7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
1/118
!"#$ &'())*+ &* ,-$./
0$.1#2-+ &* 3$-2&* 42/5-26* &* ,-$./
7#8*9*25 ! :; 2":?
;=* 6@-91$* 6"$$*65."22*++*
AB 9.2#5* ! :
AB )-$C#*5 ! #$#%&'''##&
7D3EFEA0 !GHHE!04GAAEI
( )*+,-./01/ 2,3).4,/ -, 56.3,0+) 7866/19.800/) -/ :+6.; )/ 5 ?75?@AB CB=D
E>FFB G=>HIBJ
+ K9K +22/)K/ )L+MM+.6/
EA0HE J
E+-+N/ )/ :A?7=AB=A CB F( AB:=@F>G=B O>H(H7>BAJ 26P; 1/ 96.3,0+)J
-/N+0-/,6 /9 28,6;,.Q+09
,(H04EK !4L4IEK J
I'(3EA0 7DM4!4(4HE ME I'E0(0J -809 )/ ;.PR/ ;81.+) /;9 ;.; :F(7B
@B(=S(= T&U'' :(A>V UBEBJ 2+69./ 1.Q.)/J
6/26K;/09K 2+6 E+W96/ :./66/ C*(IBE(A -/ O(@ABX=BVJ +Q81+9 +, 3+66/+, -/
:+6.; YV7: =A@>H? (;;81.K; Z :#$T[J 4,. -K28;/ -/; 1801),;.80; 6KR,).P6/N/09
-+9K/; /9 ;.R0K/; 2+6 )/ :6K;.-/09 /9 )/ R6/MM./6 /9 \8.09/; +, -8;;./6]
I* !GF40E ME KGD04EA (D ,HENE0 OGAAE0 E0 ( I(
F(A4NEK0(04GA ME I( LEH40EP -809 )/ ;.PR/ ;81.+) /;9 ;.; ^_` A,/ -/
58,6Q.))/ TU#'' V5 XBAE(>H BH F(aB J 2+69./ 1.Q.)/J
080 18N2+6+09 6/26K;/09K ;+0; N+0-+9
+'(//"6.-5."2 KGK L.65.9*/ &* A"5-.$*/J -809 )/ ;.PR/ ;81.+) /;9 ;.;J 2+69./ 1.Q.)/J
080 18N2+6+09 6/26K;/09K ;+0; N+0-+9
+* !"9.5Q &* K"#5.*2 R 3#S 3H(IIP -809 )/ ;.PR/ ;81.+) /;9 ;.;
J 2+69./ 1.Q.)/J
080 18N2+6+09 6/26K;/09K ;+0; N+0-+9
F"2/.*#$ O4M(IGD 7-6C#*/P -/N/,6+09 ! J 2+69./ 1.Q.)/J
18N2+6+09
,-8* : T ::U
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
2/118
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
3/118
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
4/118
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
5/118
!"#$%&
'()*+,-. 012-3, 45"$6%"#$ %&'(#')*) +"*,-$ ." $()/'-,0 1 0, ("2'3$" +' 4,(2'"$5,$)&-,0 6)-,-.)"( #&'# 0, %(7*"-$)&- 8
9:,*&)( 7 8$9:&; ,)-+11,< ?@@? ,< 1, A@ B2.* ?@@C ; "- $&'$ .,# #'( 0"$"(()$&)(" -,$)&-,0 "$ +"%')# $"
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
6/118
'()*+,-. !2)+,1 0$6"8$"#$ %&'(#')*) +"*,-$ ." $()/'-,0 1 0, ("2'3$" +' 4,(2'"$5,$)&-,0 6)-,-.)"( #&'# 0, %(7*"-$)&- 8
9:,*&)( 7 8$9:&; ,)-+11,< ?@@? ,< 1, A= 2(J< ?@@A; "- $&'$ .,# #'( 0"$"(()$&)(" -,$)&-,0 "$ +"%')# $"
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
7/118
R"# +7/,$# &-$ 7$7 $"-'# "- ,'+)"-." %'/0)2'"J
$-3+,)D, 3- ?I *,Q).?"0 @AB9C5; +" >&-#)"'( 9,-)"0 MA5N4A; +">&-#)"'( >).?"0 MA>BT "$ +" >&-#)"'( @7(,(+ >UCVVNRC5; %(7*"-'#J
@BNA5O M0,'+" , .&
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
8/118
R" >)-)#$D(" 4'/0). , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #"# (72')#)$)&-#J
