Top Banner
LAW MERIT BADGE
60

Law Merit Badge

Apr 21, 2017

Download

Law

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Law Merit Badge

LAW MERIT BADGE

Page 2: Law Merit Badge

REQUIREMENT 1

Define “law”.

Tell some of its sources.

Describe functions it serves.

Page 3: Law Merit Badge

LAW IS A SYSTEM OF IDEAS AND ACTIONS,

A WAY TO HELP SOCIETY KEEP ORDER AND STAY TOGETHER.

Sources & Functions Constitution: Supreme Law of the United States. It gives

power of Congress to make laws and gives power to states to legislate.

Ten Commandments: is called Divine Law. Societies have developed laws based social customs and religious and tribal laws.

The U.S. legal system is a good example of a system that drew upon its origins in English law, which in turn developed from certain concepts of Roman, Norman, and Germanic laws. Every society added something of its own to make the law fit special needs.

Page 4: Law Merit Badge

REQUIREMENT 2

Discuss.

The development of the jury system.

Two famous trials in history.

Page 5: Law Merit Badge

THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE JURY SYSTEM The 1st rather primitive jury system began

in ancient Greece. Before a trial, a large number of citizens was chosen; then, just before a trial began, a smaller number was taken from the larger group. This was done so that no one could know ahead of time who would be a juror and try to influence the decision. Very often, hundreds of citizens would be on the jury. The very size of it made attempts to corrupt, bribe, or scare individual jurors difficult.

Page 6: Law Merit Badge

THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE JURY SYSTEM

Romans(Italy): a judge defined the issues of dispute, and a group of private persons called the judice made the decision on how to handle the problem. The judice worked without a judge present. Their decisions were final and often harsh. Poor people who couldn’t buy their debts were put in jail or killed.

Germany: the head of the court would gather a small group of landowners to decide cases-usually 7-12. They talked about the case away from the judge.

Norway, Sweden, & Denmark all adopted juries. France: began when Norseman brought it with them when

invading France. England: William the Conqueror brought system in 1066 when

he invaded the British Isle. When English settlers cam to America, they brought the system with them.

Page 7: Law Merit Badge

THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE JURY SYSTEM

After many years, the jury became a group that decided whether the facts of a case warranted an innocent or guilty verdict.

The Jury System is seen as a way to keep the administration of justice in the hands of ordinary citizens and to prevent powerful or rich citizens from influencing the court.

Page 8: Law Merit Badge

THE JURY AND U.S. LAW The first 10

Amendments to the Constitution, known as the Bill of Rights, guarantee the right to a jury trial.

The package of rights include a fair and speedy trail, right to confront witnesses, right to counsel, and do not have to testify.

Page 9: Law Merit Badge

THE TRIAL OF SOCRATES: Socrates was a philosopher, thinker and teacher

who lived in Athens in ancient Greece. His ideas were unpopular with the rulers of Athens.

Socrates believed that goodness is based on knowledge, and wickedness on ignorance. He tried to teach people the meaning of his motto Know Thyself and to open their minds to new thoughts.

He always searched for truth and never hesitated to criticize the government and its leaders.

Page 10: Law Merit Badge

THE TRIAL OF SOCRATES:

Because they feared and hated him, the government leaders arrested Socrates and put him on trial for “corruption of the young” and “neglect of the gods whom the city worships.”

Most of the jury of 500 men disagreed with Socrates and his defense of freedom of speech and thought.

He had no lawyer to assist him.

Page 11: Law Merit Badge

THE TRIAL OF SOCRATES: Because the truth often hurts when it

uncovers dishonesty, evil people sometimes want to stamp out the free exchange of ideas.

Socrates did not convince the jury of his innocence and was condemned to death by swallowing poison.

He spent his last hours of life talking over his ideas with friends.

He took the poison and died peacefully, with the knowledge that the truth will never die.

Page 12: Law Merit Badge

THE TRIAL OF SOCRATES:

Because the truth often hurts when it uncovers dishonesty, evil people sometimes want to stamp out the free exchange of ideas.

Socrates did not convince the jury of his innocence and was condemned to death by swallowing poison.

He spent his last hours of life talking over his ideas with friends.

He took the poison and died peacefully, with the knowledge that the truth will never die.

Page 13: Law Merit Badge

THE NUREMBERG WAR CRIMES TRIALS: CONSCIENCE, MORALITY, AND THE STATE.

During World War II the Nazi government of Germany set out to conquer Europe. In the process, millions of people were thrown into the horrors of war. Huge numbers of soldiers on all sides died in the long, bloody combat.

