Top Banner

of 97

m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

Apr 13, 2018

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    1/97

    !" $%&' ()**+, -.,'/%01* (/.%,$2%,)%01* 3/14/%5 6 7+2.+8 19

    :;+/%01*%, 3+/91/5%*+;+*>+*' 7+2.+8 71,+ !" $%&' ?./ -.,'/%01*

    3/1@+

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    2/97

    !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    !" $%&' ()**+, -.,'/%01* (/.%,

    $2%,)%01* 3/14/%5 6 7+2.+8 19

    :;+/%01*%, 3+/91/5%*+;+*>+*' 7+2.+8 71,+ !" $%&' ?./ -.,'/%01*

    3/1@+ (B3

    &$F'=&$G$B1> @H @'& CE=$B1>I J1 => B@1 =B1$B3$3 H@& (B3 >=%=E=1) =>

    'B3$&1(A$B 1@ (B) 1 1'EDBK 'BE$>> >?$C=LC(EE) (>>=KB$3 =B

    ?!:F-@B(>< X'>=B$>> 0(&A

    +P X'>=B$>> 0(&A N&=U$5@YBK Z=EE [J4 R+6:

    ,'>1&(E=(

    ; \6+ R P78! R9**

    # \6+ R P78! R9P*

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    3/97

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    4/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 iii

    $G$HI(=J$ AI!!?7K

    T@(3> (B3 -(&=DG$ ]$&U=C$>S 5]^ _T-]$&U=C$>` $a1$B>=U$E) =BU$>DK(1$3 @?D@B> H@& =G?&@U=BK

    (=& F'(E=1) =B 11 1'BB$E @U$& 11 3$C(3$I

    JB W'B$ !**6 1e (B3

    ! 4@GG$BC=BK (B +: G@B1< 1&=(E 1@ $>1(%E=>< 1> @H (=& LE1&(D@B 1$C'KK$>1$3 (> ( G$(B> @H =G?&@U=BK 1'BB$E (=& F'(E=1)I

    Z@M$U$&S T-]$&U=C$> =BU$>DK(D@B> &$U$(E$3 1 (B

    (>>$>>G$B1 @Hd

    ! ; 11$3 @H (B (&&() @H G@3'E$> C@B1(=B=BK (CDU(1$3 C(&%@B (> ( LE1$& G$3='GI ,??&@a=G(1$E)

    7*GRh> @H (=& => 3&(MB 1 M=1< 1

    M$&$ C@B>=>1$B1 (B3 $>1(%E=>=KB$3 $BCE@>'&$I

    J1 M(> B@1$3 1 B@1 C@B>'G$3 %) 1$3 +8i @H 1@ C@'E3 B@1 =B 1=KB @H N$5.a LE1$& 1@ LE1$& (EE @H 1 =1 M@'E3 &$F'=&$ ( G'C< E(&K$& LE1&(D@B %'=E3=BK H@@1?&=B1I

    Z@M$U$& E(%@&(1@&) $a?$&=G$B1> 3$G@B>1&(1$3 1G(EE$& F'(BDD$> 1 @H &$3'C=BK 5.!=B 1'BB$E>I

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    5/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 iv

    Z@M$U$&S '>=BK (CDU(1$3 C(&%@B 1@ &$3'C$ 5.! =B ( 1'BB$E M=EE @BE) >E=K$3 @U$&>$(> 1@ &$3'C$ ?(&DC'E(1$ $G=>>=@B> =B 1'BB$E> M(>

    =B>1(EE$3 (B3 =1> (%=E=1) 1@ &$3'C$ ?(&DC'E(1$ G(m$& _0-` M(> (>>$>>$3I

    ,??&@a=G(1$E) !**GRh> @H (=& => 3&(MB 1>=@B> (>>$>>$3I 0-+*&$H$&> 1@ (EE ?(&DCE$> E$>> 1 _nG` =B ($&@3)B(G=C 3=(G$1$&I 0-!I7=> 1 E$>> 1 ( >'%>$1 @H 0-+*I

    ;=BK 1 M$&$ C@B>=>1$B1 (B3 > G'C< E$>> 1@ H@'B3 1G(EE$& ?(&DCE$> 1@ H@&G U$&) E(&K$ _@U$&!*nG` ?(&DCE$>I J1 M(> $3 1 $=11$GI

    J1 M(> C@BCE'3$3 11$GI X@1< @H

    1$ @?D@B> M@'E3 (33 1@ 11 @H 1)>1$G (B3 1@ 1?(C$ &$F'=&$3 H@& =1>

    =B>1(EE(D@BI

    ()**+, %./ O)%,.'P

    ;=G=E(& =G?&@U$G$B1 1@ 1=%=E=1) @H 1$3 1 (B3 G@&$ C@B>=>1$B1E) 1 1)?=C(E =B @1 =B 1 @& =B1$&O3$?$B3$B1 C@G?@B$B1>S?&@%E$G> M=1< &$E(DU$E) G=B@& C@G?@B$B1> C@'E3 >e

    r+6G H@& G(C1> M$&$

    $>DG(1$3 (1 r:R7S***h(BB'GI

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    6/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 v

    ;1 @H 5.!&$G@U(E M(> C(EC'E(1$3 (1d

    ! r8S*+8S***h1 =H 11&'CD@B (B3 G(C1> M$&$ (G@&D>$3 @U$& !* )$(&>

    (B3 @?$&(DBK C@>1> =BCE'3$3I

    ! r+S9++S***h1 =H (EE C=U=E C@B>1&'CD@B C@>1> M$&$ =KB@&$3 (B3 1

    (G@&D>$3 @U$& !* )$(&> (B3 @?$&(DBK C@>1> =BCE'3$3I

    ! r:98S***h1 =H (EE C=U=E C@B>1&'CD@B (B3 G(C1> M$&$ =KB@&$3 (B3 @?$&(DBK C@>1>

    =BCE'3$3I

    ;1 @H 0-+*&$G@U(E M(> C(EC'E(1$3 (1d

    ! r+9SRPRS***h1 =H 11&'CD@B (B3 G(C1> M$&$ (G@&D>$3 @U$& !*

    )$(&> (B3 @?$&(DBK C@>1> =BCE'3$3I

    ! r9S8+7S***h1 =H (EE C=U=E C@B>1&'CD@B C@>1> M$&$ =KB@&$3 (B3 1

    (G@&D>$3 @U$& !* )$(&> (B3 @?$&(DBK C@>1> =BCE'3$3I

    ! rRS9:9S***h1 =H (EE C=U=E C@B>1&'CD@B (B3 G(C1> M$&$ =KB@&$3 (B3 @?$&(DBK C@>1>

    =BCE'3$3I

    ,> ( C@G?(&=>@B 11 @H &$G@U=BK ?(&DC'E(1$ ?@EE'D@B '>=BK U$1 $g$CDU$E) &$G@U$ 0- (> C@BLK'&$3 (B3 =1>

    @?$&(D@B M(> 'B&$E=(%E$I JG?&@U=BK 11 $g$CDU$B$>> (B3

    (33 1@ =1> C@G?E$a=1) M'&$G$B1 G() ?&@U=3$ ( H@'B3(D@B

    H@& =BU$>DK(D@B> =B1@ (B (E1$&B(DU$ 3$>=KB @H ( E@M$& C@>1 (B3 G@&$ $oC=$B1 >)>1$G H@& 0-

    &$G@U(EI

    X(>$3 @B 1=3$&$3d

    +I ;=KB>I

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    7/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 vi

    (?QR$ :- H:C($C(A

    S =C(7:LIH(=:CEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES

    +I+ 5.-b542,;sTbIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII R

    T L$C:G -=R($7 3$7-:7!?CH$EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"

    !I+ ]t];b- b[,2s,;J.5 -b;Z.NIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 6!I+I+ 4IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII6

    !I! Tb]s2;] .# ]t];b- b[,2s,;J.5 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII :!I!I+ 4IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII+7

    RI+IR ,$&@3)B(G=C 0(&DCE$ ]=u$&> _,0]`IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII+6

    RI! Tb]s2;]IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII +:RI!I+ ;b.-IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII+:

    RI!I! 2@M [@E'G$ ](G?E$&IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!*

    RI!IR ,0]IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!+

    RIR NJ]4s]]J.5IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII !+

    V $--$H( :- -=R(7?(=:C :C (ICC$R ?=7 WI?R=(KEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEETT

    8I+ -7 b,]; ;s55b2 [b5;J2,;J.5 ]t];b-IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII !!

    8I! -b;Z.NIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII !R

    8IR Tb]s2;]IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII !R8IRI+ [=>=%=E=1) JG?&@U$G$B1 ,C&@>> ;=%=E=1) JG?&@U$G$B1 ,C&@>> ;=%=E=1) JG?&@U$G$B1 JB ;1%@'B3 ;'BB$EIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!P

    8I8 NJ]4s]]J.5IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII R*

    " :3$7?(=:C?R 3$7-:7!?CH$ :- (X$ AKA($!EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEUU

    7I+ Tb2J,XJ2J;t ,5N ,[,J2,XJ2J;t IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII RR

    7I! ,JT #2.^ T,;b]IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII R77I!I+ -$(>'&$G$B1 ,B3 4(EC'E(D@B .H #E@M T(1$>IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR7

    7I!I! ;'BB$E ,B3 ,#0 #E@M T(1$>IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR7

    7IR ,#0 0.^bT ,5N b5bT/t 4.5]s-0;J.5IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII R6

    7I8 ,#0 4.];] IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII R:7I8I+ 4(?=1(E 4@>1IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR:

    7I8I! .?$&(D@B(E 4@>1> IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR:

    7I7 /Tbb5Z.s]b /,] b-J]]J.5] IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII RP7I7I+ 4@B>1&'CD@B /&$$B$ bG=>>=@B>IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIRP

    7I6 ;.;,2 0.22s;,5; Tb-.[,2IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 8*

    7I9 4.]; 0bT v/ .# 0.22s;,5; Tb-.[bNIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 8*7I9I+ ;@1(E JB>1(EE(D@B ,B3 .?$&(D@B(E 4@>1> 0$& vK 0@EE'1(B1 T$G@U$3IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII8*

    7I9I! .?$&(DBK 4@>1 0$& vK 0@EE'1(B1 T$G@U$3IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII8+

    7I9IR ]$B>=DU=1) ,B(E)>=>IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII8+

    7I: /Tbb5Z.s]b /,] b-J]]J.5] 0bT vJ2./T,- .# 0.22s;,5; Tb-.[bN IIIIIIIIII8R

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    8/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 vii

    7I:I+ ;@1(E JB>1(EE(D@B ,B3 .?$&(D@B(E /&$$B>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    9/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 viii

    R=A( :- (?QR$A

    ;(%E$ +d N(=E) ]$?(&(D@B T(1$> #@& 0-!I7 ,B3 0-+* _-@B3() +*1< W(B'(&) !*++ x #&=3() !:1< W(B'(&)

    !*++`IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII+P

    ;(%E$ !d 5$?'&$3 [=>=%=E=1) JG?&@U$G$B1 ;=%=E=1) JG?&@U$G$B1 X$1M$$B ,#0 JBE$1 ,B3 .'1E$1 N'&=BK ,#0 .?$&(D@B x Z@'&>

    ^=1< 6* -=B'1$> .H ,#0 .?$&(D@BIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!:;(%E$ 8d ,U$&(K$ ,B3 0$(A ;'BB$E [=>=%=E=1) T$(3=BK> #@& ^$$A3()> +!?G x 6?G IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIII!P

    ;(%E$ 7d ,U$&(K$ Z@'&E) ;&(oC 4@'B1> ^$>1%@'B3 ,B3 b(>1%@'B3 #@& N()> ^ T'BB=BK ,B3

    5@1 T'BB=BKIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIII!P

    ;(%E$ 6d T$>'E1> .H 4@G?(&=>@B X$1M$$B Z@'&> ,#0 T'BB=BK ,B3 5@1 T'BB=BK #@& ,4]8*8 X(>$3 .B

    JB=D(E T(BK$> .H s**8y[](= [=>=%=E=1) T$(3=BKIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR*

    ;(%E$ 9d -@B1 N'&=BK ,#0 .?$&(D@BIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIR7

    ;(%E$ Pd ,#0 0@M$& 4@B>'G?D@B x N(=E) ,U$&(K$> X) -@B1$ ]=BC$ ,?&=E !*+*IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR9

    ;(%E$ ++d ]'GG(&) T'BB=BK 4@>1> .H ,#0IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR:

    ;(%E$ +!d 4@B>1&'CD@B /&$$B1> 0$& vK .H 0@EE'1(B1 T$G@U$3IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII8+

    ;(%E$ +7d ,??@&D@B$3 ;@1(E /&$$B1(,T- T$C@&3$3

    ,=&>?$$3IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIII!

