Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

1/22

AKZ@I

YKAZIJ_ZEZI_JA_Z\AOZOCY\ZNC\Z@IKC\Z@I\KJA_Z\AOZCNAMMAKCA_

IE_ZI\KJA^A_ACKSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

Kc+5855o~409:4

ETTMI-AKO+ekjKiPZ_CNZRE\IAKO+-

(n#f#eKiPZOCGTYZI\-AKO+!-

Tmeakzanns-

~+

GCZC\CME-AKO+-

ekjGCZC\CMEGCLAMAZQ-AKO+-

Jinikjekzs+

SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

CTAKACKekjC\JI\cnGeq

z`i

`ie|akb-

ncmmcrij

lq

c|em

e|

bygikzlqocyksimnc|EttmiekjGczc|cme+

Z`ickmqassyicnekqsabkanaoekoiockoi|kakbJckc`cirese

tcssalmiocknmaozcnakzi|iszcrakbzc`asnc|gi|igtmcqgikzlq

Oesi8 5855'o~'409:4 Jcoygikz /8 19> Namij8 49#

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

2/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 5N+?j>10-249(2z`Oa|+

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

3/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 ?

ly|jik cn t|ccn e|i z`i z|ejazackem ekj ett|ct|aezigieks cn

ezzeofakb

s`efq

lyz

ejgassalmi

i~ajikoi+

Jeyli|z

~+

Gi||imm

JcrT`e|geoiyzaoems-Ako+-syt|e-941Y+_+ez91>6siiemscLaimsfas

~+Mcyas~ammiMejji|-Ako+->>?N+?j002-01:(2z`Oa|+2N+?j5:>-594 (?jOa|+5111!6 Ak |i

Tecma \+\+ Qe|j TOL Mazabezack- ?9 N+?j 252- 2:> (?jOa|+ 511:!

(z`ihyjbi s`cymjkczipomyjii~ajikoi sagtmqlioeysi`ic|

s`iz`akfsz`ezz`i|iasenmerakz`iipti|zsak~iszabeza~it|co

issr`ao`|ikji|s z`iipti|zsockomysacks akoc||ioz+Z`ihyjbi

s`cymjckmqipomyjiz`ii~ajikoianz`inmerasme|biikcyb`z`ez

z`iipti|zmeofsbccjb|cykjsnc|`asc|`i|ockomysacks!+Z`i

ncoysz`ys

as

kcz

ck

|isymzs

lyz

ck

giz`cjcmcbq+

Z`i

ipti|z

gysz ysi e t|cti| giz`cjcmcbq- ek eooitzelmi

giz`cjcmcbq+Remfi|~+_ccMaki\+\+-

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

4/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 :

Ekcz`i|ziszcnz`iejiuyeoqcnt|ctcsijipti|zziszagckqas

r`iz`i|

z`i

ipti|z

`es

synnaoaikzmq

iptmeakij

`cr

`i

ji|a~ij

`as ctakack n|cg z`i i~ajikoi z`ez `i ocksaji|ij+ Ak cz`i|

rc|jsz`ihyjbigyszjizi|gakir`iz`i|z`igiz`cjsysijlq

z`i ipti|zri|i t|cti|mq ettmaij zc z`i neozs cn z`i oesi+ _ii

Nij+\+I~aj+ 24

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

5/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 9

ackz`ezz`ioesiak~cm~ishyszoimmt`ckis!Ettmistezikzijak

~ikzack

cn

e

scnzre|i

t|cb|eg

z`ez

t|i~ikzs

z`i

kczanaoezack

rakjcrn|cgliakbte|zaemmqclsz|yozijlqekettmaoezackt|c

b|egsimiozijlqz`iysi|+Zczem-escttcsijzcte|zaem-clsz|yo

zackcooy|sr`ik-nc|ipegtmi-z`iysi|simiozsz`ioegi|et|c

b|egck z`i aT`cki-r`ao` namms z`iikza|iso|iik6 z`itezikzij

ak~ikzackjciskczt|i~ikzzczemclsz|yozack+

G|+Rebki|essi|zs z`eze |iesckelmi |cqemzq nc|Gczc|cmes

ysi cnEttmis ak~ikzackrcymjli *544-444+Gczc|cmercymj

teq kcgc|i- `i ockzikjs-lioeysi o|iezakb z`i emmibijmq ak

n|akbakb kczanaoezack rakjcr ak z`i na|sz tmeoi `ej ocsz ckmq

*>2-444-ekj

sc

az

rcymj

(`i

|iescks!

