Page 1
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 1/35
1© 2012 UWE
This pack is intended to support you with yourrevision.
The course materials are contained in:
The two handout handbooks;The set textbook.
These materials are essential for your revision.
Page 2
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 2/35
2© 2012 UWE
• Read the set textbook! – In addition, the information that
you need is in the Handbooks containing the handouts so
it is really important that you revise from them, and
understand their content;
• The lectures link together in a sequence that work
towards a critical overview of the subject, so it might be
helpful to approach revision in the same way;
• The work that you have done for the workshops is similar
to the work that you will have to do in the exam.
Page 3
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 3/35
3© 2012 UWE
You have one final assessment for this module:An exam.
To prepare for the exam you
MUST ENSURE THAT YOU DO THE FOLLOWING:
Page 4
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 4/35
4© 2012 UWE
YOU WILL BE PROVIDED WITH ADVANCEMATERIALS FOR THE EXAM ON BLACKBOARD.
YOU MUST PRINT A COPY OF THESE AND FOLLOWTHE INSTRUCTIONS IN THE MATERIALS.
THEY WILL DIRECT YOU TO THE CASES YOU NEEDTO FIND, PRINT AND BRING WITH YOU TO THE
EXAMINATION, TOGETHER WITH THE ADVANCESTATUTORY MATERIALS.
You may annotate these materials.
Page 5
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 5/35
5© 2012 UWE
Section A (worth 60% of the marks)
Case law and precedent – MCQs (answer all questions)(You need to bring a printed copy of the cases which you will be directed to in
the advance materials).
Section B (worth 20% of the marks)
Statutory Interpretation – MCQs (answer all questions)
(You need to bring the advance statutory materials with you to answer thissection as the sample statute will be in these materials)
Section C (worth 20% of the marks)
Essay question (answer ONE question)
(You do not need any supplementary materials to answer this section).
Page 6
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 6/35
6© 2012 UWE
•How does the courseprogress through theinformation and skills youneed?
Course structure1
•Some of the key pointsare listed in the guidance – use your notes toidentify any others you
think are relevant...
Identify the keypoints of each lecture •As you revise, check your
knowledge against thekey points to make surethat you have not left outanything that you need.
Structure yourrevision around thekey points and skills.
Page 7
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 7/35
7© 2012 UWE
• The most sensible way to start your revision is to makesure that you understand the way in which the course isstructured to make sure that you do not miss anyrelevant information.
• The course links together with each lecture building onthe information in the lecture before so it would be
sensible to start with an overview of the course and the‘big picture’ before moving on to the key issues fromeach lecture.
Page 8
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 8/35
8© 2012 UWE
Lecture One
Introduction andoverview
Lecture Two
Legal History:development of the
common lawEnglish legal system
Lecture Three
Case Law andPrecedent
Lecture FourStatutes and
StatutoryInterpretation
Page 9
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 9/35
9© 2012 UWE
Lecture Five
Legal method inpractice
Lecture Six
Socio-legal method
Lecture Seven
Jurisprudence,theory and method
Page 10
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 10/35
10© 2012 UWE
•
The lectures introduced key concepts in relation toeach topic – it is important to understand and revise
the key concepts.
• Each lecture introduced its own key concepts.
• Some of the key concepts are set out in the next fewslides:
Page 11
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 11/35
11© 2012 UWE
• Introduced the four quadrants;
• Emphasised the importance of identifying theappropriate legal method, and how to do so;
• Introduced the concepts of primary andsecondary sources;
• Introduced basic legal research concepts;
• Explained relevant reading and learning methods.
Page 12
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 12/35
12© 2012 UWE
Four important legal methods:
Doctrinal or ‘black letter’ law Legal Practice
Socio-Legal Methods Jurisprudence and legal theory
Ways and methods
of considering law
Page 13
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 13/35
13© 2012 UWE
• Gave an introduction to the English common
law system;• Traced the history of the modern legal system
from Feudal origins;
•
Explained the development of moderncommon law and equitable principles.
Page 14
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 14/35
14© 2012 UWE
• Doctrine of judicial precedent;
•
The doctrinal methods of forming precedent;• Stare decisis, ratio decidendi, obiter dicta;
• The doctrinal methods of application of precedent;
• Material facts, levels of abstraction, rules of application.
Page 15
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 15/35
15© 2012 UWE
• The process of creating a statute;
•
Drafting issues (e.g. clarity etc);• Amending statutes and implications of amendment;
• Statutory aids of interpretation (primary aids (rules)and secondary aids (sources that can be consulted);
• Lists;• Hansard and Pepper v Hart [1993] All ER 42
Page 16
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 16/35
16© 2012 UWE
• This lecture ‘walked through’ the progress of
Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] UKHL 100;• It demonstrated how doctrinal method works in
practice in the adversarial common law system;
• Use this lecture’s materials to check that you
understand the method principles that were usedby counsel and the judiciary at all the levels thatthe case was heard.
Page 17
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 17/35
17© 2012 UWE
• What is socio-legal method?