    ;(%E$ +Pd 0-+* T$G@U(E 0$& t$(&IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!

    ;(%E$ !*d 0-+* T$G@U(E 0$& t$(&IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    10/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 ix

    R=A( :- -=FI7$A

    #=K'&$ + d 2@C(D@B .H ,#0 JB ;1 ;'BB$EIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!

    #=K'&$ ! d N$5.a ,CDU(1$3 4(&%@B -@3'E$>IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII7

    #=K'&$ R d [O]$> N$>=KB$3 ,B3 4@B>1&'C1$3 X) 4]JT. ;@ #(C=E=1(1$ JB1$K&(1$3 ,=& ](G?E$> X$H@&$ ,B3,q$& N$5.a #=E1$&IIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIII9

    #=K'&$ 7d T$(EODG$ 5.a ,B3 5. -$(>'&$G$B1> JB ,#0 _#=K'&$ 7I7 .H z7{` IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIII:

    #=K'&$ 6d N=g$&$BD(EE) 4(EC'E(1$3 T$(EODG$ 5. ,B3 5.! T$G@U(E boC=$BC=$> _#=K'&$ 7I9 .H z7{` IIII III IIII I:

    #=K'&$ 9d ba(G?E$ .H 4,0] 5.! 4@BC$B1&(D@B> -$(>'&$3 X$H@&$ ,B3 ,q$& ;1$G _#=K'&$

    7I: .H z7{`IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIP

    #=K'&$ :d ba(G?E$ .H 4,0] 5.! T$G@U(E boC=$BC) N(1( #@& ;1$G _#=K'&$ 7IP .H z7{` IIIIIII+*

    #=K'&$ Pd N$?$B3$BC$ .H 5.! T$G@U(E boC=$BC) N(1( ^=1< T$>?$C1 ;@ JB=D(E 5.! 4@BC$B1&(D@B>

    _#=K'&$ 7I++ .H z7{`IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIII+*

    #=K'&$ +*d ]C1(EE$3 ^=1IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIII+8

    #=K'&$ +R d ,??(&(1'> s>$3 #@& 2[ /&(U=G$1&=C -$(>'&$G$B1> ^=1@B 0'&?@>$>` _#=K'&$ 7I+( #&@G zP{` IIIIIIIIII+9

    #=K'&$ +7 d 0-!I7 ,B3 0-+* #@& -@B3() !81< W(B'(&) !*++ IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII+:

    #=K'&$ +6 d ba(G?E$> .H 0-!I7S 0-+* ,B3 ;]0 2[ #=E1$&> _#=K'&$ 8I7 #&@G zP{` IIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIII IIIIII!*

    #=K'&$ +9 d ,#0 0(&DCE$ 4(?1'&$ boC=$BC) #'BCD@B _#=K'&$ 7I8 #&@G zP{` IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII II!+

    #=K'&$ +: d -7 b(>1 [$BDE(D@B ])>1$G ]C3() +91< #$%&'(&) !*++IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!6

    #=K'&$ !R d ;'BB$E [=>=%=E=1) .B -@B3() +91< W(B'(&) !*++IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!9

    #=K'&$ !8 d -@B1 0$& Z@'& JB ^$>1%@'B3 ;'BB$E IIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIII8!

    #=K'&$ !9d Z@'& .H ;T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    11/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 x

    R=A( :- $WI?(=:CA

    bF'(D@B +IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR

    bF'(D@B !IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    12/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 (

    S =C(7:LIH(=:C

    4@BC$&B> $3 (%@'1 11$3 (> ( >@E'D@BI

    T-]$&U=C$> $a1$B>=U$E) =BU$>DK(1$3 @?D@B> H@& =G?&@U=BK (=& F'(E=1) =B 11 1'BB$EI

    ;$ =BU$>DK(D@B> H&@G (&@'B3 1< %$>1 ?&(CDC$ 1'BB$E U$BDE(D@Be

    ! , T-]$&U=C$>S 50T, 3$E$K(D@B 1@ 5@&M() =B !**+ 1@ =B>?$C1 1'BB$E U$BDE(D@B >1&(1$K=$> =B

    .>E@S 2($&3(ES ;&@B3 3$E$K(D@B 1@ W(?(B =B !**R 1@ =BU$>DK(1$ 1'BB$E U$BDE(D@B (B3 (=& CE$(B=BK

    1$C (B3 B@1$3 1=%=E=1)S M$U$B 1'BB$E> )>1$G> 1@ (33&$>> C@GG'B=1) C@BC$&B> (%@'1 $a1$&B(E (=& F'(E=1)I 5@ 3(1( M(> (U(=E(%E$ 1@=B3=C(1$ 11$G> '>$3e (B3

    ! 4@GG=>>=@B=BK 4>@C=(1$> 1@ &$U=$M =B1$&B(D@B(E 3$U$E@?G$B1> =B $G=>>=@B

    1&$(1G$B1 >)>1$G> =B &@(3 1'BB$E>I , &$?@&1 z+{ M(> =>>'$3 M (>>$>>G$B1 @H 1> @H

    LE1&(D@B 1$C$3 =B >@G$ @U$&>$(> 1'BB$E> 1@

    LE1$& ?(&DC'E(1$ G(m$& (B3 B=1&@K$B @a=3$> &$>?$CDU$E)I

    JB W'B$ !**6 1e (B3

    ! , 1&=(E 1@ $>1(%E=>< 1> @H (=& LE1&(D@B 1$C1$3 =B ,??$B3=a ,e

    ! N$U$E@?$3 ( G@B=1@&=BK ?&@K&(G H@& 1'E1(D@B M=1< 1 (B3 (B (CDU(1$3

    C(&%@B N$5.a >)>1$G 1@ &$G@U$ B=1&@K$B @a=3$>I #=E1&@B1$C M(> >$E$C1$3 (> 1'??E=$& @H

    1$ >)>1$G>e (B3

    ! 4@B1&(C1$3 X('E3$&>1@B$ Z@&B=%&@@A _XZ` 1@ C@B>1&'C1 11(EE$3 1T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    13/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 %

    ; C@B>1&'C1$3 (1 K&@'B3 E$U$E @B X$aE$) T@(3 =B b(&EM@@3 (3Q(C$B1 1@ 11$&B $B3

    @H 11 ;'BB$EI , 1'BB$E M(> C@B>1&'C1$3 H&@G 11&$(G @H 1)>1$G>

    (B3 1=>I ; C@GG=>>=@B$3 1@ 3$1$&G=B$ 11$G> =B 1$&G> @H ?(&DCE$ &$G@U(E (B3 B=1&@K$B @a=3$> &$G@U(EI ;1&'G$B1> (B3 ?&@C$>>$> (B3 'B3$&1@@A (33=D@B(E 3(1( (B(E)>=>I

    ;

    $BK(K$3 %) T-]$&U=C$> (> (B =B3$?$B3$B1 @&K(B=>(D@B 1@ (>>=>1 =B 1>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    14/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 E

    ; &$?@&1 @'1E=B$> 1 @H 1>$>>G$B1I ; >1&'C1'&$3 (> H@EE@M>d

    ! ]$CD@B ! ?&@U=3$> (B (>>$>>G$B1 @H 1>$>>G$B1 @H 1C'>>$> 1>$>>G$B1 @H 1 ( 3=>C'>>=@B @H 1&=(E &$>'E1>e

    ! ]$CD@B : E=>1> C@BCE'>=@Be (B3

    ! ]$CD@B P E=>1> &$C@GG$B3(D@B>I

    SES C:!$CHR?(I7$

    ,$&@3)B(G=C N=(G$1$& 0=C(E 3=(G$1$& @H ( 'B=1 3$B>=1) >? 11@B$ Z@&B=%&@@A

    XZXX X('E3$&>1@B$ Z@&B=%&@@A X=ELBK$& \ X$&K$&

    4,0] 4(U=1) ,m$B'(1$3 0$ ]1&(E=(B b(>1$&B N()E=K>'&$ JG?(C1@&

    b]0 bE$C1&@ ]1(DC 0&$C=?=1(1@&

    b]; ,'>1&(E=(B b(>1$&B ]1(B3(&3 ;=G$

    #N-] #=E1$& N)B(G=C> -$(>'&$G$B1 ])>1$G

    #=E1&@B1$C 4@G?(B) $BK(K$3 H@& 1'??E) (B3 =B>1(EE(D@B @H 1T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    15/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 F

    /Z/ /&$$B (B3 .'1?'1>

    2[ ](G?E$& 2@M [@E'G$ ](G?E$&

    5,;, 5(D@B(E ,>>@C=(D@B @H ;$>DBK ,'1

    5/, 5(D@B(E /&$$B

    5. 5=1&=C @a=3$

    5.! 5=1&@K$B 3=@a=3$

    5.a 4@G%=B(D@B @H B=1&@K$B @a=3$> 5. (B3 5.!

    50T, 5@&M$K=(B 0'%E=C T@(3> ,3G=B=>1&(D@B

    5]^ 5$M ]@'1< (E$>

    0J,T4 0$&G(B$B1 JB1$&B(D@B(E ,>>@C=(D@B @H T@(3 4@BK&$>>$>

    0- 0(&DC'E(1$ -(m$& _0-!I7(B3 0-+*(&$ 1> H&(CD@B> M=1 @H ($&@3)B(G=C 3=(G$1$&> E$>> 1`

    T-]$&U=C$> T@(3> (B3 -(&=DG$ ]$&U=C$>S 5]^

    ]4,N, ]'?$&U=>@&) 4@B1&@E ,B3 N(1( ,CF'=>=D@B

    ;b.- ;(?$&$3 bE$G$B1 .>C=EE(DBK -=C&@%(E(BC$

    ;] 0 ;@1(E ]'>?$B3$3 0(&DC'E(1$ _(EE ?(&DC'E(1$ G(m$& =B 1>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    16/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 +

    T L$C:G -=R($7 3$7-:7!?CH$

    ;)>1$G C@B>=>1> @H ( H&(G$M@&A >'??@&DBK ( B'G%$& @H LE1$& G@3'E$> (B3 1M@

    H(B> 1@ 3&(M (=& 1I b(C< G@3'E$ C@B>=>1> @H ( M=&$ %(>A$1 C@B1(=B=BK (CDU(1$3

    C(&%@B (> 1 > (%@'1

    P7G!zR{ (B3 1 7*GRh>I

    #=K'&$ ! d N$5.a (CDU(1$3 C(&%@B G@3'E$>

    #=K'&$ R d [O]'(EE) (&@'B3 7i` 5. !I #&@G ( ?$CDU$

    5.!=> @H K&$(1$>1 C@BC$&BI

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

    $A3

    L+C:M

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    17/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 )

    ;1$G =B ?E(C$ =B 1 (>>$>>$3 (> M$EE (> 1=BKE$ LE1$& G@3'E$ =B ( E(%@&(1@&) $BU=&@BG$B1I

    4]JT. 'B3$&1@@A (B $a1$B>=U$ ?&@K&(G @H M@&A 1@ (>>$>> 1>G$B1 => C@B1(=B$3 =B 4]JT. &$?@&1 j,=& LE1&(D@B ?E(B1 @H 1$>>G$B1 => ?&$>$B1$3 =B 1$CD@B>I

