Top Banner
L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota
38

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

Dec 21, 2015

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Particle distributions in large scale radio jets

Lawrence Rudnick

University of Minnesota

Page 2: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

conclusion

FRI (low luminosity, non-classical double source) jets have a narrow distribution of low frequency

spectral (energy) indices around -0.55 ( -2.1), not the test particle strong shock limit of -0.50 ( -2.0).

CONCLUSIONS

Page 3: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Particle acceleration in kpc jets

Why look in the radio?

How do you look in the radio?

What do we find about particle distributions?

Page 4: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

WHY look in the radio?

Low frequencies – can see injection power law

– averages over long timescales

Page 5: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

HOW do you measure low frequency (injection) slope?

1. Need clear indication of low frequency power law

2. Must measure homogeneous population - resolve spatial variations in spectra - separate out background (lobe) confusion

Page 6: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Has the low frequency power law been seen?

Are spectral variations adequately resolved?

Has jet/lobe emission been separated?

Page 7: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Multi- resolution filtering

3C438

Page 8: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Spectral Tomography

Make series of images, St by varying t

St = S(2) – (2/1) * S(1)t

Page 9: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Jet spectra from tomography

Page 10: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

x = original map = filtered

= filtered= tomography

Page 11: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Has the low frequency power law been seen?

Are spectral variations adequately resolved?

Has jet/lobe emission been separated?

Page 12: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Determining the low frequency index

1. Asymptotic behavior nucleus

2. Color-color diagrams

Page 13: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Evolving electron population – spectral changes

Log

Int

ensi

ty

Log Frequency

Page 14: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Page 15: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Tomographyseparation –

Original spectrum

Jet (& sheath)

Page 16: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

COLOR-COLORDiagrams

reconstructing full spectral shapes from three frequency observations

Page 17: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Log

Int

ensi

ty

Log Frequency

Evolving electron population – mapping

spectral shape

Page 18: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Page 19: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Color-color – problem diagnosis

Page 20: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

North South

3C449

Page 21: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

= -0.55

Page 22: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Summary of spectra

= -0.55

Page 23: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Summary of spectra

= -0.55

Page 24: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Regulating ~ -0.55 -- where?Initial acceleration at nucleus? [ – e.g.,Hydra A pc scale, optically thin regions -0.7, kpc scale, ~ -0.59 ]

Flaring region? – jet flaring/ brightening regions post “gap”

NGC3153C449

Multifrequency. Spectra needed

1553+24

Page 25: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Regulating ~ -0.55 – how?

First-order regulation? Other regulation?

2nd order, shock-drift in turbulence/shear at flare?

Ultra-relavistic (but -2.25?)

Shock modification – self-regulation?

Page 26: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Short digression…

Page 27: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Crab Nebula

= -0.3

pileup from highenergy losses

Page 28: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

caveat - NGC315

Multifrequency observations of the jets in the radio galaxy

NGC315, 2006MNRAS.368...48L Laing, R. A.; Canvin, J. R.; Cotton, W. D.; Bridle, A. H.

Page 29: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

conclusion

FRI (low luminosity, non-classical double source) jets have a narrow distribution of low frequency spectral (energy) indices around -0.55 ( -2.1), not the test particle strong shock limit of -0.50 ( -2.0).

We need a characteristic acceleration mechanism; And, it’s not the whole acceleration story.

Page 30: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Page 31: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Page 32: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Page 33: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Page 34: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Page 35: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Page 36: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Page 37: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006

Page 38: L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006 Particle distributions in large scale radio jets Lawrence Rudnick University of Minnesota.

L. Rudnick - Krakow - June 2006