Karl Barth on the nature of Religion

8/12/2019 Karl Barth on the nature of Religion

1/21

!"#$%&' )*+,-. /0*1" 2*13& #4 56",%,#$7 *4- 8116",%,#$7 8-#"*319: 84!"#$%&'() +%$,-

.#',/01 02 &/- 304$-5 -%'$( 67"%0,85 %2" 9/'0,&0%20&(: ;-,36- &64 !. 2*13#4'

=36>&64. ?6@ A#1BC DED !"*1B' FGGH' FIJKFFH.

L3#> #M >*%6 FIJN

"#$% $'( )* +,%-.-)/0 #*1 2$$,%-.-)/0 21)%#'$3

)*+,- !"#$%&

O7 M*1 *7 P61Q*49 ,7 R#4R6146-' 3&6 R1,3,R,7Q #M 16",%,#4 &*7 "636-' *4- 3&6 R1,3,R,7Q #M 16",%,#4 ,7 3&6 >167$>>#7,3,#4 #M *"" R1,3,R,7Q

S D&6 M#$4-*3,#4 #M ,116",%,#$7 R1,3,R,7Q ,7 3&,7C Q*4 Q*B67 16",%,#4' 16",%,#4

-#67 4#3 Q*B6 Q*4.T0*1" U*1V' IWXX

IY

!&1,73,*4,39 16>1#*R&6- &6*3&64,7Q M#1 ,-#"*319' Z1#3673*43,7Q 16>1#*R&6-

!*3",R,7Q' #1 6*1"9 !&1,73,*4,39' M#1 ,-#"*319' *4- 5*3,#4*",7Q 4#@

16>1#*R&67 Z1#3673*43,7Q' *3 "6*73 3&6 #"-61 #13-#V Z1#3673*43,7Q' M#1

,-#"*319' 7 * Q*4 *7 P#-' *4- 3&616M#16 *4 ,Q*%6 #M P#-[

M#1 3&*3 ,7 @&*3 Q*4 ,7[,4 >"*R6 #M 3&6 #1,%,4*"' ,4 >"*R6 #M 16*"


2/21

F

*4 6V61R,76 3&*3 *"7# Q*B67 R"6*1 *3&7 3&*3 *16 #>64 3# 3&6#"#%,R*" 64]$,19

*4- 3&6 >*3&7 3&*3 *16 M#1$"76 ,4 &$Q*4 #77,,R3$167 #M -6,3,67' @,3&

*"Q#73 *"@*97 *4- 6+619@&616 3&6 >,R3$16 #M * 7$>16Q6 *4- #4"9 -6,39 Q#16

#1 "677 R"6*1"9 +,7, Q*9 6173,3,#4m #13# @Q ,3 #$%&3 4#3 3# 6R3 3&6 M,173 7>6R,67 #M 3&,7 %64$7 ,7 k,-#"*319l'

@&,R& $4-$"9 %,+67 -,+,46 #$1 3# * R16*3$16.: TO]$,4*7' A788% E/-#$#=0%-' 31*47.

_*3&617 #M 3&6 ;4%",7& )#Q,4,R*4 Z1#+,4R6 T?6@ A#1BC 264i,%61 21#7.' IdXHY' FnF'

dF.FY.X0*1" 2*13&' 9/7'B/ D#=8%&0B,' 6-. P. f. 21#Q,"69 *4- D. _. D#11*4R6' 31*47. P. D.

DQ7#4 *4- `*1#"- 04,%&3' +#". 8gF T;-,4


3/21

J

7*3,7M9 3&,7 466-' &6 736>7 #$3 ,4 * Q643 ,4 16",%,#4 M1#Q "#@61 M#1Q7 3# &,%&61C >*43&6,7Q %,+67 @*9 3#

>#"93&6,7Q' >#"93&6,7Q 3# Q#4#3&6,7Q' *4- Q#4#3&6,7Q #M >*%6 FIhN

3# *3&6,7Q.eO>*13 M1#Q 3&6 "*73 736>' Q*49 !&1,73,*4 3&6#"#%,*47 &*+6 7664 Q61,3 ,4

3&,7 *RR#$43C ,3 766Q7 &,73#1,R*""9 16*7#4*


4/21

X

/H-02IJ,7 3&6 #46K@#1- 3,3"6 #M 3&6 31*R3 2*13& @1#36 ,4 167>#476 3# 21$4461:7

@#1B' @&,R& 64-6- 3&6,1 M1,64-7&,>.H2*13& R#47,-616- 3&*3 3&6 *>>1#*R& 3# 4*3$1*"

