Page 1
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 1 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
UniversityPressScholarshipOnline
OxfordScholarshipOnline
ArchitectsofPiety:TheCappadocianFathersandtheCultoftheMartyrsVasilikiM.Limberis
Printpublicationdate:2011PrintISBN-13:9780199730889PublishedtoOxfordScholarshipOnline:May2011DOI:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199730889.001.0001
KinshipwiththeMartyrs
SaintsasRelativesandRelativesasSaints
VasilikiM.Limberis(ContributorWebpage)
DOI:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199730889.003.0004
AbstractandKeywords
ThischapteraddresseshowtheCappadocians’imbricationwiththeirownfamiliesmergeswiththeirpromotionofmartyrpiety.Theyuseittoforgenewrelationshipswiththemartyrsandtopromotetheirownfamilies.Theyweresuccessfulbecauseavibrantsacramentallifeforthelaitywasnotyetthenorm;everypiouscatechumencouldparticipateinapanegyrisformartyrs.Theypromotekinshipwiththemartyrsasspiritualkinship,opentomonasticsandlaityalike.BasilandGregoryofNyssaevenclaimedthreesaintsasrelatives:GregoryThaumaturgus,Thecla,andtheFortyMartyrs.Hence,theprestigeoftheirownfamilywentbeyondallsocialparameters.Finally,GregoryofNazianzusandGregoryofNyssainscribetheirrecentlydeceasedkinintotheranksofthemartyrs.TheCappadocianssucceedinbypassingtheneedforprocreation,sincethroughmartyrpietytheirfamily’shonorisforever.
Page 2
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 2 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
Keywords:kinship,asceticism,baptism,marriage,godparents,Emmelia,Macrina,Gorgonia,Caesarius,Nonna
Itisverydifficultforthepresent-dayreadertograsptheideathatfamiliesasaristocratic,educated,andrichastheCappadocianswillingly“chosesocialextinction”fortheirgens.1Ordidthey?Onewouldbehard-pressedrightnowtocomeupwiththenameofevenonefamousfamilyoffourth-centuryCappadociawhosemembersmarried,hadchildren,andpassedonvastestates.Contrarytothealmostuniversalnotionsofwaystoperpetuateone’sfamilyline,nearlyalltheCappadocianswentagainstthetraditionalstandardsoftheirownsocietyandinvestedtheirenergiesinacompletelynewwayofliving—asceticism.Yet,theyblendedaristocraticidealsofsocietyinlateantiquity—suchaspatronage,statesmanship,socialnetworking,andmaintenanceofagoodreputation—intotheirliveswhilepursuingChristianasceticisminvaryingdegrees.Theycontinuedtofollowallthesocietalnormstheyhadinheritedthrougheducationandacculturation,mostnotablyinmasteringtheconventionsofpublicspeaking,civicdeportment,andnegotiatingpoliticalaffairs.Thesetheycarriedoutinrhetoricalcompositions,inproperlydeliveredaddresses,infinelycraftedletters,andthroughpatronageandleadershipfortheircommunitiesintheformsofmartyria,churches,monasteries,hospitals,andorphanages.Infact,theywere(p.98) alsoquitesuccessfulinutilizingallthetraditionalmediacommoninlateantiquityforpromotingtheirfamilies.WhiletheCappadocianFatherswerecertainlycelibate,theirpersonalversionsoftheasceticlifeaccommodatedthestrengtheningofkinshiptieswiththeirfamiliesforever.
Whatwassorevolutionarywastheirjustificationforwhytheirfamiliesweresospecialanddeservedmemorializing.Throughanelaborate,lifelongeffortattelling(andretelling)thestoriesofthelocalmartyrsandinconnectingtheirfamiliestothosestories,BasilandGregoryofNyssasuccessfullylaidclaimtothemartyrsastheirspiritualkin.Theirownfamilywas“related”tothemostimportantmartyrsoftheregion:Thecla,GregoryThaumaturgus,andtheFortyMartyrsofSebasteia.Theirsuccessatjustifyingsuchclaimsistheepitomeofwhathasbeenaptlycalled,“theculturemakingaspectsofmartyrdom’srepresentations.”2AllthreeCappadocianswentevenfurther.Theirwritingsimmortalizedtheirdeceasedfamilymemberswithfuneralpanegyricsthatbestowedthemartyrs’virtuesontotheconductoftheirlives.Knowingwhotheiraudienceswereandthat“thetextsaregenerativeofcollectivememory,theCappadociansactivelycontributedtotheirownmemorializing.”3Insodoingtheyalsoincreasedtheirpowerandprestige.
ThischapterwillexploretheformsofkinshipknowntotheCappadocians—affinal,adoptive,andspiritual—andwhatthesemeantinthecontextoftheChurch.Eachofthesecouldbeachievedthroughoneormoremeans:monasticism,marriageandbirth,ormartyrpiety.Ofcourse,theseveralmeanstokinshipoftenoverlap,asweshallseefirstinthebriefdiscussionofmonasticism,whichisbothadoptiveandspiritual.Atthispoint,itwillbecrucialtothenexplainhowaffinalrelationshipscameaboutinfourth-centuryCappadocia,withspecialattentiontothestatusofbaptismspecifically,andsacramentallifegenerally,inthefourth-centuryChurch.Aswillbeevident,theCappadociansendedupbeingbeneficiariesofthisbriefperiodinchurchhistorywhenanactivesacramentallifeforthelaitywasstilldevelopingandnotwidespread,andwhenmartyrpietyservedasthecustomarywaypeopleshowedChristiandevotion.ThoughsomereadersmayknowthefamilystoriesoftheCappadociansverywell,itisessentialnexttoreviewtheirbiographiestobringtotheforewhattheyfoundmostvaluableinkinship.Thischapterwillthenhighlightsomeofthemostimportant
Page 3
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 3 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
relationshipsintheCappadocians’ownfamilies,andhowtheyinfluencedeachother’slifedecisions.Suchdiscussionsperfectlycontextualize,asweshallsee,theCappadocians’conceptof“kinshipwiththemartyrs.”
(p.99) ThenextsectionexploreshowtheCappadocianFathersmadestrategicuseoftherathernebulous,formativesituationinecclesiasticalpiety(atleastnebulousbylaterstandards)inordertopromotekinshipwiththemartyrsforeveryone,andhowkinshipwiththemartyrsqualifiedforthemostpartasspiritualkinship.Yetfortheirownfamilies,kinshipwithmartyrswassovaluedthatitbecamesomethingmorethanspiritual.ForBasilandNyssen,connectingtheirownfamilymemberstocertainmartyrsinnearlyconsanguineousrelationshipsbasedonfamilymodelsgavethemspecialadvantagesintheChurch.Theiruniqueconceptofkinshipwiththemartyrs(consanguineousandspiritual)wassopervasivethatreferencestosuchhereditaryconnectionsarescatteredthroughouteverygenreoftheirwritings.Itisimportant,therefore,topayparticularattentiontowhatmartyrtheyclaim,inwhatcontext,andforwhichfamilymember.
ItispreciselyinthiscontextthattheCappadocians’martyrpietymovedseamlesslyfromtheinnersanctumoftheirfamiliestothepublicsphereoftheChurch.AstheybecamebishopsoftheChurchonthepublicstage,alltheCappadocianseventuallytooktheirbrothers,sisters,mothers,fathers,andbestfriendsintoanevenmoreprivilegedposition—intotherealmofthesaints.ThelastsectionofthechapterwillrevealhownaturalitwasfortheCappadocianstoblurtheboundariesbetweenapanegyrictoamartyrandafuneralencomiumforadeceasedfamilymember.Bymergingtheirvirtuesinlife—includingmiracles—withtherhetoricalformoftheclassicpanegyric,theCappadociansassurethattheirbelovedrelationswouldachieveindeaththesamesaintlystatusasthemartyr.Inthisregard,GregoryofNyssa’sliteraryeffortsforhissisterMacrinawereexceptional;heinventedanewgenreforherthatgoesbeyondafuneralencomium.TheLifeofMacrinaistrulyahagiobiography.
Finally,thechapteranalyzesthebitsandpiecesofdescriptionsoftheirfuneralrituals,whicharenearlyidenticaltotherubricsofamartyrfestival.Notonlydoesthisreinforcetheidentityofthedeceasedpersonasamartyr,butinabrilliantwayitalsotemporarilydemolishesclassbarriers,sinceallpeoplewerewelcomeat—andindeedfamiliarwith—amartyr’spanegyris.ThisbecomesallthemoredistinctiveandextraordinarywhenwerememberthattheCappadociansconstantlypreachedthateveryone,richandpooralike,shouldbecome“friendsofthemartyrs.”
TheProceduresofKinshipBeforedelvingintotheepisodesintheCappadocians’livessobrimmingwiththevitalityoffamilylife,itishelpfultotakealookatthemeansofsocialinteractionthatcreatedkinshipforthem.Thislaysthefoundationfor(p.100) understandingtheirconceptoftheirownkinshipwiththemartyrs.“Kinspeoplehaveaspecialrelationshipofobligation,trust,honesty,andsupport”infourth-centuryCappadocia.4Mostespecially,kinshipfortheCappadociansisnotdefinedsolelyasbiologicalreproduction,althoughbloodrelations,ofcourse,fitintotheirideaofkinship.“Itisbesttoviewkinshipasaninstrumentforconceivingofsocialrelations.”5Seeingkinshipasaqualityofbehavior,disconnectedfrombiologicalreproduction,freesitfromtheconstraintsofboth“metaphorickinship”and“fictivekinship.”6Asweshallsee,onceoneisrelatedtoanotherperson,theobligationsandprivilegesoftherelationshiparesous
Page 4
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 4 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
entendus.Thekeytounderstandingkinshipinthislightistofocusonhowpeoplebecomerelated.FortheCappadocians,therewereseveralpathways.Thebestroutetoestablishkinship,intheirview,wasformalentryintothemonasticlifewhichestablishedspiritualkinshipties;butthiswascertainlynotforthemajorityofChristians.Theothermeanstokinshipweremarriage,birth,andmartyrpiety,opentoeveryonenotcommittedalreadytoamonasticvocation;yet,ofcourse,monastics,too,couldparticipateinkinshipthroughmartyrpiety.7Tothisend,itisfirstnecessarytoexaminemonastickinshipbrieflybeforeexploringthestatusofmarriageandbirth—thelatterthroughthesacramentofbaptism—intheirCappadociancontext.
MonasticKinship
FromthetremendousamountofrecentliteratureontheemergenceofcoenobiticmonasticisminAsiaMinor,itisquitewellestablishedthatBasilofCaesareaculledwhathefoundusefulinextantmonasticpracticesfromallovertheeasternMediterraneanandEgypttofoundmonastichouseholdsbasedonaclearlydelineatedcommunalrule.8Hecertainlyrefinedandregularizedmonasticlife,buthedidnotcreateitanew.9BasilexplicitlysaysthatthebestmeansforeachpersontorestorethelikenessofGodistochoosetheasceticlife,not(p.101) inisolation,butincommunity.10ThroughouttheAsceticon,whereBasilreiterateshowoneistoliveharmoniouslywithothersinthemonastery,hedemonstrateshowthecoenobiticlifecreatesspiritualkinshipamongthebrothers,orsisters,attheexpenseofbiologicalkinship.Basilconsciouslyassumesthelanguageoffamilialkinship,supplantingboththeneedandimportanceofthetraditionalfamily,andappliesittothedailycommunallifeofthemonastery.“Themonasterywasnotasupplementtothetraditionalbondsofsocietybutawholesalereplacementofthem.”11ThefollowingthemesaboutspiritualkinshipemergeconsistentlyintheAsceticon.
First,thecoenobiticliferequiresthateachcandidaterenounceallbiologicalbondsofkinship.BasillacestheAsceticonwithJesus’wordsinLuke14:26invariousformsandsimultaneouslycutsthroughtheveryfoundationsofsecularsociety—thefamily:“Whoevercomestomeanddoesnothatefatherandmother,wifeandchildren,brothersandsisters,yes,evenlifeitselfcannotbemydisciple.”12Heisveryclearthateachnovice“mustrenouncealltiesofphysicalrelationshipandhumanfriendships.”13Basilwiselysuggeststhatifthecandidatehasanywishtogetmarried,heorsheshoulddoso“beforemakingthepromisetolivethereligiouslife,”becauseweretheindividualtodosoafterward,heorshewouldbreakavowtoGod.14Monasticscouldnotgovisittheirrelativesforanyreason,includingsickness,andonlypiousrelativescouldvisitthemonasteryforashorttime,withsupervisionandwithoutextensiveconversation.Moreover,everyvisitingrelativewastobeconsideredtherelativeofeveryotherbrother(orsister)ofthemonastery,neverone’s“own.”15
Despitesodrasticarepudiationoffamily,monasticsdidnotfindthemselvesalone,alienated,andinchaos.Theyhadanewfather(ormother)inthesuperiorofthemonastery,andtheyhadmanysiblings,allhierarchicallyarrangedasseniororjuniormonasticsinaworkinghousehold,actinginvariousrolesasteacher,boss,orhelper.16“Thebasicunitofmonasticlife,justasoutsidethemonastery,was‘household,’ledbya‘congregationalparent,’a‘memberofthehousehold,’or‘kinsmen.’”17Basilstatesquiteclearlythatamonastic’s“true(p.102) parents”arethosewhobroughthimtothespirituallifeoftheGospel.Mostimportant,amonastic“looksuponashisbrethrenthosewhohavereceivedthesamespiritof
Page 5
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 5 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
adoption.”18Thus,monasticismhasacompletefamilysysteminplacethatsupplantsphysical,affinalkinshipwithspiritualandadoptivekinship.
Thefinalbenefitofmonastickinshipismaterialwelfare.Basilmakescarefulprovisionsforcandidatestodisposeoftheirproperty.Hesuggests,first,thatthepersondisposeofithimself,butifhehasproblemsofanysort,beitwithrelativesoranyoneelse,heshouldnotletabloodrelativetakecharge.19Ifheneedstoseekajudgment,heshouldnottakeittoasecularcourt.Thoughhedoesnotsayso,onecansafelyassumethejudgewouldbethesuperiorofthecommunity,orabishop,sinceBasilworkedsteadilytomovemonasticismunderecclesiasticaladministration.20Furthermore,Basildisapprovedofrelativesbestowinggiftsonthemonastery,butheleftthefinaldecisiontothesuperior.21Aswithmattersofdiscipline,workschedule,prayer,andconduct,alldecisionsconcerningland,money,shelter,livestock,clothing,andfoodweremadesolelybythesuperior.Sojustasitfunctionedinthefourth-centuryhousehold,propertyownershipinthemonasterydefined“theruleofthefather”overthehouseholdmuchmorethandidblood.22
FromtheAsceticonweseehowBasilanticipatedeverymaterialneedofthenewmonastic,justaswouldanygoodfather.Hegivesampleattentiontoawidevarietyofmaterialconcerns,suchassuitableclothing,belts,comfortableshoes,moderationinconsumingmeals,dinnertimedeportment,careforthesickmembersofthecommunity,manuallabor,honorabletradestoteachtheorphans,andmethodstoconductbusiness.23Basilknewthatmaterialsupportwasthemostrudimentaryobligationandbenefitoffamily,andhemadesurethatthemonasteryfulfilledthatrole.Likeawell-runfamilyhousehold,themonasteryprovidedforeveryneed.Inthisway,alltieswiththesecularworldcouldbemoreeasilybroken.Monasticsnolongerneededanysupportoftheirfamilies,anyformofcharity,oranyrichperson’spatronage.24
Finally,itiswellworthnotingwhatBasilhastosaywhenmonasticsattendamartyr’spanegyris.Hedealswiththesubjectbecauseitseemslucrative(p.103) emporiaweresetupadjacenttomartyriawhenthepanegyriswastakingplace.Basilspecifiesingreatdetailinseveralotherplaceshowmonksweretomarkettheirhandiwork,butundernocircumstancescouldtheyconductbusinessatamartyrshrine.
Weshouldnotmaketheshrinestheoccasionandplaceforamarketandafairandcommontradeinsteadofprayingforoneanother,adoringGodtogether,imploringHisaidewithtears,makingsatisfactionfortheirsins,thankingHimforHisbenefactionandstrengtheningtheirfaithbyhearingwordsofexhortation(practiceswhichweknowtohaveoccurredwithourownmemory),weoughtnottoimitatethemandconfirmtheirunseemlyconductbyalsoparticipatinginsuchcommercialpursuits.25
Wehavearareglimpsehereofaconvergenceoftwoworlds—monasticsatthemartyrshrine,wherehoardsoflaitywouldbe—andmartyrpietyseemstobethegreatlevelerofthetwo.Monasticsandlaypeople—twogroupsofChristianswhointentionallyliveapartfromeachother—havenodistinctionbeforethemartyrs.Nomatterwhattheirsocialarrangementinsociety,allChristianscometothemartyrsalike,andallmustshowthesamereverence.
KinshipthroughMarriageandBirth
Page 6
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 6 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
Inthefirstfourcenturies,theChurchdidnothingtocontravenetheRomanlawsandcustomsconcerningtheinstitutionofmarriage,evenafterthesettlementofConstantine.“Untilatleasttheendoftheninthcentury,theByzantinesgenerallyconcludedmarriagesascivilcontractswithoutanyinvolvementoftheChurchinthelegalaspectsofthemarriagecontract.”26Asdemonstratedin1Corinthians,Ephesians,1Timothy,andTitus,theearlyChurchwasprimarilyinterestedinhowpeoplelivedafterthemarriage.Thatpeoplecontinuedtocontractmarriagesfortheirchildrenorthemselves,andhostedtheceremonyandcelebrationsaccordingtoRomanlawandcustom,wassimplyagiveninChristianlife.MarriagecustomsfromGreco-Romanantiquitycontinuedinfourth-centuryCappadocia.Theseincludedsuchpracticesasbetrothalgiftsfrombridegroomtobride,crownsofeitherpreciousmetalorwreathedflowersforthecouple,exchangeofrings,andcelebrationsafterward,includingfeastinganddancing.27
(p.104) ThediscussionsofmarriagefoundinthewritingsoftheCappadocianFathersfitthispattern.Infact,nearlyhalfofBasil’seighty-fourcanonsonpracticalmattersinthelifeoftheChurchconcernmarriage.Yetheneverdealswiththeprocessofcreatingthemarriageceremony,decidingwhoofficiatesatthewedding,ordesignatinghowtheChurchblessesthemarriage.HemostcertainlydoesnotproposeatheologyofmarriageorspeakofmarriageasasacramentintheChurch.Basil’sconcerniscenteredmuchmoreonethicallivingduringmarriage,thenumberofremarriagesonemighthave,andpenancesforthosewhoviolateethicallivingstandards.Hence,Basil’scanonscallingforrestrictionsonsecondandthirdmarriagesandprohibitionoffourthmarriageswouldbecomenormativeattheCouncilinTrulloin692.28
ThefollowingcanonbesttypifiestheCappadocians’viewofmarriage:“Marriagescontractedwithoutthepermissionofthoseinauthorityarefornication.Ifneitherfathernormasterbeliving,thecontractingpartiesarefreefromblame;justasiftheauthoritiesassenttothecohabitation,itassumesthefixityofmarriage.”29Thus,theCappadociansacceptedthatmarriageswerecontractualrelationshipsbetweenaconsentingmanandwoman,thattheywereconductedoutsidetheprovenanceoftheChurch,andthatthemostfundamentaltiesofkinshipresultedfrommarriage.
SomeofGregoryofNazianzus’lettersshowastrongrespectforweddings,andintheprocessthelettersalsogiveusevidenceaboutweddingritualsandcustomsatthetime.Christianclergywereinvitedtoweddingsjustlikeanyotherguest.Suchinvitationsweresporadicinthefourthcenturyanddependedonthefriendshipandsocialstatusoftheparentsandclergy.30IfGregoryhadbeenabletoattendtwoweddingstowhichhewasinvited,hewouldhavedeliveredtheepithalamios,thetraditionalhymndeliveredatGreco-Romanweddings,notasabishopbutasanhonored,talentedrhetor.Unfortunately,onbothoccasionshewastoosicktoattend.
(p.105) Inoneletter,NazianzenasksacertainEusebiustoexcusehimfromtheweddingofthelovelygirlEvopia.HeinsiststhatEusebiussingtheepithalamiosinhisstead,andthatthefatherplacethecrownsontheheadsofthebrideandgroom.31FortheweddingofOlympias,daughterofhisfriendVitalianus,hesentanexquisiteweddinghymn,writteninhisimpeccableGreekverse.32WhenGregorybegsofftheinvitation,hewritesthathewouldbethelaughingstockofthereceptionsincehehas,inessence,twoleftfeet!33Hewritesfurther
Page 7
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 7 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
thatjokesandlightheartednessarerequiredforweddings,butthenhebecomesmoreserious,addingasalientcommentontheweddingceremony.Ifhewereattendingtheweddinghewould“jointhecouple’srighthandstogether,andthenunitethemtoGod,tobringthebestthingstotheirunionaccordingtoourcommonprayers.”34ThisishisChristianinnovationandaddendumtotheceremony,hisuniquepersonalblessing.
BothlettersshowthatChristianityhadlittletonoinfluenceontheweddingceremonyofthattime.Infact,GregorystateshisownpersonalinnovationonGreco-Romantraditionwhenheattendsweddings:healwayshasthefathercrownthecouple,andhesaystheprayers,“whichareneverlimitedbyplace.”35CrowningthecoupleandthejoiningoftheirrighthandsasasymbolofConcordiaweretheage-oldritualsofRomanmarriage.36Gregory’smoralconcernscenternotonforgingthecontractbutonthetraditionalweddingcelebrationsaftertheceremony.Letter232standsoutparticularlybecauseheissoworriedaboutmaintainingthedecorumofthecelebration.Andheisnoteveninvitedtothewedding!HewritestoacertainDiocles,thefatherofthebride,sayingthathewillbeattheweddinginspirit.Withhisownwistfulpastoralnote,headds:
(p.106) ForoneofthemostbeautifulthingsataweddingistohaveChristpresent,andwhereverChrististhereismodesty,andwaterbecomeswine.Thatistosay,everythingistransformedintosomethingbetter,notjustahodge-podgeofbishopsandclowns,prayersandapplauses,psalmsandstimulatingflutemusic.ItisnecessaryforChristianstoguardtheirmodestyonalloccasions,andthisincludesatweddings.Ifyourson-in-lawrespectsthis,youshallhaveason.Ifnot,thenyouwillbestuckwithasoldier.37
Gregory’sadditionofChristtotheweddingisanotableinnovation.MarriagewasnotyetundertheumbrellaoftheChurch—evenlesswasitregardedasasacrament.YettheevidenceshowsthattheCappadociansheldmarriageinhighesteemandobviouslyvalueditasmeansofkinship.
Aftermarriage,birthestablishesfundamentalbondsofkinship.Butlikemarriage,theChurchofthefourthcenturyhadnomeansofsanctifyingbirth,orevenofincludingitundertheauspicesofecclesiasticaldominion.BecausetheeventsofbirthandchildbaptismnotonlybecameinextricablylinkedbutalsobecamethenorminChristianityfromtheeighthcenturyonward,itiscrucialheretodecouplethetwoevents.Birthandbaptismweretwoeventsnotassociatedinfourth-centurychurchpractice.Infact,baptism’sroleinkinshipisyetunformedinthefourthcentury.
