Top Banner
EIE*H trE I Ezs1#"iT ffi42# F,zEltfr#s0t€l 2001+2 F25E ts72+ 8 E3rE ffi3ta*gIp.+h=eq ISSN 0047-r89s KANGO-KYO|KU ffiffi 00 Wcl ,*2 ffim.k {+t EffiruIHffiH = H s.Dfr#,ffi r H * e 5 Effi ffi = H#fre &DFH t ts6?-frEmt=H+H€# OIfnh +fE E u-,+ Hffi ffi = H +H € E X t'/ <O =iFEEHEff E#f;s^ovh+?Deafi*e'}tfi {& Elhfi+ / tL{X c} b + / jffi trrs6/E)€ff+/ +ffF+ rffiFFa*nt6H<6ffif^.HfH€ z ^,/ r, - t AffiL \ /: EfimE;€+= H AR7*1 ELTY++l{tffi€+/H-H b2+ fttr€a4nF,*d-+nufc ffi?+f+E#*HOEF# httrE#'JtHli9hETEr OH# MVIIH + /Mr)llfrtE r€5 , rtrtrlll tr A E:it,ffi D b at/cfirElfr#frH Affi{t e FE EE H AH{++/BIFflHH+ T+EUHffi A O r Dr eh'bHD=rflfrndUV T 6, H = ffii*AtT A) zf -tv .7, yy Paul Allison/(;R)EBl+t+ fA 75\ffi ffi z:.' b + lvltzX, Zvclh#l==ttuht \ z C Hffi>'> b I I- I I r F t I ? r = I FN - LrJ - tr:t D { - LJ =, ffi#.trft
10

Japan Nursing Educators Journal

Jun 14, 2015

Download

Health & Medicine

Paul Allison

Article on how to utilize horticulture as therapy in health care facilities. Examples of case studies and evaluation methods of Horticultural Therapy programs.
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Japan Nursing Educators Journal

EIE*H trE I Ezs1#"iT ffi42# F,zEltfr#s0t€l 2001+2 F25E ts72+ 8 E3rE ffi3ta*gIp.+h=eq ISSN 0047-r89s KANGO-KYO|KU

ffiffi 00Wcl ,*2ffim.k

{+tEffiruIHffiH=

H s.Dfr#,ffi r H * e 5 Effi ffi =

H#fre&DFH t ts6?-frEmt=H+H€# OIfnh +fE E u-,+

Hffi ffi =

H +H € E X t'/ <O =iFEEHEff

E#f;s^ovh+?Deafi*e'}tfi{& Elhfi+ / tL{X c} b + / jffi trrs6/E)€ff+/ +ffF+rffiFFa*nt6H<6ffif^.HfH€z

^,/ r, - t AffiL \ /: EfimE;€+= H AR7*1

ELTY++l{tffi€+/H-H b2+fttr€a4nF,*d-+nufcffi?+f+E#*HOEF#httrE#'JtHli9hETEr OH# MVIIH + /Mr)llfrtE

r€5, rtrtrlll

tr A E:it,ffi D b at/cfirElfr#frH Affi{t e FE EE HAH{++/BIFflHH+

T+EUHffi

A O r Dr eh'bHD=rflfrndUV T 6, H =

ffii*AtT A)zf -tv .7, yy Paul Allison/(;R)EBl+t+

fA 75\ffi ffi z:.' b + lvltzX, Zvclh#l==ttuht \ z CHffi>'>

bI

I-I

IrFtI

?r=IFN

-LrJ

-tr:t

D{

-LJ

=,ffi#.trft

Page 2: Japan Nursing Educators Journal
Page 3: Japan Nursing Educators Journal
Page 4: Japan Nursing Educators Journal
Page 5: Japan Nursing Educators Journal
Page 6: Japan Nursing Educators Journal

t .))-7>.7t4 t-/ Paul Allison(-iR)trEl+y+

L*tffif 6#'tilu LI-:!lJ, Aa'L,L{6:*=*1f'T Lt*#az L 17'H*ffii*"Tfr>b-:(horticulture) L E :z<v.*f. ao):'aisl*l*ffii*("f.Lf++affiffitffi-.*-r(t,.*f. El=6,,6{:o>t+h.v.*i:",FgAU, MWtat-Ftrrzg+pfra:.ifiEl ? -::

arfiD)fi_alFIh'aE;,?

Eqatr";fr, E /i:,.):. L?f.l#,*a/ >zr-(': rti* L i*, )ua4I4:-.ffi A}H€ L, ,L'L F :rEW L H*ifiEJ] tT.=,

eL(u.*f.

t L iJ, TEI*, E:*

, 1+,8t1 rt =- X tF',V-L l)zrU'r) +-

bbrL3fu<v'*Tti*iJEl: I '>aEai t:'ft\/)> L*tL.-

: H *ffii*flh+i:fn F L, #A t * V, -Fd.E 3

: l lJu. Ct * t L. #ACiff 4 > l- ftU Lls ->a

.: . :4 z l- ijtlTa I) ne .H l: +2r,fi-*f.

