List New2.ASP

IDNo.150/12

16.04.2015

WW2 StatementofSh.MohanLalagedabout42yearss/o.LateSh.KajodiLal,R/o.H.No.C7/151,Sultanpuri,NewDelhi110086

OnSA

Ihereby tender myevidencebywayofaffidavit Ex.WW2/Awhichbearsmy

signaturesatpointsA&B.IrelyupondocumentsEx.WW2/1toEx.WW2/3

andEx.WW1/3toEx.WW1/6.DocumentsEx.WW2/1toEx.WW2/3objected

tobyld.counselformanagementassamearephotocopies.Howeverwitnessstates

thathehascertifiedcopiesofEx.WW2/2andoriginalofEx.WW2/3andoriginal

receipt ofEx.WW2/1whichhavebeenfiledinconnectedcaseIDNo.164/12

titledasNaliniVs.MaharajaAgrasenHospitalassamearerequiredforother

casesaswell.

xxxxxxxxbyMs.DeeptiSingh,Advocateformanagementno.1.

Crossexaminationisdeferredtillthenextdateofhearing.

RO&AC

...............................

(ANANDSWAROOPAGGARWAL)POLCXI/KKD/DELHI/16.04.2015*

IDNo.155/12&156/12

16.04.2015

WW2 StatementofSh.MohanLalagedabout42yearss/o.LateSh.KajodiLal,R/o.H.No.C7/151,Sultanpuri,NewDelhi110086

OnSA



andEx.WW1/4toEx.WW1/7.DocumentsEx.WW2/1toEx.WW2/3objected

tobyld.counselformanagementassamearephotocopies.Howeverwitnessstates

thathehascertifiedcopiesofEx.WW2/2andoriginalofEx.WW2/3andoriginal

receiptofEx.WW2/1whichhavebeenfiledinconnectedcasetitledasMukesh

DeviVs.MaharajaAgrasenHospitalassamearerequiredforothercasesaswell.

xxxxxxxxbyMs.DeeptiSingh,Advocateformanagementno.1.

Crossexaminationisdeferredtillthenextdateofhearing.

RO&AC

...............................


IDNo.50/14

16.04.2015

WW1 StatementofSh.OmSinghagedabout60yearss/o.Sh.FatehSingh,R/o.H.No.RZ35N,NewRoshanPura,NewDelhi.

OnSA



andMarkA.DocumentEx.WW1/1objectedtobyld.counselformanagement

forwantofproofofserviceandsameisnotbeingoriginal.Ontheotherhand,ld.

counselforworkmanstatedthatoriginalofEx.WW1/1issenttomanagementand

same is carboncopyof the Ex.WW1/1. Further ld. counsel for management

objectedtodocumentEx.WW1/3andEx.WW1/4assamearenotbeingcertified

copyfromconcernedofficeandthereisnoproofonrecordwhichestablishesthe

filingofthesaiddocumentbeforetheconcernedoffice.

xxxxxxxxbyMr.VikasTiwari,Adv.formanagement.

Crossexaminationis deferredtill thenext dateofhearingat therequestof ld.

counselformanagement.

RO&AC

...............................


DIDNo.668/14

16.04.2015

Present: WorkmanwithMr.RajeshKhanna,ARW.Mr.ManishMalhotra,Adv.formanagement.

Heardonthepointwhetheranissueasregardthelengthofservice

ofworkmanwiththemanagementcanbeframedornotinthepresentproceedings.

Putupon28.04.2015forconsiderationonissues. Ld.counselfor

managementisatlibertytofilecaselawsonorbeforethenextdateofhearing.


IDNo.150/112

16.04.2015

Present: Mr.MohanLal,ARW.Ms.DeeptiSingh,Adv.formanagementno.1.Noneformanagementno.2.

InRWE,Mr.MohanLal,ld.ARWexaminedhimselfasWW2.His

cross examination is deferred. Put up on 08.07.2015 for cross examination of

WW2Mr.MohanLal.


