Summer project report on Retail Insight and competition analysis for apparel Industry IN PARTIAL FULLFILMENT OF PGDM PROGRAMME OF BALAJI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT (BIMHRD) Under the Guidance of: Submitted by- Mr. Vishal Gaurav Deepak Shandil (Regional Manager, North) PGDM-MARKETING Rollno HRD250 Page | 1
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Summer project report on
Retail Insight and competition analysis for apparel Industry
IN PARTIAL FULLFILMENT OF PGDM PROGRAMME OF BALAJI INSTITUTE
OF MANAGEMENT AND HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT (BIMHRD)
This report bears the imprint of many people. Right from the experienced staff of Arvind Brands ltd. (ARROW) to the staff of without whose support and guidance I would have not got the unique opportunity to successfully complete my internship in this esteemed organization.
I take this opportunity to express my deep gratitude to all the employees of, Arvind Brands ltd. (Arrow) Also I am indebted for the rich guidance, knowledge and suggestions provided by my guide, Mr. Ankit Kumar who took sincere efforts and helped me in carrying out my internship.
I am gratified to Mr.Vishal Gaurav for their earnest coordination owing to which, I had the leg-up of undertaking the internship at the prominent organization, Arvind Brands ltd. (ARROW).
Last but not least, I also thank all those people whom I met in the industry during my internship and helped me to accomplish my assignments in the most efficient and effective manner.
Page | 3
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Sr. No.
Particulars Pg. No.
1 Company’s Certificate 2
2 Acknowledgement 3
3 Declaration 5
4 Executive Summary 6
5 Industry Profile 8
6 Company Profile 11
7 Research Objectives 16
8 Research Methodology 17
9 Retail in Practical 18
10 Footfall rate Analysis 19
11 Hourly Footfall rate analysis 21
12 Competitors Stock Report 23
13 Attribute based Perceptual Mapping 25
14 Market Share 28
15 Recommendations 29
16 Bibliography 30
17 Annexure 31
Page | 4
DECLARATION
I Deepak Shandil hereby declared that this project titled “ Retail Insight
and competition analysis for apparel Industry”, is submitted to Balaji
Institute of Management and Human Resource Management as a partial
requirement for the award of Degree of PGDM, during the year 2011 –
2012.
It is the record of an original & independent study carried out by me, under
the able guidance and supervision of Mr. Vishal Gaurav, Arvind Brands
LTD. (Arrow) This project report has not been submitted earlier by me or
by anybody else for the award of any other degree in any University in
India or abroad.
Date: Signature of the Student
Place: Pune (Deepak Shandil )
Page | 5
Executive Summary
There is growing competition between retail firms in post reform India.
Indian Retail Industry is standing at its point of inflexion; waiting for the
boom to take place. Retail market in India is full of brands and their outlets
adding on to cut throat competition.
Research was carried to find the competitive position of Arrow as a brand
in formal wear as well as in casual wear.
Through this report I was also able to understand, what are our Company’s
Arvind Brands ltd. (Arrow) positive and strong points, on the basis of
which we come to know what can be the basis for positioning in ours
customers mind. This project focuses on the strength areas of the company
while at the same time tries to identify the weak areas so that it can be
overcome. A comparative analysis of Arrow with other Retail Firms has
been done. I went for the field work, talked to customers and tracked their
responses about the effectiveness and efficiency of Arrow being a Formal
brand.
My job here was to analyze the footfall and gather information about
competitors stock. I have also worked as a part of sales force of the
company and sold lot of items during my stay of two months.
I have visited to many Arrow stores in Delhi. Most of the data has been
collected from the customers regarding their views about Arrow. Having
said that, a comparative study has carried out to see where Arrow stands in
the race for offering Products and services. I have been handling the profile
Page | 6
of Fashion Assistant at a store. I was also a part of tele calling team. Main
focus was on calling the potential customers of Arrow and inviting more of
them to our stores. Being a fashion Assistant and doing sales for the brand
is really interesting and worth appreciating. I have concentrated on sales
and even interacting with customers to get an idea about Arrow as a formal
brand. Interaction with the customers helped to know the image of the
company in the minds of the customers and it helped me to come up with
suggestions to further improve the services of the company. I hope my
findings are useful for the company.
