This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
\vegsdd! mg~gk|bif d ndef~f f hf }|bċbiv(Ad~ if 30(3;(<33>( kgndhf! v eabnvb Ybeghgj g dhmg|jdbhiv! b hbghg}v |ifŢfhib l|gi 23*>3*2>?=;'3>vsdbh v f}dnfhov ib}hd` kabdabLghf d @f|ofkg}dhf sgn |fnhdj l|gifj >2(Hb ghg}v jdŢaifhib Mfnf|bahgkjdhd~b|~}b gl|byg}bhib d hbvef l|gi36*26*<064'3> gn 3<(3;(<33>( kgndhf‑Ebebhief hg}dhf‚ v s|gdy}gn hbegid f hf sabċb sg|fy hb s|gjf~s|gdy}gnb(
źd|g |bĊvh92?>*3<3*333330?<>> egn DE lbhef Yfhdob
V]GNHDE
]fċ hfeg }|fjf sg kab}d jdav~b dnfib nb de|d~devifj jhg*kd ċf |fċd! d hf yhbŢ hdŢ~b n|vkg$d djfj }f hg}ghb~baf eb*ebhief ‘jbhdmf~bof‚( Dnfib ifvs|b}g s|fhffhb hb sbsd|! b}f g~bag Ţ~g dnf vy hiv! g~dŢag if v yblg|b}! jgŸnb lbŢ ylgk~gkb Ţ~g jd if }bŢ~b sbnbag hbsbjf~! b jb~f|bab Ċd~bi9 jbhd*mf~bob$ djb d s|f}dŢf( Nb ifegidj avĊbifj gnkbĒbhif dylg*|b yb n}dif kgndhf hbdŢag hbsgyd~d}bh gnife! hbŢb jbab
|fndhb ldab ld ve|bċfhb yb g}fhbihbs|fnhf ~fsbŢef s|d|fn* lf yb ~f d~f n}f kgndhf( Ebnbbj }fċ egn g}gk gnkbĒbhib dylg|b!hbjb ‘jbadj‚ aivndjb ~g hdebeg hf lddŢag v s|dagk( Ybjdad~f nb f ifndhfgsċd d agebahd dylg|d! sb nb lvnv }befs|f~vshf kgndhf! ghnb hbŢf }ab~d f hf ld ~gadeg ~|ybaf hb hbŢf yb`~if}f! b egadeg ld hb ~fe ghnb ldag v s|fnvyfċv yb hf*ybsgafhf! hbŢfj n|bkgj LD\G*v( _n|vkf ~|bhf! n}f kgndhf l|yg s|gĒv d}beg jbag f e|fhf v s|fndylg|hv ebj*sbhiv! b jd eg|g gsf~ hb d~gj(
2233 EJ yb ‘Nbhf sd~f‚Hg! nb f }|b~dj hb! ebeg }fċ hby}b`!~fsbŢef s|d|fnlf( Hf jgkv d` hdebegn|vkbĊf hby}b~d! if| v ghf lbŢ ~be}f d}f v v g|kbhdybod ‘N|vŢ~}b ifnhgkadob‚( _~dŸf jd hb jbda gn |fnbeof Eb*ebhied` hg}dhb hfŢ~g }fybhg yb gsċdh*ef egjdf( Ad~bj ib ~beg ~g d gsf~egh~bj e—g d s|gŢaf kgndhf( ‘Sb|b hbsb|v! vŢ hb mveb|v‚! ba— hf dnf nb f sg*hg}g g}|ċfj hb ~g! dghbeg jf if s|f}d*Ţf( Ifnbh jd sgnb~be ybsbnf yb geg(\bnd f g egjddid yb g|kbhgyg}bhifjbhdmf~bof ‘Nbhd sd~f v Ebehiv‚( L|g*
idj ib ghf dyhgf d Ċdhd jd f sgl|gib``daibnv d ~g eb*fjg}b( \byjdŢaibj eg*adeg v ~fsv ~bhf edab sd~f! sb nb dy|b*Ċvhbj egadeg ~g ldifŢf ~fsdib hb ~dj‘Nbhdjb‚( Hdbj nbaif kafnbab ~f ‘eg*jdf‚ if| jd if s|gŢbg e|gy kab}v sg*nb~be nb ifnbh vsgafhde Gsċdhf Ebebhinhf}hg sg~|gŢd ~|d |gahf sbsd|b( g jd if ldag ng}gaihg( Hb e|biv f }d jd sd~bjgybŢ~g hbj if lvnŸf~ g~dŢbg hdyl|ng(Nb ad hbj if ebŢdeb v jfnv7"
B ċf~fhb d ba}b! f! ~g }bj if sgflhb}|~b s|dĊf( gadeg sgflhb d }fadeb! nb igihd v}gnhde hf ld ldg ng}gaibh( LbŢ jf
Ċvnd ebeg if ‘vsifab‚ ~b Ċf~fhb v s|dv*~}v jvŢeb|ob( EbŸv nb ghb gldĊhg hfvsf}b v hid`g}gj ‘n|vŢ~}v‚( Hdbj
SdŢfBajb Eb`}fnŸdċ
Hbegh ċf~fhdif d `ba}f
V _FS^FJL\V HB_GāFEVIV ‑NBHD IBKJF‚
}if|g}bab nb v Ebehiv sg~gid‘ngl|d‚ Ċg}ife! bad bn bj fv}if|dab( EbŸv nb Nglgief s|b}fhbilgaiv |fŢfnv! b Ÿfhf n|vkf~|bhf Lghf dyhbn ^f|jgfafe*~|bhf dyvyf~hg ngl|g s|b}aibivċf~fhv( Hdknif hf s|gĊd~b` egv jbi~g|dof v s|b}aibhiv `ba*}f( ‘Nbhd v|jbŢdof‚ f gn|ŸbŢfhb _fgov! b agevjd ‘ybifnbŢf‚hb @|bhv( Labkg hbjb }djb!yhbjg ybjifd~d! sgif~d d sgsd~d!b g g~badj s|glafjdjb ċfjg|byjdŢaib~d iv~|g hbegh bknb~f
hgċd( Hdjg f sd~bad dy egifkmghnb f dyn}bibiv |fn~}b ybg}be}f! hbyg}djg d` s|d|fnlf(
Gsċdhed lvnŸf~ sg~gid yb`}baivivċd hb*jb! nb ad ċfjg ngy}gad~d nb f ~|gŢd hbg}be}f d adĊhf e}byd jbhdmf~bof( Yhb~fad egib if }|`b g}d` ~fsbŢed` s|d|fnld7]bainb jg `}b~dad nb if ngŢag }|fjf nbd jd eghbĊhg s|gkafnbjg( Hdif hbjbebŢdeb v jfnv! ebeg hb jhgkd vlifĒviv(Hf jfjg ngy}gad~d nb f g}g hbhd|bnd|fe~hg dy lvnŸf~b! b nb f s|gŢagkgndŢ*hib s|fn~b}b ebebhiegk N|bjegk~vnb ‘_j|~ Gjf|b d Jf|djf‚ dyb gĊv
ib}hg~d djf( Hbdjf! eg if s|dv~}g}bgg}gi s|fn~b}d djbg if s|dadev hb e|biv}dnif~d ebeg hbŢ ‘]faded l|b~‚ nfad eg}f|*~f kavjodjb v egidjb if dyhg gn sg 233EJ( Dykafnbag if ebg hb kf~b! bad ~fe ~vsgĊdhif s|dĊb( _b} ~bi hg}bo egid if sgnf*aifh! nd|fe~hg if edhv~ |bĊvhb IV ybeva~v|v d gl|byg}bhif( If~f! hb kf~b"Lfy ‘Nbhb edfagk evsvb‚
~|bŸdg if nb f g s|fnagŸfhgj lvnŸf~v dyibhd s|fnabkbĊ! ~fnb f s|ghbĒv ybifnhdĊed! egj*s|gjdhd ~b}g}d( Sg~gj v f]difċv gl|b~dad s|fnabkbĊd lvnŸf~b! gsċdhed hbĊfahde! Ţfm_avŸlf yb hbhf! ~f nd|fe~g|Yb}gnb yb sabhdbhif d dyk|bn*hiv gsċdhf Ebebhi( Hbegh nvŸfsbvyf! eavl }fċhdeb _NB ifs|fnagŸdg nb f g }dj hid`g*}dj bjhnjbhdjb kabb v sb*ef~v! ~i( ybifnhg! hb Ţ~g v gn*jb` |fbkg}bad s|fnifnhdod
eavlg}b @NY*b d _NS*b d~b*eb}Ţd nb v gĊfed}bad ngnb~hf|bykg}g|f d sg~dybhif egjs|g*
Jb|b~gheb >< ifnhdob Gsċdhegk }difċb Ebebhi
V_]GIFH LVNźF^ YB <32< KGNDHV V DYHG_VGN 2<43=<=0!3; EJ
Gsċdheg }difċf Ebebhi9 D sg|fn l|gihd` hfabkbhib! ldag if d }dif~ad` ~|fhv~beb
]difċhdod _NS*b hbsv~dad bav ~gegj kabbhib g lvnŸf~v
jdb! bad ebeg f ~g hf nfdag!
