~JL~M9~MI~1~P~R~~~LCU~I9C~99R~P~P~ .. …

onr snw? ~~~gu~yo(uu~z~pr~;~~mer~yh~)zrpr~u P

~JL~M9~MI~1~P~R~~~LCU~I9C~99R~P~P~ ?l)rLpbl2L .. .. ..

n-~i~~a"~w'uir a ~ i i ~ n ~ u i u ~ : : ~ i i ~ d a : : ~ n n ~ u n ~ ~ u i u n i u ' I w dn?iurfiunidnqa~d~a~b~~fiu~~nodw qag

1. n q ~ f dualisme ~ & % J ~ ~ s R ' ~ ~ A Y u ~ @ ~ u Triepel, Helbom,

2. Y ' l q ~ l Monisme bbddbd~ 2 W?fl

1Anziletti. Cours de droit international public T.l

traduction Gilberl Gidd Paris sirey 1929 p.51

wanusn 'lo~ingamrmia~uddi~ad~n~~n~auisata~~~dat- ~ ~ d J L ~ u ~ ? l u L f i ~ V ~ J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l W ~ f Ldu lellinek, Wentzel. Akzin bll

LdI.4 Duguit, Scell, Verdross LLWf Kunz

! ~ n f f ~ r m h ~ d ~ z ~ n ~ ~ f l u f l ? o d ~ ~ u i n m s d u o ~ u 4 i n g ~ u i u ~z~k&nn~ijqmh~~don41ng~mumu'Iu ~crQnn.finpmu5qmqy

, ? I E . I ~ I$u dw# Alabama 3 ~ M h J ~ M ~ f i ~ i n o y y i k q m n - n ' A L ~ G ? ~ ~ 6 ~ a B u 4 1 k n c ( a o r f i o ~ d ~ ~ ~ 1 1 u o ~ a d a z ~ w ~ a z ~ ~ i ~ d a z ~ ~ ~

~ d u ? f i u ~ f l i d ~ o J f ~ ~ ~ u n n i ~ d ~ d j n ~ a s n ~ u u n z a n n ~ ~ q 7 ~ ~ 3 f l ~ q i ~ S J L n.R. 1871 G l d a m ~ u ~ ~ n ~ i i n.R. 1903 lCiWormuflmua41 o y q l i l n ~ ~ i n i ~ S h o ~ l i a f t u a ~ ~ n g ~ u i u a z ~ 4 i ~ d a z ~ n ~ I a u l d A ~ f l ~ ~ i i ~ ~ n i ~ M a f i ~ n g ~ u i u m u l u lun# AroaMines h z ~ i u o ~ ~ i I a q m n n n d 1 7 . J 1 lun~tiifafiu~~~4~~ng~uiuaz~4i~dat~n~1~ung~,uiuniu~u~o~uoarQu ~ E h n n ~ n g v m m z ~ k ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ i ~ o ~ q i l a q m n n ~ ~ c ~ n l u & r n ~ e de navigation de I' erlnoque fl~(lb~IdEl 25 ?6nfiU 1910 ~ ~ H ' ~ J R H ~ ~ ~ L I

I? wqbn R hun.;lunff Compagnie de navigation ~orv&ienne li(l8~bd~

13 (IRWJ 1922 ~ z M ~ I J R M ~ ~ ~ ~ u o ~ L ? ~ ~ ~ z y j i n i ~ o z J 7 n g v ~ i u n i u ~ u ~ l ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ ~ f i d ~ b b ~ n ~ ~ ~ l ~ n i ~ ~ ~ !ribafiungnuiosz~4i~d3z~nm

o v w ~ a 9 ~ n ~ ~ ~ f i f f f l ~ l Y 1 3 f M ~ J ~ ~ M Q ~ K ~ K ~ ~ ~ A I ! $ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M L ~ 24 mngifiu 1930 11.Tfi~iu$u41 t f r r i r n o ~ i ~ n g ~ m u n i u ' I u ~ A o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ f i ~ i ~ u ~ a a o u

r i a . f j d i ~ d . r z ~ n ~ ~ u n ~ ~ ~ i r i o ~ J i ~ F i a ~ ? i u ~ # u ~ i n u ~ a r r ~ q a i h ~ i ~ d a z ~ n ~ ~

RicoJ~zS7qhIY3~ Y ~ ~ H ~ I J ~ ~ ~ L ~ B I ~ ~ L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ W I ~ ~ ~ H ~ I J I ~ L ~ ~ ~ -

u n d f i u ~ h ~ ~ n ~ t o ~ u d 6 $~?l f iu I930 lunn Zones ;ranches UAYRJ

ufidi ~ ~ J I R R ' L ~ ~ i u i 3 n o z ~ i ~ n g ~ u i u n i n 1 u ~ o ~ ~ 1 u ~ ~ o n u &id#oY nflu ~ z ~ 4 1 ~ d . r z ~ n ~ ng~~ iun iu~u~r in iurrnnu 6 i ~ n g ~ u ' 1 u a z ~ 4 1 ~ n l ~ z ~ n ~ 7 &

a A w u o n a i n ~ u ~ i ~ h m u r z ~ 4 1 d a z ~ n ~ 1 l a u u u u ~ f i n n n $ i ~ n i i lu1on-w ~ ~ 1 3 m l n f f ~tcheries bd~?Ud 18 $U?IRU 1951 L L ~ h f l l ~ l n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ J

11st~nmii.s q fi~~!6~nu4oislu1nl~uso~um1u~nanniiun~npnu1u / -- ,'

stnii~rhz~1~donpnuiuaiuIu du ~i~c/~~;nuo~~na';!&~nufiwinw~ . -'

l u n l Frank COOL ~ 6 n ~ u d 23 unsinu 1933 f i !CiYi~inwid~~ulIggi

CIW a~0unpcluiuuo~dst~n~ fld-ILM Zleunpnuiumu q n r l u ~ i ~ u n ~

aria'; ~~5~zqnirUnpcl uiuu~~~uaf;fimiu I

uon~inrfuazfi~is~inaiu'b~u~6u~dnnua'uiinpnuiuaz~ii~ ! dst~n~f lqmdi~nf lonhnpn uiunis~u!6~inf;asauyg91n ddst ,

unidiuiocii.s 7 idu ~ ; a s s u y ~ u e ~ ~ & . m n . ~ . I 958 13qyj-ii RUP .

c ~ q y i c l i o ~ a n a d d ~ ~ ~ u n i s ~ ~ ~ a u i s ~ ' ~ n i no y . ~ i ~ 6 a i ~ q n r r i i ~ n ~ o n i 1 r

npnuiuludst~nn 6du&ufi!6dazrnn f;~nuyy~uosrhtatTuan n.R.

1949 fpissuyq6mf n.R. I 947 ~ l i s s u y y n n ~ ~ a ~ u n . ~ . 1920 ~61::

~B~~UUIIIRLLJU y u n . ~ . 1931 ' f i ! ~ ~ ~ ~ q o n a i u d f i ~ n w m t ~ d u ~ ~ o a f u d n~nsth(imul6~nufldiifiwinr~uo~mastnii~dsrinR~&ntiu1u

rn~srr~fiu+iu Insun uTui~np~uiumu~ufldi~~flnn-iinp~u~ust~ii~

LhtRlR L h fld Van Bokkenlen l tcl~ldR~fgfi i!~h iklhh 4 CU~I~~U

1888 ~ d i d n ~ ~ i n L ~ J U R F ~ ~ ! K I ~ ~ ~ U ~ I P ~ I ~ L L ~ ~ ~ ~ n t J n G A ~ i ~ d d a u l n n j

Wiiuhul~uinnaiui i f iq!d

unn~innpnuius~n~i~dstin~~tflqmFii~~Qnniinpnu~u

muluundg ah kliqmdiindnniinpnuiua'g~aa uygdnhu lung .

Montijo szni i~~nT;KuIna~u~f i~~ ~ ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ ~ l ~ l ~ ! ~ ~ ~ ( i W j l ~u5cPgg-1 . Lldi~nirnniifgnssuyq91n~a"; npnuiuun ~ ; ~ i r d u h d ~ n n n & d f i P ; ~ d f f q y ~ u ~ d ~ d I ~ ~ i ~ o n n ~ n d f i u n p ~ u i u u n s a ' ; f;4iii?u~t(ind

i1~npnu1dn~i i~df fy~ id~f iu~f l6 ~ im lszhq l rnu rzn - i i~dsz~n~

!tirml99"na7u~iu ~dn5ud 4 qumfluf 1932 duafiunndfi%idnm8qpi;

'bdum6luGui~nu&u%nii f;~iniqunfgsrs u y ~ ~ d u ~ n ~ i ~ d n f ~ d a i d e

n~n~du~d~zd~fin~n~nw'uluwu1cP~qin4~npnuiua zn1idds t LHR

itnfifi~iduiwiiu L.du Hobbes, Spinoza, John Austin, Felix-

Stier Semlo, Lundstedt, Lasson, Binder LLIZ Hole-Fesneck ~ ~ I ~ I ~ L ~ U ~ I

o~Arhrnnwf4 3 d3rnnkniiadi~liu L~udJ+tnr~u~unn ilfinwwurrflunglrluin d~di~fumynnu~~uuo~nfi~wiwdfi~ndia~~u11 n g w m u r z ~ d i ~ ~ z m ~ l d d ~ n w ~ ~ O ~ n g w u i t l ~ ~ ~ ~ f l u w h ~ f l u ~ I n m u uinnll ksumw~w n l i

nu9n%~yi

h t n g ~ u i o ~ z ~ h ~ d ~ z ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ t ' u f l n a i u d i & i ~ ~ ~ u o e i i ~ u i n ~ ~ ~ ~ d ~ n a ~ ~ w d 19 liou~u"iduf1~~sdnu81~qidoSin'uf ~ ~ ~ l i ~ H ~ 1 ~ ~ 8 ~ $ i R ~ l ~ ~ g l & i ~

%hhu bdu n~8r?ry~lb'2~6dvhdu bd R.R. 1648 ~ ~ R U ~ # ~ ~ I ~ J / I # T U

fkd~gludiuaur lou d n m b ~ n n a i u ~ u ~ u ~ ~ a d o f z ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ u i n % ~ n z 2 A d l i u a u f p b i ~ f l a u u n n s q nir~iinu8$~~lnz~diJf~tJLs'ubfluiJ

I ILO~ ua:~iuaunufi#y~ifl~duBuoeii~uinm . r z ~ I i ~ ~ n m u C ; i 9

~ ~ ; d n l f d 3 ~ ~ ~ ~ M ~ l ~ f ~ L d 0 ~ l ~ l ~ ~ f i ~ i ~ f l ~ l ~ ~ b d ~ ~ ~ J f i R J t n l ~