    TES AKA($! $J?RI?(=:C !$(X:L

    ;'&$G$B1 1$C$3 1@ $>1(%E=>< 11$G 1@ &$3'C$ 5.aI

    b(C< 1$C %$H@&$ (B3 (q$& 1'=1 1$3 O @B$ ?(=& %$H@&$

    (B3 @B$ ?(=& (q$& 1S @B$ (B(E)>$& M(> >$1 @B 5.aG@3$ (B3 1 (B3 C(EC'E(1$3 5.! U(E'$>I 5.! U(E'$> (&$ C(EC'E(1$3 %)

    >'%1&(CDBK 1$1 %) +*

    >$C@B3> 1@ (CC@'B1 H@& 1(G?E=BK %$H@&$ (B3 (q$& 1)>1$GI

    T$K'E(& C(E=%&(D@B> M$&$ ?$&H@&G$3 @B (EE =B>1&'G$B1> '>=BK 1(G$ C(E=%&(D@B K(> G=a1'&$

    >=G'E1(B$@'>E)I

    TESET H%2.'P ?_+*)%'+> 3^%&+ A^.` aH?3Ab C:T!1*.'1/&

    ;S ( ?&@1@1)?$ 3$U=C$ H@& >?$C=LC(EE) G$(>'&=BK 5.!S M$&$ @%1(=B$3 1@M(&3 1 H(& >'?$&=@& 1@ C =B>1(EE$3 %$H@&$ 1'&$G$B1> H&@G 3=g$&$B1 5.a (B(E)>$&>I ](G?E$> @H (=&S H&@G %$H@&$ (B3 (q$& 1)>1$GS M$&$ C(?1'&$3 =B =G?$&G$(%E$ ;$f@B %(K>I ;(G?E$ M$&$ 1$3 =B 1'&B @B 1(G$ C(E=%&(1$3 ;'&$ @H 5. (B3 5.!&$3'CD@B (C&@>> 1> @H&$(EODG$ =BH@&G(D@BI

    #=K'&$ 8 =EE'>1&(1$> 1@G$ %(K G$(>'&$G$B1>I #=K'&$ _(` > ( 1)?=C(E C(>$

    C@B1(=B=BK 1M@ R2 ;$f@B %(K>S (B3 ( U(EU$ (B3 LE1$& (&&(BK$G$B1 (1 1'&$3 3=&$C1E) =B1@ 1(G?E$ ?@&1 @H 1 1M@

    C(>$> >(G?E=BK (=& =B>=3$ 11$G(DC C@OE@C(1$3 G$(>'&$G$B1> M$&$ C@B3'C1$3

    @U$& 1'&$ 1I

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    18/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 G

    _(` X(K> %$=BK >(G?E$3 %) C(G?E$ (=& =B>=3$ N$5.a LE1$&

    #=K'&$ 8 d X(K C(>$> 3$>=KB$3 (B3 C@B>1&'C1$3 %) 4]JT. 1@ H(C=E=1(1$ =B1$K&(1$3 (=& >(G?E$> %$H@&$

    (B3 (q$& N$5.a LE1$&

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    19/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 &

    TET 7$AIR(A :- AKA($! $J?RI?(=:C

    TETES H^+5.,)5.*+& (B $a(G?E$ @H 5.S 5.aG$(>'&$G$B1 %) 1S 1 @U$& DG$S (> 3@$> 1>$& $a1$B1I

    #=K'&$ 7d T$(EODG$ 5.a(B3 5. G$(>'&$G$B1> =B ,#0 _#=K'&$ 7I7 @H z7{`

    #=K'&$ 6d N=g$&$BD(EE) C(EC'E(1$3 &$(EODG$ 5. (B3 5.!&$G@U(E $oC=$BC=$> _#=K'&$ 7I9 @H z7{`

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    20/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 H

    .U$& 1 (B3 ++: M=1< 1 C(EC'E(1$3 '>=BK 1

    G$1 M C(B %$ H@'B3 =B z7{I

    TETET H?3A !1*.'1/

    #=K'&$ 9 => (B $a(G?E$ @H 5.!C@BC$B1&(D@B 3(1( G$(>'&$3 %) 1$&I ; LK'&$ >

    1 @U$& DG$S M=1< >=KB=LC(B1E) 1&$(G @H 11&$(GI

    #=K'&$ 9d ba(G?E$ @H 4,0] 5.!C@BC$B1&(D@B> G$(>'&$3 %$H@&$ (B3 (q$& 1)>1$G

    _#=K'&$ 7I: @H z7{`

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    21/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 ($

    #=K'&$ : > (B $a(G?E$ @H 1 (&@'B3 77iI

    #=K'&$ :d ba(G?E$ @H 4,0] 5.!&$G@U(E $oC=$BC) 3(1( H@& 1)>1$G _#=K'&$ 7IP @H z7{`

    #'&1=> > >?$C1 1@ =B=D(E 5.!C@BC$B1&(D@B>

    _#=K'&$ 7I++ @H z7{`

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    22/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 ((

    TETEU Q%4 A%5;,+&

    ,B(E)>=> @H %(K >(G?E$> H&@G ( B'G%$& @H 3=g$&$B1 E@C(D@B> (C&@>> 1> >$CD@B @H 11$GS > (C&@>> 11&$(G (B3 3@MB>1&$(G @H 1 H@'B3 1?$CDU$E)I

    N'&=BK 11> 1?$$3 M(> U(&=$3 H&@G R7i 1@ P*i @H 1'KK$>DBK 1)>1$G C@'E3 %$

    @?$&(1$3 (1 'E1 (E@BK M=1< 1'&$3 'B3$& E(%@&(1@&) C@B3=D@B>I

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    23/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 (%

    TEU !:LIR$ $J?RI?(=:C !$(X:L

    , >$&=$> @H E(%@&(1@&) 1$>1> M$&$ C@B3'C1$3 1@ $>1(%E=>< =H 1 @H (CDU(1$3 C(&%@B M$&$ >$C'&$3 =B 1 > 3&(MB 1 (B3 U(&)=BK (G@'B1> @H 5. (B3 5. !M$&$ 3&(MB1I -$(>'&$G$B1> 1(A$B (q$& 1$3 (CDU(1$3 C(&%@B 1@ %$ C(EC'E(1$3I

    #=K'&$ +*d ]C1(EE$3 M=1T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    24/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 (E

    ;1 &=K M(> @?$&(1$3 M=1 C(&$H'EE) $a1&(C1$3 H&@G 1$3k (CDU(1$3 C(&%@B '>$3 =B C@BQ'BCD@B M=1< ( G@3=L$3 G@3'E$ 3$>=KB 1@ 3$C&$(>$

    E$(A(K$ (=&f@M 1 M$&$ C@B3'C1$3 '>=BK 1 1$>1 &=KS (> M$EE (> RR U(E=3(D@B &'B>I

    TEUES 7$AIR(A :- !:LIR$ $J?RI?(=:C

    J1 M(> H@'B3 1 1(A$B H&@G 11(B3(&3 G@3'E$ 3$>=KB $3 (CDU(1$3 C(&%@B =B ( G@3=L$3 G@3'E$ 3$>=KB > 1$>1$3 1 ( K(? (1 1$3 %) $B1&(=BG$B1 @H (CDU(1$3 C(&%@B =B 11&$(G @U$& DG$`

    (EE@M=BK ( E(&K$ (G@'B1 @H (=& 1@ ?(>> @U$& 1DBK =1 M(> B@DC$3 11@??=BK =BQ$CD@B @H $=1> @H +! =@B @H 1$>DBKI ; ? 1$&G$3 j@gO

    K(>>=BKkS (B3 E=A$E) =B3=C(1$3 C(1(E)DC C@BU$&>=@B %) 1 H@& 1$F'$B1 3$E()$3 5. $G=>>=@BI

    J1 M(> B@1$3 1 B@1 C@B>'G$3 %) 1 => ( &$E(DU$E) B$M 3$U$E@?G$B1 (B3 =1 => CE$(& 1)>1$G> (&$ B@1 )$1 @?DG=>$3I ; 1&=(E >1$G C@'E3 %$

    =G?&@U$3 1@ @%1(=B %$m$& 5.!&$G@U(E $oC=$BC)I

    J1 M(> H@'B3 1 $g$CDU$ (1 &$G@U=BK 5.!%'1 3@$> B@1 M@&A (> $g$CDU$E) H@&

    5. 3'$ 1@ 1=BKkI .U$& DG$S 1 5.S (> M$EE (> >@G$ @H 1@ =B3=C(1$> 1 ( C(1(E)>1 &(1 ( LE1$& >T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    25/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 (F

    U $R$H(7:A(?(=H 37$H=3=(?(:7 3$7-:7!?CH$

    ;=>1> @H %(BA> @H G$1(E ?E(1$> (&&(BK$3 (C&@>> 1$& M=1< ( C$C@B3 %(BA @H =@B=>=BK ?E(1$> (O+*A[ C$3 H@& 1 => 3$?=C1$3 =B #=K'&$ +!S (B3 @CC'&> %$H@&$ 1O>$CD@B(E (&$( @H 1 (%@'1 7*G!z8{ M 1 ?(>>=BK 1I

    0(&DC'E(1$ G(m$& _0-` =B (=& => ( C@G?E$a >)>1$G =BCE'3=BK (=&%@&B$ >@E=3 ?$ ?(&DCE$> (B3 E@M

    U(?@'& ?&$>>'&$ E=F'=3 ?$ ?(&DCE$>I 0(&DCE$ >=u$> =B (=& C(B U(&) >=KB=LC(B1E)S M=1< ($&@3)B(G=C

    ?(&DCE$ >=u$> &(BK=BK H&@G %$E@M *I*+ 1@ @U$& +** nGI Z=>1@&=C(EE)S 0- G$(>'&$G$B1

    C@BC$B1&(1$3 @B 1'&$G$B1 @H (EE ?(&DCE$> @& 1 _;]0`I

    Z@M$U$& &$>$(&C< @B 1> 1>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    26/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 (+

    b]0 ?$&H@&G(BC$ => Q'3K$3 %) 3$1$&G=B=BK 1 1 1 1 11$GI

    4]JT. 'B3$&1@@A (B $a1$B>=U$ ?&@K&(G @H M@&A 1@ (>>$>> 1 z:{(B3 ( ?&@K&(G @H K&(U=G$1&=C (B3 ?(&DCE$ B'G%$& G$(>'&$G$B1>I ;'&$G$B1> (B3 (B(E)>=> C@B3'C1$3 H@& ?(&DCE$> => C@B1(=B$3 =B 4]JT. &$?@&1 j,=& LE1&(D@B ?E(B1

    @H 1$>>G$B1 => ?&$>$B1$3 =B 1$CD@B>I

    UES !$(X:L

    ;$3 1@ (>>$>> ?(&DCE$ ?$B$1&(D@BS B(G$E)d

    UESES (%;+/+> $,+5+*' :&)>1$G H@& (G%=$B1 (=& F'(E=1) (B3 G$(>'&$?(&DCE$ C@BC$B1&(D@B> (> nKhGRI

    ;1&$(G @H 11&$(GI b(C'&$3 0-!I7(B3 0-+*I ; M$&$ (3Q'>1$3 1@ ?&@U=3$ &$(3=BK> '?3(1$3 $U$&) 6

    G=B'1$> (B3 M$&$ >)BC$3 =B 1 (> &$C@GG$B3$3 %) 4]JT. z:{I ;

    'DE=>$3 1 -$(>'&$G$B1 ])>1$G _#N-]` 1@ (CC@'B1 H@& 1 @H U@E(DE$

    C@G?@B$B1> 1'&$3 >$?(&(1$E) M=1< @1I

    ; M$&$ @?$&(1$3 @B M$$A3()> H&@G ! 1@ 7 ?G 1@ (E=KB M=1< ?$(A (G?E$&> M$&$ '>$3I s? 1@ ++ >(G?E$&> M$&$ '>$3 (1 U(&=@'>

    ?@>=D@B> '?>1&$(G (B3 3@MB>1&$(G @H 11(%E=>< b]0 ?$B$1&(D@B $oC=$BC) H@& 0-!I7S

    0-+*(B3 ;]0I ; @U$& 1> >$CD@B @H 1 M$&$ @?$&(1$3 H@&

    (&@'B3 +* >'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    27/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 ()

    #=K'&$ +R > 1$3 1@ >'>?$B3 1 M=1 M$&$ G$(>'&$3 '>=BK 1M@ ;]J G@3$E RR!+ ,0] >)>1$G>I ;$

    =B>1&'G$B1> C(B G$(>'&$ ?(&DCE$> &(BK=BK =B >=u$ H&@G *I7 1@ !*nGI ;1&'G$B1> M$&$

    C(E=%&(1$3 (B3 G(1C1'3) %) 1'&$G$B1> M$&$ C@B3'C1$3 '>=BK @B$ ,0] '?>1&$(G @H 11&$(GI ;

    (EE@M$3 ( 3$1$&G=B(D@B @H 1=u$ 3=>1&=%'D@B @H ?(&DCE$> _%$H@&$ (B3 (q$& 1I

    ,B bE$C1&=C(E 2@M 0&$>>'&$ JG?(C1@& _b20J` M(> '>$3 =B (>>@C=(D@B M=1< 1=u$ >$E$CDU$E)

    C(?1'&$ ?(&DCE$> H@& G=C&@>C@?) (B(E)>$> 3'&=BK 1 >1'3)I

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    28/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 (G

    #=K'&$ +8 d ;M@ ,0] 'B=1> 3$?E@)$3 (3Q(C$B1E) _H@& C@G?(&=>@B ?'&?@>$>` _#=K'&$ 7I+( H&@G zP{`

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    29/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 (&

    UET 7$AIR(A

    UETES ($:!

