Top Banner
!"# "% #%"&& ' ()*+,- ./%/0)12/34/0 3)05'%"6"%* "3 7"34/02'0%/3 89 '3"7' 3":)&/ #%';;)04 4<=>?@A <B %CDAEFDG 4?HI>AJ :?>>DID KLLM (N'NG #<@?B ;FAJDF OB<PDFJ<E9 QRRS 5N'NG *?FT OB<PDFJ<E9 QRRU ' %./#"# #O(5"%%/4 "3 V'0%"'& ;O&;"&&5/3% ); %./ 0/WO"0/5/3%# ;)0 %./ 4/20// ); 4):%)0 ); V."&)#)V.* <B %./ ;':O&%* ); 20'4O'%/ '34 V)#%4):%)0'& #%O4"/# X2DBYDFG 0AZDG #D[HA><E9G ABY #?Z<A> \HJE<ZD] %./ O3"6/0#"%* ); (0"%"#. :)&O5("' X6ABZ?HPDF] 4DZD@8DF QRKS ^ 'B<TA 3<Z?>D #EA__?FYG QRKS
277

Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Apr 02, 2023

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

!"#$"%$#%"&&$'$()*+,-$

./%/0)12/34/0$3)05'%"6"%*$"3$7"34/02'0%/3$

!

89$

'3"7'$3":)&/$#%';;)04$

$

4<=>?@A$<B$%CDAEFDG$4?HI>AJ$:?>>DID$KLLM$

(N'NG$#<@?B$;FAJDF$OB<PDFJ<E9$QRRS$

5N'NG$*?FT$OB<PDFJ<E9$QRRU$

$

'$%./#"#$#O(5"%%/4$"3$V'0%"'&$;O&;"&&5/3%$);$

%./$0/WO"0/5/3%#$;)0$%./$4/20//$);$

4):%)0$);$V."&)#)V.*$

$

<B$

$

%./$;':O&%*$);$20'4O'%/$'34$V)#%4):%)0'&$#%O4"/#$

X2DBYDFG$0AZDG$#D[HA><E9G$ABY$#?Z<A>$\HJE<ZD]$

%./$O3"6/0#"%*$);$(0"%"#.$:)&O5("'$

X6ABZ?HPDF]$

$

4DZD@8DF$QRKS$

^$'B<TA$3<Z?>D$#EA__?FYG$QRKS$

Page 2: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

""!

!

'8JEFAZE$$

!

#$"%!%&'()!*+,-".*%!*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%!3&,456!14,)6!2'00"2'4'-7!".!

8".(*09,0&*.!&$,&!:;05%!:"&$!,.(!,9,".%&!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!!#;!2;.('2&!

&$"%!0*%*,02$6!>!%1*.&!&$0**!-;.&$%!".!,!8".(*09,0&*.!24,%%0;;-!".!,!?,.2;'/*0!

1'@4"2!%2$;;4=!>.!,(("&";.!&;!2;.('2&".9!*/*0)(,)!;@%*0/,&";.%6!>!A,2"4"&,&*(!A;2'%!

90;'1%!:"&$!%&'(*.&%!,.(!".&*0/"*:%!:"&$!*('2,&;0%!@,%*(!;.!&$*"0!*+1*0"*.2*%!

14,..".9!,.(!&,5".9!1,0&!".!2'00"2'4'-!A;0!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)6!D.&"EF'44)".9<G".5!H$"0&!

C,)6!,.(!I;&$*0B%!C,)=!#$"%!2;-@".,&";.!;A!(,&,!"44'%&0,&*(!:,)%!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-%!@*2;-*!".%&"&'&";.,44)!0;'&"."J*(!".!8".(*09,0&*.!0*9,0(4*%%!;A!10;90*%%"/*!

("%&0"2&!%2$;;4!1;4"2"*%!,.(!&$*!;22,%";.,4!%1*2",4!*/*.&%!&$,&!("%2;'0,9*!

$;-;1$;@"2!@'44)".9=!!

KA!20"&"2,4!"-1;0&,.2*!&;!-)!,.,4)%"%!,0*!("%20*1,.2"*%!@*&:**.!("%2;'0%*!

,@;'&!!"#$!2$"4(0*.!,0*!3*=9=6!"..;2*.&6!-,%2'4".*6!A*-".".*7!,.(!:$,&!2$"4(0*.!%&!

:"&$".!&$*"0!14,)!,.(!%;2",4!".&*0,2&";.%=!H'2$!("%2;'0%*%!.*'&0,4"J*!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!

,.(!9*.(*0!2;.A;0-"&)!,%!,%*+',46!,.(!$)1*0E%*+',4"J*!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!

%'@M*2&"/"&"*%6!0*.(*0".9!&$*-!N".,110;10",&*O!".!8".(*09,0&*.=!I)!0*%*,02$!

%'99*%&%!&$,&!&$"%!.;0-,4"J*%!&$*!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4!%&,&'%!L';!:$"4*!;&$*0".9!

2$"4(0*.!:$;!-,)!.;&!A"&!:"&$".!&$*%*!4"-"&*(!1,0,-*&*0%=!#$"%!("%%*0&,&";.!

2;.&0"@'&*%!&;!*('2,&";.,4!,.(!20"&"2,4!2$"4($;;(!%&'("*%!&$,&!%**5!&;!'.(*0%&,.(!&$*!

0;'&*%!@)!:$"2$!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%&'(*.&%!,0*!"%;4,&*(!,.(!;%&0,2"J*(!:"&$".!

1'@4"2!%2$;;4!%;2",4!4"A*=!

Page 3: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

"""!

!

VFD_AZD$

!

#$"%!("%%*0&,&";.!"%!&$*!%;4*!".&*44*2&',4!:;05!;A!&$*!,'&$;0=!P;!1,0&!;A!&$*!

:;05!$,%!@**.!10*/";'%4)!1'@4"%$*(!,.(!,44!0*%*,02$!:,%!2;.('2&*(!".(*1*.(*.&4)=!

#$"%!0*%*,02$!"%!2;/*0*(!@)!&$*!F*$,/";'0,4!Q*%*,02$!R&$"2%!F0;,(!S*0&"A"2,&*!

.'-@*06!TUUEVVWWU!,.(!&$*!?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!F;,0(!Q*%*,02$!S;--"&&**=!! !

Page 4: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

"/!

!

%A8>D$?_$:?BEDBEJ$

'8JEFAZE$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$<<!

VFD_AZD$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$<<<!

%A8>D$?_$:?BEDBEJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$<P!

'ZTB?`>DYI@DBEJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$P<<<!

"BEF?YHZE<?B$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$K!

)PDFP<D`$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$S!

0DJDAFZC$:?BED[E$ABY$0AE<?BA>D$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$a!

0DJDAFZC$WHDJE<?BJ$<B$:?BED[E$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KS!

59$VFDJDBZD$<B$ECD$:>AJJF??@$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QQ!

:CA=EDF$)PDFP<D`J$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$Qa!

:CA=EDF$)BD,$%CD?FDE<ZA>$;FA@D`?FT$ABY$:?BEF<8HE<?BJ$E?$&<EDFAEHFDSQ!

"BEF?YHZE<?B$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$SQ!

7D9$%DF@J$ABY$"B_>HDBZDJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$SQ!

:?BEF<8HE<?BJ$E?$/[<JE<BI$&<EDFAEHFD$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$ab!

:?BZ>HJ<?B$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$bb!

:CA=EDF$%`?,$:ABAY<AB$VH8><Z$#ZC??>J$<B$:?BED[EG$4<JFH=E<BI$"YDA><cDY$

VAJEJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$bM!

"BEF?YHZE<?B$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$bM!

2DBYDFDY$:?>?B<A><J@$ABY$ECD$/FAJHFD$?_$'8?F<I<BA>$:H>EHFDJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$bL!

;D@<B<cAE<?B$?_$/YHZAE<?B$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$MR!

:?BZ>HJ<?B$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$ML!

Page 5: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

/!

!

:CA=EDF$%CFDD,$5DEC?Y?>?I<DJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$LK!

"BEF?YHZE<?B,$VF?P<BZ<A>$'ZE<P<J@$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$LK!

#EHY9$)PDFP<D`$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$LS!

%DAZCDFJd$OB<?B$ABY$#ZC??>$#D>DZE<?B$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$Le!

5DEC?Y?>?I<ZA>$"B_>HDBZDJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KRK!

"BEDFP<D`J$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KRa!

)8JDFPAE<?BJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KKR!

;?ZHJ$2F?H=J$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KKa!

4AEA$'BA>9J<J$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KQS!

:?BZ>HJ<?B$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KQb!

:CA=EDF$;?HF,$.DEDF?JD[HA><E9$AJ$/PDF9YA9$&<_D,$/[A@<B<BI$!"BB?ZDBZD-

$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KQM!

"BEF?YHZE<?B$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KQM!

fCAE$fAJ$#A<Y$'8?HE$:C<>YFDB+$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KSR!

fCAE$fAJ$4D=<ZEDY$<B$ECD$:>AJJF??@+$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KSb!

fCAE$fDFD$:C<>YFDB$4?<BI+$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KeK!

fCAE$fDFD$:C<>YFDB$#A9<BI+$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KeL!

:?BZ>HJ<?B$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KaU!

:CA=EDF$;<PD,$WHDDFBDJJ$AJ$A$#=DZ<A>$/PDBE,$/[A@<B<BI$!4<__DFDBZD-$

4<JZ?HFJD$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KaL!

"BEF?YHZE<?B$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KaL!

:H>EHFA>$:><@AED$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KbK!

V<BT$4A9$/PDBEJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KbM!

Page 6: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

/"!

!

:?BZ>HJ<?B$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KMK!

:CA=EDF$#<[,$4?I$:C<>YFDB$ABY$2DBYDF$:F?JJ<BI$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KMS!

"BEF?YHZE<?B$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KMS!

5?YD><BI$0DJ=DZE$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KMa!

;DD><BI$&<TD$A$2<F>$"BJ<YD$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KLR!

!%C?JD$fC?$;DD>$%CD9$'FD$4?IJ-$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$KLU!

0A>>9<BI$ABY$f??Y$:C<=J$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QRa!

:?BZ>HJ<?B$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QKR!

:?BZ>HJ<?B$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QKQ!

0DJDAFZC$;<BY<BIJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QKS!

"@=><ZAE<?BJ$?_$0DJDAFZC$;<BY<BIJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QKa!

#HIIDJE<?BJ$_?F$:CABID$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QKU!

G$"4;%;1$)X!S$,44*.9".9!&$*!C;'@4*!H&,.(,0(!,.(!Q*2;9."J".9!S$"4(0*.B%!

D9*.2)!=============================================================================================================================================!YUZ!

H&0'2&'0,4!S$,.9*%X!F,&$0;;-%!,.(!G0;.;'.%!=============================================================!YUZ!

G*(,9;9)!,.(!S'00"2'4'-!======================================================================================================!YUW!

G0;A*%%";.,4!C*/*4;1-*.&!,.(!G,0*.&,4!R('2,&";.!====================================================!YYV!

'FDAJ$_?F$;HFECDF$0DJDAFZC$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QQK!

;<BA>$%C?HICEJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QQa!

(<8><?IFA=C9$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QQM!

'==DBY<[$',$;?ZHJ$2F?H=$#EAFEDF$WHDJE<?BJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QeM!

"B<E<A>$;?ZHJ$2F?H=$#EAFEDF$WHDJE<?BJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QeM!

?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!H,-14*!L'*%&";.%!======================================================================================!Y[Z!

Page 7: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

/""!

!

D.&"EF'44)".9!C,)!H,-14*!\'*%&";.%!=================================================================================!Y[W!

I;&$*0B%!C,)!H,-14*!\'*%&";.%!==========================================================================================!Y]V!

'>EDFBAED$;?ZHJ$2F?H=$#EAFEDF$WHDJE<?BJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QaK!

?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!============================================================================================================================!Y]U!

G".5!C,)!=========================================================================================================================================!Y]U!

I;&$*0B%!C,)!================================================================================================================================!Y]Y!

'==DBY<[$(,$#A@=>D$"BEDFP<D`$#EAFEDF$WHDJE<?BJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QaS!

%DAZCDF$ABY$#EHYDBE$#H==?FE$f?FTDF$#EAFEDF$WHDJE<?BJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QaS!

#A@=>D$'8?F<I<BA>$/BCABZD@DBE$f?FTDF$"BEDFP<D`$#EAFEDF$WHDJE<?BJ$NNNNN$Qae!

#A@=>D$'Y@<B<JEFAE<?B$"BEDFP<D`$#EAFEDF$WHDJE<?BJ$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$Qaa!

'==DBY<[$:,$#A@=>D$:?BJDBE$;?F@J$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$Qab!

VAFDBEA>$:?BJDBE$;?F@$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$Qab!

%DAZCDF$:?BJDBE$;?F@$NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN$QbQ!

! !

Page 8: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

/"""!

!

!

'ZTB?`>DYI@DBEJ$

!

!

#$"%!:;05!:;'4(!$,/*!@**.!"-1;%%"@4*!:*0*!"&!.;&!A;0!&$*!&"-*6!(*("2,&";.6!

,.(!*+1*0&"%*!;A!-)!D(/"%;0)!S;--"&&**X!C0=!I;.,!^4*,%;.6!C0=!F*25"!Q;%%6!,.(!C0=!

S4,'(",!Q'"&*.@*09=!>!;AA*0!$*,0&A*4&!&$,.5%!&;!,44!;A!&$*-=!>!2;'.&!-)%*4A!*+2**(".94)!

A;0&'.,&*!&;!$,/*!$,(!C0=!I;.,!^4*,%;.!,%!,!H'1*0/"%;06!$*0!-*.&;0%$"1!&$0;'9$;'&!

-)!G$C_'1!&;!,.(!".24'(".9!&$*!("%%*0&,&";.!$,%!@**.!"./,4',@4*=!

!

#$"%!10;2*%%!$,%!,4%;!".24'(*(!,!90*,&!(*,4!;A!1*&"&";.".9!A0"*.(%!,.(!4;/*(!

;.*%!A;0!10;;A0*,(".9!%'11;0&=!`*%%"2,!C*0).256!`,25"*!C";.6!8,&)!R".@4,'6!8,0).!

R44"%6!Q;@".!T,.(6!I*9,.!T,00"%6!D(0"*..*!T"446!8"-!I28,)6!T*,&$*0!I"&2$*446!H,0,$!

Q'(0'-6!,.(!a".(%,)!b*4&*06!$,/*!0*1*,&*(4)!;AA*0*(!&$;'9$&A'4!A**(@,256!5**.!

*)*%!A;0!&)1;%6!,.(!1,&"*.&!4"%&*.".9!&;!2;1";'%!@0,".%&;0-%=!I,.)!&$,.5%c!

!

>!,-!90,&*A'4!&;!&$*!%2$;;4!&$,&!:*42;-*(!&$"%!%&'()=!>!,110*2",&*!&$*!-'%"2!

&*,2$*0B%!*AA;0&%!&;!%*&!'1!&$*!14,2*-*.&6!&$*!&"-*!;AA*0*(!@)!,(-"."%&0,&";.!

,%%"%&,.&%6!,.(!&$*!24,%%0;;-!&*,2$*0B%!2;-A;0&,@4*!;1*..*%%!&;!-)!1,0&"2"1,&";.=!

#$*!%2$;;4!10".2"1,46!%&'(*.&!&*,2$*06!%'11;0&!:;05*06!,.(!,@;0"9".,4!*.$,.2*-*.&!

:;05*06!,44!-,(*!/,4',@4*!2;.&0"@'&";.%!;A!&$*"0!10;A*%%";.,4!*+1*0&"%*=!#$"%!%&'()!

:;'4(!.;&!$,/*!@**.!1;%%"@4*!:"&$;'&!&$*!2;.%*.&!;A!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!1,0*.&%!;0!&$*!

1,0&"2"1,&";.!;A!&$*!%&'(*.&%!:$;!"./"&*(!-*!".&;!&$*"0!:;04(%!,.(!*.&$'%",%&"2,44)!

%$,0*(!&$*"0!/"*:%=!

!

>!90,&*A'44)!,25.;:4*(9*!&$*!%'11;0&!;A!&$*!H;2",4!H2"*.2*%!,.(!T'-,."&"*%!

Q*%*,02$!S;'.2"46!`;%*1$ED0-,.(!F;-@,0("*0!S,.,(",.!^0,(',&*!C;2&;0,4!

H2$;4,0%$"16!A;0!A'.(".9!-)!(;2&;0,4!(*90**'

Page 9: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U!

!

"BEF?YHZE<?B$

Nb,&2$!;'&!A;0!$*06O!>!:,%!&;4(6!NH$*!"%!0*,44)!.**()!,.(!(*1*.(*.&=!!H$*B(!

0,&$*0!M'%&!24".9!&;!$*0!%'11;0&!:;05*0!&$,.!".&*90,&*!:"&$!$*0!1**0%_(;.B&!4*&!$*0!

9*&!,:,)!:"&$!"&=O!!>&!:,%!,-;.9!-)!A"0%&!:**5%!,%!,!H&'(*.&!H'11;0&!b;05*0!:"&$!

?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4%=!#$*!2$"4(!".!L'*%&";.!:,%!,!%&'(*.&!:"&$!,!A0,9"4*!@;.*!2;.("&";.!

:$;-!>!:,%!&;!:,&2$!24;%*4)!('0".9!0*2*%%!,.(!4'.2$!,%!1,0&!;A!-)!("%,@"4"&)!

%'11;0&!0;4*=!!!

D4&$;'9$!>!0*-,".*(!%5*1&"2,4!;A!&$"%!(*%20"1&";.6!>!:,%!.;&!*+1*2&".9!&$*!

/*0@;%*6!&$*,&0"2,46!,.(!L'"05)!%*/*.E!)*,0E;4(!:$;-!>!%'@%*L'*.&4)!-*&=!!K/*0!&$*!

2;'0%*!;A!-)!14,2*-*.&6!>!@*9,.!&;!.;&"2*!&$"%!%&'(*.&!&'0.!(;:.!;AA*0%!&;!M;".!

9,-*%!:"&$!&$*"0!1**0%=!U!!DA&*0!10;-1&".96!&$*)!M;".*(!,!9,-*!;.4)!&;!2;-*!@,25!

;/*0!&;!-*!,.(!%"9$6!ND."5,6!&$*)B0*!14,)".9!A,"0"*%cO!!b$*.!>!;@%*0/*(!&$,&!&$*)!

(;.B&!4"5*!&;!14,)!A,"0"*%6!&$*)!*+24,"-*(6!NP;c!!>!:,.&!&;!@*!,!@;)cO!!P;&!@*".9!%'0*!

:$*0*!&$"%!:,%!2;-".9!A0;-6!>!0*14"*(!&$,&!&$*0*!,0*!@;)%!:$;!4;/*!14,)".9!A,"0"*%!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

U!>!,-!1,0&"2"1,&".9!".!,!2'%&;-!;A!'%".9!N&$*)O!,.(!N&$*"0O!,%!,!%".9'4,06!9*.(*0E

.*'&0,4!10;.;'.!,%!>!,-!'.2*0&,".!:$*&$*0!&$"%!2$"4(!10*A*00*(!9*.(*0!10;.;'.%!

:"&$".!&$*!-,4*EA*-,4*!@".,0)=!!

!

!

!

!

!

Page 10: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y!

!

,.(!9"04%!:$;!$,&*!14,)".9!A,"0"*%6!@'&!&$,&!"&!:,%!,4%;!;5,)!&;!:,.&!&;!@*!,!

@;)=!!#$*"0!(*4"9$&!'1;.!$*,0".9!&$"%!:,%!1,41,@4*=!!#$*)!&$*.!,11*,0*(!&;!%**5!

;11;0&'."&"*%!&;!$,/*!&$"%!*+2$,.9*!,9,"._%,)".9!&$*)!:,.&*(!&;!@*!,!@;)!,.(!&$*.!

4;;5".9!,&!-*!*+1*2&,.&4)=!#$*!%&'(*.&B%!*+10*%%";.!;A!&$*"0!9*.(*0!.;.2;.A;0-"&)!

&$*.!90*:!".!@;&$!A0*L'*.2)!,.(!&$*,&0"2,4"&)X!&$"%!".24'(*(!,!%1*2&,2'4,0!*+*2'&";.!

;A!,!N-)!-;-!@0"@*(!-*!&;!:*,0!,!(0*%%!;.!1"2&'0*!(,)O!%&;-1!&$0;'9$!&$*!$,44%6!,%!

:*44!,%!,!0"/*&".9!1*0A;0-,.2*!;A!N#$*!H*20*&!F;)!P,-*!C,.2*O!31*0A;0-*(!@)!&$*!

%&'(*.&!,.(!&$*"0!@*%&!A0"*.(!:$*.!>!,%5*(!"A!&$*0*!:,%!,!@;)!.,-*!&$,&!&$*)!:;'4(!

10*A*0!&;!@*!2,44*(!,.(!:,%!".A;0-*(!&$,&!&$*0*!:,%!@'&!"&!:,%!,!%*20*&_:"&$!,!

(,.2*!&$,&!A;44;:*(7=!!

DA&*0!,!A*:!:**5%6!&$"%!%&'(*.&!$,(!24*,04)!(*2"(*(!&$,&!>!:,%!,!2;E

2;.%1"0,&;0!".!&$*"0!0*%"%&,.2*!&;!&$*!10*%%'0*!&;!2;.A;0-!&;!N9"04O!,%%;2",&*(!%;2",4!

14,)=!K.*!(,)!&$*)!2,-*!'1!&;!-*6!0'@@".9!&$*"0!$,.(%!&;9*&$*0!,%!"A!14;&&".96!,.(!

,..;'.2*(6!N%;6!&$*)B0*!14,)".9!@;)%!2$,%*!9"04%=O!!

Nd$!;$6O!:,%!-)!&$;0;'9$4)!9*.'".*!0*%1;.%*6!N:$,&!%$;'4(!:*!(;!,@;'&!

&$,&eO!!#$*)!0,"%*(!;.*!A".9*0!".!&$*"0!'%',4!:,)!;A!-,5".9!10;24,-,&";.%=!!N>!&$".56O!

&$*)!10;.;'.2*(6!N>!:"44!&*44!&$*-!&$,&!,.);.*!2,.!14,)!,.)!1,0&=O!

>!:,&2$*(!A0;-!,!("%&,.2*!,%!&$*)!,%%*0&*(!&$,&!&$*)!:*0*!N;.!&$*!2$,%".9!

&*,-=O!!>!:,&2$*(!,%!%;-*!;A!&$*!@;)%!%&,0&*(!&;!2;-*!&;!&$*!;1".";.!&$,&!@*".9!

2$,%*(!%**-*(!&;!@*!,!9;;(!(*,4!,.(!2,44*(!;'&6!N.;:!>B-!;.!&$*!2$,%*E-*!

&*,-=O!!#$*!%&'(*.&!2,-*!@,25!@*,-".9!,%!>!2;.90,&'4,&*(!&$*-=!!NC"(!);'!.;&"2*6O!>!

1;".&*(!;'&6!N.;&!;.4)!("(!);'!A".(!,!:,)!&;!-,5*!&$*!9,-*!A"&!A;0!);'6!);'!(;".9!

Page 11: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

f!

!

&$,&!-,(*!"&!;5,)!A;0!;&$*0!1*;14*!&;!14,)!&$*!9,-*!&$*!:,)!&$*)!:,.&*(!&;e!!g;'!

2$,.9*(!&$*!9,-*cO!!

N>!5.;:cO!#$*)!2,44*(!;'&6!$,.(%!&$0;:.!".!&$*!,"0_(0,-,&"2!

*-1$,%"%=!!DA&*0!&$,&!(,)6!&$*!%&'(*.&!.;!4;.9*0!%&'25!&;!-)!%"(*6!,.(!".%&*,(!

,22*1&*(!"./"&,&";.%!A0;-!1**0%!&;!M;".!%;2",4!9,-*%=!

(#$"%!*+2$,.9*!%1*,5%!&;!&$*!%'@&4*!:,)%!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!2,.!@*!*.,2&*(!,.(!

2$,44*.9*(!:"&$".!,.!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4!%*&&".9=!#$*!*+2$,.9*%!,-;.9!,!2$"4(6!A*44;:!

*('2,&;0%6!,.(!-)%*4A!1;".&!&;!,.!*+24'%";.,0)!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*!&$,&!

10"/"4*9*%!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!@*$,/";'0!,.(!,&&"&'(*%=!!S$"4(0*.!:$;!A,"4!&;!

4"/*!'1!&;!%'2$!.;0-%!0'.!&$*!0"%5!;A!@*".9!4,@*4*(!,%!%;-*$;:!A4,:*(!;0!!

N,@.;0-,46O!0*%'4&".9!".!&$*"0!%;2",4!"%;4,&";.=!P;.*!;A!&$*!:,)%!&$*!2$"4(!:,%!

(*%20"@*(!&;!-*!$,(!,.)&$".9!&;!(;!:"&$!@0*,5".9!9*.(*0!.;0-%!.;0!:,%!&$*!:,)!

-)!2;44*,9'*!(*%20"@*(!&$*-!1,0&!;A!;AA"2",4!*('2,&";.,4!&*+&%6!2'00"2'4'-6!;0!1;4"2)=!!

>&!$,11*.*(!".!".A;0-,4!-;-*.&%!@*&:**.!%&,AA6!@*&:**.!%&,AA!,.(!%&'(*.&6!,.(!

@*&:**.!%&'(*.&%!3".!&$*!2,%*!;A!N#$*!H*20*&!F;)!P,-*!C,.2*O7=!!>&!:,%!&$*%*!

;22'00*.2*%!&$,&!".%1"0*(!&$*!10*-"%*!'1;.!:$"2$!&$"%!0*%*,02$!10;M*2&!"%!@,%*(=!!

)PDFP<D`$

#$"%!("%%*0&,&";.!*+14;0*%!*/*0)(,)!9*.(*0!10,2&"2*%!3&,456!14,)6!2'00"2'4'-7!

&$,&!*%&,@4"%$!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!2'4&'0*!".!,!8".(*09,0&*.!24,%%0;;-=!>!,09'*!

&$,&!("%2;'0%*%!;A!2$"4(0*.B%!)**&+,*+,!,.(!("%2;'0%*%!;A!%)--,.,*+,!:;05!&;9*&$*0!&;!

.;0-,4"J*!0"9"(4)!9*.(*0*(!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)6!2;-1*44".9!2$"4(0*.!&;!2;.A;0-!&;!%'2$!

Page 12: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

[!

!

.;0-%!;0!A,2*!%;2",4!;&$*0".9!".!&$*!A;0-!;A!"%;4,&";.!,.(!1*0%*2'&";.!A;0!&$*"0!

2$,0,2&*0"%&"2%!&$,&!(;!.;&!A"&!:"&$".!&$*!%&0"2&!@;'.(,0"*%!;A!.;0-,42)=!!

#$"%!10;M*2&!"%!@,%*(!;.!&$0**!-;.&$%!;A!*&$.;90,1$"2!0*%*,02$!2;.('2&*(!

:"&$!,!?,.2;'/*0!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4!8".(*09,0&*.!24,%%!".!YVUY=!!#$*!0*%*,02$!:,%!

2;-1;%*(!;A!;@%*0/,&";.%6!A;2'%!90;'1%!:"&$!%&'(*.&%6!,.(!".&*0/"*:%!:"&$!

*('2,&;0%=!#$*!A;2'%!90;'1%!:"&$!%&'(*.&%!,.(!".&*0/"*:%!:"&$!*('2,&;0%!*+14;0*(!

14,..".9!A;0!,.(!0*%1;.%*%!&;!,2&"/"&"*%!;.!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)6!D.&"!F'44)".9<G".5!H$"0&!

C,)6!,.(!I;&$*0B%!C,)=!#$*!%1*2",4!;22,%";.!(,)%B!0*%1*2&"/*!A;2'%!;.!4;/*6!

("AA*0*.2*6!,.(!A,-"4)6!0*%'4&*(!".!-)!9,&$*0".9!0"2$!(,&,!;.!9*.(*0!.;0-%!".!&$*!

24,%%0;;-!,.(!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*=!#$"%!2;-@".,&";.!;A!(,&,!,4%;!"44'%&0,&*%!("%20*1,.2"*%!

@*&:**.!:$,&!:,%!%,"(!,@;'&!2$"4(0*.!3*=9=6!&$*"0!"..;2*.2*7!,.(!$;:!2$"4(0*.!

.,/"9,&*!&$*"0!1'@4"2!%2$;;4!%;2",4!4"/*%!".!2;-14*+!:,)%=!

I)!,110;,2$!(0,:%!A0;-!A*-"."%&6!,.&"E0,2"%&6!L'**06!,.(!20"&"2,4!("%,@"4"&)!

&$*;0)!,.(!,.,4)J*%!&$*!0;4*!;A!24,%%E@,%*(!.;0-%!".!-)!%&'()=!#$*!10;M*2&!".24'(*%!

%&;0"*%!A0;-!A"*4(:;05!.;&*%!;.!24,%%0;;-!,2&"/"&"*%6!/"9.*&&*%!A0;-!A;2'%!90;'1%!

&$,&!"44'%&0,&*!2$"4(0*.B%!*.9,9*-*.&!:"&$!&$*%*!,2&"/"&"*%6!,.(!".&*0/"*:%!:"&$!

*('2,&;0%!:$;!0*A4*2&!;.!&$*"0!10;2*%%!,.(!1*(,9;9)=!#$0;'9$;'&!&$*!(,&,!,.,4)%"%!

10;2*%%6!>!*+,-".*(!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!".!&$*!10"-,0)!)*,0%!;A!1'@4"2!*('2,&";.!".!,!:,)!

&$,&!(;*%!.;&!(*.)!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!A;0!);'.9!1*;14*=!#$"%!

2;.%&*44,&";.!;A!(,&,!,.(!,.,4)%"%!2;.&0"@'&*%!&;!20"&"2,4!2$"4($;;(!%&'("*%!,.(!

*('2,&";.,4!%2$;4,0%$"1!;.!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!%;2",4!".24'%";.!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!!

Page 13: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

]!

!

0DJDAFZC$:?BED[E$ABY$0AE<?BA>D$

h0;-!%2$;;4!@;,0(%!@,..".9!@;;5%!:"&$!2$,0,2&*0%!".!%,-*E%*+!0*4,&";.%$"1%!

&;!10;&*%&%!:$*.!%2$;;4!@;,0(%!,(;1&!,.&"E$;-;1$;@",!1;4"2"*%6!0*,2&";.%!&;!

-;/*-*.&%!&;:,0(!0*('2".9!$;-;1$;@",<$*&*0;%*+"%-!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!$,/*!

0*2*"/*(!-'2$!1;1'4,0!,.(!,2,(*-"2!,&&*.&";.!%".2*!&$*!-"(EUWWV%!3D%&6!F'05*6!

C'5*6!`,-"4!,.(!T,01*06!I,2".&;%$6!G,%2;*6!H,4*0.;6!#,)4;0!*&!,4=6!b"45".%;.!,.(!

G*,0%;.7=!!>.!UWWi!&$*!H'00*)!H2$;;4!F;,0(!3,!4,09*!%2$;;4!("%&0"2&!".!&$*!h0,%*0!

?,44*)6!.*,0!?,.2;'/*07!@,..*(!&$0**!@;;5%!:"&$!N9,)O!A,-"4"*%!0*%'4&".9!".!4*9,4!

2,%*%!&$,&6!;/*0!-,.)!)*,0%6!:*0*!2$,44*.9*(!A0;-!4;2,4!&;!%'10*-*!2;'0&%!3H&,AA;0(!

YVVi7=!S;--'."&)!-**&".9%!,.(!2;'0&!$*,0".9%!(*@,&*(!:$*&$*0!"&!:;'4(!(,-,9*!

2$"4(0*.!&;!@*!,:,0*!;A!A,-"4"*%!:"&$!N$;-;%*+',4O!-*-@*0%!3)/)%7=Y!!T;:*/*06!

0*2*.&!,25.;:4*(9-*.&!;A!&$*!0*4,&";.%$"1!@*&:**.!$;-;1$;@"2!@'44)".9!,.(!

L'**0!);'&$!%'"2"(*%!$,%!@**.!&,5*.!'1!@)!1'@4"2!A"9'0*%!,%!("/*0%*!,%X!S,.,(",.!

1;4"&"2,4!%,&"0"%&!Q"25!I*02*0j!FS!I"."%&0)!Q*10*%*.&,&"/*!A;0!S$"4(0*.!,.(!g;'&$6!

I,0)!R44*.!#'01*4!a,A;.(j!D-*0"2,.!2;4'-."%&!C,.!H,/,9*6!,.(!&,45!%$;:!$;%&!R44*.!

C*^*.*0*%=!R,2$!$,/*!(0,:.!-*(",!,&&*.&";.!&;!&$*!1;%%"@"4"&)!&$,&!(*.)".9!L'**0!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Y!>!'%*!L';&*%!,0;'.(!N9,)O!,.(!N$;-;%*+',4O!,%!&$"%!:,%!&$*!4,.9',9*!'%*(!".!&$*!

(*@,&*%!0*9,0(4*%%!;A!:$*&$*0!;0!.;&!-,.)!A,-"4"*%!'%*!&$,&!4,.9',9*!&;!(*%20"@*!

&$*-%*4/*%=!#$*!&*0-!N$;-;%*+',4O!$,%!@**.!-;@"4"J*(!".!:*%&*0.!%&'("*%!".!

%*+',4"&"*%!,.(!9*.(*0%!&$0;'9$!&$*!1,&$;4;9"J".96!-*("2,4"J*(!9,J*!;A!%*+;4;9"2,4!

,.(!1%)2$;,.,4)&"2!&$*;0"*%_A0;-!I,9.'%!T"0%2$A*4(!,.(!Q"2$,0(!?;.!80,AA&ER@".9!

&;!H"9-'.(!h0*'(=!I,.)!1*;14*!0*M*2&!&$*!24"."2,4!2;..;&,&";.%!;A!&$*!&*0-!,.(!(;!

.;&!A".(!"&!0*A4*2&"/*!;A!&$*"0!"(*.&"&"*%=!>.!,(("&";.6!-,.)!1*;14*!:$;!,0*!90;'1*(!

'.(*0!&$*!2,&*9;0)!N9,)O!'%*!;&$*0!&*0-".;4;9)!3*=9=!4*%@",.6!()5*6!L'**07=!!

Page 14: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

k!

!

*+"%&*.2*!,.(!A,"4".9!&;!,((0*%%!".%&"&'&";.,4!$;-;1$;@",!"%!,2&',44)!:$,&!2,'%*%!

(,-,9*=f!

Q*1;0&%!;A!);'&$!%'"2"(*%!('*!&;!$;-;1$;@"2!@'44)".9!$,/*!@**.!A*,&'0*(!".!

&$*!.*:%!;/*0!&$*!1,%&!A*:!)*,0%!,.(!$,/*!%1,05*(!>.&*0.*&EA;2'%*(!2,-1,"9.%!

%'2$!,%!C,.!H,/,9*B%!N>&!^*&%!F*&&*0O!10;M*2&!:$"2$!0*,%%'0*%!L'**0!);'&$!&$,&!,('4&!

L'**0!4"A*!"%!A,0!@*&&*0!&$,.!4"A*!".!$"9$!%2$;;4=[!I)0",(!".("/"(',4%6!90;'1%6!,.(!

2;01;0,&";.%!&;;5!'1!&$"%!2,-1,"9.=!#$*!Q;),4!S,.,(",.!I;'.&*(!G;4"2*!3QSIG7!

9,0."%$*(!-'2$!".&*0.*&!,&&*.&";.!&$0;'9$!&$*"0!N>&!^*&%!@*&&*0O!/"(*;!".!:$"2$!9,)!

,.(!4*%@",.!QSIG!*-14;)**%!A0;-!,20;%%!&$*!2;'.&0)!".&0;('2*!&$*-%*4/*%6!&*44!

&$*"0!%&;0"*%!,@;'&!$;:!&$*)!A"0%&!5.*:!&$*)!:*0*!9,)!;0!4*%@",.6!@'44)".9!&$*)!

*+1*0"*.2*(!90;:".9!'1!3".24'(".9!,!4,25!;A!0;4*!-;(*4%76!2;-".9!;'&6!,.(!A".,44)!

&$*"0!2'00*.&!1;%"&"/*!0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!A0"*.(%6!A,-"4)6!,.(!4;/*(!;.*%!3NQSIG!".!

/"(*;!&*44!9,)!);'&$!l>&!^*&%!F*&&*0Xl!?"(*;!;.!g;'#'@*!A*,&'0*%!".&*0/"*:%!:"&$!F=S=!

I;'.&"*%!%$,0".9!);'&$!%&0'994*%O7=]!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

f!#$*!,@;/*E-*.&";.*(!".("/"(',4%!,.(!,9*.2"*%!$,/*!%1;5*.!;'&!".!.'-*0;'%!

-*(",!%*&&".9%6!&:;!;A!:$"2$!2,.!@*!A;'.(!".!&$*!A;44;:".9X!

3$&&1X<<;&&,:,=;1*.A"4*=2,<@4;9<2'0,&;0E@4;9<2'0,&*(E.*:%<YVUU<(,.E%,/,9*E

&$".5%E&;0"*%E/"(*;EM,-"*E$'@4*)E:,%E4*,%&E&$*)E2;'4(7!,.(!

3$&&1X<<:::=);'&'@*=2;-<:,&2$e/mnFE$?b\.MMI7=![#$*!>&!^*&%!F*&&*0!G0;M*2&!%1,05*(!-'2$!-*(",!,.(!,2&"/"%&!0*%1;.%*!".24'(".9!FS!

Q*10*%*.&,&"/*!A;0!S$"4(0*.!,.(!g;'&$B%!>&!^*&%!F*&&*0!G0;M*2&!

3$&&1X<<:::=02)@2=2,<2;.&*.&<$;-*=,%17!,.(!2;'.&*0E10;M*2&%!%'2$!,%!&$*!I,5*!"&!

F*&&*0!3$&&1X<<:::=-,5*"&@*&&*010;M*2&=;09<7=!]!N>&!^*&%!F*&&*0O!$,%!@**.!20"&"L'*(!A;0!,%%'-".9!&$,&!*/*0);.*!"%!,@4*!&;!2$,.9*!

&$*"0!A'&'0*%6!:$"2$!"%!;A&*.!4".5*(!&;!-;@"4"&)!,AA;0(*(!&;!&$;%*!:"&$!0,2",4"J*(!,.(!

24,%%!10"/"4*9*=!#$*!A;44;:".9!%;'02*%!&,5*!'1!&$*%*!"%%'*%!".!-;0*!(*1&$X!8"05!

^0*%$,-6!Nh0;-!K.*!b$"&*!^,)!I,4*!&;!D.;&$*0X!S,44".9!;'&!&$*!>-14"2"&!Q,2"%-!".!

C,.!H,/,9*l%!oa"@*0,4B!G;4"&"2%!p!&$*!o>&!9*&%!@*&&*0B!S,-1,"9.=q!0",(1,2)*)3$(4).,=!YZ$

Page 15: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

i!

!

T;:*/*06!);'&$!2,..;&!,4:,)%!*.('0*!&$*!4*/*4%!;A!$,0,%%-*.&!&$*)!

*+1*0"*.2*!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!'.&"4!&$*)!90,(',&*!,.(!2,.!A".(!;'&!"A!&$*"0!%"&',&";.!

:"446!".!A,2&6!9*&!@*&&*0=!>.!K2&;@*0!YVUU6!`,-"*!T'@4*)6!,!9,)!&**.!".!K&&,:,6!*.(*(!

$"%!4"A*!('*!&;!$;-;1$;@"2!@'44)".9=!T*!"%!0*1;0&*(!&;!$,/*!@4;99*(!&$,&!$*!2;'4(.B&!

9;!;.!".!&$*!A,2*!;A!.;&!@*4"*/".9!&$".9%!2;'4(!,2&',44)!9*&!@*&&*0!3F'05*7=!T'@4*)!"%!

2"&*(!,%!$,/".9!@4;99*(6!!N>!0*,44)!:,.&!&;!*.(!"&=!a"5*!,44!;A!"&6!>!.;&!9*&&".9!@*&&*0!

&$*0*%!f!-;0*!)*,0%!;A!$"9$%2$;;4!4*A&6q!$*!:0;&*O!3I,'0;7=!Q"25!I*02*0!0*%1;.(*(!

&;!.*:%!;A!T'@4*)B%!%'"2"(*!:"&$!,!N0,.&O!;.!$"%!#?!%$;:6!".!:$"2$!$*!%&,&*(!%&0;.94)!

&$,&6!N>&l%!.;!4;.9*0!9;;(!*.;'9$!A;0!'%!&;!&*44!5"(%!:$;!,0*!("AA*0*.&!&$,&!"&B%!9;".9!&;!

9*&!@*&&*0=!b*!$,/*!&;!-,5*!"&!@*&&*0!.;:=O!T*!*+14,".*(!&$,&!&$"%!-*,.%!*/*0)!

N&*,2$*06!,('4&6!%&'(*.&!$,%!&;!%&*1!'1!&;!&$*!14,&*=O!I)!0*%*,02$!*+,-".*%!$;:!

*/*0)(,)!;22'00*.2*%!".!8".(*09,0&*.!&$,&!2,.!@*9".!&;!.;&!;.4)!%"&',&*!L'**0!,.(!

&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!,%!N("AA*0*.&O!@'&!,4%;!*.&0*.2$!$"*0,02$"*%!:$*0*!%'2$!

("AA*0*.2*%!,0*!%"&*%!;A!;%&0,2"%-=!!

>%%'*%!;A!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!&0,.%1$;@",!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!,0*!:"(*%10*,(=!D!

0*2*.&!%&'()!@)!R9,4*!S,.,(,!T'-,.!Q"9$&%!#0'%&!%'0/*)*(!f6iVV!9,)6!4*%@",.6!

@"%*+',46!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!);'&$!,20;%%!&$*!2;'.&0)!,%!&;!&$*"0!*+1*0"*.2*%!".!$"9$!

%2$;;4!3#,)4;0!*&!,4=7=!#$*"0!A".(".9%!1'01;0&!:"(*%10*,(!1$)%"2,46!/*0@,46!,.(!%*+',4!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

h*@0',0)!YVUY=!b*@!Uf!D'9'%&!YVUfj!a,&;),!G*&*0%;.6!Nb$*0*!"%!&$*!G0;;A!&$,&!>&!

^*&%!F*&&*0e!\'**0!GKS!,.(!&$*!H;4"(,0"&)!^,1'O!5#+)#6)+)&73=!UW!K2&;@*0!YVUV=!b*@!

Uf!D'9'%&!YVUfj!^0,2*!b,45*0EH&*/*.%;.6!N\'**0!>.&*0%*2&";.%!p!D44"*%X!b$*.!C;*%!

>&!^*&!F*&&*0eO!8*+&22&*(0"&79"$(:&7.*#6;(<*#6=3)3(&-(>.)$)+#6(?337,3(&-(&7.(0)2,3=!YZ!

`'.*!YVUf=!b*@!Uf!D'9'%&!YVUf=!!

!

Page 16: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Z!

!

$,0,%%-*.&!,4;.9!:"&$!%&,&"%&"2,4!%'11;0&!&$,&!,.&"E$;-;1$;@",!1;4"2"*%!0*('2*!

$,0,%%-*.&=!#$*)!:0"&*X!

ZVr!;A!a^F#\!%&'(*.&%!A0;-!%2$;;4%!:"&$!,.&"E$;-;1$;@",!1;4"2"*%!

0*1;0&*(!.*/*0!$,/".9!@**.!1$)%"2,44)!$,0,%%*(!/*0%'%!;.4)!kir!;A!a^F#\!

%&'(*.&%!A0;-!%2$;;4%!:"&$;'&!,.&"E$;-;1$;@",!1;4"2"*%j!

[kr!;A!a^F#\!%&'(*.&%!A0;-!%2$;;4%!:"&$!,.&"E$;-;1$;@",!1;4"2"*%!

0*1;0&*(!.*/*0!$,/".9!@**.!/*0@,44)!$,0,%%*(!('*!&;!&$*"0!%*+',4!;0"*.&,&";.!

/*0%'%![Vr!;A!a^F#\!%&'(*.&%!A0;-!%2$;;4%!:"&$;'&!,.&"E$;-;1$;@",!

1;4"2"*%=! !

b$"4*!&$"%!"%!A0,-*(!,%!'.*L'"/;2,44)!1;%"&"/*6!"&!(;*%!4*.(!"&%*4A!&;!1;%".9!,.!

;@/";'%!L'*%&";.X!:$)!,0*!%;-*!%&'(*.&%!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!%&"44!1$)%"2,44)!,.(!

/*0@,44)!$,0,%%*(!;.2*!1;4"2"*%!,0*!".!14,2*e!T;:!,0*!&$*!2'4&'0,4!24"-,&*%!;A!1'@4"2!

%2$;;4%!%$,1*(!@)!A,2&;0%!;&$*0!&$,.!1;4"2)e!>.!,(("&";.6!&$*0*!,0*!%&'(*.&%!:$;6!

@*2,'%*!;A!%'2$!*./"0;.-*.&%6!,0*!.;&!;1*.!:"&$!&$*-%*4/*%!,.(!;&$*0%!,@;'&!&$*"0!

10*A*00*(!9*.(*0!;0!%*+',4!;0"*.&,&";.=!!b$"4*!&$*)!-,)!3;0!-,)!.;&7!,/;"(!/";4*.2*!

,.(!;&$*0!@'44)".96!&$*!2'4&'0*!;A!&$*!%2$;;4!0*-,".%!".$;%1"&,@4*=!b"&$".!-)!

0*%*,02$6!10;90*%%"/*!1;4"2"*%!,0*!%$;:.!&;!$,/*!10;/"(*(!%;-*!4*/*0,9*!&$,&!

*.,@4*(!*('2,&;0%!&;!:;05!,9,".%&!,2'&*!$;-;1$;@",!".!&$*!A,2*!;A!1,0*.&,4!("%%*.&!

,9,".%&!%'2$!:;05j!$;:*/*06!1;4"2)!("(!.;&!10;/"(*!&$*!-*,.%!:"&$!:$"2$!&;!

,((0*%%!*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%!&$,&!2;.&0"@'&*(!&;!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!2'4&'0*=!!

G*0$,1%!1;4"2"*%!:;'4(!@*!@*%&!2;.2*1&',4"J*(!,%!;.*!%&0,&*9)!,-;.9!-,.)!A;0!

,((0*%%".9!,.(!2;.A0;.&".9!%;2",4!2$,.9*=!

Page 17: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

W!

!

b"&$!-'2$!1;1'4,0!,&&*.&";.!2'00*.&4)!(*/;&*(!&;!$;-;1$;@"2!@'44)".9!".!

$"9$!%2$;;4%6!"&!"%!"-1;0&,.&!&;!*+14;0*!$;:!&,@;;%!,0;'.(!20;%%".9!.;0-%!

0*9,0(".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!2;-*!&;!@*!%;!".%&"&'&";.,44)!*.&0*.2$*(!@)!

$"9$!%2$;;4=!H*/*0,4!;@%&,24*%!,11*,0!:$*.!,&&*-1&".9!&;!("%2'%%!$;:!%'2$!.;0-%!

,0*!2'4&"/,&*(!".!*,04"*0!90,(*%6!.;&!&$*!4*,%&!;A!:$"2$!,0*!24,"-%!&$,&!9*.(*0!,.(!

%*+',4"&)!,0*!.;&!,9*E,110;10",&*!&;1"2%=!h;0!*+,-14*6!".!&$*!A,44!;A!YVUU6!&$*!

#;0;.&;!H2$;;4!F;,0(!35.;:.!A;0!"&%!10;90*%%"/*!%&,.2*!;.!%*+E*('2,&";.!,.(!,.&"E

$;-;1$;@",!1;4"2)7!1'@4"%$*(!2'00"2'4'-!&$,&!:"44!@*!,!-,.(,&;0)!1,0&!;A!%2$;;4%!

A0;-!8EUY!3D%&6!*&!,4=7=!#$*!2'00"2'4'-!,((0*%%*%!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!$*&*0;%*+"%-!,%!

%;2",4!M'%&"2*!"%%'*%=!#$*!2'00"2'4'-!A;0!*,04)!90,(*%!".&0;('2*%!A,-"4)!("/*0%"&)=!>&!

,4%;!*.2;'0,9*%!2$"4(0*.!&;!0*&$".5!&$*!.;&";.!&$,&!&$*0*!,0*!@;)%B!,2&"/"&"*%!3%'2$!,%!

%1;0&%7!,.(!9"04%B!,2&"/"&"*%!3%'2$!,%!14,)".9!$;'%*!;0!:"&$!(;44%7!,.(!A,2"4"&,&*%!24,%%!

("%2'%%";.%!,@;'&!$;:!,.);.*!2,.!$,/*!,.)!".&*0*%&=!!!

C*%1"&*!&$*!#;0;.&;!H2$;;4!F;,0(B%!2,'&";'%!*AA;0&%!&;!(*/"%*!,.!,9*E

,110;10",&*!2'00"2'4'-6!&$*!>.%&"&'&*!A;0!S,.,(",.!?,4'*%!0,.!,!2,-1,"9.!&"&4*(!

NH&;1!S;00'1&".9!S$"4(0*.6O!&$,&!10;&*%&*(!&$*!F;,0(B%!10;1;%*(!2'00"2'4'-=!#$*"0!

2,-1,"9.!"./;4/*(!14,2".9!,(%!".!&$*!-,".%&0*,-!S,.,(",.!.*:%1,1*06!0",(

@#$)&*#6(A&3$B!;.!H*1&*-@*0!YW6!YVUU!3H,4*0.;7=!C'*!&;!,.!;'&20)!A0;-!L'**0!,.(!

&0,.%9*.(*0!%'11;0&".9!".("/"(',4%6!0",(@#$)&*#6(A&3$!%&,AA!0,.!,.!,1;4;9)!A;0!

1'@4"%$".9!&$*!,(!;.!H*1&*-@*0!fV6!YVUU=!#$*!1'@4"2!0*%1;.%*%!&;!&$*!,1;4;9)!&$,&!

,11*,0!;.!&$*!.*:%1,1*0B%!:*@%"&*!,0*!0"A*!:"&$!,22'%,&";.%!&$,&!*('2,&";.!

0*9,0(".9!9*.(*0!*+10*%%";.!;0!%*+',4!;0"*.&,&";.!%*+',4"J*%!2$"4(0*.6!"%!.;&!,9*E

Page 18: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UV!

!

,110;10",&*6!,.(!%$;'4(!@*!4*A&!A;0!$"9$!%2$;;4!%*+!*('2,&";.k!3&$*!2;./*0%,&";.%!

,0;'.(!&$"%!,(!,.(!&$*!,1;4;9)!,0*!*+14;0*(!".!-;0*!(*1&$!".!S$,1&*0!h;'07=!!

D%!-)!0*%*,02$!&;;5!14,2*!".!,!8".(*09,0&*.!24,%%0;;-6!>!:,%!&$*0*@)!,@4*!&;!

*+,-".*!:,)%!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!2,.!@*!".%&"&'&";.,44)!10*/,4*.&!3;0!

2;.&*%&*(7!A0;-!&$*!*,04)!)*,0%!;A!1'@4"2!*('2,&";.=!#$*%*!(,&,!2;.&0,("2&!

,%%*0&";.%!&$,&!%*+',4"&)!,.(!9*.(*0!,0*!.;&!("%2'%%*(!".!*,04)!90,(*%=!^"/*.!&$,&!

"%%'*%!,0*!*/*0E10*%*.&!".!.;0-,&"/*!".%&"&'&";.,4!4"A*6!"&!@*2;-*%!,!-,&&*0!;A!"&!6!

.;&!)-B!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)!,0*!&,'9$&=!C;!*('2,&;0%!10;/"(*!(,"4)!*+,-14*%!;A!

;11;%"&*E%*+!(*%"0*!".!&,456!4"&*0,&'0*6!,.(!14,)!:$"4*!;.4)!-*.&";.".9!L'**0.*%%!".!

0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!@'44)".9e!!C;!%'2$!*/*0)(,)!;22'00*.2*%!0*".A;02*!&$*!%&,&'%!L';6!

*%&,@4"%$".9!.;0-%!&$,&!,4"*.,&*!&$;%*!:$;!-,)!.;&!A"&6!;0!(;!&$*)!,44;:!A;0!,!:"(*0!

%2;1*!;A!*+10*%%";.%e!b$,&6!>!,%5!&$0;'9$!&$"%!%&'()6!,0*!&$*!"-14"2,&";.%!;A!:$*0*!

,.(!$;:!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)!,0*!("%2'%%*(!".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4e!!

I)!%&'()!&;;5!14,2*!,&!,.!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4!&$,&!"%!1,0&!;A!&$*!?,.2;'/*0!

H2$;;4!F;,0(!3?HF76!,!%2$;;4!@;,0(!&$,&!$,%!-,(*!*AA;0&%!0*('2*!10;@4*-%!;A!

$;-;1$;@",!,.(!$*&*0;%*+"%-=!D-;.9!&$*%*!*AA;0&%!:,%!&$*!20*,&";.!;A!,!("%&0"2&!

ND.&"ET;-;1$;@",!,.(!C"/*0%"&)!I*.&;0O!1;%"&";.!3&$*!$;'0%!;A!&$"%!1;%"&";.!$,/*!

@**.!0*('2*(!,.(!0*%&;0*(!.'-*0;'%!&"-*%!;/*0!&$*!1,%&!A"/*!)*,0%7j!&$"%!*-14;)**!

%'11;0&%!:;05!%'2$!,%!&$*!(*/*4;1-*.&!;A!^,)EH&0,"9$&!D44",.2*%!,.(!1'&&".9!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

k!$&&1X<<.*:%=.,&";.,41;%&=2;-<YVUU<VW<fV<,.E,1;4;9)EA0;-E&$*E.,&";.,4E1;%&!

Page 19: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UU!

!

%&0'2&'0*%!".!14,2*!&$,&!:"44!$*41!A,2"4"&,&*!&$*!%,A*&)!;A!&0,.%9*.(*0!%&'(*.&%=i!#$"%!

1;%"&";.!:,%!20*,&*(6!".!1,0&6!&;!,%%"%&!".!1'&&".9!?HF!".24'%"/*!1;4"2"*%!".&;!10,2&"2*=!

#$*!1;4"2)!;.!&$*!?HF!:*@%"&*!%&,&*%!&$,&X!

D.)!4,.9',9*!;0!@*$,/";'0!&$,&!(*4"@*0,&*4)!(*90,(*%6!(*."90,&*%6!4,@*4%6!

%&*0*;&)1*%6!".2"&*%!$,&0*(6!10*M'("2*6!("%20"-".,&";.6!$,0,%%-*.&!&;:,0(%!

%&'(*.&%!;0!*-14;)**%!;.!&$*!@,%"%!;A!&$*"0!0*,4!;0!1*02*"/*(!%*+',4!

;0"*.&,&";.!;0!9*.(*0!"(*.&"A"2,&";.!:"44!.;&!@*!&;4*0,&*(!3A&6)+=(C#*7#6;(

D,3/)#*B(E#=B(F)3,G7#6B(0.#*39,*%,.B(0!&HIJ).)$B(K7,3$)&*)*9L=!

#$*!?HF!1;4"2)!"%!*+&*.%"/*=!>&!*+14"2"&4)!4".5%!"%%'*%!;A!%,A*&)!&;!"%%'*%!;A!

".24'%";.!A;0!a^F#!%&'(*.&%=!>&!"./;4/*%!,!0,.9*!;A!%*2&";.%X!".&*.&6!4*,(*0%$"16!

2;'.%*4".9!,.(!%'11;0&6!,.&"E$,0,%%-*.&6!2'00"2'4'-!4*,0.".9!0*%;'02*%6!%&,AA!

(*/*4;1-*.&6!2;--'."&)!"./;4/*-*.&6!,.(!*-14;)-*.&!*L'"&)=!T;:*/*06!&$*0*!"%!

2'00*.&4)!;.4)!;.*!;1&";.,4!2;'0%*!".!;AA"2",4!FS!2'00"2'4'-6!H;2",4!`'%&"2*!UY6!&$,&!

*+14"2"&4)!-*.&";.%!9,)!,.(!4*%@",.!1*;14*!3I&+)#6(:73$)+,(MN(0,#+",.(E7)%,;(

?*3$.7+$)&*(#*%(<33,332,*$(I7JJ&.$7=!S,.!&$"%!N".24'%";.O!0*,44)!@*!%,"(!&;!@*!

%'AA"2"*.&!A;0!&$"0&**.!)*,0%!;A!1'@4"2!*('2,&";.e!!

#$*0*!,0*!;&$*0!("%&0"2&!,.(!10;/".2",4!"."&",&"/*%!&;!4".5!1;4"2"*%!2;.2*0.".9!

a^F#!%&'(*.&B%!%,A*&)!:"&$!".24'%";.!10,2&"2*%=!h;0!*+,-14*6!F"44!UZ!".!I,."&;@,!"%!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i!#$*!I*.&;0!"%!9*.*0,44)!2;.&,2&*(!@)!,!%2$;;4!:$*.!&*,2$*0%!,.(!,(-"."%&0,&;0%!

(**-!&$*-%*4/*%!,%!@*".9!".!.**(!;A!,%%"%&,.2*=!D4&*0.,&*4)!&$*!".("/"(',4!-,)!$;%&!

,.&"E$;-;1$;@",!,.(!&0,.%1$;@",!&*,2$E".%!,&!%2$;;4%=!#$*!1;%"&";.!"%!A"44*(!@)!,.!

".("/"(',4!:$;!$,%!%;-*!,2,(*-"2!,.(!1*0%;.,4!*+1*0"*.2*!(;".9!0*4,&*(!:;05!,.(!

"%!".!2$,09*!;A!(*/*4;1".9!&$*"0!;:.!&*,2$".9!-,&*0",4%6!,%!"&!"%!,!("%&0"2&!1;%"&";.6!

0,&$*0!&$,.!&$*"0!:;05!@*".9!4".5*(!&;!4,09*0!10;/".2",4!;0!.,&";.,4!2'00"2'4'-=!

Page 20: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UY!

!

&"&4*(!N#$*!G'@4"2!H2$;;4%!D-*.(-*.&!D2&!3H,A*!,.(!>.24'%"/*!H2$;;4%7O(3NF"44!UZO7=!

T;:*/*06!(*%1"&*!&$*!0*2;9."&";.!;A!&$*!"-1;0&,.2*!;A!".24'%";.6!&$*!A;2'%!;A!@;&$!

&$*!?HF!1;4"2"*%!3".24'(".9!&$*!%*2&";.!;.!2'00"2'4'-7!A;2'%*%!;.!,.&"E@'44)".9=!I)!

0*%*,02$!"44'%&0,&*%!&$*!".,(*L',2)!;A!,.&"E@'44)".9!2,-1,"9.%!,.(!0*%;'02*%!,4;.*!

&;!%$"A&!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*%!A0;-!&$;%*!&$,&!;%&0,2"J*!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%&'(*.&%!&;!

&$;%*!".!:$"2$!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!,0*!,!:*42;-*!1,0&!;A!*/*0)(,)!

%2$;;4!4"A*=!!

^"/*.!&$,&!&$*!?HF!%&,0&*(!,(;1&*(!&$*"0!,.&"E$;-;1$;@",!1;4"2)!".!YVV[!

3^,4".,76!&$*!("%&0"2&!:,%!"(*,44)!%"&',&*(!A;0!-)!0*%*,02$!;.!*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%!&$,&!

%$,1*!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!,.(!:$,&!&$*%*!10,2&"2*%!(*-;.%&0,&*!".!0*4,&";.!&;!&$*!.**(!

A;0!%;2",4!2$,.9*!@*);.(!&$*!0*,2$*%!;A!1;4"2)=!D4&$;'9$!90;'.(:;05!$,%!@**.!4,"(!

&;!"(*.&"A)!;/*0&4)!$;-;1$;@"2!/";4*.2*!,.(!&;!*.2;'0,9*!,.!*./"0;.-*.&!&$,&!

0*2;9."J*%!@,%"2!$'-,.!0"9$&%6!%&'(*.&%!".!?,.2;'/*0!%2$;;4%!%&"44!,&&*%&!&;!9*.(*0E

@,%*(!,.(!$;-;1$;@"2!@'44)".9!3T,%5*44!,.(!F'0&2$7_-,5".9!"&!20"&"2,4!&;!%&'()!

$;:!*/*0)(,)!0*1*&"&";.!;A!.;0-%!3F'&4*0!UWWf!,.(!UWWW7!0*9'4,&*!%*+',4"&)!,.(!

9*.(*0=!I)!0*%*,02$!"%!2;.2*0.*(!:"&$!&$*!10,2&"2,4"&"*%!;A!%&'(*.&%B!(,"4)!4"/*%!,.(!

&$*"0!0"9$&!&;!*('2,&";.,4!24"-,&*%!&$,&!(;!.;&!M'(9*!,.(!("%20"-".,&*!,9,".%&!&$*-=!

H'2$!,.,4)%"%!"%!'%*A'4!&;!%2$;;4!@;,0(%!:"&$!10;90*%%"/*!1;4"2"*%!,%!:*44!,%!&;!

*('2,&;0%!,.(!,2&"/"%&%!%**5".9!%;2",4!M'%&"2*!".!&$*!*/*0)(,)!*+1*0"*.2*%!;A!&$;%*!

:"&$".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%6!0*9,0(4*%%!;A!:$*&$*0!&$*"0!%2$;;4!@;,0(%!$,/*!,(;1&*(!

("%&0"2&E:"(*!1;4"2"*%!;.!&$*!"%%'*=!!

Page 21: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Uf!

!

0DJDAFZC$WHDJE<?BJ$<B$:?BED[E$

>!2,-*!&;!-)!G$C!,A&*0!$,/".9!:;05*(!,%!,!H&'(*.&!H'11;0&!b;05*0!3HHb7!

:"&$!&$*!?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!F;,0(!A;0!&$0**!)*,0%=!D%!>!,40*,()!$*4(!,!I,%&*0B%!(*90**!

".!b;-*.B%!H&'("*%6!>!:,%!90,&*A'4!A;0!-)!*('2,&";.,4!$"%&;0)B%!*-1$,%"%!;.!

20"&"2,44)!*+,-".".9!&$*!%&,&'%!L';=!#$"%!10;/"(*(!,.!*+2*44*.&!%10".9@;,0(!&;!-)!

:;05!".!N%1*2",4O!*('2,&";.6!,!A"*4(!".!:$"2$!,!$,@"&!;A!*+14;0".9!,4&*0.,&"/*%!&;!

(;-".,.&!.;0-%!"%!&$;0;'9$4)!@*.*A"2",4=!HHb%!,0*!,%%"9.*(!&;!%&'(*.&%!:"&$!

("%,@"4"&"*%6!;A&*.!;.*E&;E;.*6!&;!10;/"(*!1$)%"2,46!@*$,/";'0,46!%;2",46!,.(!,2,(*-"2!

%'11;0&=!b;05".9!".!&$"%!2,1,2"&)!-*,.&!&$,&!>!:;'4(!0*9'4,04)!%*&!'1!4*,0.".9!

,2&"/"&"*%!,.(!&$*.!-;/*!&;!&$*!;'&%5"0&%!;A!&$*!90;'1%6!;AA*0".9!,%%"%&,.2*!:$*.!,.(!

:$*0*!"&!:,%!.**(*(=!!C'*!&;!&$*!;.*E&;E;.*!.,&'0*!;A!-'2$!;A!&$*!:;056!HHb%!,0*!

0;'&".*4)!10*%*.&!A;0!%;2",4!-;-*.&%!&$,&!,0*!*,%"4)!-"%%*(!@)!,('4&%!:;05".9!".!

;&$*0!10;A*%%";.,4!2,1,2"&"*%!:"&$".!%2$;;4%=!D%!&$*!;1*.".9!%&;0)!"44'%&0,&*%6!&$*!

10,2&"2,4!:;05!;A!@*".9!,.!HHb!10;/"(*(!;11;0&'."&)!&;!:"&.*%%!0*10;('2&";.%!,.(!

2;.&*%&,&";.%!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!#$*%*!3,.(!;&$*07!-;-*.&%!10;-1&*(!

-)!0*&'0.!&;!,2,(*-",6!%1*2"A"2,44)!&;!2;.('2&!A"*4(:;05!*+14;0".9!*/*0)(,)!

10,2&"2*%!&$,&!2;.&0"@'&*(!&;!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!".!*,04)!10"-,0)!%2$;;4=!I)!

0*%*,02$!L'*%&";.%!:*0*X!!

Page 22: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U[!

!

• b$,&!".A;0-,4!10,2&"2*%!3*=9=!*/*0)(,)!&,456!%&;0)&*44".96!2;--*.&%!;.!&$*!

%&'(*.&B%!14,)7!&,5*!14,2*!@*&:**.!%&'(*.&%!,.(!@*&:**.!*('2,&;0%!,.(!

%&'(*.&%!&$,&!0*A*0!&;!,&&0,2&";.6!2;'14".96!%*+',4"&)6!,.(!9*.(*0e!Z!

• b$,&!10,2&"2*%!3*=9=6!&,456!14,)7!(*-;.%&0,&*!%&'(*.&%B!0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)e!!

>!%*&!;'&!&;!"./*%&"9,&*!:,)%!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!".&*014,)*(!:"&$!

0,2*6!24,%%6!,.(!("%,@"4"&)!:"&$".!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!>!*.2;'.&*0*(!%;-*!".&*0*%&".9!

A".(".9%6!,%!:*44!,%!,!%"9."A"2,.&!@,00"*0!".!A'44)!".&*90,&".9!,.!".&*0%*2&";.,4!,.,4)%"%!

".&;!&$*!0*%'4&%!;A!&$"%!0*%*,02$=!#$*!24,%%0;;-!&*,2$*06!I,09,0*&!Q;/*44,W6!$,(!2;-*!

&;!&*,2$".9!A,"04)!*,04)!".!$*0!4"A*=!>.!$*0!-"(E&$"0&"*%6!%$*!$,(!@**.!&*,2$".9!A;0!

*4*/*.!)*,0%!,.(!$,(!:;05*(!,%!,!-'%"26!("%,@"4"&)!%'11;0&6!,.(!24,%%0;;-!

&*,2$*0=UV!H$*!$,(!(;.*!-'2$!:;05!&;!".&*90,&*!,!0,.9*!;A!("%,@"4"&"*%!".&;!&$*!

*/*0)(,)!4"A*!;A!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!b$*.!,22;--;(,&";.!.**(*(!&;!@*!-,(*!A;0!,!

%1*2"A"2!%&'(*.&B%!("%,@"4"&)6!&$,&!&;;4!:;'4(!@*2;-*!,.!;1&";.!A;0!&$*!24,%%0;;-!,%!,!

:$;4*!,.(!"&%!'%*!*+14,".*(!&;!*/*0);.*=!h;0!*+,-14*6!%;-*!2$"4(0*.!;.!&$*!D'&"%-!

%1*2&0'-6!;0!:$;!$,/*!%*.%;0)!".&*90,&";.!"%%'*%6!A".(!"&!'%*A'4!&;!$;4(!,!N%L'"%$)O!

&;)!&$,&!&$*)!2,.!-,."1'4,&*!:$"4*!&$*)!.**(!&;!A;2'%!;.!;&$*0!&$".9%=!K/*0!&$*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Z!T*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!"%!*.&:".*(!:"&$!.;0-%!0*9,0(".9!2;4;."J,&";.6!0,2*6!

24,%%6!,.(!("%,@"4"&)=!#$0;'9$;'&!-)!".&*0/"*:%6!A;2'%!90;'1%6!,.(!;@%*0/,&";.%6!>!

1,"(!,&&*.&";.!&;!%'2$!".&*0%*2&";.%!,.(!,&&*-1&*(!&;!".&*90,&*!&$*-!".&;!&$*!

