8/3/2019 Kyle Brennan Scientology Case - COS Subpoenas Sent to USDOJ 10 Mar 2010 http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kyle-brennan-scientology-case-cos-subpoenas-sent-to-usdoj-10-mar-2010 1/21 JOHNSON, POPE, BOKOR, RUPPEL & BURNS, LLP ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELLORS AT LAW E . D . A RM ST R ON G III ALEKSAS A.BARAUSKAS BRUCE H. BOKOR C HA RL ES A . B UF OR D GUYM.BURNS K AT HE RIN E E.COLE JONATHAN S.COLEMAN MICHAEL T . C R ON IN E LI ZA B ET H J. DANIELS C OL LE EN M. FLYNN MICHAEL G. LITTLE S AR A llJ . M A NT H EY M IC HA EL C.MARKHAM Z AC HA RY D . M ES SA F•WALLACE POPE, JR. ROBERT V.POTTER, JR. DARRYL R. RICHARDS PETER A. RIVELLlNI D E NN IS G . R U PP EL CHARLES A.SAMARKOS SCOTT E. SCHILTZ' KIMBERLY L. SHARPE WILLIAM B. SPOTTSWOOD JOAN M. VECCHIOLI STEVEN H . W E IN B ER G ER JOSEPH J. WEISSMAN STEVEN A. WILLIAMSON 'OFCOUNSEL JENNIFER A. FICARROTTA JOSEPH W. GAYNOR R Y AN C . G R IF FI N MARION HALE S C O TT C. ILGENFRITZ FRANK R. JAKES TIMOTHY A. JOHNSON, J R.' S HA RO N E.KRICK ROGER A . L AR SO N A NG EL IN A E.LIM 911 C HE ST NU T ST.• C LE AR WA TE R, fL OR ID A 33756 P OS T O FF IC E B OX 1368. CLEARWATER, F LO R ID A 33757·1368 T E LE P HO N E: ( 72 7) 461-1818. TELECOPIER: ( 72 7 ) 462-D365 FILE NO. 101799 March 8, 2010 Kennan Dandar, Esquire P.O. Box 24597 Tampa, FL 33623-3858 RE: ESTATE OF KYLE THOMAS BRENNAN CASE NO. 8:09-CV-00264-T-23-SDM-EAJ Dear Mr. Dandar: Please find enclosed copies of documents that I have received in response to subpoenas recently served on various third parties in the above-referenced case. Very truly yours, <.">. /\11 tA/~~'J ~<L_~ Robert V. Potter RVP/jeh Enclosures cc: Church of Scientology Flag Service Organization 491510v4 CLEARWATER + TAMPA
21
Embed
Kyle Brennan Scientology Case - COS Subpoenas Sent to USDOJ 10 Mar 2010
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
8/3/2019 Kyle Brennan Scientology Case - COS Subpoenas Sent to USDOJ 10 Mar 2010
Paul V. PotterJohnson, Pope, Bokor, Ruppel & Burns, LLP911 Chestnut StreetClearwater, Florida 33756
RE: Church of Scientology Flag ServiceOrganization v. Estate of Kyle ThomasBrennan
Dear Mr. Potter:
We have received your request for testimony, unfortunately,we are unable to comply with your subpoena at this time. Thedisclosure of information in the possession of the Department ofJustice is controlled by 28 C.F.R. 16.21-16.29. To properly requestthe information you seek/ you must comply with section 16.22 andfurnish a relevancy statement in sufficient detail to allow theDepartment of Justice to determine the relevancy of the testimony youare requesting to the issues in your legal proceeding. Upon receiptof that information, we will consult with the ;Department of Justice todetermine what information, if any, should be··released.
AS a practical matter, Mr. Potter, I conducted a search ofour records and located no documentation in the FBI's files regardingthe matter referenced above. Should you wish to pursue your subpoenarequest for some reason, please comply with the above requirements.
Once a decision is made regarding the disclosure of theinformation you seek, if you are not aatLs fLed with that decision,jUdicial review is available under,the·Administrative Procedure Act, 5U.S.C. 701 et seq. See Edwards v. U.S. Department of Justice, 43 F.3d312 (7th Cir. 1994). Should you have questions or concerns, pleasedo not hesitate to contact me at 402-530-1565.