    #=K'&$ +7 > 1)?=C(E @'1?'1 H&@G 1I ;?=A$ => C('>$3 %) 11&$(G G$(>'&$G$B1 H&@G 11&$(G @H 1 &$>?@B3 F'=CAE) 1@ C$U$&(E T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    30/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 (H

    ;(%E$ + > ?(&DC'E(1$ >$?(&(D@B &(1$> H@& +*1< 1@ !:1< W(B'(&) !*++I ;'E1> 3'&=BK ?E(B1

    @?$&(D@B =B3=C(1$ (B (??&@a=G(1$E) 67i &$3'CD@B =B %@1< 0-!I7(B3 0-+*13()

    ++h*+h++

    R+PI6 +*PI: RP*I7 +!9I9 67I6i 69IRi

    ^$3B$>3()

    +!h*+h++

    R7+IP +!RI7 8+PIR +7:I: 68IPi 6!I+i

    ;3()

    !*h*+h++

    R8*I6 +!:I9 8*PIP +86I* 6!I!i 68I8i

    #&=3()!+h*+h++

    !P6I8 +*8IP R7:I8 +R+I! 68I6i 6RI8i

    -@B3()

    !8h*+h++

    8+9I8 +!*I! 7*9I6 +78I+ 9+I!i 6PI6i

    ;'$>3()

    !7h*+h++

    R:7IR +R6I7 87PIR +97I! 68I6i 6+IPi

    ;T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    31/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 %$

    UETET R18 J1,)5+ A%5;,+/

    #=K'&$ +6 > $a(G?E$> @H $a?@>$3 LE1$&> E@C(1$3 '?>1&$(G _1@? &@M` (B3 3@MB>1&$(G _%@m@G

    &@M` @H 1=BK 2[ >(G?E$&>S M(> 6Pi H@& 0- !I7S

    9*i H@& 0-+*(B3 6+i H@& ;]0I

    ;$ &$>'E1> >'KK$>1 1 (E>@ K$B$&(DBK

    E(&K$& ?(&DCE$> ?@>>=%E) (> ( &$>'E1 @H C@(K'E(D@B @H 1I

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    32/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 %(

    UETEU ?3A

    #=K'&$ +9 > 1 1$ @H 1G(EE

    C@B1&=%'D@B @H ?(&DCE$> @H 1 >=u$ 1@ 0-!I7(B3 0-+*(B3 11&'G$B1(D@B1@ G$(>'&$ 1 7Pi (B3 6+i &$>?$CDU$E)I J1 > (&$ @B ( ?(&DCE$

    B'G%$& %(>=>S M H&@G ]$CD@B RI!I!S >=BC$ K&(U=G$1&=C (B(E)>=> 1$B3> 1@ %$ M$=KI

    UEU L=AHIAA=:C

    ;'&$G$B1 '>$3 (EE >1 1 => C&$(DBK E(&K$ ?(&DCE$> _@U$&

    !*nG` 1=DBK @B $(&1'&H(C$> =B 11&$(G @H 1 (BDC=?(1$3 11$G M@'E3 %$ C(?(%E$ @H

    &$G@U=BK (EG@>1 (EE @H 1$ E(&K$ ?(&DCE$> %'1 1 @BE) 6*iI ;@ $a?E(=B

    1'&?&=>=BKE) ?@@& ?$&H@&G(BC$ @H 1S =1 M(> $3 1 H@&G$3 @B 1 (B3 1>=%E$ $a?E(B(D@B => 1 E=G=1 =B 1$&G> @H 1T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    33/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 %%

    V $--$H( :- -=R(7?(=:C :C (ICC$R ?=7 WI?R=(K

    ; ]$CD@B 3=>C'>>$> 1=%=E=1)S =B ?(&DC'E(& (1 11$&B $B3 @H 11%@'B3 C(&&=(K$M()I

    VES !" $?A( (ICC$R J$C(=R?(=:C AKA($!

    ;1&$(G =B 1 G@U$ (=& 1I#=K'&$ +:> 1)>1$G E()@'1I

    #=K'&$ +: d -7 b(>1 [$BDE(D@B ])>1$G ]CC1 $>1%@'B3 (B3 b(>1%@'B3 ;'BB$E

    ; &$1'&B$3 1@ 1'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

    4T.]]O[b5;J2,;J.5

    0,]],/b

    4T.]]O[b5;J2,;J.5

    0,]],/b

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    34/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 %E

    VET !$(X:L

    ;1&$(G (B3 3@MB>1&$(G @H 1'&$ 1C(m$&=BK (B3 &$f$CD@B @H E=K>=BK 1C(m$&=BK (B3 &$f$CD@B => &$E(1$3 1@ 1=1) @H ?(&DCE$> =B 1 AB@MB 1'&=BK 1=%=E=1) @H 1'BB$E (=& H&@G %$H@&$ 1=%=E=1) >$B>@&> M$&$ =B>1(EE$3 =B 11%@'B3

    1'BB$ES @B$ _s**8y[=>` %$H@&$ 1` (q$& 1 G$(>'&$3 M=1< 1 ?(>>(K$ 1H$&> (=& H&@G 11%@'B3 1'BB$E 1@ 11%@'B3

    1'BB$EI ; (B(E)>$3 %) C@G?(&=BK U=>=%=E=1) (1

    ,c]8*8 M=1< (B3 M=1=> (E>@ =BU$>DK(1$3 1

    (1 1 B@1

    ?@>>=%E$ 1@ @%1(=B >=KB=LC(B1 $U=3$BC$ @H (B) $g$C1 @B U=>=%=E=1) =B 11%@'B3 1'BB$E 3'$ 1@ 11(BC$ 3@MB>1&$(G H&@G =1 =BC&$(>$>I ; (E>@ 11%@'B3

    1&(oCI

    VEU 7$AIR(A

    VEUES J.&.c.,.'P =5;/12+5+*' ?=%=E=1) G$(>'&$G$B1> M$&$ 1(A$B MI ; (C&@>> 1T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    35/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 %F

    ;(%E$ !d 5$?'&$3 [=>=%=E=1) JG?&@U$G$B1 ; CE@>$E) M=1 3$1(=E$3 =B

    ]$CD@B RI!I+I

    ;)?=C(E B$? (&$ >1&$(G B$? %$1M$$B 8** (B3 6** -GO+ MT$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    36/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 %+

    #=K'&$ +Pd 5$? -@B3() +*1< W(B'(&) !*++

    #=K'&$ !*d 5$? ^$3B$>3() +!1< W(B'(&) !*++

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    37/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 %)

    VEUET J.&.c.,.'P =5;/12+5+*' ?$CD@B C@B>=3$&> =BO1'BB$E U=>=%=E=1) >$B>@&> s**8y[](= (B3 s**7y[](= H&@G %$H@&$ 1 U=>=%=E=1) G$(>'&$G$B1> %$H@&$ (B3 (q$&

    1?=A$> =B U=>=%=E=1) C(B %$ @%>$&U$3 M=1< ( >E=K3() +91< #$%&'(&) !*++

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    38/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 %G

    #=K'&$ !R=> 1)?=C(E ?E@1 @H 1 (

    !7 1@ R*i =G?&@U$G$B1 =B U=>=%=E=1) 3'&=BK b]0 @?$&(D@BI

    #=K'&$ !R d ;'BB$E U=>=%=E=1) @B -@B3() +91< W(B'(&) !*++

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    39/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 %&

    ;=%=E=1) C M ^=1< 6* -=B'1$> .H ,#0 .?$&(D@B

    -@B1 ,q$& .(A$

    N'&=BK ,#0 .?$&(D@B

    ,U$&(K$ i

    T$3'CD@B

    _+hAG` _+hAG` _i N=g$&$BC$`

    -(&C< !*+* !I6+7 !I877 6I+i

    ,?&=E !*+* +I8!R *IP++ R6I*i

    -() !*+* +IR7P *IP*R RRI6i

    W'B$ !*+* +I!** *I9R+ RPI*i

    W'E) !*+* +I!++ *I9P! R8I6i

    ,'K'>1 !*+* +I6P8 +I+77 R+IPi

    ]$?1$G%$& !*+* +IRR8 *IPR7 !PIPi

    .C1@%$& !*+* +I7R8 +I++7 !9IRi

    5@U$G%$& !*+* +I698 +I+77 R+I*i

    N$C$G%$& !*+* !I+*+ +I88! R+I8i

    W(B'(&) !*++ +I7P7 *IP69 RPI8i

    #$%&'(&) !*++ +I:*+ +I!*! RRI!i

    -(&C< !*++ +I68P +I*R: R9I*i

    ,?&=E !*++ +I9!9 +I!R7 !:I7i

    -() !*++ +IR*: +I*99 +9I6i

    W'B$ !*++ +I!77 *IP79 !RI9i

    W'E) !*++ +I!*: +I*77 +!I9i

    ?2+/%4+ SE"Z] SEST" T\E]e

    ; !PiI

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    40/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 %H

    VEUEU J.&.c.,.'P =5;/12+5+*' =* (^+ D+&'c1)*> ()**+,

    [=>=%=E=1) (1 11$&B $B3 @H 11(EE$3 H@& @?$&(D@B(E &$(>@B>I ; G@B=1@&S =3$BDL$3 (> ,c]8*8S => E@C(1$3 Q'>1 %$H@&$ 11$&B C&@>> ?(>>(K$I

    ;@ 1 _R** G=B'1$>` @& G@&$S M M (&$ >=%=E=1)

    T$(3=BK #&@G +!?G x 6?G

    ,#0 &'BB=BK ,#0 B@1 &'BB=BK ,#0 &'BB=BK ,#0 B@1 &'BB=BK_+hG` _+hG` _+hG` _+hG`

    ,c]8*8 *I**!+* *I**!+R *I**!7P *I**!66

    ;'E1> =B3=C(1$ 1 M$&$ U$&) >E=K$$B =B;(%E$ 7S 11%@'B3 #@& N()> ^ T'BB=BK ,B3 5@1 T'BB=BKI

    ,#0 ]1(1'> bX ] =B 1@&1$3 (CC@&3=BK 1@ M=1< 1 M$&$

    =BCE'3$3 =B H'&1=>S (B3 T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    41/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 E$

