Job analysis defining effective performance of the employees of PJ Lhuillier

8/20/2019 Job analysis defining effective performance of the employees of PJ Lhuillier

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/job-analysis-defining-effective-performance-of-the-employees-of-pj-lhuillier 1/56

JOB ANALYSIS DEFINING EFFECTIVE PERFORMANCE OF THE EMPLOYEESOF PJ LHUILLIER INCORPORATED YEAR 2015-2016

A Thess P!ese"#e$ #% #he C%&&e'e %( B)s"ess *"$ E"#!e+!e"e)!*& Te,h"%&%' %( R.*&Te,h"%&%',*& U"/e!s#

I" P*!#*& F)&(&&e"# %( #he Re)!ee"#s (%! #he De'!ee %( B*,he&%! %( S,e",e "B)s"ess A$"s#!*#%" M*%! " H)*" !es%)!,e De/e&%+e"# M*"*'ee"#

B3

H*&"*4 D*""e B

Pe!e!*4 M*! Be" A

R*!e.4 C&e%7e& L

T*#%4 R%"*&$ B!*" C

Ve&*s,%4 Re"e&e"e C

2016



CHAPTER I

THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND

Introduction

A# #he he*!# %( *&%s# e/e! h)*" !es%)!,es *"*'ee"# +!%'!* %! *,#/# s

#he "ee$ (%! *,,)!*#e *"$ #h%!%)'h %7 "(%!*#%" As h)*" !es%)!,e *,#/#es '!%8 "

s,%+e *"$ ,%+&e9#4 *" h)*" !es%)!,e +!*,#,es s),h *s !e,!)#e"# *"$ se&e,#%"4

,%+e"s*#%"4 +e!(%!*",e *"*'ee"#4 ,*!ee! +&*"""'4 #!*""' *"$ $e/e&%+e"# *"$

!e8*!$s *!e $e&e'*#e$ #% #he H)*" Res%)!,e $e+*!#e"# M%s# %( #he H)*" Res%)!,e

s+e,*&s#s $% "%# "%8 *7%)# #he $e#*& %( %7s :"%8&e$'e *7%)# #he %7s *"$ #he!

!e)!ee"#s )s# 7e ,%&&e,#e$ #h!%)'h * +!%,ess "%8" *s %7 *"*&ss4 " 8h,h

"(%!*#%" *7%)# %7s s ss#e*#,*&& ,%&&e,#e$4 e/*&)*#e$ *"$ %!'*".e$ D*#* *7%)#

e*,h %7 7)# "%# *7%)# e/e! +e!s%" s '*#he!e$ " *" %!'*".*#%" I# s * $es,!+#/e

+!%,ess %( 7!e*"' $%8" * s+e,(, %7 "#% #s ,%+%"e"# 7 )s"' * ,%&&e,#%" %( #%%&s

*"$ #e,h")es #% es#*7&sh %7 !e)!ee"#s



Theoretical ra!e"or#

The %7 *"*&ss $e(""' e((e,#/e +e!(%!*",e %( #he e+&%ees &e$ *"

*)#h%!#es #% e9+%)"$ %! /e!( se/e!*& #he%!es 8h,h &*#e! 7e,*e #he #he%!e#,*&

(!*e8%! %( #he !ese*!,he!s



Re$earch Paradi%!

The !ese*!,h +*!*$' #h*# ')$e$ #he s#)$ s sh%8" " F')!e 1 7e&%83

i%ure &'(o) Anal*$i$ De+inin% E++ecti,e Per+or!ance o+ the E!-lo*ee$ o+ P(

Lhuillier Incor-orated S'.' /0&12/0&3

The F')!e *7%/e +!ese"#s #he !ese*!,h +*!*$' 8h,h ,%"#*"s %( #h!ee +*!#s3

I"+)#4 P!%,ess *"$ O)#+)# The I"+)# ",&)$es #he "s#!)e"# #% 7e )se$ #% e*s)!e #he

O)#+)#P!%,essI"+)#

1. De%'!*+h, P!%(&e%( #he !es+%"$e"#s3Ge"$e!4 A'e4 C/&S#*#)s4 E$),*#%"*&A##*"e"# *"$ Le"'#h%( Se!/,e

2. E((e,#s %( J%7 *"*&ss#% #he Pe!(%!*",e %(#he e+&%ee " PJ

Lh)&&e!; O/e!*&& %7

s*#s(*,#%" &e/e&s %(e+&%ees " #e!s %(#he %7 $es,!+#%""$e9< I" !e'*!$s 8#h#he (%&&%8"' *s+e,#s3=%! *s+e,#s4 Pe%+&e*s+e,#s4 P* *s+e,#s4

S)+e!/s%" *s+e,#s*"$ P!%%#%"*s+e,#s

1 D*#* ,%&&e,#%"2 A"*&ss *"$

"#e!+!e#*#%" %(

#he $*#* )s"' #he

(!e)e", *"$

+e!,e"#*'e4

8e'h#e$ e*"4

*"$ Pe*!s%" ! #%#es# #he s'"(,*"#

!e&*#%"sh+

7e#8ee" J%7

A"*&ss $e(""'

e((e,#/e

Pe!(%!*",e %(

E+&%ee

1 A8*!e"ess %( #he

!e&*#%"sh+ %( J%7

A"*&ss *"$ J%7

Pe!(%!*",e %(

E+&%ee se&e,#e$

s)7e,#s %( BS HR

S#)$e"#s



J%7 A"*&ss *"$ J%7 Pe!(%!*",e %( E+&%ee The P!%,ess ",&)$es #he $*#* ,%&&e,#%">

*"*&ss *"$ "#e!+!e#*#%" %( #he $*#* )s"' #he +e!,e"#*'e4 Pe*!s%" ! *"$ T-#es# *"$ #es#

%( s'"(,*"# !e&*#%"sh+ 7e#8ee" #he e((e,#s %( J%7 A"*&ss #% #he J%7 Pe!(%!*",e %(

E+&%ee The O)#+)# +!ese"#s #he *8*!e"ess %( #he !e&*#%"sh+ %( J%7 A"*&ss *"$ J%7

Pe!(%!*",e %( E+&%ee se&e,#e$ s)7e,#s %( BS HR S#)$e"#s

State!ent o+ the Pro)le!

Ths s#)$ *s #% ("$ %)# #he J%7 *"*&ss $e(""' e((e,#/e +e!(%!*",e %( #he

e+&%ees " #he ,%+*" %( PJ Lh)&&e! I",%!+%!*#e$4 M**# C# SY 2016-201?

S+e,(,*&&4 # sees #% *"s8e! #he (%&&%8"' )es#%"s3

1 =h*# *!e #he $e%'!*+h, +!%(&e %( #he !es+%"$e"#s " #e!s %(31 Ge"$e! 2 A'e; C/& s#*#)s@ E$),*#%"*& A##*"e"#5 Le"'#h %( Se!/,e

2 =h*# *!e #he e((e,#s %( J%7 *"*&ss #% #he Pe!(%!*",e %( #he e+&%ee " PJ

Lh)&&e!<

; =h*# *!e #he %/e!*&& %7 s*#s(*,#%" &e/e&s %( e+&%ees " #e!s %( #he %7

$es,!+#/e "$e9< I" !e'*!$s 8#h #he (%&&%8"' *s+e,#s31 =%! *s+e,#s2 Pe%+&e *s+e,#s; P* *s+e,#s@ S)+e!/s%" *s+e,#s5 P!%%#%" *s+e,#s

H*-othe$i$

The!e s * s'"(,*"# Re&*#%"sh+ 7e#8ee" %7 *"*&ss *s $e(""' e((e,#/e

+e!(%!*",es #%8*!$s #he e+&%ee %( PJ Lh)&&e! I",%!+%!*#e$

Si%ni+icance o+ the Stud*



E((e,#)*& !e,!)#e"# s /#*& #% e"h*",e #he %7 +e!(%!*",e *"$ +!%$),#/# %(

*" %!'*".*#%" #h!%)'h +!%+e! %7 *"*&ss 8h,h s *" +%!#*"# ()",#%" %( h)*"

!es%)!,e +!*,#,es Ths /*&)*7&e "(%!*#%" %( %7 *"*&ss 8&& ,%"#!7)#e #% #he

"%8&e$'e %( #he !ese*!,he!s *s 8e&& *s +!%/$e ),h "ee$e$ "(%!*#%" #% #he h)*"

!es%)!,e *"*'e!s The %)#,%es %( #he +!ese"# s#)$ 8%)&$ 7e %( '!e*# *##e"#%" #% #he

h)*" !es%)!,e +!%(ess%"*&s *"$ #%+-*"*'ee"# 7e,*)se #hs s#)$ 8&& h%+e()&&

+!%/$e %!e "s'h#s %" %7 *"*&ss $e(""' e((e,#/e +e!(%!*",e %( #he e+&%ees "

PJ Lh)&&e!

E!-lo*ee' The !es)&# %( #hs s#)$ 8%)&$ he&+ #he 8%!e!s #% 7e %!e (*&*! #% #he! #*s *"$ !es+%"s7&#es %! "(%!"' #he " #he +*!#,)&*! %7 *"$ &esse" #he *%!

+!%7&es %( +!%(ess%"*& ",%+e#e",e "s$e #he ,%+*" A"$ *&s% e+&%ees ,*"

%!e e((e,#/e& ,%"#!7)#e #%8*!$s #he %!'*".*#%"

E!-lo*er' The !es)&# %( #hs s#)$ 8%)&$ +!%/$e !e,%e"$*#%" %" h%8 #% e/*&)*#e

#he +e!(%!*",e %( *" e+&%ee A"$ e+&%e! 8%)&$ !e*&& ()&(&& #s !es+%"s7&# *"$

)s# #% +!%%#e %! se&e,# 7es# ,*"$$*#e #h*# s)#e$ #% #h*# +*!#,)&*! !e)!ee"#s

Student$ o+ Hu!an Re$ource De,elo-!ent Mana%e!ent' The !es)&# %( #hs s#)$

8%)&$ 7e 7e"e(,*& #% #he s#)$e"#s %( HRM #% h*/e *" e((e,#/e &e*!""' " #!*""'

'!%)"$4 s#)$e"#s 7e *ss)!e$ %( * ,%+e##/e *$/*"#*'e *"$ 7e "%8&e$'e*7&e " $((e!e"#

,%",e+#s !e&*#e$ #% #he )se %( J%7 A"*&ss $e(""' e((e,#/e +e!(%!*",e

Hu!an Re$ource De-art!ent' The !es)&# %( #he s#)$ 8%)&$ he&+ #he #% '*" %!e

"s'h#s %" 8h*# ,!#e!* ,*" 7e )se %( se*!,h"' *++!%+!*#e ,*"$$*#es

uture Re$earcher' Ths !es)&# %( s#)$ 8%)&$ 7e se!/e *s ()#)!e !e(e!e",e (%! !ese*!,he!

%" A"*&."' #he J%7 +e!(%!*",e *"$ # 8%)&$ ')$e %!e "#e"s/e e# s&*!



!ese*!,hes " %#he! s,h%%&s %! !e'%"s %( #he ,%)"#! %" * 8$e! s,%+e #% es#*7&sh 'e"e!*&

(%)"$*#%" %" &e*!""' *7%)# *"*&."' #he e((e,#/e +e!(%!*",e %" %7

Sco-e and Li!itation

The !es+%"$e"#s *!e 120 8h,h s E+&%e$ #% PJ Lh)&&e! I",%!+%!*#e$4 The

S#)$ s L#e$ #% "%8 #he J%7 Pe!(%!*",e %( #he E+&%ee *"$ E+&%e!

De+inition o+ Ter!$

The (%&&%8"' *!e $e("e$ #% (*,&#*#e )"$e!s#*"$"' %( #he s#)$3

Ada-ti,e Per+or!ance s !e(e!s #% *$)s#"' #% *"$ )"$e!s#*"$"' ,h*"'e " #he

8%!+&*,e A" e+&%ee 8h% s /e!s*#&e s /*&)e$ *"$ +%!#*"# " #he s),,ess %( *"

%!'*".*#%"

Anal*$i$ s #he +!%,ess %( 7!e*"' * ,%+&e9 #%+, %! s)7s#*",e "#% s*&&e! +*!#s "

%!$e! #% '*" * 7e##e! )"$e!s#*"$"' %( # The #e,h")e h*s 7ee" *++&e$ " #he s#)$

%( *#he*#,s *"$ &%', s",e 7e(%!e A!s#%#&e ;@;22 BC4 #h%)'h *"*&ss *s *

(%!*& ,%",e+# s * !e&*#/e& !e,e"# $e/e&%+e"#

Co!-en$ation s #he *,# %! s#*#e %( ,%+e"s*#"'4 *s 7 !e8*!$"' s%e%"e (%!

se!/,e %! 7 *"' )+ (%! s%e%"es &%ss4 $**'e4 %! ")! 7 '/"' #he

")!e$ +*!# *" *++!%+!*#e 7e"e(#

Conte4tual Per+or!ance s 'e"e!*&& *((e,#e$ 7 +e!s%"*&# #!*#s *"$ /*&)es ",&)$es

he&+"' %#he!s4 e"$%!s"' %!'*".*#%"*& %7e,#/es4 ,%"#!7)#"' #% #he %!'*".*#%"*&

,&*#e

De$cri-ti,e inde4 s * ?2-#e "s#!)e"# $es'"e$ #% e*s)!e (/e $e"s%"s %( %7

s*#s(*,#%"3 s*#s(*,#%" 8#h s)+e!/s%"4 ,%8%!e!s4 +*4 +!%%#%"*& %++%!#)"#es4 *"$

#he 8%! #se&(

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Workplace

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Employee


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complexity


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematics

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logic

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aristotle


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Before_Christ


http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/compensate



https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematics

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logic



http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/compensate

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Workplace



eed)ac# s #he "(%!*#%" *7%)# !e*,#%"s #% * +!%$),#4 * +e!s%"s +e!(%!*",e %( *

#*s4 )se$ *s * 7*ss (%! +!%/ee"#

Hu!an Re$ource Mana%e!ent s * ()",#%" " %!'*".*#%"s $es'"e$ #% *9.e

e+&%ee +e!(%!*",e " se!/,e %( *" e+&%e!s s#!*#e', %7e,#/es

(o) Anal*$i$ s ,%"ss#s %( * #h%!%)'h *"*&ss %( #he %7 $)#es *"$ "%8&e$'e4 s&&s4

*7&#es4 *"$ +e!s%"*& ,h*!*,#e!s#,s :SAPCs !e)!e$ (%! s),,ess " * ,e!#*" +%s#%"

(o) De$cri-tion s * &s# #h*# * +e!s%" 'h# )se (%! 'e"e!*& #*ss4 %! ()",#%"s4 *"$

!es+%"s7&#es %( * +%s#%" I# * %(#e" ",&)$e #% 8h% #he +%s#%" !e+%!#s4

s+e,(,*#%"s s),h *s #he )*&(,*#%"s %! s&&s "ee$e$ 7 #he +e!s%" " #he %74 *"$ *s*&*! !*"'e

(o) E,aluation s * ss#e*#, 8* %( $e#e!""' #he /*&)e8%!#h %( * %7 " !e&*#%" #%

%#he! %7s " *" %!'*".*#%" I# #!es #% *e * ss#e*#, ,%+*!s%" 7e#8ee" %7s #%

*ssess #he! !e&*#/e 8%!#h (%! #he +)!+%se %( es#*7&sh"' * !*#%"*& +* s#!),#)!e

(o) P$*cho%ra-hic$ s #he s#)$ %( +e!s%"*&#4 /*&)es4 %+"%"s4 *###)$es4 "#e!es#s4 *"$

&(es#&es

(o) S-eci+ication s * s#*#ee"# %( #he esse"#*& ,%+%"e"#s %( * %7 ,&*ss ",&)$"' *

s)*! %( #he 8%! #% 7e +e!(%!e$4 +!*! $)#es *"$ !es+%"s7&#es4 *"$ #he

") )*&(,*#%"s *"$ !e)!ee"#s "e,ess*! #% +e!(%! #he esse"#*& ()",#%"s %(

#he %7

Per+or!ance A--rai$al s #he !es)&#s %( * %7 *"*&ss ,*" *&&%8 *" %!'*".*#%" #%

$e/e&%+ *" e+&%ee *,,%!$"' #% #he s+e,(, "ee$s %( #he! %7 ##&e



P$*cholo%ical re$earch s * ,%"#!7)#%" #% * 7*s, )"$e!s#*"$"' %( h)*" +e!,e+#%"4

*##e"#%"4 e%! *"$ *,#%" I# s $e/%#e$ #% #he $sse"*#%" %( "%8&e$'e 7*se$ %"

(! e9+e!e"#*& '!%)"$4 "$e+e"$e"# %( *" +*!#,)&*! *++!%*,h %! s,h%%& %( #h%)'h#

Recruit!ent s !e(e!s #% #he %/e!*&& +!%,ess %( *##!*,#"'4 se&e,#"' *"$ *++%"#"'

s)#*7&e ,*"$$*#es (%! %7s e#he! +e!*"e"# %! #e+%!*! 8#h" *" %!'*".*#%"

Re,!)#e"# ,*" *&s% !e(e! #% +!%,esses "/%&/e$ " ,h%%s"' "$/$)*&s (%! )"+*$

+%s#%"s4 s),h *s /%&)"#*! !%&es %! )"+*$ #!*"ee !%&es

Succe$$ion Plannin% s * s#!*#e' %( 8%!(%!,e +&*"""'4 HR +!%(ess%"*&s ,*" )se %7

*"*&ss !es)&#s #% he&+ (&& e !%&es 8#h" #he! %!'*".*#%"4 "%8 *"$ " #he ()#)!eTa$# Per+or!ance s 'e"e!*&& *((e,#e$ 7 ,%'"#/e *7&#es4 s&&s4 "%8&e$'e

e9+e!e",e

5or#+orce Plannin% s *" e((e,#/e %7 *"*&ss ,*" 8%! " #*"$e 8#h *"

%!'*".*#%"s ()#)!e-,*s#"' B $e"#("' #he $)#es *"$ :SAPCs (%! /*!%)s %7

##&es4 HR +!%(ess%"*&s ,*" *#,h #he "ee$s %( #he! %!'*".*#%" 8#h #he #*&e"# %( #he!

,)!!e"# *"$ ()#)!e 8%!(%!,e

CHAPTER II

RE6IE5 O THE RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIES

http://www.referenceforbusiness.com/knowledge/Recruitment.html

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Job

http://www.referenceforbusiness.com/knowledge/Recruitment.html

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Job



Ths ,h*+#e! $e*&s 8#h #he !e&*#e$ s#)$es #% #he +!ese"# "/es#'*#%" These

s#)$es *!e e9,e!+# (!% #he !e(e!e",e 7%%s4 *!#,&es *s 8e&& *s 8e7s#es 8h,h '/es #he

"%8&e$'e %" #he 7*,'!%)"$ #% #he +!%7&e *"$ #he !es)&#s %( #he +!ese"# "/es#'*#%"

(o) Anal*$i$

J%7 *"*&ss s *" %!'*".e$ s#)$ %( %7s #% !e,%'".e #he /s7&e 8%! *,#/#es4

#*ss4 *"$ !es+%"s7&#es !e&*#e$ 8#h * +*!#,)&*! %7 %! ,&)s#e! %( %7s I# s * +!%,ess %(

&%%"' *# e9*,#& 8h*# * %7 e"#*&s *"$ #% $e"#( #he +*!#,)&*! %7 $)#es *"$

!e)!ee"#s " $e#*& !e(&e,#"' #he +%!#*",e %( #hese $)#es (%! * '/e" %7 The

s'"(,*",e %( %7 *"*&ss " *++&"' h)*" !es%)!,e +!*,#,es ,*""%# 7e '"%!e$4 *s

%7 *"*&ss h*s 7ee" $es,!7e$ *s #he ()"$*e"#*& 7)&$"' 7&%, )+%" 8h,h *&& &*#e!

