcmyaumv bh doav- Ka vcv ykava cua dcmyaumv bh doav$ ykava cua dcmyaumv bh doav cv hcu cv kov vycyalamyv cua

    fbmfaumai eafcqva ykava ibfqlamyv ~aua iadoxauai yb la e yka A{afqyoxa Iouafybu bh yka CLDF-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kb ov yka A{afqyoxa Iouafybu bh yka CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oy ~cv cmv~auai avyauic$ oy ov Xof Csqomb-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Oh bqu cddancyobmv uancuiomn yka cffqucf cmi cqykamyofoy bh ykava CLDF

    ibfqlamyv cua eaomn sqavyobmai$ ~kcy ~bqdi ea yka eavy axoiamfa bh yka icyc cmi omhbulcyobm uancuiomn

    Fkoah Jqvyofa Fbubmcv cffbqmyv om yka ecm`v2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add----

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Olwubwau$ _bqu Kbmbu$ ollcyauocd-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    20/68

    57 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cua bq cv`omn yka bwomobm bh yka Bleqivlcm2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov ~k ~a bejafy bm ykcy nubqmi$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov yka wquwbva bh ykcy sqavyobm$ Fbqmvad2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O ~cmy yb avycedovk$ _bqu Kbmbu$ ykcy yka eavy axoiamfa ~odd ea yka Fkoah Jqvyofav

    cffbqmyv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov bqu bwomobm-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cmi ka uahqvav yb bwam kov cffbqmyv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov bqu bwomobm- ^a cua bejafyomn$ _bqu Kbmbu- Lc ~a ea kacui om

    fbmmafyobm ykaua~oyk$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Vqvycomai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Iahamva kcv sqavyobmai$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ yka xcdoioy cmi cqykbuoy bh yka Bhhofa bh yka

    Bleqivlcm ~oyk uavwafy yb bqu cfyobmv bm ykov omxavyoncyobm- ^kcy fcm bq vc cebqy ykcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ykom` O kcxa cduaci lcia lvadh fdacu- O cl lcmicyai e yka

    Fbmvyoyqyobm yb omxavyoncya wqedof bhhofocdv yb iayauloma ~kaykau ykaou cfyobmv cua omahhofoamy$ ouuanqdcu$

    olwubwau cmi yka do`a- Vafbmi$ ykaua ov yka Bleqivlcm Dc~ ~kofk afkbav yka fbmvyoyqyobmcd wubxovobm

    yb omxavyoncya- Cmi yka Bleqivlcm Dc~ om hcfy ciiv ykcy yka Bleqivlcm fcm wubvafqya-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq$ Lcicl ^oymavv-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cmi bm ybw bh ykcy$ bh fbquva$ cv O vcoi acudoau$ yka Fkoah Jqvyofa$ om kov

    Vycyalamy bh Cvvayv cmi Doceodoyoav$ kci cqykbuozai la yb vaa` yka kadw bh cnamfoav$ omfdqiomn yka EOU$

    yb iayauloma ~kaykau ykaua cua wubwauyoav$ cvvayv$ doceodoyoav$ may ~buyk$ eqvomavv omyauavyv cmi yka do`a

    hubl yka yola ka jbomai yka nbxaumlamy cv ~add cv yka omyauavyv bh kov hclod- Yb la ykcy ov c edcm`ay

    cqykbuoy hbu la yb fbmiqfy omxavyoncyobm-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq-

    _bq acudoau lamyobmai ykcy bq fuacyai c wcmad yb omxavyoncya yka fblwdcomy-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykcy ov uonky-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ioi bq noxa cm ~uoyyam buiau bu uavbdqyobm yb olwcmad ykov omxavyoncyobm nubqw2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ Vou-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ib bq kcxa c fbw bh ykcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ovvqai cm buiau- _av-

    Fcm O kcxa c fbw bh yka buiau2

    _av$ av- Ykov ov yka buiau- Oy ov Bhhofa Buiau 377 cmi oy ~cv ovvqai e la bm Haeuqcu 55$ 5735-

    O fbmvyoyqyai c wcmad bh omxavyoncybuv fbmvovyomn bh bma fkcou cmi hoxa +1/ laleauv- O iouafyai ykal yb

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    21/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 53

    fbmiqfy hcfy,homiomn omxavyoncyobm bm yka fblwdcomy hodai e Uovc Kbmyoxaubv,Ecucsqad$ Uqwauyb Cdaubzc$

    Noee Nbuuav$ Kcuxa @ak cmi Cdeauy Fbmfawfobm cncomvy Fkoah Jqvyofa Uamcyb F- Fbubmc hbu cddanai

    mqlaubqv xobdcyobmv bh yka wubxovobmv bh U-C- 673?$ U-C- 36>?$ U-C- ?3?9 ay fayauc cmi ibf`ayai

    cv FWD mqleau vb cmi vb$ cmi yb vqeloy oyv uawbuy-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Yka ^oymavv kcv kcmiai yb Fbqmvad cm Bhhofa Buiau Mb- 377$ vauoav bh 5735$

    qmiau yka dayyaukaci bh yka Bhhofa bh yka Bleqivlcm$ iqd vonmai e yka Bleqivlcm$ cmi ykov ov cfauyohoai yuqa fbw$ yka fbmyamyv bh ~kofk ~aua jqvy uaci e yka ^oymavv-

    Lc ~a cv` ykcy ykov ea lcu`ai cv A{koeoy WWWWWWWWWWWW2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lcu` oy cffbuiomnd-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^bqdi bq `mb~ oh yka wcmad ioi fbmiqfy cm omxavyoncyobm2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ Vou-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Fcm bq euoahd yadd qv kb~ yka ~amy cebqy fbmiqfyomn yka omxavyoncyobm2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ yka vqewbamcai fauycom bhhofocdv bh yka nbxaumlamy hbu ibfqlamyvykcy ~bqdi kcxa c eacuomn ~oyk yka homcmfocd

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Bhhkcmi$ ~kcy cua ykava nbxaumlamy cnamfoav ~kb ~aua vqewbamcai e yka