Page | 7
INTRODUCTION
Indian Retail Industry is standing at its point of inflexion; waiting for the
boom to take place. The Indian retail industry is divided into organized and
unorganized sectors. Organized retailing refers to trading activities
undertaken by licensed retailers, that is, those who are registered for sales
tax, income tax, etc. These include the corporate-backed hypermarkets and
retail chains, and also the privately owned large retail businesses.
Unorganised retailing, on the other hand, refers to the traditional formats
of low-cost retailing, for example, the local kirana shops, owner manned
general stores, convenience stores, hand cart and pavement vendors, etc.
Growth in Retail from 1997 – 2007 -: India in 1997 allowed foreign direct
investment (FDI) in cash and carry wholesale. Then, it required
government approval. The approval requirement was relaxed, and
automatic permission was granted in 2006. Between 2000 to 2010, Indian
retail attracted about $1.8 billion in foreign direct investment, representing
a very small 1.5% of total investment flow into India. Single brand retailing
attracted 94 proposals between 2006 and 2010, of which 57 were
approved and implemented. For a country of 1.2 billion people, this is a
very small number.
Growth in retail 2011 onwards: - Organized retailing has become more
popular in big cities in India and most of the metropolitan cities and other
big cities are flooded by modern organized retail stores. Many semi rural
areas have also witnessed entry of such organized retail outlets. Indian
retail sector is estimated to touch US$ 833 billion by 2013 and US$ 1.3
trillion by 2018, with CAGR of 10%, which is quite lucrative. Organized
Page | 8
retail market in India is expected to reach US$ 50 Billion mark by 2011.
Number of shopping malls is expected to increase at a CAGR of more than
18.9% by 2015. Retail sector in India adds on to 10% of the GDP and also it
employs almost 8% of India’s employable population.
Indian Apparel Industry: - The size of the Indian apparel market has
increased from USD 17,803 million in 2003 onwards to USD 32,458 million
in 2011 at a CAGR of 10.5%. During 2007-2009, the industry registered a
double digit growth rate. Individuals have become more conscious
regarding their outerwear and are willing to spend more on the apparels.
Over the years the expenditure has increased from USD 16.2 in 2003 to
USD 27.2 in 2009, registering a CAGR of 9.0%. Menswear was the largest
segment with a market share of 43.1% and the value of USD 13,974 million.
Out of the total apparel market of USD 32,458 million, Women’s wear
commands a market share of 37.5% followed by Kids wear boys with
10.2% and Kids wear girls with 9.2%
In the study, among 24 popular locations for organized retail in India,
Mumbai was found to be the most preferred location as 7% of the
respondent companies reported to have retail stores/ outlets in Mumbai,
and 6.5% respondents had stores/outlets in Bangalore. Nonetheless, the
northern region is also popular among these companies as 35.6% of the
companies denoted their preference to have their retail stores in the
northern region. This region has been riding high on the success of the IT
and ITeS-BPO companies operating in the region, especially the NCR that
has witnessed a spurt in the development of shopping malls, which appears
as the primary reason for the region’s increasing preference among
retailers.
Page | 9
Need of Retailing: - Retail had played an important role in distribution
from ages. This part of distribution ensures that products of manufacturer
reach to its end users effectively and efficiently. It provides wide choice to
its customer as retailer is the best person who can anticipate the need of
customers. Also it takes care of the quantity, since customers do not seek
bulk orders; they need in small number which is ensured by retailer.
Sometimes retailer also ensures credit facility and they also assure regular
supply of goods.
There is no universally accepted distribution network, however flowchart
mentioned above is an ideal channel network which can be found across
organizations. The above Flowchart also describes the importance of
retailing. It clearly signifies that retailing is the closest point of exchange
available to customer. Thus, for a company which indulges into this part of
distribution network it should be a priority. The market intermediaries
play an important role in the development of market by providing different
types of services.