    ;'E1> (&$ K=U$B =B;(%E$ 6I

    ;(%E$ 6d T$>'E1> .H 4@G?(&=>@B X$1M$$B Z@'&> ,#0 T'BB=BK ,B3 5@1 T'BB=BK #@&

    ,4]8*8 X(>$3 .B JB=D(E T(BK$> .H s**8y[](= [=>=%=E=1) T$(3=BK

    JB=D(E s**8 [=>=%=E=1) T$(3=BK

    JB T(BK$d _+hG`

    ,U$&(K$ ,c]8*8 T$(3=BK _+hG` i T$3'CD@B

    ,#0 .B * -=B'1$> ,#0 .B 6* -=B'1$>

    *O*I**+ *I**+R! *I**+!R 9i

    *I**+O*I**! *I**!R* *I**!+* Pi

    *I**!O*I**R *I**!9R *I**!7: 6i

    *I**RO*I**8 *I**R8R *I**!:+ +:i

    ?2+/%4+ ]E]]TVV ]E]]TS[ SSe

    ,B (U$&(K$ ++i ,#0 ?$&H@&G(BC$ =B =G?&@U=BK ,c]8*8 U=>=%=E=1) M(> C(EC'E(1$3 @U$& 1I J1 (??$(&> H&@G 1=%=E=1) @H *I**RO*I**8GO+

    @BE) (CC@'B1$3 H@& !I7i @H 1 (%@'1 6iI

    VEV L=AHIAA=:C

    J1 => AB@MB 1 =B 1T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    42/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 E(

    #=K'&$ !8 d -@B1=%=E=1) =B 1?=1$ (B =BC&$(>$ =B U$ 11(&DBK

    ?@=B1 =B -() !**RI ;&(oC C@'B1> $3 @U$& DG$S ?(&DC'E(&E) H@& E@BK U$S %'1

    U=>=%=E=1) (1 ,c]8*8S =G?&@U$3I J1 => $a?$C1$3 1T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    43/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 E%

    ; (%@'1 6*i @H 1 1=%=E=1) E$U$E> (1 11$&B $B3 @H 1 (B3 1&(oC G=aI [=>=%=E=1) (1 1 ?@=B1 =>?(&DC'E(&E) >$B>=DU$ 1@ $G=>>=@B> H&@G 1&'CA> 1&(U$EE=BK '? 1T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    44/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 EE

    " :3$7?(=:C?R 3$7-:7!?CH$ :- (X$ AKA($!

    ,>>$>>=BK 11$G =BU@EU$3d

    ! -@B=1@&=BK ?E(B1 >1(1'> 1@ $>1(%E=>< 11(%E=>< f@M &(1$> 1$ $G=>>=@B>I

    ! 4(EC'E(DBK 11 (B3 K&$$B

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    45/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 EF

    ;(%E$ 9d -@B1

    ]C

    .?$&(D@B(E

    i 5@I N()>

    6 Z@'&>

    i 5@I N()>

    7 Z@'&>

    .& 2$>>

    i

    ,?&=E !*+* +*:I* :!I* 97IPi 9 R:IPi P 7*I*i

    -() !*+* +!7I* P7I7 96I8i : R:I8i P 8RI!i

    W'B$ !*+* +!8I* ++RI* P+I+i +R 6!IPi 7 !8I!i

    W'E) !*+* +R!I* +!*I7 P+IRi +8 6RI6i R +RI6i

    ,'K'>1 !*+* +R!I* ++6I* :9IPi +7 6:I!i 8 +:I!i

    ]$?1$G%$& !*+* +R!I* +!6I7 P7I:i +7 6:I!i ! PI+i

    .C1@%$& !*+* ++RI7 :+I* 9+I8i : 8!IRi ++ 7:I!i

    5@U$G%$& !*+* +R*I* +**I7 99IRi +! 77I8i 9 R!IRi

    N$C$G%$& !*+* +!*I* P+I7 96IRi +! 6*I*i 9 R7I*i

    W(B'(&) !*++ ++8I* P*I7 9PI8i ++ 79IPi 6 R+I6i

    #$%&'(&) !*++ ++PI* +*+I* :8IPi +8 9*I6i 7 !7I!i

    -(&C< !*++ +R!I* +!RI* PRI!i +7 6:I!i 7 !!I9i

    ,?&=E !*++ P*I7 :8I7 PRI8i +R :6I!i 7 RRI+i

    ?2+/%4+ ST]E\ S]TE] [VE]e STES Y]E]e YE] U]E]e

    J1 C(B %$ >$$B H&@G;(%E$ 9 1 M=1< 1 @& E$>> M(> @B (U$&(K$ R*iI

    J1 > H('E1OH&$$ @?$&(D@BI

    ! 7! @'1 @H 76 M$$A> @H @?$&(D@B M >C1(&1 (B3 $a?$&=$BC$3 (E(&G> (B3 $&&@&> =B 11 'C< (> S 3(G?$&> B@1 @?$B=BK @& H(B> H(=E=BK 1@

    $B$&K=>$I ^'C< H(=E'&$> @CC'&&$3 @?$&(D@B> @BB$E @BO>=1$S &(BK=BK H&@G >=G?E$ &$>1(&1> 1@ >1(&DBK 1T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    46/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 E+

    "ET ?=7 -R:D 7?($A

    "ETES !+%&)/+5+*' ?*> H%, 1 (B (U$&(K$ @H 1M@ f@MO

    G$1$&>e @B$ =B>1(EE$3 %$H@&$ 1 @H ,#0 @?$&(D@B (&$

    E=>1$3 =B ;(%E$ :I ;I ; N'&=BK ,#0 .?$&(D@B

    -@B1 GRh> GRh>

    ,?&=E !*+* R+PIR +:8IR 8!I6

    -() !*+* R+6I+ +:8I! 7!I:

    W'B$ !*+* R*8IR +:7I6 87IR

    W'E) !*+* R+RIR +:8I! 86I:

    ,'K'>1 !*+* R*7I8 +:8I* 87I9

    ]$?1$G%$& !*+* R!PIR +:7I8 88I7

    .C1@%$& !*+* R!:I! +:+I9 8*I+

    5@U$G%$& !*+* R!9I* +PRI6 8RI9

    N$C$G%$& !*+* R+PI6 +P*I: 8!I+

    W(B'(&) !*++ R!+I9 +:!IP 8+I8

    #$%&'(&) !*++ R+9I6 +:*I* 8RI!

    -(&C< !*++ R+7I9 +:+I7 8+I8

    ,?&=E !*++ R+6I8 +9:I7 8RI6

    :2+/%,, ?2+/%4+ US[E] S[VEV VVES

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    47/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 E)

    "EU ?-3 3:D$7 ?CL $C$7FK H:CAI!3(=:C

    ; @%1(=B$3 H&@G 1)>1$G (B3 G$(>'&$3 H@& DG$> 1 M$&$&'BB=BK 1 H@& 1 (B3 1@ C1&'G$B1 C(E=%&(D@BI

    ;(%E$ Pd ,#0 0@M$& 4@B>'G?D@B x N(=E) ,U$&(K$> X) -@B1I

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    48/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 EG

    ;@1(E $B$&K) '>$ (U$&(K$3 M$$AE) %$$B K=U$B H@& M$$A> =B G@B1 H&@G ,?&=E !*+* 1@ W'B$ !*++

    =B ;(%E$ +*I ;$

    H@& 1 69+-^$ ]=BC$ ,?&=E !*+*

    -@B1< ;@1(E 4@B>'G?D@BS ,U$&(K$ A^1 !*+* 9R:9

    ]$?1$G%$& !*+* P+7P

    .C1@%$& !*+* 97*65@U$G%$& !*+* 998+

    N$C$G%$& !*+* :P!P

    W(B'(&) !*++ :9+R

    #$%&'(&) !*++ PP+8

    -(&C< !*++ +!R6R

    ,?&=E !*++ P8*7

    -() !*++ :66!

    W'B$ !*++ P+:*

    ?2+/%4+ fD^g D++f [Y]V

    .B 11 W(B'(&) !*++ 1'G?D@B M=1< 1)>1$G> @?$&(D@B(EI ;1 H@& &'BB=BK 1 H@'B3 1@ %$ (??&@a=G(1$E) !!A^S @& ++i @H 1@1(E ,#0 $E$C1&=C=1)

    C@B>'G?D@BI ;$ @H H@EE@M=BK C(EC'E(D@B> =1 M=EE %$ (>>'G$3 1 (1 !*A^

    (B3 6 '$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    49/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 E&

    "EV ?-3 H:A(A

    "EVES H%;.'%, H1&'

    ;1 @H C@B>1&'CDBK 1 r6*G M1> .H ,#0

    4@>1 _rh(BB'G`

    -(=B1$B(BC$ @H (>>$1> r+7PS896

    -(=B1$B(BC$ @H (>>$1> 1@ %$ C@B3'C1$3 %) >'%OC@B1&(C1@&> r+R:S!6:

    -@%=E=>(D@B r66S*99

    X(>=C 4@B>'G(%E$> r8S7P:

    0&@Q$C1 4@@&3=B(D@B rR8RS!**

    /]; @B (%@U$ =1$G> r9+S+6!

    ^(1$& 4@B>'G?D@B r9S!6*

    (:(?R hZ\]i]VS

    bE$C1&=C=1) 4@B>'G?D@B rRRS!::

    (1'%, 8.'^ $,+ =1 M=EE %$ (>>'G$3 11 r*I*988 ?$& A^1 H@& ?@M$& M@'E3 %$ rR7S*7+I

    ,>>'G=BK H'1'&$ &'BB=BK C@>1> @H (%@'1 r:**S*** ?$& (BB'G 11> ?$& (BB'G

    H@& H'1'&$ ,#0 @?$&(D@B M=EE %$ (>>'G$3 1@ %$ r:R7S***I

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    50/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 EH

    "E" F7$$CX:IA$ F?A $!=AA=:CA

    "E"ES H1*&'/)$ /(> JBU$B1@&) H@& T@(3 4@B>1&'CD@B 0&@Q$C1> z++{I ; 1@@E (EE@M> C(EC'E(D@B @H$F'=U(E$B1 $G=>>=@B> H&@G C@B>1&'CD@B ?&@Q$C1> (B3 => K$B$&(EE) C@B>=>1$B1 M=1< 1@'&C$> JB>D1'1$ (B3 ,'>1&(E=(}> 5(D@B(E /&$$B @H K&$$B '>$3 @B >=1$I

    ! ]C@?$ !d JB3=&$C1 /Z/ $G=>>=@B>I #@& $a(G?E$ $G=>>=@B> K$B$&(1$3 1$ @B >=1$I

    ! ]C@?$ Rd JB3=&$C1 /Z/ $G=>>=@B> H&@G >@'&C$> B@1 @MB$3 @& C@B1&@EE$3 %) 1>=@B> K$B$&(1$3 %) 1 >1$$E (B3 C$G$B1I

    ; ,??$B3=aNS (B3 1'E1> (&$ >'GG(&=>$3 =B ;(%E$ +!%$E@MS M=1=@B> K=U$B =B 14.!$S $G=>>=@B> M=1< K&$$B1&'CD@B /&$$B>=@B b>DG(1$

    _14.!$`

    bE$C1&=C=1) '>$3 @B >=1$

    H@& C@B>1&'CD@B

    P6:*** A^< +*R77

    4@BC&$1$ +!::7 ;@BB$ +PP*

    ]1$$E 7!7 ;@BB$ +**7

    ]$E '>$3 H@& ?E(B1

    $F'=?G$B1

    877** 2 +R*

    N=$>$E C@B>'G$3 H@&

    M(>1$ 1&(B>?@&1

    R9R** 2 ++*

    .1$> @H 1 $U(E'(D@B 1>'G=BK *IP*AK @H C(&%@B 3=@a=3$ (&$ &$E$(>$3 ?$& A^< z+!{S 1$ $G=>>=@B>

    &$>'EDBK H&@G ?@M$& C@B>'G?D@B (&$ 8!814.!$I

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    51/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 F$

    "EY (:(?R 3:RRI(?C( 7$!:J?R

    ; (>>'G$3 1S (B3 (U(=E(%=E=1) @H :8iI

    ! #'1'&$ ?@M$& '>$ @H 1 !+*A^ M 11 @H &'BB=BK 1 @H 0-+*@& 5.!&$G@U$3 @U$& ( ?$&=@3I

    "EZES (1'%, =*&'%,,%01* ?*> :;+/%01*%, H1&'& 3+/ j4 31,,)'%*' 7+512+>

    ;1 @H 1 r6*G (B3 11> @U$& +* (B3 !* )$(&> H@& %@1< 0- +*(B3 5.!(&$ >1> &$f$C1 11 $g$CDU$B$>> @H C@B>1&'CDBK 11> 0$& vK .H 0@EE'1(B1 T$G@U$3

    N$>C&=?D@B 4@>1 0$& vK 0-+* 4@>1 0$& vK 5.!

