-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 1
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning) 9th July 2019 More
Eurozone QE: Is it time to BUY the banks? Euan Brown, Economics
& Markets Analyst, Longview Economics Direct Line: +44 (0) 207
062 8808 Email: [email protected]
Summary
“I can imagine that [an interest rate hike during 2019]” ECB’s
Ewald Nowotny, 11th January 2019
While Nowotny is one of the ECB’s well-known hawks, others on
the governing council have shared his expectation (in early 2019
and before) that European rates should be working their way higher.
Those expectations, though, have now fully reversed. In March, the
ECB committed to holding rates steady this year; in June that
commitment was extended (to mid-2020); and, last week, rumours of a
new QE program have surfaced (aided and abetted by the appointment
of Christine Lagarde as ECB president). With that, the rates market
has moved appropriately: EURIBOR futures have shifted from pricing
hikes, to expecting policy rates to move further into negative
territory (FIG A). FIG A: Implied change in 3m EURIBOR by Dec 2019
(bps)
Basis
poin
ts (
bps)
-20
-10
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
Jan Mar May Jul Sep Nov Jan Mar May Jul Sep Nov Jan Mar May Jul
Sep Nov Jan
2017 2018 2019
Implied change in 3m EURIBOR by Dec 2019
Source: Longview Economics, Macrobond
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 2
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
That change of ECB policy direction has revived a number of key
questions. In particular: Will the next phase of ECB easing
successfully re-stimulate growth and inflation in Europe? If so,
how will German bund yields perform? And, linked to that, is there
now a case for buying European banks (which have significantly
underperformed the broader market, FIG B)? FIG B: German 10y yield
(%) vs. EZ banks vs. index (relative performance)
The common answer is that ECB easing (either via rate cuts or
QE) squeezes bank interest margins and is negative for banking
sector equities. The evidence for that, though, is somewhat patchy
(with no correlation between ECB easing and the relative
performance of EZ banks). Indeed, there have even been bouts of
aggressive ECB stimulus in which Eurozone banks have meaningfully
outperformed (e.g. mid 2016 – mid 2017). Instead, the correlation
of Eurozone banks with bund yields is more convincing/stable, and
is shown in FIG B above. How bund yields perform, and over what
time frame, are therefore the key questions for Eurozone banks
outlook. In the longer term, German bund yields are likely to stay
pinned at/around zero, resulting in long term poor performance of
Eurozone banks. That reflects the ‘Japanification’ of Europe’s
economy, in which generating growth and inflation is likely to
become increasingly challenging for the ECB (for detail see
Longview Letter No 125, 9th May 2019: “China & Europe: The new
Japans – Part II”). Of
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 3
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
interest in that respect, bund yields, which used to trade in
lock-step with US Treasuries, have latched onto JGB yields (i.e.
since the Eurozone crisis, see FIG C). FIG C: US, German &
Japanese 10 year government bond yields (%)
In the shorter term, the key question becomes: What is driving
bund yields? It’s not, in our view, ECB policy: Bund yields do not
correlate particularly well with phases of QE/policy easing (i.e.
as with the banks). That’s probably linked to (growing) evidence
that the ECB is losing its ability to meaningfully influence growth
and inflation in Europe (for detail on the European economy see
Extract from Quarterly Asset Allocation No. 38, 19th June 19: “EZ:
How much does ECB easing really matter?”). Instead, bund yields are
more closely correlated with global growth (expectations) than
marginal changes in ECB policy (e.g. FIG E). In that respect,
Eurozone banks are looking increasingly attractive (i.e. on a 6 – 9
month time frame). Of note, there’s an emerging case for a bounce
in global (and therefore Eurozone) growth, probably in the second
half of this year (see Quarterly Global Asset Allocation No. 38,
5th July 2019: “Keep BUILDing ‘Risk-On’ Exposure
in Strategic Portfolios”). If that happens then bund yields, as
well as US yields, should bounce along with banks in both the EZ
and US.
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 4
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
This then throws up an additional question: Should investors
allocate to US or Eurozone banks? Typically, as we show in FIG D
below, the relative performance of these sectors (i.e. US banks vs.
EZ banks) has been driven by the spread of US bond yields over
German. In recent months however (i.e. since late April), that
relationship has broken down (FIG D). FIG D: US banks relative to
EZ banks vs. US - German 10y bond spread (bps)
Our central expectation is that US bond yields back up by more
than bund yields over coming months and quarters (given a stronger
US macro outlook*), and the relationship re-establishes itself. As
a result, US banks should continue to outperform those in the
Eurozone. Additionally, in the near term, and from the perspective
of an overseas investor, the recent unwinding of net SHORT
positioning in the EUR increases the risk of currency weakness (fig
11). Of interest in that respect, our medium term technical scoring
system for the euro recently generated a SELL signal which has not
yet fully unwound (FIG F). This therefore adds to the case for
owning US rather than Eurozone assets. *Certain key, cyclical
sectors in the US are showing early signs of recovery (e.g.
housing). In Europe, in contrast, leading indicators are not yet
pointing to a pick-up in economic activity (for detail see US &
EZ extracts from QAA no. 38, published 12th & 19th June as well
as the asset allocation recommendations extract published 5th
July).