Page | 10
Manufacturer Distributor Retailer Customer
Arvind Brands ltd : Profile
Arvind Ltd is the largest cotton textiles manufacturer and exporter in
India. They are the leading player in the branded garments in the
domestic market. The company's principal business consists of
manufacturing and marketing of Denim Fabric, Shirting Fabric, Shrits,
Knitted Fabric and Garments. The company having the rights to market
international brands such as Lee, wrangler, Arrow and Tommy Hilfiger
in India. The company has also owns popular brands such as Newport,
Flying Machine, Excalibre and Ruf & Tuf. They are having their
production facilities at Ahmedabad, Mehsana, Gandhinagar in Gujarat,
Pune in Maharashtra and Bangalore in Karnataka. Arvind Ltd was
incorporated in the year 1931 as Arvind Mills Ltd by three brothers
Kasturbhai, Narottambhai and Chimanbhai. In the year 1934, they
established themselves amongst the foremost textile units in the
country. They are first company to bring globally accepted fabrics such
as Denim, yarn dyed shriting fabrics & wrinkle free gaberdines to India
Page | 11
in the year 1986. In the year 1987, they started retail outlets for 'Arrow'
brand and became the first company to bring international shrit brand
'Arrow' to India. The company joint venture includes their echnical and
marketing alliance with F M Hammerie Von-Ogensver Waltungs, Austria,
the US based Alamac Knit Fabrics & Spinners and Webexi Dict Turt,
Switzerland. Arvind Mills in 1985 has diversified into electronics by
setting up a plant to manufacture electronic telephone exchanges
(EPABX). They also entered into marketing pharmaceutical products
and B&W and colour television sets under the name Pyramid. During the
year 2001-02, the compnay increased the number of Spindles and
Stitching Machines by 2036 Nos and 38 Nos respectively. In the next
year, they further increased the number of Stitching machines by 7 Nos.
During the year 2003-04, the company expanded their shirts
manufacturing capacity from 2.4 million pieces to 4.8 million pieces per
annum. During the same year, their subsidiary company, Arvind
Spinning Ltd commenced their operation. In March 2005, the company
commenced their operations of producing Jeans Pant in Bangalore with
the installed capacity of 4 million Pcs per annum. During the year 2005-
06, new Denim collection was launched which was aimed at the Super
Premium brands of the USA, Europe, Japan & Korea. The response to this
collection was good and they have opened new venues for the Denim
division. The company demerged and transfered the Garments Business
Division of their 100% subsidiary company, Arvind Brands Ltd and
amalgamate Arvind Fashions Ltd, a 100% subsidiary of Arvind Brands
Ltd with themselves with effect from April 1, 2006. Also The company
has a joint venture company namely Arvind Murjani Brand Pvt Ltd,
through which they hold license to sell Tommy Hilfiger brand apparel in
India. The operations of Arvind Brands Limited and their subsidiaries
Page | 12
were merged with the Company with effect from April 1, 2006. The
wholesale branded apparel business of Arvind Fashions Ltd has been
sold to VF Arvind Brands Pvt Ltd with effect from August 31, 2006. In
March 2008, the company signed a exclusive license agreement with
The Philips-Van Heusen Corporation for designing, distribution and
reatiling of IZOD brand apparels in India. From May 2008, the company
name was changed from Arvind Mills Ltd to Arvind Ltd.
Page | 13
Arrow: - an overview
Since 1851, Cluett, Peabody & Co., Inc. (a subsidiary of PVH) and its
predecessors have been producing shirts for the American man. Since its
introduction in 1885, Cluett’s ARROW brand has been a cornerstone in the
American men’s dress shirt business, defining authentic American style.
ARROW commands extraordinary brand recognition for its fashionable yet
functional apparel, and consistently ranks in the top 50 in consumer brand
awareness in the United States.
Today’s ARROW shirt began as the once revolutionary idea that a collar
could detach from its shirt, giving women an easier way to clean their
husbands’ stained shirt collars without laundering the entire shirt. From
this idea, born by Mrs. Hannah Montague in her home in Troy, NY, grew an
internationally acclaimed dress shirt brand. Today, ARROW is licensed in
55 countries and offers a broad assortment of men’s, women’s, and
children’s apparel and apparel-related products. The brand’s look and
appeal reflect a youthfulness and optimism that embody the American
spirit.