IDNo.155/12&156/12

16.04.2015

Present: WorkmanwithMr.MohanLal,ARW.Ms.DeeptiSingh,Adv.formanagementno.1.Noneformanagementno.2.

InRWE,Mr.MohanLal,ld.ARWexaminedhimselfasWW2.His

cross examination is deferred. Put up on 08.07.2015 for cross examination of

WW2Mr.MohanLal.


IDNo.348/12,153/12,164/12

16.04.2015

Present: Mr.MohanLal,ARW.Ms.DeeptiSingh,Adv.formanagementno.1.Noneformanagementno.2.

TodaycaseisfixedforcrossexaminationofWW2Mr.MohanLal

butld.counselformanagementno.1requestforadjournmentasdocumentstobe

confrontedwiththewitness(WW2)arenotavailablewithher.Assuch,putupon

08.07.2015forcrossexaminationofWW2Mr.MohanLal.


DIDNo.(KaramveerSinghVs.M/s.BasEngineeringPvt.Ltd.)

16.04.2015

Freshclaimundersection2AoftheIndustrialDisputesAct,1947fileddirectlyintheCourtalongwithfailurereportdated15.12.2014.Itbecheckedandregistered.

Present: WorkmanwithMr.KailashJonwal,Adv.forworkman.

Statementofclaim and documents perused. Issue notice of the

claimtothemanagementfor13.05.2015.


IDNo.323/12

16.04.2015

Present: WorkmanwithMr.AjitSingh,Adv.Ms.PoonamDas,Adv.formanagementno.1withMr.VijayJain,Supervisor.Mr.SanjaySharma,Adv.formanagementno.2.Noneformanagementno.3.

Reportdated12.03.2015receivedfromDMC,KKDCourts,Delhi

perused.Letthestatementsofpartiesberecorded.

StatementofMr.PradeepKumars/o.Sh.SukhChainSingh.

OnSA

Ihavesettledallmydisputes/claims/duesagainstmanagementno.1M/s.DHL

ExpressIndiaPvt.Ltd.intermsofreportfromDMC,KKDCourts,DelhiEx.X.

In terms of said settlement I have received Rs.10,000/ in cash and signed of

receiptEx.Y.Ihavesignedtwocopiesofthereceiptonekeptbythemanagement

andanother kept on judicial record. AlsoI havereceived the original cheque

(amountingRs.30,000/bearingno.020508dated25.03.2015drawnonDeutsche

Bank,ECEHouse,28,KasturbaGandhiMarg,NewDelhi)photocopyofwhichis

Ex.Z.AftertheencashmentofthischequeIshallbeleftwithnoclaims/dues/

disputes against the management no.1 in terms of report Ex.X. Henceforth,

management no.1 need not attend the court proceedings and same stands

dischargedfromitsliabilities/obligations/responsibilities.

RO&AC


StatementofMr.VijayJain,Supervisorwiththemanagementno.1.

OnSA

Ihaveheardthestatementmadebyworkman. Chequeinquestiongiventothe

workmanshallbehonouredandincaseofeventualdishonourworkmanisfreeto

adoptlawfulrecoursesavailabletohim.

RO&AC


Ld. counsel for management no.2 has noobjection to the settlement as

abovesaidbetweenworkmanandmanagementno.1.

Put up on 12.05.2015 for arguments on workman's application for

productionofrecordsfrommanagement.Ld.counselforworkmansubmittedthat

henceforthheshallnotbepressinghisapplicationseekingproductionofrecordsas

againstmanagementno.1.Inviewofabovestatementsdisputes/claims/duesof

theworkmanagainstthemanagementno.1M/s.DHLExpressIndiaPvt.Ltd.shall

betakenassatisfied/compromised.