AswasthecustomforthemajorityofChristiansinthefourthcentury,alloftheCappadocianswerebaptizedasadults.Wehavenoexamplesintheirfamiliesofinfantorchildbaptism.GregoryofNazianzusintroducestheideaofbaptizingsmallchildren,butnotbabies,“foritisbetterthattheyshouldbeunconsciouslysanctifiedthanthattheyshoulddepartunsealedanduninitiated.”38Butthisisanovelidea.HejustifiesitbyequatingittoJewishcircumcisionontheeighthday,“whichwassortofatypicalseal.”39Forthosechildrennotindangerofdying,Gregorysuggeststhatchildrenofagethreeorfourshouldbebaptized,“whentheymaybeabletolistenandtoanswersomethingabouttheSacrament.”40
Forthesamereason,alltheCappadocianspleadwithpeopletostopdelayingbaptism.
Page 8
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 8 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
Nazianzenstatesthecommonreasonfordelayedbaptism:“ButareyouafraidlestyoushoulddestroythegiftofGod,anddoyouthereforeputoffyourcleansing,becauseyoucannothaveitasecondtime?”41AndGregory(p.107) ofNyssabegs,“Youfindyourselfoutsideofparadise,Ocatechumen,andpartofthecompanyoutsidetheboundarieswithAdamtheforefather….Asayoungpersonyousay,‘Iamnotoldyet.’Donotbedeceived,fordeathisnotlimitedbythepreferencesofage,neitherisdeathfrightenedbythoseintheirprime,itspowerisnotonlyoveroldpeople.”42Basil’soration,althoughriveting,obviouslyhadlittleeffect.“Whatwillconqueryou?Pleasureofthefleshorholinessofthesoul?Enjoymentofthepresentortheyearningforthefuture?Shouldtheangelsskipoveryou,orshouldtheyholdyouclose?”43Theexcusesoftheirparishionersecholoudlyinthesewritings.
TheCappadociansmakenomentionofeithersponsorsorgodparentsforbaptism,althoughotherChristianauthorssuchasHippolytus,Egeria,JohnChrysostom,andAugustinegivesomeevidenceofsponsorswhotestifiedthatthecatechumenwasworthyofbaptism;andtheyremainedwiththeircatechumenduringtheweeksofpreparationforthebaptism.44Oncethebaptismalceremonywasfinished,thesponsorshadnofurtherroletoplay.45EventhoughafewdecadeslaterJohnChrysostomreferstothesponsorasthe“spiritualfather,”andthecatechumenasthe“spiritualchild,”neithertheclergynorthelaityofthefourthcenturysawthesocialutilityyetofmakingsponsorsintokin,ofmakingthemintogodparents.46Inessence,thepracticedidnotcatchonuntilwellintothefifthandsixthcenturies.WhileitislikelythattheCappadocianFathershadsponsorswhentheywerebaptized,perhapstheywerefamilymembersorbishopswhohadtaughtthem,wehavenoevidence.Insteadofmentioningsomeonetovouchforthecatechumen,Nazianzenconsistentlystressesthatbaptismisanindividualdecisionandthateachpersonmustpreparehimselfforthecleansingmystery.Hescoldspeopleforquibblingaboutwhowillbaptizethem,amerepriestorabishopofhighrank;forconcerningthemselvesaboutthequalityofthefabricofthebaptismalrobetheywillwear;andfordisdainingtobebaptizedwithpoorpeople.47
Inthenexttwocenturies,baptizingchildrenandinfantsbecamemorecommon,astheirparentsbroughtthemtothechurchandactedastheirsponsors.Thatbiologicalparentswouldbecomespiritualparentsinbringing(p.108) theirchildrentobaptismatfirstposednotheologicalproblemfortheChurch.Thispracticechanged,though,bythetimeoftheCouncilinTrullo,692.Furthermore,everyregionofChristendomdevelopedatheologyofspiritualincestthattaughtthatbiologicalparentsandthegodparent(sponsorforeternity)oftheirchildinbaptismwererelatedtooneanotherinspiritualkinship.Physicalmarriagebetweenmembersofthesefamilieswashenceforthstrictlyforbidden.Throughsponsoringtheirchildinbaptism,heorshewouldbecomethefamily’sspiritualrelative,withallthebenefitsoftheimplicitfriendship,loyalty,andpatronage.Biologicalparentsthussawtheadvantagesofinvitingafriendorsocialacquaintancetobecometheirchild’sgodparent.Inessence,theywouldbeinvitinganewpersonintothefamily.Ittookverylittletimeforthistheologyofgodparenthoodtotransformliturgicalactionsintoapatternofsocialbehavior.”48
ItmayseemoddtostresswhatisnotpresentintheconceptofkinshipfortheCappadocianFathers.ItisnecessarytodothisprimarilybecauseoncethesacramentaltheologyofbaptismandmarriagedevelopedsomuchlaterinChristianity,itcametodominateall
Page 9
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 9 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
discussionofthesubject,overpoweringthehistoricalrealityofbothinstitutionsinearliercenturies.Thislatersacramentaltheologyofbaptismandmarriage,withitsexplicitramificationsforChristiankinship,simplydidnotexistinthefourthcentury.
FortheCappadocians,baptism,indeed,wasavitalsacrament;butbaptism,eitherofadultsorchildren,didnotestablishkinshipforthem.Conversely,marriagedidestablishkinshipinthefourthcentury,butitwasnotasacramentoftheChurch,nordidtheChurchyethavecontroloverthemarriageortheceremony.SincetheCappadocianswereavidpromotersoftheasceticlife,marriageandprocreationweredecidedlyasecondchoiceforlivingtheChristianlife.Intheirview,tocreatekinshipthroughthisconventionalwayoflifewasalsoinferior.Byconsciouslychoosingasceticism,eachoftheCappadocianFathersactivelystoppedthesocialproductionofconventionalkinship,basedonmarriageandbirth.
Thoughtheypreachedrepudiationofkinshiptiesforthosewhojoinedthemonasteries,andthoughallthreeofthemwerecelibate,theCappadocianscontinuedtovaluekinshiptieswiththeirownfamilymembersquiteseriously,justasthelaitydidinthewidersociety.Kinshipwiththeirownfamilieswasofgreatconsequencetoeachofthem,andtheywerebothassiduousandresponsibleinperformingalltheobligationsthatkinshipdemanded.Giventheirstrongattachmentstotheirfamilies,itmayappearthattheywereultimately(p.109)stymiedbycelibacy,sincekinship,conventionallyspeaking,dependedontraditionalmarriagepatternsandeventualbirths.ButfortheCappadocians,therewas,indeed,onemoreoutstandingwaytoestablishkinship,andthatwasthroughmartyrpiety.
Astheyactivelypromotedofthecultofthemartyrs,theCappadocianscreatedanewnetworkofrelatives—kinshipwiththemartyrs.Theirasceticismmayhavecausedthedemiseoftheirfamilylinesonearth,buttheywereassuredablessedexistenceforeternitybyjoiningthecelestialfamilyofthemartyrs.Furthermore,itwasmartyrpiety,withallitsattendantritualsatshrinesandchurches,thatcreatedaflourishinglifeintheChurchforthefaithfulinthefourthcentury.Christianpietyexpressedthroughactiveparticipationinthesacramentssimplywasnotavisible,popular,ortypicaloccurrenceinthefourthcentury.Fewpeopleelectedtobebaptizedbeforetheendoftheirlives,soatmosttherewouldhavebeenonlyahandfulofpeoplereceivingHolyEucharistattheliturgies.AndwithsomanycatechumensintheChurchorderedtodepartaftertheGospelreadingandthesermon,itishardtoimaginethatthechurcheswerefullduringthesecondhalfoftheliturgyeachSunday.49Inotherwords,fourth-centurypietyoflayChristianswasnotcenteredonthesacraments.50
Thecultofthemartyrswasthebestwaytoestablishkinship,bothforthemselvesandtheirlayparishioners.Theyfoundthatthelaityneededlittlepromptingintheirdevotiontothecultofthemartyrs,andcertainlymostpeoplecontinuedtomarryandhavechildren,whilefewjoinedthemonastery.TheCappadocianstappedintothevastreservoirofextantmartyrpietyamongthelaity,takingcontrolofitandreshapingitthroughorations,buildingmartyria,andconductingceremoniesatmartyrpanegyreis.Indoingso,theypreachedthateveryoneshouldbecomekinwiththemartyrs.Buttheyalsosetthemselvesapartfromthelaityintheirowndevotiontothecultofthemartyrs.Theyclaimedspecialrelationshipsoftheirownancestorstocertainfavoritemartyrs.Andastheybecameadeptatthepracticeofasceticismwithintheconfinesoftheirestates,theyfruitfullyreinterpreted“thestrugglesof‘dailylife’in
Page 10
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 10 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
lightofthetrialsofthemartyrs.”51
(p.110) SketchesofTwoFamiliesThefamiliesofBasilandofhisfriendGregoryofNazianzusbothfitthedefinitionofapatrilineal,nuclearfamily,wherethefatherpresidedovertheentirehousehold,whichincludedservantsandslaves.Theywere“nuclear”totheextentthattherewasnoextendedfamilyunderoneroof,astheirdaughtersmarriedouttothehusband’shouseandsonsestablishedtheirownhouseholds.52The“ruleofthefather”overthehouseholdwasmuchlessdeterminedbybiologythanbypropertyownership.53Inpractice,womenoftenruledovertheirhouseholds,dependingontheirstatusaspropertyowner,andthenoftenaswidow.54
BecausealltheCappadocians’historiesarefraughtwithinconclusivenessandreneweddebatesabouttheprecisedatingoftheirlifeevents,acarefulreviewoftheactualstoriesoftheCappadocians’familiesisextremelyimportant,thoughitmayseemtedioustosome.Yetitisalsovitaltomakeperfectlyclearthatmypurposeisnottosetouttheirdefinitivebiographies.55Rather,mypurposeistopresenttheirlivesinthecontextoftheirfamilyhistoriesinordertoconveyasconciselyaspossibletheircloseinterdependencyandtheirstrongfamilyallegiances.NoticingtheirparticularsensitivitiesandspottingtheirsilencesandabsencesatcrucialmomentsintheirlivesisanexercisefordiscoveringtherudimentsoftheCappadocians’ideasaboutkinship.TheirfamilialrelationshipsandinteractionsprovideaninsightnotonlyintotheirownintimatecirclesbutalsointothescenariosrevealinghowhighlytheCappadocianshonoredkinshipofallsorts.“Bynotingthestrategiesandfunctionsofsuchoccasional“profamilialtendencies,”wecanbegintodiscernhowChristianfamiliesweremoldedtofitnewChristianidentitiesinthefluctuatingperiod;andhowthefamilyitselfexertedameasureofinfluenceonthosenewlyfashionedidentities.”56ThroughthebondsofkinshiptheCappadociansknewexactlywhatobligationstheyowedtoeachother,aswellaswhatextraordinary(p.111) privilegessuchkinshipprovided.Thus,theCappadocians’claimofcertainmartyrsastheirkintakesonamuchmoremomentousmeaning,extendingtheirancestrybackinhistorytothemartyrsandtheirindividualfamilymembersforwardintoeternityassaints.
Macrina’s,Basil’s,andGregoryofNyssa’sFamily
Nyssen’sLifeofSaintMacrinaandNazianzen’sPanegyriconSt.Basil,supplementedwithbitsofbiographicalinformationscatteredthroughoutletters,giveagoodsketchofMacrina’s,Basil’s,andGregoryofNyssa’sfamily.BothsetsoftheirgrandparentswereChristian(seetable3.1).Theirpaternalgrandparents,ElderBasilandElderMacrina,werefromPontus.WhenthelastpersecutionbrokeoutunderMaximinDaia,around305–306,thecouplespentsevenyearshidinginthePontianmountains.Afteritended,theyapparentlywereabletoretrievealmostalloftheirconsiderableproperty.Theyprobablyhad(p.112) otherchildreninadditiontotheirsonBasil,sincetherearereferencestopaternalrelativesinNeocaesareawhowouldplayapartintheirnephews’andnieces’liveslateron.57TheirsonBasilwouldbecomethefatherofMacrina,Basil,Naucratius,GregoryofNyssa,Peter,andfourotherdaughters.
Table3.1GenealogiesoftheTwoFamilies
Page 11
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 11 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
Page 12
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 12 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
TheirmaternalgrandparentswerefromCaesarea.Theyhadatleasttwochildren,Emmelia(laterthemotherofMacrina,Basil,Gregory,andtheirsiblings)andherbrotherGregory,namedinlettersas“UncleGregory,”whobecameabishopinCaesarea.58Thesegrandparents,too,werewealthylandholderswithconsiderablestatus,buttheylefteverythingwhentheyfledforsafetyduringthepersecution.Thegrandmotherdiedofnaturalcausesduringtheordeal,andthegrandfatherdiedamartyr.
WhenBasil,afamousadvocateandteacherinPontus,andEmmeliamarried,probablyinthemid-320s,theybroughttogetheragooddealofmoneyandproperty.Theyunitedtwoprestigiousfamiliesandsecuredafutureofprivilege,wealth,power,andstatusfortheirprogeny.Macrinawastheiroldestofninechildren,followedbyBasil,thetwoprobablybornbetween327and331,respectively.Theywerejoinedbyanotherbrother,Naucratius,andthenbyGregoryandfourothersisters,althoughnooneisquitecertainoftheirbirthorder.59WhatiscertainisthatPeterwasbornlast,around343.OneortwoofthesisterscouldhavebeenbornbetweenMacrinaandBasil,sinceBasilwrotehistractToYoungAdolescentsforhisnephews,thechildrenofatleastoneofhissisters.Thesenephewswouldhavebeenoldenoughtocorrespondwiththeiruncleinthe360sonlyiftheirmother,orrespectivemothers,hadbeenbornintheearly330s.60
OnedaughterwasmostlikelynamedTheosebeia,thoughthisisbynomeansagreedupon.SomescholarsthinkshebecameanunwithhersisterMacrina.Basedonthefollowingevidence,Ithinkthatthisdaughter,Theosebeia,wasmarriedtoapriestnamedGregory.61GregoryofNazianzuswrote(p.113) Letter197toconsoleGregoryofNyssaonthedeathofhis“holyandblessedsister,”Theosebeia,“theconsortofapriest”(syzygos).Nazianzen’spraiseofheriseffulgentandproper.Hewrotetheletterlateinhislife,inthe380sor390s.InEpigrams161and164,healsopraisesdeceasedEmmeliaandherchild(daughter),Theosebeia,respectively:
Emmeliaisdead.Whatcanbesaid?Havinggiventolifethelightofsomanychildren,bothsonsanddaughtersmarriedandunmarried?Thisonealoneofmortalshadwonderfulchildrenandmanychildren;Threeofthemwerefamouspriestsandonewasthespouseofapriest,andtheothersiblingslikeanarmyofthebrightones.62
Andyou,Theosebia,childoffamousEmmelia,trulyspouseofgreatGregory,hereyoulieundertheholyground,supportofpiouswomen,youdepartedliferipeinyearsinfullness.63
FromallthreetextsweknowthatTheosebeiawasthechildofEmmelia,makingherthesisterofGregoryofNyssa,Basil,andMacrina.Wealsoknowthatshewasthesyzygos,commonlyknownasthewifeorconsort,ofapriestnamedGregory.InnoneofthesewritingsdoesNazianzensayunequivocallythatTheosebeiaisthewifeofGregoryofNyssa,butonlythatshewasmarriedtoapriestnamedGregory.Moreover,thename“Gregory”wasverycommon,anditseemsmostlikelythatthissisterwasmarriedtoapriestofthatname.
Asthefatherofsuchaprominentfamily,BasilmadesurethathiseldestdaughterMacrinawasbetrothedtoayoungmanfromanequallydistinguishedfamily.Andasadutifuldaughter,shewouldhavemarriedattheappropriateagehadtheyoungmannotdied.Intheinterestofhisdaughter’sfuture,herfatherwantedtofindheranotherfiancé,butMacrina
Page 13
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 13 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
outmaneuveredhisautocraticinterventionbyappealingtotheeternalworld.Shestatedthathertrueandonlyhusbandwasaliveinheaven,andshevowedthatshewouldsomedayafterherdeathjoinherbetrothed,butinthislifeshewouldremainasshewas.Suchreasoningconvincedherfather,andheallowedMacrinatodedicateherlifetovirginity.
WhenhediedshortlyaftertheirsonPeter’sbirth,approximately343,BasillefthiswifeEmmeliaawidow.Macrina,nowfatherless,wasthenaroundsixteenyearsoldandhadalreadybegunassumingalltheresponsibilitiesofPeter’scare,ataskthatrelievedhermotherconsiderably.ShockedbyBasil’s(p.114) death,bothMacrinaandEmmeliahadtoreorienttheirlives.Inthenextfewyears,Emmeliaexecutedtheresponsibilitiesofsole“rulerofthehousehold”quiteadmirably,managinghervastestatesandarrangingthemarriagesofherfourotherdaughters.Foreachofherfoursonsshesecuredafineeducationandconsolidatedaninheritance.64By345,Emmeliacompletedthephysicaltransitiontoanewlife.Emmeliahadmovedallthechildrenremainingathome(Macrina,Gregory,Naucratius,andPeter),togetherwiththeentirehouseholdofservantsandslaves,fromNeocaesareatotheirhugePontianestateinAnnesiontheIrisRiver.Duringthoseyearstheoldestson,Basil,wasanadolescentattendingschoolinCaesarea,wherehemethislifelongfriend,GregoryofNazianzus.
Inthenextdozenyears,Macrina’sstronginclinationstowardtheasceticlifeeffectedaspiritualtransitioninthehousehold,turningitintotwoasceticcommunities,onefemaleandonemale.65Itmustberememberedhere,however,that“inthefourthcentury,tothedegreethatsomemonasterieswereabletodistinguishthemselvesasauniquehouseholdform,thedistinctionwasaccomplishedbymeansofculturaltools,notlegaldistinctions.”66Naucratius,too,wasdrawntoasceticism,forgoingtheworldlyrewardsofhisinnategiftsofphysicalbeauty,athleticism,andsharpintelligenceforthespirituallifeofpoverty,simplicity,andprayer.Around352,heandhisslaveChrysaphiusleftthemainhouseandlivedintheforest,wheretheironlysustenancecamefromwhattheycouldhuntorgather.Naucratiusmadeithismissiontosharehisprovisionswithneedyoldpeopleinthearea.Inthemeantime,BasilhadgonetostudyinConstantinopleandthenAthens.GregoryandPeterremainedunderMacrina’stutelageuntilGregorywasoldenoughtogotoschoolinCaesarea,around348.
WhenBasilreturnedtoPontusin356–357,hefoundhismotherandsisterperforminghouseholdchoreslikewasherwomenandscullerymaids,rightalongwiththoseherememberedastheservantsandslaves.Healsofoundthateveryoneinthehouseholdnowworked,prayed,andatetogether.Therewasnolongeranydistinctionindress,rank,ordutiesinthehousehold,sinceMacrinahadconvincedhermotherthatthebetterlifewasoneofrenunciation,work,andprayer.Basilhadbeenbackashorttime,perhapsonlyayear,whenNaucratiusandtheslaveChrysaphiusdiedinatragicfishingaccident.67EmmeliawassoinconsolablethatMacrinaemergedastheonlystabilizinginfluenceinthefamily.Basileventuallyhonoredhisbrother’smemorybycontinuinghiswayof(p.115) lifeandsettingupanasceticabodenotfarfromhisfamily.ThereseemsnodoubtthatNaucratius’lifeanddeathhadinfluencedthatdecision.68
Asthefirststep,Basilwasbaptizedaroundthistime,atagetwenty-seven.Hewassuccessfulinurginghisbestfriend,GregoryofNazianzus,tojoinhiminhisretreatonthefamily
Page 14
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 14 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
propertyatAnnesi.Theyspentroughlytwoyearsthere,writingandcompilingthePhilokalia,theclassiccollectionofsayingsofOrigenandotherFathersforthoseinterestedinpursuingthespirituallife.By360,theclergyofCaesareaenlistedBasiltohelpthemintheAriandisputes,drawinghimoutofretreatintothepublicworldofecclesiasticalpolitics.In364,hewasordainedapriestbyEusebiusofCaesarea,butleftsoonafterbecauseofafightwiththebishop.69In370,hewaselectedbishopofCaesarea,theyearbeforeEmmelia’sdeath.Basilhimselfwouldliveonlyninemoreyears,buttheywerepackedfullofeventsthatheinstigated,accomplishmentsthathefoughtfor,andbrillianttheologicaltreatisesthathecreated.Basil’seffortsduringhisepiscopacychangedthecourseoftheChurchintheology,monasticism,institutionalphilanthropy,canonlaw,andrelationswiththeimperialcourt.
Basilhadanequallysignificantimpactonhisimmediatekin.ThoughMacrinahadtaughtbothherbrothersGregoryofNyssaandPeterintheiryoungeryears,GregorylaterwouldspeakofbothBasilandMacrinaashisgreatestteachersineverything.70WhenNyssenwasatschoolinCaesareainhislateteensorearlytwenties,hetraveledbackandforthfromAnnesi.ItwasononeofhistripshomethathismotherprevaileduponhimtoattendthepanegyrisfortheFortyMartyrsattheshrineshehadjustbuiltatIbora,around355.Gregoryagreedtoattend,veryreluctantly.Tohisgreatsurpriseandterror,hewasscoldedseverelybytheFortyMartyrsinadream,sincehehadslippedawayfromtheliturgyandfellasleepinthegarden.71TheincidentwiththeFortyMartyrshadaprofoundeffectonhim,influencingtherestofhislife.Andalthoughhedoesnotdirectlysaytheincidentwasthecause,withinapproximatelytwoyearshewasbaptized.
AfterGregoryfinishedhisschoolinginCaesarea,hepursuedacareerasarhetorician,fromapproximately358to365,andwasalsoordainedareader.HisfriendNazianzenupbraidedhimforchoosingrhetoricoveralifeintheChurch.Nyssenobviouslyhadsomeambivalenceaboutsuchadecisionpreviously,(p.116) sinceBasilmentionsthathewantedhisbrothertojoinhiminthemonastery.72Infact,NyssennevermentionshisinvolvementattheretreatinPontusinanyofhiswritings.73WhatiscertainisthatMacrinafinallyconvincedhimtoabandonhissecularcareerandretiretoBasil’smonastery,around365,rightaroundthetimeBasilwenttoCaesareapermanently.Uptothispoint,theadultGregoryhadbeentheleastinvolvedinhisfamily’sexperimentsinmonasticliving.74Butonemustrememberthathehadbeentherefromthebeginning,andthroughouthisboyhoodhewitnessedtheentireevolutionofthesetwofamilymonasteries.