3&6#"#%9 21$4461 &*- *-#>36- 3&16*3646- 3# "#76 *"" 3&6 %1#$4- 3&69 &*- 673*16>*1*3#19 73*%6 #M 3&6 761+,R6 #M 3&6 31$6 P#-a:W2*13&:7 46%*3,+6 *47@61 3# 3&,7

]$673,#4 16737 #4 &,7 "#7,+6 R#QQ643*19' /D&6 ?,%&3:' *4- #4

+6176 FJ R#QQ6437C

D&69 R&*4%6- 3&6 %"#19 #M 3&6 ,4R#11$>3,61R6,+6 3&,7 -,73,4R3,#4' &*7

%'$ 3%'&/' IhW.

dK7+/-472=,7 * -,MM,R$"3 @#1- 3# 31*47"*36. P*11633 P1664 R#QQ6437 /2*13& &*7


5/21

h

61,64R6. 84 *"" 3&,7 Q,73 3&6 >1,Q6 M*R3#1 ,7 >1#+,-6- #77,61,64R6. 2*13& @,346776- 3# @ 3&,7 M#R$7 #4 3&6 &$Q*4

"6*-7 3# *"" Q*4461 #M Q$1B9 16"*3,#47&,>7


6/21


7/21

H

P643,"67 ,4 3&6Q76"+67 *4- *7 7$R&' 1#R"*Q*3,#4 3# 3&6 O3&64,*47 3&*3 &6 @,"" Q*B6 B4#@4 3&6 $4B4#@4 %#- 3&69 &*+6

>,4% 3&1#$%& ,-#"7. O%*,4' 2*13& *1%$67 3&*3 Z*$" ,7 4#3 16M611,4% 3# 7#Q6

,4-6>64-643 B4#@"6-%6 #M P#- -61,+6- M1#Q R16*3,#4' 617#47 *16

>"*R6- ,4 ,1,3:C /?#@' =>,1,3 ,7 3&6 -,16R3 -64,*" #M ,QQ6-,*R9. 8M

!&1,73 >#7,4%

-,16R3 R#QQ$4,R*3,#4 @,3& P#- ,7 >#77,"6[3&676 -,+,4,3,67 *16 3&1#@4 $> ,4 3&6 Q#73 6V31*+*%*43 4$Q


8/21

W

M63,7&,7Q ,7 >6*1 ,4 @&,R& P#- ,7 6V>61,64R6 ,4 /167643*3,#47 #M `,7

R16*3,+6 **13,R$"*1 @#1B7[,4 3&6

-6361Q,4,4% *4- $7,4% #M R613*,4 R16*3$16"9 16*",3,67 3# 163 3&6 16R$11643 M#1Q$"* /O4- P#- 7*,-: *7 >1##M 3&*3 3&6 2,#B6 3# U#767 M*R6 3# M*R6' *7 *

Q*4 3# &,7 M1,64-. D&,7 R*44#3 Q6*4 -,16R3 64R#$4361' 2*13& *1%$67' *77*%6 %#67 #4 3# *MM,1Q 3&*3 4# #46 R*4 766 P#- *4- ",+6. ;+64 ,4 3&,7 Q#73 1*16 #M

64R#$43617' U#767 ,7 >61Q,336- #4"9 3&6 7,%&3 #M P#- M1#Q 3&6 &*" T2"##Q,4%3#4C 84-,*4* c4,+617,39 Z1677' IdddY' IXXneW.


9/21

d

3&6 >1#>&637 16>#13 P#-:7 7>66R&' 2*13& *1%$67' 3&69 *16 3673,M9,4% 3# @&*3 3&69 &*+6

7664 #M P#-:7 *R3,+,39 ,4 3&6 @#1"-. P#- 16*""9 73*4-7 "*R6' 4#3 ,4 * -,16R3' *13 M1#Q P#-:7 16+6"*3,#4m M*,3& "##B7 3# 3&6 @#1"- @,3& 3&6 *,Q #M 16R6,+,4% P#-:7

@#1- *7 ,3 ,7 Q6-,*36- 3&1#$%& R16*36- 16*",39.