With a heritage dating back to 1851, Cluett, Peabody & Co., Inc. is
celebrating its 160th anniversary of selling superior quality apparel. In
1820, Mrs. Hannah Montague created the first detachable shirt collar in her
home in Troy, NY as a way of cleaning her husband’s collar without
laundering the entire shirt. In 1851, Ebenezer Brown recognized the
possibilities in the detachable collar industry and began manufacturing
Page | 14
collars in the back of his general store in Troy and the predecessor to the
original Cluett, Peabody & Co., Inc. was born. This modest beginning would
eventually lead to the introduction of the ARROW brand in 1885 as a
pioneer in men’s fashion.
Arrow: - In India
Arvind Clothing Ltd., a subsidiary of Arvind Brands Ltd., a member of the
Ahmedabad-based Lalbhai Group, signed up with the 150-year old Arrow
Company, a division of Cluett Peabody & Co. Inc., U.S., for licensed
manufacture of Arrow shirts in India. Arrow's first plant, with a 55,000 sq.
ft. area and capacity to make 3,000 to 4,000 shirts a day, was established at
Bangalore in 1993 with an investment of Rs. 18 crores. The over two-
dozen quality check points during the conversion of fabric to finished shirt
was unique to the industry at that point of time. It is among the very few
plants in the world that makes shirts with 2 ply 140s and 3 ply 100s cotton
fabrics using 16 to 18 stitches per inch. The reputation of this plant has
spread far and wide and now it is loaded mostly with export orders from
renowned global brands such as GAP, Next, Espiri and the like.
In fact, the demand pressure from global brands which want to outsource
from Arvind Clothing Ltd. is so great that the company has had to set up
another large factory for export jobs on the outskirts of Bangalore.
Page | 15
RESEARCH OBJECTIVES
Our research study has two objectives:-
PRIMARY OBJECTIVE: To study about the competitive position of
Arrow as a brand in Competitive apparel Market.
SECONDARY OBJECTIVE: -
1. To know about the customers footfall in different locations.
2. To study about the effectiveness & efficiency of Arrow in
relation to its competitors.
3. To know the market Share of Arrow in competitive market.
Page | 16
Research Methodology
Sampling design
Types of sampling
Convenience Sampling
Research Approach
Descriptive approach
Techniques to be used in research approach
Survey and interview
Sampling Unit
Questionnaire
In this project Questionnaire is used as the research instrument. These questionnaires include Close Ended as well as Open Ended questions. The questionnaire is attached at the end of Annexure.
Data collection
Primary Data Collection
Structured questionnaire for the customer.
Secondary data collection
Web-sites
Page | 17
Retail in Practical
Note: - Above chart states different concepts practiced in retail. Concepts
highlighted are the ones which I came across during my stay of 2 months. I
would also like to know about the remaining ones; however, due to time
constraint it was not possible for me to cover all of them.
Page | 18
RetailSupply Chain Visual MerchandisingPromotionsEnd of Season salesFootfall
RetailTargetsSalesKeeping StockRole of ITReportingCustomer service
RetailFinding Key Store LocationReplinishmentStore operationsCompeting Brandscustomer loyalty programs
Footfall Rate analysis
It is a key factor while choosing a location of a store; however, lot depends
upon the footfall at a location. Store should operate at a place where
footfall is high. Higher will be the footfall higher will be the chances of
conversion and higher will be sales leading to higher profits. Generally
footfall is high at places like malls or in markets which are in existence for a
very long time. While analyzing the footfall an organization must keep the
track of the clients coming in because footfall can be higher at number of
places but the category of customers do matter end of the day.
Footfall rate analysis across Arrow Stores in June
Stores Cannaught
place store
SouthX
Store
Ambience
Mall Store
JankakPuri
Store
Shipra mall
Store
Total no. of
Walk-ins 450 82 170 39 69
Conversion
by head count 17.77% 36.58% 17.64% 28.20% 17.39%
Conversion
by footfall 29.09% 50.84% 25.40% 47.82% 25.53%
Page | 19
Note: - Above table shows conversion rates across all the Arrow store in June 2012
Conclusion:-
Foot fall rate has drastically come down in comparison to the month
of May. Conversion rate across the entire stores in May was 60 to 70
percent, however, June it has shown a downfall and has reached to 30
percent on an average.
Walk-ins at CP store are high, but conversion rate is not so good since
it is market for masses it attract people but conversion are still very
less.
Foot fall suddenly increases after 5:00PM at all the stores.