;/*0/"*:!;A!&$*!%&'()!,.(!4,)*0%!;A!,.,4)%"%=!!W!D%!:"&$!,44!.,-*%!9"/*.!A0;-!-)!A"*4(:;056!I,09,0*&!Q;/*44,!"%!,!1%*'(;.)-=!UV!I,09,0*&!Q;/*44,!$,(!,!A;'0E)*,0!'.(*090,(',&*!(*90**!,.(!,!A"A&$!)*,0!&;!

2;-14*&*!,!&*,2$".9!&0,".".9!10;90,-=!b$"4*!%;-*!%2$;;4%!.;:!0*L'"0*!,!I,%&*0B%!

(*90**!&;!:;05!,%!,!0*%;'02*!&*,2$*06!%$*!("(!.;&!$,/*!&$"%!%1*2",4"J,&";.!,&!&$,&!

4*/*4=!!

Page 23: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U]!

!

)*,0%!".!I,09,0*&B%!24,%%0;;-6!&$*0*!$,(!@**.!%1*2"A"2!2$"4(0*.!A;0!:$;-!%'2$!

NA"(9*&!&;)%O!:*0*!'%*A'4=!H$*!$,(!".2;01;0,&*(!&$"%!&;;4!".&;!&$*!4,09*0!24,%%0;;-!

:$*0*!,!@'25*&!;A!A"(9*&!&;)%!:,%!,/,"4,@4*!A;0!,.)!%&'(*.&!&;!'%*6!"A!&$*)!A;'.(!&$*-!

$*41A'4=!#$*!10;&;2;4!:,%!*%&,@4"%$*(!&$,&!%&'(*.&%!:;'4(!.**(!&;!1'&!&$*!A"(9*&!&;)!

,:,)!"A!"&!:,%!@*".9!'%*(!".,110;10",&*4)!3*=9=!&;!$"&!,!1**06!9*&!&$0;:.!,0;'.(!&$*!

0;;-7=!b$"4*!&$*0*!:*0*!.;!2$"4(0*.!:"&$!D'&"%-!(",9.;%*%!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-6!&$*!

&;;4!0*-,".*(!,/,"4,@4*=!

I,09,0*&!$,(!&$;'9$&!*+&*.%"/*4)!,@;'&!:,)%!&;!'%*!$*0!90;:".9!,:,0*.*%%!

;A!("%,@"4"&)!,22*%%!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!&;!*+1,.(!$;:!,44!&$*!2$"4(0*.!2;'4(!&$".5!

,@;'&!'.(*0%&,.(".9!&$*-%*4/*%!,.(!&$*"0!;:.!:,)%!;A!4*,0.".9=!#$"%!,110;,2$!&;!

("%,@"4"&)!,.(!".24'%";.!:,%!-;(*4*(!('0".9!-)!A"*4(:;056!:$*0*@)!".%&*,(!;A!

4*,0.".9!,@;'&!&$*!N;&$*0O!:$;!.**(*(!,22;--;(,&";.6!%&'(*.&%!:*0*!&,'9$&!,@;'&!

("AA*0".9!:,)%!;A!'.(*0%&,.(".9!$;:!1*;14*!.,/"9,&*!&$*!24,%%0;;-!,.(!&$*"0!.**(%=!

H&'(*.&%!:*0*!*.2;'0,9*(!&;!,%5!"A!,!%&'(*.&!:"&$!,!("%,@"4"&)!.**(*(!,%%"%&,.2*!

0,&$*0!&$,.!@*9"..".9!&;!$*41!:"&$;'&!2;.%*.&=!#$"%!*-1$,%"%!;.!%&'(*.&%!@*".9!

,@4*!&;!5.;:!,.(!*+10*%%!&$*"0!;:.!.**(%!$,(!"-14"2,&";.%!A;0!2;'.&*0".9!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!3*+14;0*(!".!S$,1&*0!H"+7=!!

#$*0*!:,%!%'@%&,.&",4!("%2'%%";.!;A!("%,@"4"&)!".!-)!".&*0/"*:%!:"&$!&$*!

24,%%0;;-!&*,2$*0!,.(!HHb=!C*%1"&*!("%2'%%";.!;A!("%,@"4"&)!$,/".9!,!0;4*!".!-)!

A"*4(:;056!>!("(!.;&!$,/*!1,0*.&,4!2;.%*.&!&;!".24'(*!&$*!%&'(*.&!:"&$!&$*!-;%&!

;@/";'%!.**(!A;0!,22;--;(,&";.!".!-)!0*%*,02$=!K.!&$*!2;.%*.&!A;0-%6!1,0*.&%!$,(!

&$*!;1&";.!;A!2"024".9!&$,&!&$*)!("(!;0!("(!.;&!2;.%*.&!&;!&$*"0!2$"4(B%!1,0&"2"1,&";.!".!

Page 24: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Uk!

!

&$*!%&'()!3%**!D11*.("+!>>>76!:"&$!.;!L'*%&";.%!,%5*(=!>.!&$*!A;0-%6!1,0*.&%!:*0*!

,%%'0*(!&$,&!>!:;'4(!.;&!&,5*!.;&*%!;.!&$*"0!2$"4(!"A!&$*)!("(!.;&!2;.%*.&!&;!&$*"0!

"./;4/*-*.&!".!&$"%!0*%*,02$=!F*2,'%*!;A!&$"%6!>!$,/*!4*A&!;'&!&$*!("%2'%%";.%!

0*9,0(".9!("%,@"4"&)!".24'%";.!A0;-!-)!(,&,!,.(!,.,4)%"%!,%!&$*)!0*/;4/*(!,0;'.(!,!

1,0&"2'4,0!2$"4(!,.(!&$*"0!("%,@"4"&)!,.(!>!:;'4(!.;&!-,".&,".!*&$"2,4!@;'.(,0"*%!

:*0*!&$*%*!(",4;9'*%!&;!@*!".24'(*(=!!

>.!&*0-%!;A!24,%%!,.,4)%"%6!&$*!%2$;;4!:,%!".!,!:*44E;AA!.*"9$@;'0$;;(!".!

:$"2$!&$*0*!:,%!,!("%20*1,.2)!@*&:**.!&$;%*!:$;!;:.*(!10;1*0&)!,.(!&$;%*!:$;!

0*.&*(!@,%*-*.&!%'"&*%!;'&!;A!10;1*0&)!;:.*0B%!$;'%*%!3-;0*!;.!&$"%!".!S$,1&*0!

#$0**7=!D%!%'2$!,!0*.&*06!".!,!4*%%!,AA4'*.&!.*"9$@;'0$;;(6!>!2,.!,&&*%&!&$,&!&$"%!"%!.;&!

.*2*%%,0"4)!".("2,&"/*!;A!".("/"(',4%!@*".9!".!1;/*0&)=!b$"4*!>!("(!.;&!$,/*!,22*%%!&;!

("AA*0".9!A,-"4"*%B!".2;-*!4*/*4!:"&$".!-)!%&'()6!"&!:,%!*/"(*.&!&$,&!%;-*!2$"4(0*.!

,.(!&$*"0!A,-"4"*%!%**-*(!&;!@*!(0*%%*(!".!-;0*!*+1*.%"/*!24;&$*%!,.(!;&$*0%!".!

24;&$*%!&$,&!:;'4(!4"5*4)!@*!,/,"4,@4*!".!4,09*06!".*+1*.%"/*!(*1,0&-*.&!%&;0*%=!D44!

&$*!%&'(*.&%!".!-)!A"*4(:;05!24,%%0;;-!:*0*!,(*L',&*4)!%'114"*(!:"&$!:".&*0!,.(!

%10".9!24;&$*%!('0".9!-)!;@%*0/,&";.%=!!

>!$,(!:;05*(!,&!%;-*!"..*0E2"&)!%2$;;4%!:"&$!%'@%"("J*(!4'.2$!10;90,-%6!".!

:$"2$!2$"4(0*.!:*0*!24*,04)!'.A;2'%*(!,.(!4*&$,09"2!@*A;0*!4'.2$!,.(!$,(!-'2$!

@*&&*0!,2,(*-"2!A;2'%!,A&*0!4'.2$=!b$*.!,%5*(6!&$*!-,M;0"&)!;A!%&'(*.&%!".!&$*!4'.2$!

10;90,-%!:;'4(!2;.A"0-!&$,&!&$*)!$,(!.;&!*,&*.!@0*,5A,%&=!#$*0*!:*0*!.;!

%'@%"("J*(!4'.2$!10;90,-%!,&!&$*!%2$;;4!>!:,%!%&'()".96!:$"2$!>!$,/*!9"/*.!&$*!

Page 25: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Ui!

!

1%*'(;.)-!H;'&$!H"(*!R4*-*.&,0)!H2$;;46!,.(!,44!&$*!%&'(*.&%!$,(!,(*L',&*!

%'114"*%!;A!A;;(!:"&$!&$*-!*/*0)(,)=!!

>!0*-*-@*0!-)!.*1$*:!&,5".9!-;.&$%!&;!("%24;%*!&$*!1;;0E%$,-".9!&$,&!$*!

*+1*0"*.2*(!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!".!?,.2;'/*06!M'%&!b*%&!;A!H;'&$!H"(*!R4*-*.&,0)!

H2$;;46!;.4)!,!2;'14*!;A!)*,0%!@*A;0*!-)!A"*4(%&'()!:,%!'.(*0&,5*.=!T*!$,(!

*.2;'.&*0*(!@'44)".9!,.(!%;2",4!*+24'%";.!A;0!@*".9!N1;;0O!,.(!4"/".9!".!,!%$,0*(!

;.*E@*(0;;-!,1,0&-*.&!:"&$!$"%!-;&$*0=!T,/".9!%**.!%"-"4,0!&*,%".9!,%!,!?HF!

*-14;)**6!>!$,(!.;&!@**.!%'010"%*(!&$,&!&$"%!$,(!;22'00*(=!T;:*/*06!>!$,(!@**.!

("%-,)*(!&$,&!$*!$,(!5*1&!&$"%!".A;0-,&";.!A0;-!,('4&%!".!$"%!4"A*j!&$;'9$!;.4)!".!

^0,(*!U6!&$"%!%'99*%&*(!&;!-*!&$,&!$*!$,(!".&*0.,4"J*(!&$*!%$,-".9!"-@*((*(!".!&$*!

M**0".9!2;--*.&%!$*!*+1*0"*.2*(=!F*2,'%*!;A!&$"%6!>!1,"(!,&&*.&";.!&;!*/*0)(,)!&,45!

&$,&!2;'4(!1;&*.&",44)!.;0-,4"J*!,!-"((4*E24,%%!@,2590;'.(=UU!>!:,%!,4%;!/"9"4,.&!".!

;@%*0/".9!2$"4(0*.B%!14,)_>!:,&2$*(!A;0!2;--*.&%!:$"2$!:;'4(!%$,-*!;&$*0!

2$"4(0*.!@,%*(!;.!A,-"4)!".2;-*!,.(!@,2590;'.(6!,%!:*44!,%!A;0!2$"4(0*.!@*".9!

%$'..*(!@,%*(!;.!-,&*0",4!10"/"4*9*!3*=9=6!;.4)!2$"4(0*.!:$;!$,(!,!1,0&"2'4,0!

*+1*.%"/*!&;)!@*".9!,@4*!&;!14,)!,!1,0&"2'4,0!9,-*!:"&$!&$*"0!1**0%7=!!

I,09,0*&!10*%*.&*(!-'4&"14*!;1&";.%!:$*.!("%2'%%".9!2$"4(0*.B%!$;-*%!,.(!

4"/*%=!h;0!*+,-14*6!;.*!*+*02"%*!,%5*(!2$"4(0*.!&;!(0,:!,!1"2&'0*!;A!&$*"0!0;;-%=!H$*!

%1*2"A"*(!@*A;0*!&$*!*+*02"%*!@*9,.!&$,&!%;-*!1*;14*!-"9$&!%$,0*!,!0;;-!:"&$!-,.)!

1*;14*!,.(!%;-*!1*;14*!-"9$&!$,/*!&$*"0!;:.!0;;-%=!H'2$!,&&*.&";.!-,)!$,/*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

UU!#$;'9$!>!,-!.;:!,.!,2,(*-"26!-)!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!24,%%!"%%'*%!".!*('2,&";.,4!

".%&"&'&";.%!:,%!,4%;!".A;0-*(!@)!-)!$"%&;0)!;A!2$"4($;;(!1;/*0&)=!

Page 26: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UZ!

!

,%%"%&*(!".!10*E*-1&"/*4)!-,5".9!("%20*1,.2"*%!".!2$"4(0*.B%!@,2590;'.(%!4*%%!

4;,(*(!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!fU<V[<UY7=!!

#$*0*!:*0*!,!A*:!".%&,.2*%!:$*.!-;.*)!,.(!24,%%!*-*09*(!".!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!

14,)=!C'0".9!-)!A"0%&!(,)6!&:;!2$"4(0*.!:*0*!14,)".9!$;'%*!,.(!;.*!)*44*(!&;!,.;&$*0!

&;!N9;!,.(!9*&!,!20*("&!2,0(O!:"&$!%;-*!'09*.2)6!:$"4*!".!,.;&$*0!9,-*6!&:;!2$"4(0*.!

:*0*!@'"4(".9!,!2,%&4*!&;!10;&*2&!,9,".%&!J;-@"*%!3&,5*.!A0;-!&$*!1;1'4,0!/"(*;E

9,-*!NG4,.&%!/%=!s;-@"*%O7!,.(!;.*!'09*.&4)!)*44*(!&;!&$*!;&$*0!&$,&!$*!2;'4(!.;&!

2;-*!".&;!&$*!2,%&4*!:"&$;'&!,!-"44";.!(;44,0%!3&;!:$"2$!$"%!A0"*.(!0*14"*(!&$,&!$*!

;.4)!$,(!N;.*!-;.*)O7!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!Uf<VY<UY7=!K.!,.;&$*0!(,)!&:;!2$"4(0*.!

%&,0&*(!)*44".9!,&!*,2$!;&$*0!,@;'&!:$;%*!1,0*.&%!-,(*!-;0*!-;.*)!3h"*4(:;05!

.;&*%!Yi<Vf<UY7=!h0;-!&$*%*!&:;!*+,-14*%6!"&!2,.!@*!*+&0,1;4,&*(!&$,&!&$*!2$"4(0*.!

:*0*!1"*2".9!&;9*&$*0!&$*!"-1;0&,.2*!;A!-;.*)!3,.(!*/*.!(*@&7!A;0!,22*%%".9!

%1,2*%!,.(!,&&,".".9!%&,&'%=!T;:*/*06!9"/*.!&$*!,-;'.&!;A!&"-*!>!:,%!10*%*.&!A;0!

2$"4(0*.B%!".&*0,2&";.%6!&$*%*!2;--*.&%!("(!.;&!4;;-!4,09*=!!

D%!1,0&!;A!(*/;&".9!,&&*.&";.!&;!24,%%!,.(!-;.*)!".!-)!A"*4(:;05!%"&*6!>!

;@%*0/*(!&$*!0;4*!;A!@0,.(".9!".!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!4"/*%_:$,&!2;-1,."*%!,.(!4;9;%!

:*0*!;.!&$*"0!@*4;.9".9%6!:$,&!1;1'4,0!2'4&'0*!0*A*0*.2*%!,11*,0*(!".!%&'(*.&%B!

:;05!,.(!14,)e!#$*!2$"4(0*.!A0*L'*.&4)!-*.&";.*(!/"(*;!9,-*%X!G4,.&%!/%=!s;-@"*%!

3:$*0*6!,-;.9!;&$*0!&$".9%6!J;-@"*%!2,.!@*!A;'9$&!:"&$!2;0.E;.E&$*E2;@76!D.90)!

F"0(%!3".!:$"2$!14,)*0%!&$0;:!@"0(%!,&!1"9%!/",!%4".9%$;&76!,.(!I,0";!3,!9,-*!".!

:$"2$!,!-,4*!4*,(!9;*%!&$0;'9$!-,.)!N4*/*4%6O!&$*!&$*;0*&"2,4!*.(!;A!:$"2$!:"44!%,/*!

Page 27: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UW!

!

,!10".2*%%7=!D44!;A!&$*%*!,0*!-,%%!-,05*&*(!&;:,0(!);'.9!1*;14*!,.(!,/,"4,@4*!;.!

-'4&"14*!A;0-%!;A!-*(",!A0;-!2;-1'&*0%!&;!1$;.*%=!!

b$"4*!>!,4%;!.;&"2*(!&$*!;((!C"%.*)!10".2*%%!10;('2&!@*4;.9".9!&;!,!9"046!

"-,9".,&"/*!14,)_0,&$*0!&$,.!@0,.(".9_(;-".,&*(!24,%%0;;-!".&*0,2&";.%=!F;)%!

14,)*(!:"&$!2,0%!-;0*!;A&*.!&$,.!9"04%j!9"04%!14,)*(!:"&$!%&'AA*(!,."-,4%!-;0*!;A&*.!

&$,.!@;)%=!#$*!10".2*%%*%!:*0*!.;&!,4:,)%!,%%;2",&*(!:"&$!C"%.*)6!@'&!A,"0)!&,4*!

2'4&'0*!("(!$,/*!,!10*%*.2*!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!>.!&$*!4"@0,0)6!&$*!9"04%!:;'4(!;A&*.!

24'%&*0!,0;'.(!@;;5%!;A!A,"0)&,4*%!,.(!&,45!,@;'&!:$,&!2$,0,2&*0%!&$*)!:,.&*(!&;!@*!

,.(!:$;!$,(!&$*!N-;%&!@*,'&"A'4O!:*((".9!(0*%%!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!Uf<VY<UY7=!#$"%!

(;*%!.;&!-*,.!&$,&!;.4)!9"04%!:*0*!".&*0*%&*(!".!&$*%*!@;;5%6!@'&!&$,&!&$*%*!@;;5%!

:*0*!9*.(*0*(!,%!9"04%B!@;;5%=!K.!-)!A"0%&!(,)!;A!A"*4(:;05!;.*!@;)6!S;..*06!M;".*(!

&$*!9"04%!,.(!%1;5*!*+2"&*(4)!,@;'&!,!10".2*%%!,.(!,!(0,9;.=!b$*.!$"%!1**0%!1,'%*(!

@*A;0*!0*%1;.(".9!&;!$"-!3>!2;'4(!.;&!&*44!"A!&$"%!:,%!('*!&;!%'010"%*!;0!:,%!M'%&!,!

@0*,5!".!2;./*0%,&";.6!&$*)!("(!.;&!,11*,0!M'(9-*.&,476!$*!4;;5*(!%*4AE2;.%2";'%!

,.(!%,"(6!N"&B%!,!('-@!@;;56O!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!Uf<VYUY7!"--*(",&*4)!$'00)".9!

,:,)=!#$"%!%'99*%&*(!&$,&!$*!-"9$&!$,/*!@**.!,:,0*!&$,&!$"%!".&*0*%&!".!&$*!%&;0)!

:,%!.;&!,22*1&,@4*=!

#$,&!&$*!9"04%!:0;&*!&$*-%*4/*%!".&;!&$*!A,"0)&,4*%6!10;M*2&".9!

$*&*0;.;0-,&"/*!A'&'0*!:*((".9%6!.**(%!&;!@*!*+,-".*(!".!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!&$*!

4,09*0!0;4*!;A!2$"4(0*.B%!1"2&'0*!@;;5%!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!I'2$!;A!&$*!4*,0.".9!".!&$*!

24,%%0;;-!&;;5!14,2*!&$0;'9$!14,)!,.(!,0&!0,&$*0!&$,.!:;05%$**&%=!T;:*/*06!&:"2*!,!

(,)6!&$*!2$"4(0*.!:;'4(!,44!,%%*-@4*!,%!,!24,%%!A;0!%&;0)!&"-*%!:$*.!&$*!&*,2$*0!

Page 28: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YV!

!

:;'4(!0*,(!1"2&'0*!@;;5%!;'&!4;'(!&;!&$*!24,%%=!#$*!10".2"1,4!,4%;!$*4(!:**54)!%&;0)!

&"-*%!".!&$*!4"@0,0)6!('0".9!&$*!24,%%0;;-!&*,2$*0B%!,44;&&*(!10*1!&"-*=!!

>.!&$*!&$0**!-;.&$%!&$,&!>!:,%!:"&$!&$*!24,%%6!&$*0*!:,%!;.4)!;.*!%&;0)!0*,(!

".!24,%%!:"&$!,!A*-,4*!10;&,9;."%&=!#$*!:;-*.!,.(!9"04%!".!&$*!%&;0"*%!9*.*0,44)!

;22'1"*(!&$*!0;4*%!;A!4;/*!".&*0*%&%6!-;&$*0%6!,..;)".9!4"&&4*!%"%&*0%!,.(!24,%%-,&*%6!

;0!,.&$0;1;-;01$"J*(!,."-,4%!".!.**(!;A!0*%2'*=!#$*)!:*0*!;A&*.!&$*!@,2590;'.(!

'1;.!:$"2$!&$*!-,4*!2$,0,2&*0%!$,(!,(/*.&'0*%=!#$*0*!*+"%&%!,!:*,4&$!;A!1'@4"%$*(!

1"2&'0*!@;;5%!:"&$!,!0,.9*!;A!;&$*0!9*.(*0!().,-"2%!A0;-!%-,44!1'@4"%$*0%6!%'2$!,%!

H*2;.(!H&;0)!G0*%%=UY!T;:*/*06!H2$;4,%&"2!F;;5%!2,&,4;9'*%!,0*!2"02'4,&*(!:"&$!

*/*0)!24,%%0;;-!&*,2$*0=!#$*!2,&,4;9'*%!,0*!,4%;!%*.&!$;-*!:"&$!A,-"4"*%!,%!1,0&!;A!

,..',4!A'.(0,"%*0%6!&$*!%,4*%!A0;-!:$"2$!,0*!'%*(!A;0!%2$;;4!*%%*.&",4%6!%'2$!,%!

4"@0,0)!@;;5%!3>!("%2'%%!9;/*0.-*.&!@'(9*&!2'&%!,.(!1,0*.&,4!A'.(0,"%".9!".!-;0*!

(*1&$!".!S$,1&*0!#$0**7=!#$*!-;%&!,22*%%"@4*!:,)!A;0!&*,2$*0%!&;!@')!@;;5%!"%!

&$*0*A;0*!&$0;'9$!H2$;4,%&"26!:$;%*!@;;5%!,0*!;A&*.!A,"04)!-,".%&0*,-!,.(!(;!.;&!

0*10*%*.&!&$*!2$,.9*%!".!2$"4(0*.B%!4"&*0,&'0*!&$,&!$,/*!&,5*.!14,2*!&$0;'9$!&$*!1,%&!

&$"0&)!)*,0%!;A!,.&"E0,2"%&6!A*-"."%&!-;/*-*.&%!,.(!&$*"0!"-1,2&!;.!2$"4(0*.B%!@;;5!

1'@4"%$".9!3G,'47=!#*,2$*0%!:$;!,0*!,40*,()!;/*0E:;05*(!,.(!1,)!A;0!0*%;'02*%!

:"&$!&$*"0!;:.!-;.*)6!:;'4(!&$*.!@*!0*L'"0*(!&;!(*/;&*!,(("&";.,4!*AA;0&!&;!*.%'0*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

UY!h;0!,.!;/*0/"*:!;A!&$*-*%!".!S,.,(",.!2$"4(0*.B%!1"2&'0*@;;5%!%**!<(E7)%,($&(

>#*#%)#*(>")6%.,*O3(F&&P3(@)!C*"(0*!F,5*0!,.(!8*.!H*&&*0".9&;.=(#;0;.&;X!P,&";.,4!

a"@0,0)!;A!S,.,(,6!YVVf=!

!

Page 29: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YU!

!

&$,&!2$"4(0*.B%!4"&*0,&'0*!".!&$*"0!24,%%0;;-%!(;*%!.;&!0*20*,&*!&$*!-;%&!@,%"2!

9*.(*0!.;0-%!;A!,2&"/*!-,4*<1,%%"/*!A*-,4*6!,2&"/*!%'@M*2&<1,%%"/*!;@M*2&=!!

K/*0!&$*!2;'0%*!;A!&$"%!%&'()6!&$*0*!:*0*!&:;!@;;5%!".!:$"2$!&$*!A*-,4*!

2$,0,2&*0%!&;;5!,2&"/*!0;4*%!3,!@'9!".!;.*6!,!&0,".!".!&$*!;&$*07=!>.!@;&$!".%&,.2*%6!&$*!

9"04%!@*9,.!&;!2,44!;'&6!N&$,&B%!-*6O!,.(!N>B-!&$,&!;.*=O!^*.*0,44)!-,4*!10;.;'.%!:*0*!

9"/*.!&;!,44!2$,0,2&*0%!:$;!:*0*!.;&!-;&$*0%6!%"%&*0%6!;0!;22'1)".9!,!1*0"1$*0,4!0;4*!

".!,!-,4*!2$,0,2&*0B%!4"A*=!#$"%!:,%!2;.%"%&*.&!:"&$!&$*!14,)!".!24,%%!".!:$"2$!,44!&$*!

2$"4(0*.!0*A*00*(!&;!%&'AA*(!,."-,4%!,%!N$*O!'.4*%%!&$*)!:*0*!("%&".2&4)!A*-"."J*(=!!>.!

@;;5%!:"&$;'&!:;0(%!;0!:$*0*!9*.(*0!:,%!.;&!%1*2"A"*(6!&$*!2$"4(0*.!:;'4(!%&"44!

(*A,'4&!&;!-,4*!10;.;'.%=!K.*!%&'(*.&6!a"4)6!:$;!1,0&"2'4,04)!*.M;)*(!N0*,(".9O!

%&;0"*%!&;!-*!3:,45".9!'1!&;!-*!:$"4*!>!:,%!:0"&".9!,.(!&*44".9!-*!,@;'&!1"2&'0*%!;.!

*/*0)!1,9*!;A!&$*!@;;5!%$*!:,%!$;4(".97!:;'4(!0*A*0!&;!,44!2$,0,2&*0%!,%!N$*O!

0*9,0(4*%%!;A!&$*"0!,11*,0,.2*=!S,0;4".*!P*4%;.Uf6!&$*!%2$;;4!10".2"1,46!2;--*.&*(!

;.!&$"%!&0*.(!,%!:*44=!H$*!$,(!@**.!0*,(".9!,!%*0"*%!;A!@;;5%!,@;'&!NR4*1$,.&!,.(!

G"99)O!@)!I;!b"44*-%=!H$*!&;4(!-*!&$,&!%$*!,.(!,44!&$*!%&'(*.&%!$,(!,%%'-*(!&$,&!

G"99)!:,%!,!@;)!&$0;'9$!-,.)!@;;5%!'.&"4!G"99)!:,%!%$;:.!:"&$!,.;&$*0!2$,0,2&*0!

:$;!0*A*00*(!&;!$*0!,%!$*0!%"%&*0=!>.!,!4,&*0!@;;56!G"99)!:;0*!,!(0*%%!&;!&$*!1,0&)!,.(!

&$*!@;)%!".!&$*!24,%%!*+10*%%*(!("%&0*%%!;/*0!$,/".9!&$;'9$&!&$,&!G"99)!:,%!,!@;)=!

#$"%!1;".&%!&;!&$*!:*"9$&!@*".9!9"/*.!&;!N5.;:".9O!,!9*.(*06!,4;.9!:"&$!%'@%*L'*.&!

("%&0*%%!;/*0!$,/".9!0*,(!,!9*.(*0!N:0;.9=O!T*.2*6!&$*!@;)%B!0*%1;.%*%!&;!&$*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Uf!#$"%!.,-*!"%!,4%;!,!1%*'(;.)-=!!

Page 30: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YY!

!

%&;0"*%!,44'(*!&;!,!%;2",4!24"-,&*!:$*0*".!&0,.%9*.(*0!,.(!9*.(*0!.;.E2;.A;0-".9!

2$"4(0*.!:;'4(!@*!-*&!:"&$!%'%1"2";.!,.(!("%&0*%%=!!

#$*!2$"4(0*.B%!0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!&$*!4"&*0,&'0*!0*A4*2&!$;:!-,4*.*%%!"%!,!(*A,'4&!

,%%;2",&";.!A;0!2'4&'0,4!,2&;0%=!Q,&$*0!&$,.!,.)!;.*!2;01;0,&*!10*%*.2*!$,/".9!

(;-".,.2*!".!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!24,%%0;;-!4"/*%6!,02$*&)1*%!%'2$!,%!&$*!%&*0*;&)1"2,44)!

@*,'&"A'4!o10".2*%%6B!;0!&$*!,@4*E@;("*(!-,4*!o$*0;B!:*0*!:$,&!,11*,0*(!&;!%$,1*!

&$*"0!,%%;2",&";.%!,.(!"(*.&"A"2,&";.%=!#$*%*!,%%;2",&";.%!:*0*!2;.%"%&*.&!:"&$!&$*!

1;:*0E@,%*(!9*.(*0*(!().,-"2%!&$,&!:*0*!10*%*.&!".!2$"4(0*.B%!14,)=!>.!S$,1&*0!

h;'06!>!:"44!*+14;0*!".!-;0*!(*&,"4!$;:!9*.(*0!,.(!1;:*0!:*0*!10*%*.&!".!2$"4(0*.B%!

14,)!,.(!&$*!,9*.2)!&$*)!(*-;.%&0,&*(!".!0*".A;02".9!,.(!0*%"%&".9!(;-".,.&!1;:*0!

.;0-%6!,.(!&$*!"-14"2,&";.%!;A!&$*"0!14,)!".!0*"A)".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!

10"/"4*9*!,.(!;&$*0".9!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%=!!

59$VFDJDBZD$<B$ECD$:>AJJF??@$

C'0".9!-)!A"0%&!-;0.".9!:"&$!&$*!24,%%6!;.*!%&'(*.&!%&;11*(!&$*!-;0.".9!

2"024*!&;!,%5!-*!,@;'&!,!&,&&;;!;.!-)!,0-!,.(!&;!%,)!&$,&!%$*!&$;'9$&!"&!:,%!N0*,44)!

@*,'&"A'4O!,.(!&$,&!"&!4;;5*(!4"5*!%;-*;.*!&;;5!N4;/*4)!4".*%!,.(!%L'"%$*(!&$*-O!".&;!

-)!%5".!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!VY<Uf<UY7=!>!,-!,4:,)%!0*-".(*(6!:$*.!".!-;0*!

-,".%&0*,-!9*.(*0!*./"0;.-*.&%6!&$,&!&$*0*!,0*!:,)%!>!(;!.;&!*.&"0*4)!@4*.(6!%'2$!

,%!&$*!N4;/*4)!4".*%O!%L'"%$*(!".&;!-)!%5".=!>!$,/*!1;.(*0*(!1;%%"@4*!:,)%!&$,&!-)!

(*1,0&'0*%!A0;-!-,".%&0*,-!A*-"."."&)!2;'4(!$,/*!".A4'*.2*(!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!

0*%1;.%*%!&;!-*X!@)!9"/".9!&$*-!"-14"2"&!1*0-"%%";.!&;!(*1,0&!A0;-!(;-".,.&!

%&,.(,0(%!".!-)!10*%*.2*6!@)!&0)".9!&;!9"/*!&$*!N0"9$&O!,.%:*0%!:$*.!*+10*%%".9!

Page 31: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Yf!

!

;1*.E-".(*(!%*.&"-*.&%!".!0*9,0(!&;!9*.(*0!20;%%".96!@)!,($*0".9!&;!.;0-%!

/"9"4,.&4)!".!;0(*0!&;!%**!$;:!>!:;'4(!0*%1;.(=!b"&$".!-)!".&*010*&,&";.!;A!(,&,6!>!

$,/*!1,"(!,&&*.&";.!&;!:,)%!2$"4(0*.!:*0*!0*%1;.(".9!&;!-)!10*%*.2*!,%!:*44!,%!&;!

$;:!>!0*%1;.(*(!&;!&$*-=!I)!%;2",4!4;2,&";.%!,.(!:;05!$"%&;0)!".A4'*.2*!@;&$!-)!

0*%*,02$!L'*%&";.%!,.(!A".(".9%!".!2;-14*+!:,)%6!A;0!:$"2$!>!.;:!10;/"(*!%;-*!

;/*0/"*:!,.(!0*A4*2&";.=!!

I)!4;.9E%&,.(".9!"./;4/*-*.&!:"&$!L'**0!2;--'."&"*%!"%!1,0&!;A!&$*!4*.%!

&$0;'9$!:$"2$!>!".&*010*&!-)!;@%*0/,&";.%=!#$,&!>!%$,0*!2;--'."&)!:"&$!1*;14*!

:$;!:*0*!;&$*0*(!&$0;'9$;'&!&$*"0!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4!)*,0%!A;0!@*".9!9*.(*0!.;.E

2;.A;0-".9!,.(!$,/*!-)!;:.!$"%&;0)!;A!@*".9!,.!;'&%"(*0!&;!&$*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-,&"/*!-,".%&0*,-6!(0*:!-)!,&&*.&";.!&;!*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%!&$,&!$,/*!@**.!

*+1*0"*.2*(!,%!,4"*.,&".9!&;!&$*!2;'.&*0E2'4&'0*!&;!:$"2$!>!@*4;.9=!T;:*/*06!,%!>!,-!

,4%;!2"%9*.(*06U[!>!:;05!&;!*.%'0*!&$,&!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!,0*!.;&!

-,09".,4"J*(!:"&$".!-)!0*%*,02$j!-)!%&'()!(;*%!.;&!,%%'-*!&$,&!,44!%&'(*.&%!:*0*!

;0!%$;'4(!@*!2"%9*.(*06!;0!&$,&!&$*"0!9*.(*0!(*%"9.,&";.!:"44!-,&2$!:$;!&$*)!,0*!

&$0;'9$;'&!&$*"0!4"A*&"-*%=!!

D%!>!:,.(*0*(!&$*!14,)90;'.(!,&!0*2*%%!,.(!4'.2$!3:"&$!,!/"%"&;0B%!1,%%76!>!

:,%!-".(A'4!&$,&!-)!:$"&*.*%%!,.(!2"%9*.(*0!A*-,4*!,11*,0,.2*!:*0*!2;.%"%&*.&!

:"&$!:$,&!(;-".,.&!2'4&'0*!$,%!2;.%&0'2&*(!,%!,.!'.&$0*,&*.".9!10*%*.2*!".!

2$"4(0*.B%!%1,2*%!,.(!-,)!$,/*!,%%"%&*(!".!-)!,@"4"&)!&;!&0,/*0%*!&$*!%2$;;4),0(!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

U[!S"%9*.(*0!0*A*0%!&;!&$;%*!:$;!"(*.&"A)!,%!&$*!%*+!&$*)!:*0*!,%%"9.*(!,&!@"0&$!

3-;0*!;.!&$"%!".!&$*!.*+&!2$,1&*07=!!

Page 32: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y[!

!

-,5".9!;@%*0/,&";.%6!2$,&&".9!:"&$!2$"4(0*.6!,.(!&,5".9!.;&*%=!I)!:$"&*!10"/"4*9*!

%"&',&*(!-*!;'&%"(*!*/*0)(,)!*+1*0"*.2*%!;A!0,2"%-%!,.(!&$*"0!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!2'4&'0*%!;A!4;2,4!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!!I)!,110;,2$!&;!0*%*,02$!

:,%!".A4'*.2*(!@)!A*-"."%&!,.&"E0,2"%&!%2$;4,0%!%'2$!,%!@*44!$;;5%6!G,&0"2",!T"44!

S;44".%6!T"-,."!F,..*0M"6!,.(!R.,5%$"!C',6!:$;!%&0*%%!$;:!0,2",4"J*(!&$",.)*9!

:"&$".!,2,(*-",!,.(!(;-".,.&!b*%&*0.!,%%'-1&";.%!"%!;A&*.!A'0&$*0!.;0-,4"J*(!@)!

:$"&*!,2,(*-"2!A*-"."%&%=!D%!:"&$!/"9"4,.2*!0*9,0(".9!2"%E10"/"4*9*6!>!:;05!,9,".%&!

,%%'-1&";.%!@,%*(!".!b*%&*0.!.;0-%6!:$"2$!2;'4(!9;/*0.!-)!".&*010*&,&";.!;A!

0*%*,02$!(,&,=!h;0!*+,-14*6!&$*0*!"%!,!&*.(*.2)!A;0!:$"&*6!L'**0!,2&"/"%&%!&;!A0,-*!

0,2"%-!,%!,.!"%%'*!&$,&!$,%!@**.!(*,4&!:"&$!".!,!:,)!&$,&!$;-;1$;@",!$,%!.;&=!>!&0)!

&;!*+,-".*!&$*!:,)!%'2$!10,2&"2*%!2,.!0*".A;02*!.;0-%!%'00;'.(".9!:$"&*.*%%!

:$"4*!%"-'4&,.*;'%4)!0*".A;02".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!

I)!:;05!$"%&;0)!,%!,.!HHb!".A4'*.2*(!-)!(*2"%";.!&;!2;.('2&!&$"%!%&'()!,.(!

,4%;!10;/"(*(!-*!:"&$!,.!,:,0*.*%%!;A!:,)%!&;!2;.('2&!-)%*4A!:"&$".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!

,.(!14,)90;'.(!".!;0(*0!&;!;@%*0/*!2$"4(0*.B%!14,)!,.(!A;0-,4!4*,0.".9!,2&"/"&"*%!

'.;@&0'%"/*4)=!#$,&!&$*!2$"4(0*.!L'"254)!@*2,-*!2;-A;0&,@4*!:"&$!-)!10*%*.2*!:,%!

".!1,0&!('*!&;!-)!;:.!*AA;0&%!,.(!-,)!,4%;!$,/*!@**.!('*!&;!:,)%!&$,&!>!3,4-;%&7!

/"%',44)!,4"9.*(!:"&$!&$;%*!:$;-!&$*)!,0*!,22'%&;-*(!&;!%**".9!".!&$*!%2$;;4=!#$"%!

'.(;'@&*(4)!10;('2*(!("AA*0*.&!0*%*,02$!A".(".9%!&$,.!%;-*;.*!*4%*!:;'4(!

'.2;/*0!".!,!%"-"4,0!*./"0;.-*.&=!

Page 33: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y]!

!

:CA=EDF$)PDFP<D`J$

I)!("%%*0&,&";.!"%!;09,."J*(!".&;!%"+!-,".!2$,1&*0%!&$,&!@0,"(!&;9*&$*0!&;!

*+14;0*!$;:!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!-,."A*%&%!".!8".(*09,0&*.!".!:,)%!&$,&!

-,5*!%;2",4!;&$*0".9!;A!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!2;--;.14,2*!A0;-!&$*!

*,04)!)*,0%!;A!10"-,0)!%2$;;4=!#$*!2$,1&*0%!,4%;!*+14;0*!1;".&%!;A!0*%"%&,.2*!

9*.*0,&*(!&$0;'9$!,2&";.%!;A!&$*!*('2,&;0%!,.(!&$*!2$"4(0*.=!#$*!A"0%&!&$0**!

2$,1&*0%!%*&!'1!&$*!&$*;0*&"2,4!A0,-*:;056!$"%&;0"2,4!2;.&*+&6!,.(!-*&$;(;4;9"2,4!

,110;,2$*%!:"&$".!-)!0*%*,02$!,.(!:0"&".96!,.(!&$*!0*-,".".9!&$0**!(0,:!-;0*!

%'@%&,.&",44)!A0;-!-)!A"*4(:;05!(,&,=!!

>.!&$*!2$,1&*06!N#$*;0*&"2,4!h0,-*:;05!,.(!S;.&0"@'&";.%!&;!a"&*0,&'0*6O!>!

(*A".*!5*)!&*0-%!,%!&$*)!,0*!'%*(!&$0;'9$;'&!&$"%!%&'()X!%'2$!,%6!$*&*0;%*+"%-6!

$;-;1$;@",6!,.(!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!#$"%!%"&',&*%!-)!:;05!:"&$".!,.&"E

0,2"%&6!A*-"."%&6!,.(!L'**0!&$*;0)6!".A4'*.2*(!@)!%2$;4,0%!%'2$!,%!8*/".!8'-,%$"0;6!

`'("&$!F'&4*06!,.(!I"2$*4!h;'2,'4&=!>.!,(("&";.6!>!10;/"(*!,.!;/*0/"*:!;A!4"&*0,&'0*!

;.!L'**0.*%%$3".24'(".9!$;-;1$;@",6!&0,.%1$;@",6!$*&*0;%*+"%-7!,.(!9*.(*0!".!

1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!&;!:$"2$!-)!:;05!2;.&0"@'&*%=!h".,44)6!>!14,2*!-)!%&'()!".!&$*!2;.&*+&!

;A!*-*09".9!:;05!A0;-!20"&"2,4!2$"4($;;(!%&'("*%6!:$"2$!*+,-".*%!2'4&'0,4!

2;.%&0'2&";.%!;A!L'**0.*%%!,.(!2$"4($;;(=!H'2$!:;05!*+,-".*%!$;:!

2;.2*1&',4"J,&";.%!;A!2$"4($;;(!"..;2*.2*!,.(!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!0*.(*0!

L'**0!2$"4(0*.!'.&$".5,@4*!3,%!2$"4(0*.!,0*!'.(*0%&;;(!&;!@*!&;;!);'.9!,.(!

N"..;2*.&O!&;!(*1,0&!A0;-!&$*!.;0-7!,.(!L'**0!2$"4($;;(%!,%!"-1;%%"@4*!3,%!

Page 34: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Yk!

!

2$"4($;;(!"%!2'4&'0,44)!(*A".*(!,%!,!&"-*!;A!"9.;0,.2*!;A!("/*0%*!9*.(*0%!,.(!

%*+',4"&"*%7=!!

#$*!%*2;.(!2$,1&*0_S,.,(",.!G'@4"2!H2$;;4%!".!S;.&*+&6!C"%0'1&".9!

>(*,4"J*(!G,%&%_10;/"(*%!$"%&;0"2,4!2;.&*+&%!:"&$".!:$"2$!&$"%!%&'()!;A!9*.(*0!".!

S,.,(",.!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!"%!%"&',&*(=!#$"%!2$,1&*0!@0"*A4)!;/*0/"*:%!S,.,(,B%!2;4;.",4!

1,%&6!&$*!2'4&'0,4!9*.;2"(*!;A!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%6!,.(!&$*!4*9,2)!&$"%!$,%!4*A&!;.!

D@;0"9".,4!1*;14*!,.(!2;--'."&"*%=!#$*!4*9,2)!;A!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%!".24'(*%!

2;4;.",4!,&&*-1&%!&;!*+&".9'"%$!D@;0"9".,4!2'4&'0*%B!0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!9*.(*0!,.(!

%*+',4"&)=!#;!("%2'%%!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!".!,!S,.,(",.!%2$;;4!"./;4/*%!

0*2;9."J".9!2'00*.&!.;0-%!,%!&$*!;'&2;-*!;A!2;4;.",4"%-=!>!,4%;!("%2'%%!*AA;0&%!&;!

2$,.9*!&$*!*AA*2&%!;A!&$*%*!4*9,2"*%6!%'2$!,%!&$*!20*,&";.!;A!&$*!D@;0"9".,4!

R.$,.2*-*.&!b;05*0!3DRb7!1;%"&";.!&;!%'11;0&!D@;0"9".,4!%&'(*.&%!,.(!A,-"4"*%!

:"&$".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!#$*!DRb!:;05*(!:"&$!&:;!2$"4(0*.!".!&$*!24,%%!:$*0*!-)!

A"*4(%&'()!&;;5!14,2*=!#$"%!2$,1&*0!".&0;('2*%!&$*!0*4*/,.2*!;A!&$*!DRbB%!:;05!,%!"&!

0*4,&*%!&;!9*.(*06!%*+',4"&)6!,.(!&$*!D@;0"9".,4!%&'(*.&%!%$*!%'11;0&*(=!#$"%!2$,1&*0!

,4%;!*+,-".*%!$"%&;0"*%!;A!9*.(*0!".!-,".%&0*,-!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!,.(!:,)%!$"%&;0"2,4!

N-;0,4!1,."2O!;/*0!&$*!-,2)*)Q#$)&*(&-(,%7+#$)&*!%$,1*!("%2;'0%*%!;A!9*.(*0!,.(!

1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!".!2'00*.&!2;.&*+&%=!b"&$".!@;&$!%*2&";.%!;A!&$"%!2$,1&*06!>!(0,:!A0;-!

:;05!(;.*!@)!*('2,&;0%!".!-)!A"*4(:;05!:$;!:*0*!,&&*-1&".9!&;!2$,.9*!1'@4"2!

*('2,&";.,4!10,2&"2*%!&;!@*&&*0!-**&!&$*!.**(%!;A!,44!%&'(*.&%=!!

S$,1&*0!#$0**6!NI*&$;(;4;9"*%6O!*+,-".*%!-)!,110;,2$!&;!2;.('2&".9!&$"%!

%&'()!:"&$".!"&%!2'00*.&!2'4&'0,4!2;.&*+&=!>!;/*0/"*:!(*&,"4%!;A!&$*!%&'()!,.(!"&%!

Page 35: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Yi!

!

/,0";'%!2;-1;.*.&%!,.(!0*%*,02$!L'*%&";.%j!,%!:*446!>!10;/"(*!%;-*!9*.*0,4!

".A;0-,&";.!,@;'&!&$*!%2$;;46!"&%!4;2,&";.!:"&$".!?,.2;'/*06!,.(!1;4"&"2%!;A!

10;/".2",4!1;4"2"*%!,&!&$*!&"-*!;A!-)!%&'()=!>!(*4".*,&*!$;:!&$"%!,AA*2&*(!-)!%2$;;4!

%*4*2&";.!,.(!&$*!*&$"2,4!2;.%"(*0,&";.%!"./;4/*(!".!%*&&".9!'1!&$"%!%&'()=!!#$"%!

2$,1&*0!*+,-".*%!-*&$;(;4;9"2,4!4"&*0,&'0*!;.!2;.('2&".9!A;2'%!90;'1%!,.(!(;".9!

0*%*,02$!:"&$!2$"4(0*.!,%!:*44!,%!4"&*0,&'0*!;.!0*%*,02$*0!%&,.(1;".&=!>!0*A4*2&!;.!

$;:!>!%&0'2&'0*(!&$"%!%&'()!:"&$!&$*!9;,4!;A!,/;"(".9!&$*!;@M*2&"A"2,&";.!;A!2$"4(0*.6!

L'**06!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!1*;14*!".!0*%*,02$!,.(!".%&*,(!-,".&,".!,!A;2'%!;.!&$*!

,.,4)%"%!;A!".%&"&'&";.,4!10,2&"2*%=!!

I,.)!2;44*,9'*%!,.(!-'2$!-*&$;(;4;9"2,4!4"&*0,&'0*!3S'44*.!,.(!H,.()6!

S'00,.,6!S$",0;44"@6!,.(!G,44;&&,ES$",0;44"26!b,44"%!,.(!?,.R/*0)7!2,'&";.*(!&$,&!('*!

&;!&,@;;%!,9,".%&!("%2'%%".9!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!:"&$!);'.9!

2$"4(0*.6!,!%&'()!%'2$!,%!-".*!:;'4(!A,2*!&;;!-,.)!%)%&*-"2!@,00"*0%!&;!@*!

2;.('2&*(!%'22*%%A'44)=!D%!%'2$6!&$"%!2$,1&*0!,4%;!*+,-".*%!$;:!>!.,/"9,&*(!

".%&"&'&";.,4!.;0-%!:$*.!%*&&".9!'1!,.(!*+*2'&".9!-)!0*%*,02$!".!;0(*0!&;!-,5*!&$*!

%&'()!1;%%"@4*!".!4"9$&!;A!%'2$!&,@;;%=!

S$,1&*0!h;'0X!NT*&*0;%*+',4"&)!,%!R/*0)(,)!a"A*X!R+,-".".9!o>..;2*.2*6O!

'.1,25%!$;:!&$*!2;.2*1&%!;A!N"..;2*.2*O!,.(!N,9*E,110;10",&*O!4*,0.".9!,0*!;A&*.!

%&**1*(!".!.;0-,&"/*!,%%'-1&";.%!&$,&!4"-"&!;11;0&'."&"*%!A;0!%;2",4!2$,.9*=!>.!&$"%!

2$,1&*06!>!*+,-".*!&$*%*!2;.2*1&%!A;0!$;:!&$*)!(*%*+',4"J*!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!,.(!

1;%"&!9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!,%!%"-14*!:$"4*!;/*0E%*+',4"J".9!L'**0.*%%!,.(!1;%"&".9!

&0,.%9*.(*0!"(*.&"&"*%!,%!'.('4)!2;-14"2,&*(=!#$'%!2;-14"2,&*(!,.(!;/*04)!

Page 36: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YZ!

!

%*+',4"J*(6!("/*0%*!9*.(*0%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%!,0*!(**-*(!".,110;10",&*!A;0!10"-,0)!

90,(*%6!:$"4*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!"%!10*(;-".,.&!".!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*%=!

D&&*-1&%!&;!".&*0/*.*!@)!2$,44*.9".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!&$*.!A,2*!&$*!

,%%'-1&";.!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!.,#66=(#.,("..;2*.&6!0,&$*0!&$,.!*+,-".".9!:$,&!&$*)!

,2&',44)!(;!,.(!&,45!,@;'&=!>.!;@%*0/".9!2$"4(0*.B%!*/*0)(,)!&,45!,.(!14,)6!"&!:,%!

*/"(*.&!&$,&!&$*)!:*0*!*.9,9*(!".!("%2'%%".9!9*.(*0!.;0-%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%=!>.!&$"%!

2$,1&*06!>!,.,4)J*!$;:!'.20"&"2,44)!A0,-".9!2$"4(0*.!,%!N"..;2*.&O!4*,/*%!(;-".,.&!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!'.2$,44*.9*(!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!,.(!&$'%!,44;:%!&$*-!3*=9=6!

9*.(*0!1;4"2".9!".!:,%$0;;-%6!1$)%"2,4!-,4*!(;-".,.2*7!&;!@*!.,&'0,4"J*(!".!&$*!

A;'.(,&";.,4!)*,0%!;A!1'@4"2!*('2,&";.=!#$*%*!(;'@4*!%&,.(,0(%!,.(!2;.&0,("2&";.%!

&,5*!14,2*!(*%1"&*!&$*!?HFB%!1;4"2"*%!10;-;&".9!%;2",4!*L',4"&)!".!%2$;;4%=!!

#$*!?HF!$,%!,!10;90*%%"/*!%&,.2*!;.!,.&"E$;-;1$;@",=!I,.)!3@'&!.;&!,447!

%2$;;4!,(-"."%&0,&;0%!,.(!&*,2$*0%!,4%;!@*4"*/*!&$,&!&$*"0!%2$;;4%!,.(!24,%%0;;-%!

%$;'4(!10;/"(*!*./"0;.-*.&%!".!:$"2$!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%&'(*.&%!2,.!&$0"/*=!

>(*,%!,@;'&!:$,&!5".(!;A!:;05!:"44!20*,&*!%'2$!*./"0;.-*.&%!("AA*0!:"(*4)!A0;-!

%2$;;4!&;!%2$;;4=!>.!&$*!2,%*!;A!-)!A"*4(!%&'()6!&$"%!:;05!:,%!4,09*4)!2;.2*1&',4"J*(!

,%!".&*0/*.&";.!".!&$*!A,2*!;A!,.&"E9,)!%&,&*-*.&%=!S$,1&*0!h"/*6!N\'**0.*%%!,%!,!

H1*2",4!R/*.&X!D.!D.,4)%"%!;A!oC"AA*0*.2*B!C"%2;'0%*6O!(0,:%!A0;-!".&*0/"*:%!:"&$!

*('2,&;0%!&;!%"&',&*!%1*2",4!*/*.&%!:"&$".!&$*!4,09*0!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*!,.(!1;4"&"2%!;A!

1,0*.&,4!2;.2*0.6!A'.(".9!%$;0&,9*%6!,.(!%&,AA!$;-;1$;@",=!>.!&$"%!2$,1&*06!>!*+14;0*!

&$*!"-14"2,&";.%!;A!:$*0*!,.(!$;:!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!1*;14*!,11*,0!".!&$"%!

A0,-*:;05!;A!".&*0/*.&";.=!G,0&"2'4,04)6!,%!L'**0.*%%!:,%!-*.&";.*(!%;4*4)!".!&$*!

Page 37: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YW!

!

2;.&*+&!;A!@'44)".96!>!L'*%&";.!$;:!&$"%!A;0*24;%*%!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!A;0!%&'(*.&%!:$;!%**!

&$*-%*4/*%!;'&%"(*!(;-".,.&!.;0-%=!!

S$,1&*0!H"+6!NC;9!S$"4(0*.!,.(!^*.(*0!S0;%%".96O!(0,:%!A0;-!A"*4(:;05!(,&,!

&$,&!"44'-".,&*!1;&*.&",4!".&*00'1&";.%!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!;&$*0".9=!

b"&$;'&!,(;1&".9!,!%1*2"A"2,44)!9*.(*0*(!1*0%1*2&"/*6!&$*!24,%%0;;-!&*,2$*0!

A;2'%*(!;.!*.2;'0,9".9!%&'(*.&%B!%*4AE,:,0*.*%%!,.(!%*4AE,(/;2,2)=!!#$"%!,110;,2$!

$*41*(!&;!-"&"9,&*!%;-*!;A!&$*!10;@4*-%!"(*.&"A"*(!".!4"&*0,&'0*!0*9,0(".9!9*.(*0!

,.(!*('2,&";.!:$*0*@)!@;)%!,0*!%,"(!&;!N,2&!;'&O!,.(!9*&!".!&0;'@4*!

("%10;1;0&";.,&*4)!2;-1,0*(!&;!9"04%!:$;!,0*!&$;'9$&!&;!1,%%"/*4)!2;-14)!:"&$!

,('4&%B!:"%$*%=!I,09,0*&B%!1*(,9;9)!-,(*!0;;-!A;0!%&'(*.&%!&;!A".(!,4&*0.,&*!-*,.%!

&;!*.9,9*!:"&$!&$*"0!*('2,&";.,4!,.(!1*0%;.,4!.**(%j!".!1,0&"2'4,06!;.*!%&'(*.&6!

C'.2,.6!&;!'.(*0%&,.(!$;:!$"%!N,2&".9!;'&O!:,%!0*4,&*(!&;!A**4".9!A0'%&0,&*(!&$,&!

,%1*2&%!;A!$"-%*4A!&$,&!("(!.;&!2;.A;0-!&;!9*.(*0!.;0-%=!!

>!,4%;!*+,-".*!.,00,&"/*%!&$,&!2,44!".&;!L'*%&";.!&$*!".*/"&,@"4"&)!;A!

*+1*0"*.2".9!("%&0*%%!;/*0!@*2;-".9!,:,0*!;A!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%=!

>!2;.&0,%&!C'.2,.B%!*+1*0"*.2*!:"&$!;&$*0!A;0-%!;A!%*4AE*+14;0,&";.!".!:$"2$!

%&'(*.&%!*+1*0"*.2*(!,!%*.%*!;A!*+2"&*-*.&!;0!1*0%;.,4!*+1,.%";.=!>!,09'*!&$,&!

0*A0,-".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!-*,.".9%!;A!"..;2*.2*!,.(!2$,44*.9".9!"-14"2"&!

$;-;1$;@",!,.(!&0,.%1$;@",!".!("%2;'0%*%!;A!N,22*1&".9!("AA*0*.2*6O!A;0-!,!@,%"%!

A0;-!:$"2$!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!2;'4(!@*!@*&&*0!".&*90,&*(!".&;!&$*!

*/*0)(,)!4"A*!;A!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!h0;-!&$"%!@,%"%6!&$"%!2$,1&*0!*+14;0*%!:,)%!;A!

Page 38: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

fV!

!

0*2;.2*1&',4"J".9!9*.(*0%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%!&$,&!-;/*!,:,)!A0;-!-;(*4%!&$,&!

2;.A4,&*!N2;-".9!;'&O!:"&$!1,".A'4!"%;4,&";.=!!

#$"%!%&'()!10;/"(*%!,.!"..;/,&"/*!,.,4)%"%!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!

2'4&'0*!".!8".(*09,0&*.!:"&$!".%"9$&!".&;!$;:!%'2$!.;0-%!,0*!0*10;('2*(!".!

;0(".,0)!:,)%X!%'2$!,%!%&;0)!&"-*6!24,%%0;;-!1;%&*0%6!,.(!2,%',4!$,44:,)!&,45=!!H'2$!

".%"9$&%!$,/*!"-14"2,&";.%!A;0!:,)%!%;2",4!2$,.9*!2,.!@*!,110;,2$*(=!#$"%!0*%*,02$!

(*-;.%&0,&*%!2$"4(0*.B%_".24'(".9!8".(*09,0&*.!%&'(*.&%B_,2&"/*!1,0&"2"1,&";.!".!

20*,&".9!,.(!0*%"%&".9!%;2",4!.;0-%6!,((".9!,.!"-1;0&,.&!2;.&0"@'&";.!&;!4"&*0,&'0*!

;.!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!9*.(*0!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!F)!*+,-".".9!&$*!"-14"2,&";.%!;A!

$*&*0;<.;0-,&"/*!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!A;0!1;&*.&",44)!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!1*;14*6!&$"%!

0*%*,02$!(*1,0&%!A0;-!&0*.(%!&$,&!*0,%*!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!A0;-!

2;.2*1&',4"J,&";.%!;A!2$"4($;;(!3:$"4*!,%%'-".9!&$,&!,44!2$"4(0*.!,0*!10*E

$*&*0;%*+',4!,.(!9*.(*0E.;0-,&"/*7=!!

#$0;'9$;'&!(,&,!9*.*0,&";.!,.(!,.,4)%"%6!>!%;'9$&!&;!*-14;)!,.&"E0,2"%&!

,110;,2$*%!&;!2;'.&*0".9!.*9,&"/*!*AA*2&%!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!".!%2$;;4%=!

D%!%'2$6!>!9"/*!20"&"2,4!,&&*.&";.!&;!&$*!1;%"&";.".9!;A!:$"&*.*%%!,.(!("%2;'0%*%!;A!

0,2*!:"&$".!&$*!24,%%0;;-_&$"%!".24'(*%!,&&*.&";.!&;!2$"4(0*.B%!,9*.2)!".!

0*10;('2".9!,.(!2$,44*.9".9!%'2$!.;0-%=!I;0*;/*06!&$"%!,110;,2$!-,.(,&*%!&$,&!

*('2,&;0%!,0*!,22;'.&,@4*!A;0!2'4&'0,44)!.;0-,4"J".9!10,2&"2*%!,.(!:,)%!&$*!

24,%%0;;-!2,.!10"/"4*9*!:$"&*.*%%6!;0!&$*!:,)!,.&"E$;-;1$;@",!:;05!2,.!

1*01*&',&*!;0!-,%5!0,2"%-%=!D%!%'2$6!&$"%!:;05!:"44!@*!@*.*A"2",4!&;!&$;%*!%**5".9!

,.&"E0,2"%&!,110;,2$*%!&;!'.0,/*4".9!"%%'*%!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!".!

Page 39: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

fU!

!

*('2,&";.,4!".%&"&'&";.%=!#$"%!0*%*,02$!:"44!@*!;A!10,2&"2,4!'%*!@;&$!:"&$".!,2,(*-"2!

("%2"14".*%!%'2$!,%!H;2";4;9)6!b;-*.B%!,.(!^*.(*0!H&'("*%6!,.(!R('2,&";.6!,.(!&;!

*('2,&;0%6!1,0*.&%6!%;2",4!:;05*0%6!,.(!;&$*0%!2;.2*0.*(!:"&$!"%%'*%!;A!9*.(*0!,.(!

%*+',4"&)!&$0;'9$;'&!&$*!4"A*%1,.=!$

$ $

Page 40: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

fY!

!

:CA=EDF$)BD,$%CD?FDE<ZA>$;FA@D`?FT$ABY$:?BEF<8HE<?BJ$E?$&<EDFAEHFD$

"BEF?YHZE<?B$$

>.!RJ)3$,2&6&9=(&-($",(>6&3,$B(R/*!H*(9:"25!(*%20"@*%!3,GB(9,*%,.6!,.(!

3,G7#6)$=$,%!N&$0**!&*0-%!:$;%*!'%,9*!0*4,&";.%!,.(!,.,4)&"2,4!0*4,&";.%!,0*!,4-;%&!

"00*-*(",@4)!%4"11*0)O!3Yi7=!b$,&!&$*%*!&$0**!&*0-%!-*,.!("AA*0%!".!,4-;%&!*/*0)!

2;.&*+&!".!:$"2$!&$*)!2,.!@*!'%*(=!>&!"%!.;!:;.(*0!&$,&!,!:"(*!9,-'&!;A!:,)%!

".("/"(',4%!'.(*0%&,.(!"%%'*%!2;.2*0.".9!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!

*+"%&%=!#$"%!2$,1&*0!"%!(*("2,&*(!&;!-,5".9!-)!&$*;0*&"2,4!,110;,2$*%!&;!&$"%!%&'()!

,%!&0,.%1,0*.&!,%!1;%%"@4*=! !

>.!&$"%!2$,1&*06!>!2;.&*+&',4"J*!-)!%&'()!:"&$".!0*4*/,.&!4"&*0,&'0*=!#$*!8*)!

#*0-%!%*2&";.!*+14"2,&*%!-)!,110;,2$!&;!%&'()".9!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)=!>.!&$"%!

%*2&";.!>!".&0;('2*!2;.2*1&%!;A!.;0-%6!$"((*.!2'00"2'4'-6!;&$*0".96!,.(!$;:!%'2$!

;&$*0".9!"%!,22;-14"%$*(!&$0;'9$!0;'&".*!1*0A;0-,&"/*!,2&%!,.(!*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%=!

b$"4*!-'2$!$,%!@**.!:0"&&*.!;.!$"9$!%2$;;4%!,.(!$;-;1$;@",6!,.(!9*.(*0!,.(!

*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;46!8".(*09,0&*.!,%!,!%"&*!A;0!&$*!10;('2&";.!,.(!0*10;('2&";.!;A!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!$,%!.;&!@**.!&$*!%'@M*2&!;A!,!%'@%&,.&"/*!%2$;4,04)!%&'()!

".!S,.,(,=!D%!%'2$6!&$"%!%&'()!2;.&0"@'&*%!&;!&$*!("%2'%%";.%!,@;'&!$;:!*('2,&";.,4!

*+1*0"*.2*%!".!&$*!*,04)!10"-,0)!)*,0%!2,.!.;0-,4"J*!9*.(*0%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%!,.(!

@;&$!20*,&*!,.(!2$,44*.9*!&$*!*+24'%";.,0)!%&,&'%!L';=!

7D9$%DF@J$ABY$"B_>HDBZDJ$

>!2;.2*.&0,&*!;.!",$,.&3,G)32(3&$*!10"/"4*9".9!;A!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)7!0,&$*0!&$,.!

"&2&J"&/)#!".!;0(*0!&;!&,5*!".&;!,22;'.&!%'@&4*6!*/*0)(,)!;22'00*.2*%!&$,&!

Page 41: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

ff!

!

0*".A;02*!&$*!%&,&'%!L';!;A!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)=U]!>!&,5*!&$"%!A;2'%!A;0!&$0**!0*,%;.%X!

"&!".20*,%*%!,&&*.&";.!&;!&$*!%'@&4*!10"/"4*9".9!;A!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!0,&$*0!&$,.!%;4*4)!

;.!@4,&,.&!,.&"E9,)!/";4*.2*j!"&!,44;:%!A;0!,!A;2'%!;.!&$*!".&*014,)!@*&:**.!

$*&*0;%*+"%-!,.(!%*+"%-!*-@*((*(!".!9*.(*0!.;0-%j!,.(!"&!&,5*%!&$*!A;2'%!;AA!

$;-;1$;@",!,%!,.!".("/"(',4!1%)2$;4;9"2,4!10;@4*-!,.(!*+,-".*%!"&!".!"&%!%;2",4!,.(!

".%&"&'&";.,4!2;.&*+&=!!D%!Q*@*22,!T,%5*44!,.(!F0",.!F'0&2$!:0"&*!".!E,$($"#$(1.,#P;(

S&2&J"&/)#(#*%(0.#*3J"&/)#()*(S)9"(I+"&&636!No1$;@",BO!"-14"*%!&$,&!&$0*,&%6!

1'&(;:.%!,.(!9*.*0,4!$,0,%%-*.&!;A!L'**0!1*;14*!%&*-!A0;-!".("/"(',4%B!

1%)2$;4;9"2,4!"-1,"0-*.&%6!,!A;2'%!&$,&!(;*%!.;&!,((0*%%!%;2"*&,4!,.(!".%&"&'&";.,4!

0;;&%O!3Uf7=!

#$;-,%!H2;&&!C'5*!-,5*%!&$*!A;44;:".9!("%&".2&";.!@*&:**.!$;-;1$;@",!

,.(!$*&*0;%*+"%-X!$;-;1$;@",!"./;4/*%!NA*,0!,.(!4;,&$".9O!3U]V76!:$"4*!

$*&*0;%*+"%-!"%!&$*!@*4"*A!&$,&!N;.4)!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!"%!9;;(6!$*,4&$)!,.(!o.;0-,4BO!

3U]V7=!b"&$".!&$*!2;.&*+&!;A!-)!0*%*,02$6!>!("%2'%%!$;-;1$;@",!,%!;.*!;A!-,.)!

1;%%"@4*!;'&2;-*%!;A!$*&*0;%*+"%&!@*4"*A%6!:$"4*!10"-,0"4)!9"/".9!,&&*.&";.!&;!

.;0-,4"J,&";.=!S=`=!G,%2;*B%!%&'()6!T7%,B(U&7O.,(#(1#9;(C#3+76)*)$=()*(S)9"(I+"&&6!

3YVVi76!("%2'%%*%!&$*!("%&".2&";.!@*&:**.!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!$*&*0;%*+"%-!,%!%$*!%,:!

"&!14,)!;'&!,&!Q"/*0!T"9$!".!S,4"A;0.",=!H$*!:0"&*%6!NT;-;1$;@",!&;;5!&$*!A;0-!;A!

@4,&,.&!,.&"9,)!10,2&"2*%!,.(6!-;0*!2;--;.4)6!&$*!%&,9".9!;A!&,5*.EA;0E90,.&*(!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

U]!b$"4*!-)!0*%*,02$!A;2'%*%!;.!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!,.(!$*&*0;%*+"%-6!

-'2$!;A!&$*!4"&*0,&'0*!>!&,5*!'1!0*9,0(".9!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!0*A*0%!&;!$;-;1$;@",j!

&$*0*A;0*6!:$"4*!>!20"&"L'*!,%1*2&%!;A!&$"%!&*0-".;4;9)6!>!,4%;!0*A*0!&;!"&!,%!1,0&!;A!&$*!

("%2;'0%*!".!:$"2$!-)!%&'()!"%!%"&',&*(=!!

Page 42: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

f[!

!

$*&*0;.;0-,&"/*!%2$;;4!2*0*-;."*%!,.(!&0,("&";.%O!3G,%2;*!UkU7=!>.!-)!A"*4(:;056!

&$*!0*1*&"&";.!;A!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!,%!0;'&".*!,.(!*/*0)(,)!1;%"&";.*(!"&!,%!.;0-,4!3&;!

&$*!*+24'%";.!;A!;&$*0!%*+',4"&"*%7!*/*.!:$*.!*('2,&;0%!*%1;'%*(!,!@*4"*A!&$,&!:"(*!

0,.9*%!;A!%*+',4"&"*%!:*0*!N9;;(O!,.(!N$*,4&$)=O$

H&'("*%!;A!10"-,0)!%2$;;4%!$,/*!*+,-".*(!$;:!9*.(*0!.;0-%!".!*4*-*.&,0)!

*('2,&";.!0*2,1"&'4,&*!-,4*!2;.&0;4j!&$*!&$0*,&!;A!@*2;-".9!N4"5*!,!9"04O!"%!,!:*,1;.!