    JB>1(EE(D@B (B3 .?$&(DBK 4@>1> x +* )$(& E=H$ rR*SPPP r9S+7R

    JB>1(EE(D@B (B3 .?$&(DBK 4@>1> x !* )$(& E=H$ r+9SRPR r8S*+8

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    52/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 F(

    "EZET :;+/%0*4 H1&' 3+/ j4 31,,)'%*' 7+512+>

    ; (&$ 1 >1> $aCE'3$ =B>1(EE(D@B C@>1S

    (B3 >@ ?&@U=3$ ( G$(>'&$ @H 11 $g$CDU$B$>> @H &'BB=BK 11> 0$& vK .H 0@EE'1(B1 T$G@U$3

    N$>C&=?D@B 4@>1 0$& vK 0-+* 4@>1 0$& vK 5.!

    .?$&(DBK 4@>1 rRS9:9 r:98

    "EZEU A+*&.02.'P ?*%,P&.&

    ;$B>=DU=1) @H 1>=@B M=1< T-]$&U=C$> >'KK$>1$3 1>=%E$ C 1 H&@G 6 1@ +! 1> H&@G rR7S*** 1@ r9*S*** ?$& (BB'GI

    #@& 1 (%@U$I

    ; => &$(>@B(%E$ %$C('>$ 1 @H A$) G$3='G (B3 E@BK U$ =B 11%@'B3

    1'BB$E (&$ M$EE (> +!?G 1@ 6?GS (> > 11 (EE

    G(a=G'G &$(3=BK> >'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    53/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 F%

    #=K'&$ !6d ,U$&(K$ G$3='G (B3 E@BK U$1%@'B3 1'BB$E

    #=K'&$ !9d Z@'& @H 11(EE(D@B (B3 @?$&(DBK C@>1>S 1$ C M@'E3 &$>'E1 =Bd

    ! 4@>1 ?$& AK @H 0-+*&$G@U(E @H r:996e (B3

    ! 4@>1 ?$& AK @H 5.!&$G@U(E @H r!*!7I

    bE$C1&=C=1) C@>1> (&$ >G(EE =B &$E(D@B 1@ C@B>1&'CD@B (B3 @?$&(D@B C@>1>I bU$B M=1< 1 3'$ 1@ 11> _$aCE'3=BK ?@M$&`

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    54/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 FE

    (B3 E$>> 1 3'$ 1@ ?@M$& C@>1>I Z$BC$ &'BB=BK 1 E@BK $g$CDU$E)

    11 ?$& AK @H ?@EE'1(B1 &$G@U$3I

    JH @BE) @?$&(D@B(E C@>1> (&$ C@B>=3$&$3 1$ C M@'E3 &$>'E1 =Bd

    ! 4@>1 ?$& AK @H 0-+*&$G@U(E @H r+P9Re (B3

    ! 4@>1 ?$& AK @H 5.!&$G@U(E @H r877I

    ; $g$CDU$E) 11 ?$& AK @H ?@EE'1(B1 &$G@U(E (>

    $E$C1&=C=1) C@>1> (&$ E@M C@G?(&$3 1@ @11>I ; (>>'G$> 1 @H 1 ?@EE'1(B1 E$U$E>S (B3

    1 6?GI

    "E[ F7$$CX:IA$ F?A $!=AA=:CA 3$7 j=R:F7?! :- 3:RRI(?C( 7$!:J$L

    ;$ /(> $G=>>=@B> H@& $(C< AK @H ?@EE'1(B1 &$G@U$3 M$&$ C(EC'E(1$3

    '>=BK %@1< 1>=@B> H@& (BB'(E ,#0 $E$C1&=C=1) C@B>'G?D@BS (> C(EC'E(1$3 =B ]$CD@B7I7I!I

    ;1&'CD@B K&$$B1>d P*i 1@ ?(&DC'E(1$ &$G@U(E (B3 +*i 1@ 5.!&$G@U(EI

    ;>=@B> ?$& AK @H ?@EE'1(B1 &$G@U$3 @ %$$B C(EC'E(1$3 H@& ,#0 @?$&(D@B '>=BK

    G$(>'&$3 ,#0 $E$C1&=C=1) C@B>'G?D@B M=1< 1=KB E=H$ (B3 K=U$B C@B>1&'CD@B K&$$B=@B> ?$& AK @H ?@EE'1(B1

    &$G@U$3 (&$ >C&=?D@B vK 4.!$ 0$& vK

    0-+*

    vK 4.!$ 0$& vK

    5.!

    JB>1(EE(D@B (B3 .?$&(DBK bG=>>=@B> 7S*6* +S!!*

    "E[ET :;+/%01*%, F/++*^1)&+ F%& $5.&&.1*& 3+/ j4 31,,)'%*' 7+512+>

    ,#0 @?$&(DBK ?@M$& M=1< (B3 M=1'&$3 3(1( 1@ K=U$

    1'G?D@BI ;$ bG=>>=@B> 0$& vK .H 0@EE'1(B1 T$G@U$3

    N$>C&=?D@B vK 4.!$ 0$& vK

    0-+*

    vK 4.!$ 0$& vK

    5.!

    .?$&(DBK bG=>>=@B> +S*P9 !9*

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    55/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 FF

    Y L$3?7(!$C( :- 3R?CC=CF H:CL=(=:CA :- ?337:J?R

    , C@G?(&=>@B @H 11 1$ ?$&H@&G(BC$ M(> G@B=1@&$3 (B3 U$&=L$3 1@ >(D>H) 0&@Q$C1 X&=$H

    &$F'=&$G$B1> (> M$EE (> 11&=(E 5@=>$ 0@E=C) _b0,S !***`S

    (> 3$1(=E$3 =B ,??$B3=a#I

    ; T$?@&1d ~-7 b(>1 ;'BB$E #=E1&(D@B ;&=(E bU(E'(D@B 0&@K&(G O T$U=$M @H

    .?$&(D@B(E 0$&H@&G(BC$~S ,-./S&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+S !! #$%&'(&) !*+! M(>=>>'$3 (1 1 (&$ H@'B3 =B ]$CD@BP@H 1 T$?@&1I

    :+-_M` *:370:873< 9=4/O I28.9:3/O 8457.M7570L .3I .'.75.M7570L :A 0K4 J508.9:3 04DK3:5:>$3 =B ]$CD@B7I+I ; @?$&(1$3 K$B$&(EE) H&@G +!?G 1@ 6?G M$$A3()> $aC$?1 3'&=BK DG$> @H

    ?E(BB$3 @& 'B?E(BB$3 3@MBDG$S (B3 'BE$>> @1$ &$F'=&$3 %) 4]JT. H@&

    >?$C=LC $a?$&=G$B1(E (CDU=1)I

    ;C&=%$3 =B ]$CD@B>! (B3RI

    0-+*E$U$E> (U$&(K$3 (&@'B3 R7*nKhGR%$H@&$ 1S M=1< (B (??&@a=G(1$ 67i &$3'CD@B 1'&$3 ?$&=@3>S M=1< (B (??&@a=G(1$ 67i &$3'CD@B 1S M=1< (B (??&@a=G(1$ +!i &$3'CD@BI

    5.!E$U$E> (U$&(K$3 *IRR??G %$H@&$ 1'&$G$B1> S M=1< (B (??&@a=G(1$ 77i &$3'CD@BI

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    56/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 F+

    ;(%E$ +9d 4@B3=D@B .H ,??&@U(E :+- _-@B=1@&=BK ,B3 T$?@&DBK`

    4@B3=D@B .H

    ,??&@U(E

    T$F'=&$G$B1 .H 4@B3=D@B ,B3 4@BCE'>=@B

    :+-_4` *:370:873< 8454'.30 C.8.=4048/ @70K73 0K4 C8:Q4D0 023345/O 0: .//4// 0K4 4T4D0/

    :A 0K4 J508.9:3 04DK3:5:'&$G$B1> M$&$ &$C@&3$3 =B 1=%=E=1) G@B=1@&> =B>1(EE$3 %$H@&$ (B3 (q$& 1=%=E=1) (1 11$&B $a=1 @H 11%@'B3 1'BB$E @U$& DG$ M(> (>>@C=(1$3 M=1< ,#0 @?$&(D@BI

    :+-_A ".5D25.9:3 :A 0K4 C48A:8=.3D4 :A 0K4 J508.9:3 04DK3:5: @H ?@EE'1(B1> &$G@U$3S (> M$EE (> 11> ?$& AK

    &$G@U$3 M$&$ C(EC'E(1$3 =B ]$CD@B>7I8S7I6 (B37I9I

    ;1 @H 0-+*_=BCE'3=BK =B>1(EE(D@B 3$?&$C=(1$3 @U$& !*

    )$(&>` => r+9SRPR ?$& AK 0-+*&$G@U$3S (B3 r8S*+8 ?$& AK 5.!&$G@U$3I

    ;1> H@& 17IRS7I7 (B37I:I

    ;'G?D@B (>>@C=(1$3 M=1< 1I

    ;$ K(> $G=>>=@B> @H C@B>1&'CD@B M$&$ +RP+*14.!I

    ;>=@B> (??@&D@B$3 1@ @BK@=BK @?$&(D@B @H 1$3 >'%Q$C1 1@ (??&@U(EI

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    57/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 F)

    Z L=AHIAA=:C

    ; C@B3'C1$3 %$C('>$ @H C@BC$&B> (%@'1 1 H&@G 1C(m$&=BK @& &$f$CD@B @H E=K)>1$G>I ,E1 1 '>$3 (B3 1'%Q$C1$3 1@ &=K@&@'> (B(E)>=>I

    ;'C< (> 0- (B3 5.!=> C@G?E$a (B3 1'&$G$B1 => ( 3=oC'E1 (B3

    $U@EU=BK >C=$BC$I ; M$&$ (B@11&'G$B1(D@B => C@BLK'&$3 H@& 1E@M C @H

    ?@EE'1(B1 E$U$E> =B (G%=$B1 (=&I ;@ $B>'&$ ?@EE'1(B1 G$(>'&$G$B1> M$&$ C&$3=%E$ 1

    C@GG=>>=@B$3 1@ (3U=>$ @B 1=BK 1=KB @H 1 1'&$I J1 M(> (E>@ H@'B3 1'KK$>1 1>=%E$ 1@ 3$U$E@? ( G@&$ $g$CDU$ N$5.a >)>1$GI Z@M$U$&S

    (> C@BLK'&$3 1)>1$G => B@1 C@>1 $g$CDU$I J1 => =G?@&1(B1 1@ B@1$ 1 H@'B3 1 C@BU$&1$3 1@ 5. %) 1 =B 1$&> %'1

    5.a$G=>>=@B> H&@G 11(CA G() @BE) %$ >E=K>=BK E(1$&I

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    58/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 FG

    ZET $A3

    ;> 11$GI

    4@B>=3$&(D@B @H 1@B> H@& 1>=%E$ 1@ =BC&$(>$ $oC=$BC) %'1 11$GS @& G@&$ C@EE$CD@B ?E(1$>I ,B) @?D@B 1@ =G?&@U$ $oC=$BC) M@'E3 (33 1@ 11

    @H 1)>1$G (B3 H'&1$ 11$GI J1 M(> =B1$B3$3 1 (U(=E(%=E=1) M(> @BE) :8iI JH 1)>1$G M$&$ %$=BK '>$3 =B (1'BB$E 1@ G(B(K$ (=& F'(E=1) =1> &$E=(%=E=1) M@'E3 =KB=LC(B1E) =G?&@U$3 @& 1 @& (1 E$(>1 ?$&=@3> @H ?@@& (=& F'(E=1)I