Millions of innocent civilians were deliberately put to death by the Nazis. These deaths were not unavoidable, accidental, or battle-connected. They were planned mass murders carried out as part of the Nazis’ insane quest to produce a “master race.” The main group of civilian victims were 6 million European Jews, who were starved, shot, or fed into gas chambers and fiery furnaces. This number included more than 1 million children. Soldiers who were prisoners of the Nazis also were executed. Millions of innocent people died.

Page 14: Law Merit Badge

THE NUREMBERG WAR CRIMES TRIALS: CONSCIENCE, MORALITY, AND THE STATE.

When the war ended in 1945, the victorious Allies-United States, Britain, and Russia-were shocked at the Nazi crimes. Many nations had long agreed to obey certain laws-rules of war-that would keep civilians out of violence and danger as much as possible, and would treat prisoners of war humanely.

The Nazis violated all such rules of war. Worse, they violated rules of humanity, decency, and morality. The Allies put Nazi officials, generals, admirals, and private citizens on trial in Nuremberg, Germany, for their crimes against humanity.

Page 15: Law Merit Badge

THE NUREMBERG WAR CRIMES TRIALS: CONSCIENCE, MORALITY, AND THE STATE.

A panel of judges from many nations decided that people could not abandon their basic humanity even if the government says they must. The court also ruled that a government that orders the killing and torture of innocent people is acting outside the law and thereby loses its right to govern.

The principles of decency and human rights for all were affirmed by the Nuremberg War Crimes Trials. Many Nazi war criminals were executed or imprisoned.

Page 16: Law Merit Badge

REQUIREMENT 3Tell what civil law is;

Tell what criminal law is.

Tell the main differences between them.

Give examples of each.

Page 17: Law Merit Badge

Civil Law is a disagreement between two parties about how their rights and responsibilities are handled. They involve the private and civil rights of individuals, corporations, government bodies, and others.

Criminal Law is concerned with harmful acts called crimes. Crimes are forbidden by statute law, and if a person who commits a crime is discovered, the state will take that person to court to seek punishment in the name of the people.

Page 18: Law Merit Badge

CRIMINAL LAW CIVIL LAW Who is involved?

The state prosecutes, it goes to court against the accused person.

“Burden of Proof” The state must prove the accused person is guilty “beyond a reasonable doubt.”

Penalties: Imprisonment and/or fine.

Who is involved? Usually a person or corporation goes to court against another person or corporation.

“Burden of Proof” The plaintiff must prove its position by a “preponderance of the evidence.”

Penalties: No imprisonment. An award of money (called “damages”) or an order to perform or refrain from performing an act is issued.

Page 19: Law Merit Badge

ContractsMarriage

TrustsWills

EstatesPatentsTaxes

Page 20: Law Merit Badge

Offenses Against Person:Homicide, Assault, Kidnapping, Robbery

Offenses Against Property:

Burglary, Arson, Larceny, Theft, Fraud, Forgery, CounterfeitingOther Crimes: Hijacking boats, airplanes Unlawful use of a weapon Illegal eavesdropping

Page 21: Law Merit Badge

REQUIREMENT 4Ask 5 people about the

role of law enforcement officers in our society.

Discuss their answers with them.

Talk with a law enforcement officer in your neighborhood.

Ask about their responsibilities & duties.

Report your findings.

Page 22: Law Merit Badge

SAMPLE QUESTIONS TO ASK THE GENERAL PUBLIC FOR REQUIREMENT 4 ABOUT THE ROLE OF LAW ENFORCEMENT

Agree, Disagree, No Opinion1. Police do the best job possible at all times. 2. Police do not understand the needs of the average

person. 3. Police Officers should be free to shoot looters and

rioters. 4. I can trust most police officers.5. There are relatively few dishonest police officers.6. We can do little to help law enforcement. 7. Street patrol is a good crime deterrent. 8. Being a police officer is not at all risky. 9. Police should have more education and better training. 10. Society would be unsafe and unpleasant without police. 11. Police Officers should be allowed to strike. 12. Police Officers are paid too much.

Page 23: Law Merit Badge

SAMPLE QUESTIONS TO ASK THE LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER FOR REQUIREMENT 4

Discuss the questions below with a law enforcement officer.

1. How do you feel about people in general? Do you enjoy being a police officer? Do you think you are misunderstood by the general public?