>,Z$(" 4?)0)%%" 9NbA4CUO; ,*&.,$ ,' /,((",' +" 4,()#; .&-#")0 +" >&-#)"'( >).?"0@AB9C5; %(7*"-'; , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #, %0,)+&)()" #'( 0"# -'00)$7#J
>,Z$(" 4?)0)%%" aUBMbN_ NR @bU_C; ,*&.,$ ,' /,((",' +" 4,()#; .&-#")0 +">&-#)"'( M0,'+" @BNA5O; %(7*"-'; , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #, %0,)+&)()"; ,%(D# +7%^$ +".&-.0'#)&-# #'( 0, %("#.()%$)&-J
>,Z$(" 4?)0)%%" 9NbA4CUO; ,*&.,$ ,' /,((",' +" 4,()#; .&-#")0 +" >&-#)"'( >).?"0@AB9C5; %(7*"-'; , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #, %0,)+&)()"; ,%(D# +7%^$ +" .&-.0'#)&-# #'( 0,%("#.()%$)&-J
>,Z$(" 4)"((" 9:A_N>A` 9N 6Aa`N@BNV; ,*&.,$ ,' /,((",' +" 4,()#; .&-#")0 +"R:A@N5O [B9CMCAC`N 9N R:NOAO; %,($)" .)*)0"; , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #, %0,)+&)()";,%(D# +7%^$ +" .&-.0'#)&-# "- (7%&-#" #'( 0, %("#.()%$)&-J
R" >)-)#$D(" 4'/0). , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #"# (72')#)$)&-#J>,Z$(" 4?)0)%%" 9NbA4CUO; ,*&.,$ ,' /,((",' +" 4,()#; .&-#")0 +" >&-#)"'( >).?"0@AB9C5; %(7*"-'; , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #, (7%&-#"J
R" >)-)#$D(" 4'/0). , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #, (7%&-#"J
>,Z$(" [,.2'"# cUb5; ,*&.,$ ,' /,((",' +" 4,()#; .&-#")0 +" >&-#)"'( 9,-)"0MA5N4A; %(7*"-'; , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #, %0,)+&)()"J
>,Z$(" 4?)0)%%" aUBMbN_ NR @bU_C; ,*&.,$ ,' /,((",' +" 4,()#; .&-#")0 +">&-#)"'( M0,'+" @BNA5O; %(7*"-'; , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #, %0,)+&)()"J
>,Z$(" 4?)0)%%" aUBMbN_ NR @bU_C; ,*&.,$ ,' /,((",' +" 4,()#; .&-#")0 +">&-#)"'( M0,'+" @BNA5O; %(7*"-'; , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #, %0,)+&)()"; ,%(D# +7%^$ +".&-.0'#)&-# +" #'%%07A` 9N 6Aa`N@BNV; ,*&.,$ ,' /,((",' +" 4,()#; .&-#")0 +"0:A@N5O [B9CMCAC`N 9N R:NOAO; %,($)" .)*)0"; , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #, %0,)+&)()"J
R" >)-)#$D(" 4'/0). , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #"# (72')#)$)&-#J
>,Z$(" [",-\]*"# 9B4NBT; ,*&.,$ ,' /,((",' +" 4,()#; .&-#")0 +" >&-#)"'( M0,'+"@BNA5O; %(7*"-'; "- #, %0,)+&)()"J
R, %(7#)+"-$" , (,%%"07 0" %0,--)-E %(7*)#)&--"0 +"# ,'+)"-."#J
R, %(7#)+"-$" , )-+)2'7 ,'L %,($)"# 2':'-" .&%)" +"# %(&.D#\*"(/,'L "$ %)D."# +" 0,%"(2')#)$)&- "==".$'7" ,' +&&-#)"'( M0,'+" @BNA5O #"(,)$ ("F??&-#)"'( [",-\[&f0 VMbC59RN`; .)$7 "- 2',0)$7 +" $7F??).?"0 RAB`NO; ,*&.,$ ,' /,((",' +" 4,()#; .&-#")0 +" >&-#)"'( @7(,(+
>UCVVNRC5; %(7*"-'; , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #, %0,)+&)()"; ,%(D# +7%^$ +" .&-.0'#)&-#J