# E- . EiH,. Effi. ,L'4E EAAWTA+fH-Y r

=D*Im, H*ffiitaifrffia+f;F(,t7 >7.r-' : qtetu), El*ffii*f#,*coffiiF+t$#, llh

: : -,i. v> /:V - / 2 a,y 7 <' aifrfifi, /J L" .

GHTEOEE' E+01 L" Ht, )u*F,o>+Hft,ijJ&'l. tb 3 ffiD *

iErr 6 l-tZ b n'> U t: L l- f: b, < nl|'ltL,

:""::a'&3(u.ll bat tHr^U<v.* t-./:. tt: i" Z t+rfrt=lj* $ fr> 6 h'6 frn ttfs t,. L, A,.i t,

; =

-r lJt ,'v : '7 rrfx rL6 r. 6 *nfi-lj l/r. AT:'b{LiJ&3trU6. Lrr?3 6. <

: . f*/:t> lJ+? 6 ffifi,aBnffiv. t3{E&f$-- DT CJ /r vr ? L r r ,. . tEWl itif t bftLl:: -

=#, RH0J, fiL/:baFl:6{:iFlltffilj 0 [: -

- 1 ; . (, fiL/:b IIH 3 6 /:D i:fEWh:'Y,t/s: : ? . +.* fLlr is tt l:*n -> ( v. 6 o>?f.

o: :HU400+bF, "Ei#A'L" L- t .*r tt/:L.,t: , 7z ;. U U 2 frAtrYhrfr>6rs b 1frA L.ti"

:*fE L q1 t ffi Lls 3 v. L v. v. * t-/:. fiL/:: -

=;f;ltlJ, EWfuft?/r ( +LA U{'F/.'L1 ., 6 At' L,E, U. * f. * l:',tV.trt, ffi L (hea-

-:; :u.) 4oo>t$, F+ffiltJ ->a/r5l'Lbh:, Eilifr:. 3-r,.fl 4)'Y,*Tfr>6t Ur-r/:4 i?f.

in =€i*cj, 4 ar 3 ->h'il_r l: ls Y) 1+a U or:': *- ;.8, -> A u. * f. + lJ g frE,frBfr, + FIZ>TL+

; 7 :; /: ir 1 i. E +ri i3 i[:" L f:tritLItWt #k

- : =-i /J 3 v., I +r"l#t l3L& :" L f:trJllljff*

ffi - :3 u. (f;Eu. ?f /,a) , 6 l- fr>fst:ir-A A += : € :" l.-t:IttLlJtr l=tt AfE Lrs 3 v. , L ur -r

- >; -<.f\,lt

: .- ; ) i3, H*ffii*o*AFitBf;aij, f r...i.'

= i- ; fr> = /:.L,8, r,. * f. 6 l_h, l,-/: b, A#F

: _ - 1 &ul o) t, v- /J' o /:r. 6 *nfu* rt,t." a > f- )v 6 tr q'sHl++rffifi,/:': /: L 3

03, iffr.ir++ ->a x( < rLl:$? AtE cs I ->a,, L.

i. i: fi,++ b hrtn LT+l,:/s -> t:.i. l: ? 1, r ( g:u., (u. * f. * /:, HX+#alfrFfiC, W.a,J.3 /s{.h't,*tn<, Hfet,' L?urfsh:0 af+t ) tu<r,r /:Ea3 e o*u +Hvr( u. * f. tt 0>&,t:

? !r ( U frfr,tL<t,r (, f,rrt,.?trrrfrH I:b b t EAA /- bfrniF,kt b, Ft'./EiJEAA Lt t < tofx.tr-

3ri 6 tBu.(t'. *f. tffiftall+03iJ, t?c3 J -r(ffif#lqtrfriIJ btL/:Y), T,l'*t=/s =/:Y) t 6

{alsarf *r. ,ffiHlciJfiglfr/rA?lJ/r (, ffifi,o>Aisu. 6 alaL r,. ) a L t, rtLftblJH,za*jr.lstrlnil/s v) *t/,.

* /: , tbt/ttffiEc:Et'r ( *i ( t-UPRt t btrL

6 t u. ) 4 zcJ,FHll'(v.6 L 6ff,.i(v.*f. *iJ+? U < L/r-J- r l: t'. ) tr-frHrfr8 /,iru. * frr,qJtt iJtu t-4HAFA{*ffi U< < nbacf.

3 (, 1960+{t r= 4 +' U x ("H*ffii*#rAirtg+.U, r970+{ttr=7.t t) /r H*ffii*tly+ 6if;fl6ffi&) * t-/:. 1980+{ti3 lJ rt t /"0>H*ffii*li|+aEkt^t rtLH q U +{6t'. * l- t:.

B +("iJ, +h'b 5 +01 L"Ffrl: B

^H*ffi?*Dfi\*n'w+^u<r,. * f. * /:, B +H*ffii*ffrn+t v'l ?"tv-7Uc3*U/:.

H*ffii*ij B ArlJ * /J'*f Lv.4 Lfr, MF.a

i*r,.ifiSrtZni *f ,', ftACJ < ) ("IJ/sur L,E,L.