2. How can we help you do a better job? Do you want the public’s help?

3. Are police trained well enough to handle emergency situations like riots, mobs, terrorist acts, and so on?

4. Do police officers think their work is hampered by the courts and by laws that protect defendants? Are you satisfied with the criminal justice system?

5. What are the biggest crime problems in our area? How do police deal with these problems?

Page 24: Law Merit Badge

REQUIREMENT 5Tell about several laws that were passed to protect the

consumer and seller.

Tell about several organizations that provide

help to them.

Page 25: Law Merit Badge

LAWS TO PROTECT CONSUMER/SELLERTruth in Lending Act of 1968 set of laws requires seller to inform buyer in clear terms how much interest will be charged for a loan or credit agreement. Identity Theft and Assumption Deterrence

Act of 1998 makes the Federal Trade Commission log & acknowledge identity complaints and refer them to appropriate agencies and law enforcement.Laws also enforce truth in labeling & advertising also help. The Federal Trade Commission, the Food and Drug Administration, and even the Federal Communications Commission have taken steps to protect American Consumers. Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act of

1998 protects young people’s privacy by giving parents the tools to control what information is collected

Page 26: Law Merit Badge

ORGANIZATIONS THAT HELP PROTECT CONSUMER/SELLER

State and Local Governments have departments of consumer affairs and laws to help victims of fraud and dishonest business practices.

For example, the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deception Business Practices Act protects people who have been talked into buying things they don’t need by high-pressure door-to-door salespeople. The law says that people can cancel an order within three days of a sale.

Small claims courts exist to settle legal disputes over relatively small amounts of money or property.

Page 27: Law Merit Badge

REQUIREMENT 6

Plan and conduct a mock trial.

After trial over, discuss it with the group.

Page 28: Law Merit Badge

MOCK TRIAL The internet has many free sample mock trial scripts

to help plan and conduct a mock trial. This powerpoint has a sample at the end of the slides.

Recommendation to continue through requirements and complete the mock trial at the end.

Page 29: Law Merit Badge

PLANNING A MOCK TRIALJudge

Defendant Lawyer

Prosecutor or Plaintiff Lawyer

Court ClerkCourt Reporter

Bailiff Witnesses

Jurors

Page 30: Law Merit Badge

REQUIREMENT 7Arrange a visit with a

lawyer who works for a business, bank,

title company, or government.

Find out about their duties and

responsibilities.

Report what you learned.

Page 31: Law Merit Badge

Bank Lawyer or Corporation Counsel: Responsible to keep

company out of court

Court involves time, trouble, money and they want to avoid litigation or lawsuits.

They research contracts, advised owners and managers how to stay out of court.

City Attorney Writes laws, such as

ordinances, in proper legal form.

Represents the city in court

Helps prepare contracts for city purchases and services

City Prosecutor Represents the city

in court. Gives advice to the

police department

Page 32: Law Merit Badge

REQUIREMENT 8

Explain the requirements for becoming a lawyer in your

state.

Describe how judges are selected in your state.

Page 33: Law Merit Badge

BE A LAWYER BE A JUDGE

Graduate High School with Good Grades

Graduate College with Good Grades

Take the Law School Admissions Test (LSAT)

Graduate from Law School Pass the State Bar

Examination

Georgia lawyers can become judges by winning campaign elections in Georgia.

In some other states judges are appointed by the office of the governor with the consent and confirmation of a legislative body, or the state legislature.

Page 34: Law Merit Badge

REQUIREMENT 9

Make a list of 15 jobs that deal with some aspects of

law or legal processes.

Tell which you prefer. Why?

Page 35: Law Merit Badge

CAREERS IN THE LAW OR LEGAL PROFESSION

1. Lawyer2. Judge3. Court Bailiff4. Paralegal5. Police Officer6. Court Clerk7. FBI Agent8. Private Detective9. Parole Officer10. Juvenile Officer11. Probation Officer12. Sheriff’s Deputy13. Legal Secretary 14. Elected Legislators 15. State TroopersWhich of the above do you prefer and

why?

Page 36: Law Merit Badge

REQUIREMENT 10

Tell where people can go to obtain the help of a lawyer if they are unable to pay for one.

Tell what you can do if you can a lawyer but do not know of any

in your area.

Page 37: Law Merit Badge

FINDING A LAWYER Any local or state bar

association can refer you to a legal aid service. Legal aid services offer the help of a lawyer for free, or for a small fee to people who can’t afford a lawyer.

Some charitable organizations help people obtain legal services when they can’t afford to pay.

One helpful agency is the Legal Services Corporation, a private, nonprofit corporation established by Congress in 1974 to ensure equal access to justice under the law for all Americans. It offers legal aid in every state.