>,Z$(" 9,-)"0 >N`MbAO; ,*&.,$ ,' /,((",' +" a&/)E-X; .&-#")0 +" >&-#)"'(>).?"0 MA>BT; %(7*"-'; , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #, %0,)+&)()"; ,%(D# +7%^$ +" .&-.0'#)&-#J
>,Z$(" [,.2'"# cUb5; ,*&.,$ ,' /,((",' +" 4,()#; .&-#")0 +" >&-#)"'( 9,-)"0MA5N4A; %(7*"-'; , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #, %0,)+&)()"; ,%(D# +7%^$ +" .&-.0'#)&-#J
>,Z$(" [",-\]*"# 9B4NBT; ,*&.,$ ,' /,((",' +" 4,()#; .&-#")0 +" >&-#)"'( M0,'+"@BNA5O; %(7*"-'; , 7$7 "-$"-+' "- #, %0,)+&)()"; ,%(D# +7%^$ +" .&-.0'#)&-#J
R"# %(7*"-'# &-$ "' 0, %,(&0" "- +"(-)"(J
82F, =@ H ==I
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
11/118
R" E("==)"( , $"-' -&$" +' +7(&'0"
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
12/118
&M''$:9"
$U &59 NV$0%:M6 85#N:W5" X %,E" Gg
:Y Z$:%& "% 89M0"!59" %,E" Gg
!"!0E.()(1(F+, 3, 12 Q.(DL3-., %,E" Gg
!"#N, .2QQ(.< 3, 1V:4$H:486 *-. 1,* [.2+* 3V,)\-]
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
13/118
ARA N,* [.2+* 3V,)\-]
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
14/118
CR? !,* Q.L1b^,B,)-*\-V2- S B2+ ?@@?U X 3,* Q.L1b^,B,)
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
15/118
3L,< 3L[+)+ 7 1V2.-+) =T?P
PRA &-. 1, 3L1+< 3, 3L
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
16/118
:KY &59 N"& 8":6"& X %,E" GHH
TR= Y 012-3, 45`$6% %,E" GHH
TR?Y '+DE,1 4$5!:6 %,E" GHh
TRAY !2)+,1 0$6"8$ %,E" GHg
TRC 4L.2.3 'M:&&"N:6 %,E" GHP
TRGY '+DE,1 0$'5K %,E" GHj
#U &59 NV$0%:M6 0:h:N" X %,E" GGH
:Y N,* 3,B2)3,* 3, '()*+,-. e2D\-,* #:!$NM5; 3- 0(B+
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
17/118
N,
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
18/118
R, %(7#"-$" %(&.7+'(" +:"-2'3$" %(70)
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
19/118
=R?R= 0()
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
20/118
N- A--"L" F =)E'(" 0, 0)#$" +"# %"(#&--"# ("-.&-$(7"# %,( 0,
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
21/118
M" +7.("$ %"(1 T,;C+B$, ,$ %+(*,#..";/,V *,(% ., /F"'#$(, 70282F, ?= H ==I
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
22/118
?1 "+ $#$(, 9, ." /:;%:.#9"$#:; 9,% /()9#$% .#)% E ." /()"$#:; 9, .D#;9,-;#$) 9,%+R)$#:;% '"($#/+.#G(,% 9,% ',(%:;;,.% 9,% /"A#;,$% -#;#%$)(#,.%qJ
C0# ("0D*"-$ 2'" p." -:;$), ,; '+#%%";/, 9, ." (,%%:+(/, "..:+), ':+( .,'"#,-,;$ 9, .D#;9,-;#$) 9, %+R)$#:;% '"($#/+.#G(,% 9,% ',(%:;;,.% 9+ /"A#;,$ 9+
-#;#%$(, 9, .D#;$)(#,+( ,;$(, 1??1 ,$ 1??8 T"+K-,;$"$#:; 9, '.+% 9, 7??mV *"9";% ., %,;% 9, /,$$, FS':$FG%,qJ
C0# %(7#"-$"-$ '- $,/0",' +" 0:7*&0'$)&- +" 0, ("##&'(." ,00&'7" %&'( 0" %,)"
