Leveraging Boiler Room Control Data for Optimized … · Leveraging Boiler Room Control ... Boiler Control System 12 Fuel Air Burner Management ... • Proves pre-ignition interlocks

Leveraging Boiler Room Control Data for

Optimized Operations

Presented by Steve Connor

May 27, 2015

2

Today’s Topics

Plant Automation Evolution &

Monitoring/Control points

SCADA , the What, How & Why

The Industrial Process Control System

(ICS) & link to the Boiler Room

Leveraging Automated Boiler Room

Control Data for facility optimization

1

2

3

4

The way we were…

3

MA Station & Strip Charts

4

Manual/Auto stations allowed operators to individually

control many elements of the boiler

DDC

5

Note:

Technology started to

advance but operators could

still not get a complete feel

for the total plant operation

DCS

6

The Digital Control System allowed for

• Expanded information and larger

displays

• Viewing historical information and

trending capabilities

• Higher resolution computer screens

and more variables to be included

on the screen at one time

Fuzzy Logic

7

• Boiler scaling?

• Boiler sooting?

Discipline Separation

8

Maintenance

Operations

Power Plant

Improved overall

efficiency was now

within reach

SCADA

9

3 Distinct Categories

• Industrial

• Infrastructure

• Facility

Industrial Control System (ICS)

10

• Manufacturing

• Maintenance & Power Generation

• Power Generation For the Boiler Room

Boiler Room Control

11

The Boiler Room highly impacts

the facility’s efficient operation.

Overview

Boiler Control System

12

Fuel Air

Burner Management

Combustion Control

The Burner Management System (BMS)

13

• Manages burner control and safety

• Monitors and displays burner status

• Proves pre-ignition interlocks

• Proves burner blower motor is on

• Proves running interlocks and starts

burner cycle

• Proves pre-purge high and low limit

travel switches with a minimum of 4

air changes required by code

• Proves pilot flame signal prior to main

valves opening

• Proves main fuel signal prior to

releasing the burner to full modulation

• Displays any burner related alarms and

forces automatic shut down of the

burner requiring manual reset

14

Burner Management System & Sequencing

15

• Traditional Jack

Shaft Control

• Parallel Positioning

w/Cross Limited

Feedback Control

• O2

trim

• FGR Damper Control

• Variable Speed Drive

on Burner Blower

Motor

• Draft Control

• Feedwater control

• Lead lag load control

• Full Metered Control

Fuel Air

Combustion Control

And Sub-Systems

Combustion Control System

Sensing & Sending Devices

16

RTD

Transducer

Transmitter

Thermistors Thermocouple

Sensing & Sending Devices

17

Water Flow Meter Steam Flow Meter

Flow meters measure forces produced by a

flowing stream as it overcomes a known

constriction to indirectly calculate flow.

18

Loop Controllers vs PLC Platform

Loop Controller PLC Platform

19

Firing

Rate

Control

Fuel-Air

Ratio

Control

O2

Trim

Draft

Control

Economizer

ControlVSD

Control

Requires

• Individual loop

controllers

• Separate control

panel

• Interface wiring

for BMS

• Relays and timers

• Extra wiring

• Expert tuning

Multiple Control Loops

Lead/Lag

Control

Single Platform for All

20

PLC Based System

21

21

Plant Master

22

• Automatic sequencing

of Lead and Lag

boilers to maintain

changing plant loads

• Equal run time on

boilers

• Automatic boiler

rotation schedule

• Lead/Lag or Unison

firing rate control

• Overall system

efficiency and control

Common

Header

Transmitter

Lead – Lag

Controller

Common Header

Multi Boiler Lead-Lag Control

23

Ambient Air

Temp

Fuel

O2

Boiler

Exhaust

Gases

Air

O2

Trim Control

24

Parallel Positioning: Fuel Air Ratio Control

25

Stack Draft

Transmitter

Stack Draft Damper

Draft Control

Feed Water Flow

26

Steam flow integration with

modulating feed water control and

firing rate can be used for chemical

treatment monitoring.