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 5
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
FIG E: World trade growth (Y-o-Y, %) vs. Y-o-Y change in 10y
bund yield (p.p.)
FIG F: Longview EUR medium term technical scoring system vs.
EUR/USD
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 6
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Summary table:
FigNet
positions
1 week
change
12-week
change
Percentil
e
Data
Since
US Dollar, Bonds & Rates
US 10-yr 1 -259,443 DOWN DOWN 10 Jan-86
US 5-yr 2 -91,122 DOWN DOWN 26 May-88
US 2-yr 3 -202,128 DOWN DOWN 3 Jun-90
US Long Bonds 4 -208,611 UP UP 6 Jan-86
US Dollar Index 5 23,713 UP DOWN 75 May-92
Three-month Eurodollar 6 1,206,932 UP UP 98 Jan-86
Equities
S&P 500 7 15,517 DOWN UP 37 Jun-10
DJIA 8 19,589 UP UP 78 Jul-10
Nasdaq 100 9 3,911 UP UP 20 Aug-10
VIX 10 -135,094 DOWN UP 3 Sep-10
Curencies
Euro 11 -7,316 UP UP 41 Jan-99
Japanese Yen 12 1,327 UP UP 65 Jan-86
UK Pound 13 -77,933 DOWN DOWN 4 Apr-88
Swiss Franc 14 -20,645 UP UP 32 Jan-86
Australian Dollar 15 -68,380 UP UP 4 Jan-87
Canadian Dollar 16 19,773 UP UP 65 Jan-86
New Zealand Dollar 17 -26,840 UP DOWN 1 Jan-99
Brazilian Real 18 -3,390 UP UP 11 Nov-95
Mexican Peso 19 112,991 DOWN DOWN 94 May-95
Russian Ruble 20 33,653 UP DOWN 98 Apr-98
Energy
Oil 21 398,231 UP DOWN 90 Jan-86
Nat Gas 22 -128,480 UP DOWN 15 Apr-90
Heating Oil 23 1,059 UP DOWN 20 Jan-86
Base Metals
Copper 24 -25,027 DOWN DOWN 7 Jul-89
Steel 25 4,834 DOWN UP 99 Feb-14
Precious Metals
Silver 26 52,063 DOWN UP 69 Jan-86
Gold 27 286,822 UP UP 97 Jan-86
Palladium 28 12,107 UP UP 71 Jan-86
Platinum 29 17,298 UP DOWN 66 Jan-86
Agricultural - Grains
Corn 30 361,020 UP UP 98 Jun-98
Oats 31 3,013 DOWN UP 49 Jun-98
Rice 32 314 DOWN UP 47 Oct-94
Soybeans 33 -17,169 DOWN UP 31 Jun-98
Wheat 34 29,887 UP UP 93 Jun-98
Agricultural - Softs
Coffee 35 6,662 UP UP 45 Jan-86
Sugar 36 15,752 UP UP 30 Jan-86
Cocoa 37 51,706 UP UP 85 Jan-86
1 & 12 week changes show whether positioning has gone up
(more bullish) or down (more bearish). Percentile shows how
bullish/bearish positioning is relative to (entire) history. The
charts show current positioning on a Bollinger Band basis (i.e.
200-week standard deviation bands).
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 7
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
US Dollar, Bonds & Rates Fig 1: US 10-year Treasury note
futures vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT positions
Fig 2: US 5-year Treasury note futures vs. net speculative
LONG/SHORT positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 8
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Fig 3: US 2-year Treasury note futures vs. net speculative
LONG/SHORT positions
Fig 4: US 30-year Treasury bond futures vs. UST bonds net
speculative LONG/SHORT positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 9
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Fig 5: US dollar index vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT
positions
Fig 6: Three-month Eurodollar futures vs. net speculative
LONG/SHORT positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 10
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Equities & Volatility Fig 7: S&P500 vs. net speculative
LONG/SHORT consolidated* positions
Fig 8: DJIA vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT consolidated*
positions
*Consolidated positions aggregate the standard and mini size
futures contracts (and weight the mini contracts accordingly).
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 11
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Fig 9: NASDAQ 100 vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT consolidated*
positions
Fig 10: VIX vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT positions
*Consolidated positions aggregate the standard and mini size
futures contracts (and weight the mini contracts accordingly).