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
23/118
N- #X-$?D#"; 0,
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
24/118
+' 9)(".$"'( @7-7(,0 +" 0, 4&0)." 5,$)&-,0" m9@45o; M0,'+" aARA59; "-+,$" +' Q I')00"$ FHGi; +:'-" -&$" +' M&-$(^0" /'+E7$,)(" "$ .&o ,' 9@45 "- +,$" +' GG I')- FHGi "$ +"# &/#"(*,$)&-#+7=)-)$)*"# +" 0, M&'( +"# .& #HH%qJ
82F, ?C H ==I
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
25/118
R"# "-2'3$"'(# &-$ "-#')$" "==".$'7 +"# .&-#$,$,$)&-# #'( 0" (,%%&($ +" 0:C@A "$("."-#7 0"# $"L$"# ,%%0).,/0"# 1 0:,$$()/'$)&- +"# =(,)# +:"-2'3$" "$ +"#'(*")00,-."; 2') &-$ 7$7 ,--"L7# ,' +#)"(J
C0# &-$ "-#')$" "-$"-+' 'R $12+) N$9$64`; )-#%".$"'( E7-7(,0 +"
0:,+
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
26/118
C0 ,%%,(,)##,)$ 2':b"-()"$$" aUCVVNAB; .)$7" %,( $&'# 0"# )-$"(*"-,-$# .&JMA5N4A; R,'("-$ VURR] "$>JaN`RCU_; ."# pC+"$(, 9)/#9,+(% )$"#,;$ /,+I C+# A);)=#/#"#,;$ 9, /,$"A:;9,-,;$ ,$ C+#4 ,; /:;$(,'"($#, "*"#,;$ 9,% /:;$("#;$,% '"($#/+.#G(,%4;:$"--,;$ 9, ',(-";,;/,qJ
M0,'+" @BkA5O )-+)2',)$ ,*&)( #&00).)$7 ." *"(#").?"0@AB9C5; 9@45; 2') +"*,)$ 3$(" +" 0:&(+(" +" GF HHH "'( "- "#%D."# %,(BTo "$ 1 >JaN`RCU_J
40'#)"'(# $7
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
27/118
9"# *7()=).,$)&-# 7$,)"-$ +:,/&(+ J@BkA5O; %')# +"# (".?"(.?"# 7$,)"-$ "==".$'7"# #'( 0"# .&
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
28/118
=RG :)^,*
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
29/118
%(70"*7" #'( 0"# =(,)# +:"-2'3$" "$ +" #'(*")00,-." m6NVo +" 0, %&0)."J C0#:,E)##,)$; #"0&- 0'); +" .&
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
30/118
("#%".$)*").?"0 MA>BT .&-=)(
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
31/118
0:?&
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
32/118
R"# %(7*"-'# ,*,)"-$ "-=)- 0, =,.'0$7; 0&(# +" 0, %?,#" I'()+).$)&--"00"; +" =,)(".)$"( +"# $7
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
33/118
AR= N, B+)+*
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
34/118
R:)-#%".$)&- E7-7(,0" +" 0:,+
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
35/118
N- ." 2') .&-."(-" 0"# (7
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
36/118
+7#)E-7"# %,( 0"# >>4 ., N:+*,(;,-,;$ "*"#$ 9D"#..,+(% ("'',.) .D:A.#K"$#:; 9D"%%:#(.,% '(#-,% ,$ #;9,-;#$)% 9, $:+$, ;"$+(, %+( 9,% A"%,% .)K#%."$#*,% :+()K.,-,;$"#(,% ,$ .";/) +;, :')("$#:; 9, (,-#%, ,; :(9(, R+(#9#C+,4 C+# " 9)RE9:;;) .#,+ E ." '+A.#/"$#:; 9,% $,I$,% #;$)(,%%";$% '.+%#,+(% /:('% 9, ."
