1 Recycle Human Waste For Health, Wealth and Energy ****************************************** MALAPRABHA BIOGAS PLANT Developed By Dr. S. V. Mapuskar ****************************************** NEW DESIGN FOR RECOVERY OF BIOGAS FROM LATRINE Published by Jyotsna Arogya Prabodhan, Dehu village, Tal. Haveli, Dist. Pune, Maharashtra 412 109 INDIA
40
Embed
Malaprabha Biogas Plant developed by Dr S V Mapuskar
The concept and construction details of Malaprabha biogas plant. The plant has been designed to function mainly for human nightsoil as a substrate. It was developed by Dr S V Mapuskar in 1980.
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
1
Recycle Human Waste
For Health, Wealth and Energy
******************************************
MALAPRABHA
BIOGAS PLANT
Developed By
Dr. S. V. Mapuskar
******************************************
NEW DESIGN FOR
RECOVERY OF BIOGAS FROM
LATRINE
Published by
Jyotsna Arogya Prabodhan,
Dehu village, Tal. Haveli,
Dist. Pune, Maharashtra 412 109
INDIA
2
Copy right
Dr. S. V. Mapuskar,
Dehu village, Tal. Haveli,
Dist. Pune, Maharashtra 412 109
INDIA
Published – June 1988
Updated: November 2011
For Private circulation only
3
Recycle Human Waste
For Health, Wealth and Energy
***************************************
MALAPRABHA
BIOGAS PLANT
Developed By
Dr. S. V. Mapuskar
***************************************
NEW DESIGN FOR
RECOVERY OF BIOGAS FROM
LATRINE
4
CONTENTS
Sr. No. Particulars Page No.
1. Development of Nightsoil 4
Based Biogas Plants
2. Introduction To Malaprabha 12
3. Basis Of The Design 14
4. Design Calculations 18
5. Construction Work 24
6. Field Implementation of the design 32
ANNEXURES
1. Material Estimates 34
2. Labour Component Estimates 37
5
Chapter 1:- Development of Night Soil
Based Biogas Plant
In India, biogas technology is in use very effectively for
nearly five decades. Curiously, one of the first few biogas
plants in the world which was constructed at Leprosy Home at
Wadala in Bombay in about 1901, worked on sewage.
Subsequently, in 1937, biogas generation was undertaken at
Dadar Sewage works at Bombay, again, during the treatment of
sewage sludge.
Unfortunately, for the last several years, it is being
presumed at various levels, that cattle dung is the only
appropriate feed for the biogas plant. This presumption received
a further boost, because the biogas plants in India were and are
still known by people as ‘Gobar Gas Plant.’ This name has been
an unfortunate nomenclature in the development of biogas
technology in this country, as it gave rise to the impression that
gas is possible only from Gobar (cattle dung).
We are aware that biogas is generated during the
anaerobic digestion of any naturally produced dead organic
matter. It is now high time that we start working more
vigorously on the use of organic feeds (which are at present a
wasted resource) other than cattle dung for biogas generation.
The earlier we do it, the better it will be.
The review of the cattle population in India gives some
interesting findings. Only about 15% families in the country
own 2 or more cattle heads. Therefore, it becomes obvious, that,
6
hardly about 10% population in the country (if all are ideally
covered) can manage to run biogas plants. If biogas technology
remains restricted to cattle dung feed, only the rich farmers will
benefit from the biogas technology. The poor and weaker
sections of the society will remain deprived from the benefits of
biogas.
We can take the benefits of biogas technology to these
deprived people only if, we are able to use alternative feeds
(other than cattle dung) for the production of biogas. Further, it
is also necessary to think in terms of establishing community
biogas production facilities.
When we think in terms of use of alternative feeds, the
existing technology has to be modified to suit the alternative
feeds. Unfortunately, the technology in use for cattle dung feed
was used in toto for other feeds also. This resulted in several
problems. As a result, in many cases, the use of alternative
feeds was abandoned. This is a negative approach. To take a
more positive view, the parameters, the design criteria and
characteristics of the feed will have to be considered as a
package.
Many such alternative feeds are available. At present,
most of them are treated as an organic waste, a nuisance and
hazard. The biogas programme could be easily extended to a
wider section of population, if these alternative feeds are tapped
imaginatively and adequately.
Human nightsoil is one such alternative feed. At present,
human nightsoil treatment is a major sanitation problem in the
country. It is a major source of pollution, health hazard and
social injustice. It has become a nuisance to rural and urban
environment. Its effective treatment is becoming unmanageable.