AlongtraditionclaimsthatGregorywasmarriedduringhiscareerasarhetorician,buttheevidenceisinconclusive.75Thestrongestadvocatesforthispositioneventhinkthathiswife’snamewas“Theosebeia,”positingthatitisNyssen’swifewhoisthesubjectofNazianzen’sLetter197.Buttheletterdoesnotsaythis.AsweexaminedbeforeinthecontextoftheidentityofTheosebeiaasasisterofthesiblings,intheletterNazianzencallsherNyssen’ssisterandthewife,orconsort,ofapriest.Whatismore,Epigram164praisesTheosebeia,wifeofapriestnamedGregory,asthechildofEmmelia,notherdaughter-in-law.AndthisTheosebeiadieswhenNyssenisold.IfthisTheosebeiawasnot(p.117) Nyssen’ssisterbuthiswife,NazianzenwouldhavetakeneveryopportunitytoidentifyGregoryofNyssaasthatverypriestandhusbandofTheosebeia.AndatthetimeNazianzenwrotetheletterandthetwoepigrams,Nyssenwasnotapriest;hewasalreadyordainedthebishopofNyssa.YetifNyssenhadhadawife,sheprobablystillwouldhavebeenalivein365,whenheleftthe
Page 15
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 15 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
careerinrhetoric;andthusitisoddthatthereisnomentionofher.Noristhereanymentionofher,herearlydeath,oranyarrangementstobemadeforherwhenhelefthiscareerandenteredthemonasticlife.IfGregoryofNyssawasmarried,andIdonotknowthathewas,wesimplydonotknowthenameofhiswife.
GregoryofNyssawatchedhisbrother’smeteoricriseintheChurchtobecomethebishopofCaesarea.ButNyssenalsounwittinglybecameapawninBasil’sstrategiesagainsttheAriansandtheimperialcourtwhenBasilforcedhisyoungerbrothertobecomebishopoftheobscurevillageofNyssain372.Duringthefirstfiveyearsofhisepiscopalcareer,Nyssenunfortunatelyfellvictimtothepro-ArianpoliciesofEmperorValens.Twicehewasbroughtuponfraudulentcharges;andin374,hewasdeposedandbanishedtoSeleucia.Itwasduringthethreeyearsoftheseclusionofhisexile(374–377)thathewashismostproductive,writingsomeofhismostimportanttheologicaltracts.76
GregoryreturnedtohisseeafterValens’deathin378.ButhewouldspendlittletimeinNyssa,sincehewouldsoonbecomeaneffectiverepresentativeoftheOrthodoxpositionatmanydifferentcouncilsandchurchesduringthenextfewyears.Gregory’srecognitionasanOrthodoxstatesmaninbothimperialandecclesiasticalcirclesspreadfarbeyondAsiaMinor.ThisismostevidentinthedynamicleadershiproleheplayedintheproceedingsattheCouncilofConstantinoplein381.
Duringthisperiod,bothBasilandMacrinadiedinclosesuccession—379and380,respectively.TheirdeathsaffectedGregorydeeply,andhewrotememorialsforeachofhissiblings.TheLifeofSaintMacrinaisamasterpiece,fornotonlydoeshehonorMacrinaintheworkbuthealsopreservespreciousdetailsoftheentirefamily’sstory.Gregory’saccomplishmentsinthenextfifteenyearsofhislifedemonstratehowsuccessfullyhetookontheroleofresponsibleleaderafterhissiblings’deaths.Hediedin395.
(p.118) TheevidenceforNyssen’sinteractionsandinfluenceovertheyoungestsibling,Peter,issparseandcomeslateinbothoftheirlives.PeterstayedwithinthefamilyuntilBasilandMacrinadied.Hewouldhavebeenonlytwoyearsold(atthemost)whenhisfamilymovedtothecountryestate,soheliterallygrewupinthemonasticenvironmentofAnnesi.WhileunderthecarefulwatchofMacrina,Petermodeledhimselfafterhisbrothers,NaucratiusandBasil,andeventuallyenteredthemonasticlifeatthecompound.HeneverleftPontus.AfterBasilwenttoCaesarea,Peterbecamethesuperiorofhisbrother’smonasticcompound;andapparentlyevenwhileNyssenwasthere.PeterwasordainedapriestbyBasilin370,andheremainedinAnnesi.
Duringthefamineof368–369,Peterandhiscommunityorganizedasystemoffooddistribution.Peter’sconsiderableinheritancefromhisfamilymusthaveallowedthisaidtoreachasmanypeopleaspossible.SoonafterMacrina’sdeathin381,hisbrotherGregoryofNyssasawtheopportunitytomakePeterabishop.GregorywascalledtoSebasteiatosettleanecclesiasticaldisputeovertheselectionofthenextbishop.WithGregory’sconsiderableinfluencePeterwaselectedbishopofSebasteia.PeterdiedafewyearsbeforeGregory,sometimein392–393.
ImportantDynamicsinTheirFamily
Fromthewrittenevidenceofthesiblings’relationships,BasilandGregorywereclose,and
Page 16
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 16 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
MacrinaandGregorywereevencloser.ButnoletterordocumentindicatescommunicationbetweenMacrinaandBasilafterheleftforCaesarea.Basil’ssilenceonhisextraordinaryoldersisterMacrinaisasshockingasitisnoisy,leavingmuchroomforspeculationabouttheirpossibleestrangement.GregoryclaimsthatitwasMacrinawhostraightenedoutthearrogant,youngBasilwhenhereturnedfromAthens.Infact,thisistheonlyreferencetoanyinteractionbetweenthem.MaybeinBasil’sviewshewasthebossy,omniscient,oldersister.AndyetGregoryunequivocallypurportsthatMacrinaguidedBasiltobecomeanascetic.77Suchinfluenceisbynomeanscertain,ofcourse,sincehecouldaseasilyhavemodeledhimselfontwootherasceticswhowereinfluentialinhislife:EustathiusofSebasteia,amentorofBasil’sandapioneerinasceticism;andhisownbrother,Naucratius.Whateverthecase,whenNyssenmakessuchaclaimaboutMacrina’sinfluenceonBasil,hebothhonoredhisrecentlydeceasedsiblingsandbroughtthetwotogether.Gregory’sclaimhadanadditionaladvantageofprotectingBasil’smemoryandespeciallyofexcisingEustathiusofSebasteia’sinfluenceonaspectsofBasil’stheology(p.119) andasceticism.Basil’sfriendshipwithEustathiushadendedbitterlyin373,afterEustathiusrepeatedlyaccusedBasilofSabellianism.78
WhileitremainsanunsettlingfactthatBasilnevermentionshisoldersisterinanyletterorextanttract,Gregory’srelationshipwiththeirsisterissharplydifferent.MacrinawasabufferforGregory,evenarefugeforhiminthefaceofhisgreat“masterandteacher,”brotherBasil.Inherlifelongroleasteacherandspiritualcenterofthefamily,MacrinaservedasasoundingboardforGregory.Heextolsherwisdom,care,andpatienceinboththeLifeofSaintMacrinaandOntheSoulandResurrection.HisrelianceonMacrina’spowerfulsteadinessanddevotionisclearinLetter19:“Mysisterwasmyteacheroflife,mymotheraftermymother,sincesuchboldnessofspeechdidshehavetowardsGodthatshewasatowerofstrengthandashieldofcontentment,justastheScripturessay.”79
TheintensityofNyssen’srelationshipwithhisimpressiveolderbrotherbynomeansprecludedhisrespectforBasil.Throughtheircorrespondenceandinthecourseoftheirinteractions,thetwoseemgenuinelyfondofeachother,althoughtheywereforeverunequal.EventhoughhemadeGregorybishopofNyssain371,Basil’scorrespondenceexposesthefactthathehadlittleconfidenceinGregory’sadministrativeacumen.Basilwasheavy-handedinhisorderstohisyoungerbrotherandinhischastisementsofthewayheconductedbusiness.Forhispart,GregoryseemstohavebeenconstantlyoverwhelmedbyBasil.HealternatedbetweenaweandresentmentofBasil,bridlingunderhisauthoritarianism,havingnorecoursebutMacrina’spatientear.
ThefollowingepisodesillustratethenearlylimitlessextenttowhichBasilandGregorycouldstretchtheirbondsofkinship.In371,BasilwasbroughtbacktohisownfamilyowingtothegriefhefeltatEmmelia’sdeathandthemisunderstandinghehadwithhismother’sbrother,UncleGregory,abishopinCaesarea.80BasilhadopenlycampaignedtobeconsecratedasbishopofCaesareatheyearbefore.Manylocalbishopshadopposedhisconsecration,andUncleGregorywasoneofthem.Untilthen,UncleGregoryhadbeenquitegracioustohistalentednephew,helpinghimsincehisarrivalinCaesareaasapriest.
Inanattempttohealthefamilydissension,GregoryofNyssaforgedthreelettersofreconciliationtoBasilinthenameofUncleGregory.Theirolduncle(p.120) foundoutabout
Page 17
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 17 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
thefirstletterandrepudiatedit,embarrassingBasilsomuchthathewishedfortheearthtoswallowhimup.WhenBasilfoundoutthattheothertwowereforgeriesaswell,hewasjustifiablyoutraged.HescoldshisbrotherGregoryinLetter58bysaying,“HowstupiddoyouthinkIamthatIwouldfallforthesamerusethreetimes?Iwriteattackingyoursimplicity,whichIseeplainlytobeneitherwhatgenerallybecomesaChristianmannorisappropriatetothepresentemergency.”81Succinctlyhetellshisbrother,“Mindyourownbusiness,sinceyouareanunworthyministerofthingssogreat.”82
WhatismostinterestingisthatBasiljustifiesupbraidingGregoryongroundsoftheirbeingrelated.Hetakesthebondsofkinshipveryseriously.“Yououghttohavekeptinmindthatyouaremybrother,andhavenotyetforgottenthetiesofnature,anddonotregardmeinthelightofanenemy,forIhaveenteredonalifewhichiswearingoutmystrength.”83HeblamesGregoryforwarringwithhim,insteadofcomingtohisaidandsharinginhistroubles.Evenagoodfriendwouldhavedoneasmuch.ButfromBasil’spointofviewGregory’sactionswereevenworse,sincetheyshowednofamilyloyaltyorsolidarity.HeimpugnsGregorymosteffectivelywithaquotefromEcclesiasticus:“Kindredandhelpersareagainsttimesoftrouble.”84
BasilbaseshisstrongestargumentsaboutkinshipinLetter59,whichhewritestohisunclebegginghimnottocuthimoff.Basil’sardorexposeshowmuchheprizedhisuncle’saffections,asheremindshimthathehad“alwaysbeenasafathertohim.”OneisleftwiththeimpressionthatUncleGregoryhaddemonstratedmorecareforhimallhislife,likefathertoson,thantheirkinship,uncletonephew,wouldhavedemanded.85
TheentireepisodeapparentlycametoanendwithLetter60tohisuncle.Theletterhasatoneofoverallreliefthatrelationsbothwithhisuncleandhisbrotherweremended.HereportshowhappyhewastoreceivehisbrotherwhobroughtanotherletterfromUncleGregory—thisonelegitimate—inajovial,rough-and-tumbleway:“Whynot,sinceheismybrotherandsuchabrother?”86NorhadBasillostanyaffectionforyoungerGregory:“GodforbidthatIshouldeversofeelastoforgetthetiesofnatureandbeatwarwiththosewhoarenearanddeartome….Ineednotaddtomylifeanydolefulepisodeofquarrel(p.121)betweenkithandkin.”87BasilsealsthelightheartedintroductionbyrequestingUncleGregory’scontinuedsolicitations;alongwithhisprayers,heasksfor“careformeinallthings,asyourownrelative.”88Basilalsohopesforaconversationwithhisuncle,buthewouldneedaletterconfirmingit,sincehecannotdependonhisbrotherasamessenger,sinceGregoryhadfabricatedsomuchbefore!89
Notalloftheinteractionsbetweenthebrotherswerenegative,nordotheyallreflectBasil’spressuringofGregory.Sometimeinthelate360s,whenGregorywasstilllivinginthefamilymonasticestatesinPontus,BasilaskedhimtowriteOnVirginity.90Thistreatisewasthefruitoflivelytheologicalexchangesbetweenthetwobrothers.Letter38ofBasiltoGregoryisaremarkabletestimonytothisexchange.Itrehearsesveryclearlythedifferencebetweenhypostasisandousia,“lestyoufallintosimilarerror.”91ThatBasilcontinuedtorelyunwaveringlyonGregory’stheologicalperspicacitywhileseekingtostrengthenhisbrother’sweakpoliticalskillsinordertoadvancetheOrthodoxcauseisabundantlyclearinhiscorrespondence.92TheperilsofsuchasituationarealltooobviousinLetter100,writtenin372,inwhichhebemoansthefactthatGregoryinallhis“simplicity”summonedasynodin
Page 18
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 18 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
Ancyra,unknowinglythwartingallBasil’sefforts.93
Basil’slettersshowmuchlessannoyancetowardhisbrotherafterGregoryisexiledbytheAriansin374.Manyofthoseletters,infact,revealabrotherlyprotectivenesstowardGregory.AcaseinpointisLetter225,which,amongmanyotherthings,explainsthereasonsthatGregory’strialwasdelayed,apparentlybecauseof“irregularities”inGregory’sconsecrationandhisallegedembezzlementofchurchfunds.Basildefendshisbrotherstaunchly,explainingthatheissufferinggreatlyfromaterriblefluandfromkidneydisease,chronicfromyouth,aboutwhichonlyabrotherwouldknow.94Letter215explainswhyhisGod-belovedbrotherGregorycouldnotpossiblygotoRomeinthewinter.Notonlyishean“unsuitableenvoytoDamascus”(acloserdestinationthanRome),heis“tooinexperiencedinecclesiasticalaffairs”tohandlethemachinationsofthosewhoarewily,ingenuous,andarrogant.95Letters231,237,and(p.122) 239allshowhowtirelesslyBasilworkedonGregory’sbehalfwhenhewasexiled.Throughoutthemall,Basilrevealsoutrageattheinjusticeofthecharges,respectforhisbrother’smaturecourage,andprotectivecareforGregory’swell-being.96
Basil’sideasabouttheboundariesofkinshipareperhapsbestexpressedinhisletterabouthissyntrophos,translatedclumsilyas“foster-brother.”97Basilwrotethislettersometimeinthelate360stoanunnamedofficialonbehalfofhisfosterbrother,whowasthesonofhisnurseandwithwhomhegrewup.SomemisunderstandingwithBasil’snatalhouseinPontusoccasionedtheletter,sinceBasilisquiteconcernedthathisfosterbrotherstillbeabletoeitherliveinitorreceivebenefitfromit,probablyfromrentmoney.Basilwantstomakesurethattheofficial“sparethehouse”forbothhisfosterbrotherandhimself,sincetheybothstillgettheirsupportfromthenatalhouse.Inaddition,Basilstipulatesthattheslaves,whichhadbeenbequeathedtothefosterbrotherbyhisparentsforhisuseandbenefit,shouldreverttoBasilafterthefosterbrothershoulddie.Basil’sletterrevealsauniquesituationaboutsomeonewhowaspartofthehousehold,andbyextension,partofthefamily.
FamilyofGregoryofNazianzus
ThepaternalgrandparentsofGregoryofNazianzuswerenotChristiansbutHypsistarians.(seetable3.1)ThesectworshippedtheGod“thehighest,”or“hypsistos,”andwasrathercommonthroughoutthenortherncoastalregionsoftheBlackSeaandtheBosphorus.TheirideasaboutGodderivedfromasyncretizedmonotheism,combiningelementsoftheCappadociancultofZeusSabazioswiththeJewishGodYahwehSabaoth.HypsistariansaccordinglyamalgamatedreligiouspracticesfrompaganismandJudaism.Whiletheyrejectedidolsandpagansacrifices,theyworshippedfireandlightandrefusedthetitle“Father”forGod.TheyobservedsomeJewishlaws,includingthoseregardingtheSabbathandcertainfoodlaws,yettheyrejectedcircumcision.98GregoryofNazianzusdoesnotmentionhisgrandparents’nameswhenhedescribesthefamilyhistoryofhisbelovedfather,ElderGregory.Thisisperhapsnotsurprising,sinceElderGregorygrewupaHypsistarian.
GregoryofNazianzus’maternalgrandparentswerePhiltatusandGorgonia.99Theyhadthreechildren—Amphilochius,Gregory,andNonna—thelatterof(p.123) whomwouldbecomeGregory’smother.100AthoughGregorymakesrathervaguereferencestotheChristianancestryofhismotherNonna,hedoesnotpursuetheissue.101WhenElderGregorymarriedNonna,shewasChristianandhewasaHypsistarian.Itisdifficulttoimagine
Page 19
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 19 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
thecircumstancesunderwhichaChristianfatherwouldhavearrangedamarriageforhisdaughterwithaHypsistarian.Itis,therefore,likelythatonlyoneofherparentswasChristian.102Itisequallypossiblethatthepersecutionhadsomethingtodowithhermarriagetoanon-Christian,orthatthemarriagealliancesobenefitedPhiltatusfinanciallythatNonnawasinstructedtocompletelyoverlookherfuturehusband’sreligion.
Inanycase,themarriageofGregoryandNonnatookplaceinthemid-tolate-320s,andtheylivedthereafterinthesmalltownofNazianzus,Cappadocia.103NonnaandElderGregoryhadthreechildren—Gorgonia,Gregory,andCaesarius—borninthatorder,withGregory’sbirthdatesometimebetween328and331.Duringtheearlyyearsofhermarriage,Nonnaworkedatherhusband’sconversiontoChristianityslowlyandsteadily,“likewaterconstantlystrikingarock.”104Herhusbandwasbaptizedatagefifty,whentheirsonGregorywasaboutfiveyearsold.ElderGregory’smother,Gorgonia,disinheritedhersonforawhilebecausehehadconverted.105RightafterBishopLeontiusofCaesareabaptizedElderGregory,heconsecratedhimbishopofNazianzus.ElderGregorylefthispostasatownadministratorandtookuphisnewpositionwithexemplarypatienceandenduringdevotiontotheChristiancommunity.IntheannalsoftheChurch,Nonnawouldendupbeingoneofthelast“episcopalwives.”106
GregoryofNazianzus’parentsrealizedthattheirsonwasexceptionallybrightwhenhewascompletingthefirstlevelofhisstudiesinCaesarea,wherehefirstmetBasil.TheysentGregoryofftoAthensforfurtherschoolingaround347,andthenontoCaesareainPalestineandAlexandria.GregorythrivedintheintellectualenvironmentatAthens,defendinghisfriendBasil,sparringwithhisclassmateJulian(thefutureemperor),anddevelopinghislifelongpassionforthesecluded,scholarlylife.GregorystayedinAthensforroughlytenyears.AtBasil’sinsistence,GregoryreturnedtoCappadociatojoinhimatthe(p.124)retreatinPontus.HestayedwithBasilforthreeyearsonly,sinceElderGregory’spoorhealthrequiredthathissonreturnin360toNazianzustohelphim.
GregoryofNazianzusmusthavebeenbaptizedduringthisperiodbecausehisfatherordainedhimapriestonChristmasdayin361,notlongafterhereturnedfromAthens.ElderGregoryseemedtohaveconsideredhisownvocationafamilybusinessandthushopedhissonwouldsucceedhimfirstaspriestandthenasbishop,inakindofChristianversionofRomancurialresponsibilities.Horrified,GregoryfledtoPontusuntilEaster.Whenhereturned,hedeliveredanapologeticsermononEasterdaytohisfather’scongregation,explaininghisflightinbiblicalterms,exposinghisownfeelingsofunworthinesstobeapriest.107
SuchpatternswouldcharacterizeGregory’sbehaviortherestofhislife.SeveralmoretimesGregoryfelthimselfburdenedwithresponsibilitieshedidnotwanttoshoulderandthatwerefoistedonhimbyothers—eitherfairlyorunfairly—whobelievedhehadleadershipqualities.Whetherintruthhehadthesequalities,hecertainlystroveconsistentlythroughouthislifetoproveotherwise.UnlikehisfriendBasil,Gregorythrivedinsolitude;hewantedonlytostudy,write,andpray.AsGregoryputit,“Mygreatestbusinessalwaysistokeepfreefrombusiness.”108BasilneverreallyunderstoodGregory’ssensitiveproclivities.Toservehisownpoliticalpurposes,in370BasilforciblyconsecratedGregoryasbishopofSasima,amiserablevillage.Gregorywasagainastoundedanddismayed,feelingutterlybetrayedby
Page 20
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 20 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
hisfriend.Althoughhedidnotphysicallyrunawaythistime,andhewasbarredfromtakingpossessionofhisseebythereigningArianbishopAnthimos,Gregoryalwaysdidhisbesttostayoutoftheadministrativelimelight.Eventhoughhewasabishop,hespentthenextfouryearshelpinghisailingfatherwiththehomeparishinNazianzus,acceptinghispriestlyresponsibilitiesintermsofthefamilybusiness:“Forsweetitistoinheritafather’stoils,andthisflockismorefamiliarthanastrangeandforeignone.”109
Afterbothhisfatherandmotherdiedin374,Gregorywasfreeofparentalobligations,andherelishedhislifeofseclusionattheshrineofSt.TheclainSeleucia.However,hisscholarlypursuitstherewereeventuallyinterruptedin379.TheOrthodoxclergyofConstantinople,backedbyEmperorTheodosiusI,prevailedonhimtocometoConstantinopleastheirbishopanderadicatetheArianismthere.Gregorybenttotheirpressure,buthisstayasbishopwas(p.125) neithersuccessfulinriddingthecityofAriansnorinquellingthesharpfactionalismattheCouncilofConstantinoplein381.HewillinglyresignedhispostthatsameyearandretiredtothepeaceandquietofNazianzus,closetotheshrineofthemartyrs.There,hespenttheyearsuntilhisdeath,in394,writingmanyletters,poems,andepigrams.
Gregory’soldersister,Gorgonia,wasmarriedtoamannamedAlypiusprobablyearlyinthe340s,whenGregorywasatschoolinCaesarea.ItseemsGregorydidnotknowhimverywell,whichisrathersurprising.110EventhoughGorgoniawouldhaveleftherownfamilyforherhusband’shouse,sheandAlypiuscouldnothavelivedtoofarfromNazianzus,sinceherparentswereabletobeatherhousewhenshedied.GorgoniawasraisedaChristian,butshewasnotbaptizeduntilimmediatelybeforeherdeathin369.WhetherAlypiuscamefromasimilarreligiousbackgroundisunknown,butGregorywritesthatasshelayonherdeathbed,Gorgoniaconvincedherhusbandtobebaptized.
Alypiuswasarichlandowner,andGorgoniahadalargehouseholdtomanage.SheandAlypiushadthreedaughters—Alypiana,Eugenia,andNonna.AlypianamarriedNicobulusaround365,soGorgonialivedlongenoughprobablytohaveseenatleastonegrandchild.Nonna’sgrandchildrenandgreat-grandchildrenweremorethanlikelyfrequentguestsattheirgrandparents’houseinNazianzus.Astheymatured,Gregorytookonapaternalroleforhisniecesandtheirchildren.111
Gorgonia’slifestyleandaccomplishmentsbearthedistinctmarkofNonna’sinfluence.HerdaughterwaseducatedinScriptureandthefaith.ShemadesureherownchildrenandhusbandpracticedChristianpiety.Gorgoniacultivatedmodestyandsimplicity,qualitiesthatcouldnothavecomeeasilygivenherclass,wealth,andstatusasanoblematron.112Shewasgenerouswithtimeandmoney,evenofferingherhouseasaccommodationtomany.Gorgoniabalancedherobligationsofwife,mother,andmanagerwithherdisciplinedlifeofChristianpiety,allwithinthecontextofagrandestate.