* f . rtLCJHF+, HfrR r:fr> 6+yWH7\BI5tSt AEd

Af 6*tiludBl:1? 3 * tu/:. +lSFtSt0J B #.tL\htfa'i.t ryiJru/:A?, B +?4-E A ful:tEWa 3/4lJ:. Ofrh:ft4 t_/: L v. brL( u. * f .

*{il'TdB ow.c3 lJ, ts* a*3 /r5F t:ha=x,rift z brL< u. * l,/:. r )u0>-4(., H f&l:*; 1.-

fu L r,. ) a. L 01 L" H#/r :. L li fr> Y) * t.l. r"1

iJ U t U L H,*a-trfsarf h' b, Hf*l: t IJ

. LT a 4, lJ D e><e3 (u. 7a t 4.t,l.A/*f6 a L rr("S 6 o)/i L,E r,. *f. Hf*03*L L{r/:D l: lJ, * f *: o>fLt+S( ( H *a F l:frt^' . L?r. ( :. L ("f . < u<, b/: L/: tra H c:n4 I ,

4l:Ffl: Z, lj/J'l3l*f a Lattfs*:rcEn*U,? zh' b 4 < o bab#tr t 6: L ?fr.cf h' b, El*ffii* L l*'fFI h'*n L v. &xE 0>Sl 3

E##A 4?/? 2001-2 129

Page 7: Japan Nursing Educators Journal

/J'LiJ,E,blsLr?( /:'3u.. a LiJH{6iJ*f Lr,.

4t o>e 6 , AFfi L t4Wot fr>v,li0)Fq,ffi tWfr+t b

*; o> t L ( lJ, #r' b fr> b+ Zfrls a("f .

* /::. rLlJ, fl-E )UaI+bLL(" 3 /:4 Z ? U

fr>'() *tr. E+oF l: U fr ( ,'trf$?'u.( v.6

t Za r'>rso?t.

H=HEOtr6tH3ffii*a{Fft.i3, tffuryr t JfEWtsF€rg t_t:if;$l

t+89.t U<flJH L, )uaHI+W, +lAH!, 'lH#f

F!@RAHa>b:. L?f. ?lJ, gtrofi-f.:> ?"ifr6ltt H*ffii*L v. ) t7 u-l3f 6 U o)tI

'foJcLr)i'.H*ffit*7u ?, At'41r mi:, ffii**L,tl7

>, .t 7tJ, EAa4n#fr;+{ffi4 *f4Tu., ihffi77 > A*H.tu att'rLf,^( *f. * /:ffii*tljH*ffii*FtE olFrtx, xm, relrltiE o;d$*, 4 L (;+{ffi441v.*f . ?U< 3 t, IsEHEF!l:7u?"7AAFtAFf, F+{ffi , IrrEt 6 o><'t.

aa7u t 7t'41 ) : L C: I'tA,, El*ifiSJJCJ

t 7 u- (H*ffii*) l: ls Y) * f . :al}Ylffi a €e>/:

i0tg trs ( L( lJ, H/r 611"-f.: > ?"ifrfrfiTK'>

< U* u. * f . rct:cvr( U E D :. List,.i *f.H*ffii*arcB"healing garden(ffi L on" L

r,./r tL*f ,t, <tLII{ffi.LF!lswl iJEr,. *f. 6

b4 Ltftt LEo>tr|J, f+EH{+i'r,ffi UtB t)

b a L ii?3 *f. Lh't-, ?fLtHo>"mUaW"t3f b t:&>[: ii, H*ffi i*to>F.ant,y,Wri . ffii** hr7 t 7 t > l. L"=+{ffi t'41 ) /:D t: iJ, A *a" * ls t) z h a 0fr.-> a, Intt L" I ffi*t 6 ar'+-A'u'F hr fr> Y) * f . SHt L4tAa--a*lffio> 4 fL" {Lt:cvr(+Et baTt.

. fL b o>ifiS, A rE U<H*ffii**CJ, H*ffii*O>#R*J J UTEWJ L A rfr Affif* T AHbfrA EIfl^ 6

[ftX,r,:, t 3 rs'tk5ila*f '\ ( trWi U< v. * f .

H=HfrA /*Ettel-/]u? lJ, El*Hi* t ffi.'> a l1trt L iSIl J ) t t

130 E##a 4?/? 200r-2

bo>?L J ) i'. 6tr 4Lltx#aFffiftt,L'q'p#H)|tifr,aBu. iC' J ->T, El*ffii* t Hv.( r -

6Il /: \',. 3'- tvllfrts v) * f iJ, +E lJ, -tir/r Hl*ffii* o J - tv l:? t' r <{Fgif L * f.1 ) fi-f=>, A*tUt=8>o), *A/rffitrtlE{*t a

$rF|J U<'E+t bt 6 I ) rs -. L IJ'I'fEtJ7;/LlJ ls Y) * t /.'. ,t'. - 7 t6.Et U -> h'trJ /: t) _ -;

t'.jrl:itHL*f.trfl.?ifislf b a t h:4v,a?, EIL0>95 r,', ,r*.-

B 'tfr tJ rs L" c: 6 fi t lfrv. * f . tS l:#o>ri v. i- :Ub=(, ffLrrt< bfitl*/rA{9gv,o)("f. E

?EIEL(1. < lH0:iJ, /s 6"i ( F*/r Ea{':=fr+Jfs *: o>lJ{F bfsu. } i t: L t f. tr l:n6 Z 4 4

WJ 4), ffi,1$ Als u. 6 0> t rE[} * f .

