Page 1
Sustainable energyin engineering applications
Presentation to the National Committee of Applied Mechanics Sustainability in Practical
Engineering, Series 2, Energy, Manufacturing and Infrastructure
Scott LoseeScott Losee Consulting
19/2/2015, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2. Brisbane
Page 2
Scott LoseeConsultingFocus
How can the concept of
sustainability guide engineers in
making decisions that concern
energy?
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 3
Scott LoseeConsultingOutline
Lest we forget: remembering why Think sustainable Technology perspectives
The supply side silver bullet
Tyranny of the status quo
Sketching a sustainable energy future Infrastructure
Measuring the unmeasurable
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 4
Lest we forget. Remembering why
Page 5
Scott LoseeConsultingEcological footprint
Number of Earth's required Number available
If all the world lived like Australians...
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 6
The world’s lights at night
Page 7
Photo: Fernando Hidalgo Molina, 2008Picture taken near to Cascavel - PR - Brazil. Detail of the HVDC Line of Furnas (600kV)
1.3 billion~20% of the
world, have no electricity
Page 8
The carbon budget conceptBy The World Resources Institute
Page 9
When my Dad was born
Page 11
When my 1st daughter was
born
Page 15
Athabasca Glacier, 1978
Page 16
Athabasca Glacier, 2003
Page 17
Scott LoseeConsulting
Not just climate impacts
Page 18
Think sustainable.
Image source: imgkid.com
Page 19
Scott LoseeConsulting
Sustainability: used and abused
Low environmental impact Consumer products Lifestyles Tack on design consideration Added cost, discretionary, fashionable accessory? Accreting assumptions
Such as the idea that renewable is, by definition, sustainable
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 20
Scott LoseeConsulting
Environmental Protection
Economic Prosperity
Social Advancement
Thinking about sustainability
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 21
Scott LoseeConsulting
Sustainability = f (Environment, Society, Economy)
1
Equation 2: Integration
Balance versus integration
Equation 1: Balance
Environment + Society + Economy3
Sustainability =
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 22
Scott LoseeConsulting‘Eighties’ sustainability
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 23
Scott LoseeConsultingAustralia NSESD 1992
Development safeguards future generations
Equity within and between generations
Protect biodiversity, ecological processes
Integrated decision making
Precautionary principle
Global environmental dimension
Strong economy can enhance capacity for environmental protection
International competitiveness in an environmentally sound manner
Cost-effective/flexible policy instruments
Broad community involvement on issues
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 24
Scott LoseeConsultingRefreshed considerations
The well-being of people, social equity and fairness
The interests of future generations Involvement of people in decisions that
affect them Precaution where there are risks and
uncertainty Future as well as immediate implications
(including the impacts of climate change) Effects that extend beyond project
boundaries Potential interaction amongst the above
considerations
Protection of the natural environment, communities and local economies
Opportunities for improved environmental and resource outcomes
Maintenance and efficient use of natural resources:
Energy efficiency and renewable energy
Water efficiency and protection of surface and groundwater
Building materials (e.g. recycled content, recyclability, embodied energy, lifespan, toxicity)
Waste (e.g. construction and demolition waste)Source: after Gibson, R., Sustainability Assessment
- Criteria and Processes, 2005
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 25
Scott LoseeConsultingWhat does this mean?
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 26
Scott LoseeConsultingHierarchies
Waste
ReduceReuseRecycleRecoverTreatDispose
Water useEnd use needsEfficiencyMatch qualityRecover/recycleTreatDispose
Energy useEnd use needsEfficiencyMatch qualityRecover/recycleOffset/trading
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 27
Scott LoseeConsultingWhat we want
Hot showers
Cold beer
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 28
Scott LoseeConsultingNot electricity
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 29
Scott LoseeConsultingEarly thinking
Sustainable Energy Systems:
1. Rely on renewable energy flows
2. Diverse
3. Flexible and relatively low-tech
4. Scale and geographic distribution matched to end use needs
5. Energy quality matched to end-use needs
1977
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 30
Scott LoseeConsultingEnd-use/least cost
How much energy of what kind at what scale and from what source would do each desired task in the cheapest way?