Bar associations and government public defender offices also offer free legal advice and assistance.

Page 38: Law Merit Badge

FINDING A LAWYER People who can afford to

pay for legal services can still contact the local and state bar association and ask for the Lawyer Referral Service. The service can help find a lawyer who can assist them in the particular area of law in which they need help. The service also can make an appointment with a lawyer for a certain fee.

The internet can be a great way to find lawyers.

The American Bar Association has a website www.findlegalhelp.org

They offer a number of public services and can be found on the web at www.americnabar.org

Page 39: Law Merit Badge

REQUIREMENT 11

Discuss the following areas of law:

Environmental Law

Patent Law

Page 40: Law Merit Badge

ENVIRONMENTAL LAW National Environmental Policy Act 1969

Basic national charter for environmental protection that establishes policy and means to carry out policy.

Clear Air Act 1970 Regulates air emissions to protect public health

and environment Clean Water Act 1977

Regulates the discharge of pollutants into America’s waterways, rivers, lakes, and streams.

Endangered Species Act 1973 Established a program to protect threatened and

endangered plants, animals and habitats. Pollution Prevention Act 1990

Focuses on reducing pollution through cost-effective changes in production, operation, and use of raw materials. Protect our resources through conservation.

Page 41: Law Merit Badge

PATENT LAW U.S. Patent and Trademark Office:

The patent laws in the United States are among the oldest of our country’s laws, dating to 1790. Patent law protects the inventor of a new product who obtained a patent on that product. Generally, patent owners can prevent others from making, using, selling, or importing the patented invention for 20 years. If someone uses an invention without the inventor’s permission, the inventor can sue for patent infringement.

Page 42: Law Merit Badge

MOCK TRIAL SCRIPT

The Case of the Missing Lunch 

John Friendly, PlaintiffVs

Mike Goodman, Defendant 

Approximate Time: 1 hour

Participants in Trial: Judge, Bailiff, Court Reporter

Plaintiff, Plaintiff’s LawyerDefendant, Defendant’s Lawyer

Witness 1, 2, 3, 4Jury (12 or rest of class)

Page 43: Law Merit Badge

Bailiff: This honorable court of the BSA Judicial Circuit with the Honorable Judge now in session. All rise.

Judge:Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, the case involves the disappearance of John Friendly’s lunch from his lunch box. In this case, John, who is a scout with Troop 123, is the Defendant. He is asking you to decide whether or not Mike Goodman stole his lunch from his lunch box, leaving only a banana peel and a few crumbs. Mr. Friendly’s lawyer, do you wish to make an opening statement?

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: The evidence in this case will prove that on Friday, June 14th, Mike Goodman took my client’s lunch box from the Troop basket while taking the Troop basket to the scout dining hall. When John Friendly opened his lunch box in the dining hall, his peanut butter sandwich, his bag of potato chips and his Capri-Sun drink were missing. The only thing left in the lunch box were a few crumbs and a banana peel.

Defendant’s Lawyer: Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, my client, Mike Goodman, has been wrongly accused of stealing John Friendly’s lunch. He was asked by the Scoutmaster to carry the lunches from camp to the dining hall but did not eat John Goodman’s lunch. He did carry them down to the dining hall, but did not eat John Friendly’s lunch.

Opening

Page 44: Law Merit Badge

Judge: Plaintiff’s lawyer, please call your first witness.

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: I call John Friendly to the witness stand.

Court Report: Raise your right hand. Do you solemnly swear that the testimony you are about to give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

John Friendly: Yes

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: Please state your name and where you attend scouts.

John Friendly: John Friendly, Troop 123

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: Could you describe the lunch that you brought to camp on June 14

John Friendly: I brought a banana, a Capri Sun drink, potato chips and a peanut butter sandwich in my Superman Lunch box.

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: What was in the lunch box when you opened it in the dining hall?

John Friendly: Some crumbs and a banana peel.

PlaintiffJohn

Friendly

Page 45: Law Merit Badge

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: John, I hand you what is marked as Exhibit #1 and ask if this is your lunch box that you found empty on June 14 in the dining hall?

John Friendly: Yes, it is.

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: I move that Exhibit #1 be admitted into evidence.

Judge: Exhibit #1 is admitted into evidence.

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: That’s all, you honor.

Judge: Defense Counsel. Do you want to cross- examine John Friendly?

Defendant’s Lawyer: John, you didn’t actually see Mike Goodman eat your lunch, did you?