$e,s%"s " #he +!%,ess 8%)&$ !es#

I+%!#*",e %( J%7 *"*&ss h*s 7ee" "*!!*#e$ " #he s)7e,# %( +e!s%""e&

+s,h%&%' 8h,h $e#e!"es #he +e!s%"*& *##!7)#es &e "%8&e$'e4 s&&s *"$ *7&#es

:SA 8h,h *!e +e!*#/e (%! #he #h!/"' %7 +e!(%!*",e B!*"", *"$ Le/"e

2002 $e("e$ #he %7 *"*&ss *s *" %!'*".e$ +!%,ess 8he!e7 "*#)!e %( * %7 s

$s,%/e!e$ J%7 %! #*s s $/$e$ "#% s*&&e! )"#s M,C%!,4 s#)$e$ " 1?6 #h*# #he

,%&&e,#%" *"$ +!%,ess"' %( %7 !e&*#e$ "(%!*#%" *"$ %#he! !e&*#e$ #*ss *"$

)*&(,*#%"s #h!%)'h %7 *"*&ss 8*s * 7*se (%! h)*" !es%)!,e *"*'ee"# HRM

I" H)*" Res%)!,es HR ()",#%"s &e !e,!)#e"# se&e,#%"4 #!*""' $e/e&%+e"#4 ,%+e"s*#%" +e!(%!*",e *"*'ee"#4 %7 *"*&ss h*s * /#*& !%&e

S*",he. *"$ Le/"e4 $s,)sse$ " 2000 #h*# e!!%"e%)s +!*,#,e %( #he %7 *"*&ss *

*((e,# %#he! HR *,#/#es 7*se$ %" #



P!*,#,e %( J%7 *"*&ss *s * *"*'ee"# #%%& 8*s $e/e&%+e$ )s# *7%)# 100

S",e #he" J%7 *"*&ss 7e,%e %"e %( #he +e!*#/e #%%&s 7 8h,h *"*'e!s *"$

+!%(ess%"*&s $!e,#e$ #he %!'*".*#%"s F%!e! !ese*!,h 7 M)&&"s :7!%)'h4

1> A/%&% =*&$*"4 1> S,h## C%he"4 1 *"$ L*"$V*se4 11 %" %7

*"*&ss +e!ss#e"# %" #he /*!*7&e &e $e%'!*+h, " %7 *"*&ss !*#"'s

H*/"' "#e!es# " +!%/"' #he e((,e", %( %74 T*&%!4 s#)$e$ #he %7 *s %"e

%( hs +!",+&es %( s,e"#(, *"*'ee"# F!% hs $e*s *"$ $*#*4 #e *"$ %#%"

s#)$ %( %7s 8*s ee!'e$ Ths ,%"s,%)s"ess %" %7 *"*&ss s#)&*#e$ *s #he h)*"

!e&*#%"s *ss%,*#e$ 8#h #he $e#e!"*#%" %" %#he! ss)es *"$ %#he! h)*" !es%)!,e

+!*,#,es ee!'e$ Beh*/%)!*& s,e"#s#s *"$ Ps,h%&%'s#s !e$s,%/e!e$ " 160 %7s *s

* (%,*& +%"# %( s#)$ " #he %!'*".*#%"s T&& s),h #e4 %7 *"*&ss h*s 7ee" (%,)se$

%"& %" #he 8%! 7e"' ,*!!e$ %)# Ths 8*s *&#e!e$ " #he 1?0s *s +s,h%&%'s#s 8e!e

*##!*,#e$ " %7 *"*&ss The! "/%&/ee"# 8*s " #h!ee *!e*s s),h *s )*"#("' %7

*"*&ss 7 $e/e&%+"' )es#%""*!es (%! $*#* ,%&&e,#%"> 8%!e! %!e"#*#%" #% %7

*"*&ss> *"$4 (%,)s"' %" s*&&e! )"#s !*#he! #h*" #he 8h%&e %74 #*s4 %! e&ee"#s

8#h" %7s

C*s,%4 1 *"$ B%8" H*!/e 2000 s#!esse$ #he s'"(,*",e %( %7

*"*&ss *s * s#!*#e', HRM +!*,#,e &"e$ 8#h #he %!'*".*#%"*& +e!(%!*",e A"#he"

e# *&>2002 *"$ Dess&*!4 200; !e,%e"$e$ #h*# 8#h #he !e,%'"#%" %( #he H)*"

Res%)!,ePe!(%!*",e &"*'e4 %!'*".*#%"s /'%!%)s& *$%+#"' %7 *"*&ss *s *

h)*" !es%)!,e s#!*#e' 8e!e &e& #% '!%8 %!e *"$ +)# %" *''!ess/e 7e"e(#s

G*#e8%%$Fe&$4 1@ &&)s#!*#e$ #h*# e9#e"# #% 8h,h #*ss *"$ e+&%ee *##!7)#es (%!

*" *ss'"e$ %7 8*s #e!e$ *s %7 *"*&ss he",e4 %7 *"*&ss #e,h")es ,*" *&s% 7e



#e!e$ *s 8%!e!-%!e"#e$ %! 8%!-%!e"#e$ The ()!#he! $s,)sse$ #h*# 8%! %!e"#e$

e#h%$s e"'*'e$ ,&e*! $es,!+#%" %( * /*!e# %( %7s %! #*ss #% 7e +e!(%!e$4 8h&e4

8%!e!-%!e"#e$ e#h%$s e9*"e$ h)*" 7eh*/%)!s ,%",e!"e$ 8#h #he 8%!

*,#/#es =%! %! 8%!e!-%!e"#e$ #e,h")e 8h*# s% e/e! 7e4 %7 *"*&ss e#h%$s

*&&%8 #he *ss)+#%" %( e+&%ees "%8&e$'e4 s&&s *"$ *7&#es :SAs

,h*!*,#e!s#,s D*/s 154 G*#e8%%$Fe&$4 1@ s#)$e$ #he :SAs ,h*!*,#e!s#,s

",&)$e$ " %7-!e&*#e$ "(%!*#%" *"$ #he "e,ess*! h)*" *7&#es #% +e!(%! ,e!#*"

%7 *,#/#es The s'"(,*",e %( *++&,*7&e :SAs ,%)&$ "%# 7e %/e!s#*#e$4 *s #hese h*/e

*" *ss%,*#%" 8#h %7 +e!(%!*",e A,,%!$"' #% G*#e8%%$Fe&$4 1@ %7 *"*&ss8*s *" "s#!)e"# #% *"*&#,*&& '*#he! $*#* %" #*ss *"$ 7eh*/%)!s &e*$"' #% :SAs

*7%)# /!#)*&& *"$ *" "$ %( 8%! *,#/#

P!e"4 1?? e+h*s.e$ %" #he +%!#*",e %( ,*!!"' %)# %7 *"*&ses #%

!e,%'".e /*&$ +!e$,#%!s *"$ ,!#e!* (%! %7 s),,ess 8h,h h*s *&s% 7ee" *,"%8&e$'e$

7 #he %#he! !ese*!,he!s *"$ h)*" !es%)!,e +!%(ess%"*&4 ()&& e"'*'e$ " !e,!)#e"#

*"$ se&e,#%" +!%,ess D)""e##e4 1?6 *"$ =e!"%"# C*+7e&&4 16 &"e$ %7

*"*&ss "(%!*#%" 8#h !e,!)#e"# +!%,ess 8h,h 8*s %!'"*#e$ " #he &#e!*#)!e

S%e %( #hese !ese*!,he!s +%"#e$ %7 *"*&ss *s #he 7*se %( #he e"#!e !e,!)#e"# *"$

se&e,#%" +!%,ess The $/e!'e",e 8*s " * #h!%)'h ,%"s$e!*#%" %( #he %7 +e!(%!*",e

!e*& 8h,h ,%)&$ &e*$ #% #he $e/e&%+e"# %( #he ss#e " 8h,h #he +e!s%"*& *##!7)#es

:SA !e)!e$ #% *,,e+#*7& +e!(%! #he %7s4 $e"#(e$ *"$ e+!,*&& &"e$ 8#h

,%!!es+%"$"' %7 +e!(%!*",e I" 114 H*!/e *,"%8&e$'e$ #he %7 *"*&ss "

!e&*#%" 8#h 8%! 7eh*/%)!s *"$ *ss%,*#e$ #*ss #h%se 8e!e !e)!e$ (%! s),,ess()& %7

+e!(%!*",e



S,h)&e! J*,s%%"4 164 Sh*!*" e# *&4 1 Dess&*! e# *&4 1

$s,)sse$ #he +%!#*",e %( J%7 A"*&ss *"$ ,%"$),#%" %( J%7 A"*&ss 8h,h 8*s

%7/%)s (!% #he (*,# #h*# %s# %( #he !ese*!,he!s h*/e $e,&*!e$ %7 *"*&ss *s *

7*,7%"e *"$ ,%!"e!s#%"e %( e*,h *"$ e/e! h)*" !es%)!,e *,#/# J%7 *"*&ss

+!%/$es * (%)"$*#%" %( !e)s#e "(%!*#%" !e'*!$"' %7s *"$ e+&%ees #h*# h)*"

!es%)!,e +!%(ess%"*&s )se$ #% 7)&$ )+ s),h +%!#*"# $%,)e"#s s),h *s %7 $es,!+#%"

JD4 %7 s+e,(,*#%"s *"$ +e!(%!*",e *++!*s*& Des+#e %( #he *,"%8&e$'e"# %( #he

+/%#*& !%&e %( %7 *"*&ss " *&& h)*" !es%)!,e *,#/#es4 #he!e 8*s !e*! e+!,*&

!ese*!,h 8h,h &"e$ %7 *"*&ss #% %7 +e!(%!*",e s+e,(,*&& T%8*!s4 124 P(e((*!414G!e!!4 2001 *"$ D!),e! 2002 s#)$e$ #h*# #he *,,%+&she"# %( %7e,#/es se# 7

#he %!'*".*#%"s " #he ,)!!e"# *''!ess/e s#)*#%" *"& $e+e"$s )+%" #he #*&e"# %(

#he! h)*" !es%)!,es *"$ +!%(ess%"*& $e/e&%+e"# +!%'!*es H)se&$ 1@4

H)se&$4 15> De&*"e H)se&$4 16 ,%"(!e$ #h*# 8e&&-es#*7&she$ h)*"

!es%)!,e +!*,#,es "%# %"& e"h*",e %7 !e#e"#%" 7)# *&s% *e * ,%"s$e!*7&e

"/%&/ee"# " %7e,#/e +e!(%!*",e *"$ e"h*",e +!%$),#/#

As "%#,e$ *7%/e4 &"*'e 7e#8ee" #he +!*,#,e %( %7 *"*&ss *"$ J%7

+e!(%!*",e h*s "%# 7ee" *"*&#,*&& (%)"$ *s e#4 s% #he!e s *" *$e)*#e *%)"# %(

s)7e,#/e e/$e",e " #he ,)!!e"# h)*" !es%)!,e +!*,#,es -+e!(%!*",e &#e!*#)!e #%

*"#,+*#e * s'"(,*"# +*,# %( %7 *"*&ss %" %7 +e!(%!*",e D*#* %( ,*se s#)$es

h*s $es,!7e$ h%8 /*!%)s %!'*".*#%"s h*/e *,he/e$ *" *$/*"#*'e )+%" (%&&%8"' #he

+!*,#,e %( %7 *"*&ss4 %"e +e!*#/e !e*s%" (%! e9+&%!"' * s'"(,*"# *ss%,*#%"

7e#8ee" %7 *"*&ss *"$ %7 +e!(%!*",e 8*s #he ""e!%s# +%s#%" #h*# %7 *"*&ss

%,,)+ " #he h)*" !es%)!,e +!*,#,es #h*# ,%"#!7)#e$ #% %7 +e!(%!*",e Sh*!*" e#



*& 1 ,&*e$ #h*# #he $e("#/e !*#%"*&e %( %7 *"*&ss 8*s #% +!%/e %7

+e!(%!*",e *"$ %)#+)# %( *" ;; e+&%ee The s'"(,*",e *"$ ,*!!"' %)# #he %7

*"*&ss h*s #he &*#e"# #% $e/se #hs "+)# #% %7 +e!(%!*",e 7%#h $!e,#& *"$ "#e!-

*,#/e& 8#h %#he! ,%!e HR +!*,#,es

I" 1@4 C&((%!$ s#)$e$ #h*# #he %!'*".*#%"s *$!"' #he +%!#*",e %( #he %7

*"*&ss *"$ !e')&*!& +!*,#,"' #he %7 *"*&ss h*/e * 7e##e! "%8&e$'e *"$

)"$e!s#*"$"' %( #he! e+&%ees s#!e"'#hs *"$ 8e*"esses *,,%!$"'& * #e&

!ee$*& *,#%" * 7e #*e" #% +!%/e #he! $e(,e", " s&&s *"$ *7&#es P!*,#,e

%( ,%"$),#"' !e')&*! %7 *"*&ss ,*" *sss# *" %!'*".*#%" " es#*7&sh"' *"

*++!%+!*#e "(!*s#!),#)!e 7 $e#e!""' #he #*ss #% 7e +e!(%!e$ *s 8e&& *s #he

$e*$&"es (%! +e!(%!"' #he Re')&*! +!*,#,e %( %7 *"*&ss ,%"#!7)#e$ #% #he

%!'*".*#%"*& +e!(%!*",e 7 e"h*","' * +%s#/e %7 *###)$e *"$ %7 $e$,*#%" I"

*$$#%"4 %7 *"*&ss 8*s ,*+*7&e #% $e"#( (*,#%!s s),h *s e+&%ees %#/*#%" *"$

%7 s*#s(*,#%" G%e. Mee* e# *&42000M%"$ e# *&4 2002 s#)$e$ #h*# "%!*& !e/e8

%( J%7 $es,!+#%"s JDs *"$ +e!(%!*",e *++!*s*& s#*"$*!$s 7 *++&"' %7 *"*&ss

e"%!%)s& he&+e$ #he HR +!%(ess%"*&s *"$ !ese*!,he!s #% !e,%'".e *"$ e!*$,*#e

!e$)"$*"# %7 !e)!ee"#s *"$ *!e*s %( $/e!'e",e ,*)s"' %7 (!)s#!*#%"

In$tru!ent$ o+ (o) anal*$i$ and 7o) -er+or!ance

I" %!$e! #% "#*#e #he *"*'ee"# $e,s%"s4 *" %!'*".*#%" !e)!es *"

e((e,#/e H)*" Res%)!,e I"(%!*#%" Ss#e HRIS Ths ss#e )s# e"$%8 8#h



e9s#"' 7)# ,%!!e,# $*#* %( #he e+&%ees J%7 *"*&ss 8*s (%)"$ * )se()& e*"s #%

'&*",e "s'h# #he *,#)*& %7 (e*#)!es %( e*,h %7 7e"' *" esse"#*& e&ee"# %( *" e((,e"#

HRIS The e $%,)e"#s &e %7 $es,!+#%"4 %7 s+e,(,*#%" *"$ %7 s#*"$*!$s 8e!e

)s)*&& ",&)$e$ " *" %!'*".*#%"s h)*" !es%)!,e "(%!*#%" ss#e O#he!

"(%!*#%" ,%"#*"e$ " #he HRIS ,%",e!""' 8#h #he e+&%ees4 &e %7 +e!(%!*",e

s#*"$*!$s4 (!"'e 7e"e(#s4 +e!s 4 ;@ ,%+e"s*#%"4 '%/e!"e"# !)&es *"$ +!e/*&"'

!e')&*#%"s4 &e'*& ss)es4 e#,4 *$e # * /#*& !es%)!,e (%! h)*" !es%)!,e +!%(ess%"*&s

*"$ *"*'e!s #% s#* *&%"'s$e e*,h %#he! %( %!'*".*#%"*& "ee$s *"$ ""%/*#/e

$e/e&%+e"#s " #he e9#e!%! e"/!%"e"# HRIS4 * /*&)*7&e h)*" !es%)!,e +&*"""'#%%&4 8%)&$ ,e!#*"& +!%/e e((e,#/e"ess *"$ e((,e", %( *" %!'*".*#%" *"$ %7

+e!(%!*",e

C*!$D%77*"s4 12 *"$ L*"'$%%"=h##es$e4 16 *"$ Se'*&4 1?

$e("e$ e*,h %7 " #e!s %( #s s+e,(, !%&e " *" %!'*".*#%"4 !e,!)#e"# *"$ se&e,#%"

()",#%"s ,%)&$ 7e +%&she$ #% $e"#( #he ,*"$$*#es 8h% 'h# *,#/e& %/e (%!8*!$

%!'*"s*#%"*& #*!'e#s *"$ '%*&s C*!$ D%77"s4 12 *"$ L*"'$%" =h#es$e4

16 *"$ Se'e&4 1? e+h*s.e$ %" #he ,%+e#e",-(%,)se$ *++!%*,h " #he

+!ese"# e"/!%"e"#4 8he!e %7s *"$ s&&s !e)!e$ #% +e!(%! #he s),,ess()&& *!e

!*+$& ,h*"'"' *"$ * 7e see" *s *" "$s+e"s*7&e +!%/ee"# %/e! #he ,!#e!%"

*++!%*,h #% *,he/e %!'*".*#%"*& '%*&s

I" 11 H*!/e h*s $s,)sse$ (%)! s#e+s 8h,h 8e!e *,#/e& "/%&/e$ "

,%"$),#"' #he J%7 *"*&ss F!s#4 %7 %! 8%! *,#/#es +e!(%!e$ %" #he %7 8e!e

e&,#e$ (!% %7 %,,)+*"#s *"$ s)+e!/s%!s Se,%"$4 *,#/#es *"$ %+e!*#%"s 8e!e

'!%)+e$ "#% #*ss %! $)#es #% s+&( *"$ %!'*".e s#*#ee"#s *"$ #% e&"*#e



%/e!&*++"' Th!$4 #he !es)&#*"# &s#s %( %7 #*ss 8e!e !*#e$ %" e*s)!es %( %/e!*&&

s'"(,*",e #% s),,ess()& %7 +e!(%!*",e F"*&&4 #he "%8&e$'e4 s&&s *"$ *7&#es

!e)!e$ (%! s),,ess()& %7 +e!(%!*",e 8e!e $e"#(e$ (%! $e/e&%+e"# %( se&e,#%"

"s#!)e"#s *"$ +%#e"#*& #!*""' "ee$s

(o) De$i%n

A,,%!$"' #% F!e$ Fe!ss4 1?> P*!*!4 =*&&4 C%!!$*!4 2001 J%7 $es'"

h*s $e/e&%+e$ * '!e*# $e*& %( "#e!es# " #he *!e* %( HRM $)!"' #he !e,e"# $e,*$es

M%!'*s%" C*+%"4 200; *"$ P*!*!=**&&4 1 h*/e $s,)sse$ * 7*s, +!",+&e

" #he %7 $es'" !ese*!,h *,,%!$"' #% 8h,h %7s 8e!e s#)&*#e$ *"$ *ss%,*#e$ 8#h

%#/*#%"*& (*,#%!s 8h,h ,%"#!7)#e$ #% #he *###)$"*& *"$ 7eh*/%)!*& %7 +e!(%!*",e

%)#,%es H*,*" O&$h*4 1?64 10 $e/e&%+e$ J%7 Ch*!*,#e!s#,s M%$e&

JCM $e!/e$ (!% #he %$e!" !ese*!,h %" %7 $es'" C%!e %7 ,h*!*,#e!s#,s %( J%7

Ch*!*,#e!s#,s M%$e& 8e!e s&& )&#+&,#4 #*s $s#",#/e"ess4 #*ss +&,*#%"s4

se&(-s)((,e", *"$ %7 (ee$7*, 8h,h *,#/e& ,%"#!7)#e$ #% %7 s#)&)s *"$

s)7se)e"#& #% #h!ee /#*& e%#%"*& s#*#es +!*,#se$ e*""'()&"ess4 e9+e!e",e$

!es+%"s7&# *"$ "%8&e$'e %( !es)&#s4 8h,h h*s * '!e*# +%s#/e& +*,# %" e+&%ee

%#/*#%"4 %7 +e!(%!*",e *"$ %)#,%e %( #hese &e %7 s*#s(*,#%" *"$ %7 !e#e"#%"