ocsz

i~ik

miss

zc

emzi|

z`i

ocji nc| z`ikczanaoezackrakjcr smab`zmq sc z`ez azrcymjkcz

t|i~ikz ettmaoezacks n|cg te|zaemmq clsz|yozakb z`i rakjcr-

z`ys e~cajakb akn|akbigikz+Rebki| akzi|~airijJ|+ \ao`e|j

Occti|- cki cnGczc|cmes zio`kaoem ipti|zs ak z`as mazabezack-

r`cr|czielazcnocji akzc z`iettmaoezackrakjcrt|cb|eg

z`ez emmcrij az zclite|zaemmq clsz|yozijlq cz`i| ettmaoezack

rakjcrs+Ette|ikzmq`ires elmi zcjc z`as ake sakbmi enzi|

kcck+Rebki| ny|z`i| essi|zs z`ez ocksygi|srcymjkzlityz

cnnlq

ek

cooesackem

te|zaem

clsz|yozack-

r`ao`

an

z|yi

gieks

z`ez

Gczc|cme`esclzeakijkc|i~ikyin|cgazsakn|akbigikzekjsc

crisEttmikc |cqemzqliqckj z`igiebi|ocsz se~akbs z`ez az

ji|a~ij n|cg kcz ak~ikzakb e|cykj+ Rebki| |cykjij yt zc

*544-444cyzcnekipoisscnbiki|csazq+

Rebki|st|ctcsijziszagckqz`ezz`iakn|akbakbkczanaoezack

rakjcr ocszGczc|cme *>2-444 zc ji~imct as kcz ipti|z zisza

gckq lyz neoz ziszagckq+ Z`i stioaem magazezacks z`ez \ymi

(e!(

kissr`cgi|imq ziszanais z`ez `as ocgtekq stikz *p zcgefi

scgiz`akb+Az

emsc

as

kcz

z`i

lisz

i~ajikoi

cn

z`ez

neoz-

an

az

as

e

neoz6ekjr`amiekipti|zrazkissasti|gazzijzclesiekctakack

ck `ie|seq i~ajikoi- `i askz ti|gazzij zc ysi z`ez t|a~amibi

Oesi8 5855'o~'409:4 Jcoygikz /8 19> Namij8 49#

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

6/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 >

gi|imq zc s`aimj z`i scy|oi cn z`i i~ajikoi n|cg o|css

ipegakezack+

Esnc|Rebki|s|itc|zcn`asock~i|sezackraz`Occti|-azas-

mafiz`i*>2-444naby|i-egi|iio`ccnekcz`i|razkissekcz`i|

akzi|iszijrazkissekjazz`ys~acmezisz`it|akoatmiz`ezezisza

nqakbipti|zgyszysiz`isegiett|ceo`(anazasniesalminc|`ag

zc jc sc! z`ez `ircymj ysi cyzsaji z`i mazabezack ockzipz+ _c

agebaki z`ezGczc|cme`ejkczliiksyij-lyz`ejett|ceo`ij

Rebki|ekjzcmj`agri|iockoi|kijz`ezrigeqlieooysij

cn akn|akbakbEttmis tezikz 44

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

7/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 2

esfij zc taof- n|cg e masz cn z`i ezz|alyzis cn eGczc|cme oimm

t`cki-

z`csi

ezz|alyzis

z`ez

ri|i

egckb

z`i

|istckjikzs

zct

na~igeak|iescksnc|lyqakbz`i* Namij8 49#

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

8/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 0

jikzsmaszrcymjocgizc944ti|oikzcnz`i~emyicnz`it`cki+

Z`ezs

agtcssalmi+

Emm cz`i| clhiozacks zcKetti|sgiz`cj zc cki saji- azji

tikjijckz`iyk~i|anaij-akjiije|laz|e|q-essygtzackz`ezco

oesackem te|zaem clsz|yozack cn z`i kczanaoezackrakjcrrcymj

nc|oiGczc|cmezc|ijyoiz`it|aoicnazsoimmt`ckin|cg*

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

9/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 1

e~i|ebijeq3R`ezrakjcrsjcqcyctikgcszn|iuyikzmqakek

e~i|ebi

jeq3

_yttcsi

z`i

eksri|

akomyjis

z`|ii

rakjcrs

r`ao`r`ik ctikijrcymj te|zaemmq clsz|yoz z`i kczanaoezack