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ yka Vqwuala Fbquy ~cv vqewbamcai- O ykom` yka Fdau` bh Fbquy

    ~cv vqewbamcai yb vami c fauyohoai yuqa fbw bh yka Vycyalamy bh Cvvayv cmi Doceodoyoav bh yka Fkoah

    Jqvyofa-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cmi ~kcy ~cv yka uavwbmva bh yka

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ O ykom` qw yb mb~$ yka dcyavy ykcy O uaci ~cv ykcy oy ov vyodd wamiomn

    eahbua yka ecmf- Om bykau ~buiv$ yka fcdamicuai yka uasqavy om yka fcdamicu bh yka ecmf cmi yb icyaykaua ov mb fblwdocmfa-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vb yka wcmad vqewbamcai yka Vqwuala Fbquy hbu fbwoav bh yka VCDM bh yka Fkoah

    Jqvyofa cmi yka ioi mby fblwd2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ ykcy ov ~kcy yka uafbui vkb~v cy ykov yola- Oy cdvb vqewbamcai yka

    kaci bh yka cffbqmyomn hbu fauyohofcya bh acud fblwamvcyobm cmi cddb~cmfav-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Bh yka Vqwuala Fbquy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _ack$ bh yka Vqwuala Fbquy- Eqy yka kaci$ c fauycom Lv- Kbdncib$

    uahqvai yb fblwd ~oyk yka dayyau-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^cv ykov uahqvcd ~uoyyam ib~m e yka Vqwuala Fbquy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ oy ~cv ibfqlamyai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cvoia hubl yka Vqwuala Fbquy$ ~kb adva

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka Kbqva bh Uawuavamycyoxav Adafybucd Yuoeqmcd eafcqva yka Uavwbmiamy

    ~cv bma,yola laleau bu fkcou bh yka Kbqva bh Uawuavamycyoxav Adafybucd Yuoeqmcd cmi yka Adafybucd

    Yuoeqmcd fblwdoai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cvoia hubl ykabq lamyobmai yka Vqwuala Fbquy$ yka EOU$ ioi yka wcmad

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    22/68

    55 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av- Yka cv`ai cdvb hbu vbla icyc hubl yka EOU eqy yka EOU kcv

    mby fblwdoai qw yb yka lblamy-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kofk bykau cnamfoav ioi bq---

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka Kbqva bh Uawuavamycyoxav Adafybucd Yuoeqmcd-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kcy ioi bq cv` hubl yka Kbqva bh Uawuavamycyoxav2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka fauyohofcya bh cddb~cmfav$ fblwamvcyobm cmi cddb~cmfav ykcy

    FJ Fbubmc uafaoxai ~koda ka ~cv c laleau cmi"bu fkcou bh yka Kbqva bh Uawuavamycyoxav

    Adafybucd Yuoeqmcd-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cmi ~cv ykov vqewbamc hbddb~ai2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ yka ioi- Yka fblwdoai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Yka fblwdoai-

    Cvoia hubl yka Kbqva bh Uawuavamycyoxav$ ~kb adva ioi bq vqewbamc2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka Vafuaycu bh yka Wkodowwoma Vamcya-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Hbu ~kcy wquwbva$ Lcicl ^oymavv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Hbu yka wquwbva bh uasqavyomn yka Vycyalamy bh Cvvayv cmi Doceodoyoav bh

    FJ Fbubmc hbu 5775hubl 5775 yb 5737$Uafbui"Jbqumcd bh yka Vamcya voyyomn cv cm Olwacfklamy

    Fbquy icyai Jcmqcu 51$ 5735$ Jcmqcu 58$ 5735 cmi Haeuqcu 8$ 57350 ecm` fauyohofcyobmv icyai

    Haeuqcu >$ 5735 hubl WVEcm`$ @cyowqmcm Eucmfk$ wauycomomn yb yka ecdcmfav bh yka wavb cffbqmyv

    cv bh Iafaleau 63$ 577?-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Fbqmvad$ ~kcy ov yka wquwbva bh ykov doma bh sqavyobmomn2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O cl yuomn yb avycedovk$ _bqu Kbmbu$ ykcy yka Bleqivlcm ioi mby cfy cueoyucuod$

    ~kolvofcdd ~oyk uavwafy yb yka fblwdcomyv cncomvy yka Fkoah Jqvyofa-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^add$ cfyqcdd$ ykcy ov cduaci cmv~auai- Yka Bleqivlcm vcoi$ vka

    ~cvyka cua fbmiqfyomn cm omsqou cebqy yka Fkoah Jqvyofa vb lqfk vb ykcy yka kcxa ~uoyyam c dayyau

    yb kol yb cmv~au

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yb noxa cm cmv~au om >5 kbquv vb

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq$ Lu- Wuavoiamy-

    Jqvy bma dcvy wbomy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov yka wbomy om eadcebuomn ykov ovvqa2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Jqvy bma dcvy wbomy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av- Nb ckaci-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ bq lamyobmai ykcy bq cv`ai hbu yka cvvovycmfa bh

    yka FBC2

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    23/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 56

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykcy ov uonky$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ioi yka FBC uamiau cm uawbuy om ~uoyomn ~oyk uavwafy yb ykaou homiomnv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka fcla qw ~oyk ykov wuadolomcu uawbuy cmi ykam chyau vbla iovfqvvobm$

    chyau vbla a{wdcmcyobmv$ chyau vbla cmcdvov$ yka fcla qw ~oyk ykov cmcdvov bh uawbuy cmi O ybdi ykal

    yb wqy om xovqcd hbul yka homiomnv$ cmcdvov-Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq xau lqfk$ Lcicl ^oymavv-

    Ykcy ov cdd hbu yka fubvv-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cua bq ykubqnk ~oyk bqu fubvv2 Cua bq ykubqnk2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ av-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Oh$_bqu Kbmbu$ wdacva-

    _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ov yka Iahamva uaci yb ib c uaiouafy2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu- Eqy lc ~a uasqavy c bma,lomqyac bma dbmn,lomqya uafavv-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Bma dbmn,lomqya uafavv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka yuocd ~cv vqvwamiai cy 6:5; w-l-