~ s n s d ~ d ~ ~ u ~ n a ~ l a u n n o ~ i w u ~ # ~ ~ n z ~ I i ~ ~ ~ d i ~ 7 6uflnaiu$i(it-g d o s u l m w ~h duu8ATglqiiq~~30uui R.H. 1 81 5 f m a ~ m ~ ~ f l u n a i J

mmo~rt?rb~o.ofaw~bbaz~i~ua~fnnnb~u~~1u~b&i~3~ nd#qqi

1. au~#qjqir0uUfinnuaoJhu vl~oacnucliu nnuanronui ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l J f o i i r O w ~ u 5 # q q i rdu nnnd~p~.rr mnn?iu~flunnid~n~~ d ~ \ r l ~ i ~ i a ~ l I q q i f w o ~ n ~ i u r ~ u n ~ i ~ ( r d ~ n l d a ~ f l L ( ~ f ~ d ~ ~ f I i ~ miu~Ounai~f u.rzy~fluf~a.rsuyq)~~lri'aoht0uautIqqi ucirflu ~flu~ubuwuod'~~n'idu od~fi~uondni.r+ 7ddr~n-a:: &~IIT~H 8dnl.r hrqu~9onn w u d ~ . r r ~ i i ~ . X ~ ~ S r ~ ~ u i n t i ~ u ~ d ~ ~ ~ i rfluau8#q,1qji ud

r4aniidonncl~uo~~mr(~r,w (oentleman's Agreement) ~d~f!~qf~fiionncld n i ~ r f l w ~ u ~ d i L rdu unn~nn~+amt~i~~~:nui~fifi~a~~fi~~~clr

' ~ h , Rouueau. Droit international public TI 1970. p.63

a:fu iramna~r:nii~~onvuGi~u~ulo~~io~:nii.j,fg~~~onvu 1durnr61ur3u nir~fifludmuu?mmniairor::dou~id~ii~fl~nu~ f i c yodcyod i sin ~nrrrrrmii.rdr:~~~undu3rinrf:i~ud~n~'~1fi~o'n1iu ~~siniluido 22 nmpinu iaoz ii duJmudil~ur:nii~iguindnJiu fiulonrdlidfinv~:ldunu3d~qi

s. nu~~qqirioIfi18nwagn~miunpnuiuuri~d"Jqid~~i~du dio.rdrjli8imiu ninigrj~qcyildddl~aimiuduanr4ddinunl~lw nu$ifgqi dou~df~irnfiid~i~ainiu~.jndntfluni~n~~~~~on~nuiu

2 r ~ n i i . ~ d r : ~ n s J ~ f ~ u u o : f i o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r ~ ~ v ~ 1 1 b ( 6 i u n i u n i o u i a o : ~ n flwrdnaindflcyryi!d uonainfuigjd~qi~doiooz~i~n~nuiuniu~u u o . r m u ~ d o ~ 3 n ~ d u ~ d d ~ ~ 8 m ~ r r n ~ 3 d ~ q i ~ d o~dqqin~~l?uuui

4 i l d i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l ~ n u i i n ~ q l n.s. iosg t:qiid~q~ryqilJiulndivnu~~tJ niuirodi.rnpnuiuniu~uuo.rmudoiduiwslJ/o:~idd~bi~1unu8 flqq1ld

(Convention) hnna~ (Agreement) ngrlkr (Cbula) n ln l (Pla) un flq@ (Statute) daqjqi (~ec~asation) Wan ( P ~ M ~ c Q ~ ) M3lJRI3 w) ua-8u 7 Bnl ~ n ~ ~ ~ i c m f d i u ~ d ~ I 1 L n u ~ s u ~ u n i r i ~ u n ~ o ~ n f i 3 t ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ d r - ~ n d u ~ d i i ~ q 'IM~J 38 do d ~#ann~~di~&uu~o:1118adi~ 7 fh4

~uttt'qlqjidrr ~nnnpam d~~f~flau~udmrnfimvd 10

LfhW~~#qjqj~d J ~ H R w ~ J ~ ~ H u ~ u ~ ~ I J ~ u ~ ~ H ~ ~ J ~ ~ ~ I , ~ R V ~ S H U ~ ~ I ~ R U ~ ~

~ 7 ~ c : m ~ ~ # n ~ n ~ h ~ n ~ ~ u 7 u ~ f l d ~ : : ~ n ~ d i J q dnilorla~Yl I rub- flqql~ffulimw ilrmi~nq~rli4a n.s. less ~duq.~1om~miuni~nzifi

uimi i i o (a) ro~nglTnr~~d.r~aiai3~ry.5ingd~1~rl3~du

f l~ f l~~~fs tdoa iaa~bf~h d ~ t n a anmwuvi~rnaasuf~1~~~~~11?1~~tl~h4r a ~ ~ i a r - * n h ~ u r i ~ u 3 t n u l ~ ~ unt\of u~u l i t~Uo anfjo trRni an: 4 i u m f i ~ a n n t d ~ ~ u 7 d d ~ m i u ~ u ~ ~ i h t t h ngIIma~hrtrmill aduiud 26 Pquiou 1845 &IRI.~)JUI#L~DTU~ 26 (1~inu 1845

do M ' I U O U ~ (Acceptance) l l ~ : ~ l ~ ~ i ~ 7 l ~ l ~ ~ ' t l ~ l J (Approval) MBl71 14 4 (io 1 oyzlqq1n~~iuuuir:q~~n~iu~uuouno~ynriunu3dq~i

fIl~~#a"91tJl L h (Ratification)

luds:%~iwmi ~~Siui~niadnmn~~~n:nia$i~u%Iyyi a~urinGmi8 nis1flInn~u~u~Iy~'1~glu^a#niad~:1fln~m58d~1d

~uflq?flu da:rn~dau~~~%iadnmngatunuda:~i%d'b~u Iiui~~uni~~flI~ui~u~n~au~ubaua",~~ni snudn~ni~~flImuiGu~gIu

n~idundda:~nfi; ~dCioc'bGia"uny~~ina"~wni~~urinu din iu

dnnn~Jdiinaiudifiydnda:m~ ~ J ~ I C U L U U ~ # ~ I T ~ ~ ~ ~ " ~ R ~ I R ~ ~ ~ ~ I ubuuiudisda: ~n~uosditluf ~1a'bdl~Ga

~aiunuiuu~~n1.rlflC~uiGu8~~a$i0miu~~nn1aui~u~~o~- I q ~ i q d ~ u u u i ~ i $ F a u n p ~ u i u ~ u ~ I ~ ~ ~ i R.R. 1969 nuiu8dnd6naniulu

d d d i u i ~ ~ u o ~ q d I y y i lfl~m-nu~~uanulunia~iwu%Iyyid~rin~fl

~iianaiugnGuniunpfsuiud~~:Cia~d~fimiu~u%dyyi6u1 eniuln

~K~'b~dnialfllinuiflu~u~Iyyi6u i?K~Iddwn ( ~ ' i u ~ ~ 6 ~ u ~ ~ y y i d

j i imu~~uuio) nia1flImnGuftoii~~u7~b#ua1unia~~wadnnnunda"~d o:iwnud~~m~nYnw"ud~iHua'bfluwu8Iyyi dnrn~dn~?im~Iy~i

n-(t~~suuihhunp~uiawu8Iqyi n.R. ,969 uimi i i YOJOI.&J~I

ftoiinia~~;~nuiflu~~~~flu7#niandi~~#ma~uniada"~~n~a"ugnGu'bu~u%

(iyqjidnuns:jii nian~uiu LonRisu~nLdduudriaZflL~~wu~~y~i niaunua"~ nialflnaiu~Auaou~innnia~~1-5au v l i o h i ~ o l i i ~ ~ u ~ a r n u

~ n n a ~ ~ u d u 6 u ~ ~ U u + r ~ n i a u n a ~ n n n ~ ~ n u i ~ n o ~ i ~ ~ d ~ l u n i a d i ~ u o u a"uynviudn~u%i$'yyi&au

uinn 12 n i ia i i ~ a i u i i u u n ~ ~ n J i ~ ~ ~ u % ~ y y i ~ ~ u r i ~ ~ a i u g nGui~nflnianduiu fiiilffui~yyi~&ndia'bfn"an'b&mnndn"u~nu~u

- - ' ~ h . Rousseau. Droit international public. TI 1970 p. 88

$ EL-

CC

k! 2

3n-

6 2

CC

se

2

e

53

4

s)

2 4

3

e e

3 $

5-

9

9 ti

e

ns~da:~n~~'inc.aof LLWMA ~ f i i i fpasuqy R.R. 1874 1:

~:~hniajii~u8dyqji~uf~d1~da:~n~0:o~~u~iu1~~o~f~ni~n

GfiRl R m f Ldu Guggenheim & Burckhardt b h & < l d 1 ~ 1 3 ~ ~ ~ 7 3 % f l t ? ~ ~ l ¶h o i d h u u i ~ n (Conseil Federal) ~dAi~ui~i~~:~i~ian~fs;dmuifiu!&fi

dn~:of~n n ioyf i luuiamiiriJui~~munn~~t?maiDu~f ~ L L ? ~ ? Y R ~ % -

~ y i l & & a u n u ~ o ~ ~ o i & o ~ a o " ~ o o ~ ~ ~ i n a " ~ ~ n ~ l~ r insddnu~dyy i -

~uriolflLlimrinS~uldd.8.o~ nrr"u~9o~dolfs;~~mflu~in~n~nrr"uddod riou unnnn~~lfanrauyy~~~flrin%da:aiau~%iuiddau~unnnau~u

n i s ~ ~ ~ u % ~ y i & a u ~ u n a d d ~ u ~ ~ y y i ~ ~ ~ i ~ u ~ a : u t ~ a ~ i ~ u ~ m ~ " a o

nu8$$y~dflmqlfiunh 15 fl i i i d~hmauR~~ in i~~du~u~90 8 ~ R f b (canton) Sn~uolS;eds:aiufiniulu 90 ~u ~uud~udflniads:ni~fio:

( ~ ~ J J I R ~ I ~ ~ I ~ ~ B J - I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : " I I I " I I U W ~ ~ ~ ~ iiids:aiauunufuid~tBwa

liilduoa8ukfludirmn!d auna:&dfl R.R. 1976 ddutnu%t?qjqji 2 alju

d!~(r?nliiui~fs;dr:aiau~~ufi~o~u~dyyia:~a'i~el~~~- lufl R.R. 1923 L L R : R U % ~ ~ I ~ L M ~ I ~ ~ ~ I # - I ' ~ I l ~ f l R.R. 1958

miunp~uiusz~a'i~dsz~mer maqRassusz~a'i~daz LW er'b&fiwinwi!u

nhmunii ~ d q n8 Ambatielos ~ d a n.R. 1952 kundna'i n?sb?Imnih

~ ~ ~ Q ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I L U ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ H U ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O ~ B ~ W Q ~ K E ~ ! ~ luni i L9angla - iranian &rutdo 22 nsnpinu i 952 ~in'b&szya'i nislflRSIuiflufii1S

~uSfyy i f ina iunu y3$

R; lod i~ l~n "m iun i~ l f i $mu i f l u f iB~ounwWjo~~~~ izBqo~e j i u

nszuautrf nisdi.s 7 rnudii~unlflui~~issu~yd~InudnRni~il:a.u nsz .uaun is~~o~~d~an iu iu o i o r i n t ~ i r ~ i n n i . n i u ~ i u ~ d o - ~ a i n ~ f ~ ~ n ~ s h i

undInnLdbuuudnjldoeii~aamL~a 0jl&itriij~gnisdilzLLitt"11~0.u n w i s ~ k

ndia ~ u i ~ ! n i ~ m a ~ ~ u o u l f i i n i a d ~ ~ m i u w u ~ ~ y q i ~ f l u n i a ~ a n s i a

Wl~nuJu~~~~dl$idn~sn~u~ulu~w~oni~lfi~mui~gu ~ d u ~ufR'yyi I

Zmsrnw irMiiJk~umfHirdu5ub"dn'bnH'bwaiL?u nd f i d 12 f u n n u

Eu Jnn~~u iuu i~W' iu du STRUPP, BOURQUIN LAPRADELLE L L W ~

CHARLES ROUSSEAU d n a i u ~ f i u a ' i ~ u f ~ q ~ i d ~ n ~ a ' b ~ ~ m u i Q u ~ ~ ~ &

ns:fii'bdmiudnp~uiuniu'b~ii~un'b~eiou~*lriuldsd~wsizfioii i ~ l n ' I

! iraeuhunj)~uisd~ulidwnm~na~uiu fianssuyyd$dL~n n . ~ .