:%+e&*"4 15> F!e$ Fe!!s4 1?> F!e$4 11> O&$h*4 16 *"$

P*!e! e# *&4 2001 e9+%se$ $/e!se !es)&#s %" #he &"*'e 7e#8ee" "s+!"' %7,h*!*,#e!s#,s *"$ %7 +e!(%!*",e *"$ %)#,%e &e #)!"%/e! *"$ *7se"#ees

R%)sse*) F!e$4 2001 *"$ J%h"s4 2006 (%)"$ ",%"ss#e"# !es)&#s *"$ s)''es#e$ #h*#

7*,'!%)"$ 'h# +&* * /#*& !%&e " %$e!*#"' e+&%ee !e*,#%"s F!e$ Fe!!s4



1?> F!e$4 11> Ke4 F*"' 12 *"$ P*!e! e# *&4 2001 s)++%!#e$ #he

h+%#hes.e$ &"*'e 7e#8ee" s#)&*#"' %7 ,h*!*,#e!s#,s *"$ %7 s*#s(*,#%"4 #he

e9#e"# %( #he !e&*#%"sh+ 7e#8ee" #he ,%!e %7 ,h*!*,#e!s#,s *"$ %)#,%es *++e*!e$ #%

7e %$e!*#e !*#he! #h*" h'h

J%h"s4 2006 %7se!/e$ #h*# %7 $es'" #he%! *"$ !ese*!,h e"$)!e (!% * &*, %(

s#!),#)!e$ *##e"#%" #% se&e#%" $)e #% #he s#)*#%"*& %++%!#)"#es *"$ ,%"s#!*"# #h*#

h*/e *" e((e,# %" *###)$es *"$ 7eh*/%)!s :e&&4 12> L$*"4 =*"e S+*!!%8e4 2000>

P*!*! e# *&4 2001> R%)sse*) F!e$4 2001> =*&&4 C%!$e!! C&e''4 2002 4 T%!!*,%4

2005 h*/e !e,%e"$e$ #he *"*&#,*&& ",%!+%!*#e$ !e&*#/e (*,#%!s "#% %7 $es'"

#he%! *"$ !ese*!,h S,h%&*!s &e :e&&4 12> C*+%"4 P*++e!Me$se!4 16> P*!e!

=*&&4 1> L$e" e# *&4 2000> P*!e! e# *&4 2001> =*&& e# *&4 2002> A"$!e%) B%%"e4

2002> M%!'es%" H)+h!e4 2006> G!*"#4 C*+7e&&4 Che"4 C%##%"e4 L*+e$s4 Lee4

2002 h*/e "%#,e$ #h*# 7 ",%!+%!*#"' * !*"'e %( (*,#%!s s),h *s %+e!*#%"*& *"$

e"/!%"e"#*& )",e!#*"#4 #e,h"%&%',*& *$/*",ee"#s4 "(%!*#%" #e,h"%&%'4

,%&&e,#/e "%!s *"$ ,h*!*,#e!s#,s *"$ s%,*& !e&*#%"s *"$ !e&*#%"sh+s 'h# %/e

(%!8*!$s #he )"$e!s#*"$"' %( %7 $es'"

He!.7e!'4 166> Ches4 1?6> S#ee!s M%8$*4 1?? *"$ H*,*" O&$h*4

10 $s,)sse$ (%)! %7 $es'" *++!%*,hes 8h,h h*/e 7ee" $e&"e*#e$ *s # $e%"s#!*#e$

#h*# e*,h *++!%*,h 8*s %!e"#e$ #%8*!$ #he %+#) )#&.*#%" %( * $((e!e"# s%!# %(

%)#,%es The (!s# %7 $es'" *++!%*,h e/%&/e$ 8*s $e!/e$ (!% #he %!'*".*#%"*&

+s,h%&%' 8h,h 8*s #he %#/*#%"*& F%,)s %( #hs *++!%*,h 8*s %" #h%se

,h*!*,#e!s#,s %( %7s #h*# e"h*",e$ +s,h%&%',*& e*""' *"$ %#/*#%"*& +%#e"#*&

%"& &e s&& /*!e#4 *)#%"% *"$ #*s s'"(,*",e H*,*" *"$ O&$h* 10



s#!esse$ #h*# 7 '!%8"' s&& /*!e#4 #h!%)'h )#&."' * '!e*#e! ")7e! %( s&&s4 8%)&$

&e*$ #%8*!$s %7 e"&*!'ee"# *s He!.7e!'s 166 "%#%" %( %7 e"&*!'ee"# S%,%

#e,h",*& *"$ *"*'e!*& *++!%*,hes $e("e$ 7 Ches4 1?6 8%)&$ *&s% ",!e*se #he

s&& /*!e# 7 e9+*"$"' #he 7%)"$*!es %( #he 8%! +!%,ess

T*&%!4 1114 B*es4 10 *"$ Ne7e&4 1 $s,)sse$ #he se,%"$ *++!%*,h

8h,h ,*e (!% ,&*ss, "$)s#!*& e"'"ee!"' I# +!e$,#e$ #h*# $e,!e*se$ ,%+&e9#

8%)&$ ",!e*se h)*" !es%)!,e ,%+e#e",e *"$ (&e97&e %)#,%e &e e*se s#*(("' *"$

sh%!# #!*""' +!%'!*es !es)&#*"#& # 8%)&$ $e,!e*se s&& !e)!ee"#s E((,e",

,%)&$ 7e *##*"e$ *s s+e,*&.e !e$),e$ #he s&& /*!e# *"$ s+&(,*#%" !e$),e$ #he

"#e"s# %( s&&s !e)!e$

As#!*"$R%$*h&4 1??> T,h*)e!4 1? *"$ G!*"$e*"4 10 $s,)sse$ #he #h!$

*++!%*,h %( #he %7 $es'" 8h,h 8*s #he 7%&%',*&4 e/%&/e$ +!*!& (!% e!'%"%,s

8h,h (%,)sse$ %" !e$),"' +hs,*& $**'e %" #he e+&%ee 7 #)7&"' s#!e"'#h *"$

s)!//*& !e)!ee"#s *"$ 8%!"' ,%"$#%"s I# !es)&#e$ " &ess $s#!ess4 (*#')e *"$

&&"ess (%! e+&%ees *"$ #he %7s h*/e $e,!e*se$ +hs,*& *7&# !e)!ee"#s *s 8e&&

The (%)!#h %7 $es'" *++!%*,h 8*s $s,)sse$ 7 =e&(%!$4 1?6> S*&/e"$4 1? *"$

S*"$e!s M,C%!,4 1? *,,%!$"' #% 8h,h #he +e!,e+#)*&%#%!4 8h,h ,*e

+!*!& (!% h)*" (*,#%!s %!e"#e$ #%8*!$ h)*" e"#*& ,*+*7&#es *"$ &#*#%"s4

+!*!& 7 s#!/"' #% !e$),e #he *##e"#%" *"$ ,%",e"#!*#%" !e)!ee"#s %( %7s

H*,*" O&$h*4 1?64 10 *"$ P*s%!e4 1 s#)$e$ #8% $%"*#e$

#he%!e#,*& (!*e8%! %( %7 $es'"4 %"e 8*s J%7 Ch*!*,#e!s#,s M%$e& *"$ %#he! S%,%-

#e,h",*& Ss#e S)s*"4 1?6> R%)sse*)4 1??> C)"'s4 1?> :e&&4 1?>



P*s%!e4 F!*",s4 H*&$e*"Sh*"4 12> =*&& J*,s%"4 15> O&$h*4 16>

H%&*" =*&&4 2002 s#!esse$ *7%)# #he e+&%ee *)#%"% %/e! #he *s+e,#s %( #he %7

e'4 #"' *"$ e#h%$s 8h,h 8e!e *,"%8&e$'e$ *s #he %7 ,h*!*,#e!s#, %( /#*&

s'"(,*",e

=*&& *"$ J*,s%" " 15 "%#,e$ #he s'"(,*",e %( !ese*!,h e9+&%!e$ 7 #hese

%7 $es'" #he%!es " #he ,)!!e"# 8%!"' e"/!%"e"# I" #he! /e84 %7 $es'" #he%!

h*s (*&e$ #% ; ee+ +*,e 8#h #he !*+$ ,h*"'es " #he #e,h"%&%' +*!#,)&*!& #h%se

8h,h *!e $%"*#e$ 7 #he "(%!*#%" #e,h"%&%' *"$ 7 %#he! *"*'ee"# +!*,#,es

s),h *s )s#-"-#e JIT *"$ #%#*& )*&# *"*'ee"# TM

I" #hs +e!s+e,#/e4 R%7e!#s G&,4 11> S#%"e G)e)#*&4 15> *,,*!%

S#%"e4 1> O&$h*4 16> *!')e$ *"$ )es#%"e$ * $e"'!*#%" 8h,h h*$ 7ee" !*se$

!e+e*#e$& %/e! #he e*!s #h*# +!e/*&"' %7 $es'" (!*e8%!s +!ese"#e$ *" e9,ess/e&

&#e$ +e!,e+#%" %" +s,h%&%',*&& +%!#*"# 7*s,s %( %7 ,%"#e"# =*&& *"$ J*,s%"

15 $s,)sse$ * s#!%"' +!e)$,e "s$e #he %7 $es'" #he%! he*$e$ (%! %#/*#%"*&

e9+&*"*#%" %( #he &" 7e#8ee" %7 ,h*!*,#e!s#,s *"$ +s,h%&%',*& %)#,%es4 &e %7

+e!(%!*",e *"$ %7 s*#s(*,#%"

E+!,*& s#)$es %( =*&&4 C%!7e##4 C&e''4 J*,s%"4 10> J*,s%" =*&&4

11> =*&&4 J*,s%"4 D*/$s4 12 s)''es#e$ #h*# ",!e*se$ " *)#%"% 8e!e !e&*#e$

8#h )*&#*#/e ,h*"'es " e+&%ees 7eh*/%)! s#e*$ 8#h #he &e*!""' *"$ (%! %7$es'" !ese*!,he!s #% ",&)$e * "%8&e$'e-7*se$ e,h*"s " #he! ')$e$ (!*e8%!s

Dee!%)#4 B*e!4 N*,h!e"e!4 S,h*)(e& 2001 e+h*s.e$ #he !e)!ee"# #%

7!%*$e" #he /*!e# %( /*!*7&es $s#!ess"' %7 e9+e!e",es



Fe&$*" B%&"% 16 $s,)sse$ (*,#%!s s),h *s 8%!&$ *s * '&%7*& /&&*'e4

!'h#s."' $%8"s."' *"$ !*+$ #e,h"%&%',*& *$/*",ee"#s 7!%)'h# *7%)# +e!%$s %(

/*')e"ess *"$ !e/%&)#%".*#%"4 8h,h 8e!e &e& #% *((e,# e+&%ees e9+e!e",es *"$

%7s 7%#h *# +!ese"# *"$ #he! ()#)!e ,*!ee! s#*'es As +e! H*&& Ch*"$&e!4 2005 s#)$es

,*!ee! ,h*"'es *"$ %7 #!*"s#%"s h*$ 7e,%e '!*$)*&& %!e !e,)!!e"#> e+&%ees

!e*,#%" #% #he! %7s ; 8e!e +!%7*7&e #% 7e ,!e*#e$ " * $%"*"# 8* Th%+s%"4

B*e!4 S*&&8%%$4 16 *"$ H*&&4 16 s#)$e$ #h*# #he ,*!ee!s %( +!%(ess%"*&

e+&%ees "%!*&& "/%&/e$ se/e!*& s#*'es 7)# %s# +%!#*"# 8e!e #he (!s# #8% s#*'es

%( #he Th%+s%" e# *& %$e& B&*)4 1

I" #he (!s# s#*'e4 e+&%ees 8e!e &e& #% (%,)s %" #he! !%)#"e 8%!4 7 '/"'

#he &##&e *)#%"% I" #he se,%"$ s#*'e4 +!%(ess%"*& e+&%ees 8e!e "/%&/e$

"$e+e"$e"#& 7 '/"' #he h'h *)#%"% e/e" " ,%+&e9 #*ss 8h,h !e)!e$ #he

)se %( )&#+&e s&&s C*!s#e"se"4 Is**,%8#. Ch*!&es4 1 s#)$e$ #h*# e+&%ees

"e*! #% #he! !e#!ee"# 7e,%e %!e ,%",e!"e$ 8#h 7)&$"' e*""'()& !e&*#%"sh+s

" 8h,h #he ,*" *e &%"' &*s#"' ,%"#!7)#%"s #h*# %)#&*s# #hese&/es4 7e"e(# ()#)!e

'e"e!*#%"4 *"$ 7)&$ * &e'*, 8h,h h*s ()!#he! 7ee" %7se!/e$ 7 =*$e-Be".%" "

2006 F)!#he! G!*"#4 200? s#)$e$ #h*# e+&%ees "e*! #% #he! !e#!ee"# %! ,%+&e#%"

%( #he! ,%"#!*,# +e!%$ 8e!e e9+e,#e$ #% e9h7# +!e$%"*"#& ,%"s#!),#/e !es+%"se #%

#*s %! %7 s'"(,*",e %++%!#)"#es #% h*/e * ,%"s#!),#/e +*,# %" %#he! e+&%ee *s

* +*#h8* #% 7)&$ !e&*#%"s *"$ ,!e*#"' e*""'()&4 &%"' &*s#"' ,%"#!7)#%"s #h%se

h*/e 7ee" *++!e,*#e$ *"$ *,,e+#e$ 7 #he %#he!s

(o) E,aluation



As $e("e$ 7 =e!#he! D*/s 1; J%7 e/*&)*#%" s * ss#e*#, +!%,ess

)se$ #% $e#e!"e #he 8%!#h %( %7s *"$ ,!e*#"' * &" 7e#8ee" %7 8%!#h *"$ s*&*!

G)+#* Ch*!*7%!# 1 ()!#he! ,&*!(e$ #h*# *s #he 8%!#h %( * %7 s $e#e!"e$4 #

'h# 7e see" " #e!s %( s*&*! *"$ %#he! (!"'e 7e"e(#s " *,,%!$*",e 8#h #he e9s#"'

s*&*! s#!),#)!e %( #he %!'*".*#%" N%!*&&4 %#he! (*,#%!s &e *'e4 'e"$e!4 !e&e/*"# %7

e9+e!e",e *"$ *$$#%"*& )*&(,*#%" 8e!e *&s% ,%"s$e!e$ The /#*& !%&e %( %7

e/*&)*#%" " 8*'e *$"s#!*#%" h*s 7ee" '!%8" *"$ '*"e$ +%!#*",e he",e se/e!*&

%!'*".*#%"s *!e +&ee"#"' *&e 8%!#h +%&,es D*s G*!,*-D*. 2001 "#*#e$

* 8$e& )se$ e#h%$ %( %7 e/*&)*#%" ,*&&e$ +%"# 7*se$ %7 e/*&)*#%" e#h%$4 8he!e %7s 8e!e !*#e$ %" * se# %( /*!%)s (*,#%!s4 8h,h 8e!e e*s& )"$e!s#*"$*7&e Ths ss#e

h*s !e&*7&# " +!%$),"' *,,)!*#e !es)&#s

J%7 e/*&)*#%" s +&ee"#e$ " *" &*!'e +!/*#e *"$ +)7&, se,#%!

%!'*".*#%"s s",e &%"'4 h%8e/e! s*&&e! %!'*".*#%"s *!e &ess "#e!es#e$ #% *$%+# #

F%!*& %7 e/*&)*#%" s,hees h*/e 7ee" +!e+*!e$ h*/"' e+!,*& !ese*!,h ,%"$),#e$

s",e #he 1@0s Se/e!*& *##e+#s h*/e 7ee" *$e #% es#*7&sh #he (*,#%!s *"$ #he! +%"#

8e'h#*'es Ch*!"*se# *& 1554 L&e8*&&" 16@4 G)+#* Ah*$ 14 Ah*$

1> G)+#* Ch**!7%!# 1 $e/e&%+e$ * &"e*! %$e& #% e/*&)*#e #he

,%+*!*#/e 8%!#h %( #he %7 I" s),h e#h%$4 #he 8e'h#*'e 8*s '/e" #% e/e! (*,#%!