IDNo.320/1216.04.2015Present: Smt.MunniDevi(Mother)andSmt.KavitaPal(earlierwifeof

deceasedworkman)LRsofdeceasedworkmanwithMr.AjitSingh,Adv.(vakalatnama/authoritysignedbySmt.MunniDevibefiledpositivelyinthecourtproceedings)Ms.PoonamDas,Adv.formanagementno.1withMr.VijayJain,Supervisor.Mr.SanjaySharma,Adv.formanagementno.2.Noneformanagementno.3.

Report dated 12.03.2015 received from DMC, KKD Courts, Delhi

perused.Letthestatementsofpartiesberecorded.

StatementofSmt.MunniDevi(Motherofdeceasedworkman)/w/o.Sh.KunwarPal.

OnSA

IbeingtheLRofMr.SanjeevKumar(deceasedworkman) havesettledall disputes /

claims/duesagainst managementno.1M/s.DHLExpressIndiaPvt. Ltd.intermsof

reportfromDMC,KKDCourts,DelhiEx.Xonbehalfofmydeceasedson.Intermsof

saidsettlementIhavereceivedRs.10,000/incashandsignedofreceiptEx.Y. Ihave

signedtwocopiesofthereceiptonekeptbythemanagementandanotherkeptonjudicial

record. Also I have receivedtheoriginal cheque(amounting Rs.30,000/ bearingno.

020765dated10.04.2015drawnonDeutscheBank, ECEHouse, 28, KasturbaGandhi

Marg,NewDelhi)photocopyofwhichisEx.Z.AftertheencashmentofthischequeI

shall beleftwithnoclaims/dues/disputesagainstthemanagementno.1intermsof

reportEx.X. Henceforth,managementno.1neednotattendthecourtproceedingsand

samestandsdischargedfromitsliabilities/obligations/responsibilities. Thesaidtotal

amount of Rs.40,000/ shall beequally dividedbetweenmeandmygrandsonnamely

HarshPal(agedabout1years).

RO&AC


StatementofMs.KavitaPal(earlierwifeofdeceasedworkman)w/o.Sh.KapilKumar.

OnSA

IamthenaturalguardianofMasterHarshPal. IhaveheardthestatementmadebymymotherinlawnamelySmt.MunniDeviandIhavenoobjectionifthesettledamountofRs.40,000/shallbedividedequallybetweenmymotherinlawnamelySmt.MunniDeviandmychildMasterHarshPal.IdonotpressforclaimsagainsttheabovesaidsumofRs.40,000/ inasmuch as I have remarried after the death of Mr. Sanjeev Kumar myhusband.

RO&AC


StatementofMr.VijayJain,Supervisorwiththemanagementno.1.

OnSA

IhaveheardthestatementmadebySmt.MunniDevi(Motherofdeceasedworkman)andMs. Kavita Pal (earlier wife of deceased workman) is true and correct. Cheque inquestiongiventoSmt.MunniDevishallbehonouredandincaseofeventualdishonourSmt.MunniDeviisfreetoadoptlawfulrecoursesavailabletoher.

RO&AC


Ld.counselformanagementno.2hasnoobjectiontothesettlementasabovesaid

between workman and management no.1. Put up on 12.05.2015 for arguments on

workman's application for production of records frommanagement. Ld. counsel for

workman submitted that henceforth he shall not be pressing his application seeking

productionofrecordsasagainstmanagementno.1.Inviewofabovestatementsdisputes/

claims/duesoftheworkmanagainstthemanagementno.1M/s.DHLExpressIndiaPvt.

Ltd.shallbetakenassatisfied/compromised.


IDNo.06/14

16.04.2015

Present: WorkmenPraveenandPawanwithMr.KailashJonwalAdv.Mr.SanjeevKumarAdv.proxyforMr.AmitGuptaGovt.Counsel

for managementno.1.Mr.AmanKumarPathakAdv.formanagementno.2.

Mr.SanjayAggarwalAdv.earlierrepresentingformanagementsno.