I 946 LIRE n . ~ . ,958 szy i i ~ u t ~ ~ y i ~ z ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ f i u i / ~ o ~ d o I ~ ~ u n i s

lflfmniflu'bnugn&o~miun~~uie~ l u m ~ d i j ~ s ~ ~ a ' ~ ~ d s z ~ w e r i l ~ & ~ n u ~ niifiwiw du n ~ s z ~ i i ~ n o ~ m i i n i n " . u ~ n ~ a i i i a oyy-~'bmqninndsza~

uifiuii CLEVAND I&&~PUL~DTU~ 22 iluinu 1888 ndiaa'i naiu

l u n d f i f i n l ~ u ud~nnp~uiuuidfiiu~~1aiufinidu~n~~~d idu Laband,

Scellc. Carre de Malberg, ~itzmaurice i f l~a'l RU8!$ggld!fia"Un13~$

l I l d l u u o ~ f f $ ~ ~ l ! & $nnlJMul~¶Jldfilu idu Anzilotti, Cavaglieri

~Guii ( i i o d ( l n ~ d ~ f l ~ ~ e r ~ f l ~ i f l u d a t ~ u a d a " ~ ~ ~ o d i e r u ~ ~ i a ~ d ~ n q arflnnaiufu~naouI~!fi i~a1:qd1CIaeril~~lneria~)u6aern~~uier

np~uin'

i~d~nnfA~i~afluflogfluui~fiiu idu P. Vellas ~dufiocmu

naiufinuor Labaad mindiaa'i ni3iJu~oul$a"~uon~?lnIyq~ilner~i~

ni~~C!$auii~ud~~n~o~aiun~~uiernierluvo~au ~ztio1C~Tinnaiu

na:nun3:i~inucionnuiunta:Miirds:LnR i ~ 3 i : n i 3 d ~ : ~ ~ f ~ i $ i

I

nqw@nt Laband ~a~fiUny~gqJin~~~uuu~a'iEiaernp~uis - - --- --_ * . .

Ch. Rousseau. Droit international public. T1 1970 p. 109

P. Vellas Droit international public. 1970 p.127

3. f g d i ~ 7 Guuil~f~inut1~~~niu~~uutiod~niu~~n1# ~~~fiulllrMneld)io Pfl$nuiflun"uuin~

4. ~~%~qlq l l l l~ l l lh~~ l~~~~ DIQQZ~ZLI~'I#~~J~~IJICT #I WfH'puiBnlnfintYiu bu fg~u i%n~dhbAf l$~u i f fu ~n' i~u~2luni.r

~ f i ~ n u i ~ u ~ n u ~ ~ h l ~ ~ i u n~u uinsi 4 bif~isiuJUd 14 f is iuu 1929 tkq

I ? u n ~ s ~ t ~ ~ u n f l q l ~ ~ o ~ ~ i n d ~ : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a ' ~ u ~ : ~ ? ' i ~ d a : ~ n ~ d ~ ~ o d ~ n ~ ~ ~dfintYiuffonis~fl~nuiflu~aud~uiu I

5. nu%$yqi$u~mwo~~~:l$~~6ul&~nufPddd~uI&L~u

~ d ~ f l f l d h ~ l f f ~ f f ~ ~ ~ d~ ~u%~qlqidir~niwn~ddia"nf:)r(?'7~~7~

fiviuafiasfiudiu~uoa~u iud 1 o quniflui 1 947 a i u i s n I i ~ f i ~ ~ u I X

~ f l u ~ ~ r r i n i s ~ i ~ $ n u i f l u w i ~ ~ a ~ 4 u ( n ~ i u i ~ d ~ u : ~ ~ n ~ i ~ tlo n a q otu3ni j k d u k n q v ~ ~ n : c l h ~ n ~ -

6. uinsi 14 o y $ q q l ~ n ~ ~ ~ ' l u u u ~ ? ' ~ ~ ~ ~ n g ~ ~ i t l n u ~ I ~ ~ i iud 23 wqvninu 1969 flaiinisuaufu (acceptance) uirnnl~tnqiu

~fiugou (approval) Lflu?fnisLLmJL~num ~ ~ ~ t n D t i i d v $ d ~ u n i f d ? ~

- d ad

~ f l ~ 2 l ~ L r s " ~ ~ ~ ~ f l f l 2 1 ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ f l d 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ (An C.D.I. 1966, Vol 2 p. 216)

~fnis1flnisuaufu16Lt'u1fn"u1uniJd~1~s:M?'idds:~nndsin~1w oyfiqinnisaflu ~du uinsi 1 5 ny$qlqlin7~nounou iud i s

wqn(niuu 1945 6ofid U.N.E.S.C.O. uinsi i i 0~1~qlid06~1uifin

?fniaun~u.lloanw~fii~rX~~mnaiumzman aa w~faIuniafh6u

I % m u d ~ q l Madame S. Bastid (A.F.D.I. 1967 M c l 545) \~&L(IULRUD aiu~iua'1'bu4iuau~na11~gaz~?'1~da~~w~1 4667 ibgu 28.82% lbnazf i

Iu~dnialfl8'auilJu 12.1 2% ~muniaunufu~f nnial A i i u h Auanu 50.29% Tmunias~uiud~~finTmu~fn~andi~Bu

d~~a"Yda:bw~~wudia'iIrnuiflu niaunua"~1~~onia'b$i~1a~u h ~ u a n u ~ d d w s b b m n d i d n " u ' b u ~ ~ u n ~ ~ u ~ u ~ ~ n f i d n i u $ i ' aiu d n ~ ~ u ~ ~ ' r y q ~ ~ z f i ~ ~ u m a ' ~ ~ n a n a ~ d r f ~ ~ ~ f l n ~ ~ A f u n ~ a ' b ~ ~ a u i ~ u ~ f a n i a u ~ u f u ~ ~ a n i a ~ b a i ~ 1 b ~ ~ ~ n u ~ ~ n ~ f n i a 8 ~ ' b ~ 8 1 ~ 1 n n i a a ~ u i u ~ d

ldtfluJwodqzfi i lrXmud~q~iflwR

~u~$qqid!&funaiu~Auanu~inf~nni~inn wif3 uua3 k l d d o a ' i ~ ~ 1 ~ q i ~ ~ ~ & f u n i a ' b f l 1 a u 1 f l u nia'bfl$mu~fluozrf~~h ~nnm~.rhuf~d$tgqi dundl " $Vlulflu~la" (Instrument of Ratification)

ddn~zfilluuludazyuun~f3nio.fjuIa ~ ~ d a i ~ ~ z s ~ u i u T m u f ~ u u m S d i ~ d a z ~ w ~ f i l 6 ' b u ~ u i k n m o ~ ~ z ~ n n a ~ u ' b u ~ u d $ y y ~ ~ , b ~ z d ~ f u a n d

~ ~ : ~ ~ ~ T ~ ~ ~ I & ~ ~ W " U I U R U ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ U wma~mu~~'%(qi~~m4ubdag~ nnuan~dduuctan0umnaz~~13cj~yyi Fln.j~mud$y~~fiul~unn'b$

cTnuiGuuAi h~Uunudti 'qqi 2 diu Qrjdqq~fi?zna-.Jiiniabb~n

~ h u i f i n i a ru ~~vlddqlndlhwu6il~uKuS$y~l'bnui~1dfioiilil:

~ ~ u f ~ d d n ~ a a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i v l i o ~ i ~ ~ m u ~ ~ u ~ i a d n o ~ ~ a u i I n i a u o ~ nddnirs:vlditda:~n~ nia~~~rn~dsu~wsil3irniail:aniailanl~u~n

L?~ndl Certificate of Exchange of Instrument of Ratification LL~:+J%'ELJ~I

o:rfiu$maflunimo~~ncliuvld~13 u n n 11 o(2) un~ngflmnvlda:ami~ d r:yii ~ $ m u i l ~ u n i a o r u e u l T n ' u Q ~ ~ i ~ ~ r i ~ a ~ a ' ~ o r u ~ n i ~ ~il:~~-8dliYf~

d ~ ~ u ~ u ~ ~ d ~ ~ m ~ o ~ ~ u ~ ~ u ~ S n ~ a ~ o a o ~ ~ n ~ a ~ d o ~ & i f u ~ d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ & ~ ~ ~

naiuddniauourrda:n<d

nai u(iufiu~wS~~nzbnd6nQ

f l l l ~ . ~ ~ l ~ n l ~ ~ f % l (Deferred Signature)

n n a w i u r n u ~ k lii~38nmtld~u~~da~uiaana~an1uddriou

mmi i 9 %a 5 lii~umlfia"~~ui~nu~~~~dnia~~unii ~nyr~qqj i

vl4ofouu:dido t6i~C1d~ddiu1a~u~udaz-'bfs"$ms1du~~et'b$d~~ua1u

ay$qyido~dmu'bu 1 fl niaJiiny$yyr~ndnd61n~anaaunaa:vl~1~dat ~wfi~~andi~n'u

+rbrli$yyiia~dq' 3 damn fin

'ICi RMW flnng~uissli?~~a'Ifl~~~~n~ini~kdoa~3u\u#qlq~aodd~s h fi~~iiauli~nnd~~aan~~~flS~s~flur(fo~i'fu~~~~~~o~~tl~~dd~~ hndo~dnd#qlqiuoufu n ~ f ~ ~ n u d ~ ~ a a l d s a ~ f i a ~ ~ m w ? ~ ~ l ~ d ~ L n ~ ~ lug n.n. 1929 B a f i f i o m r ~ ~ i ~ : : ~ d ~ u ~ a ~ a ~ m ~ u nd?ufi' 29 mwsu