John Friendly: No, I guess not.

Defendant’s Lawyer: No further questions, your honor.

PlaintiffJohn

Friendly

Page 46: Law Merit Badge

Judge: Plaintiff’s counsel, you may call your next witness.

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: I call Senior Patrol Leader to the stand.

Court Reporter: Raise your right hand. Do you solemnly swear that the testimony you are about to give is the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Senior Patrol Leader: I do.

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: State your name and title?

Senior Patrol Leader: _____name, SPL

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: On June 14 did scouts Mike Goodman and John Friendly attend a camping trip?

Senior Patrol Leader: Yes

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: Do you think that they are good scouts?

Defendant’s Lawyer: Objection! The question is not relevant to the case.

Judge: Objection sustained.

Witness 1

Senior Patrol Leader

Page 47: Law Merit Badge

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: Did you ask Mike Goodman to take John Friendly’s lunch box to the dining hall on June 14?

Senior Patrol Leader: Yes, along with the rest of the Troop’s lunch boxes. They were all in a basket.

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: About how long was Mike gone from the camp?

Senior Patrol Leader: About 5 minutes

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: How far is it to the dining hall from camp?Senior Patrol Leader: About 50 yards.

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: When Mike returned to camp, did anything unusual happen?

Senior Patrol Leader: Yes, he and Able Minded were repeatedly giggling when I was trying to give instruction about lunch. I I had to correct them more than once.

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: I have no further questions, your honor.

Witness 1

Senior Patrol Leader

Page 48: Law Merit Badge

Judge: Do you wish to cross-examine, defense counsel?

Defendant’s Lawyer: Yes. Senior Patrol Leader, you don’t know why my client and Able Minded were giggling, do you?

Senior Patrol Leader: No

Defendant’s Lawyer: How many other people could have touched John Friendly’s lunch box while it was in the dining hall?

Senior Patrol Leader: Oh, I don’t know, probably anyone in the other Troop’s that eat before our Troop.

Defendant’s Lawyer: Thank you. That’s all, your honor.

Judge: You may be excused, Senior Patrol Leader. Next witness.

Witness 1

Senior Patrol Leader

Page 49: Law Merit Badge

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: I call Justin Cool to the stand.Court Reporter: Raise your right hand. Do you solemnly

swear that the testimony you are about to give is the truth, the whole truth, so help you God?

Justin Cool: I do.Plaintiff’s Lawyer: State your name and titleJustin Cool: Justin Cool, scout with Troop 123

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: Did you notice anything unusual about Mike Goodman on June 14?

Justin Cool: I noticed he had peanut butter on his mouth.Plaintiff’s Lawyer: No further questions

Defendant’s Lawyer: Justin Cool, did you notice this peanut butter on Mike Goodman’s mouth before or after lunch on June 14?

Justin Cool: I don’t remember.Defendant’s Lawyer: I have no further questions.

Judge: You may be excused. Any more witnesses?

Witness 2: Justin Cool

Page 50: Law Merit Badge

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: Just one. I call Kyle Brave to the stand. Court Reporter: Raise your right hand. Do you

solemnly swear that the testimony you are about to give is the truth, the whole truth, so help you God?

Kyle Brave: I do.Plaintiff’s Lawyer: State your name and title.Kyle Brave: Kyle Brave, Dining Hall Quartermaster

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: Did you find anything when you cleaned the boys bathroom on June 14?

Kyle Brave: Yes, I found an empty Capri-Sun in the trash can.

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: Kyle, I hand you what is marked as Exhibit #2 and ask if you can identify this.

Kyle Brave: Yes, this is the same one I found in the boys trash on June 14

Witness 3: Kyle Brave

Page 51: Law Merit Badge

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: I move the Exhibit #2 be admitted into evidence.

Judge: Exhibit #2 is offered into evidence. Do you want to cross-examine this witness, defense counsel?

Defendant’s Lawyer: Yes. Kyle, what time did you find the empty Capri-Sun?

Kyle Brave: When I cleaned up after the lunches-about 3:00pm.

Defendant’s Lawyer: You have no idea who put it there or when, do you?

Kyle Brave: No.

Judge: Thank you, you are dismissed. Plaintiff’s Lawyer: Plaintiff rests his case.

Witness 3: Kyle Brave

Page 52: Law Merit Badge

Judge: Defense counsel, you may present your case to the jury.

Defendant’s Lawyer: I call Mike Goodman to the stand.

Court Reporter: Raise your right hand. Do you solemnly swear that the testimony you are about to give is the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Mike Goodman: I do.