=:;/$#:; '+A.#C+,7 "=#; 9, -,$$(, ,; '."/, +;,:(K";#%"$#:; 9+ '"#,-,;$ 9,% !OQ 9:;$ .D:AR,$ %,("#$ 9)%:(-"#% /#(/:;%/(#$ E9,% A,%:#;% %')/#=#C+,% 9D#;*,%$#K"$#:; E .D,I/.+%#:; 9+ *,(%,-,;$ "+I
=:;/$#:;;"#(,% 9, K("$#=#/"$#:;% =#;";/#G(,% ,$ 9, (,-A:+(%,-,;$ 9, =("#% 9,-#%%#:; :(9#;"#(,%^BT; .?"= +" .,/)-"$J
CR=R? !,* Q.L1b^,B,)>7V C+# " -#% ,; '."/, ., ()K#-, 9,.D"K,;$ A);)=#/#"#(,4 C+# ="#$ C+D#. ',(-,$ E +; =:;/$#:;;"#(, 9)%#K;) 9, (,$#(,(
9,% ,%'G/,%4 %";% :A.#K"$#:; 9, $,;+, 9, /:-'$,%qJ82F, GG H ==I
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
56/118
C0 , (,%%"07 ,*&)( 0')\
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
57/118
C-$"((&E7 #'( 0"
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
58/118
V"0&- 0'); .&-.(D$"
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
59/118
Gjjj; p')(#:9, "+ /:+(% 9, ."C+,.., #. T.+#V "*"#$ )$) 9:;;) 9D"''(,;9(, C+, ."'("$#C+, 9,% *,(%,-,;$% 9, /:-'.)-,;$% 9, ()-+;)("$#:; ,; .#C+#9, E 9,%=:;/$#:;;"#(,% 9+ J#;#%$G(,4 S /:-'(#% E 9,% =:;/$#:;;"#(,% C+#;D"''"($,;"#,;$ '"% E 9,% /:('% 9, ':.#/, -"#% (,.,*"#,;$ 9, T%"V K,%$#:;4 )$"#$9, '("$#C+, /:+(";$,qJ
C0 )E-&(,)$ 0:&()E)-" +"# "#%D."# 2') 0') 7$,)"-$ ("
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
60/118
C0 "#$)
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
61/118
C0 , +7#)E-7 M0,'+" @BkA5O .&
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
62/118
A*,-$ ."$$" +,$"; 0"# *"(#"
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
63/118
$,((:(#%-,V< X,% %:--,% %,(*"#,;$ )K".,-,;$ TUV E K("$#=#,( 9,% ',(%:;;,.%-)(#$";$%qJ
pX,% =:;9% T)$"#,;$V K)()%4 ',(e+% ,$ 9#%$(#A+)% '"( ." gN@\< g, T%:;V $,-'%/D)$"#$ +;, 9"-, C+# %D://+'"#$ 9, /,."< O.., )$"#$ %+(;:--), p,;(#,$$,< XD)$"#$
,.., %,+., C+# (,-,$$"#$ .,% =:;9% "+I 9#(,/$,+(% :+ E .,+(% (,'()%,;$";$%
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
64/118
%"#"!"#
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
65/118
%"#"# $- *,+) 3- D2O+),< *-+^2)< c!(B+)+\-, 3,h:NN"8:6UX 3,* Q.L1b^,B,)
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
66/118
%"#"#"# IB:0.1212,3 4* 5R*3/*5,::* 4ROAF *3 #HH% *1B/,5712,3 4* 50 4,1012,3 0337*55* 07 8,7.+ 4*+ 033B*+751B.2*7.*+
C0 ("##&($ +" 0, %(&.7+'(" 2'" 0, ("##&'(." ,00&'7" %&'( 0"# CV4 +'
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
67/118
R:CV4
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
68/118
! +)(" "$ I'E"( 2'"; #) 0" %&)-$ +" +7%,($ +' +70,) +" %("#.()%$)&- +"0:,.$)&- %'/0)2'" +&)$ 3$(" ("%&($7; "- (,)#&- +" 0, #'%%" -,$'("&..'0$" +" 0:)-=(,.$)&- +" +7$&'(-").?"0 MA>BT #&00).)$"-$ %,(0S)-$"(
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
69/118
R, +7="-#" #&'$)"-$ 2'" 0, #'#%"-#)&- +" 0, %("#.()%$)&- -" %"'$ (7#'0$"( +".)(.&-#$,-."# #)h4 ." '()*,;$#:; *#%";$ ."