Sincerely,
Weysan Dun
_ s p e r / ? ~ : ; : _~ti K. JohnsonChief Division Counsel
;; 'T.tL:~; ".'/~:ij~ ~ : i..
.. I;;;~.~· ·~T . lr:'~ .... ~ .,;\ ...,
8/3/2019 Kyle Brennan Scientology Case - COS Subpoenas Sent to USDOJ 10 Mar 2010
th e u nde rsign ed, h ere by auth oriz e and re que st th at p aym ent fo r
n sta r, P O B ox 3 10 74 , T am pa , F lo rid a 33631 f or ~n y ambu la n c; e ,. ~ :
. .' . .... Rerifaf
th oriz e a ny h old er o f m edic al info rm atio n o r do cu me ntatio n a bo .'
v ic es , In clu din g its a ge nts a nd c arrie rs , a s w e ll a s to S un sta r, a ny i
by S uns ta r o r re late d se rvic es no w and in th efu lu re . I ap pro ve th ~id er to S un sta r n ec es sa ry to p ro ce ss m y In su ra nc e b en efits 'c la lr
Med l ,icare w ill o nly pay fo r se rvic es th at it de le rm lne s to be "reasonab
ic are de te rm ine s th at a partic ular se rvic e, alth ough il w ou ld o th er
ic are w ill d en y p ayme nt fo r th at s erv ic e, M e dic are m a y d en y p ay rr
c e o f h os pita l is no t th e c lo se st h ospital) o r w he nJ~ e:p~ l!~ ht:~ F
rd an ce w ith 1 86 2(s }(7 ) o f th e M e dic are L aw , a s rn atb ea me n'd (-
.. . M adl~and that I am r esp ons ib le f o r t h e p a yme l )t (l ~ ~ I J, se t vlC?~<c le te t ,
c aid b e ne fits , o r r, en de re d w ith o ut p rio r a uthO riz at io n o f M e d ic al dj
'G Jde rstand th at I am fin anc ia lly re spo nsible fo r all c harge s fo r arnb~g es in fu ll w ith in n in ety (9.0) d ay s o f th e s erv ic es b ein g re nd ere d.]
e ne fits to r th e am bu lance se rvice s re nde re d, [ am aw are th at I anic are o r o th e r in su ra nc e,
JENNl rHR C , LYI1 1E~ IS TANT CO{ )N lY ATTORN'EY
G R E G K A M P T N E RDEPUTY COUNTY A TTORNEY
February 17, 2010
Y,ia Facsimi.!g
Robert V. Potter, Esq.
J oh ns on , P op e, B o ko r, R up t)e l& B urn s, L.L.P,
911 Chestnut Stree t
Clea rwa te r, F lo r id a 33156
Sincere ly ,
Re: SUbpoenas issued in C h urc h o f S cie nto lo gy F la g S e rv ic e D rg . v, rstate of K y l e Thomas
B r e n n a n, U.S. District Court for the Middle District of FloridaCase No . 8 :09 -CV-264 -T-23 EN
De ar M r . P o tte r:
1 re p re s en t t he Albemarle Co un ty p ub lic S ch oo ls a nd th e Albemar le County Police Department,
We received the subpoenas you issued 0(1 r~bruary 2,2010 In the above-referancad case seeklng
do cumen ts r'~ la tjn 8 to Kyle Th omas B re nnan.
P le a se b e ad vis ed that I o b je c t t o t he se subpoenas on th e b as is th at th ey we re imp rope rl y
issued pursuant toFed. R. elv. P,45 (a)(2) an d (b)(2)_ The s ub po e na s h av e been Issued under the
c ap tio n o f th e U nite d S ta te s D istric t C ou rt fo r th e W e ste rn D Is tric t o fV lrg ln la J although th e d o cumen ts
have b ee n re qu es te d fo r return to yo ur o ffice In Clearwater, F lo rid a, w hic h is m ore th an 100 m ile s fr omthe Western District of VirginIa.