• Scope of socio-legal study;
•
When is it appropriate to use a socio-legal method?• How socio-legal study developed (Weber and Durkheim etc);
• Identifying and distinguishing main categories of socio-legalmethods:
– Positivist (quantitative),
– Interpretivist (qualitative); and
– Theoretical
• Identifying and distinguishing the sub-groups of the key socio-legalmethods identified in the categories above.
Page 18
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 18/35
18© 2012 UWE
• What is jurisprudence and legal theory?
• Why is it important (historical context, analysis,
application)?• How to use and apply a theory;
• Theoretical questions (what is law? What is legalreasoning?);
• Natural law and legal positivism: compare and contrast;• Hart/Devlin/Dworkin debate;
• Modern legal theory.
Page 19
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 19/35
19© 2012 UWE
The following slides give:
• Sample MCQs for Section A and Section B;
• Advice on answering the essay question in Section C
Page 20
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 20/35
20© 2012 UWE
• Answer ALL the MCQs;
• There will be a number possible answers for each question;
• Work logically through the options;
• It’s a two-hour exam and this section amounts to 60% of your
mark, so think about how you manage your time during the
exam;
• Five example/practice questions are included here using the
material from workshop 5.
Page 21
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 21/35
21© 2012 UWE
CASE: Re M (A Minor) (Care
Order: Threshold Conditions)
[1994] 2 FCR 871 (see Workshop 5)
• Question: Which adult, child or
children were the primary focus
of the case?
A. The twins
B. Child L
C. Child M
D. Mrs W
E. All four children
Page 22
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 22/35
22© 2012 UWE
CASE: Re M (A Minor) (Care
Order: Threshold Conditions)
[1994] 2 FCR 871 (see Workshop 5)
• Question: Which one of the
following statements LEAST
ACCURATELY represents the facts
before the court?
A. Mrs W was the cousin of the mother
of M.
B. Neither of the fathers of L or the
twins visited the children.
C. The mother of M had three children.
D. M’s mother was murdered by M’s
father.
E. M’s mother was not born in Jamaica.
F. M’s mother married a Nigerian.
Page 23
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 23/35
23© 2012 UWE
CASE: Re M (A Minor) (Care
Order: Threshold Conditions)
[1994] 2 FCR 871 (see Workshop 5)
• Which answer MOST closely
represents the issue before the
House of Lords?
A. Whether M was being properly cared for.
B. Whether to reinstate the care order.
C. Whether M was suffering, or was likely to
suffer significant harm.
D. The literal meaning of the statute.
E. Whether to reinstate the care order when
it was agreed that M was no longer
suffering, or likely to suffer significant
harm.
F. None of the above.
Page 24
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 24/35
24© 2012 UWE
CASE: Re M (A Minor) (Care
Order: Threshold Conditions)
[1994] 2 FCR 871 (see Workshop 5)
• What was the history of the case?
A. (1) A Care Order under S.31 Children Act 1989 was
granted to the local authority; (2) The Court of
Appeal reversed this decision and substituted a
Residence Order in favour of Mrs W; (3) The House
of Lords dismissed the appeal.B. (1) Bracewell J granted a Care Order under S.31
Children Act 1989 in favour of the local authority;
(2) The Court of Appeal reversed this decision and
substituted a Residence Order in favour of Mrs W;
(3) The House of Lords reinstated the Care Order.
C. (1) At first instance a Residence Order under S.31
Children Act 1989 was granted; (2) The Court of
Appeal reversed this decision and substituted aCare Order in favour of Mrs W; (3) The House of
Lords reinstated the Residence Order.
D. (1) Family Court; (2) Court of Appeal; (3) Supreme
Court.
E. None of the above.
Page 25
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 25/35
25© 2012 UWE
CASE: Re M (A Minor) (Care
Order: Threshold Conditions)
[1994] 2 FCR 871 (see Workshop 5)
• Question: What could be
considered to be the widest valid
ratio from the case?
A. The tense of the statute could be
substituted by any which the court
considers would match Parliament’s
intention.B. That the Court of Appeal erred in its
decision to reverse Bracewell J’s
judgment.
C. The "use of the present tense . . . 'is
suffering' - makes it clear that the harm
must be being suffered at the relevant
time, which is when the court . . . decides
whether or not to make a care order."
D. The House of Lords can substitute the
tense of a statutory provision to fit the
facts of a case.
Page 26
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 26/35
26© 2012 UWE
• Section B asks multiple choice questions about the statutorymaterial in the Advance Materials provided for the exam.
•Answer ALL the MCQs.
• Section B is worth 20%, so allocate your time appropriately.
• Ensure you are familiar with the material before the exam.
• Bring the advance materials with you to the exam.
• Five example/practice questions are included here concerning the
sections of the Children Act 1989 which you covered in workshop 5.• To answer the questions work through the options methodically.
• Eliminating answers you know to be wrong will narrow the numberof options containing the correct answer.