')(#:9, 9, 0>>6 E 1??14 ;, %:;$ '"% %,.:; .,% 9#(,% 9, ." '()*,;+, /:+*,($%'"( ." '(,%/(#'$#:; n C+D,; ,==,$4 %D"K#%%";$ 9D+;, #;=("/$#:; ://+.$,4 J"(#,2[;;, ~6 E 1??1V $:+$, $("/, 9, =("+9, "+ ;#*,"+ 9, ." -"#(#, 9,
!(,S-#;K2J,(.,A"/F "#;%# C+, /,." " )$) %:+.#K;) '.+% F"+$4 9, $,..,
%:($, C+, ., 9).#$ ;D" '+ B$(, /:;%$"$) 9";% 9,% /:;9#$#:;% ',(-,$$";$.D,I,(/#/, 9, .D"/$#:; '+A.#C+, "*";$ .D#;$,(*,;$#:; 9+ -#;#%$G(, 9, .D)/:;:-#,49,% =#;";/,% ,$ 9, .D#;9+%$(#, *#" ., /F,= 9, %,(*#/, P("/=#; '()/#%)-,;$ n
T).?"0 @AB9C5 "$."'L +" .&
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
70/118
0:"
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
71/118
4')#; .&
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
72/118
GRA &-. 12 Q.,*D.+Q
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
73/118
012-3, 45`$6% "#$ %&'(#')*) %&'( #:3$("; +,-# 0"#
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
74/118
%,(*#/,% ,;$#,(% "+ %,#; 9, /, -#;#%$G(,4 ;:; ,; /F"(K, 9, -#%#:;% 9,':.#/, :')("$#:;;,..,4 :;$ A);)=#/#) 9,% /,% !OQq
C0 #&'$)"-$ "-.&(" 2'" 0, %(7*"-$)&- #" (7=D(" 1 +"# 707
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
75/118
PR=R? 0()D1-*+()* 3, '+DE,1 4$5!:6
4,( .&-.0'#)&-# (7E'0)D(",Z$(" 4?)0)%%" 9NbA4CUO; >).?"0 @AB9C5 #&00).)$" 7E,0"
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
76/118
PR?R= N,* Q.+B,* ,) ,*QbD,* 3,* B,BO.,* 3, D2O+),< B+)+*
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
77/118
.&
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
78/118
R:,'$&()$7 .?,(E7" +" 0, %&0)." ,' -)*",' -,$)&-,0; 2'"02'" #&)$ #&-(,$$,.?"50 :,528* 3012,305*"+ /:+(% 9, ." 9,(;#G(, 9)/,;;#, :;$ )$) -#%,% ,; /"+%,&-#)"'( aN`@UB@5UBT +7.0,(,)$ 8
p\:;4 '+#%C+D#. %D"K#$ 9, -#%%#:;% 9, ;"$+(, 9#==)(,;$,< L, $("*"#. 9+ /"A#;,$ 9+-#;#%$(, ;D,%$ '"% +; $("*"#. 9, ':.#/,4 /D,%$ +; $("*"#. "9-#;#%$("$#= :+
':.#$#C+,4 *:+% ;D,I,(/,b '"% +; $("*"#. 9, ':.#/#,(4 :; '"($#/#', E ." -#%, ,;
'."/, 9, ':.#$#C+,% 9, %)/+(#$)4 /D,%$ "+$(, /F:%,^).?"0 MA>BT #&00).)$" 0, ("0,L"; =,)#,-$ *,0&)( 2'" 0:)-=(,.$)&- -" #"(,)$ %,#.&-#$)$'7" +' =,)$ +" #&- ,/#"-." +"
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
98/118
>).?"0 MA>BT #"(, +7.0,(7 .&'%,/0" +"# =,)$# 2') 0') #&-$ ("%(&.?7#J