    Cy 6:18 w-l-$ yka yuocd ~cv uavqlai-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka yuocd ov uavqlai- Lc ~a uasqavy yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm yb

    uayqum yb yka ~oymavv vycmi vb ykcy ~a fcm wubfaai- PDbmn Wcqva\

    Yka yuocd ov vqvwamiai hbu bma lomqya-

    Yka yuocd ~cv vqvwamiai cy 9:77 w-l-

    Cy 9:75 w-l-$ yka yuocd ~cv uavqlai-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka vavvobm ov uavqlai- Yka Iahamva lc mb~ wubfaai-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Nbbi chyaumbbm$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Nbbi chyaumbbm$ Jqvyofa Fqaxcv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Lc O ea cddb~ai yb fbmyomqa$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Wubfaai-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$_bqu Kbmbu-

    Mb~$ om ykava ibfqlamyv ykcy ~aua noxam qv$ _bqu Kbmbu$ O mbyofai yka mqleau bh yka iohhauamy

    cffbqmyv$ eqy oy ov mby omiofcyai om ykaua yka mcyqua bh yka cffbqmyv- Hbu omvycmfa$ Cffbqmy Mb- ;379-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    24/68

    59 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lc ~a `mb~ yka mcyqua bh ykcy cffbqmy2 Ov oy c vcxomnv cffbqmy$ c fquuamy cffbqmy$ bu yola

    iawbvoy bu ~kcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oy ov mby omiofcyai$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Oy ov mby omiofcyai- Cdd uonky- _bq cua mby om c wbvoyobm yb yadd qv yka mcyqua bh

    ykov cffbqmy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Volodcud$ om bykau cffbqmyv: Cffbqmy Mb- 7?660 Cffbqmy Mb-76890 Cffbqmy

    Mb- 3;8>0 Cffbqmy Mb- 39>8 cmi Cffbqmy Mb- 7>79$ bq cdvb ~odd mby ea om c wbvoyobm yb yadd

    ykov Kbmbuceda Fbquy yka mcyqua bh ykava cffbqmyv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb$ Vou-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky- Eqy hubl bqu a{clomcyobm bh yka wcwauv cmi uafbuiv vqeloyyai yb bq

    hbu bqu fbmvoiaucyobm$ ov ykaua cm bh ykava cffbqmyv ykcy ov c fquuamy cffbqmy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykaua ov mb omiofcyobm kaua$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Vb$ bq ~odd mby ea ceda yb yadd yka Fbquy----

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ oh oy ov c fkaf`omn cffbqmy bu c vcxomnv cffbqmy bu c yola iawbvoy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Eqy bq ~odd cnuaa ~oyk la ykcy omvbhcu cv c fkaf`omn cffbqmy ov fbmfaumai$ cdykbqnk$

    cv bq vcoi$ bq cua mby yucomai om loddobmv eqy$ day qv vc$ om vlcdd cffbqmyv$ _bqu Kbmbu$ yka iawbvoy

    om ykcy wcuyofqdcu cffbqmy ov axoiamfai e c iawbvoy vdow2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oh bq ~bqdi iawbvoy----

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Fquuamy cffbqmy$ av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- av$ ~kaykau om fcvk bu om fkaf`-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Fbuuafy$ _bqu Kbmbu- Ykcy ov fbuuafy-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ ykcy ov fbuuafy$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmi om ~oykiuc~cdv$ ykaua ov cdvb ykcy ~oykiuc~cd vdow vonmai e yka iawbvoybu2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oh bq ~oykiuc~ oy$ oh bq ~oykiuc~ fcvk2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykam oy ov fbxauai e c ~oykiuc~cd vdow-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Fbuuafy-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oh yka ~oykiuc~cd ov xoc fkaf`$ ykam bq kcxa yka fkaf` ykcy ov wubbh ykcy

    ykcy clbqmy ~cv iaeoyai hubl yka fquuamy cffbqmy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Fbuuafy- Cmi oh oy ov c wdcom vcxomnv cffbqmy bu buiomcu cffbqmy$ oy ov fbxauai bu

    yka iawbvoy ov fbxauai e c ecm`ebb` vqwwdoai e yka ecm`2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Komio mc qvb mncbm cmn ecm`ebb`$ Jqvyofa Fqaxcv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ eqy O cl mby cv`omn bq cebqy yka qvb- Oy ov vyodd wucfyofai-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    25/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 51

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb- Mby cdd ecm`v ovvqa wcvvebb`v-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Eqy oh ykaua ov c wcvvebb`$ yka wcvvebb` lqvy ea wuavamyai hbu wquwbvav bh iawbvoy

    cmi ~oykiuc~cd-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Eqy oh bq kcxa c fcui ~kaua bq fcm qva oy cv fcvk ~kam bq wqufkcva

    vblaykomn$ bq jqvy WOM bqu mqleau cmi ykcy ov cduaci iaeoyai hubl bqu cffbqmy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O cl mby nbomn ykcy hcu$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ Vou-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O cl bmd qw yb ykcy a{yamy ~kaua c ~oykiuc~cd ov lcia cmi yka iawbvoy hubl ~kofk

    yka ~oykiuc~cd ov eaomn lcia ov cm buiomcu vcxomnv cffbqmy bu buiomcu cffbqmy-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cncom$ O sqcdoh l cmv~au$ Jqvyofa Fqaxcv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oh bq ~oykiuc~ oy$ bq ~cmy fcvk$ bq kcxa ykov ~oykiuc~cd vdow$ bu oh bqib mby maai yka ~oykiuc~cd vdow$ bq nb yb yka CYL cmi jqvy WOM cmi WOM cmi WOM cmi ykam bq