2) ffin EtrglH?rr, fl*H +, H{E tHba3 ) -#.*EHE'Jtfi|Jff L, #+ htHe>a

,B# A ^,iru'i'ccffUil,;fft

9,W<, 4 fLA+'- :7u ?"7 A Cc 81nt 6h'b, fi#Ahrfr>*L0fFtF :

n< ( ft8 r,.. frArt7u ?"7 /AaIFEX,U<ffirE_:

+Htl3+Tbal2rt bt b L 3, ',y'-f L t,. '>T'.' .

Lls icFt,.H*Ffi7u ?"7 Att:+zl[<" 3 /rt,. L,E,' -

L v. u. * f. t--h'1._, 7v ?"7 Aa&|*]=i*r: --

lst:rH"+rL6ati ! -r LH ( aTt.4) ++EIJ'EF.AIEL(, +tf aretElf 6

/: t Z iJtr("€+ tX. L{-r, ffi+../\o- 7 4 *=

-<*,' -tt 6, 4 U<'so("H( l:tfuWtf ;L v. r :. L +)+ L btL*t. ftL:.:blJrtt f1 ,;+l: zB0l UhEW{- tvt'41v. * f. <{LiJE:,ioAHtEhii*f L, El*ffii*b/11 ->a r.6 I :bH4hii,o>frt"7 U- )vt 6Wi: 6 ls v) * f .

5 ) ( c 6 *^ t, *.t,tEtha+f,f, I) tF U t* -t'#at*ft+xtatEWl:fiHttt:, rFv./:' r) t 6 a L c, .E,be t

'H+Ed1Hrrrub.t U/:( 3efr>Y) *f. /rr=-

6) I#J UaffitrEtLSAbt:ul., *t={EAmt*E&.t#'.rilt a#*t*EI*t a

tJ.cJ arLt t- ( 6 EF ts#l|4*/J'L,E - ( u. =

T

rfrti

{ll

',ll: j:

{'l"l

'i

tA2

-;--'.Jt.

ffii

,i;i@

ilrry

iltl f,=tf 6

l{, ;. *=

'iS

. --

-:="-;-.=

*t;

Page 8: Japan Nursing Educators Journal

X#o+ffit,1'q:-Hi*tryvr(Ft -ir, +tr iJ, -fft::r,EilL*f.

: L ij/'f rtstt /; .'t U -> h,Il /: v) L.;

C)<', flll,o>$$ t,. /t,--

. t+[3# o)le.\,'/i : U ?v,oTi.

=.

*f . ffi,l3fE ZaE.-J-J-tg.

, H IEtHV>a,htanaIt<, Z{Lb# L.r"

ffiAt'fr>tLiJ+ffi,:t^trcEX,U<fnFi-.

,'y'f LVr=(1...)EAA&lJ, 7t<4fin?3/svrL,E,, _

, Lo&t*.l3ijr: --

DTT.

=oEt6tf 6i, ffiE-r{-7 4 ticH(/:fEWttfr.aftL/:trl|/J t /"? ':ir,.*f. <tLiJffiii(i*411 .(\,'b::1l:6ls0*f.)+fi[ u tE t) t* -

-baL(", Et"c.*iLfr>Y) *f. ftr*-t 4 o> l'>?f .

t t= u V, * t4EAut

e#Et a

if;fi L,E ->A, v. i T

{ r r)a LrrEAA La/:&>IZ11b{L<v.*fi',E ::.iiJ, 4o>: L l:J ->A E#3/, IJHhA!-i t = > l. r: -)vi 6 L v. ? HffitXu.irbt:: Z L,B. ) A?f . L.?rt$ 3 (, ur?ft,\(, Lr

- E 4 h', f<(+FfroT I='41 btLbh' bTt . 6

-E:/,ir, Hi}f HftA,ft$ts= 71. rr -)vT? T ::, tts.o>Wr,=*i tt A iftffin+R * , :' L ,rf

1 :_ z l- v Trrig J 6 L,E v. * t Lh'. ?f h'lr,- = ," 7 Aa Ff iJ, rffi 3 fs&Aig LTt L v. );' ,r, 'ftrIr.AiE+Rf 6ffiet4<lFaaTt. *-:. folr.+ L v. { atWtr, < tLr, b Hft:.:bT-F=iAtu.)HffiAH(*f.-, roHED*ift,O>#*ti€If-ta

i-r:b o>J&#t a + t: iJ, +&+p+gafft-#+Hffi€ nfffi#rsfr>->a, <tL?rlrrI/Itf L(v. *f.) v--?fL&) Ffr?Hb U< u. 6 A/: br,:, El*ffi;.^ 7'v ?" 7 Ao) F <": rshr Y) Af+/:-tt 6 a L ,r-.t+-|---=.t.