hbkabdad v nb hfċf sgn|Ÿb~dg}be}g kabbhif( _b 2; kabg}byb d < kabb s|g~d} v}gifh ifs|fnagk g ybifnhdĊegj dyibŢ*hib}bhiv yb }f bjbhnjbhfnb~f gn Eavlb }fċhdeb _NB(]fċhdod eavlb _NS*b d hfyb}d*hd ebhndnb~ NŸf}bn B`jf~g*}dċ hdv `~ifad vĊf~}g}b~d vkabbhiv d hbsv~dad v bavGsċdhegk }fċb( Hbegh Ţ~ghdv s|d`}bċfhd bjbhnjbhdEavlb }fċhdeb @NY*b! b 2;kabg}b yb d < kabb s|g~d}v}g* ifh if lvnŸf~ Gsċdhf Ebebhi yb<32<( kgndhv v dyhgv gn2<(43=(<=0!3; EJ(
N|vkb ~bĊeb nhf}hgk |fnbS|fnagk gnavef g dy}|Ţfhiv lvnŸf~b Gsċdhf Ebebhi yb<32<( kgndhv v}gifhb if vybjbhnjbhf s|fnagŸfhf gn~|bhf @b|db ]fdsb`dċb! s|fn*ifnhdeb Eavlb }fċhdeb _NB(Vy nvŸf ngkg}b|bhif ~f|jdhbgn|Ÿb}bhib hb~b}eb ifnhdof!d~b i s|fedhv~b b hifydh hb~b*
N|vkgk nbhb |bnb ifnhdof|bs|b}aibag f g Dy}ifŢ~biv gs|goifhd Ţ~f~b gn s|d|gnhd` dn|vkd` hf|fċb hb sgn|vĊivgsċdhf Ebebhi! Ţ~g f s|}fh*~}fhg gnhgd hb mfl|vb|efhfŸhf sbnb}dhf( S|fjb dy*}ifŢ~biv! Ţ~f~b if hb~bab hbsgn|vĊiv 2= ebebhied` jif*
hd` ybifnhdob! hb vevshg 263ngjbċdh~b}b( ţ~f~b hb k|bĒf*}dedj glife~djb if v dyhgvgn ;6(626!33 EJ! hb sgaigs|d*}|fnhdj ngl|djb 0?(;>6!33EJ! b ngnb~hg bhkbŸg}bhifjf`bhdybod if egŢ~b ag i f23(<?=!33EJ( Hbi}fċb Ţ~f~b ifhb~bab v|vŢb}bhifj Ngjbeva~v|f! b s|godifhifhb if hbdyhg gn 2(3?0(422!33 EJ! ~begnb if vevshb Ţ~f~b s|gofhifhbhb 2(<30(>3;!33 EJ( G}bi dy}if*Ţ~bi if ifnhgkabhg v}gifh(
_aifnfċb ~bĊeb nhf}hgk |f*nb ldad v dy}ifŢ~bid g v~|gŢev|fn~b}b hbehbnf yb k|bĒf*
}dheg yfjaidŢ~f d v~|gŢev|fn~b}b egjvhbahf hbehbnfyb <322( kgndhv( Dy}ifŢ~bi ifsgnhdg nd|fe~g| Yb}gnb ybsabhd|bhif d dyk|bnhiv gsċdhfEbebhi Ybn Hfdjb|ab( Eavl}fċhdeb _NB if djbg s|djifn* lf hb hfegadeg ~b}ed egn egid`v s|feg|bĊfhd sabhd|bhd dyhg*d! b egid v |flbabhgj ldadsghvĒfhd ]fċv hb nfofjlb|*edj ifnhdobjb ]fċb! ~f ~bnbhdv ngldad sgn|Ţev ]difċb(S|fnagk Eavlb _NS*b ldg if nbf dy}ifŢ~bid }|b~f hb ng|bnv! ~f
if nb~b sbvyb( Hbegh sbvyfngkg}g|fhg if nb f dy}|Ţd ng*svhb sgjfhv~gk dy}ifŢ~bib! ~fnb f sghvnd ]fċv hb v}bib*hif(
S|gk|bj v~|gŢeb |fn~b}bhbehbnf yb k|bĒf}dheg yf*jaidŢ~f yb <32<( kgndhv sabhd*|bh if v vevshgj dyhgv gn62?(333!33 EJ! ebg d s|gk|bjv~|gŢeb |fn~b}b egjvhbahfhbehbnf yb <32<( kgndhv vdyhgv gn <(2>4(233!33 EJ(Hbegh nvŸf |bs|b}f d hfegad*
ef bebof Ld@! Bndab Gjbhg}dċb jgsd~bad nb ad v v bjgj }|`v _NB Ld@glb}aibhf eghva~bof geg s|fjb Ċab*hg}b _~|bhef yb Ld@ v ebebhiev gsċdh*ev gs|kbhdybov _NB(
oifhf g s|djbhiv hg}d` Ċabhg}b v sg~svhg*~d s|fsvŢ~bjg gsċdhedj d ebh~ghbahdjg|kbhdybobjb( Beg f |bnd g aivndjb egid
v bv~g|d~f~d! dh~fafe~vbaod d beg |bnd hid`
hf ngabydag ng sgkg|Ţb}bhib jfĒvaivned`gnhgb v Ebehiv d beg ~g hfċf sgkbĒb~dĊabh~}g _NB! hbŢf be~d}d~f d Ċabhg}f Dy*}|Ţhgk gnlg|b _NB Ebebhi! ghnb ~|flb
s|djb~d hg}f Ċabhg}f! ebybg if Gjbhg}dċ(Ybjifhdeb s|fnifnhdeb _NB Ld@
Bdjb _b|biadċb! sd~bad jg Ţ~b if gs|fnd* ifadag hbi}dŢf |veg}gn~}g _~|bhef nf*jge|b~ef beof nb nb}bhif bkabhg~Gsċdhegi g|kbhdybodid v Ebehiv nbs|djd v Ċabh~}g aivnf dy _~|bhef yb Ld@(
* Dy _NB v aivnd gnabydad ngl|g}gaihg(Hdeg hf g~if|bh( Gnabydad v d sgevŢb}badn|vkdj jf~gnbjb d dnfibjb ngċd ng odaib( D g}d aivnd v Ebehiv v ~|bkbad yb ~dj |ifŢfhid*jb d }dnifad v s|g~feagj sf|dgnv nb lfy _NB!ebg ibef sgad~dĊef ~|bhef! egib s|fn~b}aib
s|}fh~}fhg LgŢhibef hfjb |fyva~b~b( ]|f*jf if sgebybag nb g~bad hfjbiv |ifŢfhib( _NBf |fmg|jdbab v jgnf|hv f}|gsev ~|bhevd hg|jbahg if nb aivnd! egid Ÿfaf hg|jbahvLghv d @f|ofkg}dhv! v _NB }dnf s|gjifhf!eg`fydghv hbkv d gevsaibivċd mbe~g| egifj~|flbiv s|dċd( \bykg}b|bivċd b s|fnifnhdod*jb ebh~ghbahf d gsċdhef g|kbhdybof _NBjd jg }dnifad nb g}nif hdebnb hf hb|vŢfhbjlfh~( Lfy glyd|b Ţ~g v s|dsbnbad n}ifjb
~|bhebjb kbidad v aivlb} s|fjb Ebehiv dEbebhi dj if ldg hb s|}gj jif~v( Yb~g hfjb|byagkb ~b}aib~d ldag ebe}v j|aiv hb nbhbŢhivbe~d}hg~ ! d~bebg if _b|biadċ
Ebeg ċf~f v ebn|g}egj jdav ~|f*~d|b~d ng ivĊf }dgeg sgydodghd|bhgkmvheodghf|b _~|bhef yb Ld@! kgsgndhb_fibnb Ybdjg}dċb! sd~bad jg s|fnifn*hdeb Ebh~ghbahgk gnlg|b _NB Jd|bnbYbdjg}dċb! egid hbj if |febg9
_dkv|hg if nb ċf e|gy dylg|f vhvb~b| _~|bh*ef |b}hgs|b}hg vĊf~}g}b~d egjsaf~hgĊabh~}g( Gsċdheb g|kbhdybob ċf }djb
s|vŸd~d ifnhbef Ţbhf(_adĊhg sd~bhif jg sg~b}dad d s|fn*
ifnhdev Gsċdhef g|kbhdybodif _NBEbebhi! Hf|jdhv Jbhn|d( Ebeb} ~b~vv ebn|g}egj jdav! v gnhgv hbg~baf Ċabhg}f _NB V Ebehiv ċf djb~dhg}gs|djaifhd Ċabhg}d dy _~|bhef yb Ld@7
* V sgaifnhid` Ţf~ kgndhb bj djbg}|ag lgkb~g dev~}g v |bnv b Ċabhg}djb d
mvheodghf|djb _~|bhef yb Ld@( Sgnifċbj nb
if ~g e|gy |bn v Gsċdhegj }fċv d v Ebh~g*hbahgi }abnd ldag }|ag sagnhg }|fjf yb Eb*ebhi( g if }|fjf ebnb v yhbĊbihb |fn~}b
ngabydab b ebh~ghbahgk hd}gb d jg|bj |fċdnb if }f |bĒfhg vy }dge ~fsfh bkabhg~db ~bnbŢhidj mvheodghf|djb _~|bhef yb Ld@(S|f }fkb! jdadj hb _fibnb Ybdjg}dċb dMb`|vndhb Gjf|`gnŸdċb egid v bnb Ċabhg}d_NB( Ebnb if v sd~bhiv hid`g} ~b~v b~bhg}dŢ~b mb}g|dyd|bhib! ~|flb djb~d v }dnvnb f |bnd g dyk|bĒfhdj ebn|g}djb! g aivndjbegid v f hb jhgkdj sgaidjb ngebybad( Ldagld sgk|fŢhg ~g hf deg|d~d~d( Dev~}g _fibnbYbdjg}dċb d g~bad` Ċabhg}b egid v hbj s|d*~vsdab yb hb if gn dyvyf~hgk yhbĊbib! hb*kabdg if Jbhn|b
Hb e|biv jg g }fjv yb~|bŸdad degjfh~b| _fibnb Ybdjg}dċb( Sgflhg
jg ~|bŸdad nb sgibhd jg~d}f }|bċbhib v_NB d nb egjfh~b|dŢf sdbhif hfed` sg|*~bab egid hifkg} dyabybe dy _~|bhef yb Ld@jb~|biv gnabegj _dabinŸdċf}gk eabhb(\febg hbj if nb v _~|bhod yb Ld@ hdebnbhf s|dsbnbg eabhg}djb }fċ if |veg}gndgYfhdĊeg*nglgiedj! ifnhdj gn hbi}fċd`}fċb _~|bhef yb Ld@ d ngnbg9
* Djbg bj s|glafjb ylgk aivnd egid vldad geg _dabinŸdċb( Eghe|f~hg f |bnd g @fċdd Badċv egid v hb }bed jgkvċd hbĊdh sgev*Ţb}bad nb ghfjgkvċf jgi |bn d dylg| hb Ċfag
s|fnifnhdeb Ebh~ghbahgk }difċb( Jd v
Ebh~ghv! gn <33;( kgndhf! ng e|bib jbhnb*~b! knif if }abnbivċb kb|hd~v|b ldab dy _~|bh*ef yb Ld@ d _NB! hdjg djbad s|glafjb(Hfedjb if ~g jf~bag( Hb mfnf|bahgj hd}gv~g hf ldag ~beg( Vsgyg|b}bg bj hb ~g dhdbj ldg gjdaifh( _b ~|fhv~hdj |veg}gn*~}gj _~|bhef yb Ld@ hfjgkvċf if s|g}f~dldag ebeb} odai( Sgflhg ghd}bĊef odaif}f(Sgyd}bj }f Ċabhg}f _~|bhef yb Ld@! dj*
sb~dyf|f! k|bĒbhf egid v kabbad yb jfhf daivnf egid v gn nbhb v _~|bhod nfjge|b~efbeof nb `}b~f ebeg gn dnfib _~|bhef yb Ld@ }dŢf hfjb hdŢ~b( NgŢag if }|fjf nb }gi
bhkbŸjbh sg~|bŸf v _~|bhod nfjge|b~efbeof( Hb ~bi hbĊdh d Ebebhi ċf ld~d hb ng*ld~ev( Byf|dh _bad`lfkg}dċ
Dy Vn|vŸfhif sfh*ydghf|b gsċdhf Ebebhivsvċfh if bsfa egidj
f ~|bŸd sgjgċ v ldagegj gladev if| if ngŢ*ag! ebŸf f v bsfav! ngn|b~dĊhgk sbnb |fba*hd` sfhyb( GĊfevif*jg svhg |byvjf}b*hif d nb hbj v k|bhd*objb }gid` jgkvċ*hg~d gngl|d~f d ng*yhbĊd~f ldag ebe}vsgjgċ! sdŢf hb e|bivg}gk bsfab egid if ng*~b}aifh9 ^f|jgfafe~|bhd Ebebhi! ^}g|hdod of*jfh~b Ebebhi! \vnhdev Ebebhi! Gsċdhd Eb*ebhi! \vn~|giv! BL Sf~|gav! Nfa~b Sf~|gav!Ebebhi Sf~|gav! ^|kgŢsfnv! Hg}gi ~|kg}dhd!~|kg}dhbjb BN_! jfhdobjb Yjbif}bo d Ev*
lb~! bsg~febjb Jfndob! Dh}f~dodghg*egjf|*obahgi! Vhde|fnd~ d \bimbiyfh lbhebjb( Fivl_sb`dċ! s|fnifnhde Vs|b}hgk gnlg|b Vn|v*Ÿfhib sfhydghf|b ebŸf nb if ngŢag if ng n|b*~dĊhgk sbnb |fbahd` sfhyb egif f vkab}hgjkgndhbjb hf sg}fċb}biv(
* \bnd hb}fnfhd` |byagkb ~bhnb|n sfhydghf*|b if }f ~fŸd d ~fŸd( HbŢd sfhydghf|d v sg~bad
