Top Banner
Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate, College of Arts and Social Sciences Affiliate, Centre of Excellence for the Dynamics of Language (COEDL) [email protected]
23

Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Jun 24, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language matters in

aid effectiveness:

Overview

Hilary Smith Affiliate, College of Arts and Social Sciences

Affiliate, Centre of Excellence for the Dynamics of Language (COEDL)

[email protected]

Page 2: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language and development

[email protected] AAC February 2017 2

(Casey & Owen, 2014)

High ethnolinguistic diversity tends to co-occur with:

• Topographic heterogeneity

• Rapidly growing populations

• Low economic growth

… Australasian region?

Page 3: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Territory size shows the proportion of the world's

Indigenous living languages that are spoken there.

[email protected] AAC FEbruary 2017 3

(Worldmapper.org, 2016)

Page 4: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Linguistic dimensions of the Sustainable

Development Goals (SDGs)

(Language and the UN, 2016):

1. Language as a goal

‘a substantive element of the goal itself’

2. Language as a tool

‘a means of communication, dialogue, response

and implementation’

[email protected] AAC FEbruary 2017 4

Page 5: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

AAC FEbruary 2017 5

• Illiteracy/pre-literacy highly

correlates with poverty

[email protected]

Page 6: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

• Marginalised/remote

communities are more

likely to speak minority

languages → need to

communicate effectively

AAC FEbruary 2017 6 [email protected]

Page 7: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

• Everyone needs to be able to understand health

promotion materials

AAC FEbruary 2017 7 [email protected]

Page 8: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

• Mother-Tongue based Multi-Lingual Education (MTB-

MLE) most cost-effective: cognitive, social, cultural

benefits – and faster to other languages

AAC FEbruary 2017 8 [email protected]

Page 9: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

AAC FEbruary 2017 9

• Girls’ education in Mother Tongue has even more

benefits

[email protected]

Page 10: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

• Everyone needs a

‘voice’ in decision-

making, e.g. for

privatisation of water

AAC FEbruary 2017 10 [email protected]

Page 11: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

• Dialogue with stakeholders will ensure sustainability

of innovations

AAC FEbruary 2017 11 [email protected]

Page 12: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

• Access to official and ‘international’ languages =

opportunity for work

AAC FEbruary 2017 12 [email protected]

Page 13: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

AAC FEbruary 2017 13

• Linguistic issues

underpin sustainable

growth

[email protected]

Page 14: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

• Increasing power of a global Anglophone élite

AAC FEbruary 2017 14 [email protected]

Page 15: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

• Disaster preparedness plans need to reach all language

groups

AAC FEbruary 2017 15 [email protected]

Page 16: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

• Traditional knowledge

systems encoded in

language

AAC FEbruary 2017 16 [email protected]

Page 17: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

• Climate change mitigation efforts more sustainable if

linked in to traditional concepts

AAC FEbruary 2017 17 [email protected]

Page 18: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

• Local languages carry

traditional knowledge

about the sustainable

use of marine

resources

AAC FEbruary 2017 18 [email protected]

Page 19: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

• Ethnobotany links to linguistic knowledge of terrestrial

ecosystems

AAC FEbruary 2017 19 [email protected]

Page 20: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

AAC FEbruary 2017 20

• Languages are central to cultural identity (→ justice,

peace, inclusiveness)

[email protected]

Page 21: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Language dimensions of the SDGs

(examples)

• Translation and interpretation will enable everyone to be

included in the partnerships

AAC FEbruary 2017 21 [email protected]

Page 22: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

Conclusion

Language and the UN (2016, p. 2):

‘[T]here is an urgent need to include

language at the planning, implementation

and assessment stages of each of the

SDGs.’

→ aid projects and programmes

[email protected] AAC FEbruary 2017 22

Page 23: Language matters in aid effectiveness: Overviewdevpolicy.org › ... › Presentations › Panel1b_overview.pdfLanguage matters in aid effectiveness: Overview Hilary Smith Affiliate,

References

Casey, G. P., and A. L. Owen. 2014. ‘Inequality and fractionalisation.’ World

Development 56: 32-50.

Language and the UN. 2016. ‘Conclusions’. Symposium on Language and the

Sustainable Development Goals, 21-22 April 2016.

www.languageandtheun.org

UNESCO Bangkok. 2012. Why language matters for the Millennium

Development Goals.

http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0021/002152/215296e.pdf

SIL. 2014. Why languages matter: Meeting the Millennium Development Goals

through local languages.

https://www.sil.org/sites/default/files/mdg_booklet_2014_english_web.pdf

UN Sustainable Development Knowledge platform.

https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org

AAC FEbruary 2017 23 [email protected]