CaesariuswastheyoungestofGorgonia’sandGregory’ssiblingsandwasprobablybornsometimebetween332and335.AfterhefinishedhisschoolinginCaesarea,hisparentssenthimtoAlexandria,sincehewantedtobecomeadoctorandthatcityhadthebestsciencefaculty.CaesariusreturnedtoConstantinoplein357,enticedbyasparklingcareerinthenewcapital.Fromallevidence,emperorConstantiuswaswillingtodojustaboutanythingtokeephimthere.Buthisolderbrother’swheedlingcausedCaesariustochangehismind(p.126)andtoreturntoNazianzus.Gregorylatergloated,quitegratifiedthathisbrother
Page 21
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 21 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
“preferredhimtotheEmperor.”113
Caesarius’stayinNazianzusdidnotlastlong.Gregorycouldnotconvincehimthathewaspursuingvainambitionsandglory,andCaesariusleftshortlyforastellarpositioninthecapital.WhenJulianbecameemperor,GregoryworriedevenmoreaboutCaesarius’chosencareerandthenegativeinfluencesofcourtlife.ThecombinedpressuresofJulian’santi-ChristianpoliciesandGregory’spowersofpersuasionforcedCaesariustoreconsider.
FortunatelyforCaesarius,Juliandiedsoonafterthis,andCaesariuswasabletotakeupEmperorValens’offertobecomequaestorinBithynia.Caesariuswasacultivatedmaninthehighestcircleofthecourt,andinashorttimehebecamequiterich.Heprobablywouldeventuallyhavemarriedhadhenotdiedsuddenlyofanillnessin369.HehadbeenbaptizedatEasterofthatyear.ElderGregoryandNonnamadeallthearrangementstoburytheirson,andstoicallyNonnaforcedherselftoshownogrief,evenwearingherbrightestclothesfortheoccasion.114Addingtothissadness,sheandElderGregorywouldattendtheirdaughterGorgonia’sfunerallaterthatyear.
ImportantDynamicsinNazianzen’sFamily
GregoryofNazianzus’relationshiptohisparentsandsiblingsisdifficulttoteaseoutofhiswritings,sincehewroteverylittletooraboutthemwhentheywerealive.Theintriguingevidence,nevertheless,allowsusthefollowingobservations.Hewasutterlydevotedtohisparentsandmadespecialaccommodationsatleastthreetimesinhislifeeithertoworkwiththemortotakecareofthem.WhenBasilkeptremindinghimthathehadpromisedtostayyear-roundinAnnesiatthemonasticretreat,Nazianzenrepliedthathemustspendhalftheyearwithhisparents.SuchadutywasadivinecommandmentandallowedhimtobreakhispromisetoBasil.“Onelawprevailedagainstanother;Imeanthelawwhichbidsushonourourparentsoverpoweredthelawoffriendshipandintercourse….Ishallbewithyouhalfthetimeandhalfofityouwillbewithme,thatwemayhavethewholeincommon…andsoitwillbearrangedinsuchawaythatmyparentswillnotbegrieved,andyetIshallgainyou.”115NazianzentooktheMosaicinjunctiontohonorone’sparentsquiteseriouslyanduseditasthebasisforallhisinteractionswithhisrelatives.(p.127) Theinjunctiontotendone’sparentsorspouseinoldagewas“writteninthebookofChrist.”116
Nazianzenspentagreatdealofhisadultlifewithhisfather,andhisgenuineaffectionforhimisobvious.ElderGregorywas,ofcourse,setapartfromhissonthroughvenerableage,hisauthorityashisfather,andhisauthorityasabishop.Yetasason,Nazianzendidnotenvyhisfatheranddidnotcompetewithhim.Hisfather’spractical,hands-onqualityofministeringtohisparishwouldeludeGregoryallofhislife,althoughhebenefitedfromhisfather’sconstantdevotiontohisflockinNazianzus.ElderGregoryseemstohavebeenaustere,simple,andoccasionally“unsympathetic,evenbrutal.”117Hissonwasmuchmoreintrospective,sensitive,studious,andattimestooworriedexcessivelyaboutothers’opinionsofhimself.YetNazianzen’sevidentanddeep-seatedloveforhisfathermakestheirdifferenceslesssignificant.NazianzenfledtoPontusforfourmonthsafterhisfatherordainedhim,butthatescapehadmuchmoretodowithhisqualmsaboutbecomingapriestthanapermanentriftwithhisfather.Inshort,hegotoverhisfrustrationswithhisfather.Allhiswritingsbetraythatfact.“Ihavebeenoverpoweredbytheoldageofmyfather,andtousemoderateterms,thekindlinessofmyfriend….ThereforeInowconsenttoshareinthecaresofmyexcellent
Page 22
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 22 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
father,likeaneaglet,notquitevainlyflyingclosetoamightyandsoaringeagle.”118
Letter7,writtentohisbrotherCaesariusin362,givesarare,wonderfulglimpseatthefamily’sdynamicsduringacrisis.There,GregoryofNazianzuschastiseshisbrotherforbeingemployedbytheapostateEmperorJulianatthecourtinConstantinople.Gregoryisquiteexplicitthatitishewhohastodealwiththeirfather’sintensedistressthatCaesariusisservingEmperorJulian,theenemyoftheChurch.Whatishetodowiththeirfatherwhoissoupsetthatheiseven“disgustedwithlifeitself?”119
Byvirtueoftheirfather’sepiscopaloffice,Caesarius’jobcouldnotbeconcealedasaprivatefamilymatter.Infact,thewholecommunitywasbandyingaboutrumorsandblandishments.Asabishop,ElderGregoryhadaverypublicroleintheircommunity.ThefactthatCaesarius,sonofthebishop,wasservingthegodlessEmperorhadbecomeapublicmatterinNazianzus.ItisnowonderthatElderGregorywasupsetandhumiliated.ElderGregorymusthavereliedheavilyonNazianzen’semotionalsupportatthattime,sincethelatterexplains(p.128) thathe“consolesandcomfortshimasbestIcan.”120GregoryrepeatedlystresseshowheassuredhisfatherthatCaesariuswouldreturntohissensesandresignsuchadishonorableposition.
TheaffairofCaesarius’employmentatJulian’scourtshowswhatthefamilydefinedasacceptableinrelationships,whatwasdemandedbykinship,andwhatwasprohibited.AfterdetailingalltheharmCaesariuswascausingtheirfather,Gregorysavesthebestforlast—Nonna’slikelyreaction.Gregorywasutterlydevotedtohismother,statingquiteassuredlyinseveralplacesthathewasherfavoritechild.121ButGregorywroteverylittleaboutNonnaoutsidethecontextoffuneralrhetoric,andhispurposethereistodetailherextravagantpietyandgenerosity.Nonnadominatedhermarriageandconductedthehouseholdwithsuchparticulardiscretionthatheractivitieswereundetectabletotheoutsideworld.ItisclearthatNonna’sidealssetthestandardforGregory’sownbehavior,andhedidhisutmosttoliveuptoherexpectationsthroughouthislife.GregorytookcareofNonnaduringherillnessbeforeshediedin374.Onthatoccasion,heexplainedtoBasilwhyhecouldnotvisithim,“ForIamsittingatthesideofmydearlady,mymotherwhohasalreadybeensufferingforalongtimefromsickness.IfIwouldnotleaveherinanuncertainstate,pleaseknowIwouldnotdeprivemyselfofyourcompany.”122
Thus,agreatdealwasatstakeasCaesariusjeopardizedtheentirefamily’sreputationandriskedalienatingtheirmother,Nonna.GregoryshowsthatheproceededwithcautionashenearlythreatensCaesarius.Gregoryconfessesthattheywerehidingtruthfromtheirmother:“untilnowwehavekeptthesecretthroughmanyinventivediversions,”implyingthattheirstrategiesofdeceptioncouldnotgoonindefinitely.123HedeclaresthatwereNonnatoknowthetruthaboutCaesarius,shewouldbeutterlyinconsolable,“sinceasawomansheissmallmindedandthroughhergreatpietyisotherwiseunabletobalancesuchmattersandfeelings!”124
Suchclaimsabouthismotherarestartlingbecausetheyarecompletelyoutofcharacter.ToattributetoNonnaa“smallmind”owingtohergenderisarhetoricaltropeintendedtomakeCaesariuscapitulatetoGregory’swishes.SuchaclaimcontradictsallthatGregoryeverwroteaboutNonna.Hequicklyregroups,however,andthreatensamorefrighteningand
Page 23
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 23 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
truthfulscenario.(p.129) EssentiallyhesaysthatthereisnopredictingwhatNonnamightdo,basedonhergreatpiety.ThisisamuchmorepowerfulimpetusthatCaesariuswouldcertainlyrecognizeinkeepingwithhismother’scharacterthantheoffhandedcliché,“smallmindofawoman.”
Whatismore,bothhersonswouldhaveknownimmediatelythattheirmotherwouldfinditimpossibletobearthepublichumiliationcausedbyCaesarius’positionatcourt.Discretioninpublic,basedonhergreatpiety,wasavirtuemostrareandhard-won.ItwasoneNonnahadcultivatedsteadilyallherlife.BothhersonsknewthatCaesarius’careerwasjeopardizingtheirmother’sreputationandthehonorofthefamily.
Finally,theletteralsoexposesGregory’srelationshiptohisyounger,moreurbanebrother.ThereisnodoubtthatGregorywasveryproudofCaesarius’accomplishments;butinacceptingapositionwithJulian,Caesarius’ambitionhadputhiminaperiloussituation.GregorypointsouttoCaesariusthathehadlostallsightoftheconsequencesofhisactions,throughhisowngreedydesireformoneyandposition.Notonlywasheharminghisfamily,hewasalsolosinghimself.Caesariuswassoblindedbygreedthathewasinaprecariousdilemma,andbothoutcomeswerebleak.Inbothcases,JulianwouldpressurehimwithsuchintensitythathewouldeitherbedemotedtoaninferiorpositionorabandonChristianitytoadvancehisowncareer.Whateverhappened,Caesariuswouldlose,andinthelattercasehewouldlosehissoulforeternity,“hav[ing]ashareinthesmoke,ifnotthefire.”125Gregoryspeaksfranklyfromthebeginningoftheletter,wastingnotimeonpolitediscourse.Attheendoftheletter,Gregoryrealizesthatwhathehaswrittenmayangerhisbrother,buthecertainlyisconfidentthattheirownfraternalbonddependsonhiscandor.
Gregory’sonlyotherlettertohisbrotheris,inretrospect,alostopportunitytoshowerhimwithgenuinebrotherlyaffection.In368,CaesariushadmiraculouslyescapedfromanearthquakethatdestroyedhisentirehouseholdinNicaea.Gregory’sletterisashort,boringsermonpreachingthathisbrothershouldlookupontheearthquakeasalearningexperience,anaturalafflictionthatshouldbringhimclosertoGod.ItshouldserveasanoccasionforhisthankfulnesstoGodnotonlyforpreservinghimbutalsoforteachinghimthatallthethingsonearthpassaway.This,ofcourse,maybetrue,butinthiscontextitobscuresanywarmemotion,spontaneousrelief,orgenuinethankfulnessGregorymayhavefeltthatCaesariuswasalive!Heevenadmitsthisattheend,writing,“PerhapsIseemtoyousomewhatofabore,bywritingtoyousooftenonthesamesubject,andyouwillthinkmyletterapiecenotof(p.130) exhortationbutofostentation,soenoughofthis.”126Boringexhortationandostentationitcertainlyis.Hehintsthathehaswrittenseveraltimestohisbrother,butperhapsCaesariuswastoobusyrecoveringfromtheearthquaketorespond.AndGregoryalsomayhavefeltguiltythathecouldnotleavehisparentsinordertogohelpCaesarius.OnlyinthelasttwosentencesdoesGregorypermithimselftheslightestemotion,“IwishespeciallythatImightbewithyouandshareyourjoyatyourpreservation,andtotalkoverthesematterslateron.”
Hemustsoonhaveregrettedhisreserveandpreachiness,foronlyafewmonthslaterCaesariuswoulddiequiteyoung.Then,Gregorycaptureshissadnessandunabashedloveinwords:“YouescapedtheroaringmenaceofthecruelearthquakewhenNicaeawasleveledwiththeground,anddidperishbypainfuldisease.Oforyourchasteyouth,andyour
Page 24
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 24 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
wisdom,beautifulCeasarius.”127AndtohisoldschoolchumPhilagriusheexpressedhisdeepestgrief:“IdonothaveCaesariusanymore.Ishallsaysomething,eveniftheemotionisnotconsonantwiththephilosophiclife.IdeeplyloveCaesarius,andeverythingIseeremindsmeofhim,Iembracehimandgreethimwithakiss,andIthinkIseehim,gooutwithhim,andtalkwithhim.”128Gregory’ssixteenemotionalepigramstoCaesariusrevealprofoundloveforhisbrother.129
ItisnoexaggerationtosaythatconventionalbiologicalkinshipandallitimplieswasanextremelypowerfulforceinGregoryofNazianzus’life.Henotonlywrotefuneralpanegyricstohissister,brother,andfather,healsowrotethirty-fiveletterstooronbehalfoffamilymembers.Hewrote106epigramsforhisfamily,81ofwhichwereforhisimmediatefamily.130OfthemanyfamilialsituationsGregorymentionsthroughouthislife,twoepisodesstandoutasparticularexamplesofhowstronglyhefeltthetiesofkinshipandthekindsofbehaviortheynecessitated.Intheearly370s,hisowncousin,youngAmphilochius,foundhimselfinmuchthesamesituationasGregory:ascaretakerforhiselderly,sickfather.Gregory’sfatherdiedin374,andnotlongafterwardhegotwordthathisUncleAmphilochiuswasangryathim,blamingGregoryforsuggestingthathissonAmphilochiusbecomebishopofIconium.OldUncleAmphilochiusfeltthathehadbeenrobbedofhissonandcaretaker.Infact,ithadbeenBasilofCaesareaorchestratingyoungAmphilochius’consecrationthathadrecentlytakenplace.Gregory,stillinmourningforhisownfather,becamedistraughtovertheentiresituation.HewroteLetter63toassuage(p.131) UncleAmphilochius,whileatthesametimetryingtoexoneratehimself.Gregoryexplainsthathisowngriefpreventedhimfromcomingtovisithisuncle,andheinvokestheintimatebondsofkinshiptomakethecasethatheandhisuncleareinthesamesituation.Heclaimsthattheyhavebothbeen“tyrannized”bytheircommonfriend,Basil.131Theybothhavesufferedloss,hewrites,buthisownisworsesincehisunclewillseehissonagain.Gregorycallshiscousinhis“brother”andexpresseshisfearandsorrowthathenowhasbecomeabishop,anawesomeresponsibilitythathe,too,bears.Incloser,morefamiliarlanguageheendstheletter,nearlyorderingUncleAmphilochiustoputasidehisgriefandblame,andtorememberthatheformerlyhadregardedGregoryashisonlybenefactor.
ThatGregorytooksuchakeeninterestinthefamilyofhisnieceAlypianaalsoconfirmshowseriouslyGregorytooktheobligationsofkinship.Alypiana,thedaughterofGregory’ssisterGorgoniaandherhusbandAlypius,marriedNicobulus,amanofhighrankbutwho,overtheyears,wasnotabletoadequatelyprovideforhisfamily.Gregory’scorrespondencerevealsaninterestinthefamilysustainedfrom365onward.
NicobulusandAlypianamusthavebeennewlywedswhenNazianzenfirstwrotetotheyoungman.Nicobulusapparentlyhadcommentedonthecontrastinsizebetweenhisdiminutivewifeandhimself.GregoryatfirstgetsintothespiritofNicobulus’jokingabouthis“monstroussize,”thencounselshimtolookbeyondhersmallnesstoherformidablevirtuesasadevoutChristianandindustriouswife.“Thenyouwillcongratulateyourselfonyourmarriage.”132Theletteralmostmakesoneblush,sinceitbetraysGregory’sclumsinessatcommentingonthetransitionofthenewlywedstothenuptialstate,fullofthejoysofyouthfulintimacy.ButGregory’slackofexperienceasahusbanddidnotpreventhimfromactingasaresponsiblegreatuncle,orevenasagreat-grandfather,presidingoverthecaresofhisextendedfamilynomatterwhatthesituation.
Page 25
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 25 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
YetNicobuluswasdestinedneitherforsuccessnoralonglife.GregorywroteLetters13,21,and146–148tohelpextricateNicobulusfromhisterriblelegalandfinancialstraits.Letter13tohiscousinAmphilochiusofIconiumandLetter21totheprefectSophroniusshowthatNicobulushadgotteninto“unexpectedtroubles”earlyinhismarriage.133Letter147isparticularlypoignant.GregoryasksthegovernortohelpNicobulus,justifyingthisparticularlyonthe(p.132) dutiesofkinship.Inhisview,NicobulusisworthyoffavorssincehecaresforGregoryinhisoldageandsickness.134
Thingsneverreallyimproved,andby385,whenNicobulusdied,hehadlefthisaffairsindisarrayforAlypianaandthechildren.GregorywroteLetter195tothegovernortohelpouthiswidowednieceandherchildren,especiallyhisgrandnephew,hisdear,illustriousNicobulus.135GregoryobviouslyhadasoftspotinhisheartforyounggrandnephewNicobulus.Hisfifteenletterstoorforthisyoungmansetouttoteachhimtheartoflaconicletterwriting,tointroducehimtomenofinfluence,andtosecuretutorsforhim.136Perhapsevenmoreimportant,Gregorylovedhimgreatly,anditisclearthathetookgreatdelightinhisstimulatingcompany,wheneverNicobuluscouldsqueezeinashortvisittohisgreat-uncle.137
ItisalmostredundanttoconcludethatfamilytiesloomedlargefortheCappadocianFathers.Quitetheoppositeofrenouncingallfamilyties,theyspentagooddealoftheirlivesreinforcingthemineverywayaffordedthembytheirstatus,wealth,andprivilege.Theirlivesspeaktotheoverridingcaretheyhadforpreservingtheintegrityoftheirfamilies’reputations,aswellastheprimaryplacefamilyconcernsconsistentlytookforthem,nomatterwhatthesituation.Andwecannothelpbutnoticethegenuine,deepemotionsthatopenlysuffusetheirfamilyinteractions.Clearly,theCappadocianspracticedtheasceticlifewhilecontinuingtosustainthefamilialobligationsandbenefitsoftheirnatalhouseholds.Theymusthavebeenkeenlyaware,however,thattheirchoicetoliveincelibacydidhavesignificantrepercussionsforthefutureoftheirfamilies.Butnowweshallseehowtheychosetosolvethatproblem.
MartyrsasTheirAncestorsOftheirmyriadaccomplishments,nothingrevealsmoreexplicitlyhowhighlyBasilandNyssenvaluedconsanguineouskinshipthantheirappropriationof(p.133) threefamoussaintsastheirownrelatives.Ratherthanminimizetheimportanceofbloodrelationshipsinfavorofspiritualkinshipwiththemartyrs,astheypreachedintheirascetictreatisesandpanegyricsalike,theyinsteadengagedinaquasi-mergerofthetwoforthebenefitoftheirownfamily.Inaratherparadoxical,untidyfashiontheyconstructakindofphysicalyetspiritualkinshipwiththesemartyrs.Throughtheprocessofclaimingthesefamousmartyrsastheirexclusiveforebears,theynotonlywidenedthedefinitionofkinshipfortheirownfamilybuttheyalsoenhanceditsprestigeandhelpedsecureitsfuture.
GregoryThaumaturgus
WhenBasilandhissiblingsweregrowingup,ElderMacrinakepttheordealofthepersecutionaliveforhergrandchildrenthroughrousingstoriesofheroismofthemartyrs.Theserivetingaccountsreinforcedbyherindomitablepresencehadalastingeffectonhergrandchildren.ThepersecutionbecamethedefiningeventforthewayBasil’sfamilyunderstooditsroleinsocietyandhoweachmemberrelatedtoeachother.Thetimeofthe
Page 26
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 26 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
martyrsassumedmythicproportionsforBasil,evenwhenhewasfullygrown;anditdirectlyinfluencedhowhewouldrepresenthisfamily.138
WhentheclergyofNeocaesareaaccusedBasilofArianism,hisdefensewentrightbacktohisgrandmotherMacrinaandherpersonalconnectiontotheirmostfamous,heroicsaint,GregoryThaumaturgus.139“Whatclearerevidencecantherebeofmyfaith,thanIwasbroughtupbymygrandmother,blessedwoman,whocamefromyou?ImeanthecelebratedMacrinawhotaughtmethewordsoftheblessedGregory;whichasfarasmemoryhadpreserveddowntoherday,shecherishedherself.”140HealsoinsistedthatthespecialqualityofPontuswhereGregoryThaumaturgusperformedallhismiracleswasanintegralpartofhim.NotonlydidElderMacrinaraisehiminPontus,hekeptreturningtherequiteoftentothemonasticretreat,“becausemybrothersarenowlivinghere.”141
ForBasiltorefertohisgrandmother,tothelandofPontusashishomeland—his“patrida”—andtoGregoryThaumaturgusashis“spiritualfather”(p.134) wasadeftrhetoricalcombinationsinceallthreearelinkedbytheintimatelanguageoffamily.HewritestotheNeocaesareans(Pontus)inhisowndefense:
Ifittendmuchtowardsintimacytohavethesameteachers,therearetoyouandtomethesameteachersofGod’smysteries,andspiritualFathers,whofromthebeginningwerethefoundersofyourChurch.ImeantheGreatGregory,andallwhosucceededinordertothethroneofyourepiscopate….Andtruly,ifbloodrelationshipsarenottobecastaside,butevencontributegreatlytoanunbrokenunionandfellowshipoflife,thesebirthrightsalsoexistbetweenyouandus.142
Throughjuxtaposingthegrandeuroftheeraofthemartyrswithhisverypersonal,childhoodmemoriesofElderMacrina,heintentionallyelevatedthestatusofhisfamilyevenfurther.Butbyplacingthetwosidebyside,heincorporatedGregoryThaumaturgusintothefamily.HisdefenseagainsttheiraccusationsofArianismwasembeddedinthePontians’owntradition,anditwasabrilliantstrategy.
