This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
172 Tallawong Road Rouse Hill NSW 0 22 May 2017
MacKay Tree Management 37 Duntroon Street Hurlstone Park NSW 2193
JS Architects on behalf of their client Northern West Pty Ltd have commissioned MacKay Tree
Management to assess trees located on the site 172 Tallawong Road, Rouse Hill (the subject site).
JS Architects are proposing a two block, home unit development for the site. The development
comprises demolition of the existing buildings, tree removal and construction of two, six storey flat
buildings made up of 115 units and two levels of basement parking.
Twenty nine (29) site trees are over three (3) metres in height and are within five (5) metres of the
proposal and are the subject trees of this report.
The report assesses the twenty nine trees and provides basic arboricultural data for each tree;
species type, dimensions, health and condition and retention value.
This report and any works recommended herein are to form part of the Development Application
to Blacktown City Council.
2. Assessment Methods
A visual tree assessment (VTA) 1. was carried out from the ground by a level 5 Consulting Arborist
on 19 My 2017.
Tree height and age was estimated and Diameter at Breast Height (D.B.H.) was measured 1.4
metres (m.) above ground.
No tree root investigation or soil exploration was undertaken.
Tree Protection Zones and Protection Methods are referenced from Standard® AS 4970 - 2009
Protection of Trees on Development Sites. 2.
The report has relied upon the following plan/s and documents:
Plan/Document Designer Drawing No. Date
Drawings J S Architects 00/22 – 22/22 23/03/2017
3. Legislation
The site abuts 160 Tallawong Road to the east which holds Shale Plains Woodland vegetation
classified as a Critically Endangered Ecological Community under the Environment Protection
and Biodiversity Conservation Act (EPBC) 1999 and the NSW Threatened Species Conservation
Act 1995.
172 Tallawong Road is zoned R3 medium density residential as part of the Cudgegong Road
Structure Plan, North West Rail Link (Rapid Transit Rail Facility, Tallawong Road, Rouse Hill.
Environmental Impact Statement July 2013). (Cudgegong Road Structure Plan, North West Rail
Link (Rapid Transit Rail Facility, Tallawong Road, Rouse Hill. Environmental Impact Statement July
2013)).
Tallawong Road Rouse Hill is rated as a Development Area as part of the North West Growth
Centre (NSW Planning, Sydney Growth Centres Strategic Assessment, Program Report November
2010).
Government Directions and Policy for the Growth Centres has Biodiversity Certification over the
State Environment Planning Policy (Sydney Region Growth Centres) 2006, (Growth Centres SEPP)
allowing development to proceed without NSW threatened species assessment.
To compensate for loss of threatened conservation areas NSW Planning will acquire new land for
conservation area reinstatement.
172 Tallawong Road Rouse Hill NSW 2 22 May 2017
4 Report Findings and Recommendations
The site is zoned for R3 Medium Density Residential Dwelling.
The twenty nine site trees require removal to make way for the 115 unit development.
The trees are exempt from environmental controls under the Growth Centres SEPP.
The location of the Proposed Sub – Divisional Roads provides a short term Tree Protection Zone for
boundary trees Nos 151 and 160 Tallawong Road.
Removal of the twenty nine trees is recommended.
Cheryl MacKay
Advanced Certificate of Horticulture, Diploma of Arboriculture, Certificate in Tree Surgery
Founding Member I.A.C.A (ACM0062003), I.S.A (Member 200984) & L.G.T.R.A.
Level 5 Qualified and Practicing Arborist/Horticulturist since 1995
Qualified Tree Risk Assessor (TRAQ 2016)
DISCLAIMER I have no vested interest in any forthcoming tree works or actions carried out from
recommendations made in this report. The report is an independent assessment of the trees and
does not reflect the opinions of the owner. The author does not receive commission to prune or
remove the trees which are the subject trees of this report.
Information contained in this report covers only those trees assessed. It reflects their condition at the
time of assessment. The inspection was limited to a Visual Assessment without dissection, excavation,
probing or core drilling. By the nature of their size, weight and miscellaneous structure, constant
exposure to the weather and the elements, susceptibility to insects, pest and decay organisms, trees
always pose an inherent degree of hazard and risk from breakage or failure. Recommendations
made by MacKay Tree Management are intended to minimise, reduce or eliminate hazardous
conditions associated with the trees.