rakjcr+Z`ikipzuyiszackrcymjli8Anieo`cnz`isirakjcrs-

r`ik ctikij- te|zaemmq clsz|yozij z`i kczanaoezack rakjcr-

rcymjz`ezlielabekkcqekoi-emazzmiekkcqekoi-c|kcekkcq

ekoi3@crgyo` mcri|rcymj z`it|aoicnesge|zt`cki`e~i

zcli zc ocgtikseziqcy nc| z`icooesackemte|zaemclsz|yozack

oeysijlqz`isirakjcrs3

Agkczz|qakbzcj|enzeocksygi|sy|~iq+Aeggi|imqessi|z

akb z`ez z`i sy|~iq z`ezGczc|cmejaj ockjyoz-r`ao`jajkcz

mccfnc|

e~i|sack

zc

te|zaem

clsz|yozack

ekj

sc

ne|

es

Aoek

zimm

`ej kcz`akb zc jcraz` t|aoakb-lyz |ez`i|raz` `imtakb z`i

ocgtekq zc jizi|gakir`ao` t|cb|egs ekj niezy|is e|i te|

zaoyme|mqagtc|zekzzcoimmt`ckiysi|s-askczz`ifakjcnsy|~iq

z`ezKetti|essygakb`agzclie|istcksalmiej~asi|ckge|

fizakb c| ocksygi|li`e~ac|rcymj `e~i ockjyozij `ej `i

liik`a|ijcyzsaji z`i mazabezackockzipz zcjizi|gaki z`i |ime

za~i ~emyis zcGczc|cmes ocksygi|s cn e kczanaoezackrakjcr

z`ezoeklite|zaemmqclsz|yozijekjckiz`ezoekkczli+

B|ekzij-z`i

Gczc|cme

sy|~iq

askz

uyazi

emm

z`ez

Ketti|

|i

maij ck+@as |itc|z emscgikzackij ek ettmaoezack oemmij Masz

Kczanai|Rajbiz-r`ao` sge|zt`cki ysi|s oek jcrkmcej nc|

*5+?? ekjr`ao` ti|nc|gs scgi cn z`i segi nykozacks es z`i

tezikzij kczanaoezack rakjcr+ Zc imagakezi n|cg ocgte|asck

z`i niezy|is cn MaszKczanai|Rajbiz z`ez jc kcz jytmaoezi z`i

tezikzij ak~ikzack- `i `em~ij z`i t|aoi- z`i|ilq clzeakakb ek

iszagezij~emyi nc| z`ikczanaoezackrakjcrcn*4+>>-r`ao` as

omcsi zc z`i*4+04iszagezi z`ez`ibcz n|cg z`i sy|~iq+Lyzlq

abkc|akb z`i kckclsz|yozack niezy|i `i ctiks `agsimn zc z`i

segio|azaoasg

es

`as

ysi

cn

z`i

sy|~iq+

Aeggakjnymz`ezejib|iicnstioymezackasti|gazzijakoem

oymezakbjegebis-H+Z|yizzTeqkiOc+~+O`|qsmi|Gczc|sOc|t+-:95

Y+_+992-9>>>2 (5105!6LO__i|~aois- Ako+~+@ie|zrccj00-MMO-

Oesi8 5855'o~'409:4 Jcoygikz /8 19> Namij8 49#

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

10/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 54

>?2N+?j294-291(2z`Oa|+9?->90(2z`Oa|+6MyoikzZio`kcmcbais-Ako+~+Bezireq-Ako+-904

N+?j 5?45- 5????: (Nij+Oa|+

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

11/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 55

za~i+ Ykamco Y_E- Ako+ ~+Gao|cscnz Oc|t+- >?

tcsiek akock~ikaikoickscgiocksygi|s- z`cyb`t|clelmqe

smab`zcki6lyzRebki|t|c~ajijkcekemqsascn az+Z`i na|szem

zi|keza~i`iiszagezij zcocszckmq*50-444-ekj|cykjijyt zc

*544-444ckmq

(A

eg

byissakb!

lioeysi

hy|c|s

rcymj

li

gc|i

sfitzaoem cn z`i mcri| kygli|- istioaemmq ak mab`z cn z`i ip

z|igimq `ab` kygli| z`ezRebki| ocymj ekzaoatezi n|cgEt

tmis ipti|zrazkiss+ Ebeak `as t|coijy|i nc| ocsz iszagezack

Oesi8 5855'o~'409:4 Jcoygikz /8 19> Namij8 49#

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

12/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 5 Namij8 49#

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

13/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 5?