T ha nk yo u fo r yo ur atte ntio n to th is matter,
Annie Kim
P A G E 2 J 2t
R C V D A T 2 1 1 7 1 2 0 1 0 2 : 0 3 : 2 2 P M [ E a s t e r n S f a n d a r d T l m e l * S V R :R 1 G H T F A X 1 /0 iD N I S : O t C S I D : 4 3 4 9 7 2 4 0 6 8 t D U R A T I O N ( m m . s s ) : 0 1 . 3 6
8/3/2019 Kyle Brennan Scientology Case - COS Subpoenas Sent to USDOJ 10 Mar 2010
Johnson, Popel Bokor, Ruppel & BurnsJ LLP,911 Chestnut St.1 Clearwaterl FL 33756Attn: Robert Potter
February 261 2010
10:00 a.m.
AO 88 (Rev. 6/09) Subpoena to Produce D( tents, Information, or Objects or to Permit Inspect IfPremises in a Civil Action
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTWESTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA
CHARLOTTESVILLE DIVISION
Estate of Kyle Thomas Brennan,
By and through its administrator,
Victoria L. Brennan .SUBPOENA IN A CIVIL CASE
Plaintiff,
v.Church of Scientology Flag Service Organization,
Denise Gentile, Gerald Gentile,
and Thomas Brennan
CASE NO: 8:09-C V -264- T - 23 E AJ
(U.S. Middle District of Florida
Defendant.
SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS
TO: Piedmont Virginia Community College
501 College Drive
Charlottesville, VA. 22902
o Production: YOU ARE COMMANDED to produce at the time, date, and place set forth below, the following documents, electronica
stored information, or o bj ec ts , a nd p erm it their inspection, copying, testing, or sampling of the material:
SEE EXHIBIT ADate and Time
*Pleasemail copies of the requested documents to the above addresson or before the scheduled date. Pleasec
the attorney Indicated below with any questions. Reasonablecopying andmailing expenses will be reimbursed.
D Inspection of Premises: YOU ARE COMMANDED to permit entry onto the designated premises, land or other property possessed
controlled by you at the time, date and location set forth below, so that the requesting party may inspect, measure, survey, photograph, test, or sample
property or any designated object or operation on it.,
Premises Date and Time
TIle provisions of Fed. R. Civ. P. 45(c), relating to your protection as a person subject to a subpoena, and Rule 45(d) and (e), relating to your
to respond to this subpoena and the potential consequences of not doing so, are attached.
Date: F(;~ L .2010
CLERK OF COURT
Attorney's signature
The attorney representing the defendant, Church of Scientology Flag Service Organization, who issues or requests this subpoena is:
Re: Estate of Kyle Thomas Brennan, By and through its administrator,
Victoria L. Brennan, Plaintiff, v Church of Scientology Flag Service
Organization, Denise Gentile, Gerald Gentile',"and Thomas Brennan,Defendants. .
" i ( i A X i l 1 ~ i r ~ t , ; :Subpoena to Produce Documents
Subpoena in a Civil Case
Case No.: 8·09·CV·264· T-23 EAJ(U.S. Middle District of Florida)
Dear Robert V, Potter, Esq.:
Attached please find the subpoenaed reports for the above-mentioned case.
Also, attached please ftnd the statement with a balance due of $24.10, Please make the check payable to:
Maui Police Department, and mail it attention; Records Division.
If you have any questions, please feel free to call or:~~~iJ~sn"e.
Mahalo!
Jill
Confidentiality Notice: This facsimile message, including m r y attachments, is for the sale use of the intended
recipientts) and may contain confidential and privileged information, Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure, 01'
distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient,please contact the sender byfax 01' phone and destroyallcopies of the original message. .., H·'. . .
.:f.;~,{i(~irn;'~'~'.f,
fax cover
Maui Police Department I Records & . Identification Division
I i ILASTNAME FII<ST MIDDlE I ~ I SO C I"'. SECURITY NO . IORIVEI<UCENSE NO.rIO. orE ADDRESS STRE!::,' CITyrrOVIN STA"rE I 3US1EMplSCliOOL I\bORESS STREET ClTYrrOWN $T/,TE
SOllER I IINTOXICATED I I SINGLE llVORCEr OCCUPt ,nml I BUSJEMf'. PIIGHE NO. RESIDENCEPHONENO.