gobahd mfhgjfh egid b g}beg hdedj s|djbhid*jb vsf}biv nb s|fŸd}f( Ylgk v|fnhgk sabċbhib}gid` glb}fyb! sfhydghf|d v }|ag e|b~egj |gevoifagevshv sfhyv }|bċbiv n|vŢ~}v! n|Ÿb}d! Ţ~g
ld f sgflhg ~|flbag ofhd~d! ebŸf _sb`dċ(Sfhydiv gn ?22 EJ s|djb <==< sfhydghf|b
Hb sgn|vĊiv gsċdhf Ebebhi! ybeaivĊhg b?2(2<(<322( kgndhf! Ÿd}d 6(2<? sfhydghf|b(Vkab}hgj f |bnd g hfebnbŢhidj |vnb|djb!fhf|kf~dĊb|djb! ofjfh~bŢdjb( V <322( kgndhds|fjdhvg if <?2 sfhydghf|( Sfhyv gn ?22 EJs|djb <(==< sfhydghf|b! 64; sfhydghf|b djbsfhyv gn ?26 ng >33 EJ! b sfhyv gn >2>
EJ s|djbiv 64? sfhydghf|b( V s|gŢagi kgndhdsfhydghf|djb Ebehib! b sg|fn~}gj g}gkvn|vŸfhib! sgjgkad v9 \vnhde j|egk vkaibEbebhi! ^}g|hdob ofjfh~b! Gsċdhb Ebebhi! ^|*kgŢsfn d Hg}b ~|kg}dhb( Vn|vŸfhif if dy |fn~b*}b Ċabhb|dhf d |fn~b}b ngldifhd` v gladevhg}Ċbhf sgjgċd s|gŢaf kgndhf dsab~dag sgjgċdhbivk|gŸfhdidj sfhydghf|djb v dyhgv gn<4(>43!33 EJ( Sg|fn ~gkb! yb sg~|flf j|~hd`avĊbif}b dsabċfhg if 60(0<6!33 EJ( Yb 4=6 Ċab*hg}b Vn|vŸfhib! dy |fn~b}b gsċdhegk lvnŸf*~b vsabċfhb if vl}fhob yb ~|gŢeg}f sabċbhib}gnf v dhgv gn <0(463!33 EJ( _}f if ~g bjgvlabŸdag! b hdebeg d sgs|b}dag! ebeg ebŸf _sb`dċ!fkyd~fhobahd ~b~v sfhydghf|b( By_
Ifn bh sg yd ~d }bhs|djif| sgag}bhibngjċbf |jf if }b*ebeg |jb BN_ eg*jf|o! egib if s|g~fead`nbhb g~}g|dab }gi hg*}d s|gnbihd glifeb~ vNglgiv( G}g if Ţf~dsg |fnv ~|kg}bĊed jb*ags|gnbihd glifeb~g}f |jf! Ţ~g if ngebyhid`g}gk vsifŢhgksgag}bhib(
Evsod v }fċ s|f*
sgyhbad e}bad~f~ hid`g*}f vavkf! ~beg nb v dhb nbh g~}g|fhib jhg*kd vk|bĒbhd ngŢad dv}if|dad f v hid`g}ve}bad~f~hv sghvnv(Ghg Ţ~g if sgflhg
‘Ebnb if v sd~bhiv Ebebhi! sg}|*Ţdhb Ţvjb d Ţvjed` yfjaidŢ~b dyhg*d 24(202 `b( Ifnhb gn hbigsbhd`sgib}b! ebnb v v sd~bhiv Ţ~f~f hbŢvjbjb d hf~bibhif Ţvjb! if ŢvjedsgŸb|( s|gaifċf ebnb v dh~fhyd}hd|bng}d hb ĊdŢċfhiv sgaigs|d}|fnhd`sb|ofab! Ċf~g ngabyd ng Ţvjed`sgŸb|b( ]fċdhb sgŸb|b vy|geg}bhb
if hfsbŸhigj d hfjb|gj aivnegkmbe~g|b( L|gi Ţvjed` sgŸb|b dyby}b*
hd` aivnedj mbe~g|gj dy kgndhf vkgndhv sg}fċb}b f( Ybd~b v }fadefŢ~f~f Ţvjed` sgŸb|b ebg Ţ~g v9
G}d vĊfhdod dylg|dad v sabjbh hb ebh~ghbahg ~bejdĊfhif dymdydef egif ċf f gn|Ÿb~d <2( bs|dab v Yfhdod! v Gţ ‑Fn`fj
Jvablndċ‚( źfadjg dj jhgkg |fċf d vsif`b( Bjdhb Evag}dċ
V v~g|be <2( jb|~b! v Kdjhbydid ‑Jv`dh \dy}dċ‚!gn|Ÿbhg if Ţegaeg ~bejdĊfhif dy S|gife~b k|bĒbhdh! ybŢegaev <322'2<( kgndhv( G}f kgndhf ~bejdĊdaf v f Ċf~d|dfedsf gnifaifhib ~|fċd` |by|fnb! egid v bhbadyd|bad d l|bhdad
ibeg ybhdjaid}f ~fjf( f ~fjv v ldaf9 ‑S|glafj glabĊfhibv Ţegabjb‚ DDD*2$! ‑S|glafj hfgs|fjaifhg~d hbŢf Ţegaf‚DDD*<$! ‑Hfng~b~be lbyfhb v Ebehiv‚ DDD*?$ d ‑Hf$eva~v*|b ~bhg}bhib v Ebehiv‚ DDD*>$(
_vnf v b~b}v9 s|gmfg|d @bg}dċ Ybnb d Kg|babJbdn! sfnbkgkdob ]danbhb Hfdjb|ab! ~f vĊfhdod Lifagsga*
ibe Bjdhb! KbĊdċ NŸfhbhb! Ebndċ Jd|bn d _~|deb Jb`d|!djbad v ~fŸbe ybnb~be( Hbegh dyabkbhib }d` s|gifeb~b!egjdib if nghfab }gi eghbĊbh vn d s|gkabdab sglifn*hdeb! b ~g v ldad vĊfhdod DDD*2! egid v b }gigj ~fjgj‑S|glafj glabĊfhib v Ţegabjb‚! dylg|dad sabjbh nb s|fn*~b}aibiv Ţegav hb }dŢdj hd}gdjb ~bejdĊfhib( Fedsb DDD*<g}gidab if <( jif~g! ?( jif~g if s|dsbag fedsd DDD*>! nge vhbijbhif g}gifhd` lgng}b djbad vĊfhdod DDD*?(
_vnf v }dj vĊfhdodjb Ċf~d~bad hb mf| d sgŢ~fhgj
~bejdĊfhiv! b sglifnhdĊegi fedsd ybŸfaifad |fċv hb nbaifjhb~ifobhiv( Bjdhb Evag}dċ
Gsċdheg ~bejdĊfhif vĊfhdeb gjd` |by|fnb dy fhkafegk ifydeb
if _^ţ ‑Efjba Ebsf~bhg}dċ‚Ebebhi( Dhdob~d}b if ngŢab gnbjd` vĊfhdeb Jfn|ff egidv Ÿfaifad nb f vsgyhbiv b}gidj }|Ţhibodjb egid sg`b*Ēbiv g}v Ţegav! ebg d nb fvsgyhbiv b eva~v|hdj hbaif*Ēfj hbŢfk k|bnb(
Ngjbċdhd v kg~f ngĊfeb*
ad v }gigi Ţegad knif if vs|dad*Ċfh gldabybe Ţegaf d ebldhf~b!knif f dy}gnd |fng}hb d s|be*~dĊhb hb~b}b( Hbegh ~gkbkg~d v f ybsv~dad v s|g~g|d*
if K|bnef ldlad~fef knif v djngjbċdhd s|d|fndad s|dkgnbhs|gk|bj ngl|gngŢadof( VĊfhd*of v s|gĊd~baf ghg}hf sgnb~*ef g Ţegad! l|giv vĊfhdeb!~|vebjb egif f Ţegaviv dvag}djb |bnb( Hbegh ~gkb ifkg~djb s|fyfh~d|bhb e|b~eb
VĊfhdod Jfn|ff v f ybg}bi sgif~ sgflhg s|ds|fjd*ad( S|fyfh~d|bad v |bn }gid`hbivsifŢhd` feob d gnvŢf*}dad s|dv~hf( S|}g v f s|fn*~b}dad vĊfhdod |fod~b~g|effeodif b |fod~bagj ‑Kbyd@v|f}*lfk‚ bv~g|b \fŢbnbEbndċb( Hbiybhdjaid}did ndgs|gk|bjb if ldg s|fn~b}aib*
~v hb ~fjv ‑Jabnd v Ld@djbiv lvnvċhg~‚( V g}ginflb~d sglfndg if b|jbo*ed ~dj! egid if e|gy }gif b|*kvjfh~f ngebybg nb jabnd vLd@ djbiv lvnvċhg~( Nflb~*hd eavl hb~vsb hb |byhdj~bejdĊfhidjb ~f }|~f! ~f sg*~dŸf ybsbŸfhf |fyva~b~f ddy}bh hbŢf yfjaif(
VĊfhdod Jfn|ff v s|deb*ybad d |bn }gif jvydĊef fe*
of egib if dy}fab n}f s|dkgn*hf sifjf( Hbi}dŢf jf`bdyby}bad v vĊfhdod n|bjef
feof egid v s|ds|fjdad sb*|gnv hb nflb~v! Ċb if ~fjbkabdab ‑Sgad~dĊb|d djbiv hfeb*e}b s|b}b‚( Kg~d v v s|fn*~b}aibhiv hb}fad hfef ghg}*hf sgnb~ef g Jfn|fd ebg
ifnhgi gn hbi~b|d` gl|byg}*hd` dh~d~vob v hbŢgi yfjaid(D~bead v d sgflhf sfodĊ*hg~d hid`g}gk Ţegag}bhibdh~f|hb~ed jifŢ~bi! |bjb*ybhev s|bev! sgkgnhg~dyb `byf d adĊhg$(
Hb e|biv s|gk|bjb nd|fe*
~g|v _^ţ vĊfhdod v v|vĊdads|dkgnbh sgeagh9 sgflhgdynbhif ad~b vĊfhdeb Jfn|ff‑Yfjyfj‚(
Hbegh g}gk n|vŸfhib ng*kg}g|fhb if vy}|b~hb sgif~bvĊfhdeb d s|gmfg|b _^ţ ‑Ef*jba Ebsf~bhg}dċ‚ Jfn|fd!Ţ~g yb odai djb s|dib~faiegsg}fyd}bhif vĊfhdeb! |byjif*hb dev~b}b! jfĒvglhgvsgyhb}bhif b n|vkbĊdidjeghofs~gj gl|byg}bhib! bad d
vsgyhb}bhif d sg}fyd}bhibhbŢfk k|bnb b kab}hdj k|b*ngj( Bjdhb Evag}dċ
V sf~be <?( jb|~b ~fevċf kgndhf!gn|Ÿbhg if nvkg gĊfed}bhg sgavhbahg}fĊf sgn hbyd}gj ‘ bafh~ `g{‑( S|dif*~d~ ċfjg f nb f g}g sgavhbaf ~|flbagvs|dadĊd~d v mfl|vb|v! jfĒv~dj! ylgkngl|g sgyhb~d` |byagkb! ~bĊhf v|vŢb*}bhib e|g}hf egh~|veof Ngjb eva~v*|f! sgavhbaf if ~fe bnb gn|Ÿbhg( \b*yagk afŸd d v bnbs~bod Jbaf baf Ngjbeva~v|f yb gn|Ÿb}bhif |byadĊd~d` be~d}hg*~d v eagsv nifab~hg~d IV yb eva~v|v dgl|byg}bhif Ebebhi(
Hb sgavhbahgi }fĊf|d if hb~vsbag
n}bnff~ ebhndnb~b( V s|fnfafeod ifhb~vsbag geg Ċf~|nff~ jabnd` ~bafhb~b!jfĒv~dj! v dh~f|fv g|kbhdyb~g|b if nbv sgavhbaf s|gĒv lgaif s|ds|fjaifhd! bv hbaf bjg ghd hbilgaid( ^beg if ldag d~f vkgnhf |bsif}bhf }fĊf|d( Geg ~g~dhv
^bafh~ `g{
Sglifnhde Nfhdba B`jf~g}dċ
S|fsvhb bab hb mhbahgi }fĊf|d
]faded dh~f|f yb g}bi ngkbĒbia Mdhbaf kafnbag s|feg n}dif ~g*~dhf sgif~dabob a ţ~f~b hb Ngjv eva~v|f hfċf ld~d bhd|bhb ng
e|bib kgndhf7"
Nfhdba B`jf~g}dċ ybavŸfhd sglifnhde
_}dj vĊfhdodjb v|vĊfhf yb`}bahdofd ~|dnff~ sgif~dabob! Ţ~g if g~s|dadef debsbod~f~ Jbaf baf! vŸd}bag if geg n}bb~b v gnadĊhdj dh~f|s|f~bobjb jabnd`~bafhb~b( źd|d v b~b}v9 Hd`bn Nfjd|!Jfndhb _b|bĊ d \b~dab} Kvlf|bo vdjbad ~fŸbe ybnb~be nb gnblf|v ghf egidċf f ~bejdĊd~d v hbav( Gnbl|bhg if hid`2?9 Nfhdba B`jf~g}dċ! Biab _dabinŸdċ! Bndhţgaldċ! Afiad Kbmv|g}dċ! Bjb| JvŢfaidċ!B|jdh _vaidċ! Fjdhb JviĊdhg}dċ! BjdabLifagsgaibe! Bnhbh Badċ! Bajb Mbyadċ!NŸfhbh Egyag! Jb|~dhb Igydhg}dċ d safhbk|vsb v b~b}v9 Mb|b` Ef}dai! Bjhb Ib*Ţb|sb`dċ! E|d~dhb _~fsdċ! Fnhb _b|biadċ!Biab _dabinŸdċ d Bjd| Jvjdhg}dċ( _}djvĊfhdodjb sgavhbahf }fĊf|d v v|vĊfhfd yb`}bahdof yb vĊfŢċf(Dybl|bhd s|b}d sglifnhdod
V hbahgi }fĊf|d gn|Ÿbhgi ?3( jb|~b!hb~vsdag if ~|dhbf~ ~bejdĊb|b egid vs|gŢad sgavhbahv }fĊf| fnjdov |bhf(Jbab bab Ngjb eva~v|f if ifnhg~b}hg