I. au8ffgrtfuio~Ii#iaf 2. ~ ~ % # g ~ 7 ' I 4 f l ~ ~ u w n ~ I F L ~ k d o ~ 32~14 3. L~~m%do?jlqt:uh ~ Q ~ U ) / J H V I W D J ~ U ~ # ~ ~ ~ ~

rnm 20 oyff q q ~ q ~ i l u u u ~ .hiwngnm~uPffqjqpndn+ hmuu~#~~ay~m\~flnn~&1~3~'I4i nn#doa3?~1~4~~f luhj 1~lf~ddqqidufiniruoufu~~ddi~innu3dq~1~ r=:148~ q19111 rn9A

for ~ q u ~ r f l ~ afidordo~~~ffqq~~u~inn~uod~~ffou i fj uarwa 1~%ff~qj~lfl~~~nu~111hr'Orl7du n n ~ ~ e ~ a J I U O ~ ~ P T L ~ C ~ B U ~ U ~ ~ O II'IX ndiqllo~~d#qj~du 7 ' I d ~ i n n ( l w ~ ~ r ~ ~ u n 7 u \ u f ~ 1 1 ~ ..tqm ~uffo~lffou~i~u&~uu#d81~1uh~u Hff1.rfirudmu~uuma0~7 I # ~ U ~ ~ ' ~ ~ I ~ N ~ ~ T J ~ U ~ I ~ U U ~ ~ U ~ ~ Z ~ ~ U ~ \ ~ I O W ~ ~ : U ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ H ~ J A ~ J I .

anm 21 o y f f q q i q ~ ~ ' J ~ ~ ~ i ~ i ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ u i ~ a ~ S f f ~ g i ~ & ~ t : y % nm~uffur~wfqr n1idf dckdo~l d~ufl~r~cjfqjqidu 1 .do niluldnlu boa4714 uddmf un?~uffuf lu#~t~4id~dff~~idu q &u k(dou~Ou\d .

aiuau8ffqjglivlnrhznn ud~ildni~R~don~mufitf~ dffrywi8u q 6, A

n n h hiu ago a~rud~rll$~Y dfu~ri+'~d~~c~ h i w l l i ~ ~ d w mu , .

k ~ # ~ ~ ~ l d ~ ~ # c r g l ~ l ~ r : h ~ l # d ~ ~ ~ ~ n L ~ w l ~ ~ qdaplqli u&Tb!HiiirrnfLfidh t ~ ~ q ~ q j ~ i a L ~ ~ & H ? O W $ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ¶ J ' I

~ ~ o l u u n u l ~ ~ i ~ l u d ~ u d ~ l ( n ~ ~ ~ ~ d o ~ d u ¶ i l ~ ~ n ~ ~ n t ~ d ~ ~ ~ u >r~.hrhr ~nulultlijlJ 7 nu5 ~ycuqlim~oSuoiart:l$ir3ciuu~~ua=: ~i~o&ro~d#y~iwfoflu\d&?n ih - au%fytgi#uRrnw~teiffif~[d # y r y ~ ~ d d . r r u a d r t ~ ~ # ~ ~ C F ~ u r i ~ d ~ d u ~ ~ ~ a u ficn~rdE'~tiorr?u\5 f l A ' ~fo lun~f ld ( io~nn ldr l j ( lu t~d~~o&&~n ficto~rlhmiulfi nriuhrg~=:~13~i~nQotu~t1ct:lfl#~uiflu r r l ~ c l u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t i i f ~ U ~ I I U B

#QMl

~ n u o q r r u ~ ~ ~ ~ i d t d u ~ f i u a ~ d n ' 1 v a 4 ~ ~ (diuuhn ilai~qp qminn) ni unqiu~dud?ulnflch nuf ffplqildai unnfddaciu ~ ~ r i Ihrainu~~ura1~llcu~un~~u1uniulu ~w. r i ru~ t#q~ i~ inu~~Qo ynflufrnh~13rlaf3~riidu ~ n ~ ~ i l m ~ i d a r f i a ~ ~ ~ r 3 ~ a i u i i c ~ n ~ u d fiiaun\unu~#~qli Bdoiaor oon~~un~mrnu~fo#ad~ci~ niu~u~do ~ ~ i a ~ % f ~ ~ l d ~ ~ ~ ~ ' t 6 ~ d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t t ~ ~ 1 ~ L f l ~ d 9 ~ ~ ~ 6 1 ~ ~ " r ~ ~ l d ~ f ~ 0 1 9 9 ~

Ihcninlflnu%dwqi\fltlw wtdfldfi~ ~Uhgpan~~\&~u ~dudfrrnnkdma auld meme i o4a rn~k~~nnoruo~r~'t#wu%#r~~i'tSi~~fiu~~un~~ui~

I

\dffido~douufi#~ qliduId~tlnif df zrtm ~flunidflifatiidpfia~~~fia min

an-r dn~f~ilurraii~doc~~i~\ut~uiig~~~ii~~~t~~~uiun~t~\~ dndriou I n~i~oonbiniutr k nu5 flylyiii~ndiafifl~flw8~46~r,flungp?uif~ uh::

~i~linp~mnrnuI~~fimu mmi ea, 28 M J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ F ~ ~ ~ ~ I H A t l . ~ 1946

q q i r ~ ~ O # ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ U ~ ~ ~ U ~ Z I ~ ~ ~ ~ I O L L W = : I ~ ~ ~ I ~ I U H Q J ~ ~

rionn~;di~dou~rii~~Qonhngn uiornulu

a. a~~tYqjgiflo~firnrnmodg nuurflJau#ffqvifkl~ds ' d ~ d l ~ ~ ~ n ? ~ ~ ~ l q r l i i ~ ~ l ' ~ : ~ . 1 1 ~ f l ~ ~ A 0 5 1 0 ~ f l ~ a l # f ~ \ f i f ~ u ~nnfia1fiuf~h(Ilunif~7d~::flu1~1~i~fluni~'1~1~8#g~i ~dulufl' n.n. i ~ n i bjnqp ~ J L F I F I (ni l u~:Q[du Ih:~uron~iaua~~fiui~Ctu

me*. i esr. bjnqa kJ~ntv Bml hrfiu~aminuo~ocsr~du

)rlkomn~6fi7ad#ty~1iiB? ~ P ~ J I ~ ~ u S ~ ~ Q I ~ ~ ~ ~ L ~ J ~ U H U I U u o u n n ~ ~ o ~ u f i ~ d ~ n t l o ~ n ~ u ~ ~ n ~ = : ~ i ~ ~ o ~ a u t r ~ q ~ i fiar(io~iln1.r ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ # ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ ) r l 1 ~ ~ ~ l t l 0 J ~ r ~ ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ h ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ # ~ ~ l

n iar~~l i~~.r~mnorB~~Qn\uni . rAn~i~muSrQqgl i l~~wini idu ~Anvor Vartd dli r ~ h b ~ l n n u\udhr i~ l~~luf io ~finqiu (~w.riz4a nnUa~iiO~o~iiB?) )rlEhnm~mq~nhur)~~~n~mi~i)~1~m~~5#~~ iflu)rl#n\uni.rfln? f i i n i . r f i n ? i u m u h d n ~ . r ~ ~ n . r ~ ~ ~ ~ n ? i ~ ~ ~ ~ u i u ao~auWrgtyi fi~a~~on~iu~uiuuo~~ut#~q~~ilu~Qn\~ni.r~fi~iu ~ ~ ~ ~ ? ~ ~ ~ ~ J L ~ U ~ ~ \ U ~ I J ~ O : : ~ \ ~ ~ W U B I ~ ~ I ~ Q ~ ~ ~ U H C S ~ ~ ~ ~ U ~ U J : : H ~ ~ J

J.rr inn Sir Arnold Maenair iflud1 i~nfindid 1 daf ~iui(9oi.r ~ i f i u 1 l o ~ ~ 0 u ~ ~ n a i . r d ~ m u ~ ~ g l q i ~ n c l i ~ d ~ ~ o u ~ 4 o l ~ ~ i ~ n ~ d b u f i ~ l u

\ au~~qq~nquintto ~ o i a ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ u u i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i f ~ n u t r ~ ~ ~ i d ~ q U (Iqodi~~du mnoy q i ~ n ~ ~ i n i ~ ~ f i d i a ~ ~ i i d o 27 L)IYIUU 101 i iihdi'u ti?~u)rlwsuo~AiIi "i)rlho~u\ulwri" muaut #iyqjini.r E ~ I Y Z M ~ I J ~ ~ I ~ fiuu3aiaaf u~ud nd?ud 19 iuwau 1892 I[6.rry~flin&ih JOTfi~ifu

, rn~uw~niii~6iirri1 L L ~ ~ I ~ I M ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U L ~ U ? ~ U L H & I B ~ U I H ~ I ~ ~

,

IA~u~-I~IAIJ~:~~uML~~u nni~a13f doddJllnl'vfidrllqidu~iS~ 1ni4 n~irfiuf~du q bi r l~un i rn :~~~~ i r l~~4~~d1~1unn i4o i3 r ~ j o q n ~ d ~ u 3 ~ ~ ~ i ~ o ~ l ~ a n i w n Q ~ ~ 1 ~ d ~ ~ ~ 1 n ~ 3 d q q 1 r 4 ~ l 4 1 d uinn 20 niinir(u~uinaiddi1~1n11i3nduJ11i~~idn'1au3d~~i~~~~u t g Jr :m~uw~~Qu~~a i i?