I u',6u'5I*E[:H U t a#*ttBl#-t a

{-;iA * ?, /: ( 3 /, a*L u.Errr6Pfi+}E-#

1 ? ),{L( u. 6 0>b n( 3 * L/:. Li. L, tt]-L

j ;i, +lHl:EA a ,rr'H xY) ? 3 /3 Lr€ I l:-; -- ar. * t-/:. Ht6+T'413X?3 btt]U+A:- : 3 A f$ - ( L' /4vrrflE&fs fr> - /: Y) i 6 OTt .

ffi =€i* 07 u ?" 7 L?iJ , '8 A /, i: t,. 4v,4tsE :S xY) t bffi+b+EtRi 6.. L ir, t < U EG -.*

r tr =ffi

]t7" a 2. 2 L[:*] t aEEffi t ffiffi t*.tEED 6

€=ffii*lj, v,4v,4 /rA aWK|-tI+<, F/JII

t € .j/!IttLlJ*l*f,frr 3 *rt&. H*ffii*o>,fffi{E

t= ( -#.#u< 6 t, ) a. Lrr, 4affi48?f.: +il L" Et, tJ^lJ 7 / t) rt o+f > 7 4 r- 3'("47

;: ; - -:A;#?rm UaWo>7 t. z / > l- L "=T{ffir

il"':-;6L* L/:' ffiiHl#.'t'=/\-'s- r^ ' '74+ . 4? -)VAwHfrT' 4 t) 7 A. l. 77y Zt$

: =. '. ) frhr* brL<, F fr>/s/:a* ->a v, b'fts

,; =

1 i €4/r r. L /J._r L t'. b{L* L/:.:t ;. trffiffr#tffi+tLffi-# l: f3 vr (, 3 = aX

5 /r f"lE,fi h: fr> 6 , < fL],JilfrtrH (loneliness) , ) c(depression), ]JE'E (boredom) Tfr> b t t,. L. * U

ft. rfrL7>EA 3 & iJ, ,L'[ffirffiTYEhL D 3 /s t,r.

hr LTyEhaT 6 t r,.. tt\UH t ) c LEtr, Z a3 c A /:Y\ t:rEL? L. < L/:'r L t, r ! r, rf,J, /:b A

41 - ( t'. bW+0: iJ, :. fu b A ift€' b++*h U +ff'TU tt,.. ?U H*ffii*iJ:. a g->o)f''1E,f;fcr.

ls 0 f$r3 r'il 6 a L rr?3 6. /:.h'bfr>rsf:altSiJ t < 6 EF ls a/:'.r L t,. ) aTt .

a {L b 3 = 0)f"18 b+A L< v. 6 A/: t' IJH l}tse3 (v. bWH a Rclt r'fLf , qI+F!l: U x l.

v \a+t=fr> ->a, fuE> 77 /^Dtfih3 u Tir-(\'.3 *f L, XWtaie-UHZ*f. H*ffii*Lt'.1 att, *WJoIfr.H:eATll 6a L?= 7lo>HtJrIiIl3 U cfsh:67)Tt.

tr=HEOHilffiffiryJRtJ^iJ, El*ffii** L U< /:"ft?/r ( , H*ffii*

a7 pr -, - L L< o,ft$U U< u. *f. ("fh' b, El*ffii* t trr> 6 /:&>c: El*ffii* A E U<

1+ b{L6*[XLf{#t=cvr( U *rFf; L U< u. * f.H*ffii*aqx,

^tLb. Lt: t->a,

'E-#rsif,rfr+Jl:F.E1#? 3 b*hX( s rF El ) +, ffi-pka ruS[F!rsfirl?# (10tF H ) rr L' U *j;f; Ut b acf ir, +triJ, FlHlrF€ b bfr a rsR 6 F€l,L'Af+ /:tL6 ?fiffi

W-'nJX(ffii* L U<*hffi) r,='> v' ( /J'ftit"i 6 :. Llr L * L r ) . aa+?, E*ffii*a*lHc::r,.( 6,,|rL/3'Ct1"frrfif, rLb: Lir?3 6 L,E r,.-j- -l-sg.

H*ffii* a '4i ) F+l: iJ, t/.ij t -z{- t - )vtE(, ?E+$f*is/: ( 3

'L )r.= /:r{ 7J 'v h Af+->a,ffipfitffray.A * by) *f (p.8LaryH4HH) . z{

zj ,y I aF c:lJ, Ifi/=4)tEWJ[cF€)g t-l: 4ta, /:L LIJ|LE L i'ErER, +ft;f;/r L't

^fL< *j 3 *

f. f,/,r' < Lfstffilr, rE-#+ffiFftaHSt.EBT A

s ( L, ,# E LhrtI6,L, af+ ->A fr,t:3 * f . ,t6,L, lJ H*ffii*.:Affitffi)tl Cc fs y) * f. f,/.rrt

-zr-t-)vt#6 U, IcorEHiJ, *jtrA8L*tr#hfr E7", L ffi i€ Z r, ttfs u r /: &b ?f . a o)