    ~odd nay c uafaowy- Mb~----Cua bq fbcfkomn kol2

    Xbofa- _av$ O cl cdvb c dc~au cmi mby c ~oymavv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ka ov cvvovyomn$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ouuavwafyoxa bh ~kaykau bq cua c ~oymavv bu bq cua c dc~au$ ykcy ov

    cwwdoai yb cdd wcuyofowcmyv om ykov iuclc-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O qmiauvycmi ykcy axam om buiomcu fcvav c wcvvebb` ov uasqouai- _bq vc oy ov mb

    dbmnau wucfyofai2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ib mby ykom` dcyad ykcy kcv eaam yka wucfyofa qmdavv wubeced bq cv` hbu

    c wcuyofqdcu wcvvebb`-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O cl vwac`omn hubl a{wauoamfa eafcqva ykaua cua wcvvebb`v ovvqai e Fkomc Ecm`$

    wcvvebb` ovvqai e yka----Cmi eahbua bq fcm ~oykiuc~ cmi iawbvoy$ c wcvvebb` lqvy ea wuavamyai-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb$ mby ~oyk uavwafy yb Ecm` bh yka Wkodowwoma Ovdcmiv- Oh bq ~oykiuc~$

    bq jqvy hodd qw c ~oykiuc~cd vdow cmi yka `aaw oy- Yka uafbui oy- Oy ov cdd fblwqyauozai mb~$ Jqvyofa

    Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky$ cvvqlomn ykcy ~a cua vyodd om ykcy wucfyofa bh kcxomn ykov wcvvebb`$ ~kcy ov bqu

    sqavyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^bqdi bq do`a la yb ea bm yka ~oymavv vycmi cmi cmv~au2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb- Ykcy ibav mby wuaxamy la hubl vaa`omn fdcuohofcyobm hubl bq-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Eqy bq cua mby fdcuohomn- _bq cua cv`omn la c sqavyobm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb$ eafcqva bq wuahcfai bqu sqavyobm cebqy ykov wcvvebb` ykomn-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cmi vb O ~cmyai fdcuohofcyobm-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    26/68

    58 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _bqu Kbmbu wdacva$ ykaua ov mb wamiomn sqavyobm- Yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm kci

    cduaci cmv~auai-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cfyqcdd$ yka Bleqivlcm vcoi vka ibav mby `mb~ ~kaykau yka cffbqmyv

    cua fquuamy cffbqmyv$ vcxomnv cffbqmyv bu ~kcyaxau omi bh cffbqmy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ ~a kcxa iovfqvvai ykcy cduaci-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka hcfy ov ykcy ykaua ov c ecm` cffbqmy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av- Cmi yucmvcfyobmv kcwwamai om yka fbquva bh yola om fbmmafyobm ~oyk

    ykcy ecm` cffbqmy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Lc O mb~ nb yb cmbykau vqejafy$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Nb ckaci-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cncom$ om cmbykau wcna bh ykov Cffbqmy Mb- ;379$ acu 577>$ ykaua cua xcuobqvcffbqmy mqleauv- ^odd bq `omid nb bxau ykal2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cua ~a dbb`omn cy yka vcla wcna$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av- Ykov ov a{koeoy hbu yka Wubvafqyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- B`c- Cffbqmy Mb- ;379$ 577>-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^odd bq ea `omi ambqnk yb yadd qv yka mcyqua bh ykov cffbqmy lamyobmai om kaua bu

    bq cua mby cdvb om c wbvoyobm yb omhbul qv cebqy yka mcyqua bh ykov cffbqmy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ~bqdi mby ea ceda-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Oh$ _bqu Kbmbu wdacva-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmv~auai cduaci-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lu- Jqvyofa Fqaxcv$ bq cua cv`omn sqavyobmv cebqy Cffbqmy Mb- ;379- Cua bq

    ciloyyomn ykcy ykava cua yka cffbqmyv bh yka Fkoah Jqvyofa2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cua bq fubvv,a{clomomn la2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Mb$ eafcqva oh bq cua mby ciloyyomn ykcy$ ykaua ov mb maai yb fubvv,a{cloma----

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykov ov amyouad bqy bh buiau$ _bqu Kbmbu$ qmdavv bq cua yka Wuavoiomn Jqina bu c

    laleau bh yka Vamcya fblloyyaa-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^odd bq `omid ciiuavv yka Fkcou eahbua bq----

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Day qv ea wubfaiqucd cmi lbua fbquyabqv$ _bqu Kbmbu-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    27/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 5>

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Fbqmvad hbu yka Wubvafqyobm$ cddb~ yka Iahamva fbqmvad yb fbmiqfy yka

    uaiouafy a{clomcyobm- Oh bq kcxa cm bejafyobm$ ucova cm bejafyobm$ eqy ib mby wbvoy c sqavyobm yb kol-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Vb buiauai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O cl vbuu$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- O ykom` ~a eayyau fbmiqfy ykov kacuomn om cm buiaud hcvkobm- ^a cua cdd

    dc~auv cmi ~a `mb~ yka uqdav- Oh bq kcxa cm bejafyobm$ ucova cm bejafyobm- Vycya yka uacvbm hbu

    bqu bejafyobm$ vb ykcy ykov Fkcou fcm uqda yb cddb~ bu mby yb cddb~ cm cmv~au-

    Cdd uonky$ Fbqmvad hbu yka Iahamva$ wubfaai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _bqu Kbmbu$ wdacva-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Lc O wubfaai$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _bqu Kbmbu$ wdacva- O uavwafyhqdd bejafy yb yka sqavyobmv ucovai e yka Iahamva-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^k2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Bm yka nubqmi bh ouuadaxcmfa- Eafcqva ykaua kcv eaam mb cilovvobm bu wubbh ykcy

    yka Fkoah Jqvyofa ov ciloyyomn ykava yb ea kov cffbqmyv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykaua ov mb wamiomn sqavyobm cmlbua-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^coy c lomqya- Ykaua ov mb----

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Wamiomn sqavyobm-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cilovvobm$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Bm yka wcuy bh yka Fkoah Jqvyofa-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Eqy yka Bleqivlcm ~cv wuavamyai e yka Iahamva yb yavyoh kaua- Cmi

    yka Bleqivlcm vcoi ykcy vka uafaoxai c uawbuy hubl CLDF yb yka ahhafy ykcy ykaua ov c ecm` iawbvoy

    cffbqmy eacuomn yka mcla bh Uamcyb Fbubmc cmi ykaua ~aua yucmvcfyobmv om fbmmafyobm ~oyk oy- Cua

    bq iamomn ykcy2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Mb$ _bqu Kbmbu- Yka cua yka bmav iamomn ykcy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov yka lcyauocdoy bh ykcy sqavyobm ykcy bq cua ucovomn2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^a vqeloy$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mb- ^kcy ov yka lcyauocdoy2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^a ~oykiuc~ yka bejafyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _bq cua fbmhqvomn yka ovvqav kaua- O ykom` ~a eayyau mby ib cm lovdaciomn

    ahhbuy kaua eafcqva ~a cua sqoya cdauy om ykov Fbquy-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    28/68