Ketti|s ocgte|asckraz` z`iGebaoZ|eoftej neams zc ascmezi

z`i

~emyi

zc

ocksygi|s

cn

z`i

zet

nc|

kipz

azig

nykozack+

Z`ez

eocksygi|rammteqscgiz`akbnc|biszy|emockz|cmjciskczik

elmiekiszagezackcn`crgyo``irammteqnc|ete|zaoyme|ag

t|c~igikzakesqszigcnsyo`ockz|cm-syo`esz`iejjazackcne

kir biszy|i zc ti|nc|g e nykozack z`ez oek em|iejq li ti|

nc|gijraz`ekcz`i|biszy|i+Z`ikipzazignykozackoekliti|

nc|gijraz`esraticnz`inakbi|esrimmesezet-ekjA~i|ymij

z`ezz`izetlyzkczz`isratiasoc~i|ijlqz`itezikz+

Z`as ascki nezemjinioz akKetti|st|ctcsij ziszagckqlyz

z`i|iasekcz`i|-ekjz`ezaseneamy|izcocksaji|emzi|keza~iszce

*?9gammack

|cqemzq

z`ez

rcymj

ikelmi

Gczc|cme

zc

t|c~aji

z`i

syti|ac| biszy|em ockz|cm ikelmijlq z`i |imi~ekz omeag ak z`i

Ettmitezikz+Z`i|iaskclesasakekqipti|z|itc|znc|syttcs

akbz`ezazrcymjocszGczc|cmegammackscnjcmme|s-iaz`i|akak

~ikze|cykj scnzre|i ji~imctgikz c| ak mcss cn ocksygi|

bccjramm (|isymzakb ake mcsscn semis |i~ikyi!- zcj|ct z`i zet

nc|zy|kakbz`itebiakz`iFakjmiettmaoezack(z`cyb`zcjcz`as

azrcymjkiijEgexcksti|gassack!c|zcj|ct z`iFakjmiet

tmaoezackazsimn-miejakbocksygi|sr`crekzijazzcjcrkmcejaz

z`igsim~is(r`ao`

ocszs

kcz`akb!+

Es

az

as-

Gczc|cme

simms

gekq

cnazsoimmt`ckisraz`cyzz`iFakjmiettmaoezack+

Ettmie|byis z`ezes mckbes azsipti|zt|cjyoisetmeysalmi

giz`cj cn e~cajakb akn|akbigikz (`i|i- maoiksakb z`i tezikz!

ekjz`yselesasnc|iszagezakbe|iesckelmi|cqemzq(z`i|cqemzq

liakbz`iocszcnz`igiz`cj!-z`iipaszikoicnemzi|keza~igiz`

cjs z`ezgab`zli sylszekzaemmq o`ieti| as ek assyi zcli |i

scm~ijez z|aemlqeocgte|asckcnz`itezikziisi~ajikoiraz`

ej~i|sii~ajikoit|isikzij-c|o|cssipegakezacklqz`imerqi|

nc|z`iemmibijakn|akbi|-ekjasa||imi~ekzzcz`iejgassalamazqcn

z`iipti|zs

ziszagckq+

Z`ez

oekkcz

li

oc||ioz-

nc|

ebeak

cki

gyszocksaji|`crz`iipti|zrcymjt|coiijakete|emmimkck

mazabezackockzipz+_csyttcsiGczc|cmeoegizcG|+Ketti|ekj

seaj8nakjcyznc|ys`crrioekezmcriszocsz-r`iz`i|akscnz

Oesi8 5855'o~'409:4 Jcoygikz /8 19> Namij8 49#

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

14/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 5:

re|iji~imctgikzc|mcsscnocksygi|bccjramm-e~cajakn|akb

akb

Ettmis

tezikz6

ri

kiij

zc

fkcr

z`ez

mcrisz

ocsz

lioeysi

az

rammliz`ioiamakbckcy|rammakbkisszcteqnc|etezikzmaoiksi+

Anrioeke~caj akn|akbigikzez*5et`cki-rirammkczteqe

|cqemzqakipoisscn*5+

Ak|istcksizcsyo`ekessabkgikzz`iipti|zrcymjkczseq8

Azrammocszqcy*?9gammackzclyqeo`atz`ezrammjytmaoeziz`i

nykozackemazq cn Ettmis tezikzraz`cyz akn|akbakb az+ Lioeysi

Gczc|cmercymjesf`ag8Asz`ezz`ickmqreqrioeke~cajak

n|akbigikz3Z`iipti|zrcymj|itmq8Rimmeozyemmqqcyoekj|ct

z`izet`iy|aszaon|cgqcy|Fakjmiettmaoezackc|qcyoekj|ct

z`iettmaoezack

ekj

zimm

qcy|

ocksygi|s

z`ez

an

z`iq

rekz

az

z`iq

oekjcrkmcej azraz`cyzo`e|bi6ekjz`as asr`ezieo`cnz`isi

emzi|keza~isrcymj ocszqcy ak mcsz semis- ockz|eozjegebis-c|

r`ezi~i|+Ekipti|zrazkissgyszt|c~aji|iescksnc||ihiozakb

emzi|keza~i `qtcz`isis ysakb soaikzanao giz`cjs ekj t|coi

jy|isekjz`iimagakezackcnz`csi`qtcz`isisgyszlincykjij

ckgc|i z`ek sylhioza~ilimainsc|yksyttc|zij stioymezack-

Omeysik ~+G#^ KIR OE\A__E- ??1 N+?j 54:1- 5490 (1z` Oa|+

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

15/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 59

ettmaoezacklioeysiz`ezsz`ickmqoesiakr`ao`Gczc|cmesoimm

t`ckis

ysi

e

zet

nc|

kipz

azig+

Z`i

te|z

cn

z`i

tezikz

omeag

ck

r`ao` Ketti|s t|ctcsij ziszagckq as geakmq lesij as e

`iy|aszao (ek aksz|yozack zc z`i oimmt`cki! z`ez zimms z`i oimm

t`ckizcz|iezekytre|jc|jcrkre|jgczackcnz`inakbi|es

e~i|zaoemsratii~ikanazaskczti|niozmq~i|zaoem6esmckbesazas

raz`akestioanaij|ekbi zc|ab`zekj minzcn~i|zaoem (z`akfcne

nek!-z`ioimmt`ckiakzi|t|izsz`ibiszy|ieseti|niozmq~i|zaoem

biszy|i+Z`asasemgcszoi|zeakmqegc|i~emyelminiezy|icneoimm

t`cki z`ek z`i nakbi|zet `iy|aszao nc| zy|kakb tebis ak t|i

akszemmijFakjmiettmaoezacks+

LyzKetti|s

t|ctcsij

ziszagckq

jcis

kcz

t|c~aji

e|imaelmi

lesasnc|akni||akbz`i~emyii~ikcnz`i~i|zaoemso|cmmakbniezy|i+

Z`i neoz z`ez gekq ocksygi|s ramm teq gc|i nc| e Gebao

Z|eoftej z`ek nc|egcysi zimmsckikcz`akb elcyzr`ez z`iq

rammteq zc e~cajcooesackemmq sratakbyksyooissnymmqlioeysi

z`ia| sratakb nakbi| reskz eozyemmq ~i|zaoem zc z`i so|iik+

Geqliocksygi|srcymjteq* Namij8 49#

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

16/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 5>

nakbi|zettebizy|kakbimigikzcnz`itezikz+@igikzackijz`i

ocgtckikz

ak

`as

ipti|z

|itc|z

es

ek

ej~ekoi

c~i|

ipaszakb

giz`cjs lyz `i jaj kcz iszagezi azs ~emyi+ Iaz`i| z`ez

ocgtckikz asly|aij scgir`i|i ak z`i *?9gammack-raz` z`i