2. ~~~qqii~~~ullntncu~ff.sfl~u~.sn~uuiur::w~i4dr::tnu ~ J S CW~KS) n6ntn(ud~4~uu~.jn~uuiur~r~di~d~::tnu (JUS CO~ENS)

i~uidudfbn~ukttd~nirndi~6~.soinn(~~nrrunirn~~uiur::udi.s drz1n~ lufl nn. l o r e I ~ ~ I O Y # Q ( Y I ~ ~ ~ ~ U U U I ~ I ~ ~ ~ U ~ U ~ # ~ Q ~ U ~ O ~ I I 6s 1Andi2 .Iirm3#qqidodi?Jilwa~di1uu~~t:~ri#~qi ~lryqilfu~~firmdntncudU~-

fi~u~.sn~w~iurmdi.rd~rin~ ~ ~ n ~ n c u d l ~ ~ ~ u ~ o . s n ~ u u i ~ r : : u ~ i ~ d r ~ i n u tduurTntncudduoufu1t11::fur~.s1n~d~2:~1~urru~i~dr::t~1uu0~f~1~~d~u nuIufiu::dtdundnintud d~osni4u~1Attaro::~n~tfi1~'1bi1nuln'nwdn-

t n c u ~ ~ ~ u o ~ n ~ u u i u ~ u ~ i . j ~ ~ r ~ t n ~ d i l f i n ~ t u z o ~ i 4 i ~ ~ ~ f i u mnn sr ~ u r ~ i l i i t r 7 n u ~ t n o 1 d ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i . s d r : : i n u d ~ u i 1 w d mi) ~ ( ~ q i ~ o ~ J ~ ~ ~ 2 i u ~ f i n n 1 1 d ~ i s n ~ u d~ou?dil~('~~itn::ifu~m

~o~ l lu~~~d~n i rn ' iuua~f in tnm~f f~ tTuuo~n~uuiu1zw~14

Jr::tnd5arlwulJ1r~n tiCIttdrln~dnn~3vfJuaiufldjrJniu1romnn.s~A lulbtdd.soiotdun~n~ndo~ldf~~dq~idhlo4nir~ontd~qqndi~6i.s nbn J U S . O ~ ~ E N ~ ido~ild~qildil~n ii(ltd~duoufufi~1~trd~1~~udn

rnordff.sfiu tdu u~mcudn~?riHrh~.sr2:\1~4o~~inudnn1r'Idjnnu drzinadu nanniridu2fiun lt~unro.s~nirurwuvu ufinmlidu7fiu

uyvumu t~unird~l~dolnncldn~dnni~~hu~fi~ldnrrr ~Judimir liin~a irWm Ihuiimril@ a u ~ a u ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ * i l ~ i l ~ ~ f i u u d n t ~ ~ u u i u ' ~ ~ ~ i ~

drrtna i Ju a u i r d ( ~ ~ i n d ~ u u n ~ y ~ i ~ ~ u u o ~ f ~ ~ u maydrrru~m.1~ '

dr:1n)IA11~Lj1nu3d~qinj.si-iuuui nn. lsls kd~rzuj~.s~nidufiv t~afiidu idonznd41dunud~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ n o i n d ~ n u ~ d ~ ~ i ~ n ~ u ~ d o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~umiunsuduufeuvou~.snur~uji~ J~ttnrrrinrnbnn~sIungi5nr~u-

4 4~ 3

ee

-'

c.

se S

e2

d,

2 *

Se S

5%

- e

2 2'

$

e

r

BB-

an- 2

- s

-a

Y. nnLdIeu~Ldadddbba~doufim~dqindddbfluoiuwiiid'yyi

(n) R 8 X i l u r ~ n ~ 8 R l R m ~ u R ~ u R m a . r a d 18 bdu vattel, Mably

I d lnu8ngwa~n~ Jean - Jacques Rousseau db~udl atnsi%Jbflufl?lu ciuGufs:~iitfpiiIfg dnulJna:nunaz~flnudt~],nna a:iutfyyi

rntnia61ilkntfl~ncia~dtrfiiiil: btflntnaiua:~iita"gd$yyiiiaiu

(Y) niardduuLLdnddJLLagdouijmld~in"um:fli$;q RIU

~Rnnp~uiubrTu floa'i(iil)ni.ndiuubLdndoeiiddiflqj'buddbbaadou~a

ld;nm~rl1r i ry~1~o1~~1I09"d~~1~~d1~0u ~4o~unnmwlTJlilr R ~ ~ U S

sic stantibus ( ~ J ~ J M R ~ u K ~ R ~ L u u B ~ ~ U W n7W) TlpM~7fl L L ~ J I U R ~ Y T ~ I ~ ~ ~ ! A um~6nn~a6dndi?un:nniubflu~fnniaduoua"uCudo~un~~uitla~~~id

d

da,ubnR Cn%iRlwmf~ldw'lu du Jellinek, Strupp dnaiubfiu$iau~uMfin

I ~unhahnniwnaiu0i1~udou~flu~~~w~09"wul~qy1~u~a n d k Cavaglieri ~iuii~inrKami~a~~~~iiua:~a'~~ona~u~unultfyqi

fiuiin~~unn(iirdri~"uoda"~bbda ~iyqjiBoulJdwnDd&~~lfl& Grotius

d n a i u ~ ~ u i - ~ ~ ~ ~ n i a nin'~dduu~rdnd~s:dwnIGnu~~;;iiu~an~r~i lio~~~lu~w~niadd~&Qjdbddaubbdn~wia;difl~odwul~qqi annQA- ~iamfui~viiu ~ d u vattel ~iuii~~?nnnidi&;d~dduubbdn~&o~~flu ~vqnia ~ d ~ ~ ~ u ~ n ~ ~ ? ~ ~ ~ ~ a w u ~ ~ ; q j i ~ ~ i t u i~il:ii~sI~wulr~yqji

~uqand& nm:naaunianpclmuatt9ii~da:bw~lfl&~~6nbm4l~a'i

niudn6MKn Rebus sic stanfibus ~imzui'bffd?u'b~~bbiau~- d

I ~ ' t y ~ ~ d ~ l i l ~ ~ m : ~ ~ : ~aniuiu ~ 5 o r l ~ l i u ~ ~ u u l d d i i ~ ~ u ~ a z u t b a n i .ad

szuznniuiauiu~;uoio~ftanis~dduu~~d~~u vl~1fldniunndi)IXi~niu

' M ~ n H 1 ~ ~ y ~ l a ~ q n i n l ~ ~ l n 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ 6 u nla'bffM$n Rebus sic stantibus

dsing'bun~ni$uQuia%i@uimai 19 d a z y h nrhraiiiuQuimaifioio

dyaui%nvo~$ufiui~"~~i@uifioia m i n ~ 9 ~ ~ ~ 1 d l d r n u i ~ n 0 ~ ' b f l f l u ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ i m : ~ i i ~ d s z ~ n ~ f i ~ l a i ~ n u a i ~ ~ # n n i a l 5 ~ 1 ~ ~ a ~ ~ 0 ~ RIROUUI- 9 .8

bqnin~sn~~~an~&nandia'bun~fi~i~~z~a'~~~~~s%ufluq~~'bufl n.R.

i91n iinaiuYn$ud3poid~flniu~u8fyy~~ua~uld l i in isdaf l

munu9Cyqli oiooz11~'bflnaiun~n@8~mno~~u~unsin

liiflaismidsz%~ic7nfuh o - ~ ~ u i i d w n i u n $ ~ d f ~ d ~ ~ y i

h w K n Rebus sic stantibus ~douon~~nauf i$ygi urh'iuidn$dor tflu

n 1 s n s z r 5 ~ k u w n n i ~ ~ u ~ d ~ ~ f u n a 1 u ~ u u ~ u o 1 n ~ 1 ~ y 1 ~ n d 1 u ~ bdu n. ~ f i u d s z n i r n t s ~ u i 31 qninu 1870 i i n u I a i ~ o q n ~ u

'bunufitt$yid#n ~ u d 30 fluin u 1 856 ~iuafiun?iu~~unni~~nanzbn

~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ l ~ j , r ~ i d n m l ~ ~ Y ~ n ~ s d u u ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ u a ~ ~ u i i ~ ~ ~ ~ i n ~ ~ u iwsizY~iiinis

'~nzilotti. La claus rebus sic stantibus in R.G. D.I.P, 1930 p. 287.

4. fin8uuomfin*glqi$u~baa ?ud 26 wqwnlnu iene d di'l%#udjnqadt:dbna Lbn~Ld 7 wqwmnu i 955

o. ~lidbon~fin~gli$u~~~~do~il%fiu8~nqw L G ~ n.q. 1836 LLI:: n.n. 1950 b u b i d ~ ~ ~ n i ~ ~ ~ d ~ d d u u ~ d n ~ ~ d ~ ~ i ~ m

~iad#glqliunzmFi~l~nia$rauin'ou~u a z & i ~ ~ U w ~ n a ~ ~ d o ~ ~ n a u E #qqi~5oaou~aoonainau$#q;blilil$i uonain

n. n ~ i u ~ ~ u o ~ u r i ~ ( i ~ b ~ ~ ~ d o u d ~ ~ u ~ a ~ u I ~ n i a d i i ~ ~ n n ~ u a u I$fln?iugn$umuaub#qqi

Y. WOUdJnl3Ldd~UIUUdRJfll1fx:bbd3R bllW9181) bYflLbhJHddJ9~

fio~d#ilRdofiu 2. ~ V L ~ ~ ~ U ~ ~ I ~ ~ O J ~ J ~ L ~ ~ ~ O U ~ ~ ~ O U I ~ E ~ I ~ & I J L Q ] U ~ W L M ~

d a L ~ n g u l c ~ g q i ~9anau~~oona innuE#qq i n. di~flun3 d$nw%#qqlil&iii~u~bva~~au Y. ~ i n i t ~ ~ d u ~ ~ ~ n ~ t i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ] u w n u i a i n n i a d ~ i ~ ~ o ~ ~ $ i ~ ~ ~

cnwdbb~:~au%#glqi ~ f d h l ..

dorn(l~ncJiu~d~

76 LW 403

f l p l p l ~ ~ i t r r ~ u o b l ( l i u l l 0 6 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

b h ~luumudtmut~no~l~tldj 'Ii1um(I;rt&6rrr: ~AtfiA. bdonUad~fwu t ~~rylh1~(4~~i~~~~bu iht L~(MLIB

t d a l 6 ~ u r o n ~ l a u i n d ~ o t n ( r l ~ 1 1 ~ ~ n ~ w 1 d u o ~ u ~ 1 ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ d d ~ ~ ~ ~ w ~ W i l w i i ~ t m ( r i m i ~ u t o m ~ ~ ~ ~ u t ~ u ~ : ~ m d m d ~ c w ~ ) ~ ~ a l u n t ~ h ~ ~ d d ~ f i f i i a u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ f i ~ ~ d u wklo~-G~~~~gl*~ ' (lmiaoSlfln~om~ld ~ & ~ u ~ w d ~ u i ~ o i F f l f i ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ ~ r ~ ~ ~ # .gW 'cUSlidf3.6ulir4~lj.n"o~1 w t ~ i l d ~ u i ~ o d d ~ ~ ~ . idu m l j ~n i~ f i tdogn m m ? n ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ o o o u ~ d ~ ~ d o ~ n w u ~ n t ~ i i i u i ~ ~ ~ ~ u d f ~ ~ i ~ ~ni~l~focoarnfu1(lui11~11~0.5i8~~mw~