;0!".%'4&!A;0!@;)%!3,!4;%%!;A!1;:*07!:$"4*!N&;-@;)O!"%!,!1;".&!;A!10"(*!A;0!-,.)!9"04%6!

,.(!0"%5%!4*%%!;A!,!4;%%!;A!%&,&'%!:"&$!&$*"0!1**0%!3F,"4*)6!T,4@*0%&,-!YVV[6!#$;0.*7=!

H"-"4,04)6!%&'("*%!;A!9*.(*0!.;0-%!,.(!%*+',4"&)!".!$"9$!%2$;;4!$,/*!'09*(!

*('2,&;0%!&;!,.,4)J*!$;:!N.;0-,&"/*!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4!"(*.&"&"*%!1*01*&',&*!

'.*L',4!9*.(*0!,00,.9*-*.&%O!3G,%2;*!UkZ7=!!G,%2;*B%!,.,4)%"%!,09'*%!&$,&!-'2$!;A!

&$*!,.&"E9,)!&,45!%$*!;@%*0/*(!A0;-!$"9$!%2$;;4!@;)%!:,%!,@;'&!,%%*0&".9!

(;-".,.2*!;/*0!9"04%!,%!,!:,)!;A!*%&,@4"%$".9!-,%2'4"."&)6!*%1*2",44)!/"%EtE/"%!1**0%!

3G,%2;*!UV[7=!!F)!A;2'%".9!;.!$*&*0;%*+"%-!,%!%)%&*-"2,44)!".%&"&'&";.,4"J*(6!&$*!

*-1$,%"%!2,.!@*!&,5*.!;AA!!",$",.(&.(*&$!,!1*0%;.!"%!9,)!,.(!0*-,".!;.!:$,&!

$*&*0;%*+"%-!%&,3B(%'2$!,%!0*".A;02".9!9*.(*0*(!,.(!;&$*0!%;2",4!".*L'"&"*%=!$

b"&$".!1,0&"2'4,0!%2$;;4%!;A!L'**0!&$*;0)!3F'&4*06!T,4@*0%&,-!UWWZ6!P;@4*7!

$*&*0;.;0-,&"/"&)!0*A*0%!.;&!;.4)!&;!2;-1'4%;0)!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!3Q"2$76!@'&!,4%;!&;!

:,)%!&$,&!.;&";.%!;A!-,%2'4"."&)!,.(!A*-"."."&)!.;0-,4"J*!1,0&"2'4,0!

$*&*0;%*+',4"&"*%=!!>.!NH2$;;4!S'4&'0*!,.(!&$*!b*44EF*".9!;A!H,-*EH*+!D&&0,2&*(!

g;'&$6O!a".(%,)!b"45".%;.!,.(!`*.."A*0!G*,0%;.!(*A".*!&$"%!(',4!'%,9*!&$'%X!

Page 43: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

f]!

!

T*&*0;.;0-,&"/"&)!"./;4/*%!&$*!2*4*@0,&";.!;A!$*&*0;%*+',4!0*4,&";.%$"1%!,%!

:*44!,%!&$*!;09,."J,&";.!;A!2'4&'0*6!".24'(".9!".%&"&'&";.%6!,0;'.(!%'2$!

0*4,&";.%$"1%!3h;'2,'4&!UWiZ7=!>&!,4%;!"./;4/*%!&$*!2*4*@0,&";.!;A!%;2",44)!

2;.%&0'2&*(!9*.(*0*(!@*$,/";0%!&$,&!$"9$4"9$&!&$*!("AA*0*.2*%!@*&:**.!-*.!

,.(!:;-*.!,%!:*44!,%!&$*!%,.2&";.".9!;A!9*.(*0!&0,.%90*%%";.%!&$,&!("%0'1&!

&$"%!N.,&'0,4O!@".,0)=!3][[7!

T;:*/*06!>!0*A*0!&;!",$,.&V9,*%,.(*&.2#$)W)$=!".!;0(*0!&;!9"/*!10"-,2)!&;!&$*!

-*2$,."%-%!,&!14,)!".!&$*!30*710;('2&";.!,.(!2;.&*%&,&";.!;A!@;&$=!>!'%*!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!&$0;'9$;'&!-)!0*%*,02$!&;!0*A*0!&;!@;&$!$*&*0;%*+"%-!

,.(!(;-".,.&!9*.(*0!.;0-%6!,%!&$*!&:;!2,&*9;0"*%!".A;0-!*,2$!;&$*0_

$*&*0;%*+"%-!:;'4(!.;&!-,."A*%&!2'4&'0,44)!".!&$*!:,)!&$,&!"&!(;*%!:*0*!"&!.;&!A;0!

.;0-,&"/*!9*.(*0!0;4*%6!,.(!9*.(*0!0;4*%!:;'4(!@*!("AA*0*.&!:*0*!&$*)!.;&!4".5*(!&;!

,!$*&*0;%*+',4!"-1*0,&"/*=!!

b$*.!("%2'%%".9!$*&*0;%*+"%-!,.(!9*.(*0!.;0-%!*-@*((*(!".!&$*!9*.(*0!

2'4&'0*!:"&$".!-)!A"*4(:;056!>!'%*!&$*!2;.2*1&%!;A!9,*%,.B(3,G7#6)$=B(9,*%,.(+76$7.,B(

#*%(*&.23!:"&$".!%1*2"A"2!&0,M*2&;0"*%=!>!*.9,9*!:"&$!9,*%,.!,%!,!10;2*%%!;A!%;2",4!

,.(!@";4;9"2,4!'.(*0%&,.(".9%!&$,&!10;('2*!-*,.".9%!;A!:$,&!"&!"%!&;!@*!-,4*!,.(!

A*-,4*6!-,%2'4".*!,.(!A*-".".*!3-;0*!;.!&$"%!%$;0&4)7=!>!0*A*0!&;!&$;%*!:$;%*!@"0&$!

,%%"9.,&";.!%'"&%!&$*"0!%*4AE"(*.&"A"2,&";.!3,%%"9.*(!A*-,4*!,&!@"0&$!,.(!2;.&".'*%!&;!

"(*.&"A)!,%!,!:;-,.7!,%!2"%9*.(*06!:$"4*!2"%%*+"%-!0*A*0%!&;!&$*!"(*,!&$,&!,44!1*;14*!

;'9$&!&;!@*!2"%9*.(*0!;0!&$,&!&$*0*!,0*!;.4)!&:;!9*.(*0%!,.(!*/*0);.*!-'%&!@*!;.*!

;0!&$*!;&$*0=!#$*!&*0-!&0,.%9*.(*0!*.2;-1,%%*%!&$;%*!:$;!"(*.&"A)!,%!&0,.%%*+',4!

Page 44: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

fk!

!

,.(!'&"4"J*!$;0-;.*!&$*0,1)!,.(!%'09*0)!&;!,4"9.!&$*"0!1$)%"2,4!,.(!%;2",4!@;("*%!

:"&$!&$*"0!9*.(*0!0*,4"&"*%=!#$*!:;0(!&0,.%9*.(*0!,4%;!0*A*0%!&;!1*;14*!:$;!(;!.;&!

"(*.&"A)!:"&$!&$*!9*.(*0!&$*)!:*0*!,%%"9.*(!,&!@"0&$=!#$*"0!"(*.&"A"2,&";.!-,)!&$*.!

@*!&$,&!;A!,!9*.(*0!(**-*(!N;11;%"&*6O!;0!,%!@;&$6!;0!,%!.*"&$*0!-,4*!.;0!A*-,4*!

3.;.E@".,0)!9*.(*0%!,0*!A'0&$*0!("%2'%%*(!".!&*0-%!;A!&:;E%1"0"&!"(*.&"&"*%!".!

S$,1&*0!#:;7=!I,.)!1*;14*!:$;!(;!.;&!2;.A;0-!&;!%;2",4!*+1*2&,&";.%!A;0!&$*"0!

,%%"9.*(!9*.(*0%!;0!:$;!(;!.;&!"(*.&"A)!:"&$".!,!@".,0)!-,)!"(*.&"A)!,%!

9*.(*0L'**0!;0!9*.(*0E.;.2;.A;0-".9=Uk!b$*.!>!("%2'%%!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!".!1'@4"2!

%2$;;4%!,.(!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%6!;0!:$*.!>!("%2'%%!("/*0%*!9*.(*0%!

,.(!%*+',4"&"*%6!>!,-!0*A*00".9!&;!,44!;A!&$*!,@;/*!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!&$,&!(*1,0&!A0;-!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!2'4&'0*=!!

D!.'-@*0!;A!%2$;4,0%!".!#0,.%9*.(*0!H&'("*%!("%2'%%!$;:6!:$*.!&$*!9*.(*0!

@".,0)!"%!("%0'1&*(6!%*+',4"&)!2,.!,4%;!@*2;-*!-;0*!2;-14*+!&$,.!2,&*9;0"*%!;A!

9,)<%&0,"9$&<@"!2,.!1;%%"@4)!,44;:=!#$*!*AA*2&%!;A!&$*!9*.(*0!@".,0)!;.!4,09*0!

2'4&'0,4!&$".5".96!0'.%!(**1=!D.9"*!h**!1;".&%!;'&!&$,&!&$*!N4"-"&*(!2;.2*1&',4!

%1,2*O!3YVi7!;A!$*&*0;%*+',4!("%2;'0%*!,.(!&$*!$;-;1$;@",!,%%;2",&*(!:"&$!"&6!0*%&%!

;.!!N@".,0)!%*+!,.(!9*.(*0O!3)/)%7!2,&*9;0"*%=!h**!,09'*%!,9,".%&!&$*!N2;.A4,&";.!;A!

%*+E9*.(*0E(*%"0*!:$"2$!4*,(%!&;!&$*!.;0-,4"J,&";.!;A!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)O!3)/)%L=!H$*!

*+,-".*%!$;:!.;0-,&"/*!"(*,%!;A!%*+',4"&)!,.(!9*.(*0!0'.!,%!(**1!,%!A,-"4",4!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Uk!H;-*!&0,.%9*.(*0!1*;14*!"(*.&"A)!,%!L'**0!,.(!%;-*!(;!.;&j!%;-*!"(*.&"A)!,%!

9*.(*0!.;.E2;.A;0-".9!,.(!%;-*!"(*.&"A)!,%!2;.A;0-".9!&;!&$*!.;0-%!;A!&$*"0!

,2&',4!0,&$*0!&$,.!&$*"0!,%%"9.*(!9*.(*0%!3&$*0*A;0*!9*.(*0E.;.2;.A;0-".9!"%!

".,22'0,&*!A;0!&$*-7=!

Page 45: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

fi!

!

.,-*%!3:"A*6!(,'9$&*06!%;.7=!H$*!%&,&*%6!N#$*0*!"%!.;!.,-*!A;0!,.!".&"-,&*!2,0".9!

%;2",4!'."&!&$,&!(;*%!.;&!0*4)!;.!,!.;0-,&"/*!'.(*0%&,.(!;A!A,-"4)!,%!%;-*&$".9!

:$"2$!2;-10"%*%!;A!;.*!A,&$*0!,.(!;.*!-;&$*0O!3YUf7=!b$*.!A0,-*(!".!&$"%!4"9$&6!"&!

"%!.;&!$,0(!&;!*+,-".*!$;:!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!"%!10*%*.&!A0;-!&$*!;.%*&!;A!

1'@4"2!*('2,&";.!,%6!0*4,&";.,44)6!(;-".,.&!2'4&'0*!"%!;09,."J*(!&;!(*.;&*!A,-"4",4!

@*4;.9".9!,4;.9!@".,0)!4".*%=!#$"%!,4%;!-,5*%!24*,0!&$*!*+&*.&!&;!:$"2$!".("/"(',4%!

-,)!@*!;&$*0*(!:$*.!&$*)!.;&!&;!A"&!24*,04)!".&;!,!9*.(*0!@".,0)=!!

P;&";.%!;A!%*+',4"&)!,0*!"--".*.&4)!@;'.(!&;!@".,0)!.;&";.%!;A!9*.(*0=!

S$0"%&;1$*0!H$*44*)!,.(!#,-!H,.9*0!$,/*!2;.('2&*(!0*%*,02$!&$,&!("%2'%%*%!&$*!

1,0,("9-!%$"A&%!&$,&!,0*!-,(*!1;%%"@4*!@)!0*&$".5".9!%*+',4"&)!;'&%"(*!;A!,!9*.(*0!

@".,0)=!H$*44*)!0*A*0%!&;!&$"%!,%!N1,0,(;+"2,4!$)@0"("&)O!:$"2$!*.&,"4%!,!N-'4&"14"2"&)!

,.(!0*4,&*(!2;.A"9'0,&";.%O!3YU7=!!T*!2"&*%!F;@@)!P;@4*B%!%&,&*-*.&!&$,&!$*!"%!No,!9')!

:$;!"%!$,4A!4*%@",.BO!3YU7=!#,-!H,.9*0!%'99*%&%!&$,&!&$;%*!:$;!-,1!&*00,".!;'&%"(*!

%'2$!@".,0"*%!N;AA*0!.*:!("0*2&";.%!A;0!%;2";4;9)O!3Y]W7=!H,.9*0!2"&*%!0*%*,02$!

1,0&"2"1,.&%!:$;!(*%20"@*!$;:!@"%*+',4"&)!"%!&;;!%"-14"%&"2!&;!*.2,1%'4,&*!&$*!0,.9*!

;A!.;.E@".,0)!9*.(*0%!&;!:$;-!&$*)!,0*!,&&0,2&*(!3YkkEYki7=!K&$*0!1,0&"2"1,.&%!

&;;5!&$*"0!;:.!;0!&$*"0!4;/*0%B!4"/*(!*+1*0"*.2*%!;'&%"(*!;A!&$*!9*.(*0!@".,0)!,%!

;11;0&'."&)!&;!2$,44*.9*!&$*"0!;:.!".&*0.,4"J*(!$;-;1$;@",!;0!9*.(*0!%&*0*;&)1*%=!

#$*%*!1,0&"2"1,.&%!(*%20"@*(!%'2$!*+1*0"*.2*%!,%!$,/".9!10;/"(*(!,!:,)!&;!;1*.!'1!

&;!,!90*,&*0!0,.9*!;A!&$*"0!;:.!%*+',4"&"*%!,.(!%*+',4!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!3Yki7=!>!'%*!&$*!

&*0-!L'**0!:"&$".!-)!0*%*,02$6!%1*2"A"2,44)!&;!*.2;-1,%%!,%!:"(*!,!0,.9*!,%!

1;%%"@4*!:$*.!0*A*00".9!&;!%*+',4"&"*%!;'&%"(*!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!!

Page 46: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

fZ!

!

>.!E,*%,.(5,W,.3#63(#*%(E,*%,.(>76$7.,3B(H,@0".,!G*&0,!Q,-*&!("%2'%%*%!

9,*%,.(+76$7.,!,%!q,!%;2"*&)l%!'.(*0%&,.(".9!;A!:$,&!"%!1;%%"@4*6!10;1*0!,.(!

1*0/*0%*!".!9*.(*0E4".5*(!@*$,/";0O!3Y76!:$"2$!".24'(*%!:$,&!N%*&!;A!/,4'*%6!-;0*%6!

,.(!,%%'-1&";.%u*%&,@4"%$*%!:$"2$!@*$,/";0%!,0*!&;!@*!%**.!,%!9*.(*0E4".5*(O!3Y7=!!

>!,114)!&$"%!2;.2*1&!;A!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!&;!-)!0*%*,02$!:"&$".!&$*!8".(*09,0&*.!

24,%%0;;-!,.(!;.!&$*!14,)90;'.(=!#$*!(,&,!>!9,&$*0*(!*+14;0*!&$*!A;44;:".9!

L'*%&";.%X!:$,&!*/*0)(,)!;22'00*.2*%!(*4".*,&*!N10;1*0!,.(!1*0/*0%*O!9*.(*0*(!

@*$,/";'0e!b$,&!@*$,/";'0%!,0*!%'@M*2&!&;!9*.(*0".9!,.(!$;:!(;*%!&$"%!;22'0!".!

*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%e!b$,&!A;0-%!;A!1;:*0!,.(!$"*0,02$"*%!,0*!.;0-,4"J*(!@)!%'2$!

10,2&"2*%e!b"45".%;.!,.(!G*,0%;.!,.,4)J*!%'2$!L'*%&";.%!".!&$*!2;.&*+&!;A!%2$;;4!

2'4&'0*=Ui!!#$*)!("%2'%%!$*&*0;.;0-,&"/*!2'4&'0*!,&!14,)!".!$"9$!%2$;;4!,.(!,%%*0&!

&$,&!"&!$,%!,(/*0%*!*AA*2&%!;.!&$*!4"/*%!;A!);'&$!:$;%*!(*%"0*%!(*1,0&!A0;-!%'2$!

.;0-%=!#$*)!:0"&*6!N>.!%2$;;4%6!,%!".!&$*!@0;,(*0!2'4&'0*6!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!"%!;A&*.!

,%%'-*(!,.(!".%&"&'&";.,44)!*.A;02*(!&$0;'9$!0"&',4%6!(,"4)!".&*0,2&";.%!@*&:**.!

%&'(*.&%!,.(!&*,2$*0%6!,.(!&$*!2'00"2'4'-O!3][Y7=!!b"&$".!-)!%&'()6!>!&;;5!".&*0*%&!

.;&!M'%&!".!:$,&!:,%!9*.(*0*(!3*=9=!&$*!2;4;'0!1".57!@'&!&$*!N/,4'*%6!-;0*%6!,.(!

,%%'-1&";.%O!&$,&!:*0*!*-@*((*(!".!&$"%!9*.(*0".9!3*=9=!&$,&!:*,0".9!1".5!-,05*(!

,!4;%%!;A!%&,&'%!A;0!@;)%!,.(!0*A4*2&*(!%*+"%&!,%%'-1&";.%!".!:$"2$!,&&0"@'&*%!(**-*(!

A*-".".*!$,/*!,!4;:*0!%&,&'%!&$,.!&$;%*!(**-*(!-,%2'4".*7=!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ui!b"45".%;.!,.(!G*,0%;.B%!%&'()!(0*:!A0;-!(,&,!9,&$*0*(!@)!&$*!dHD!@#$)&*#6(

D&*9)$7%)*#6(I$7%=(&-(<%&6,3+,*$(S,#6$"'!

Page 47: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

fW!

!

C'0".9!-)!A"*4(%&'()!,&!H;'&$!H"(*!R4*-*.&,0)!H2$;;46!I,09,0*&!

(*-;.%&0,&*(!;1*..*%%!&;!,!0,.9*!;A!9*.(*0!*+10*%%";.%!A0;-!%&'(*.&%6!:$"4*!

*+10*%%".9!%;-*!&0*1"(,&";.!,0;'.(!2;.A0;.&".9!9*.(*0!"%%'*%!("0*2&4)=!H$*!%&,&*(!

&$,&!".20*,%".9!$*0!2;-A;0&!4*/*4!:"&$!&,45".9!,@;'&!9*.(*0!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!:,%!

1,0&!;A!:$)!%$*!:,%!".&*0*%&*(!".!$;%&".9!-)!%&'()=!H$*!0*A4*2&*(!;.!$;:!M'%&!

5.;:".9!>!:,%!".!&$*!0;;-!:,%!*.2;'0,9".9!$*0X!!

v#w;!&$".5!-;0*!,@;'&!&$*!9*.(*0!0*4,&*(!%&'AA!:$"2$!"%!$;.*%&4)!%;-*&$".9!

&$,&6!@*2,'%*!>!$;.*%&4)!(;.B&!5.;:!:$,&!"%!N0"9$&O!,.(!:$,&!"%!N:0;.96O!>B-!

.;&!.*2*%%,0"4)!2;-A;0&,@4*!(;".9!,.)&$".96!;0!@0".9".9!"&!'1!,%!,!%'@M*2&!

*/*.6!4"5*!;$6!9"04%!,.(!@;)%6!$;:!"%!&$,&e!a*&B%!&,45!,@;'&!&$,&=!>!$,/*.B&!0*,44)!

(;.*!&$,&!:"&$!-)!24,%%6!,.(!.;:!>B-!".%1"0*(!&;6!M'%&!@)!$,/".9!);'!$*0*6!>B-!

4"5*!N;5,)6!>B/*!0*,44)!9;&!&;!&$".5!,@;'&!&$,&!1"*2*!&;;6!&$,&B%!,.;&$*0!/*0)!

"-1;0&,.&!,%1*2&6!>!-*,.6!;'0!"(*.&"&)6!%&0;.94)!".24'(*%!:$;!:*!A**4!4"5*!

9*.(*0E:"%*=!3Q;/*44,!YV!h*@=!YVUY7!

b$"4*!I,09,0*&!("(!.;&!,((0*%%!9*.(*0!"%%'*%!10*E*-1&"/*4)!".!&$*!

24,%%0;;-6!:$*.!>!,%5*(!$*0!"A!%$*!$,(!*/*0!$,(!,.)!%&'(*.&%!:$;!20;%%*(!9*.(*0!

.;0-%!('0".9!$*0!*4*/*.!)*,0%!;A!&*,2$".9!*+1*0"*.2*6!$*0!,.%:*0!"44'%&0,&*(!$*0!

(*%"0*!A;0!$*0!24,%%0;;-%!&;!$,/*!,!%,A*6!.;.E1'."&"/*!2'4&'0*!A;0!2$"4(0*.!&;!*+10*%%!

&$*-%*4/*%=!H$*!0*2;'.&*(!&$*!A;44;:".9!%&;0"*%X!!

D.(!".!-)!24,%%6!M'%&!&$".5".9!@,256!>B/*!$,(!,!2;'14*!)*,0%!,9;6!,!4"&&4*!@;)6!>!

'%*(!&;!$,/*!,!(0*%%!'1!2*.&0*!v:"&$w!,44!("AA*0*.&!5".(%!;A!2;%&'-*%!&$,&!&$*!

5"(%!2;'4(!&0)!;.!,.(!&$*0*!:,%!&$"%!@*,'&"A'46!4,2*!(0*%%!,.(!&$"%!4"&&4*!@;)!

Page 48: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

[V!

!

'%*(!&;!4;/*!&;!:*,0!&$"%!(0*%%!,.(!>!0*-*-@*0!;.2*!$*!:,%!&0)".9!"&!;.!,.(!

$*!5".(!;A!4;;5*(!,&!-*!,.(!$*!9"994*(!4"5*!N$**$**$**6!>B-!1'&&".9!;.!,!

(0*%%6O!D.(!>B-!4"5*6!NK$!:$,&!,!4;/*4)!(0*%%c!g;'!4;;5!/*0)!10*&&)!".!&$,&!

(0*%%=O!>!M'%&!5".(!;A!%,"(!&$,&!&;!$"-!,.(!5".(!;A!:,45*(!,:,)!,.(!2"02'4,&*(!

,.(!%,:!:$,&!&$*!;&$*0!5"(%!:*0*!(;".96!4*A&!"&!,&!&$,&=!D.(!$*!1'&!;.!&$*!

(0*%%!,4-;%&!*/*0)!%".94*!(,)!,.(!$*!M'%&!4"5*(!:*,0".9!&$*!(0*%%6!4"5*(6!);'!

5.;:6!@'&!"&!("(.B&!$,/*!&;!-*,.!,.)&$".9=!T*!M'%&!*.M;)*(6!:*,0".9!&$*!

(0*%%=!D.(!$*!:;'4(!1'&!$"-%*4A!".!,!A*-,4*!0;4*!:$"4*!$*!:,%!:*,0".9!&$*!

(0*%%!%;!$*!*L',&*(!&$*!(0*%%!:"&$!@*".9!A*-,4*6!%;!$*!:;'4(!@*!-;--)!,&!

&$,&!&"-*6!$*!:;'4(!@*!-;--)!;0!$*!:;'4(!@*!@"9!%"%&*0!,.(!$*!:;'4(!@*!

2;;5".9!-*,4%!A;0!:$;*/*0!*4%*!:;'4(!@*!14,)".9!:"&$!$"-!,%!$"%!A,-"4)!,.(!

$*!("(.B&!(;!&$,&!A;0!,!/*0)!4;.9!&"-*6!-,)@*!,@;'&!,!:**56!,.(!$*!5".(!;A!

*+14;0*(!&$,&!,.(!&$*.!$*!4*A&!&$,&!,.(!-;/*(!;.!&;!%;-*&$".9!*4%*6!,.(!,&!.;!

&"-*6!,&!4*,%&!&$,&!>!.;&"2*(6!,.(!>B-!:"44".9!&;!,22*1&!&$*!A,2&!&$,&!&$*0*!:,%!

10;@,@4)!%&'AA!&$,&!$,11*.*(!&$,&!>!M'%&!("(.B&!%**!*/*0)!%".94*!-;-*.&6!@'&!>!

("(!.;&!:"&.*%%!$"-!,&!,.)!&"-*!@*".9!1"25*(!;.!;0!L'*%&";.*(!@)!;&$*0!5"(%6!

Nb$)!,0*!);'!:*,0".9!,!(0*%%e!g;'B0*!,!@;)cO!#$*)!M'%&!5".(!;A!,22*1&*(!"&!

,.(!M'%&!5".(!;A!:*.&!;.=!#$*0*!:*0*!10;@,@4)!,!A*:!9"994*%!,&!&$*!@*9"..".96!

>!$;.*%&4)!2,.B&!0*-*-@*0=!>!0*-*-@*0!$"-!9"994".9!,.(!4;;5".9!,&!-*6!>!

0*-*-@*0!&$,&6!>!(;.B&!0*-*-@*0!:$,&!&$*!;&$*0!5"(%B!0*,2&";.!:,%=!!

D.(!&$*.!,.;&$*0!A*:!)*,0%!,9;!>!$,(!,.;&$*0!4"&&4*!@;)!:$;%*!A,/;'0"&*!

2;4;'0!:,%!1".56!%;!$*B(!2;-*!,.(!$*B(!:*,0!1".5!%$"0&%!&;!%2$;;46!,.(6!);'!

Page 49: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

[U!

!

5.;:6!:$*.!:*!:*0*!$,/".9!&,45%!,@;'&!;'0!A,/;'0"&*!2;4;'0%!,&!&$*!

@*9"..".9!;A!&$*!)*,06!$*!:,%!N:*446!-)!A,/;'0"&*!2;4;'0!"%!1".5cO!D.(!$*!:,%!

/*0)!A0,.5!,@;'&!"&6!,.(!$"%!1,0*.&%!2,-*!&;!-*6!&$*)!,2&',44)!:,0.*(!-*!&$,&!

&$*"0!2$"4(!4"5*(!1".5!,.(!&$,&!&$,&!:,%!;5,)!:"&$!&$*-!,.(!&$,&!&$*)!$;1*(!

&$,&!:;'4(!@*!;5,)!:"&$!-*!,.(!>!%,"(6!N)*,$c!D@%;4'&*4)6!>!-*,.6!&$,&B%!,!

2;4;'0=O!H;6!'-6!,.(!$*!:,%!/*0)!2,4-!,.(!2;.A"(*.&!,@;'&!&$,&!,.(!,!4;&!;A!

&$,&!:,%!&$,&!&$*!1,0*.&%!$,(!,44;:*(!&$,&!,.(!&$,&!"&!:,%!;5,)!:"&$!&$*-!%;!

"&!:,%!;5,)!:"&$!$"-!,.(!"&!:,%!,@%;4'&*4)!;5,)!:"&$!-*!,.(!&$*!;&$*0!5"(%!

".!&$*!24,%%!("(.B&!1"25!'1!;.!&$,&!4"5*6!N;;;6!&$,&B%!,!9"04!2;4;'0=O!#$,&!.*/*0!

2,-*!'1!,.(!>!:,%!/*0)!"-10*%%*(6!&$,&!,&!4*,%&!&$*%*!5"(%!:*0*.B&!,&!&$*!

1;".&!)*&!:$*0*!&$,&!:,%!%;-*&$".9!&$,&!&$*)!:;'4(!2$;;%*!&;!1"25!;.!

%;-*;.*!*4%*!A;0=!H;!)*,$=!>&!:,%!5".(!;A!2;;4=!

DX!D.(!$"%!1,0*.&%!,4-;%&!10*E*-1&"/*4)!-,5".9!%'0*!$*!("(.B&!9*&!%&0,.9*u=!

IQX!Q*,2&";.%u!,.(!,4*0&".9!-*!&;!&$,&!&;;6!%;!;@/";'%4)!&$*)!2,0*(!*.;'9$!

,@;'&!&$,&!,.(!>!9'*%%!:*0*!&$".5".9!,$*,(6!);'!5.;:6!%;-*!1*;14*!-"9$&!

.;&!@*!;5,)!:"&$!,!@;)!4"5".9!1".5!,%!&$*"0!A,/;'0"&*!2;4;'06!;0!%,)!%;-*&$".9!

&;!$"-!&$,&!9;*%!,9,".%&!:$,&!:*!@*4"*/*!,%!,!A,-"4)6!%;!&$*)!M'%&!:,.&*(!&;!

4*&!-*!5.;:!,.(!>!%,"(6!N&$,&6!&$,&B%!A".*=O!3)/)%7!

#$*!%*4A!2;.%2";'%.*%%!;A!&$*!@;)!:$;!1'&!;.!&$*!(0*%%!,.(!&$*!/*0)!A,2&!&$,&!

&$*!;&$*0!2$"4(B%!1,0*.&%!A*4&!&$*!.**(!&;!:,0.!&$*!&*,2$*0!;A!&$*"0!%;.!4"5".9!1".5!".!

;0(*0!&;!-,5*!%'0*!%$*!:,%!;5,)!:"&$!"&6!%1*,5%!&;!&$*!1*0/,%"/*.*%%!;A!&,@;;%!

0*9,0(".9!@;)%!20;%%".9!9*.(*0!.;0-%!3".!S$,1&*0!H"+6!>!,4%;!,((0*%%!9"04%!20;%%".9!

Page 50: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

[Y!

!

9*.(*0!.;0-%7!,.(!,%%;2",&".9!:"&$!L',4"&"*%!(**-*(!A*-".".*=!#$*0*A;0*6!:$"4*!

I,09,0*&!(*%20"@*(!$*0!$*%"&,.2)!&;!,((0*%%!9*.(*0!("0*2&4)6!:$*.!,!2$"4(!@0;'9$&!

A;0:,0(!9*.(*0!.;.E2;.A;0-"&)6!$*0!;1*..*%%!,%%"%&*(!".!-"&"9,&".9!&$*!1;4"2".9!;A!

&$*!@;'.(,0"*%!;A!!N10;1*0O!;0!N1*0/*0%*O!9*.(*0!*+10*%%";.%!:"&$".!&$*!2'4&'0*!;A!

$*0!24,%%0;;-=!T;:*/*06!,%!4,09*0!2'4&'0,4!.;0-%!:*0*!%&"44!10*%*.&!".!2$"4(0*.B%!

4"/*%!3,%!>!("%2'%%*(!".!&$*!>.&0;('2&";.76!2$"4(0*.!-,)!$,/*!,40*,()!%*4AE2*.%;0*(!

&$*"0!*+10*%%";.%!&;!@*&&*0!A"&!:"&$".!2'4&'0,4!*+1*2&,&";.%!;A!9*.(*0*(!@*$,/";'0=!

>.!;'0!"."&",4!".&*0/"*:6!&$*!H&'(*.&%!H'11;0&!b;05*0!3HHb76!`,-*%!T'9$*%6!

("%2'%%*(!$;:!$*!*+1*0"*.2*(!:;05".9!:"&$!I,09,0*&!,%!1;%"&"/*6!@'&!.;&!".("2,&"/*!

;A!&$*!4,09*0!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*=!`,-*%!$,(!:;05*(!,%!,.!HHb!:"&$!&$*!?HF!A;0!;/*0!

%"+&**.!)*,0%!,.(!(*%20"@*(!$,/".9!:;05*(!".!%2$;;4!*./"0;.-*.&%!&$,&!$*!A;'.(!&;!

@*!-'2$!-;0*!,.(!-'2$!4*%%!$;-;1$;@"2!&$,.!H;'&$!H"(*!R4*-*.&,0)!H2$;;4=!!T*!

(*%20"@*(!$"%!*+1*0"*.2*%!&$'%X!

H;!>!A**4!4"5*!>B/*!$,(!&$*!1*0A*2&!*./"0;.-*.&!A;0!%;2",4!0*%1;.%"@"4"&)!v,&!,!

A;0-*0!14,2*!;A!*-14;)-*.&w=!D.(!%;!,.)&$".9!>!*+1*0"*.2*!A0;-!&$*0*!:"44!

10;@,@4)!@*!4*%%!*-@0,2*(_%$,44!:*!%,)=!g*,$=!G0;@,@4)=!H;!>_@'&!>_>!

5.;:!:$*0*_>!5.;:!:$*0*!&$*_&$*!1*0A*2&!*+,-14*!"%!,.)$;:6!);'!5.;:e!

>!$,/*!,!0'@0"26!%$,44!:*!%,)6!;A!:$,&!"&!%$;'4(!@*6!,.(!%;_)*,$=!>!2,.B&!%1*,5!

A;0!&$*!0*%&!;A!&$*!%2$;;46!0*,44)=!>!2,.!;.4)!%1*,5!A;0!-)!;.*!*+1*0"*.2*!&$"%!

)*,0!".!&$,&!24,%%0;;-6!,.(!%,)!&$,&_,.(_,.(!:$,&!:*!*+1*0"*.2*(!&$*!4,%&!

A*:!:**5%6!&;;=!#$,&!:,%!/*0)!1;%"&"/*=!>!&$".56!'$6!,(-"."%&0,&";.!(*A"."&*4)!

$,%!@**.!/*0)!10;,2&"/*!,.(!/*0)!1;%"&"/*!,.(!*-@0,2*(!&$*!:$;4*!&$".9!

Page 51: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

[f!

!

v0*A*00".9!&;!G".5!C,)!*/*.&%w=!>!:;'4(.B&_>!:;'4(.B&!%,)!&$,&!%;2",4!M'%&"2*!

:,%!,!@"9!"%%'*!$*0*u!>!(;.B&!0*,44)!%**!,!$*,4&$)!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*!$*0*_!,44!

,0;'.(6!%;=!D.(!>!5.*:!&$,&6!2;-".9!$*0*=!a"5*6!>!$,(!.;!*+1*2&,&";.%!;A!

2;-".9!"._>!("(.B&!2;-*!$*0*!A;0!&$*!%2$;;4=!>!2,-*!$*0*!A;0!&$*!%&'(*.&%6!

%;_d-6!>!$,/*!/*0)!4;:!*+1*2&,&";.%!,0;'.(!&$,&=!?*0)!4;:=!H;!,.)&$".9_

,.)&$".9!1;%"&"/*!"%!,!@;.'%=!g*,$=!D&!&$*!%,-*!&"-*6!>!(;.B&!A".(!"&!,_,!

$;-;1$;@"2!*./"0;.-*.&6!);'!5.;:=!d-6!,.(!>!$,/*!:;05*(!".!&$;%*=!H;6!

)*,$=!H;!"&B%!5".(!;A_"&B%!,!5".(!;A!,_'-6!>!9'*%%!-"((4*!4".*!5".(!;A!14,2*6!

);'!5.;:e!>B-!&0)".9!&;!A".(!&$*!:;0(!A;0!&$,&=!d-6!.*'&0,46!>!9'*%%!"%!:$,&_

&$*!:;0(!>B-!&$".5_>B-!A**4".96!0"9$&e!#$*0*B%!,!.*'&0,4!5".(!;A!,&-;%1$*0*=!

a"5*6!"&B%!.*"&$*0!1;%"&"/*!.;0!.*9,&"/*=!H;6!)*,$=!d-6!,.(!>!&$".5!);'!:;'4(!

A".(!".!&$*_&$*!-,M;0"&)!;A!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4%!:;'4(!&*.(!-;0*!&;:,0(%!

&$*!.*'&0,4=!3T'9$*%!Vi!I,02$!YVUY7!

`,-*%B!(*%20"1&";.!1;".&%!&;!,!.;&*:;0&$)!A,2&;0!".!&$*!%2$;;4B%!9*.(*0!

2'4&'0*X!&$,&!"&!("(!.;&!&*.(!&;!,2&"/*4)!0*10;('2*!:$,&!$*!A*4&!&;!@*!,!$;%&"4*!;0!

'.%,A*!24"-,&*!A;0!%&,AA!.;0!("(!"&!*.9,9*!:"&$!,2&"/*4)!2$,44*.9".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-,&"/"&)!,.(!"&%!"-14"2,&";.%!A;0!%;2",4!;&$*0".9=!>.!&$"%!".E@*&:**.!%1,2*6!&$;%*!

(*1,0&".9!A0;-!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!-,)!.;&!$,/*!A,2*(!/";4*.2*!;0!4;%%!;A!,!M;@6!

@'&!0,&$*0!:;'4(!$,/*!@**.!;.!&$*!;'&%"(*!;A!&$*!%;2",4!%1$*0*!3".!,.;&$*0!".&*0/"*:!

`,-*%!(*%20"@*%!@*".9!,.!;'&%"(*0!:"&$!&$*!%&,AA!('*!&;!$*&*0;<.;0-,&"/*!9*.(*0!

*+1*2&,&";.%6!%**!S$,1&*0!h"/*7=!D%!>!*+14;0*!&$0;'9$;'&!2$,1&*0%!h;'0!&$0;'9$!H"+6!

9"/*.!&$*!1*0/,%"/*.*%%!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)6!,!o.*'&0,4B!*./"0;.-*.&6!

Page 52: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

[[!

!

&$*.6!%&"44!;&$*0%!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%=!!D%!&$*!%&,&'%!L';!$,%!@**.!

.*'&0,4"J*(6!&$"%!0*%*,02$!"44'%&0,&*%!$;:!,.!,2&"/*!*.9,9*-*.&!&;!".&*90,&*!L'**0!

,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!".&;!*/*0)(,)!%2$;;4!4"A*!"%!0*L'"0*(!&;!0*/*0%*!&$*!

;%&0,2"J".9!*AA*2&%!;A!*/*0)(,)!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%=!!

#$*;0"%&%!3a*/*06!a;0@*06!b*%&!,.(!s"--*0-,.7!$,/*!4;.9!,%%*0&*(!&$,&!

9*.(*0!"%!*-@*((*(!:"&$".!&$*!A"@*0!;A!(;-".,.&!2'4&'0*!&;!%'2$!,.!*+&*.&!&$,&!"&!

@*2;-*%!("AA"2'4&!&;!@*!,:,0*!;A!,.(!,0&"2'4,&*!9*.(*0*(!10;2*%%*%=!`'("&$!a;0@*0!

:0"&*%6!N^*.(*0!"%!%;!-'2$!&$*!0;'&".*!90;'.(!;A!*/*0)(,)!,2&"/"&"*%!&$,&!

L'*%&";.".9!"&%!&,5*.EA;0E90,.&*(!,%%'-1&";.%!,.(!10*%'11;%"&";.%!"%!4"5*!

:;.(*0".9!,@;'&!:$*&$*0!&$*!%'.!:"44!2;-*!'1O!3Uf7=!>!*.2;'.&*0*(!%'2$!0*%1;.%*%!

A0;-!%&'(*.&%!:$*.6!A;0!*+,-14*6!>!,%5*(!:$,&!:,%!@,(!,@;'&!,!@;)!$,/".9!9;.*!

".&;!&$*!N:0;.9O!@,&$0;;-!;.4)!&;!@*!4;;5*(!,&!@)!&$*!%&'(*.&!:"&$!%$;25!,.(!

("%@*4"*A!&$,&!>!2;'4(!*/*.!,%5!%'2$!,!L'*%&";.!3-;0*!;.!&$"%!".!S$,1&*0!h;'07=!

H2$;4,0%$"1!*+,-".".9!9*.(*0!A;'.(,&";.%!&$,&!&,5*!14,2*!".!*/*0)(,)!".%&"&'&";.,4!

%*&&".9%!2;.&0"@'&*%!&;!,!@,%"%!A0;-!:$"2$!4,09*0!"%%'*%!;A!9*.(*0!.;0-%<%*+',4"&)!

,0*!("%2'%%*(=!!D%!:"&$!S,.(,2*!b*%&!,.(!C;.!s"--*0-,.B%!:;056!-)!0*%*,02$!

10;('2*%!.*:!'.(*0%&,.(".9%!N;A!9*.(*0!,%!,!0;'&".*!,22;-14"%$-*.&!*-@*((*(!".!

*/*0)(,)!".&*0,2&";.O!3UY]7=!!

`'%&!,%!&$*!N0;'&".*!,22;-14"%$-*.&%O!%'00;'.(".9!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)!

2,..;&!@*!A'44)!*+&0"2,&*(!A0;-!*,2$!;&$*06!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!"%!*.&0*.2$*(!".!

0,2",4"J*(!,.(!,@4*E@;("*(!.;0-%j!&$*0*A;0*6!("AA*0*.&!%&'(*.&%!$,/*!("AA*0*.&!

*+1*0"*.2*%!;A!&$*!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!,&!14,)!:"&$".!,!9"/*.!%2$;;4!;0!24,%%0;;-=!G,%2;*!

Page 53: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

[]!

!

("%2'%%*%!$;:!9*.(*0!1*0A;0-,.2*%!,&!,!$"9$!%2$;;4!(,.2*!("%14,)%!:$,&!%$*!

(*%20"@*%!,%!.;&!M'%&!%*+',4"&)!@'&!,!N0*4,&";.%$"1!@*&:**.!0,2*6!9*.(*06!,.(!

%*+',4"&)!&$,&!0*.(*0*(!@4,25!@;)%!%;!1;&*.&",44)!(,.9*0;'%!&;!&$*!(*4"2,&*!@,4,.2*!

;A!&$*!3$*&*0;7!%*+',4!;0(*0!*%&,@4"%$*(!@)!&$*!%2$;;4O!3[W7=!!b"&$".!-)!,.,4)%"%!;A!

-)!A"*4(:;05!(,&,6!>!:;05!&;!*+1;%*!2'4&'0,44)!.;0-,4"J".9!10;2*%%*%!&$,&!1;%"&";.!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!:"&$".!,.!,%%'-*(!:$"&*!;0!(;-".,.&!b*%&*0.!2'4&'0,4!

2;.&*+&=!h;0!*+,-14*6!:"&$".!-)!A"*4(:;056!2$"4(0*.!:$;!,11*,0*(!:$"&*!:*0*!

,%%'-*(!&;!@*!:$"&*!@)!1**0%!,.(!*('2,&;0%6!0*9,0(4*%%!;A!&$*"0!@,2590;'.(%=!h;0!

*+,-14*6!C'.2,.!,.(!8"*0;.!:*0*!0*A*00*(!&;!,%!&$*!&:;!N:$"&*!@;)%O!3T'9$*%!

YY<VY<UY7!".!&$*!24,%%6!(*%1"&*!@;&$!@*".9!D@;0"9".,4=!!

I)!0*%*,02$!'&"4"J*%!,!h;'2,'4(",.!*.9,9*-*.&!:"&$!*&.2#6)Q#$)&*(#*%(

*&.2#$)&*!,%!1,0&!;A!&$*!1*01*&',&";.!;A!1;:*0!%&0'2&'0*%!".!*/*0)(,)!4"A*=!!

h;'2,'4&B%!:;05!"(*.&"A)".9!N&*2$."L'*%!;A!.;0-,4"J,&";.O!3UWiZ7!(*%20"@*%!&$*!

10;2*%%!;A!%;0&".9!&$*!N.;0-,4O!A0;-!&$*!N,@.;0-,4O!,%!N.;0-,&";.=O!!P;0-,&";.6!

&$*.6!@*9".%!:"&$!&$*!.;0-!A0;-!:$"2$!&$*!N.;0-,4O!"%!&$*.!*%&,@4"%$*(=!!#$"%!"%!

2;.&0,%&*(!:"&$!.;0-,4"J,&";.6!:$"2$!@*9".%!:"&$!&$*!N.;0-,4O!A0;-!:$"2$!&$*!

.;0-!"%!&$*.!(*('2*(=!#$*!.;0-!"%!&$*.!,.!*AA;0&!&;!0*10;('2*!,.!".&*014,)!;A!@;&$!

%&,&"%&"2,4!(*%20"1&";.%!,.(!%;2",4!10*%20"1&";.%!3.;0-%!(**-*(!2'4&'0,44)!(*%"0,@4*7!

3kf7=!!F;&$!.;0-,&";.!,.(!.;0-,4"J,&";.!,0*!%;2",4!10;2*%%*%!".!:$"2$!%;-*!

L',4"&"*%!,0*!$*4(!,%!-;(*4%!&;!:$"2$!&$*!1;1'4,&";.!,&!4,09*!%$;'4(!,%1"0*!,.(!;&$*0!

L',4"&"*%!,0*!.;&=!!h;'2,'4&!(*%20"@*%!&$*!("%&".2&";.!,%!%'2$X!

Page 54: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

[k!

!

C"%2"14".,0)!.;0-,4"J,&";.!2;.%"%&%!A"0%&!;A!,44!".!1;%"&".9!,!-;(*46!,.!;1&"-,4!

-;(*4!&$,&!"%!2;.%&0'2&*(!".!&*0-%!;A!,!2*0&,".!0*%'4&6!,.(!&$*!;1*0,&";.!;A!

("%2"14".,0)!.;0-,4"J,&";.!2;.%"%&%!".!&0)".9!&;!9*&!1*;14*6!-;/*-*.&%6!,.(!

,2&";.!&;!2;.A;0-!&;!&$"%!-;(*46!&$*!.;0-,4!@*".9!10*2"%*4)!&$,&!:$"2$!2,.!

2;.A;0-!&;!&$"%!.;0-6!,.(!&$*!,@.;0-,4!&$,&!:$"2$!"%!".2,1,@4*!;A!

2;.A;0-".9!&;!&$*!.;0-=!3]i7!!

b$*.!>!0*A*0!&;!9*.(*06!>!,-!0*A*00".9!&;!,44!;A!&$*!:,)%!&$,&!".("/"(',4%!,.(!

1;1'4,&";.%!-,)!@*!,%%"9.*(!9*.(*0*(!2$,0,2&*0"%&"2%X!A0;-!&$*!("/"%";.!;A!@;("*%!

".&;!N-,4*O!,.(!NA*-,4*O!@".,0"*%!&;!&$*!(*%20"1&";.!;A!2$,0,2&*0"%&"2%!,%!N-,%2'4".*O!

,.(!NA*-".".*=O!#$*0*A;0*6!9*.(*0!.;0-%!2,.!2;;0(".,&*!.;&!M'%&!&$*!,2&";.%!;A!

@;("*%6!@'&!&$*!@;("*%!&$*-%*4/*%=!D..!h,'%&;EH&*04".9!A'0&$*0%!&$"%!,09'-*.&!@)!

'%".9!%;2",4!%2"*.2*!@,%*(!&$*;0"*%!".!$*0!:;05!,%!,!-"20;@";4;9"%&=!H$*!:0"&*%X!

K'0!@;("4)!*+1*0"*.2*%!,0*!@0;'9$&!".&;!@*".9!@)!;'0!(*/*4;1-*.&!".!

1,0&"2'4,0!2'4&'0*%!,.(!$"%&;0"2,4!1*0";(%u!*%1*2",44)!,%!,!@";4;9"%&6!>!:,.&!&;!

-,5*!&$*!,09'-*.&!-;0*!%1*2"A"2=!!D%!:*!90;:!,.(!(*/*4;16!:*!4"&*0,44)6!.;&!

M'%&!N("%2'0%"/*4)O!3&$,&!"%6!&$0;'9$!4,.9',9*!,.(!2'4&'0,4!10,2&"2*%76!

2;.%&0'2&!;'0!@;("*%6!".2;01;0,&".9!*+1*0"*.2*!".&;!;'0!/*0)!A4*%$=!!#;!

'.(*0%&,.(!&$"%!24,"-6!:*!-'%&!*0;(*!&$*!("%&".2&";.%!@*&:**.!&$*!1$)%"2,4!

,.(!%;2",4!@;()=!3YV7!

h,'%&;EH&*04".9!10;/"(*%!*+,-14*%!;A!&$*!-*("2,4!-,.,9*-*.&!;A!@;("*%!;A!

".A,.&%!&$,&!,0*!1;%"&*(!,%!;'&%"(*!9*.(*0*(!.;0-%!A;0!@;("*%=!!!H$*!:0"&*%!,@;'&!&$*!

.;0-!-,.(,&".9!&$,&!@;("*%!(*%"9.,&*(!,%!A*-,4*!$,/*!24"&;0"%*%!&$,&!,0*!

Page 55: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

[i!

!

%"9."A"2,.&4)!%-,44*0!&$,.!1,0&%!;A!&$*!@;()!(*%"9.,&*(!,%!1*."%*%=!!b$*.!&$*!@;("*%!

&$,&!(*/",&*!A0;-!&$"%!.;0-!,0*!%*1,0,&*(!A0;-!&$;%*!&$,&!2;.A;0-6!&$"%6!,22;0(".9!

&;!,!h;'2,'4(",.!A0,-*:;056!"%!,!10;2*%%!;A!.;0-,&";.=!!b$*.!&$*!-*("2,4!%)%&*-!

(*2"(*%!;.!,.!"(*,4!4*.9&$!;A!".A,.&!24"&;0"%*%!,.(!&$*.!'09*%!1,0*.&%!:"&$!@,@"*%!

:$;%*!@;("*%!(;!.;&!2;.A;0-!&;!&$"%!"(*,4"J*(!.;0-!&;!,90**!&;!%'09"2,4!

".&*0/*.&";.6!&$"%!"%!,!10;2*%%!;A!.;0-,4"J,&";.=!>.!*"&$*0!2,%*6!.;0-,&";.!,.(!

.;0-,4"J,&";.!2,.!@*!/"*:*(!,%!2;.%&0'2&".9!*/*0)(,)!*-@;("-*.&6!1,0&"2'4,04)!,%!

*/*0);.*6!0*9,0(4*%%!;A!:$*&$*0!&$*)!N1,%%O!;0!NA,"4O!&$*!.;0-6!"%!$*4(!,9,".%&!%'2$!,!

%&,.(,0(=!!!!!

b$*.!,09'-*.&%!A;0!-,".&,".".9!&$*!%&,&'%!L';!,0*!1'&!A;0:,0(6!*"&$*0!

10;2*%%!2,.!@*!,&!14,)_,.!,09'-*.&!"./;4/".9!.;0-,&";.!-,)!,%%*0&!&$,&!@";4;9"2,4!

&0*.(%!0*9,0(".9!9*.(*0!("2&,&*!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!:"&$!/,0",.&!9*.(*0!*+10*%%";.%!

%$;'4(!2;.A;0-!&;!&$*!9*.(*0!@".,0)6!".%"%&".9!&$,&!&$*!.;0-%!&$*)!&$*.!,%%;2",&*!

:"&$!&$*"0!,%%"9.*(!9*.(*0!-'%&!@*!&$*"0!N&0'*O!9*.(*0=!D!.;0-,4"J".9!,09'-*.&!

-,)!2"&*!&$*"0!0"%5!;A!*+1*0"*.2".9!1*0%*2'&";.!@)!(*1,0&".9!A0;-!*%&,@4"%$*(!

.;0-%=!!

#$*;0"%&%!%'2$!,%!`'("&$!F'&4*0!,.(!R/*!H*(9:"25!10;/"(*!A;'.(,&";.,4!:;05!

&$,&!1;%"&%!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!10;2*%%*%!,%!&,5".9!14,2*!&$0;'9$!J,.-&.2#$)W,!

0*1*&"&";.=!#$*;0"*%!,@;'&!9*.(*0!,.(!J,.-&.2#$)W)$=(*+,-".*!$;:!*/*0)(,)!

0*1*&"&"/*!,2&%!%"&',&*!9*.(*0*(!@;("*%<4"/*%_$;:!-'.(,.*!&,45!,.(!-;/*-*.&!

".&*0,2&%!:"&$!.;0-%=!P;0-%!2,.!@*2;-*!%'@&4)!2;*02"/*!,.(!&$"%!2;*02";.!&$*.!

@*2;-*%!1,0&!;A!*/*0)(,)!;22'00*.2*%!&$,&!1;%"&";.!&$;%*!:$;!(;!.;&!;0!2,..;&!

Page 56: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

[Z!

!

2;.A;0-!&;!&$*!.;0-!,%!;'&%"(*0%!3>!,4%;!0*A*0!&;!&$"%!,%!;&$*0".97=!#$"%!10;2*%%!$,%!

&,.9"@4*!"-14"2,&";.%!A;0!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*%!".!,.)!%;2",4!".%&"&'&";.=!H'2$!".A;0-,4!

10,2&"2*%!10;/"(*!2,%',4!1*0A;0-,&"/*!0*1*&"&";.%!&$,&!0*".A;02*!("%2"14".,0)!.;0-%6!

&$,&6!".!&'0.6!%;4"("A)!:$;!"%!2;.%&0'2&*(!,%!".%"(*!,.(!;'&%"(*!%;2",4!@*4;.9".9=!h;0!

*+,-14*6!".!,!&*,2$*0!".&*0/"*:6!I,09,0*&!Q;/*44,!&;4(!;A!;.*!@;)!".!$*0!24,%%!$,/".9!

*.2;'.&*0*(!0*1*,&*(!%&,AA!2;--*.&%!&$,&!$"%!4;.9!$,"0!:,%!N2;.A'%".9O!3-;0*!;.!

&$"%!".!S$,1&*0!H"+7=!#$*%*!*/*0)(,)!0*1*&"&";.%!-;(*4*(!20;%%".9!9*.(*0!.;0-%!,%!

&$*!%'@M*2&!;A!2;.A'%";.!,.(!M'(9-*.&_@;&$!;A!:$"2$!.;0-,4"J*!;'&%"(*0!%&,&'%=!!

b$*.!,.,4)J".9!&$*!1*0A;0-,&"/*!,.(!"&%!0;;&%!".!%1**2$E,2&!&$*;0)6!H'%,.!

H&0)5*0!10;/"(*%!,!24*,0!,0&"2'4,&";.!;A!&$*!&$*;0"J*(!0*4,&";.%$"1%!@*&:**.!

9*.(*0".9!,.(!1*0A;0-,&"/*!%1**2$E,2&%=!!H$*!:0"&*%!&$,&6!Na,.9',9*!"%!,4:,)%!

,22;-14"%$*(!@)!,.(!&$0;'9$!1,0&"2'4,0!3J,,+"(#+$3u!H1**2$!"%!%;2",4=!>&!.*2*%%,0"4)!

"./;4/*%!%1*2"A"2!%1*,5*0%!,.(!,'("*.2*%6!,.(!2,.!.*/*0!@*!*.&"0*4)!("/;02*(!A0;-!

*+&0,E4".9'"%&"2!2;.&*+&%O!3UV7=!!#$*%*!*+&0,E4".9'"%&"2!2;.&*+&%!,0*!20'2",4!&;!

'.(*0%&,.(".9!$;:!%1**2$E,2&%!A'.2&";.!,%!1*0A;0-,&"/*=!!#$*!1*0A;0-,&"/*!%1**2$E

,2&!*.,2&%!:$,&!"&!(*%20"@*%j!&$*!(*%20"1&";.!"%!1,0&!;A!&$*!*+"%&*.2*!;A!&$*!&$".9!"&!

(*%20"@*%=!!H&0)5*0!;'&4".*%!&$"%!,%!%'2$X!

R+,-14*%!;A!1*0A;0-,&"/*!%1**2$!,2&%!:;'4(!".24'(*!/;:".9!3N>!(;O76!

-,00)".9!3N>!.;:!10;.;'.2*!);'!-,.!,.(!:"A*=O76!;0!@*".9!@,0!-"&J/,$*(!

3N#;(,)!>!,-!,!-,.O7=!!#;!%,)!&$,&!9*.(*0!"%!,!1*0A;0-,&"/*!,2&!"%!&;!%,)!&$,&!

"&!(;*%!.;&!.**(!,!-,&*0",4!0*A*0*.&!&;!@*!-*,.".9A'46!"%!("0*2&*(!,&!;&$*0%!".!

,.!,&&*-1&!&;!2;--'."2,&*6!"%!.;&!%'@M*2&!&;!A,4%"A"2,&";.!;0!/*0"A"2,&";.6!,.(!

Page 57: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

[W!

!

"%!,22;-14"%$*(!@)!N(;".9O!%;-*&$".9!0,&$*0!&$,.!N@*".9O!%;-*&$".9=!!D!

:;-,.6!1*0A;0-,&"/*4)!%1*,5".96!"%!;.*!:$;!%,)%!%$*!"%_,.(!:$;!&$*.!(;*%!

:$,&!:;-,.!-*,.%=!!#$*!@";4;9"2,44)!%*+*(!@;()!9',0,.&**%!.;&$".9j!"&!"%!

.*2*%%,0"4)!&$*0*6!,!90;'.(!A;0!&$*!,2&!;A!%1*,5".96!@'&!"&!$,%!.;!(*&*0-"."%&"2!

0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!1*0A;0-,&"/*!9*.(*0!3UV7=!!!

C"%2'0%"/*!1*0A;0-,&"/"&)6!&$*.6!"%!("AA*0*.&!A0;-!1*0A;0-,.2*!,.(!0*A*00".9!&;!

9*.(*0!,%!1*0A;0-,&"/*4)!0*10;('2*(!"%!.;&!&;!24,"-!&$,&!9*.(*0!"%!M'%&!,!

J,.-&.2#*+,=!!

S4,'(",!Q'"&*.@*09!24,0"A"*%!&$*!("AA*0*.2*X!NC"%2'0%"/*!1*0A;0-,&"/"&)!-*,.%!

.;&!&$,&!>6!,%!,'&;.;-;'%!%'@M*2&6!N1*0A;0-O!-)!"(*.&"&)!&$*!:,)!,.!,2&;0!1*0A;0-%!

,!0;4*6!@'&!0,&$*0!&$,&!>6!,%!%'@M*2&6!#2(J,.-&.2#$)W,6=(J.&%7+,%(@)!&$*!("%2;'0%*!".!

:$"2$!>!1,0&"2"1,&*O!3YkY7=!Q'"&*.@*09!0*4,&*%!("%2'0%"/*!1*0A;0-,&"/"&)!".!*('2,&";.!

,.(!1'01;0&%!&$,&!%&'(*.&%!,.(!*('2,&;0%!$,/*!,9*.2)!:$*.!1,0&"2"1,&".9!;0!

0*%"%&".9!".!1*0A;0-,&"/*4)!10;('2*(!.;0-%!,.(!-*,.".9%=!#$"%!2;.2*1&',4"J,&";.!;A!

,9*.2)!"-14"2,&*%!*/*0);.*!".!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!2'4&'0*!&$,&!-,5*%!

$;-;1$;@"2!,.(!&0,.%1$;@"2!@'44)".9!*AA*2&"/*=!Q'"&*.@*09!:0"&*%X!

v>w&!"%!"-1;0&,.&!.;&!&;!&,5*!&$*!@'44)!,%!"%;4,&*(!,9*.&!;0!,%!%;'02*j!&$*!

1,0&"2'4,0!("%2;'0%*!:,%!,40*,()!,/,"4,@4*6!,%!:,%!&$*!2;.&*+&!".!:$"2$!&$*!

1,0&"2'4,0!("%2;'0%*!2;.%&"&'&*%!$,0-=!>&!"%!0*4,&"/*4)!*,%)!A;0!%2$;;4%!&;!1'&!

&$*!@4,-*!A;0!&$*!10;4"A*0,&";.!;A!$;-;1$;@"2!("%2;'0%*!*.&"0*4)!;.!&$*!

%$;'4(*0%!;A!".("/"(',4!@'44"*%j!"&!"%!-'2$!-;0*!'.2;-A;0&,@4*!A;0!%2$;;4%!&;!

,((0*%%!&$*!:,)!".!:$"2$!&$*!("%2;'0%*%!&$,&!"&!2"02'4,&*%!$*41!-,".&,".!&$"%!

Page 58: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

]V!

!

$;-;1$;@"2!2;.&*+&=!#$*!,@%*.2*!;A!%,-*E%*+!A,-"4"*%!A0;-!"&%!2'00"2'4'-!

-,&*0",4%6!&$*!;AAE$,.(!%*+"%&!2;--*.&!;A!,!&*,2$*0!&;!,!-,4*!%&'(*.&!3N>A!);'!

(;.B&!%-,0&*.!'16!>B-!9;".9!&;!1'&!);'!;.!&$*!9"04%B!&*,-cO76!,.(!&$*!

'.L'*%&";.*(!,%%'-1&";.!,@;'&!&$*!2;-1;%"&";.!;A!2;'14*%!;.!10;-!."9$&!,44!

$*41!5**1!$;-;1$;@"2!("%2;'0%*!".!2"02'4,&";.6!,/,"4,@4*!A;0!&$*!.*+&!@'44)!&;!

2"&*!3Ykk7=!!

>!,114)!%'2$!&$*;0)!&;!&$*!*+,-".,&";.!;A!*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%!".!1'@4"2!

%2$;;4%!&$,&!*.9,9*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!,.(!,.,4)J*!&$*%*!10,2&"2*%!".!&*0-%!

;A!%1**2$E,2&%=!!S;--*.&%!&$,&!,!%&'(*.&!-'%&6!A;0!*+,-14*6!@*!*"&$*0!,!@;)!;0!,!9"04!

,0*!%1**2$E,2&%!&$,&!20*,&*!&$*!9*.(*0!@".,0)!&;!:$"2$!&$*)!0*A*0=!H'2$!1*0A;0-,&"/*!

%1**2$E,2&%!,0*!,4%;!1,0&!;A!("%2;'0%*%=!I)!%&'()!10;('2*(!0"2$!(,&,!;A!*/*0)(,)!

&,45!,.(!10,2&"2*%!&$,&!:;05*(!:"&$!,.(!,9,".%&!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!2'4&'0*!".!

8".(*09,0&*.=!>!$,/*!'%*(!("%2;'0%*!,.,4)%"%!&;!"./*%&"9,&*!:,)%!*/*0)(,)!&,45!:,%!

2;;0(".,&*(!:"&$".!4,09*0!%;2",4!2;.&*+&%!".!:$"2$!&$*!".&*0,2&";.%!&;;5!14,2*=!!

>.!?*W)3)/6,(D)W,3;(0",(R.#37.,(&-(0.#*33,G7#6(#*%(0.#*39,*%,.,%!A,&J6,B(

?"/",.*!P,-,%&*!2;.2"%*4)!%'--,0"J*%!,!h;'2,'4(",.!,110;,2$!&;!("%2;'0%*!

,.,4)%"%=!!H$*!:0"&*%!&$,&!&$*0*!,0*!&$0**!2*.&0,4!2;.2*1&%6!N%&,&*-*.&6!("%2;'0%*6!

,.(!("%2'0%"/*!A;0-,&";.O!3i[76!,.(!(*4".*,&*%!&$*%*!@)!10;1;%".9!&$,&!:*6!

N2;.%"(*0!%&,&*-*.&%!:"&$!0*9,0(!&;!$;:!&$*)!,0*!90;'1*(!".&;!%1*2"A"2!("%2;'0%*%6!

,%!:*44!,%!&$*!10".2"14*%!;A!0*9'4,&";.!&$,&!(*&*0-".*!&$*"0!*+"%&*.2*!,.(!2"02'4,&";.!

3,!("%2'0%"/*!A;0-,&";.7O!3i]7=!!b$*.!,.,4)J".9!10,2&"2*%!&$,&!&;;5!14,2*!".!&$*!

%2$;;4!%*&&".96!>!("(!.;&!M'%&!*+,-".*!&$*!%&,&*-*.&%!-,(*6!@'&!,4%;!$;:!%'2$!

Page 59: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

]U!

!

%&,&*-*.&%!A;0-!(;-".,.&!("%2;'0%*%!0*9,0(".9!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)6!,.(!&$*!

0*9'4,&;0)!10;2*%%*%!&$,&!%'00;'.(!&$*-=!h;0!*+,-14*6!:$*.!,!2$"4(!"%!&;4(!&$*)!2,.!

;.4)!@*!*"&$*0!,!@;)!;0!9"046!&$*!%&,&*-*.&!&,5*%!14,2*!:"&$".!,!2;.&*+&!;A!("%2;'0%*%!

:$"2$!".%"%&!&$*0*!"%!.;!9*.(*0!;'&%"(*!&$*!-,4*<A*-,4*!@".,0)6!,!("%2;'0%*!&$,&!2,.!

@*!'.(*0%&;;(!,%!2"02'4,&*(!@)!;&$*0!*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%!%'2$!,%X!@0*,5".9!'1!".&;!

N@;)O!,.(!N9"04O!&*,-%6!9*.(*0*(!:,%$0;;-%6!,.(!%;!;.=!!

S*4",!8"&J".9*0!,.(!?"2&;0",!a,.(!$,/*!2;.('2&*(!%&'("*%!'%".9!S;./*0%,&";.!

D.,4)%"%!3SD76!,!%'@EA"*4(!;A!("%2;'0%*!,.,4)%"%6!".!;0(*0!&;!*+,-".*!&$*!

N0;'&"."J,&";.O!;A!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)=!>.!NH1*,5".9!,%!,!a*%@",.X!S;00*2&".9!&$*!

T*&*0;%*+"%&!G0*%'-1&";.6O!a,.(!,.(!8"&J".9*0!("%2'%%!*/*0)(,)!&,45!@)!4*%@",.%!&;!

2;00*2&!$*&*0;%*+',4!,%%'-1&";.%!,.(!&$*"0!%'@%*L'*.&!2;.2*0.!:"&$!@*".9!

'.(*0%&;;(!,%!NA4,'.&".9O!&$*"0!%*+',4"&)=!#$*)!:0"&*!&$,&!('*!&;!$*&*0;.;0-,&"/"&)6!

$*&*0;%*+',4%!2,.!N&,5*!A;0!90,.&*(!&$*"0!0"9$&!&;!0*A*0!&;!&$*"0!$*&*0;%*+',4!

0*4,&";.%$"1%!:"&$;'&!&$"%!@*".9!&0*,&*(!,%!2;./*)".9!".A;0-,&";.!,@;'&!:$;!&$*)!

9;!&;!@*(!:"&$!;0!,%!%&,&".9!&$,&!&$*)!,0*!$*&*0;%*+',4O!3fZi7=!I,5".9!%'2$!

10;2*%%*%!*/"(*.&!$,%!1,0&"2'4,0!0*4*/,.2*!&;!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4!*('2,&";.6!,%!"&!"%!

;A&*.!,09'*(!3,%!("%2'%%*(!".!&$*!%*2&";.!;.!0*%*,02$!0,&";.,4*7!&$,&!10"-,0)!%2$;;4!

2$"4(0*.!,0*!N&;;!);'.9O!&;!*.2;'.&*0!"%%'*%!;A!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)=!a,.(!,.(!

8"&J".9*0!.;&*!0*A*0*.2*%!&;!%*+',4"&"*%!&$,&!,0*!.;0-,4"J*(!,.(!N0;'&"."J*(O!,0*!

2;.%*L'*.&4)!.;&!2;'.&*(!,%!("%2'%%".9!%*+',4"&)!3,%!"%!&$*!A;2'%!;A!S$,1&*0!h;'07=!!

G*0A;0-,&"/*4)!10;('2*(!.;0-%!-,5*!1;%%"@4*!%1*2"A"2!A;0-%!;A!0*%"%&,.2*!&;!

%;2",4!2$,.9*=!>.!0.&7/6)*9(R%7+#$)&*;(K7,,.(<+$)W)32(#*%(<*$)&JJ.,33)W,(A,%#9&9=B!

Page 60: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

]Y!

!

8*/".!8'-,%$"0;!("%2'%%*%!A;0-%!;A!0*%"%&,.2*!$*!*.2;'.&*0*(!:$*.!&0)".9!&;!@'"4(!

,.&"E;110*%%";.!@,%*(!1*(,9;9)!,.(!2'00"2'4'-!".&;!&$*!&*,2$*0!*('2,&";.!2;'0%*%!

$*!&,'9$&=!!T*!&$*;0"J*%!&$,&!1*0A;0-,&"/*!0*1*&"&";.!@*2;-*%!2;-A;0&".9=!!b$*.!