ldab s|fjbab nb s|djd s|feg n}f ~g~dhf
sgif~dabob egid v s|b}dad gnadĊhv b~jg*mf|v! hbk|bnd}Ţd }begk ~bejdĊb|b k|gjg*
kabhdj bsabvygj( V |f}bahgj nfav}fĊf|d hb~vsbab if ]fhb gjdĊdċ( Sglifn*hde g}gkgndŢhifk ~bafh~ `g{b if ybavŸf*hg Nfhdba B`jf~g}dċ! vy jvydĊev s|b~hivBjb|b IbŢb|sb`dċb( Jhgkd ld f agŸdad d|fead nb if ybavŸfhg! if| if v n}f hgċd g}bijabnd jgjbe sgebybg yb}dnhg vjifċfdh~f|s|f~bof hb|gnhf jvydef(
‘Ybng}gaibh bj g}gkgndŢhigj g|*kbhdybogj ^babfh~ `g{b( ţ~f~b Ţ~g fhf jgkab gn|Ÿb~d v Ngjv eva~v|f if|bj dkv|bh nb ld ldag jhgkg }dŢf sg*if~dabob( Hbnbj f nb ċf kb eg|g |fhg*
}d|b~d d nb ċfjg ngkgndhf sghg}g hb*~vsb~d v }fadegi bad( ţ~b nb ebŸfj!`}bab }djb egid v }if|g}bad v jfhf! ibbj f s|ds|fjbg ibeg nvkg if| d sif}bjsg eavlg}djb d ~|vndj f Ţ~g lgaif dh~f|*s|f~d|b~d }bev sifjv( IgŢ ifnhgj Ċf*~d~bj g|kbhdyb~g|v hb vsifŢhg g|kbhd*yg}bhgi }fĊf|d‑* |febg if sglifnhdeg}gkgndŢhifk ~bejdĊfhib ^bafh~ `g{!Nfhdba B`jf~g}dċ(
N|vkgsabd|bhb g}f kgndhf if Jb|~d*hb Igydhg}dċ! nif}giĊdob egib if d v s|gŢ*agkgndŢhifj ^bafh~ `g{v v nvf~v b
ċd! ~beg nb if hfebeg agkdĊbh sg~fy ldgnb f d g}f kgndhf s|b}dj hb ^bafh~`g{! nb f n|vŸdj g~badj ebhndnb*~djb d hg s|g}fnfj( Ybng}gaihb bjn|vkdj jif~gj d Ÿfadj Ċf~d~b~d IV ybeva~v|v d gl|byg}bhif Ţ~g v hbj g|kb*hdyg}bad g}g ~bejdĊfhif dbeg hbj fNgj eva~v|f |vŢdg‑(
Hb ~bejdĊfhif f s|}d sv~ s|b}dg dBndh ţgaldċ( Bndh if g}gidg ~|fċf jif~gd ebeg ebŸf! s|fybng}gaibh if(
‘S|}d sv~ bj f s|b}dg d g~e|dg }gi~bafhb~ b ~g if sif}bhif( G}gkgndŢhibg|kbhdybob if ldab mfhgjfhbahb( S|fng*
l|g if ldag( S|fybng}gaibh bj hb~vsgj}bev sifjv bj sif}bg dy |ob( Hb*
|b}hg! gĊfed}bg bj ifnhg gn ~|d jif~b(S|ds|fjbhif if ldag }bed nbh( _bjg
vsg|hg~ f dsab~d‑(Sg|fn g}d` ebhndnb~b! Ÿd|d if gnavĊdghbk|bnd~d igŢ ifnhgk ebhndnb~b( ^g if sf*obahb hbk|bnb svladef yb hbilgaid sf|mg|*jbh d hbilgaiv e|fbov( Jgjbe egid if|byn|jbg }f sgif~dgof v n}f }fĊf|d^bafh~ `g{b! }gigj hfgldĊhgj djd~bod*
igj sgyhb~d` jvydĊb|b if Afiad Kbmv|g}dċ(‘Ib bj s|f|f~bh! hf yhbj Ţ~b nb
ib g}gidg g}v hbk|bnv d Ÿfadj nb fyb`}badj IV yb eva~v|v d gl|byg}bhif d
gs~dĊegj ~vnv Lifagsgaibe Ţ~g v hbjg}g g|kbhdyg}bad‑(ţ~f~b hb Ngjv eva~v|f hfċf ld~dbhd|bh ng e|bib kgndhf 7"
G gn|Ÿb}bhiv jbhdmf~bof v Jbagibad! ~f g |bng}djb hb Ngjv eva~v|f!}dŢf if |febg nd|fe~g| IV yb eva~v|v dgl|byg}bhif Dyf~ Mfiyg}dċ(
‘\bng}d hb Ngjv eva~v|f f dy}gnf(\byagyd v gĊd~d( Jd hf jgŸfjg ~b~d(S|gk|bjd dnv v g~fŸbhdj vag}djb! e}b*ad~f~b hf jbhieb! jbhib if ldab b abldjfmfe~djb bad ib bj s|fybng}gaibh b |f*beodigj svladef( Jd jg g}f kgndhfdjbad d s|ffnbh v ngnifaid}bhiv hbk|bnbb ~b hbk|bnb if yb hbig|dkdhbahd ofhedhb~vs( Jd jg jg|bad }|bċb~d aivnf bvabyb nb f hf ld ~}b|bab s|f}fadeb kvŸ}b(Ngj eva~v|f f ~|fhv~hg Ċd~d d ib f hb*nbj nb ċf ng e|bib kgndhf lb| ld~d v|b*Ēfhb d sg~b}aifhb e|g}hb egh~|veob‑(
G}f kgndhf! v gnhgv hb s|g~feav if ldag yhb~hg ~fŸf g|kbhdyg}b~d g}v jbhd*mf~bov( Nb hf kg}g|djg g g~badj }f*ċdj jbhdmf~bobjb! b }f sgn sabŢ~gjv|vŢb}bhib Ngjb eva~v|f d hfjgċd}ab~d nb f dybĒf b eghe|f~hdj s|fn*agydjb hbĊdhb s|dlb}aibhib hg}ob(
V g|kbhdybod jvbaadjb JfnŸadb DY Ebebhi gn|Ÿbhg if igŢ ifnhg v hdyv s|fnb}bhib yb Ÿfhf( G}gkb sv~b! v jbagi bad Ngjbeva~v|f Ebebhi 2>( jb|~b ~fevċf kgndhf kgŢċb if ldab @b|db@b}f|dċ*Gebhg}dċ! egib if gn|Ÿbab s|fnb}bhif hb ~fjv ‘Bk|f*d}hg~ nifof d }|ŢhibĊeg hbdaif‑( G}gi ybhdjaid}gi ~fjd s|dv*~}g}bg if }faded l|gi Ebebhied( S|fnb}bĊdob if dyagŸdab |fyva~b~fd byhbhib b eghmf|fhof g jbagaif~hdĊegj hbdaiv egib if gn|*Ÿbhb v Lfgk|bnv! b hb egigi if vĊf~}g}bag ; yfjbaib( Ebg sfnb*kgk ghb f v|fab b |byhdj }dng}djb }|ŢhibĊegk hbdaib! egif if ghnb gnavĊdab nb d~|bŸd( g hifhg d~|bŸd}bhif g jbagaif~hdĊegjhbdaiv s|fsgyhb~g if v ib}hg~d! ~f kb ghb s|fyfh~d|b ebg ifnbh
gn jgkvċd` }dng}b |ifŢb}bhib s|glafjb jbagaif~hdĊegk hbdaib(Hb}gnfċd hdy s|djif|b dy hb~b}hdĊef d gld~faief s|bef! s|fn*agŸdab if ebeg |fbkd|b~d v d~vbod ebnb if nf~f hbdahg(
G}bi odev s|fnb}bhib yb Ÿfhf sgĊfg if v jiffov jb|~v! byb}|Ţhb jbhdmf~bob ċf ld~d g|kbhdyd|bhb hbegh be~d}hg~d egiff s|g}gnf v agebahgi ybifnhdod! b }f v odaiv s|gjgof Ÿfhf dhifhd` s|b}b! ~f fnvebof Ÿfhb dy |byhd` glab~d( Bjdhb Evag}dċ
V eagsv be~d}hg~d jbhdmf~bof ‑Nbhd sg}fċfhd Ÿfhd <32<(‚v Ebehiv if kg~g}bab Jfndhb Ivdċ*_gdċ! egib if gn|Ÿbab s|f*
nb}bhif yb Ÿfhf! ebg d |bndghdov yb vĊfhdof _|fnhif ~|vĊhfŢegaf Ebebhi( Hb ~|dldhd yb Ÿfhf kg}g|dab if g }bŸhg~d oifagŸd}g~*hgk vĊfhib( D~behvab if nb f hf ~|flbjg lgib~d dybyg}b egif s|fnhbjb ~b}aib Ÿd}g~ d nb f ~|flbjg ~bahg fnvod|b~d d v}bib~dhg}b yhbhib d }ifŢ~dhf(
Sgflhg if dh~f|fbh~hb |bndghdob egiv if dy}fab b vĊfhdob*jb n|vkgk |by|fnb ~|kg}dhef ~|vef _|fnhif ~|vĊhf ŢegafEbebhi( ‑S|fnhg~d d hfng~bod eg|dŢ~fhib Dh~f|hf~b‚! ldab if~fjb |bndghdof( Hb ibeg e|fb~d}bh d sgvĊbh hbĊdh |bs|b}aibagf g ~gjf Ţ~b jgŸfjg eg|dhg hbvĊd~d hb Dh~f|hf~v! b Ċfkb f~|flbjg Ċv}b~d( Ebg hfed gn hfng~b~beb Dh~f|hf~b hb}fnfhdv9 gnvydjbhif }|fjfhb yb vĊfhif! agŢ v~dobi hb yn|b}aif av`d }dn$! yagvsg~|flb mg~gk|bib d sgnb~beb! hfvkgnhg~ ylgkhfs|d~gihd` bn|Ÿbib! sg}vĊfhg~! bn|Ÿbid hfs|djif|fhd yb
vy|b~! n|vŢ~}fhd Ÿd}g~ f ybjifhivif }d|~vfahdj Ÿd}g~gj( Ngev ebg s|fnhg~d hbkabŢfhf9 l|y s|d~vs dhmg|jbobjb! egjv*hdebob hb nbaidhv! |byhg}|hg~ dhmg|jbob! sg}fyd}bhif b~b|dj s|b~faidjb! }fŸf hg}g~d dy yfjaif d }f~b! vŸd}g s|b*ċfhif |byhd` bn|Ÿbib d n|vkf s|fnhg~d( Bjdhb Evag}dċ
Vn|vŸfhif Ÿfhb gsċdhf Ebebhi vb|bnhid b g|kbhdybogj [g|an ]ddghb ifndŢ~fj v Yfhdod g}d` nbhb djsaf*jf~d|b s|gifeb~ v ghg}hdj Ţegabjbsgn hbyd}gj ‘S|f}fhob hfkb~d}hd`v~ifobib dh~f|hf~b hb nifov‑( ]gnd~fais|gk|bjb Aivldob _vlg~dċ ebŸf nb if odaig}gk s|fnb}bhib s|f}fhob hfkb~d}hd`
* S|fnb}bhif if hb~bag ebg |fyva~b~s|f~`gnhd d~|bŸd}bhib knif if vebybhghb s|fnhg~d d hfng~b~ef Dh~f|hf~b d hif*kg}d` f|}db! b sv~fj s|be~dĊhd` s|djif*|b vsg~b}aifhb if dhf~f|be~d}hb egjvhd*ebob b vĊfhdodjb! d~dĊf _vlg~dċ(
G}gj s|fnb}bhiv v Gţ ‑26( bs|da‑v Ebehiv s|dv~}g}bad d jhgkgl|gihd|gnd~faid Ċb nifob }begnhf}hg eg|dd*~f Dh~f|hf~ d s|fnb}bĊd n|( Hbndhb Eg*}bĊ d Efhbh ]dadċ( Sgflhg if vĊfhdodjbvkf|dbhg nb ~|flb ld~d gs|fybh v
glib}aid}bhiv adĊhd` sgnb~beb hb Dh~f|*hf~v! ~f gs|fybh v v|f~djb b gglb*jb egif f vsgyhbiv b Dh~f|hf~v(
* Hbild~hf if nb ~|flbiv sabhd|b~d}|fjf d }|`v eg|dŢ~fhib g}gk fafe*
~|ghegk sgjbkbab! b glb}fyhg nbs|b}f hbdaif dad hfngadĊhg sghbŢbhifhb Dh~f|hf~v! ebŸf _vlg~dċ( By_
Ifnbh gn hbisgyhb~d` s|gmfg|bb Vhd}f|yd~f~b v _b|bif}v egid }fċnvkd hdy kgndhb gn|Ÿb}b s|fnb}bhib
yb eb~fn|gj hb Mbeva~f~v sgad~dĊed`hbveb v _b|bif}v! egid if vifnhg ddy}bh|fnbh egjvhdegagk! ~fe~gsd*bo! kavjbo d jvydĊb|! Ċb v s|fnb*}bhib hbehbnhg s|fs|dĊb}bhb! ldg if kg~ hb ~|dldhd g Lghd d @f|ofkg*}dhd hb Nbh hfyb}dhg~d Lghf d@f|ofkg}dhf v K|bnegi ldladg~fod(\fĊ if g s|gm( n|( Lfdjv _sb`dċvegid if s|fn dsvhifhgj K|bnegj ldladg~fegj kg}g|dg hb fld sfod*Ċbh hbĊdh g sgad~dĊedj ~|bhebjb!
egĊhdobjb n|vŢ~}b! }if|bjb! hb*~bhev Ld@! g sg|feadjb sgyhb~d``d~g|ed` gglb b sgn|vĊib hbŢfyfjaif! g ghdjb egid vs|b}aibivg}gj n|Ÿb}gj( Hdeg hdif g~bg|b}hgnvŢbh( Hbegh jiffo nbhb!