7. R U I ~ ~ ~ I U ~ U J R ~ O H ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ J ' ~ ~ ' I I ~ O ~ ~ Q H U ~ U ~ S H ~ ~ ~ jrsmrrdr~fi4wktli

mnn sr i y ~ q ~ n p ~ ~ u u u i n.R. 1989 diwufii~ i i j~ifi~ ~Hfi" t~dfl4flUVU4nQHLI1~'ISH~N~'I~Infl4~LI1'IHd T r ~ a f l ~ ~ d r h . ~uuidoU1"~~~on?lu~"fiUHdnniIVO4~~H~i~IZ~i14d1~1n~d

id~ii i~jutwddouldj~ai1'~~du~"a~ ~~11~3ilqryldtim~b kd , ~iy~~lUilAvouunl?~ny nflu1~udiuiu n~afl~~1ddimr~ud~iit~u~i1'11 . d ~ ~ h : * t d ~ d ~ ~ a s i w d u o u ~ munn6u#w(ioy n~u'Iudu3flcyryl!6' 1

nn(iuqnao~uu9#xgqji rry 1qqinf~iI0uui ~i(hay)Hn : nut#qqlgli R.R. 1 t ~ 9 ulm 54 1~q0.11 f i ? l ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ u % ~ ~ ~ ~ fifi nnn~w~mo~mdd#q~'~o~nuin~u%#q~fl~ -ni\fii~(urd*

(n) ~Ou'WmuumYq~oauut #qgi (9) duut #w91ibu 7 ~nnidI#dh~ihunr\fifi31~uoou '

'R. m o . tr pmcription m R.I. in coum A&. D.I. LA Haye, 1959, I, p. 399.

dou uian a9 o yflqqinp ilduuindiaii nu3flqqir sgnfiiiu~ip ~ 1 ~ ~ b ~ ~ ~ a ~ i d o n i 8 ~ n d i u u o ~ n u ~ A ~ ~ i 1 d i d i n ~ 3 f l q ~ 1 a U i l 1 ~ J ~vl~o~idu~flu~umuvkiia:

n. ~ l ~ ~ ~ ~ f l ~ ~ l d d l d ~ 1 1 1 ~ ~ d 4 d ~ ~ R ~ i l O ~ ~ l ~ o 4 ~ f l ~ ~ l 4~ m ~ ~ h ~ ~ c y ~ i n i l u v d q ~ u 1404 6hndia

u. (iidonaidunu~flqqii~uu~54~flfiunu~flqqi~~udou ~ ~ d ~ ~ ~ d i 1 ~ d n l n a o ~ ~ u 1 ~ n u l ~ q ~ 1 d ~ 2 a h Iul?mriiu?fiu uinn 6~ d4a:ydi ~~c~flqqialludou~ioo:dod~1:~~~4hnai?di TAU ii!oaiu~nuUaflq~iailuwtf.j v!ofiiduiitflu ianuiuo.sdnu3 #c\~(uI luqnnrdiinu3flqqiauamfi~l~duzl~~~b~ioi14~u14 mwidom1ud?dQaflunu3flqqi~r~1~vd~

~ ~ ) q v i i d ~ d u ~ ~ n a d ~ ~ ~ v ~ ~ n ' i n u ~ f l q q i ~ n ~ ~ f l u ~ n i ~ ~ d ~ iidd~lnmuv~~~Ei~ddiflqr\liisuf Arnu&~~iona9u~~ilunuUaflqqi fhuy n~uod i h o i u idu allu 1 o f ~ n i a i a u a u f i iin:8qnqu doluorilu ~' l id in~3f lqqi~ub~~i lnrdkmnat:~ddinu~f l~qi fluilniwtiunoi~u i~d~duntf~~ddinu3flqqidudniwiiu~u~u Iuidouta~uiuu lois ~ m ~ d i u q i u si wcluninu i g s ~ fiu iuoa~ud1add~iau3flqqin4udnllunoinfiu lid ti ituddvfiflcycyi n.rudnfiuhu~u~us~naido~ud 8 llrruinu lgss

IJ nm. i ~ r o dkt~d4t~bl6qn~u~i nuX~~ninfit~ulflqt~i I ~ J I H ~ ~ ~ ~ U ~ ~ T U I H U ~ I * k a ~ ~ ~ n a u ~ o ~

f3dn'inu3Acyryimund~nudi~nua'dqqi~liudouoioo=:do~ Qu~fiaou6rfifinnuiduwiu~u1un~dig z fgJqiiIumcinu~Aqw nrnudiunr:~i?1~3Aqqi~:~-ii~fiu uimn 103 o~fhrmdr:naiii r:$i ~unrdtAfirnr~ab.rfiur~-ii~.(io~ nfluuo\lfgnui(andiiifi

4 ainnpu'nmnndr:aiaiAdu4o~nfluniiifioin4omnn;1r::~-ii~dr:~n~ 4 4 1

I

ouoo~i4~yn~umiun~iirnr~wnuinndi~~ uimn 73 qrm 2 o y ~ q q i /

npiiuuui n.u. less .IiCi7unoiuflu~udn\1~nrzq<i G(ionna.lu * e w 4 oyflqqia~d1Jfi iufgninnivo~nn~r=:n<i~drzi~~~u~~~ufin~mz

4 diduiiuuuiuiion.nu n ianr~~~u~~uoao~dryry i~ f iud ma.r~lnu n.nu~~~nr:rh~omnn~r:n-i i~dr:~n~d~o~\~iu.u'~n'u~y~qqii ln.s ~fi!d!&~~ uimn so (4) oy ~ q i n l ~ t i u u u i -iihungnuiunu3flqcy1 n . ~ . loso r=:$ilunrddf~didu1)id1u~um'~q~i~~uriou1rild~~d ~dumdnfiunfi~ lumuflu~u#r:ndi~~~diduni~d\1 2 a h f i u ~ dt~unirit~u.rnl~ui~m~u z eiiu nui/flqryidirfi\1 2 idumiio:tiIu ~ r ~ i ~ ~ f i i ~ n ~ l ~ ~ : ~ ~ d ~ ~ \ 1 ~ d ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ < 1 \ 1 ~ ~

\

nnctb'lurdduua~n~au3d~~1

ido1Arhn~3~cyiii6~1u ianidoui noiumrdrrn.lwd~:tn~ , oioo: dduu iida4!d ~boioamu(iounwio~~uni~i~dclb1#au3d~qi

d~d1td~o:~o~fln1~tlfi1~n1iio1oo:~1nn4~dd~~ iidn4 iifi!uau3dcyqi ICinonnbo4fiunoiuni1duo41nn d o ido iifilu(iounwi~~uo~nw3 rltyq1 nir~ifi!unu3dqcyidiu~8~a1fi~~ri!Afuni~u'u~ouoin~dq(11i 1na~~nni11ib~4oiin~:n'i!~!oi~e~~oii~1d~=:~wri]~=:~-ii~d1::~n~d4 l~funiruoufuluni~dr~~udnounou n.a. 1871 nrdnu3dqqinp d ~ h .lird 30 iluinu i s s e iduatlum~~n:i~di~e~uiumdnonn~i~ douiluil n.a. 1870 f~uwnidi~Jrz~nnin~dulAd~ni~~d12i~nid nu~dqcyiub~~ifnldu~o~nia~n~dn~undno~~~i'1~8~nzinAi~iddiu 1 8 u a d ~ j n i d n u ~ ~ q i d u ~ f i ~ i i u o ' ~ ! ~ ~ ~ n ~ r ~ n d ~ z ~ u n ~ ~ n o u n o u ~ u ~ ~houannnu 1871 d drqlilAdufiw~6nnidi~n~dnu~.iTqqi 'Id nui~od~:n~4o~nvfumiunu3dq~i~3o~~fi!unu3~~~ 1muh.l'IA

v funaiu~uuominmd~~qi~~d~uor~u!A~n~~~fi~unua'dqqidu~ni~ n.n. i s i s luil n.n. i s 3 3 ~~lj i id~z~nnu~iri iwi~~~~mfliwniri i i5!~ nu3~q~it~oidial8uauo~iuo~~u

.3ittd'luau3#qrl(~da~ 2 33 , 1. mrlifi~u~nuul~onduduo4niii ndiadovlnqd i d u m d ~

naiu~iluro~~umri~fi~u~mu~ondud 43mrfintiiaQuul4odi4iiwi ~aiuluodm ~ ~ u i a w i : n u ~ ~ q i d d f i n ~ m : n 1 ~ n i ~ i ~ 0 4 ~ ~ o n i ~ n ~ i 1 idu mc3dqqilioi~mwn'n n a lore, m3.iTqjcynofvof n.n. 1066,

nu3d~qinlJlru n.n. 1067 di~un~~klmri~liluun~q~3diclcyd~ 7 uo~au3~cycyido~~4u3iandud uinn as uomoqqunirdu3=:~41~ d ~ = : i n n f l r l ~ w n r m ~ c y ~ d v ~ ~ c y q ~ ~ z ~ m ~ 4 u ~ izzndiufiu~i~i iflu

2. mnltl~v'Ifiu14izlu~4i~uin ido.roindicnuumf$ud3r:mnu ~ m ~ i ~ d ~ z i n d ~ t d u ~ ~ u i n 6 ~ ~ ~ u ~ 0 o 1 n d ~ : i n d ~ i n 6 ~ ~ ~ n = : d ~ t : ~ n n o~~lfinrilA$rnn~w mndPl~uiilu~ion~udluni~~itllunu~.ilqryi

matt(nvnu3i(rycy~du4niw nn, 191 8 tf luflq~&$~u~:lfv ~m:&td n.n. 1946 nu~dqqi~niuhu~au~awi:nwa*d~y~id~~.j ,

~~niaamii~da:~nm:n'i~~fi'i#niatL'fi'Iu~'i~unu~~~qid~ u auld ~fi~~'l~ufi'I~mr~tfi~u'I4u~~~~tilu.~d~u'I~oj~~du~~~~td~ uian i g

nilmduil~inni4a:~~inrJn~iduiluim~i~~io13qnui3nu~~duil u ~ ~ n i i ~ i ~ o i ~ r u i t t f i l ~ n u 3 ~ q q i ~ ~ ~ u ~ n m w ' I i n i u i a n ~ ~ ~ . ~ i l u

'\d~~onmumada:~~i4d~:l~~~1'Ifinia~~'I'i%o~nu~d~qioioo:do ~fitfia~uflfl3r~fidu3ni~uo.~Inn n~~mflu4uin'11iii1ff uiinirll A'lu ~ u ~ ~ q c y ~ n ~ a o : ~ o d d f u ~ ~ i u ~ ~ ~ ~ u o i n ~ n d i ~ ~ ~ v T i ' I ~ n ~ a t ~ ~ ~ u n i y

8 4 , u i m l o ' ~ d da:nunnrhlfotdidn3ad~o~n~.~~duii~'im'11i~n1uiat1 ttfl'lunu3flqqilEi tdw ~ o f i q ~ d r n f i u t t ~ d i m Y dil n . ~ . 1921 ltfilu Iuil n.H, i ~ s s ttn: 1838, ~ ~ ~ ~ q q i I n ~ i ~ t t f i Y u ' I u i l nrm. 1037 nil? t~uttfiksaauY (Uainda~o'iU~~aaua:~d~pda:~~drida:nu wnditQo twn:YdYAfumaluuouainnifiqndiu niu~6-a n.a. 184s 'ldil3dnia d~fl31urnanli'lunu~~til~nnoii4fiufidd