Likehisbrother,GregoryofNyssawasdeeplydevotedtoGregoryThaumaturgus.In380,hedeliveredapanegyricforthesaintatthegatheringofbishopsassembledforanelectoralsynod.AlthoughtheeventsNyssenrecountsthereinhavescarcelyanyresemblancetotheThaumaturgus’ownlife,Nyssen’sversionreconfirmshisfamily’spowerovertheChurchinPontus.143Whatismore,hissermonbringstolifethesaintwhomheclaimedwaspartoftheirfamily’shistory.Tohiswayofthinking,hewastheThaumaturgus’spiritualgreat-grandsonthroughhisgrandmother.144Throughouthislengthypanegyric,NyssennotonlyrevisedthetraditionsabouttheWonderworker,makinghimthepreeminentsaintofPontus,butalsopreservedthefamily’scontrolovertheThaumaturgus’imageastheirspiritualancestor.145
Nyssen’spanegyricreliesonwhatheheardabouttheThaumaturgusasachildcombinedwiththelocalloreabouthimgatheredfromvillagesalloverPontus.HeprobablydeliveredthepanegyricatthemainchurchinNeocaesarea,sincetherewasnoshrinefortheThaumaturgus.146Nyssendeliberatelystressesthisfactattheendofthepanegyric,claimingthattheThaumaturguspromotedthecultofthemartyrstoallhispeopleandthathepurposelyhadno(p.135) gravesothathewouldnotberankedwiththemartyrs.147Even
Page 27
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 27 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
thoughtheThaumaturgusdidnottechnicallydieamartyr,thefaithfulhonoredhimasaprotomartyrlikeTheclaandStephen,sincehewasthepreeminentsaintofPontus,founderofChristianityinPontus.148NyssenknewthatsuchanironicstatementwouldhavestunnedtheaudienceandonlyenhancedthegreatnessoftheThaumaturgus,sincetheymostcertainlydidcelebratehimasamartyr.149
Justlikehisbrother,NyssenevokestheThaumaturgusthroughpersonalmemoryhandeddownthroughthegenerations.BothbrothersclaimtheThaumaturgusastheirownkinintwowaysthatthelaitycouldnotimitate.First,ElderMacrina’slinktotheWonderworkerfixedtheirclaimtokinshipwithhimastheirspiritualancestor.Buttheirgrandmother’sconnectiontohimeasilyblurredthedistinctionbetweenspiritualandphysicalkinship.Second,linkingthemselvestothefirstbishopofPontusreinforcedtheirelevatedstatusandauthorityasbishopsandclerics,andgroundedtheirdoctrineinthetraditionofsanctityandorthodoxy.150Italsoextendedthegulfbetweenthemandthelaity,whocouldneverclaimsuchhereditarysanctitywithsuchanillustrioussaint.
Thecla
GregoryThaumaturguswasonlyoneofahandfulofexceedinglypopular,powerfulsaintsinAsiaMinor.TheclaofSeleucia,too,hadgreatauthority.151ExactlyliketheThaumaturgus,Theclaleftnobodyatherdeath,sincearockopenedupandengulfedher,savingherfromhostilecriminals.152AshrinetoSt.Theclasoonwaserectedaroundtherock,andpilgrimsvisitedyear-round.AndexactlyasinthecaseofGregoryThaumaturgus,thecultgrewuparoundaplacethatexplainstheveryabsenceofrelics.153BecauseTheclaperformedallsortsof(p.136) miracles,thelaitysoonmergedherstorywith“thecharismaticreputationofthemartyr.”154SowidespreadwashercultthatTheclawasacommonnameforwomeninthefourthcentury.155
GregoryofNyssarecordsthathissisterMacrinawassupposedtohavebeennamedThecla.Whileinlaborwithherfirstchild,EmmeliahadavisionofaheavenlyfigurewhorepeatedthreetimesthatherdaughtershouldbecalledThecla.Inthanksgivingfortheholyvisitation,Emmeliawantedtodoso.ButshecompliedwiththecustomofnamingtheeldestdaughterafterthepaternalgrandmotherandnamedthechildMacrina.YetthisdidnotpreventEmmeliafrombestowing“Thecla”onherdaughterashersecretname.Gregorysayssuccinctlythatthename“foretoldthelifeofthechild.”156
WecansafelyassumethatEmmeliawasdevotedtoTheclaandtaughtherchildrenaboutthemiraculouspowersofthesaint.IntheLife,GregoryimmortalizedMacrina’sconnectiontoTheclaandgroundedhissisterpersonallyintheearliestgenerationsofChristianwomenbyassociationwiththissaintwhohadaccompaniedPaul.157Yetintermsofkinship,Gregorydoesevenmore.Significantly,hewritesthatTheclaentersMacrina’sliferightatthetimeofherbirth,establishingherconnectionwiththechildinname,vocation,andakindofgodmotherhood.Inthisway,GregoryimpliesthatTheclaspirituallybirthedMacrinaandwatchedoverhissisterfromthatmomenton.Macrina’sdestinywassetbyThecla,“theprotomartyr,virginandmartyr,andthenewmartyrofasceticism.”158Macrina’skinshipwithTheclaasherspiritualdaughterwasevidentinherrejectionofmarriageandherdevotiontoasceticism.
Page 28
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 28 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
Macrina’skinshipwithTheclaasherveritableyetspiritualdaughterisalsoplayedoutresoundinglyinherrelationshiptohermotherEmmelia.GregorystatesclearlythatfromaveryearlyageMacrinabecameEmmelia’steacher,instructinghergraduallyintheasceticlife.159WhenbrotherNaucratiusdied,Macrinaassumedthefullreversalofroleswithhermother.MacrinaguidedEmmeliathroughmourningbymotheringhermother,andsheeventuallyconvincedEmmeliatolivethelifeofcompletepoverty.Macrinabecamethematernalauthorityoftheentirefamily.GregoryshapeshisaccountaroundthefactthatThecla’sinfluenceasMacrina’sspiritualmotherandguidingforceincreasedthroughoutherlife,whileEmmelia’swaned.
(p.137) OneofNyssen’smajorpurposesintheLifeofSaintMacrinaistoclaimkinshipwithSt.TheclanotonlyforMacrinabutalsoforhisfamily.ForbothBasilandGregory,“theparadoxesofsanctitywererootedinfamilialground.”160“Gregoryconflatesthefamilyinasinglegenea;allmemberssharethegloryofeach.”161Anoblefamilylineinthetraditionoffourth-centuryCappadociawasnolongerenoughforGregory,norwasitacceptableforhisfamilytobelumpedwiththelaitywhowereclaimingmartyrsasadoptedancestorsoftheirlocalcommunities.162Inaninnovativeredefinitionofblood,hisfamily’sconnectiontothemartyrsembodiedanancestryofsanctity,demonstrablydirectandintimate.
TheFortyMartyrsofSebasteia
Sometimebetween355and358,EmmeliadisplayedherardentdevotiontotheFortyMartyrsofSebasteiabybuildingashrineforthematIbora,onlyonemilefromthefamily’sestateinAnnesi.Itisnoaccidentthattheshrinewasdirectlyadjacenttoherfamily’scrypt,whereherhusbandBasilandhersonNaucratius(ca.+357)werealready(orwouldbe)buried.Toeventuallybeburiednearthemartyrswastheidealforeveryone.163Bluntlystated,Emmeliacouldaffordthistangiblelinkbetweentheseverypopularmartyrsandherfamily.164Thecrypt’sproximitytotheFortyMartyrsannouncedthesocialandeconomicprestigeofthefamily,aswellastheir“closeness”to,andthusevenproprietaryattitudetoward,themartyrs.Italsopublicizedtheirpietythroughlargessetothecommunity,sincetheyfacilitatedthecultthroughabeautifulshrinewherefestivals,petitions,andmiraclescouldtakeplaceforeveryone.Emmelia’ssponsorshipoftheshrineexplicitlyproclaimedherfamily’skinshipwiththeFortyMartyrsinamaterialway.
EmmeliaalsofosteredthespreadofthecultoftheFortyMartyrsthroughhersonsBasilandGregory.OnthedaywhentherelicswerebroughttothenewshrineatIbora,EmmeliainsistedthatGregoryaccompanyhertothepanegyris.(p.138) Twenty-fiveyearslater,inoneofhistwohomiliestotheFortyMartyrs,Gregoryrelateswhatapersonal,life-changingeventitwasforhim,sincetheFortyMartyrsintervenedinhislifethatday.Whenhefellasleepduringthefestivities,theycametohiminadream.SofrightenedwasGregorybytheirremonstrationsandthrashingwithsticksthathechangedhislife.Withinayearorsohewasbaptized.165
ItisunimaginablethatthiswasthefirsttimeGregoryrelatedthismomentousencounterwiththeFortyMartyrs.Theyactedintheroleofwhatlaterwouldbecalled“godparent.”Nolivingpersonhadhadsuchaneffectonhim,leadinghimtobaptism.TheFortyMartyrshadpersonallyintervenedashisspiritualmentors,andhewasindeedboundtothemasagodchildwouldbe.Hisrelationshipwiththemonlyreinforcedthekinshipbondsalready
Page 29
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 29 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
establishedbyhismother,whenshebuilttheshrinenexttotheircrypt.166
Althoughitisnotcertain,BasilprobablybuiltashrinetotheFortyMartyrsinCaesareawhenhebecamebishopthere.167HishomilyontheFortyMartyrsismuchlesspersonalthanthoseofhisbrother;rather,heseemstobeintroducingtheFortyMartyrs,soclosetohisfamily,tohisnewcongregation.Afterall,hewasobligedtolearnaboutthelocalmartyrsofCaesarea,Sts.Gordius,Mamas,andJulitta.Buthissinceredevotiontothemisevidentinhisemotionalspeech,whichwouldhaveinspiredhimtobuildsuchashrine.Followinghismother’sexample,hetookonthefamilyobligationtospreadtheculttohisnewcity,havingassumedhisownkinshipwiththemfromhisfamily.
Nevertheless,Basil’sandGregory’sfamilyclaimstospecificrelationshipsofkinshipwiththesemartyrsdidnotbydefinitioncompletelyexcludethelaityandotherclergy.Itdid,however,signifyahierarchyofaffiliationwiththemartyrs.ItmeantfirstthattheirownfamilyheldthehighestofChristianranks,transcribingthehumansocialorderontothespiritualonebymeansoftheirclosenesstoGregorytheWonderworker,Thecla,andtheFortyMartyrs—themostpopular,famoussaintsofAsiaMinor.Inaddition,theconnectionsthatexistedbetweentheirfamilyandthoseancestralmartyrsconferredthespecialprivileges,benefits,andexpectationsonthefamily.Thatthesaintsweremartyrsmadethatkinshipricherstill.Itimpliedthattheirfamilymembersparticipatedreciprocallyintheheavenlygraceandholypowerofthoseancestral(p.139) martyrsinthesamewayasadaughtermightgethergrandmother’sgreeneyesordistinctiveblackhair.Onceagainboundariesblur.Technicallyspeaking,kinshipwiththemartyrswasspiritualkinship.Butbecausetheseancestralmartyrshadsomephysicalproximityand/orphysicalcontactwiththeirfamilymembers—tutelagefromtheThaumaturgustoElderMacrina,abirthinginthecaseofTheclawithMacrina,andadisciplinaryactioninGregory’sthrashingbytheFortyMartyrs—theirkinshipwiththeseancestralmartyrstookontingesofconsanguineouskinship,intentionallyamalgamatingseeminglymutuallyexclusivekindsofkinship:biologicalandspiritual.
ForalltheotherChristians,monasticsandlaityincluded,theCappadocianspreachedthateveryonecouldhaveanadopted,spiritualkinshipwiththemartyrsbyhonoringthemartyrsatthepanegyreisandthroughimitationoftheirvirtues.Ratherthanthemoresociallyconfinedmodelofcivicpatronage,theCappadociansstressedthatallChristiansideallybelongedtothecommunitylikemembersofanadoptedfamilyinwhicheachmemberis“graftedon,”inthePaulinesense.Martyrsofeachtownorregionbecametheadoptedancestorsofallwhodweltthere.168And,indeed,alltheotherChristiansdevotedtothemartyrscouldexpecttheirintercession,protection,andevenmiracles.Theyrelatedtothemartyrshierarchically,aschildrenrelyontheirparents.Andbecauseoftheirkinshipwiththefaithful,themartyrsansweredthelaity’sprayersandprotectedthemfromharm.169ThoughtheCappadociansdonotexplicitlysayso,byimplicationeveryoneelse’skinshipwiththemartyrswasamuchlessexclusive,lesspersonalizedrelationshipthantheonestheywereclaimingfortheirfamily.
Monasticsandlaityalsohadakinshipwiththemartyrsbyactuallybecomingmartyrsthroughasceticdiscipline.Thiswasmostdifficultofallandrarelyoccurred.Nolongerwouldthepersonbeinaninterdependent,reciprocalrelationshipwithamartyr;heorshewouldbeamartyr.AsBasilwrotetootherbishopswhenheinvitedthemtoattendthepanegyreisofSts.
Page 30
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 30 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
EupsychiusandDamas,“Moreover,thereisakindofbloodrelationship(suggenes)betweentheonelivingameticulouslifeandthosewhoreachedperfectionthroughendurance.”170Attainmentofsuchafeatwasopentoall,sinceBasilalsochallengedhisflock:“Becomeamartyrbychoice,andendupbeingworthyofthesamerewardsastheirs,withoutpersecution,withoutfire,withoutblows.”171(p.140) Butattainmentofmartyrdomwasadifferentexistentialstateofrelationshipfrom“kinshipwiththemartyrs;”itwasoutsidetherealmoffamilyandwasthehighestofallChristiangoals.
TurningTheirFamiliesintoMartyrsGregoryofNazianzuswrotethefollowingtributetohisentirefamilywithaheavyheart.“FirstCaesariuswasthecommonsorrow,thenGorgonia,afterwardsbelovedfather,andthennotverylongafterwardsmother.”172TheCappadociansweresetapartfromothersnotonlybecauseoftheirnobility,wealth,andachievementsintheChurchbutalsobecauseoftheiradmirable,particularattentiontothebondsoffamilyrelationships.Theirattentivenessdidnotweakenasmembersoftheirfamiliesdied.Basilwrote,“NowformysinsIhavelostmymother,theonlycomfortIhadinmylife.”173Intheprocessofmemorializingtheirrelatives,theirfamilialdevotionincombinationwiththeirclaimstokinshipwiththemartyrstransformedtheirrelativesintomartyrs,crystallizingtheiridentitiesintheranksofthesaints—extraordinarilysoonafterdeathandthenforever.
Throughastoundingfuneralpanegyrics,theCappadocianssuccessfullyturnedtheirdeceasedrelativesintomartyrswhereintheyassimilatedtheeventsoftheirlivestothetrialsofthemartyrs.Combinedwithalloftheotherstrategiesthatassuredtheirownprestigeintermsofthemartyrcults,thepanegyricsfirstsecuredtheirrelativeseternallifewiththemartyrs.Andbestofall,sucheffortssecuredthefutureoftheirlineagebymakingtheirrelativesintosaintswithinafewyearsoftheirdeaths.Whatisquiteremarkable,formallyspeaking,isthatwearewitnessinganexceptionalconfluenceofrhetoricalgenresintheCappadocians’writingsfortheirrelativesandthemartyrs.Isitanaccident,then,thatideastraditionallyexpressedinseparategenresalsomergeandblur?
Bythetimetheyhadcompletedtheirsecondaryeducation,theCappadocianshadmasteredtherulesofrhetoricalcomposition,knowinghowandwhentowriteavarietyoforations,dependingontheoccasionandvenue.Theywereadeptatdeliveringpanegyricspraisingpeopleongreatoccasions,suchasbirthdays,churchfestivals,weddings,andfunerals.Allofthesepanegyricsfellunderthecategoryof“epideicticspeeches.”Afuneralencomium,theepitaphioslogos,likeanyotherpanegyric,wasconstructedaccordingtostrictrulesofrhetoricsetouthandbooks:aprologue,descriptionofcountry,thenobilityofthe(p.141)family,circumstancesofbirth,education,theextraordinarycharacteristicsoftheindividual,heroicdeeds,andcomparisonswithothergreatpeople,andfinallyanepilogue.174
Unlikefuneralencomia,generalpanegyricswerecomposedformanysortsoffestivecelebrationsandcouldberepeatedyearlyatthecommemoration.Aswehaveseen,theCappadociansharnessedtheubiquitousenthusiasmforthecultofthemartyrsbycomposingbeautifulpanegyricsforthemfortheyearlyfestivals.Theybasedthesepanegyricspreciselyontherulesofclassicalrhetoric.Alongwithencouragingtheburgeoninggrowthofdevotiontothemartyrs,theirpanegyricscontributedsubstantiallytoanewgenreofliterature—hagiobiography—blendingininfinitevarietiesaspectsoftraditionalbiography,funeral
Page 31
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 31 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
oration,andtheparticularChristiantoposoftheholyperson,thehagios.175ItisnosurprisethattheybringChristianvirtuesandtopoitotheforeintheirnewversionsoftheage-oldgenreoffuneralpanegyric.Infact,thoughtherewerehandbooksandrulesforfuneraloratorybasedonMenander,“breakingtherulesistherulethroughoutthetradition,anddoesnotstartwiththeChristianorators.”176
Whentheirownclosefriendsandrelativesdied,theCappadocianscommemoratedthemasremarkableChristiansinvariousepigrams,funeralorations,andhagiobiographies,“withthesamespiritofpraisetheyusedforthemartyrs.”177Itisquiteremarkablethat,thoughmosthagiobiographiesofchurchfathersastheywouldcomedowntouslater,“whetherintheformofavita,anenkomion,orafuneraloration,[were]rarelybasedonthehagiographer’spersonalexperienceorinvestigation,”thoseoftheCappadociansactuallywere.178While,ontheonehand,theydonotlackthehagiographical“ingredientsofattractivestory-telling,”sodefinitiveforthegenre,ontheotherhand,themostsensationalelementsofstory-telling,socommoninhagiographyandnovels,suchasappearancesofdemons,miraclesofallsorts,prophesies,anddivinecommunicationthroughdreams,areeithermitigatedorexcluded.179Mosttellingly,theliterarytropesofsexualallurement,sexualpursuit,sexualviolence,sexualrebuff,andhorrificviolenceofallsortswiththe(p.142) attendantvoyeurismaremissinginnearlyallhagiobiographiesofachurchfatherormother.Boththegenreandthecontentoftheorationsconveyedtheunambiguousmessagethatthesepiousfriendsandrelativeswerenotonlylikethemartyrs,theyalsoaccomplishedsimilarfeatsandshouldbereveredassuch.NorweretheCappadociansuniqueinthisrespect.“Itispossibletotalk,forthefourthcentury,ofasimilardrifttowardsa‘martyrization’ofthedeceased.”180
ItisworthnotingthatDelehaye,thegreatscholarandpioneerofhagiographicalstudies,equivocatedonthispoint,findingthesubjectuncomfortable.AfterassertingthattheCappadocianslaudedtheirrelativesinthe“samespirittheyusedforthemartyrs,”hethenqualifiesthestatement,“albeitatarankinferiortothemartyrs.”181Delehayeappearsclosertothetruthwhenhelatercommentsthatclosereadingsofthepanegyricsreveal“thenearlyindetectable[sic]enlargementintheevolutionofthecultofthesaints,whereoneseethehonors,atfirstreservedforthemartyrs,nowequallysharedwithbishops,ascetics,andvirgins,”whoalsohappenedtobetheirparents,brothers,sisters,andfriends.182
CaesariusEulogized
Nazianzen’syoungerbrotherCaesariusdiedin369,unfortunatelyyoungandbeforeanyoneelseinhisfamily.Caesariuswasunabashedlyacosmopolite,secular,andambitiousforacareerfirstinConstantinopleandtheninBithynia,sohislifedoesnotlookatfirstglanceasifitcouldconformtothemodelofthemartyrs.“Thoughhislifewasbynomeansscandalous,itcouldonlybesetupasanexamplewithdifficulty.”183YetGregorycleverlywovemartyrthemesintohiseulogyforhisbrotherattwocrucialpartsofthepanegyric.
Therulesofthegenremadethefirstinstanceeasy:Caesariuscamefromasaintlyfamily.Gregorysparednopraisefortheextraordinarypietyofhisfatherandmother.HisfavoritecomparisonfortheirfatherwastoAaronorMoses.HethenmovedtoNonna,whosepietywasparticularlyexemplary.Asacouple,GregoryandNonna“loveChristmorethantheydotheirchildren.”WhenthemourningperiodforCaesariusbegan,Nonnadecidedtowearbrightclothes(p.143) suitableforafestival,ratherthansomberrobesofsorrow.She
Page 32
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 32 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
“overcamehertearswithphilosophy.”Insteadofwailing,shesoftlysangpsalms.BothNonnaandElderGregoryprovidedasceticmodelsfortheirson’seulogy.
Inthesecondinstance,NazianzenusedthesectionoftheorationonheroicdeedstoequateCaesarius’virtueswiththoseofthemartyrs.WhenhefirstmovedtoConstantinople,Caesariuswasmuchsoughtafterinsocialcircles.Yethewasabletostaveoffallthepotentialvenuesthatcould“corrupthissoul…foramonghismanyclaimstohonor,hecaredmostforbeing,andbeingknown,tobeaChristian;andcomparedwiththis,allotherthingsweretohimbuttriflingtoys.”184Caesariusshowedsuperhumanstrengthinhisabilitytowithstandthetemptationsofthesumptuouslifeattheimperialcourt.Infact,self-controlpracticeddailyamidsuchalifewasmuchmoredifficultthanfleeingfromittoamonastery.
TherealtestcamewhenJulianbecameemperor.SinglingouttheChristiansatcourt,Julianbribedsome,othersheflattered,andthemostobstinatehethreatened.WhenhesethissightsonCaesarius,theyoungdoctorrosetoJulian’schallenge.GregoryscoffedatJulian’suselessattempttoswayhisbrother,“thesonofparentslikeours!”
Gregoryusedthefamiliarlanguageofthemartyr’sarenaquiteboldlytodescribeCaesarius’ordeal.Christpresidedasjudgeoverthecontest,armingCaesarius,“theathlete,”withhisownsufferings.185“Caesarius,having‘torntoshreds’theargumentsoftheopponent,inaloud,clearvoicedeclaredthathewasandremainedaChristian.”WilyJulianstillretainedhim,becauseheenjoyedCaesarius’companysomuch;andwhileshowingcourageandself-denialforhisChristianfaith,Caesariuslefthissplendidpositionatcourt.“SuchwasthegodlinessofCaesarius.”186
TheeulogywasperformedaspartoftheliturgicalactofCaesarius’funeral,anditexplicitlyreferstotheritualsofamartyr’spanegyris:procession,psalmsinging,andtheoration.GregoryoftenbreaksintoprayerstoGodtoacceptCaesarius’soulintoheaven,whilereferringtohisorationasan“offering.”Moreover,justasforamartyr’spanegyris,hestatesspecificallythathisbrother’smemorywillbecelebratedeachyear.“Partofourgiftisnowcomplete,theremainderwewillnowpaybyoffering(thoseofuswhostillsurvive)everyyearourhonorsandmemorials.”187Noticeablylacking,however,areanymiraclesperformedbyCaesarius,anypowersofintercessionhemighthave,oranymentionofhisburialclosetoothersaints.Thelastomissionisless(p.144) significant,sinceweknowfromotherevidencetheirfamilytombwasnexttosomemartyrs.188
GorgoniaMemorialized
BittercircumstancesforcedGregory’sparentstoburytwooftheirchildren.NotlongafterCaesarius’death,theoldestchildofthefamily,Gorgonia,died.AshehaddoneforCaesarius,Gregorydeliveredamovingfuneralpanegyric,anepitaphioslogosforhissister,notonly,ashesays,becauseshewashisrelationbutalsobecauseherlifewastrulyworthyofcommendation.189Again,Gregorywasconfrontedwitheulogizingaquotidian,secularlifethatonthesurfacewasthepolaroppositefromeithertheidealofthe“philosophiclife”ofasceticismorthestarkrealityofmartyrdom.Gorgoniawasarichmarriedwoman,motherofthreedaughters,matronoveralargehousehold,andsupervisorofmanyservantsandslaves.Yetdespiteherworldlystatus,Gregory’spanegyricissosuccessfulthateverylistenerwouldknowthatGorgoniahadallthevirtuesofamartyr:thebestChristianancestry,
Page 33
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 33 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
alifeofcharityandself-denialforChrist,andmostofall,performanceofamiracle.Infact,addingtothischallenge,Gregory’sfuneralpanegyricforhissisteristheearliesthagiographictextinpraiseofaChristianwoman.190
GregoryspendsashorttimelikeninghisparentstothegreatbiblicalancestorsAbrahamandSarah,bluntlyconcluding,“FromthemGorgoniaderivedbothherexistenceandherreputation.”191WhatwasexceptionalinGorgonia’slife,however,washowshemanagedtoconductit.Hermarriedlifewasmodeledonasceticpiety,thefirststepinthevoluntarylifeofthemartyrs.Gorgoniawasabletoachieveaharmoniousbalancebetweentheresponsibilitiesofmarriageandherpersonalgoalsofself-abnegation,fasting,dailyprayer,ultimatediscretion,andpersonalasceticrigor.Hewrote,“Shelivedanddiedamidthewordofpiety.”Gorgonia’smodesty,prudence,discretion,andpatiencedrewpeopletoher.Shewasknownforhergenerousofferingstochurches,poorneighbors,andneedyrelatives,makingherhabitsofliferoughlyparalleltothedailyroutineofamonastery.