8h,h 8*s *ss'"e$ *" /*&)e *"$ *&& #he (*,#%!s 8e!e e)*&& +%!#*"# P##*& 1

*"$ D*s G*!,* D*. 2001 $e#e!"e$ #he (*,#%! 8e'h#s 7 e*"s %( #he !e'!ess%"

*"*&ss !es)&#s %( #he s*&*! s)!/e F)!#he! s#)$es %( C%&&*"sM),h"s 1;4 Che"

e# *& 14 R)##D%/e!s+e 14 O&s%" e# *& 20004 =e&7%)!"eT!e/%! 20004



A!"*)&# e# *& 20014 M%!'es%" e# *& 20014 R%#)"$%S*,*##4 200@ h*/e *&s% #es#e$ #he

/*&$# *"$ %)#,%e %( #he %7 e/*&)*#%" ss#e " /%')e )se$ (%! s*&*! $e#e!"*#%"

J%7 e/*&)*#%" * 7e ,%"$),#e$ #h!%)'h #8% $s#",# +!%,esses "*e& *#,h"'

*"$ !es#!,#e$ e/*&)*#%" )#e * &%# %( %7s 8e!e * &e$ #% e*,h %#he! *"$ ,%!!es+%"$"'

%7s "/%&/e$ "#e!+!e#"' #he *"$ ,%+*!"' #he (*,#%! 7 (*,#%! Th!ee s#*'es 8e!e

"/%&/e$ $)!"' #he %7 e/*&)*#%" +!%,ess3

=*##s G!ee" 200@ $e/e&%+e$ * (%!# (%)! +*'e %7 *"*&ss

)es#%""*!e 8h,h 8*s #% 7e ,%+&e#e$ 7 #he e+&%ees 8#h he&+

%( #he! s)+e!/s%! %! +ee!s )es#%""*!e 8*s !e/e8e$ 7 #8% +!%(ess%"*& %7 *"*&s#s #% *e

s)!e #h*# # 8*s *,,)!*#e )es#%""*!e %" ,%+&e#%" h*s #% 7e s'"e$ *"$ * +*"e& 8*s $e+)#e$

#% e/*&)*#e # I( *&& (*,#%! &e/e&s 8e!e 8#h" #he s+e,(e$ !*"'e4 #hs

,*&&e$ * +e!(e,# +!%(&e

The $e/e&%+e"# %( * h'h +e!(%!*",e 8%! ss#es h*s !*se$ )es#%"s *7%)#

#he /*7&# %( %7 e/*&)*#%" " #he 8%!+&*,e J%7 e/*&)*#%" s esse"#*&& * ss#e #h*#

(%!*&& ,%+*!es #he ,h*!*,#e!s#,s %( $ss&*! %7s *"$ &"s #hese #% +* I# h*s 7ee"

%s# +!e/*&e"# " &*!'e %!'*".*#%"s *"$ (%! %7s (%! 8h,h #he!e s "% $!e,# *!e# !*#e

%( +* *"$ ,*" /*! " #e!s %( #s ,%"#e"#4 %!e"#*#%" *"$ %7e,#/es A&& %7s *!e

e/*&)*#e$4 7)# " s%e ,*ses #he +!%,ess %( e/*&)*#%" s %!e (%!*& E/*&)*#%" ,*"#h)s "/%&/e4 %" #he %"e h*"$4 #he "/%,*#%" %( * (%!*& ss#e (%! ,%+*!"' %7s

*,!%ss *" %!'*".*#%"4 %!4 %" #he %#he!4 * se# %( *$ h%, +!",+&es $e/e&%+e$ 7

*"*'ee"# F%!*& ss#es #hese&/es ,*" /*! *!e$& *"$ * e $s#",#%" s



7e#8ee" #h%se 8h,h "/%&/e #he $e#*&e$ +%"#s !*#"' %( %7s *"*&#,*& s,hees *"$

#h%se 8h,h *$%+# * %!e h%&s#, *++!%*,h "%"-*"*&#,*&

Le/"e4 1; s#)$e$ #he "*#)!e %( %7 e/*&)*#%" 8h,h ,*" *&s% /*! *,,%!$"'

#% #he !*#%"*&e 7eh"$ #s "#!%$),#%" I" s%e ,*ses4 # !e+!ese"#e$ *" *##e+# #%

$e/e&%+ * (ee&"' @2 %( (*!"ess *%"' e+&%ees *7%)# #he !e&*#/e !e)"e!*#%" %(

8%!e!s 8h% 8%! *&%"'s$e e*,h %#he! As s),h4 # ,%)&$ 7e see" *s * +*!# %( #he +!%,ess

(%! 'e"e!*#"' #he ,%#e"# %( e+&%ees #% #he! %!'*".*#%"s *s *"$ %7e,#/es

S),h ,%#e"# 8e!e )"&e& #% 7e +e"$"' *%"' 8%!e!s 8h% (e&# #h*# #he

$s#!7)#%" %( !e8*!$s 8*s "%# e)#*7&e C%"se)e"#&4 #he! %!'*".*#%"s 8e!e )"&e&

#% %+e!*#e *# * h'h &e/e& %( e((,e", A$$#%"*&&4 (%!*& %7 e/*&)*#%" "/%&/es #he

%!'*".*#%" s+e,("' %7 s#!),#)!es *"$ ,*!ee!-+*#hs4 #he!e7 s)''es#"' #% e+&%ees

,&e*! $e/e&%+e"# +*#hs *"$ +!%%#%" %++%!#)"#es Ths ,%)&$ 7e *" +%!#*"#

e&ee"# " 'e"e!*#"' #he e+&%ee ,%#e"# %" 8h,h *" h'h +e!(%!*",e 8%!

ss#es $e+e"$

(o) e,aluation and (o) de$i%n relation$hi-

M&%/,h Ne8*"4 10 s#)$e$ #h*# J%7 $es'" *"$ %7 e/*&)*#%" *!e

",&)$e$ " #he sh*+e %( %7 *"*&ss (%! /*!%)s +)!+%ses I" %!$e! #% ,%"$),# %7

*"*&ss 7 *ss'""' #he #*ss *"$ (%!*#%" %( %7 $es,!+#%"s JDs # 8*s

!e,%e"$e$ #% ,%"$),# %7 e/*&)*#%" *s * (!s# s#e+ Rese*!,he!s S,h8*74 10>M&%/,h Ne8*"4 10 s)''es#e$ #h*# 8h&e ,%"s$e!"' %7 $es'" *s * e#h%$ %(

*"*&ss # )s# 7e ",%!+%!*#e$ (%! ,%"$),#"' %7 e/*&)*#%" F"*&&4 %s# %7 $es'"

e*s)!e &e J%7 E*'"%s#, S)!/e 8*s ,*!!e$ %)# 7 H*,*" O&$h* " 1?5>



Ss4 S.&*'4 :e&&e!4 1?6 $s,)sse$ J%7 ,h*!*,#e!s#,s I"/e"#%! " 1?6 *"$ M)&#

e#h%$ %( J%7 $es'" )es#%""*!e 8*s $s,)sse$ 7 C*+%" " 1

C%!!e&*#%" 7e#8ee" %7 e/*&)*#%" *"$ %7 $es'" h*s 7ee" s#)$e$ *"$

e+!,*&& +!%/e$ D)"h* 1?? #es#e$ ,%!!e&*#%"s 7e#8ee" %7 e/*&)*#%" 7*se$ %"

#he P%s#%" A"*&ss @; )es#%""*!e M,C%!,4 Je*""e!e#4 Me,h*4 1?2 *&s%

(%)"$e$ ,%!!e&*#%"s 8#h %7 e/*&)*#%" O#he! e+!,*& s#)$es %( R%)sse*)4 12>

S,h"e$e!4 Re,he!s4 M#,he&&4 12 *"$ Ge!h*!#4 1 +!%/$e$ "$!e,# s)++%!# 7

#es#"' ,%!!e&*#%"s 8#h J%7 s&& !e)!ee"#s I" *&& s),h ,*ses4 +%s#/e ,%!!e&*#%"s

8e!e %7se!/e$4 #he!e 8*s (%)"$ "% "e'*#/e ,%!!e&*#%"s 8#h s&& !e)!ee"#s *"$

"e'*#/e !e&*#%"sh+s 8e!e *&s% %7se!/e$ 8#h +hs,*& "ee$s C*+%" !e+&,*#e$ #hese

("$"'s " 1

(o) Securit*

J%7 se,)!# s $e("e$ *s e+&%ees $es!es #% 7e !e#*"e$ " #he! ,)!!e"# %7s

#&& #he! !e#!ee"#s G!ee"h*&'h R%se"7&*##4 1@> B%!' E&.)!4 12> G!ee"h*&'h

S)##%"4 11 *"$ J*,%7s%"4 11 s#)$e$ *++!ehe"s%" %( #he e+&%ees )+%" &*, %(

e"/*7&e %7 ,h*!*,#e!s#,s &e s&%8 +!%%#%"s4 8%!"' e"/!%"e"# *"$ ,%"$#%"s

*"$ e"$)!"' ,*!ee! %++%!#)"#es J%7 se,)!# 8*s *" +%!#*"# !ese*!,h #%+, (%! #he

s%,*& s,e"#s#s *s # h*s *" +*,# %" s%,*& )s#,e *"$ h)*" $'"# H)*" $'"#

8*s $!e,#& !e&*#e$ #% #he %7 se,)!# *s # *((e,#e$ #he *7&# %( e+&%ees #% s*#s( #he 7*s, +hs%&%',*& *"$ se,)!# "ee$s Ps,h%&%'s#s h*/e !e,%'".e$ %7 "se,)!# *s

*" +e!*#/e ,*)se %( s#!ess 8h,h "/%&/e$ *"9e# *"$ +*",





,%"se)e",es (%! #he %!'*".*#%"s *"$ !e+!ese"#e$ * %)"#"' *++!ehe"s%" (%! * &%# %(

+!%(ess%"*&s

C%"ss#e"# 8#h #he !ese*!,h %" +s,h%&%',*& ,%"#!*,# 7!e*,h4 M%!!s%"

R%7"s%"4 1? Les#e!4 T)!"&e4 B&%%$'%%$4 B%&"%4 2002 *!')e$ #h*# !e')&*!

e+&%ees 8%)&$ *e e9#e!"*& *"$ "#e!"*& *##!7)#%"s #% "%#,e #h*# 8h s),h

%!'*".*#%" h*s !e&e$ %" #e+%!*!es %! ,%"#!*,#)*& e+&%ees P(e((e! B*!%"4 1>

D*/s-B&*e U..4 1;> M*#)s H&&4 1 s#)$e$ #h*# #e+%!*!4 ,%"#!*,#)*& *"$

$*& 8*'es e+&%ee * 7e h!e$ $)!"' #he +e* +e!%$ *"$ s)7se)e"#& * 7e

!e&e*se$ 8he" $e*"$ 8*s $%8"8*!$s

J*,%7s%"4 11 s#)$e$ #h*# * &*!'e ")7e! %( e+&%ees h*/e e9+e!e",e$ *

7*s, *"$ "s#",#/e ,h*"'e " #he! se# %( 7e&e(s *7%)# #he %!'*".*#%" *"$ #he!

+%s#%" " # C*e!%"4 S)##%" =he##e"4 1> D*/4 :", S,he,4 11>

G!ee"h*&'h S)##%"4 11 s#!esse$ #h*# #he "/%&)"#*! ,h*"'e " 7e&e(s 8*s #!''e!e$

7 e!'e!s4 &*%((s s'"s %( !e$),e$ e((e,#/e"ess 7 #he %!'*".*#%"4 !es#!),#)!"' #%

,)# ,%s#s The +%!#*",e %( )"$e!s#*"$"' %7 se,)!#s !%&e h*s 7ee" s#)$e$ 7

B!%,"e!4 De=##4 G!%/e! Ree$4 10 *"$ D*/ e# *&4 11 " ,%""e,#%" 8#h #he

e+h*ss %/e! #he +*s# $e,*$e %" e+&%ee !e*,#%"s #% *%! %!'*".*#%"*& ,h*"'e

D*/4 :",4 :&!% S,he,4 1 e9+&*"e$ s),h *%! %!'*".*#%"*& ,h*"'es *s

$%8"s."' *"$ e!'e!s4 #he %s# #h!e*#e"e$ se# %( e+&%ee e9+e,#*#%"s 8*s %7

se,)!# The!e(%!e4 # 8*s "e,ess*! #% )"$e!s#*"$ h%8 #hs #h!e*# h*s *" +*,# %"

"$/$)*&s +s,h%&%',*& *"$ ,%'"#/e !e*,#%"



I"#e!es# " #he e((e,#s %( %7 se,)!# *"$ "se,)!# h*s &e$ #% * +!e/*&e",e %(

e+!,*& !ese*!,h (%,)se$ %" #he !e&*#%"sh+ 7e#8ee" %7 se,)!# *"$ #s %)#,%es

A!"%&$ *"$ Fe&$*"4 12> O&$h*4 J)&4 A7!%se4 S#e+"* B!*"$4 16 s#)$e$ *"$

#es#e$ #h*# %7 se,)!# 8*s +%s#/e& ,%!!e&*#e$ 8#h %7 s*#s(*,#%" *"$ %!'*".*#%"*&

,%#e"# 7)# %" #he %#he! h*"$ A!"%&$ *"$ Fe&$*"4 12> Ash(%!$ e# *&4 1 (%)"$

"e'*#/e& ,%!!e&*#e$ 8#h "#e"#%" #% )# A&#h%)'h #hese s#)$es )",%/e!e$ s'"(,*"#

,%!!e&*#%"s4 #he $$ "%# "/es#'*#e #he se)e"#*& *"$ "$!e,# e((e,#s 7e#8ee" %7

se,)!# *"$ +%!#*"# 8%! %)#,%es These s#)$es *&s% (*&e$ #% e9*"e 8he#he! #he

"*#)!e *"$ s#!e"'#h %( #he !e&*#%"sh+s 7e#8ee" %7 se,)!# *"$ #s %)#,%es *!e$((e!e"# " s#)*#%"s 8#h $((e!e"# &e/e&s %( "se,)!# %! #h!e*# These *!e +%!#*"#

%ss%"s 7e,*)se #he &# #he *7&# #% #he%!e#,*&& e9+&*" %! )"$e!s#*"$ #he

+s,h%&%',*& +!%,ess 7 8h,h %7 "se,)!# *((e,#s /*!%)s ,!#e!* Ths &*, %(

)"$e!s#*"$"' &#s %)! *7&# #% $e/e&%+ e((e,#/e !ee$*& +!%'!*s #h*# 8&& &#

se!%)s %!'*".*#%"*& ,%"se)e",es

R%ses L%)s-G)e!"4 10> D*/4 :",4 S,he,4 11> Ge*!4 12> Ts)4

Pe*!,e4 P%!#e!4 T!+%&4 1? (%)"$ #h*# e+&%ee h*/"' ,%",e!"s !e'*!$"' %7

se,)!# 8e!e (%)"$ *s * !es)&# (!% #he %!'*".*#%"*& +!*,#,es 8h,h *((e,#e$ #he

e9s#"' e+&%ee *"$ e+&%e! !e&*#%"sh+4 *s +e! G!ee"h*&'h R%se"7&*##4 1@>

Ash(%!$4 Lee4 B%7%4 1> s#)$es %! (!% #he "*#)!e %( #he +s,h%&%',*& ,%"#!*,#

#se&( *s $s,)sse$ 7 R%)sse*) " 1 R%)sse*)4 10> R%7"s%" e# *&4 1@> Sh%!e

Te#!,4 1@> C*/*"*)'h N%e4 1 *"$ S#hs%" Le8s4 2000 7e&e/e$ #h*# %7

se,)!# 8*s +e!*#/e " #hs s#)*#%" *s # 8*s "$,*#e$ #h*# e9#e"# #% 8h,h #he

e+&%ees +s,h%&%',*& ,%"#!*,#s 8e!e 7*se$ %" ,%"/,#%" *"$ sh*!e$ *((e,#%"



Ash(%!$ e# *&4 1> B%se&e4 Hesse&"4 P**)8e4 V*" De! =e&e4 2000 s#)$e$

#h*# J%7 "se,)!# 8*s "e'*#/e& !e&*#e$ #% #he 7e&e( *"$ #!)s# " #he %!'*".*#%"4

()!#he! Ash(%!$ e# *& (%)"$ #h*# +e!,e/e$ %7 "se,)!# e9+&*"e$ 26 %( #he /*!*",e

%( #!)s# *"$ 7e&e( " #he %!'*".*#%"s Th)s4 ("$"'s %( P%!#e! e# *&4 " 1?@ +!%/$e$ *"

e/$e",e %( %7 se,)!# *s * !e&*#%"*& +s,h%&%',*& ,%"#!*,# 7)&# %" sh*!e$ #!)s# *"$

,%"($e",e O!'*".*#%"*& ,%#e"# 8*s (%)"$ *s * s#!e"'#h %( *" e+&%ees

!e,%'"#%" 8#h #he! *((e,#%" #% *" %!'*".*#%" A&&e" Mee! $e"#(e$ #h!ee (%!s

%( ,%#e"# " 16 8h,h 8e!e *((e,#/e4 "%!*#/e *"$ ,%"#")*",e A((e,#/e 8*s

e9*"e$ *"$ !e&*#e$ 8#h #he %7 +e!(%!*",e4 ORe&& Ch*#*"4 16 *"$ R*"$*&&410 &"e$ 8#h %7 s*#s(*,#%"4 B%8e" S,h"e$e!4 1 8#h #)!"%/e! *"$

B&*)B%*&4 1?> H)se&$ D*4 11> C%he" H)$e,e4 1; *"$ S%e!s4 15 8#h

I"#e"#%" #% #)!"%/e! M%7&e e# *&4 1? *"$ Te## Mee!4 1; s#)$e$ 8&&"'"ess %(

e+&%ees #% &e*/e #he %!'*".*#%" (%! *"%#he! %7 *"$ #he! "#e"#%" #% 7e'" se*!,h"'

(%! * "e8 %7 I"#e"#%" #% #)!"%/e! 8*s #he %s# +!e$,#/e /*!*7&e %( *,#)*& #)!"%/e! "

%!'*".*#%"s *&s% ,%"(!e$ 7 H% e# *&4 12> G!((e#h e# *&4 " 2000

(o) Succe$$ion Plannin%

J%7 S),,ess%" +&*"""' 8*s * +%s#/e e((%!# #% e"s)!e #h*# #%+ *"*'ee"# *"$

h)*" !es%)!,e +!%(ess%"*&s " *" %!'*".*#%" 8%)&$ 7e $e"#("' h%8 #he /*,*"#

+%s#%"s 8%)&$ 7e (&&e$ ( *" e+&%ee )# hs %! he! %7 R%#h8e&&4 2005 s#)$e$ #h*#

%7 S),,ess%" +&*"""' JSP ",&)$e$ ,)&#/*#"' *"$ +!e+*!"' #*&e"# (!% 8#h" *"

%!'*".*#%"4 %! (%!e,*s#"' !e,!)#e"# *"$ se&e,#%" *,#/#es (%! %)#s$e #*&e"# J%7

S),,ess%" +&*"""' s * 8* %( ,%"$),#"' +%#e"#*& e/*&)*#%"s Ths +!%,ess4 8h,h s

)s)*&& $%"e (%! #%+ *"*'ee"# +%s#%"s4 !e)!es se"%! *"*'e!s #% $e"#(



e+&%ees 8h% sh%)&$ 7e $e/e&%+e$ #% !e+&*,e #he I"(%!*#%" 'e"e!*#e$ $)!"'

s),,ess%" +&*"""' * "%# 7e ,%)",*#e$ #% #he e+&%ee

I( #%+ *"*'ee"# 7e&e/e #h*# e+&%ee h*s * h'h +%#e"#*& (%! *$/*",ee"#4

#he * 7e %!e &e& #% e/*&)*#e #he +e!s%" (*/%)!*7& *"$ +!%%#e h %! he! %!e

),& #h*" *,#)*& +e!(%!*",e 8*!!*"#s I( s),,ess%" +&*"s *!e "%# ,%)",*#e$ #%

#he e+&%ee4 #he %!'*".*#%" !)"s #he !s %( * s*#,h 7e#8ee" #he e+&%ees ,*!ee!

+&*"s *"$ #s +&*"s (%! #he e+&%ee M*"' #hs "(%!*#%" */*&*7&e #% #he e+&%ee

,*" e"s)!e #h*# he %! she $e/e&%+s !e*&s#, ,*!ee! +&*"s *"$ !e$),es #he ,h*",es #h*# #he

+e!s%" 8&& !e()se #he +%s#%" J%7 S),,ess%" +&*"""' s *" +%!#*"# h)*" !es%)!,e

+!*,#,e (%! +!/*#e *s 8e&& *s +)7&, se,#%! %!'*".*#%"s A,,%!$"' #% F!*)e"he

s#)$es " 2006 4 J%7 S),,ess%" +&*"""' 8*s 7e,%"' /e! ,%%" +!*,#,e " #he

P)7&, se,#%! %!'*".*#%"s *&s% G!ee"8*&$4 2001 (%)"$ #h*# J%7 S),,ess%" +&*"""'

8*s %!e &e& #% h*++e" ( "e8 +%s#%"s 8e!e ,!e*#e$ Be!"#h*&4 R%)9=e&&"s4 1>

G)&(%!$4 2000 $s,)sse$ #he /s)*&.*#%" %( *" e9#e"s/e +e!,e"#*'e %( se"%!

*"*'ee"# !e#!ee"#s $)!"' #he "e9# #h!ee #% (/e e*!s ,%"s$e!"' * *%! ,h*&&e"'e

#% (&& s),h +%s#%"s

P!e/%)s& * 8$es+!e*$ %$)s %+e!*"$ )se$ #% !es%&/e +!%7*7&e !e+&*,ee"#s

%( se"%! *"*'e!s 8*s !e(e!!e$ *s +&ee"#*#%" %( %7 s),,ess%" +&*"""' The #e!