I· IOlltER MARRIED N,DOWEl
OF OESCRIP"FIDN MCE SEX AT. O. O. B. AG!, flAIR EYES I HI Iwr J IDENTIFYINGMARKS ALb\S
I SHIRT COLOR PANTS COLOR ~OTHER OElSl:rNABLE PHYSICALDEFECTS
I BLOUSE SKIRT
vl N lui ARREST~C RIGHTS ~ ADMISSIONS . tM DATE TIME Y1A.OEIO PLACEMlifJE
READ MADE N I
C I P iN P
:'llJSE!) IN CRlM" STOLEN IYR. I h W < E BODYT'lPE COLOI< STATEL1C PLATENO. REGISTEREDOW'NER
.IIN P_OSSESSIQljOr- IAIRls ATrACKED IPHOPERTY ATTACI<EO POINT OF F.DDDR IROOF IOTHER
ENTRY RDOOR IW l f ·m o w _HOWATrACKEO MEANS OF KEY CUTTING IOTHER
"""'DNA*H ATTACK JIMMY HMiDS
PECULIARITIES (TRADEMARKS, ETC.) ! PROPERTY 1 MONEY JEWELS A e P L iNONETAKEN I PIlOTO EO CLOTHING AUTOACe IOTHER
r+ lY N JOlliER EVlDENCE DATE TU.IE PLACEFOUI10
LATENTPRINTSN P I
r;l PERSON CODE WEAPONSf~TYPE I TYPE rrWlfIlES I ITI1.EATEOBY
IPLACE TREATED
INJURED INJURED FORCE USE N SUSlAiNED
!JW Etm .E J O TH ER
. CIA l------.b-;o==,.+.;;=-=:::~~..",_,~-7~~-'~~p~:';_;;c~-'-", i'r~~;=.~~:_;:;;__;=;o-:c=""'~-----.---
J _ . _ . -
OT Arm TiME
VALUERECOVERED
CT-UPS REPORT NOS TOTALS:
ASSISTING I~NESTIGATORS
8/3/2019 Kyle Brennan Scientology Case - COS Subpoenas Sent to USDOJ 10 Mar 2010
0 E. Kamehameha Avenue Kahului Mon- 020507 2122S. N <)
5. . . . .PORTf.O flY ADDRESS DArF. -(I ME
See Below 020507 2122 =:I X jPflONE_[ IBEAT II W IRE I NVEST IGATOR MS iG r lH l 1 ! 1 l V ~ l l flMESEN, ARRIVAL BACK
~l
HOW_,.'
I IS'iN. I IViEW I IUR. KIHATA, K. 011513 2122 2129 2140
o""-II
-J..
oN-O00
orm.: c -COMPlAiNANT v - VICTIMDE Ii ILAST NAl,lE FIRST MIDDLE l~-OCI" ' , ~Fr.lJRlTYHO.
I ~~ I~l~T'lpn~No.1 DF1 BRENNAN Kvle .Ihomas .-STflEET Cr rYr rOWN STATE IBUS IE I~ P IS C H O Ol A DO RE S" StREFf cWlrrovm ~ n l < ' - f l : :
o Local Address UnemoJovedTOUR1~T• I .OGA1 .HOTf -UGONDO fllPr tOOM ~ lO 'I OM E D EP p.rrr I<t f~XATION B US .1E f,IP P HO NE N O I~N~aICf PHO IIF. /-iO
DNA
I I 1 U ' . s r n'ME F IRST M I[lD !.F .
rt-S O Cl I\ L S F. Cl IR rf '{ N O I MCE f F . X J A T . r · o9.
NO. o r -S,REET CIW ITOVI/N STATE rU S/E Mf> I Sr:f fO Ol AOORESG STREET r:.rr((rOV~IN STATE
T OUR IST . LOCAL HOTi:Ur.ONIlO.lil1 'f. I R OOM N°'ID A'E D EPA IH IOGCUPi \TIOH sus IE MP . P HO IIE riO IR ES ioalC E PH ON E ~ IO
I I IBUSINESS!FiRM I BU ~ l rl F. ~S ADDRESS STHEET C~r', 'rr.(rJ-\lN SfI\Tf'
NO . Of
J 1 IMGR 10 'r HF .R IRES IDENCE AO l) J1 F .S S SYREn 01fYriOWN ~r(Afi:-
JF~W. PHOtlF /1 0
IflE SJD EilC f P HO Nf' H O. IOCCL)PAT'ON lSC t'OOL GR . ~ SOC~\L SECURrU NO . I il.".f.E
r~\ ( I \ T I o .o s .