GregorydeclaredthatGorgonia’struehomewasJerusalem,“combiningthebestofthemarriedandtheunmarriedstate.”192Significantly,shededicated(p.145) toGod“nothersinglesoul,butthewholehousehold,andmakingwedlockillustriousthroughherownacceptabilityinwedlock.”193Gorgoniakeptlongfasts,prayedintearfulvigils,chantedthepsalms,andwasabletoreceivepropheciesfromGod.Insum,sheperfectedalltherequirementsoftheasceticlifequitediscreetlywhilekeepingupwithalltheworkrequiredofawealthymatron.Gorgonia’srelentlessvigilancesanctifiedeverydaymarriedlife.194
Likeamartyr,Gorgoniaeffectedtwomiraculouscuresthroughherexemplaryfaith.195Thisalonewouldspreadherreputationasasaintamongthelaity.Whenshesufferedbrokenbonesandinternalbruisesafteracarriageaccident,sherefusedtoseeadoctor.Rather,asashocktotheoutsidecommunity,Gorgonia’sinjurieswerecompletelyhealedbyGodthroughhersteadfastprayersandresolutetrust.Anothertimeshecontractedahorriblediseasethatwastedawayherbodyinfever,comas,andparalysis.Physicianswereconsultedthistimeonthecase,andherparentsprayedandsupplicatedGod,yetthediseasepersisted.“Despairingofallotheraid,”Gorgoniamusteredenoughstrengthtogetherselftochurchonenightwithoutanyone’sknowing.Thereshespentanentirenightprostrateinprayer,resolvednottoleaveuntilshewascured.Gregorycalledit“anactofpiousandsplendideffrontery.”Sheleftthechurchhealed.
Gorgoniawasbaptizedlateinlife,beforeherfinalillness.Whileallherfamily,includingheragedparents,gatheredroundheratherdeathbed,Gorgoniaspokeaboutthethingsofheaven,andthedayofherdeathproceededlikea“solemnfestival,”likeamartyrpanegyris.Asshelaydying,shewhisperedPsalm4.Nonnaattendedheratherdeathbed,“withanguishandaffection.”Thelocalbishopwasalsothere.Yettherewasnokeeninginlamentation;rather,therewas“solemnsilence,asifherdeathhadbeenareligiousceremony.”GregoryhintsthatGorgoniamayrespondtofuturepetitions,adding:“Andifyoutakeanyaccountofouraffairs,andholysoulsreceivefromGodthisprivilege,acceptthesewordsofmine,inplaceof,andinpreferencetomanypanegyrics.”196Headdsalmostironicallythathewaslefttogivethefuneralorationsforbothhissiblings,“Ifanyonewill,afteryou,paymethelikehonor,Icannotsay.”197Whateverhisoriginalintent,thestatementlinkshimselfwithhismartyrsiblings.
Page 34
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 34 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
GorgoniawasburiedinLyconiawithherhusband’sfamily.Whetherthecryptwasclosetomartyrrelicsisuncertain,butinthisepigramforhissister(p.146) Gregoryassuresussheiswiththemartyrs:“ThereisnothingofGorgoniaremainingontheearth,onlybones.Everythingwasplacedabove,OyouMartyrsvictorious.”198
NonnaandElderGregory,Memorialized
Nazianzen’smovingeulogytohisfather,whodiedatacenturyinage,praisesbothofhisparents.199Accordingtotheirson,NonnaandGregoryconsciouslystyledtheirlivesinimitationofthepiousobedienceofthebiblicalsaints,especiallyAbrahamandSarah.Incomparisonwiththepanegyricstohissiblings,thefuneralencomiumforhisfathercontainsmuchmorebiographicalinformationandhasmuchlessincommonwiththeformofamartyrpanegyric.Eventhoughhisparents’ascetichabitswouldqualifythemas“aspiringmartyrs,”verylittleinthepanegyricinvitesthehearerstoviewhisparentsasmartyrs.200Therearenopetitionstohisdeceasedfathertograntsomethingtotheliving.Evendetailsofthefuneralaremissing,soitisnotcomparabletoamartyrpanegyris.Indeed,ifGregoryhadwrittenonlythisfuneraloration,wewouldconcludethathehadnodesiretomemorializehisparents’transformationintomartyrs.Butthisisnotthecase.
Gregorysavedthelinkagetothemartyrsfortheepigrams.Gregorycomposedoverfiftyepigramstohismother(althoughhewrotenofuneralpanegyricforher)andoveradozentohisfather.Insomeway,hisepigramswerethespeedywaytoensurethatChristiannobilitywouldmakeitsmarkvisiblyandpermanentlyinsociety.201Variousepigramsconveyweariness,sorrow,bitterness,orlonging;butallofthemconveydeepest,sincerestlove.Short,crisp,andimmediate,theepigramsclearlylikenhisparentstothemartyrs,especiallysincetheydrawspecialattentiontothefactthatthefamilycryptwasfortunatelysituatedrightnexttothelocalmartyrshrine.202CaesariusandNonnawereburiedinonegrave,andthetwopriests,ElderGregory,andeventuallyhissonGregory,inanother.203
Incountlessvariationsofthesametheme,GregorysavorsthemomentofNonna’sdeath.Sheprayedceaselesslyatthealtar,neverleavingthechurchuntilshediedthere.Nonna’sunwaveringfaithhadgivenherpowertodefeat(p.147) thedevil,shehadperformedmiracles,nowindeathsheintercedesforothers.204“Nonna’swingedsoulleftfortheheavens,wesetherbodyoutsidetheshrinetothemartyrs.Mayyoumartyrsacceptthegreatsacrifice,theonewhoisfollowingyourveryownbloodwiththemuchlaboringflesh,shesilencedthegreatpowerofthedestroyerofsoulsthroughlong-livedlabors.”205Shelookslikeadivinepersonaswell,θεοείδης.206Inanotherepigram,Gregorypetitionsthemartyrsonbehalfofhismother,whonowisoneofthem,“Martyrs,begracious,indistressesbelovedNonnaisnotinferiortoyou,bythehiddenandyetpublicwar.”207Althoughitissuccinct,thisepigramshowsundoubtedlythathealsoconsideredhisfatheramartyr:“Savemenowfather,bythyprayersofmight,andyoumother,whodiedpraying.”208
BasilMemorialized
GregoryofNazianzus’PanegyriconSt.Basilisastunningtributetohisgreatfriend’slife,includinghisaccomplishmentsinasceticvirtueandhisillustriousepiscopalcareer.Indescribingthenobilityofhislineage,NazianzenimmediatelyplacesBasilinthecontextofthemartyrs.DescribingtheferocityofthepersecutionunderMaxminus,hedescribesBasil’s
Page 35
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 35 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
grandparents:“SopreparedanddeterminedweretheytobearreadilyallthosethingsonaccountofwhichChristcrownsthosewhohaveimitatedHisstruggleonourbehalf.”209BecausehisenduranceduringtrialsrivaledtheMaccabees,“hewontheirglory.”210“ByrankingBasilwiththegreatpatriarchsofScripture,hedoesnothesitatetoconferonhisherothetitleofsaint.”211
NazianzendeliveredthisfuneralpanegyricasamemorialtwoyearsafterBasil’sdeathin381.Yet,astheclimaxoftheoration,hepurposelyre-createdthelastmomentsofhisfriend’sdeathandthefuneral,andhedoessotospectaculareffect.Bydramatizingtheritualsofthefuneraltwoyearspast,hemadetheoccasionevenmorelikeamartyr’spanegyris,sinceeveryonepresentwouldhavebeenquitefamiliarwiththeritualsperformedyearlyatmanyamartyr’sshrine.“ThiseloquentcompositionofhagiographyisoneofGregory’smostpoeticworks.”212OfBasil’sdeathhewrites,“Thetimeforhiscrownwas(p.148) approaching.”Therewasacrushofpeoplewhenthefuneralprocessionbegan.Everyoneclamoredtotouchthebier,tobeinitsholyshadow,ortotouchhisholyremains,“forwhatcouldbemoreholyorpurethanthatbody?”213Psalmssungintheprocessiongavewaytounrulylamentationsandoutburstsofemotion.Evenworse,violenceerupted,andpeoplewerekilled,endingupas“funeralvictims!”Basil’sbodywasthenplacedinanepiscopaltombinCaesarea,“themartyrtothemartyrs.”Gregoryexclaims:“Andnowheisinheaven,offeringsacrificesforusandprayingforthepeople.”214FinallyGregoryendsthemovingpanegyricforhisfriend,withthestaunchbeliefthatBasilcaneffectmiraclesforpeopleandofferintercessionsforthosewhocalluponhim.“Yetmayyougazeuponusfromabove,youdivineandsacredperson,eitherstaybythyentreatiesourthornintheflesh…orprevailuponustobearitboldly,andguideallourlifetowardthatwhichismostforourprofit.”215Gregory’sfirmbeliefinhisfriend’ssaintlypowerisechoedlaterinthisepigram:“ContinueIimploreyou,tostandofferingupthygiftsfortheworld.”216
ThoughGregoryofNyssaalsomemorializedhisbrotherBasilwithafuneralpanegyric,surprisinglythatisnottheplacewhereheconnectsBasiltothemartyrs.Interestinglyenough,helinkedBasilandthemartyrsinhissecondpanegyricfortheFortyMartyrsdeliveredinCaesarea,March379,onlytwomonthsafterBasil’sdeath.Inamomentoffraternaladmiration,hepraiseshisvirtuousbrotherforhisintrepiddefenseofthefaith,hisgoodworks,andhisservice“tothesaintsasasaint.”217Gregory’spraiseofhisbrotherhereisthemostexuberantandpersonalofallhisstatementsaboutBasil,anditgetsclosesttoequatinghimtoamartyr.Basil’sgrievingflockwouldhavebeenabletorecognizetheirbishopinthesepraises,butthatwouldbelessthecaseafewyearslaterinNyssen’sfuneralpanegyric.
NyssenhadlostbothBasilandMacrinawithinayearofeachother.UnabletoattendBasil’sfuneral,Nyssenmemorializedhisgreatbrotherin381,severalyearsafterhisdeath.BasilwasnotburiedinthefamilytombinIbora,butinCaesarea,soNyssengavetheaddressinCaesareaonJanuary1,rightafterthecelebrationsofChristmas,St.Stephen’s,andthefeastofHolyApostles.218ThesesaintsprovidedtheperfectsegueintotheparticularthemesofNyssen’s(p.149) funeraloration.ThecontrastbetweenNazianzen’spanegyrictoBasilandNyssen’sisastonishing.ThemostobviousdifferenceisthatNyssen’spanegyricgivesaremote,distant,andimpersonaldepictionofBasilasbothabrotherandahumanbeing.NyssenmanagedtoavoidsayingeverythingabouthisbrotherthatNazianzanhadnarrated
Page 36
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 36 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
soeloquentlyandmeticulously.219
Nyssen’sPanegyriconSt.BasilplaceshiminthepagesoftheBiblewithqualitiessovauntedthattheyarefarfromNyssenandthefamily.220Hisrhetoricisalsosostylizedthattheirparentsarenotworthmentioning,sinceBasil’sraceis“familiaritywithGodandvirtue.”221HeranksBasilalmostendlesslywithPaul,John,Stephen,Elijah,Samuel,andMoses,whowereindeedimitablesaints,buttheywereatthesametimeremoteinlocationandtime.Theywerenotnearlysoconnectedtothecommunityaswerethelocalmartyrs,familiartotheminplace,inheritedlore,recentmemory,andpassionatedevotion.Rather,NyssenframesBasil’sfeatsinuniversalterms,firstfortheworldstageandtheninbiblicalhistory.222ButhedoesnotdrawBasilneartothepeoplethroughpetitionsorcallsforintercession.
GregoryofNyssacomesclosesttolikeningBasiltothemartyrswhenhesayshewas“abravesoldierofChrist,”anobliquequotationof2Timothy2:3.223HealsoclaimsforBasilunitywiththemartyrsindeath,sinceaperson’s“misfortunecannotalwaysimitatethemartyrs’strugglesonbehalfofthetruth.”224Hisquestion,“Isthecelebrationinferiorincomparisonwiththerestofthesaints’festivals?”seemsgratuitous,sincehedoesnotpursueanycontextofapanegyris,sofamiliarandpopularwiththeaudience.
Finally,Basilisnotenshrinednexttothetombofthemartyrs.Dramatically,NyssencomparesBasil’stombwiththelostgraveofMoses,sincebothofthem“departedlifeanddidnotleavebehindamemorialofhisbodilyexistence.”225Thismayhaveworkedrhetorically,butitisstillquiteoddsinceBasilwasburiedinCaesareaalongwithalltheotherbishopsandpriestsofthecity,andNyssenwasprobablystandingrightinfrontofthecryptwhenhedeliveredthisoration.226
(p.150) Inhisbrother’spanegyric,Basilbelongedtotheclergy,“highpriestwithpriests,”notwiththemartyrs.Hehadlosttiesbothtothefamilyandtothelocalcommunity.SincethemartyrswereancestorstobothinNyssen’sworldview,itmakessensethatBasiltranscendedallspecificlocalizationofhisorigins,mitigatinghisrelationshiptothemartyrs.ThisstandsinconspicuouscontrasttoGregory’sLifeofSaintMacrina,wherehemergeshissister’slifewithavibranttheologyofmartyrdom,virtue,intercession,miracles,andbeneficence.GregorymemorializesMacrinaasamartyrbypromotingarelationalqualitybetweenherandthosewhovenerateher.Theeffectwouldbehealingandblessingonherbelieversandeternalmemoryforhissister.Therewasatrueinterchange.AllofthatisconspicuouslymissinginNyssen’sPanegyriconSt.Basil.
MacrinaMemorialized
GregoryofNyssa’sLifeofSaintMacrinatransformsthenarrationofMacrina’slifeintothevitaofasaintthroughtheprocessof“hagiographicalcomposition.”227Becauseitappearstobeintheformofaletter,theLifeofSaintMacrinaisaheartfeltmeditationonhissister’slifeasamartyr,notapanegyricforhermemorialcelebration.Itisamasterfulwork,thebestexampleofhagiobiography,asGregorycreativelycombinesfundamentalelementsofpanegyricandbiography.TheprocessofwritingtheLifeofSaintMacrinaprovidedaworthymemorialandatthesametimehelpedNyssentoovercomehisoverridinggriefatthelossofhissister.228AsabsentasGregory’semotionswereinhispanegyrictoBasil,thusaretheypalpablypresentintheLifeofSaintMacrina.Gregorywroteitayearorsoafterherdeathin
Page 37
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 37 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
380.
Thetextdividesneatlyintotwoparts.ThefirsthalfisabiographyofMacrinawithinthecontextoftheirentirefamily;infact,mostofthehistoryofallthefamilymembersiswrittenhere.Thishalfcorrespondstothedescriptionsofancestry,education,anddeedsinamartyrpanegyric.ThesecondhalfrecountsGregory’svisitwithMacrina,thelastdaysofherlife,andhermovingfuneral.Almostpointforpoint,thishalfdrawsanobviouscorrespondencebetweenamartyr’sdeathandMacrina’sdeath,andthenbetweentheritualsofapanegyrisandMacrina’sfuneral.
SincetherichbiographicaldetailsofMacrina’slifewereanalyzedbefore,itisnecessaryhereonlytopointouthowGregoryconstantlystressesMacrina’s(p.151) saintlinesswithinthecontextofherfamily.ForGregory,Macrina’sachievementsprimarilytaketheirmeaningwithintheboundsoftheirfamily,asa“cohesiveunit,”inwhichallmembersparticipateineachother’sglory.229Again,thecontentofbiographyandpanegyricmeldinthediscussionofMacrina’snobleancestry.ButatthispointGregoryintroducesaninnovation:aheavenlypersonintervenesduringEmmelia’slaborandaddressesthechildas“Thecla.”ThesaintwoulddirectMacrina’slife,andEmmeliawascomplicitenoughinthisdivineplanthatallthefamilyeventuallyknewthat“Thecla”wasMacrina’ssecretname.
EveryfamilymemberintheLifeplaysasupportingroleinMacrina’slifelongpursuitofsaintliness.EachencounterwithaparentorbrotherwasanoccasionforGregorytoemphasizeMacrina’sunflinchingresolvefortheasceticlifeandherspiritualsagacity.Herstrong-willed,thoughwell-meaning,fatherisnomatchforMacrinawhen,ontheearlydeathofherbetrothed,sheconvinceshimthatshewillremainforeveravirgin.230Instagessheleadshermothertotheasceticlifeinaprocessthattookseveralyears.231MacrinasucceedsintakingBasil“inhand”despitehisconceitedattitudeabouthisrhetoricalskillsand“swiftlywinshimovertotheidealofphilosophy.”232WhenNaucratius’deathplungedtheentirefamilyintouncontrollablegrief,Macrinabravely“roseabovenature”andemergedastheemotionalandspiritualleaderofthehousehold.Sheascended“above”hernature,butclearlynotabovekinship.
Whatismoretothepoint,herqualitiesofleadershipwerecompletelyfocusedontheasceticlife.AsGregorytellsit,Macrina’slifewasaprocessofmaturingintohigherlevelsofrenunciation.Herrigorousasceticismallowedherparticipationintheranksofthemartyrs.233AsGregorylaysoutherlife,thereaderseesherprogressofconformingprogressivelyandsteadilytothemartyrs.Frombirthtodeath,Gregorychartsherlifeasaspiritualascenttomartyrdomthroughasceticdiscipline.
BythesedevicesGregoryframesMacrina’slifeinsuchawaythatfromthetimeofherbirthshewasavirginmartyrandissetapartfromherfamilyinherasceticinitiative,accomplishments,andteachingability.TheformulaicnarrativeofthebiographyofanobleChristianCappadocianwomaninterfacesseamlesslywiththefamiliarstoryofanexceptionalvirginmartyr.ItstartsatMacrina’sbirthwiththeinterventionofSt.Thecla,whohasamoreimportant(p.152) roleinshapingherlifethanhernoble,Christianparents.EachsuccessivepointinMacrina’slifegoesbeyondeverydayhumanmeaningsincesheparticipateslikeanathleteintheasceticcontests,earningheraplaceintheranksofthemartyrs.
Page 38
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 38 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
ThesecondhalfoftheLifeturnstoMacrina’slastdays.Gregorybeginsthestoryofherdeathwithhisdreamthatperfectlyparallelstheeventsthathadsurroundedherbirth.HisdreamechoesEmmelia’sheavenlyvision,thriceheraldingThecla’sroleinherdaughter’slife.WhenGregorywasonlyaday’sjourneyawayfromAnnesi,hedreamtthreetimesthathewasholdingtherelicsofmartyrswhosebrightlightblindedhim.234Thevisionperplexedhim.Onarrival,hefoundthatMacrinawasverysickandthathisbrotherPeterhadgoneouttomeethim.AfterconversingwithMacrinafornearlyawholeday,reminiscingabouttheirfamilyandsobbingoverBasil’sdeath,Gregoryrealizedwhatthedreamhadmeant.HissisterMacrinawastheholymartyr.“WhatIhadseenbeforemewastrulytheremainsofaholymartyr,onewhohadbeendeadtosin,butilluminedbytheindwellinggraceoftheHolySpirit.”235GregorywasdespondentaboutMacrina’sapproachingdeath,butMacrinaurgedhimtocheerup.Shewasalreadylookingtowardtheprizeofvictory,themartyr’scrown.236Macrinalongedfordeath,justasthemartyrsdid.
Attheendofthesecondday,MacrinautteredherlastprayertoGod.Justasintherecountingofamartyr’sordeal,Macrina’sprayermirrorstheconfessionofthemartyr,thetrialssheenduresbecauseofherfaith,andherhopeforeternallife.ThefirsteightlinesareapatchworkofPsalmsandotherbiblicalquotescombinedwiththeprayersofvespers.TheyexpressMacrina’sbeliefintheGodwhocreatedallhumanity,whocrushedthedevilwhohadcapturedadisobedienthumanityintherealmofdeath,andwhoultimatelyopenedthegatesofhelltoeternallifeoftheresurrection.SheaffirmsherbeliefthatthecosmicbattlehasbeenwonthroughthecrossandresurrectionofChrist.Herconfessioninallthesewaysisatruemartyr’sconfession.237
Thesecondpartofherprayerreflectsontheconsequencesofherfaith.Inamartyr’sstory,aftertheconfession,theoppressorstorturetheChristianforherfaith,andshediesapainfuldeath.Similarly,inMacrina’sprayersherecountshowshewasdedicatedtoGodfrombirthandhowshewascrucified(p.153) withGodfromthatmomentandthenthroughoutallherlife:“forIhavenailedmyfleshoutofreverenceforyouandhavefearedyourjudgments.”238Herasceticlifeofunrelentingself-abnegationbroughtherthemartyr’ssufferingeachdayofherlifeonearth.Justassomemartyrswerescourgedorflayed,MacrinaimploresGodthat“inthestrippingoffofmybodyImaybefoundwithoutstainorblemishinthebeautyofmysoul.”239AndliketheFortyMartyrswhowereburned(andnearwhomshewouldsoonbeburied),thelastlineofherprayerreferstohersoulrisingtotheLord“asanincenseofferingbeforeyourface.”240Sheendsherprayerandherlifewiththesignofthecross.
AftertwoofMacrina’sfellowvirginsreadiedherbodyforburial,theygaveGregoryherring.Itwasengravedwithacrossandcontainedasliverofthetruecrosswithin.241ThroughoutMacrina’slifetheringanditscontentshadservedasarelic,yetitsimultaneouslytranscendedtheboundariesofarelic’smeaning:shehadliterallycarriedthecrossallherlife.ForGregorytheringwouldserveforeverasarelicofhisbelovedmartyredsister.