There is no guarantee, expressed or implied, that problems or deficiencies of the subject trees may
not arise in the future
172 Tallawong Road Rouse Hill NSW 3 22 May 2017
Appendices
Appendix 1: Tree Survey 4, 5, 6
Appendix 2: References 6
Appendix 3: Site Plan indicating Tree Locations 7
Appendix 4: General Tree Protection Measures 8
Appendix 5: Tree Significance Assessment Criteria (STARS) 9
Appendix 6: Retention Value Priority Matrix 10
Appendix 7: Matrix - Sustainable Retention Index Value 11
Vigour Class and Condition Class
Appendix 8: Glossary of Terms 12, 13
172 Tallawong Road Rouse Hill NSW 4 22 May 2017
Appendix 1 Tree Survey 172 Tallawong Road Rouse Hill
Tree
No.
Genus/species
Common Name
Height
Spread
D.B.H.
mm
Age Crown Form
Condition
Vigour STARS
Sign.
Observations/ Condition of Trees
1 Eucalyptus molluccana
Grey Box
17
10
480 M Codominant
Asymmetrical
Normal High Street boundary planting, forest form tree with significant size.
2 Corymbia maculata
Spotted Gum
16
10
200
320
M Codominant
Asymmetrical
Normal High Street boundary planting, forest form tree with significant size.
3 Pinus radiata
Monterey Pine
4
5
340 M Dominant
Symmetrical
Normal Low Weed tree lopped for powerline clearance
4 Eucalyptus paramattensis
Parramatta/Drooping Red
Gum
11
9
400
420
M Dominant
Symmetrical
Low Low Forest tree with 30% canopy cover, 20% epicormics and holding large size,
large volume of deadwood. Crown dieback, dead 1st order limb to 350 mm
diameter.
5 Jacaranda mimosifolia
Jacaranda
4
4
220 Semi Suppressed
Asymmetrical
Normal Low Suppressed tree with poor condition.
6 Melaleuca linariifolia
Snow in Summer
5
4
240 M Intermediate
Symmetrical
Normal Low Small tree with average condition
7 Pinus radiata
Monterey Pine
4
5
240 M Suppressed
Symmetrical
Normal Low Weed tree lopped for powerline clearance
8 Eucalyptus punctata
Grey Gum
13
7
410 M Suppressed
Symmetrical
Low Low Trunk wound ground to 2.5 m. exposed heartwood, 20% epicormic growth,
suspect termite activity.
9 Corymbia citriodora
Lemon Scented Gum
15
7
300 300
at .5m.
M Codominant
Asymmetrical
Normal Medium Street boundary planting, forest form tree with significant size.
10 Corymbia citriodora
Lemon Scented Gum
14
11
200 310
450 at
.5m.
Codominant
Asymmetrical
Normal High Street boundary planting, forest form tree with significant size.
11 Corymbia citriodora
Lemon Scented Gum
17
8
420 Codominant
Asymmetrical
Normal High Street boundary planting, forest form tree with significant size.
172 Tallawong Road Rouse Hill NSW 5 22 May 2017
Tree
No.
Genus/species
Common Name
Height
Spread
D.B.H.
mm
Age Crown Form
Condition
Vigour STARS
Sign.
Observations/ Condition of Trees
12 Corymbia citriodora
Lemon Scented Gum
16
10
300 410
at .5m.
Codominant
Asymmetrical
Normal High Street boundary planting, forest form tree with significant size.
13 Eucalyptus punctata
Grey Gum
6
5
240 Semi Suppressed
Asymmetrical
Normal Low Small tree suppressed by dominant canopy.
STAND
14
Eucalyptus punctata
Grey Gum +
Corymbia citriodora
Lemon Scented Gum
3 – 10
x
3 - 8
150 – 350 M Codominant
Asymmetrical
Normal High Neighbouring property No 151 Tallawong Road, stand of 16 trees lining edge
of dam.
15 Allocasuarina torulosa
Forest She Oak
8
6
340 M Codominant
Symmetrical
Normal Medium Forest tree.
16 Melaleuca linariifolia
Snow in Summer
7
6
330 at
1m.
M Codominant
Symmetrical
Normal Low Stunted, small tree reaching full maturity.
17 Melia azedarach
White Cedar
4.5
6
280 at .5
m.
M Intermediate
Asymmetrical
Normal Low Stunted weed species.
18 Juniperus Sabina
Savin Juniper
4
7
multi M Intermediate
Symmetrical
Normal Low Low ornamental conifer.
19 Syagrus romanzoffianum
Cocos Palm x 2 palms
7
4
400 M Dominant
Symmetrical
Normal Low 2 x weed species.
20 Macadamia integrifolia
Macadamia Nut tree
6
7
320 at
base
M Intermediate
Asymmetrical
Normal Low Small native nut tree with moderate amenity and retention value.