A - AR Rf,STEB PRRSON CA ·TIT]:;·EN ARREST fl. - RESPONSl En f- ; s- StigPECT- - -!?," I ILAST NN .,E FIRST MIDDLE r ~ 'I SOr.W SFCURWI HO JORNEflUr :F .NSE' ,10.
NO.j or j IINKN()WNN)J)RFSS STREET CIT-fffOWN STlirE IDUS ;HAP iSCHOOL ADDRess ~mlf.EJ GWilTOWn S-rf\j~
I S08m I l tHOXICArEO I ISING l.E ~ II/OnCEI OCCUPAtiON I B\lS.lEM P P HO NE NO . RESif)fNU' PH'lHP. NO
IDRINKING I JOOHER I MARRIED N!OO 'A l:D
SO!)flCF. Of ( l~SCRIPlIOI1 P""r:E SEX JAT. D. O. B. AGE ~~ \IR EYES I HT , I wr I 'DE'- lT'F'f 'NG MN\!{<; }-'~-l.I;';_~
HSP M Bl K_ BR O fi'11' 2()(}
t.llrnHNG X I SfflRf COLI}R rAms COLOR ~'~ :;I~RH()RT~ OBSERVMllF. PHYSICI IL DEf>,r;'fS<NOFUJ I BLOUSE i81 M':I< SKIRT
'riY! l.ul ,\fU lEST I Y C fliGHTS h f - l AOMLSSIOHS ill DATE T IM E' !~ .D E TO PI .ACE . \ 1i \Or- :
DESIRED ~ J' " I j:leI p Hr,AD ~ WIDE X i DNA DI'iA NA DNAI . IUSED IN CRll<lE STOLt:N I'IR t MAKE ~OD,{ TYPE COI ,OR ST/ITE Lie PI ME NO RE018TEp.F .n nW'~r ' ll
-±~JIN POSSESSION OF IA!,.,qls ATTt\C!(! :O I ?QQ3 Ioy.o__,_____4nsw .--'lllHIIE__ IMKY.M R HI lsu, 4 O O , _ Q llGftinaA-PR lPEi'tH MT I\CKW PO!NTOF I ,," DOOR ROOF OHlfR
ENTRY R noon \ ' J INO<"}VIHO W ATfl' .CKE 11 KE Y f(j-r~n~c(
'Mf-A tlS O ~ C 'ffllN (:;
~F··ATTI \CI ( JII.!MY HANDS
Pf .Cl IUMHTIES CrRADEMAHKS, F.r(;) I PflOP f.R ,~ ( l MONEV JEWELS IIPPl. INONErfPJ<EN I 1()ThERP HO TO EO cLOHflNO ALrr0ACC
: ± iV N I (!THER EVIOENCE of-.TE TI!.iF' PLACE FO !J N r,
EVlnEN( ;~ :.DhJA_ lJWA;:-WNAX lATENT PR lm s ~}{ l P lnMA
PERSON ~~lER SO N C OD E WEP,P(JNS! [~lYPE I TYPE n J JURIES I r M ~ ~ ~ ~ E ; B YC~~~E ,flEf\I~nINJURED 14 IWUHED C-1 FOR(:f. USE[ N PUNCH SUSTfo.INf.D ! PAIN
--
C-1 reported R-1 (unknown)walked up to him while hewas siUingon the sidewalk and slapped him inthe(al~reasons. C-1 statedR-1 lhen gol into a vehicle (MKY·066)and ned'he o",a. C-1 suffered pain ' 0 l&t~ e
resultlnq (rom'he blow. C-1 treated and released at thescene by Medi,-1. Report lor dooum~~ ~ ~1lI\OIl
~~~ 1)\~1I1~~ ~ \OIlO Il
rfo.~?~\§~\jC
;\'fR EV( : ~o crsrosmcs Records
OT Y ITflM\RTIClE PROP ERn DESCRIPTION (ff<t,OcWIRI( COI.OH, SIZE ETC.i S L 'R 1 N. I H IW1 ER \liLliE:\!I<l.UE
' \ECOVF.RI'[)
--
*-*DNA···
,- '---.--.----.---.~~--~ 'c,.f I f''! i U, ,'O H T . .l OS