*('2,&".9!,9,".%&!&$*!%&,&'%!L';!$*!A;'.(!&$,&!%&'(*.&%!,.(!&*,2$*0%!:"44!@;&$!%**5!

*('2,&";.,4!*+1*0"*.2*%!&$,&!2;.A"0-!:$,&!&$*)!,40*,()!5.;:=!!T*!*.2;'.&*0*(!

-'2$!-;0*!;1*..*%%!&;!&*,2$".9!,@;'&!N-".;0"&"*%O!,.(!$;:!N&$*)O!:*0*!4"5*!N'%O!

3f7!&$,.6!A;0!*+,-14*6!4*,0.".9!,@;'&!$*&*0;%*+"%-!3:$"2$!"./;4/*(!2$,44*.9".9!1,0&!

;A!&$*!10*-"%*!'1;.!:$"2$!&$*"0!:;04(!/"*:%!:*0*!@,%*(7=!$

S$,.(0,!I;$,.&)B%!:;05!;.!-'4&"2'4&'0,4"%-!,%!,!&*2$."L'*!&;!N-,.,9*!

("/*0%"&)O!,4%;!10;/"(*%!,!'%*A'4!A0,-*:;05!A;0!*+,-".".9!:,)%!0,2",4"J*(6!L'**0!

,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!,0*!10;('2*(!".!2;.&*+&%!&$,&!4*,/*!&$*!%&,&'%!L';!".!

&,2&=!b"&$".!-)!A"*4(:;056!"%%'*%!;A!0,2"%-!,.(!$;-;1$;@",!:*0*!%"-"4,04)!&,5*.!'1!

'.(*0!&$*!0'@0"2!;A!N("AA*0*.2*O!,.(!,.&"E@'44)".9j!&$"%!".24'(*(!L'**0.*%%!;.4)!

@*".9!-*.&";.*(!".!&$*!2;.&*+&!;A!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!,.&"E9,)!@'44)".9!,.(!"%%'*%!;A!

0,2"%-!@*".9!*L',&*(!:"&$!,22*1&".9!&$,&!*/*0);.*!$,%!N("AA*0*.&O!2;4;'0%!;A!%5".!

3S$,1&*0!h"/*7=!>!,.,4)J*!%'2$!&,2&"2%!A;0!:,)%!&$*)!,0*!1;&*.&",44)!&$",.)*9=!!

>.!8'-,%$"0;B%!,.,4)%"%!;A!&0*.(%!2'00*.&4)!,&!14,)!:"&$".!,.&"E;110*%%";.!

*('2,&";.6!$*!10;@4*-,&"J*%!:$,&!$*!2,&*9;0"J*%!,%!NR('2,&";.!A;0!&$*!K&$*0=O!T*!

2,'&";.%!,9,".%&!&$*!&*.(*.2)!&;!A;2'%!%;4*4)!;.!("%20"-".,&;0)!&0*,&-*.&6!A;0!

*+,-14*6!@'44)".96!,.(!:,0.%!&$,&!&$"%!2,.!0'.!&$*!0"%5!;A!,!1*(,9;9"2,4!,110;,2$!

1;%"&".9!&$,&!N:"&$;'&!&$*!K&$*06!%2$;;4%!:;'4(!.;&!@*!;110*%%".9!,.);.*O!3fi7=!!

b$*.!%'2$!,!A0,-*:;05!"%!&,5*.!&;!"&%!2;.24'%";.%6!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!:$"&*!10"/"4*9*!

Page 61: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

]f!

!

2*,%*!&;!@*!,.!"%%'*!"A!.;!;.*!"%!0*,(!,%!9,)!;0!@'44"*(!A;0!"&6!;0!"%!&$*!0*2"1"*.&!;A!

0,2",4!%4'0%=!H,(4)6!&$"%!-"%%*%!&$*!("%2"14".,0)!&0*.(%!&$,&!-,)!$,/*!,40*,()!&,'9$&!

&$;%*!:"&$".!%2$;;4%!&;!2;.A;0-!&;!.;0-,4"J*(!9*.(*0%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%!".!,!:,)!&$,&!

"%!2;.%"%&*.&!:"&$!,22*1&*(!N-,%2'4".*O!,.(!NA*-".".*O!9*.(*0!*+10*%%";.%!:"&$".!

(;-".,.&!b*%&*0.!2'4&'0*=!!

8'-,%$"0;!,09'*%!&$,&!&$*!10*%*.2*!;A!$*&*0;%*+"%-!,.(!:$"&*!10"/"4*9*6!

0,&$*0!&$,.!("%20"-".,&";.!,9,".%&!1,0&"2'4,0!%&'(*.&%6!-,)!@*!,!@*&&*0!9,'9*!;A!

&$",.)*9=!!#$"%!("%&".2&";.!".A;0-*(!-)!,.,4)%"%!('0".9!-)!A"*4(:;05X!:$,&!$,11*.%!

&;!,.!".&*90,&";.!;A!L'**0.*%%!".&;!&$*!2'00"2'4'-!:$*.!2$"4(0*.!,0*!2;.%"(*0*(!

N&;;!);'.9O!&;!5.;:!&$*"0!%*+',4!;0"*.&,&";.%!3,.(!&$*0*A;0*!,40*,()!@*!,!.;.E

.;0-,&"/*!10*%*.2*7e!>.!:$,&!:,)%!"%!L'**0.*%%!,@4*!&;!&,5*!'1!%1,2*!".!*/*0)(,)!

4"A*!,.(!".!:$,&!:,)%!"%!"&!2;.%&0'2&*(!,%!,.()337,!,.(!&$*0*@)!2;.A4,&*(!:"&$!

$;-;1$;@",e!T;:!,0*!,.&"E$;-;1$;@",!("%2;'0%*%!0,2",4"J*(e!D0*!N"%%'*%O!

2;.%"(*0*(!(*,4&!:"&$!"A!,!9'*%&!%1*,5*0!/"%"&%!&$*!%2$;;4!,.(!&,45%!,@;'&!("AA*0*.2*e!

>.!-)!,&&*.&";.!&;!*/*0)(,)6!".A;0-,4!10,2&"2*%6!>!:,%!".!&$*!1;%"&";.!&;!.;&*!:$*.!

N*('2,&";.!A;0!&$*!;&$*0O!:,%!&,5".9!14,2*!,.(!:$*.!:;05!:,%!(;.*!&;!%$"A&!&$*!

;/*0,44!2'4&'0*!;A!&$*!24,%%0;;-!&;!2$,44*.9*!-;0*!(**14)!*.&0*.2$*(!.;0-%=!!

>.!&$*!UWiV%!20"&"2,4!*('2,&";.,4!%2$;4,0%$"1!&'0.*(!"&%!,&&*.&";.!&;!N$"((*.!

2'00"2'4'-O!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!I)!,&&*.&";.!&;!;&$*0".9!,.(!.;0-,4"J,&";.!".!

*('2,&";.!"%!".A;0-*(!@)!&$"%!,.,4)%"%=!#$*!$"((*.!2'00"2'4'-!9*.*0,44)!0*A*00*(!&;!

:$,&!%&'(*.&%!:*0*!4*,0.".9!,%!1,0&!;A!&$*!%&0'2&'0*!;A!&$*!%2$;;4%!,.(!&$*"0!

2'4&'0*%!0,&$*0!&$,.!:$,&!:,%!;AA"2",44)!1,0&!;A!&$*!2'00"2'4'-!;@M*2&"/*%_".!FS6!

Page 62: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

][!

!

&$*%*!,0*!5.;:.!,%!&$*!G0*%20"@*(!a*,0.".9!K'&2;-*%!3GaK%7=!D%!R4"J,@*&$!?,44,.2*!

:0"&*%!".!NT"(".9!&$*!T"((*.!S'00"2'4'-X!D.!>.&*010*&,&";.!;A!&$*!a,.9',9*!;A!

`'%&"A"2,&";.!".!P".*&**.&$ES*.&'0)!R('2,&";.,4!Q*A;0-6O!$"((*.!2'00"2'4'-!

".24'(*%!&$*!!N.;.,2,(*-"2!@'&!*('2,&";.,44)!%"9."A"2,.&!2;.%*L'*.2*%!;A!%2$;;4".9!

&$,&!;22'0!%)%&*-,&"2,44)!@'&!,0*!.;&!-,(*!*+14"2"&!,&!,.)!4*/*4!;A!&$*!1'@4"2!

0,&";.,4*%!A;0!*('2,&";.O!3i7=!!H$*!1;%"&";.%!&$*!$"((*.!2'00"2'4'-!,%!1,0&!;A!N&$*!

%;2",4!2;.&0;4!A'.2&";.!;A!%2$;;4".9O!3i7=!H"-"4,04)6!".!Nb$,&!H$;'4(!b*!C;!:"&$!,!

T"((*.!S'00"2'4'-!b$*.!b*!h".(!K.*eO!!`,.*!Q;.,4(!I,0&".!%&0*%%*%!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!

4*,0.!&;!@*!N(;2"4*!,.(!;@*("*.&O!3Ufk7!1*0$,1%!:"&$!-;0*!*AA"2"*.2)!&$,.!&$*)!4*,0.!

&$*!%'@M*2&%!&$,&!,0*!1,0&!;A!&$*!2'00"2'4'-!"&%*4A=!#$*!$"((*.!2'00"2'4'-!&$*.6!,%!>!

'%*!"&6!(;*%!.;&!%;4*4)!0*A*0!&;!%'@&4*!10,2&"2*%6!,%!'.;AA"2",4!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*!2,.!

"./;4/*!@4,&,.&4)!("%20"-".,&;0)!*/*.&%!&$,&!,0*!.;&!1,0&!;A!&$*!GaK%!;A!*('2,&";.=!!

h'0&$*0".9!&$*!:;05!;A!%2$;4,0%!%'2$!,%!?,44,.2*!,.(!I,0&".6!8'-,%$"0;!,.(!

T,%5*44!,.(!F'0&2$!A;2'%!;.!%;2",4!;&$*0".9!,.(!@'44)".9!,%!1,0&!;A!,!$"((*.!

2'00"2'4'-!".!,(("&";.!&;!"%%'*%!;A!(;2"4"&)!,.(!;@*("*.2*=!b$*.!("%2'%%".9!&$*!0"%5!

;A!&;5*."%&"2!*('2,&";.!;.!N-".;0"&"*%6O!8'-,%$"0;!:0"&*%!&$,&!&$*%*!A;0-!1,0&",4!

5.;:4*(9*%=!T*!%&,&*%!&$,&X!

b$,&!-,5*%!&$*%*!1,0&",4!5.;:4*(9*%!%;!10;@4*-,&"2!"%!&$,&!&$*)!,0*!;A&*.!

&,'9$&!&$0;'9$!&$*!".A;0-,4!;0!o$"((*.B!2'00"2'4'-!3`,25%;.6!UWkZ76!:$"2$!

-*,.%!&$,&6!@*2,'%*!&$*)!,0*!&,'9$&!".("0*2&4)6!1*0/,%"/*4)6!,.(!;A&*.!

'.".&*.&";.,44)6!&$*)!2,.!2,00)!-;0*!*('2,&";.,4!%"9."A"2,.2*!&$,.!&$*!;AA"2",4!

2'00"2'4'-!3`,25%;.6!F;;%&0;-6!p!T,.%;.6!UWWf7=!3[V7!

Page 63: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

]]!

!

#$*!$"((*.!2'00"2'4'-!"%!@,%*(!;.!:$,&!"%!%,"(!*+14"2"&4)!,%!:*44!,%!:$,&!"%!

4*A&!;'&=!T,%5*44!,.(!F'0&2$!1;%"&";.!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!,%!

%;!10;A;'.(!,%!&;!20*,&*!,!N$"((*.!2'00"2'4'-!;A!@'44)".9O!3UU7!A;0!L'**0!);'&$!".!

?,.2;'/*0=!!I)!0*%*,02$!'.*,0&$%!$"((*.!2'00"2'4'-!".!*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%!".!

8".(*09,0&*.6!20*,&".9!24"-,&*%!&$,&!("%10;1;0&";.,&*4)!%*+',4"J*!L'**0!,.(!

&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!,.(!0*4*9,&*!&$*-!&;!&$*!2;.A".*%!;A!&;1"2%!2;.2*0.".9!

$;-;1$;@",!,.(!@'44)".9!3S$,1&*0!h;'0!,.(!S$,1&*0!h"/*7=$$

>.!A;2'%".9!;.!*/*0)(,)(J.#+$)+,3!&$,&!A;0-!,!$"((*.!2'00"2'4'-6!0*9'4,&".9!

9*.(*0!.;0-%!,.(!%*+',4"&)6!>!,4%;!(0,:!;.!h;'2,'4(",.!.;&";.%!;A!("%2"14".*!:"&$".!

1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!>.!T)3+)J6)*,(#*%(A7*)3";(0",(F).$"(&-($",(A.)3&*B!h;'2,'4&!("%2'%%*%!

$"%&;0"2,4!10;2*%%*%!;A!%'0/*"44,.2*!".!h0,.2*!&$,&!:*0*!,&!14,)!:"&$".!".%&"&'&";.,4!

4"A*!".!10"%;.%!,.(!$;:!&$*)!-"-"25*(!10,2&"2*%!*.,2&*(!".!;&$*0!".%&"&'&";.%!%'2$!,%!

$;%1"&,4%6!A,2&;0"*%6!,.(!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!h0;-!*+,-".,&";.%!&;!0*9'4,&";.%!0*9,0(".9!

$,.(:0"&".96!&;!%;0&".9!("AA*0*.&!o24,%%*%B!;A!%&'(*.&%!3:"&$!&$;%*!".!&$*!o4;:*0B!

24,%%*%!%&0"/".9!&;!-;/*!o'1B76!%2$;;4%!:*0*!%&0'2&'0*(!&;!10;('2*!'."A;0-"&)=!

h;'2,'4&!:0"&*%6!N#$*!1*01*&',4!1*.,4"&)!&$,&!&0,/*0%*%!,44!1;".&%!,.(!%'1*0/"%*%!

*/*0)!".%&,.&!".!&$*!("%2"14".,0)!".%&"&'&";.%!2;-1,0*%6!("AA*0*.&",&*%6!$"*0,02$"J*%6!

$;-;9*."J*%6!*+24'(*%=!>.!%$;0&6!"&!.;0-,4"J*%O!3UZf7=!!

D22;0(".9!&;!h;'2,'4&6!&$"%!("%2"14".,0)!.;0-,4"J,&";.!%1*2"A"2,44)!&0,".%!

@;("*%=!T*!,((%6!N#$'%!("%2"14".*!10;('2*%!%'@M*2&*(!,.(!10,2&"2*(!@;("*%6!o(;2"4*B!

@;("*%=!!C"%2"14".*!".20*,%*%!&$*!A;02*%!;A!&$*!@;()!3".!*2;.;-"2!&*0-%!;A!'&"4"&)7!,.(!

("-"."%$*%!&$*%*!%,-*!A;02*%!3".!1;4"&"2,4!&*0-%!;A!;@*("*.2*7O!3UfZ7=!!b$*.!&$"%!"%!

Page 64: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

]k!

!

,114"*(!&;!.;0-%!0*9,0(".9!9*.(*0<!%*+',4"&)6!*/*0)(,)!,2&";.%!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%_

A0;-!9*.(*0E,110;10",&*!:,)%!&;!:,456!2;4;'0%!&;!:*,06!&;1"2%!;A!2;./*0%,&";.6!

10;.;'.%6!,.(!%;!;._*.9,9*!%&'(*.&%!:"&$!10,2&"2*%!:$"2$!30*710;('2*!;0!

2$,44*.9*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!b"&$".!&$"%!A0,-*:;056!%&'(*.&%!-,)!*.9,9*!

".!10,2&"2*%!&$0;'9$!:$"2$!&$*)!4*,0.!&;!-,.,9*!&$*"0!@;("*%!".!%1*2"A"2!:,)%!:"&$".!

*('2,&";.,4!".%&"&'&";.%j!@;("*%!&$*-%*4/*%!@*2;-*!J.#+$)+,%=!!

>.!&*0-%!;A!-)!A"*4(:;05!24,%%0;;-!,.(!%2$;;46!*/*0)(,)!J.#+$)+,3(

2;;0(".,&*(!9*.(*0!,2L'"%"&";.!%'2$!,%!9*.(*0!1;4"2".9!".!14,)!,.(!:,)%!;A!A0,-".9!

A,-"4)=!#$*)!:*0*!10*%*.&!:$*.!%&'(*.&%!:*0*!.,/"9,&".9!,&&0,2&";.6!:$;!9;&!

&*,%*(6!,.(!:$;!9;&!*+24'(*(=!#;!%,)!&$,&!@;("*%!@*2;-*!10,2&"2*(!"%!&;!;@%*0/*!

&$,&!2$"4(0*.!3,.(!,('4&%7!-;("A)!&$*!:,)%!&$*)!-;/*6!'.(*0%&,.(6!,.(!'%*!&$*"0!

@;("*%!@,%*(!;.!%'2$!*/*0)(,)!2;;0(".,&";.=!D%!b*%&!,.(!s"--*0-,.!:0"&*6!

*/*0)(,)!9*.(*0*(!10,2&"2*%!N,0*!/"*:*(!,%!("%&".2&!A0;-!@'&!,0&"2'4,&*(!:"&$!-;0*!

2;.%*L'*.&",4!,2&"/"&"*%6!%'2$!,%!1*0A;0-".9!&,%5%!;0!*.9,9".9!".!("%2;'0%*O!3b*%&!

,.(!s"--*0-,.!UYW7=!!I)!%&'()!20"&"2,44)!*+,-".*%!%'2$!;22'00*.2*%!,.(!:,)%!&$,&!

2$"4(0*.!*+&0,1;4,&*!,22*1&,@4*!,.(!'.,22*1&,@4*!.;0-%!0*9,0(".9!9*.(*0!,.(!

%*+',4"&)!".!&$*"0!A"0%&!)*,0!;A!A;0-,4!%2$;;4".9=!!!

:?BEF<8HE<?BJ$E?$/[<JE<BI$&<EDFAEHFD$

H".2*!&$*!UWiV%6!-,.)!%2$;4,0%!$,/*!*+,-".*(!&$*!0;4*!;A!2$"4($;;(!

%;2",4"J,&";.!,.(!9*.(*0!,2L'"%"&";.=!K.*!;A!&$*!*,04"*0!".A4'*.&",4!:;05%!:,%!&$,&!;A!

`,.*&!a*/*0=!>.!$*0!,0&"24*!UWik!,0&"24*6!NH*+!C"AA*0*.2*!".!&$*!^,-*%!S$"4(0*.!G4,)6O!

%$*!L'*%&";.%!&$*!&0*.(!3,&!&$*!&"-*7!:$"2$!*+,-".*(!&$*!"-1,2&!;A!,('4&!

Page 65: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

]i!

!

".%&"&'&";.,4!,.(!A,-"4",4!%;2",4"J,&";.!;.!&$*!N/,4'*%6!,&&"&'(*%6!,.(!@;("*%!;A!

5.;:4*(9*O!3[iZ7!;A!);'.9!1*;14*=!>.%&*,(!%$*!A;2'%*%!;.!2$"4(0*.B%!14,)!,.(!&$*!

".&*0,2&";.!@*&:**.!);'.9!1*;14*!,%!,.!"-1;0&,.&!A,2&;0!".!&$*"0!(*/*4;1-*.&=!a"5*!

$*0!2;.&*-1;0,0"*%6!%$*!,.,4)%*%!%*+!("AA*0*.2*%!".!%;2",4"J,&";.!,.(!&$*!*+&*.&!&;!

:$"2$!;.*!90;'1!3-*.7!"%!,(/,.&,9*(!;/*0!,.;&$*0!3:;-*.7O!3)/)%7=!T;:*/*06!$*0!

A0,-*:;05!*+,-".*%6!N&$*!1**0!90;'1!,%!&$*(#9,*$!;A!%;2",4"J,&";.6!2$"4(0*.B%!14,)!,%!

&$*!,2&"/"&)!;A!%;2",4"J,&";.6!,.(!0;4*E%5"44%!,%!&$*!J.&%7+$!;A!%;2",4"J,&";.O!3[iZ7=!

b"&$".!-)!*/*0)(,)!;@%*0/,&";.%!;A!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!14,)6!>!(0*:!A0;-!&$"%!1;%"&";.".9!

&;!,.,4)J*!$;:!&$*!2$"4(0*.!3&$*!,9*.&%!;A!%;2",4"J,&";.7!*.9,9*(!".!14,)E@,%*(!

,2&"/"&"*%!&$,&!0*".A;02*(!;0!2$,44*.9*(!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!3&$*!10;('2&!;A!

%;2",4"J,&";.7=!d.4"5*!a*/*0B%!:;056!-)!0*%*,02$!A;2'%*%!;.!$;:!N-*.O!,.(!

N:;-*.O!@*2;-*!("%20*&*!,.(!@".,0)!2,&*9;0"*%!".A;0-*(!@)!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%=!

>.!;&$*0!:;0(%6!&$*!/*0)!2,&*9;0"*%!;A!-*.!,.(!:;-*.!,0*!.;&!&,5*.!,%!9"/*.!".!-)!

0*%*,02$6!@'&!,%!2'4&'0,44)!10;('2*(!,.(!(*1*.(*.&!;.!.;&";.%!;A!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!

,.(!9*.(*0!("AA*0*.2*!3>!*+1,.(!;.!&$*!2'4&'0,44)!(*1*.(*.&!,%1*2&!;A!&$"%!-;0*!

:$*.!("%2'%%".9!&:;E%1"0"&*(.*%%!,.(!D@;0"9".,4!2;.&*+&%7=!!

I)!0*%*,02$!@**.!".A4'*.2*(!@)!F,00"*!#$;0.*B%!-;.;90,1$!E,*%,.(A6#=;(

E).63(#*%(F&=3()*(I+"&&6=!KA!1,0&"2'4,0!".A4'*.2*!"%!&$*!:,)!&$,&!#$;0.*!0*2,%&%!

L'*%&";.%!;A!2$"4($;;(!9*.(*0!%;2",4"J,&";.!A0;-!,%5".9!!"=!9*.(*0!%*90*9,&*(!14,)!

$,11*.%6!&;!,%5".9!"&!'!#$"%!A;2'%!:,%!9*.*0,&"/*!".!#$;0.*B%!:;05!,%!"&!A,2"4"&,&*(!

,.!*+,-".,&";.!;A!$;:6!A;0!*+,-14*6!3$*&*0;7%*+',4"J,&";.!2;-1*44*(!@;)%!,.(!9"04%!

&;!5**1!&$*"0!A0"*.(%$"1%!%*20*&!".!&$*!%2$;;4!%*&&".9!3]V7=!Q,&$*0!&$,.!.,&'0,4"J".9!

Page 66: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

]Z!

!

("AA*0*.2*%!@*&:**.!@;)%!,.(!9"04%!@)!*+,-".".9!:$)!&$*)!(;.B&!14,)!&;9*&$*06!&$"%!

A;2'%!*.,@4*%!0*%*,02$*0%!&;!*+,-".*!$;:!10;2*%%*%!;A!%*90*9,&";.!:;05=!I)!

0*%*,02$!,4%;!&,5*%!'1!L'*%&";.%!;A("&!!9*.(*0!.;0-%!:*0*!*.,2&*(!&$0;'9$!

*/*0)(,)!14,)j!$;:*/*06!-)!0*%*,02$!@0*,5%!.*:!90;'.(!@)!*+,-".".9!9*.(*0!

:"&$;'&!,%%'-".9!&$,&!,44!2$"4(0*.!%$;'4(!"(*.&"A)!,%!*"&$*0!,!N@;)O!;0!,!N9"04O!;0!&$,&!

&$*"0!".&*0.,4!%*.%*%!;A!%*4A!:"44!.*2*%%,0"4)!-,&2$!&$*"0!%;2",4<-*("2,4!,%%"9.,&";.%=!

>!A;44;:!#$;0.*B%!-;/*!N,:,)!A0;-!&$*!L'*%&";.6!oD0*!9"04%!,.(!@;)%!("AA*0*.&e!

b$"2$!2*.&*0%!-'2$!;A!&$*!0*%*,02$!;.!2$"4(0*.!,.(!9*.(*0O!3[7=!#$;0.*!,%5%!

".%&*,(6!N$;:!(;!2$"4(0*.!,2&"/*4)!2;-*!&;9*&$*0!&;!$*41!20*,&*6!,.(!%;-*&"-*%!

2$,44*.9*6!9*.(*0!%&0'2&'0*%!,.(!-*,.".9%eO!3[7=!F)!,4%;!2$,44*.9".9!&$*!,%%'-1&";.!

&$,&!,44!2$"4(0*.!,0*!10*E$*&*0;%*+',4!3'.&"4!L'**0.*%%!"%!0*&0;,2&"/*4)!,114"*(!&;!

2$"4($;;(!A0;-!,('4&$;;(76!-)!0*%*,02$!,4%;!2;.&0"@'&*%!&;!&$"%!4".*!;A!L'*%&";.".9!

@)!*+,-".".9!10;2*%%*%!@)!:$"2$!-*,.".9%!;A!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!

,0*!-,(*6!2$,44*.9*(6!,.(!%&0'2&'0*(!".!*,04)!2$"4($;;(!*('2,&";.=!

D%!"%!&$*!2,%*!:"&$!#$;0.*B%!,.(!a*/*0B%!:;056!>!1;%"&";.!2$"4(0*.!,%!

(*-;.%&0,&".9!,9*.2)!".!&$*"0!%;2",4!:;04(%=!b$*.!2;44*2&".9!,.(!,.,4)J".9!(,&,6!>!

%&0;/*!&;!(*1"2&!&$*!%&'(*.&%6!N.;&!,%!&$*!.*+&!9*.*0,&";.B%!,('4&%6!@'&!,%!%;2",4!

,2&;0%!".!,!0,.9*!;A!".%&"&'&";.%O!3#$;0.*!f7!,.(!&$'%!0*2;9."J*!:,)%!&$*)!N,2&6!

0*%"%&6!0*:;056!,.(!20*,&*O!,.(!$;:!N&$*)!".A4'*.2*!,('4&%!,%!:*44!,%!@*".9!

".A4'*.2*(!@)!&$*-O!3#$;0.*!Y7=!#$"%!:,%!,!/*0)!A0'"&A'4!-;(*4!:"&$".!-)!A"*4(:;05!

,%!&$*!24,%%0;;-!&*,2$*0!0*9'4,04)!("%2'%%*(!$;:!%$*!4*,0.*(!A0;-!$*0!%&'(*.&%!,.(!

$;:!&$*)!%$;:*(!$*0!$;:!%$*!2;'4(!%'11;0&!&$*"0!4*,0.".9=!b$*.!&$*!@;)!:$;!NA*4&!

Page 67: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

]W!

!

4"5*!,!9"04!".%"(*O!*+10*%%*(!$"%!2;.A4"2&*(!A**4".9%!&;!$*06!%$*!%;'9$&!;'&!0*%;'02*%!

3%'2$!,%!%1*,5".9!:"&$!&$*!D@;0"9".,4!R.$,.2*-*.&!b;05*07!,.(!9*.*0,&*(!2$"4(E

%1*2"A"2!:,)%!&;!%'11;0&!$"-!9"/*.!&$*!N%&0;.9!A**4".9%O!$*!:,%!$,/".9!3h"*4(:;05!

.;&*%!VY<V]<UYj!%**!S$,1&*0!H"+!A;0!-;0*!(*&,"47=!T"%!9*.(*0*(!*+1*0"*.2*%!

2$,.9*(!$*0!&*,2$".9!,%!-'2$!,%!$*0!&*,2$".9!-,(*!0;;-!A;0!$"-!&;!%1*,5!,@;'&!$"%!

*+1*0"*.2*%X!,!(*A"."&*!&:;E:,)!4*,0.".9!10;2*%%=UZ!

D9*.2)6!$;:*/*06!"%!.;&!&;!@*!2;.A4,&*(!:"&$!,.!,@%*.2*!;A!$"*0,02$"*%!".!

.;0-,&"/*!4"A*=!H&'("*%!%'2$!,%!a,'0"*!I,2^"44"/0,)!,.(!D.,!I,0"&J,!I,0&".*JB!

NG0".2*%%*%!b$;!S;--"&!H'"2"(*X!G0"-,0)!S$"4(0*.!b0"&".9!:"&$".!,.(!,9,".%&!

^*.(*0!H&*0*;&)1*%6O!*+,-".*!&$*!1;:*0!;A!9*.(*0!.;0-%!,%!0*A4*2&*(!".!10"-,0)!

%&'(*.&%B!4"&*0,2)!,2&"/"&"*%=!>.!&$*"0!%&'("*%6!@;&$!9"04%!,.(!@;)%!:0;&*!%&;0"*%!:"&$!

-,4*!10;&,9;."%&%!,%!$*0;*%!,.(!9"04%!,%!/"2&"-%=!#$*)!1;%"&";.!&$"%!0*%*,02$!,%!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

UZ!I)!:;05!,4%;!(0,:%!A0;-!%2$;4,0%!:$;!20"&"L'*!%;2",4"J,&";.!-;(*4%!:$*.!

*+,-".".9!9*.(*0!,.(!*,04)!2$"4($;;(!*('2,&";.6!%'2$!,%!F0;.:).!C,/"*%!,.(!Q;-!

T,00*!,.(!?,4*0"*!b,45*0(".*=!H'2$!%2$;4,0%!2;-14"2,&*!%&'("*%!;A!2$"4($;;(!

%;2",4"J,&";.!@)!*+,-".".9!&$*!2;-14*+"&)!;A!&$*!%'@M*2&"A"2,&";.!"&%*4A=!b,45*0(".*!

%&,&*%!&$,&!".("/"(',4%!,0*!N,2&',44)!10;('2*(!:"&$".!%"9."A)".9!0*4,&";.%!

&$*-%*4/*%O!3[]Y7=!#$*%*!10;2*%%*%!;A!%'@M*2&"A"2,&";.!$,/*!%;2",4!"-14"2,&";.%=!

C,/"*%!,.(!T,00*!:0"&*!&$,&!1*;14*!9"/*!*,2$!;&$*0!N1,0&%!".!,!%&;0)O!3[Z7!&$*)!&*44!;A!

&$*"0!4"/*%!,.(!%*4/*%!,.(!&$'%!N,!%1*,5*0!-,5*%!,/,"4,@4*!,!%'@M*2&!1;%"&";.!&$,&!&$*!

;&$*0!%1*,5*0!".!&$*!.;0-,4!2;'0%*!;A!*/*.&%!:;'4(!&,5*!'1=!D!1*0%;.!2,.!@*!%,"(!

&$'%!&;!o$,/*!@**.!1;%"&";.*(B!@)!,.;&$*0!%1*,5*0O!3[Z7=!H;2",4"J,&";.!%&'("*%6!:$"4*!

4*%%!2;-14*+!&$,.!&$*%*!&$*;0"J,&";.%!;A!%*4A6!(;!10*%*.&!/,4',@4*!,.,4)%"%!,%!&;!:,)%!

%&'(*.&%!1;%"&";.!*,2$!;&$*0!;0!,0*!1;%"&";.*(!@)!*('2,&;0%!:"&$".!*,04)!2$"4($;;(!

*('2,&";.=!h;0!&$"%!0*,%;.6!>!(;!.;&!1;%"&";.!%'@M*2&"A"2,&";.!".!;11;%"&";.!&;!

%;2",4"J,&";.!&$*;0"*%6!@'&!0,&$*0!,%!2;-14"2,&".9!.;&";.%!,%!&;!:$,&!"%!0*L'"0*(!&;!

20*,&*!2$,.9*!".!%;2",4!%1$*0*%!3,%!&$*!%'@M*2&%!&$*-%*4/*%!,0*!20*,&*(!@)!

".&*0,2&";.%!0,&$*0!&$,.!2;-".9!,%!%&,@4*!%'@M*2&%!&;!,!%;2",4"J,&";.!10;2*%%7=!!

!

Page 68: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

kV!

!

@*".9!0*A4*2&"/*!;A!$;:!-,4*%!,.(!A*-,4*%!".&*0.,4"J*!,.(!1*01*&',&*!%*+"%&!

%&*0*;&)1".9!,.(!0;4*!"(*.&"A"2,&";.=!#$*)!:0"&*6!N9"04%!,%!:*44!,%!@;)%6!1;%"&";.*(!&$*!

$*0;*%!,%!-,4*!,.(!/"2&"-%!,%!A*-,4*=!#;;!;A&*.!@;)%!,.(!-*.!,0*!2;.%"(*0*(!&$*!

;110*%%;0%!:"&$!4"&&4*!,&&*.&";.!&;!&$*!:,)%!".!:$"2$!A*-,4*%!1,0&"2"1,&*!".!&$*!

2;.&".',&";.%!;A!0"9"(!9*.(*0*(!"(*.&"&"*%O!3iW7=!

H'2$!10;2*%%*%!@*9".!/*0)!*,04)!".!2$"4(0*.B%!4"/*%=!#:;!%&'("*%!;A!10*%2$;;4!

*+,-".*!:,)%!-,4*!1;:*0!,.(!10"/"4*9*!"%!0*".A;02*(!:"&$".!10*%2$;;4!%*&&".9%=!>.!

NF*2;-".9!,!G0*%2$;;4!S$"4(X!H'@M*2&"A"2,&";.!".!#;((4*0%!C'0".9!#$*"0!>.&0;('2&";.!

&;!G0*%2$;;46!A0;-!,!^*.(*0!G*0%1*2&"/*6O!D.."5,!Ix.%%;.!,.,4)%*%!&*,2$*0%B!

".&*0,2&";.%!:"&$!10*%2$;;4!2$"4(0*.!A;0!:,)%!@;)%!,0*!*.2;'0,9*(!&;!%**!

&$*-%*4/*%!,%!,2&"/*!,9*.&%!-,5".9!2$;"2*%!&$,&!2;.&0;4!&$*"0!*./"0;.-*.&%!-;0*!

;A&*.!&$,.!9"04%=!!H"-"4,04)6!8,0".!D=!I,0&".B%!0*%*,02$!;'&2;-*%!10;/"(*!,.!

"-1;0&,.&!,.,4)%"%!;A!&$*!.;0-,4"J,&";.!;A!9*.(*0!,.(!1;:*0X!%'2$!,%!9"04%B!24;&$".9!

@*".9!.;.E2;.%*.%',44)!-,."1'4,&*(!3@;)%!A4"11".9!9"04%B!(0*%%*%6!:;05*0%!

o2$*25".9B!&;!%**!"A!9"04%!.**(!,!(",1*0!2$,.9*!:"&$;'&!,%5".9!"A!"&!"%!;5,)!&;!4"A&!&$*"0!

%5"0&%7!,.(!@;)%!@*".9!4;'(*0!,.(!0;'9$*0!".!&$*"0!14,)!:$"4*!9"04%!0*2*"/*!-;0*!

,('4&!10;-1&%!&;!-;('4,&*!&$*"0!/;"2*%!,.(!*+*02"%*!1$)%"2,4!2;.&0;4=!!

F;&$!0*%*,02$*0%!1;%"&";.!&$*"0!%2$;4,0%$"1!,%!2$,44*.9".9!&$*!.,&'0,4.*%%!;A!

9*.(*0*(!1;:*0!().,-"2%=!I,0&".!20"&"L'*%!A*-"."%&!%2$;4,0%$"1!A;0!A;2'%".9!&;;!

*+24'%"/*4)!;.!&$*!1;4"2".9!;A!,('4&%B!@;("*%=!H$*!:0"&*%!&$,&!-,.)!%&'("*%!NA;2'%!;.!

&$*!,('4&!9*.(*0*(!@;()!,.(!A,"4!&;!2;.%"(*0!$;:!&$*!@;()!@*2;-*%!9*.(*0*(=!#$"%!

.*94*2&!-,)!,22*.&',&*!9*.(*0!("AA*0*.2*%!,.(!-,5*!&$*-!%**-!.,&'0,4O!3]UV7=!

Page 69: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

kU!

!

Ix.%%;.!&,5*%!&$"%!,.,4)%"%!A'0&$*0!@)!L'*%&";.".9!&$*!N'."&,0)O!L',4"&)!;A!&$*!

2,&*9;0"*%!&$*-%*4/*%=!H$*!%&,&*%6!Nv&w$*0*!,0*!.;!'."&,0)!2,&*9;0"*%!;A!o@;)%B!,.(!

o9"04%Bj!".%&*,(6!&$*%*!,0*!2;.%&0'2&*(!".!&$*!".&*0%*2&";.!;A!/,0";'%!1;%"&";.%u!

S$"4(0*.!4*,0.!:$,&!"%!0*L'"0*(!;A!&$*-6!&$0;'9$!1;%"&";.".9!&$*-%*4/*%!,%!o9"04%BB!;0!

o@;)%BO!3UV7=!F)!,25.;:4*(9".9!&$,&!);'.9!1*;14*!,0*!2;-1*&*.&!&;!'.(*0%&,.(!

&$*-%*4/*%!,%!;'&%"(*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!@".,0"*%6!-)!0*%*,02$!".&*00;9,&*%!

&$*!"-14"2,&";.%!;A!%'2$!4*,0.".96!,%!(*%20"@*(!@)!Ix.%%;.6!A;0!,!:"(*0!0,.9*!;A!

2$"4(0*.=!!

b"&$".!S,.,(,6!8".(*09,0&*.!-,05%!&$*!A"0%&!)*,0!;A!A;0-,46!%&,&*EA'.(*(!

%2$;;4".9=!F*2,'%*!;A!&$"%6!"&!"%!,.!"-1;0&,.&!)*,0!".!:$"2$!&;!%&'()!$;:!9*.(*0!"%!

".%&"&'&";.,44)!10;('2*(!:"&$".!&$*!1'@4"2!%)%&*-=!h;0!*+,-14*6!".!S$,1&*0!h;'06!>!

*+14;0*!8".(*09,0&*.!%&'(*.&%B!A;2'%!;.!4*,0.".9!N&$*!0'4*%O!%;2",44)!,.(!

".%&"&'&";.,44)!".!2;.M'.2&";.!:"&$!".%&"&'&";.,4!9*.(*0!.;0-%!%'2$!,%!9*.(*0E

%*90*9,&*(!:,%$0;;-%=!#$*!2;-@".,&";.!"44'%&0,&*%!10;2*%%*%!@)!:$"2$!9*.(*0!

20;%%".9!;0!@*".9!".(*&*0-".,&*4)!9*.(*0*(!3.;&!0*2;9."J,@4)!-,4*!;0!A*-,4*7!,0*!

*%&,@4"%$*(!,%!@0*,5".9!%;2",4!,.(!".%&"&'&";.,4!0'4*%!A0;-!*,04)!10"-,0)!%2$;;46!

0*9,0(4*%%!;A!10;90*%%"/*!%2$;;4!1;4"2"*%=!$

>.!&$*!$"9$!%2$;;4!2;.&*+&6!&$*0*!*+"%&%!,!90;:".9!@;()!;A!4"&*0,&'0*!&$,&!

,((0*%%*%!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!$*&*0;%*+"%-!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!3C'5*6!`,-"4!,.(!T,01*06!

T,%5*44!,.(!F'0&2$6!a;'&J*.$*"J*06!I,2>.&;%$6!b"45".%;.!,.(!G*,0%;.6!C'5*7=!C'5*!

,09'*%!&$,&!$"9$!%2$;;4!);'&$!%'AA*0!A0;-!$;-;1$;@"26!("%20"-".,&;0)!1;4"2"*%6!,!

4,25!;A!0;4*!-;(*4%6!/*0@,4!,@'%*6!,.(!,%%,'4&!3UkY7=!F,%*(!;.!%&'("*%!;A!);'&$!:$;!

Page 70: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

kY!

!

N2;-*!;'&O!:$"4*!".!$"9$!%2$;;46!*('2,&";.,4!%2$;4,0%!;A&*.!0*2;--*.(!&$,&!

*('2,&;0%!2;.A0;.&!$;-;1$;@"2!$,0,%%-*.&!("0*2&4)!,.(!10;/"(*!a^F#<L'**0!

);'&$!:"&$!N;'&O!0;4*!-;(*4%!3`,-"4!,.(!T,01*06!C'5*6!b"45".%;.!,.(!G*,0%;.7=!H'2$!

,'&$;0%!,(/;2,&*!A;0!1;4"2)!0*A;0-!&;!,((0*%%!@'44)".9!,.(!&*,2$!0*%1*2&6!'%".9!9,)E

1;%"&"/*!1;%&*0%!,.(!"2;.%!&;!"(*.&"A)!o%,A*!%1,2*B!".!%2$;;4%6!,.(!2'00"2'4,0!2$,.9*!&;!

,((0*%%!&$*!,@%*.2*!;A!a^F#<L'**0!1*;14*!".!%2$;;4!2;'0%*:;05!3`,-"4!,.(!T,01*06!

C'5*6!b"45".%;.!,.(!G*,0%;.7=!!

a;0"!I,2>.&;%$!,.(!a"%,!a;'&J*.$*"%*0!20"&"L'*!2'00*.&!&0*.(%!".!&$*!

*('2,&";.,4!4"&*0,&'0*!("%2'%%*(!,@;/*=!h;0!*+,-14*6!I,2>.&;%$!"./*%&"9,&*%!$;:!

%2$;;4!@;,0(%!-"9$&!"./;4/*!2;--'."&"*%6!10;A*%%";.,4!(*/*4;1-*.&!&0,".".9!

10;90,-%6!,.(!;&$*0!'.(*0'&"4"J*(!%"&*%!".!;0(*0!&;!2$,44*.9*!$*&*0;.;0-,&"/*!

10,2&"2*%!".!&$*!2'4&'0*%!;A!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%B(&$'%!&,5".9!&$*!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!A;0!2$,.9*!

@*);.(!&$*!0*,4-!;A!@'44)".9!,.(!$,0,%%-*.&!,.(!&;:,0(!A,0!0*,2$".9!2'4&'0,4!

%$"A&%=!b$"4*!&$"%!%2$;4,0%$"1!"%!9*,0*(!&;!%&'("*%!;A!$"9$!%2$;;46!>!$,/*!(0,:.!A0;-!

$*0!%'99*%&*(!%2;1*!;A!".&*0/*.&";.!,9,".%&!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!".!-)!(,&,!

,.,4)%"%=!>!&$*0*A;0*!*+,-".*!A,2&;0%!%'2$!,%!&$*!0;4*!;A!1,0*.&%!,.(!4,25!;A!

0*%;'02*%!:$*.!("%2'%%".9!&$*!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!10*%*.&!".!-)!A"*4(%&'()=!!

H'@%&,.&"/*!:;05!;.!9*.(*0!,.(!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!10;/"(*%!,!%;4"(!@,%"%!'1;.!

:$"2$!-)!:;05!"%!@'"4&=!b"&$".!&$"%!%2$;4,0%$"16!&$*0*!,0*!,!A*:!*&$.;90,1$"2!

%&'("*%!;A!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!&$,&!$,/*!@**.!1,0&"2'4,04)!".A4'*.&",4!&;!&$"%!10;M*2&=!!>.!

,(("&";.!&;!#$;0.*B%!%&'()6!G,%2;*B%!*&$.;90,1$)!10;/"(*%!,.!*+,-".,&";.!;A!,!

%2$;;4!2'4&'0*!;A!-,%2'4"."&)!,.(!$;:!"&!".A;0-%!,!0,2",4"J*(!2'4&'0*!;A!%*+"%-6!

Page 71: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

kf!

!

$;-;1$;@",6!$*&*0;%*+"%-6!,.(!9*.(*0*(!%*+',4!/";4*.2*=!G,%2;*B%!:;05!10;/"(*%!

/,4',@4*!".%"9$&%!".&;!&$*!-*2$,."%-%!@)!:$"2$!9*.(*0*(!4"A*!"%!*%&,@4"%$*(6!1;4"2*(6!

,.(!2;.&*%&*(!:"&$".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!".!P;0&$!D-*0"2,=!T;:*/*06!&$*!,@;/*!

4"&*0,&'0*!0*/"*:%!A;44;:!&0*.(%!".!:$"2$!%&'("*%!;A!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!$*&*0;%*+"%-!

,0*!;.4)!,((0*%%*(!".!&$*!$"9$!%2$;;4!2;.&*+&=!^*.(*0!".!&$*!*4*-*.&,0)!2;.&*+&!"%!

,((0*%%*(!,%!"&!1*0&,".%!&;!2"%9*.(*0!@;)%!,.(!9"04%!:"&$;'&!,.,4)%"%!;A!"-14"*(!

%*+',4!;0"*.&,&";.!;0!2"%%*+"%-!".!*,04)!10"-,0)!%2$;;4!9*.(*0!0;4*%=!!

K.*!;A!&$*!;@%&,24*%!&;!10;('2".9!,.,4)%*%!;A!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!$*&*0;%*+"%-!

".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4%!"%!&$*!@*4"*A!&$,&!%'2$!"%%'*%!2;.2*0.!-,&&*0%!;A!,('4&!%*+',4"&)!

,.(!,0*!&$*0*A;0*!"00*4*/,.&!;0!(,.9*0;'%6!,%!2$"4(0*.!,0*!N&;;!);'.9O!&;!5.;:!&$*"0!

%*+',4!;0"*.&,&";.%!3F0'$-!,.(!T'04*)6!T,4@*0%&,-!YVV[6!H*(9:"256!H&;25&;.7=!#$"%!

,%%*0&";.!"%!@,%*(!;.!,%%'-1&";.%!&$,&!("%2'%%".9!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)<$*&*0;%*+',4!

2;'14".9!"%!.;&!("%2'%%".9!%*+',4!;0"*.&,&";.!3;0!'1;.!&$*!(*.",4!&$,&!10*%'-1&";.%!

;A!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!,0*!("%2'%%*(!".!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!10"-,0)!%&'(*.&%76!&$,&!,44!

2$"4(0*.!".!*,04)!90,(*%!@*4"*/*!&$*)!:"44!90;:!'1!,4;.9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!

4".*%6!,.(!&$,&!"%%'*%!;A!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!$*&*0;%*+"%-!,0*!;.4)!0*4*/,.&!:$*.!a^F#!

1*;14*!,0*!10*%*.&=!!

>.!&$*!".&0;('2&";.!&;!>7.)&73,.;(X*($",(K7,,.*,33(&-(>")6%.,*B!H&*/*.!F0'$-!

,.(!P,&,%$,!T'04*)!("%2'%%!2;.2*1&',4"J,&";.%!;A!2$"4($;;(!"..;2*.2*!&$,&!*L',&*!"&!

:"&$!(*A,'4&!2$"4($;;(!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)=!#$*)!:0"&*X!

#$*0*!"%!2'00*.&4)!,!(;-".,.&!.,00,&"/*!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!,0*!3,.(!%$;'4(!%&,)7!

"..;2*.&!;A!%*+',4!(*%"0*%!,.(!".&*.&";.%=!!D&!&$*!%,-*!&"-*6!$;:*/*06!

Page 72: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

k[!

!

2$"4(0*.!,0*!,4%;!;AA"2",44)6!&,2"&4)6!,%%'-*(!&;!@*!$*&*0;%*+',4=!!S'&*!@;)E9"04!

0;-,.2*!0*,(%!,%!*/"(*.2*!A;0!&$*!-,&'0*!%*+',4"&)!&$,&!,:,"&%!&$*-6!,.(!

,.)!$;-;*0;&"2!@*$,/";0!0*,(%!,%!$,0-4*%%!14,)!,-;.9!A0"*.(%!;0!,%!,!

-"%&,5*!&$,&!2,.!4,&*0!@*!2;00*2&*(!@)!-,00",9*=!3"+7!

I)!0*%*,02$!".&;!10,2&"2*%!&$,&!0*".A;02*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!2$,44*.9*%!&$*!

2;.%&0'2&*(!.*'&0,4"&)!;A!$*&*0.;0-,&"/"&)!".!10"-,0)!90,(*%!,.(!,%%"%&%!".!

,((0*%%".9!&$*!$*&*0;%*+',4m"..;2*.&<9,)m2;00'1&!("2$;&;-)=!Q,&$*0!&$,.!

,&&*-1&".9!&;!N10;/*O!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!;0!L'**0.*%%!".!2$"4(0*.6!-)!0*%*,02$!

,((0*%%*%!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!10,2&"2*%!,.(!2$,44*.9*%!&;!&$*-6!@;&$!;A!:$"2$!

,0*!*L',44)!14,'%"@4*!,.(!0*4*/,.&!&;!&$*!2;;0(".,&";.!;A!9*.(*0*(!2'4&'0*%!".!1'@4"2!

%2$;;4!0*9,0(4*%%!;A!,9*=!!

!

D!A*:!0*2*.&!,0&"24*%!$,/*!("0*2&*(!,!.*:!20"&"2,4!%20'&".)!,&!1'@4"2!10"-,0)!

%2$;;4%B!,&&*-1&%!&;!,((0*%%!L'**0.*%%=!D-)!b,44"%!,.(!`;!?,.R/*0)!:0"&*!;A!&$*!

2$,44*.9*%!&;!".24'(*!,2&',4!2$"4(0*.!".!&$*"0!0*%*,02$!('*!&;!%,"(!&,@;;%=!>.%&*,(!

&$*)!("%2'%%!&*,2$*0%B!,.(!A0"*.(%B!*+1*0"*.2*%!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!".!&$*!

24,%%=!h".!S'44*.!,.(!a,'0,!H,.()!("%2'%%!&$*"0!,110;,2$*%!&;!".&0;('2".9!&$*!

*+"%&*.2*!;A!9,)%!,.(!4*%@",.%!".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4!24,%%0;;-%!3".24'(".9!;.*!:$*0*!

,.!,('4&!0;4*E14,)*(!!N4*%@",.!S".(*0*44,6O!&;4(!$*0!%&;0)6!,.(!,%5*(!&$*!24,%%!"A!&$*)!

$,(!,.)!L'*%&";.%7=!#$*"0!%&'()!A;2'%*(!;.!*('2,&;0%B!0*A4*2&";.%!;.!&$*"0!

1*(,9;9"2,4!,110;,2$*%!".!&$"%!*('2,&";.=!!

Page 73: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

k]!

!

K.4)!;.*!;&$*0!1'@4"%$*(!A'44E4*.9&$!%&'()6!1'@4"%$*(!".!D'%&0,4",6!$,%!

".24'(*(!2$"4(0*.B%!1*0%1*2&"/*%!".!,.,4)J".9!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!,.(!9*.(*0!.;0-%!".!

10"-,0)!%2$;;4=!>.!I$.#)9"$;(8*+&W,.)*9(E,*%,.(T)3+&7.3,3()*($",(R#.6=(>")6%"&&%(

>6#33.&&2B(I".()!F4,"%*!2;.('2&%!,!%&'()!;A!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!,.(!9*.(*0!.;0-%!

10*%*.&!".!8".(*09,0&*.!&$,&!"./;4/*(!(;".9!0*%*,02$!:"&$!2$"4(0*.=!H$*!%'--,0"J*%!

%2$;;4!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*%!".!&$*!A;44;:".9!-,..*0X!

T*&*0;%*+',4!@*$,/";'0%!,0*!&0*,&*(!,%!.;0-,4!&$0;'9$;'&!&$*!%2$;;4!(,)=!

h;0!".%&,.2*6!:$*.!&*,2$*0%!0*,(!%&;0"*%!('0".9!90;'1!&"-*6!&$*)!0,0*4)!

L'*%&";.!:$*&$*0!&$*!,('4&!A*-,4*!,.(!-,4*!2$,0,2&*0%!".!&$*!%&;0"*%!,0*!

-,00"*(=!Q,&$*06!"&!"%!%"-14)!,%%'-*(!&$*)!,0*=!T*&*0;%*+',4!@*$,/";'0%!,0*!

0*".A;02*(!,%!&*,2$*0%!;@%*0/*!&$*!14,)!,0*,!,.(!%"-14)!%-"4*!;0!4,'9$!:$*.!

2;--*.&".9!;.!$;:!2'&*!&$*!9"04%!,0*!,%!&$*)!9*&!0*,()!&;!9;!;'&!(,.2".9!

:"&$!&$*!10".2*=!D!L'**0!'.(*0%&,.(".9!;A!9*.(*0!,%%'-*%!&$,&!

$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!A'.2&";.%!&;!10;('2*!o.;0-,4B!'.(*0%&,.(".9%!;A!-,%2'4"."&)!

,.(!A*-"."."&)6!"-14)".9!&$,&!$*&*0;%*+"%-6!10*M'("2*!@)!$*&*0;%*+',4!

,9,".%&!$;-;%*+',4%6!"%!,.;&$*0!A;0-!;A!%*+"%-!&$,&!"%!;A&*.!;/*04;;5*(!".!

&$*!24,%%0;;-!3YYEYf7=!!

F4,"%*!*+,-".*%!:,)%!2$"4(0*.!&,5*!N,.!,2&"/*!1,0&!".!2;.%&0'2&".9!:$,&!"&!

-*,.%!&;!@*!,!9"04!,.(!,!@;)!,&!,!1,0&"2'4,0!&"-*!,.(!14,2*O!3U]7=!#$"%!%&'()!&;;5!

14,2*!".!D'%&0,4",j!-)!0*%*,02$!0*-,".%!&$*!A"0%&!%&'()!;.!&$*!%'@M*2&!:"&$".!,!

S,.,(",.!2;.&*+&=!F4,"%*!20"&"L'*%!&$*!*%%*.&",4"%-!".!-'2$!;A!2$"4($;;(!

(*/*4;1-*.&!&$*;0)!A;0!&$*!:,)%!"&!0*('2*%!N,44!A*-"."."&"*%!,.(!-,%2'4"."&"*%!&;!,!

Page 74: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

kk!

!

%"-14*!,.(!1,0&"2'4,0!:,)!;A!@*".9!,)$",.!,!9"04!&.!,!@;)6!,.(!@*2,'%*!&$*)!,0*!'.,@4*!

&;!&$*;0"J*!1;:*0O!3Uf7!,.(!,09'*%!&$,&!&$*;0"*%!;A!9*.(*0!2;.%&0'2&";.!(;!.;&!

2;.%"(*0!&$*!"-1,2&!&$,&!N:,)%!%;2"*&)!/,4'*%!@*".9!,)$",.!,!@;)!&.!,!9"046!-"9$&!$,/*!

;.!$;:!:*!@*2;-*!9*.(*0*(!@*".9%O!3U[7=!!

D4&$;'9$!A;2'%*(!;.!*+1,.(".9!;1&";.%!A;0!-,%2'4"."&)!,.(!A*-"."."&)!,.(!

&$*!1;:*0!("AA*0*.2*%!@*&:**.!@;)%!,.(!9"04%6!F4,"%*!*+14;0*%!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!,%!

@*&:**.!@;)%!,.(!9"04%6!&$'%!'1$;4(".9!&$*!@".,0)!".!:$"2$!%&'(*.&%!-'%&!@*!*"&$*0!

,!@;)!;0!,!9"04=!>.!?3()$(I$)66(#(F&=Y!>!*+,-".*!10;2*%%*%!&$,&!.,&'0,4"J*!&$*!9*.(*0!

("2$;&;-)!,.(!&$*!"-14"2,&";.%!&$"%!-,)!$,/*!A;0!;&$*0".9!%&'(*.&%!;A!,.)!9*.(*0=!!

:?BZ>HJ<?B$

^"/*.!&$*!2'00*.&!%;2",4!2;.&*+&!".!?,.2;'/*06!1,0&"2'4,04)!?,.2;'/*0B%!

%2$;;4%6!&$"%!0*%*,02$!$,%!&$*!1;&*.&",4!&;!2$,44*.9*!.;&";.%!;A!"..;2*.2*!,.(!

("AA*0*.2*!&$,&!1*01*&',&*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!,.(!%'@%*L'*.&!$*&*0;%*+"%&!,.(!

$;-;1$;@"2!24"-,&*%=!!b"&$".!-)!A"*4(%&'()6!$*&*0;%*+"%-!:,%!*/*0E10*%*.&6!@'&!%;!

&;;!:,%!4*/*0,9*!A0;-!:$"2$!&;!2$,44*.9*!@4,&,.&!$;-;1$;@",=!#$"%!&*.%";.!

"44'-".,&*%!4"-"&,&";.%!;A6!,.(!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!A;06!,110;,2$".9!%;2",4!2$,.9*=!!

I)!2;.&*-1;0,0)!%&'()!"./*%&"9,&*%!$;:!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*%!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-,&"/"&)!&,5*!14,2*!".!,!8".(*09,0&*.!24,%%0;;-j!$;:*/*06!2'00*.&!%2$;;4!

2'4&'0*%!$,/*!%1*2"A"2!$"%&;0"2,4!2;.&*+&%=!T"%&;0"2,4!,.,4)%"%!"%!20"&"2,4!&;!-)!;/*0,44!

10;M*2&!,%!"&!0*/*,4%!$;:!*+24'%";.,0)!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*%!:*0*!A"0%&!"-14*-*.&*(=!

d.(*0%&,.(".9!&$*!0;;&%!A0;-!:$"2$!2'00*.&!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!,0"%*!10;/"(*%!

".%"9$&!".&;!&$*!-*2$,."%-%!&$,&!$,/*!@**.!,&!14,)!".!&$*"0!10;('2&";.!,.(!

Page 75: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

ki!

!

0*10;('2&";.=!>!.;:!&'0.!-)!,&&*.&";.!&;!&$*!$"%&;0"2,4!2;.&*+&%!".!:$"2$!>!

2;.('2&*(!-)!%&'()=!>!A;2'%!;.!S,.,(",.!2;4;.",4"%-!,.(!$"%&;0"*%!;A!9*.(*0%6!

%*+',4"&"*%6!,.(!1'@4"2!*('2,&";.=!b"&$".!&$*!A;'.(,&";.!;A!S,.,(",.!0*%"(*.&",4!,.(!

1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!:,%!(*4"@*0,&*!:;05!&;!*.%'0*!&$,&!b*%&*0.!.;0-%!0*9,0(".9!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!:*0*!'1$*4(!;.!,!.,&";.,4!%2,4*=!

! !

Page 76: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

kZ!

!

:CA=EDF$%`?,$:ABAY<AB$VH8><Z$#ZC??>J$<B$:?BED[EG$4<JFH=E<BI$"YDA><cDY$VAJEJ$

"BEF?YHZE<?B$

D44!S,.,(",.!%2$;;4%!,0*!4;2,&*(!".!,.!$"%&;0"2,4!2;.&*+&!;A!2;4;."J,&";.!_,!

2;.&*+&!".!:$"2$!F0"&"%$!"-1*0",4!0'4*!'%'01*(!D@;0"9".,4!4,.(!,.(!%;'9$&!&;!&,5*E

;/*0!4;2,4!2'4&'0*%=!#$"%!2;4;.",4!2;.&*+&!$,%!".24'(*(!A;02"@4*!*AA;0&%!&;!;@4"&*0,&*!

".("9*.;'%!0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)!,.(!&;!0*14,2*!&$*-!:"&$!b*%&*0.!

2'4&'0,4!.;0-%=!D!5*)!&,2&"2!;A!&$"%!2;4;.",4!:;05!&;!(*%&0;)!D@;0"9".,4!2'4&'0*%!&;;5!

14,2*!&$0;'9$!9;/*0.-*.&E-,.(,&*(!,.(!A'.(*(!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%=!^"/*.!&$*!

,110;10",&";.!;A!4,.(!,.(!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%!3,-;.9!;&$*0!A,2&;0%!.;&!2;/*0*(!".!

&$"%!("%%*0&,&";.76!2;4;.",4"%-!$,%!@**.!$,%!.;&!M'%&!,.!$"%&;0"2,46!@'&!0,&$*0!1,0&!;A!,!

%*&!;A!;.9;".9!S,.,(",.!9;/*0.".9!10,2&"2*%=!!

K/*0!&$*!1,%&!&:;!(*2,(*%6!D@;0"9".,4!,.(!,44"*(!%2$;4,0%!$,/*!@*9'.!&;!

,((0*%%!&$*!;.9;".9!"-1,2&!;A!2;4;.",4"%-!;.!(*4"-"&".9!9*.(*0%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%=!

S'00*.&!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!*+&*.(!A0;-!&$"%!$"%&;0)j!&$*0*A;0*6!

"&!"%!2;4;.",4!.;&";.%!;A!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)!&$,&!(;-".,&*!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!#;!

("%2'%%!$;:!&$*%*!.;0-%!,0*!'1$*4(!".!,!?,.2;'/*0!%2$;;46!:"&$;'&!,25.;:4*(9".9!

&$*!2;4;."J,&";.!&$*)!0*10*%*.&6!:;'4(!A'0&$*0!%'110*%%!&$*!1;:*0!,.(!/";4*.2*!

*.,2&*(!&$0;'9$!?,.2;'/*0B%!$"%&;0)=!>.!;0(*0!&;!,/;"(!0*14"2,&".9!%'2$!*0,%'0*6!&$*!

A"0%&!%*2&";.!;A!&$"%!2$,1&*0!"%!(*/;&*(!&;!&0,2".9!$;:!9*.(*0!,.(!2;4;.",4"%-!$,/*!

@**.!&,5*.!'1!$"%&;0"2,44)!".!S,.,(",.!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!!

#$*!%*2;.(!%*2&";.!;A!&$"%!2$,1&*0!:"44!;/*0/"*:!$"%&;0"2,4!%2$;4,0%$"1!&$,&!

20"&"2,44)!0*%1;.(%!&;!A*-"."J,&";.!;A!*('2,&";.!("%2;'0%*!S,.,(",.!1'@4"2!%2$;;4!

Page 77: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

kW!

!

$"%&;0)=!#$"%!$"%&;0";90,1$)!;A!9*.(*0!,.(!-,".%&0*,-!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!(*1"2&%!4,09*0!

S,.,(",.!%&0,&*9"*%!&;!0*10;('2*!S,.,(,!,%!,!:$"&*6!$*&*0;%*+',4!.,&";.!:"&$!

"(*,4"J*(!9*.(*0!.;0-%=!I)!A"*4(%&'()!2;.&0"@'&*%!;0"9".,4!(,&,!&;!&$*%*!&;1"2%!,%!"&!

10;/"(*%!2'00*.&!*+,-14*%!;A!$;:!*('2,&;0%!3&$*!24,%%0;;-!&*,2$*0!,.(!&$*!

D@;0"9".,4!R.$,.2*-*.&!b;05*07!&;;5!'1!&$*%*!4".*,9*%!,.(!,&&*-1&*(!&;!

2$,44*.9*!&$*-!,&!H;'&$!H"(*!R4*-*.&,0)!H2$;;4=!#$"%!2$,1&*0!10;/"(*%!,.!,.&"E

0,2"%&6!A*-"."%&!,110;,2$!&;!'.(*0%&,.(".9!$"%&;0"2,4!2;.&*+&%!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-,&"/"&)!".!S,.,(",.!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%6!,%!:*44!,%!10,2&"2,4!:;05!(;.*!@)!*('2,&;0%!

:$;!2;.2*1&',4"J*(!&$*"0!:;05!,%!20*,&".9!%,A*!%1,2*%!A;0!,44!&$*"0!%&'(*.&%=!!

2DBYDFDY$:?>?B<A><J@$ABY$ECD$/FAJHFD$?_$'8?F<I<BA>$:H>EHFDJ$

I;%&!;A!&$*!G0;/".2*!;A!F0"&"%$!S;4'-@",!"%!'.2*(*(!D@;0"9".,4!4,.(=!#$*!2"&)!

;A!?,.2;'/*0!"%!;.!S;,%&!H,4"%$!&*00"&;0)!&$,&!$,%!.*/*0!@**.!0*4".L'"%$*(!&$0;'9$!,!

&0*,&)!10;2*%%=!#$*!@*9"..".9!;A!&$*!,0*,B%!;22'1,&";.!@)!2;4;.",4!F0"&"%$!0'4*!@*9,.!

".!F0"&"%$!S;4'-@",!".!&$*!4,&*!UZ]V%!:"&$!FS!@*2;-".9!,!S,.,(",.!10;/".2*!".!

UZiU6!A;'0!)*,0%!,A&*0!S,.,(",.!S;.A*(*0,&";.=!C'0".9!S,.,(,B%!N*+1,.%";.O!b*%&6!

:$"&*!2;4;."J*0%!%10*,(!("%*,%*!,.(!20*,&*(!4*9,4!("%*.A0,.2$"%*-*.&!;A!D@;0"9".,4!

1*;14*!:"&$".!@'09*;.".9!F0"&"%$!4*9,4!0'4*=!D@;0"9".,4!1*;14*!:*0*!A;02*(!;AA!&$*"0!

4,.(!,.(!;.&;!0*%*0/*%=!H"-'4&,.*;'%4)6!&$*!9;/*0.-*.&!0*-;/*(!D@;0"9".,4!

2$"4(0*.!A0;-!&$*"0!2;--'."&"*%!,.(!14,2*(!&$*-!".!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%!".!:$"2$!

&$*)!:*0*!,.(!A;0@"((*.!A0;-!4*,0.".9!,@;'&!&$*"0!2'4&'0*%=!#$0;'9$!&$"%!

2;-@".,&";.!;A!&,2&"2%6!&$*!S,.,(",.!9;/*0.-*.&!$;1*(!&;!;@4"&*0,&*!4;2,4!.,&";.%!

,.(!&$'%!&$;%*!2'4&'0*B%!24,"-%!&;!&$*"0!;:.!4,.(=!#$"%!2;4;.",4!10;M*2&B%!*+*0&";.!;A!

Page 78: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

iV!

!

1;:*0!:,%!%&**1*(!".!b*%&*0.!.;&";.%!;A!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)!,.(!:,%!1*0-*,&*(!

@)!&$*"0!$"*0,02$"*%=!!

Q"((".9!D@;0"9".,4!.,&";.%!;A!&0,("&";.,4!0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!9*.(*0%!,.(!

%*+',4"&"*%!2,.!@*!'.(*0%&;;(!2*.&0,4!&;6!0,&$*0!&$,.!,!%"(*!*AA*2&!;A6!2;4;.",4"%-!

"&%*4A=!>.!I+"&&63(-&.(0!&(IJ).)$(U&7$";(<(97)%,(-&.($,#+",.3(#*%(3$7%,*$3B(I,((,4*.,!

^*.;/*%*!(*A".*%!2;4;.",4"%-!,%X!!

D!%;2",4!10;2*%%!2$,0,2&*0"J*(!@)!A"/*!".&*02;..*2&*(!1$,%*%X!(*.",4!;A!

>.("9*.;'%!2'4&'0*j!(*%&0'2&";.!;A!%)-@;4%!;A!2'4&'0*j!(*."90,&";.!;A!

>.("9*.;'%!@*4"*A!%)%&*-%!,.(!2*0*-;."*%j!&;5*."%-6!".!:$"2$!&$*!0*-.,.&%!

;A!2'4&'0*!,0*!&;4*0,&*(!,%!A;454;0*j!,.(!*+14;"&,&";.!;A!,%1*2&%!;A!&0,("&";.,4!

2'4&'0*6!%'2$!,%!-'%"2!,.(!,0&6!&$,&!0*A'%*!&;!("%,11*,0=!S;4;.",4!0'4*0%!

;1*0,&*!:"&$".!&$*!A0,-*%!;A!2;.L'*%&6!*+14;"&,&";.!,.(!0*10*%%";.!&;!@0*,5!

*+"%&".9!%;2",4!1,&&*0.%!,.(!0*,%%*-@4*!&$*-!,22;0(".9!&;!R'0;1*,.!

%&,.(,0(%=!3k7!

K.*!;A!&$*!-,.)!A;0-%!;A!2'4&'0,4!9*.;2"(*!1*01*&0,&*(!,9,".%&!D@;0"9".,4!

1*;14*!:,%!&$*!S,.,(",.!^;/*0.-*.&B%!"-14*-*.&,&";.!;A!Q*%"(*.&",4!H2$;;4%=!

D@;0"9".,4!2$"4(0*.!:*0*!A;02"@4)!&,5*.!A0;-!&$*"0!$;-*%!,.(!A,-"4"*%6!@)!;0(*0!;A!