7
If it is used imaginatively in biogas plant, it can become an asset
instead of a nuisance.
Realizing the importance of proper nightsoil disposal in
rural India, Mahatma Gandhi included it in his ‘gramsafai’ and
village upliftment programme. Sanitary disposal of nightsoil
was visualized to serve fold three purpose, viz. 1. emancipation
of scavenger community (Bhangi Mukti), 2. clean villages
(gram safai) and 3. production of manure (Khad nirmiti).
Proper treatment of human waste (Nightsoil) is an
essential requirement for better village sanitation and promotion
of health, with the ultimate objective of ‘Health for all.’
Recycled imaginatively, it can also partially meet the energy and
fertilizer needs of the country. Thus, the waste can turn into
wealth.
‘On site’ nightsoil treatment methods are very
satisfactory in developing countries as they obviate the process
of manual lifting, carriage and occasional spilling of faeces.
The aqua privy or septic tank latrines (an ‘on site’ disposal
method) which are essentially anaerobic digestion processes, are
increasingly being constructed in the country. Human nightsoil,
being a naturally occurring organic material, emits methane
containing gas (i.e. biogas, which is an asset, not a nuisance)
during anaerobic digestion in the septic tank. Unfortunately, no
attention is given to this component, while promoting the
construction of latrines. The gas emitted from these latrines is
considered as a ‘nuisance gas’ and is let off through as high a
vent as possible, polluting the air and depleting ozone layer.
Late Appasaheb Patwardhan took up human nightsoil
treatment this activity as a mission for his life. He worked
feverishly, since 1928, on the problem of nightsoil disposal,
8
devising in the process, several innovative designs for latrines
such as ‘Sopa Sandas’ (simple latrine), Gopuri latrine etc. and
subsequently biogas plants.
The technological design for a biogas plant to be used
for nightsoil feed must be suitable for the characteristics of
human nightsoil. In the initial stages, the design which was
found to be suitable for cattle dung was used for human
nightsoil without any change. Human nightsoil has physical,
chemical and microbial characteristics which markedly differ
from those of cattle dung. Therefore, the parameters, design
criteria etc. fixed for cattle dung biogas plants are not valid for
human nightsoil.
Late Appasaheb Patwardhan a dedicated Gandhian
worker, pioneered nightsoil based biogas plants in India, with
the construction of the first nightsoil based biogas plant at
Kankavli in Ratnagiri district of Maharashtra in 1953.
It was based on ‘Gramlaxmi’ design developed by Shri.
Jasbhai Patel in 1951 (which was adopted for propagation by
KVIC since 1962). Appasaheb Patwardhan worked further on
‘Gram laxmi’ design and modified this design for the use of
human nightsoil as a feed.
The design which he devised, was a water jacketed
digester with a floating dome gas holder. He termed it ‘water
jacket gas plant’ later called as ‘Gramgaurav gas plant’. This is
the design which is now known as ‘Floating Dome Water
Jacketed Digester’ design. Subsequently he constructed many
such plants throughout the country, creating a cadre of trained
social workers in the process.
The feasibility of ‘on site’ treatment of nightsoil in a
biogas plant was effectively demonstrated by him. He was a
9
visionary, quite ahead of his times. He constructed the first
nightsoil based biogas plant in India, at a girls’ hostel in
Kankavli.
The plant receives nightsoil directly via pipes (no
manual handling and exposure of nightsoil) from four adjacent
latrines which are being used by the inmates of the hostel. The
biogas is being used in the kitchen. The effluent slurry is being
used as a fertilizer for plantation.
The original plant at Kankavli still continues to function
satisfactorily even after nearly 35 years. This fact speaks
effectively for the suitability of the design and for the feasibility
of biogas generation from nightsoil.
Appasaheb Patwardhan, in his capacity as Chairman of
Bhangi Mukti Samiti of Gandhi Smarak Nidhi, tried to
popularize nightsoil fed biogas plants throughout the country
and also arranged for the subsidy to be paid by Gandhi Smarak
Nidhi headquarters in New Delhi.
After the biogas programme was taken up by D N E S, it
has given a positive boost for the propagation of nightsoil based
biogas plants.
In 1981, Dr. S. V. Mapuskar developed an innovative
design ‘MALAPRABHA BIOGAS PLANT’ for recovering
biogas from anaerobically digested human nightsoil. While
developing this design, he had taken into consideration the
relevant hygiene factors along with the parameters for
biomethanation of human nightsoil. The relevant social factors
and convenient latrine use also were considered.