    5; YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Wubfaai$ Fbqmvad hbu yka Iahamva-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^oyk yka `omi waulovvobm bh yka kbmbuceda Fbquy-

    Cncom$ lc O ea wauloyyai$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ yb `omid iouafy bqu cyyamyobm yb ~kcy cwwacuv

    om ykov Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm----

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy wcna bh yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm cua bq uahauuomn yb2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Oy ov ykaua$ _bqu Kbmbu- O cl uahauuomn yb ykcy wbuyobm dceadai Cffbqmy ;379,577>-

    O vqwwbva ykcy yka cffbqmy mqleau ykaua lamyobmai ov yka Cffbqmy Mqleau cmi 577> ov yka acu-

    Mb~$ l sqavyobm yb bq ov----

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ykcy ov Cffbqmy Mb- ;379,577>-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Fbuuafy$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Mb~$ l sqavyobm yb bq mb~ ov$ ~odd bq ea `omi ambqnk yb yadd ykov Kbmbuceda

    Fbquy yka mcyqua bh yka cffbqmyv$ mclad: Cffbqmy Mbv- 5;79$ 58?6$ 5971$ 9613$ >81?$ 66?;$ 5;35$

    5;;>$ 69>?$ cmi 63?62 Ykcy ov yka sqavyobm- ^odd bq ea ceda yb cmv~au2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _bq cua mby hclodocu ~oyk ykava mqleauv cv mqleauv bh c ecm` cffbqmy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka cua vqwwbvai yb ea ecm` cffbqmyv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av- Eqy ~kcy O lacm----

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Eqy ~kaykau yka cua fquuamy$ vcxomnv$ O ~bqdi mby `mb~- Oy ov mbyomiofcyai om yka icyc hubl ~kofk O ncykauai$ hubl l cmcdvov-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ Lcicl-

    Mb~$ lc O `mb~ hubl bq kb~ ykava ibfqlamyv cwwacuomn om ykov Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm kcv

    eaam lcia cmi ~kb cqykbuai yka vcla2 _bqu bhhofa2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- L bhhofa$ ~oyk yka cvvovycmfa bh yka FBC- O cv`ai ykal yb xovqcdoza oy

    eafcqva oy ~bqdi ea acvoau yb qmiauvycmi-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Om bykau ~buiv$ bq cua mby wauvbmcdd omxbdxai om ykov2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ~cv wauvbmcdd omxbdxai- Eqy om yka iuc~omn bh ykov bu yka----Kb~ ib bq

    fcdd oy2 ^kcy ov yka yaul2 Om yka wqyyomn bh yka cuub~v cmi ~kcy dbb`ai do`a ecddbbmv$ yka ~aua yka

    bmav ~kb wommai oy om yka fblwqyau-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lc ~a ea omhbulai cv yb yka a{yamy cmi mcyqua bh bqu wcuyofowcyobm- Ov oy vqwauxovbu bu cfyqcd2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cfyqcd$ vqwauxovbu cmi fbmyubd-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmi om ~kcy vamva ~cv ykcy cfyqcd vqwauxovobm lcia2 ^odd bq omid day qv mb~2

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    29/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 5?

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka ~aua wauvbmcdd wuavamy om yka bhhofa- Vb$ ~a ~amy hubl bma amyu

    yb cmbykau- Cmi chyau ykcy ~cv ibma$ yka kci yb yadd la ykcy oy ov mb~ uahdafyai cv bq ~ovkai om ykov$

    om ykcy$ om ykcy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky-

    Cmi omvbhcu cv bqu bhhofa ov fbmfaumai$ ~kaua ioi ykava lcyyauv cwwacuomn om ykov CffbqmyMb- ;379,577> fbla hubl2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka ~aua dohyai hubl yka amyuoav noxam e yka CLDF-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O vaa-

    Cmi ykava amyuoav ykcy bq lamyobmai c ~koda cnb$ ~aua yka wuavamyai yb bq xau hbulcdd e

    yka CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oy ~cv hbu~cuiai yb la e yka CLDF-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Vb$ oy ~cv mby hodai ~oyk bqu bhhofa xau hbulcdd ~oyk cm cyycfklamy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Eafcqva oy ov vyuofyd fbmhoiamyocd$ oy ~cv wauvbmcdd iadoxauai yb la-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- E ~kbl2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- E Lu- Xof Csqomb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O mbyofai avyauic ykcy bq kci c kcui yola uaciomn yka amyuoav ykauaom cwwacuomn

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykcy ov uonky eafcqva yka cua vb lomqya-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ykqv$ noxomn la yka olwuavvobm ykcy ykcy cwwacuv yb ea yka houvy yola bq kcxa nbma

    bxau ykava ibfqlamyv-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb$ _bqu Kbmbu- Cv bq ~odd mbya om yka fbw O kci$ O kci l

    cmmbycyobmv- O kci l lcu`omnv cmi ykcy ov ~k O cv`ai yka waulovvobm bh yka Vamcya oh yka fbqdi

    wkbybfbw yka fdacm fbw bh ykava ibfqlamyv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov yka hcuykavy bq kcxa nbma omvbhcu cv vqwauxovobm bu om yka wuawcucyobm

    bh ykov

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Hbu ykov O kcxa nbma2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- bu wuavamycyobm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- E2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O kcxa cv`ai bq c xau iahomoya sqavyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov yka wquwbva bh ykov doma bh sqavyobmomn$ Fbqmvad2 Cua bq

    olwacfkomn bqu ^oymavv2 Olwqnmomn kau fblwayamfa2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Oh _bqu Kbmbu wdacva$ yka Fbquy cddb~ai qv yb omyubiqfa kau cv c kbvyoda ~oymavv-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmi eaomn cddb~ai yb ib vb----