Vkafnhd s|gfg| g ~bhiv d `d~g|did Lghf d @f|ofkg}dhf
g~ebeg if glib}aifh }dnfg b ~|dldhfLfdjb _sb`dċb v ~|d nfab hb tgv*~vlf(ogj gn ~|bhf hg}dhb|b ]d*hf*~b _dhdŢf _vlg~dċb! ybldaifŸfhg ifs|feg 2=6(333 s|fkafnb d s|feg =33egjfh~b|b( |dldhb v g|kbhdybod IVK|bneb ldladg~feb Ebebhi if ldabsvh sgkgnbe if| if ng~beab |ob
jhgkd`! sg~beab hb |byjdŢaibhif dg}f~dab hfg}fŢ~fh hb|gn( |dld*hb hb egigi if s|gmfg| Lfdj _sb`dċg~}g|dg nvŢv agebahdj jgċhdodjb!}if|edj d ~|bhbĊedj fad~bjb! hb*|gnv! jfĒvhb|gnhgi ybifnhdod! |f*ebg ghg Ţ~g kgndhbjb hdeg dy ib}*hgk Ÿd}g~b hf djbg sf~aif nb ebŸf(
beg hb s|djif| ‘_aglgnhb Lghb‑gsdvif g}v ~|dldhv ebg ‘ţge v Eb*ehiv‑ knif glibŢhib}biv ebeg v
vs|b}g g}d }dnfg difĊod sg~bad}gif}|hb jfneb d sgad~dĊeb fh*ybob v Lghd d @f|ofkg}dhd(
‘Ybjif|dad v jd hfed Ţ~g f |vkbjebeg eg kg}g|d( Hf |vkbj f! ~dobifjgegahg~d djbg bj kavjbĊegk d jvydĊ *egk nb|b d aivndjb bj sgevŢbg nb ng*Ċb|bj nb kg}g|djg d~d ifyde d nb bjge|f~fh d jfndge|d~f~ sg|fn ~gadeg adĊhg*~d jgŸf |fċd nb kg}g|djg ~|d ifydeb‑(Lghb d @f|ofkg}dhb iffesf|djfh~ ebe}b if ldab d Ivkgab}dib
jhgkb sd~bhib egiv hb|gn v Ld@jb~|b ~blv ~fjbjb! s|gmfg| _sb*`dċ dnf ng e|bib ~f ednb jbefsgifndhd` sgad~dĊb|b ebg d egjsaf~sgad~dĊef ofhf( S|febĊvċd ~fjfhb ~fjv! egif v vŢ~dhd Ċdhf ifnhvoifadhv! dyjfĒv g~bagk if |febgebeg if Lghb d @f|ofkg}dhb }if~*ed fesf|djfh~! ebe}b if ldab d Iv*kgab}b5 n|Ÿb}b b }dŢf hb|gnbknif f hbdabyd hb jbaf jfĒvhb|gn*
hf |byadef egif f s|f~}b|biv v }f*adef! hb|gnhg |fĊfhg ‘s|b}d~d gnjv`f jfn}ifnb‑( Ebe}b hbj ~gn|Ÿb}b v eghbĊhdod ~|flb ebeg ld}d ldad ybng}gaihd7
‘^|flbab ld ld~d ~g Ţ~g if~f( Hd ^v|od if hdv bhvad|bad d Lghb ċf g~b~d( S|g*lafj Lghf if Ţ~g if nfadjg( źbaghg ifŢ~g djbjg n}f Ţegaf sgn d~dj e|g}gj(Sg Ċfjv f |seb jb~fjb~deb |byadevifgn lgŢhibĊef dad |}b~ef7 Lghb if hdĊd* ib d }bĊb ‟ ghb if }gib ! ibĊb gn }fkb(
Hbjb ~|flb bjggn|Ÿd}b n|Ÿb}b b hfn|Ÿb}b egib djb ~g~dhv d fnbjhbf~~|bhbeb( V Fhkafegi d Bjf|dod djb~f sg n}b lageb d ~g if ~g( Nb jg jd hg|*jbahb n|Ÿb}b! s|}g f hf ldjg y}badLghb d @f|ofkg}dhb! if| @f|ofkg}dhb vhbyd}v n|Ÿb}f hfjb d~g|eg vsg|dŢ~f(Y}bad ld f Lghb b k|bĒbhd Lghf ldldad lgbhod eb~gadĊef! s|b}gab}hf! dabj*ef ebg d |fadkf g~bad` k|vsb‑(
Hb~b}aibivċd s|dĊv g |byadĊd~g~d'
adĊhg~d hb|gnb v Ld@! s|gm( _sb`dċhb~b}aib(‘Nbajb~dhbo d _ab}ghbo v nff~
sv~b }dŢf |byadĊd~d hfkg }d hb|gnd vhv*~b| Ld@( Jd ifjg yfjaib ngl|d` aivnd!bad ngl|d` aivnd egid v ybsvŢ~fhd! egid*jb if ‘}if|b‑ n|bŸb gn hg|jbahgk Ÿd*}g~b( Jd f }badjg hbŢdj kavsg~djb( Jd djbjg feghgjv egib if vjif*|fhb ifnhb s|g~d} n|vkd`( Jvadjbhddjbiv }dŢf eg|svb ~f v }dŢf ifnhd
s|g~d} n|vkd hfkg _|ld d @|}b~d v Ld@(HbŢd dh~fafe~vbaod v ybebybad( Hbjb~|flbiv sgad~dĊb|d egid yhbiv Ţ~b if sgad*~deb( HbŢd sgad~dĊb|d kgndhv s|fn dylg|fd kgndhv hbegh dylg|b hdŢ~b hf |bnf(‑(V Ld@ hfjb hg}f }ab~d
‘G}nif ~|flb sg}fċb~d s|bk d s|gjd* ifhd~d dylg|hd ybegh( Beg hdjg v ~bhivdjb~d ifnhgk Ċg}ifeb hb Ċfav n|Ÿb}f! beghdjg v ~bhiv hbvĊhg |bs|b}d~d ebeg~|flb nb f yg}f n|Ÿb}b! ghnb hf ybav*Ÿvifjg n|Ÿb}v( \fod~f jd! nb ad ċf v FV
vċd @f|ofk*Lghb7 @gċf ad v FV b _|*lgj vċd d \_7 Aivnd d~behv yb~b}v}gif n|Ÿb}f d fld abŸv if| LgŢhibodjbhf jf~b ebnb f hb jfnŸdn ~b}d yb~b*}b _bvnef B|blf dad ^v|ef( ]bŸhghbj if nb hb}bjg yb v|ev ebnb dk|b s|g~d} @|}b~ef v egigi dk|b }fċdhb dk|b*Ċb dy Ld@! b hbjb ^v|eb n|bŸb‑ * b|*eb~dĊhg if yb}|Ţdg }gif s|fnb}bhifs|gm( Lfdj _sb`dċ egid f sg yb}|*Ţf~ev ~|dldhf n|vŸdg b sgif~dgodjb
egid v Ÿfaifad nb byhbiv dhmg|jbov}dŢf sg~b}aibivċd sf|ghbahb sd~bhib(Fjf|dh B`jf~bŢf}dċ
V v~g|be! <;(3?(<32<( kgndhf! vyk|bnd Jvyfief yld|ef \vnhdeb Eb*ebhi g~}g|fhb if dyagŸlb adeb Hf|jdhbEgyaf( ]dŢf gn ?3 hg}d` adeb dy Egyad*hgk b~faifb ldċf fnbj nbhb dyagŸfhghb ydng}djb |vnhdĊef jvyfief yld|ef(G}f adef v hb~baf v hfegadeg sgaifn*hid` jiffod! ebg dy|by adeb|f}gk |b*sgagŸfhib d gnhgb s|fjb }begnhf}*hdod( Hb hidjb hfjb s|fsgyhb~aid}d`‘Egyadhd` lgib‑ egif jg vgĊb}bad e|gysvhg gef| hbhd( Dad d` djb! bad hdvngjdhbh~hf ebg v hfedj |bhdj ad*eb|edj sf|dgndjb Hf|jdhb Egyaf(
* Vkab}hgj! ~g if ~|dnfb~be ‘vaibhb sab~hv‑ egib kg}g|f g vhv~|bŢhifj!vjif~hdĊegj! ngŸd}aibiv yb}dĊbib v
hbivŸfj jdav( Gn ebhb~b hb b}ab*jb ~b|d` lgbhed` evċb dy9 J|bjg|b!Sgsb! L|fŸbhb! \dlhdof! }f ng v|lbhd`gad~f|ed` ynbhib v ngadhd YkgŢċf!