These parameters could be enumerated as follows:
• There should not be any direct handling of nightsoil,
10
• Undigested nightsoil should not get exposed to
surroundings and should be inaccessible to insects and
animals,
• Aesthetically there should be freedom from odour and
unsightly conditions,
• There should not be any contamination of subsoil or
surface water,
• Surface soil should not get contaminated,
• Maintenance of the treatment process should be easy and
should not evoke any repulsive feelings,
• The recycling should give maximum possible
advantages,
• The social and behavioural aspects need to be tackled by
educational process.
Taking all the abovementioned parameters into
consideration, it is felt that for human nightsoil biomethanation,
only two designs are suitable:-
1. Floating dome water jacketed biogas plant developed by
Shri S.P. alias Appasaheb Patwardhan in 1953.
2. Fixed dome ‘Malaprabha Biogas Plant’ developed by Dr.
S.V. Mapuskar in 1981.
Malaprabha biogas plant has a cubical shape and hence
can be installed even inside the house. Latrine seat can be
installed above the biogas plant, minimizing the land
requirement. It is very easy for operation and maintenance. As a
result the design has been accepted widely.
Since 1981, hundreds of Malaprabha biogas plants have
been constructed. The results are very good. The plants have
been designed from 1 CuM capacity to 30 CuM capacity.
In Dehu village nearly 80 Malaprabha plants, working on
human nightsoil are functioning satisfactorily. Dehu is probably
11
the only village in India which has such a large number of
functioning nightsoil based biogas plants.
In the following pages ‘Malaprabha Biogas Plant’ design
is described.
12
Chapter 2: Introduction to ‘Malaprabha’
Any naturally grown dead organic matter generates
biogas after anaerobic digestion. However, so far, the stress has
been on using cattle dung as main feed material for the biogas
plant.
During the past few years, there has been a distinct
change in this attitude. The presently available designs were
designed mainly for the cattle dung feed. These designs may
not be the optimized designs for other feeds. Hence, the designs
need to be evolved so that the optimum conditions are created
for the utilization of these feeds within the right parameters.
Now the efforts are being made to decide on the parameters
which would be suitable for the use of feed materials other than
cattle dung.
Human nightsoil is one of the important and readily
available feed materials for biogas generation. The biogas
programme could be given an additional boost if the human
faeces are utilized for the biogas generation.
However, for the use of human night soil feed and for
the efficient functioning of human night soil based biogas plant,
the parameters and the design criteria as regards the procedures
for the feeding and handling the feed, the physical and chemical
characteristics of the feed, the movement of slurry, odour,
aesthetics, etc. need to be considered so as to create optimum
conditions for the use of human nightsoil. Further, from health
point of view, it will be necessary to see that the raw human
nightsoil is not exposed to environment, insects, animals etc.
and is not manually handled. During the digestion process, it
should not be exposed to environment. Further, the most
important parameter from health point of view will be the extent
13
of pathogen kill or pathogen inactivation achieved, during the
process so that the effluent is not pathogenic.
It may be necessary to accommodate such a biogas plant
in close proximity of the residence, perhaps in the house itself.
Thus, it may be desirably suitable for the space constraints and
the conventional cubical format of house construction. Further,
the cost of the unit and the space requirement could be
minimized if the biogas plant and the toilet seat are made into an
integrated unit where the toilet seat is superimposed on the
biogas plant, although offset toilet seat may be a requirement in
some situations.
Keeping these factors in mind, a new design specially
suitable for the human nightsoil has been evolved, by Dr. S. V.
Mapuskar, in 1980. After watching the performance for five
years, the design was presented at national conference on
‘Biogas from Human Waste’ organized by ‘CORT’ at New
Delhi from 22nd
Aug. 1985 to 23rd
Aug. 1985.
It is named as ‘MALAPRABHA BIOGAS PLANT. It
could be classified as a fixed dome biogas plant.
With a little modification, it can also be used for other
feeds.
14
Chapter 3: BASIS OF THE DESIGN
As stated earlier, the basis for the biogas plant
functioning on human nightsoil will necessarily differ from that
for the cattle dung based biogas plant.
Number of studies has already been done throughout the
world on the anaerobic digestion of human nightsoil. These
studies have been in the context of a human nightsoil disposal
system and not as a biogas generation system. However, since
these studies are for anaerobic digestion, such available data was
taken into consideration while developing this design.