FI2*13&' 9/7'B/ D#=8%&0B,88gI' Id.FF

2*13&' 9/7'B/ D#=8%&0B,88gI' FG. _#1 * 16M"6R3,#4 #4 3&6 +6,"6-4677 #M !&1,73 ,4

2*13&:7 3&6#"#%9' 766 D16+#1 `*13' /D&6 f#1-' 3&6 f#1-7 *4- 3&6 f,34677C

Z1#R"*Q*3,#4 *7 ),+,46 *4- `$Q*4 56*",39: ,4


10/21

IG

D&616 R*4 1#%1677,+6 -6+6"#>Q643 #M 16",%,#4' 3&616M#16' *7 _6$61#,43 #M 16+6"*3,#4 ,3 3## R*4 *36 @&*3 P#- ,4 `,7 16+6"*3,#4 @,""7 3# -# *4- -#67

-#. 83 ,7 3&6 *336Q>36- 16>"*R6Q643 #M 3&6 -,+,46 @#1B *13 M1#Q 16+6"*3,#4' !&1,73,*47 &*+6 3&6 -$39 3# *>>"9 P#-:7 \$-%6Q643 #4 16",%,#4

M,173"9 *4- Q#73 *R$36"9 3# 3&6Q76"+67.Fe8 &*+6 *"16*-9 16M6116- 3# 2*13&:7 +,6@ #M 3&6

-,7*731#$7 3$14 #M P61Q*4 Z1#3673*43 3&6#"#%9 ,4 3&6 Id3&

*4- 6*1"9 FG3&

R643$1,67.

f&64 &6 3$147 3# 5#Q*4 !*3",R

L3#> #M >*%6 FFGN

3&6#"#%9 &,7 R1,3,]$6 ,7 4# "677 76+616' R"*,Q,4% 3&*3 3&6 >1#


11/21

II

f6 16\6R3 3&,7 "67 *4- @,3& Q*361,*"7 3*B64

M1#Q 3&6,1 >,""*17 *4- M$14,7&,4%7 S D&,7 %#67 3# 7@ 3&*3 @&,"6 3&6

-6+*"$*3,#4 *4- 46%*3,#4 #M @&*3 ,7 &$Q*4 Q*9 #RR*7,#4*""9 &*+6 * >1*R3,R*"

*4- 79Q


12/21

IF

L3#> #M >*%6 FFIN

16+6"*3,#4 R*4 1676436- *7

#&616 *>*13 M1#Q 3&6 >",%&3 #M 3&6 46,%&3$16 ,4 16"*3,#4 3# 3&6 R&$1R& ,7 >1676436- *7 3&6 ",M6"677 R*"Q #M

,R9 Q#$43*,4 >6*B7mJh#1 @&64 3&6 R&$1R& &6*17 P#-:7 @#1- @,3$3 *R3,4% #4 ,3'

Q*B,4% 3&6 f#1- #M P#- ,43# * ",M6"677 ,-#".Je

O"#4%7,-6 3&676 *"6137 3# @

16+6"*3,#4 R*4 %# @1#4%' 2*13& #MM617 * 761,67 #M R1,361,* M#1 @ 3&6 R&$1R& R*4 *+#,-

,-#"*319C 3&*3 ,3 ,7 3&6 4*Q6 #M !&1,73 3&*3 M$4R3,#47 *7 3&6 M,4*" 3673'JH

3&*3 3&6 B69

]$673,#4 ,7 @&63&61 3&6 *-&616437 *4- 16>167643*3,+67 *16 16*""9 P#-:7 R&$1R&'JW

*4-

3&*3 3&6 ,77$6 ,7 @&63&61 !&1,73,*47 &*+6 M#$4- %1*R6 64-643 #4 3&6 %1*R6 *4- 16+6"*3,#4 #M P#-.XG

D&616M#16 3&676 *"6137 *4- 36737' 6,3&61

JI0*1" 2*13&' 9/7'B/ D#=8%&0B,' 6-. P. f. 21#Q,"69 *4- D. _. D#11*4R6' 31*47. P.

f. 21#Q,"69' +#". 8gI T;-,4


13/21

IJ

,4-,+,-$*""9 #1 R#""6R3,+6"9' @,"" 4#3 &63,R \$-%6Q643 87*,*& #1 OQ#7

>1#4#$4R6- #4 3&6,1 R#436Q>#1*1,67. 2*13&:7 *"6137 *4- 36737 *,Q 3# B66> $7 *@*16 #M

3&6 R#473*43 >,3M*""7 ,43# @&,R& @6 Q*9 M*"" ,4 #$1 16",%,#$7 ",M6' 4#3 3# >1#+,-6

7$>>#13 M#1 #$1 64-6Q,R >16#RR$>*3,#4 @,3& 76"MK\$73,M,R*3,#4.