&$*!S,.,(",.!9;/*0.-*.&6!,.(!14,2*(!".!&$*%*!%2$;;4%!:$*0*!&$*)!:*0*!1'."%$*(!

%*/*0*4)!A;0!%1*,5".9!&$*"0!4,.9',9*%6!20*,&".9!&$*"0!,0&6!;0!14,)".9!9,-*%!A0;-!&$*"0!

2'4&'0*%!38*4-6!I"44;)7=!#$*0*!,0*!,4%;!0*1;0&%!;A!:"(*%10*,(!1$)%"2,4!,.(!%*+',4!

,@'%*!,%!:*44!,%!-*("2,4!.*94*2&!".!2,%*%!;A!2;.&,9";'%!"44.*%%!%'2$!,%!&'@*02'4;%"%!

,.(!%-,44!1;+!30*%'4&".9!".!&$*!%10*,(!;A!"44.*%%*%!&;!1**0%7!,.(!0*1;0&%!;A!2$"4(0*.!

Page 79: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

iU!

!

9;".9!:"&$;'&!A;;(!:$"4*!*('2,&;0%!,&*!:*44!3)/)%7=!>.!&$*!Nh;0*:;0(O!&;!S*2"4",!T,"9!

F0;:.B%!@;;56!5,3)3$#*+,(#*%(5,*,!#6;(I7.W)W)*9($",(?*%)#*(5,3)%,*$)#6(I+"&&63B!

Q,.()!h0*(!:0"&*%X!

S;4;."J*0%!'&"4"J*!&:;!A;0-%!;A!9*.;2"(*X!".&*.&";.,4!,.(!'.".&*.&";.,4=!#$*!

".&*.&";.,4!A;0-%!".24'(*!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%6!4,.(!90,@@".96!,.(!(;:.0"9$&!

-'0(*0=!d.".&*.&";.,4!A;0-%!".24'(*!&$*!".&0;('2&";.!;A!("%*,%*!3,4&$;'9$!".!

%;-*!2,%*%!&$"%!:,%!".&*.&";.,47=!3U]7!!

Q*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%!&;;5!1,0&!".!9*.;2"(*!@;&$!".!&*0-%!;A!2'4&'0*!,%!:*44!,%!

&$*!%$**0!-;0&,4"&)!0,&*%=!b$"4*!A;'0!;'&!;A!&*.!2$"4(0*.!*.0;44*(!("*(6!&$*!

9;/*0.-*.&!("(!.;&!(**-!&$"%!&;!@*!%'AA"2"*.&!0*,%;.!&;!,@;4"%$!&$*!%2$;;4%!3I"44;)7=!

h,0!A0;-!&$*!-;0&,4"&)!0,&*%!@*".9!".2"(*.&,46!,!0*2*.&!%&'()!@)!>,.!I;%@)!2;/*0%!UV!

)*,0%!;A!-*("2,4!*+1*0"-*.&,&";.!;.!D@;0"9".,4!%&'(*.&%!:"&$".!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%=!

b$"4*!&$*!S,.,(",.!9;/*0.-*.&!$,(!&,5*.!D@;0"9".,4!4,.(!,.(!(*%&0;)*(!0*%;'02*%!

".&*90,4!&;!.'-*0;'%!.,&";.%B!:,)%!;A!4"A*6!"&!A,'4&*(!D@;0"9".,4!2;--'."&"*%!:"&$!

N(*1*.(*.2)O!3I;%@)!U]f7!;.!9;/*0.-*.&,4!10;90,-%!,.(!A".,.2",4!,"(=!H;4/".9!&$*!

10;@4*-!;A!(*1*.(*.2)!:,%!&$*.!1,&*0.,4"%&"2,44)!1;%"&";.*(!,%!,!9;/*0.-*.&,4!

0*%1;.%"@"4"&)!,.(!'%*(!,%!&$*!0,&";.,4*!&;!%&'()!1;&*.&",4!N%;4'&";.%=O!H&'("*%!:*0*!

&$*.!2,00"*(!;'&!;.!2$"4(0*.!&;!%**!:$"2$!1;1'4,&";.%!:;'4(!@*2;-*!0*%"%&,.&!&;!

("%*,%*!A,%&*0!&$,.!;&$*0%!:$*.!%;-*!:*0*!10;/"(*(!:"&$!,(*L',&*!.'&0"&";.!,.(!

;&$*0%!:*0*!.;&!3U]U7=!I;%@)!:0"&*%6!&$,&!N%&'(*.&%!".!&$*!*+1*0"-*.&,4!%2$;;4%u!

:*0*!(*."*(!&0*,&-*.&!&$,&!;&$*0!%&'(*.&%!:;'4(!$,/*!$,(!,22*%%!&;!('0".9!&$*!A"/*!

)*,0!%&'()!1*0";(O!3Ukf7=!!

Page 80: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

iY!

!

>.!YVVZ6!&$*!S;.%*0/,&"/*!S,.,(",.!^;/*0.-*.&!A;0-,44)!,25.;:4*(9*(!&$*!

(*4"@*0,&*!,.(!%&0,&*9"2!.,&'0*!;A!&$*!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4!10;M*2&!&;!(*%&0;)!

D@;0"9".,4!2'4&'0*%=!D%!1,0&!;A!&$*!NP,&";.,4!D1;4;9)O!&;!D@;0"9".,4!2;--'."&"*%!A;0!

Q*%"(*.&",4!H2$;;4%!,.(!&$*"0!*AA*2&%!;.!D@;0"9".,4!1*;14*!,20;%%!S,.,(,6!G0"-*!

I"."%&*0!H&*/*.!T,01*0!%&,&*(X!

#:;!10"-,0)!;@M*2&"/*%!;A!&$*!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%!%)%&*-!:*0*!&;!0*-;/*!

,.(!"%;4,&*!2$"4(0*.!A0;-!&$*!".A4'*.2*!;A!&$*"0!$;-*%6!A,-"4"*%6!&0,("&";.%!

,.(!2'4&'0*%6!,.(!&;!,%%"-"4,&*!&$*-!".&;!&$*!(;-".,.&!2'4&'0*=!#$*%*!

;@M*2&"/*%!:*0*!@,%*(!;.!&$*!,%%'-1&";.!,@;0"9".,4!2'4&'0*%!,.(!%1"0"&',4!

@*4"*A%!:*0*!".A*0";0!,.(!'.*L',4=!>.(**(6!%;-*!%;'9$&6!,%!"&!:,%!".A,-;'%4)!

%,"(6!q&;!5"44!&$*!>.(",.!".!&$*!2$"4(=q!3d.1,9".,&*(7!

#$*!%2$;;4%!"./;4/*(!9*.(*0!%*90*9,&";.!,.(!*+14"2"&!&0,".".9!".!;0(*0!&;!

,%%"-"4,&*!2$"4(0*.!".&;!b*%&*0.!9*.(*0*(!1;:*0!().,-"2%!3F,0-,.7=!#$*!

9*.(*0*(!"-14"2,&";.%!;A!%*1,0,&".9!2$"4(0*.!".!&$*!%2$;;4%!("(!-;0*!&$,.!%*90*9,&*!

,4;.9!-,4*<A*-,4*!4".*%=!F)!"%;4,&".9!9*.*0,&";.%!A0;-!*,2$!;&$*06!D@;0"9".,4!

2;--'."&"*%!:*0*!'.,@4*!&;!1,%%!(;:.!.;.Eb*%&*0.!'.(*0%&,.(".9%!;A!9*.(*0!,.(!

%*+',4"&)!A0;-!;.*!&;!&$*!;&$*0=!C'0".9!&$*!,1;4;9)6!-,.)!D@;0"9".,4!1*;14*!:*0*!

"./"&*(!&;!%1*,5!,&!&$*!T;'%*!;A!S;--;.%!,.(6!".!(;".9!%;6!,((0*%%*(!,!0,.9*!;A!

4*9,2"*%!4*A&!A0;-!Q*%"(*.&",4!H2$;;4%=!D-;.9!&$*!%1*,5*0%!F*/*04*)!`,2;@%6!;0!

^;:*$9)'%*$6!%1;5*!;.!@*$,4A!;A!&$*!P,&"/*!b;-*.B%!D%%;2",&";.!;A!S,.,(,!,@;'&!

1,0&!;A!&$*!9*.(*0*(!0;4*!;A!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%=!H$*!@*9,.!@)!%&,&".9!&$,&!%$*!:,%!

A0;-!&$*!I;$,:5!P,&";.!;A!&$*!T,'(*.;%,'.**!2;.A*(*0,2)6!F*,0!S4,.6!,.(!&;4(!;A!

Page 81: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

if!

!

$*0!2'4&'0*B%!&0,("&";.%!&;!&*,2$!);'.9!1*;14*!0*%1*2&!A;0!&$*-%*4/*%!,.(!*,2$!;&$*0!

,.(!&;!A;%&*0!9*.(*0!*L'"&)!,.(!0*%1*2&!A;0!:;-*.=!H$*!0*2;'.&*(!%;-*!;A!&$*!

,@'%*%!$*0!90,.(-;&$*0!A,2*(!".!Q*%"(*.&",4!H2$;;4%!,.(!$;:6!$,/".9!@**.!&,'9$&!

:*%&*0.!2'4&'0,4!-"%;9).)6!%$*!("(!.;&!1,%%!;.!&$*"0!A;0-*0!2'4&'0,4!&0,("&";.%!;A!

9*.(*0*(!0*%1*2&!3YYfEYY[7=!!#$*!9*.(*0*(!1;:*0!().,-"2%!>!,.,4)J*!".!-)!

0*%*,02$!2;-*%!A0;-!,!4*9,2)!".!:$"2$!,4&*0.,&*!3;A&*.!0*%1*2&A'47!,110;,2$*%!&;!

:;-*.!,.(!9*.(*0!:*0*!0*10*%%*(=!!

S,00"*0!%2$;4,06!I"2$*44*!S,-*0;.6!,4%;!:0"&*%!&$,&!:$"&*!2;4;.",4!/";4*.2*!

%'110*%%*(!,.(!;@M*2&"A"*(!D@;0"9".,4!.,&";.%B!9*.(*0!%)%&*-%=UW!!S,-*0;.!

(*%20"@*%!$;:!-,.)!2'4&'0*%!$,(!0;4*%!A;0!,&!4*,%&!&$0**6!@'&!,%!-,.)!,%!%"+6!9*.(*0%!

3S,-*0;.!UY[7=!a"5*!`,2;@%6!S,-*0;.!:0"&*%!,@;'&!&$*!0;4*!;A!9*.*0,&";.,4!

%*90*9,&";.!".!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%!,%!;.*!:$"2$!%;'9$&!&;!2;.&0;4!D@;0"9".,4!

0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!9*.(*0%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%=!H$*!%&,&*%X!

K'0!R4(*0%_&$*!9,&*5**1*0%!;A!5.;:4*(9*!".!D@;0"9".,4!2;--'."&"*%_$,/*!

.;&!1,%%*(!(;:.!&$*"0!&*,2$".9%!0*9,0(".9!&:;E%1"0"&*(!1*;14*l%!14,2*!".!;'0!

2;--'."&"*%=!R"&$*0!&$*0*!"%!2;-14*&*!%"4*.2*!;.!&$*!"%%'*6!;0!&$*0*!"%!@4,&,.&!

(*.",4!,.(!$;-;1$;@",!".2;01;0,&*(!".!&$*"0!&*,2$".9%=!#$"%!$,%!$,(!&$*!

'.A;0&'.,&*!*AA*2&!;A!9*.*0,&";.%!90;:".9!'1!:"&$!.;!2;.2*1&!;A!:$,&!"&!

$"%&;0"2,44)!-*,.&!&;!@*!&:;E%1"0"&*(!,.(!&$"%!$,%!4*(!&;!&$*!*0,%'0*!;A!&$"%!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

UW!b$"&*!,.&$0;1;4;9"%&%!,.(!0*%*,02$*0%!'%*(!&$*!&*0-!N@*0(,2$*O6!:$"2$!:,%!

@;00;:*(!A0;-!D0,@"26!&;!(*%20"@*!*AA*-".,&*!-*.!;0!-*.!:$;!("(!.;&!A"44!

-,%2'4".*<-,4*!%;2",4!0;4*%!3b"4%;.!fV[7=!!!

Page 82: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

i[!

!

$"%&;0)!A0;-!&$*!2;44*2&"/*!-".(%*&!;A!&$*!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4!9*.*0,&";.%6!,.(!

%'@%*L'*.&!9*.*0,&";.%!&$*0*,A&*0!3UY[7=!!

H'2$!&*%&"-;."*%!"44'%&0,&*!".&*0%*2&";.%!@*&:**.!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!,.(!

2;4;.",4"%-!,%!:*44!,%!&$*!(*1&$!&;!:$"2$!2;4;.",46!9*.(*0*(!1;:*0!().,-"2%!,0*!

*.&0*.2$*(!".!S,.,(",.!".%&"&'&";.,4!4"A*=!!

S,-*0;.!*4,@;0,&*%!;.!&$*!".,(*L',2)!;A!&$*!b*%&*0.!2;.2*1&',4"J,&";.%!;A!

N$;-;%*+',4"&)O!&;!(*%20"@*!&0,("&";.,4!S,00"*0!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)=!

H$*!*+14,".%X!

b$*&$*0!>!2$;;%*!&;!@*!:"&$!,!-,.!;0!,!:;-,.6!".!&$*!2;.&*+&!;A!&$*!;0"9".,4!

-*,.".9!;A!&$*!&*0-!&:;E%1"0"&*(6!>!:;'4(!2;.&".'*!&;!@*!2;.%"(*0*(!&:;E

%1"0"&*(!(*%1"&*!-)!q-,4*q!2$;"2*!;A!9*.(*0!0;4*=!g*&6!@*2,'%*!-)!1,0&.*0!"%!,!

:;-,.6!>!,-!2;.%"(*0*(!$;-;%*+',4!".!&$*!:*%&*0.!%*+',4!("2$;&;-)!3UY[7=!!

F*".9!4,@*4*(!,!N4*%@",.O!&$*.!@*2;-*%!,.!,2&!;A!2;4;.",4"%-!&;!S,-*0;.!:$;!

(*%20"@*%!&$*!".,(*L',2)!;A!&$*!&*0-!".!4"9$&!;A!&$*!2'4&'0,4!4;2,&";.!,%!.*"&$*0!,!

N-,.O!.;0!,!N:;-,.=O!

>.!*,04"*0!2;4;.",4!&"-*%6!&$*!("%&".2&";.!@*&:**.!D@;0"9".,4!,.(!.;.E

D@;0"9".,4!:,%!%&0*%%*(!,.(!@*2,-*!&$*!@,%"%!A;0!4,.(!&$*A&!,.(!Q*%"(*.&",4!H2$;;4%=!

S'00*.&!2;4;.",4!.;0-%!%&"44!&,5*!A;0*E90,.&*(!2;4;.",4!4,.(!;:.*0%$"1!,.(!

(;-".,.&!b*%&*0.!2'%&;-%!,%!&$*!(*A,'4&!4;2,4!2'4&'0*=!G0*%*.&E(,)!("%2;'0%*%!;A!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!2,.!0*".A;02*!2;4;.",4"%-!@)!A0,-".9!b*%&*0.!.;&";.%!;A!

9*.(*0!;0!%*+',4"&)!,%!&$*!%;4*!-;0,4!,.(!%2"*.&"A"2!'.(*0%&,.(".9%!;A!&$*%*!

Page 83: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

i]!

!

2;.2*1&%=!T*.2*6!.;.ED@;0"9".,4!1*;14*!".!S,.,(,!1,0&"2"1,&*!,.(!,0*!"-14"2,&*(!".!

-'.(,.*6!*/*0)(,)!,2&";.%!;A!2;4;.",4"%-=!

#$*!,2&!;A!0*%"%&".9!2;4;.",4"%-!0*L'"0*%!-,".%&0*,-!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!

2;--'."&"*%!&;!(*E2*.&0,4"J*!b*%&*0.!'.(*0%&,.(".9%!;A!%*+',4"&"*%!,.(!9*.(*0%!

3*=9=!&$,&!2'4&'0*%!'."/*0%,44)!$;4(!,!-,4*<A*-,4*!9*.(*0!@".,0)7=!T;:*/*06!

S,-*0;.!("AA*0*.&",&*%!@*&:**.!%'2$!2'4&'0,4!4"&*0,2)!,.(!2'4&'0,4!,110;10",&";.=!

H$*!%&,&*%6!N#$*!&*0-!&:;E%1"0"&*(!$,%!#(3J,+)-)+(2'4&'0,4!2;.&*+&6!,.(!0*-;/".9!"&!

A0;-!&$,&!2;.&*+&!%"-14)!@*2,'%*!;.*!4"5*%!&$*!-*,.".9!;A!"&!"%!,.!,2&!;A!2;4;."J,&";.!

,.(!-'%&!@*!0*%"%&*(O!3UYf7=!>!,-!.;&!,.!D@;0"9".,4!1*0%;.!,.(!.*"&$*0!:*0*!&$*!

-,M;0"&)!;A!&$*!%&'(*.&%!".!-)!%&'()=!>!(;!.;&!'%*!&:;E%1"0"&!:"&$".!-)!4,09*0!

,.,4)%"%!,%!&$*!&*0-!"%!%1*2"A"2!&;!D@;0"9".,4!2;--'."&"*%!,.(!:;'4(!@*!

,110;10",&"/*!&;!'%*!;&$*0:"%*!3S,-*0;.7j!$;:*/*06!"&!:,%!,.!D@;0"9".,4!%&'(*.&!".!

-)!A"*4(%&'()!:$;!*+10*%%*(!$,/".9!-"+*(!A**4".9%!".!0*9,0(%!&;!9*.(*0=!C*1,0&".9!

A0;-!2;4;.",4!.;0-%!".!-)!0*%*,02$!0*L'"0*%!.;&!%'1*0E"-1;%".9!,!b*%&*0.!4,@*4!

;.&;!$"%!*+1*0"*.2*=!S0"&"2,4!&;!-)!0*%*,02$!"%!,.!*+,-".,&";.!;A!&$*!2'4&'0,4!

%1*2"A"2"&)!;A!&$*!b*%&*0.!&:;E9*.(*0*(!%)%&*-6!"&%!,%%;2",&*(!.;0-%!,.(!&$*!

("AA*0*.&!%"&*%!;A!1;:*0!&$,&!$,/*!-;@"4"J*(!"&=!!

K&$*0!%2$;4,0%!$,/*!:,0.*(!,9,".%&!0;-,.&"2"J".9!,!'."/*0%,44)!N-;0*!

,22*1&".9O!D@;0"9".,4!&0,("&";.=!#$"%!0;-,.&"2"J".9!*0,%*%!("AA*0*.2*%!@*&:**.!

2'4&'0*%=!I;0*;/*06!"&!(;*%!.;&!0*2;9."J*!2$,44*.9*%!*+1*0"*.2*(!:"&$".!".("/"(',4!

&0,("&";.%=!h;0!*+,-14*6!:"&$".!-)!0*%*,02$6!I"2$*44*!R/*0*&&!3&$*!D@;0"9".,4!

H'11;0&!b;05*07!("%2'%%*(!%;-*!;A!&$*!2$,44*.9*%!%$*!A,2*(!:;05".9!:"&$!&:;E

Page 84: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

ik!

!

%1"0"&!%&'(*.&%!".!,.(!&$*"0!A,-"4"*%=!H$*!(*%20"@*(!&$*!".&0"2,2"*%!".!;.*!2;--'."&)!

,%!%'2$X!!

vSw'4&'0,44)6!10,9-,&"2,44)6!&$*!0;4*%!,0*!/*0)!(*A".*(!@*&:**.!-,4*!,.(!

A*-,4*=!!H;!"&_>!&$".5!"&B44!@*!,.!".&*0*%&".9!2$,44*.9*!A;0!-*!,%!>!9;!A;0:,0(6!

@*2,'%*6!'-6!:*B/*!2;-*!,!4;.9!:,)!@'&!:*!$,/*!v%"9$w!,!4;.9!:,)!)*&!&;!9;=!

D.(!&:;E%1"0"&*(!1*;14*!,0*!.;&!1*;14*!&$,&!,0*_);'!5.;:6!&$*)!:*0*!

$*,4*0%!,.(!&$*)!:*0*6!'-6!4*,(*0%!,.(!&$".9%!4"5*!&$,&=!D.(!&$*)!:*0*!

$*0,4(*(!".!,!@"9!:,)6!@'&!A;0!&$*!0*%&6!"A!);'B0*!.;&!&:;E%1"0"&*(!;0!"A!);'B0*!

.;&!:$,&*/*06!.;6!.;6!.;6!.;6!.;=!g;'B0*!,!-,.6!);'B0*!,!:;-,.=!R/*.!A0;-!

%*+',4"&)6!"&B%_.;&!&$*!%,-*=!g;'!2,.!@*!&:;E%1"0"&*(!".!%;-*!2;--'."&"*%_

@'&!);'!2,.B&!@*!9,)=!H;!"&B%!5".(!;A_)*,$=!H;!:"&$".!,.)!2'4&'0*6!>!-*,.6!>!

%$;'4(.B&_);'!5.;:6!(;.B&!,4:,)%!$,/*!&;!@0".9!"&!,0;'.(!&;!D@;0"9".,4!

2'4&'0*6!@'&!)*,$=!>.!%;-*!0*4"9";'%!2;--'."&"*%_&$*)B0*!9"/*.!&$*!9;!,$*,(!

&;!1*0A;0-!9,)!-,00",9*6!@'&!&$,&!10"*%&!;0!&$,&!1,%&;0!@*&&*0!.;&!@*!9,)=!!

g*,$=!H;!"&B%!".&*0*%&".9=!3R/*0*&&!Uk!I,)!YVUY7!

D%!%'2$6!I"2$*44*!R/*0*&&!.;&*%!&$,&!9*.(*0*(!,.(!%*+',4!.;0-%!:"&$".!,!

/,0"*&)!;A!2'4&'0*%!,0*!.;&!:"&$;'&!&$*"0!4"-"&,&";.%=!Q,&$*0!&$,.!$;4(".9!'1!;.*!

1,0&"2'4,0!-;(*4!,%!N&$*!,.%:*06O!I"2$*44*!("%2'%%*(!$;:!%$*6!,.(!;&$*0%6!@*4"*/*%!

".!2$,44*.9".9!.;0-%!A0;-!:"&$".!&$*"0!;:.!&0,("&";.%6!".!,!:,)!&$,&!"%!0*%1*2&A'4!;A!

&$*!2'4&'0*%!&$*-%*4/*%=YV!Q*2;9."J".9!&$,&!2'00*.&!1'@4"2!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*%!;A!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

YV!S,-*0;.!(*%20"@*%!,(("&";.,4!:,)%!2;4;.",4"%-!$,%!".A4'*.2*(!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-%=!H$*!:0"&*%6!!NT*&*0;%*+"%&!,.(!$;-;1$;@"2!&$;'9$&!$,%!1*0-*,&*(!&$*!

Page 85: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

ii!

!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!*+"%&!".!,!2;4;.",4!2;.&*+&!"%!20"&"2,4!&;!0*2;9."J".9!,.(!

0*%"%&".9!,%%"-"4,&";."%&!/";4*.2*%=!b;05!A;0!2'4&'0,4!2$,.9*!0*L'"0*%!,&&*.&";.!&;!

,2&%!&$,&!2;.&".'*!&;!.;0-,4"J*!2;4;.",4"%-6!0,&$*0!&$,.!24,"-".9!&$,&!&$*0*!*+"%&%!,.!

"(*,4!-;(*4!A0;-!:$"2$!&;!(0,:!;0!&;!:$"2$!&;!0*&'0.=!

Q*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%!@*9,.!".!&$*!UZ[V%=!#$*!4,%&!%2$;;46!4;2,&*(!".!

H,%5,&2$*:,.6!("(!.;&!24;%*!&"44!UWWk!3ND!&"-*4".*!;A!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%6!&$*!#0'&$!

,.(!Q*2;.2"4",&";.!S;--"%";.O7=!#$*!*AA*2&%!;A!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%!".24'(*!".&*0E

9*.*0,&";.,4!&0,'-,6!,.(!$,0-".9!2;--'."&"*%!,.(!A,-"4"*%=!K.*!D@;0"9".,4!

%2$;4,06!Q;@".!^0,)6!A0,-*%!%'2$!*AA*2&%!,%!$,/".9!-,."A*%&*(!.;&!;.4)!".!N%;2",46!

2'4&'0,46!*2;.;-"26!1;4"&"2,46!%1"0"&',46!-*.&,46!*-;&";.,46!1$)%"2,46!,.(!4".9'"%&"2!

:,)%O!3'.1,9".,&*(7!@'&!,4%;!".!$,/".9!,AA*2&*(!&$*!A,@0"2!;A!-*-;0)!"&%*4A!:"&$".!

9*.*0,&";.%!;A!A,-"4"*%!,.(!2'4&'0*%!:$;!$,/*!&0,'-,!&;;!90*,&!&;!0*-*-@*0!24*,04)!

;0!%1*,5!,@;'&=!#$*0*A;0*6!&$*!*+&*.&!&;!:$"2$!Q*%"(*.&",4!H2$;;4%!$,/*!(*/,%&,&*(!

2'4&'0*%!0*-,".%!'.L',.&"A",@4*=!

#$*!4*9,2)!;A!&$*%*!%2$;;4%6!,4;.9!:"&$!,2'&*!%)%&*-"2!0,2"%-!,.(!1;/*0&)6!

2;.&".'*%!&;!20*,&*!-)0",(!@,00"*0%!A;0!D@;0"9".,4!S,.,(",.%B!,22*%%!&;!L',4"&)!

1'@4"2!*('2,&";.=!>.!;0(*0!&;!,((0*%%!%;-*!;A!&$*%*!@,00"*0%6!&$*!?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!

F;,0(!,.(!4;2,4!D@;0"9".,4!4*,(*0%!(0,A&*(!&$*!</&.)9)*#6(R*"#*+,2,*$(<9.,,2,*$(

)*(NZZ['(6!#$"%!D90**-*.&!"./;4/*(!&$*!(*/*4;1-*.&!;A!&$*!D@;0"9".,4!R.$,.2*-*.&!

b;05*0!3DRb7!1;%"&";.=!#$*!DRb!1;%"&";.!:,%!&;!,%%"%&!".!D@;0"9".,4!%&'(*.&%!@*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

&*,2$".9%!;A!%;-*!;A!;'0!R4(*0%!('*!&;!&$*!"-1;%"&";.!;A!S$0"%&",.!/,4'*%!"-1;%*(!;.!

&$*-!".!&$*!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%=!#$*%*!%*.&"-*.&%!;A&*.!0*-,".!'.2$,44*.9*(!:$*.!

%1;5*.!@)!,.!R4(*06!('*!&;!&$*!0*%1*2&!&$*)!$,/*!".!&$*!2;--'."&)O!3UY[7=!

Page 86: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

iZ!

!

,@4*!&;!*+1*0"*.2*!,!%*.%*!;A!@*4;.9".96!,!2'4&'0*6!,.(!,!2;--'."&)!".!4;2,4!%2$;;4%!

3</&.)9)*#6(R%7+#$)&*(R*"#*+,2,*$(<9.,,2,*$7=!#$*!M;@!,2&"/"&"*%!;A!&$*!DRb!

".24'(*%!&$*!A;44;:".9X!!

G0;/"(*%!2;'.%*4".9!,.(!,2&"/"&)!14,..".9!&;!,%%"%&!%&'(*.&%!0*L'"0".9!

(*/*4;1-*.&,46!@*$,/";'0,4!,.(<;0!-'4&"2'4&'0,4!%'11;0&=!b;05!".24'(*%!

10;-;&".9!,.(!".&*010*&".9!4,.9',9*%!,.(!2'4&'0*%6!4"A*!%5"44%!(*/*4;1-*.&6!

2;'.%*4".9!".!;.*E&;E;.*6!90;'1!;0!A,-"4)!%*%%";.%6!,%%*%%".9!@*$,/";'0!,.(!

10;-;&".9!%*4AE"-,9*!,.(!10;/"(".9!%5"44%!&0,".".9=!h,2"4"&,&*%!

2;--'."2,&";.!@*&:**.!%2$;;46!$;-*6!2;--'."&)!,9*.2"*%!,.(!:"&$".!

%&'(*.&!90;'1%=!C;2'-*.&%!2,%*!.;&*%!,.(!-,".&,".%!A"4*%=!I,)!%'1*0/"%*!

%&'(*.&%!".!%2$;;4!0*4,&*(!,2&"/"&"*%=!3ND@;0"9".,4!R('2,&";.!R.$,.2*-*.&!

b;05*0EH2$;;4!C"%&0"2&!yfWO7!

C*%1"&*!$,/".9!24;%*!&;!]VV!%&'(*.&%6!H;'&$!H"(*!R4*-*.&,0)!H2$;;4!0*2*"/*(!

;.4)!,!A*:!$;'0%!;A!@":**54)!%'11;0&!A0;-!,.!DRb6!I"2$*44*!R/*0*&&=!I"2$*44*B%!

'.(*0%&,.(".9!;A!.',.2*(!("AA*0*.2*%!@*&:**.!2'4&'0*%!10;/"(*(!"-1;0&,.&!

*+1*0&"%*6!1,0&"2'4,04)!".!0*%1;.%*!&;!C'.2,.B%!9*.(*0!,.+"*&"*%=!I"2$*44*!:,%!,@4*!

&;!10;/"(*!1,-1$4*&%!&;!C'.2,.B%!A,-"4)!;.!:,)%!;A!'.(*0%&,.(".9!&:;E%1"0"&!

2$"4(0*.6!;AA*0".9!&$*!A,-"4)!2'4&'0,44)!0*4*/,.&!%'11;0&!3%**!S$,1&*0!H"+7=!!

>.!NR('2,&;0%B!G*0%1*2&"/*%!,@;'&!,!G'@4"2!H2$;;4!C"%&0"2&B%!D@;0"9".,4!

R('2,&";.!R.$,.2*-*.&!D90**-*.&!".!F0"&"%$!S;4'-@",6O!8*/".!b$"&*!*&!,4=!*+,-".*!

&$*!"-14*-*.&,&";.!;A!&$*!DRRD!".!&$*!F'0.,@)!H2$;;4!C"%&0"2&!3,!("%&0"2&!,(M'.2&!&;!

?,.2;'/*07=!#$*!0*%*,02$!&*,-!,114,'(%!&$*!,90**-*.&!A;0!:;05".9!,9,".%&!

Page 87: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

iW!

!

S,.,(,B%!1,&*0.,4"%&"26!2;4;.",4!*('2,&";.,4!$"%&;0)=!#$*)!,4%;!%&0*%%!&$*!"-1;0&,.2*!

;A!&$*!10;M*2&!".!&$*!:,5*!;A!&$*!".&*09*.*0,&";.,4!(*/,%&,&";.!@0;'9$&!A;0:,0(!

A0;-!Q*%"(*.&",4!H2$;;4%=!C*%1"&*!b$"&*!*&!,4=B%!20"&"L'*%!;A!&$*!DRRD6!&$*)!2;.2*(*!

&$,&!N&$*!DRRD!"%!,44;:".9!D@;0"9".,4!%&'(*.&%!&;!A**4!90*,&*0!10"(*!".!&$*"0!2'4&'0,4!

$*0"&,9*!,.(!,!%&0;.9*0!%*.%*!;A!@*4;.9".9O!3]]7=!>.!&$"%!:,)6!&$*!DRRD!2,.!@*!

A0,-*(!,%!;.*!,-;.9!-,.)!.*2*%%,0)!,110;,2$*%!&;!'.:*,/".9!&$*!2;4;.",4"%-!

10*%*.&!&$0;'9$;'&!S,.,(",.!1'@4"2!*('2,&";.,4!%)%&*-%=YU!

b"&$".!-)!;:.!0*%*,02$6!&$*!&:;!%&'(*.&%!".!-)!24,%%0;;-!;A!%&'()!:$;!-*&!

:"&$!I"2$*44*!R/*0*&&6!@;&$!@*.*A"&&*(!A0;-!$,/".9!2'4&'0,44)!0*4*/,.&!-;-*.&%!".!

&$*"0!*('2,&";.,4!*+1*0"*.2*%=!I"2$*44*!:,%!;.4)!,&!&$*!%2$;;4!*/*0)!;&$*0!:**5=!H$*!

:;05*(!:"&$!@;&$!C'.2,.!,.(!8"*0;.!A0;-!I,09,0*&!Q;/*44,B%!24,%%=!H;-*&"-*%!&$"%!

:;'4(!"./;4/*!A"A&**.E-".'&*!;.*E&;E;.*!%*%%";.%j!;&$*0!&"-*%!&$*)!:;'4(!@*!1,0&!;A!

%-,44!90;'1!,2&"/"&"*%!:"&$!D@;0"9".,4!%&'(*.&%!A0;-!;&$*0!24,%%*%!,&!&$*!%2$;;4=!

C*%1"&*!&$*!,@%'0(4)!@0"*A!&"-*6!$*0!%&'(*.&%!%1;5*!;A!$*0!A,/;'0,@4)!,.(6!,%!

("%2'%%*(!A'0&$*0!".!S$,1&*0!h"/*6!%$*!%**-*(!&;!$,/*!,!1;%"&"/*!"-1,2&!;.!8"*0;.B%!

*('2,&";.,4!*+1*0"*.2*%=!>.!,.!".&*0/"*:6!I,09,0*&!,4%;!0*A4*2&*(!A,/;'0,@4)!;.!

I"2$*44*B%!:;05!:"&$!&$*!%&'(*.&%!A0;-!$*0!24,%%!@'&!0*90*&&*(!&$,&!&$*0*!:,%!.;&!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

YU!C*%1"&*!&$*!0*%*,02$*0%B!1;%"&"/*!,%%*%%-*.&6!&$*)!:0"&*!&$,&!&$*!".&*.(*(!-;(*4!

;A!&$*!DRRD!:;05%!".!1,0&.*0%$"1!@*&:**.6!N&$*!".("/"(',4!%2$;;4!("%&0"2&!,.(!4;2,4!

D@;0"9".,4!2;--'."&"*%O!3[k7!".!;0(*0!&;!N(*/*4;1!9;,4%6!&,09*&%6!,.(!".("2,&;0%!;A!

%'22*%%O!3[k7=!T;:*/*06!&$*"0!%&'()!A;'.(!&$,&!&$*!N%'22*%%O!;A!,!10;90,-!:,%!;A&*.!

-*,%'0*(!,22;0(".9!&;!b*%&*0.!A0,-*:;05%6!%'2$!,%!90,(',&";.6!0,&$*0!&$,.!

>.("9*.;'%!@,%*(!$;4"%&"2!-;(*4%!A;0!,.!".("/"(',4B%!:*44E@*".9!;0!1,0&"2"1,&";.!".!

&$*"0!2;--'."&"*%=!!

!

Page 88: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

ZV!

!

-;0*!&"-*!,AA;0(*(!&;!$*0!10*%*.2*!,&!&$*!%2$;;46!,%!;.*!;A!$*0!0;4*%!:,%!&;!%1*,5!&;!

("AA*0*.&!24,%%*%!,@;'&!D@;0"9".,4!2'4&'0*%=!I,09,0*&!:;'4(!$,/*!:*42;-*(!&$"%!

2;.&0"@'&";.!".!$*0!8".(*09,0&*.!24,%%0;;-!3Q;/*44,!Y<YV<YVUY7=!!

#$"%!%*2&";.!$,%!*+,-".*(!%;-*!;A!&$*!0;4*%!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!$,/*!14,)*(!".!

*.A;02".9!2;4;.",4!.;&";.%!;A!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)!".!S,.,(,=!H"&',&".9!&$*!

".&*0%*2&";.!;A!2;4;.",4"%-!,.(!S,.,(",.!%2$;;4".9!,%!&$*!A;'.(,&";.!A0;-!:$"2$!&;!

,.,4)J*!;&$*0!".%&"&'&";.,4!10,2&"2*%!0*9'4,&".9!9*.(*0!,.(!*('2,&";.!,/;"(%!

2;.%&0'2&".9!"(*,4"J*(!$"%&;0"*%!;A!$;:!%2$;;4%!".!S,.,(,!$,/*!:;05*(6!&$'%!

*.,@4".9!,.,4)%*%!;A!$;:(10*%*.&!%;2",4!"%%'*%!$,/*!-,."A*%&*(=!>.!;0(*0!&;!10;/"(*!

,!90*,&*0!%*.%*!;A!&$*!2;-14*+!0;4*%!;A!9*.(*0!".!&$*!S,.,(",.!*('2,&";.,4!%)%&*-6!

&$*!A;44;:".9!%*2&";.!"./*%&"9,&*%!2'00*.&!,.(!$"%&;0"2,4!9*.(*0*(!10,2&"2*%!:"&$".!

-,".%&0*,-!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!!

;D@<B<cAE<?B$?_$/YHZAE<?B$$

>.!,.!".&*0/"*:6!I,09,0*&!("%2'%%*(!$;:6!('0".9!$*0!&*,2$*0!&0,".".9!

10;90,-!A0;-!YVVVEYVVU6!%$*!*+1*0"*.2*(!,!1*(,9;9"2,4!*-1$,%"%!;.!".%&"44".9!".!

%&'(*.&%!,!%*.%*!&$,&!N9"04%!2,.!(;!,.)&$".9cO!3Q;/*44,!U]!I,)!YVUY7=!H$*!(*%20"@*(!

$,/".9!:"&.*%%*(!,!%$"A&!".!$*0!*4*/*.!)*,0%!;A!&*,2$".9!&;!:$,&!%$*!(*%20"@*(!,%6!N,!

0,44)".9!A;0!oC;.B&!A;09*&!,@;'&!&$*!@;)%BO!3)/)%7=!>!("(!.;&!A".(!&$"%!%'010"%".9=!D%!,!

?HF!*-14;)**6!>!:;'4(!0;'&".*4)!$*,0!9*.(*0!("%2'%%*(!".!%&,AA!0;;-%6!".!:$"2$!&$*!

2'00*.&!%"&',&";.!;A!@;)%!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!:,%!&$*!%'@M*2&!;A!-'2$!2;.2*0.=!#$*%*!

&,45%!;A&*.!@4,-*(!A*-"."%-!A;0!$,/".9!9;.*!&;;!A,0!".!%**5".9!".%&"&'&";.,4!2$,.9*!

,.(!&$'%!("%20"-".,&".9!,9,".%&!@;)%!,%!,!0*%'4&=!!

Page 89: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

ZU!

!

>.!F&=3(#*%(E).63(D,#.*(T)--,.,*$6=\(<(E7)%,(-&.(A#.,*$3(#*%(0,#+",.36!1;1'4,0!

,'&$;0!I"2$,*4!^'0",.!*+10*%%*%!2;.2*0.!&$,&!WVr!;A!8".(*09,0&*.!&;!^0,(*!H"+!

&*,2$*0%!".!&$*!d."&*(!H&,&*%!,0*!:;-*.!,.(!24,"-%!&$,&!&$"%!20*,&*%!,.!

*./"0;.-*.&!".!:$"2$6!N&$*!A*-,4*!@0,".B%!4*,0.".9!,.(!&*,2$".9!%&)4*%!(;-".,&*%6!

,.(!-;0*!@;)%!,0*!4*A&!;'&O!3kk7=!T*!,(/;2,&*%!A;0!,44!&*,2$*0%!N9*&&".9!&0,".*(!".!

-,4*!@";4;9)!,.(!-,4*!2'4&'0*O!3kk7=!S0"&"2,4!%2$;4,0%!3S,/,.,9$!YVV]!p!YVVi6!C*$4"6!

h0,.5!*&!,4=6!^'"4(A;0(6!^0*"96!8*$4*06!8"--*46!a4*:*44).6!I,0&".;7!:$;!*+,-".*!

"%%'*%!;A!-,%2'4"."&)6!*('2,&";.6!,.(!%2$;;4%!$,/*!20"&"L'*(!&$*!A*-"."J,&";.!;A!

*('2,&";.!("%2;'0%*!A;0!A,"4".9!&;!0*2;9."J*!1'@4"2!*('2,&";.B%!".%&"&'&";.,4!$"%&;0)=!

#$*%*!%2$;4,0%!20"&"L'*!&$*!N1;;0!@;)%O!3R1%&*".!*&!,4=7!("%2;'0%*!A;0!1*01*&',&".9!

&$*!*L',&";.!;A!-,%2'4"."&)!:"&$!/";4*.2*!,.(!&0*,&".9!@;)%!,%!,!-;.;4"&$"2!90;'1!

:"&$!,!'."/*0%,4"J*(!-,%2'4"."&)=!!

>.!NI,4*!#*,2$*0%!,%!Q;4*!I;(*4%X!D((0*%%".9!>%%'*%!;A!I,%2'4"."&)6!

G*(,9;9)!,.(!&$*!Q*EI,%2'4"."J,&";.!;A!H2$;;4".96O!b,).*!`;$.!I,0&".;!;@%*0/*%!

&$,&!0*2*.&!,.+"*&)!;/*0!&$*!A*-"."J,&";.!;A!*('2,&";.!4,@*4%!@;)%!,%!N&$*!.*:!

("%,(/,.&,9*(O!3UWY7!,%!%2$;;4%!,0*!2;.%"(*0*(!N(;-".,&*(O!@)!:;-*.=!T*!%&,&*%!

&$,&!&$"%!"9.;0*%!$"%&;0"2,4!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*%!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!".!:$"2$!:;-*.!:*0*!

&$;'9$&!&;!@*!*#$7.#6!2,0*9"/*0%!;A!);'.9*0!2$"4(0*.!,.(!&$*0*A;0*!.;&!0*L'"0".9!

:,9*%!;.!1,0!:"&$!&$;%*!;A!&$*!3-'2$!-;0*!A0*L'*.&4)7!-,4*!$"9$!%2$;;4!&*,2$*0%=!

T*!@*9".%!@)!%&,&".9!&$,&!A,0!A0;-!&$*!A*-"."J,&";.!;A!*('2,&";.!@*".9!,!.*:!

2;.2*0.6!"&!$,%!N".&*.%"A"*(!,&!2*0&,".!$"%&;0"2,4!M'.2&'0*%!%".2*!&$*!-"(EUZVV%6O!

3UWV7!;A&*.!@,%*(!;.!1*0";(%!;A!$"9$!2'4&'0,4!N2;.2*0.%!,@;'&!A*-"."J,&";.!,.(!"&%!

Page 90: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

ZY!

!

1;&*.&",4!&;!2;.&,-".,&*!-*.B%!,.(!@;)%B!-,%2'4"."&)O!3UWV7=!I,0&".;!;@%*0/*%!&$,&!

2;--;.!("%2;'0%*!,@;'&!&$*!:,)%!@;)%!,0*!.;&!%*0/*(!@)!*('2,&";.!:"44!,%%*0&!&$,&!

N%2$;;4%!,0*!.;&!o@;)!A0"*.(4)B!,.(!A,/;0!9"04%!;0!A*-,4*!:,)%!;A!5.;:".9O!3YVZ7!('*!

&;!N&$*!%*.%*!&$,&!%2$;;4%!*.A;02*!1,%%"/*!4*,0.".9!,.(6!,%!,!2;.%*L'*.2*6!&*.(!&;!

,22;--;(,&*!9"04%B!0,&$*0!&$,.!@;)%B!4*,0.".9!.**(%O!3YVZ7=!!>&!"%!".&*0*%&".9!&$,&!&$*!

10;@4*-%!A,2".9!@;)%!".!*('2,&";.!,0*!;A&*.!4".5*(!&;!&$*!*+1*2&,&";.!&$,&!&$*)!%"&!

L'"*&4)!".!24,%%6!4"%&*.!&;!&$*!&*,2$*06!,.(!:;05!".!&*+&@;;5%=!T;:*/*06!.;.*!;A!&$*%*!

*+1*2&,&";.%!,0*!0*2*.&=!!!

>.!R.94"%$!S,.,(,6!&$"%!("%2"14".,0)!-;(*!;A!*('2,&";.!(,&*%!@,25!&;!&$*!

A;'.(".9!;A!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!#$*!@*4"*A!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!0*L'"0*(!*('2,&";.!".!;0(*0!&;!

(*/*4;1!%;'.(!-;0,4!4"/*%!:,%!1,0&!;A!".%&"&'&".9!0*9"-*.&*(!*('2,&";.,4!10,2&"2*%!

3C*$4"6!^'"4(A;0(6!T'-*6!I2S'44;'9$7=!#$,&!9"04%!;A&*.!2;-14)!:"&$!%)%&*-"2!

*+1*2&,&";.%!(;*%!.;&!10"/"4*9*!;0!.*2*%%,0"4)!%*0/*!&$*-=!I,.)!9"04%6!('*!&;!-)0",(!

A,2&;0%6!-,)!@*!,@4*!&;!,($*0*!&;!,!4*,0.".9!*./"0;.-*.&!&$,&!10;-;&*%!1,%%"/*!

4*,0.".9=!T;:*/*06!24,"-".9!&$,&!&$"%!2,&*0%!&;6!;0!"%!10;('2&"/*!A;0!&$*-6!0*".A;02*%!

9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!&$,&!0*:,0(%!A*-,4*!1,%%"/"&)=!I,0&".;!A'0&$*0!,09'*%!&$,&!@;)%!,0*!

(**-*(!-;0*!4"5*4)!&;!,2&!;'&!,.(!0*2*"/*!.*9,&"/*!,&&*.&";.!&$,.!2;.A;0-!&;!

*+1*2&,&";.=!H'2$!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*!(;*%!.;&!%*0/*!&$*%*!@;)%!:*44!*"&$*0=!!

>A!"%%'*%!A,2".9!@;)%!,0*!(*A".*(!,%!0*2*.&6!&$*0*!"%!,!&*-1&,&";.!&;!"(*,4"J*!,!

1,%&!&$,&!:,%!4*%%!10;@4*-,&"26!@'&!4*%%!10;@4*-,&"2!A;0!:$;-!,.(!,&!:$,&!2;%&e!>.!

F&=3(<%.)-$;(0",(1)W,(1#+$&.3(T.)W)*9($",(RJ)%,2)+(&-(8*2&$)W#$,%(F&=3(#*%(

8*%,.#+"),W)*9(U&7*9(C,*6!-,".%&0*,-!:0"&*0!a*;.,0(!H,+!%'99*%&%!&$,&!

Page 91: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Zf!

!

2;.&*-1;0,0)!P;0&$!D-*0"2,.!%;2"*&)!4;;5%!&;!N*.('0".9!2'4&'0*%O!3UkZEUkW7!A;0!

&$*!:,)!&$*)!1,%%!9*.(*0!0;4*%!;.&;!&$*"0!);'.9=!T*!2;--*.(%!2'4&'0*%!&$,&!(*A".*!

-,.$;;(!,%!,!%*0"*%!;A!&*%&%!,.(!&$,&!&*44!%&;0"*%!&$,&!%'11;0&!&$"%!%)-@;4;9)=!T*!

%&,&*%6!NvKw'0!2'4&'0*!'%*(!&;!&*44!%'2$!%&;0"*%!,%!:*44=!b*!.;!4;.9*0!(;O!3Ui[7=!KA!

2;'0%*!&$*%*!%&;0"*%!:*0*!.;&!*+1*0"*.2*(!:*44!@)!-,.)!9"04%6!&0,.%9*.(*0!1*;14*6!

1*;14*!:"&$!("%,@"4"&"*%6!,.(!;&$*0%!:$;!2;'4(!.;&!,2$"*/*!(*%"0*(!%&,&'%=!b$*.!

S,.,(",.!2'4&'0*!&,5*%!'1!,(/;2,&".9!N;'0O!2'4&'0,4!1,%&6!"&!"9.;0*%!2'4&'0*%!;A!

("%20"-".,&";.!".!:$"2$!&$*%*!%&;0"*%!&;;5!14,2*=!P;&!&$*!4*,%&!;A!&$*%*!,0*!

*('2,&";.,4!%&0'2&'0*%!&$,&!("%*.A0,.2$"%*(!%;-*!90;'1%!3`,1,.*%*!S,.,(",.%6!

D@;0"9".,4!1*;14*6!1*;14*!:"&$!("%,@"4"&"*%7!:$"4*!*.&0*.2$".9!&$*!24,%%!%&0'2&'0*%!

,-;.9%&!:$"&*6!,@4*E@;("*(!S,.,(",.%!3^4*,%;.!,.(!F,0-,.7=!!>.!N#$*!b,0!D9,".%&!

F;)%eO!I"2$,*4!8"--*4!0*-".(%!&$*!0*,(*0!&$,&X!

#$;'9$!&$*!2'00*.&!@;)!,(/;2,&*%!24,"-!&$,&!%2$;;4%!'%*(!&;!@*!-;0*!q@;)!

A0"*.(4)q!@*A;0*!,44!&$*%*!qA*-"."%&q!0*A;0-%6!&$*)!;@/";'%4)!("(.l&!9;!&;!

%2$;;4!".!&$;%*!$,42);.!(,)%6!&$*!UW]V%6!%,)6!:$*.!&$*!24,%%0;;-!:,%!A,0!

-;0*!0*9"-*.&*(6!2;01;0,4!1'."%$-*.&!2;--;.6!,.(!&*,2$*0%!A,0!-;0*!

,'&$;0"&,0",.j!&$*)!*/*.!9,/*!90,(*%!A;0!q(*1;0&-*.&=q!Q,-@'.2&";'%!@;)%!

:*0*!%"-14)!.;&!&;4*0,&*(j!&$*)!(0;11*(!;'&=!^*.(*0!%&*0*;&)1".9!$'0&%!@;&$!

@;)%!,.(!9"04%=!>A!&$*0*!"%!,!J*0;E%'-!9,-*6!"&l%!.;&!@*2,'%*!;A!%;-*!1'&,&"/*!

A*-"."J,&";.!;A!&$*!24,%%0;;-!3kk7=!

S4*,04)6!*('2,&";.!".!S,.,(,!$,%!.*/*0!%*0/*(!*/*0);.*!:*44=!#$*0*!"%!.;&!,!

$"%&;0)!;A!A,2"4"&,&".9!0;;-!A;0!@;)%!:$;!,0*!%&0'994".9!,9,".%&!.;0-%!;A!

Page 92: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Z[!

!

-,%2'4"."&)6!,%!&;;5!14,2*!".!-)!A"*4(:;05=!P*"&$*0!$,%!&$*0*!@**.!0;;-!A;0!9"04%!

:$;!,0*!%&0'994".9!,9,".%&!.;0-%!;A!A*-"."."&)=!>A!&$*0*!,0*!&;!@*!4*,0.".9!

*./"0;.-*.&%!2;.('2"/*!&;!,!:"(*!0,.9*!;A!%&'(*.&%6!".24'(".9!,44!@;)%6!&$"%!:"44!@*!

@0;'9$&!,@;'&!@)!4;;5".9!&;:,0(!*('2,&"/*!2$,.9*6!0,&$*0!&$,.!"(*,4"J".9!,!A"2&"/*!

1,%&=!!!!

`,.*&!^'"4(A;0(!,09'*%!$;:6!,4&$;'9$!:;-*.!$,/*!;22'1"*(!-;0*!;A!&$*!

&*,2$".9!1;%"&";.%6!-*.!:*0*!%&"44!,2&"/*4)!0*20'"&*(!,.(!&$*!A"0%&!10;-;&*(=!b$"4*!

-,.)!:;0514,2*%!$,/*!,.!,@'.(,.2*!;A!A*-,4*!%*20*&,0"*%6!&$*)!(;!.;&!(;-".,&*!,!

:;0514,2*!".!1;%"&";.%!;A!1;:*0!,.(!2;.&0;4=!#$*!0*10*%*.&,&";.!;A!A*-,4*!&*,2$*0%!

".!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4!"%!%"-"4,04)!2;-14"2,&*(=!^'"4(A;0(!(*%20"@*%!$;:!&$*!N1'@4"2!

%2$;;4!%)%&*-!:,%!20*,&*(!@)!-,4*!1;4"&"2",.%6!,(-"."%&*0*(!,.(!%'1*0/"%*(!@)!

-,4*!*('2,&";.!;AA"2*0%6!,.(!"&%!%*.";0!&*,2$".9!1;%"&";.%!:*0*!0*&,".*(!A;0!-,4*!

&*,2$*0%O!3k[7=!>.!A,2&6!@*A;0*!&$*!S;4(!b,06!A*-,4*!&*,2$*0%!:*0*!0*L'"0*(!@)!4,:!&;!

@*!%".94*=!#$"%!:,%!&;!N,/;"(!2;.A4"2&%!".!&$*"0!10"-,0)!,44*9",.2*%O!3F4;'.&!U]7!,%!

&$*"0!,44*9",.2*!&;!&$*!-,4*!,(-"."%&0,&";.!:,%!&$;'9$&!&;!@*!".!2;.A4"2&!:"&$!

(*A*0*.2*!&$*)!:;'4(!.**(!&;!%$;:!&$*"0!$'%@,.(%6!'1;.!-,00",9*=!H'2$!2;.&*+&!

(;*%!0*L'"0*!0*&$".5".9!2;.A4,&";.%!@*&:**.!&$*!.'-@*0!;A!A*-,4*!&*,2$*0%!,.(!,!

A*-,4*!N(;-".,.&O!:;0514,2*=!!

I,0&".;!20"&"L'*%!4"&*0,&'0*!;.!&$*!A*-"."J,&";.!;A!*('2,&";.!A;0!"&%!A,"4'0*!&;!

*+,-".*!A*-,4*!&*,2$*0%B!*+1*0"*.2*%!".!&$*!:;0514,2*!,.(!A;0!'.20"&"2,44)!

0*14"2,&".9!%*+"%&!0*,%;.%!:$)!A*-,4*!&*,2$*0%!,0*!.;&!,%!9;;(!A;0!@;)!%&'(*.&%6!

%'2$!,%!,%%'-1&";.%!&$,&!N-,4*!&*,2$*0%!,0*!@*&&*0!,&!("%2"14".".9!@;)%O!@*2,'%*!

Page 93: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Z]!

!

N@;)%!,22*1&!-,4*!,'&$;0"&)!@*&&*0!&$,.!A*-,4*!,'&$;0"&)O!3YUY7=!b$"2$!5".(%!;A!

:;-*.!:*0*!&$;'9$&!&;!@*!,22*1&,@4*!&*,2$*0%!$,%!2$,.9*(!;/*0!&$*!2;'0%*!;A!

S,.,(",.!$"%&;0)6!:$"4*!2;.&".'".9!&;!A,44!,4;.9!$*&*0;.;0-,&"/*!4".*%=!h;0!*+,-14*6!

:$"4*!".!&$*!.".*&**.&$!,.(!*,04"*0!&:*.&"*&$!2*.&'0"*%6!A*-,4*!&*,2$*0%!:*0*!A;02*(!

&;!0*&"0*!"A!&$*)!-,00"*(6!&$*!4,:!&$*.!2$,.9*(!".!;0(*0!&;!*.%'0*!&$,&!A*-,4*!

&*,2$*0%!:*0*!-,00"*(!".&;!$*&*0;%*+',4!0*4,&";.%$"1%!3S,/,.,9$!YVV]!p!YVVi6!

^'"4(A;0(6!a4*:*44).7=!!

H$*"4,!S,/,.,9$!(*%20"@*%!$;:!2'4&'0,4!-;0*%!('0".9!&$*!S;4(!b,0!2$,.9*(!

&$*!4,:!&$,&!-,.(,&*(!A*-,4*!&*,2$*0%!0*-,".!%".94*=!b$*.!&$*!4,:!2$,.9*(6!%".94*!

A*-,4*!&*,2$*0%!@*9,.!&;!@*!/"*:*(!:"&$!%'%1"2";.=!#$"%!%$"A&!:,%!@,%*(!;.!,!A*,0!;A!

$;-;%*+',4"&)!".!%;-*!".%&,.2*%!,.(!,!@*4"*A!&$,&!%".94*!A*-,4*!&*,2$*0%!:*0*!4"5*4)!

&;!@*2;-*!,&&0,2&*(!&;!;4(*0!-,4*!%&'(*.&%!".!;&$*0!".%&,.2*%=!>&!:,%!&$;'9$&!&$,&!

&$*!4,&&*0!:;'4(!A,"4!&;!("%2"14".*!-,4*!%&'(*.&%!,110;10",&*4)!3;0!*.M;)!%,"(!

("%2"14".*!".,110;10",&*4)7=!S,/,.,9$!:0"&*%6!N>.!*('2,&";.,4!$"%&;0";90,1$)6!A*-,4*!

&*,2$*0E("%2"14".,0",.%!,0*!&$;'9$&!&;!@*!@*9'"4*(!,.(!*.2$,.&*(!@)!&$*!

("%;@*("*.&6!;4(*0!@;)O!3YVVi6!UfW7=!!!

I;0*;/*06!>!,((6!&$*!,%%'-1&";.!&$,&!A*-,4*!&*,2$*0%!:"44!,'&;-,&"2,44)!

A,/;'0!A*-,4*!%&'(*.&%!(;*%!.;&!,22;'.&!A;0!:,)%!&$,&!(;-".,.&!2'4&'0*!&0,".%!

*/*0);.*!".!%*+"%&!.;0-%!,.(!&$,&!:;-*.6!*/*0)!@"&!,%!-'2$!,%!-*.6!,0*!2,1,@4*!;A!

0*20*,&".9!9*.(*0!.;0-%!&$,&!1*01*&',&*!-,4*!1;:*0!,.(!10"/"4*9*=!b$"4*!("AA*0".9!

0;4*!-;(*4%!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!-,)!$,/*!,!0,.9*!;A!@*.*A"&%!&;!("AA*0*.&!%&'(*.&%6!

Page 94: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Zk!

!

I,09,0*&!:,%!,@4*!&;!$*41!A,2"4"&,&*!&;;4%!A;0!2$"4(0*.!.,/"9,&".9!&$*"0!%;2",4!

*./"0;.-*.&%!@,%*(!;.!"&!!%$*!&,'9$&6!0,&$*0!&$,.!$*0!9*.(*0=!

T*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!&$,&!%&0'2&'0*!:;0514,2*!".*L'"&)!A;0!A*-,4*!&*,2$*0%6!

$,/*!,4%;!1;%"&";.*(!-,4*%!:;05".9!".!2$"4(2,0*!,.(!*,04)!*4*-*.&,0)!*('2,&";.!,%!

%'%1*2&=!H'%,.!I'00,)!,.,4)%*%!$;:!&$*!2;.A4,&";.!;A!.;.E2;./*.&";.,4!9*.(*0!

0;4*%!:"&$!$;-;%*+',4"&)6!&$*!;/*0E%*+',4"J,&";.!;A!9,)!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%6!,.(!&$*!

("%1,0,9*-*.&!;A!L',4"&"*%!3;0!:;057!,%%;2",&*(!:"&$!A*-,4*.*%%6!,44!:;05!&;9*&$*0!

&;!0*9'4,&*!-,4*!2$"4(2,0*!:;05*0%=!H$*!:0"&*%X!

b$*.!9*.(*0!9*&%!2;.A4,&*(!:"&$!%*+',4"&)6!&$*.!,2&";.%!&,5*!;.!,!

$*&*0;%*+"%&!A4,/;0!,%!:*44!,%!,!%*+"%&!;.*u!I*.l%!,2&";.%!@*2;-*!%'%1*2&!

@*2,'%*!&$*)!,0*!2$;;%".9!&;!(;!%;-*&$".9!&$,&!:;-*.!(;u!^,)!"%!,!

%*+',4"J*(!"(*.&"&)u=b"&$".!&$*!2$"4(2,0*!%*&&".96!,.)&$".9!$,/".9!&;!(;!:"&$!

,('4&!%*+',4"&)!"%!%&0"2&4)!;AAE4"-"&%=!H;6!:$*.!,!1*0%;.l%!"(*.&"&)!,%!,!9,)!

1*0%;.!"%!("%2;/*0*(!;0!*/*.!%'%1*2&*(!3,%!-,)@*!&$*!2,%*!:"&$!%&0,"9$&!-*.!

(;".9!q:;-*.l%!:;05q76!&$,&!1*0%;.l%!2;-1*&*.2*!,%!,!&*,2$*0<2,0*9"/*0!

9*&%!2,44*(!".&;!L'*%&";.!3fZU7=!!

#$*!,@;/*!L';&*!"44'%&0,&*%!&$*!2;-14"2,&*(!.,&'0*!;A!9*.(*0!,.(!A*-"."."&)!".!&$*!

0*,4-!;A!*,04)!2$"4($;;(!*('2,&";.=!S4,"-%!&$,&!:;-*.!N(;-".,&*O!,!A"*4(6!-'%&!@*!

'.(*0%&;;(!".!2;.M'.2&";.!:"&$!&$*!'.(*0/,4'".9!;A!:$,&!"%!(**-*(!&;!@*!N:;-*.B%!

:;05O!,.(!:,)%!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)!,0*!2;.A4,&*(!,.(!%'@%*L'*.&4)!1;4"2*(=!!

I,0&".;!,4%;!2;-14"2,&*%!&$*!.;&";.!;A!-,4*!0;4*!-;(*4%6!,%!"&!;A&*.!,%%'-*%!

&$,&!-*.B%!"(*.&"&"*%!,44!A,44!,4;.9!.;0-,&"/*!4".*%=!T*!:0"&*%!&$,&!-*.!,.(!@;)%!".!

Page 95: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Zi!

!

%2$;;4%!,0*!1;%"&*(!N,%!/"2&"-%!;A!A*-"."J,&";.6!,.(6!,%!,!2;.%*L'*.2*6!10;.*!&;!

*-,%2'4,&";.O!3YV[7=!T;:*/*06!$*!2,'&";.%!&$,&!&$"%!,.+"*&)!;/*0!&$*!%$;0&,9*!;A!

-,4*!&*,2$*0%!2,.!0*%'4&!".!,!N10;M*2&!;A!0*E-,%2'4"."J,&";.!&$,&!,-;'.&%!&;!"./;5".9!

&$*!b$"&*!,('4&!-,4*!$*&*0;%*+',4!%'@M*2&!,%!&$*!"(*,4"J*(!0;4*!-;(*4!2,1,@4*!;A!

,-*4";0,&".9!&$*!%;2",4!"44%!".A4"2&".9!@;)%B!%;2",4!,.(!,2,(*-"2!:*44E@*".9!".!

%2$;;4%=O!3YV[7=!#$'%!&$*!2,44!&;!$,/*!N-,4*!0;4*!-;(*4%O!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%6!:$*.!

*.9,9*(!'.20"&"2,44)6!2,.!0*14"2,&*!&$*!,%%'-1&";.%!&$,&!@;)%!.**(!-,%2'4".*!-*.!

:$;!-;(*4!&$*!.;0-%!;A!(;-".,.&6!:$"&*6!,@4*E@;("*(!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!

-,%2'4"."&)=!!

>A!"%%'*%!;A!("/*0%*!0;4*!-;(*4%!".!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4!&*,2$".9!:*0*!&;!@*!

&,5*.!%*0";'%4)6!&$*.!&$*0*!:;'4(!.**(!&;!@*!N-,%2'4".*O!:;-*.!0;4*!-;(*4".9!

N-,%2'4"."&)6O!NA*-".".*!-*.O!0;4*!-;(*4".9!NA*-"."."&)6O!,%!:*44!,%!,!0,.9*!;A!;&$*0!

9*.(*0!/,0",.&!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%1*2&0'-!1*;14*!;A!,44!*&$."2!@,2590;'.(%=!#;!

20"&"2,44)!*.9,9*!0;4*!-;(*4!("%2;'0%*6!:"&$;'&!0*14"2,&".9!(;-".,.&!%;2",4!1;:*0!

%&0'2&'0*%6!:;'4(!,4%;!0*L'"0*!2'4&'0,4!2;.2*0.!"A!,44!&*,2$*0%!2,-*!A0;-!:*44E;AA!

24,%%!@0,25*&%!,.(!.;!;.*!-;(*4*(!:;05".9E24,%%!@,2590;'.(%!".!,!1;%"&"/*!:,)6!

M'%&!,%!"&!:;'4(!.**(!&;!@*!2;.%"(*0*(!,!10;@4*-!"A!,44!&*,2$*0%!:*0*!,@4*E@;("*(6!

,.(!%;!;.=!!

b"&$".!("%2'%%";.%!;A!9*.(*0!10"/"4*9*!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%6!"&!"%!,4%;!"-1;0&,.&!

.;&!&;!(*1"2&!%&'(*.&%!,%!,!-;.;4"&$"2!90;'1=!F4)*!h0,.5!*&!,4=!:0"&*!&$,&!%**".9!

N@;)%!,%!,!2;$*%"/*!90;'1!*.,@4*%!,!1,0&"2'4,0!0*,(".9!&$,&!$"9$4"9$&%!".M'%&"2*%!

,%%'-*(!&;!"-1,2&!;.!#66(@;)%6!:"&$;'&!,25.;:4*(9".9!&$*!10"/"4*9*(!*4*-*.&%!;A!

Page 96: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

ZZ!

!

-,%2'4"."&"*%!&$,&!,(/,.&,9*!3&2,(@;)%!;/*0!;&$*0!@;)%!,.(!;/*0!%;-*!9"04%O!3h0,.5!

*&!,4=!UYV7=!I,4*!&*,2$*0%!(;!.;&!%$,0*!,!'."/*0%,4!2'4&'0*!&$,&!"%!*L',44)!10"/"4*9*(!

,.(!("%,(/,.&,9*(6!,.(!.*"&$*0!(;!-,4*!%&'(*.&%=!

>&!"%!,4%;!"-1;0&,.&!.;&!&;!;/*0E%"-14"A)!:$,&!"&!-*,.%!&;!@*!,(/,.&,9*(!

:"&$".!,!4*,0.".9!*./"0;.-*.&=!b$*.!("%2'%%".9!$;:!%2$;;4%!(;!.;&!%*0/*!@;)%6!H,+!

,%%*0&%!&$,&6!N^"04%!,0*!-;0*!4"5*4)!&;!,%%*%%!&$*"0!:;05!,%!&$*"0!&*,2$*0%!(;=!F;)%!,0*!

4*%%!4"5*4)!&;!2,0*!:$,&!&$*!&*,2$*0!&$".5%!;A!&$*"0!:;05=!#$,&!("/*09*.2*!4*,(%!&;!,.!

*.('0".9!1,0,(;+X!,&!*/*0)!,9*6!9"04%!(;!@*&&*0!".!%2$;;46!@'&!,0*!4*%%!%,&"%A"*(!:"&$!

&$*"0!,2$"*/*-*.&%6!2;-1,0*(!:"&$!&$*!@;)%O!3Yi7=YY!>!("(!%**!%;-*!;A!&$*%*!&0*.(%!

14,)!;'&!('0".9!-)!*-14;)-*.&!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!I,.)!9"04%!:$;!:*0*!&;1!%&'(*.&%!

:*0*!:;05".9!&;!14*,%*!&$*!&*,2$*0%!3-,4*!;0!A*-,4*76!:"&$!.;!2;.A"(*.2*!".!&$*"0!

;:.!5.;:4*(9*!;0!&$*"0!%5"44%!,%!4*,0.*0%=!I*,.:$"4*6!@;)%!".!&$*!%,-*!24,%%!;A&*.!

&;;5!.;!10"(*!".!&$*"0!:;056!:$"4*!1'&&".9!;.!,!2;.A"(*.&!(*-*,.;'0!:$*.!&,45".9!

,@;'&!:$,&!&$*)!5.*:!30*9,0(4*%%!;A!&$*!9*.(*0!;A!&$*!1*0%;.!&$*)!:*0*!&,45".9!&;7=!

>.!&*0-%!;A!A'&'0*!*-14;)-*.&6!%;2",46!,.(!4"A*!%5"44%6!>!(;!.;&!%**!*"&$*0!;A!&$*%*!

&0*.(%!%*0/".9!,.)!;A!&$*%*!%&'(*.&%!:*44=!!!!