Gebao Z|eoftej giekz zc t|c~aji ek ekemcbq zc z`i tebi

zy|kakbt|cb|eg (z`cyb` z`as siigsykmafimq- sakoi zettakbes

jaszakozn|cgsratakbsiigsgc|imafiomaofakbckegcysiz`ek

gc~akbckisnakbi|cke z|eoftej!-c|Ketti|ocksaji|ij z`i

jegebis mafimq zcli ettmaoelmi zc syo` ek akn|akbigikz zcc

smab`zzclcz`i|elcyz-es`i`est|c~ajijkci~ajikoickr`ao`

zclesiekiszagezicne|iesckelmi|cqemzqnc|z`ezt|cb|eg-miz

emckinc|

z`i

sylt|cb|eg

ettmaoelmi

ckmq

zc

z`i

Fakjmi

ettmaoezack+_c ne|esettie|s- z`ickmqi~ajikoi z`ezocymjli

t|c~ajijrcymjli ocksygi|sy|~iq i~ajikoi6 az asgyo` zcc

mezinc|Ettmizcliti|gazzijzcockjyozesy|~iq+

Ketti|sziszagckqelcyzEttmitezikz1:1asipomyjij+

Ettmi?+Z`asasetezikzckesqszignc|gefakbsy|iz`ezt|cb|egsr`ao` t|isikz ~ajic c| ey|emgezi|aem ak |iem zagi

(|ez`i|z`ekszc|akbaznc|mezi|~airakb#`ie|akb!e|ielmizct|i

sikz z`ezgezi|aemsgccz`mq-raz`cyz akzi||ytzackc|jaszc|zack+

Z`asykuyiszackelmq

as

e~emyelmi

niezy|i

cn

esge|zt`cki

es

cn

cz`i|zqtiscnocgtyzi|+G|+Ketti|essi|zsak`asipti|z|itc|z

z`ezazrcymjocszGczc|cme*

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

17/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 52

rcymjkcz`e~ibckizcz`itezikziinc|z`ezaknc|gezack%Nc|az

rcymj

li

ak

z`i

tezikziis

akzi|isz

zc

sybbisz

e

giz`cj

cn

ak

~ikzakbe|cykj z`ezresipz|igimq ocszmq-lioeysi z`i ocszmai|

z`i ak~ikze|cykj- z`i`ab`i| z`i oiamakb ck e |iesckelmi |cq

emzq+Cn ocy|siTcmas` askczEttmi6`i asek akjitikjikz ock

z|eozc|+Ekj an`iri|i z`ickmqti|sckocgtizikz zcctakick

sylszazyzis nc| z`i ?-`asi~ajikoircymjliejgassalmi-ekj

z`ihy|qrcymjlire|kij z`ez`i`ejeocknmaozcn akzi|iszli

oeysi`ias`ekjscgimqocgtiksezijlqEttmizct|c~ajizio`

kaoemi~ajikoiaksyttc|zcnEttmisomeagz`ezGczc|cme`esak

n|akbijz`i?+Lyzz`i|iaskci~ajikoiz`ez`iasz`ickmqik

bakii|r`c

as

negamae|

raz`

ocgtyzi|

`e|jre|i

(c|

scnzre|i!

z`ezjytmaoezis z`i nykozackemazq cn z`i ?+ _c ebeak agebaki

z`as agebake|q ock~i|sezack lizriik Ketti| ekj Gczc|cme-

r`ao`Ammt|izikj`a|ijKetti|zcej~asick`crezmcriszocsz

zc jytmaoezi z`i tezikzs nykozackemazq raz`cyz akn|akbigikz8

Gczc|cme8 R`ezramm az ocszys zc ak~ikze|cykj- nc| z`ezramm

tmeoieoiamakbckz`i|cqemzqrimmteqEttmi3Ketti|8L|eoi

qcy|simn8*?9gammackb|iikleofs+Gczc|cme8Z`ezscykjs`ab`6

r`i|ijajqcy biz z`i naby|i3Ketti|8 A esfij ek ikbakii|

r`crc|fs

nc|

Ettmi+

Gczc|cme8

Jyggfctn%

Qcy|i

na|ij+

Ketti|st|ctcsijziszagckq|ibe|jakbjegebisnc|emmibij

akn|akbigikzcnEttmistezikz?asipomyjij+

Ettmi >:2 (sz|yozy|i jiziozack ekj makfakb!+Ketti|s |itc|zszezisz`ezazrcymjocszGczc|cme*54+9gammackzcjytmaoezi