EVA^V\B
Gjabndheg vn|vŸfhif JfnŸadbDY Ebebhi g|kbhdyg}bag if s|gjgod*
iv ehidkf @bad~b F|~vė|vab sgn hbyd*}gj ‘_|gnhb |ob‑( G}b ehidkb if hb~v|egj ifydev ngŸd}ifab 6; dynbhibd sg~bab hfybgldabyhg Ţ~d}g ngabyf*ċd` kfhf|bodib ebn if v sd~bhiv ad~b*|b~v|b dy l|bĊhf ~fjb~def( _}ifngodjg nb f v lgbheg`f|ofkg}bĊ*egj n|vŢ~}v }|difnhg~ sg|gndofvk|gŸb}b! hbk|dyb b }d` ~|bhb gnjfndib ng vadof( Hbnbjg f nb ċfg}b ehidkb sgjgċd v gnkbibhiv lg*aid`! ibĊd` kfhf|bodib ngl|d` LgŢhib*hb( ^fjf v ehidyd ‘_|gnhb |ob‚
gl|bĒfhf v hb ifnbh sfodmdĊbhhbĊdh( V gnhgv hb ~fg|dieg yhbhif!beofhb~ if jhgkg }dŢf ~b}aifh hbs|be~dĊhb dev~}b( Sg|fn ~gkb! vs|}d sabh v dyhffhd }begnhf}hds|glafjd d sd~bhib egib yb }begkĊg}ifeb s|fn~b}aibiv }gif}|hv`d~hv sg~|flv9 s|b}dab gnbld|b l|bĊ*hgk n|vkb! ebeg f v sg|gndod vsg*~b}aibiv sgegi d |fċb! ybŢ~g fvs|vŸhdod |by}gnf! |ifŢfhib ybsbŢb}bhif l|beb! eaivĊf}d l|bĊhf|fċf! d n|(
* ^|bŸd~d |fċv! ng~dċd if d Ÿd}if~d ifv sg~svhg~d s|fn~b}aib bh }begk
Sgyg|dŢ~f hbŢag hbĊdhbnb s|fŸd}d
Oblb|f~ gndk|bhv Fhigtv
Sdghd|ed sgnv`}b~
ebebhied` kavjbob
Sdghd|ed sgnv`}b~ ebebhied`
kavjbobHdebnb f v Ebehiv gn ghd}bhibN|bjegk ~vnb hf ybldaifŸdab d~vbobnb ebebhied kavjod gndk|biv s|fn~b}vv ebċv" Sdghd|ed sgnv`}b~ ebebhied`kavjbob v b|bnhid b }abhdodjb sgsv*ab|hgk ebebhiegk glife~b Fhigt ngŢab ifb}dj sgh~bhg( V ifev |vŢfhib eva~v|*hgk djlgab! Ngjb eva~v|f! ebebhiedkavjod v g~bad ve|bċfhd nb }gi kav*jbĊed ~bafh~ sgebŸv hb sgyg|dŢhdj nb*ebjb( ^f sgyg|dŢhf nbef v ybjfhdadsgnfj v ebċv( Vs|b}g f ~beb} ifnbhs|ffnbh nfdg v sghfnifaibe <=( jb|~b(
Oblb|f~ ebg kavjbĊed dy|bŸbi sgnafŸfdjs|g}dybodid d vs|b}g v g}d kavjodsgevŢbad nb e|gy djs|g}dybov v ~|bibhivgeg =3 jdhv~b gnkg}g|f d s|debŸv hfef~blv ~fjf( V s|fn~b}d v kavjdad9 Jd|hfEvlb~! D|hd LdŢĊg! Nbibhb Jb`jv~g}dċ dFjf|dh B`jf~bŢf}dċ! Ċabhg}d ebebhiegk‑N|bjegk ~vnb‑( S|feg ~g~dhv sgif*~dabob! gn egid` v }fċdhb ldaf y}bhdof!sgad~dĊb|d! nd|fe~g|d! s|fnifnhdod ~|bhbebd ~beg nbaif! ldad v }fgjb ybng}gaihd }d*Ēfhdj ~f v kavjof hbk|bndad k|gjgkab*hdj bsabvydjb(
‘HbŢ odai if nb eva~v|b v Ebehiv Ÿd}d
hb g}bi dad hb ghbi hbĊdh( Jd jg s|}d sv~v|bndad hfŢ~g adĊhg v Ebehiv d n|bkg jd if nb if }f s|gŢag ebeg ~|flb( Jd ċfjgf d nbaif ~|vnd~d nb hb g}beb} d adĊbhhbĊdh v ngkg}g|v b kavjodjb ngkg}g*|djg adĊhf }fĊf|d‑! d~bebg if _bjd|Djbjg}dċ! ifnbh gn }abhdeb obf Fhigt(
Lvnvċd nb if g}g s|}d sv~ nb f sg*yg|dŢhf s|fn~b}f dy}gnf v ifnhgjebċv! yb s|}d sv~ v g|kbhdyb~g|d v|v*Ċd}bad sgyd}hdof( ]fċ <( bs|dab! oblb|f~*eb s|fn~b}b ċf f sghg}g gndk|b~d vd~gj agebav! ebnb ċf }d egid Ÿfaf sg*kafnb~d d vĊf~}g}b~d v hfĊfjv hg}gjjgċd nb |fyf|}dŢv }gif jif~g( \fyf|*}bof ċf f vydjb~d v ebċv Fhigt( FB
Yb}dĊbihg*ebebhieb
DyagŸlb adeb Hf|jdhb Egyaf
Gn ebhb~b hb b}adibjb ~b|d`lgbhed` evċb ng v|lbhd`gad~f|ed` ynbhibebŸf Egyag(
G}g if s|}b gn n}bnff~be Egyadhdbjg~bahd` dyagŸld yb egiv f jgŸf |fċd
nb if sg~svhg ebebhieb( V g}gj yb}dĊbi*hg*ebebhiegj gsvv gif~d f adeb|f}ngŸd}aibi e|bigadeb dy}bh k|bnegk ge|v*Ÿfhib d v k|bnegj ge|vŸfhiv( By_
Ÿfaib( Sg~gif n}f ghg}hf |bnhifegif ~|flbiv v|bnd~d l|bĊhd sb|g}degid Ÿfaf ld~d |f~hd( Ifnhb if byhbhif~fg|ed` d hbvĊhd` yhbhib d jdŢaifhif~|vĊhibeb d gn|bĒd}bhif s|ds|fjb(N|vkb if s|ghbabybe |f~hd` sb|g}b vge|vŸfhiv d nglbhif dhmg|jbob g~gjf ebeg v ghd mg|jd|bad }gif af*sg khfyng! d g s|b}dadjb egid` v f~gj s|dadegj s|dn|Ÿb}bad( Ebnb fb~b}f ~fg|eb byhbhib d s|be~dĊhds|djif|d! dkv|bh bj nb ċf sb|g}degid Ÿfaf ld~d |f~hd v l|bev! ngċd ng
eaivĊf}b |fċf! d~bebg if bv~g| hbs|gjgod v Ebehiv( _E
ab ld ndif~f v }gj ~bhv egid f hbabyd vvadod ;( jvadjbhef << egn ]f~f|dhb|*ef ~bhdof*s|dyfjaif$ v Ebehiv( źd}dj bvs|vkgj hb~b}hdegj v sfhydid( Y}b~dhb ~fafmgh 3?<'66?*46< dad hb jgld~fa3=<'0;2*<;25
Fedsb \vnb|b hbegh |f*jb v Ld`bċv! d v ge}d|v 2;(egab if ldab kg~! g}bi sv~
egn fedsf Gjabndhob dyJdghdof( Gjabndhbo if! dhb*Ċf! fedsb egib if ~|flbab nbd~vsd dy Adkf! bad v dsbehb~b}dad b ~bejdĊfhifj beavl v dj hbsv~dad kg~g}g}d dk|bĊd sb v fedsv \vnb*|b hb }gj ~|b}hibev ngĊf*ebad b kg~g}g ivhdg|edjb~b}gj( ^g f hb e|bivgn|bydag d hb |fyva~b~! b fed*sb \vnb|b ab}dab if |fyva~b*
~gj =93! Ţ~g dj if vifnhg dhbi}fċb kg~vivċb sglifnbgn ebnb f ~bejdĊf v g}gj|bhkv ~bejdĊfhib( _~|faodyb fedsv \vnb|b ldad v9
Fedsb Jabng~d hb~b}dab if ~bejdĊfhif v s|gaif~hgjnfav s|}fh~}b N|vkf adkf MLD@( V n}f v~bejdoffedsb Jabng~d vldaifŸdab if > lgnb( V s|}gi v~bejdodkg~g}bad v v _b|bif}v ~f v b fedsgj ]|b~hdeb gndk|b*ad hf|fŢfhg ?9?! dbeg v djbad }gn~}g gn ?92( M|aibe!
Jvdċ d Lbi|bjg}dċ ldad v ~|faod yb fedsv Jabng~d(Hbegh ~gkb fedsb Jabng~d if s|fn }gidj hb}bĊdjb
vkg~dab fedsv Gy|fhb dy _fjdyg}ob! ~f v dybl|bhdod HbybEbsf g~}b|dad v}if|aid}v sglifnv |fyva~b~gj ?93( _~|faod v ldad LgŢhibe! M|aibe! ~f Sdaivk(
Hbegh g}f v~bejdof ~|fhf|b Ebsv jgŸf |bng}b~dĊdhifhdob nb fedsb Jabng~d sghg}g nifavif egjsbe~hg!b sghbi}dŢf jgkv ld~d ybng}gaihd Ċdhifhdogj nb if eghbĊ*hg s|g|bndab |fbadybob sb v v n}f v~bejdof }fċ vsif*ad nb sg~dkhv Ţf~ kgag}b! b |fbadybob if ldab ifnhb gn}faded` lgaied fedsf Jabng~d v iffhifj nfav s|}fh~}b(G}gj sglifngj Jabng~ f }|bċb v kg|hid ndg ~blfaf sbv ~beg }fċ bnb hb Ţf~gj jif~v s|}fh~}fhf ~blfaf! b~|fċfsabd|bhd \vnb| dy L|fyf lifŸd dj bjg 6 sgfhb(
\feg|nhb sglifnb v Jdghdodfedsv \vnb|b kv|hvab eb }|`v ~blfaf
}bab if egn fedsf _~vnfh~b ~f ifvldaifŸdab sglifnv! b hbegh ~gkbhb }gjf ~f|fhv ngĊfebab if fedsvHbs|f~eb! Ċf v lgif l|bhdad hf*ebnbŢhid dk|bĊ GE Ebebhi āv|bhBjd|! ~f Ebebhibo B|jdh Mfiyg}dċ(V n}g|bhd v Ebehiv evsdag f geg<33 kafnbabob! b djbad v jhgkg~gkb yb }dnif~d( Fedsb Hbs|f~ebngŢab if v sgevŢbiv nb dyhfhbndfedsv GE Ebehib d jbag if mbadagnb v ~gjf d vsf( S|}d f~ fedsbHbs|f~eb djbab if sf|jbhfh~hg}gn~}g ng |fyva~b~b 20920! ebnbfedsb GE Ebebhi hb ibihv f|}vNbhkvldċb s|fvydjb }gn~}g ~f
hb e|biv vydjb d f~ |fyva~b~gj<69<?( V n|vkgj f~v d~b d~vbobhb ~f|fhv! Hbs|fnbe djb }gn~}gng s|fn bjd e|bi f~b b ~bnb |b*sgagŸfhd Jv~fnbhg}dċ nghgd
s|f}bkv d k|bĒf}dhb|d g}bibiv f~|fyva~b~gj <69<? lbŢ ebg d v s|}gjf~v( V ~|fċfj f~v |bydk|bad v fkg~d( _ibihv sb|~v v d~gj s|vŸdg
if jabnd Mfiyg}dċ ~f fedsb Hbs|f~ebg}bib g}bi f~ |fyva~b~gj <692?(Dsbe! v }dŢf gn ~gkb hdv jgkad! vĊf~}|~gj f~v fedsb GE Ebebhigndk|bab if ngl|g ~f if |byadeb ve}bad~f~d hb e|biv dsbe s|fvndab! sbv k|bĒf}dhb|d g}gidad f~ |fyva~b*~gj <69<<( Dbeg v v eghbĊhgjeg|v gnlgiebŢd GE Hbs|fnbe ldad
lgaid |fyva~b~gj 4?900! dykvldad vg}bi v|f~! b kafnbgod v Ebehiv veghbĊhg djbad s|b}v s|dadev }dnif*~d n}f e}bad~f~hf fedsf hb sb|ef~vng}g|bhf v Ebehiv d s|b}b if Ţ~f~bŢ~g fedsb Hbs|f~eb hdif dylg|dabsabjbh hb yb}|Ţhdov Evsb LD@(Ngjbċb svladeb bsabvydjb if hb*k|bĒd}bab }bed nglb| sg~fy ‘hb*Ţd`‑ āv|bhb d Mfiyg}dċb! b hb e|bivv k|gjgkabhdj bsabvydjb b~f|fhb ds|b~dad glf fedsf( Fedsb GEEbebhi g}gj sglifngj vldaifŸdab