>!:"%$!&;!&,5*!%*0";'%4)!&$*!2;.2*0.!A;0!@;)%!".!*('2,&";.=!T;:*/*06!&$"%!(;*%!

.;&!0*L'"0*!,@"(".9!@)!%*+"%&!.;0-%!&$,&!2,.!,4%;!-,5*!%2$;;4%!".$;%1"&,@4*!14,2*%!

A;0!9"04%j!.;0!(;*%!"&!0*L'"0*!,($*0".9!&;!,!("2$;&;-)!&$,&!,44!%&'(*.&%!:"44!@*!

2"%9*.(*06!;0!"(*.&"A)!:"&$".!,!9*.(*0!("2$;&;-)=!Q,&$*06!>!1;%"&!&$,&!9*.(*0!.;0-%!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

YY!H,+!(;*%!.;&!-*.&";.!&$*!9*.(*0!;A!&$*!&*,2$*06!$;:*/*0!$*!(;*%!'.20"&"2,44)!

,(/;2,&*!A;0!-,4*!0;4*!-;(*4%!A;0!@;)!%&'(*.&%!&$0;'9$;'&!$"%!("%2'%%";.!;A!1'@4"2!

%2$;;4%!

Page 97: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

ZW!

!

,.(!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!2,.!14,)!;'&!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!".!:,)%!&$,&!(;!.;&!%*0/*!2$"4(0*.!

;A!,.)!9*.(*0=!b$"4*!&$*!9*.(*0!.;0-%!-,)!,AA*2&!-,.)!@;)%!,.(!-,.)!9"04%!

("AA*0*.&4)6!"&!"%!.;&!&$,&!;.*!9*.(*0!"%!@*".9!"44!%*0/*(!:$"4*!&$*!;&$*0!"%!&$0"/".9=!

I)!0*%*,02$!(;*%!.;&!A;2'%!%;4*4)!;.!@;)%!;0!;.!9"04%6!;.!-,%2'4"."&)!;0!;.!

A*-"."."&)=!b$*.!*+,-".".9!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*6!>!A;2'%*(!".%&*,(!;.!&$*!:,)%!("AA*0*.&!

1*;14*!2,.!*+1*0"*.2*!%*+"%-6!2"%%*+"%-6!,.(!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!b"&$".!-)!

A;2'%!;.!9*.(*0!"%%'*%!,.(!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%6!>!2,44!".&;!L'*%&";.!&$*!-;0,4!1,."2!

0*9,0(".9!&$*!A*-"."J,&";.!;A!*('2,&";.!,.(!24,"-%!&$,&!@;)%6!0,&$*0!&$,.!9"04%6!,0*!

("%20"-".,&*(!,9,".%&!".!%2$;;4%=!R('2,&";.,4!%2$;4,0%!$,/*!20"&"L'*(!&$"%!0'@0"2!A;0!

0*4)".9!;.!$"%&;0"2,44)!'.%'@%&,.&",&*(!'.(*0%&,.(".9%!;A!9*.(*0!"%%'*%!".!1'@4"2!

%2$;;4%!&$,&!(;!.;&!".&*90,&*!,.!,.,4)%"%!;A!".%&"&'&";.,4!1;:*0!0*4,&";.%!3S,/,.,9$!

YVV]!p!YVVi6!C*$4"6!h0,.5!*&!,46!^'"4(A;0(6!^0*"96!8*$4*06!8"--*46!a4*:*44).6!

I,0&".;7=!I)!0*%*,02$!,((%!,.!,.,4)%"%!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!1*01*&',&*(!

@)!%,"(!,110;,2$*%!&;!9*.(*0!,.(!%2$;;4".9!,.(!,.,4)J*%!$;:!"&!A'0&$*0!.,&'0,4"J*%!

$;-;1$;@",6!$*&*0;%*+"%-6!,.(!2"%%*+"%-!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!!

:?BZ>HJ<?B$

T*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!$,%!@**.!".%&"&'&";.,44)!*.90,".*(!&$0;'9$;'&!

S,.,(,B%!1'@4"2!*('2,&";.,4!$"%&;0)=!Q*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%!:*0*!1,0&!;A!,!-'4&"E4,)*0*(!

9;/*0.-*.&!10;M*2&!&$,&!"./;4/*(!,110;10",&";.!;A!D@;0"9".,4!.,&";.%B!4,.(!,.(!

*0,%'0*!;A!D@;0"9".,4!1*;14*B%!2'4&'0*%=!D-;.9!;&$*0!A;0-%!;A!2'4&'0,4!(*%&0'2&";.6!

&$*!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4!10;M*2&!%;'9$&!&;!0*14,2*!&0,("&";.,4!0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!9*.(*0%!

,.(!%*+',4"&"*%!:"&$!(;-".,.&!b*%&*0.!-;(*4%=!>.%&"&'&".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!

Page 98: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

WV!

!

:*0*!&$'%!,.!*+14"2"&!1,0&!;A!0*%"(*.&",4!%2$;;4%!10,2&"2*%=!T*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!".!

2'00*.&!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!".!?,.2;'/*0!&,5*!14,2*!:"&$".!&$"%!4*9,2)=!S,.,(",.!

$"%&;0";90,1$)!(*-;.%&0,&*%!$;:6!&$0;'9$!-;."&;0".9!&*,2$*0%B!4"/*%6!1'@4"2!

%2$;;4%!,4%;!$,(!,.!,9*.(,!;A!".%&"44".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!,%!1,0&!;A!&$*!

*('2,&";.,4!9;,4%!A;0!%&'(*.&%=!F*".9!&$'%!".%&"&'&";.,44)!*.&0*.2$*(6!"&!"%!.;!:;.(*0!

&$,&!%'2$!.;0-%!,0*!.;:!;A&*.!0*.(*0*(!%;!-,&&*0!;A!2;'0%*!,%!&;!@*!-,(*!"./"%"@4*=!

T;:*/*06!'.(*0%&,.(".9!&$*!A;02"@4*!$"%&;0)!A0;-!:$"2$!&$*)!%&*-!2,.!,%%"%&!".!

0*2;.2*1&',4"J".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!,%!1,0&!;A!1'@4"2!*('2,&";.,4!

2;./*0%,&";.%!,@;'&!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)=!!

b$*.!;@%*0/".9!9*.(*0!().,-"2%!".!-)!A"*4(:;056!-)!,.,4)%"%!:,%!%"&',&*(!

".!&$*!$"%&;0"*%!0*2;'.&*(!".!&$"%!2$,1&*0X!&$,&!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!$,/*!.*/*0!%*0/*(!

*/*0);.*!:*446!&$,&!9*.(*0!().,-"2%!,11*,0".9!&;!A,/;'0!;.*!9*.(*0!-,)!*.A;02*!

2;-14"2,&*(!A;0-%!;A!1;:*0!,.(!10"/"4*9*6!&$,&!&*,2$*0%B!,2&";.%!$,/*!4;.9!@**.!

2'0&,"4*(!:"&$".!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%6!,.(!%;!;.=!h0;-!A;0-'4,&".9!-)!0*%*,02$!

L'*%&";.%!,.(!'.(*09;".9!*&$"2,4!0*/"*:!&;!9,&$*0".9!,.(!:0"&".9!,@;'&!(,&,_$;:!

9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!"%!%"&',&*(!:"&$".!-'4&"14*!%"&*%!;A!1;:*0!,.(!10"/"4*9*!:,%!".&*90,4!

&;!*/*0)!%&,9*!;A!&$*!0*%*,02$!10;2*%%=!#$*!A;44;:".9!2$,1&*0!10;/"(*%!,.!*+14"2,&";.!

;A!-)!0*%*,02$!-*&$;(%!,.(!:,)%!>!:,%!%"&',&*(!:"&$".!&$*!0*%'4&%!&$,&!"&!10;('2*(=!$

! !

Page 99: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

WU!

!

:CA=EDF$%CFDD,$5DEC?Y?>?I<DJ$

"BEF?YHZE<?B,$VF?P<BZ<A>$'ZE<P<J@$

>.!S,.,(,6!"%%'*%!%'00;'.(".9!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%&'(*.&%!".!1'@4"2!

%2$;;4%!,0*!&$*!%'@M*2&!;A!-'2$!(*@,&*6!,2&"/"%-6!,.(!10*%%=!D.!,0&"24*!,11*,0".9!".!

]$.#6!S,.,(,B%!4*,(".9!9,)!,.(!4*%@",.!.*:%1,1*06!("%2'%%*%!&$*!@"44!".!4"9$&!;A!,!

0*2*.&!10;/".2",4!,.&"E@'44)".9!2,-1,"9.!".!FS=!G0*-"*0!S$0"%&)!S4,05!"%!(*%20"@*(!,%!

@,45".9!,&!&$*!%'99*%&";.!&$,&!&$*!,.&"E@'44)".9!1;4"2)6!RQDHR!3R+1*2&!Q*%1*2&!,.(!D!

H,A*!R('2,&";.76!("0*2&4)!(*,4%!:"&$!$;-;1$;@",!:"&$!&$*!0,&";.,4*!&$,&!.;!;.*!

%$;'4(!@'44)!,.);.*!A;0!,.)!0*,%;.!3&$'%!*0,%".9!&$*!.**(!&;!&,45!,@;'&!%1*2"A"2!

%;2",4!"%%'*%7!3a*:"%7=!!

D2&"/"%&%!%'2$!,%!D.&$;.)!T;1*!,.(!a"%,!S,-1@*446!&*.(!&;!$;4(!,!("AA*0*.&!

'.(*0%&,.(".9!;A!$;:!&;!0*('2*!@'44)".9!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!,.(!$,/*!,%%*0&*(!&$,&!

%1*2"A"2!"%%'*%!-'%&!@*!.,-*(!,.(!("%2'%%*(!".!;0(*0!&;!10;-;&*!0*4*/,.&!:;05!A;0!

%;2",4!2$,.9*=!D2&"/"%&!2;.2*0.%!,0*!:*44!A;'.(*(=!H'00*)!H2$;;4!%&'(*.&!D.&$;.)!

T;1*!(*%20"@*%!$;:!*/*0)&$".9!$*!$*,0(!,@;'&!@*".9!9,)!".!%2$;;4%!:,%!.*9,&"/*!

,.(!&$,&!&$"%!2;.&0"@'&*(!&;!$"%!A*,0!;A!2;-".9!;'&=!DA&*0!,!A0"*.(!;A!$"%!:,%!9,)E

@,%$*(!,.(!%'@%*L'*.&4)!2;--"&&*(!%'"2"(*6!$*!@*9,.!$"%!:;05!&;!2$,.9*!1;4"2"*%!

:"&$".!&$*!H'00*)!H2$;;4!F;,0(!%1*2"A"2,44)!&;!,((0*%%!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!"%%'*%!&$,&!

,AA*2&!L'**0!%&'(*.&%!3Q*).;4(%7=!H"-"4,04)6!8,-4;;1%!%&'(*.&!a".(%,)!S,-1@*446!

&0,/*44*(!&;!%2$;;4%!,44!;/*0!$*0!("%&0"2&6!9"/".9!%1**2$*%!,.(!2;44*2&".9!iVV!

%"9.,&'0*%!".!%'11;0&!;A!"-14*-*.&".9!%1*2"A"2,44)!,.&"E$;-;1$;@"2!1;4"2"*%!:"&$".!

&$*!%2$;;4!("%&0"2&=!F;&$!%&'(*.&%!2"&*!&$*!".&*.%"&)!;A!$;-;1$;@",!&$*)!:"&.*%%*(!,%!

Page 100: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

WY!

!

&$*!0*,%;.!&$,&!1;4"2"*%!.**(*(!&;!,((0*%%!$;-;1$;@",!%1*2"A"2,44)6!0,&$*0!&$,.!

A;2'%!;.!@'44)".9!".!9*.*0,4!3Q*).;4(%7=!!

>.!,!10;/".2*!".!:$"2$!-,.)!%2$;;4!@;,0(%!,0*!%&"44!%&0'994".9!*/*.!&;!.,-*!

$;-;1$;@",!,.(!$*&*0;%*+"%-!,%!"%%'*%6!2;.('2&".9!&$"%!%&'()!0*L'"0*(!2,0*A'4!

%&0,&*9"2!14,..".9!".!;0(*0!&;!:;05!:"&$".!&$*!%&0'2&'0*%!;A!&$*!%2$;;4!,.(!2'4&'0*!

24"-,&*!;A!?,.2;'/*06!FS=!b"&$!'.2$,44*.9*(!*L',&";.%!@*&:**.!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%!

%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!,.(!&$*!2;00'1&";.!;A!"..;2*.2*6!>!5.*:!&$,&!-)!0*%*,02$!10;1;%,4!

:;'4(!$,/*!&;!&,5*!&$*%*!A*,0%!".&;!,22;'.&!A;0!"&!&;!-;/*!A;0:,0(=!#$"%!2$,1&*0!

10;/"(*%!,!(*&,"4*(!,22;'.&!;A!-)!-*&$;(;4;9"2,4!,110;,2$*%!&;!%&'()".9!9*.(*0!

2'4&'0*!".!8".(*09,0&*.!&$,&!-,(*!&$*!10;M*2&!(;,@4*=!h;0!*+,-14*6!>!,4"9.*(!-)!

0*%*,02$!A;2'%!90;'1%!,.(!".&*0/"*:%!:"&$!2'00"2'4,0!*/*.&%!,.(!A;2'%*(!;.!

*/*0)(,)!".&*0,2&";.%!,.(!:,%!&$*0*@)!,@4*!&;!2"02'-/*.&!,.+"*&"*%!&$,&!>!:;'4(!@*!

".&0;('2".9!.*:!3'.(*0%&;;(!&;!@*!".,110;10",&*7!&;1"2%!&;!&$*!2$"4(0*.=!!

>.!&$"%!2$,1&*06!>!,4%;!10;/"(*!,.!;/*0/"*:!;A!&$*!("AA*0*.&!-*&$;(%!>!'%*(!A;0!

9,&$*0".9!(,&,X!;@%*0/,&";.%6!A;2'%!90;'1%6!,.(!".&*0/"*:%6!:$"4*!(0,:".9!A0;-!,.&"E

0,2"%&6!A*-"."%&!4"&*0,&'0*!0*9,0(".9!0*%*,02$!-*&$;(%!".!;0(*0!&;!20"&"2,44)!0*A4*2&!;.!

"%%'*%!"./;4/*(!".!2;.('2&".9!&$"%!%&'()!,.(!-)!0;4*!,%!,!0*%*,02$*0!:"&$".!"&=!>!

10;/"(*!(*&,"4%!;A!$;:!%;-*!1;4"&"2%!,.(!1;4"2"*%!".A4'*.2*(!&$*!10;2*%%*%!&$0;'9$!

:$"2$!>!:,%!,@4*!&;!A".(!,!8".(*09,0&*.!24,%%!&;!1,0&"2"1,&*!".!-)!0*%*,02$=!#$"%!

2$,1&*0!(;2'-*.&%!,(,1&,&";.%!,.(!2$,.9*%!>!-,(*!&;!&$"%!%&'()!".!;0(*0!&;!,/;"(!

;@M*2&"A)".9!1,0&"2"1,.&%!,.(!&;!5**1!&$*!%&'()!,22*%%"@4*!&;!&$*!8".(*09,0&*.!

%&'(*.&%!:$;!:*0*!1,0&"2"1,&".9=!

Page 101: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Wf!

!

#EHY9$)PDFP<D`$

#;!2;.('2&!&$"%!%&'()6!>!%1*.&!h*@0',0)EI,)!;A!YVUY!2;.('2&".9!0*%*,02$!,&!

H;'&$!H"(*!R4*-*.&,0)!H2$;;46!M'%&!:*%&!;A!&$*!?,.2;'/*0B%!*,%&<:*%&!("/"(*=!C'0".9!

&$"%!&"-*6!>!:,%!1,0&!;A!,!8".(*09,0&*.!24,%%!A;'0!&;!A"/*!(,)%!,!:**5=!#$*!%&'()!

"./;4/*(!".E%2$;;4!;@%*0/,&";.%!&$0;'9$;'&!&$*!(,)=!K.!&$0**!%1*2",4!;22,%";.!

(,)%_?,4*.&".*B%!C,)6!G".5!C,)<D.&"EF'44)".9!C,)6!,.(!I;&$*0B%!C,)_>!2;.('2&*(!

A;2'%!90;'1%!:"&$!&$*!%&'(*.&%!,.(!".&*0/"*:%!:"&$!&$*!24,%%0;;-!&*,2$*06!H&'(*.&!

H'11;0&!b;05*0!3:;05".9!:"&$!%&'(*.&%!:"&$!("%,@"4"&"*%76!,.(!%&'(*.&!&*,2$*0!

3:$*.!%$*!:,%!1,0&!;A!&$*!24,%%!A;0!&$*!I;&$*0B%!C,)!".&*0/"*:%7=!K/*0!&$*!2;'0%*!;A!

&$*!%&'()6!>!,4%;!2;.('2&*(!,.!".&*0/"*:!:"&$!&$*!%2$;;4B%!D@;0"9".,4!R.$,.2*-*.&!

b;05*06!,.(!,.!".&*0/"*:!:"&$!&$*!%2$;;4!10".2"1,4=Yf!

D%!>!%&,&*(!".!-)!;1*.".9!2$,1&*06!-)!0*%*,02$!L'*%&";.%!:*0*X!

• b$,&!".A;0-,4!10,2&"2*%!3*=9=!*/*0)(,)!&,456!%&;0)&*44".96!2;--*.&%!;.!&$*!

%&'(*.&B%!14,)7!&,5*!14,2*!@*&:**.!%&'(*.&%!,.(!@*&:**.!*('2,&;0%!,.(!

%&'(*.&%!&$,&!0*A*0!&;!,&&0,2&";.6!2;'14".96!%*+',4"&)6!,.(!9*.(*0e!!

• b$,&!10,2&"2*%!3*=9=!&,456!14,)7!(*-;.%&0,&*!%&'(*.&%B!0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)e!!

#$*!*&$"2,4!0*/"*:!A;0!&$"%!%&'()!:,%!A,"04)!"./;4/*(_>!;@&,".*(!*&$"2%!,110;/,4!

A0;-!&$*!?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!F;,0(6!A0;-!&$*!d."/*0%"&)!;A!F0"&"%$!S;4'-@",B%!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Yf!#$*0*!:*0*!,!&;&,4!;A!A"/*!,('4&%!:$;!1,0&"2"1,&*(!".!&$*!%&'()!:"&$!,!&;&,4!;A!.".*!

".&*0/"*:%=!h;'0&**.!2$"4(0*.!1,0&"2"1,&*(!".!&$*!%&'()=!D!&;&,4!;A!.".*!A;2'%!90;'1%!

:*0*!2;.('2&*(6!:"&$!*,2$!2$"4(!1,0&"2"1,&".9!".!&$0**!90;'1%=!!

Page 102: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

W[!

!

F*$,/";'0,4!Q*%*,02$!R&$"2%!F;,0(6!,%!:*44!,%!2;.%*.&!A0;-!%2$;;4!,(-"."%&0,&";.6!

1,0&"2"1,&".9!*('2,&;0%6!,.(!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!1,0*.&%!3%**!D11*.("+!>>>7=!!

G0";0!&;!%&,0&".9!-)!A"*4(:;056!>!%*.&!2;.%*.&!4*&&*0%!$;-*!&;!,44!;A!&$*!

2$"4(0*.B%!1,0*.&%!,.(!9',0(",.%!3%**!D11*.("+!>>>7=!h;'0&**.!;A!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!

1,0*.&%!,.(!9',0(",.%!2;.%*.&*(!&;!&$*!2$"4(B%!1,0&"2"1,&";.!".!&$*!%&'()=!K.*!.*/*0!

0*14"*(!,.(!&$0**!("(!.;&!2;.%*.&=!>!("(!.;&!&,5*!.;&*%!;.!&$*%*!A;'0!2$"4(0*.6!.;0!("(!

&$*)!1,0&"2"1,&*!".!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1%=!

%DAZCDFJd$OB<?B$ABY$#ZC??>$#D>DZE<?B$

#$*!"-14"2"&6!*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%!,.(!A;2'%!90;'1!L'*%&";.%!,0*!%"&',&*(!".!

@;&$!%&,&*E-,.(,&*(!,.(!&*,2$*0!20*,&*(!2'00"2'4,!,%!:*44!,%!&$*!2'4&'0,4!24"-,&*!;A!

*('2,&";.!".!&$*!%2$;;46!2"&)6!10;/".2*6!,.(!2;'.&0)=!#$"%!%&'()!&,5*%!14,2*!:"&$".!,44!

A;'0!;A!&$*%*!&"*0%=!b"&$".!*,2$!%2$;;4!".!F0"&"%$!S;4'-@",6!)*,04)!*%&"-,&*(!@'(9*&%!

,0*!%'@-"&&*(!&;!0*%1*2&"/*!%2$;;4!@;,0(%=!#$*!%2$;;4!@;,0(%!%'@-"&!%,"(!@'(9*&%!&;!

&$*!10;/".2",4!I"."%&0)!;A!R('2,&";.=!#$*!10;/".2*!,110;/*%!;0!,-*.(%!&$*!@'(9*&%!

,.(!A'.(%!,0*!,44;2,&*(!,..',44)!&;!%2$;;4%!@;,0(%!&$,&6!".!&'0.6!,0*!("%&0"@'&*(!&;!

".("/"(',4!%2$;;4%!@,%*(!;.!*.0;44-*.&!,.(!*,2$!%2$;;4B%!(*-;90,1$"2%=!#$*!-;0*!

N(*%"9.,&*(O!%&'(*.&%!,!%2$;;4!$,%!3*=9=!%&'(*.&%!(*%"9.,&*(!,%!0*L'"0".9!R.94"%$!,%!

,!H*2;.(!a,.9',9*!%'11;0&!,.(!%&'(*.&%!:"&$!H1*2",4!P**(%!(*%"9.,&";.%76!&$*!

-;0*!-;.*)!&$*!%2$;;4!0*2*"/*%!3FS#h!>.A;0-,&";.!H*0/"2*%!,.(!Q*%*,02$!

C*1,0&-*.&%6!NYVUY!FS!R('2,&";.!h,2&%O7=!b$"4*!&$"%!%&0'2&'0*!2;'4(!@*!'.(*0%&;;(!

,%!*L',4"J".9!("%20*1,.2"*%!@*&:**.!.*"9$@;'0$;;(%!:"&$!-;0*!A,-"4"*%!".!1;/*0&)!

Page 103: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

W]!

!

,.(!-;0*!,AA4'*.&!2,&2$-*.&!,0*,%6Y[!-,.)!;&$*0!24,%%E@,%*(!A,2&;0%!".A4'*.2*!

2$"4(0*.B%!*L',4!,22*%%!&;!*('2,&";.X!1,0*.&,4!*('2,&";.!4*/*4%6!,@"4"&)!&;!10;/"(*!

*+&0,!,2,(*-"2!%'11;0&!,.(!2$"4(!,(/;2,2)6!A;;(!%*2'0"&)6!1,0*.&,4!A'.(0,"%".96!,.(!

,22*%%!&;!,(("&";.,4!*('2,&"/*!0*%;'02*%=!#$*%*!,0*!,44!*.&0*.2$*(!".!24,%%E@,%*(!

10"/"4*9*!,.(!".A4'*.2*!-,.)!%&'(*.&%B!".%&"&'&";.,4!*('2,&";.,4!*+1*0"*.2*%=!

I;0*;/*06!&$*!%)%&*-!:$*0*@)!%&'(*.&%!-'%&!0*2*"/*!(*%"9.,&";.%!".!;0(*0!&;!$,/*!

,22*%%!&;!%'11;0&!"%!;.*!&$,&!*.2;'0,9*%!%&0*,-4".".9!2$"4(0*.!".&;!(",9.;%*%!A0;-!

/*0)!);'.9!,9*%=!!

#$*!1;4"&"2%!;A!&*,2$*0%B!'.";.%!:*0*!0"A*!:"&$!%&0'994*!('0".9!&$*!&"-*!;A!-)!

A"*4(:;05=!#$*!F0"&"%$!S;4'-@",!9;/*0.-*.&!:,%!".!&$*!10;2*%%!;A!"-14*-*.&".9!F"44!

SEYY6!"0;."2,44)!&"&4*(!N#$*!R('2,&";.!>-10;/*-*.&!D2&6O!:$"2$!0,"%*(!10"-,0)!,.(!

0*-;/*(!".&*0-*(",&*!24,%%!%"J*!4"-"&%=!>&!,4%;!0*-;/*(!2,1%!;.!&$*!.'-@*0!;A!

%&'(*.&%!:"&$!("%,@"4"&"*%!:$;!2;'4(!@*!,22;--;(,&*(!:"&$".!;.*!24,%%=!D&!&$*!%,-*!

&"-*6!"&!0*%&0"2&*(!2;44*2&"/*!@,09,".".9!,.(!"9.;0*(!FS!H'10*-*!S;'0&!0'4".9%!:$"2$!

-,.(,&*(!-"."-'-!4*/*4%!;A!%'11;0&!%*0/"2*%!A;0!%&'(*.&%!,.(!%2$;;4%X!%'2$!,%!

&*,2$*0E4"@0,0",.%6!0*%;'02*!&*,2$*0%!3%'11;0&".9!%&'(*.&%!:"&$!("%,@"4"&"*%76!,.(!

R.94"%$!,%!,!H*2;.(!a,.9',9*!%'11;0&!3NF"44!YY!T'0&%!H&'(*.&%!,.(!D&&,25%!

#*,2$*0%B!Q"9$&%6O!FS!#*,2$*0B%!h*(*0,&";.7=!!

C'0".9!&$*!&"-*A0,-*!&$,&!>!:,%!4;;5".9!A;0!,!A"*4(!%&'()!%"&*6!&*,2$*0%!:*0*!

2,00)".9!;'&!,!b;05!&;!Q'4*!M;@!,2&";.!".!0*%1;.%*!&;!&$*!10;1;%*(!@"44=!>.!&$*!M;@!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Y[!H2$;;4%!:"&$".!,!%2$;;4!@;,0(!,0*!("/"(*(!".&;!2,&2$-*.&!,0*,%!:$"2$!(*&*0-".*!

&$*!9*;90,1$"2,4!@0*,5(;:.!;A!:$"2$!%&'(*.&%!:"44!,&&*.(!:$"2$!%2$;;4%!@,%*(!;.!

10;+"-"&)=!!

Page 104: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Wk!

!

,2&";.6!FS!&*,2$*0%!,&&*-1&*(!&;!5**1!&$*"0!:;05".9!$;'0%!:"&$".!&$*!2;.A".*%!;A!

&$*"0!1,"(!$;'0%=!>.!;0(*0!&;!"44'%&0,&*!&$*!,-;'.&!;A!'.1,"(!:;05!*+1*2&*(!;A!&$*-!

:"&$".!&$*"0!10;A*%%";.%6!&$*)!("(!.;&!(;!,(("&";.,4!%'1*0/"%";.6!$;4(!2;.2*0&%!".!&$*!

*/*.".96!;0!:0"&*!0*1;0&!2,0(%=!K/*0!&$*!2;'0%*!;A!-)!A"*4(:;05!&$*0*!:,%!,!&$0**E

(,)!%&0"5*6!,A&*0!:$"2$!&$*!FS!9;/*0.-*.&!4*9"%4,&*(!&$,&!&*,2$*0%!:*0*!,.!

N*%%*.&",4!%*0/"2*O!,.(!:*0*!.;&!*.&"&4*(!&;!%&0"5*!A;0!4;.9*0!1*0";(%=!F)!&$*!*.(!;A!

-)!%&'()!,&!&$*!%2$;;46!F"44!SEYY!$,(!@**.!1,%%*(!,.(!&$*!%2$;;4!4;%&!,.!*.&"0*!

("/"%";.!3;.*!24,%%7!,.(!$,(!&;!4,)!;AA!,.(!0*('2*!&$*!$;'0%!;A!%*/*0,4!*-14;)**%=!!

#$"%!24"-,&*!".A4'*.2*(!:$*0*!,.(!$;:!>!,110;,2$*(!1;&*.&",4!%"&*%!&;!

2;.('2&!-)!0*%*,02$=!>.!&*0-%!;A!%2$;;4!%*4*2&";.6!-)!;0"9".,4!10;1;%,4!;'&4".*(!

&$,&!>!:;'4(!*-,"4!,(-"."%&0,&"/*!0*10*%*.&,&"/*%!,&!,!/,0"*&)!;A!%2$;;4%!,.(!&$*)!

:;'4(!".!&'0.!2;.&,2&!1;&*.&",44)!".&*0*%&*(!8".(*09,0&*.!,.(!^0,(*!K.*!&*,2$*0%=!

h0;-!&$*0*6!>!".&*.(*(!&;!-**&!&$*!&*,2$*0%!,.(!,00,.9*!&;!%2$*('4*!-)!0*%*,02$=!

C'*!&;!b;05!&;!Q'4*!2;.("&";.%6!,(-"."%&0,&"/*!0*10*%*.&,&"/*%!2;'4(!.;&!10;1;%*!

,.)!.*:!:;05!&;!&*,2$*0%=!#$*!4,%&!&$".9!>!:,.&*(!&;!(;!:,%!&;!20;%%!,!1"25*&!4".*6!%;!

>!-*&!:"&$!&$*!("%&0"2&!R('2,&";.!S;;0(".,&;0!".!1*0%;.!".!;0(*0!&;!@*!,%!:*44E/*0%*(!

,%!1;%%"@4*!;.!,.)!,2&";.%!;.!-)!1,0&!&$,&!2;'4(!20;%%!&$*!@;'.(,0"*%!;A!b;05!&;!

Q'4*!2;.("&";.%=!>!:,%!".A;0-*(!&$,&6!@*2,'%*!>!:,%!.;&!,.!,(-"."%&0,&;06!"&!:,%!&$*!

".("/"(',4!&*,2$*0B%!(*2"%";.!:$*&$*0!;0!.;&!&$*)!:;'4(!:;05!:"&$!-*=!>A!

,(-"."%&0,&";.!2;.&,2&*(!,!&*,2$*0!".!,.)!:,)6!&$,&!2;'4(!@*!2;.%&0'*(!,%!

0*L'*%&".9!&$,&!&$*)!&,5*!;.!,(("&";.,4!:;056!&$,&!:;'4(!/";4,&*!&$*!2;.("&";.%!;A!

Page 105: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Wi!

!

b;05!&;!Q'4*=!>.!,(("&";.6!>!:,%!:,0.*(!&$,&!'.4*%%!>!5.*:!,!&*,2$*06!&$*)!:;'4(!

10;@,@4)!.;&!:,.&!&;!@*!"./;4/*(!,&!&$"%!&"-*=!

b$"4*!>!5.*:!&*,2$*0%!A0;-!-)!*-14;)-*.&!:"&$!&$*!?HF6!>!("(!.;&!:,.&!&;!

2;.('2&!0*%*,02$!".!,!%2$;;4!:$*0*!>!$,(!10*/";'%4)!%1*.&!,!%'@%&,.&",4!,-;'.&!;A!

&"-*!".!;0(*0!&;!,/;"(!&$*!1;&*.&",4!,:5:,0(.*%%!&$,&!2;'4(!,0"%*!A0;-!&,5".9!.;&*%!

;.!A;0-*0!2;E:;05*0%=!>.%&*,(6!>!2;.&,2&*(!1*;14*!:"&$".!-)!%;2",4!%1$*0*!:$;!

:;05*(!".!;&$*0!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!,.(!%*.&!&$*-!,!@0"*A!(*%20"1&";.!;A!-)!0*%*,02$!&$,&!

&$*)!2;'4(!1,%%!,4;.9!&;!8".(*09,0&*.!&*,2$*0%=!d1;.!("%2'%%".9!(*&,"4%!;A!-)!

10;M*2&!,.(!-**&".9!".!1*0%;.!:"&$!A;'0!("AA*0*.&!&*,2$*0%6!&:;!A*4&!&$*"0!24,%%0;;-%!

:;'4(!,40*,()!@*!A'44!,%!&$*)!:*0*!,22;--;(,&".9!%&'(*.&!&*,2$*0%!;/*0!&$*!&"-*!

1*0";(!;A!-)!%&'()=!

K'&!;A!&$*!0*-,".".9!&:;!%2$;;4%!&$,&!:*0*!;1*.!&;!-)!1,0&"2"1,&";.6!;.*!$,(!

,!.'-@*0!;A!*-14;)**%!:$;-!>!5.*:!A0;-!L'**0!2;--'."&"*%!".!?,.2;'/*0=!#$*!

%-,44!D..*+!%2$;;4!$,(!,110;+"-,&*4)!UVV!%&'(*.&%!@*&:**.!8".(*09,0&*.!,.(!

^0,(*!#$0**=!>&!:,%!2;.%"(*0*(!&;!@*!,!$"9$4)!(*%"0,@4*!4;2,&";.!@)!L'**0!?HF!

*-14;)**%!('*!&;!%'@%&,.&",4!:;05!&$,&!,(-"."%&0,&";.!,.(!&*,2$*0%!$,(!

'.(*0&,5*.!&;!20*,&*!,!:*42;-".9!*./"0;.-*.&=!b$"4*!0*%*,02$!,&!%'2$!,!%2$;;4!

:;'4(!'.(;'@&*(4)!10;/"(*!"&%!;:.!%*&!;A!(,&,!&$,&!:;'4(!@*!'%*A'4!A;0!,.,4)%"%6!>!

$,(!;A&*.!$*,0(!&$"%!%2$;;4!("%2'%%*(!@)!A0"*.(%!,.(!2;E:;05*0%=!>!:,%!&$*0*A;0*!

2,'&";'%!,@;'&!*.&*0".9!A"*4(:;05!:"&$!4;.9E%&,.(".96!10*E2;.2*"/*(!.;&";.%!,%!&;!

"&%!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!,%!&$"%!2;'4(!$,/*!'.('4)!".A;0-*(!&$*!4*.%!&$0;'9$!:$"2$!>!

;@%*0/*(!*/*0)(,)!".&*0,2&";.%!A;0!&$"%!%&'()=!>.%&*,(!>!%*4*2&*(!&$*!%2$;;4!>!:,%!

Page 106: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

WZ!

!

'.A,-"4",0!:"&$!".!;0(*0!&;!,/;"(!,.,4)J".9!-)!(,&,!@,%*(!;.!5.;:4*(9*!>!$,(!

10*/";'%4)!,2L'"0*(!,@;'&!&$*!%2$;;4B%!2'4&'0*=!a"5*!&$*!-,M;0"&)!;A!%2$;;4%!".!&$*!

("%&0"2&6!H;'&$!H"(*!R4*-*.&,0)!H2$;;4!*.2;-1,%%*(!8".(*09,0&*.!&;!^0,(*!H*/*.=!>!

$,(!.*/*0!$*,0(!,.)&$".96!1;%"&"/*!;0!.*9,&"/*6!,@;'&!H;'&$!H"(*!R4*-*.&,0)!H2$;;4=!

>!$,(!.;&!-*&!&$*!10".2"1,46!24,%%0;;-!&*,2$*06!%'11;0&!:;05*06!;0!%&'(*.&!&*,2$*0=!!

D&!&$*!&"-*!;A!-)!A"*4(:;056!&$*!H;'&$!H"(*!R4*-*.&,0)!H2$;;4!:,%!M'%&!;/*0!

UVV!)*,0%!;4(=!#$*!;0"9".,4!@'"4(".9!0*-,".%!:"&$!,!%"9."A"2,.&!,(("&";.!&;!

,22;--;(,&*!"&%!90;:&$!A0;-!"&%!@*9"..".9!.'-@*0%!;A!,110;+"-,&*4)!Y]V6!&;!"&%!

2'00*.&!*.0;44-*.&!;A!,110;+"-,&*4)![]V=!#$*!%2$;;4!1;1'4,&";.!:,%!0*4,&"/*4)!

("/*0%*X!.*,04)!WV!R.94"%$!,%!,!H*2;.(!a,.9',9*!H&'(*.&%6!UV!D@;0"9".,4!%&'(*.&%6!

,.(!f]!%&'(*.&%!:"&$!H1*2",4!R('2,&";.!(*%"9.,&";.%!3:"&$!,!L',0&*0!;A!&$;%*!@*".9!

%&'(*.&%!:"&$!4*,0.".9!("%,@"4"&"*%!,.(!.*,04)!,!&$"0(6!%&'(*.&%!:"&$!,'&"%-!

(",9.;%*%7=Y]!R('2,&;0%!%$,0*(!".A;0-,&";.!:"&$!-*!2;.A"(*.&",44)!,.(!("(!.;&!:"%$!

&$*"0!"(*.&"&"*%!&;!@*!&0,2*,@4*!&;!&$*"0!14,2*%!;A!*-14;)-*.&=!H"-"4,04)6!&$*!2$"4(0*.!

%$,0*(!".A;0-,&";.!,@;'&!&$*-%*4/*%!&$,&!>!2,..;&!*&$"2,44)!,44;:!&;!@*!4".5*(!&;!

&$*-!,%!".("/"(',4%=!D44!*('2,&;0%!,.(!%&'(*.&%!$,/*!@**.!9"/*.!1%*'(;.)-%!&;!

*.%'0*!2;.A"(*.&",4"&)=!!!

#$*!)*,0!-)!A"*4(%&'()!&;;5!14,2*6!?,.2;'/*0!$,(!@**.!0,.5*(!&$*!-;%&!

*+1*.%"/*!2"&)!".!P;0&$!D-*0"2,!3g'*g,.97=!#$*!4".*!%*1,0,&".9!&$*!R,%&!,.(!b*%&!

%"(*%!;A!&$*!2"&)!$,%!@**.!2;.2*1&',4"J*(!10"-,0"4)!".!&*0-%!;A!24,%%6!:"&$!$;'%".9!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Y]!>!,-!5**1".9!&$*!.'-@*0%!,110;+"-,&*(!A;0!2;.A"(*.&",4"&)!1'01;%*%=!!

Page 107: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

WW!

!

10"2*%!%1"5".9!90*,&4)!M'%&!".&;!&$*!b*%&=!b$*.!(*%20"@".9!&$*!A".,.2",4!%"&',&";.%!;A!

2$"4(0*.!,&!&$*!H;'&$!H"(*!R4*-*.&,0)6!*('2,&;0%!,&!&$*!%2$;;4!%1;5*!;A!&$*!

(*-;90,1$"2!("/"(*!@*&:**.!$;-*E;:.".9!A,-"4"*%!,.(!&$;%*!:$;!0*.&*(!

@,%*-*.&!%'"&*%!,.(!N:*0*!%&0'994".9O!3P*4%;.!YV!D10"4!YVUY7=!#$"%6!$;:*/*06!.**(%!

&;!@*!2;.&*+&',4"J*(X!,44!$;'%".9!".!?,.2;'/*0!"%!&$0**!&"-*%!&$*!.,&";.,4!,/*0,9*6!

:"&$!&$*!2;--;.!10"2*!;A!,!@'.9,4;:!0'..".9!,&!,110;+"-,&*4)!;.*!-"44";.!(;44,0%!

3NT;'%".9!G0"2*%!T"9$*0!".!I;%&!S,.,(",.!I,05*&%!".!R,04)!YVUfX!Q*1;0&O7=!b$"4*!

&$*!%2$;;4B%!.*"9$@;'0$;;(!:,%!-;0*!*+1*.%"/*!&$,.!&$*!2"&)!,/*0,9*6!,!&:;E

@*(0;;-!@,%*-*.&!0*.&,4!%'"&*!".!&$*!2"&)!,/*0,9*(!,&!,@;'&!zU6YkU!,!-;.&$!

3NQ*.&,4!D1,0&-*.&!?,2,.2"*%!d1O!Uf!C*2*-@*0!YVUY7=!R-14;)**%!(*%20"@*(!&$*!

24,%%!("%&".2&";.!,%!-"((4*!24,%%!/*0%'%!%&0'994".9!A,-"4"*%=!#*,2$*0%B!%,4,0"*%!".!&$*!

?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!C"%&0"2&!0,.9*!A0;-!,110;+"-,&*4)!zfW6VVV!,&!&$*!%&,0&!;A!&$*"0!

*-14;)-*.&!&;!z]]6VVV!,A&*0!,!(*2,(*!3(*1*.(".9!;.!&$*!.'-@*0!;A!,(/,.2*(!

(*90**%!,!&*,2$*0!$;4(%7!3NH,4,0)!^0"(%O!FS!#*,2$*0B%!h*(*0,&";.7=!#$"%!-*,.%!&$,&!

*/*.!,!1'@4"2!%2$;;4!*-14;)**!2;'4(!@*!24,%%"A"*(!,%!N%&0'994".9O!:"&$".!?,.2;'/*0B%!

$;'%".9!-,05*&=!!

#$*!&*,2$*06!I,09,0*&!Q;/*44,6!$,(!(*2;0,&*(!&$*!24,%%0;;-!:$*0*!>!

2;.('2&*(!-)!0*%*,02$!".!,!:,)!&$,&!0*A4*2&*(!I,09,0*&B%!*AA;0&%!&;!20*,&*!,!

%&"-'4,&".9!4*,0.".9!*./"0;.-*.&=!>--*(",&*4)!'1;.!*.&*0".9!&$*!24,%%0;;-6!&$*0*!

:,%!,.!*,%*46!,!:,&*0!&,@4*6!,.(!,!20,A&!&,@4*=!S$"4(0*.B%!(0,:".9%!:*0*!A0,-*(!

,0;'.(!&$*!0;;-=!#$*0*!:*0*!%$*4/*%!:"&$!@".%!;A!20,A&!%'114"*%!;.!;.*!%"(*!,.(!

@".%!;A!&;)%!;.!&$*!;&$*0=!#$*)!".24'(*(!%*/*0,4!("AA*0*.&!2;..*2&".9!2'@*%6!%&0,:%6!

Page 108: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UVV!

!

,.(!;&$*0!@'"4(".9!&;)%6!1'11*&%6!,!&*+&"4*!@;,0(6!&;;4%6!,!2,%&4*6!%-,44!,."-,4%6!,.(!

;&$*0!A"9'0*%=!#$*0*!:,%!,!4"@0,0)!2;0.*0!:"&$!@;;5%!,.(!@".%!;A!9,-*%=!#$*0*!:*0*!

&$0**!24'-1%!;A!(*%5%6!1;%"&";.*(!".!90;'1%6!:"&$!,!2$"4(B%!.,-*!;.!*,2$=!!

b$"4*!A'.(0,"%".9!*AA;0&%!A0;-!1,0*.&!90;'1%!$,(!%'114"*(!&$*!%2$;;4!:"&$!

%&,&*E;AE&$*E,0&!14,)90;'.(!*L'"1-*.&!,%!:*44!,%!A"*4(&0"1!,2&"/"&"*%6!&*,2$*0%!%1;5*!

-,&&*0E;AEA,2&4)!,@;'&!*('2,&";.,4!9,-*%!,.(!&;)%!&$*)!:;'4(!1"25!'1!".!&$*"0!%1,0*!

&"-*!;A!&$*"0!;:.!,22;0(!,.(!:"&$!&$*"0!;:.!A'.(%=!D%!"%!A0*L'*.&4)!&$*!2,%*!".!

10"-,0)!%2$;;4!24,%%0;;-%6!I,09,0*&!$,(!1'02$,%*(!-;%&!;A!&$*!%'114"*%!A;0!&$*!

24,%%0;;-!;'&!;A!$*0!;:.!1;25*&=!#$*!:*44E%&;25*(!*./"0;.-*.&6!%*&!'1!&;!@*!

2;.('2"/*!&;!$,.(%E;.6!,2&"/*!4*,0.".9!,2&"/"&"*%6!:,%!".("2,&"/*!;A!-,.)!,A&*0E$;'0%!

;A!:;05!,%!:*44!,%!1*0%;.,4!A".,.2",4!*+1*.("&'0*=!#$"%!:,%!".!&$*!2;.&*+&!;A!,!

1'@4"24)!A'.(*(!'0@,.!%2$;;4!".!,!A,"04)!:*44E;AA!.*"9$@;'0$;;(=!R2;.;-"2%!,.(!

24,%%!14,)*(!,!0;4*!".!-)!%&'()!,%!"&!:,%!*/"(*.&!&$,&!*/*.!&$;%*!:"&$!,!A,"0!,-;'.&!

;A!A".,.2",4!10"/"4*9*!-,)!%&"44!@*!A".,.2",44)!%&0'994".9!:"&$!&$*!$"9$!2;%&!;A!4"/".9!".!

&$*!2"&)6!,.(!*/*.!%2$;;4%!&$,&!:*0*!A".,.2",44)!:*44E;AA!0*4"*(!;.!&*,2$*0%B!;'&E;AE

1;25*&!,2L'"%"&";.!;A!*('2,&";.,4!-,&*0",4%=!

I)!:;05".9!0*4,&";.%$"1!:"&$!&$*!%2$;;4!:,%!/*0)!1;%"&"/*!&$0;'9$;'&!&$*!

%&'()=!d1;.!$*,0".9!,@;'&!-)!0*%*,02$!A0;-!&$*!%2$;;4!-'%"2!&*,2$*06!I,09,0*&!

*+10*%%*(!90*,&!".&*0*%&!".!1,0&"2"1,&".9!".!&$*!%&'()=!H$*!@*4"*/*(!"%%'*%!;A!9*.(*0!

,.(!%*+',4"&)!:*0*!20"&"2,44)!"-1;0&,.&!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!,.(!,4%;!A*4&!&$,&!%$*!$,(!

.;&!&$;'9$&!*.;'9$!,@;'&!&$*-=!H$*!$;1*(!&$,&!&$*!0*%'4&%!;A!&$*!%&'()!:;'4(!

@*2;-*!,!0*%;'02*!&$,&!&*,2$*0%6!%'2$!,%!$*06!2;'4(!'%*!&;!9,".!2;-1*&*.2)!,.(!

Page 109: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UVU!

!

2;.A"(*.2*!:$*.!,((0*%%".9!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4!("/*0%"&)!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!H$*!

3,4;.9!:"&$!;&$*0!*-14;)**%!>!*.2;'.&*0*(7!:,%!;1*.!,.(!:*42;-".9!&;!-*!

&$0;'9$;'&!&$*!%&'()!,.(!".&*0*%&*(!&;!5.;:!,@;'&!&$*!0*%'4&%!'1;.!"&%!2;-14*&";.=!

#$"%6!".!"&%*4A6!20*,&*(!,.!*./"0;.-*.&!;A!0*2"10;2"&)6!,%!*('2,&;0%!,11*,0*(!&;!

@*4"*/*!&$,&!:*42;-".9!-*!".&;!&$*"0!%2$;;4!:;'4(!9*.*0,&*!10;A*%%";.,4!

(*/*4;1-*.&!&$*)!:"%$*(!&;!0*2*"/*=!!

5DEC?Y?>?I<ZA>$"B_>HDBZDJ$

S0"&"2,4!-*&$;(;4;9"%&%Yk!$,/*!:;05*(!&;!,((0*%%!"%%'*%!;A!1;:*0!,.(!

;@M*2&"A"2,&";.!".!%;2",4E%2"*.2*!0*%*,02$=!>.!NQ*%*,02$*0!,.(!Q*%*,02$*(E

S;--'."&)!G*0%1*2&"/*%X!#;:,0(!F0"(9".9!&$*!^,1O!I,0",..*!H'44"/,.!*&!,4=!

".&*0/"*:*(!-*-@*0%!;A!2;--'."&)!%'11;0&!,9*.2"*%!0*9,0(".9!&$*"0!*+1*0"*.2*%!

:;05".9!:"&$!,2,(*-"2!0*%*,02$*0%!,&!,!.*,0@)!'."/*0%"&)=!D20;%%!&$*!@;,0(6!

2;--'."&)!-*-@*0%!2"&*(!$,/".9!*+1*0"*.2*(!A**4".9!!N'%*(O!3Uf]7!&;!A'0&$*0!

0*%*,02$*0%B!2,0**0%!0,&$*0!&$,.!0*%*,02$!2;.&0"@'&".9!&;!&$*!2;--'."&"*%!

&$*-%*4/*%=!#$*!1,0&"2"1,.&%!0*1;0&*(!&;!A**4".9!4"5*!N;@M*2&%O!;A!%&'()6!0,&$*0!&$,.!

%'@M*2&%!2;.&0"@'&".9!&;!,2,(*-"2!5.;:4*(9*=!>!$,/*!(0,:.!A0;-!4"&*0,&'0*!&$,&!

;AA*0%!&;;4%!A;0!0*%*,02$*0%!&;!2;.%&0'2&!&$*"0!%&'("*%!".!;0(*0!A;0!&$*"0!0*%*,02$!

-*&$;(%!&$,&!:;'4(!2$,44*.9*!(;-".,.&!$"*0,02$"*%=!!D-;.9!%'2$!10,2&"2*%!,0*X!

,&&*.&";.!&;!".%"(*0<;'&%"(*0!0*4,&";.%$"1%!".!0*%*,02$6!0*A4*+"/"&)!".!0*9,0(!&;!

1;:*0!().,-"2%6!,.(!2;--'."&)!,22;'.&,@"4"&)=!$

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

YkH**!:;05%!@)!%2$;4,0%!%'2$!,%X!T"-,."!F,..*0M"j!`"44!S$0"%1j!H'J,..*!(*!S,%&*44!,.(!

I,0)!F0)%;.j!b*.()!h0"%@)6!G,&0"2",!I,9'"0*6!,.(!S;44**.!Q*"(j!@*44!$;;5%j!T"4,0)!

a*/)j!`,)!G0;%%*0j!a".(,!#'$":,"!H-"&$j!S$0"%&;1$*0!H$*44)j!F,00"*!#$;0.*=!

Page 110: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UVY!

!

#$*!".%"(*0<;'&%"(*0!(*@,&*!$,%!@**.!9"/*.!20"&"2,4!,&&*.&";.!:"&$".!A*-"."%&!

0*%*,02$!3P,14*%j!Q,-,.J,.;94'!,.(!T;44,.(j!Q;-,.76!,%!"&!$,%!("0*2&!"-14"2,&";.%!

A;0!$;:!0*%*,02$*0%!.*9;&",&*!1;:*0!:"&$".!&$*"0!A"*4(:;05=!d.(*0%&,.(".9!:$*.6!

,.(!".!:$,&!:,)%6!>!:,%!2;-".9!A0;-!,!1;%"&";.!;A!10"/"4*9*!;0!.*9;&",&".9!-)!;:.!

-,09".,4"J,&";.6!@*2,-*!1,0&!;A!&$*!%&;0)!&$,&!-)!0*%*,02$!&*44%!0*9,0(".9!9*.(*0!

2'4&'0*=!R4"J,@*&$!T;AA-,.!(*%20"@*%!&$"%!10;2*%%!;A!.,/"9,&".9!%;2",4!().,-"2%!".!

0*%*,02$!,%!;.*!;A!*-;&";.,4!:;056!;0!4,@;'0=!H$*!("%2'%%*%!*-;&";.,4!4,@;'0!,%!

4".5*(!&;!%$"A&".9!0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!1;:*0!".!0*%*,02$=!!H$*!*+14,".%6!Na"5*!;&$*0!4,@;0!

&$,&!(*-,.(%!90*,&!*AA;0&6!*-;&";.,4!4,@;0!%$"A&%!&;!&$;%*!:"&$!&$*!4*,%&!%&,&'%!,.(!

1;:*0!,&!&$,&!-;-*.&uO!3fY]7=!!>.!&$*!A;44;:".9!%*2&";.%6!,%!>!("%2'%%!;@%*0/,&";.%6!

".&*0/"*:%6!,.(!A;2'%!90;'1%6!>!".24'(*!0*A4*2&";.!0*9,0(".9!&$*!A"*4(:;05!10;2*%%6!

-)!0;4*%!,%!".%"(*0<;'&%"(*06!,.(!,110;,2$*%!&;!2;--'."&)!,22;'.&,@"4"&)=!!

>!;0"9".,44)!2;.2*1&',4"J*(!&$"%!0*%*,02$!,%!,!%&'()!;A!&0,.%9*.(*0!);'.9!

,('4&%B!,22;'.&%!;A!&$*"0!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4!*+1*0"*.2*%=!#$*!9;,4!;A!&$"%!:,%!&;!9*&!,!

%*.%*!;A!".%&"&'&";.,4!10,2&"2*%!&$,&!20*,&*!9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!2'4&'0*!,%!0*2,44*(!@)!

1*;14*!:$;!$,/*!&$;'9$&!2;.%2";'%4)!,@;'&!&$*"0!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!%'2$!.;0-%=!>!$,(!

$;1*(!&$*!1,0&"2"1,.&%!:;'4(!10;/"(*!,(("&";.,4!'.(*0%&,.(".9!,%!&;!10;2*%%*%!;A!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,4"J,&";.!".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4=!T;:*/*06!:$*.!>!:;'4(!(*%20"@*!

-)!0*%*,02$!".!@;&$!,2,(*-"2!,.(!.;.E,2,(*-"2!2;.&*+&%6!2;44*,9'*%!,.(!

,2L',".&,.2*%!:;'4(!,%%'-*!&$,&!&$*!1,0&"2"1,.&%!:*0*!&$*!;@M*2&%!;A!%&'()_!&$,&!>!

:,%!%&'()".9!:$)!1*;14*!@*2,-*!:$;!&$*)!:*0*!@,%*(!;.!&$*"0!*4*-*.&,0)!

*+1*0"*.2*%6!0,&$*0!&$,.!%&'()".9!".%&"&'&";.,4!10,2&"2*%!&$,&!,AA*2&!1*;14*B%!4"/*%=!

Page 111: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UVf!

!

h'0&$*0-;0*6!>!0*2*"/*(!-'2$!A**(@,25!A0;-!&0,.%9*.(*0!,.(!9*.(*0L'**0!A0"*.(%!

&$,&!&$*!4,%&!&$".9!;'0!2;--'."&"*%!.**(*(!:,%!-;0*!%&'("*%!,@;'&!$",2=!b$)!

%&'()!&0,.%!1*;14*6!>!:,%!,%5*(e!C;*%!&$"%!,110;,2$!.;&!A'0&$*0!1;%"&";.!;/*0E

-*("2,4"J*(!,.(!1,&$;4;9"J*(!1;1'4,&";.%!,%!;@M*2&%!;A!%&'()e!#$*%*!0*,(".9%!;A!

,.(!A**(@,25!;.!-)!10;1;%*(!0*%*,02$!2,'%*(!-*!&;!0*E*+,-".*!:$,&!".A;0-,&";.!>!

:,%!,2&',44)!%**5".9!,.(!&;!:$,&!*AA*2&=!!

>!:,.&*(!&;!*+,-".*!:,)%!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!,0*!*%&,@4"%$*(!".!&$*!

A;'.(,&";.%!;A!1'@4"2!*('2,&";.,4!4"A*!,.(!$;:!&$"%!2;;0(".,&*%!%;2",4!;&$*0".96!,.(!

;&$*0!%)%&*-"2!*+24'%";.%=!I;0*;/*06!>!:,.&*(!&;!*+14;0*!4;;1$;4*%!".!&$*%*!

*+24'%";.%!&$,&!$,(!10,2&"2,4!"-14"2,&";.%!A;0!1;".&%!;A!0*%"%&,.2*!&;!(;-".,.&!

9*.(*0!2'4&'0*=!#$"%!-,(*!,!8".(*09,0&*.!24,%%0;;-!,!4;9"2,4!%"&*!A0;-!:$"2$!&;!

2;.('2&!&$"%!%&'()=!#$0;'9$!*/*0)(,)!;@%*0/,&";.%!,.(!%1*2",4!;22,%";.!A;2'%!

90;'1%!,.(!".&*0/"*:%6!>!:,%!,@4*!&;!2;.2*.&0,&*!,&&*.&";.!;.!*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%!

%'2$!,%!&,456!14,)6!,.(!2'00"2'4'-6!,%!&$*)!:*0*!10*%*.&!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!>!,.,4)J*(!

10,2&"2*%!&$,&!0*10;('2*(!,.(!2$,44*.9*(!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)6!,&&*.(".9!&;!

&$*!:,)%!".!:$"2$!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&%!:*0*!1;%"&";.*(=!#$*0*A;0*6!&$*!

".%&"&'&";.!;A!&$*!1'@4"2!%2$;;4!24,%%0;;-!,.(!"&%!.;0-%!@*2,-*!&$*!;@M*2&%!;A!-)!

%&'()6!0,&$*0!&$,.!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!".("/"(',4%=!!

I)!*&$"2,4!.,/"9,&";.!;A!%'@M*2&%!,.(!;@M*2&%!:"&$".!A"*4(:;05!$,%!@**.!

".A;0-*(6!".!1,0&6!@)!C;0;&$)!H-"&$B%!:;05!;.!"%%'*%!;A!;@M*2&"A"2,&";.!".!

%;2";4;9"2,4!0*%*,02$=!C;0;&$)!H-"&$B%!>.%&"&'&";.,4!R&$.;90,1$)!3>R7!20"&"L'*%!

2;./*.&";.,4!H;2";4;9)6!,%!%$*!@*4"*/*%!"&!&0*,&%!1*;14*!,%!;@M*2&%!:"&$".!0*%*,02$=!!

Page 112: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UV[!

!

>.%&*,(!%$*!10;1;%*%!&$,&!0*%*,02$!1,0&"2"1,.&%!@*!1;%"&";.*(!,%!".A;0-,.&%!:$;!

,0*!*+1*0&%!".!&$*"0!*/*0)(,)!4"/*%=!D22;0(".9!&;!H-"&$6!&$*!10*-"%*!A;0!,!%&'()!

N(;*%.B&!@*9".!".!&$*;0)!@'&!".!&$*!,2&',4"&"*%!;A!1*;14*B%!4"/*%!:"&$!,!A;2'%!;.!

"./*%&"9,&";.!&$,&!2;-*%!A0;-!$;:!&$*)!1,0&"2"1,&*!".!;0!,0*!$;;5*(!'1!".&;!

".%&"&'&";.,4!0*4,&";.%O!3YVV]6!YVi7=!a"5*:"%*6!-)!%&'()!"%!1;%"&";.*(!A0;-!&$*!

%&,.(1;".&!;A!1*;14*B%!*/*0)(,)!4"/*%6!.;&!A0;-!1;4"2)!,.,4)%"%!;0!&$*;0"J".9!!"&!

1*;14*!,0*=!!!

>.!-)!;@%*0/,&";.%6!".&*0/"*:%6!,.(!A;2'%!90;'1%6!>!@*9,.!:"&$!H-"&$B%!

10*-"%*!&$,&!0*%*,02$!1,0&"2"1,.&%!,0*!".A;0-,.&%!A;06!0,&$*0!&$,.!;@M*2&%!;A6!%&'()=!

>.!&$"%!:,)6!>!@*9".!A0;-!&$*!%&,.(1;".&!;A!&$*!%&'(*.&%!,.(!&$*"0!*/*0)(,)!

*+1*0"*.2*%=!!D%!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1%!10;90*%%*(6!%;!&;;!("(!-)!A,-"4",0"&)!:"&$!&$*!

%&'(*.&%B!*/*0)(,)!4"/*%6!,.(!>!:,%!@*&&*0!,@4*!&;!,.,4)J*!$;:!&$*"0!(*%20"1&";.%!;A!

*/*.&%!:*0*!2;;0(".,&*(!@)!*/*0)(,)!;22'00*.2*%!&,5".9!14,2*!:"&$".!&$*!%2$;;4=!

b$"4*!-)!,110;,2$!&;!0*%*,02$!'%*%!&$"%!:;05!@)!H-"&$6!&$"%!10;M*2&!("(!.;&!@*2;-*!

,!A'44EA4*(9*(!>R=!!>&!("AA*0%!".!&:;!%"9."A"2,.&!0*%1*2&%=!b$"4*!>R!"(*.&"A"*%!

2;;0(".,&".9!&*+&%!@,%*(!;.!".A;0-,&";.!A0;-!1,0&"2"1,.&%6!-)!0*%*,02$!0*-,".*(!

A;2'%*(!;.!*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%=Yi!H*2;.(4)6!:$"4*!>R!&,5*%!"(*.&"A"*(!&*+&%!&;!-,1!;'&!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Yi!>.%&"&'&";.,4!*&$.;90,1$*0%!'%*!&$*!%&;0"*%!A0;-!&$*"0!".A;0-,.&%B!*/*0)(,)!

*+1*0"*.2*%!;A!&$*"0!:;05!&;!"./*%&"9,&*!$;:!&$*"0!*/*0)(,)!4"/*%!,0*!2;;0(".,&*(!@)!

&*+&%!,.(!$;:!&$*%*!&*+&%!,0*!4".5*(!".&;!4,09*0!".%&"&'&";.,4!1;:*0!;06!,%!H-"&$!2,44%!

"&6!0*4,&";.%!;A!0'4".9=!h;0!*+,-14*6!,!%;2",4!:;05*0!-,)!$,/*!&;!(;2'-*.&!&$*"0!

:;05!:"&$!A;0-%!3&*+&%7!&$,&!,0*!("/;02*(!A0;-!&$*"0!24"*.&B%!,2&',4!.**(%!@'&!

0*L'"0*(!@)!9;/*0.-*.&!1;4"2"*%=!!#$*!&*+&%!,0*!&$*.!1,0&!;A!N0*4,&";.%!;A!0'4".9O!&$,&!

2;;0(".,&*!&$*"0!*/*0)(,)!:;05!,.(!,0*!9"/*.!10"-,2)!;/*0!&$*!,2&',4!.**(%!;A!

24"*.&%!;0!:;05!&$*!%;2",4!:;05*0!-,)!(*%"0*!&;!(;=!>&!"%!&$*.!&$*!M;@!;A!&$*!

Page 113: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UV]!

!

N0*4,&";.%!;A!0'4".96O!&$*!0*%'4&%!;A!-)!%&'()!,.,4)J*!$;:!%'2$!10,2&"2*%!2;.&0"@'&*!

&;!,.!*/*0)(,)!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!:"&$".!&$*!%2$;;4=!h;0!*+,-14*6!".!N>.%&"&'&";.,4!

R&$.;90,1$)X!d%".9!>.&*0/"*:%!&;!>./*%&"9,&*!Q'4".9!Q*4,&";.%O!I,0M;0"*!C*?,'4&!

,.(!a"J,!I2S;)!A0,-*!&$*!".&*0/"*:!10;2*%%!,%!,!:,)!;A!A".(".9!(*&,"4%!.*2*%%,0)!&;!

*+14,".!,!1,0&"2'4,0!1$*.;-*.;.=!C*?,'4&!,.(!I2S;)!1'&!A;0:,0(!&$"%!10;2*%%!,%!

"./;4/".9!&$0**!%&*1%_N3,7!"(*.&"A)!,.!*+1*0"*.2*6!3@7!"(*.&"A)!%;-*!;A!&$*!

".%&"&'&";.,4!10;2*%%*%!&$,&!,0*!%$,1".9!&$,&!*+1*0"*.2*6!,.(!327!"./*%&"9,&*!&$;%*!

10;2*%%*%!".!;0(*0!&;!(*%20"@*!,.,4)&"2,44)!$;:!&$*)!%*1,0,&*!,%!&$*!90;'.(%!;A!&$*!

*+1*0"*.2*O!3YV7=!#$"%!,110;,2$!10;/*(!@*.*A"2",4!".!-'2$!;A!-)!(,&,!,.,4)%"%=!h;0!

*+,-14*6!:$*.!I,09,0*&!(*%20"@*(!$*0!:;05!&;!,((0*%%!$;-;1$;@",!".!$*0!

24,%%0;;-6!$*0!(*%20"1&";.!*/"(*.2*(!".%&"&'&";.,4!10;2*%%*%!&$,&!2'0&,"4*(!3*=9=!

1,0*.&,4!("%%*.&6!4,25!;A!0*%;'02*%7!,.(!*.,@4*(!3*=9=!10;90*%%"/*!1;4"2"*%7!$*0!

,110;,2$!3%**!S$,1&*0!H"+7=!!

"BEDFP<D`J$

DA&*0!*,2$!%1*2",4!;22,%";.!(,)6!>!$*4(!".&*0/"*:%!:"&$!&$*!24,%%0;;-!&*,2$*06!

H&'(*.&!H'11;0&!b;05*06!,.(!%&'(*.&!&*,2$*0!3:$*.!%$*!:,%!1,0&!;A!&$*!24,%%!

('0".9!I;&$*0B%!C,)7=!#$*!".&*0/"*:%!@*9,.!:"&$!L'*%&";.%!,@;'&!:$,&!&$*)!.;&"2*(!

,.(!0*A4*2&*(!;.!".!&*0-%!;A!&$*!24,%%0;;-!,2&"/"&"*%!,.(!:$,&!&;;5!14,2*!;/*0!&$*!

(,)6!&$'%!,((".9!&$*!*('2,&;0B%!".%"9$&%!,.(!0*,%;.".9!&;!-)!,.,4)%"%!;A!&$*!2'4&'0*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

0*%*,02$*0!&;!-,1!".%&"&'&";.,4!10,2&"2*%!".!,!:,)!&$,&!2,.!@*2;-*!,!'%,@4*!&;;4!A;0!

,2&"/"%&%!,.(!;&$*0%!4"/".9!%,"(!*+1*0"*.2*%!&;!A".(!*.&0)!1;".&%!A;0!:;05".9!&;:,0(!

".%&"&'&";.,4!2$,.9*=!!!!

!

Page 114: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UVk!

!

:"&$".!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!>!2;.('2&*(!&$*!%".94*!".&*0/"*:!:"&$!&$*!D@;0"9".,4!

R.$,.2*-*.&!b;05*0!3DRb76!I"2$*44*!R/*0*&&6!;.!$*0!0;4*!".!&$*!%2$;;4!,.(!$*0!

;@%*0/,&";.%!;A!&$*!".&*014,)!:"&$!9*.(*0!,.(!&$*!2'4&'0,4!:;05!%$*!2;.('2&*(!,%!,.!

*('2,&;0=!#$*!".&*0/"*:!:"&$!&$*!%2$;;4!10".2"1,4!,((0*%%*(!4,09*0!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*6!

$"%&;0)6!,.(!(*-;90,1$"2%=!!

#$*!DRb!"(*.&"A"*(!,%!$,/".9!I*&"%!,.(!`*:"%$!@,2590;'.(%!3%$*!("(!.;&!

%1*2"A)!A0;-!:$*0*7=!#$*!;&$*0!1,0&"2"1,.&%!,11*,0*(!&;!@*!;A!R'0;1*,.!(*2*.&!,.(!

("(!.;&!("%2'%%!&$*"0!*&$."2"&"*%=!>!0*,4"J*(6!".!$".(%"9$&6!&$,&!-)!L'*%&";.%!A;2'%*(!

*+24'%"/*4)!;.!&$*!1,0&"2"1,.&%B!10;A*%%";.,4!0;4*%6!0,&$*0!&$,.!&$*"0!1*0%;.,4!;0!

%;2",4!4;2,&";.%=!#$*0*A;0*6!:$"4*!>!,%5*(!,@;'&!&$*!%2$;;4!10".2"1,4!,@;'&!$*0!:;05!

,0;'.(!,.&"E0,2"%-!,.(!-'4&"2'4&'0,4"%-6!>!("(!.;&!,%5!,@;'&!$*0!;:.!*&$."2!

@,2590;'.(!,.(!$;:!"&!".A;0-*(!&$"%!:;05=!D%!&$"%!0*%'4&*(!".!("%24;%'0*!;A!

*&$."2"&)!,4;.9!0,2",4"J*(!4".*%6!".!A'&'0*!%&'("*%!>!:;'4(!A".(!,!:,)!&;!".2;01;0,&*!

("%2'%%";.%!;A!*&$."2!@,2590;'.(%6!".24'(".9!-)!;:.6!".&;!,44!&$*!".&*0/"*:%!%;!,%!&;!

,/;"(!:$"&*E:,%$".9!;A!2'4&'0,4!@,2590;'.(%!;A!&$;%*!:"&$!0,2",4"J*(!10"/"4*9*=!!

T;:*/*06!-;%&!1,0&"2"1,.&%!-,(*!-*.&";.!;A!&$*"0!9*.(*0!"(*.&"&"*%=!