Amory Lovins
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 31
Scott LoseeConsultingDiesel
What kind? – source/fuel substitution exampleDiesel provides some lifecycle energy and GHG benefit over petrol
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 32
Scott LoseeConsultingHybrid
Smart technology in hybrids offer further energy benefits
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 33
Scott LoseeConsultingElectric
Energy benefits of electric cars depend on where the electricity came fromElectrification generally can allow for easier decarbonisation
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 34
Scott LoseeConsultingBananas and muesli
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 35
Scott LoseeConsultingTrade-off rules
1. Maximise net gain
2. Burden of argument on proponent
3. Avoid significant adverse effects
4. Protection of the future
5. Explicit justification
6. Open process
Source: Gibson, Sustainability Assessment- Criteria and Processes, 2005
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 36
Scott LoseeConsultingTrade-offs in practice
The tube that never was. Traded off with community engagement for more optimal outcomes
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 37
Example of major infrastructure with significant energy demand4.6 km tunnel connecting Western Freeway and Inner City Bypass. Opening this year and will be run by Transurban
Page 38
Scott LoseeConsultingTunnel energy use
Electricity Demand
VentilationLightingPresurisation fansPumps
Legacy Way example
Based on EIS
22,873 MWh pa
21,513 tCO2-e pa
=1,434 Households
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 39
Scott LoseeConsulting
Image source: http://www.bmd.com.au
Ventilation outlet vs. portals
Potential optimising between energy hungry stack ventilation and portal emissions
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 40
Scott LoseeConsulting
Result of systematic approach
Leads us to more sustainable solutions, choices and decisions
Shows why
Avoids jumping to conclusions e.g. not just renewable supply for its
own sake
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 41
Technology perspectives
Image source: Ratcliffe Power Plant, Nottinghamshire, by Alan Zomerfled, Wikipedia, 2006
Page 42
Scott LoseeConsultingThe supply side silver bullet
There is a tendency to think in terms of finding a single, major new energy source that will fulfil all our needs cleanly and affordably
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 43
Scott LoseeConsulting
Sustainable energy technologies
Today’s examples Solar concentrating with storage (Prof. Gurgenci)
Personal microturbines (Dr Skoufa)
Supply side: more sustainable generation? Solar PV, wind, tidal, wave, hydrogen, offshore wind, solar thermal, biomass,
biogas…
Demand side: energy efficiency technologies? LED lights, variable speed drives, chilled beams, smart grids, batteries,
daylighting, hybrid motors, smart grids…
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 44
Scott LoseeConsultingCompetition between sources
Example of former Gold Coast Mayor Ron Clarke becoming fixated on a tidal power opportunity
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 45
Scott LoseeConsulting
Logic and messy reality
Big ‘P’ politics Small ‘p’ politics
Who wins/who loses among voters and stakeholders
Image, posturing Dogma
Who is the smartest engineer? Whose feels threatened? Hobby horses, pet projects, bias
Graphic source: Australian Renewable Energy Agency, 2014
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 46
Good technologyis not enough
Council buses on theroads in 1999
Page 47
Scott LoseeConsulting
Image source: www.busesworldwide.org
EOI and tender evaluation looked at performance instead of fuel type
Page 48
Engineers argued to wait for H fuel cell and WA Government promoted this view
Page 49
Old technology electric storage hot water systems removed during sustainable retrofitting project, presented as art at Powerhouse Museum
Page 50
Image source: http://aaa-lux-lighting.com/schiphol/
LEDs – breakthrough happing now
Page 51
Sketching a sustainable energy future
Image source: Scott Losee
Page 52
Scott LoseeConsulting
Uranium Mining, Processing and Nuclear Energy - Opportunities for Australia? 2006
Macro-level choices
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 53
Scott LoseeConsultingWhy not nuclear?
Issues: No solution for high level waste
½ life of plutonium = 24,000 years
Upstream low level waste
Security risk
Radiation leaks, meltdowns
Nuclear priesthood
Would you call it sustainable?