1, nado~dniarm~i~da:1n~dniadod.~~6n~fwzni~a1~~n'i~ua a:~:t~m~no:t(1~ud3n1a1tfi\~nu~d~~1~"i tdo ' I f inu3t~~~ i~ f l31~ i~uimutlut~~niac~"dt1~duutt~a\11~

2, nadnu3dqcyi~niudi~~jn~i3n~~uo'iu3uuin nirti6lu d~cllioio~:na:vli'l~1~ulddod~fuwiu~uuouoinqndiu~fiul.k nu~zkqq~d~wn~nr~utawiz~~dfuniattfilu unrzdnui?dyqitc3u ~~~wnI+fifiufiuf~d'lriuo~~~unir~tfi'~u idu o ydqqinplan nn. 1907 ~ i ~ ~ u n ~ ~ u i ~ o i ~ ~ ~ z t w ~ I u n i ~ ~ i n ~ n a i u n ~ ~ u n Jdltfi~u oydqqinl.rtan n.u. i s e ~ tdu3fiunqnnmi.run I

- aytfqrym tan n.u. 1907 do~ i t t~udo~~qq in~ .s t~n n . ~ . 1 8 0 ~ T ?miiqd~lqcyinuoufu~ydqq~il nn. 1907 itdoytTqqi n.H. isso flu'41+il4fiudi~fuf~d'lri~8ufuo~fqq1i~ n.H. 190,

ey r k q c y ~ n 3 ~ t ~ r u u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d u u ~ ~ r l a ~ ~ u t ' ~ q ~ ~ n i a ~ ~ ~ u ~ u ~ q ~ ~ n n ' 7 ~ u ~ ~ u u i 0 1 n a o i l oytTqtympliuuui

82 LW 403

uinuwfjnifi ctrlrkfidi~~lf#0r6o~1fido~uiiJu6~~ LJW nunpflm mrhzninil uinn loo (2) rr$G~uiJnni~rd~~1dd01uiiJu1uau3 diy~i ldu~f iu~~~~n~~~?bi i?j~udi~:6~~~~funi~~dnui1Ju buf'uluw fdd~d~ndrz~urbldu$1fl~~ud~f an16

~uchunnmn~fi~umtdffrllCllid~~d~f#d~d~ddnuiflu ui4nf.l ' rmdiwum1~~1r~~fi"lu~~1~d0~~d?~1~#n11i1J~~~~ uinn is rrrrry cy

uonaino:~flunrddauidQqidinulfiafi'lu~Anlonrdd nu~-~iy~iriinun1~~~uo~ii4du mf iand13 l lo~ ld t l a~d1~4~o4~n~

~unif~ri(liomnn~llfiIuil~munr:~ioionu~~qqi~finifidunnuun~~q~~ rkndi~~i~~u~4~awi:nir~(lii~ddfud~~nu~ffqq1~~3~d~t~fi~tlwizni~ 2 f#lodidu iid'lildmfihna~

1mun8nd~1dldo~mfi~d.1~~o~niuf~~1o~nirllfi1unuidqqi 8oia tdu~jidan~oo~dnirrz~~i~drz1n~6iaa:n'i~~~~fi~4dnru~481u ~nGid1du~il:u~ilriunir~~fiYunu3ff~~i nr:uaunirllflumia n~lTArmdr:aiaid 1~udn~arn1n~~nGid1unir~ndr::~ud31d~do ~ ~ f i ~ u n Z l ~ ~ a n u ~ ~ q i n n i u d i u u i ~ t l ~ u dunu3-~iycyinnoqsl6d ~ o f i n u ~ ~ ~ d n i r d r : ~ u ~ f l u n f ~ n n ~ r : i i ~ d o ~ a i r o c i l l f i l u mri?dqqil6lnrdaqaiuil n.H. i o n G~irociufimafiiunsllwi ~ ~ u ~ a ~ u c m i w ~ & ~ ~ o i ~ s ~ a ~ f l d u f u o ~ n u ~ d q q i ~ w d 1 nmplnu ~ o e s 6 y d ~ ~ i 6 4 d m l ~ ~ d ~ ~ ~ f ~ i d ~ 1 ~ 2 ~ n ~ ~ ~ i ~ n : ~ u h u d hmh.duilu~in:rn ainn is6 c t i n ~ n l k d n i l a i ~ o l i n i ~ d ~ ~ d ~ i ~ qn 6 il ~ ~ l l ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ n [ ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ h l l 4 ~ ~ d 6 l ~ 6 1 ~ f ~ n 1 ~ f i d 8 1 U i 1 ~ ~ ~ i ~

slu r uo.1ip8 lun$tilnuiMq~i a Phu rjnrddmnn~llfilufiul~4

nirl~filunu~~qqioi~~:n~zv~i'Lu~3niIn~IA dom8duaou i I o ~ ~ l $ u d n i f i u ~ ~ o i n u ~ l l t y ~ i u i ~ a l i u ~ i ~ n ' i ~ ~ ~ 1 A ~ d ~ ~ ~ A nfioinw'ur:u:~d~~ul~~~~~~q~idwn~4~~1~d.1d~doaz1Ar~m ~ l d ~ r n i f i ~ n n u # o u n w ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ n i ' ~ ~ ~ n u ~ d ~ q i n ~ a ~ ~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ n i ~ t d n ~ i u nirdnloif~ll~ndoadd1onin~dduut~dn~vTilfi~nair~dite~udo4~~fi1~ m3ffqqi oyffqqinndrmm~i63unp~uiun:ln uinn 812

riinwm1~~rnn~filvlA~do~ur:u::~3ni lo il ~ a i n ~ u S o ~ ~ q q i d w nldrl4flu n n h n e ~ v e ~ f ~ m ~ u n u l d q q ~ I*.*. h mpm or-)

mr~r~nomuo~~lauiu~4naiunir tu"ni~~~o4~u~u~~nund~~~ d~uuada~ddtoirazi6m~innirunilu~~nund~1~~ld~r:~~~dumr

oydqqinpduuui n.n. 1078 w~n~d'L~jiwfin~n(~dnirdunom ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ A U ~ ~ ~ ~ R ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ U ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ O S ' I ~ ~ ? . J ~ ~ U I Q M I ~ ~ I I ~ ~ M ~ ~ us.j~dQnlio.jniunQvuiur:vdl.jdf:lnfl niduaomuo.rf~Imumr ~~k~~ion~i?nrrmdr:'11irndoydqqido::~d'14i?~rlu uonoin cf~~~~~~ido:1~~~nliouvfi.jn*ol4~~~i:nirdunomuo.jf~d~fimdu niuvko y t~qtyil~~.jrlu d.jdl3u lidnrciio:nnn.jfiiduociwdu ( u i ~ n 7 2rm 1) uimn 7 2nn 2 rhvw~tUuGounl3u-h idoilmrlfi ~~il~uuilol~ihuf~oiodrt:nidi~t:~~o~dqqi~~~uilflunirdunom

4 ~o~aud~6~~udou.lun~ydqqi~~n'1~i?.jfiu~~n'idr:ni~1Ci.jn6iao:d ~u~u~~n . ju iuv~o~~dqq i~d~ in~~~ i . jnd i~uoufun ' id r t :n i f ldu

uinn 8 ~o.joyd qi~~fFivu~linir~iGonnn.j~~~it:~dunflu Y dunomnu3dqq~rlui~nmu~ddoificln~iu ynv!uni.jnpvuiu ~z~~i.jf~ljdunombuf~dniuVl~Bunii~vo.jnui)dq~id'll~udu llmu uo.jflCjdunoariouodECiu~onri% ~dudkl~nvhdonmtflud.jn~u 1Aua~unirduna~nu~dqqi~no'13~~.j~Bu~.jv~mud.j~o.jdr".j~~n d~ln~duouynvlubud.jnqulunu3dqq~dd~.j~md1'1'i~du~fiud~~~m~ uowudoudnvldfulonm

o ydQqiau'ud~~~imum~6n~n~dl~d~~fiunirdunomv~.jf1 mlm~d~ldmud~i?8uilu drh4 q idu 1 1. 4onnn.jni~dunoa .jb.jnqudod~i?dlunr~d14~do.jdu d1.j q lUu5nr: f'dldu5nr:uou ndudoSd~i?drniunu3dvqidln u '1Bi~ljfidudu trmuuo.jolu ~s~nn.j~.jndi~~fluni~~uu'uronuirud uo.jf~~~du5nrzda:1~nu~d~~ij~(ndold

lunr~~uMqqivniu~iu~ nir~mn:lilounu3dqqiduno~d~ zh~n~iumuiSmrrmd~z'11itnfid.j~Jl4u.jwo f~v~o:(io.jJudulonui uo.jnwdo:yn~u~urm3d~qidnnQ.jvd.j

2. ~ ~ d d ~ n o m ~ n o : d r : n i f l d i u ~ d ~ ~ ~ ~ n m . j l o m u i ~ (ionnn.rdrli~waluum3dqqi d.jui.jnf.jf~dhnomoi~ot:n'i~umr:ut: nnidau~uuou~finu~dqqi~~~flu~udw~~mw~~.jnu~.joiol~u i i!

iosr mmu~u~n~~n~uoonf iun~~wmn~do s qninu ".a. 1980

uinn si oydqqi~:vhnua~q~~dil~n14fi.jflufiufIdu~nufiu fldjjwnl.8fi4llufiufflad 1lrio:~wnl~wl:zi3~uo.j~ull~~dqa~a ~qil4~.jfluo~'I~.1uduno~~riidu (od~fi.jtluldfi.riflnd~ud~(liiui nlmhf$~Jkda:mn) kdl~uiti~:il4onnn~1~w~rii.jdu ahma fl~flul4au~dqcyi~:s~~eio~fi~~~uiut~a:.1nr]da:n~R~o.jn~~dq~i ~ 3 o r i o ~ ~ d ~ n i ~ i d d u u i~dn.jod1.ju1n~od~~~un11fl~flu1~nu3dq~i

d i~ funudqq i~nud iu iyuliluno~oiea:a~~~~niiidunnudi m ~ ~ : 1 4 a ~ a d ~ ~ 1 g q f 1 ~ t t r i 8 ~ l t ~ ~ ~ ~ q n ~ d . j ~ ~ t5~1tdhnljcl~'IB nu~~qtycyio:~~doq~~~~uiu~~n:.I~qda:n~du~~num'dqcyia~~do 121li5~n1rdduu11da~oci1.juindolfou!unirfl.jflumiu~u3fl~~1

lundawSdqcylu'~~dl4fi.j~ulu~usSunm f'~do:ifluljvio~acui i 1 ~ : ~ ~ ~ f u a ~ a f l ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ 3 ~ l d d 1 ~ f ~ n ~ 3 d ~ ~ 1 d i j ~ ~ r i ~ d ~ . j ~ 1 1 a ~ u i d a u d ~ d m a ~ d n u i f l u n i r u o u f u ~ ~ o n ~ a ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ w ~ a u f l o ~ ~ u ~ I U I Q U D ~ ~ ~ I J.ha:'Idfl31~3~ uou~3o'Id

s. nacild~iiunoona~n fiu d u 38dd-Jdu nu flu iidrioui ilun oona~nlhu uinn i r oyflqqidi~u~~~au3dqqid.jdwnI~ri~flufiu f ' t~~nfi ldldold l~ut~rinu3~qcll~o:~.jfl~~~l~~1:~~~Iq~~.j~~lt"~

iiidu fu~gjtmnn,a:~~w~daun~l~lf luol i i idu ~ionafi.jttui4

i els el sen. Thearie general du droit intcmnadonal contumlv 1939, p. 253.