2whowishtowithdrawhisauthorityonbehalfofmanagementno.2.Hehasalso

no objection if Mr. Aman Kumar Pathak Adv. is permitted to represent the

managementno.2.Allowed.

Certaindocumentsincludingatrueattestedcopyofpartnershipdeed

filedbymanagementno.2. Authority letterandlist ofwitnessesalsofiledon

behalfofmanagementno.2.Copysupplied.

Putupon15.05.2015forrejoinderandissues.Workmantotakea

specific stands in the rejoinder as regards the documents relied upon by

management.

(ANANDSWAROOPAGGARWAL)POLCXI/KKD/DELHI/16.04.2015+

IDNo.44/14

16.04.2015

Present: Mr.KailashJonwalAdv.forworkman.Mr.SanjeevKumarAdv.proxyforMr.AmitGuptaGovt.Counsel

for managementno.1.Mr.AmanKumarPathakAdv.formanagementno.2.Noneformanagementno.3.








Putupon15.05.2015forrejoinderandissues.Onthenextdateof

hearing,allthepartnersofmanagementno.2toappearinpersonbeforethecourt

withoutfail. Workmantotakeaspecificstandsintherejoinderasregardsthe

documentsrelieduponbymanagement.


IDNo.46/14

16.04.2015

Present: WorkmenwithMr.KailashJonwalAdv.Mr.SanjeevKumarAdv.proxyforMr.AmitGuptaGovt.Counsel

for managementno.1.Mr.AmanKumarPathakAdv.formanagementno.2.








Putupon15.05.2015forrejoinderandissues. Workmantotakea

specific stands in the rejoinder as regards the documents relied upon by

management.


DIDNo.687/14&688/14

16.04.2015

Present: WorkmanwithMr.RajeshKhannaARW.Mr.O.P.TiwariAdv.formanagementwithMr.RamjasMishra,proprietor.

Atjointrequest,matterisreferredtoDelhiMediationCenter,KKD

Courts,Delhifor 22.04.2015at12.00noon. Putupon28.05.2015for report

aboutmediationproceedings.


IDNo.700/14

16.04.2015

Present: Workmaninperson.Mr.RamAnugrahSinghAdv.formanagement.

WS, documents with list of witnesses filed. Copy supplied.

Vakalatnamaalsofiled.Letcourtfeebeaffixedonthevakalatnamaasandwhen

available.Putupon18.05.2015forrejoinderandissues.


DIDNo.43/15

16.04.2015

Present: Mr.AjitSinghAdv.forworkman.Mr.AlokKumarAggarwal,UnitHeadwithmanagement.

Certified copy of Board Resolution filed by Mr. Alok Kumar

Aggarwal.Copyoftheclaimanddocumentssupplied.Putupon12.05.2015for

WSalongwithallthedocumentstoberelieduponbymanagementduringtrialwith

listofwitnesses.


DIDNo.42/15

16.04.2015

Present: WorkmanwithMr.GajenderSinghAdv.

Mr.RajRishiAdv./ARformanagement.

Managementstandsservedwiththesummons

Memo.ofappearancefiledbyARM.Copyofclaim,documentsand

listofwitnessessuppliedtold.counselforthemanagement.Putupon22.05.2015

forWS,documentstoberelieduponbymanagementduringtrialofthiscaseand

listofwitnesses.


DIDNo.660/14

16.04.2015

Present: Workmaninperson.

Mr.PradeepKumarAdv.proxyforMr.OmKanwarSharmaAdv.

for management.

Rejoinderfiled. Copysupplied.ld.counselforthemanagementis

statedtobenotavailableonaccountofillhealth.Managementtoproduceoriginl

documentswhicharetobeputtoworkmanforadmissiondenial.Alsoworkmanto

producetheoriginaldocumentswhicharetobeputtomanagementforadmission

denialpurposes.Somecompetentpersontoappearonbehalfofmanagementfor

thepurposeofadmissiondenialofdocuments.Putupon22.05.2015foradmission

denialofdocumentsandconsiderationonissues.