21 Casuarina
cunninghamiana
River She Oak
9
6
420 M - OM Codominant
Symmetrical
Normal Low Small forest tree reaching full maturity, with poor structure.
22 23
24
X Cupressocyparis
leylandii
Leyland Cypress x 3 trees
6
4
250
average
M - OM Codominant
Asymmetrical
Normal Low Nuisance conifers.
25 Eucalyptus melliodora
Yellow Box
17
12
380 350
from
base
Semi Suppressed
Asymmetrical
High Medium Neighbouring property No 151 Tallawong Road. Tree with poor vigour and
declining condition.
172 Tallawong Road Rouse Hill NSW 6 22 May 2017
Appendix 2
References
1. A Visual Tree Assessment (VTA) is a systematic method of identifying tree characteristics and hazard potential recognised by The International Society of Arboriculture.
Journal of Arboriculture, Vol. 22, No. 6, November 1996.
The VTA was formulated by Mattheck and Breloer and described in, - Mattheck, C. and Breloer, H (2001) The Body Language of Trees a Handbook for Failure Analysis,
Department of Transport, Local Government and the Regions. London, Research for Amenity Trees No. 4.
2. Standards Australia 2009, Australian Standard 4970 Protection of trees on development sites, Standards Australia, Sydney, Australia.
3. Draper BD and Richards PA 2009, Dictionary for Managing Trees in Urban Environments, Institute of Australian Consulting Arboriculturists (IACA), CSIRO Publishing,
Collingwood, Victoria, Australia.
Tree
No.
Genus/species
Common Name
Height
Spread
D.B.H.
mm
Age Crown Form
Condition
Vigour STARS
Sign.
Retention
Value
Observations/ Condition of Trees
26 Eucalyptus crebra
Narrow Leaved Ironbark
18
14
200 400
from .5
m.
M Codominant
Symmetrical
Normal High Medium Neighbouring property No 151 Tallawong Road. Large forest tree.
27 Eucalyptus molluccana
Grey Box
17
15
Multi
from
base
M Codominant
Symmetrical
Normal High Medium Neighbouring property No 151 Tallawong Road. Dominant forest
tree
28 Eucalyptus punctata
Grey Gum
17
12
350
450
M Codominant
Symmetrical
Normal Medium Low On eastern boundary with No 160 Tallawong Road
29 Eucalyptus punctata
Grey Gum
18
13
450 M Codominant
Asymmetrical
Normal Medium Low On eastern boundary with No 160 Tallawong Road
172 Tallawong Road Rouse Hill NSW 7 22 May 2017
Appendix 3
SITE PLAN – Indicating Tree Locations Trees 1 – 29 - Canopies are indicative only.
25
Tree13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 Tree 1
17
16
15
24
23
22
19 20
18 21
Stand
14
26
27
28
Tree
29
Tallawong Road
172 Tallawong Road Rouse Hill NSW 8 22 May 2017
Appendix 4 General Tree Protection Measures
4.1 Tree Protection Fencing
The Protective fencing where required may delineate the TPZ and should be located as determined
by the project or council arborist.
Fencing should be erected before any machinery or materials are brought onto the site and before
the commencement of works including demolition.
Once erected, protective fencing must not be removed or altered without approval by the project
or council arborist.
The TPZ must be secured to restrict access.
AS 4687 Temporary fencing and hoardings specifies applicable fencing requirements.
Shade cloth or similar should be attached to reduce the transport of dust, other particulate matter
and liquids into the protected area.
Fence posts and supports should have a diameter greater than 20 mm and be located clear of
roots.
Existing perimeter fencing and other structures may be suitable as part of the protective fencing.
Chain wire mesh panels with shade cloth attached, held in place with concrete feet.
Alternative plywood or wooden paling fence panels. The fencing material also prevents building
materials or soil entering the TPZ.
Mulch installation across surface of TPZ (at the discretion of the project arborist).
No excavation, construction activity, grade changes, surface treatment or storage of materials of
any kind is permitted within the TPZ.
Bracing is permissible within the TPZ. Installation of supports should avoid damaging roots.
4.2 Activities Restricted within the TPZ
Activities generally excluded from the TPZ included but are not limited to -
Machine excavation including trenching;
Excavation for silt fencing;
Cultivation;
Storage;
Preparation of chemicals, including preparation of cement products;
Parking of vehicles and plant;
Refuelling;
Dumping of waste;
Wash down and cleaning of equipment;
Placement of fill;
Lighting of fires;
Soil level changes;
Temporary or permanent installation of utilities and signs, and