E##e 4?/? 2001-2 l3l

Page 9: Japan Nursing Educators Journal

t -.2r- t - )va *j[*?, ]so 3 LtJqffiz f ltfi.$tl:f/,l:Ef; L h'tl( 3 * f.

tJ^iJ, ESEFII: #W# 3 r+€-#fFA &, rg+ffii*t, (Fxffii*ta)un tA"=#twb, 6H,JHW:'lFfRtffir>z/ ,y 7 t

^+ftU<, E#A L

0>ihffiI:'rLfr^( * f . jg, Ihffi?H e> b/Ll:1HfF

A U L l:, ifrffi77 Tirjt< r'fL< u. ( aTt. <L<tJ^ 6, El*ffii* L U< a 3' - )v t ? 0>+ ?ftH.

ht<<3(, El#affii*L U<a*hH<"fir, -fiqF!

/rbal-t:'fiHfL*f.t ) B# t z ?'y 7 o t=&>Eif,ffi o?ffilfttrH fH*ffii** L U< -6$ft L u.:. L iJ, /: ( A /,

fr> bifrfi)ta Fr. b E{Ltjts}'r. L v. r :. L ?f. /:L ZiJ, rg+ffii*trsr+b+86 Lv.) EEltSr( iI L r,.EA 3 'Lisu. 6 L/:'r L fH;^ L< 3 /: t U

* f . fr'ls-,o>ffi.e4 LTf it, ,ti - tvt+86=dtlfiH

AfrftIt 6attm,3 ( L* ->/:LTfr2. AAtt, ?{Ltt-r ( u. 6WH aB D/rv. L r,. ) a?f. a0> ffi.# A L t =, El *ffii* a ttkc L" L ls fri*,h: 4L b{Lbh'. t/.Ci /J"-f.;- > ?" . 2 e 'z 7?rJ.3rrpSfE L t-, 4 atfuWaf:bo>#rx.3 aH v. * U

/:. < U< , ,fl# 3 /, i:, t,r? $tEWt=#uR 3 ?zKt t -r ( u 6 r'. * l-/:. lol DE llliFt E\a+ , f?,t6 L'>alFtJcf.

DJBIi:, ,J',Ef+Tfhv.(v./::, L hrfr> I *fit,tFH i:i&&t(", v' 4v,4 /rH l:l** L+f u.+ U

6 rtv. * t_/:. fi-/- /"t4 +' t) zrij, <lsA U U t" rs7 tvV tv l^' y >" L ryU'* f . iF, b

iiffiHz > | a+rH b U(t,. 6h' b<'T. 4a+iJ*/J'4 ffi?, *jEA& t-HErL<7> | ar<"H r, A e fi{Llj /r b/sv.o)T, t < U Slfg UWb

[L?u. * t-t:. <L/:ATf iJ' <fuTJAO J , /r U AT L/:.

,63 r, t t)'f )v7 > t:E*n ?f ,.. flr*fFt^'( u. -: (, 4 a*,t:Ttfrts(" 3 * f . ftLtrJt t)

'l)v7 >aWt<at lt-Et(, r atLhr*iBA/..,C, a. a. t:*fr L ( ?3(v,6,J'3 rs#l|hl!trl:" j_r

L t,. v. * tu/:. <t",, L/J'ftt t xfu<, +ffib ? A,J' 3 /r$61:tr6

132 E##H 4?/? 2001-2

L, rE LE D j ) i:, t t)'l)v7 >at L" U l::7 > F A r.A'rt< fr>tf} ) iar t fz l- &i."A't

=t-/:. 2 iflffr 01 U t:.->A , + L" b 0>t t) ':l")v7 > .^

7> FAffilt6t, t'*LLfEc'v.(v.*L/:. :tLT, 4 0>Tl: , f aa+ L" { at t) ,y")v7 > :- -:

3 ( /t -t:h'r,*:Ba Lh't HEU< fr>If J ) r . .

->(,, /\lf :A^fL< 6t,r,.*Lt:. rn<:"4,.-.

t t) 'f )v, > aA L" U iJ, *jE 3 '1,

h' t'*W#tr-< ,-

:. i ,t: <)trF,i:H r'U(v. b tt. <a1*.<r.ilJ, f n#u'c3 3 /: FE A Lh:rfr 6 t 3 l:, Hi 1

UiUu./: I , ,ffiu./:'9 Lrr ( ls Y) * L/:.2 ) #i L u't#t{6frIj E J t, , zg 'y 7 o{EX ttffit6trffiqHIz/,y 7tJ, EAE Da L tt 6 : .:

? > ri r,l l3pfi b a L ir fr> Y) * f ,r, H*ffii*t,-u 77 4'l3 J ->a, 7/ .y Z b*nUu.frRffitf:t *n6 a L l: ts Y) * f . frLCJ a. fu*?l: /r"-+ -> ?"al+ 3 ls 7 / .y 7 Afit:/: ( a /,4v. * L -1"

\ffirkt: u + L r.,fts hr'y,4 ("f .