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    30/68

    67 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _bq fcm fubvv,a{cloma- O `mb~ yka uqdav-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu- Ykcy ov bqu wquwbva-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Oy ov om hubmy bh la-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu$ ykcy ov yka wquwbva- ^a cua yuomn yb iayauloma yka xaucfoy cmi

    yka cffqucf-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _bq cua yavyomn yka fuaioeodoy bh yka ^oymavv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- E ~c bh olwacfklamy$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Wubfaai-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Mb~$ ~kam bq ~amy bxau ykov yceqdcyobm hqumovkai bq e yka CLDF wabwda$ bq

    ioi mby kcxa c ycd` ~oyk cmbma bh ykal2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^oyk cm bh yka2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- CLDF wabwda-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- CLDF wabwda$ mb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Mbma- Om bykau ~buiv$ oy ~cv jqvy noxam yb bq-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykaua ov mb fbxauomn dayyau-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykaua ~cv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmi bq cvvqlai ykcy ykov ~cv yka ibfqlamy----

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykaua ~cv$ ykaua ~cv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykaua ~cv2 Ck$ O vaa-

    Lc ~a ea cddb~ai yb nb bxau yka fbxauomn dayyau-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Vqua- Yka dayyau bh yka CLDF ~kam yka yucmvloyyai yka ibfqlamy yb la-

    Yka Lcufk ?$ 5735 dayyau- ^a kcxa kaua yka fbxauomn dayyau- Oy ov kaua-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Nbomn bxau ykov dayyau$ oy vycyav: ^a cua hqumovkomn bq ~oyk yka cyycfkai omhbulcyobm

    hbu omyaddonamfa wquwbvav bmd om fbmmafyobm ~oyk yka omxavyoncyobm bh yka cebxa,lamyobmai fblwdcomy-

    Ioi bq mbyofa ykcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ O `mb~ ykcy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky- ^odd bq `omid amdonkyam qv cv yb yka vfbwa bh ~kcy ov lacmy$ oh bq `mb~$

    bh lamyobmomn kaua bh omyaddonamfa wquwbvav bmd-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Day la vaa yka dayyau$ Fkoah- P^oymavv nbomn bxau yka dayyau-\

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    31/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 63

    ^kam oy vcv oy ov vyuofyd fbmhoiamyocd$ oy vcv: Yka cyycfkai omhbulcyobm hbu omyaddonamfa wquwbvav

    bmd om fbmmafyobm ~oyk yka omxavyoncyobm bh yka cebxa,fcwyobmai fblwdcomyv-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lacmomn$ omhbulcyobm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Omhbulcyobm$ av- Hqumovkomn bq yka cyycfkai omhbulcyobm hbu omyaddonamfa

    wquwbvav bmd om fbmmafyobm ~oyk yka omxavyoncyobm bh yka cyycfkai lamyobmai fblwdcomy- Yka lamyobmaifblwdcomy ~cv Uovc Kbmyoxaubv$ ay cd- xauvqv Fkoah Jqvyofa Uamcyb F- Fbubmc-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Lc O fbmyomqa mb~$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Nb ckaci- _bq cua ibomn c fubvv,a{clomcyobm- Ib mby `aaw cv`omn

    waulovvobm hubl yka Fkcou-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu- O ~cv ykom`omn ykcy yka Fkcou lc kcxa c sqavyobm$ ykcy ov ~k-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mb$ mb$ nb ckaci-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Om bykau ~buiv$ oy ov iahomoya cmi vwafohof ykcy ykov omhbulcyobm eaomn uadcai yb bq ~cv wquvqcmy

    yb ykov cddanai fblwdcomy bh Uovc Kbmyoxaubv$ ay cd-$ cncomvy Fkoah Jqvyofa Fbubmc-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ vou-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Lamyobm ov lcia om kaua bh cm omxavyoncyobm- Ov ykov omxavyoncyobm lauad

    cilomovyucyoxa bu wuadolomcu cv oy ov qmiauvybbi2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Hcfy,homiomn omxavyoncyobm bu fcva eqodiqw-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov vyuofyd fbmhoiamyocd2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmi oy bqnky mby yb ea `mb~m e cmebi adva bqyvoia bh ykbva fbmmafyai bhhofocdd

    ~oyk oy-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky- Lacmomn$ bmd e wabwda ~oykom bqu bhhofa cua wuoxodanai yb `mb~ ykov

    omxavyoncyobm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mby cdd laleauv bh l vychh `ma~ cebqy oy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ eqy ykbva ~kb vkbqdi `mb~ cebqy ykov cua bmd ykbva ~bu`omn ~oyk bq omfbmmafyobm ~oyk ykov fblwdcomy-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ eqy O sqcdoh ykcy- Eafcqva O kci iohhofqdy cmcdzomn yka icyc$ O kci

    yb amncna yka cvvovycmfa bh bykau nbxaumlamy cnamfoav-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ eqy l sqavyobm yb bq ov: Yka a{yamy cmi vfbwa bh yka fbmhoiamyocdoy

    lamyobmai om kaua uahauv yb yka hcfy ykcy oy vkbqdi ea `mb~m bmd yb yka laleauv bh bqu vychh bu bhhofa2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^kb ~aua cvvovyomn la om yka omxavyoncyobm bh ykov fcva-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq- Ykcm` bq xau lqfk- B`c-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    32/68

    65 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Mb~$ oh O nb ecf` yb bqu dayyau yb yka Fkoah Jqvyofa cv`omn kol yb cmv~au yka cddanai fkcunav om

    ykaua$ bq lamyobmai cebqy vauobqv lovfbmiqfy om bhhofa- @omid nb bxau yka fbw oh bq kcxa oy-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O cl nbomn bxau oy uonky mb~$ Jqvyofa-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov yka sqavyobm2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O cl uahauuomn$ _bqu Kbmbu$ yb c wbuyobm bh yka dayyau ciiuavvai e yka Kbmbuceda