!e(e!!e$ #% * ss#e*#, *"$ ,%"#!%&&e$ ss#e %( $e"#("' %7 +%s#%" s)7s##)#%"4

7es# )se$ " ,%+*!*#/e& s#*7&e 8%! e"/!%"e"#s Be!"#h*& e# *&4 1 s#)$e$ #h*# #

!e&e$ * '!e*# $e*& %" +e!(%!*",e *"*'ee"# $*#* *"$ !e,%e"$*#%"s %( #he #%+

*"*'ee"# 8#h" #he %!'*".*#%" I" 2001 Bh* e# *&4 "%#,e$ #h*# se/e!*&

%!'*".*#%"s s)++%se$ %7 s),,ess%" +&*"""' *s ,)7e!s%e *"$ "e#he! e((e,#/e



"e#he! " #he !e#e"#%" %( #*&e"#e$ s#*(( "%! " #he !e+&*,ee"# %( %)#'%"' se"%!

*"*'ee"#

H*&& Ass%,*#es 16 $e("e$ %7 s),,ess%" +&*"""' *s * +!ee$#*#e$

+!%,ess (%! se&( *8*!e"ess4 ,%"s#!*"#4 ,h%,e4 %++%!#)"# *"$ ,%"se)e",es #% $e"#(

,*!ee! !e&*#e$ '%*&s *"$ $e/e&%+e"# (%! ()#)!e %7s4 e$),*#%" *"$ !e&*#e$ e9+e!e",e #%

+!%/$e #he $!e,#%"4 #"' *"$ se!es %( s#e+s #% *,he/e * +!e,se ,*!ee! '%*& A

s'"(,*"# s#!ess 8&& 7e %" #he $e/e&%+e"# %( "#e!"*& ,*+*7&#4 8h,h ,*" *&s%

,%"#!7)#e #% %!'*".*#%"*& 8&&"'"ess 8he" ,%"#"'e", ,!%+ )+ F)#)!e ,%+e#e",es

*!e )#&.e$ *s #he ,!#e!* #%8*!$s 8h,h e+&%ees sh%)&$ 7e #!*"e$ *"$ $e/e&%+e$ The

!%&e %( #%+ *"*'ee"# s "%# #% ,*#e'%!.e s+e,(, e+&%ee #% !e+&*,e #he4 7)# #%

$e"#( $e/e&%+e"#*& %++%!#)"#es4 ,!e*#e ,h*&&e"'"' *ss'"e"#s #h*# *!e ""e!%s#

#% #he %!'*".*#%" *"$ ,!e*#e * #e* %!e"#*#%" *"$ se!/e *s * !%&e %$e&s (%! #h%se 8h%

*!e 7e"' $e/e&%+e$

G!ee"h*)s4 e# *& s#)$e$ " 2000 #h*# ,h*"'"' e"/!%"e"#s4 &e ,h*"'e %(

7)s"ess s#!*#e'es *"$ $!e,#%"s4 %!'*".*#%" $%8"s."' *"$ !'h#s."'4 e!'e!s *"$

*,)s#%"s *"$ (*s# +*,e$ #e,h"%&%',*& ,h*"'es4 8%)&$ !e)!e (!*'e"#*! ,*!ee!

*"*'ee"#4 !es)&#"' " #he "ee$ #% !e*++e*! ,*!ee! %+#%" *"$ %$("' %7

s),,ess%" +&*"""' F)!#he! !ese*!,h 8%! ,*!!e$ %)# 7 G!ee"h*)s4

C*&&*"*"G%$sh*& " 2000 s)++%!#e$ #he ,%"#!%/e!s #h*# e((e,#/e %7 s),,ess%"

+&*"""' ,%)&$ e"*7&e "$/$)*&s #% *e "(%!e$ $e,s%"s #h%se 8e!e s#e*$ 8#h

#he! *s+!*#%"4 #*&e"#s *"$ /*&)es #% +!%/e %!'*".*#%"*& e((e,#/e"ess



Lee 2000 s#)$e$ #h*# +!*,#,e %( %7 s),,ess%" +&*"""' " #he %!'*".*#%"s

8*s e9+e,#e$ #% 7%%s# e+&%ees %7 s*#s(*,#%" *"$ !e$),e #)!"%/e! Se/e!*&

!ese*!,he!s4 8h% s#)$e$ %#he! /e8s %( %7 s*#s(*,#%"4 h*/e *&s% *++!e,*#e$ #hs

,%",e+# F!s#4 *" *)#h%!s $e"#(e$ %7 s*#s(*,#%" *s * ,%"$#%" %( 7!*"s *"$

"#e!+!e#e$ $((e!e"#& Ch*B!)/%&$ " 200; $e("e$ %7 s*#s(*,#%" *s *" e+&%ees

*!%)s"' ,%e7*, #% e9+&,# *s+e,#s %( #he %7 N%e 16 $e("e$ # *s * e"%*7&e

e%#%"s #h*# !es)&#e$ (!% #he %7se!/*#%" #h*# hs %! he! %7 ()&(&e$ %! *&&%8e$ (%! #he

*,he/ee"# %( hs %! he! +%!#*"# %7 /*&)es *s s#*#e$ 7 A++e&7*) e# *&4 " 2002

Che"4 Ch*"' Yeh 200@ s)!/ee$ #he *7&# %( %7 s),,ess%" +&*"""' " !es+%"$ #%,*!ee! $es!es *# $((e!e"# ,*!ee! s#*'es *"$ #s "(&)e",e %" %7 s*#s(*,#%"4 #!*""' *"$

$e/e&%+e"# *"$ +!%$),#/# *%"'s# #he !ese*!,h *"$ $e/e&%+e"# 8%!(%!,e O"e %(

#he *%! ,%",&)s%"s %( #he !ese*!,h 8*s %7 s),,ess%" +&*"""' +%s#/e& "(&)e",e$

%7 s*#s(*,#%" *"$ +!%$),#/# The e/e"#)*& +)!+%se %( %7 s),,ess%" +&*"""' 8*s #%

+!e+*!e *" %!'*".*#%" (%! !ss &"e$ 8#h #he +&*""e$ %! )"+&*""e$ &%ss %( "%8&e$'e

#h*# 8*s /#*& #% #he *,he/ee"#s %( #he %!'*".*#%"

E!-lo*ee Recruit!ent

The!e s *" e9#e"s/e ",!e*se " #he !ese*!,h %( e+&%ee !e,!)#e"# s",e

1?0s I( s%e%"e +e!)se !e/e8 %" !e,!)#e"# !ese*!,h %( R"es4 11> B!e*)'h4 12>

=*"%)s4 12 *"$ B*!7e!4 1>4 %"e ,*" ("$ * 9 %( h%+e()&"ess *"$ '&)"ess

Rese*!,he!s 8e!e s*#s(e$ )+%" ",!e*se$ !ese*!,h %" !e,!)#e"# 8#h * ,%"($e",e #h*#

*$/*",ee"# " *++!e,*#/e %( #he 7e&%"'"'s %( !e,!)#e"# *,#/#es 8*s 7e"'

,%"s$e!e$ A# #he s*e #e #he 8e!e (%)"$ (!)s#!*#e$ $)e #% s&)''sh *$/*",ee"# "



)"$e!s#*"$"' #he !e,!)#e"# +!%,ess =%!"'s %( R"es " 114 B!e*)'h 12 *"$

B*!7e! 1 8*s !e(e!!e$ *s * ,%+!ehe"s/e e9+%s)!e %( !e,!)#e"# !ese*!,h

T*&%! C%&&"s4 2000 s#)$e$ !e,!)#e"# *s %"e %( #he %s# ,!#,*& H)*"

Res%)!,e *,#/# 8h,h 8*s /#*& (%! #he %!'*".*#%"*& s),,ess B%)$!e*) R"es4

15 s#)$e$ #h*# # 8*s "%# s% e*s (%! %!'*".*#%"s #% *##!*,# +%#e"#*& e+&%ee *s

#he %!'*".*#%"*& *##!*,#%" "(&)e",e$ #he e((e,#/e"ess %( s),,ess/e se&e,#%"

B*!7e!4 1> Ch*+*"4 U''e!s&e/4 C*!!%&&4 P*se"#" J%"es4 2005 ,%"$),#e$ *"

e9#e"s/e !ese*!,h " #he *!e* %( !e,!)#e"# *"$ ,*"$$*#e *##!*,#%" $)!"' #he &*s# 25

e*!s B*!7e!4 1 $s,)sse$ #he !e,!)#e"# ()",#%" %!e ,&%se& !e&*#e$ #% #he

%!'*".*#%"s s#!*#e', h)*" !es%)!,e +&*"""' F!% #he %!'*".*#%"s +e!s+e,#/e4

$e/e&%+"' * !e,!)#e"# s#!*#e' "/%&/es #h!ee 7*s, $e,s%"s4 $e#e!""' #he #*!'e#

+%+)&*#%"4 $e#e!""' #he *++&,*"# s%)!,e4 *"$ $e,$"' h%8 #% *##!*,# *++&,*"#s #%

#he %!'*".*#%" O!'*".*#%"s )s# ,%"s$e! 8h*# #% %((e! *++&,*"#s " #he (%! %( +*4

7e"e(#s4 8%! e"/!%"e"#4 *"$ %#he! (!"'e$ 7e"e(#s Rese*!,h S,h%&*!s R"es4 114

B*!7e!4 1> B!e*)'h S#*!e4 2000> A"$e!s%"4 2001> H'hh%)se H%((*"4 2001

h*/e (!e)e"#& *se$ (%! %!e !ese*!,h *$$!ess"' #he !e,!)#e"# +!%,ess *s

,h*!*,#e!.e$ 7 #he ,*"$$*#es ,%"'!e'*#%" "(%!*#%" (!% * /*!e# %( %!'*".*#%"s

*"$ ,%"#!%&&e$ +e!s%"*& !e&*#%"s 8#h #he %!'*".*#%"*& !e+!ese"#*#/es T*&%! C%&&"s4 20004 T)!7*" C*7&e4 200;4 S&*)'h#e!4 S#*"#%"4 M%h!4 S,h%e&4 2005 $s,)sse$

#h*# s),h s#*'es 8e!e s'"(,*"# *s #he "(%!*#%" ",%!+%!*#e$ " !e,!)#e"# *#e!*&



+!e$s+%se$ #he %7 seee!s (!s# %!'*".*#%"*& *##!*,#/e"ess *"$ #h)s #he #+e %( #h%se

,%+%s"' #he *++&,*"#s +%%&

Re,!)#"' s "%# )s# * '*e %( h)*" ")7e!s *"%!e F%! HR +!%(ess%"*&s4

#hs e*"s '%"' * s#e+ ()!#he! #h*" $e/e&%+"' * !e,!)#e"# +&*" I# e*"s 8%!"'

,&%se& 8#h *"*'ee"# %" sh*+"' %!'*".*#%" ,)&#)!e *"$ &%%"' ,&%se& *# #he %7

*##!7)#e +!e(e!e",es %( #s ,)!!e"# *"$ ()#)!e e+&%ees O"e &*7&# %( #he HR

+!%(ess%"*& s #% ,%"/e!se #he *##!7)#es %( * +*!#,)&*! %7 )"$%)7#e$& B)#&e!4 S*"$e!s4

=h#e,%##%"4 2000 s#)$e$ #he e9#e"# #% 8h,h #he !e,!)#e! "e84 8h*# 8*s !e*&&

+%!#*"# #% #he ,*"$$*#e4 s*e "(%!*#%" *7%)# #he %7 ,%)&$ 7e +!%/$e$ T% *##!*,#

#he +e%+&e 8*"#e$4 *" %!'*".*#%"s *!e )s# ",!e*s"' #he! +* &e/e&s4 #!"' #%

7) #he #*&e"# #he "ee$ 7 +*"' %!e H%8e/e!4 #hs s#!*#e' * "%# 7e $e&/e!"'

#he 7es# !es)&#s S&&s #h*# *!e s,*!,e "%8 * "%# !e*" s% " #he ()#)!e4 +!ese"#& IT

s&&s *!e s,*!,e4 7)# *" !ee7e! 8he" e"'"ee!s 8e!e " sh%!# s)++& P*"' %!e

,*" &e*$ #% *" e/e"#)*& 7*&*",e 7e#8ee" 8h*# +e%+&e *!e +*$ *"$ h%8 ),h #he!

s&&s *!e 8%!#h " #he &%"'e! #e! P*"' %!e *&s% &e*$s #% h'he! ,%+e"s*#%" ,%s#s

(%! #he %!'*".*#%"s

The #e! !e,!)#e"# $e("e$ 7 B*!7e! s)((,e$3 !e,!)#e"# ",&)$e$ s),h

*,#/#es 8h,h 8e!e 7e"' ,*!!e$ %)# 7 #he %!'*".*#%" #% $e"#( *"$ *##!*,#

+%#e"#*& e+&%ees R"es 11 "%#,e$ #h*# * &*!'e *%)"# %( #he !e,!)#e"#

!ese*!,h h*s $e#e!"e$ #he !e,!)#e"# s%)!,es Be!'*"" T*&%!4 1@> R"es4 11>

=&&*s4 L*7'4 S#%"e4 1; *"$ Ve,,h%4 15 s#)$e$ #h*# %s# %( #he !e,!)#e"#

!ese*!,h (%,)se$ %" #he *,,%+&she"# %( %"e !e,!)#e"# e#h%$ %/e! *"%#he! *"$ #he

e((e,# %" %7 ,*"$$*#es *"$ !e*&s#, %7 +!e/e8s *s s#)$e$ 7 B!e*)'h4 12> Fe$%!4



B),&e4 *"$ D*/s4 1?> H%4 G!((e#h4 P*&,h4 B!*,e!4 1 *&&%8e$ *++&,*"#s #%

(ee& e*s *"$ se&(-se&e,#e$ 7 '/"' #he +%s#/e *"$ "e'*#/e "(%!*#%" *7%)# #he

%7

R"es4 B!e#.4 Ge!h*!#4 11 $s,)sse$ #h*# HR +!%(ess%"*&s h*/e #% +&* * /#*&

!%&e " #he %/e!*&& !e,!)#e"# +!%,ess *s #he h*/e #% ,%)",*#e "(%!*#%" *7%)# #he

%7 #se&( *"$ #he %!'*".*#%" B*!!, e!*"4 2005 ()!#he! s#)$e$ #h*# s%)!,e %(

"(%!*#%" *7%)# #he %7 *"$ #he %!'*".*#%" "(&)e",e$ s&*! #% +e!,e/e$ +e!s%"-%7

(# *"$ s)7se)e"# *##!*,#%" *"$ %7 !e#e"#%" =*"%)s4 1??4 B!e*)'h4 12> B!e*)'h

S#*!e4 2000 s#)$e$ #h*# #he ()"$*e"#*& *ss)+#%" 8*s #h*# +!e,se *"$ +!*'*#, %7

"(%!*#%" e"*7&es *++&,*"#s #% #h" *7%)# #he $e'!ee %( s&*!# 7e#8ee" #he!

"%8&e$'e4 s&&s *"$ *7&#es :SA *"$ #he %#he! %7 !e)!ee"#s

Ph&&+s4 1 *"$ Me'&"%4 R*/&"4 De Ns4 2000 s#)$e$ #h*# +!e,se *"$

+!*'*#, %7 "(%!*#%" $)!"' #he !e,!)#e"# *"$ se&e,#%" +!%,ess 8*s &"e$ 8#h

+%s#/e 8%! %)#,%es &e &%8 *##!#%"4 %7 s*#s(*,#%"4 &%8 /%&)"#*! #)!"%/e! *"$

e"h*",e$ %7 +e!(%!*",e A++&,*"#s 8h% (e&# * 7e##e! (# 7e#8ee" #he! "%8&e$'e4

s&&s *"$ *7&#es :SA *"$ #he! %7 !e)!ee"#s 8e!e &e& #% *,,e+# * %7 %((e!

Ch*#*"4 1 $s,)sse$ " Pe!s%"-O!'*".*#%" P-O (# #he e9+e!e",e %(

h!"' 8%!(%!,e (%! %!'*".*#%"s "%# )s# %7s Pe!s%"-%!'*".*#%" (# *##e+#e$ #% 7e

*8*!e %( se&e,#%" +!%,esses #h*# %,,)!!e$ 7e%"$ "%8&e$'e4 s&&s *"$ *7&#es,%!!es+%"$"' #% %((e! #he +%#e"#*& (%! * %!e s#!e#,h *"$ 7!%*$ *++!%*,h #% e+&%ee

The s'"(,*",e %( +e!s%"-%!'*".*#%" (# (%! %!'*".*#%"s 8*s s#)$e$ 7 s'"(,*"#

!e&*#%"sh+s 7e#8ee" +e!s%"-%!'*".*#%" (# *"$ #)!"%/e! 7 Ch*#*"4 11>



L*)/e!:!s#%(-B!%8"4 2001> C*7&e DeR)e4 20024 8%! %! %7 *###)$es 7

D*8sL%()s#4 1@> C*7&e DeR)e4 20024 %!'*".*#%"*& ,#.e"sh+ 7eh*/%)!s 7

ORe&& Ch*#*"4 16> C*7&e DeR)e4 20024 #e*8%! 7 P%s"e!4 124 e#h,*&

7eh*/%)! 7 P%s"e!4 :%).es S,h$#4 154 s#!ess 7 M*##es%" I/*",e/,h4 12

*"$ %7 +e!(%!*",e 7 T."e! " 1?

Recruit!ent Proce$$

Pe!s%""e& !e,!)#e"# *"$ se&e,#%" *,#/#es *!e )#e *" "/es#e"# E/e! e*!4

%!'*".*#%"s s+e"$ e"%!%)s *%)"#s %( %"e !e,!)#"' *"$ se&e,#"' %7 *++&,*"#s

Pe*!&*" *"$ B*!"e 2000 es#*#e4 (%! e9*+&e4 #h*# %!'*".*#%"s s%e#es s+e"$

" e9,ess %( Q104000 (%! #he !e,!)#e"# *"$ *$"s#!*#%" %( s#*"$*!$ se&e,#%"

+!%,e$)!es (%! e*,h %7 *++&,*"# N%# %"& $%es #hs ,%s#& es#*#e h'h&'h# #he

+%!#*",e %( )#&."' /*&$ se&e,#%" +!%,e$)!es s% #h*# %"e s "%# 8*s#e$ h!"'