L3#> #M >*%6 FFFN

85 6(, -1)%#'$3 )7 *#'-)*0

8-#"*319 ,7 3&616M#16 * 16",%,#$7 >1#&616. 84 IdFF' ,4 &,7$1>#76 *4- R#43643 *4- 64-. O4- 4#@ Q64 &*+6 16*""9


14/21

IX

8M 3&,7 @*7 R"6*1 ,4 IdFF' ,3 #4- 3# 3&676 -6+6"#>Q6437' 2*13& R#47,-616- ,3 R1$R,*" 3# $4-6173*4-

3&6Q M#1 @&*3 3&69 @616C 4#3 Q616 1&63#1,R' 4#3 Q616 >#",3,R7' 4#3 7#Q6 ,46V>",R*"*R6?-02 >%81+#4 3&6 *"3*1 Q643 *7 /3&6 "*73' M$""673 *4- @#173 Q#4731#7,39 #M 46#K

XJD,Q#3&9 P#11,4%6'>%'$ 3%'&/) K=%02,& G-=-8#2(TbVM#1-C !"*164-#4 Z1677'

IdddY' IFdnJG.


15/21

Ih

L3#> #M >*%6 FFJN

Z1#3673*43,7Q:' 61M6R3"9 R"6*1 3&*3 @6 *16 4#3 R#K#>61*3,4% ,4 3&*3 16+617*" #M 16+6"*3,#4 *4-

16",%,#4. D# >$3 ,3 R#4R1636"9' @6 *16 -6M64R6"677 *%*,473 3&6 kP61Q*4

!&1,73,*47l #M #$1 #@4 3,Q6' $4"677 @6 B4#@ @ 3# %$*1- *%*,473 3&6

-6+6"#>Q643 @&,R& 3##B >"*R6 ,4 +*4 D," *4- 2$--6$7' *4- 6+64 6*1",61.XX

_#1 3&,7 16*7#4' 3&6 IdJX 2*1Q64 )6R"*1*3,#4 #M 3&6 !#4M677,4% !&$1R&' @&,R& 2*13&

-1*M36-' @*7 4#3 >1,Q*1,"9 * -64#$4R,4% #M #>>#46437' $37 2*13&:7 ,47,7364R6 #4 3&6 >1,#1,39 #M 16+6"*3,#4' *4-

&,7 16\6R3,#4 #M *"3614*3,+6 7#$1R67 #M B4#@"6-%6 #M P#-' ,4 R#436V3C

k8 *Q 3&6 f*9 *4- 3&6 D1$3& *4- 3&6 ^,M6m 4# #46 R#Q67 3# 3&6 _*3&61 6VR6>3

3&1#$%& Q6l S

j67$7 !&1,73' *7 &6 ,7 *336736- 3# $7 ,4 `#"9 =R1,>3$16' ,7 3&6 #46 f#1- #M P#-

@Q @6 &*+6 3# &6*1' *4- @Q @6 &*+6 3# 31$73 *4- #1#R"*Q*3,#4' #@617' &,73#1,R M,%$167' *4- 31$3&7 *7 P#-:7 16+6"*3,#4.Xh

D&6 ,43,Q*36 R#446R3,#4 2*13& 7*@ %'$ 3%'&/' IXd. ?#36 P1664:7

,-643,M,R*3,#4 #M 3&6 M,4*" M#$1 *""$7,#47 3# `,3"61:7 76,i$16 #M >#@61 ,4 IdJJ' 3&6

6V*"3,4% #M /


16/21

Ie

3&6 kD&,1- 56,R&l #M O-#"M `,3"61 Q*-6 7&,>@16RB. ^63 3&,7 764364R6 6-' *4- *3 #46 XhG >1#>&637 #M