Macrina’svigilandfuneralhadalltheelementsofapanegyrisforthemartyrs,theantiphonalchantingofpsalms,sharedresponses,andtheprocessionwithcandles.242Thelamentationstookontheovertonesofamartyr’sfestival.“Wespentthewholenightsinginghymnsaround
Page 39
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 39 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
herbody,justastheydoincelebratingthedeathofmartyrs.”243CrowdsofpeoplefromneighboringvillagesjoinedthefuneralprocessiontotheshrineoftheFortyMartyrsafewmilesawayatIbora.Alongwithdeacons,priests,andthreebishops,piouslaitysqueezedintothemartyrium,clamoringtotouchMacrina’sbier,“sincenobodycouldseeenoughofthatholyspectacle.”244
BeforeplacingMacrina’sbodyinthefamilytombnexttotheirparents’remains,Gregorycouldnolongercontainhisdeepfear.Hewasparalyzedwithpanicthatwhentheyopenthetomb,heshouldbreakGod’scommandandsee“theshameofhisownmotherandfather,”thenaked,decayedremainsofhisparents.GregoryhadinmindLeviticus18:6–7:“Noneofyoushallapproachanyonenearofkintouncovernakedness,IamtheLord.Youshallnotuncoverthenakednessofyourfather,whichisthenakednessofyourmother;sheisyourmother,youshallnotuncoverhernakedness.”ThatGregoryunderstood(p.154) thecommandtwoways,firstassexandsecondliterallyasseeing,isobviousfromhisnextcommentandhissolutionoutofthepredicament.245Consistentwithhistheology,hesubsumessexualintercourseintheoverridingconsequenceoftheFall:death.246Hisworryatthetombisevident:“HowwillIbefreeofsuchcondemnationifIlookatthecommonshameofhumannatureinthebodiesofmyparents,sincetheycanonlybedecomposedanddisintegratedandchangedintoahideous,repulsiveformlessness?”247
Gregoryfoundthesolution(andhishermeneuticofthecommandinLeviticus)intheactionsofShemandJapheth,twoofNoah’ssonsinGenesis9:18–27.Noah’sotherson,Ham,sawhisnakedfatherNoah,whenhewasinadrunkenstupor.Notonlydidhenotaverthisgaze,heboastedtohisbrothersaboutitafterward.ShemandJapheth,however,actedmorehonorably.TheywalkedbackwardintoNoah’spresenceand,withoutlookingathim,coveredhimupwithacloth.Withsomerelief,Gregoryimitatedthemandmadesurethataclothwaslaidoverhisparents’remainsbeforetheybecamevisible.
AstheylaidMacrina’sbodyinthetombnexttohermother,Gregory’sgriefwaspalpable.AdjacenttothetombwasthemartyriumoftheFortyMartyrs,literallywhereheavenandearthmergedinGregory’sworld,sovividlycrowdedwithfamily,thesaints,andhismemories.HismotherhadbuiltthatveryshrinewheretheFortyMartyrshadclubbedhim,aneventaffectinghimsomuchthathewaseventuallybaptized;wherehisfamily’sremainswere;andwhereallhisbelovedkinwouldriseupearlywiththemartyrsatthefinalresurrection.248Alongwithherfamily,MacrinawasnowburiednexttotheFortyMartyrs.Kissingthedustathergrave,likegreetingthemartyratthepanegyris,Nyssengavehissistervenerationasasaint,theonlyproperfarewell.
Inconsolablewhenheleft,Gregorymetatearfulsoldier,wholikehimwasalsomourningMacrina’sdeath.ThesoldiertestifiedtoMacrina’sinnumerablemiracles,whichweretheultimateproofofthepowersoftheholymartyrsandtheirworthinessofveneration.249Gregory’smagnificentverbalmemorialtohis(p.155) sistergoesfarbeyondhisstatedjustification:“alifeofthisqualityshouldnotbeforgottenforthefuture,andthatshewhohadraisedherselfthroughphilosophytothehighestlimitofhumanvirtueshouldnotpassalongthiswayveiledandinsilence.”250Rather,muchmoresimply,withtheLifeofSaintMacrina,Gregorydoesinhisrhetoricwhatamartyr’sfestivalaccomplishesinritual,“tokeepthemartyrs’memoryalive.”251
Page 40
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 40 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
ConclusionClearly,kinshipwiththemartyrsfunctionedastheheartofChristianpietyfortheCappadociansonavarietyoflevels.WecannowassesstheCappadocians’achievementsfromdifferentvantagepoints.Inmostways,itappearsthattheCappadocianFathersstraddledtwoverydifferentworlds—theasceticlifeandthedomesticlife—withsupremeequipoise.Andsuchadroitnessallowedthemtocreatearich,resonantsystemofrelationshipswiththemartyrsthatsustainedallChristianslikeafamily.Infact,theyviewedtheimportanceoffamily,householdorganization,andobligationsofkinshipasthemodelofChristiansocialorganization,includingmonasticism.Thoughtheyallembracedthecelibatelife,theCappadociansnever“left”theirnatalfamilies,eventhoughtheyenjoinedmembersofcoenobiticmonasteriestodoso.Theevidenceissuffusedwithexamplesoftheirextraordinarydevotiontotheirfamilymembersthroughouttheirlives.Intheirdualrolesascelibateandfamilymen,theyusedmartyrpietytoforgenewwaystoenvisionrelationshipswiththemartyrsandtopromotetheirownfamilymembers.252
AsignificantreasontheCappadociansweresosuccessfulisthatvenerationofthemartyrswasthemostpervasiveandmostpopularliturgicalactivity.Avibrantsacramentallifeforthelaitywasnotyetthenorminfourth-centuryChristianity.Mostpeopledelayedbaptismuntillateinlife,soveryfewpeoplereceivedtheHolyEucharistatliturgies.Buteverypiouscatechumencouldparticipateinpanegyreisformartyrs,whichoccurredmonthly,attheminimum.
TheCappadocianscapitalizedonthissituationbypreachingthateveryChristiancouldbecomefriendsofthemartyrs,andevenkinwiththemartyrs,throughtheirpietyandmoralbehavior.Kinshipwiththemartyrsconstitutedanadoptive,spiritualkinship,opentomonasticsandlaityalike.Ofcourse,allChristianswereurgedtoactuallybecomemartyrsthroughheroicasceticlives(p.156) andmoralaction.Butmostpeoplecouldneverachievesuchheights;andweretheytodoso,theywouldlosethereciprocal,relationalnetworkthatsupportedthemintheirdailylivesbybeingkinwiththemartyrs.
BasilandGregoryofNyssaattachedsomuchimportancetokinshipwiththemartyrsthattheyclaimedthreemostfamoussaintsasfamilialrelatives.Theirmotivesareallthemoreobviouswhenwerememberthattheirowngrandfatherwasmartyredinthelastpersecution.Yettheydonotwriteabouthim.Sts.GregoryThaumaturgus,Thecla,andtheFortyMartyrsintervenedintheirlivesinsuchawaythattheyappearparadoxicallytobebothconsanguineousandspiritualancestors.Asaresult,theprestigeoftheirownfamilywentwellbeyondallsocialparameters,reachingtheawesomerealmofthesaints.
GregoryofNazianzusjoinsNyssenintheultimatemeansforestablishingkinshipwiththemartyrs.Throughfuneralpanegyrics,epigrams,andthefamousLifeofSaintMacrina,theybothinscribetheirrecentlydeceasedfamilymembersintotheranksofthemartyrs.Notonlydidthisensuretheirkinshipwithmartyrsbutalsosoonafterwardtheirfamilymemberswereveneratedassaints.Againweseefamilyconcerns,preeminentfortheCappadocians,mergewiththepromotionofmartyrpiety.Throughkinshipwiththemartyrs,theCappadocianssucceedinbypassingtheneedforprocreation.Theirfamily’shonorisforever,eternal.Finally,theCappadociansenvisionedasystemthatwhileappropriatingandexpandingonpopularmartyrpiety,puttheirownelitepietyonahigherplane,therebyperpetuatingthe
Page 41
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 41 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
distinctionbetweentheirownfamiliesandthegeneralpopulace.Withsiblingsandparentsensconcedwiththemartyrs,yetstillidentifiableintheirfamilialroles,weshallnowturntoanexaminationofthefascinatingrolegenderplayedintheirascenttomartyrdomandintheirunceasingpromotionofmartyrpiety.
Notes:
(1.)RaymondVanDam,FamiliesandFriendsinLateRomanCappadocia(Philadelphia:UniversityofPennsylvaniaPress,2003),122;andseeAndrewJacobs,“AFamilyAffair:Marriage,Class,andEthicsintheApocryphalActsoftheApostles,”JECS7(1999):125.JacobspointsoutthatChristianrenunciationofmarriageinlateantiquityhasrepercussionsalong“socialstatuslines.”
(2.)ElizabethCastelli,MartyrdomandMemory:EarlyChristianCultureMaking(NewYork:ColumbiaUniversityPress,2004),4.
(3.)Ibid.,70.
(4.)JohnDavis,PeopleoftheMediterranean(London:Routledge,Kegan,andPaul,1977),219.
(5.)BernhardJussen,SpiritualKinshipasSocialPractice,trans.PamelaSelwyn(Newark:UniversityofDelawarePress,2000),21.
(6.)Ibid.
(7.)Adoptionwasindeedanotherlegalwayofestablishingkinshipinthefourthcentury,butitdoesnotpertaintotheCappadocians’families.
(8.)AndrewT.Crislip,FromMonasterytoHospital,ChristianMonasticism&theTransformationofHealthCareinLateAntiquity(AnnArbor:UniversityofMichiganPress,2005),139.
(9.)MarilynDunn,TheEmergenceofMonasticism,fromtheDesertFatherstotheEarlyMiddleAges(Oxford:BlackwellPublishers,2000),34–35.
(10.)BasilofCaesarea,AnAsceticalDiscourseI,inSaintBasil,AsceticalWorks,FOTC,vol.9,trans.SisterM.MonicaWagner,C.S.C.(Washington,DC:CatholicUniversityPress,1962),207,210.Basilestablishesseparatemonasteriesforwomenandformen.
(11.)Crislip,56.
(12.)BasilofCaesarea,TheLongRules,8,inSt.Basil,AsceticalWorks,FOTC,vol.9,trans.SisterM.MonicaWagner,C.S.C.(Washington,DC:CatholicUniversityPress,1962),253.
(13.)Ibid.
(14.)Basil,AsceticalDiscourseI,Wagner,208.
(15.)Basil,LongRules,32,Wagner,295–296.
Page 42
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 42 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
(16.)RebeccaKrawiec,“‘FromtheWomboftheChurch’:MonasticFamilies,”JECS11(2003):285.
(17.)Crislip,59.
(18.)Basil,LongRules,8,Wagner,253.
(19.)Ibid.,LongRules,9,Wagner,257.
(20.)PaulJ.Fedwick,TheChurchandtheCharismaofLeadershipinBasilofCaesarea(Toronto:PontificalInstituteofMediaevalStudies,1979),15.
(21.)BasilofCaesarea,ShorterRules,187,inTheAsceticWorksofSt.Basil,trans.W.K.L.Clarke(London:SPCK,1925),199.
(22.)KateCooper,“ApproachingtheHolyHousehold,”JECS15(2007):133.
(23.)Basil,LongRules,8,Wagner,254;18and19,273–277;22and23,281–285;38and39,311–313;42and43,317–320;55,330–335;AsceticDiscourseI,Wagner,211.
(24.)Crislip,56.
(25.)Basil,LongRules,Wagner,313–314.
(26.)JohnMeyendorff,“ChristianMarriageinByzantium:TheCanonicalandLiturgicalTradition,”DOP44(1990):99–107.
(27.)Ibid.,104.
(28.)BasilofCaesarea,Letter188,CanonicaPrima,CanonIV,225;CanonicaSecunda,CanonsXXI,XLI,L,NPNF,vol.8,238,239,240;CononicaTertia,CanonLXXX,258.Therearethreelettersonthecanons,alladdressedtoAmphilochiusofIconium,Letters188,199,217,constitutingeighty-fourrulesandopinionsonpracticalmattersofadministrationoftheChristiancommunity.ItisnotmyintentioninmybooktodiscusstheCappadocians’viewsonthedifferencebetweenthevirgin/celibatelifeandthemarriedlife.Thatisaverydifferenttopic.Itisimportanttonote,however,thatGregoryofNyssasaidhewasnotdepreciatingmarriageasaninstitutionwhenhewroteOnVirginity.“Butourviewofmarriageisthis;that,whilethepursuitofheavenlythingsshouldbeaman’sfirstcare,yetifhecanusetheadvantagesofmarriagewithsobrietyandmoderation,heneednotdespisethiswayofservingthestate.”NyssenmentionsnothinganywhereaboutthemarriageserviceortheincorporationofmarriageintotheChurch.
(29.)Ibid.,Letter199;CanonicaSecunda,CanonXLII,329.
(30.)Meyendorff,105.Thesechurchblessingsatweddingsturnedintochurchweddingsin741bytheEcloga.Thisbecameanalternateformofconcludingalegalmarriage.InthereignofLeoVI(886–912),itwasrequiredbylawthatmarriagebe“sanctionedbythewitnessofthesacredblessing.”TheChurchfromthenonhadallrightsovermarriageanddivorce.
(31.)GregoryofNazianzus,Letter231,inSaintGrégoiredeNazianze,Lettres,vol.2,ed.
Page 43
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 43 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
andtrans.PaulGallay(Paris:Sociétéd’édition“lesbelleslettres,”1967),122–123.
(32.)GregoryofNazianzus,Carminaquaespectantadalios,PraisesforOlympias’Wedding,PG37.1542–1550(Poem6).ForthediscussionofVitalianusandhisfeudwithhissonsPhocasandPeter,whomhebannedfromattendingtheweddingoftheirsister,seeKristoffelDemoen,“GiftsofFriendshipthatWillRemainForever,”JbOB47(1997):4–9.SeealsoGregoryofNazianzus,LetterGallay,vol.2,163.
(33.)GregoryofNazianzus,Letter193,Gallay,vol.2,84.
(34.)Ibid.
(35.)GregoryofNazianzus,Letter231,Gallay,vol.2,123.
(36.)KorbinianRitzer,LemariagedansleségliseschrétiennesduIerauXesiècle(Paris:ÉditionsduCerf,1970),136.Thepriestorbishopcrownedthecouplebyendofthesixthcentury.TheearliestartisticdepictionsofChristianmarriagearefromthefifthcentury.ThemostfamousisasoliduscommemoratingthemarriageofEmpressPulcheriaandEmperorMarcian.ItisablendofRomanandChristian:theirrighthandsarejoined,Christisthecelebrant,andhisarmsarearoundthecouple.ChristhasreplacedtheroleofConcordiainthedepiction.SeeOxfordDictionaryofByzantium(Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress,1991),vol.2,1307.
(37.)GregoryofNazianzus,Letter232,Gallay,vol.2,123.SeeJn2:1–11,whereJesusandhismotherareattheweddingatCanaandheturnswaterintowine.
(38.)GregoryofNazianzus,OrationonHolyBaptism,NPNF,vol.7,370.
(39.)Ibid.
(40.)Ibid.
(41.)Ibid.,364.
(42.)GregoryofNyssa,Deiisquibaptismumdifferent,PG46.419.
(43.)BasilofCaesarea,Homiliaexhortatoriaadsanctumbaptisma,PG31.432.
(44.)JosephH.Lynch,GodparentsandKinshipinEarlyMedievalEurope(Princeton,NJ:PrincetonUniversityPress,1986),54–55,97.JohnChrysostomistheearliestoftheGreekFatherstotalkaboutsponsors;seehisSecondCatecheticalSermon,15–16,inBaptismalInstructionsbySaintJohnChrysostom,ACW,vol.31,trans.PaulWilliamHarkins.(Mahwah,NJ:PaulistPress,1963)48–49.SeealsoEgeria’sTravels,trans.JohnWilkinson(London:SPCK,1973),27–90;ApostolicTradition,16–19,trans.BurtonScottEaston(Hamden,CT:ArchonBooks,1962),48–49.
(45.)Jussen,119.
(46.)Ibid.
Page 44
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 44 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
(47.)Ibid.,369.
(48.)JosephH.Lynch,ChristianizingKinship,RitualSponsorshipinAnglo-SaxonEngland(Ithaca,NY:CornellUniversityPress,1998),17.
(49.)JeanBernardi,LaprédicationdesPèresCappadociens(Montpellier:PressesUniversitairesdeFrance,1968),68.
(50.)Baptism,Eucharist,andChrismationarethesacramentsmentionedintheearliestchurchfathers.AugustineandDionysiustheAreopagite(c.500)werethefirsttodiscussthesacramentsatlength,withDionysiusattemptingtoclassifythem.Hislistincludedordination,monasticconsecration,andthefuneralservice.
(51.)Cooper,“Approaching,”140.
(52.)Davis,172–173.
(53.)Cooper,“Approaching,”133.
(54.)Ibid.
(55.)Ihavebasedthesesketchesontheworksofscholarscitedinthefootnotes.ForchronologyofalltheCappadocians,IhavefollowedGallay,Bernardi,Rousseau,andVanDam.ThereisconsiderabledebateconcerningthedatingofthebirthsanddeathsoftheCappadocians;seeespeciallyPierreMaraval,“RetoursurquelquesdatesconcernantBasiledeCésaréeetGrégoiredeNysse,”RHE99(2004):153–157;AnnaSilvas,GregoryofNyssa:TheLetters(Leiden:Brill,2007),1–65;BrianE.Daley,GregoryofNazianzus(London:Routledge,2006),1–34;JohnMcGuckin,SaintGregoryofNazianzus.AnIntellectualBiography(Crestwood,NY:St.Vladimir’sPress,2001).
(56.)AndewJacobs,“‘LethimGuardPietas’:EarlyChristianExegesisandtheAsceticFamily,”JECS11(2003):268.
(57.)VanDam,Families,27;BasilofCaesarea,Letters204,207,210,NPNF,vol.8,243,245–248,249.
(58.)VanDamsaysthattheunclefromCaesareaismostlikelyamaternaluncle;seeFamilies,30.Rev.BlomfeldJackson,editoroftheNPNF,vol.8,thoughthewasapaternaluncle.
(59.)Thedatesoftheirbirthsareapproximate.
(60.)PhilipRousseau,“BasilofCaesarea:ChoosingaPast,”inReadingthePastinLateAntiquity,ed.GraemeClarke(Sydney:AustralianNationalUniversityPress,1999),39.
(61.)OpinionsontheevidenceaboutTheosebeiavarywidely.SilvasthinksthatTheosebeiaisasisterandshebecameanuninMacrina’shousehold.Thoughthisisanattractivethesis,Nazianzen’sLetter197andEpigram164arewrittenlongafterMacrina’sdeath.GregoryofNyssa,Ithink,wouldhavereferredtohissisterTheosebeiaif,infact,shehadbeenlivingatMacrina’smonastery.IagreethatTheosebeiaisasisterofMacrina,Basil,andGregory,butI
Page 45
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 45 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
thinkshelivedsomewhereelsewithherhusband,anothermannamedGregory,thepriest.SeeSilvas,GregoryofNyssa,4.PaulGallaysetsouttheevidenceandseemstofavorthepositionthatsheisasister;seePaulGallay,SaintGrégoiredeNazianze,Lettres,vol.2,164,note3.ManyscholarsthinkthatLetter197referstoGregoryofNyssa’swife,Theosebeia,whohadrecentlydied.IdiscussthequestionofGregory’smaritalstatuslateroninthischapter—seeespeciallynote75.
(62.)GregoryofNazianzus,Epigram161,inTheGreekAnthology,VII-VIII,LCL,vol.68,trans.W.R.Paton(Cambridge,MA:HarvardUniversityPress,2000),470–471.
(63.)Ibid.,Epigram164,Paton,470–471.“Gregory”isacommonnameintheircircles.TherearesixGregoriesinjustthesetwofamilies.
(64.)Cooper,“Approaching,”133;SusannaElm,VirginsofGod(Berkeley:UniversityofCalifornia,1994),78.
(65.)Elm,100.
(66.)Cooper,“Approaching,”140.
(67.)GregoryofNazianzus,Epigrams156,157,158,Paton,466–469.
(68.)Elm,83–84.
(69.)AndrewLouth,“Cappadocians,”inCambridgeHistoryofEarlyChristianLiterature,eds.FrancesYoung,LouisAyres,andAndrewLouth(Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,2004),290.
(70.)GregoryofNyssa,Letters13,19,inLetters,GrégoiredeNysse,SC,vol.363,trans.PierreMaraval(Paris:ÉditionsduCerf,1990),198–199,248–251.
(71.)GregoryofNyssa,Encomiuminxlmartyresii,PG46.784.56–785.30.Thisincidentisalsodealtwithelsewhereinseveralothercontexts;seechapters1and2.
(72.)GregoryofNazianzus,Letter11,Gallay,vol.1,16–18,writtensometimebetween362and365;Basil,Letter14,NPNF,vol.8,124.
(73.)Rousseau,“ChoosingaPast,”51;BasilremarksinLetter210,addressedtotheNeocaesareans,thathisbrothersliveinPontus,NPNF,vol.8,249.
(74.)Rousseau,“ChoosingaPast,”49.
(75.)ChurchtraditionandmostscholarshaveheldthatGregoryofNyssawasmarriedtoawomannamedTheosebeia,basedonNazianzen’sLetter197andtwocommentsinOnVirginity.Nazianzen’sLetter197,asIhavediscussed,addressedtoGregoryofNyssa,consoleshimonthedeathofacertainTheosebeia.SeeJeanDaniélou,“LemariagedeGrégoiredeNysseetlachronologiedesavie,”REA2(1956):71–78;MichelR.Barnes,“‘TheBurdenofMarriage’andOtherNotesonGregoryofNyssa’sOnVirginity,”SP37(1999):12–19.AnnaSilvasgivesanintriguingargumentonwhyshethinksGregorywasmarried,butnottoaTheosebeia,andSilvasproposesrevisionsofdatesofhiscareerasa
Page 46
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 46 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
rhetorician.SeeSilvas,GregoryofNyssa,:4,15–25.SeealsothemoretraditionaldiscussioninGregoryofNazianzus,Letters,Gallay,vol.2,164,note3.Louth,too,thinksthatNyssenwasmarried,buthethinksthatTheosebeiawashissister,withwhomhelivedafterhisunnamedwifedied;thusshewasthe“helper,”or“consort”(syzygos)ofGregoryofNyssa,thepriest;seeLouth,“Cappadocians,”298,301,note9.MoutsoulasholdsthatTheosebeiaisasisterandenteredthemonasticlife;seeEliasMoutsoulas,ΓΡΗΓΟΡΙΟΣΝΥΣΣΗΣ,Βίος,Συγράμματα,Διδασκαλία(Athens:EptalophosA.B.E.E.,1997),20.IthinkthattheirsisterTheosebeiawasmarriedtoanotherpriestnamedGregory.Moreover,IdonotthinkthereissufficientevidencetosaythatGregoryofNyssawasmarried.InOnVirginity3,heclaimsthereisachasmbetweenhimandthelifeofvirginitybecausehehaschosenthesecularlife;hedoesnotsayhewasmarried.Isimplydonotknowifhewasmarried.InOnVirginity,Nyssenarguesthatchoosingalifeofvirginityallowsonetoescapetheextremelypainfulexperienceofmarriage.ThetreatiseissorhetoricallycomplexthatitisquitedifficulttodistillNyssen’spersonalposition.Hetakesmanysidesinthetreatise.Iamconvincedthat“virginity”forhimisamind-set,aphronema,havingtodowithvirtueandself-control,notmerephysicalvirginity.SeeMorwennaLudlow’sexcellentdiscussionofvirginityinGregoryofNyssa,Ancientand(Post)modern(Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress,2007),190–201.Theonlyotherevidenceistenuous,citedinGregoryofNazianzus’Letter197andtheEpigrams161,164,theveryevidencethatclearlynamesTheosebeiaashissisterandasEmmelia’schild,GregoryofNazianzus,Letter197,Gallay,vol.2,88–90,Epigrams161,164,Paton,467–468,470–471.