3 ) B#rftr,t,H*/nr7A[:85*2 atffiAhr.*6t/'ci :- rL* ?of;I,.ffi?, H*ffii*nrn'lY0>,8 +

A/." l3++l:Afi.hrfr> A a t t#,nL * U/:. E':t3 lJ 41{F!?/3 t,r frh:4 < , f/t\f U< L * vr f,---

("f L, /:/:-ftLr,.Lr,.)a.Llv) U, tr:=n*a fr> 6:. L br+ * fLA Mlfur' fr> 6 J ? rs'-xr- -* f. ("th'b, gr*txwt-l'#i-Ha 6 : :is, Z0>A/: b0> HH,L'Aiffi,E Art 6 a L l:---_irt *f. Eaa Lh,rrHv./:FaL-tt:, ,..-

Ux/,y7lt:I ( U< Utr-tAu.6aT, E*:"H( /:tt ttLbt:fr>If btLbalJ#9l:6 Lu.. -

v.) Ah:fr>t() *f.4 ) 7 l. v 7@+E;Ht'EtEa)rA[: /4 5

7 t) 7,t,,/ 2 - o J a Y e.'-'7t+f, ++ tr:z

'y t:4 ? - oE# 3 ,1, at*->*)J HlfrFrfu l: -> i .1

o"6Hl6hy41bfLf: J. L ,r fr> Y) * f . rc,o fr> 6F,;:L, /4 t'r ffiat.?Cj, ,B.A A LaRAIJ L' ) €' :"

t a/:a?f ,r, Wo>fr> 6fft,=,katk6, 7 )v"'4 ? - 0),BA 3 A a {r* )J'l+., rfg1'g t Gsor ;d

bt:. L rr? 3 /: L u. ) ffinfrE4rr'U /:4 ) 1'=

-t2--\--. --l _

-lt.l'

:.:=:-t:.:gF. L EF=J(

'+nr -_ - t- j--_- -- t

liiL:

iiiti

iut::!.19.

, ,,{l-

ff:

fr' 1

i|$,

riii

:,{j,i,,.lJil

Page 10: Japan Nursing Educators Journal

) '/'tv7 > o>* L' u i: :-

iar L t7 F Ai'.!:'t=r L*' { 0>t t) 'l)v7 > '-

L fEr v.( v. * L/:. .fLo>tt)'ftv7>i--'ir"ffiEU<fr>Illi t:'u. * l.-/:. t n<:" a -- .

b-E A /, h'b%Etta' '-

.u.,6 Ir. zcotA?"-

3/.,irrffibt 5l:, H-:

l(lsY)*L/:.t) , 7, 'v 7 Otffrtlt

B IA D., t tt b z':1i) *frs, H*ffii*r-.y7U*RLu.f;nffitT:

f{l* afL* ?t=fi-+ -

fr t:/: ( a 'LAv. * '' -:

E("f.,7AEEE*2 6ffiefi*1

'', H*ffii*rrE'l:ko>,= *

, Y- tW,n L * t-/:. f,'=;(, fit\ll.U< l--*uri'-r):Ljry u, tr11, {bFIfiJ hi fr> b I 't /s-^)' -

?xwt-##l3Ha 6:::'Aiffi,E 3rt b z L l:.-,; H l"r /3 F 0> I 2lt:,

! b->(r,. b7)T, H7-,itba;lJ+9 l:fiE Lt,'. -

!'tr o>rfrt=tt 6

e / u7t+c, ++l::nt+'>&h?!F1lftt l:'> ' '''b:fr>t) *f . rcOfr>b7-'t.

# 3 Lo>FAlt L" ) ig' -

b bffiey,atk#, 7 tv

'> * )7'l:8, &#'l:E t 65' -'i[

i Fff XfrERrr't' /:4 ) ::

: - tr"ljjt 3 v.?ffi. 7 t,v 7 ofr 6 U Lls--: :- 4 h'Tgfu* t/,. *)JH+lrs{rF["'J t++2 Lb

-- -_ r 4 /:&>lzlfr.->a ur /: frh t, ,Ba 3 /, o,- ,,:'rr,: {fr_) :. L rr(" 3 6 ATth'b. * /:, 7 tV

r a> -aEAz, tt:/I f'fubEF4WL;, 6 L 4 Z: f € 3 'l aBIt 5Trc,ht fr> - /: t l-/: b, WWo>

'r { =:f.u. ( Ifr,o>A L A: h'-> /:0, {& a#ll.F.

: ;. :LLCL* j -. LATEII 6:. LirrS *f.lryg+t,7"74rt>

€ry i'b H,*aF l:'U( U 7 'v / zt 6thh:fr>

;. lLt^C:El *fLb a LTE'L'L(E: (\,.: -ir("3*f. 'so8Li), 3->L<) r,.)l*

'H: lf+f[/j'L,ff,!.*f.n

=fi tgl+aFtHal a€ry n#o>{friJrf e >t[fr.-( U "*frkptsg.