+%%!& )*&(e$ "$/$)*&s4 7)# # *&s% h'h&'h#s #he +%!#*",e %( e"s)!"' #h*# *"

%!'*".*#%"s se&e,#%" +!%,e$)!es $% "%# 8%! *'*"s# # 7 #)!""' *8* )*&(e$ *"$

$es!*7&e *++&,*"#s Re,e"# e*!s h*/e see" *" *7)"$*",e %( !ese*!,h "%#,"' #he

*++&,*"# !e*,#%"s #% !e,!)#e"# *"$ s#*"$*!$ se&e,#%" +!%,e$)!es

R"es 114 + @24 He"e*"S%'&"$ 1? *"$ J)$'e 2006 $es,!7e$

!e,!)#e"# +!%,ess *s * +*!# %( #he s#*(("' +!%,ess 8he!e7 #he "$/$)*& *"$ #he

%!'*".*#%" 7e,%e *#e$ #% (%! #he e+&%e"# !e&*#%"sh+ Mee!s 12 $e("e$!e,!)#e"# *s #he h)*" !es%)!,e *"*'ee"# *,#/# %( $e/e&%+"' e9#e!"*& *"$

"#e!"*& s%)!,es %( )*&(e$ *++&,*"#s The !e,!)#e"# +!%,ess ,%",e"#!*#e$ %" +&*"""'

*7%)# #he !e,!)#e"#4 ,)&#/*#"' !e,!)#e"# s%)!,es4 *##!*,#"' *++&,*"#s (%! %7



/*,*",es *"$ e/*&)*#"' #he! !es)&#s These $e("#%"s $es,!7e$ #he !e,!)#e"# +!%,ess

(!% #he %!'*".*#%"*& +e!s+e,#/e Rese*!,h s,h%&*!s h*/e s)''es#e$ * $((e!e"#4 *"$

%!e +!%$),#/e4 *++!%*,h #% #he !e,!)#e"# +!%,ess Ne8#%" 1 s)''es#e$ #h*# #he

!e,!)#e"# +!%,ess s "%# )s# * ()",#%" %( #he %!'*".*#%"4 7)# !*#he! *" "#e!*,#/e

+!%,ess 8he!e 7%#h #he %!'*".*#%" !e+!ese"#*#/e *"$ #he *++&,*"# *e $e,s%"s

H%8 *"$ 8he!e #% *$/e!#se +%s#%" /*,*",es4 $e,$"' 8h,h *++&,*"#s #% "#e!/e8

*"$ "/#e (%! s#e /s#s *"$ %((e!"' %7s *!e *&& $e,s%"s *$e 7 %!'*".*#%"*&

!e+!ese"#*#/es A++&"' (%! %+e" +%s#%"s4 *,,e+#"' "#e!/e8s *"$ s#e /s#s4 *"$

8he#he! %! "%# #% *,,e+# * +%s#%" ( %((e!e$ *!e *&& $e,s%"s *$e 7 %7 *++&,*"#sB%#h #he *++&,*"# *"$ #he %!'*".*#%"*& !e+!ese"#*#/e )s# *e *((!*#/e $e,s%"s

*# e*,h s#*'e %( #he +!%,ess (%! #he !e,!)#"' e((%!#s #% 7e s),,ess()& S,h8*74 R"es *"$

A&$*' 1? $e("e$ !e,!)#e"# *s * #8%-8* +!%,ess 8he!e %!'*".*#%"*&

!e+!ese"#*#/es *"$ %7 *++&,*"#s *e $e,s%"s

M%s# %( #he !ese*!,he!s 7e&e/e #h*# )"$e!s#*"$"' #he !e,!)#e"# +!%,ess (!%

7%#h +e!s+e,#/es s ,!),*& #% *,he/"' +%s#/e !e,!)#"' !es)&#s S#e!" 1 s)''es#s

#h*# %!'*".*#%" sh%)&$ #!e*# ,*"$$*#es *s ,)s#%e!s *"$ #h*# %!'*".*#%" "ee$ #% se&&

#he! +%s#%"s *s 8e&& *s #he! %!'*".*#%" C%"se)e"#&4 he ,%"#e"$s #h*# %!'*".*#%"s

"ee$ #% 7e +!%*,#/e " se&&"' #he! %7 %+e""'s 7 #*&%!"' #he se&& #%8*!$ #he *++&,*"#

s+e,(, "ee$s O!'*".*#%"s #h*# /e8 *++&,*"#s *s ,)s#%e!s 8&& *&s% +&*" #he! se*!,h

+!%+e!&4 $e/%#e #he *++!%+!*#e #e %" #he +!%,ess4 )"$e!s#*"$ #he %7 *!e#4 ("$ %)#

*&& #he ,*" *7%)# #he *++&,*"#s4 )"$e!s#*"$ *"$ !es+%"$ #% #he *++&,*"#s ,%",e!"s %!

s'/"'s e*!&4 *ss)e #he *!e ,%+e#"' (%! e*,h *++&,*"# *"$ 7e +!e+*!e$ #% +!*se

#he %!'*".*#%" *"$ %)#&"e ()#)!e '%*&s *"$ %7e,#/es



As #he ")7e! %( )*&(e$ *++&,*"#s ,%"#")es #% $e,&"e4 s),,ess()&

%!'*".*#%"s *!e 7e'"""' #% )"$e!s#*"$ #he +%!#*"# !%&e #h*# *++&,*"#s h*/e " e"#!e

#he !e,!)#e"# +!%,ess Re'*!$&ess %( 8h,h *++!%*,h 'h# 8%! 7es#4 +!*,##%"e!s *"$

!ese*!,he!s *'!ee #h*# #he !e,!)#e"# +!%,ess "ee$s #% 7e 8e&& +&*""e$ *"$ %!'*".e$

Fe!"*"$e. *"$ A!*%. 1 s)''es#e$ #h*# # 8*s +!*,#,*7&e #% !%#*#e h!"' "#% *

S,e",e 7)# # 8*s (%)"$ #h*# *" %!'*".e$ *++!%*,h s'"(,*"#& +!%/es #he

+!%7*7&# %( h!"' #he !'h# +e!s%" He"e*"S%'&"$4 1? s#)$e$ #h*# ,%"ss#e"#

8#h *,#)*& !e,!)#"' +!*,#,es4 e*!& !e,!)#e"# s#)$es (%,)se$ %" %!'*".*#%"*&

+e!s+e,#/es "/es#'*#"' *,#/#es )"$e!#*e" #% ()!#he! #he *##*"e"# %( %!'*".*#%"*&'%*&s4 s),h *s s)!//*&4 +!%(#*7&#4 *"$ '!%8#h V*!%)s &#e!*#)!e !e/e8e$ 7 H*!!s

F" 1?4 U&!,h e# *&> 15 s)''es#e$ #h*# $)!"' #he (!s# h*&( %( #he ,e"#)!

!ese*!,he!s "/es#'*#"' +e!s%""e& se&e,#%" $$ s% (!% #he %!'*".*#%"*& +e!s+e,#/e

A!/ee# *&4 12 "%#e$ #h*# !ese*!,he!s h*/e $e+&e#e$ %!e #h*" 60 e*!s *##e+#"'

)"s),,ess()&& #% es#*7&sh #he !e&*7&# *"$ /*&$# %( #he se&e,#%" "#e!/e8

Rese*!,he!s see #% *'!ee #h*# e/e" #h%)'h #he "#e!/e8 s "%# * '%%$ +!e$,#%!

%( ()#)!e %7 +e!(%!*",e4 # s s#&& 8$e& )se$ #% $e"#( *"$ se&e,# *++&,*"#s As *

!e,!)#e"# #%%& #he "#e!/e8 ,*" 7e *" "/*&)*7&e #%%& (%! sh*!"' "(%!*#%" *7%)#

/*,*"# +%s#%"s *"$ #he %!'*".*#%" A,,%!$"' #% #he !ese*!,h &#e!*#)!e %" "#e!/e8s4

s%e s#!),#)!*& (*,#%!s 8&& *9.e #he s),,ess %( #he "#e!/e8 +!%,ess4 es+e,*&& *s

# !e&*#es #% !e,!)#"' C*+%"4 e# *&> 16 !e/e8e$ "e*!& 200 *!#,&es *"$ 7%%s #%

$e"#( * ")7e! %( s#!),#)!*& ,%+%"e"#s #h*# e"h*",e #he "#e!/e8 +!%,ess

(o) Per+or!ance



I" %!$e! #% $e"#( #he /#*& *s+e,#s %( * %7 *"$ 8h*# "%8&e$'e4 s&&s *"$

*7&#es :SA *!e *"$*#%! (%! #h!/"' %7 +e!(%!*",e4 J%7 *"*&ss e#h%$s *"$

%)#,%e %( %7 *"*&ss &e %7 s+e,(,*#%"s *"$ %7 $es,!+#%"s *!e #he %!'*".e$

+!%,e$)!es *"$ $%,)e"#s e9#e"s/e& )se$ " #he %!'*".*#%"s Vsse!e# *&4 1?

s#)$e$ " Ps,h%&%' &#e!*#)!e #h*# ,%!e ,%+e#e",es 8e!e ,h*!*,#e!s#,*&& )"%!'"*&

7 e*"s %( /*!%)s %7 *"*&ss e#h%$s J%7 +e!(%!*",e * 7e $e("e$ *s h%8

'&%8"' #he %7 s 7e"' ,%+&e#e$ *s +e! 8e&&-"%8" s#*"$*!$ %+e!*#"' +!%,e$)!es

M,C%""e&&4 200; $e("e$ %7 +e!(%!*",e *s *" *,,%+&she"# 8h,h ,%)&$ 7e

+!*'*#, *"$ e*s)!*7&e P%+%/,h 1 "*!!*#e$ J%7 +e!(%!*",e *s * ,%+&e9 +he"%e"%" *s $/e!se /*!*7&es *"+)&*#e %7 +e!(%!*",e S),h /*!*7&es ,%+!s"'

*'e s#)$e$ 7 =!'h# B%"e##4 20024 !e,%'"#%" %( *,he/ee"#s $s,)sse$ 7 C!%""

Be,he!e!4 1> F%!# V%&#e!%4 200@ *"$ %7 s*#s(*,#%" 7 M,C%""e&&4 200;> T.e"'4

200@ E*,h *"$ e/e! %"e %( #hese /*!*7&es 8%)&$ +%s#/e& +e!s)*$e e+&%ee %7

+e!(%!*",e

J)$'e Fe!!s4 1; ,%"s$e!e$ J%7 +e!(%!*",e *++!*s*& *s %"e %( #he %s#

+e!*#/e h)*" !es%)!,e HR +!*,#,es A&#h%)'h #he !e)!ee"# (%! se/e!*& /*!e#

%( +e!(%!*",e *++!*s*& PA ss#e 8*s (!e)e"#& *,"%8&e$'e$ 7)# #he !e*&s#,

8%!#h %( +e!(%!*",e *++!*s*&s 8*s %(#e" )es#%"e$ *s s#)$e$ 7 M,Ne!"e4 15>

M)!+h C&e/e&*"$4 15 7)# #hs 8*s (%)"$ s#e*$ 8#h %#he! *"*'ee"# +!*,#,es

M)!+h C&e/e&*"$4 15 $s,)sse$ #he +e!(%!*",e *++!*s*& +!%,e$)!e *s %"e %(

#he ()",#%" 8h,h 7e&e/e$ #% 7e * !e)!ee"# " #e!s %( *"' *$"s#!*#/e *"$

("*",*& $e,s%"s4 +!%/$"' &e'*& +!%#e,#%"s *"$ e/e" !e,)+e!*#"' %7 +e!(%!*",e



e$e,C*s,% 124 Be!"*!$" Be*## 1@> De-Ns4 C*((e!#4 Me'&"%

1@> :e&&*4 A!s#!%"' 1@4 DeNs4 B&e",%e4 C*((e!# 154 L%"'e"e,e!4

G%*4 Ss 1?> M)!+h4 B*&.e!4 M)!+h C&e/e&*"$ 15> $s,)sse$ #h*#

e*!&e! !ese*!,h s+e,(e$ #h*# #he $e/e&%+e"#*& *"$ e/*&)*#/e )se %( +e!(%!*",e

*++!*s*& 8e!e )"s)#e$ H)*" !es%)!,e +!%(ess%"*& H*!/e4 15> M,Ne!"e4 15

*$/se$ #% se+*!*#e #he %7 e/*&)*#%" (!% e+&%ee ,*!ee! '!%8#h4 e/e" +%!#e"#%)s #h*#

e+&%ees ,%)&$ "%# !e,e/e *,,)!*#e (ee$7*, *7%)# #he! s#!e"'#hs *"$ $e/e&%+e"#*&

"ee$s ( )se %( +e!(%!*",e *++!*s*& 8e!e *ss%,*#e$ Ths $/e!'e",e 8*s 8hs+e!e$ #%

#h8*!# #he +e!(%!*",e *++!*s*& +!%,e$)!e (!% *##*""' #s #*!'e#s *"$ '%*&s *"$ 8%!#h#% #he %!'*".*#%"

B%!*"M%#%8$&% 1; +!ese"#e$ * %$e& %( %7 +e!(%!*",e 8h,h

!e(&e,#e$ s),h 7eh*/%)!s #h*# 8e!e ",&)s/e %( %7 +e!(%!*",e s+he!e 4 ,&*ss(e$ *s

e#he! #*s %! !e&*#/e +e!(%!*",e C%&e*" B%!*"4 2000 s#)$e$ #h*# #*s

+e!(%!*",e 8*s #e!e$ *s 7eh*/%)!s #h*# ,%"#!7)#e$ " * s#!*'h# &"e #% #he

%!'*".*#%"s #e,h",*& ,%!e *"$ ",&)$e$ #h%se *,#%"s 8h,h 8e!e #+,*&& !e,%'".e$

*s * +*!# %( #he %7 B%!*"M%#%8$&%4 1; s#)$e$ #h*# *++!%+!*#e +e!(%!*",e

!e(e!!e$ #% #h%se 7eh*/%)!s #h*# *"#*"e$ #he e"%!%)s s%,*& e"/!%"e"# " 8h,h

#he #e,h",*& ,%!e )s# ()",#%" I# ",&)$e$ %!e )"!es#!,#e$ 7eh*/%)!s #h*# *sss#e$

#he %!'*".*#%"s #% ()",#%"

Pe!s%""e& se&e,#%" )s)*&& !e)!es #he $e"#(,*#%" %( #he h)*" *##!7)#es

!e)!e$ (%! %7 +e!(%!*",e *"$ #he s)7se)e"# *ssesse"# %( *++&,*"#s " #h%se #e!s

A" +%!#*"# ss)e " #hs +!%,ess s #he #!*"s&*#%" %( %7 $es,!+#%"s "#% #he *##!7)#es

!e)!e$ #% *##*" *++!%+!*#e &e/e&s %( +e!(%!*",e Ge"e!*&& #hs +!%,ess s ,%"$),#e$



"#)#/e& *"$4 *s G)%" 1?6 !e*!s4 s %"& 7*se$ %" s%e %!e %! &ess +&*)s7&e

!e&*#%"sh+ 7e#8ee" %7 $)#es *"$ h)*" *##!7)#es The ,h*&&e"'e %( es#*7&sh"' *

ss#e*#, #!*"s&*#%" 7e#8ee" $es,!+#%!s %( %7 *"$ h)*" *##!7)#es h*s !e,e"#&

!e,e/e$ ,%"s$e!*7&e *##e"#%"

T8% 7!%*$ *++!%*,hes %( %7 +e!(%!*",e h*/e 7ee" $e/e&%+e$ The (!s#

"/%&/e$ #he *7&# !e)!ee"#s *++!%*,h *"$ 8*s ,h*!*,#e!.e$ 7 #he 8%! %(

F&esh*" *"$ hs ,%&&e*')es F&esh*"4 16?> F&esh*" H%'*"4 1? A" *&#e!"*#/e

*++!%*,h ,%",e!""' %7 ,%+%"e"#s h*s &*!'e& 7ee" *ss%,*#e$ 8#h #he 8%! %(

M,C%!, *"$ hs ,%8%!e!s *# P)!$)e U"/e!s# M,C%!,4 154 16?4 1?@>

M,C%!, e# *&4 1? F&esh*"s *7&# !e)!ee"#s *++!%*,h $es,!7e$ %7s "

+!%/s%s %( #he *7&#es %7&'*#%! #% +e!(%! #he The *##!7)#es "/%&/e$ " * %7 *!e

*ssesse$ 7 )s"' * se# %( 7eh*/%)!*&& *",h%!e$ !*#"' s,*&es P!%(&es %( 7*s, *7&#es

8h,h *,,%)"# (%! %7 +e!(%!*",e ,*" #he!e(%!e 7e $e!/e$ F&esh*" H%'*"4 1?

s#)$e$ #h*# +e!(%!*",e %" #*ss 8#h s&*! *7&# !e)!ee"#s ,*" 7e +!e$,#e$ *"$

"$/$)*& +e!(%!*",e s ,%"se)e"#& +!e$,#*7&e %" #he 7*ss %( #he !e)s#e *7&#es

+%ssesse$

The +!%(ess%"*& HR &#e!*#)!e s ,)!!e"#& $e$,*#e$ #% e*s)!"'4 *"$ !e+%!#"'

)+%"4 #he )*"#(*7&e !e&*#%"sh+ 7e#8ee" *" %!'*".*#%"s h)*" !es%),e +!*,#,es

*"$ #s +e!(%!*",e4 !e(e!!e$ #% he",e(%!#h *s #he H)*" !es%)!,e - Pe!(%!*",e &"

:"'s&&4 " 200; s#)$e$ #h*# #he '%/e!"e"# 8*s *&s% "#e!es#e$ " #hs &" =!'h# e#

*&4 1 $s,)sse$ #he )es#%" %( h%8 HRM +%&,es *"$ +!*,#,es 8e!e &"e$ #%

%!'*".*#%"*& +e!(%!*",e 8h,h 8*s * s)7e,# %( e"se *##e"#%" #% 7%#h *,*$e,s

*"$ +!%(ess%"*&s H%8e/e!4 &""' h)*" !es%)!,e *"*'ee"# +!*,#,es 8#h



e+&%ee %7 +e!(%!*",e 8*s )"e9+&%!e$ *"$ !e)!e$ *" e"%!%)s ,%"s$e!*#%"

+!e$%"*"#& " #he +e!s+e,#/e %( +)7&, se,#%! %!'*".*#%"s C*s,%4 1> B%8" *"$

H*!/e4 2001 h*/e #*e" * s#e+ 7 e+h*s."' #he +%!#*",e %( %7 *"*&ss "%# %"& *s

* /#*& h)*" !es%)!,e +!*,#,e 7)# *&s% *s * s#!*#e', h)*" !es%)!,e *"*'ee"#

+!*,#,e h*/"' * ,%"#!7)#%" #% #he %!'*".*#%"*& +e!(%!*",e A"#h%" e# *&4 2002>

*"$ Dess&e!4 200; e9+&%!e$ #h*# 8#h #he '!%8"' $e"#(,*#%" %( #he h)*" !es%)!,e

+!*,#,e - +e!(%!*",e &"*'e4 # h*s 7ee" !e,%e"$e$ #h*# %!'*".*#%"s #h*#

/'%!%)s& (%&&%8 %7 *"*&ss *s * H)*" Res%)!,e P&*"""' HRP s#!*#e' 8e!e &e&

#% *,he/e ,%+e##/e &e*$ %" %#he!s

E*!&e! !ese*!,h 7 Bee! e# *&4 15> B*!"e4 114 P(e((e!4 1@> L*$% *"$

=&s%"4 1@4 Be,e! e# *&4 1?> Le"'",-H*&& MLe"'",-H*&& CA 1>

S*"$7e!'4 2000> " #he (e&$ %( h)*" !es%)!,e *"*'ee"# $e"#(e$ s%e "s#*"#

s%)"$ e((e,#s %( h)*" !es%)!,es +!*,#,es4 *,"%8&e$'e$ *s h)*" !es%)!,e

*"*'ee"# %)#,%es S),h h)*" !es%)!,e *"*'ee"# %)#,%es ",&)$e$

"%8&e$'e4 s&& *"$ *7&#es :SA %! ,%+e#e",e G*""' * &e*$ (!% #he ,%",e+# %(

#he se&( "s'h# 8h,h s #he ,%+e#e",e *"$ %7 "s'h#4 h)*" !es%)!,e +!*,#,es &e

%7 *"*&ss4 #*ss *"$ !es+%"s7&#es ,%",e+#)*& %$e&s *"$ e$*#e h)*" !es%)!,e

*"*'ee"# %)#,%es $e"#(e$ 7 e*!&e! !ese*!,he!s4 # 8*s +%ss7&e #% $e/e&%+ *"

"#e'!*#e$ HR +!*,#,e-%7 +e!(%!*",e %$e&

U"$e!+"""' ,&*s (!% #he +!%(ess%"*& HR ,%)"# *"$ '%/e!"e"#4

e+!,*& !ese*!,h +*+e!s #h*# h*/e *++e*!e$ %/e! #he &*s# $e,*$e4 ,&*"' #he!e 8*s *

)*"#(*7&e &" 7e#8ee" *" %!'*".*#%"s h)*" !es%),e +!*,#,es *"$ #s +e!(%!*",e

H%8e/e!4 #he!e 8*s * +!%7&e 8#h #hs *++!%*,h %( e+!,*& !ese*!,h %" #he HR-



Pe!(%!*",e &" #h*# 8*s )"$e!-#he%!.e$ S%e4 7)# 7 "% e*"s *&&4 %( #h%se "/%&/e$

" #hs !ese*!,h 8e!e *8*!e %( #he +!%7&e

(o) Sati$+action

O"e %( #he %s# )se$ !ese*!,h $e("#%" %( %7 s*#s(*,#%" 8*s "*!!*#e$ 7 L%,e

" 1?64 8h% $e("e$ # *s * +&e*s*"# %! %+#s#, *!%)s"' s#*#e ,%"se)e"#*& (!% #he

e/*&)*#%" %( %"es %7 %! %7 e9+e!e",es I"he!e"# " L%,es $e("#%" 8*s #he

s'"(,*",e %( 7%#h *((e,#s4 %! e%#%" *"$ ,%'"#%" %! #h%)'h#s =he"e/e! 8e *'"e4

8e h*/e 7e&e( *7%)# 8h*# 8e ,%"s$e! O" #he ,%"#!*!4 8he" 8e (ee&4 8e *ss)e *7%)#

8h*# 8e 7e&e/e C%'"#%" *"$ "(&)e",e *!e #h)s "e9#!,*7& !e&*#e$ " +s,h%&%' *"$

e/e" " 7%&%' Th)s4 8h&e e/*&)*#"' #he %7s %s# +%!#*"# (*,#%! 8*s 7%#h #h""'

*"$ (ee&"' "/%&/e$

F!e$ Fe!!s4 1?> P*!s =e"e!4 1> =e"e!4 2000 s#)$e$ #h*# (%!e%s#

%7 s*#s(*,#%" *!e* 8*s $e+e"$e"# %" #he "*#)!e %( #he %7 #se&(4 8h,h "#e'!*#e$ %7

,h*&&e"'es4 *)#%"%4 s&& /*!e# *"$ %7 s,%+e4 7es# +!e$,#e$ %/e!*&& %7 s*#s(*,#%"4

*"$ %#he! +%!#*"# %)#,%es &e e+&%ee !e#e"#%" Th)s4 #% ,%+!ehe"$ 8h*# *$e

+e%+&e #% 7e s*#s(e$ 8#h #he! %7s4 "*#)!e %( %7 #se&( 8*s %"e %( #he (!s# +&*,es (%!