Image source: logo-kid.com
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 54
Scott LoseeConsultingFuel mix transition
BREE, Australian Energy Projections to 2050, Dec. 2012
2013 2035 20500
100
200
300
400
GeothermalSolarBioenergyWindHydroOilGasBrown coalBlack coal
Page 55
Image source: Origin Energy advertising campaign
Page 56
Scott LoseeConsultingSmart grids
Image source: Space-Time Insight via Smart Grid News
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 57
Scott LoseeConsultingSmart grid possibilities
Image source (above): Scott LoseeImage source (left): Amazon.com, Leviton EVB22-3PM Evr-Green 160 Home Charging Station, 3.8kW output, Level 2
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 58
Infrastructure –measuring the unmeasurable
Image source: easysewingforbeginners.com
Page 59
Scott LoseeConsulting
Defining sustainability for buildings
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 60
Scott LoseeConsulting
The rating schemeInfrastructure Sustainability Council of Australia
A scheme to guide (and rate) the sustainability of design, construction and operations of Australia’s infrastructure
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 61
Scott LoseeConsulting
55+ member organisations
employing
70,000+ people
Industry leadership
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 62
Scott LoseeConsultingIS benefits
Common national language for sustainability Consistent application and evaluation in tendering Scoping whole-of-life risks for projects and assets,
enabling smarter solutions that reduce risks and costs Fosters resource efficiency and waste reduction,
reducing costs Fosters innovation and continuous improvement Builds an organisation’s credentials and reputation
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 63
Scott LoseeConsultingIS rating tool scorecard
Release date: 16/03/2012Original release date: 29/02/2012
Themes Categories Categories No. Credits Score Possible
Management Systems Man 8 10.5
Procurement and Purchasing Pro 4 5.0
Climate Change Adaptation Cli 2 5.0
Energy and Carbon Ene 3 10.5
Water Wat 3 7.0
Materials Mat 2 7.0
Discharges to Air, Land and Water Dis 5 10.5
Land Lan 4 7.0
Waste Was 3 7.0
Ecology Ecology Eco 4 10.5
Community Health, Well-being and Safety Hea 3 5.0
Heritage Her 2 5.0
Stakeholder Participation Sta 4 5.0
Urban and Landscape Design Urb 4 5.0
51 100
Innovation Innovation Inn 1 5
Using Resources
Emissions, Pollution and
Waste
People and Place
Management and
Governance
Graphical Summary >>
Credit Summary >>
Project/Asset Input >>
Instructions >>
Introduction >>
Start Credits >>
Menu
Infrastructure Sustainability Rating ToolVersion 1.0
Page 64
Scott LoseeConsulting
Original tunnel design(note fans)
Page 65
– Redesigned for natural ventilation
– Roof slopes up
– No fans (i.e. no replacement, testing, substations or fan control gear)
– Some natural light
Page 67
Scott LoseeConsultingISCA project energy achievements
Project/asset Energy outcomes
Whitsunday STP UpgradesDesign and As Built
• 20,700 tCO2e reduced over lifecycle• 15.5% reduction in energy use• Further savings from Design Rating
Gold Coast Light RailDesign
• 55% improvement in embodied carbon against reference design
• 104,000 tCO2e embodied carbon reduction
Googong Water Treatment Plant Chemical Facility Upgrade (ACT)Design
• 275 tCO2e avoided• 16 t of steel reduced• Halved the use of crushed rock
Great Eastern Highway Upgrade (WA)As Built
• Extensive use of recycled materials• Reducing use of limestone, sand and bitumen• 43% of imported material recycled
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 68
Scott LoseeConsultingWrap-up
Climate change is one of several pressing challenges
Sustainability more than just a word Opportunities in infrastructure abound End use/least cost What role will you play in facing sustainable
energy choices? Best technology not enough to create
changeImage source: Scott Losee
Losee, NCAM Sustainability in Practical Engineering, Series 2, Brisbane, 19/2/2015 loseeconsulting.com.au
Page 69
Thank you
Scott Losee / 0404 467 228 / [email protected]
@Scott_Losee