    ZEU (ICC$R ?=7 WI?R=(K

    ;=3$ 1 1@ (B (CC$?1(%E$ E$U$EI b]0> (&$ (B (E1$&B(DU$ G$(B> @H ?&@U=3=BK CE$(B (=& 1@ =BQ$C1 =B1@ (

    1'BB$EI

    ,=& F'(E=1) =B 11 (EM()> G$1 1=%=E=1) >1(B3(&3> >$1 (1 1=KB >1(K$I ;$

    >1(B3(&3> M$&$ %(>$3 @B 1>@C=(D@B _0J,T4` K@(E> H@& U=>=%=E=1) =B 1'BB$E> z+7{I ;1 C(>$ >=1'(D@B H@& 1'BB$E (=& F'(E=1) => C@BK$>1$3 1&(oCI 0J,T4 >?$C=L$> ( U=>=%=E=1) K@(E @H*I**9GO+M C@BK$>1$3 (B3 *I**7GO+H@& H&$$ f@M=BK 1&(oCI ;1 (C E$U$E>

    @H (&@'B3 *I**RGO+H@& C@BK$>1$3 1&(oCI 0J,T4 CE(>>=L$> ( U=>=%=E=1) @H *I**RG O+(> CE$(& (=& M=1=%=E=1) @H G$(>'&$3 %) U=>=%=E=1) =G?&@U$3 >E=K=BC$ 1 @H U$S $>?$C=(EE) (&$ &$(C=@B> ?$& U$ (&@'B3 R+:G Rh> M @B (U$&(K$ @U$& DG$ (%@'1 6iI

    /=U$B 1=%=E=1) E$U$E> 11 (E&$(3) =B 1$&>I

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    59/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 F&

    ZEV H:A( $--$H(=J$C$AA

    ;1 @H 5.!(B3 0- &$G@U(E %) LE1&(D@B => >=KB=LC(B1 M1(EE(D@B`S M=1< C@B>1(B1

    $E$U(1$3 ?(&DCE$ C@BC$B1&(D@B> (1 1DEE %$ @H 1 &$G@U$3I

    J1 => (E>@ =G?@&1(B1 1@ B@1$ 1

    =@B >1(B3(&3> (B3 &$1&@LYBK (&$ K(=B$3 @'1>=3$ 11 1'BB$EI -@1@&=>1> M@'E3 ?(>>

    1> 1?@B3=BK U$&) E@M =G?&@U$G$B1 =B 11%@'B3 1'BB$EI JB C@G?(&=>@BS 1 @H

    ?@EE'D@B &$3'CD@B G$(>'&$> >'C< (> U$>=@B> G(B(K$G$B1 (&$ K(=B$3 $U$&)M'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    60/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 FH

    [ H:CHRIA=:CA

    ,B +: G@B1< 1&=(E %$$B C@B3'C1$3 @H (B ,#0 1=>1$3 @H (B b]0 1@ LE1$& 0- (B3 ( N$5.a

    ?E(B1 1@ LE1$& 5.aI ; %'=E1 (1 ( C@>1 @H r6*G (B3 C@>1> (%@'1 r:R7S*** ?$& (BB'G 1@

    @?$&(1$I

    ,-./ M$&$ C@B1&(C1$3 1@ @U$&>$$ (B3 &$?@&1 @B 1$@B (B3 C@B3'C1 G$(>'&$G$B1> @H 11$GI

    J1 M(> H@'B3 1 =@B> (1 >@'&C$S >'C< (> B$M U$>=@B >1(B3(&3> (B3 &$1&@LYBK ?(&DCE$ 1&(?> 1@

    @E3$& 1&'CA>e

    6I J1 => B@1 ?@>>=%E$ 1@ C@>1 $g$CDU$E) &$G@U$ ?@EE'1(B1> M=1< 1)>1$G (> =B>1(EE$3 @& 1@

    G@3=H) 1)>1$G 1@ G(A$ =1 C@>1 $g$CDU$e (B3

    9I ba1$B>=U$ AB@ME$3K$ %$$B K(=B$3 H&@G 11$G> 1@ &$3'C$ ?@EE'1(B1> =B 1'BB$E>I

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    61/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 +$

    \ 7$H:!!$CL?(=:CA

    X(>$3 @B 1=3$&$3d

    +I ;=KB>I

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    62/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 +(

    S] 7$-$7$CH$A

    z+{ H^.,> k ?&&1@C=(1$> H@& T;, 5] S ]$?1$G%$& !**8

    z!{ ?!:F H1*&),0*4i}T;, -7 b(>1 ,=& #=E1&(D@B 0&@Q$C1 bU(E'(D@B 0E(BS} ;$C$(&C< &$?@&1i + 5@U$G%$& !*++

    z6{ (^+/51S ~-@3$E 8!= JB>1&'CD@B -(B'(ES 4P*+ 7+&+%/?@B>$ [$&>=@B~S W'E) !*++

    z:{ X%,,.c)/'1*i QS~bU(E'(D@B @H 1 -$(>'&$G$B1 ])>1$G ;(?$&$3 bE$G$B1

    .>C=EE(DBK -=C&@%(E(BC$ =B 1~S 4]JT. &$>$(&C< &$?@&1i : 5@U$G%$& !*++

    z+*{ 71%>& %*> (/%l< ?)'^1/.'P 19 CADi~-7 b(>1 ,=& #=E1&(D@B 0&@Q$C1 O 0&@Q$C1 X&=$HI 4@B1&(C1

    [$&>=@B~S ]$?1$G%$& !**9

    z++{ 71%>& %*> (/%l< ?)'^1/.'P 19 CADi}T;,y4@B>1&'CD@B/Z/bG=>>=@B>JBU$B1@&)y_+I6`}S !R

    #$%&'(&) !*++

    z+!{ L+;%/'5+*' 19 H,.5%'+ H^%*4+ %*> $*+/4P $lS} W'E) !*+*

    z+R{ -.,'/1*'+>=@B=BK T$?@&1S -7 b(>1 -@1@&M() ,=& #=E1&(D@B 0E(B1S} !6ORO!*+*

    z+8{ QXQQi}-7 b(>1 #=E1&(D@B 0&@Q$C1 4@G?E$D@B T$?@&1S} -(&C< !*+*

    z+7{ 3=?7HS jT@(3 ;'BB$E>d [$>=@B> (B3 ,=& N$G(B3 H@& [$BDE(D@BkS ;(%E$ JJI!O+ x 2=G=1

    U(E'$> H@& U$BDE(D@B >=u=BKS 5@U$G%$& !**8I

    z+6{ L+;%/'5+*' 19 $*2./1*5+*'i H,.5%'+ H^%*4+ %*> D%'+/S },CD@B H@& ,=&S !**P s?3(1$S}

    5@U$G%$& !**P

    N@C'G$B1 5'G%$& O&!**PIQ*7*I**RI+

    J>>'$3 (>T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

    N@C T$Hd ,1E(>dl l&!**P Q*7* **R + @31

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    63/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 ! (

    ?33$CL=G ? B H:CL=(=:C :- ?337:J?R [S!

    ,??$B3=C$> 4@B1$B1> 2=>1

    N@C'G$B1 5(G$h5'G%$& 5@ .H 0(K$>

    -@3=LC(D@B ,??&@U(E O ]$CD@B 97^ @H 1>$>>G$B1 ,C1 +P9P

    7

    5@1$>d

    +I ,EE 3@C'G$B1> =B 1 (??$B3=C$> G(=B1(=B 1T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    64/97

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    65/97

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    66/97

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    67/97

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    68/97

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    69/97

    *+ -./0 123345 67508.9:3 187.5 -'.52.9:3 ;8: ?4'74@ :A BC48.9:3.5 ;48A:8=.3D4 ! %

    ?33$CL=G Q B ?-3 ?J?=R?Q=R=(K

    ,??$B3=C$> 4@B1$B1> 2=>1

    N@C'G$B1 5(G$h5'G%$& 5@ .H 0(K$>

    B!**PIQ*7*I*RP O ,#0 ,U(=E(%=E=1)IaE> :

    5@1$>d

    +I ,EE 3@C'G$B1> =B 1 (??$B3=C$> G(=B1(=B 1T$U=>=@B +S !! #$%&'(&) !*+!

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    70/97

    Excerpt from AFP Log Date Planned work Started automatically

    Ran for approximately

    6 hours Stopped in alarm Stopped correctly

    Rinse started

    automatically Rinse occurred

    Approximate hours of operation

    Hours rounded to 0.5hrs, and grea

    than 6 unpermitted

    oliday 5/04/2010 No

    6/04/2010 Yes No

    7/04/2010 No Yes

    8/04/2010 No Yes

    9/04/2010 No Yes

    10/04/2010

    11/04/2010

    12/04/2010 Yes No

    13/04/2010 No No No

    14/04/2010 ? No No15/04/2010 No Yes No

    16/04/2010 Yes Yes

    17/04/2010

    18/04/2010

    19/04/2010 No Yes

    20/04/2010 No Yes

    21/04/2010 No Yes

    ct shutdown 1130 - RM logged in to alter th . , . I .22/04/2010 No No Yes Yes Yes No Yes

    1200 - AFP Plant Sequence st . .23/04/2010 No No Yes No Yes No Yes

    24/04/2010

    25/04/2010

    oliday 26/04/2010 No No No

    1800 - AFP shut down. 1818 - . . .27/04/2010 No Yes No Yes No Yes

    0726 AFP Alarm PLC1 / SOO 28/04/2010 No No Yes No Yes No Yes

    0600 - Pre separator sump hig . , . .29/04/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes No Yes

    2 f au lt 1210 - AFP P lant opera ti onal . . . , . , . .30/04/2010 No No No Yes No Yes Yes

    1/05/2010

    2/05/2010

    0624 - RM requested to start t . . . .3/05/2010 No No Yes No Yes No Yes

    erator 2 fault 1108 AFP Security alarm out , . ,4/05/2010 No No No Yes No Yes

    1211 AFP Started from Bexle . . , . .5/05/2010 No No Yes No No No Yes

    1150 - Prepaired to start AFP. . . . . I6/05/2010 No No Yes No No No Yes

    1150 - In contact w ith KW to e . , , I . .7/05/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    8/05/2010

    9/05/2010

    0939 Kev called from the AFP . . . .10/05/2010 No No Yes No Yes No No

    ult 0852 - AFP door alarms trigge . . .11/05/2010 No No No Yes No No Yes1200 - AFP activated by TCR , , , , , , , , ,12/05/2010 No No Yes No Yes No No

    equence Failed 1204 - AFP started 1205 - AF 13/05/2010 No No

    1155 - Energised fans, pump i . . I . . , .14/05/2010 No No Yes No No No Yes

    15/05/2010

    16/05/2010

    operational 1200 - AFP failed to start plant . . . . . .17/05/2010 No No No

    operational 1200 - AFP not started as it is . . .18/05/2010 No No No No Yes Yes Yes

    1200 - AFP started manually. , .19/05/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    g f ire detectors 0753 - WP 4592 Hol land Bros. I . .20/05/2010 Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes

    r 004 open 1210 - BB advised that CHUB , , , , .21/05/2010 No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes

    22/05/2010

    23/05/2010

    er at or 1 fa ul t 0 61 8 - W O ' S:- A2 23 5,2 21 8,2 . . . . . I24/05/2010 No Yes No Yes No No Yes

    0622 - KW and BBH (Gary Wil . , .25/05/2010 No No Yes No No Yes Yes

    opped 1150 - C heck prestar t on p lant . . . , , ,26/05/2010 No No No Yes No No Yes

    1200 - Starting AFP. 1803 - A . .27/05/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    AFP stopped in alarm without work planned, but ran for approximately 6 hours

    AFP ran for approximately 6 hours, but rinse did not occur

    AFP ran for 5 or less hours without work planned

    No AFP Report

    AFP ran for 6hrs, did not stop in alarm, AFP rinse occurred

    Work was planned during operation

    AFP had errors or alarms at start, but ran for approximately 6 hours without stopping in alarm