!ese*!,he!s #% s+%#&'h#"' The!e 8*s *" ee!'"' "#e!es# *%"'s# #he h)*" !es%)!,e

!ese*!,he!s *"$ +!%(ess%"*&s #% ("$ * $e'!ee #% 8h,h e+&%ees 8e!e s*#s(e$ 8#h

#he! %7s4 *"$ %!e )s)*&& " ,%(%!# *# %7 M*!s4 2006 $s,)sse$ * +%s#/e &"*'e 7e#8ee" e+&%ees h*++"ess *"$ +!%$),#/# P!e/%)s&4 L**!$ " 2005 h*s s#)$e$

#hs "#e!es# " e+&%ee h*++"ess 8h,h !e(&e,#e$ " %#he! (e&$s4 es+e,*&& 8#h" #he

"e8 e,%"%,s %( h*++"ess &#e!*#)!e



I" %!$e! #% e9+&%!e #he *ss%,*#%" 7e#8ee" HR +!*,#,es *"$ %7 s*#s(*,#%"4

#he!e h*s 7ee" e9#e"s/e $e7*#e " #he &#e!*#)!e %/e! #he s%)"$ e((e,#s %( HR +!*,#,es %"

%7 s*#s(*,#%" G)es#4 2002 $e"#(e$ #h*# %7 s*#s(*,#%" *s * e /*!*7&e e$*#"'

%! "#e!/e""' *" +%s#/e &" 7e#8ee" h)*" !es%)!,es HR +!*,#,es *"$

%!'*".*#%"*& +e!(%!*",e G!ee"4 2006 s#)$e$ #h*# " $s+*!#4 !ese*!,he!s s)''es#e$

#h*# " U:4 #he +&ee"#*#%" %( h)*" !es%)!,es +!*,#,es h*s 7ee" !e&*#e$ 8#h h'he!

&e/e&s %( %7 "#e"s# !es)&#*"#& &%8e!e$ #he &e/e&s %( %7 s*#s(*,#%" A++e&7*)4

2002 "%#e$ #h*# h)*" !es%)!,e +!*,#,es *$%+#e$ *s +*!# %( * h'h-+e!(%!*",e 8%!

ss#e 8e!e "%# *"& +!ee$#*#e$ #% ",!e*se %7 s*#s(*,#%"4 " +!*,#,e4 #he 'h#%! 'h# "%# h*/e s),h e((e,# I# 'h# 7e #he ,*se #h*# h)*" !es%)!,e +!*,#,es +*,#

%" %7 s*#s(*,#%" s),h *s s*#s(*,#%" 8#h se"se %( *,he/ee"# %! s*#s(*,#%" 8#h

s*&*! He",e4 ()#)!e !ese*!,h s !e)!e$ #% *ssess #he *,#)*& e((e,#s %( h)*" !es%)!,e

+!*,#,es %" "$/$)*&s %7 s*#s(*,#%" *"$ %/e!*&& %7 s*#s(*,#%"

=h*# 'h# 7e #he e9+e,#e$ +*,# %( h)*" !es%)!,e +!*,#,es %" %7

s*#s(*,#%"< I# 'h# 7e e9+e,#e$ #h*# #hese +!*,#,es 8%)&$ h*/e *" *((!*#/e +*,#

%" (*s#$%)s *s+e,#s %( %7 s*#s(*,#%" C*!#8!'h# *"$ H%&es4 2006 +%"#e$ %)# #he

,!#,*& !%&e %( h)*" !es%)!,e +%&,es4 s),h *s +*!#,+*#%! %7 +!*,#,es4 %"

e+&%ees *7&# #% $e!/e * se"se %( e*""' (!% %7 *"$ #% *,he/e s*#s(*,#%" 8#h

%7 #se&( I( h)*" !es%)!,e +!*,#,es s),h *s #e* 8%!"'4 )+8*!$ ,%)",*#%"

ss#es *"$ +!%7&e-s%&/"' '!%)+s +!%/$e$ e+&%ees 8#h '!e*#e! *)#%"% *"$

'!e*#e! %++%!#)"#es #% ,%"#!7)#e #% $e,s%" *"'4 #he" #hs 'h# 7e e9+e,#e$ #%

h*/e * +%s#/e +*,# %" %#he! *s+e,#s %( %7 s*#s(*,#%"4 +*!#,)&*!& s*#s(*,#%" 8#h

"(&)e",e H%8e/e!4 M*!,h"'#%" *"$ =&"s%" 2005 *!')e$ #h*# #he $e'!ee %(



"(&)e",e +!%/$e$ 7 +*!#,+*#%! 8%! +!*,#,es )"$e! #he )7!e&&* %( h)*" !es%)!,e

*"*'ee"# 8*s %(#e" %/e!s#*#e$ *"$ #h*# #hese "#*#/es !es)&#e$ "s#e*$ " %7

"#e"s(,*#%" *"$ h'he! &e/e&s %( s#!ess

I# * *&s% 7e #he ,*se #h*# HRM +!*,#,es +*,# %" e9#!"s, *s+e,#s %( %7

s*#s(*,#%"4 ",&)$"' s*#s(*,#%" 8#h +* Pe"$&e#%" *"$ P%)#s*4 200@> M%!!s e# *&4

2006 $s,)sse$ #h*# ("*",*& +*!#,+*#%" s,hees4 " +*!#,)&*!4 h*/e #he +%#e"#*& #%

e#he! !e$),e %! ",!e*se "e)*&#es " +* S),h ,h*"'es 8&& " #)!" +*,# %" !e+%!#e$

&e/e&s %( s*#s(*,#%" 8#h +*4 '/e" #h*# #he s*#s(*,#%" #h*# "$/$)*& e+&%ee $e!/e

(!% ",%e $e+e"$s %" !e&*#/e ",%e !*#he! #h*" *7s%&)#e ",%e T)!""' #% #he

e/$e",e4 !ese*!,h %" #he +*,# %( h)*" !es%)!,e +!*,#,es %" %7 s*#s(*,#%" h*/e

+!ese"#e$ /*!e$ !es)&#s G!ee"4 2006 *!')e$ #h*# #he 8e&&-es#*7&she$ $e,&"e " %7

s*#s(*,#%" " B!#*" $)!"' #he 10s 8*s " +*!# *ss%,*#e$ 8#h #he +&ee"#*#%" %(

h)*" !es%)!,e +!*,#,es s),h *s "/%&/ee"# s,hees *"$ +e!(%!*",e !e&*#e$ +*

He",e4 #hese +!*,#,es 8e!e seee$ #% h*/e ,%"#!7)#e$ #% h'he! 8%! e((%!# %/e! #he

10s4 &e*$"' #% &%8e! s*#s(*,#%" 8#h %7

H)*" !es%)!,e +!*,#,es4 %( ,%)!se4 8e!e "%# #he %"& (*,#%!s "(&)e","' %7

s*#s(*,#%" J%7 e((%!#4 (%! e9*+&e4 ,%)&$ 7e see" *s %"e %#he! +%!#*"# (*,#%!4 he",e4

h'he! 8%! "#e"s# 'h# 7e e9+e,#e$ #% &%8e! !e+%!#e$ %7 s*#s(*,#%"4 %#he! #h"'s

7e"' e)*& G!ee"4 200@ (%)"$ #h*# h'he! 8%! e((%!# " B!#*"4 " ,%")",#%" 8#h

$e,!e*s"' #*s $s,!e#%"4 8*s * e (*,#%! 7eh"$ #he (*&& " !e+%!#e$ %7 s*#s(*,#%"

*%"' B!#sh 8%!e!s %/e! #he 10s I" *$$#%"4 %7 se,)!# h*s 7ee" /e8e$ *s *"

+%!#*"# "(&)e",e %" s*#s(*,#%" 8#h 8%!4 8#h h'he! %7 se,)!# +%s#/e& !e&*#e$

#% h'he! s*#s(*,#%" 8#h 8%!



(o) Sati$+action and (o) Per+or!ance Relation$hi-

The!e 8*s * ,%"#!%/e!s*& hs#%! #% ("$ &" 7e#8ee" %7 s*#s(*,#%" *"$ %7

+e!(%!*",e H*8#h%!"e s#)$e$ 8e!e *##!7)#e$ $)e #% *&e!#"' #he !ese*!,he!s %" #he

s%)"$ e((e,#s %( e+&%ee *###)$es %" %7 +e!(%!*",e $)!"' 1;0 The!e*(#e!4

!ese*!,he!s ,%e",e$ * ,!),*& &%% *# #he ,%",e+# #h*# * h*++ 8%!e! 8*s *

+!%$),#/e 8%!e! H%8e/e! e*!&e! !e/e8s %( #he &#e!*#)!e $e("e$ * 8e* *"$

s%e8h*# ",%+*#7&e !e&*#%"sh+ 7e#8ee" %7 s*#s(*,#%" *"$ +e!(%!*",e

Re/e8 %( #he &#e!*#)!e %( I*((*&$*"%M),h"s " 15 "%#,e$ #he s#*#s#,*&

,%!!e&*#%" 7e#8ee" %7 s*#s(*,#%" *"$ +e!(%!*",e 8*s /e! &ess *7%)# Th)s4 *)#h%!s

,%",&)$e$ #h*# #he +e!,e+#7&e !e&*#%"sh+ 7e#8ee" %7 s*#s(*,#%" *"$ +e!(%!*",e 8*s

* *"*'ee"# (*$ *"$ &&)s%! These s#)$es h*/e *" +%!#*"# +*,# %" !ese*!,he!s

*"$ s%e *"*'e!s *"$ HR +!*,##%"e!s 8h% ,%",&)$e$ #h*# #he !e&*#%"sh+ 7e#8ee"

%7 s*#s(*,#%" *"$ +e!(%!*",e 8*s "s'"(,*"# F)!#he! !ese*!,h $$ "%# *'!ee 8#h

#hs ,%",&)s%" O!'*" s)''es#e$ " 1 #h*# #he (*&)!e #% e9+&%!e * s'"(,*"# s#!%"'

!e&*#%"sh+ 7e#8ee" %7 s*#s(*,#%" *"$ +e!(%!*",e 8*s $)e #% #he s&'h# e*"s %(#e"

)se$ #% ,h*!*,#e!.e #he %7 +e!(%!*",e O!'*" ()!#he! *!')e$ #h*# 8he" +e!(%!*",e

8*s $e("e$ #% #*e *,,%)"# %( +%!#*"# 7eh*/%)!s8h,h 8e!e "%# !e(&e,#e$ "

+e!(%!*",e *++!*s*&s4 &e %!'*".*#%"*& ,#.e"sh+ 7eh*/%)!s4 #s &" 8#h %7

s*#s(*,#%" 8*s +!%/e$

A !e/e8 %( ;01 s#)$es 7 J)$'e4 Th%!ese"4 B%"%4 *"$ P*##%" " 2001 (%)"$ #h*#

8he" #he ,%!!e&*#%"s 8e!e +!%+e!& ,%!!e,# (%! s*+&"' *"$ e*s)!ee"# e!!%!s4 #he

*/e!*'e ,%!!e&*#%" 7e#8ee" %7 s*#s(*,#%" *"$ %7 +e!(%!*",e 8*s *s h'he! I"



*$$#%"4 #he 66 &" 7e#8ee" %7 s*#s(*,#%" *"$ %7 +e!(%!*",e 8*s (%)"$ #% 7e e/e"

h'he! (%! ,%+&e9 *"$ +!%(ess%"*& %7s Th)s4 $e/*#"' #% e*!&e! !e/e8s4 # *++e*!e$

#h*# %7 s*#s(*,#%" 8*s4 " (*,#4 +!e$,#/e %( %7 +e!(%!*",e *"$ #he &" 8*s e/e"

s#!%"'e! (%! +!%(ess%"*& %7s

B*'%.. 1?> B!%8" Pe#e!s%" 1; *&s% (%)"$ #h*# #he &" 7e#8ee" %7

+e!(%!*",e *"$ %7 s*#s(*,#%" 8*s 8e* As B!%8" Pe#e!s%" 1; "%#,e$ #h*# (

#he %)#,%e %( %7 +e!(%!*",e %" %7 s*#s(*,#%" 8*s "s'"(,*"#4 %!'*".*#%"*&

*,#/#es +&*""e$ #% e"h*",e #he %7 +e!(%!*",e sh%)&$ "%# h*/e * $!e,# e((e,# %" %7

s*#s(*,#%" *"$ !e&*#e$ %)#,%es &e e+&%ee #)!"%/e! O" ,%"#!*!4 #he!e 8*s

,%"se"s)s #h*# *" *"#e,e$e"#s %( %7 s*#s(*,#%" *"$ %7 +e!(%!*",e 8e!e ,%%"

e'4 e"$e*/%)!4 !e8*!$4 )*&# %( s)+e!/s%"4 s+&,# %( %7 !es+%"s7&#es

=*&e!4 Ch)!,h&& F%!$4 1??4 Beh!*" Pe!!e*)&#4 1@> L)s,hSe!+e",4

10> *$e *" *##e+# #% ,%"s$e! * +*!# %( %7 +e!(%!*",e $e("e$ 'e"e!*&& *s *

,%&&e,#/e *sse7&e %( e((%!#s4 s&&s *"$ %)#,%es #h%se 8e!e +%!#*"# #% #he e+&%ee

*"$ #he! %)#,%es #h*# 8e!e /e! +%!#*"# (%! #he %!'*".*#%" Re&*#e$ 8%! %(

B*'%.. " 1?4 * (e8 s#)$es )se$ * ,%"s#!,#e$ $e("#%" %( %7 +e!(%!*",e 7*se$ %"

*,#)*& %)#+)# e*s)!es H%8e/e!4 #hese s#)$es $$ "%# ",&)$e +hs,*& e9e!#%" *"$

e((%!#s *s * $e#*,he$ ,%"s#!),# The *!')e$ #h*# # 8*s +e!*#/e #% $e("e e((%!# *s

$((e!e"# (!% #he %7 +e!(%!*",e As +e! +%"# %( /e8 %( *" e+&%ee4 %7

+e!(%!*",e *"$ e((%!# 8e!e $ss&*! E((%!# 8*s *" "+)# #% 8%! *"$ %7 +e!(%!*",e

8*s *" %)#+)# (!% #hs e((%!#



(o) Retention

Be*$&es e# *& 2000 (%)"$ * +%s#/e *"$ s'"(,*"# ,%!!e&*#%" 7e#8ee" %7

!e#e"#%" *"$ %!'*".*#%"*& +e!(%!*",e C*+%" 11 (%)"$ #h*# "es,*+*7&e

#)!"%/e! 8*s ,h*!*,#e!s#,*&& /e8e$ *s ,!#,*& #% *" %!'*".*#%" The "%#%" #h*#

#)!"%/e! $e,!e*ses %!'*".*#%"*& +e!(%!*",e 8*s s)++%!#e$ 7 #he %s# %( #he

!ese*!,he!s M%7&e 12 s)''es#e$ #h*# #)!"%/e! 'h# "#e!!)+# %7 +e!(%!*",e

8he" *" e+&%ee 8h% "#e"$e$ #% &e*/e 7e,*e &ess e((,e"# *"$ e((e,#/e Sh*84

G)+#*4 De&e!4 2002 (%)"$ e+!,*&& #h*# /%&)"#*! #)!"%/e! 8*s *ss%,*#e$ 8#h #he

"(e!%! %!'*".*#%"*& +e!(%!*",e O#he! !ese*!,he!s s)''es#e$ #h*# #)!"%/e! ,%)&$

+!%/e +e!(%!*",e O"e +!%7*7&e *$/*"#*'e %( #)!"%/e! 8*s #he e9,&)s%" %( +%%!