1. Pathogenicity - The destruction or inactivation of the
pathogens will be a very important criterion for the biogas
system working on human nightsoil. The human faeces contain
various species of viruses, bacteria, protozoa as well as the
vegetative forms and ova of helminthes. It has been reported
that, for the inactivation and/or destruction of viruses, bacteria
and protozoa, a maximum period of about 45 days of anaerobic
digestion is necessary. Helminthes ova are not destructed in
anaerobic condition. However, they either float at the top or
sink to the bottom (depending on the species) in the digester.
Hence, in ‘Malaprabha’ design, the care has been taken to see
that the top and the bottom layers of the slurry do not flow
onwards and do not get in to the effluent. Thus, these ova are
retained in the plant and end in a natural death or inactivation
over a period of about two years. Thus, the effluent coming out
from the biogas plant of this design will be free from active
viable pathogens.
2. Direction of slurry flow - In biogas generation systems,
because of the buoyancy due to gas bubbles attached to slurry
particles and some other factors, there is a vertical up and down
15
movement in the slurry. However, the slurry getting in from the
inlet tends to push the digesting slurry in the digester towards
the outlet. It would be desirable not to have these two
movements in the same direction. It would be better if inlet to
outlet movement is horizontally directed. This sort of a
movement would be more akin to horizontal plug flow type of
movement. In this design, it has been arranged that the
movement of the slurry from inlet to outlet is in horizontal
direction.
The consistency and the physical characteristics of
human night soil are such that the diluted digesting slurry gets
stratified into three layers. The lighter material floats as a
suspension in upper ⅓rd portion. The heavier component settles
down in the lower ⅓rd portion. During the digestion process,
these materials tend to move up and down in vertical direction,
depending upon the attached gas bubbles, specific gravity etc.
However, the middle ⅓rd portion is found to be relatively free
from solids. Hence, in this design, care has been taken to see
that the horizontally forward movement of the digesting slurry is
from the middle ⅓rd portion. This more or less simulates the
plug flow pattern in horizontal direction, mainly from the
middle ⅓rd portion. The plant is designed to have three
horizontally interconnected chambers. This mode of movement
ensures that there is no short circuiting of incoming raw slurry.
Incidentally, slurry inlet and outlet pipes also serve as small
additional chambers regulating the flow.
16
17
3. Solid Content & Digester Volume - Available data shows
that for anaerobic digestion of human nightsoil, the optimum
solid contents need to be around 3% to 4 %, the variation being
between 2% to 5%. The fresh night soil has a solid content of
about 25%, varying between 20% to 30%. In Indians, the
average weight of fresh night soil per person/day is around 300
gm. It has been shown that the use of about 2·17 liters of water
per person/day would give an optimum solid content required
for the anaerobic digestion of slurry. Hence, this volume has
been taken as a basis for calculating the digester volume.
It has been noted that human nightsoil yields about 35 to
40 litres of biogas per person/day. Therefore, for getting 1 CuM
of biogas per day, it would be necessary to feed the night soil of
about 25 persons/day.
Thus, for a biogas plant having a capacity of producing
one CuM. Biogas per day, the digester volume should be
sufficient to accommodate the night soil of 25 persons per day
with input volume of 2·17 litres per person per day. Further,
the expected retention period required for the pathogen kill has
been taken as 45 days. This basis has been used for the
calculation of digester volume.
4. Scum Breaking & Allowance for Sedimentation – During
the digestion of slurry, the lighter solids will tend to form a
scum which will hamper the gas accumulation at the top. In
order to avoid this, a scum breaking arrangement has been
incorporated. This device consists of horizontally fixed PVC
pipe grid attached to the inlet pipe at a distance of 300mm from
the top. Every time the slurry moves up and down, this device
automatically breaks the scum accumulating on the top of the
slurry.
18
In order to prevent the helminth ova from escaping to the
second chamber, a very simple arrangement has been made at
the bottom. The displacement window between the first and
second chamber is partially closed at the bottom by placing
loose bricks up to height of 225 mm from the bottom. While
desludging the plant, these bricks can be removed so as to
facilitate the removal of the settled nondigestible sludge from
the first chamber.
5. Slurry Inlet Pipe – A 100 mm Dia. PVC pipe is embedded in
the R.C.C roof of the first chamber, with the help of M. S.
flanges and anchoring bolts, the pipe projecting in the chamber
to a depth of 700 mm from the roof. This ensures that the gas
does not escape through the inlet.
6. Gas Storage & Gas Outlet – The roof of the digester
chamber and the sides of the digester chamber are rendered gas
proof by cement plastering and by gas proofing treatment. Thus
the upper portion of the digestion chamber serves as a gas
storage space.