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    71/97

    1200 - AFP running. No faults . .28/05/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    29/05/2010

    30/05/2010

    1200 - AFP started 1809 - AF .31/05/2010 No Yes Yes No No No Yes

    1 80 4 - A FP p la nt se qu enc e a u . . . .1/06/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    0644 - RW placed clean water . . , . . .2/06/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1050 - Chris reset the fault on 3/06/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    D motor current hi 1200 - Plant sequence compr . . . . .4/06/2010 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    5/06/2010

    6/06/2010

    1 Phase 2 Current 1200 - AFP started 1209 - LV 7/06/2010 No Yes No Yes No No No

    s haft 1126 - KW Advised he w ou ld . . . . . ,8/06/2010 No No No Yes Yes No Yes

    or 1150 - AFP manual start, waiti . , . , . ,9/06/2010 No No No Yes No No Yes

    1150 - AFP manual s tart c om . . , , , .10/06/2010 No No Yes No No No Yes

    top testing 1150 - Kevin check ing with hig . . . .11/06/2010 Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes

    12/06/2010

    13/06/2010

    oliday 14/06/2010 No No No

    global reset. 1215 - Started 15/06/2010 No No Yes No Yes No Yes

    erator 1 fault 1433 - AFP Alarm ESP HV G I . I . .16/06/2010 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    1153 - Air Filtration Plant start . . . . . . . .17/06/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes1000 - WO A2817 i ss ued t o F i . , .18/06/2010 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes

    19/06/2010

    20/06/2010

    1200 - AFP did not s tart auto , . . , . .21/06/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1150 - AFP in alarm system r , , , ,22/06/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1157 - John at AFP called adv 23/06/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1155 - AFP global reset and f . .24/06/2010 No No Yes No No No Yes

    1150 - AFP s tart ed , Fans F00 , , . . , .25/06/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    26/06/2010

    27/06/2010

    1755 - Prepared to shut down 28/06/2010 No Yes Yes No No No Yes

    1200 - Received all-clear from . . , , . . , .29/06/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    ater tank top-up 1200 - AFP Started 1441 - K ,30/06/2010 Yes Yes No No Yes Yes Yes

    1/07/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    n't start 1200 - AFP global reset and e . . , .2/07/2010 Yes No No Yes Yes

    3/07/2010

    4/07/2010

    5/07/2010 No

    6/07/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    0837 - LSA picked up WO's 0 .7/07/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1210 - AFP alarms cleared 12 8/07/2010 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    9/07/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    10/07/2010

    11/07/2010

    12/07/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1756 - Air Filtration Plant shut . . . . . .13/07/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes No Yes

    14/07/2010 No No Yes No Yes No No1838 - AFP Plant Sequence c 15/07/2010 No Yes Yes No No No No

    op pe d 1 20 0 - A FP a cti va te d 1 42 5 - A , , ,16/07/2010 No Yes No Yes No No No

    17/07/2010

    18/07/2010

    19/07/2010 No No Yes No No Yes Yes

    1155 - F001,002,003 & 004 e . , . . .20/07/2010 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    1200 - BHEgis (Kevin) advise . . . I. I21/07/2010 No No Yes Yes No No Yes

    1200 - AFP plant not started, , . . , , .22/07/2010 No No Yes Yes Yes No Yes

    1200 - AFP started manually. , , . , ,23/07/2010 No No Yes Yes Yes No Yes

    24/07/2010

    25/07/2010

    26/07/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1200 - Air Filtration Plant Faile . . . . .27/07/2010 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    28/07/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    29/07/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    72/97

    30/07/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    31/07/2010

    1/08/2010

    2/08/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    0830 - AFP numerous urgent . .3/08/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1200 - AFP Started. 1339 - AF . .4/08/2010 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    1156 - AFP Started. 1157 - D0 , , , .5/08/2010 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    1840 - Clean water tank failed , , .6/08/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    7/08/2010

    8/08/2010

    9/08/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1154 - AFP f ans f ai led t o ener ;10/08/2010 No No Yes Yes No No No

    erator 1 (ioniser) fa .0836 - AFP Rinse sequence st . . . . . . .11/08/2010 No No No Yes No No Yes

    1200 - AFP Started. 1204 - De . . .12/08/2010 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    13/08/2010 No Yes Yes No No Yes Yes

    14/08/2010

    15/08/2010

    1200 - AFP started manually. , . . , .16/08/2010 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    17/08/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1200 - Failed attempt to start I . . . .18/08/2010 Yes No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    19/08/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yesation system in ala1200 - AFP unable to start du I . I . , , . .20/08/2010 No No No No No No No

    21/08/2010

    22/08/2010

    23/08/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1053 - iPower ons ite and shutt I , , ,24/08/2010 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    erator 1 fault 1202 - AFP Started. (CSIRO o 25/08/2010 No No No Yes No

    1200 - AFP f ai led t o s tart Com 26/08/2010 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    tests 0940 - KW & CSIRO on site A , . I , , . .27/08/2010 Yes No No No No No Yes

    28/08/2010

    29/08/2010

    1200 - AFP failed to start 120 , . .30/08/2010 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    31/08/2010 No No Yes No No No Yes

    1/09/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1156 AFP Started by Kevin fro .2/09/2010 Yes No Yes No No No No

    3/09/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    4/09/2010

    5/09/2010

    6/09/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    7/09/2010 Yes No

    8/09/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    9/09/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1215 - AFP fans energized an . . , .10/09/2010 No Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes

    11/09/2010

    12/09/2010

    13/09/2010 Yes Yes

    14/09/2010 No Yes

    15/09/2010Yes

    16/09/2010 Yes

    17/09/2010 Yes

    18/09/2010

    19/09/2010

    20/09/2010 Yes

    21/09/2010 Yes

    22/09/2010 Yes

    23/09/2010 Yes

    24/09/2010 Yes

    25/09/2010

    26/09/2010

    27/09/2010 Yes

    28/09/2010 Yes

    29/09/2010 No No

    30/09/2010 No Yes Yes No No Yes Yes

    ation system in ala1210 - AFP didn't start due to . .1/10/2010 No No No Yes No No No

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    73/97

    2/10/2010

    3/10/2010

    oliday 4/10/2010 No No

    Fans not running 1100 - AFP plant running start 5/10/2010 No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes

    6/10/2010 No Yes Yes No No Yes Yes

    7/10/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    8/10/2010 No No Yes No No No Yes

    9/10/2010

    10/10/2010

    Working 1150 - CSIRO ( Dave ) rang , t . I , . . I11/10/2010 Yes No No No Yes No Yes

    12/10/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    Working 1156 - C SIRO (Dan) adv is ed . . . . . I13/10/2010 Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes

    14/10/2010 No No Yes No No No Yes

    1 20 0 - Un abl e to st ar t AF P. S . . . . I . . . . I15/10/2010 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    16/10/2010

    17/10/2010

    0801 - AFP a larm, door opene . I . . I .18/10/2010 No Yes Yes No No No Yes

    king in plant 0545 - CSIRO rang they are n , . . , . .19/10/2010 Yes No No No No No No

    king in plant 1200 - AFP, KW not operating, . , .20/10/2010 Yes No No No No No No

    er at or 1 fa ul t 1 20 1 - E SP HV G en er er ato r 1 . . I I .21/10/2010 No No No Yes No No Yes

    on cancelled 0840 - Received a call from B .22/10/2010 No No No No No No No23/10/2010

    24/10/2010

    erating in Local 1200 - Kev called and advised 25/10/2010 Yes No No No No No No

    0910 - APP started by KW at . 26/10/2010 ? No Yes No No No No

    W or ki ng 1 20 0 - CSI RO o nsi te a nd wi ll r , . I27/10/2010 Yes No Yes No No No Yes

    Working 1200 - C SIRO ons it e and wi ll .28/10/2010 Yes No No No No No No

    29/10/2010 No Yes Yes No No No Yes

    30/10/2010

    31/10/2010

    1/11/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1 40 0 - A FP - Ke v, c al le d an d r . . .2/11/2010 No No Yes No No No No

    0 93 5 - A FP - I -Po we r r eq ue st I . . .3/11/2010 No No Yes No No No No

    4/11/2010 No No Yes No No Yes Yes

    uta ge 1 22 0 - A FP s ta rt ed m an ua ll y.1 , , , . .5/11/2010 Yes No No Yes No No No

    6/11/2010

    7/11/2010

    8/11/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1800 - AFP - Normal Stop & N .9/11/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes No No

    0730 - KW working on the wat . . . . ,10/11/2010 No No Yes No Yes No No

    1200 - AFP Started. 1802 - AF . . . . ,11/11/2010 Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1200 - KW advised not to run t .12/11/2010 No No No No No No No

    13/11/2010

    14/11/2010

    erator 1 fault 1048 - Received Phone Cal l f r ,15/11/2010 No No No Yes No No No

    ser HV Fault 1200 - AFP Manually Started 1 , I . I . ,16/11/2010 No No No Yes No No No

    0645 - Pre Ioniser, Started wh . I , . I , . I ,17/11/2010 No No Yes No Yes No No

    1200 - AFP started 1227 - Pre . . . .18/11/2010

    No Yes Yes No No No No19/11/2010 No No Yes No No

    20/11/2010

    21/11/2010

    1220 - AFP started1800 - AFP . .22/11/2010 No No Yes No No No Yes

    1200 - AFP Failed to start - Is . . . . .23/11/2010 No No Yes No No No Yes

    and LSA in plant 24/11/2010 Yes No No No Yes No No

    1200 - AFP Started.1800 - AF . . .25/11/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    0812 - KW said the APF wasn . .26/11/2010 No No No No No No No

    27/11/2010

    28/11/2010

    1200 AFP Started1800 AFP st . . . .29/11/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    0600 - TCRO Operator logged . . , . . . . .30/11/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    Multiple alarms for 'Plant Outl I . . . . I . . .1/12/2010 No No No No Yes Yes Yes

    1200 - AFP Started.1802 - AF I2/12/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1205 - Air Filtration Plant Start . . . .3/12/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    4/12/2010

  • 7/27/2019 m5e Tunnel Air Filtration Trial Evaluation Amog Report February 2012

    74/97

    5/12/2010

    1200 - AFP Started. 1800 - AF 6/12/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1200 - AFP started. 1220 - Pr . . . . . .7/12/2010 No Yes Yes No No Yes Yes

    1400 - AFP Started 1800 - AF . . . .8/12/2010 No No No No Yes Yes Yes

    1200 - AFP Started. 1202 - AF I . . . .9/12/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1200 - AFP Started. 1202 - AF I . .10/12/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    11/12/2010

    12/12/2010

    1200 - AFP started manually. . . . . .13/12/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1200 - AFP started manually. . . . . .14/12/2010 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    1200 - AFP StartedD1215 - A 15/12/2010 No No No Yes No No No

    1220 - AFP Started 1800 - AF . . . . , .16/12/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1220 - AFP Started 1800 - AF . . . .17/12/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    18/12/2010

    19/12/2010

    1200 - AFP did not run today, , . .20/12/2010 No No No No No No No

    1200 - AFP started. 1800 - AF . , . . . , .21/12/2010 No No Yes No Yes No No

    1200 - AFP started manually. . . .22/12/2010 No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes

    1205 - Attempted to start AFP, . , . , . ,23/12/2010 No No Yes No Yes No Yes

    1200 - AFP Started 1800 - AF . , . .24/12/2010 No Yes Yes No Yes No No

    25/12/201026/12/2010

    oliday 27/12/2010

    oliday 28/12/2010

    1200 - AFP w ould not s tart ,"V , , .29/12/2010 No No No Yes No No No

    1100 - Rang KW about not bei , . . , .30/12/2010 No No No Yes No No No

    31/12/2010

    1/01/2011

    2/01/2011

    oliday 3/01/2011

    1200 - AFP Started. * Failed t . I . . I4/01/2011 No No Yes No Yes No No

    1200 - AFP Started. * Failed t . I . . I5/01/2011 No No No No No No No

    1200 - AFP s tart ed ESP H V G . . . . .6/01/2011 No No Yes No No No No

    0845 - Wash down done by B , . , , .