z`i nykozackemazq cn Ettmis tezikz raz`cyz akn|akbigikz+@i

lesijz`asiszagezickz`it|aoicnet|cb|egoemmijOmatlce|j

Gekebi| r`ao` as e~eamelmi nc| jcrkmcej lq aT`cki ysi|s

n|cg z`i aT`ckiettszc|i nc|*5+Ketti|ettc|zackij*4+>4cn

z`i*5zcz`inykozackemazqoc~i|ijlqz`itezikzekjgymzatmaij

lqz`i

kygli|

cn

Gczc|cme

oimm

t`ckis

scmj

jy|akb

z`i

jegebis

ti|acjzc|ieo`z`i*54+9gammacknaby|i+

Omatlce|jgekebi| aseozyemmqebiki|ao zi|g6 z`ioetazem

axijkegi|ini|szcestioanao~i|sackcnni|ijakz`iaT`ckiett

Oesi8 5855'o~'409:4 Jcoygikz /8 19> Namij8 49#

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

18/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 50

szc|i+Jy|akbz`ijegebisti|acj-Omatlce|jGekebi|(z`iEt

tmi

~i|sack!

res

e

siz

cn

na~i

syl

ettmaoezacks

(z`ez

as-

az

jaj

na~i

janni|ikz z`akbs!+Z`|iicn z`isylettmaoezacks|imezij zcsz|yo

zy|ijiziozackekjmakfakb-z`icz`i|zrczcemt`elizaxezackekj

agebisz`ezsr`qKetti|ettc|zackij z`|iinanz`scn z`iet

tmaoezacks*5t|aoizcz`i>:2ak~ikzack+Z`iz`|iiz`ez|imezizc

sz|yozy|i jiziozack ekj makfakb e|i |ijykjekz zc z`i syti|ac|

zio`kcmcbq nc| sz|yozy|ijiziozackekj makfakb z`ez as akomyjij

ak z`i aT`ckiz`i syti|ac| zio`kcmcbq as z`i zio`kcmcbq oc~

i|ijlq z`i >:2+Ketti|s |itc|z eofkcrmijbislcz` z`ez z`i

>:2 zio`kcmcbq ocgist|imcejij ck z`i aT`cki ekj z`ez az as

syti|ac|zc

Omatlce|j

Gekebi|s

~i|sack

cn

z`ez

nykozackemazq+

N|cg z`as az ncmmcrs z`ez ekq fkcrmijbielmi ocksygi| r`c

lyqsOmatlce|jGekebi| aslyqakb azscmimqnc| azsemt`elizaxe

zack ekj agebis nykozackemazq-lioeysi azs sz|yozy|i jiziozack

ekj makfakbzio`kcmcbq`eskc~emyi zcscgickir`ccrksek

aT`cki6ekj aT`ckiysi|se|i z`ickmq akja~ajyemsr`crcymj

li jcrkmcejakb z`iOmatlce|jGekebi| ettmaoezack n|cg z`i

aT`ckiettszc|i+Anemmocksygi|se|ifkcrmijbielmi- z`ity|

o`esicnOmatlce|jGekebi|t|c~ajisxi|c aknc|gezackck z`i

~emyizc

ocksygi|s

cn

sz|yozy|i

jiziozack

ekj

makfakb-

lioeysi

z`iq em|iejq `e~i z`ez nykozackemazq6 ekj an sc- z`ikKetti|s

emmcoezackcn*4+>4cn z`i*5t|aoi zc z`ez nykozackemazq assiksi

miss+

Cnocy|sikczemmocksygi|se|ifkcrmijbielmi-ekjjcylz

missgcsz~emyisz|yozy|ijiziozackekj makfakb(kcz ak z`ez zi|

gakcmcbqcnocy|si-lyzz`izi|gs|ini|zcz`ioimmt`ckiselamazq

zc |iocbkaxitezzi|ks ak zipz syo` est`ckikygli|s-ril ej

j|issis-ekjjezisekjz`ikzct|isikzz`iysi|raz`emaszcnz`i

eozacks`ic|s`ioekzefiak|ibe|jzcz`itezzi|ks-syo`esoemm

akbz`i

t`cki

kygli|

c|

o|iezakb

eoemikje|

ikz|q!+

Gekq

cn

z`csir`cjckz|iemaxiz`iq`e~iazem|iejqgeqakjiijliramm

akbzcteq*4+>4zcbizaz(z`cyb azsiigscjjzclesijegebis

cksemis|i~ikyisclzeakijese|isymzcngaszefislqocksygi|s

Oesi8 5855'o~'409:4 Jcoygikz /8 19> Namij8 49#