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 12
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Currencies Fig 11: EUR-USD vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT
positions
Fig 12: JPY-USD vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 13
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Fig 13: GBP-USD vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT positions
Fig 14: CHF-USD vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 14
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Fig 15: AUD-USD vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT positions
Fig 16: CAD-USD vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 15
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Fig 17: NZD-USD vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT positions
Fig 18: BRL-USD vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 16
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Fig 19: MXN-USD vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT positions
Fig 20: RUB-USD vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 17
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Energy Fig 21: Oil futures price (USD/bbl) vs. net speculative
LONG/SHORT positioning (no. of contracts)
Fig 21a: Oil futures price (USD/bbl) vs. net speculative
LONG/SHORT positioning (in USDbn, i.e. value)
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 18
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Fig 22: Natural gas futures (USD/MMBtu) vs. net speculative
LONG/SHORT positions
Fig 23: Heating oil futures vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT
positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 19
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Base Metals Fig 24: Copper futures (USD/lb) vs. net speculative
LONG/SHORT positions
Fig 25: Steel futures (CNY/MT) vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT
positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 20
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Precious Metals Fig 26: Silver futures (USD/fine ounce) vs. net
speculative LONG/SHORT positions
Fig 27: Gold futures (USD/fine ounce) vs. net speculative
LONG/SHORT positioning (no. of contracts)
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 21
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Fig 27a: Gold futures (USD/fine ounce) vs. net speculative
LONG/SHORT positioning (in USDbn, i.e. value)
Fig 28: Platinum futures (USD/fine ounce) vs. net speculative
LONG/SHORT positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 22
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Fig 29: Palladium futures (USD/fine ounce) vs. net speculative
LONG/SHORT positions
Agricultural - Grains Fig 30: Corn futures (USD/bushel) vs. net
speculative LONG/SHORT positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 23
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Fig 31: Oats futures (USD/bushel) vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT
positions
Fig 32: Rice futures (USD/hundredweight) vs. net speculative
LONG/SHORT positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 24
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Fig 33: Soybeans futures (USD/bushel) vs. net speculative
LONG/SHORT positions
Fig 34: Wheat futures (USD/bushel) vs. net speculative
LONG/SHORT positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 25
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Agricultural – Softs Fig 35: Coffee futures (USD/lb) vs. net
speculative LONG/SHORT positions
Fig 36: Sugar futures (USD/lb) vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT
positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 26
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
Fig 37: Cocoa futures (USD/Ton) vs. net speculative LONG/SHORT
positions
-
The SHORT VIEW (& market positioning), 9th July 2019 27
Copyright © 2004-2019 Longview Economics. All Rights
Reserved.
LV Longview Economics Investments. Trades. Macro.
p
This Publication is protected by U.K. and International
Copyright laws.
All rights are reserved. No license is granted to the user
except for the user's personal use. No part of this
publication or its contents may be copied, downloaded, stored in
a retrieval system, further transmitted, or
otherwise reproduced, stored, disseminated, transferred, or
used, in any form or by any means, except as
permitted under agreement with Longview Economics Ltd.
This publication is proprietary and limited to the sole use of
Longview Economics’ clients and trial subscribers.
Each reproduction of any part of this publication or its
contents must contain notice of Longview Economics’
copyright. This agreement shall be governed and construed in
accordance with U.K. Copyright law and the parties
hereto irrevocably submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of the
English courts in respect of any dispute or matter
arising out of or connected with this Agreement.
Any disclosure or use, distribution, dissemination or copying of
any information received from Longview
Economics Ltd. is strictly prohibited, whether derived from the
reports or from any oral or written communication
by way of opinion, advice, or otherwise with a principal of the
company; and such information is not warranted in
any manner whatsoever; and is for the use of our clients and
trial subscribers only. Longview Economics Limited
will not be liable for any claims or lawsuits from any third
parties arising from the use or distribution of this
document. This report is for distribution only under such
circumstances as may be permitted by applicable law.
This publication is for your information only and is not
intended as an offer, or a solicitation of an offer, to buy or
sell any investment or other specific product. The analysis
contained herein is based on numerous assumptions.
Different assumptions could result in materially different
results. Certain services and products are subject to
legal restrictions and cannot be offered worldwide on an
unrestricted basis and/or may not be eligible for all
investors. All information and opinions expressed in this
document were obtained from sources believed to be
reliable and in good faith, but no representation or warranty,
express or implied, is made as to the accuracy or
completeness. All information and opinions as well as any prices
indicated are current as of the date of this report,
and are subject to change without notice. Some investments may
not be readily realisable since the market in
securities is illiquid and therefore valuing the investment and
identifying the risk to which you are exposed may be
difficult to quantify. Futures and options trading is considered
risky. Past performance of an investment is no
guarantee of its future performance. Some investments may be
subject to sudden and large falls in values and on
realisation you may receive back less than you invested or may
be required to pay more. Changes in foreign
exchange rates may have an adverse effect on the price, value or
income of an investment. We are of necessity
unable to take into account the particular investment
objectives, financial situation and needs of our individual
clients and we would recommend that you take financial and/or
tax advice as to the implications (including tax) of
investing in any of the products mentioned herein.
Longview Economics Ltd. is an appointed representative of
Messels Limited. Messels Limited is authorised and regulated by the
Financial Conduct Authority.