2**" *16 *"@*97 ,4 M6*1 #M 3&6,1

L3#> #M >*%6 FFXN

",+67. 267,-6 P#- 3&616 *16 #4"9 `,7 R16*3$167 #1 M*"76 %#-7' *4- 1#M#$4- R#4+,R3,#4 /3&*3 P#-

R#473,3$367 #$1 16*",39' *4- R*44#3 3&616M#16 #",3,R7 ,4 IdJG7 P61Q*49' @,3$3 *"7# >*$7,4% 3# 16M"6R3 #4

3&6 >#77,#",3,R7 ,4 #$1 -*9. _#1 3#-*9' *7 3&64' @#1"- 6+6437 *16

-#Q,4*36- 1,4%167,-643,*" *--167767' \$73 *7 @6 &*+6 ,4

3&6 7>66R&67 #M P61Q*4 >#",3,R,*47 %'$ 3%'&/5 IXh.


17/21

IH

646Q,67 @ /6Q*13,R$"*1 c? 167#"$3,#47. b$1 M,173 3*7B7 *7 3&6#"#%,*47 *16 3# 16M"6R3 #4

3&6 3&6#"#%,R*" Q6*4,4% #M 3&6 @#1-7 $76- ,4 7$R& -6#131*97 3&6

/?#KP#-: @#17&,>>6- Cgg@@@.4$Q$3gZ*%6IHeh.*7>Y.


18/21

IW

,43#"61*&,7319 @,3& @&,R& Q64 *336Q>3 3# \$73,M9 &,Q.

b4"9 *137 R#Q>*49' M#1 2*13&' ,7 @&616 3&6

R1,3,]$6 *77 *3&6,7Q. _#1 *3&6,7Q *4- 16",%,#4 &*+6 Q$R& ,4

R#QQ#4C

84 3&6,1 %6461*" +,6@ #M 3&6 @#1"- 7R,643,737 *4- &,73#1,*47 *16 ,4 M*1 R"#761

*%166Q643 @,3& >&,"#7#>&617 *4- 3&6#"#%,*47 3&*4 ,7 4#1Q*""9 16R#%4,i6-. 83

,7 4#3 Q616"9 3&*3 3&6 @#1"- 6V,737 7,-6 "*R6' *4- &*7 ,376"M


19/21

Id

7*Q6 -6+#3,#4 @&,R& 3&6 #"-KM*7&,#46- #@617 3# @&,R& 3&6 *3&6,73 $7$*""9

7$,673 *4- Q#73 4*,+6 R16-$",39:. 837 -64,*"7 %,+6 1,76 3# ,-#"*319

*4- 76"MK1,%&36#$74677' #>64,4% 3&6 -##1 *%*,4 3# 6+619 B,4- #M 16",%,#$7 %"#1,M,R*3,#4.

D&,7 Q6*47 /83 ,7 16*""9 #>>#76- 3# 16",%,#4 #4"9 *7 3&6 7>1,4% ,7 3# 3&6 1,+61' *7 3&6

1##3 3# 3&6 3166' *7 3&6 $4#@61 3# -6+,76 *4-

M#1Q %#-7 ,7 3# 1#


20/21

FG

*RR#1-,4% 3# 2*13&'he

*4- &6 ,7 Q61R,"677 ,4 ,-643,M9,4% 3&6 ,-#"*31#$7 >#77,16R,*36- 3&6 >61," #M 3&6,1 >#7,3,#4' !&1,73,*47 7$"- 7,4% ,43# 3&6 1*R3,R67 &*+6 Q61,3 #M 3&6Q76"+67' *>*13

M1#Q 3&6 %1*R6 #M P#-. D&69 @,"" R#43,4$6 3&676 >1*R3,R67[3&616 ,7 4# *"3614*3,+6 3#

16",%,#4[ P#- ,7 4#3 *4 67R*>6 M1#Q ,-#"*319C ,3 R*4 M16]$643"9 167$"3 ,4 3&6

616R3,#4 #M ,-#"7 3# M,"" 3&6 7>*R6 M#1Q61"9 #RR$>,6-. D&6#"#%9 &*7 3&6 >#3643,*" 3#

he2*13&' 9/7'B/ D#=8%&0B,8gF' FWX.


21/21

#MM61 * Q#16 1*-,R*" R1,3,]$6 3&*4 *3&6,7Q' *MM,1Q,4% @,3& U*1V 3&*3 &$Q*4B,4- Q*B67

16",%,#4'

Karl Barth on the nature of Religion

Documents