IDNo.683/14&684/14

16.04.2015

Present: None.

Intheinterestofjustice,putupon19.05.2015forrejoinder&issues.


IDNo.39/14&108/14

16.04.2015

Present: Nonefortheworkman.Mr.RajeshKumarAdv.formanagementwithMr.SatyaNarayanAggarwal,proprietorofmanagement.Intheinterestofjustice,putupon01.07.2015forWE.


IDNo.254/12

16.04.2015

Present: WorkmanwithMr.PrithviRajChauhanAdv.proxycounselforMr.SaurabhRastogiAdv.fromDLSA.Mr.ManishMalhotraAdv.formanagementwithMr.D.N.Sharma.

Ld.Proxycounselfortheseeksadjournment.Notopposed.

Attention of ld. counsel for themanagementwas drawntoorder

dated 22.01.2015. Ld. counsel for the management submitted that one more

opportunitymaybegiventothemanagementtofileaffidavits ofMWs,ifany,

within10daysfromtoday. Heard. Opportunitygranted. Putupon28.05.2015

forM.E.


IDNo.424/14

16.04.2015

Present: WorkmanPradeepKumarinperson.Mr.ManishMalhotraAdv.formanagement.

Replyfiled.Ld.counselfortheworkmanisnotavailabletoday.On

thenextdateofhearing,ld.counselforworkmantoappearwithoutfailtoaddress

arguments on the application seeking permission to crossexamine the

management'switnesses,otherwise,courtshallproceedwiththedisposalofsaid

applicationasperlaw.Putupon14.05.2015forarguments.


DIDNo.300/14

16.04.2015

Present: Workmaninperson.

Noneforthemanagement.

Putupon05.05.2015forfurtherarguments,ifany/orderonenquiry

issue. Workman submitted that his counsel has already submitted written

argumentsanddoesnotwishtoargueanymore.


IDNo.226/11

16.04.2015

Present: WorkmanwithMr.DhananjayRanaAdv.Mr.GurpreetSingh,LitigationAssistantwiththemanagement.

Mr.GurpreetSinghhasfiledservicerulesnamelyDelhiConsumer

Cooperative Wholesale Store Ltd. Service Rules marked as Mark X for

identificationpurposes(runninginto8pages).Copysupplied.Mr.GurpreetSingh

submittedthatbesidestheserulestherearenootherservicerules.

Put up on 22.05.2015 for arguments in terms of order dated

05.02.2015.Onthenextdateofhearing,Mr.K.R.RanaAdv.formanagementand

Mr.GurpreetSinghtoappearwithoutfailandtoaddressthearguments,otherwise,

courtshallproceedwiththematterafterhearingargumentsofld.counselforthe

workman.


IDNo.162/11

16.04.2015

Present: WorkmanwithMr.PankajSrivastavaAdv.Mr.PradeepKumarAdv.withMr.SurjeetSingh,proprietorofthemanagement.

Ld.counselforthemanagementhasmovedanotherapplicationu/s.

151 CPC supported by an affidavit title as detailed affidavit. Also certain

documentsfiledbythemanagement. Copysupplied. Workmantofilereplyto

boththeapplicationsofthemanagementmovedu/s.151CPCfirstlyon17.10.2014

andtoday.Putupon22.05.2015forreplyandarguments.


IDNo.163/11

16.04.2015

Present: Mr.PankajSrivastavaAdv.forworkman.Mr.PradeepKumarAdv.withMr.SurjeetSingh,proprietorofthemanagement.

Putupon22.05.2015forfinalargumentswithconnectedcaseID

No.162/11.