I,09,0*&!Q;/*44,!("%2'%%*(!$;:!@*".9!,!:;-,.!:,%!2*.&0,4!&;!$*0!"(*.&"&)!,.(!&$,&!

@*".9!,!9"04!14,)*(!,!20"&"2,4!0;4*!".!$;:!%$*!'.(*0%&;;(!$*0%*4A!,%!,!2$"4(=!H$*!

%&,&*(X!

>!0*-*-@*0!90;:".9!'1!,.(!5.;:".9!/*0)!%&0;.94)X!>!:,%!,!9"04=!>!("(.B&!

.*2*%%,0"4)!A"&!".!:"&$!,44!&$".9%!9"04)6!@'&!&$,&!:,%!,!/*0)!%&0;.9!1,0&!;A!:$;!>!

A*4&!>!:,%!,.(!M'%&!*/*.!.;:!$;:!>!A**4!>!,-!,%!,!:;-,.6!4"5*!>!,-!,!:;-,.6!

Page 115: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UVi!

!

&$,&B%!$;:!>!"(*.&"A)=!D.(!A;0!-*!"&!:,%!.;!10;@4*-!M'%&!5".(!;A!.;!10;@4*-!

9;".9!&$0;'9$!4"A*!:"&$!&$,&!"(*,!3Q;/*44,!YV!h*@=!YVUY7=!

#$"%!:,%!@0;'9$&!'1!".!&$*!2;.&*+&!;A!("%2'%%".9!$;:!"-1;0&,.&!%$*!@*4"*/*(!

"&!:,%!&;!4*,0.!$;:!&;!-,5*!0;;-!".!$*0!24,%%!A;0!2$"4(0*.!:$;!-,)!@*!&0,.%9*.(*0!

%".2*!%$*6!,%!,!2"%!:;-,.6!'.(*0%&;;(!:$,&!"&!:,%!&;!*+1*0"*.2*!;.*B%!9*.(*0!,%!

"-1;0&,.&=!I,09,0*&!0*2;9."J*(!&$,&!&$;%*!:$;%*!"(*.&"&"*%!("(!.;&!,4"9.!:"&$!&$*"0!

9*.(*0*(!@"0&$!,%%"9.-*.&%!-,)!,4%;!*+1*0"*.2*!9*.(*0%!,%!,!10"-,0)!1,0&!;A!

&$*-%*4/*%=!I,09,0*&!*4,@;0,&*(!&$,&!%$*!0*,4"J*(!&$,&!&$*0*!2;'4(!@*!5"(%!".!$*0!

;:.!24,%%!:$;!:;'4(!@*!L'**0!;0!&0,.%9*.(*0!,.(!&$,&6!N"A!&$*)B0*!.;&!A**4".9!&$,&!

0"9$&!.;:6!&$*)!2;'4(!@*!A**4".9!&$,&!.*+&!)*,0!;0!2;'14*!)*,0%O!3)/)%7=!!I,09,0*&!

(*%20"@*(!$;:!%$*!$,(!@**.!:;.(*0".9!$;:!&;!$*41!$*0!%&'(*.&%!9*&!,!%*.%*!&$,&!

N"&B%!;5,)!&;!@*!:$;!&$*)!,0*!.;:!%;!&$,&!:$*.!&$;%*!"%%'*%!;0!A**4".9%!;0!L'*%&";.%!

,@;'&!&$*-%*4/*%!2;-*!'16!&$*)B44!$,/*!&$*!2;.A"(*.2*!&;!A;2'%!;.!&$*!"-1;0&,.2*!;A!

@*".9!&0'*!&;!&$*-%*4/*%O!3)/)%7=!!

I"2$*44*!R/*0*&&!,.(!&$*!%2$;;4!10".2"1,46!S,0;4".*!P*4%;.6!("(!.;&!("%2'%%!

&$*"0!;:.!9*.(*0%!;0!%*+',4"&"*%=!D%!>!$,/*!(*%20"@*(!*,04"*06!I"2$*44*!%$,0*(!

("AA*0*.&!:,)%!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)!:*0*!'.(*0%&;;(!".!$*0!2'4&'0,4!@,2590;'.(%=!

S,0;4".*!&,45*(!,@;'&!$,/".9!0,"%*(!9,)!2$"4(0*.!3,.(!,11*,0*(!&;!$,/*!,!1"2&'0*!;A!

;.*!:"&$!,!1,0&.*0!'1!".!$*0!;AA"2*7=!!

D-)!C,/"%6!&$*!%&'(*.&E&*,2$*06!("(!.;&!,11*,0!&;!$,/*!&$;'9$&!-'2$!,@;'&!

&$*!0;4*!;A!$*0!;:.!"(*.&"&)6!;0!("AA*0".9!9*.(*0%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%6!".!$*0!&*,2$".9!

10,2&"2*=!H$*!%&,&*(6!N"&!(;*%.B&!-,&&*0!:$,&!&$*"0!%*+',4!;0"*.&,&";.!"%6!:$,&!&$*"0!

Page 116: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UVZ!

!

9*.(*0!"%=!>B-!M'%&!&0)".9!&;!@*!0*,44)!*L',4u!"A!>!2;-*!,20;%%!"&6!"&B%!.;&!0*,44)!,!@"9!

&$".9u!>!(;.B&!&$".5!,@;'&!"&!&;;!-'2$O!3C,/"%!UY!I,)!YVUY7=!#$0;'9$;'&!&$"%!%&'()6!

>!*+14;0*!$;:!%'2$!%*.&"-*.&%!1;%"&";.!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!,%!

%1*2",4!*/*.&%!&$,&!-"9$&!$,11*.=!>.!&$*!A;44;:".9!2$,1&*0%6!>!*+,-".*!$;:!:,"&".9!

A;0!,!%&'(*.&!&;!2;-*!;'&!@*A;0*!,((0*%%".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)6!.;0-,4"J*%!

&$*!2;-".9!;'&!10;2*%%!,%!,!1,".A'4!(*1,0&'0*!A0;-!90;'1!@*4;.9".9=!!

D-)!*4,@;0,&*(!&$,&!%$*!:,%!S,&$;4"2!,.(!$,(!@;&$!,&&*.(*(!,.(!2;.('2&*(!

$*0!/;4'.&**0!$;'0%!30*L'"0*(!A;0!,(-"%%";.!".&;!'."/*0%"&)!&*,2$*0!&0,".".9!

10;90,-%7!,&!,!S,&$;4"2!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4=!H$*!%&,&*(!&$,&!%$*!("(.B&!5.;:!"A!;0!$;:!

%$*!:;'4(!$,.(4*!,!%"&',&";.!;A!,!%&'(*.&!2;-".9!;'&!&;!$*06!;0!,11*,0".9!&;!@*!

L'**0!;0!&0,.%9*.(*06!:*0*!%$*!".!,!S,&$;4"2!%2$;;4!*./"0;.-*.&=!D-)!1;.(*0*(6!

Nb$,&!:;'4(!>!(;!"A!&$"%!:,%!@0;'9$&!'1!".!,!S,&$;4"2!24,%%0;;-e!>!(;.B&!5.;:!$;:!

&$*!%2$;;4!(*,4%!:"&$!"&!,.(!>!(;.B&!5.;:!$;:!&$*)!:,.&!-*!&;!(*,4!:"&$!"&6!B2,'%*!"&B%!

,!/*0)!&;'2$)!"%%'*6!0"9$&eO!3)/)%7=!T*0!14,2*-*.&!,&!H;'&$!H"(*!R4*-*.&,0)!H2$;;4!

:,%!$*0!A"0%&!*+1*0"*.2*!".!,!1'@4"2!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4=!#$*!-,..*0!:"&$!:$"2$!D-)!

10*("2&*(!%$*!:;'4(!0*%1;.(!&;!5.;:4*(9*!;A!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%&'(*.&%6!

("AA*0*(!(*1*.(".9!;.!:$*&$*0!%$*!"-,9".*(!%'2$!5.;:4*(9*!;22'00".9!".!&$*!?HF6!

:"&$!"&%!".24'%"/*!1;4"2"*%6!;0!:"&$".!,!%2$;;4!:"&$;'&!%,A*!%1,2*!1;4"2"*%!A;0!L'**0!

,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%&'(*.&%=!D-)B%!%&,&*-*.&!0*-".(*(!-*!;A!&$*!H&'(*.&!H'11;0&!

b;05*0!3HHb76!`,-*%B!(*%20"1&";.!;A!$;:!$*!*+1*0"*.2*(!&$*!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*!,%!

.*'&0,46!:$*0*@)!.*'&0,4!-*,.&!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!@'&!.;&!$;-;1$;@"2!".!

%'2$!,!:,)!&$,&!$*!A*,0*(!A;0!$"%!%,A*&)=!!

Page 117: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UVW!

!

#;:,0(!&$*!*.(!;A!-)!A"*4(:;056!>!-,(*!-*.&";.!&;!$,/".9!@**.!".!,!L'**0!

2$;"0!('0".9!,!%&,AA!2;./*0%,&";.!,@;'&!2;--'."&)!2$;"0%!".!?,.2;'/*0=!I)!.*+&!

".&*0/"*:!:"&$!`,-*%!2;.&,".*(!-'2$!-;0*!(*1&$!,%!&;!$"%!*+1*0"*.2*%!;'&%"(*!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!,%!,!4;.9E&*0-!*-14;)**!:"&$!&$*!?HF=YZ!#$;'9$!>!$,(!

&$;'9$&!&$,&!>!$,(!-,(*!-)!L'**0!%'@M*2&!1;%"&";.!*+14"2"&6!&$"%!*+2$,.9*!2,'%*(!-*!

&;!L'*%&";.!:$*&$*0!;0!.;&!&$*!,('4&!1,0&"2"1,.&%!$,(6!".!A,2&6!0*,(!-*!,%!L'**0=!D%!

:"&$!-;0*!*+14"2"&!&,45!,@;'&!*&$."2"&)6!>!:;'4(6!".!$".(%"9$&6!-,5*!&$*!2$;"2*!&;!

-,5*!*+14"2"&!&$*!("%2'%%";.!;A!-)!;:.!1;%"&";.,4"&)!".!;0(*0!&;!A'0&$*0!%"&',&*!

-)%*4A!:"&$".!&$*!0*%*,02$=!!

#$*!".&*0/"*:%!:*0*!2;.('2&*(!".!10"/,&*!%&'()!0;;-%6!;0!".!&$*!*.24;%*(!

4'.2$0;;-!:$*.!;&$*0%!:*0*!.;&!10*%*.&=!!#$*!".&*0/"*:%!:*0*!%*-"E%&0'2&'0*(!

,.(!4,09*4)!".A;0-,4=!D&!&$*!@*9"..".9!;A!*,2$!".&*0/"*:6!>!:;'4(!0*-".(!&$*!

1,0&"2"1,.&%!&$,&!&$*)!:*0*!A0**!.;&!&;!,.%:*0!,.)!L'*%&";.!,.(!:*0*!A0**!&;!%$,0*!

".A;0-,&";.!&$*)!(**-*(!0*4*/,.&!&$,&!-)!L'*%&";.%!("(!.;&!,((0*%%=!b$"4*!&$*!

".&*0/"*:%!*.2;-1,%%*(!,!:*,4&$!;A!".A;0-,&";.!0*9,0(".9!&$*!*('2,&;0%B!

1*0%1*2&"/*%!;.!,.(!*.9,9*-*.&!:"&$!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%6!&$*!

".&*0/"*:%!;A&*.!$,(!,.!".A;0-,46!2;./*0%,&";.,4!&;.*=!#$*!1,0&"2"1,.&%!$,(!&$*!

;11;0&'."&)!&;!0*/"*:!&0,.%20"1&%!A0;-!&$*"0!".&*0/"*:%!,.(!-,5*!2$,.9*%!&;!&$*"0!

;:.!%&,&*-*.&%!&$,&!&$*)!("(!.;&!A**4!2;./*)*(!:$,&!&$*)!:"%$*(!&;!2;./*)=!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

YZ!#$*!(*1&$!;A!".A;0-,&";.!`,-*%!%$,0*(!".!&$"%!".&*0/"*:!-,)!$,/*!@**.!('*!&;!&$*!

4*.9&$!;A!-)!%&,)!$,/".9!".20*,%*(!A,-"4",0"&)!,.(!,!%*.%*!;A!2;-A;0&!,.(!.;&!('*!&;!

,!2$,.9*!".!$"%!1*02*1&";.!;A!-)!%*+',4"&)=!

Page 118: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UUV!

!

)8JDFPAE<?BJ$

K/*0!&$0**!-;.&$%6!>!2;.('2&*(!&$"%!%&'()!:"&$!;.*!24,%%!;A!%&'(*.&%!,.(!

*('2,&;0%=!#$"%!*.,@4*(!-*!&;!;@%*0/*!2'4&'0,4!&0*.(%!".!&$*!%,-*!90;'1B%!

".&*0,2&";.%!;/*0!&"-*=!>&!,4%;!9,/*!*('2,&;0%!,.(!%&'(*.&%!&$*!;11;0&'."&)!&;!

@*2;-*!2;-A;0&,@4*!:"&$!-)!10*%*.2*6!&$'%!-"."-"J".9!%*4AE2;.%2";'%!@*$,/";'0=!

I)!;@%*0/,&";.%!&;;5!14,2*!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-6!4'.2$0;;-%6!,.(!;.!&$*!14,)90;'.(6!

:$"2$!,44;:*(!-*!&;!.;&*!2$,.9*%!".!10,2&"2*%!(*1*.(".9!;.!&$*!%*&&".9!,.(!$;:!

&$"%!%1;5*!&;!&$*!;/*0,44!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!".!&$*!%2$;;4!*./"0;.-*.&=!I)!;@%*0/,&";.%!

%;'9$&!&;!2;.&0"@'&*!,.%:*0%!&;!&$*!L'*%&";.%X!

• T;:!(;!&$*!A;0-,4!2'00"2'4'-6!".A;0-,4!10,2&"2*%!3&,456!@*$,/";'06!@;()!

4,.9',9*6!,.(!;&$*0!".&*0,2&";.%76!,.(!,2&"/"&"*%!;.!%1*2",4!;22,%";.!(,)%6!

:;05!:"&$!,.(!,9,".%&!*,2$!;&$*0!&;!10;('2*!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!".!,.!*,04)!

*4*-*.&,0)!24,%%0;;-e!

• T;:!,0*!/,0";'%!%"&*%!;A!%;2",4!10"/"4*9*!,.(!-,09".,4"J,&";.!@;'.(!&;9*&$*0!

:"&$".!&$"%!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!3*=9=!0,2*6!24,%%6!("%,@"4"&)7e!!

#$*!;@%*0/,&";.%!&;;5!14,2*!,.):$*0*!&$*!%&'(*.&%!:*.&!3&$*!24,%%0;;-6!

14,)90;'.(6!4'.2$0;;-6!,.(!9)-7!&$0;'9$;'&!&$*"0!%2$;;4!(,)%6!".24'(".9!('0".9!

0*2*%%!,.(!4'.2$=!>!A;2'%*(!;.!".A;0-,4!10,2&"2*%!&$,&!&;;5!14,2*!@*&:**.!%&'(*.&%!

,.(!@*&:**.!%&,AA!,.(!%&'(*.&%!,%!&$*!%2$;;4!24"-,&*!"%!-,(*!".!1,0&.*0%$"1!

@*&:**.!,('4&%!,.(!2$"4(0*.6!,.(!@*&:**.!2$"4(0*.!3#$;0.*7!,.(!%,"(!24"-,&*!"%!.;&!

*%&,@4"%$*(!,.(!1*01*&',&*(!%;4*4)!@)!:$,&!*('2,&;0%!*+14"2"&4)!&*,2$!2$"4(0*.=!#$"%!

:,%!,4%;!-)!0*,%;.!A;0!5**1".9!-)!A;2'%!;.!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!".!8".(*09,0&*.!&$,&!

Page 119: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UUU!

!

&;;5!14,2*!:$"4*!&$*!2$"4(0*.!:*0*!10*%*.&=!#$*0*A;0*!".&*0,2&";.%!&$,&!&;;5!14,2*!

".(*1*.(*.&4)!A0;-!&$*!%&'(*.&%6!%'2$!,%!2;./*0%,&";.%!".!&$*!%&,AA0;;-6!:*0*!.;&!

".24'(*(!".!-)!%&'()!,%!>!9"/*!10"-,2)!&;!2$"4(0*.B%!2'4&'0*!,.(!*/*0)(,)!4"/*%=!!

K.!-)!A"0%&!(,)!;A!A"*4(:;056!I,09,0*&!Q;/*44,!".&0;('2*(!-*!&;!&$*!24,%%!

('0".9!&$*"0!-;0.".9!2"024*=!>!&;4(!&$*!90;'1!&$,&!>!9;!&;!,!'."/*0%"&)!".!?,.2;'/*0!

,.(!&$,&!;.*!;A!&$*!*+2"&".9!&$".9%!>!9*&!&;!(;!".!'."/*0%"&)!"%!:0"&*!,!@;;5!,@;'&!

%;-*&$".9!>B-!".&*0*%&*(!".=!>!%,"(!&$,&!>!:,%!".&*0*%&*(!".!:$,&!"&B%!4"5*!&;!@*!,!5"(!".!

,!8".(*09,0&*.!24,%%0;;-!,&!&$*"0!%2$;;4!,.(!".A;0-*(!&$*-!&$,&!&$*)!:;'4(!%**!-*!

:0"&".9!;.!-)!2;-1'&*0!:$*.!&$".9%!$,11*.*(!&$,&!-,(*!-*!&$".56!N&$"%!&*44%!-*!,!

@"&!,@;'&!:$,&!"&B%!4"5*!&;!@*!,!5"(!".!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4!$*0*cO!!I)!:,)!;A!A0,-".9!

&$*!%&'()!:,%!-;(*4*(6!".!1,0&6!;.!F,00"*!#$;0.*B%!,22;'.&%!;A!$;:!%$*!,.%:*0*(!

2$"4(0*.B%!L'*%&";.%!,@;'&!$*0!10*%*.2*!".!,!:,)!&$,&!:,%!%&0,"9$&A;0:,0(!,.(!.;.E

,22'%,&;0)_A;0!*+,-14*6!;-"&&".9!:;0(%!%'2$!,%!o@*$,/";'0B!,.(!o(;".9B!&$,&!

20*,&*(!,!%*.%*!A;0!&$*!2$"4(0*.!&$,&!%$*!:,%!-;."&;0".9!:$,&!&$*)!-"9$&!@*!(;".9!

:0;.9!3Ui7_,.(!".%&*,(!&*44".9!&$*-!&$,&!%$*!"%!".&*0*%&*(!".!:$,&!&$*)!4"5*!;0!

N:$,&!"&B%!4"5*!&;!@*!,!5"(O!3UZ7=!!

>!".&*.&";.,44)!5*1&!&$*!4,.9',9*!9*.*0,4!,.(!("(!.;&!*+14"2"&4)!".&0;('2*!

%&'()".9!9*.(*0!,%!>!:,%!".!,!@".(!0*9,0(".9!4,.9',9*=!>!("(!.;&!:,.&!&;!".&0;('2*!

9*.(*0!,%!%&'()".9!N@;)%O!,.(!N9"04%6O!,%!>!("(!.;&!:"%$!&;!0*10;('2*!,!9*.(*0!

("2$;&;-)!".!:$"2$!%&'(*.&%!2;'4(!A**4!A'0&$*0!2;-1*44*(!&;!"(*.&"A)!,%!;.*!;0!&$*!

;&$*0=!>!,4%;!("(!.;&!:,.&!&;!*%&,@4"%$!-)%*4A!:"&$".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!,%!%;-*;.*!

&*,2$".9!,!.*:!2;.2*1&!,.(!5.*:!-,.)!%&'(*.&%!$,(!.*/*0!$*,0(!("AA*0*.&!

Page 120: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UUY!

!

4,.9',9*!A;0!9*.(*0!34,&*0!".!&$"%!2$,1&*0!>!A'0&$*0!("%2'%%!$;:!>!-,.*'/*0*(!:"&$".!

&$*!24,%%0;;-!%;!.;&!&;!;/*0&4)!,11*,0!,%!,.!,'&$;0"&)!A"9'0*7=!!

DA&*0!-)!".&0;('2&";.6!I,09,0*&!,%5*(!&$*!%&'(*.&%!"A!&$*)!$,(!,.)!L'*%&";.%!

,.(!,&!4*,%&!$,4A!,!(;J*.!$,.(%!%$;&!'1!"--*(",&*4)!&;!,%5!-*!,@;'&!-)!2;-1'&*06!

&;!&*44!-*!,@;'&!:$*.!&$*)B(!%**.!-*!;.!-)!@"2)24*6!;0!:$*.!&$*)B(!%**.!-*!".!&$*!

$,44=!`*&&"*6!,!@;"%&*0;'%!%&'(*.&!:$;!M'-1*(!".&;!*/*0)!(",4;9'*6!,%5*(!:$)!>!:0;&*!

;.!-)!2;-1'&*0=!>!&;4(!$*0!&$,&!*/*0);.*!$,%!("AA*0*.&!:,)%!&$*)!4"5*!&;!0*-*-@*0!

&$".9%!@'&!>!0*-*-@*0!@*%&!@)!:0"&".9!;.!-)!2;-1'&*0=!#$*!2$"4(0*.!:*0*!/*0)!

".&*0*%&*(!".!-)!2;-1'&*0!&$0;'9$;'&!-)!A"*4(:;05!,.(!;A&*.!1**0*(!;/*0!-)!

%$;'4(*0!&;!,%5!:$,&!>!:,%!:0"&".9!,@;'&!,&!&$,&!-;-*.&=!DA&*0!90,114".9!:"&$!$;:!

&;!0*%1;.(!&;!&$"%6!>!5*1&!,!1"2&'0*!;1*.!;.!-)!2;-1'&*0=!#$*!1"2&'0*!:,%!;A!,!@*,2$!

A0;-!,!&0"1!>B(!&,5*.!&;!T,:,"B"=!b$*.!>!.;&"2*(!,!%&'(*.&!,110;,2$".9!-*6!>!:;'4(!

24"25!;.!&$*!1"2&'0*!%;!&$,&!"&!:,%!&$*!A"0%&!&$".9!&$*)!:;'4(!%**!:$*.!&$*)!4;;5*(!,&!

&$*!%20**.=!#$*)!:;'4(!&$*.!,%5!:$*0*!&$*!1"2&'0*!:,%!A0;-!,.(!&*44!-*!,@;'&!$;:!

&$*)6!;0!%;-*;.*!&$*)!5.*:6!$,(!@**.!&;!T,:,"B"6!;0!&;!&$*!@*,2$6!,A&*0!:$"2$!&$*)!

:;'4(!-;/*!;.!,.(!>!:;'4(!0*&'0.!&;!-)!A"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!!

>!:,%!,:,0*!&$,&!@;&$!&$*!(*2"%";.!&;!&*44!(*&,"4%!,%!:*44!,%!&$*!(*2"%";.!.;&!&;!

&*44!(*&,"4%6!$*4(!"-14"2,&";.%!A;0!(,&,!".&*010*&,&";.=!!T;:*/*06!>!$,(!2;.2*0.%!

0*9,0(".9!&$*!1;&*.&",4!*&$"2%!;A!".A4'*.2".9!24,%%0;;-!().,-"2%!"A!>!0*2;'.&*(!&;!

;.*!2$"4(6!.;&*%!>!$,(!&,5*.!;.!,.;&$*0=!>!2;.%*L'*.&4)!0*%"9.*(!-)%*4A!&;!&$"%!

("/*0%";.=!T;:*/*06!>!:;'4(!,.%:*0!9*.*0,4!L'*%&";.%!,%!&;!:$,&!5".(%!;A!&$".9%!>!

Page 121: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UUf!

!

:0;&*!,@;'&X!*=9=6!&$,&!>!$,(!:0"&&*.!,@;'&!,!2;./*0%,&";.!&$,&!$,(!&,5*.!14,2*!,@;'&!

,!@;;5!&$,&!:,%!0*,(!".!24,%%!&$,&!(,)!;0!,@;'&!9,-*%!&$,&!$,(!@**.!14,)*(!,&!0*2*%%=!!

b$*.!>!@*9,.!-)!%&'()6!%&'(*.&%!,%%"-"4,&*(!-*!".&;!&$*"0!'.(*0%&,.(".9%!;A!

,('4&%!".!&$*"0!24,%%0;;-%X!&$*)!,%5*(!-*!A;0!$*41!;.!,%%"9.-*.&%6!$*41!:"&$!&)".9!

&$*"0!%$;*%6!,.(!:"&$!2;.A4"2&!0*%;4'&";.=!b$"4*!>!("(!&"*!&$*!;22,%";.,4!%$;*4,2*!;/*0!

&$*!2;'0%*!;A!-)!A"*4(:;056!>!%$"*(!,:,)!A0;-!,.)!2;00*2&"/*!;0!("%2"14".,0)!

-*,%'0*%=!b"&$".!&$*!(;-".,.&!1;:*0!-"4"*'!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%6!,('4&%!$,/*!1;:*0!

;/*0!2$"4(0*.!".!-,.)!0*%1*2&%=!>!:,.&*(!&;!-"&"9,&*!&$"%!1;:*0!:$*0*!>!2;'4(!%;!

&$,&!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!%*4AE2*.%;0%$"1!,0;'.(!,'&$;0"&)!A"9'0*%!:;'4(!@*!,&!,!-"."-'-!

,0;'.(!-*!('0".9!-)!A"*4(:;05!;@%*0/,&";.%=!>!%&0;/*!&;!(*/*4;1!0,11;0&!,.(!

*%&,@4"%$!-)%*4A!,%!2;-A;0&,@4*!,.(!.;.EM'(9-*.&,4!10*%*.2*=!>!;A&*.!0*%1;.(*(!&;!

%&'(*.&!2;-14,".&%!,@;'&!,.;&$*0!%&'(*.&B%!@*$,/";'0!:"&$!2;--*.&%!%'2$!,%6!N>B-!

%;00)!&;!$*,0!&$,&6O!;0!N&$,&B%!&;;!@,(!);'0!0*2*%%!:,%!$,0(=O!^*.*0,44)6!&$"%!:,%!

%'AA"2"*.&!A;0!%&'(*.&%!:$;!;A&*.!0*%1;.(*(!@)!.;((".9!*-1$,&"2,44)!,.(!-;/".9!;.!

&;!&$*"0!.*+&!,2&"/"&)=!>!:;'4(!0*0;'&*!0*L'*%&%!A;0!$*41!:"&$!%2$;;4:;05!@)!&*44".9!

&$*-!&$,&!&$*"0!&*,2$*0!:;'4(!$*41!&$*-!,%!%;;.!,%!%$*!2;'4(=!!

I)!24,%%0;;-!;A!%&'()!2;.%"%&*(!;A!*"9$&**.!A"/*!,.(!%"+!)*,0!;4(!

8".(*09,0&*.!%&'(*.&%=!D%!"%!2$,0,2&*0"%&"2!;A!&$*!.*"9$@;'0$;;(6!&$*!24,%%0;;-!:,%!

A,"04)!-"+*(X!A;'0!2$"4(0*.!$,(!S$".*%*!$*0"&,9*%!3;.*!A0;-!@;&$!S$".,!,.(!d9,.(,6!

,.;&$*0!A0;-!S$".,!,.(!&$*!G$"4"11".*%76!&$0**!8;0*,.6!&:;!D@;0"9".,4!3;.*!:"&$!,!

Page 122: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UU[!

!

R'0;1*,.!@,2590;'.(!,%!:*44!,%!D@;0"9".,476!,.(!A"/*!:"&$!,!-"+!;A!b*%&*0.!

R'0;1*,.!$*0"&,9*%=YW!!

D%!1,0&!;A!2;.('2&".9!,.&"E;110*%%";.!A;2'%*(!0*%*,02$6!>!%;'9$&!,/*.'*%!A;0!

0*2"10;2"&)!:"&$!&$*!1,0&"2"1,.&%=!K.*!,0*,!;A!0*2"10;2"&)!:"&$!A"/*!)*,0!;4(%!:,%!M'%&!

&;!@*!,.!,AA"0-,&"/*!10*%*.2*_&$,&!>!("(!-)!@*%&!&;!'.(*0%&,.(!&$*"0!1;".&%!;A!/"*:6!

&$*"0!14,)!,.(!&$*"0!A,.&,%&"2,4!:;04(%!:"&$;'&!M'(9-*.&6!&*,2$".96!;0!".&*0/*.&";.6!

:,%!/*0)!:*44!0*2*"/*(!@)!,44!:$;!1,0&"2"1,&*(!".!-)!0*%*,02$=!>!:,%!90,&*A'4!A;0!

:$,&!&$*)!%$,0*(!:"&$!-*!,.(!-,(*!%'0*!&;!*+10*%%!&$,&!&;!&$*-6!:$"2$!9*.*0,&*(!

,.!*./"0;.-*.&!;A!0*%1*2&=!#;:,0(!&$*!*.(!;A!-)!A"*4(:;056!&$*0*!:*0*!,!A*:!(,)%!

".!:$"2$!>!:,%!*"&$*0!,@%*.&!;0!,00"/*(!4,&*0!('*!&;!;@4"9,&";.%!,&!-)!'."/*0%"&)=!>!

$,(!$*,0(!A0;-!&$*!*('2,&;0%!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!&$,&!&$*!2$"4(0*.!$,(!,%5*(!,@;'&!-*!

.;.E%&;1!,.(!*+10*%%*(!2;.2*0.!0*9,0(".9!-)!,@%*.2*=!F*2,'%*!;A!&$"%6!>!:,.&*(!&;!

-,5*!%'0*!&$*)!$,(!,!%*.%*!;A!24;%'0*!,&!&$*!*.(!;A!-)!%&'()=!!

C'0".9!&$*"0!*.(E;AE(,)!2"024*!&"-*!;.!-)!4,%&!(,)!:"&$!&$*!24,%%6!>!0,.!,!%-,44!

,2&"/"&)=!#$*!,2&"/"&)!:,%!%"-14*6!0*L'"0".9!;.4)!,!@,44!;A!),0.!,.(!%;-*!%2"%%;0%=!>!

%&,0&*(!@)!%,)".9!;.*!-*-;0)!>!$,(!('0".9!-)!%&,)=!>!&;4(!,@;'&!&$*!&"-*!*/*0);.*!

-,(*!-;'%&,2$*%6!&,"4%6!,.(!*)*@0;:%!:"&$!%&0*,-*0%6!:$"2$!0*%'4&*(!".!-;%&!;A!&$*!

24,%%!9"994".9!,.(!2,44".9!;'&!N;$!)*,$O!,.(!N>B(!A;09;&&*.!,@;'&!&$,&O!3h"*4(:;05!

.;&*%!UZ!I,)!YVUY7=!>!&$*.!:0,11*(!),0.!,0;'.(!-)!:0"%&!,.(!&$0*:!&$*!0*%&!;A!&$*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

YW!>!4*,0.*(!,@;'&!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!@,2590;'.(!('0".9!,!24,%%0;;-!,2&"/"&)!".!:$"2$!&$*!

2$"4(0*.!("%2'%%*(!&$*!2;'.&0"*%!&$*"0!A,-"4"*%!:*0*!A0;-!,.(!1'&!A4,9%!;.!,!-,1!;A!

&$*!:;04(!3&$*)!$,(!@0;'9$&!.;&*%!A0;-!$;-*!0*9,0(".9!&$*"0!A,-"4)B%!,.2*%&0)7!

3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!U[<V]<UY7=!

Page 123: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UU]!

!

@,44!&;!,!2$"4(!,20;%%!&$*!2"024*=!#$*)!&$*.!&;4(!;.*!-*-;0)!&$*)!$,(!;A!;'0!&"-*!

&;9*&$*0!,.(!&$0*:!&$*!),0.!&;!%;-*;.*!*4%*=!#$"%!2;.&".'*(!'.&"4!*/*0);.*!:,%!

$,(!),0.!,0;'.(!&$*"0!:0"%&%!,.(!$,(!%&,&*(!,!-*-;0)!3&$*0*!:*0*!&$*!;1&";.%!;A!

.;&!1,0&"2"1,&".9!;0!;A!1,0&"2"1,&".9!:"&$;'&!%,)".9!,.)&$".96!@'&!.;!;.*!-,(*!&$;%*!

2$;"2*%7=!b*!&$*.!0,"%*(!;'0!$,.(%!;/*0!;'0!$*,(%6!:"&$!&$*!),0.!-,5".9!,!:*@!;/*0!

'%=!>!%&,&*(!&$,&!*/*.!&$;'9$!:*!:;'4(.B&!,44!@*!".!&$*!%,-*!24,%%6!:*!2;'4(!&,5*!,44!

;A!&$*%*!-*-;0"*%!:"&$!'%=!#$"%!:,%!-*&!:"&$!%$;'&%!;A!N:;:6O!,.(!N;$!2;;4O!3)/)%7=!

>!&$*.!2'&!&$*!*+2*%%!),0.!,:,)6!4*,/".9!&$*!1"*2*%!&$,&!&$*)!$,(!:0,11*(!,0;'.(!

&$*"0!:0"%&%!:"&$!&$*-!&;!&,5*!$;-*=!!>!&$,.5*(!&$*-!,9,".!A;0!%$,0".9!&$*"0!%&;0"*%!

,.(!&"-*!:"&$!-*=!I,.)!4*A&!&,45".9!,@;'&!$;:!&$*)!:;'4(!5**1!&$*"0!%&0".9%!".!

%1*2",4!14,2*%=!>.!,(("&";.!&;!10;/"(".9!24;%'0*6!>!$;1*(!&$*!,2&"/"&)!:;'4(!%*0/*!,%!,!

.;.E2;*02"/*!:,)!;A!(*-;.%&0,&".9!-)!0*2;9."&";.!;A!&$*"0!2;.&0"@'&";.%!&;!&$"%!

%&'()=!!

;?ZHJ$2F?H=J$$ $

#$*!A;2'%!90;'1!&;1"2%!%*&!;'&!&;!"./*%&"9,&*!&$0**!&0*.(%!:"&$".!*('2,&";.,4!

%2$;4,0%$"1!;.!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!$*&*0;%*+"%-!3F0'$-!,.(!T'04*)6!C'5*6!`,-"4!,.(!

T,01*06!T,%5*44!,.(!F'0&2$6!a;'&J*.$*"J*06!I,2>.&;%$6!H&,AA;0(6!H&;25&;.6!b"45".%;.!

,.(!G*,0%;.7X!,110;10",&*<".,110;10",&*!4;/*6!39*.(*0*(7!@'44)".96!,.(!A,-"4)=!#$*!

&$0**!(,)%!:*0*!2$;%*.!&;!9*.*0,&*!("%2'%%";.!,0;'.(!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!

,%!"&!1*0&,".%!&;X!90;'1!().,-"2%!,.(!%)-@;4%!;A!A0"*.(%$"16!9*.(*0*(!%&)4*!,.(!

90;'1!@*4;.9".9!3@'44)".9<&*,%".976!,.(!A,-"4"*%=!#$*!L'*%&";.%!3%**!D11*.("+!U7!

%;'9$&!&;!'.*,0&$!:,)%!2$"4(0*.!".!&$*!8".(*09,0&*.!24,%%!:*0*!.,/"9,&".9!

Page 124: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UUk!

!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!%'00;'.(".9!&$*%*!&;1"2%=!!#$*!L'*%&";.%!:*0*!%1*2"A"2,44)!

9*,0*(!&;!"./*%&"9,&*X!

• $;:!&$*!2$"4(0*.!*%&,@4"%$!,.(!.,/"9,&*!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4!N.;0-%OfV!,.(!

• :$,&!&$"%!%,)%!,@;'&!&$*!0;4*!;A!%&'(*.&%!".!1,0&"2"1,&".9!".!.;0-,&"/*!%2$;;4!

4"A*=!!!

h;0!*,2$!%1*2",4!;22,%";.!(,)!>!$*4(!&$0**!A;2'%!90;'1%!".24'(".9!,44!

,%%*.&".9!%&'(*.&%!".!&$*!24,%%!:$;!$,(!1,0*.&,4!2;.%*.&=!R,2$!A;2'%!90;'1!$,(!

,110;+"-,&*4)!A;'0!%&'(*.&%_*.;'9$!2$"4(0*.!&$,&!&$*)!2;'4(!("%2'%%!&$*!

L'*%&";.%!:"&$!*,2$!;&$*06!@'&!.;&!%;!-,.)!&$,&!&$*!L'"*&*0!2$"4(0*.!4,25*(!

;11;0&'."&)!&;!%1*,5!;0!$,(!,!%*.%*!;A!%1*,5".9!".!A0;.&!;A!,44!&$*"0!1**0%=!!#$*!A;2'%!

90;'1%!2;-14*-*.&!-)!;@%*0/,&";.%!,%!&$*)!,44;:*(!%&'(*.&%B!%&;0"*%!&;!$,/*!

".20*,%*(!10"-,2)!".!-)!,.,4)%"%!;A!&$*!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*!,.(!,%%"%&*(!".!1;%"&".9!

%&'(*.&%!,%!,2&"/*!,9*.&%!:$*.!.,/"9,&".9!.;0-%!:"&$".!&$*"0!".%&"&'&";.%=!F*2,'%*!

:*!:*0*!("%2'%%".9!&$*"0!'.(*0%&,.(".9%!;A6!,.(!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;6!24,%%!*/*.&%!,.(!

2'00"2'4,6!>!:,%!,@4*!&;!,%2*0&,".!,%1*2&%!;A!&$*"0!1,0&"2"1,&";.!".!4*,0.".9!,.(!

*%&,@4"%$".9!&$*"0!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*%!:"&$;'&!".&0;('2".9!.*:!&;1"2%!;0!%'@M*2&%=!

C"%2'%%";.%!:*0*!$*4(!".!&$*!;1*.!4'.2$!%1,2*!.*,0!&$*!24,%%0;;-6!%;!>!:,%!.*/*0!

,4;.*!:"&$!&$*!2$"4(0*.=!b$"4*!".!,.!;1*.!%1,2*6!*('2,&;0%!:*0*!.;&!"./;4/*(6!%;!

&$,&!%&'(*.&%!:;'4(.B&!@*!("0*2&4)!$*,0(!;0!;@%*0/*(!@)!&$*"0!&*,2$*0%!:"&$!:$;-!

&$*)!$,(!%*&!().,-"2%=!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

fV!H**!10*/";'%!A;;&.;&*!0*9,0(".9!".&*0%*2&";.,4"&)=!!

Page 125: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UUi!

!

b$"4*!>!:,%!24*,04)!-,05*(!,%!%;-*$;:!N("AA*0*.&6O!&$*!2$"4(0*.!:*0*!,@4*!&;!

,%%"-"4,&*!-*!".&;!&$*"0!:;04(!&$,&!9*.*0,44)!2;.%"%&*(!;A!-*.!,.(!:;-*.6!@;)%!,.(!

9"04%=!>!:,%!,%5".9!L'*%&";.%!&$,&!"./"&*(!;11;0&'."&)!A;0!&$*!2$"4(0*.!&;!%1*,5!&;!

:$,&!-,)!$,/*!;&$*0:"%*!@**.!&,5*.EA;0E90,.&*(!.;0-%!0*9,0(".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-%=!>!,-!,:,0*!&$,&!$;4(".9!&$"%!%1,2*!:;'4(!$,/*!@**.!("AA*0*.&!"A!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!

9*.(*0*(!,%%;2",&";.%!$,(!@**.!-;0*!%"9."A"2,.&4)!("%0'1&*(!@)!-)!1$)%"2,4!

,11*,0,.2*=fU!

I'2$!4"&*0,&'0*!$,%!@**.!:0"&&*.!0*A4*2&".9!;.!&$*!1;%%"@4*!@*.*A"&%!;A!A;2'%!

90;'1%!&;!@0*,5!'1!&$*!1;:*0!$*4(!@)!&$*!0*%*,02$*0!3`;:*&&!,.(!KB#;;4*6!8"&J".9*06!

b"45".%;.7=!!8"&J".9*0!,((0*%%*%!&$*!1;&*.&",4!@*.*A"&%!;A!A;2'%!".!&$"%!0*9,0(6!&;!

*.%'0*!N10";0"&)!"%!9"/*.!&;!&$*!0*%1;.(*.&%l!$"*0,02$)!;A!"-1;0&,.2*l6!$",).(

4,.9',9*!,.(!2;.2*1&%6!$",).(A0,-*:;05%!A;0!'.(*0%&,.(".9!&$*!:;04(O!3UVZ7=!#$"%!

:,%!24*,0!".!-)!0*%*,02$!,%!%&'(*.&%!:;'4(!0*%1;.(!,22;0(".9!&;!&$*"0!10";0"&"*%6!

%'2$!,%!0;4*!14,)".9!%;2",4!().,-"2%!&;!"44'%&0,&*!,!1;".&!;0!2$,.9".9!&$*!%'@M*2&!&;!

2;--*.&!;.!1*;14*!1,%%".9!@)=!!

D.&"E0,2"%&6!A*-"."%&!-*&$;(;4;9"2,4!4"&*0,&'0*!90*,&4)!".A4'*.2*(!&$*!:,)%!".!

:$"2$!>!(*%"9.*(6!"-14*-*.&*(6!,.(!,.,4)%*(!&$*!0*%*,02$=!>.!Nh;2'%!^0;'1%X!D!

h*-"."%&!I*&$;(6O!H'*!b"45".%;.!("%2'%%*%!$;:!A;2'%!90;'1%!2,.!@*!10;@4*-,&"J*(!

&$0;'9$!&$*!:,)%!".("/"(',4%!,.%:*0!L'*%&";.%!("AA*0*.&4)!(*1*.(".9!;.!:$;!"%!

,0;'.(!&$*-=!#$*!A;2'%!90;'1%!"44'%&0,&*!$;:!2$"4(0*.!20*,&*!-*,.".9!0*9,0(".9!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

fU!#$*!%,-*!-,)!,4%;!@*!%,"(!;A!:$*.!>!:,%!2;.('2&".9!".&*0/"*:%=!

Page 126: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UUZ!

!

.;0-%!,.(!$;:!&$*)!,0&"2'4,&*!%'2$!-*,.".9!".!&$*!2;.&*+&!;A!1**0E@,%*(!90;'1%=!!

#$"%!:,%!1,0&"2'4,04)!&0'*!".!-)!A;2'%!90;'1%6!:$*0*!%&'(*.&%!:;'4(!0*-".(!*,2$!

;&$*0!;A6!,.(!0*".A;02*6!%;2",4!0'4*%!3S$,1&*0!h;'07!,.(!2;44,@;0,&"/*4)!0*-*-@*0!

,.(!-,5*!-*,.".9!0*9,0(".9!2'00"2'4'-!4*%%;.%!,.(!%2$;;4!,%%*-@4"*%!3S$,1&*0!

h"/*7=!b"45".%;.!%&,&*%6!NA*-"."%&!A;2'%!90;'1!0*%*,02$*0%!$,/*!%$;:.!$;:!&$*!

%;2",4!2;.&*+&!;A!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1!;AA*0%!&$*!;11;0&'."&)!&;!;@%*0/*!&$*!2;E

2;.%&0'2&";.!;A!-*,.".9!,.(!&$*!*4,@;0,&";.!;A!"(*.&"&"*%!&$0;'9$!".&*0,2&";.O!

3YiW7=!!#$"%!10;/*(!&;!@*!,!A0'"&A'4!-*&$;(!A;0!&$"%!%&'()!%".2*!"&!:,%!&$0;'9$!&$*!

2$"4(0*.B%!".&*0,2&";.%!&$,&!&$*!".&*01*0%;.,4!2'4&'0,4!.;0-%!:*0*!(*-;.%&0,&*(=!

h;2'%!90;'1%6!,%!,!0*%*,02$!-*&$;(6!$,/*!.;&!9;.*!:"&$;'&!20"&"L'*=!I;44)!

^*;09*!%'--,0"*%!&$*%*!20"&"L'*%!,%!1;&*.&",4!"%%'*%!:"&$6!N0*4",@"4"&)6!/,4"("&)6!,.(!

9*.*0,4"J,@"4"&)O!3Y]Z7=!>&!"%!&0'*!&$,&!*/*0)!90;'1!;A!A"/*!)*,0!;4(%!:;'4(!$,/*!$,(!

("AA*0*.&!,.%:*0%!3;0!&$*!%,-*!90;'1!:"&$!,!("AA*0*.&!0*%*,02$*07=!I,09,0*&!,.(!>!

&$;'9$&!,@;'&!&$*!"-14"2,&";.%!;A!("AA*0*.&!1,"0".9%!,.(!:;05*(!&;9*&$*0!&;!90;'1!

&$*!1,0&"2"1,.&%!".!%'2$!,!:,)!,%!&;!-,+"-"J*!1;&*.&",4!1,0&"2"1,&";.!;A!*/*0);.*=!!

h;0!*+,-14*6!:*!&;;5!2,0*!&$,&!%&'(*.&%!:$;!:*0*!M'%&!4*,0.".9!R.94"%$!310"-,0"4)!

&:;!2$"4(0*.!".!&$*!24,%%7!,.(!%&'(*.&%!:$;!.**(*(!-;0*!L'"*&!&"-*!".!;0(*0!&;!A**4!

2;-A;0&,@4*!&,45".9!:*0*!90;'1*(!:"&$!%&'(*.&%!:$;!:;'4(!.;&!;/*0E1;:*0!&$*!

A;2'%!90;'1!%1,2*=!>.!&$"%!:,)6!>!(;!.;&!24,"-!&$,&!&$*!90;'1".9!0*A4*2&*(!".&*0,2&";.%!

A0**!;A!,('4&!".&*0/*.&";.=!T;:*/*06!>!("(!:,.&!&;!*.%'0*!&$,&!>!:;'4(!$*,0!,%!-'2$!

,%!1;%%"@4*!A0;-!,44!&$*!%&'(*.&%!:$;!:*0*!1,0&"2"1,&".9=!#$*!A;2'%!90;'1%!10;/"(*(!

2;-1*44".9!(,&,!".!2;.M'.2&";.!:"&$!&$*!*/*0)(,)!;@%*0/,&";.%6!,%!>!:,%!,@4*!&;!

Page 127: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UUW!

!

;@%*0/*!$;:!90;'1!@*$,/";'0!("AA*0*(!A0;-!$;:!1,0&"2"1,.&%!,.%:*0*(!*+14"2"&4)!

,%5*(!L'*%&";.%=!>!*+1,.(!;.!&$"%!".!S$,1&*0!h;'0!:$*.!>!*+14;0*!&$*!("%20*1,.2)!

@*&:**.!$;:!2$"4(0*.!,.%:*0*(!L'*%&";.%!0*9,0(".9!9*.(*0!20;%%".9!/*0%'%!$;:!

&$*)!@*$,/*(!:$*.!&$*)!%,:!%;-*;.*!;A!".(*&*0-".,&*!9*.(*0!*.&*0!,!:,%$0;;-=!!

#$*!,2&!;A!$;4(".9!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1%!".!,.(!;A!"&%*4A!-,(*!%1,2*!A;0!0*A4*2&";.!

0*9,0(".9!9*.(*0!.;0-%=!C*/;&".9!&"-*!".!%2$;;4!&;!0*A4*2&".9!;.!&$*!%'@M*2&!;AA*0*(!

/,4"("&)!&;!&$*!10,2&"2*=!H&'("*%!0*9,0(".9!2$"4(0*.!,.(!9*.(*0!.;0-%!".!10"-,0)!

%2$;;46!%'2$!,%!8,0*.!F,"4*)B%!%&'()!;A!2$"4(0*.B%!9*.(*0*(!-*,.".9!-,5".96!

*-1$,%"J*(!$;:!2$"4(0*.!".!^0,(*!U!1*02*"/*(!"&!&;!@*!'.,22*1&,@4*!A;0!N@;)%O!&;!

1,0&"2"1,&*!".!14,)!,%%;2",&*(!:"&$!N9"04%O!@'&!*+10*%%*(!,!1;%%"@4*!*+2*1&";.!:;'4(!

@*!"A!,!&*,2$*0!*+14"2"&4)!&;4(!&$*-!&$,&!"&!:,%!,22*1&,@4*=!F)!@*".9!".!&$*!24,%%!,.(!

,%5".9!.;.EM'(9-*.&,4!L'*%&";.%!,@;'&!9*.(*0!.;0-%6!>!-,)!$,/*!&,2"&4)!9"/*.!

,110;/,4!&;!L'*%&";.!%,"(!.;0-%6!&$'%!".A4'*.2".9!2$"4(0*.B%!"(*,%=!!

Q,&$*0!&$,.!,&&*-1&".9!&;!A".(!(,&,!&$,&!:,%!%;-*$;:!.,&'0,46!>!A;2'%*(!

,.,4)&"2,4!,&&*.&";.!;.!*+14;0".9!:$,&!2,-*!&;!&$*!%'0A,2*!:$*.!.;0-%!:*0*!-,(*!

*+14"2"&=!8"&J".9*0!;AA*0%!&$*!A;44;:".9!*+14,.,&";.X!

Q,&$*0!&$,.!,%%'-".9!&$*!90;'1!%*%%";.!'.10;@4*-,&"2,44)!,.(!".*/"&,@4)!

0*A4*2&%!l*/*0)(,)!".&*0,2&";.%l!3,4&$;'9$!%;-*&"-*%!"&!:"447!&$*!90;'1!%$;'4(!

@*!'%*(!&;!*.2;'0,9*!1*;14*!&;!*.9,9*!:"&$!;.*!,.;&$*06!/*0@,44)!A;0-'4,&*!

&$*"0!"(*,%!,.(!(0,:!;'&!&$*!2;9."&"/*!%&0'2&'0*%!:$"2$!10*/";'%4)!$,/*!@**.!

'.,0&"2'4,&*(!3UVk7=!!

Page 128: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UYV!

!

C'0".9!;.*!A;2'%!90;'16!&$*!*/*0E*+'@*0,.&!`*&&"*!&;4(!,!4;.9!,.(!A,.&,%&"2,4!

%&;0)!,@;'&!$*0!A,&$*0!N,22"(*.&,44)O!9*&&".9!,!-,5*E;/*0!;.*!I;&$*0B%!C,)6!:$"2$!

N&'0.*(!$"%!A,2*!,4-;%&!".&;!,!9"04O!3I;&$*0B%!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1!Y!U[<V]<UY7=!H$*!

,11*,0*(!&;!@*!2,0*A'44)!2,42'4,&".9!$*0!1**0%B!0*%1;.%*%6!'11".9!&$*!,.&*!:$*.!

&$*)!("(!.;&!,11*,0!%'AA"2"*.&4)!%$;25*(!A;0!$*0!4"5".9=!F)!&$*!*.(!;A!&$*!%&;0)6!$*0!

(,(!$,(!".&*.(*(!&;!:,%$!$"%!A,2*!@'&!,22"(*.&4)!9;&&*.!1*0-,.*.&!-,%2,0,!".%&*,(!

,.(!$,(!$"%!$,"0!()*(!,&!4*,%&!$,4A!,!(;J*.!2;4;'0%=!D%!,!0*%'4&!;A!&$"%!,2L'"0*(!

A*-"."J,&";.6!,!1,%%*0@)!$,(!N&0"25*(O!,!);'.9!-,.!".&;!5"%%".9!$*0!(,(=!`*&&"*!9,/*!

%"9."A"2,.&!,&&*.&";.!&;!,!@;)!$,/".9!5"%%*(!N,.;&$*0!@;)O!3)/)%7!,%!&$*!%,4"*.&!(*&,"4!

.;&!&;!@*!-"%%*(=!b*0*!>!&;!$,/*!@**.!4;;5".9!%;4*4)!A;0!,22'0,&*!(*1"2&";.%!;A!:$,&!

$,(!&,5*.!14,2*!".!2$"4(0*.B%!4"/*%6!&$"%!%&;0)!:;'4(!.;&!@*!'%*A'4!(,&,=!T;:*/*06!,%!

&$0**!;&$*0!%&'(*.&%!:*0*!10*%*.&!A;0!&$*!*/*.&!3C)4,.6!#0"%&,.6!,.(!D%$4*)76!"&!

%'22*%%A'44)!,0&"2'4,&*(!,%1*2&%!;A!9*.(*0!&,@;;!,&!14,)!:"&$".!&$*!-"."E%;2",4!2"024*=!!

C)4,.!4;%&!".&*0*%&!,.(!("(!.;&!%**-!&;!2,0*!3&$"%!-,)!$,/*!@**.!@*2,'%*!$*!

("(!.;&!@*4"*/*!`*&&"*6!@*2,'%*!$*!A*4&!&$*!&,@;;%!("(!.;&!,AA*2&!$"-6!;0!,.)!

2;-@".,&";.!;A!A,2&;0%7=!T;:*/*06!#0"%&,.!)*44*(!N*:O!3I;&$*0B%!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1!Y!

U[<V]<UY7!:$*.*/*0!`*&&"*!(*%20"@*(!,!A*-"."J".9!;0!$;-;*0;&"2!-;-*.&=!D%$4*)6!

;.!&$*!;&$*0!$,.(6!M'-1*(!".!&;!(*A*.(!`*&&"*B%!(,(6!&*44".9!-*!&$,&!%$*!5.*:!$"-!

,.(!&$,&!$*!:,%.B&!N4"5*!&$,&O!3)/)%7=!#$*!%&;0)6!&$*.6!:$"4*!'.&0'*!:,%!"44'%&0,&"/*!;A!

*L',&";.%!;A!-,4*.*%%!,.(!A*-"."."&)!,%!N90;%%O!&;!;.*!%&'(*.&6!,.(!1;%%"@4)!

%;-*&$".9!;.*!:;'4(!$,/*!&;!@*!(*A*.(*(!,9,".%&!&;!,.;&$*0=!`;$.!h,0.%:;0&$!,.(!

F0;.:).!F;;.!:0"&*!&$,&6!NA;2'%!90;'1!".&*0,2&";.!"%!,4%;!%**.!&;!10;('2*!-;0*!

Page 129: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UYU!

!

&$,.!M'%&!o&,45BX!&,456!".!A,2&6!"%!&$*!-*,.%!@)!:$"2$!%;2",4!"(*.&"&"*%!,.(!5.;:4*(9*!

,0*!2;.%&"&'&*(!,.(!%'%&,".*(O!3kUV7=!

I,(*4*".*!`;:*&&!,.(!^"44!Kl#;;4*!%'0-"%*!&$,&!A;2'%!90;'1%!-"9$&!0"%5!&$*!

1;%%"@"4"&)!A;0!1,0&"2"1,.&%6!N&;!*+,99*0,&*!&$*"0!,22;'.&%!&;!o"-10*%%B!;&$*0%6!;0!A;0!

o1*,2*E-,5*0%B!&;!&0)!&;!@0".9!("%2'%%";.%!&;!*.A;02*(!-'&',4!,90**-*.&6!:$"2$!

-"9$&!".!%;-*!%*.%*!o%5*:B!&$*!(,&,O!3[]]7=!T;:*/*06!,%!&$*!,@;/*!%&;0)!%'99*%&%6!

%5*:".9!,.(!,&&*-1&%!&;!"-10*%%!-,)!10;/"(*!/,4',@4*!".%"9$&!(*1*.(".9!;.!:$,&!

".A;0-,&";.!,!0*%*,02$*0!"%!$;1".9!&;!94*,.!A0;-!,!%&'()=!>.!&$*!2,%*!;A!-)!0*%*,02$6!

>!:,%!,@4*!&;!*+,-".*!2;.&0,("2&";.%!@*&:**.!,%%*0&";.%!&$,&!"&!:,%!N;5,)O!A;0!,!

A,-"4)!&;!$,/*!N&:;!-;-%O!3I;&$*0%!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1%!U6!Y6!p!f!U[<V]<YVUY7!,.(!

:$,&!:,%!'.*,0&$*(!".!&$*!0*%1;.%*%!&;!A"2&"/*!%&;0)&*44".9=!8"&J".9*0!%&,&*%!&$,&!,!

1;&*.&",44)!'%*A'4!,%1*2&!;A!,!A;2'%!90;'1!"%!&$,&!1,0&"2"1,.&%!-,)!2$,44*.9*!N*,2$!

;&$*0!;.!2;.&0,("2&";.%!@*&:**.!:$,&!&$*)!:*0*!J.&-,33)*9(&;!@*4"*/*!,.(!$;:!&$*)!

,2&',44)!@*$,/*(O!3UV]7=!#$*!("%20*1,.2)!".!@*$,/";'0!10;/"(*%!,.!".&*0*%&".9!1;".&!

;A!,.,4)%"%!@*&:**.!("%2;'0%*%!;A!".24'%";.!2;.&0,%&*(!:"&$!*+24'%";.!0*".A;02*(!@)!

*/*0)(,)!.;0-%!3%**!2$,1&*0%!h;'0!&$0;'9$!H"+7=!!

h,2"4"&,&".9!A;2'%!90;'1%!0*L'"0*(!%;-*!2;-14"2,&*(!.*9;&",&";.%=!>!("(!.;&!

:,.&!&;!&,5*!&;;!-'2$!,'&$;0"&)j!,&!&$*!%,-*!&"-*6!>!:,.&*(!&;!(*-;.%&0,&*!-)!

,110*2",&";.!;A!".("/"(',4!%1*,5*0%_&$,&!&$*!".A;0-,&";.!&$*)!:*0*!%$,0".9!:,%!

"-1;0&,.&=!>!;A&*.!0*%1;.(*(!&;!$"9$!4*/*4%!;A!@,2590;'.(!&,45!@)!".A;0-".9!

1,0&"2"1,.&%!&$,&!>!:;'4(!4"5*!&;!$*,0!&$*!%1*,5*0B%!N"-1;0&,.&!:;0(%=O!#$"%!

,110;,2$!:,%!,4%;!".!14,2*!:$*.!%&'(*.&%B!,2&"/"&"*%!@*2,-*!("%&0,2&".9=!h;0!

Page 130: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UYY!

!

*+,-14*6!&$*0*!,0*!".%&,.2*%!:$*0*!>!&;4(!&$*!1,0&"2"1,.&%!&$,&!>!5.*:!"&!"%!A'.!&;!

20,:4!'.(*0!&$*!&,@4*!@'&!>!2;'4(!.;&!$*,0!&$*"0!"-1;0&,.&!%&;0"*%!:$*.!&$*)!:*0*!

&$*0*!;0!:$*0*!>!%&0*%%*(!&$,&!"&!:,%!90*,&!&$*)!:*0*!(".;%,'0%!3;0!2,&%6!(;9%6!&"9*0%6!

,.(!%;!;.7!@'&!&$,&!>!:,%!,A0,"(!&$*)!-"9$&!9*&!$'0&!"A!&$*)!&0"*(!&;!24"-@!&$*!:,44%!

3?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1%!Y!p!f!Uk<Y<YVUY7=!!

D&!&$*!@*9"..".9!;A!*/*0)!A;2'%!90;'1!>!:;'4(!,%5!%&'(*.&%!:$*&$*0!;0!.;&!

&$*)!:,.&*(!&;!,&&*.(6!-,5".9!"&!24*,0!&$,&!1,0&"2"1,&";.!:,%!&$*"0!2$;"2*=!D&&*.(".9!

&$*!A;2'%!90;'1%!@*2,-*!,!10*A*00*(!,2&"/"&)=!#$*!2$"4(0*.!:*0*!,.+";'%!A;0!"&!&;!@*!

&$*"0!&'0.!,.(!;A&*.!,%5*(!:$*.!&$*!.*+&!90;'1!:;'4(!&,5*!14,2*=!>!-,(*!"&!24*,0!

&$,&!%&'(*.&%!:*0*!A0**!&;!%5"1!,.)!L'*%&";.!&$*)!("(!.;&!:,.&!&;!,.%:*0!,.(!&$,&!

&$*)!2;'4(!4*,/*!,.(!9;!@,25!&;!&$*"0!24,%%0;;-!,&!,.)&"-*=!H;-*!2$"4(0*.!&"0*(!;A!

&,45".9!-;0*!L'"254)!&$,.!;&$*0%!,.(!:;'4(!2$;;%*!&;!0*&'0.!&;!24,%%!:$"4*!;&$*0%!

:,.&*(!&;!%&,)!,.(!&*44!%&;0)!,A&*0!%&;0)=!!

D&!,44!&"-*%6!>!:;05*(!&;!.*9;&",&*!&$*!&*.%";.!@*&:**.!.;&!*.;'9$!("0*2&";.6!

:$"2$!:;'4(!0*%'4&!".!".,(*L',&*!%&0'2&'0*!A;0!9,&$*0".9!".A;0-,&";.6!,.(!&;;!-'2$!

("0*2&";.6!:$"2$!:;'4(!%&"A4*!&$*"0!".&*0,2&";.%!,.(!9"/*!,.!;/*04)!2;.&0;44*(!

(*1"2&";.!;A!&$*"0!%;2",4!".&*0,2&";.%=!>.!&$"%!.*9;&",&";.6!>!0*A*00*(!&;!^,44,2$*0!,.(!

^,44,9$*0B%!2,44!A;0!0*%*,02$*0%!&;!*-14;)!A4*+"@"4"&)!,.(!*-@0,2*!N"--,&'0"&)O!".!

&$*!0*%*,02$!10;2*%%=!#$*)!:0"&*6!N>A!0*%*,02$*0%!:*0*!A'44)!-,&'0*6!&$*)!:;'4(!

5.;:!,44!&$*!,.%:*0%j!,.(!"A!&$*)!5.*:!,44!&$*!,.%:*0%6!&$*0*!:;'4(!@*!.;!.**(!A;0!

0*%*,02$O!3]UY7=!#$*0*!:*0*!.;!A".,4!%;4'&";.%!A;0!.,/"9,&".9!&$*%*!&*.%";.%=!R/*0)!

%"&',&";.!0*L'"0*(!0*A4*2&";.=!!

Page 131: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UYf!

!

I)!,110;,2$!&;!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1!L'*%&";.%!.**(*(!&;!@*!,(,1&*(!('0".9!&$*!

A"0%&!90;'1=!I)!".&*.(*(!%20"1&%!%;'9$&!&;!'.(*0%&,.(!:$,&!2$"4(0*.B%!&,@;;%!:*0*!

,0;'.(!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!@)!,%5".9!,!%*0"*%!;A!%"-14*6!$)1;&$*&"2,4!L'*%&";.%!3%**!

D11*.("+!U7X!%'2$!,%!,%5".9!:$;!&$*)!:;'4(!9"/*!?,4*.&".*%!&;6!:$;!&$*)!:;'4(!.;&!

9"/*!&$*-!&;6!,.(!:$,&!:;'4(!$,11*.!"A!%;-*;.*!9,/*!,!?,4*.&".*!&;!(*-;90,1$"2%!

-*.&";.*(!,%!;'&%"(*!&$*!9"/*.!,22*1&,@4*!0*,4-%!39"04%!&;!@;)%6!@;)%!&;!@;)%6!,.(!%;!

;.7=!T;:*/*06!&$*!2$"4(0*.!("(!.;&!0*%1;.(!&;!N:$,&!"AO!;0!;&$*0!$)1;&$*&"2,4!

L'*%&";.%!,.(!A;'.(!&$*%*!2;.A'%".9=!C'0".9!&$*!A"0%&!A;2'%!90;'1!>!0*%&0'2&'0*(!&$*!

L'*%&";.%!,.(!,A&*0!>!0*:0;&*!&$*!%20"1&%!&;!A;2'%!;.!L'*%&";.%!,@;'&!:$,&!$,11*.*(!

;.!&$*!%1*2",4!;22,%";.!(,)%6!&$*!2$;"2*%!&$*)!-,(*6!,.(!:$,&!&$*)!0*-*-@*0*(!

3%**!D11*.("+!U7=!#$*!2$"4(0*.B%!2;.A'%";.!:,%!.;&!@*2,'%*!&$*)!A,"4*(!&;!"-,9".*!

*/*.&%!;&$*0!&$,.!&$;%*!&$,&!&;;5!14,2*6!@'&!0,&$*0!&$,&!&$*)!:;'4(!&*44!%&;0"*%!@,%*(!

;.!*/*.&%!&$,&!$,(!$,11*.*(!;0!@,%*(!;.!:$,&!&$*)!"-,9".*(6!(*1*.(".9!;.!:$,&!

&$*)!:"%$*(!&;!"44'%&0,&*!&;!-*!;0!-,5*!%*.%*!;A!A;0!&$*-%*4/*%=!R/*0)&$".9!:,%!

0*2;'.&*(!,%!*L',44)!N0*,4=O!#$*!0*2;'.&".9!;A!4"/*(!*/*.&%!,.(!&$*!A"2&";.,4"J,&";.%!

@;&$!10;/*(!".&*0*%&".9!1;".&%!A;0!,.,4)%"%6!,%!&$*)!@;&$!(*-;.%&0,&*(!10";0"&"*%6!

:$,&!:,%!,114,'(*(6!,.(!:$,&!:,%!&,@;;=$

4AEA$'BA>9J<J$$

D44!;A!-)!0*%*,02$!(,&,!:,%!&0,.%20"@*(!,.(!2;(*(!,22;0(".9!&;!&$*-*%!&$,&!>!

"(*.&"A"*(!A0;-!&$*!2;-@".,&";.!;A!".&*0/"*:%6!A;2'%!90;'1%6!,.(!;@%*0/,&";.%=!

b$"4*!>!&0,.%20"@*(!&$*!1,0&"2"1,.&%B!("%&".2&!/;"2*%!A0;-!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1%6!>!,4%;!

0*4"*(!;.!.;&*%!&$,&!>!&;;5!0*9,0(".9!&$*"0!,2&";.%!('0".9!&$*!,'(";E0*2;0(*(!&,45!

Page 132: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UY[!

!

:$*.!,.,4)J".9!&$*!".&*0,2&";.%!&$,&!&;;5!14,2*!3*=9=!%&'(*.&%!:;'4(!M'-1!'1!;.!&$*!

@*.2$*%!;0!&,@4*!&;!*-1$,&"2,44)!-,5*!,!1;".&7=!I)!A"*4(:;05!10;('2*(!;/*0!]VV!

1,9*%!;A!0,:!(,&,6!:$"2$!:,%!2;(*(!'%".9!&$*!L',4"&,&"/*!(,&,!,.,4)%"%!10;90,-6!

T)1*0Q*%*,02$=!>.!&$*!A"0%&!0;'.(!;A!2;(".96!>!4,@*4*(!*,2$!%*2&";.!;A!-)!A"*4(.;&*%!

,.(!&0,.%20"1&%!:"&$!9*.*0,4!&;1"2%!$*,(".9%6!*=9=6!2'00"2'4'-6!1*(,9;9)6!

2;.&0,("2&";.%=!>!&$*.!2;.('2&*(!,!%*2;.(!0;'.(!;A!2;(".9!&;!"(*.&"A)!;/*0,02$".9!

&$*-*%X!%'2$!,%6!,(/;2,2)6!,9*.2)6!,.(!1;:*0=!D&!&$"%!%&,9*6!&$*!&$*-*%!;A!"..;2*.2*!

,.(!("AA*0*.2*!*-*09*(=!DA&*0!:0"&".9!,!A"0%&!(0,A&6!>!-,.',44)!2;(*(!&$*!(0,A&!A;0!

A'0&$*0!*-*09".9!&$*-*%=!>!0*E;09,."J*(!&$*!2$,1&*0%!@,%*(!;.!:$,&!&$*-*%!2;'4(!

@*!90;'1*(!&;9*&$*0!&;!A,2"4"&,&*!&$*-,&"2!2;$*%";.!A;0!&$*!0*,(*0=!#$"%!("%%*0&,&";.!

$,%!@**.!&$0;'9$!,110;+"-,&*4)!A"/*!(0,A&%=!

#$*!&$*-*!;A!"..;2*.2*!*-*09*(!,%!>!.;&*(!2;.&0,("2&";.%!@*&:**.!:$,&!

:,%!%,"(!,@;'&!2$"4(0*.!,.(!:$,&!>!;@%*0/*(!;A!&$*"0!,2&";.%!".!-)!A"*4(:;05=!h;0!

