Top Banner
KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES Congress May 2003: Ivan G. Somlai & Philip Cox; + (virtually) the CSF Team & Prem Maharjan
35

KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Jan 04, 2016

Download

Documents

Kellie Walton
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

KalTim Social Forestry Project

Executing Agency : The University College of the CaribooDonor: CIDA

Participatory Evaluation January/02Presenters at CES Congress May 2003:

Ivan G. Somlai & Philip Cox; + (virtually) the CSF Team & Prem Maharjan

Page 2: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Brunei=green; Malaysia=red; Indonesia=black

Page 3: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

KALimantan TIMur Relief Map

Page 4: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Mahakam River Arteries

Page 5: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Extent & Distribution of Logging Concessions

Page 6: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Burns

Page 7: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

1956 Hotspots !

Page 8: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Fire Fighting

Page 9: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Vegetation and land use classesArea[ha]

Burned[ha]

Burned%

Open land, alang alang, bushland 368,860 292,569 79.3

Lowland Dipterocarp forest 5,379,562 2,177,880 40.5

Farmland mixed with degraded forest areas, including Forest and Estate crop plantations *

2,304,263 1,725,735 75.5

Mangrove forest 1,042,127 91,729 8.8

Shrimp ponds 57,187 316 0.6

Swamp (peat swamp) forest 426,051 311,098 73.0

Wetlands 358,750 290,432 81.0

Mountainous region, mainly highland Dipterocarp forest 3,551,826 213,194 6.0

Total 13,488,626 5,102,954 37.8

Burned Areas

Page 10: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Rolling on the River

Page 11: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

CSF Headquarters

Page 12: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Environmental Links

Page 13: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

What the Centre for Social Forestry Does…

• Provides education and training in social forestry to stakeholder organizations and to UNMUL faculty and students (including compulsory undergraduate course);

• Conducts social forestry research to better understand the issues related to the sustainability of forests and their impact on forest communities;

• Assists local communities in better managing the forests;

Page 14: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

What CSF Does…

• Assists government, private companies, and other stakeholders in formulating policies and programs to promote social forestry;

• Develops community-based programs for sustainable forest management with mutual benefits to all stakeholders; and

• Provides information related to social forestry and natural resources.

Page 15: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Photogenic Orang Utan

Page 16: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Not-so Photogenic Orang

Page 17: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Investment of Time in Participatory Evaluation

• Evaluation Design• Orientation• Information Collection

(including field visits)• Analysis and

Documentation• Presentation and

Finalization of the Report

• 6 months (20 pd) • 2 days (25 pd)• 11 days (70 pd)

3 days ( 6 pd)

• 4 days (10 pd)

Page 18: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Asian (Nepali) Perspective

Page 19: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Orientation Seminar

Page 20: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Interviews

Page 21: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Careful Packing for Our Trip

Page 22: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

The “E” Team on the River

Page 23: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

A River “Pasar”

Page 24: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

NTFP & Gender Considerations

Page 25: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Home Sweet Home

Page 26: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Focus Groups

Page 27: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Socio-Economic Research

Page 28: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Log Transport

Page 29: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Sumalindo Meeting

Page 30: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Chained to his Big Mac

Page 31: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

Report Cover

Page 32: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

So What?…10 Propositions for Discussion

1. Evaluation Methods must be compatible with Project/Program Management Style and Purpose

2. 'Objectivity' in evaluations can be enhanced with broad stakeholder participation and the involvement of external evaluators

3. Participatory evaluations require careful preparation and orchestration

4. Results based logic models can be a very helpful point of reference in the evaluation inquiry

5. Participatory evaluations can build mutual understanding and trust between stakeholders

Page 33: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

10 Propositions, Continued…

6. Successful participatory evaluations allow critical reflection only when there is an atmosphere of mutual trust

7. Participatory evaluations can give staff the opportunity to a) examine their work from different vantage points and b) to consider findings/recommendations for future strategic planning

8. Care must be taken to balance transparency (and the public interest) with confidentiality - participatory evaluation should not erode the strategic position of the organization/ program/ project

9. At times, there are ethical considerations with the participation of potentially competing groups

10. Participatory evaluation practices can help the public to hold authorities accountable at many levels (local to national)

Page 34: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.

To Remoter Communities

Page 35: KalTim Social Forestry Project Executing Agency : The University College of the Cariboo Donor: CIDA Participatory Evaluation January/02 Presenters at CES.