(76.)ThedatingofNyssen’sworksisfilledwithproblemsandcomplications,andthereislittleagreement.ThecurrentrevisionsandpropositionsforchangingchronologyofsignificanteventsinalltheCappadocians’livesarenotconvincingand,inmyview,addmoreproblemsthantheysolve.Forthemostpart,IhavefollowedthetraditionalchronologyinconjunctionwithGallay,Bernardi,andVanDam.IamconvincedthatNyssenwroteOnVirginitysometimebetween368and370,andthatduringhisexilehewroteOntheFaith,OnNotThreeGods,OntheBaptismofChrist,andAgainstMacedonius.
(77.)GregoryofNyssa,LifeofSaintMacrina,trans.KevinCorrigan(Toronto:Peregrina,1989),32.
(78.)ThelongrelationshipbetweenEustathiusofSebasteiaandBasilisfamousforitsramificationsfortheTrinitariancontroversy,andisamplycoveredbymanyscholars.SeeRaymondVanDam,FamiliesandFriendsinLateRomanCappadocia(Philadelphia:UniversityofPennsylvaniaPress,2003),24–26;andRousseau,BasilofCaesarea,19–25,75–80.Elm’spositionthatBasilhonoredhisrecentlydeceasedbrotherNaucratiusbybecomingamonkisconvincingandplausible;Elm,83–84.
(79.)GregoryofNyssa,Letter19,Maraval,248–249.
(80.)Rousseau,“ChoosingaPast,”49.
(81.)Basil,Letter58,NPNF,vol.8,159;GregoryofNyssawasnotyetbishopofSasima.
(82.)Ibid.,160.
Page 47
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 47 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
(83.)Ibid.
(84.)Ecclus40:24.
(85.)Basil,Letter59,NPNF,vol.8,160.
(86.)Ibid.,Letter60,NPNF,vol.8,161.
(87.)Ibid.
(88.)Ibid.
(89.)Ibid.
(90.)Rousseau,“ChoosingaPast,”49.
(91.)Basil,Letter38,NPNF,vol.8,137–141.
(92.)Basil,Letters225,232,NPNF,vol.8,267,272–273.Foraninterestingdiscussionofthebrothers’relationshipsurroundingTrinitariantheology,seeJeanDaniélou,“GrégoiredeNysseàtraversleslettresdeSaintBasileetdeSaintGrégoiredeNazianze,”VC19(1965):31–41.
(93.)Basil,Letter100,NPNF,vol.8,184.
(94.)Ibid.,Letter225,267;Daniélou,“GrégoiredeNysse,”35–36.
(95.)Basil,Letter215,NPNF,vol.8,254–255.
(96.)Ibid.,Letters231,272;237,279;239,280.
(97.)Ibid.,Letter37,135–136.
(98.)GregoryofNazianzus,OntheDeathofHisFather,5,NPNF,vol.7,256.
(99.)GregoryofNazianzus,Epigrams136,165,Paton,460–461,472–473.
(100.)Ibid.,Epigram165;Paton,472–473.Nonna’sbrotherGregorywasapriest.
(101.)GregoryofNazianzus,OnCaesarius,4,NPNF,vol.7,230.
(102.)Bernardi,127–128.
(103.)SeethethoroughIntroductioninDaley,GregoryofNazianzus,1–60;andMcGuckin,SaintGregoryofNazianzus,23–26.
(104.)GregoryofNazianzus,OntheDeathofHisFather,11,NPNF,vol.7,258.
(105.)Ibid.,5,256.
(106.)Bernardi,127–128.
Page 48
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 48 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
(107.)Nazianzenwrotefourtreatisesdealingwithhissurpriseordinationandhisflight:OnEasterandHisReluctance,DefenseofHisFlighttoPontus,ToThoseWhoHadInvitedHim,andOntheEntrustingofHisFather’sChurch.SeeNPNF,vol.7,203–228,245–247.
(108.)GregoryofNazianzus,Letter49,Gallay,vol.1,63–64.
(109.)GregoryofNazianzus,OntheEntrustingofHisFather’sChurch,5,NPNF,vol.7,246.
(110.)Ibid.,OnHisSisterGorgonia,20,244.
(111.)GregoryofNazianzus,Letters12,51,52,53,54,55,157,Gallay,vol.1,19–20,66–71;vol.2,48–49.
(112.)GregoryofNazianzus,OnHisSisterGorgonia,NPNF,vol.7,238–244,especially12,13,241–242.
(113.)Ibid.,OnCaesarius,9,232;forCaesarius’knowledgeofscience,seeGregoryofNazianzus,Epigrams91,92,Paton,440–441.
(114.)GregoryofNazianzus,OnCaesarius,15,NPNF,vol.7,234.
(115.)Basil,Letter1,NPNF,vol.8,446.
(116.)GregoryofNazianzus,Epigrams32,75,76,Paton,414–416,432–433.
(117.)TomasHägg,“PlayingwithExpectations:Gregory’sFuneralOrations,”inGregoryofNazianzus,ImagesandReflections,eds.JosteinBørtnesandTomasHägg(Copenhagen:MuseumTusculanumPress,2006),146–147.
(118.)GregoryofNazianzus,OntheEntrustingofHisFather’sChurch,5,NPNF,vol.7,246.
(119.)GregoryofNazianzus,Letter7,Gallay,vol.1,8–10.
(120.)Ibid.
(121.)Ibid.,OntheDeathofHisFather,30,264;Epigram30,Paton,414–415.
(122.)GregoryofNazianzus,Letter60,Gallay,vol.1,78.Inthesamevein,althoughthesubjectofthisletterhasnothingtodowithhonoringparents,GregoryopensLetter37thisway,“Tohonoramotherisamongtheholiestofdeeds”;Gallay,vol.1,46.Thisisaveryrevealingrhetoricalflourish.
(123.)Ibid.,Letter7,Gallay,vol.1,10.
(124.)Ibid.,10.
(125.)Ibid.
(126.)Ibid.,Letter20,Gallay,vol.1,28–29.
(127.)GregoryofNazianzus,Epigram94,Paton,440–441.
Page 49
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 49 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
(128.)GregoryofNazianzus,Letter30,Gallay,vol.1,37.
(129.)GregoryofNazianzus,Epigrams85–100,Paton,436–445.
(130.)GregoryofNazianzuswroteatotalof254epigrams.Thisnumberdoesnotincludetheepigramshewroteforhimself.
(131.)GregoryofNazianzus,Letter63,Gallay,vol.1,81–83.
(132.)Ibid.,Letter12,Gallay,vol.1,19–20.Nazianzenalsowrotealovelypoemof208versesforNicobulus,whomarriedhisniece;seeCarminaquaespectantadalios,Poem4,ForNicobulus,PG37.1506–1521.
(133.)GregoryofNazianzus,Letter13,Gallay,vol.1,20–21.
(134.)Ibid.,Letters146–148,Gallay,vol.2,37–41,especially39.
(135.)Ibid.,Letter195,Gallay,vol.2,85–86.
(136.)Ibid.,Letters22–23,51–55,Gallay,vol.1,29–31,66–71;Letters167,171,174–178,187–192,Gallay,vol.2,58,60,63–69,78–83.Letters51–55aretograndnephewNicobulusabouteducation,andLetters22,23,167,171,174–178aretoEudoxiustherhetorforgrandnephewNicobulus;Letters187–192aretoEudoxius,andrhetorsStagirius,andEustochiusforgrandnephewNicobulus’education.HealsowrotePoem5forhisbelovedgrandnephew;seeCarminaquaespectantadalios,PG37.1521–1542.SeethediscussionofGregory’srelationshipwiththeseprofessionalrhetorsinNeilMcLynn,“AmongtheHellenists:GregoryandtheSophists,”inGregoryofNazianzus,ImagesandReflections,eds.JosteinBørtnesandTomasHägg(Copenhagen:MuseumTusculanumPress,2006),215–218,235,237.
(137.)GregoryofNazianzus,Letter55,Gallay,vol.1,71.
(138.)GregoryofNazianzusdoesnotclaimkinshipwithamartyrforhimselforanyofhisfamily.Hedoeswriteabouthisfamilyasmartyrs,andthatwillbedealtwithlaterinthischapter.
(139.)Seechapter1fordiscussionofBasil’sdefenseagainsttheNeocaesareans.
(140.)Basil,Letter204,NPNF,vol.8,244.Letter223alsomentionsthatbothhismotherandhisgrandmother,ElderMacrina,taughthimaboutGod;263;RaymondVanDam,“HagiographyandHistory:TheLifeofGregoryThaumaturgus,”CA1(1982):283.
(141.)Basil,Letter207,NPNF,vol.8,248.
(142.)Ibid.,Letter204,243.
(143.)GregoryofNyssa’sversionofthelifeofGregoryofThaumaturgusisdiscussedbrieflyinchapter1.
(144.)Bernardi,308.
Page 50
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 50 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
(145.)Ibid.;VanDam,“Hagiography,”286–287,307;StephenMitchell,“TheLifeandLivesofGregoryThaumaturgus,”inPortraitsofSpiritualAuthority,eds.J.W.DrijversandJ.W.Watt(Leiden:Brill,1999),120–128.
(146.)WilliamTelfer,“TheCultofSt.GregoryThaumaturgus,”HTR29(1936):232–233.HowGregoryofNyssausesThaumaturgustopromotetheauthenticityofthecreedisdealtwithinchapter1.
(147.)GregoryofNyssa,TheLifeofGregorytheWonderworker,14,15,inSt.GregoryThaumaturgus,LifeandWorks,FOTC,vol.98,trans.MichaelSlusser(Washington,DC:CatholicUniversityPress,1998),83–84.
(148.)StephenMitchell,Anatolia,Land,Men,andGodsinAsiaMinor,theRiseoftheChurch,vol.2(Oxford:ClarendonPress,1993),55.MarioGirardi,BasiliodiCesareaeilcultodeimartirinelIVsecolo,Scritturaetradizione,Quadernidi“VeteraChristianorum”21(Bari:InstitutodiStudiclassiciecristiani,UniversitàdiBari,1990),197–198.
(149.)HippolyteDelehaye,Sanctus,Essaisurlecultedessaintsdansl’Antiquité(Brussels:SociétédesBollandistes,1927),114.ThecultofGregoryThaumaturguswasoneoftheoldestforabishop,althoughitsoriginisunknown.RufinusknewGregoryThaumaturgusasamartyr.
(150.)RaymondVanDam,BecomingChristian,TheConversionofRomanCappadocia(Philadelphia:UniversityofPennsylvaniaPress,2003),79;Mitchell,“LifeandLives,”123.
(151.)ArnaldoMomigliano,“TheLifeofSt.MacrinabyGregoryofNyssa,”inOnPagans,Christians,andJews(Middletown,CT:WesleyanUniversityPress,1987),206–221,especially209.
(152.)StephenDavis,TheCultofSaintThecla:ATraditionofWomen’sPietyinLateAntiquity(Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress,2001),40–45;TomasHägg,TheNovelinAntiquity(Berkeley:UniversityofCaliforniaPress,1983),159.
(153.)Delehaye,Sanctus,147.
(154.)Davis,80.
(155.)VanDam,Families,105.
(156.)GregoryofNyssa,LifeofSaintMacrina,Corrigan,28.
(157.)FrancineCardman,“WhoseLifeIsIt?TheVitaMacrinaeofGregoryofNyssa,”SP37(1999):35.
(158.)Girardi,197–198.
(159.)GregoryofNyssa,LifeofSaintMacrina,Corrigan,35.
(160.)MoniqueAlexandre,“Lesnouveauxmartyrs.Motifsmartyrologiquesdanslaviedessaintsetthèmeshagiographiquesdansl’ÉlogedesmartyrschezGrégoiredeNysse,”inThe
Page 51
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 51 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
BiographicalWorksofGregoryofNyssa.ProceedingsoftheFifthInternationalColloquiumonGregoryofNyssa,PatristicMonographSeries,vol.12,ed.AndreasSpira(Cambridge,MA:PhiladelphiaPatristicsFoundation,1984),38.
(161.)PhilipRousseau,“ThePiousHouseholdandtheVirginChorus,ReflectionsonGregoryofNyssa’sLifeofMacrina,”JECS13(2005):172.
(162.)LisaMaugansDriver,“TheCultoftheMartyrsinAsteriusofAmaseia’sVisionoftheChristianCity,”CH74(2005):245.
(163.)GrégoiredeNysse:ViedeSainteMacrine,inGrégoiredeNysse:ViedeSainteMacrine,ed.andtrans.PierreMaraval,SC,vol.178(Paris:ÉditionsduCerf,1971),88.
(164.)Alexandre,34–46.
(165.)GregoryofNyssa,Encomiuminxlmartyresii,PG46.784.56–785.30.Nyssendoesnotsaythathewasbaptizedasaresultofthisincident,buttorelatethedramaoftheeventandthegreateffectithaduponhislifeindicateshowpowerfulitwasforhim.Healsosaysspecificallythathewasstillalaypersonwhenthemartyrsvisitedhiminadream.Soonafterwardhewasbaptized.HeclaimsMacrinaandBasilashisteachers,butthedramaticspiritualinterventioninhislifeisreservedfortheFortyMartyrs.
(166.)VanDam,BecomingChristian,141.
(167.)Bernardi,304.
(168.)Driver,245.
(169.)Girardi,179.
(170.)BasilofCaesarea,Letter252,TLG2040.05–06,mytranslation;seealsothetranslationinNPNF,vol.8,292.
(171.)BasilofCaesarea,HomilyontheFortyMartyrsofSebaste,in“LetUsDiethatWeMayLive,”GreekHomiliesonChristianMartyrsfromAsiaMinor,Palestine,andSyria,ed.andtrans.JohanLeemans,WendyMayer,PaulineAllen,andBoudewijnDehandschutter(London:Routledge,2003),68.
(172.)GregoryofNazianzus,Epigram78,Paton,432–433.
(173.)Basil,Letter30,NPNF,vol.8,134.
(174.)Itisbeyondtheintentionofmyinquirytoanalyzetheliterarygenreoftheepitaphioslogos.HägghasprovidedathoroughliteraryanalysisofGregoryofNazianzus’funeralencomiaforhisfamily.SeeHägg,“PlayingwithExpectations,”133–151.
(175.)HippolyteDelehaye,Lespassionsdesmartyrsetlesgenreslittéraires(Brussels:SociétédesBollandistes,1921),184,202;Leemans,22–23.Afullerdiscussionofthepanegyricstothemartyrsisinchapter4.
Page 52
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 52 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
(176.)Hägg,“PlayingwithExpectations,”137,footnote16.
(177.)Delehaye,Lespassions,187.
(178.)StephanosEfthymiadis,“TwoGregoriesandThreeGenres,”inGregoryofNazianzus,ImagesandReflections,eds.JosteinBørtnesandTomasHägg(Copenhagen:MuseumTusculanumPress,2006),240.
(179.)Ibid.Efthymiadis’pointaboutGregoryhavingwrittenhisownautohagiographyforlatergenerationsonlystrengthensmypointhere;seeespecially245–249.
(180.)PeterBrown,“EnjoyingtheSaintsinLateAntiquity,”EME9(2000):12.HecitestheexampleofmatronProiectaofRome.“Damasushadnohesitationaboutwritingofherasifshewerealreadyinheaven,withthemartyrs,andevenhintedthat,fromheaven,shenowbroughtcomforttoherentirefamily.”
(181.)Delehaye,Lespassions,187
(182.)Ibid.,188.
(183.)GregoryofNazianzus,Discours42–43,inGrégoiredeNazianze,SC,vol.384,trans.JeanBernardi(Paris:ÉditionsduCerf,1992),29.
(184.)GregoryofNazianzus,OnCaesarius,10,NPNF,vol.7,233.
(185.)Ibid.,12,233.
(186.)Ibid.,14,234.
(187.)Ibid.,17,235.
(188.)GregoryofNazianzus,Epigrams52,77,99,Paton,424–425,432–433,442–443.
(189.)GregoryofNazianzus,OnHisSisterGorgonia,NPNF,vol.7,238–245.
(190.)GregoryofNazianzus,Discours6–12,inGrégoiredeNazianze,SC,vol.405,trans.Marie-AngeCalvet-Sebasti(Paris:ÉditionsduCerf,1978),38.
(191.)GregoryofNazianzus,OnHisSisterGorgonia,6,NPNF,vol.7,239.
(192.)Ibid.,8,240.
(193.)Ibid.
(194.)Momigliano,212.
(195.)ThisepisodeofGorgonia’smiracleisdealtwithmorefullyinchapter4.
(196.)GregoryofNazianzus,OnHisSisterGorgonia,23,NPNF,vol.7,245.
(197.)Ibid.
Page 53
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 53 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
(198.)GregoryofNazianzus,Epigram101,Paton,444–445.
(199.)GregoryofNazianzus,OntheDeathofHisFather,NPNF,vol.7,255–269.
(200.)Nonna’smiraclesdoqualifyherasamartyr,butthesewillbedealtwithinchapter4.
(201.)JohnMcGuckin,“Gregory:TheRhetoricianasPoet,”inGregoryofNazianzus,ImagesandReflections,eds.JosteinBørtnesandTomasHägg(Copenhagen:MuseumTusculanumPress,2006),204–205.
(202.)GregoryofNazianzus,Epigram99,Paton,442–443.
(203.)Ibid.,Epigrams52,424–425;77,432–433;99,442–443.
(204.)Ibid.,Epigrams33,416–417;52b(quamartyr),424–425.36(miracleworker),35(intercessor).
(205.)Ibid.,Epigram33,416–417.
(206.)Ibid.,Epigrams68,74,430–431,emphasisadded.
(207.)Ibid.,Epigram52,424–425,emphasisadded.
(208.)Ibid.,Epigram37,418–419,emphasisadded.
(209.)GregoryofNazianzus,PanegyriconSt.Basil,6,NPNFvol.7,397.
(210.)Ibid.,74,420.
(211.)GregoryofNazianzus,Discours42–43,Bernardi,33.
(212.)Ibid.,37.
(213.)GregoryofNazianzus,PanegyriconSt.Basil,80,NPNF,vol.7,421.
(214.)Ibid.,422.
(215.)Ibid.
(216.)GregoryofNazianzus,Epigram5,Paton,402–403.
(217.)GregoryofNyssa,Encomiuminxlmartyresii,PG46.776.9–14;Bernardi,265,304.
(218.)ThoughJeanRobertPouchetandPierreMaravalhavefullyarguedforachangeofdateforBasil’sdeathto378,Iamnotconvinced.SeeJeanRobertPouchet,“Ladatedel’électionépiscopaledesaintBasileetcelledesamort,”RHE87(1992):5–33.
(219.)Momigliano,217.
(220.)GregoryofNyssa,EulogyforBasiltheGreat,trans.RichardMcCambly.Available:http://www.sage.edu/faculty/salmond/nyssa/basil.html,1–22.Thoughtwoyearsbefore,inthe
Page 54
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 54 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
secondhomilyontheFortyMartyrs,Nyssencalledhisbrothera“saintwhoservedthesaints,”thepraisesforhisbrotherthereareconsistentwiththisfuneralpanegyric.Heisagreatteacher,wisestatesman,andaccomplishedbishop.GregoryofNyssa,Encomiuminxlmartyresii,PG46.776.1–16.Seealsochapter2,thesection“EkphrasisasPedagogy.”
(221.)GregoryofNyssa,EulogyforBasiltheGreat,McCambly,19.
(222.)Momigliano,212.
(223.)GregoryofNyssa,EulogyforBasiltheGreat,McCambly,12.
(224.)Ibid.,14.
(225.)Ibid.,18.
(226.)VanDam,Families,79.
(227.)DerekKrueger,“WritingandtheLiturgyofMemoryinGregoryofNyssa’sLifeofMacrina,”JECS8(2000):501;GregoryofNyssa,ViedeSainteMacrine,Maraval,25.
(228.)Krueger,506.
(229.)Rousseau,“ThePiousHousehold,”172.
(230.)GregoryofNyssa,LifeofSaintMacrina,Corrigan,30.
(231.)Ibid.,31.
(232.)Ibid.,32.
(233.)Alexandre,39.
(234.)GregoryofNyssa,LifeofSaintMacrina,Corrigan,40.
(235.)Ibid.,43;GregoryofNyssa,ViedeSainteMacrine,Maraval,32–34.
(236.)GregoryofNyssa,LifeofSaintMacrina,Corrigan,44.
(237.)ThoughGregoryframestheprayerinitiallywiththe“brideofChrist”imagery,castingMacrinaasthebridefinallyabouttoattainherbeloved,herprayerconveysnoneofthis.Herprayerisadefenseboldlydeclaiminghersufferingequaltothatofamartyr(thoughobviouslyhepennedtheprayeraswell).
(238.)GregoryofNyssa,LifeofSaintMacrina,Corrigan,49.Italicsaddedforemphasis.
(239.)Ibid.
(240.)Ibid.
(241.)Ibid.,54.
Page 55
Kinship with the Martyrs
Page 55 of 55
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2014.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: CentralEuropean University Library; date: 07 August 2014
(242.)GregoryofNyssa,ViedeSainteMacrine,Maraval,84–85.
(243.)GregoryofNyssa,LifeofSaintMacrina,Corrigan,56.
(244.)Ibid.,57.
(245.)“Touncovernakedness”isabiblicaleuphemismforsexualintercourse.Lv18:1–30specifiessexualprohibitionsformaintenanceofthehonorofthefamily.Italicsaddedforemphasis.SeeMichaelD.Coogan,ed.,NewOxfordAnnotatedBible(NewYork:OxfordUniversityPress,2001),168–169.
(246.)GregoryofNyssa,OnVirginity,XIII,NPNF,vol.5,359.“Weshouldweanourselvesfromthislifeintheflesh,whichhasaninevitablefollower,death….Itcouldnotbeindeedthatdeathshouldceaseworkingaslongasthehumanracebymarriagewasworkingtoo.”Gregoryalwaysallowsthatsexualintercourseleadingtoprocreationistheremedialmechanismpreventinghumanity’sextinctionaftertheFall.
(247.)GregoryofNyssa,LifeofSaintMacrina,Corrigan,59.ThathedwellssomuchonthecharacteristicsofadeadbodyinthispassageisproofenoughthathehassubsumedthesexualconnotationoftheLeviticusinjunctioncompletelyinsex’stheologicalandontologicalramification—death.
(248.)Girardi,177.
(249.)Macrina’smiraclesarediscussedatlengthinchapter4ofthisbook.
(250.)GregoryofNyssa,LifeofSaintMacrina,Corrigan,27.
(251.)GregoryofNyssa,FirstHomilyontheFortyMartyrs,Ib,Leemans,98.
(252.)Jacobs,280.
Accessbroughttoyouby: CentralEuropeanUniversity
Library