    Bleqivlcm yb Fkoah Jqvyofa Fbubmc-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cmi2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmi lc O uahau yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm yb ykov wcuyofqdcu wbuyobm-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Wubfaai-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^koda bq lc bmd ea ualbxai hubl bhhofa ykubqnk olwacfklamy wubfaaiomnv$

    ykov bhhofa kcv$ cv uahdafyai acudoau$ yka wb~au cmi iqy yb omxavyoncya bq hbu cm vauobqv lovfbmiqfyom bhhofa hbu yka wquwbva bh hodomn c xauohoai fblwdcomy hbu olwacfklamy$ oh ~cuucmyai- Oy ~cv bm ykov

    cffbqmy ykcy ykov bhhofa fbmiqfyai cm omoyocd axcdqcyobm bh yka fblwdcomy-

    L sqavyobm yb bq ov: ^kcy lacmomn vkbqdi ea cyycfkai yb ykov vycyalamy bh bquv uancuiomn yka

    cddanai fbllovvobm bh vauobqv lovfbmiqfy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cm fbmiqfy ykcy ov omyamyobmcdd ibma ~kofk ov mby jqvy$ ~kofk ov mby

    wubwau$ ~kofk ov om xobdcyobm bh dc~$ ykcy yb la amfblwcvvav yka wkucva vauobqv lovfbmiqfy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Om ykov fbmmafyobm$ lc O uaci yb bq c wbuyobm bh yka iafovobm om vaxaucd fcvav$

    lbua wcuyofqdcudom yka fcva bhVcdfaib x- Omyomn$ uqdai e yka kbmbuceda Vqwuala Fbquy$ ~kauaom oy

    ov vycyai: Yka lovfbmiqfy lqvy cdvb kcxa c iouafy uadcyobm yb cmi ea fbmmafyai ~oyk yka wauhbulcmfabh bhhofocd iqyoav-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ vou-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Om bykau ~buiv$ oy ov mby cm lovhacvcmfa bu lcdhacvcmfa eqy oy ov cm cfy xobdcyoxa

    bh yka uqdav cmi yka dc~ om fbmmafyobm ~oyk yka wauhbulcmfa bh bhhofocd iqy-

    Mb~$ yka ciiuavvaa kaua ov Fkoah Jqvyofa Fbubmc- ^odd bq ea `omi ambqnk yb yadd ykov Kbmbuceda

    Fbquy ~kcy ov yka vfbwa bh ykcy vauobqv lovfbmiqfy bq cua uahauuomn yb om ykov dayyau2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oy amfblwcvvav cmykomn ykcy xobdcyav yka dc~- Om ykov fcva$ ka ov fkcunai

    yb kcxa cffqlqdcyai ~acdyk ykcy ov wquwbuyaid nubvvd iovwubwbuyobmcya yb kov omfbla-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Eqy O ~odd mby yc`a ovvqa ~oyk bq ykaua eafcqva yka jquovwuqiamfa bm yka wbomy ~a

    kcxa wdcfai bm uafbui$ _bqu Kbmbu$ cua cduaci ykaua-

    Mb~$ ~kam bq ~aua hqumovkai ~oyk ykov uawbuy bh yka CLDF wquvqcmy yb bqu uasqavy

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O kbwa bq ~amy bxau yka vcla$ cmi cv bq vcoi$ lcm yolav2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ Vou-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    33/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 66

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky- Fbqdi bq mb~ chhoul qmiau bcyk ykcy yka fbmyamyv bh yka vcoi uawbuy cua

    cffqucya$ fbuuafy$ cmi om cffbuicmfa ~oyk dc~ ecvai bm bqu a{clomcyobm2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^kaykau bu mby yka fbmyamyv bh ykcy uawbuy cua cffqucya$ fbuuafy$ bu om

    cffbuicmfa ~oyk dc~$ O ~bqdi mby kcxa cm ~c bh `mb~omn-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O vaa- Vb$ ykcy ov yka----Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Eafcqva ykcy ~cv hqumovkai yb la e yka CLDF-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov eabmi bqu fblwuakamvobm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^kcy ib bq lacm eabmi l fblwuakamvobm2 O ib mby qmiauvycmi oy2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Eabmi l fblwayamfa$ av$ eqy mby eabmi l fblwuakamvobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Kb~ ioi bq qmiauvycmi yka honquav lamyobmai om ykaua$ ~aua yka cffqucya$ ~aua

    yka fbuuafy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ yka wuavqlwyobm ov ykcy vomfa O ~cv noxam ykov ibfqlamy$ yka

    wuavqlwyobm ov ykcy ykava cua ibfqlamyv fbuuafyd uahdafyai om yka icyc bh yka CLDF-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^kcy xauohofcyobm ioi bq qmiauyc`a oh bq ioi om fbmmafyobm ~oyk yka cffqucf bh

    yka honquav ykauaom vycyai2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O fbqdi mby nb iouafyd yb yka ecm` yb xauoh ~kaykau yka icyc amyauai kaua

    cua fbuuafy bu mby-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Kb~ cebqy cm bh bqu wabwda bu wauvbm qmiau bq$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ mbma

    fbmiqfyai cm omsqou2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Hubl yka ecm`2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykaua ~aua mb omsqouoav cv yb ~kaykau ykava cddanai ~oykiuc~cdv cua fbxauai e cm