Defendant’s Lawyer: State your name.Mike Goodman: Mike Goodman

Defendant’s Lawyer: Mike, did you eat a peanut butter sandwich, a banana and potato chips and drink a Capri-Sun from John Friendly’s lunch on June 14?

Mike Goodman: No

DefendantMike

Goodman

Page 53: Law Merit Badge

Defendant’s Lawyer: Did you get in trouble by the Senior Patrol Leader that day for repeatedly giggling?

Mike Goodman:Yes.

Defendant’s Lawyer: Why?

Mike Goodman:I don’t remember.

Defendant’s Lawyer: No further questions.

Judge: Plaintiff’s counsel, do you have any cross-examination of this witness?

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: No.

Judge: Next witness, please.

DefendantMike

Goodman

Page 54: Law Merit Badge

Defendant’s Lawyer: I call Flint Firestone.

Court Reporter: Raise your right hand. Do you solemnly swear that the testimony you are about to give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Flint Firestone: I do.

Defendant’s Lawyer: State your name and title.Flint Firestone:Flint Firestone, scout with Troop 123

Defendant’s Lawyer: Do you know Mike Goodman?Flint Firestone:Yes

Defendant’s Lawyer: Is he a thief?

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: Objection!

Judge: Sustained.

Witness 4:

Flint Firestone

Page 55: Law Merit Badge

Defendant’s Lawyer: Did you eat lunch with Mike Goodman?

Flint Firestone:Yes

Defendant’s Lawyer: He had a peanut butter sandwich and some other stuff. He ate his whole lunch and part of mine. He was real hungry!

Defendant’s Lawyer: No further questions.

Judge: You may be dismissed. Any further witnesses?

Defendant’s Lawyer: No

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: No

Witness 4:

Flint Firestone

Page 56: Law Merit Badge

Judge: Plaintiff’s counsel, would you care to make a closing argument to the jury?

Plaintiff’s Lawyer: Your honor, ladies and gentleman of the jury, the evidence you have heard proves that Mike Goodman had possession of John Friendly’s lunch box after he left camp on June 14. The evidence also shows that when John opened his lunch box in the dining hall all that was left were a few crumbs and a banana peel. You heard Justin Cool saw peanut butter on Mike Goodman’s mouth and the Mike Goodman and Able Minded were “giggling” about something when he returned from the dining hall. Don’t you think it was about a trick he played on John Friendly? You also know that Kyle Brave found an empty Capri-Sun in the boy’s bathroom later that day.I ask you to do the right thing and bring back a verdict in favor of John Friendly and against Mike Goodman.

Closing

Page 57: Law Merit Badge

Judge: Defense counsel, do you wish to address the jury?

Defendant’s Lawyer: Yes, your honor. Ladies and gentleman of the jury, Mike Goodman is an innocent guy. Do you think he could take a basket full of lunch boxes 50 yards to the dining hall, eat John Friendly’s lunch, go to boy’s bathroom and still be back to camp in just 5 minutes? Do you think he could eat John Friendly’s lunch, then eat his own and part of Flint Firestone’s lunch too? He might be a hungry boy, but nobody is that hungry! Justin Cool said he had peanut butter on his mouth but he didn’t know if that was before or after he ate his own peanut butter sandwich. Plenty of scouts could have eaten John Friendly’s lunch. Remember, Senior Patrol Leader said other Troops ate their lunch in staff dining before Troop 123. I ask you to do the right thing and bring back a verdict in favor of Mike Goodman and against John Friendly.

Closing

Page 58: Law Merit Badge

Judge: Jurors, you will now retire to the jury room to deliberate. First pick one of you as the leader of your group. When you have reached a verdict, please let the Bailiff know. Bailiff, please take charge of the jury.

Recommendation: You can have the actors wait outside (so they can ask Judge questions) or send jury into another room to deliberate and then return with decision.

Deliberate

Page 59: Law Merit Badge

REQUIREMENT REVIEW__ 1. Law__ 2. Discus 2 trials and jury system__ 3. Civil Law vs Criminal Law__ 4. Talk with and about Law Enforcement __ 5. Laws to protect consumer/seller__ 6. Mock Trial__ 7. Talk with Lawyer__ 8. How to become a Lawyer/Judge in State__ 9. 15 Legal Jobs__ 10. Find a Lawyer__ 11. Discuss Environmental and Patent Law

Page 60: Law Merit Badge

REFERENCES Boy Scouts of

America, Law Merit Badge Series, 2013

Don’t forget your