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

19/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 51

nc|r`ao`z`isimmi|siigsme|bimq|istcksalmi!+LyzKetti|t|c

~ajij

kc

iszagezi

cn

`cr

gekq

syo`

abkc|ekz

ocksygi|s

z`i|i

e|i- szamm ekcz`i| uyiszack z`ez ocymjli eksri|ijraz`ak z`i

magazs cn zcmi|elmiykoi|zeakzqlq e ocgtizikzmqjisabkij ekj

ejgakaszi|ij ocksygi| sy|~iq+ _c ckoi ebeak Agysz ipomyji

Ketti|si~ajikoi+

Gczc|cme991(t|ieglmisiuyikoi!ekj010(ocykzjcrk!+Aoekjasoyss z`isi zrcGczc|cmetezikzs zcbiz`i|+Z`iqt|c~aji

nc| zimiocggykaoezacklizriik oimm t`ckis ekj oimmyme|lesi

szezacks+Aessyginc|ty|tcsiscnz`iJeyli|zekemqsasz`ezz`isi

e|i szekje|js issikzaemtezikzs-r`ao` as zc seqtezikzs z`ez

oimmt`cki

gefi|s

gysz

`e~i

emaoiksi

nc|

ak

c|ji|

zc

ocggyka

oezic~i|stioanaijzimiocggykaoezackskizrc|fs-ekjz`i|inc|i

z`ez Gczc|cme gysz maoiksi zc Ettmi ez nea|- |iesckelmi- ekj

kckjaso|agakezc|q(N\EKJ!|ezis+

Gczc|cmesjegebisipti|zGym`i|kiszagezis z`ezet|cti|

N\EKJ|cqemzqrcymj`e~iocszEttmi*?:2gammack6 Aessygi

ak z`as ctakack z`ez z`as naby|i sezasnais N\EKJ+LyzGym`i|k

neamijzcocksaji|z`i|ekbicntmeysalmiemzi|keza~is(zcmaoiksakb

Gczc|cmes tezikzs! neoakbEttmi- emzi|keza~is z`ez s`ircymj

jcylzmiss`e~i

ocksaji|ij

ak

kck

mazabezack

ocksymzakb

an

esfij

lqEttmi(seq!-r`ezasz`imcriszocszgiz`cjcnclzeakakbeo

oisszcz`inykozackemazqcnz`isitezikzs3Z`ieksri|aszcock

z|eozraz`ekcz`i|oe||ai|-|ez`i|z`ekEZ.Z-lioeysiGczc|cmes

oimmyme| tezikzs e|i kioisse|q ckmq ak ocggykaoezacks c~i|

EZ.Zs kizrc|f+Ettmi o`csiEZ.Z c~i| z`i emzi|keza~is- cn

r`ao`z`igcszezz|eoza~i-azettie|s-rcymj`e~iliik^i|axck+

_ct|isygelmqekqcz`i|emzi|keza~ircymj`e~iliik akni|ac|-

ekj z`i|inc|iEttmi clzeakij elikinaz n|cg ockz|eozakbraz`

EZ.Z aksziejcn^i|axck-ekj an z`ezlikinazrese n|yazcn ak

n|akbigikzaz

as

et|cti|

lesas

nc|

ocgtyzakb

e|iesckelmi

|cq

emzq+LyzGym`i|k`eskczz|aijzcuyekzanqz`ilikinaz6kc|jcis

s`ie|byiz`ezz`ilikinaz-z`cyb`sylszekzaem-oekkczliuyekza

naij+

Oesi8 5855'o~'409:4 Jcoygikz /8 19> Namij8 49#

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

20/22

Kc+5855o~409:4

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

21/22

Kc+5855o~409:4 0

gammackekj akomyjis mcszt|cnazscnGczc|cmetmyse |iesckelmi

|cqemzqcksemiskczsylhiozzcemcszt|cnazsekemqsas+

Z`i mcszt|cnazs iszagezi tcsazs e ocykzi|neozyem rc|mj ak

r`ao` z`i|i askcEttmit|cjyozck z`ige|fizlioeysiEttmi

jciskz`e~i

emaoiksi

zc

ysi

Gczc|cmes

oimmyme|

tezikzs+

Z`as

as

soaikoinaozack+Ettmiakn|akbisz`csitezikzsckmqckz`iEZ.Z

kizrc|f-ekjezrc|szEttmiocymj`e~iteaj z`i

7/31/2019 Judge Posner's Daubert Order in Apple v. Motorola

22/22

Kc+5855o~409:4