Week offs are the days when footfall is at its peak. On an average it
shows an increase of 5% in footfall from normal days.
Janakpuri and Noida store has lowest footfall among all the stores.
Page | 20
Hourly Footfall rate analysis across Arrow Stores
Note: - Above table shows footfall rates at different arrow stores in June 2012. Numbers
mentioned in Black are the number of walk-ins and numbers mentioned in blue are actual
customers converted. Boxes highlighted with color represent the time slot in which
conversions were highest in a particular store.
Page | 21
Stores 10:00AM-
12:00PM
12:00PM-
3:00PM
3:00PM-
6:00PM
6:00PM-
9:00PM
Conversion
in
percentage
Cannaught
place
store
Meeting
Meeting
41
8
58
11
55
11
20.12%
Ambience
Mall Store
4
0
15
4
24
4
24
3
16.41%
Southx
Store
0
0
15
3
22
9
35
11
31.94%
Janakpuri
Store
1
0
3
0
8
2
9
3
23.80%
Noida sec
18 Store
0
0
0
0
6
1
19
5
24%
Shipra
Mall Store
3
2
11
4
19
1
16
3
20.40%
Conclusion:-
It can be noticed that most of the stores get to see more number of
customers during 6:00PM to 9:00PM in the evening.
It was also noticed that lowest footfall was between 10:00AM to
12:00PM. Probably the reason is the morning time when people are
busy in office and daily chaos.
All the stores get highest number of conversions during 6:00PM to
9:00PM.
Shipra and Ambience mall stores show a different trend in terms of
conversion. Conversion rates were high during day time. Reason
could be the society’s and offices around these areas which attracts
people during day time.
Noida and Janakpuri stores sometimes find it hard to see even a
single customer in an hour, which impact their performance.
Southx has the highest conversion rate and credit goes to the loyal
customers who visit 8 year old store regularly.
Page | 22
Competitor’s Stock Report
A detailed research was carried out to find out current stock in hand detail
with competitors. Research was carried in both casuals and formal wear.
This report will enable us to know the exact units available in different
categories. More than that report also provides details about number of
style codes available and price range of different items as well. Brands who
were surveyed and researched are Louis Phillips and Van Heusen in
Formals in formal category and US Polo and Allen Solly in Casuals.
Note: - Above chart shows the brands on which the research was carried out.
Page | 23
FormaLWear
Louis PhillipsVan
Heusen
CasualWear
Allen Solly
US Polo
Conclusion: - (Refer annexure 2A -2D)
In formal segment Van Heusen and Louis Phillips were surveyed.
Both of them had a good stock and it was well organized.
Louis Phillips price ranges from 1599-8000(in Rs). Louis Phillips
concentrates on a segment of people who are working and need
formals Monday to Friday.
Louis Phillips also has a premium collection called Luxury which
costs from 3500 to 8000 (in Rs). On an average they had 10-15
options in each category.
Van Heusen target people who want to look more professional. They
also have premium collections like Pearl and Heritage which ranges
from 4000 t0 7000 (in Rs). They provide lot of variety in checks when
it comes to half sleeves shirts.
Van Heusen is more organized in keeping its stock and one can easily
find out the entire items kept in the store for display.
When it comes to casual wear Allen Solly has a lot better stock then
Us Polo. Allen Solly is focused on Monday to Friday casual wear and
they also have premium collections like Podigy and Celebration.
US Polo is a low cost brand as compared to Allen Solly and does have
a limited variety as compared to Allen Solly.
Page | 24
Attribute based perceptual Mapping
Perceptual Mapping helps you to find Unique Selling Preposition (USP). It
also tells what can be the possible Unique Selling Prepositions and also if
we have any chance or scope of introducing new product. It helps in finding
out how brand is perceived by customers on various attributes. The
average factor scores for each brand that is retail stores in this case will be
considered as co-ordinates of brands in perceptual map.
Points representing attributes will be joined by arrows starting from origin
of the graph. Arrows indicate the attributes used by the respondents in
evaluating the brands. Favorable opinion on the brand will be direction of
the arrow whereas unfavorable opinion will be on the opposite direction of
the arrow.