+e!(%!"' e+&%ees P!,e4 1 F)!#he!%!e4 S#*8 e# *&> 16 +!%+%se$ #h*#

#)!"%/e! 'h# e"h*",e +e!(%!*",e ( %s# %( #he #)!"%/e! 8*s 7 e+&%ees 8#h

&%"'e! %! /e! sh%!# #e")!e

Re')&*! %! +e!*"e"# e+&%ees 8e!e "/es#'*#e$ " #he %s# %( #he &#e!*#)!e %"

%7 !e#e"#%" C*)ses4 e((e,#s *"$ !es)&#s %( #)!"%/e! 8e!e *$$!esse$ " #he *%!# %( #he

s#)$es E+&%ees #)!"%/e! h*s 7ee" $e("e$ *s #he #%#*& ")7e! %( e+&%ees h!e$

$)!"' s9 %"#hs #% !e+&*,e #h%se 8e!e $!%++e$ (!% #he 8%!(%!,e E+&%ee

!e#e"#%" 8*s *&s% $e("e$ *s #he #e"$e", #% ee+ $*& 8*'e! e+&%ees " se!/,e *# *

#e+%!*! h%)s"' (*,&# 7e%"$ * %"e e*! +e!%$ Se/e!*& s#)$es 7 B%&es4 R%ss4

J%h"s%"4 15 *"$ M*,H*##%" V*" De4 S#e"e!4 1? (%)"$ #h*# #)!"%/e! !*#e 8*s

(%)"$ !e&*#e$ 8#h e+&%ees +e!s%"*& ,h*!*,#e!s#,s *"$ $e%'!*+h, 4 7 *"$ &*!'e

%7 s*#s(*,#%"4 8%! e"/!%"e"#4 %#/*#%"4 e9#e!"*& e"/!%"e"#4 *7se"#ees *"$

%7 +e!(%!*",e



De! *"$ Sh*8 1 s#)$e$ #he *ss%,*#%" 7e#8ee" e+&%ee #)!"%/e! *"$

%!'*".*#%"*& ,)&#)!e *"$ :**4 Fe&$4 G&es4 *"$ N%!!s " 1? e9+&%!e$ #he ,%",e+# %(

#)!"%/e! ,)&#)!e *%"'s# &%8e! s#*(( S%e s#)$es 7 P.* E&&s4 1

!e,%e"$e$ !e#e"#%" +!%'!*s #h*# ,%)&$ $"sh #)!"%/e! *"$ #s ,*)se *"$ e((e,#s

Re*&s#, %7 +!e/e8s4 %7 e"!,he"#4 s%,*&.*#%" +!*,#,es 8e!e ",&)$e$ B%&es e# *&

15 s#)$e$ #% *e )se %( #he +!e-e+&%e"# *++&,*#%" $e%'!*+h,s #% !e$),e

e+&%ee #)!"%/e! H*+#%"4 2000> Sh*"*h*"4 2000> S,h!e7e!4 2000> B*)*""4 2000

s#)$e$ #h*# #he &#e!*#)!e 8*s *&s% e!se$ 8#h !e,%e"$*#%"s #% )"$e!#*e

#)!"%/e! *"$ !e$),e !e#e"#%"

I# 8*s +%!#*"# #% e"#%" #h*# %s# %( #he s#)$es "%#,e$ #he *"*'ee"#

!e#e"#%" %( !e')&*! e+&%ees *"$ "e'&e,#e$ ,%"#!*,#)*& *"$ #e+%!*! s#*(( I" #he!

e((%!# #% ("$ *"$ ee+ h%&$ %( e+&%ees4 *" %!'*".*#%"s )se$ ",e"#/es s),h *s

",!e*se " +*4 7e"e(#s4 +!%%#%"s *"$ #!*""'s &%,*&& *"$ *7!%*$ B),"'h*

C%((*"4 1 s#)$e$ #he e((%!#s %(#e" sse$ #he '%*&4 *s s%e !ese*!,h "$,*#e$ #h*#

#he #%+ *"*'ee"# $e,s%"s 8e!e /#*& #% *##!*,# *"$ !e#*" #he e+&%ees

P!,e4 1 *"$ A77*sH%&&*"4 2000 $s,)sse$ #h*# #)!"%/e! 8*s *"

+%!#)"*#e $&e* " #he %!'*".*#%"s A77*sH%&&*"4 2000> Be*$&es4 L%8e!4

Pe##4 E.e&&4 2000 "%#,e$ #hs " e/e! #+e *"$ s.e %( %!'*".*#%" *"$ *# e/e!

%!'*".*#%"*& &e/e& A77*s *"$ H%&&*" 2000 s#*#e$ #h*# #)!"%/e! 8*s %"e %( #he

%s# s'"(,*"# ,*)ses %( $e,&""' +!%$),#/# *"$ s&)+e$ %!*&e " 7%#h #he +)7&,

*"$ +!/*#e se,#%!s T)!"%/e! 8*s *&s% /e! e9+e"s/e (%! #he %!'*".*#%"s I# 8*s

es#*#e$ " * s#)$ 7 A77*sH%&&*" " 2000 #h*# Ae!,*" "$)s#!es ",)!!e$ Q11

7&&%" *"")*&& *s * !es)&# %( /%&)"#*! *"$ "/%&)"#*! #)!"%/e! Ths ,%s# 8*s $)e #%



#e!"*#%"4 *$/e!#s"'4 !e,!)#e"#4 se&e,#%" *"$ h!"' T)!"%/e! *&s% +!%$),e$

e#he!e*& ,%s#s4 s),h *s $e,&""' %!*&e4 *"$ #he "#e!!)+#%" %( s%,*& *"$

,%)",*#%" +*##e!"s *s "%#,e$ 7 M%7&e4 " 12 Be*$&es e# *&4 2000 s#!esse$ #he

s#)$ %( #)!"%/e! *s * 8e&&-!ese*!,he$ *!e* 8h,h 8*s %"e %( #he *%! "#e!es#s "

%!'*".*#%"*& 7eh*/%!

(o) retention and (o) Sati$+action relation$hi-

C%he" 1;> H% *"$ G!((e#h 15 *"$ A&&e"4 Sh%!e G!((e#h 200; $s,)sse$

#he e/$e",es (!% #he%!e#,*& *s 8e&& *s e+!,*& s#)$es 8h,h "$,*#e$ #h*# #)!"%/e!

"#e"#%"s !e+!ese"#e$ * !e&*7&e "$,*#%! %( *,#)*& /%&)"#*! #)!"%/e! *"$ 8e!e he*/&

"(&)e",e$ 7 %7 s*#s(*,#%" F%! "s#*",e4 H% *"$ G!((e#h 15 "%#e$ #h*#

e+&%ees $e,$e$ #% &e*/e #he! %!'*".*#%" 8he" #he 7e,%e $ss*#s(e$ 8#h #he!

J%7s Le8se4 Mee! *"$ He!s,h%/#,h 2001 *!')e$ #h*# 8he" e+&%ees 8e!e

$ss*#s(e$ 8#h #he! %7s4 #he! $es!e #% !e*" " #he! %!'*".*#%" s#*!#e$ #% e!%$e I"

(*,#4 "#*& ,%"se)e",es %( #hese "e'*#/e e((e,#s4 " #he (%! %( &%8 %7 s*#s(*,#%"

8e!e #)!"%/e! ,%'"#%"s

Rese*!,h 7 A&&e" *"$ G!((e#h 20014 A&&e" e# *& 200;4 *"$ Ch) *"$

F!*",es,% 200; $es,!7e$ #h*# %7 s*#s(*,#%" 8*s * s#!%"' +!e$,#%! %( #)!"%/e!

"#e"#%"s E&*"'%/*"s 2001 e9#e"s/e !ese*!,h !e(&e,#e$ #h*# %7 s*#s(*,#%" +!e$,#s

7%#h #)!"%/e! "#e"#%"s *"$ ,%#e"# *"$ " !e#)!" ,%#e"# +!e$,#s %"&#)!"%/e! "#e"#%"s I# 8*s e"&'h#e""' #% "%#e #h*#4 *,,%!$"' #% J*!%s e# *& 1; *"$

=*s# 200;4 %!'*".*#%"*& ,%#e"# $e+,#e$ #he s#!%"'es# "e'*#/e !e&*#%"sh+

8#h #)!"%/e! "#e"#%"s V*" B!e)e&e"4 V*" $e! V&s#4 *"$ S#ee"s*200@ 4 A77%##4



=h#e4 *"$ Ch*!&es 2005> s)''es#e$ #h!%)'h e9#e"s/e !e/e8 %( &#e!*#)!e #h*#

%!'*".*#%"*& #e")!e "(&)e",e$ %7 *###)$es *"$ #)!"%/e! "#e"#%"s F%! "s#*",e4 S#ee!s

1?? s#!%"'& *!')e$ #h*# #e")!e 8*s #he s"'&e 7es# +!e$,#%! %( #)!"%/e! 7e,*)se #

!e+!ese"#e$ *" e+&%ees +*s# 7eh*/%! *"$ s)*!.e$ hs %! he! !e&*#%"sh+ 8#h #he

%!'*".*#%" The *##!*,#%" se&e,#%" *##!#%" h+%#hess +!ese"#e$ 7 S,h"e$e! *"$

Re,he!s4 1; s)''es#e$ #h*# e+&%ees 8e!e *##!*,#e$ *"$ se&e,#e$ 7 %!'*".*#%"s

#h*# s*#s(e$ #he! "ee$s *"$ $es!es *"$ &%"' #e! *"$ sh%!# #e! '%*&s I" s),h ,*ses

8he!e #he!e 8*s * '%%$ (#4 # 8*s e9+e,#e$ &%8 &e/e&s %( *##!#%" *"$ &%"'e! #e")!e I"

,*ses %( s*#,hes4 h%8e/e!4 # sh%)&$ 7e e9+e,#e$ #h*# h'h *##!#%" !*#es *"$ sh%!#e! #e")!e +!%/$e$ #h*# %#he! %7 %++%!#)"#es 8e!e !e*$& */*&*7&e Th)s4 #e")!e 8*s

e9+e,#e$ #% ,%!!e&*#e 8#h ,&*#e +e!,e+#%"s4 %7 s*#s(*,#%"4 %!'*".*#%"*&

,%#e"# *"$ #)!"%/e! "#e"#%"s



CHAPTER III

RESEARCH METHODOLOG.

Ths ,h*+#e! $es,!7es #he Rese*!,h Me#h%$%&%' 8h,h ,%+%se$ %( !ese*!,h

e#h%$ )se$4 +%+)&*#%" (!*e *"$ s*+&"' s,hee4 $es,!+#%" %( #he !es+%"$e"#s4

"s#!)e"#*#%"4 $*#* '*#he!"' +!%,e$)!e *"$ s#*#s#,*& #!e*#e"# %( $*#*

Re$earch Method U$e

The !ese*!,he!s )se$ Des,!+#/e Me#h%$ Rese*!,h *"$ C%!!e&*#%"*& Des'" "

%!$e! #% "%8 #he !e&*#%"sh+ %( %7 *"*&ss $e(""' e((e,#/e +e!(%!*",e %( #he

e+&%ees " PJ Lh)&&e!

Des,!+#/e Me#h%$ Rese*!,h %7#*"s "(%!*#%" ,%",e!""' #he ,)!!e"# s#*#)s %(

+he"%e"* #% $es,!7e 8h*# e9s#s 8#h !es+e,# #% /*!*7&es %! ,%"$#%" " * s#)*#%"

A $es,!+#/e ,*se s#)$ s %"e #h*# (%,)se$ *"$ $e#*&e$4 " 8h,h +!%+%s#%"s *"$

)es#%"s *7%)# +he"%e"%" *!e ,*!e()&& s,!)#".e$ *"$ *!#,)&*#e$ *# #he %)#se# Ths

*!#,)&*#%" %( 8h*# s *&!e*$ "%8" *7%)# #he +he"%e"%" s ,*&&e$ * $es,!+#/e

#he%! I# he&+s #% s+e,( #he 7%)"$*!es %( #he ,*se4 *"$ # ,%"#!7)#es s'"(,*"#& #% #he

!'%! %( #he ("she$ ,*se s#)$ M&&s 2010

A,,%!$"' #% D! J*"e# =*#e!s4 C%!!e&*#%"*& s#)$ s * )*"##*#/e e#h%$ %(

!ese*!,h " 8h,h %) h*/e 2 %! %!e )*"##*#/e /*!*7&es (!% #he s*e '!%)+ %(

s)7e,#s4 %) *!e #!"' #% $e#e!"e ( #he!e s * !e&*#%"sh+ %! ,%-/*!*#%" 7e#8ee"

#he 2 /*!*7&es * s&*!# 7e#8ee" #he4 "%# * $((e!e",e 7e#8ee" #he! e*"s

The%!e#,*&&4 *" 2 )*"##*#/e /*!*7&es ,*" 7e ,%!!e&*#e$ *s &%"' *s %) h*/e s,%!es %"

#hese /*!*7&es (!% #he s*e +*!#,+*"#s> h%8e/e!4 # s +!%7*7& * 8*s#e %( #e #%



,%&&e,# *"*&.e $*#* 8he" #he!e s &##&e !e*s%" #% #h" #hese #8% /*!*7&es 8%)&$ 7e

!e&*#e$ #% e*,h %#he!

Po-ulation ra!e and Sa!-lin%

The e+&%ee *"$ e+&%e! !es+%"$e"#s ",&)$e$ #% #hs s#)$ 8e!e #*e" (!%

#he ,%+*" %( PJ Lh)&&e! The 8e!e se&e,#e$ )s"' #he +)!+%s/e s*+&"' #e,h")e

P)!+%s/e s*+&"' #e,h")e s * #+e %( "%"-+!%7*7&# s*+&"' 8he!e #he !ese*!,he!

,%"s,%)s& se&e,#s +*!#,)&*! e&ee"#s %! s)7e,#s (%! *$$#%" " * s#)$ s% *s #% *e

s)!e #h*# #he e&ee"#s 8&& h*/e ,e!#*" ,h*!*,#e!s#,s +e!#"e"# #% #he s#)$ I# "%!*&&

#*!'e#s * +*!#,)&*! '!%)+ %( +e%+&e

I" *$$#%" #% #h*#4 *,,%!$"' #% P*)& O&/e! 20064 +)!+%s/e s*+&"' s * (%!

%( "%"-+!%7*7&# s*+&"' " 8h,h $e,s%"s ,%",e!""' #he "$/$)*&s #% 7e ",&)$e$

" #he s*+&e *!e #*e" 7 #he !ese*!,he!4 7*se$ )+%" * /*!e# %( ,!#e!* 8h,h *

",&)$e s+e,*&s# "%8&e$'e %( #he !ese*!,h ss)e4 %! ,*+*,# *"$ 8&&"'"ess #%

+*!#,+*#e " #he !ese*!,h

De$cri-tion o+ the Re$-ondent$

The !es+%"$e"#s %( #he s#)$ "/%&/e$ #he e+&%ees *"$ e+&%e! %( PJ

Lh)&&e!4 M**# C# $)!"' #he Sees#e! SY 2015-2016 8h,h #%#*&e$ #% 120

!es+%"$e"#s The !es+%"$e"#s %( #hs s#)$ *!e $es,!7e$ *,,%!$"' #% #he! Ge"$e!4 A'e4

C/& s#*#)s4 E$),*#%"*& A##*"e"#4 *"$ Le"'#h %( Se!/,e

6alidation o+ In$tru!ent$

The s)!/e )es#%""*!e s #he *" '*#he!"' "s#!)e"# )se$ 7 #he !ese*!,he!s

" #hs s#)$ I# s * +!e-8!##e" se!es %( )es#%"s )se$ " '*#he!"' +%!#*"#



"(%!*#%" (!% %"e %! %!e +e!s%" The )es#%""*!e #!es #% "%8 #he J%7 A"*&ss

De(""' E((e,#/e Pe!(%!*",e %( #he E+&%ees %( P Lh)&&e! I",%!+%!*#e$ SY 2015-

2016 The !ese*!,he!s 8&& ,%"s)&# s%e %( #he "%8&e$'e*7&e +e!s%" *"$ #es# e9+e!#s

(%! #he ,%"s#!),#%" *"$ /*&$*#%" %( #he ,%"ss#e", %( #he )es#%""*!es The

)es#%""*!e 8&& 7e /e!(e$ 7 #he #hess *$/se!4 P!%( A!/e C*s*s

Data Gatherin% Procedure

The +e!ss%" #% ,%"$),# #he s#)$ 8&& 7e s%)'h# (!% #he C%&&e'e %( B)s"ess

*"$ E"#!e+!e"e)!*& Te,h"%&%' #% '*#he! #he "ee$e$ $*#* (!% #he !es+%"$e"#s I"

*$$#%"4 #he !ese*!,he!s 8&& s%&,# #he ()&& s)++%!# *"$ ,%%+e!*#%" %( #he #hess *$/se!

*"$ +!%(ess%!

The !ese*!,he!s 8&& +e!s%"*&& *$"s#e!e$ #he "s#!)e"# *"$ +!%+e!& ')$e$

#he !es+%"$e"#s #% (%&&%8 "s#!),#%"s A(#e! #he #es 8e!e *&& *,,%+&she$4 #he

)es#%""*!es 8&& 7e !e#!e/e$ *"$ ,%&&e,#e$ The *"s8e!e$ )es#%""*!es *!e *"*&.e$

)s"' s#*#s#,*& #!e*#e"#s

Stati$tical Treat!ent$ o+ Data

The !ese*!,he!s )se$ #he (%&&%8"' s#*#s#,*&-#%%&s " #hs s#)$ #% *"s8e! #he

+!%7&es %( #he s#)$

The )se$ F!e)e", *"$ Pe!,e"#*'e4 =e'h#e$ e*"4 *"$ Pe*!s%"s ! P!%$),#

M%e"# C%!!e&*#%" C%e((,e"#



T% $e#e!"e #he !es+%"$e"#s +!%(&e " #e!s " 'e"$e!4 *'e4 ,/& s#*#)s4

e$),*#%"*& *##*"e"#4 *"$ &(e s#*#)s #he e#h%$ )se$ 8*s re8uenc* and Percenta%e

De& R%s*!%42005

f

9 : 4 &00

N

=he!e3

Pe!,e"# %( #he !es+%"$e"# #% #he +*!#,)&*! /*!*7&es

( F!e)e", %( #he !es+%"$e"# #% #he +*!#,)&*! /*!*7&es

100 C%"s#*"#

N N)7e! %( !es+%"$e"#s

T% $e#e!"e #he 5ei%hted Mean3

´ X =∑ fx

N

=he!e3

K8 8e'h#e$ e*"

K G!*"$ T%#*&

( F!e)e", %( e*,h ,!#e!*

N s)*#%" %( (!e)e",



Pear$on;$ r Product Mo!ent Correlation Coe++icient

! "99 "9292WX"22W

=he!e3

K s,%!e %7#*" " #he (!s# '!%)+

Y s,%!e %7#*" " #he se,%"$ '!%)+

KY +!%$),# %( K *"$ Y

" #%#*& %( +*!s

! ,%!!e&*#%" ,%e((,e"#

Me*s)!e %( #he !e&*#%" 7e#8ee" #8% %! %!e /*!*7&es s ,*&&e$ *s ,%!!e&*#%"

C%!!e&*#%" ,%e((,e"#s * !*"'e (!% "e'*#/e 100 #% +%s#/e 100 The "e'*#/e

/*&)e !e+!ese"#s * "e'*#/e ,%!!e&*#%" 8h&e * +%s#/e /*&)e !e+!ese"#s * +e!(e,# +%s#/e

,%!!e&*#%" A /*&)e %( .e!% !e+!ese"#s * &*, %( ,%!!e&*#%"

Pe*!s%" ! s #he %s# 8$e& )se$ "$ %( ,%!!e&*#%" ,%e((,e"# 8h,h *&s% ,*&&e$

&"e*! ,%!!e&*#%" Pe*!s%" ,%!!e&*#%" *ss)es #h*# #8% /*!*7&es *!e ,*&,)&*#e$ %" *#

&e*s# "#e!/*& s,*&es *"$ # $e#e!"es #he $e'!ee #% 8h,h /*&)es %( #he #8% /*!*7&es *!e

+!%+%!#%"*& #% e*,h %#he!



URL

• h##+s3888,*+&*"%),*+s,h%&%'s#)$e"#-!es%)!,es!ese*!,h-

')$e&"esC%!!e&*#%"*&-Rese*!,h-G)$e&"es• h##+3e$*es%s'%$*'es@;55?6S+$( • h##+s3e"8+e$*%!'8J%7Z*"*&ss[Me#h%$s • h##+s3e"8+e$*%!'8I"$)s#!*&Z*"$Z%!'*".*#%"*&Z+s,h%&%'[,#eZ"%#

e-,*+7e&&10-@ •

https://www.capilanou.ca/psychology/student-resources/research-guidelines/Correlational-Research-Guidelines/


http://media.kemsos.go.id/images/435576S.pdf

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Job_analysis#Methods

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Industrial_and_organizational_psychology#cite_note-campbell1990-94





http://media.kemsos.go.id/images/435576S.pdf

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Job_analysis#Methods



Job analysis defining effective performance of the employees of PJ Lhuillier

Documents