Gas outlet is fixed in the roof of the digester by
embedding it in R.C.C. roof with the help of flanges and
anchoring bolts. In order to avoid the blockage by the scum, the
diameter of gas outlet pipe is kept at 75 mm.
The continuously generating biogas will keep on
accumulating in the upper portion of the digestion chamber by
pushing the corresponding amount of slurry towards the second
chamber (Displacement chamber). As the slurry outlet level in
the third chamber is at the level of the top of the digestion
chamber, the accumulating gas in the digestion chamber will be
stored at a pressure exerted by the slurry column in the second
and third chambers which will be at a higher level than the
19
slurry level in the digestion chamber. (This action is similar to
the action in the other fixed dome designs.) The pressure on the
gas will vary between 0 to 30 cm water column.
7. Slurry Outlet Position – Slurry outlet pipe is placed in the
third chamber at the level of the roof of the digestion chamber.
Thus, when there is no gas in the gas storage space, the slurry
levels in all the three chambers will be at the outlet level.
8. Structural Provisions to Prevent Gas Leakage – As stated
earlier, the roof of the first chamber is cast in R.C.C., in which
the slurry inlet pipe and gas outlet pipe are embedded with the
help of M. S. flanges and anchoring bolts. PVC pipes are used.
In order to avoid the lifting of the edges of the slab, a brickwork
load is given on the edges of the slab. Also, anchoring for the
slab is provided in the top layer of the brickwork supporting the
slab. In order to minimize the stresses at the corners and joints,
the corners are rounded off with cement mortar plaster, thus
diverting the stresses. The joints between the brickwork and the
slab as well as slab and pipes are also rounded off in a similar
way.
9. Toilet Seats – As stated earlier, the toilet seat is placed on top
of the digestion chamber using load brickwork as a plinth. The
latrine pan is connected to the inlet pipe through the water seal
trap via inspection chamber.
If desired toilet seat may be placed off site. However, it
will increase the construction cost to that extent.
As it is necessary to restrict the use of water to about
2·17 litres per person, the water seal trap with only 20 mm water
seal is used. With this type of water seal, only 1·5 liters of
water is sufficient for flushing. Automatic flushing cistern is not
20
provided. If the situation demands, automatic flushing system
with low volume controlled flushing, can be used. Because of
the provision of water seal, there is no smell or odour from inlet
pipe. Further, the insects do not find an access to the system.
Some gases are likely to emanate from the inlet pipe. A
vent is provided for these gases. This vent also ensures that the
water seal is not disturbed by the negative pressure. An
inspection chamber provided between inlet pipe and the water
seal trap allows for the cleaning and maintenance of water seal
trap and inlet pipe whenever necessary.
The second and third chambers are completely covered.
Some gases are likely to accumulate in second and third
chambers. For these gases also a vent is provided. This vent is
combined with the vent from inlet chamber and a common vent
is taken above the roof of the latrine. Thus the system becomes
totally odourless.
10. Maintenance – The required routine maintenance is
minimal. Inspection chambers at inlet and outlet provide an
easy access for occasional cleaning. In this system it is not
necessary to manually handle the night soil. Once the night soil
gets past the water seal trap under the seat, it is not exposed to
environment anywhere in the system. After total digestion, the
end product in the form of harmless digested slurry comes out
from the slurry outlet.
Thus, in this design all the important requirements for
the biogas generation and hygienic requirements for human
night soil management are taken care of.
11. Safety – In comparison to LPG, biogas contains a mixture of
mainly methane and carbon-dioxide which is under very low
21
pressure ranging between 0 to 40cms water column. Further,
methane is not explosive, unless it is mixed with air and is under
very high pressure. Therefore, the biogas plant is very safe.
Further, in case, because of non use, more gas is stored in the
gas storage space, the pressure will never exceed 40 cms of
water column. It is because after the maximum storage space is
occupied, the excess gas escapes through inlet pipe and further
through the vent provided for inlet chamber and second and
third compartments. Therefore, this plant can be installed even
inside homes.
22
Chapter 4: Design Calculations
1. Basic Data –
i. Average weight of fresh human night soil –
300gm/person/day.
ii. Solid content -25% (varying between 20% to 30%).
iii. Quantity of biogas generated -35 to 40 litres/day/person.
iv. Optimum water use -2·17 litres/ person/day.
v. Desirable solid content of slurry – 3% to 5%.
2. Calculations for 1 CuM biogas/day – Daily feed for 1