nnisfluqitnd~r~w f i ~ r ~ i i ~ d ~ r m w ~ ~ l u d q n ~duruBffyqdiha fin t u n ~ ~ ~ d u o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ u a n ~ f i ~ o r ~ u n t m ~ ~ t ~ ~ ( ~ e a ~ . s ~ s e ~ n s d qnhzmn(lodn(lod~~ nu%#ryqno%Jliu n.cl. 1871 lunfloirmim ' L l h i ~ ~ d l n ~ n d du~fiu~~iduoJr~r~unni~unrdorn~~rt~dryfl '1~ luoyffqlglinl~\an~flud 13 n.n. i oot ~~u~fiu~*dYo*r~ ~0unm141u

I

n&ngnlnufi%.l (General PrInflplea of Law) ,

-

'ch. Roweag. Drolt~lntprnational Public Recuctl Sirey 1953 p. 70. ,

luninimrl~n~rdidn~~flufluuj'~~i aiaqAa.r.rurt.~ii~ d~r~nn~(~infiuJilm idofud 1 s Quim 2505 \fli~iwfk~~ifmn~flu r ~ d f i y f r i ~ ~ u u n ~ ~ n n ~ m u ~ ~ i ) d t l a f i u n ~ ~ u i l u ~ " d i n bo~losfa l~ncm?iu i iAa~~~vtuu~~r~~Uu~i l~~~~~~~t :~ . r ' i~ f iu~~ '~~ i f lu lm luu wdu r l ~ ~ u ~ d ~ ~ ~ u f ~ o l 3 n u 7 y o ~ f i u ~ i 1 1 ~ i m u ~ r ~ ~ ~ f i u dfr ~ ~ f i ~ n u ~ a i u agu ~ g q J ~ ~ ~ u ~ d ~ ~ ~ ~ u d 13 nmgmu I 904 .rryii 'rnuumudLsu ~ ~ ~ i l f l o ~ o i l ~ ~ d u ~ i ~ ~ u ~ i l m ~ t a : : ~ f l i i ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ u n i ~ d n ~ u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ nnrtmoAuduou#u** Iuil n.n. 1867 ~l~rmnInul[&ildfldIa~n~fii uwudmuud&~tn~~i~c~ufi::d~~d~ilnu lull n.a. I ooa t~uddrcra

mrn#u~oiaim':l~ifuioflu~ilmu~u~od~u~~ai uanlw6aitllnafi Idl44qnnLfiiuudodidI~ ~ d a ~ f i ~ n ~ u f l u ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ 1 ~ i ~ ~ ~ u A i ~ n d ~ a h r malnunuui~rll~?'iwud~~~ndnln~ld~fi~n~ufu~o~~~uni~ni~~mir u r u d a f l d u ~ l ~ o ~ ~ d ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ QIMUM h i a n ad flu aiali~g m nu kubi~~Qnng~Mltlndidi u&1iu1nuo:~~inou(uuwud~~uni~n~ udfi&fu uaudd1~~~\1ri1iir~fiiw1u~a~i~u1 uhaf unrlutr nn. 1 837

n~u~au~~od(lrliuaudk111fl~~ivtf=:'5~ifoflu~ilmfiu~~i od~lunn n.roidbdudn3 sro%~~ln1111lrlIi6~fiiu~~o~dudtlu'i~'I niat dab ~ ~ l n ~ l ~ ~ u o u f l l l 9 ~ f i ~ i ~ ~ ~ s l ~ U ~ ~ i n ' u ] ~ d l f l ~ d d l ~ i 9 0 n ^ d 1 ~ 1 ~ b ~ ~ ~

aiwft~~i~~fluraniuiufh 60 flnu(l? miu~(lnfi(lauH8nng~uiuda ~ t h n ~ n ~ ~ u i u t l ~ d i n

rCi~rlin~iun.srrin

~1d~c1uidZurm01~1ff wiW~imnati~~8nnmn~ng~u1~ft:~-r'1~ r h r ~ n n U u i n i 3s ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r n a y ( i s t ~ ~ l f : : ~ - r ' i ~ d f : : ~ n ~ ~ : : ~ d i lh (~vcinaluo~niclr(lu~~1~a~d~u'ISi~1ia7~~1&u~#nn~Ir(~~u (4winwil M ~ ~ ~ L ~ ~ L ~ U ~ ~ ~ ~ H # ~ ~ ~ H ~ I U U I ~ B " ~ U B ~ ' U ~ ~ I ~ U I ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ X I A ~ I ~ ~ 8 n n ~ H u i u b d l & I d

n ~ : : ~ u f i n i u ~ , f l w i n ~ i ~ a ~ ~ i m f i d u n u i n ' I u n i ~ f l ~ ~ n ~ ~ u ~ u ' ~ r ~ ? ' ~ ~ rhnnnl~uni~t!hu 1um td&~d

I I. ~uni~ldk(lnnp~uiufl~ciuz1ii ~flwinlnois~rhb~fln~iu #?unndl~md~a;~ui~ntlo~~u~~nnD~uiuluni~fl~81un6~uti~~~~ldIbi

2, ~uui~n~d~isroylyb~nnn~So~iaqfl~ff uf ::~-r'iddf ::- cnnai~clrl(ifuuou~uiuqin dnf l r~at iJH~n~HuiuBuui~Hd rdu'lu n i ~ r d i ~ d j n ~ r r l r ~f+ r d a ~ ~ n i . r d i u u r ~ ~ l u n ~ r ~ Behdng rda~ud 15 f l ~ ~ i n u R.R. 11383 ninny q~ilnqnini~lifuuau~uiu~in~~r(in'lSi ~ i ~ I r ( ~ n ~ ~ ~ i u 1 u n i ~ ~ u u u ~ ~ ~ ~ d a ~ o ~ f i u ~ ~ u a ~ ~ d ~ ~ ddoulfjl dh q.fifudfiflniu h 0 ~ ~ l l i r m a r l n n ~ o ~ ? 1 ~ ~ 0 ~ 6 n i ~ ' 1 ~ ~ ? ' i ~ d ~ : : ~ n n ~ chd q mdflfil~u u n u d ~ u i ~ ~ ~ a ~ i ~ ~ ~ n n ~ ~ ~ i d u u i ~ ~ u n n ~ d ~ u n ~ idu ~ 1 ~ ~ L ) n c ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 6 n i ~ n r r ~ n r r = : ~ l i ~ d ~ : : r n ~

3. ~ ~ i d ~ ~ u u i ~ i t n ~ ~ l i ~ I t r : : i n ~ ~ r 3 n a ~ i i a ~ o ~ ~ f l w i n h 1

i0urnn~iu'Iunnd~nmHIi rr~mmiu(indsrmnw~dr(inwnio~~ia l~rh~flufiluu~lfluordrndu 'lunnflonminci )German interest in silesia

djn~~~u~)andur~la~~n~u~~cIi11~fiuiu~5~ u $ d o d k ~ A ~ n i d ~ ~ o ~ dm~udhrnbn cIiabn~fiu?'i~~Iff~~(ln~u~n'i hrnabna!~(l~dmnwl 1111 q V I ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ S I I U ( I C C A I H ~ ~ ~ U ~ ~ U f i ~ f i ~ i n ~ n o ~ f i i c l f i ~ ~ ~ s ~ n ~ i u ~ 0 u ~ o r f l w o ~ n p ~ r n ~ t : ~ ? ' i ~ r ~ ~ z ~ n ~ 1 ~ u d ~ ~ 1 u ~ ~ N I ( u ~ J ( I ~ J L ~ D ~ ~ ~ ~ . ~ f i d c ~ c r : : ~ ~ a l m l r l f l ~ f i n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ru i f io i~~: :M~f lwmuwo~ml ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : L ~ ~ H ~ ~ ~ ~ L ~ u L c I ~ o ~ ~ u Q c u I ( ~ L ~ ~ crinl~noisrt\drd~ Rmnmm~uindjnqv &(1&~inwrrh~L@u~1~~1fifiiuodr~iu~ffuui n8on ~?finpIr(uiunr~slmc(lu~~n~~n'n~~i~ hn$&dsalanld' ~r i r la l ig~n~vrd~ani~2wni~n~~uiunzLw

oiopruld\Ni ufln?iur$uilodCnQfimiuwf ~r\\dddoifla ~odngnaufrn?'~Jfr:rnnotli~ufl9~~ ~~dnrnwuuouuen~enn(I~~?iu kw q r o ~ ~ n ~ f i n i r d A d e o ~ d u ~ f i o ~ 0 1 1 d 3 ~ t l ~ ~ 1 1 ~ ~ ~ r n n ~ i 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 n MIO Ihtrnndit 7 rduaouhu d~l~fi~ni~~dduuudn~ng~m~A#~)flu rfoglTu $JD~QRD'L(I?'~ ~ ~ f i n i u d ~ ~ h d u f l d ? u ~ ~ u f f ~ ~ n n p ~ u w rr~?'i~thzrnm\uni~bbu

mqc LO h " 0 ~ de la doctrine d u publlcirtu UI le dmloppanot .I W Inm-

m u & M m add PU~E 1361

n ? i u d u q o ~ ~ n ~ ~ ( l a i 1 1 1 f ' A d d ~ ~ f f ~ 3 d d ~ z t ~ ~ d ~ ~ 1 uou(u r iuti

1. Oraius L ~ u u M s ~ ~ ~ dm The Law of . W u and Peace Urn:.

M w liberum L~J?xY L A ~ R ~ W I I O J ~ Y ' L ~ ~ M ~ ~ ~

2. Puffendorf R.m. 1632 L ~ U U H J J ~ J Q ~ ~ L ' J ~ Munc et#adum

3. Bynker~hgd; n.n. 1673 1734 L~UUMCJIOID Q U M ~ Q ~

JwIs Publici ,

4. Vattcl m.R. 1714-1 707 ~ d l l ~ M ~ 4 ~ 0 < l h l l ~ g J H u ? ~ f t:Md14

d q z ~ n m n.m. 1768