IDNo.579/14

16.04.2015

M1W1Mr.SandeepKumar,OfficeSuperintendent,ShriDadaDevMaitriAvumShishuChikitsalay,Dabri,Delhi45

OnS.A

Itendermyevidencebywayofaffidavit whichis Ex.M1W1/A

whichbearsmysignaturesatpointsA&B.MyauthorityisEx.A.Irelyuponthe

documentswhichhavebeenmentionedasEx.MW1/1toEx.MW1/4.Thesaid

documentsarenottraceableaspercircularMarkA. IstatethatImyselfhave

neverseentheoriginalofdocumentsasmentionedasEx.MW1/1toEx.MW1/4in

myevidenceaffidavit. Thedocumentstoberelieduponbymemaybereadas

MarkB,C,DandErespectively.Irequestthatsaiddocumentsmaykindlyberead

asexhibiteddocumentsifIamabletoproducetheoriginalsthereofinfuture.

XXXXByMr.AnilRajputAdv.forworkman.

I have been working with the management no. 1 as Office

Superintendentsince8thApril2013.

Q. KindlytellastohowmanycontractorswerechangedsinceJanuary,2010

tillOctober,2011?

Ans. Forthesanitarypurposes,contractofM/s.PremiaSecurityServicesPvt.

Ltdwasextended. InitiallycontractwasgiventoM/s.PremiaSecurityServices

Pvt.Ltdon14.11.2009till13.11.2010andsubsequentlyitwasextendedfourtimes

andfinallyendedw.e.f.22.10.2011.

IcannottellastohowmanypersonswereprovidedbyM/s.Premia

Security ServicesPvt. Ltdto themanagementno. 1duringtheyears2010and

2011. The agreement betweenmanagement no. 1 and M/s. Premia Security

ServicesPvt.Ltdprovidedfor M/s.PremiaSecurityServicesPvt.Ltdproviding

sanitationservices.(vol.M/s.PremiaSecurityServicesPvt.Ltdwastobepaidon

the basis of area over which sanitation services were to be provided and not

number of persons provided by M/s. Premia Security Services Pvt. Ltd to

managementno.1).

Q. WhetheranySupervisorof M/s.PremiaSecurityServicesPvt. Ltdwas

thereornotatthepremisesofmanagementno.1?

Ans. Asperrecord,nosuchSupervisorwasprovided. Otherwisegenerallya

Supervisoristheredirectingthepersonsengagedinthesanitationworktodothe

needful.

Managementno.1wasnotmarkingattendanceofthepersonsprovidedby

M/s.PremiaSecurityServicesPvt.Ltd. (vol.thesaidattendancewasusedtobe

markedbytheSupervisorofM/s.PremiaSecurityServicesPvt.Ltd).Itiswrong

tosuggestthatIhaveintentionallymisplacedthefilementionedindocumentMark

A. AsyetnoFIRhasbeenregisteredregardingthenontraceabilityofthefile

videMarkA.(vol.FIRmaybegotregisteredoncealleffortstotracethefileresult

invain).

XXXX By Mr. Sunil Kumar Adv. proxy for Mr. Arvind Kumar Adv. for

managementno.2.

Nil.Opportunitygiven.

RO&AC


StatementofMr.RajKumarMittalAdv.formanagementno.1.

AtBar

OninstructionsfromMr.SandeepKumar,OfficeSuperintendentofmanagementno.1,IcloseM.Eonbehalfofmanagementno.1.

RO&AC (ANANDSWAROOPAGGARWAL)

POLCXI/KKD/DELHI/16.04.2015+

IDNo.579/14

16.04.2015

Present: Mr.AnilRajputAdv.forworkman.Mr.RajKumarMittalAdv.formanagementno.1withM1W1Mr.SandeepKumar,OfficeSuperintendentofmanagementno.1.Mr.SunilKumarAdv.proxyforMr.ArvindKumarAdv.formanagementno.2.

M1W1Mr.SandeepKumarexaminedinchief,crossexaminedby

workmanandmanagementno.2anddischarged.MEstandsclosedbyld.counsel

formanagementno.1. Put up on 21.05.2015 for M.E on behalf of

managementno.2.