Feedwater

Steam

Common Header

Design Engineering

27

SAMA Diagram

Separate but Integrated BMS & CCS

28

NFPA85

PLC Based System

Typical Status Overview Screen

29

Burner Management System

30

31

Firing Rate Control Screen

32

Natural Gas

Feedwater

Oil

Boiler Draft

Combustion

Air

Boiler Steam

Various Boiler Pressure Points

Natural Gas

Feedwater

Header

Pressure

Vortex w/Temp

Boiler Pressure

Electro Magnetic

Thermal

MassOil

Coriolis

(Accuracy)

Positive

Displacement

Bo

ile

r S

tea

m

Plant

Blowdown and

Heat Recovery

Combustion

Air

Thermal

Mass or DP

TDS,

Conductivity

33

Flow Points

34

Boiler Feedwater

35

Various Added Boiler Temperature Points

36

Boiler Room Closed Loop System

37

Leveraging the Data

Assessment Cornerstones

38

Efficiency

Sustainability

Reliability

Safety

Steam Flow vs Fuel Flow

39

1,000# of Steam/HR x Fuel Cost = Cost of Steam/1000#

Dollars/Year at 100 Psig

Equivalent

Orifice

Diameter

1/16”

1/8”

1/4”

1/2”

Lbs./Yr.

Steam

Loss

115,630

462,545

1,848,389

7,393,432

Steam Cost Per 1000 Lbs.

$5.00 $7.50 $10.00

$578 $867 $1,156

$2,313 $3,469 $4,625

$9,242 $13,863 $18,484

$36,967 $55,451 $73,934

Cost Multipliers For Other Steam Pressures:

16 Psig -. 26 50 Psig - .56 150 Psig - 1.43

200 Psig - 1.87 300 Psig - 2.74 600 Psig - 5.35

40

Cost of Steam Leaks

Steam Flow & Pressure vs Drum Level

41

Remember: For each pound of steam you evaporate a

pound of water and there’s 8.3 pounds of water in a gallon.

Feed Water Temperature Variance

42

Temperature drop from

227 Deg. F to 200 Deg. F

Steam Header Pressure Decay

43

44

TemperaturePressure

Firing rate controller

Stack Temperature vs

Drum Pressure & Firing Rate

Data points should be gathered,

stored and routinely evaluated.

Stack Temperature

Combustion Efficiency for Natural Gas

45

Combustion Air Temperature Variance

46

O2 vs Firing Rate

47

O2 Sensing Firing Rate Metering Cam

48

Excess Air Increases As The Firing

Rate Decreases

As Excess Air Increases, Efficiency Decreases

49

Lose 1% in

Efficiency

For every 2%

increase in O2

5050

Major Combustion Variable

Combustion

settings will

change as

weather and

ambient

conditions vary.

51

Data Logging and Communications

52

Alarm Printer

Data Printer

Uninterruptabl

e Power

Supply

Data Logging and Communications

53

SCADA Tie to Building Automation System

Information & System Control Data

Sample SCADA Screens

Summary

56

• Today’s advanced Industrial Control Systems allow the Power house,

Maintenance and Operations to collaborate and share information.

• SCADA tie-in allows this information to be transmitted globally.

• The Burner Management System controls and sequences the burner.

• The Combustion Control System controls other related functions such as

fuel/air metering, feed water metering, draft, motor speeds, etc.

• The BMS & CCS must be separate per NFPA85, though integrated.

• Boiler control and monitoring can be through loop controllers or a PLC platform

which is becoming the preferred method because of its high degree of

integration and ease of field install.

• The PLC based platform can be expanded to include various controls and

sensors for capturing valuable data for leveraging plant optimization.

• This information should be logged and trended to maximize fuel Efficiency,

Sustainability, Reliability and Safety in the plant and throughout the

organization.

Wendell Pipkin

Conversions Sales Manager

[email protected]

229-229-4408

cleaverbrooks.com

57