Page 27
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 27/35
27© 2012 UWE
STATUTE: Section 47 Children
Act 1989 c.41 (see Workshop 5)
• Which statement MOST
ACCURATELY represents the
‘mischief’ s.47 intends to
remedy?
A. Section 47 intends to place a duty of care
on local authority social services
departments to stop child abuse.
B. Section 47 enables local authority socialservices departments to prevent child
abuse that is either happening, or is likely
to happen in the future.
C. Section 47 intends to empower local
authority social services departments to
investigate suspected child abuse that iseither happening, or is likely to happen in
the future.
D. Section 47 intends to prevent child abuse
that is either happening, or is likely to
happen in the future.
Page 28
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 28/35
28© 2012 UWE
STATUTE: Section 47 Children
Act 1989 c.41 (see Workshop 5)
•This section states, inter alia, that ‘theauthority shall make or cause to be made,
such enquiries as they consider necessary’
when investigating suspected child abuse.
Which of the following IS THE MOST
LIKELY APPROACH to interpreting these
words a court would adopt and why if a
challenge was made with the aim of
attempting to limit the powers of the local
authority?
A. The literal rule would apply because the literal
words of a statute have to be used unless they
create an absurdity which these words do not.
B. The golden rule would apply because the wordsmust be placed in context and the context of
these words is that the enquiries are to prevent
child abuse so there should be no limit on how
that is achieved.
C. Pepper v Hart would apply because it is
important to ascertain the intention of
Parliament before deciding not to use the literalrule.
D. The purpose of the words would be considered
and they would be interpreted to mean what is
reasonably necessary to achieve their purpose.
Page 29
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 29/35
29© 2012 UWE
STATUTE: Section 47 Children
Act 1989 c.41 (see Workshop 5)
• Can a local authority decide
whether or not to make enquiries
into suspected child abuse?
A No, they must if it is reported to
them.
B Yes, because the statute would not
be interpreted to place an absolute
duty on a local authority because it is
unreasonable.
C No, they must if they suspect child
abuse.
D Yes if they do not have a reasonablecause to suspect child abuse.
Page 30
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 30/35
30© 2012 UWE
STATUTE: Section 31 Children
Act 1989 c.41 (see Workshop 5)
• Which of the following is the
MOST ACCURATE literal
interpretation of Section
31(2)(a)?
A. A court can only make a care Order if a
child is suffering or is likely to suffer
serious harm.
B. A court cannot make a care Order if achild is no longer suffering.
C. A court can make a care Order if a child
has suffered or is likely to suffer significant
harm.
D. A court can only make a care Order if a
child is suffering or is likely to suffersignificant harm.
E. A court can only make a care Order if a
child may suffer serious harm.
Page 31
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 31/35
31© 2012 UWE
STATUTE: Section 31 Children
Act 1989 c.41 (see Workshop 5)
• If Section 47 enquiries leave alocal authority believing therethat significant harm is happeningor is likely to happen does Section31 have to be invoked, and why?
A Yes, using the literal rule, because itwould be absurd not to apply for acare order if significant harm is
found.B No because there is no statutory duty
to do so, it is a discretion.
C Yes because that is the only logicalaction for a local authority to take.
D No, using the purposing approach,
because there is a discretion and aslong as a local authority can show ithas taken some action it does nothave to use Section 31.
Page 32
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 32/35
32© 2012 UWE
• There is a choice of two questions;
• Answer one question;
• It counts for 20% of the marks;
• Approach it logically and work out a coherent plan
and structure;
• You will not have time to write a long essay but try to
structure your essay to be more than ‘bullet points’.
Page 33
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 33/35
33© 2012 UWE
• Plan your essay – you could make a brief essay plan to help clarify your thoughts and list what
you want to include – but don’t spend too long (nb: 20% of two hours is 24 minutes).
• Make sure you have an introduction(brief), middle(long) and conclusion(to tie it all together).
• Use the plan as you write to ensure you don’t miss anything out and to keep focussed.
• Try to analyse and critique where possible to show the depth of your knowledge –
description only will limit your answer.
• Focus answering the question with relevant material – no marks for irrelevant material –
longer does not necessarily mean better.
• Use clear short sentences – long convoluted sentences can end up saying the opposite to
what you mean, or nothing at all.
• Strike through your plan at the end so that it doesn’t get marked in error.
Page 34
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 34/35
34© 2012 UWE
Make sure that you
understand what thequestion is asking, andpossibly make a short
plan.
Decide which legalmethod(s) you are
including in your answer…
Make sure that you
structure your answer toinclude an introduction,
main body andconclusions.
Write your introduction.It should be short and
clear.
Introduce differing
points of view andargument in the mainbody to strengthen your
answer.
Use case examples and
authorities, socio-legaland/or theoreticalmaterials where
appropriate.
Before you conclude
ensure your points areorganised into your key
arguments …
Write a short and clear
conclusion. (Do notintroduce new materialinto your conclusion).
Page 35
7/28/2019 Legal Method - Revision Materials - Powerpoint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/legal-method-revision-materials-powerpoint 35/35
35© 2012 UWE