A research was carried out on 5 brands to prepare a perceptual map. Map
will allow us to understand market gaps and brand perceptions of
customers. It will also help us to know what are the strong points for a
brand and where is it lacking. Map will also put across different brand
positioning and their USP. Brands considered for this perceptual map were
Arrow, Louis Phillips, Zodiac, Black Berrys and Van Heusen.
Page | 25
Customers were asked to rate these brands on 5 attributes. Those 5
attributes were Quality, Brand Image, Comfort, Service and Variety. Survey
was conducted through a questioner with 32 respondents.
Perceptual Map
Note: - Above perceptual map shows different brands and their perceptions in the mind of
customers. Data was collected using questionnaire at different locations.
Page | 26
Conclusion: - (Refer Annexure 3a-3b)
Map put clear picture about all the brands including Arrow. Based on
the responses of respondents it was noticed that Arrow is considered
to be a brand with high degree of quality and service.
However, it was not rated so good on Brand Image and comfort.
Louis Phillips and Van Heusen were rated very high on these
attributes. Also Arrow was rated low on Variety.
There are some gaps available in market where Arrow can approach
and can make those gaps useful.
Arrow should try to come up with Variety as there is not too much
competition and people do ask for variety.
Arrow should also try to build on Brand Image. For sustaining in long
run Arrow must build a strong brand image.
Service and quality are two attributes where arrow is strong and
must focus on them to create a USP in customers mind.
Page | 27
Market Share (Refer annexure 3a)
A model was used to find out market share of Arrow and other brands.
Based on the data gathered by questionnaire market share was found. This
model is known as “Share of Wallet”. Respondents were asked to rate 5
brands. Based on the responses market share was calculated. This method
is also called “Estimated Purchase Probability ratio”. This model is based
on a probability of a purchase by a customer.
Market Share of five major brands is as follows:-
Page | 28
26.06%
25.58%21.41%
13.73%
13.13%
Market Shares
Louis PhillipsArrowVan HeusenZodiacBlack Berrys
Note: - Above table shows market shares of different brands. It can be noticed that Louis
Phillips tops the table followed by Arrow and Van Heusen.
Recommendations Arrow being a good brand should build on service and quality to
create a differentiator. There are lots of areas where Arrow need to work hard. Brand Image,
Variety and Comfort are some of the areas where Arrow as a brand needs to work a lot.
Stock is a real problem with Arrow. It takes lot of time for replenishment. It was observed that lot of customers were lost due to unavailability of sizes. It is a major problem which needs an attention from the management.
During sale store is packed with lot of stock which is again a problem since it is hard to display everything and lot of stock remains unnoticed.
Page | 29
Also Company should go for advertisements which will attract masses.
Also associations with starts or personalities whom people follow can help the brand. New York collection was one such initiative and company should look for many more.
Women section has really contributed to total sale and more emphasis should be given to increase sales from this section.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
www . g o o g le . com
www . w i k e p e d i a. com
WWW.arvindmills.com
Page | 30
Annexure (1a)QUESTIONNAIRE
Dear
Customer,
As a Management Trainee currently working with Edelweiss Broking I want to
thank you for giving us the opportunity to serve you. Please help us serve you
better by taking a couple of minutes to tell us about the service that you have
received so far. We appreciate your business and want to make sure we meet your
Checks 15 2 30 Prints Bottoms Non-Denim Slim Fit Straight Fit Boot Cut Tapered 1 8 8 1899-2249 Bottoms Denim Slim Fit Straight Fit 1 4 4 1899-2999 Boot Cut Skinny Fit Short's Solid 1 3 3 1699-2099 Check 3 1 3 Print
Annexure (2d)
US Polo
Note: - Above sheet shows the stock available with US Polo when the store was visited.
Annexure (3a)
Page | 37
Note: - Above Graph shows different brands on service attribute. It clearly shows that Arrow is considered better in service as compared to other brands. Similarly it can be done for all the attributes.
Annexure (3b)
Page | 38
Note: - Above Graph shows different brands on service attribute. It clearly shows that Louis Phillips and Van Heusen are considered better in Comfort as compared to other brands.
Page | 39
Annexure (4a)
Estimated Purchase Probability ratio Model
[1-avg rating for a brand/no. of brands+1] * [2/no. of brands]