h:::Y &59 N$ !"'$6!" !" &588N`'"6% !V:6ZM9'$%:M6
4,( .&-.0'#)&-# (7E'0)D("
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
99/118
FHHF m2') -" .&-."(-,)$ 2'" 0"#
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
100/118
V) "00"# ("0D*"-$ +:'-" ."($,)-" .'())$7 )-$"00".$'"00"; ."# )-*"#$)E,$)&-#,'(,)"-$ %' 3$(" +" -,$'(" 1 0"*"( '- +&'$"; 2') #'/#)#$" 1 0:)##'" +"# +7/,$#; #'(0"
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
101/118
A #&- ,(()*7" .&
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
102/118
>).?"0 @AB9C5 7$,)$ "- "=="$ 9)(".$"'( +' %"(#&--"0 "$ +" 0, =&().?"0 @AB9C5 .&
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
103/118
N' 7E,(+ 1 0, E(,*)$7 "L."%$)&--"00" +" 0:,$$")-$" %&($7" 1 0:&(+(" %'/0). %,( 0"#,E)##"
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
104/118
("0D*" -7,-
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
105/118
'(:F#A,;$ 9)%:(-"#% $:+$, +$#.#%"$#:; E /,% =#;% 9,% =:;9 %')/#"+I< TUV^
K #&'0)E-7 %,( 0:,'$"'( +' (,%%&($
C0 ,%%,(,Z$ +D# 0&(# I'#$)=)7; "' 7E,(+ 1 ."
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
106/118
pJ#/F,. N[YgW\ ,%$4 E R+%$, $#$(,4 $(G% (,%',/$) ,$ "''()/#) 9, $:+% /,+I C+#:;$ $("*"#..) "*,/ .+# T
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
107/118
M"# 707
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
108/118
9,-# ."# .&-+)$)&-#; 0" (".&'(# 1 '-" %")-" +S"UCVVNRC5 #&00).)$" '-"+)#%"-#" +" %")-" ,##&($)" +:'-" ,/#"-." +:)-#.()%$)&- ,' /'00"$)- -sF +" #&-.,#)"( I'+).),)("J
A' #&'$)"- +" ."$$" +"UCVVNRC5 $(,*,)00"+7#&(
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
109/118
R" $()/'-,0 .&-#)+D(" "- &'$(" 2':)0 .&-*)"-$ +" =,)(" +(&)$; "' 7E,(+ 10:,-.)"--"$7 +"# =,)$#; 1 0, %,($ +" ("#%&-#,/)0)$7 2':)0 "- , ,##'UCVVNRC5 2') I'#$)=)" &..'%"( +7#&().?"0 MA>BT '-"%")-" +" QFH I&'(#\,BT #&00).)$" '-" +)#%"-#" +"%")-" ,##&($)" +:'-" ,/#"-." +:)-#.()%$)&- ,' /'00"$)- -sF +" #&- .,#)"(I'+).),)("J
>).?"0 MA>BT; .?"= +" .,/)-"$; ,X,-$ -&(BT;lE7 +" YY ,-#J
R" $()/'-,0 .&-#)+D(" 2'"; "- 0:,/#"-." +" (".&--,)##,-." +"# =,)$# "$ +"("
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
110/118
#U &59 NV$0%:M6 0:h:N" X