    ~oykiuc~cd vdow-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Yka iawbvoy ykcy bq lamyobmai ~cv mby cvfauycomai cv yb ~kaykau ykaua ~auaiawbvoy vdowv fbxauomn yka vcla-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Bm yka icyav lamyobmai ykauaom2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky- Vb$ cwwcuamyd$ bq noxa qv yka olwuavvobm ykcywcuibm yka dcmnqcna

    bq v~cddb~ai$ kbb`$ doma$ cmi vom`au yka amyoua fbmyamyv bh yka ibfqlamy vqeloyyai yb bq om uavwbmva

    yb bqu dayyau-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    34/68

    69 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cncom$ O vc$ yka wuavqlwyobm ov ykcy yka ~bqdi noxa yb la fbuuafy

    omhbulcyobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmi ykcy wuavqlwyobm ~cv maxau xauohoai e bq-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O fbqdi mby xauoh oy- O fbqdi mby nb yb yka ecm`- O fbqdi mby ib ykcy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ualaleau avyauic$ bq ~aua ycd`omn cebqy fbmhoiamyocdoy bh ecm`

    iawbvoyv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yb ~kofk O uaybuyai ykcy cua bq ciloyyomn ykcy ykava ecm` iawbvoyv a{ovy2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^add$ kb~ fbqdi O lc`a oy2 PDcqnkyau\ O cl yka bma wubwbqmiomn yka sqavyobm- Cua

    bq fubvv,a{clomomn----

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O cl ualomiomn bq cebqy ~kcy yucmvwouai avyauic$ Lu- Jqvyofa-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^add$ O kcxa mby hbunbyyam ~kcy yucmvwouai avyauic$ wuafovad$ yka ecvov bh l

    ciioyobmcd iouafy sqavyobmomn mb~$ eafcqva bq kcxa wabwda$ cffbuiomn yb bq$ ~kb kcxa cvvovyai bq$

    om fbmmafyobm ~oyk yka iayaulomcyobm bh yka yuqyk-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Om fbmmafyobm ~oyk yka cmcdvov-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cddb~ la yb homovk houvy- Oh bqu Kbmbu wdacva$ lc ~a uasqavy ykcy yka oymavv

    ea ualomiai-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lcicl$ ~oyk bqu omiqdnamfa$ day yka Fbqmvad homovk-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O vqeloy$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky- O ~oykiuc~ yka hbulau sqavyobm- Om ykcy cmcdvov ykcy bq lcia$ ioi bq

    cv` hbu yka cvvovycmfa bh cm bh yka wabwda om bqu bhhofa yb iayauloma yka yuqyk bh ~kcy cwwacuv om ykava

    uawbuyv vqeloyyai yb bq e yka CLDF eahbua2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb$ _bqu Kbmbu- ^a cua mby cddb~ai yb iayauloma yka yuqyk bh ~kcy

    cwwacuv ykaua-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O ykbqnky yka wquwbva bh bqu uasqavy hbu cvvovycmfa ov yb ea ceda yb cvfauycom yka

    yuqyk bh yka lcyyauv-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Iayauloma yka a{ovyamfa-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^coy$ cddb~ la yb homovk-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Vbuu- Lac fqdwc-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ ykcm` bq- O ykbqnky bqu wquwbva ~cv yb cv` yka cvvovycmfa bh yka

    CLDF yb amdonkyam bq bm ~kcy yka kcxa om fbmmafyobm ~oyk ykov fblwdcomy bh yka xcuobqv fblwdcomcmyv

    eahbua bq$ uonky2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Day la uaci l dayyau yb yka CLDF-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    35/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 61

    L uasqavy ~cv hbu yka cvvovycmfa bh yka CLDF xov,c,xov yka wuavamy omxavyoncyobm eaomn fbmiqfyai

    e bqu bhhofa bm cffbqmy bh yka dayyau,fblwdcomy bh Uovc Kbmyoxaubv$ ay cd- e ~c bh wubxoiomn uadaxcmy

    omhbulcyobm eacuomn bm yka homcmfocd yucmvcfyobmv$ oh cm$ bh yka Uavwbmiamy cmi uadcyai yucmvcfyobmv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Om yka uawd ykcy bq uafaoxai$ ~cv ykaua cm vycyalamy uadcyoxa yb yka homcmfocd

    yucmvcfyobmv ykcy bq ~aua cv`omn cvvovycmfa2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka hqumovkai la c fbw bh ykov 3>,wcna ibfqlamy cmi yka hbqu,wcna

    vqllcu bh yucmvcfyobmv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^kcy yucmvcfyobmv cua bq uahauuomn yb$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ecm` yucmvcfyobmv$ homcmfocd$ yb ea lbua cffqucya-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Yka cua yucmvcfyobmv omxbdxomn iawbvoyv cmi ~oykiuc~cdv- Mbykomn lbua2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mby mafavvcuod-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^aua bq ceda yb cvfauycom ~kaykau ykava ecm` cffbqmyv uahdafyai om yka uawbuy cua

    cfyqcdd a{ovyomn2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cncom$ O vcoi acudoau$ kb~ fcm O iayauloma oh yka cua cfyqcdd a{ovyomn ~kam

    O fcmmby nb yb yka ecm`2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O cl mby cv`omn bq kb~ bq fcm iayauloma$ eqy ~kcy O cl cv`omn bq ov$ ioi bq

    iayauloma2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cduaci cmv~auai- Vka vcoi cduaci ykcy vka ioi mby nb yb yka

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ecm`-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- yb yka ecm`v- Vka ioi mby nb yb yka uafbuiv- Vka uadoai bm yka uawbuybh CLDF- Cmi vka wuavqlai yka xaucfoy bh yka uawbuy bh cm cnamf cqykbuozai e dc~ yb kcmida ykov

    ywa bh wubedal-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ eqy---- aua bq ceda yb cvfauycom ~kaykau ykaua ov cm omxavyoncyobm fbmiqfyai

    e yka CLDF om fbmmafyobm----

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lc O bejafy$ _bqu Kbmbu wdacva2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cddb~ la yb homovk cmi O ~odd noxa bq cdd yka bwwbuyqmoy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ ~odd bq `omid cddb~ kol yb homovk$ vb ykcy

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Lu- Wuavoiomn Jqvyofa$ oy ~cv ka ~kb ycd`ai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lac fqdwc-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O kbwa ka ov mby cwwbomyai Bleqivlcm$ _bqu Kbmbu$ eafcqva ykaua ~odd ea c

    fbmhdofy bh cqykbuoy cduaci-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kb ~cv ycd`omn2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O ~cv yka bma$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _bq vaa$ yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau ov nayyomn fbmhqvai$ fcmmby nay

    ~kb ov ycd`omn-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    36/68

    68 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    E yka ~c$ ~odd bq wdacva bejafy oh bq ~cmy yb bejafy vb