if 2;( vyb~gshd ~|vjm! Ţ~g dj nbifhbi}fċf Ţbhf yb sf~d vybgshd hb*ag} s|}beb LD@(
Hbegh s|gjifhf v mg|jb~v ~bejdĊfhibn|vkd` adkb MLD@ yb gnlgiebŢf hbi}dŢf vdykvldad kafnbgod! sb if ~beg fedsb GBEbebhi g}f kgndhf hb }gjf ~f|fhv vkg*~dab bjg 6 fedsb( Hbegh sf~gjiffĊhfsbvyf egib if ~|bibab gn e|bib ge~gl|bs|gŢaf kgndhf! sb }f ng jb|~b ~fevċf!fedsb GB Ebebhi }|b~dab f ~bejdĊb|edjhb}debjb( Fedsb GB Ebebhi v jb|~v ċfgndk|b~d }d` 6 egab s|gaif~hgk nfab s|*}fh~}b! b Ċf~d|d v }fċ gndk|bad ~f vldaifŸd*ad Ċf~d|d ibihf sglifnf( Fedsb GB Ebebhis|f bjgk sgĊf~eb hb~b}eb s|}fh~}bg~bab if lfy ifnhgk gn hbilgaid` dk|bĊbg}gk eavlb! ~f`hdĊb|b Lfajdhb Lfkdċb!egid if vsdg nb g~}b|d ibibh dhgyfjhdbhkbŸjbh v Eb~b|v! knif if v Ng`d sg~sd*bg vkg}g| b fedsgj Fa B|bld Ċdif ċf lgif l|bhd~d hb|fnhd` 6 kgndhb( Dsbe! ybg}v ibihv Ţegav gnlgief d ~g hf s|fn~b}*aibag s|glafj sb v ‘bebnfjod‑ d lfy
ibihgk Lfkdċb g~}b|dad > hg}f sglifnf ~ff ~beg ng}fad hb l|giev gn 4 sglifnb dy 4
Fedsb źGE Ebebhi if dyjfĒv n}b l|gibgndk|bab n}f v~bejdof( Dybl|bhdof @badnbHfdjb|af hb }gjf ~f|fhv v vkg~daffedsv Hbs|f~eb dy GnŸbeb! nge v v kg~d*jb gndk|baf nf|ld v|f~ b fedsgj Kg|bŸ*nb( V s|}gj v|f~v fedsb GE Ebebhi if
s|fn geg 233*~dhibe kafnbabob vkg~dab fedsvHbs|f~eb( ]fċ v s|}gj f~v fedsb Hbs|f~*eb s|vŸdab if g~sg| ngjbċdj dk|bĊdobjb sb if s|}d f~ yb}|Ţfh |fyva~b~gj <69<<( Vn|vkgj f~v fedsb źGE Ebebhi if sg egyhb egid sv~ g}f fyghf! sgeafehvab sb vkgŢċf }dŢf hfkg ybavŸfhg g}gidaf g}bi f~|fyva~b~gj <692>( Dsbe! v hb|fnhb n}b f~bngjbċf dk|bĊdof v f |bydk|baf ~beg nb hdvngy}gadaf dyhfhbĒfhif hb }gjf sb|ef~v( V~|fċfj f~v źGE Ebebhi f |f}bhŢd|bgfedsd Hbs|f~eb sb d if s|fkbydg |fyva~b~gj<692<! nb ld v Ċf~}|~gj f~v |fyva~b~ ldg<692>! Ţ~g if v eghbĊhdod fedsd źGE Ebebhinghdg sglifnv |fyva~b~gj ?92(
Hbegh ~gkb źGE Ebebhi if kg~g}babv Kg|bŸnv egn d~gdjfhf fedsf! sb v v ifnhgi ibihgi s|fn~b}d vsdbaf }gi n|vkdg}gfyghed sg|by! d sg|fn ~gkb Ţ~g v ldaf hbngjbe igŢ ifnhgi sglifnd( FedsbźGE Ebebhi vŢab if v v|f~ mv|dgyhg! sbv }fċ s|}d f~ |fŢdaf v }giv eg|d~ |fyva*~b~gj <692?( Dsbe! n|vkd f~ dj if sghg}g ldg eglbh sb v v d~gj s|fkbŸfhf b ifn}b n}godm|fhdj vĊdhegj b |fyva~b~ ifkabdg <6922 v eg|d~ ngjbċd` dk|bĊdob( V~|fċfj d Ċf~}|~gj f~v ngjbċb svladebdjbab if s|dadev nb }dnd ibihv gnlgiev bglf ~|bhf( |fċd f~ s|dsbg if fedsd Ebehib|fyva~b~gj <;9<6! nb ld Ċf~}|~d f~ g}gidafngjbċf dk|bĊdof |fyva~b~gj <=9<>( V sf*~gj f~v ngjbċf dk|bĊdof gndk|baf vsghg}g ngl|g sb v v eghbĊhdod ab}daf|fyva~b~gj 26923! Ċdjf v vsifaf nb g~ed*hv < lgnb fedsd źGE Ebebhi(
G}dj sg|bygj fedsb źGE Ebebhid nbaif if g~bab hb s|}gj jif~v bd~dj gjif|gj sglifnb d sg|byb ebg dfedsb ]gkgŢċf! bad b ~|d lgnb }dŢf hfkgsgjfhv~b fedsb( Fedsb źGE Ebebhi vhb|fnhgj egav kg~g}b~ ċf vs|b}g egn
fedsf ]gkgŢċf Ţ~g ċf vifnhg ld~d d nf|lds|}fh~}b! bad d eghbĊhg jif|dag s|fjd* if|adkbŢed` bjldob g}f fedsf(
\vegjf~bŢd \E Ebebhi }fċ v ifnhgjhgkgj v S|fjdf| adkd( Dbeg f ~g Ċdhdagjhgkg ~fŸf hfkg v gĊfed}bad hbegh ydjefsbvyf! ylgk gnabeb hfegadodhf dk|bĊb dyg}gk eavlb! fedsb \E Ebebhi dsbe if ybn|*Ÿbab e}bad~f~ d ngl|f |fyva~b~f sb v bjdj~dj d nbaif hb~b}dad b sglifnbjb b hbegh2>( egab sg~bag if f}dnfh~hg nb ċf g}bfedsb dylg|d~d sabjbh v S|fjdf| adkv(
V sf|dgnv dyjfĒv n}b l|gib fedsb \EEbebhi gndk|bab if n}b v|f~b( S|}g if ldagkg~g}bhif v Ibiov knif v v ibihgi |vegjf~*hgi b~jgmf|d! v nf|lv egab! vsifad nb b}ab*nbiv ngjbċv fedsv \E Ibiof |fyva~b~gj <;9<3(]fċ v s|}gj sgav}|fjfhv fedsb \E Ebebhisgebybab if nb if ngŢab b odaifj nb f dy Ibiob}|b~d vyndkhv~f kab}f! Ţ~g v hb e|biv vsifadnb g~}b|f( Gn <; kgag}b ~|gibo Ybdjg}dċ*D}bhdŢf}dċ*Lv|ydċ sg~dkad v << kgab 4*;*=$!~f if fedsb \E Ebebhi hb hid`g}dj e|dadjbngŢab ng sglifnf( Hbegh ~gkb fedsb \EEbebhi hb }gjf ~f|fhv vkg~dab fedsv \EźfsĊb egib if vsifab hb kg~g}bhiv dyhfhb*
nd~d nghfnb}hgk eghev|fh~b yb vabybe v SAfedsd \E Ebebhi! fedsv \E _bhb ;! ~f fedsvegib f v ydjegi sbvyd sgibĊbab b hfegadod*
Nf~bai b v~bejdof GE \ved * GB Ebebhiegab v N|vkgi adkd MLD@ k|vsf L! b ~djf dybvyfad lgaiv sgydov v sabt gv yb vabybev S|}v adkv MLD@(
GB Ebebh if s|}g kg~g}bg hb DadnŸd knifv g~}b|dad sglifnv hbn d~gdjfhgj fed*sgj |fyva~b~gj ?93( Hbegh ~gkb GB Ebebhi if vkg~dg fedsv Jabng~d dy Lgbhegk Sf*~|g}ob egiv v hb }gjf ~f|fhv b}abnbad|fyva~b~gj ?92! b ghnb v dŢad hb kg~g}bhiffedsd GE \ved dy Yfhdof egid v vsifad nbb}abnbiv |fyva~b~gj ?93( Fedsb GB Ebebhi if <>( jb|~b hb }gjf ~f|fhv vkg~dab fedsv_~vnfh~b ~f v d v g}gi v~bejdod sgebybad b}}gi e}bad~f~ ~f ab}dad |fyva~b~gj ?93! Ċdjfv g}if|dad s|}g jif~g hb s|}fh~}fhgi aif*~}dod! ds|fn fedsf GE \ved( V sabt gvfedsb GB Ebebhi djb~ ċf hbi}if|g}b~hf ybs|g~d}hdef djb~d fedsf Ifndh~}b d _|fnhigŢ*egaob! Ţ~g dj ybdkv|hg nbif yb s|b}g nb fhbnbiv `d~g|egj vsif`v d sabjbhv vS|}v adkv MLD@ }fċ v n|vkgi kgndhd }gkb
sg~gibhib! Ţ~g if ybdkv|hg `}baf }|fnbhvsf` g}f bebnfjf(
\E Ebebhi ifnhgj hgkgj v S|fjdf| adkd
^blfab S|}f |vegjf~hf adkf Ld@
k|vsb _if}f|
hgj dy}|hd` dk|bĊb( Dsbe! ifnhb g}be}bv~bejdob hf s|d}veab }fadeg dh~f|fg}bhifkafnbabob sb if v n}g|bhd v Ebehiv ldag hfk*nif geg 233*~dhibe kafnbabob( _}f ~g hf jf*~bag fedsd \E Ebebi nb d nbaif hb~b}d }givsglifnghghv f|v b kg~d dy źfsĊb s|f~|sd*ad v sg|by |fyva~b~gj ?=9<;( _ibibh hb g}gjv|f~v ldg if Lv|ydċ b 2? kgag}b egid if ldghf|fŢd}b fhdkjb kg~djb dy źfsĊb! b lbŢ ebgd v s|f~`ghgj v|f~v ibihv sb|~v s|vŸdadv igŢ d D}bhdŢf}dċ ~f Ybdjg}dċ b sg 0 sg~d*khv~d` kgag}b(
Fedsb \E Ebebhi g}dj |fyva~b~djb }fċ if ifngj hgkgj v S|fjdf| adkd! b Ċfeb f igŢ bjg jb~fjb~dĊeg gdkv|b}bhif d~gk(
EgŢb|ebŢd EE Ebebhi vsdbad v igŢn}f sglifnf v sf|dgnv dyjfĒv n}b
l|gib ~f v hb ~bi hbĊdh vsifad nb ybof*jfh~d|biv s|}g jif~g egif ċf dj v
sabt gv nghf~d s|fnhg~ ngjbċfk~f|fhb( Ldabh if ~g gndk|bhf n}f v~b*ejdof d ~g 26( d 2=( egab(
V ge}d|v 26( egab fedsb EE Ebebhikg~g}bab if v _b|bif}v egn fedsf sg*
ibĊbhf fedsf _sb|b! ~f v s|fn}gĒfhdibihdj Sfai~gj egid s|fjb l|giebjbdk|b hb hd}gv hb egifj ld jv sgyb}d*nifaf d hfef jhgkg }fċf y}fynf g}gksg|~b! ngŢad ng sglifnf |fyva~b~gj;09=4( Ebebhi if gn bjgk sgĊf~ebe|fhvg mv|dgygh ~f v }fċ v s|}gi Ċf*~}|~dhd g~dŢad hb 22 sgfhb |byadef! ng
e|bib sgav}|fjfhb ngjbċb fedsbjbag if jbhidab s|fnghg~ sb f hbgnjg| g~dŢag |fyva~gj >69?0( V n|v*kgj sgav}|fjfhv fedsb EE Ebebhi|v~dhed if Ċv}bab ~fĊfhv s|fnhg~ igŢhb bjgj g~}b|bhiv v|f~b! b b |b*sgagŸfhdj Sfai~gj ~g dj d hf ldag~gadeg ~fŢeg sb if hb e|biv v|f~bfedsb EE Ebebhi ybavŸfhg gnhfabsglifnv( Sg|fn Sfai~f! gadnhv sb|~v
Hb ~v|hd|v egid f gn|*Ÿbg v vlg~v <>(3?(<32<(kgndhf v Nf|}fh~d! begib if ldab ngjbċdh 23(fhdg|egk d 4( ebnf~*egk s|}fh~}b Ld@! hb*~vsdab if d fedsb ^ENHv|( Hb s|}fh~}v ifhb~vsdag <2> ~bejdĊb|bdy <6 eavlg}b Ld@( Eb*ebhied ^EN eavl ‘Hv|‑