: ,;i. i *rit. 5*t:,H(, *trft+ts€fr,&r&v.,

:=! ieru.(, ^+{e

a6u. & R C a. L is,L, Ht:.^,;f U t, 4 L?f .

y' tv-/ifrffic J U a 7l offiftlrrEl tlai_;. ?>'y--?>o)7u?7Attb a. L 6

= i L, 7(3 ls)"tv-Ttltfut:7u 2"7 A

4=i b:. L +) fr> Y) * f . ffii*H!*r *hXAJ.il': f):i lJrJ. E v, ? tV-7h: Lr Vr ATt hr, ffi'ht

r :- : :), H*ffii*+ hr zc a. t:, \/. /J ( ( u , wa;.:'ffi*H+tts*hflA ffi tcfft{*t A.. L r,:/s 0 *:

=.a 3 ,tr H j)?zJrrfi t t t_/: Y) El u. t (F-

. E -> /: Y) )Bv. /: Y) T 3 6 0)7, Vr? 6 ;ffr.:":.tif;E'tEhIr< t'./r ( ( 6t{*fsacf.t 1 AC) E t,l ,r, HAalie#-EHEfEt aAtnJ6=€ n7 7 > tt L 6 /:&>oWifr<, 'Y 7 o+

,t-- . E--nHiFA Lh.tr*n^0 ofr.aa LTxn 0 AL.:' - '. l*''trf, 'lHt:-fsr'.IRffiA+?t..4v,4fsg

_ * a +A L( t,. 6 o>?f ir, L" I t-/:6 t,. v. L

,1i = i h, t LX= t_/:a. L hrfr> r) * f. aA ffi,#

': '-;. #, t< UfiffittsEAf+'>av./:Lt'.)' :7. frAij, 4 o> )uo>*utr befitrr, -##Erctb' :. <offiffi,o+("B#A LhrEl-i:J. L, tT3 : : >- t+ra< h* L/:. < l-< h.affi, r j i'

-_ i). ) tro>/J"-f.: > )" / 77t:*Jn L *rt

Lh'tLr*r}.i.cl, aaLL -##l:, E\aW#.u) b

11 - ( v. 3 * t-t:. a. a ^a:,e--Hrsf;I,.$ft4

ffiv. /:Y) , -##[3+F L^ t U/: Y) |/:o)Ti .

e ) IRF,nE EHrESf 6tE# tt#.t, L, *fm tfrr-h.+t6*n ur,.fRd.i L +i'fr'TlJfi wtsfr|JiBt r,=/s v) * f . -E-

Raruifff 6. L i: U:lshr0 , qfftlfr.: /:€fih?\fsry-Fcj, figJft.--0)*hRb /s 3 v. aTt.

t;bDt=3 ( , &1*.1:fLtrs5A-61fl L /: u. o iJ, H*ffii**

Sn7 >f .t TIJ, EeA LA/:&>tt"fi_f.'=7)"t U< iJv. trlfsu. L r,. ) :. L 1"f. E#A LE;f; L h'tJ, frUiff l-<, ,8.# A Lhr fi - f'- > ?" t:

Rrft tt*c j ) l:fdl * U< ( /:'3 u..

4 U<, v' 4v, b rrrpfl A+F[ Lrs ( ( 6, Xrct3*Et:fr>6 U OT/J"-f'->?hrf 3 6t v.)a. L U Htt/svr(" ( /J'3 v.. ftHFz>3 'y 7l:l*fEAtE Zfuti, fErr& Z b Ot /) b:. L ,r(" 5 * f .

f/.rrfil: ->a. ur 6 iER o I: iJlH. eo):4 7'<'

f . i6g /rE 3 tctx ->a {HZ lJ", EA 3 /, iJ{6A

ffillf c:2.'4 7 AE U<tt'Hc:fEAil+ ( .. L rrr3 * f . Hv. lJ"-f.- > ?o>jER tffi,r'.?.H blsvr?, HiErs L a 4h'bI* U< ( /J'3 u..

* /: , Wir/r ( ( rrffiWJtffi->A, v'4v,4 /r:.L ir? 3 * f . H*ffii* l: lJ'Y,f Ert,Y,ry/a' L {J

+ Z/3 ur? ( /:'3 u.. t 3 rriH.H tf<ls ( ( U,

aFfrl:fr>62 u-+f-.,t,v?l:,ta r/3 ( f vr,1.

fL<, /\ y t' 7 )"tt Z J'v l' i' ft Z ) >7 A+F l-

*bf fLiJ, EAA &i* H fta*[tr]:f+'>arfr6a Lrs?3 *f. E+O7tv,ytl4 =-a)EAALtt, +r. bz\+t*.lc lj300n

^c:rgf b t v,b{L

( v. * f. * f trffi+fiEtt03F€ t>'>( u. b'84 l-ir, H*ffi't*o>+H ^,a|1fihtthe> r'fua a t tFfif+ U< v. * f.

oi.gfi*ft : El*tFi*:L,i-i-/L . 7 t) , >PAUL ALLISON P. O. Bor

8651, Victoria, BC, CANADA V8W 3S2

Fax : I-250- 477 -047 0( B +;FOK)e-mail: pe OK)

P*t-ruc A{-i-troN @SH.AU.,J. CA

E##H 4?/? 200r-2 133