:Y N,* 3,B2)3,* 3, '()*+,-. e2D\-,* #:!$NM5; 3- 0(B+>> E .D"+A, ."A("%%,(#, ., @#/"9#..S 9D[+A,(*#..#,(%4 %#GK, %:/#". 9+ XMJWPZ gO QMYPWO\
[Y @HZ!OP qM\\OP OP L[ J[\W!OQP[PWM\ gO L[ cZHWPZ %";% C+,;+. ;, %D)-,+*, 9";% ." H)'+A.#C+, "+I -"#;% 9, /:((:-'+% 9D+; $,. /:+' 9,
=:(/, "A:-#;"A.,qJ
KKKK
N- ,%%0).,$)&- +"# ,($).0"# F "$ i +' M&+" +" %(&.7+'(" %7-,0"; 0:,.$)&- .)*)0"
"#$ &'*"($" 1 $&'# ."'L 2') &-$ %"(#&--"00"
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
111/118
N00"# #"(&-$ %,( .&-#72'"-$ +7.0,(7"# )(("."*,/0"# "- 0"'( .&-#$)$'$)&-J
::Y N,* 3,B2)3,* 3, 1V$F,)< e-3+D+2+., 3, 1V`BT; 9,-)"0 MA5N4A; @7(,(+ >UCVVNRC5; 1 %(&%&($)&- +" 0"'(
%,($).)%,$)&- 1 0, (7,0)#,$)&- +' %(7I'+)."; ,' %,)"
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
112/118
8$9 0"& 'M%:Z&
R" $()/'-,0; #$,$',-$ %'/0)2'"&-#)"'( >).?"0@AB9C5; >&-#)"'( 9,-)"0 MA5N4A; >&-#)"'( >).?"0 MA>BT; >&-#)"'(
@7(,(+ >UCVVNRC5; %(7*"-'# W0:A@N5O [B9CMCAC`N 9N R:NOAO; 0" MU>CON 9N VUBOCN5 AB 4`N6NOaU55NO NO A RA >A5C6NVOAOCU5 9N RA rN`CON; VUV r).$)
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
113/118
!LD12., '()*+,-. 012-3, 45"$6% 0M58$#N"+"# =,)$# 2') 0') #&-$ ("%(&.?7#+" 8
!MU>4RCMCON 9N VUBVO`AMOCU5; 9NOUB`5N>N5O UB 9NVO`BMOCU59N aCN5V 9:B5 9N4UO 4BaRCM 4A` RN 9N4UVCOAC`N UB B5 9N VNVVBaU`9U55NV
=,)$# .&
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
114/118
!LD12., '+DE,1 0$'5K 0M58$#N"+"# =,)$# 2') 0') #&-$ ("%(&.?7# +" 8
!`NMNR 9N aCN5 4`UrN5A5O 9:B5 9NRCO 4B5C 9:B5N 4NC5N5:NTMN9A5O 4AV h A5V 9:N>4`CVU55N>N5O
=,)$# .&
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
115/118
!LD12., '()*+,-. !2)+,1 0$6"8$ 0M58$#N"+"# =,)$# 2') 0') #&-$ ("%(&.?7#+" 8
! `NMNR 9N aCN5 4`UrN5A5O 9:B5 9NRCO 4B5C 9:B5N 4NC5N5:NTMN9A5O 4AV h A5V 9:N>4`CVU55N>N5O m%&'( '- &-#)"'( 9,-)"0 MA5N4A 2'" #:)0#S,.2')$$" +'
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
116/118
!LD12., '()*+,-. 4L.2.3 'M:&&"N:6 0M58$#N" +"# =,)$# 2') 0') #&-$("%(&.?7# +" 8
!`NMNR 9N aCN5 4`UrN5A5O 9:B5 9NRCO 4B5C 9:B5N 4NC5N5:NTMN9A5O 4AV h A5V 9:N>4`CVU55N>N5O
=,)$# .&
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
117/118
N- ,%%0).,$)&- +" 0:,($).0" GHGP A +' .&+" E7-7(,0 +"# )
7/24/2019 Jugement GUEANT
118/118
!"0N$9" 9"0"h$#N" 12 D()*,+,,+,A`4,$()."; %("