sg~bg if fhdg|ed }dof*s|}be Ld@( Lg|od g}gkeavlb v sgifndhbĊhgieghev|fhod g}gidad v= jfnbaib d ~g9 < yab~hf! 2|fl|fhv d ? l|ghybhfjfnbaif( Jfnbaibjb vf ged~dad9 @b|d JvŢb!yab~hb jfnbaib! egid ifg}gidg ;( vyb~gshv ~d*~vav s|}beb LD@! Bjf|
Lfkdċ! yab~hb jfnbaib!egigj if sg~bg fhdg|*ed s|}be LD@! Bjd|
Yb g}if|v s|}gk jif~b s|fn sabt gm
IGţ N]DIF SGLIFNF FEDSF EE EBEBHI Fedsb EE Ebebhi gdkv|bab if
s|}g jif~g v sabt gmmv e|gy egid
ċf f yhb~d sg}|b~hde v hbifad~hdifegŢb|ebŢeg ~bejdĊfhif v LD@! b
dy egifk v hb }fadeg dyhfhbĒfhif ybaivlaifhdeb v g}bi sg|~ v LD@!}fċ dsbad EE āfade ~f EE Y|dhied!~beg ċf fedsb EE Ebebhi vegadegdylg|d sg}|b~be v fad~hd |by|fn sg*
~b~d ifndhd s|fn~b}hde Yf*ng ebh*
~ghb v hbifad~hdifj egŢb|ebŢegj
~bejdĊfhiv v LD@(
s|vŸdad v igŢ d Lfkg}bo b 2<! ~f _vaib*kdċ b 23 sgfhb(
Hbegh ~gkb fedsb EE Ebebhi hb
}gjf ~f|fhv ngĊfebab if fedsv _~v*nfh~b dy ^vyaf( ^vyabod sgibĊbhd bhfegadeg dk|bĊb hfebnbŢhifk kdkbh~b_aglgnf v Ebebhi hdv ngŢad b lfagjyb~b}dogj! Ţ~b}dŢf sglifnb fedsf EEEbebhi }ddab if v y|bev ng bjgke|bib v|f~b( EE Ebebhi ibihg if g~}g*|dg v|f~! }fċ v s|}gi Ċf~}|~dhd djbadv s|fnhg~ gn 26 sgfhb |byadef! sb if}f jd|dbag hb igŢ ifnhv abkbhv sg*
lifnv( Dsbe! kg~d v n|vkg sgav}|fjfvabyf jhgkg lgaif d bk|fd}hf Ţ~g fgif~dag d hb bjgj |fyva~b~v ~beg nb
if jdhv~v s|f e|bib |fyva~b~ hb fjb*
mg|v ldg 0<90<( V bjgi yb}|Ţhdod v*|f~b fedsb EE Ebebhi vŢab if `abnhfkab}f sb if hb e|dadjb! d v g}gi v~bejd*od ibihgk Sfai~f ngŢab ng eghbĊhf sg*
v~bejdobjb fedsf EE Ebebhi hb ~|d* ldhbjb hfjb svhg kafnb~faib! b |byagk~gjv }bebeg afŸd d v Ċdhifhdobjb nbf }fċ hfegadeg }defhnb nfŢb}b nb fv _sg|~egi n}g|bhd v Ebehiv dk|bivsg ~|d v~bejdof nhf}hg egŢb|eb! jvŢ*eb gnlgieb! Ÿfheb gnlgieb! dad |veg*
jf~$! ~f ld vs|b}f g}d` eavlg}b }beb*eg ~|flbaf nb sg|bnf hb egg|ndhbod|bsg|fnb ebeg ld f hb ~bi hbĊdhgjgkdċdag ghdjb egid ~g Ÿfaf! nb hfjg|biv sg odifad nbh nb s|g}fnv v_sg|~egi n}g|bhd(
V hb|fnhgj 2;( egav fedsb EEEbebhi ld~ ċf aglgnhb! nge ċf egaghbegh ~gkb v kg~f fedsd EE Adjgjf*~ba dy Obydhb(
āabhg}d ^EN Hv| Ebebhi fhdg|ed }dofs|}bod LD@
āabhg}d EN Hv| b s|dyhbhidjb hb n|Ÿb}hgj~bejdĊfhiv v Nf|}fh~d
Jvidċ! |fl|fhb jfnbaib!egigj f ged~dg ~d~vagjfhdg|egk }dofs|}bebLD@! nge v NfadlbŢdċJd|yf~ ! Kbhdlfkg}dċ
J v ` b j f n ~ f E v l b ~Bjb| vsifad nb f ged~f l|ghybhdj jfnbaibjb(
Hb e|biv ~v|hd|b ybav*Ÿfhg if v }d~|dhf g}gkeavlb ngŢbg d sf`b| v|vef fhdg|ef fedsf! egidv hbs|b}dad ibibh |fyva*
~b~ sg~b}Ţd }dofs|}bodLd@! b yb ibibh |fyva~b~ybavŸhd v9 @b|d! Bjf|!
Bdj d Bjb|( G}g s|}fh*~}g vndab if d Ċabhdob^EN Hv| _vjfib Jvidċegib if g}f kgndhf sgagŸd*ab dsd~ yb adofhov vob ?(eabf( ]|fnhg if hbsg*jfhv~d nb n}b Ċabhb ENeavlb ‑Hv|‚ Ebebhi! @b*|d JvŢb d Bdj Jvidċ<4(3?(<32<( kgndhf hb~v*sbiv b |fs|fyfh~bogj
Ld@ hb ~v|hd|v ‑B‚ eabfv Lfakd! knif if vifnhg ds|g}if|b s|fn gnabybe hbf}|gseg s|}fh~}g vJbhĊf~f|( IgŢ ifnhb ~b*ejdĊb|eb EN eavlb Hv|d ivhdg|eb |fs|fyfh~b~d}*eb _vjfib Mfiydċ hb~vsd~ċf hb jfĒvhb|gnhgj~v|hd|v v v|egi <3( d <2(bs|dab g}f kgndhf(
_}f Ċf~d~ef d sg`}bafyb ~bejdĊb|f bfe{ghngeavlb ‘Hv|‑ Ebebhi(
Ylgk ebhgk s|fjb jb~f|bab v s|gŢagj l|g* iv jg }bj g~bad nvŸhd dhmg|jbof b hb~vsbĊabhg}b EN Ofh~b| b n|Ÿb}hgk s|}fh~}b egif ifgn|Ÿbhg v ]gkgŢċd( ^EN Ofh~b| if hb~vsdg b 0~bejdĊb|b! ~f v g}gidad = jfnbaib d ~|d sf`b|b( Vvevshgj sg|f~ev yb jabĒf ebnf~f g}gidad vn|vkg jif~g( EN Ofh~b| if ybvyfg d ~|fċf jif~gfedshg v jabĒdj ebnf~djb v jvŢegi eghev|fhod!nge if Bjdhb K|b`dċ ldab hbilgaib jabnb ebnf~edhib~v|hd|b( Jfnbaif hb g}gj s|}fh~}v v g}gidad(Bjdhb K|b`dċ* yab~g! Jb|dh Igydċ*yab~g! Jd|hf_bmvhĒb*yab~g! Jb`d| _ded|b*|fl|g! Fjdhb _b*
mvhĒdib*|fl|g! Bjjb| @fkbhg}dċ*l|ghyb( Hb~v|hd|v if ldag <6 eavlg}b d ?3; ~bejdĊb|b(Hbegh g}gk s|}fh~}b EN Ofh~b| hb~vsdg if
hb 23( sg |fnv N|Ÿb}hgj s|}fh~}v yb fhdg|f dfhdg|ef! ~f ebnf~f d ebnf~edhif v ~bfe{ghngvegif f gn|Ÿbag <>(3?(<32<( kgndhf v Nf|}fh~d(^bfe{ghng eavl Ofh~b| if g}f kgndhf hb~vsdg vsgnjabĒfhgj b~b}v d hb s|}fh~}g sg}fg bjg0 ~bejdĊb|b Ţ~g ib hb e|biv |fyva~d|bag g}bibhifj 6jfnbaib! d ~g9 ifnhgj yab~hgj! ifnhgj |fl|fhgj~f ~|d l|ghybhf jfnbaif( Hg}d n|Ÿb}hd s|}be d yab~*hb jfnbaib v ebnf~djb ng ?; ek sg~bg if Hf|jdhDjbjg}dċ egid if ng yab~b d ~d~vaf n|Ÿb}hgk s|}bebsglfndg vevshg v sf~ lg|ld gn egid` if ifnhb
yb}|Ţfhb d hgebv~gj egid if ds|bċfh gk|gjhdjbsabvygj d g}bobjb gn ~|bhf svladef d sgif~d*~faib( Fjdhb _dabnŸdċ if sg~bab }dofs|}bedhib Ld@b g}gifhdj n|vkdj jif~gj d |fl|fhgj jfnb*aigj( Fjdhb if v hbav dykvldab gn ~bhnb|nhfs|}bedhif Ld@ }fċ nvkd hdy kgndhb( ^|fċf jif~g ifybvyfg _fjd| Djbjg}dċ bad if ~ifhg dykvldg ybs|gabybe v sgavhbaf ~beg if g}gidg l|ghybhvjfnbaiv( @bjyb L|edċ d Fjd| Kg|bab v g}gidad~begĒf| l|ghybhf jfnbaif( G~bad ~bejdĊb|d g}gkeavlb! ţfjb _dabinŸdċ ylgk sg}|fnf hf vsifabnb~d }f gn flf bad if dsbe dyn|Ÿbab Ċd~b} jfĊ dbeg if ldab sgn lgag}djb( Nge v _ded|b Jv`bjfn dJd|yb NfadlbŢdċ dykvldad s|}f lg|lf(
‘āf~d~bj }gigi fedsd hb vsif`v d ybabkbhiv bsgflhg ~bejdĊb|djb egid v nbad }f gn flf!‑ |d* ifĊd v ~|fhf|b eavlb Nfhdb EhfŸf}dċb(
_bedl Ld~dċ v f b g}gk~v|hd|b }|b~dad b ~|dyab~hf jfnbaif! ifnhbg}gifhb v sgifndhbĊ*hdj lg|lbjb! ~f n}f vfedsdhdj eghev|fhob*jb! ~f ifnhgj l|ghyb*hgj jfnbaigj v sgif*ndhbĊhdj lg|lbjb( Jd*
V sf| dgnv 2; ( d20(3?(<32<( kgndhf! vg|kbhdybod _ed eavlbEbebhi vsifŢhg if gn|*Ÿbhb n}gnhf}hb Ţegabedibhib yb godibaghgvk|gŸfhf eb~fkg|difnifof( S|gifeb~ if |fbad*yg}bh vy }f|nhv sg*n|Ţev Jdhd~b|~}b gl*|byg}bhib! hbvef! eva*~v|f d sg|~b Yf*ng
ebh~ghb! ~f vy vĊfŢċf_sg|~egk b}fyb gsŢ~d*hf Ebebhi( _bj s|gif*eb~ sgn|Ÿbad v! ebeg vhb}fad g|kbhdyb~g|d! dngl|d aivnd! b s|f }f*kb _bad` IbŢb|sb`dċk|b` d Ċbi$! HflgiŢbSab}Ţdċ Ċbi d egabĊdċd$ ~fSfeb|b NfadlbŢdċ fh*n}dĊd$( G|kbhdyb~g|d vvsv~dad sgyd} }dj Ţeg*abjb hb sgn|vĊiv hbŢfgsŢ~dhf! b hb sgyd} f
gnby}bag <3 jbadŢbhb!egid v sg~svhg lf*sab~hg djbad s|dadev nb
ida d v yab~hv jfnbaiveavsed v eb~fkg|d eb*nf~b egid if v hbav sg* ldifndg |fyva~b~gj 693ngjbċdhb ~v|hd|b! ~f_bedl Ld~dċ! Jd|bafj Ib*Ţb|sb`dċ d Fajdh ţevaiegid v g}gidad yab~hvjfnbaiv eavsed v bsg*av~hgi eb~fkg|d egid if vhbav sglfndg |fyva~b*~gj 693 fedsv \ffpb(
Sgabyhdod ed Ţegaf ybifnhg b ~|fhf|djbhbvĊf ghg}f g}gkydjegk sg|~b! ~f vdeg|d~dad s|dadev d n|v*Ÿdad f b nifogj dy _edeavlb Ebebhi( Hb |b*ng~ g|kbhdyb~g|b }|f*jf d v}if~d yb g}vn}gnhf}hv Ţegav ldadv dnfbahd( Dy _ed eavlbEbebhi dy|bydad v }fad*eg ybng}gai~}g Ţ~g vhb g}bi hbĊdh djbad s|d*adev nb nbiv }gi ngs|d*
hg |by}giv ed sg|~bv hbŢfj k|bnv! bad d nbnghfv gjif`f hb adob
nifof egib hdv v hbh*egi jgkvċhg~d nbf lb}f g}be}dj }dngjsg|~b! ~f nb g}be}djsg~fygj gl|bnviv d~f!bad d s|vŸf dj jgkvċ*hg~ yb hg}b vsgyhb}b*hib! d igŢ ifnhg hfyblg*|b}hg dev~}g(
Dy _ed eavlb Ebebhi fhbnbiv nb ċf ng kgndhfg}v beodiv igŢ lgaif nbs|fsgyhbiv }d! ~f nb ċf
g}b beob hb|fnhf kgndhf ld~d igŢ e}bad~f~hb! vsifŢ*hb d jhgkgl|gihb(