*+,-14*6!I,09,0*&!Q;/*44,!*+10*%%*(!%*.&"-*.&%!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!".!8".(*09,0&*.!

4,25*(!,:,0*.*%%!;A!9*.(*0*(!().,-"2%!3,&&0"@'&*(!&;!&$*"0!(*/*4;1-*.&7=!H$*!

A'0&$*0!1;%"&*(!&$,&!&$"%!-"9$&!@*!:$)!%;-*!1,0*.&%!A*4&!&$,&!("%2'%%".9!%,-*E%*+!

A,-"4"*%!:,%!.;&!,110;10",&*!A;0!&$,&!,9*!90;'1!3%**!2$,1&*0%!h;'0!,.(!h"/*7=!H'2$!

%*.&"-*.&%!%&;;(!".!2;.&0,%&!&;!2$"4(0*.B%!14,)6!:$"2$!;A&*.!(*-;.%&0,&*(!2$"4(0*.B%!

0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!"(*,%!0*9,0(".9!1,"0!@;.(".9!,.(!0;-,.2*!,%!:*44!,%!&$*"0!2;.2*0.!

:"&$!9*.(*0!.;0-%!,.(!%;2",4!@*4;.9".9=!!

#$*!&$*-*!;A!("AA*0*.2*!*-*09*(!,%!*('2,&;0%!,.(!,(-"."%&0,&;0%!'%*(!&$*!

.**(!&;!#++,J$(%)--,.,*+,(,%!&$*!@,%"%!A0;-!:$"2$!&;!(*A*.(!&$*"0!(*2"%";.%!&;!

Page 133: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UY]!

!

10*%*.&!,.&"E$;-;1$;@",!-,&*0",4=!#$*!"(*,!;A!-,5".9!0;;-!A;0!("AA*0*.2*%!:,%!

("%2'%%*(!".!".&*0/"*:%!,.(!".!&$*!G".5!C,)!*/*.&%=!I;0*;/*06!"&!:,%!4,.9',9*!

2$"4(0*.!:;'4(!'%*!:$*.!&$*)!%*.%*(!&$,&!&$*)!:*0*!@*".9!,%5*(!,!L'*%&";.!:"&$!,!

0$*&;0"2,4!N0"9$&O!,.%:*0=!h;0!*+,-14*6!"A!,%5*(!"A!"&!:,%!;5,)!&;!@*!9,)6!;0!A;0!@;)%!

&;!4"5*!1".56!&$*!2$"4(0*.!:;'4(!,.%:*06!N)*%6O!".!'."%;.=!>&!,11*,0*(!&$,&!N)*%O!:,%!

5.;:.!&;!@*!&$*!0"9$&!,.%:*0!&;!,.)!L'*%&";.!0*9,0(".9!&$*!,22*1&,@"4"&)!;A!

%;-*&$".9!(**-*(!N("AA*0*.&=O!#$*%*!,.%:*0%!2;.&0,%&*(!:"&$!2$"4(0*.B%!,2&',4!

0*%1;.%*%!:$*.!*.2;'.&*0".9!1*;14*!:$;!("/*09*(!A0;-!9*.(*0!.;0-%6!:$"2$!:,%!

&0*,&*(!:"&$!%'%1"2";.!;0!0"("2'4*!3,4%;!A'0&$*0!("%2'%%*(!".!S$,1&*0%!h;'0!&$0;'9$!

H"+7=!!

#$*-*%!;A!D@;0"9".,4!2'4&'0,4!".24'%";.!,.(!%&'(*.&!1,0&"2"1,&";.!:*0*!,4%;!

*/"(*.2*(!&$0;'9$!&$*!2;(".9!10;2*%%=!#$*!&:;!D@;0"9".,4!%&'(*.&%!".!&$*!24,%%!*,2$!

-,(*!%"9."A"2,.&!2;.&0"@'&";.%!&;!&$"%!%&'()X!C'.2,.!&$0;'9$!$"%!9*.(*0*(!10;2*%%!

;/*0!&$*!2;'0%*!;A!-)!A"*4(:;056!,.(!8"*0;.!&$0;'9$!$"%!,0&"2'4,&*!("%2'%%";.!;A!

$;-;1$;@",!,.(!$"%!NP,&"/*O!"(*.&"&)=!F*2,'%*!&$*!D@;0"9".,4!R.$,.2*-*.&!

b;05*06!:$;!%'11;0&*(!@;&$!2$"4(0*.6!*.&$'%",%&"2,44)!,90**(!&;!1,0&"2"1,&*!".!,.!

".&*0/"*:6!$*0!".%"9$&!,.(!*+1*0&"%*!,4%;!@*2,-*!1,0&!;A!&$*!(,&,=!!

I,09,0*&!,.(!S,0;4".*!*,2$!(*/;&*(!-'2$!&"-*!&;!,.(!0*A4*2&";.!;.!

2;.%"(*0".9!:,)%!&;!A,2"4"&,&*!&$*!2$"4(0*.!*-1;:*0".9!&$*-%*4/*%!:"&$!&$*!

2;.A"(*.2*!&;!0,"%*!&$*"0!/;"2*%!0*9,0(".9!"%%'*%!&$*)!:*0*!2;.%"(*0*(!:"&$=!D%!%'2$6!

2$"4(0*.!4*,0.".9!&;!4"%&*.!&;!&$*"0!;:.!@;("*%6!9,".!&;;4%!&;!*+10*%%!&$*"0!.**(%6!,.(!

("%2'%%!,.(!0*9'4,&*!&$*"0!A**4".9%!*-*09*(!".!-)!(,&,=!!

Page 134: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UYk!

!

:?BZ>HJ<?B$

\'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!1*;14*!%$,0*!$"%&;0"*%!;A!$,/".9!@**.!&$*!;@M*2&%!;A!

".;0(".,&*!%2$;4,04)!,&&*.&";.=!KA&*.!&$"%!0*%*,02$!$,%!@**.!2;.('2&*(!&$0;'9$!

-*("2,4"J*(6!1,&$;4;9"J".96!,.(!;@M*2&"A)".9!4*.%*%=fY!?"9"4,.2*!,9,".%&!0*20*,&".9!

%'2$!;@M*2&"A)".9!&0*.(%!0*L'"0*%!,!2;.%2";'%!2;--"&-*.&!&;!A;2'%".9!;.!.;0-%!

0,&$*0!&$,.!;.!&$*!%;2",4!&$",.!3L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!1*;14*7=!#$*0*!"%!,!%$;0&,9*!

;A!10,2&"2,46!'%*A'4!0*%*,02$!&$,&!2,.!10;/"(*!".%"9$&!".&;!$;:!.;0-,&"/*!4"A*!

2;;0(".,&*%!;&$*0".9!L'**0%!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!1*;14*!:$"4*!("%*-1;:*0".9!2$"4(0*.=!

Q*%*,02$*0%!%**5".9!&;!10;('2*!%&'("*%!&$,&!:;05!,9,".%&!;&$*0".9!.;0-%!".!

(;-".,.&!2'4&'0*!-'%&!2;.&*.(!:"&$!-;0,4!1,."2!,0;'.(!.;.E.;0-,&"/*!%*+',4"&"*%!

,.(!9*.(*0%!,.(!2$"4(0*.6!;A&*.!0*.(*0".9!%'2$!0*%*,02$!("AA"2'4&!&;!*+*2'&*=!!

>.!;0(*0!&;!9',0(!,9,".%&!0*20*,&".9!;@M*2&"A)".9!10,2&"2*%!".!0*%*,02$6!&$"%!

%&'()!2;.2*.&0,&*(!;.!2'4&'0,4!10,2&"2*%!:"&$".!,.!".%&"&'&";.!0,&$*0!&$,.!;.!

&$*;0"J".9!1*;14*B%!"(*.&"&"*%=!>!%&'("*(!.;0-%!:"&$!,!A;2'%!;.!$;:!&$*)!;1*.!'1!;0!

4"-"&!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!A;0!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%6!0,&$*0!&$,.!%&'()".9!,!

.;.E(;-".,.&!1;1'4,&";.B%!%)--,.,*+,=!D%!-)!%&'()!%&,0&%!:"&$!2$"4(0*.B%!

'.(*0%&,.(".9%!;A!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%!@,%*(!;.!:$,&!&$*)!,40*,()!5.;:!,.(!

@,%*(!;.!;@%*0/,&";.%!;A!:$,&!&$*)!:*0*!,2&',44)!(;".9!".!&$*"0!14,)6!"&!;1*.*(!'1!

".20*,%*(!2,1,2"&)!&;!&,45!:"&$!2$"4(0*.!,@;'&!&$*"0!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!".!,!:,)!&$,&!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

fY!H**!&$*!10*/";'%!A;;&.;&*!0*9,0(".9!1,&$;4;9"J".9!&0*.(%!".!:*%&*0.!2'4&'0,4!

$"%&;0"*%!;A!%*+;4;9)!,.(!1%)2$;,.,4)%"%_&$*%*!1,&$;4;9"J".9!,110;,2$*%!&;!

0*%*,02$!(0*:!2;.24'%";.%!,@;'&!!"&!".("/"(',4%!,.(!1;1'4,&";.%!;'&%"(*!&$*!-,4*!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!-,".%&0*,-!:*0*!&$0;'9$!1;%"&";.".9!".("/"(',4%!,%!

;@M*2&%!&;!@*!%&'("*(=!

Page 135: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UYi!

!

".24'(*(!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!H'@%*L'*.&4)6!0,&$*0!&$,.!("%2'%%".9!"(*,%!

,@;'&!2$"4(0*.6!;0!(*@,&".9!:$*&$*0!;0!.;&!&$*)!,0*!0*,()!&;!&$".5!,@;'&!9*.(*0%!

,.(!%*+',4"&"*%!".!8".(*09,0&*.6!>!*+,-".*!$;:!%'2$!&$*-*%!,0*!,40*,()!10*%*.&!".!

&$*"0!*/*0)(,)!4"/*%!,.(!,2&"/"&"*%=!I)!%&'()!2;.&0"@'&*%!&;!4"&*0,&'0*!0*9,0(".9!

-*&$;(;4;9"*%!,.(!L'**06!&0,.%9*.(*06!,.(!2$"4($;;(!%&'("*%6!@;&$!".!&$*!2;.&*.&!

9*.*0,&*(!@)!&$*!0*%*,02$!(,&,!,.(!&$0;'9$!10;/"(".9!,.!*+,-14*!;A!%'22*%%A'4!

.,/"9,&";.!;A!%)%&*-"2!,.(!2;.2*1&',4!@,00"*0%!&;!0*%*,02$!;.!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-,&"/"&)!".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4=!

! !

Page 136: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UYZ!

!

:CA=EDF$;?HF,$.DEDF?JD[HA><E9$AJ$/PDF9YA9$&<_D,$/[A@<B<BI$!"BB?ZDBZD-$

"BEF?YHZE<?B$$

>.!YVUU6!&$*!#;0;.&;!H2$;;4!C"%&0"2&!10;1;%*(!,!8EUY!2'00"2'4'-!&$,&!:;'4(!

".24'(*!*+,-".".9!9*.(*0!0;4*%!,.(!("%2'%%".9!%,-*E%*+!0*4,&";.%$"1%=!#$*!>.%&"&'&*!

A;0!S,.,(",.!?,4'*%!0*%1;.(*(!:"&$!,.!,(!".!&$*!-,".%&0*,-!.,&";.,4!.*:%1,1*0!

0",(@#$)&*#6(A&3$'(#$*!,(6!&"&4*(!NH&;1!S;00'1&".9!S$"4(0*.6O!A*,&'0*(!,!1"2&'0*!;A!,!

:$"&*!,11*,0".96!A*-".".*!9"04!2$"4(!:"&$!@"9!@0;:.!*)*%!:"&$!NG4*,%*6!(;.B&!2;.A'%*!

-*O!:0"&&*.!'.(*0.*,&$!&$*!1"2&'0*=!G0".&*(!@*.*,&$!&$*!1"2&'0*!:,%!&$*!&*+&6!N>!,-!

,!9"046O!:"&$!10".&!@*4;:!0*,(".96!N(;.B&!&*,2$!-*!&;!L'*%&";.!"A!>B-!,!F;)6!

#0,.%%*+',46!#0,.%9*.(*0*(6!>.&*0%*+*(!;0!#:;!H1"0"&*(O!30",(@#$)&*#6(A&3$6!

H*1&*-@*0!YW&$6!YVUU7=!DA&*0!-'2$!4;@@)".9!,.(!1'@4"2!2;-14,".&6!&$*!.*:%1,1*0!

*("&;0%!"%%'*(!,.!,1;4;9)!A;0!0'..".9!&$"%!&0,.%1$;@"2!3,.(!2;4;.",47!,(=!!!

#$*!/;4'-".;'%!1'@4"2!2;--*.&%!'.(*0.*,&$!&$*!;.4".*!,1;4;9)!

.*/*0&$*4*%%!0*A4*2&*(!,.!".&*0*%&".9!2;.2*1&',4"J,&";.!;A!2$"4($;;(!"..;2*.2*=!D!

A,&$*0!(*%20"@*(!$;:!$"%!);'.9!9"04!:,%!&$*!N-;%&!@*,'&"A'4!,.(!"..;2*.&!2$"4(!

"-,9".,@4*O!3#nA0;96!ND.!D1;4;9)!A0;-!&$*!@#$)&*#6(A&3$O!fV!H*1&!YVUU7=!T*!:,%!

2;.2*0.*(!&$,&!%$*!:;'4(!4;%*!&$"%!"..;2*.2*!%;;.!*.;'9$!,.(!A*4&!N0"11*(!,1,0&O!

3)/)%7!@)!&$*!10;%1*2&!&$,&!$"%!(,'9$&*0!2;'4(!@*!&,'9$&!,@;'&!N%'2$!&$".9%O!3*=9=6!

&$,&!.;&!*/*0);.*!"%!9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!;0!$*&*0;%*+',47!@*A;0*!%$*!:,%!

,110;10",&*4)!-,&'0*=!K&$*0!0*%1;.(*.&%!&;!&$*!,1;4;9)!14*,(*(!&$,&!&$*!"%%'*!;A!

%*+',4!;0"*.&,&";.!@*!4*A&!'.&"4!$"9$!%2$;;4!%*+!*('2,&";.!N:$*0*!"&!@*4;.9%O!,.(!.;&!

@*!@0;'9$&!".&;!24,%%0;;-%!:"&$!"..;2*.&!);'.9!1*;14*!3Q9,%1,06!ND.!,1;4;9)!A0;-!

Page 137: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UYW!

!

&$*!P,&";.,4!G;%&O!fV!H*1&!YVUU7=!T*0*6!".A;0-,&";.!,@;'&!%;-*!9*.(*0%!,.(!%;-*!

%*+',4"&"*%!$,%!,!&"-*!3$"9$!%2$;;47!,.(!,!14,2*!3%*+!*('2,&";.7!:$*0*!"&!"%!

*('2,&";.,4_!;'&%"(*!;A!:$"2$6!"&!2;00'1&%!"..;2*.2*=ff!!#$*!"(*,!&$,&!%*+',4"&)!

%$;'4(!.;&!@*!("%2'%%*(!".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4!"%!2;--;.14,2*=!d.A;0&'.,&*4)6!"&!"%!0,0*!

A;0!:$,&!N%*+',4"&)O!"%!,.(!"%.B&!&;!@*!24*,04)!(*A".*(!".!1'@4"2!*('2,&";.,4!

".%&"&'&";.%!3S'44*.!,.(!H,.()j!S'00,.,6!S$",0;44"@6!,.(!G,44;&&,ES$",0;44"2j!

Q;@".%;.j!H*,0%j!b,44"%!,.(!?,.R/*0)7=!#;;!;A&*.!:$,&!"%!.;0-,4"J*(!"%!(*E

%*+',4"J*(!,.(!%'@%*L'*.&4)!.;&!2;.%"(*0*(!&,@;;6!:$"4*!:$,&!"%!;'&%"(*!&$*!

-,".%&0*,-!"%!2;.%"(*0*(!".,110;10",&*4)!%*+',4=!#$"%!1*01*&',&*%!&$*!-)&$!&$,&!

%*+',4"&)!"%!.;&!("%2'%%*(!".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4=!>.!NH*+',4"&)!".!&$*!G0"-,0)!H2$;;46O!

D-)!b,44"%!,.(!`;!?,.R/*0)!:0"&*!&$,&6!N%*+',4"&)!"%!-;0*!@0;,(4)!,@;'&!

0*4,&";.%$"1%6!4"A*!2$;"2*%!,.(!10,2&"2*%6!("%1;%"&";.%6!14*,%'0*%6!(*%"0*%!,.(!

A,.&,%"*%_,44!;A!:$"2$!,0*!,%1*2&%!;A!*/*0)(,)!4"A*!".!:$"2$!@;&$!2$"4(0*.!,.(!,('4&%!

,2&"/*4)!*.9,9*O!3YY7=!>.!8".(*09,0&*.6!,44!;A!&$*%*!,%1*2&%!;A!N%*+',4"&)O!,0*!

("%2'%%*(!*/*0)(,)!@)!@;&$!2$"4(0*.!,.(!,('4&%!3:"&$".!,!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!

A0,-*:;057=!

#$"%!2$,1&*0!@*9".%!:"&$!,.!*+,-".,&";.!;A!:$,&!:,%!%,"(!,@;'&!&$*!2$"4(0*.!

".!-)!A"*4(:;05!,.(!:,)%!("%2;'0%*%!;A!"..;2*.2*!2,.!A;0-!("%20*1,.2"*%!@*&:**.!

:$,&!"%!%,"(!,@;'&!:$,&!2$"4(0*.!#.,(,.(!:$,&!2$"4(0*.(%&!".!&$*"0!24,%%0;;-!,.(!

@0*,5E&"-*!14,)=!>!,.,4)J*!%*4*2&!".%&,.2*%!:$*0*!&$*!10;-;&";.!;A!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ff!P;&*!&$,&!N%*+',4"&"*%6O!A;0!);'.9*0!2$"4(0*.6!"./;4/*(!&,45".9!,@;'&!9,)!10"(*6!

".24'(".9!9,)!,2&"/"%&%!".!&$*!2'00"2'4'-6!,.(!;&$*0!&;1"2%!.;&!0*4,&*(!&;!%*+',4!,2&%=!

Page 138: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UfV!

!

:,%!*/"(*.&!".!*/*0)(,)!4"A*!".!8".(*09,0&*.=!>!(;!%;!A;0!&:;!1'01;%*%=!!#$*!A"0%&!"%!&;!

(*@'.5!&$*!-)&$!&$,&!%*+',4"&)!"%!.;&!,!&;1"2!:"&$".!8".(*09,0&*.=!#$"%!,((0*%%*%!

&$*!"(*,!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!$,/*!)*&!&;!&$".5!,@;'&!&$*!-*,.".9%!-,(*!0*9,0(".9!"%%'*%!;A!

%*+',4"&)!".!&$*"0!*/*0)(,)!4"/*%=!#$*!%*2;.(!"%!&;!20"&"2,44)!*+,-".*!:$,&!5".(%!;A!

$*&*0;%*+',4"&"*%!,.(!9*.(*0%!,0*!.;0-,4"J*(!3,44!&$*!:$"4*!"&!"%!(*."*(!&$,&!

%*+',4"&)!"%!("%2'%%*(!,&!,447=!!

>!2;.24'(*!&$"%!2$,1&*0!:"&$!,.!,.,4)%"%!;A!(,&,!&,5*.!A0;-!&:;!A;2'%!90;'1!

2;./*0%,&";.%=!#$*!A"0%&!&;;5!14,2*!('0".9!&$*!:**5!%'00;'.(".9!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!

*/*.&%6!&$*!%*2;.(!('0".9!*/*.&%!A;0!I;&$*0B%!C,)=!#$*!A"0%&!"44'%&0,&*%!:,)%!

2$"4(0*.!.,/"9,&*(!%;2",4!0'4*%!:$"4*!4*,0.".9!,22*1&,@4*!,.(!'.,22*1&,@4*!%;2",4!

2;(*%=!#$*!%*2;.(!10;/"(*%!,.!*+,-14*!;A!$;:!2$"4(0*.!&,5*!'1!%;2",4!2;(*%!,.(!

%'@%*L'*.&4)!1,0&"2"1,&*!".!1;4"2".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!2'4&'0*=!#;9*&$*0!

&$*)!"44'%&0,&*!$;:!.;0-,&"/*!,&&"&'(*%!&;:,0(%!%*+',4"&)!2,.!@*!*%&,@4"%$*(!".!

10"-,0)!%2$;;4!)*,0%=!#$*%*!*+,-14*%!2$,44*.9*!("%2;'0%*%!;A!2$"4($;;(!"..;2*.2*!

&$,&!1;%"&!L'**0!,.(!9*.(*0!.;.E2;.A;0-"&)!,%!-,&'0*!&;1"2%!.;&!%'"&,@4*!A;0!

);'.9*0!90,(*%=!I)!,.,4)%"%!%$;:%!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!,0*!24*,04)!1,0&"2"1,&".9!".!

-*,.".9E-,5".9!0*9,0(".9!%;2",4!0'4*%6!9*.(*06!,.(!%*+',4"&)!A0;-!&$*!;.%*&!;A!&$*"0!

*('2,&";.,4!*+1*0"*.2*%=!!

fCAE$fAJ$#A<Y$'8?HE$:C<>YFDB+$

K.!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)6!&$*!24,%%!14,)*(!,!9,-*!:$"2$!"./;4/*(!:,45".9!,0;'.(!

&$*!2"024*!%".9".96!Nb"44!);'!@*!-)!?,4*.&".*!,.(!%5"1!,4;.9!:"&$!-*eO!b$*.!,!2$"4(!

9;&!&;!&$*!*.(!;A!&$*!/*0%*6!&$*)!:;'4(!%&;1!,.(!&$*!1*0%;.!&$*)!:*0*!".!A0;.&!;A!

Page 139: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UfU!

!

:;'4(!0*14)X!N)*%=O!#$*!&:;!:;'4(!&$*.!%5"1!,0;'.(!&$*!2"024*!.*+&!&;!*,2$!;&$*0!

%".9".96!Ng*%6!>B44!@*!);'0!?,4*.&".*!,.(!%5"1!,4;.9!:"&$!);'=O!C'0".9!;.*!0;'.(!,!@;)!

%&;11*(!".!A0;.&!;A!,.;&$*0!@;)=!D!24,%%!0".94*,(*06!P,&,%$,6!%&,0&*(!9"994".9!,.(!

2,44".9!;'&!N>&B%!,!@;)E@;)!?,4*.&".*c!>&B%!,!@;)E@;)!?,4*.&".*c!#$,&B%!A'..)cO!

3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!U[<VY<UY7=!C'0".9!;'0!A"0%&!".&*0/"*:6!>!-*.&";.*(!&$*!".2"(*.&!&;!

I,09,0*&!,.(!,%5*(!"A!%$*!$,(!.;&"2*(!"&!;0!%"-"4,0!;22'00*.2*%!:"&$".!&$*!24,%%=!D%!

&$*!24,%%!:,%!/*0)!@;"%&*0;'%6!>!:,%!.;&!%'010"%*(!&$,&!&$*!2;--*.&,0)!$,(!9;.*!

'.(*0!$*0!0,(,0=!T;:*/*06!:$*.!,%5*(!"A!P,&,%$,B%!2;--*.&!:,%!,5".!&;!,.)&$".9!

%$*!$,(!$*,0(!".!&$*!24,%%!;.!;&$*0!;22,%";.%6!I,09,0*&!%&,&*(6!NP;&!%;!-'2$!:"&$!

&$"%!90;'1!,.(!>!M'%&!A".(!:"&$!8".(*09,0&*.!".!9*.*0,4!&$*)!M'%&!$,/*.B&!

(*/*4;1-*.&,44)!(*/*4;1*(!&$*!,:,0*.*%%!%;!-'2$!;A6!);'!5.;:6!"&B%!,!@;)!:"&$!,!

@;)6!"&B%!,!9"04!:"&$!,!9"046!"&B%!,!9"04!:"&$!,!@;)O!3Q;/*44,!YV<VY<UY7=!!!

T;:*/*06!".!&$*!%,-*!".&*0/"*:6!I,09,0*&!("%2'%%*(!,!2$"4(!:$;!,00"/*(!,&!

8".(*09,0&*.!24*,04)!.,/"9,&".9!-*,.".9%!;A!0;-,.&"2!0*4,&";.%$"1%=!H$*!(*%20"@*(X!

vHw$*B%!@**.!5".(!;A!;.*!;A!&$*!;.*%!&;!%,)6!o;$6!:*44!"&B%!,!@;)!,.(!,!9"046!,.(!"&!

4;;5%!4"5*!&$*)B0*!".!4;/*6!,.(!&$*)B0*!10;@,@4)!9;".9!&;!9*&!-,00"*(6B!,.(6!);'!

5.;:6!M'%&!$;:!-,.)!,%%'-1&";.%!%$*!,40*,()!$,%!,@;'&!:$,&!"&!"%!&;!@*!,!

9"046!;0!:$,&!"&!"%!&;!@*!,!9"04!&;9*&$*0!:"&$!,!@;)=!D.(!A0;-!&$*!@*9"..".9!;A!

&$*!%2$;;4!)*,0!&;;6!%$*!:,%!&,45".9!,@;'&!$,/".9!,44!&$*%*!@;)A0"*.(%!,.(!%$*!

:,%!4"5*6!o;$!:*446!&$"%!9')!"%!-)!@;)A0"*.(!.;:6B!,.(!o;$!>!$,/*!,!@;)A0"*.(6!

$*B%!;4(*0!&$,.!-*6!$*B%!".!90,(*!&$0**6B!,.(!"&!:,%!M'%&!%$*B(!2;-*!@,25!:"&$!

Page 140: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UfY!

!

,44!&$*%*!%&;0"*%!,@;'&!(,&".9!,.(!@;)A0"*.(%!,.(!&$,&!:,%!M'%&!$*0!".&*0*%&!

A;0!,:$"4*!3Q;/*44,!YV<VY<UY7=!!

#$*%*!1,%%,9*%!0*A4*2&!&$*!("%20*1,.2)!@*&:**.!("%2;'0%*!&$,&!2;.%&0'2&%!

2$"4(0*.B%!(*/*4;1-*.&,4!%&,&*!".!8".(*09,0&*.!,%!'.,:,0*!;A!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)6!

,.(!*/"(*.2*!;A!2$"4(0*.!,40*,()!.,/"9,&".9!.;&!;.4)!%'2$!"(*,%6!@'&!,4%;!&$*!.;0-%!

&$,&!%'00;'.(!&$*-=!I)!0*%*,02$!(*-;.%&0,&*%!$;:!("%2;'0%*%!;A!"..;2*.2*!,.(!

,9*E,110;10",&*!4*,0.".9!&,5*!14,2*!".!,!2;.&*+&!:$*0*".!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!,.(!

9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!,0*!.,&'0,4"J*(!,.(!&$*"0!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!%*+',4"&)!,%!,!&;1"26!

.*'&0,4"J*(=!#$*!(*.",4!&$,&!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!"%!%*+',4"&)!:;05%!".!&,.(*-!:"&$!&$*!

("%2;'0%*!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!,0*!N"..;2*.&O!3,%!*/"(*.2*(!".!&$*!2"&,&";.%!,@;/*7!,.(!(;!

.;&!&$".5!,@;'&!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4!;0"*.&,&";.=!#$*!("%20*1,.2)!@*2;-*%!,!@4;25!&;!

".&*0/*.&";.!;.!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!2'4&'0*!,%!10;1;%*(!2'00"2'4'-X!

("%2'%%";.%!,0*!-*&!:"&$!&$*!("%2;'0%*!,@;'&!!"#$(2$"4(0*.!,0*!3"..;2*.&76!0,&$*0!

&$,.!:$,&!&$*)!%&!3,%!:,%!"44'%&0,&*(!('0".9!&$*!,@;/*!".&*0/"*:%7=!!

b$"4*!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!:,%!10*%*.&!*/*0)(,)!".!24,%%6!L'**0.*%%!:,%!4,09*4)!

,@%*.&6!%,/*!;.*!4*2&'0*!;.!$;-;1$;@",=!b$*.!I,09,0*&!:,%!10*1,0".9!&;!(*4"/*0!

&$*!4*2&'0*6!%$*!%*.&!,!4*&&*0!$;-*!&;!1,0*.&%!:,0.".9!&$*-!;A!&$*!'12;-".9!&;1"2!

3-;0*!;.!&$"%!".!&$*!.*+&!2$,1&*07=!K.*!1,0*.&!5*1&!$*0!2$"4(!$;-*!A;0!&$*!(,)!

@*2,'%*!%$*!("(.B&!:,.&!$*0!(,'9$&*0!&;!,%5!L'*%&";.%!,@;'&!$*0!14,)-,&*B%!-;-B%!

0*4,&";.%$"1=f[!I,09,0*&!%1*2'4,&*(!&$,&6!N>!9'*%%!%$*!M'%&!A*4&!"&!:,%!,!@"&!&;;!-,&'0*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

f[!#$*!S;00*.EFS!I"."%&0)!;A!R('2,&";.!I,$$6,2,*$(<9.,,2,*$(;A!YVVk!"./;4/*(!,.!

,90**-*.&!A;0!("%&0"2&%!10;/".2*E:"(*!&$,&!(;*%!.;&!,44;:!1,0*.&%!&;!0*-;/*!&$*"0!

Page 141: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Uff!

!

;A!,!&;1"2!A;0!8".(*09,0&*.O!,.(!1;.(*0*(!N$;:!-,.)!;&$*0!A,-"4"*%!A**4!&$,&!:,)6!

&$,&!-,)@*6!);'!5.;:6!&$*)!:,.&!&;!%;-*$;:!".&0;('2*!&$*!"(*,!&$,&!&$*0*!,0*!

("AA*0*.&!:,)%!;A!$,/".9!,!A,-"4)!&;!&$*"0!2$"4(0*.6!@'&!-,)@*!A**4!&$,&!&$*)B0*!%&"44!

);'.9!,&!&$"%!1;".&!A;0!&$;%*!("%2'%%";.%!,.(!&$,&!5".(!;A!4*,0.".9!&;!$,11*.O!

3Q;/*44,!U]<V]<UY7=!

T,/".9!2;.('2&*(!$*0!&*,2$*0!&0,".".9!,&!&$*!d."/*0%"&)!;A!F0"&"%$!S;4'-@",!

".!YVVVEYVVU6!I,09,0*&!0*1*,&*(4)!*+10*%%*(!A0'%&0,&";.!&$,&!$*0!&*,2$*0!&0,".".9!

("(!.;&!"./;4/*!&;1"2%!;A!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)=!H$*!,4%;!2"&*(!$,/".9!("AA"2'4&)!A".(".9!

0*4*/,.&!2'00"2'4'-!;.4".*!:$*.!%*,02$".9!%"&*%!A;0!8".(*09,0&*.!*('2,&;0%=!

I,09,0*&!%1;5*!;A!&0)".9!&;!A".(!@;;5%!(*1"2&".9!%,-*E%*+!0*4,&";.%$"1%=!C*%1"&*!&$*!

*+"%&*.2*!;A!-;0*!&$,.!&:*.&)!1"2&'0*!@;;5%!9*,0*(!&;:,0(!*,04)!10"-,0)!%2$;;4!

3F*/*0"(9*6!H&,AA;0(76!4"@0,0",.%!,.(!@;;5%&;0*!24*05%!".A;0-*(!$*0!&$,&!&$*0*!:;'4(!

@*!.;&$".9!N,9*E,110;10",&*O!A;0!8".(*09,0&*.!:$*.!%$*!%1;5*!:"&$!&$*-!;.!&$*!

1$;.*!3Q;/*44,!U]<V]<UY7=!!

b"&$".!&$*!0*%1;.%*%!;A!4"@0,0",.%6!24*05%!,.(!1,0*.&%6!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!

%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!,0*!1;%"&";.*(!,%!(*/*4;1-*.&,44)!("%&".2&!A0;-!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-,&"/*!"(*.&"&"*%=!h"/*E)*,0E;4(!2$"4(0*.!,0*!9*.*0,44)!&$;'9$&!2,1,@4*!;A!

'.(*0%&,.(".9!&$,&!;11;%"&*E%*+!,&&0,2&";.!,.(!1,"0!@;.(".9!*+"%&!,.(!&$,&!

-,%2'4".*!-*.!3:$;!:*0*!,%%"9.*(!-,4*!,&!@"0&$7!,.(!A*-".".*!:;-*.!3:$;!:*0*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

2$"4(0*.!A0;-!24,%%*%!".!:$"2$!%;2",4!M'%&"2*!"%%'*%6!".24'(".9!%*+',4!;0"*.&,&";.6!"%!

("%2'%%*(!38*44)7=!#$,&!&$*!*('2,&;0%!,.(!1,0*.&%!:*0*!'.,:,0*!;A!&$"%!1;4"2)!

%1*,5%!&;!"&%!4,25!;A!2"02'4,&";.!,.(!&$*0*A;0*!"&%!*AA"2,2)!A;0!A,2"4"&,&".9!%;2",4!

2$,.9*=!!

Page 142: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Uf[!

!

,%%"9.*(!A*-,4*!,&!@"0&$7!:"44!@*!,.!*/*0)(,)!1,0&!;A!&$*"0!:;04(%=!T;:*/*06!&$;%*!

:$;!(*1,0&!A0;-!%'2$!.;0-%!,0*!*L',&*(!:"&$!"%%'*%!0*L'"0".9!(*/*4;1-*.&,4!

0*,(".*%%=!!

#$*!2$"4(0*.B%!&,45!,.(!14,)!0*A4*2&*(!&$"%!4,25!;A!".&*90,&";.!;A!L'**0.*%%!

,.(!9*.(*0!.;.2;.A;0-"&)!".&;!*/*0)(,)!4"A*=!I,.)!2$"4(0*.!5.*:!&$,&!%;-*!

A,-"4"*%!$,(!4*%@",.!-;-%!;0!9,)!(,(%6!@'&!"A!,%5*(!:$,&!,!A,-"4)!:,%6!&$*)!:;'4(!

%&"44!0*1*,&!&$,&!,!A,-"4)!$,(!,!-;-!,.(!,!(,(!,.(!@0;&$*0%!,.(!%"%&*0%!3I;&$*0B%!

C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1%!U!p!Y!U[<V]<YVUY6!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!Uf<VY<YVUY!p!

Yk<V[<YVUY7=f]!I,09,0*&!%'99*%&*(!&$,&!(*/*4;1-*.&,4!0*,(".*%%!-"9$&!@*!5**1".9!

&$"%!,:,0*.*%%!,&!@,)=!H$*!:;.(*0*(!:$*&$*06!N(*/*4;1-*.&,44)!;0!*+1*0"*.&",44)6!"A!

&$,&B%!M'%&!,!4"&&4*!@"&!@*);.(!&$*"0!90,%1=!a"5*6!&$*)!$,/*!,.!,:,0*.*%%!&$,&!&$;%*!

0*4,&";.%$"1%!*+"%&6!@'&!(;.B&!,114)!&$,&!%;-*$;:!&;!&$*_:$,&!&$*"0!(*A"."&";.!;A!,!

A,-"4)!"%O!3Q;/*44,!U]<V]<UY7=!!!!

C"%2;'0%*%!;A!,9*E,110;10",&*.*%%!2;;0(".,&*!:,)%!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-,&"/"&)!10*/,"4*(!".!*/*0)(,)!24,%%0;;-!4"A*_A0;-!1,0*.&,4!0*,2&";.%6!

,@%*.2*%!".!,/,"4,@4*!2'00"2'4'-6!&;!,!1*02*"/*(!4,25!;A!*+"%&".9!0*%;'02*%!3%'2$!,%!

1"2&'0*!@;;5%7!@*".9!,22*%%"@4*!&;!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!#$*!("%2;'0%*!;A!,9*E

,110;10",&*.*%%!@*2;-*%!,!%*4AEA'4A"44".9!10;1$*2)!@)!20*,&".9!"&%!;:.!*/"(*.2*X!,%!

"(*.&"&"*%!;'&%"(*!&$*!-,".%&0*,-!,0*!2;.%"(*0*(!;'&!;A!2$"4(0*.B%!(*/*4;1-*.&,4!

90,%16!&$*)!,0*!.;&!-*.&";.*(!,%!1,0&!;A!*/*0)(,)!4"A*_%'@%*L'*.&4)6!2$"4(0*.!;A&*.!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

f]!H,-*E%*+!1,0*.&%!,0*!.*94*2&*(!:"&$".!&$"%!.;0-,4"J*(!'.(*0%&,.(".9!;A!:$,&!,!

A,-"4)!"%6!,4;.9!:"&$!;&$*0!A,-"4)!A;0-,&";.%6!%'2$!,%!%".94*E1,0*.&!;0!1;4),-;0;'%!

A,-"4"*%=!!

Page 143: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Uf]!

!

$,/*!.;&!".&*90,&*(!&$*!0*,4"&)!;A!&$*%*!"(*.&"&"*%!".&;!&$*"0!*/*0)(,)!

'.(*0%&,.(".9%=!#$"%!4,25!;A!'.(*0%&,.(".9!"%!&$*.!2"&*(!,%!*/"(*.2*!;A!&$*!

2;-14*+"&)!;A!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!&$,&!0*.(*0%!&$*-!@*);.(!&$*!

90,%1!;A!);'.9!2$"4(0*.=!!

`,-*%!H*,0%!:0"&*%!&$,&6!NoS$"4($;;(!"..;2*.2*B!M'%&"A"*%!@;,0(".9!2$"4(0*.!".!

%'11;%*(4)!%*+EA0**!$,@"&,&%!{!,&!4*,%&!&$*%*!,0*!%*+4*%%!".!,('4&%B!-".(%O!3U]k7=!

T;:*/*0!,%!>!%&,&*(!,@;/*6!*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%!.;0-,4"J*!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)6!-,5".9!"&!

,.!*/*0E10*%*.&!1,0&!;A!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*6!:$"4*!.*'&0,4"J".9!"&%!%&,&'%!,%!%*+',4"&)=!

#$"%!.*'&0,4"J,&";.!$,%!.;&!$,11*.*(!".!,0*.,%!;'&%"(*!;A!&$*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-,&"/*!-,".%&0*,-=!#$*0*A;0*!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!,.(!9*.(*0E.;0-,&"/*!"(*.&"&"*%!

,0*!("%2'%%*(!,%!1,0&!;A!*/*0)(,)!4"A*!:$"4*!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!"(*.&"&"*%!,0*!

4,@*4*(!,%!N-,&'0*O!5.;:4*(9*%!2$"4(0*.!-'%&!.;&!4*,0.!,@;'&!@*A;0*!&$*)!,0*!

(*/*4;1-*.&,44)!0*,()6!4*%&!&$*)!".&*0A*0*!:"&$!&$*"0!"..;2*.2*=!!

H;-*!*('2,&;0%!9;!%;!A,0!,%!&;!(*A".*!2$"4($;;(!,%!"..;2*.2*!,.(!,%!

"9.;0,.2*!;A!&$*!*+"%&*.2*!;A!9,)!,.(!4*%@",.!1*;14*=!h;0!*+,-14*6!".!o#$*!S!b;0(%BX!

S4"&;0"%*%6!S$"4($;;(!,.(!S$,44*.9".9!S;-1'4%;0)!T*&*0;%*+',4"&)X!C"%2;'0%*%!:"&$!

G0*E%*0/"2*!G0"-,0)!#*,2$*0%6O!^0*9!S'00,.,!("%2'%%*%!,!&,45!$*!9,/*!;.!9,)!,.(!

4*%@",.!A,-"4"*%=!DA&*0!&$*!4*2&'0*6!,!%&'(*.&!2;.A0;.&*(!$"-!,.(!%&,&*(6!NS$"4(0*.!

%$;'4(!@*!,@4*!&;!@*!2$"4(0*.=!#$*)B0*!"..;2*.&=!#$*)!%$;'4(.B&!@*!4*,0.".9!,@;'&!

9,)%!,.(!4*%@",.%O!3U]k7=!>.!:$,&!$*!2,44%6!N;$E%;EA,-"4",06!:*44E:;0.!$*&*0;E

1,&0",02$,4!("%2;'0%*%O!3U]k7!2$"4(0*.!2*,%*!&;!@*!,44;:*(!&;!@*!2$"4(0*.6!"A!&$*"0!

Page 144: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Ufk!

!

5.;:4*(9*!*+&*.(%!@*);.(!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!b$*0*!(;*%!&$"%!4*,/*!

2$"4(0*.!:$;!5.;:6!A0;-!,.!*,04)!,9*6!&$,&!&$*)!(;!.;&!A"&!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%e!

fCAE$fAJ$4D=<ZEDY$<B$ECD$:>AJJF??@+$

K.!,.!;0(".,0)!-;0.".9!".!-)!A"*4(:;056!>!:,%!:,45".9!(;:.!&$*!$,44!,%!;.*!

A*-,4*!&*,2$*0!:,%!&,5".9!$*0!24,%%!A0;-!;.*!1,0&!;A!&$*!%2$;;4!&;!,.;&$*0=!H$*!

2,44*(!&;!$*0!2;44*,9'*!&$,&!%$*!:;'4(!2$*25!$*0!$'%@,.(B%!,/,"4,@"4"&)!@*A;0*!&$*)!

A"."%$*(!14,..".9!,!A"*4(&0"1=!H$*!2,00"*(!.;!%*4AE2;.%2";'%.*%%!;/*0!$,/".9!M'%&!

("%2'%%*(!%*+',4"&)!".!A0;.&!;A!$*0!24,%%=!S;.&".'".9!(;:.!&$*!$,44!&;!&$*!*.&0,.2*!;A!

&$*!4"@0,0)6!&$*0*!:,%!,!4,09*!("%14,)!@;,0(!A*,&'0".9!@;;5!M,25*&%!A0;-!,!:"(*!0,.9*!

;A!@;;5%X!%;-*!,@;'&!$*&*0;%*+',4!:*((".9%6!%;-*!,@;'&!,!2$"4(!".!&0;'@4*!A0;-!

&$*"0!$*&*0;%*+',4!1,0*.&%6!$*&*0;%*+',4!A,-"4"*%!;.!/,2,&";.6!,.(!;&$*0!A0*L'*.&!

&;1"2%!.;&!24,%%"A"*(!,%!("%2'%%".9!%*+',4"&)!:"&$!);'.9!1*;14*!3-'2$!4*%%!

2;00'1&".9!&$*"0!N"..;2*.2*O76!@'&!,%!%&;0"*%!,@;'&!,(/*.&'0*6!-"%$,16!,.(!2$"4(0*.!

.,/"9,&".9!&$*!:;04(!,0;'.(!&$*-=!b$*.!>!*.&*0*(!&$*!24,%%0;;-6!&$*!%&'(*.&!

&*,2$*0!:,%!&*44".9!&$*!%'11;0&!:;05*0!,.!,.*2(;&*!,@;'&!:$*.!$*0!(,(!-*&!$*0!

-;-=!H$*!:,%!.;&!("%2'%%".9!,.!"%%'*6!%$*!:,%!&*44".9!,!0;-,.&"2!%&;0)=!!

>.!*/*0)(,)!4"A*!".!&$*!%2$;;46!2$"4(0*.!:$;!'.(*0%&;;(!&$*-%*4/*%!,%!4"5*4)!

&;!90;:!'1!&;!@*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!:;'4(!@*!,@4*!&;!94"-1%*!1;&*.&",4!

A'&'0*%!&$,&!:;'4(!%'"&!&$*-!0*A4*2&*(!-'4&"14*!&"-*%!M'%&!A0;-!:,45".9!(;:.!&$*!

$,44!,.(!".&;!&$*"0!24,%%0;;-%=!#$*%*!(*1"2&";.%!:*0*!A"44*(!:"&$!&$*!%&'AA!;A!

*/*0)(,)!4"A*_14,..".9!A"*4(&0"1%6!A,-"4)!/,2,&";.%6!0;-,.&"2!@*9"..".9%_.;.*!;A!

:$"2$!:*0*!)337,3(;0!%1*2",4!&;1"2%=!#$*!A;44;:".9!&:;!24,%%!%&;0)&"-*%!"44'%&0,&*!

Page 145: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Ufi!

!

:,)%!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!:,%!&,5*.!'1!".!24,%%!2'00"2'4'-!&$,&!:*0*!.;&!

*+14"2"&4)!,@;'&!%*+',4"&)=!D9,".6!I,09,0*&B%!A;2'%!;.!20*,&".9!%1,2*!A;0!2$"4(0*.!&;!

@'"4(!%*4AE,:,0*.*%%!,.(!&$".5!20"&"2,44)6!:;05*(!,9,".%&!%;-*!;A!&$*!.;0-,&"/*!

&0*.(%!0*A4*2&*(!".!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!4"&*0,&'0*!@*4;:=!!

#$*0*!:*0*!9*.*0,44)!&:;!24,%%!%&;0)!&"-*%!*/*0)(,)=!#$*!-;0.".9!;A!

h*@0',0)!U]&$6!&$*!@;;5!:,%!U7+P\(<(D&W,(I$&.=6!@)!C;.!^"44-;0!,.(!I,0)Ea;'"%*!

^,)=!#$*!10;&,9;."%&!"%!D'%&".6!,!4"&&4*!@;)!:$;!"%!'1%*&!:$*.!,!9"04!-;/*%!".!.*+&!

(;;0=!C*%1"&*!$"%!4;'(!2;-14,".&%!,@;'&!9"04%6!$"%!,:5:,0(!20'%$!"%!-,(*!,11,0*.&!

&$0;'9$!,2&";.%!%'2$!,%!@'"4(".9!,!(".;%,'0!%5*4*&;.!,%!@"9!,%!$*0!$;'%*!;'&!;A!

1;1%"24*!%&"25%!".!$*0!@,25),0(=!>.!&$*"0!A"0%&!".&*0,2&";.6!D'%&".!%$;:%!'1!,&!&$*!

9"04B%!$;'%*!,.(!,..;'.2*%!&$*!.'-@*0!;A!&**&$!,!#)0,..;%,'0'%!Q*+!1;%%*%%*%6!

A;44;:*(!@)!&$*!9"04!".A;0-".9!$"-!&$,&!$*0!.,-*!"%!D-)=!D'%&".!4*,/*%!,.(!

2;-14,".%!&;!$"%!@'(()!&$,&!&$*0*!"%!,!9"04!.*+&!(;;0!:$;!(;*%.B&!5.;:!,.)&$".9=!

DA&*0!%"-"4,0!%;2",4!("%20*1,.2"*%6!D'%&".!&$".5%6!Nb$)!(;!9"04%!$,/*!&;!4"/*!.*+&!(;;0!

&;!);'eO!,.(!Nb$)!(;!9"04%!$,/*!&;!4"/*!,.):$*0*eO!3'.1,9".,&*(7=!#$;'9$!$*!

(*24,0*%6!N)'25cO!:$*.!$*!0*2*"/*%!,.!"./"&,&";.!&;!D-)B%!@"0&$(,)6!$*!%1*.(%!&$*!

:$;4*!."9$&!".!,!2;:@;)!2;%&'-*!4,%%;".9!&$*!-;;.!,.(!1'44".9!"&!;/*0!&:*.&)E&:;!

2;'.&0"*%!".!;0(*0!&;!&,5*!"&!&;!$*0!,%!,!@"0&$(,)!10*%*.&=!>&!&'0.%!;'&!&$,&!&$*!-;;.!

"%!-,(*!;A!@4'*!2$**%*6!:$"2$!&$*)!&,%&*6!%,)!N)'256O!,.(!(*2"(*!&;!*,&!2,5*!".%&*,(=!

#$*!4,%&!A0,-*!(*1"2&%!&$*-!%"&&".9!'.(*0!&$*!4,%%;*(!-;;.6!*,&".9!2,5*!&;9*&$*0=!!D!

2,&!,.(!,!(;9!%"&!.*+&!&;!*,2$!;&$*0!&;!&$*!%"(*=!!

Page 146: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UfZ!

!

I,09,0*&!%&;11*(!&$*!0*,(".9!".!%*/*0,4!14,2*%!&;!*.9,9*!&$*!2$"4(0*.!".!

(",4;9'*=!>.!&$*!@*9"..".9!%$*!,%5*(!$;:!D'%&".!5.;:%!&$,&!D-)!(;*%.B&!5.;:!

,.)&$".9=!8,&)!,.%:*0*(!".!$*0!L'"*&6!%*4AE,%%'0*(!:,)6!N@*2,'%*!%$*!("(.B&!%,)!

,.)&$".9!,@;'&!%2"*.2*O!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!U]<VY<UY7!&;!:$"2$!`*&&"*!M'-1*(!".6!N$*!

(;*%.B&!5.;:!$*0!)*&c!I,)@*!%$*B%!-,9"2,4cO!3)/)%7=!I,9"2!:,%!,4:,)%!,!1;%%"@4*!

*+14,.,&";.!A;0!`*&&"*6!:$;!.**(*(!&;!2;'.&!&$*!$;4*%!".!&0**%6!*/*.!".!1"2&'0*%6!&;!

%**!"A!&$*"0!1,&&*0.%!:*0*!".("2,&"/*!;A!A,"0"*%!4"/".9!".!&$*-=!I,09,0*&!("(!.;&!.**(!

&;!%&;1!&$*!24,%%!:$*.!D'%&".!:;.(*0*(!:$)!9"04%!$,/*!&;!4"/*!,.):$*0*=!8,&)!

".("9.,.&4)!M'-1*(!".6!N#$*)!2,.B&!4"/*!".!&$*!:,&*06!&$*)!2,.B&!4"/*!".!&$*!:;;(%u!

&$*)!,0*!.;&!:;4/*%cO!3)/)%7=!#$"%!:,%!A;44;:*(!,9,".!@)!`*&&"*B%!*+24,-,&";.6!N&$*)!

2,.B&!4"/*!".!%;-*;.*B%!$,"0=!>A!%$*!$,(!.;!$;'%*6!%$*!:;'4(!@*!1;;0O!3)/)%7=!F;&$!

(*-;.%&0,&*!&$*"0!2;.2*0.!A;0!&$*!"-14"2,&";.%!;A!D'%&".B%!%&,&*-*.&!;.!&$*!:*44!

@*".9!;A!9"04%=!I,09,0*&!,%5*(!:$)!D'%&".!A*4&!&$,&!:,)!,@;'&!9"04%!,.(!D%$4*)!

10;1;%*(!&$,&6!N@*2,'%*!&$*)!.*/*0!-*&!,.)O!3)/)%76!:"&$!`*&&"*B%!L'"25!".&*0M*2&";.!

&$,&!$*!NP*/*0!-*&6!.*/*0!&,45*(!&;!,.)=O!Q*9,0(4*%%!;A!&$*"0!".("9.,&";.6!:$*.!&$*)!

%,:!&$*!4,%&!A0,-*6!%*/*0,4!2$"4(0*.!2,44*(!;'&!N;;;O!,.(!N,$6O!:"&$!2;--*.&%!&$,&!

N.;:!&$*)B0*!9*&&".9!-,00"*(cO!:$"2$!0*2;9."J*(!&$*!"-14"*(!(*1"2&";.!;A!,!

0;-,.&"26!;0!(,&*E4"5*6!%2*.*!;.!&$*!24;%".9!1,9*=!!!!

#$*!&*,2$*0B%!L'*%&";.%!,.(!:"44".9.*%%!&;!,AA;0(!&"-*!A;0!%&'(*.&%B!

".&*0M*2&";.%!("(!*.2;'0,9*!20"&"2,4!*.9,9*-*.&!:"&$!&$*!%&;0)B%!"-14"2"&!%*+"%-=!

#$"%!2;'.&*0E,2&*(!:$,&!;&$*0:"%*!-,)!$,/*!.,&'0,4"J*(!@;)%!L'*%&";.".9!&$*!

%1,2*!9"04%!2;'4(!;0!%$;'4(!.;&!&,5*!'1=!D%!"&!:,%6!&$*!9"04%!/;"2*(!&$*"0!("%&0*%%!,.(!

Page 147: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UfW!

!

&"-*!:,%!9"/*.!A;0!&$"%=!T;:*/*06!,%!&$*!*.(!:,%!%&"44!".&*010*&*(!,%!,!0;-,.&"26!

1;%%"@4)!*/*.!,!:*((".96!%2*.*!&$,&!9*.*0,&*(!*+2"&*-*.&!(*%1"&*!&$*"0!10*/";'%!

'1%*&!,&!D'%&".B%!&$;'9$&%!,.(!A**4".9%!,@;'&!9"04%6!"&!"%!:;0&$!"./*%&"9,&".9!-'.(,.*!

:,)%!&$,&!9*.(*0!.;0-%!,0*!0*10;('2*(=!>.!&$"%!2,%*6!&$*!.;0-!2;'4(!0*"&*0,&*!&$*!

"(*,!&$,&!9"04%!:"44!@*!A0"*.(%!:"&$!@;)%!:"&$;'&!*+1*2&".9!*/*0)(,)!A,"0!&0*,&-*.&=!!

b$"4*!@;;5%!&$,&!%1*2"A"2,44)!(*,4&!:"&$!L'**0.*%%!:*0*!.;&!0*,(!".!&$*!24,%%6!

$*&*0;%*+',4!.;0-%!:;05*(!&$*"0!:,)!".&;!-,.)!4*%%;.%6!".24'(".9!,!'."&!;.!14,.&%!

,.(!&0**%=!G,0&!;A!&$*!I"."%&0)!;A!R('2,&";.B%!G0*%20"@*(!a*,0.".9!K'&2;-*%!A;0!

8".(*09,0&*.!0*L'"0*%!,!'."&!;.!&0**%!,.(!14,.&%!3^)*%,.9#.$,*!>7..)+7672(

A#+P#9,L=!#$;'9$!&$*%*!:;'4(!9;!'.(;2'-*.&*(!,%!1,0&!;A!(*@,&*%!,@;'&!N,9*E

,110;10",&*O!4*%%;.!14,.%!;.!9*.(*06!%*+',4"&)6!,.(!0*4,&";.%$"1%6!4*%%;.%!;.!

$*&*0;.;0-,&"/*!().,-"2%!:*0*!*-@*((*(!".!-'2$!;A!&$*!24,%%!2;.&*.&!;.!("AA*0*.&!

%'@M*2&%=!!h;0!*+,-14*6!@;)%!1"25*(!A4;:*0%!A;0!9"04%!".!@;;5%!,@;'&!$;:!A4;:*0%!

90*:!,.(!1"2&'0*%!;A!A,0-%!(*1"2&*(!$*&*0;%*+',4!2;'14*%=!!

K.!D10"4!Yi&$6!&$*!%&'(*.&!&*,2$*06!D-)!C,/"%6!0*,(!&$*!24,%%!H$*4!H"4/*0%&*".B%!

0",(E)W)*9(0.,,=!#$*!%&;0)!"%!,@;'&!,!0*4,&";.%$"1!@*&:**.!,!);'.9!@;)!,.(!&0**!:$;!

"%!0*A*00*(!&;!@)!A*-,4*!10;.;'.%=!#$*!@;)!4;/*%!&;!14,)!".!,.(!4*,.!,9,".%&!&$*!&0**6!

:$"2$!-,5*%!&$*!&0**!$,11)=!D%!&$*!@;)!90;:%!;4(*06!&$*!&0**!2;.&".'*%!&;!"./"&*!&$*!

@;)!&;!2;-*!,.(!%1*.(!&"-*!:"&$!",.=!!T;:*/*06!$*!(;*%.B&!$,/*!&"-*!,.(!".%&*,(!

:,.&%!&;!2'&!$*0!@0,.2$*%!&;!@'"4(!,!@;,&!,.(!*/*.&',44)!2'&%!(;:.!&$*!:$;4*!&0**!&;!

@'"4(!,!$;'%*=!>.!&$*!*.(6!,44!$*!.**(%!"%!,!14,2*!&;!0*%&!,.(!&$*!&0**6!:$;!&$;'9$&!%$*!

$,(!.;&$".9!4*A&!&;!9"/*6!9"/*%!$"-!&$,&=!!

Page 148: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U[V!

!

#$*!2$"4(0*.!9,%1*(!:"&$!$;00;0!:$*.!&$*!@;)!2'&!&$*!&0**!(;:.=!D%$4*)!

2,44*(!;'&!&$,&!"&B%!4"5*6!N2'&&".9!;AA!);'0!$*,(cO!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!U]<VY<UY7!:$"4*!

90,@@".9!$*0!&$0;,&!,.(!%$'((*0".9=!DA&*0!&$*!%&;0)!:,%!;/*06!D-)!,%5*(!&$*!24,%%!

:$,&!&$*!&0**!9"/*%!&$*!@;)=!H;-*!2$"4(0*.!1;".&*(!;'&!&$*!&0**!9,/*!*/*0)&$".9!@'&!

&$*!@;)!("(.B&!9"/*!,.)&$".9!@,25=!T;:*/*06!P,&,%$,!1;.(*0*(!&$,&!&$*!@;)!.**(*(!

&$".9%!,.(!&$,&!&$,&!-,(*!&$*!&0**!$,11)=!D-)!&$*.!A;2'%*(!&$*!2;./*0%,&";.!;.!

:$)!&$*!&0**!"%!$,11)6!$;:!&$*!&0**!4;/*%!&$*!@;)!,.(!"%!$,11)!&$,&!$*!"%!$,11)=!H$*!

%&,&*(!&$,&!&$*!@;)!9,/*!&$*!&0**!$,11".*%%!,.(!,%5*(6!N"%!&$,&!9"/".9!%;-*&$".9eO!

3)/)%7=!Q*2;9."J".9!&$*"0!2'*!&;!,!0$*&;0"2,4!N0"9$&O!,.%:*06!&$*!24,%%!2$"-*(!".!N)*%O!

3)/)%7=!#$*!;AA"2",4!1,0&!;A!&$*!2'00"2'4'-!"%!&$,&!".!8".(*09,0&*.!2$"4(0*.!:"44!4*,0.!

,@;'&!14,.&%!,.(!4"A*!2)24*%!;A!%**(%6!A4;:*0%6!A;;(6!;0!&0**%6!,.(!%;!;.=!b"&$".!&$"%!"%!

&$*!4*%%;.!,@;'&!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!,.(!0*4,&";.%$"1!().,-"2%6!".24'(".9!9*.(*0!

".*L',4"&)!,.(!A*-".".*!%,20"A"2*=!!

`'%&!,%!("%2;'0%*%!;A!"..;2*.2*!2,.!20*,&*!,!@,00"*0!&;!".24'(".9!L'**0!,.(!

&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%6!&$*!1,0,44*4!;@%2'0,&";.!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!,%!

,!&;1"2!,@;'&!%*+',4"&)!2,.!%*0/*!&;!0*10;('2*!9*.(*0*(!$"*0,02$"*%=!D-)!b,44"%!,.(!

`;!?,.R/*0)!:0"&*!,@;'&!$;:!0;'&".*!*/*0)(,)!$*&*0;<.;0-,&"/*!10,2&"2*%!&$,&6!

N-,".&,".!&$*!,11,0*.&!,%*+',4"&)!;A!10"-,0)!%2$;;4%!,4%;!0*".A;02*!9*.(*0*(!1;:*0!

0*4,&";.%$"1%O!3[YV7=!#$*)!&*44!;A!A*-,4*!&*,2$*0%!:$;!:;'4(!@*!9*&&".9!-,00"*(!

;/*0!&$*!%'--*0!:*,0".9!/*"4%!,&!,.!,%%*-@4)!:$"4*!&$*!10".2"1,4!,..;'.2*(!&$,&!

:$*.!&$*)!2,-*!@,25!&$*)!:;'4(!&$*.!@*!NI0%=O!3"@"(7=!#$*)!,4%;!(*%20"@*!$;:!"&!

Page 149: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U[U!

!

:,%!%**.!,%!,22*1&,@4*!A;0!@;)%!&;!&*44!9"04%!$;:!&;!%"&!:$*.!&$*)!:;0*!(0*%%*%!".!

24,%%=!b,44"%!,.(!?,.R/*0)!1;%"&";.!%'2$!".%&,.2*%!,%!A;44;:%X!

#$*!o$*&*0;%*+',4!-,&0"+B!;0!o2;-1'4%;0)!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)B!"%!.;&!;.4)!

;110*%%"/*!&;!4*%@",.%6!9,)%6!@"%*+',4%!,.(!;&$*0%!:$;!(;!.;&!2;.A;0-!&;!&$*!

$*9*-;."2!2;.%&0'2&";.!;A!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)6!"&!"%!,4%;!&$*!@,%"%!;.!:$"2$!

9*.(*06!,%!,!0*4,&";.!;A!(;-".,&";.!,.(!%'@;0(".,&";.6!"%!2;.%&0'2&*(=!P;&*!

&$,&!"&!"%!,!9).6O3(@*$,/";'0!&$,&!"%!1;4"2*(=!>&!"%!!&2,*(:$;%*!&"&4*%!-,05!&$*"0!

-,0"&,4!%&,&'%=!>&!"%!!&2,*(&*,2$*0%!:$;!:*,0!&$*"0!@0"(,4!/*"4%!&;!,%%*-@4)!

&;!,..;'.2*!&$*"0!"-1*.(".9!:*((".9%=!3[YV7!

#$*!2$"4(0*.B%!14,)!".!-)!A"*4(:;05!,4%;!(*-;.%&0,&*(!&$*!*/*0)(,)!.;0-,4"J,&";.!

;A!9*.(*0*(!1;:*0!"-@,4,.2*%=!H'2$!1;:*0!"-@,4,.2*%6!&$0;'9$!&$*"0!0*14"2,&";.!;A!

9*.(*0*(!$"*0,02$"*%6!,4%;!0*"A"*(!9*.(*0!@".,0"*%=!!

fCAE$fDFD$:C<>YFDB$4?<BI+$

C'0".9!-)!*&$.;90,1$"2!;@%*0/,&";.%6!9*.(*0*(!1;:*0!().,-"2%!".!&$*!

2$"4(0*.B%!14,)!:*0*!%&0"5".9=!#$*"0!,&&*-1&%!&;!*+*0&!&$*"0!:"44%!,.(!A;0-!%;2",4!

@*4;.9".9!,.(!*+24'%";.!2;'4(6!"A!.;0-,4"J*(6!*,%"4)!@*2;-*!%*+',4!,.(!$;-;1$;@"2!

$,0,%%-*.&=!#$*!A;44;:".9!*+2*01&%!&;;5!14,2*!;.!M'%&!&:;!(,)%6!@'&!,0*!*+*-14,0)!

;A!&$*!9*.(*0*(!1;:*0!.*9;&",&";.%!".!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!14,)!;.!,!(,"4)!@,%"%!;/*0!&$*!

-;.&$%!;A!-)!A"*4(:;05!;@%*0/,&";.%X!

>&!"%!S*.&0*%!&"-*=!8,&)!%"&%!$,11"4)!".!,!@;+!A'44!;A!1"44;:%=!C'.2,.!A4;1%!(;:.!

;.!&$*!A4;;0!,.(!0*1*,&*(4)!&*44%!8,&)!&$,&!&$*)!.**(!&;!14,)!,!9,-*!:$*0*!

&$*)!:"44!@*!-,00"*(=!DA&*0!,:$"4*!8,&)!0*14"*%6!N;5,)6!@'&!>B-!.;&!,2&',44)!

Page 150: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U[Y!

!

-,00)".9!);'=O!C'.2,.!%,)%6!N'$!$'$O!,%!"A!$*!(;*%!.;&!@*4"*/*!$*0!,.(!5**1%!

&,45".9!,@;'&!9*&&".9!-,00"*(=!T*!1'44%!8,&)B%!A;;&6!%$*!4;;5%!'.2;-A;0&,@4*!

@'&!A0;-!$*0!1*02$!;.!&$*!1"44;:%6!"&!"%!("AA"2'4&!&;!9*&!,:,)=!D%$4*)!:,45%!

;/*0!&;!&$*!%,-*!14,)!2;0.*0!,.(!@*9".%!,!-,5*E@*4"*/*!;AA"2*=!#$"%!"./;4/*%!

0*1*,&".96!N-,5*!-;0*!-;.*)6O!".!,!90'AA6!-,%2'4".*!&;.*=!8,&)!(*2"(*%!%$*!"%!

&$*!%*20*&,0)6!:$"4*!C'.2,.!M;".%!&$*!@;%%!0;4*=!T*!$;/*0%!".&"-"(,&".94)!;/*0!

8,&)!,.(!&$0*,&*.%!&;!20;%%!1$)%"2,4!@;'.(,0"*%!,%!1,0&!;A!&$*"0!-,5*!@*4"*/*!

9,-*=!T*!0*1*,&%6!N-,5*!-;0*!-;.*)!;0!:*!:"44!$'9!);'!,.(!5"%%!);'O!3)/)%7=!!

!

`*&&"*!M'-1%!".&;!&$*!9,-*!10;24,"-".96!N:*B0*!.;&!-,5".9!-;.*)6!@*2,'%*!

&$*)!,0*!.;&!%,)".9!14*,%*O!3)/)%7=!D%$4*)!,((%!14*,%*!&;!&$*!2;--,.(%!:$"4*!

`*&&"*!0,44"*%!,!90;'1!;A!2$"4(0*.!,&!,!.*,0@)!20,A&!&,@4*!".&;!&$*!9,-*!,%!

:;05*0%!:$;!:"44!.;&!-,5*!-;0*!-;.*)!'.4*%%!&$*!@;%%*%!%,)!14*,%*=!

C'.2,.!,((%!,!L'"*&!14*,%*!,%!:*44!,.(!10;2**(%!&;!)*446!N8,&)B%!*%2,1".96!9*&!

&$*!,4,0-%6!:**;;;E:**;;;=O!!

!

b$*.!8,&)!9*&%!&"0*(!;A!@*".9!2$,%*(!%$*!0*&'0.%!&;!$*0!1*02$!;.!&$*!1"44;:!

,.(!@*9".%!&;!14,)!:"&$!P,&,%$,!,.(!$*0!F,0@"*%=!C'.2,.!-,02$*%!;/*0!&;!

8,&)!,.(!,..;'.2*%6!!N2;-*!;.!8,&)6!>!$,/*!&;!&,45!&;!);'=!>P!GQ>?D#R=O!

b"&$;'&!&'0.".9!&;:,0(!$"-6!8,&)!%-"4*%!,.(!%,)%6!N.;!&$,.5!);'6O!:"&$!

2;.A"(*.2*!,.(!5**1%!14,)".9!:"&$!P,&,%$,=!C'.2,.!,9,".!-,02$*%!;/*0!&;!

8,&)!,.(!P,&,%$,!,.(!&$"%!&"-*!&*44%!P,&,%$,!&$,&!%$*!-'%&!2;-*!%1*,5!:"&$!

Page 151: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U[f!

!

$"-!".!10"/,&*6!"--*(",&*4)=!P,&,%$,!,09'*%!A;0!;.*!-;0*!-".'&*6!&$*.!%"9$%!

*+,%1*0,&*(4)6!,.(!,90**%=!T*!%&,&*%!&$,&!$*!:,.&%!&;!&*44!$*0!,!%&;0)6!:$"2$!

&$*.!@*2;-*%!&*44".9!$*0!,!%*20*&=!H$*!0*&'0.%!&;!8,&)6!)*44".96!N,096!$*!5"%%*(!

-*c=O!!8,&)!%&,.(%!'1!A0;-!$*0!1"44;:!1*02$!,.(!(*24,0*%6!N'$c!#$,&!"%!.;&!,!

/*0)!."2*!&$".9=O!

3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!]<V[<UY7=!

h,0!A0;-!@*".9!.*'&0,46!A;02*(!5"%%".9!"%!("%2'%%*(!&$0;'9$;'&!4"&*0,&'0*!

2;.2*0.*(!:"&$!%*+"%-!,.(!$;-;1$;@",!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!>.!T7%,B(U&7O.,(#(1#96!

G,%2;*!("%2'%%*%!0*%*,02$!".!:$"2$!9"04%!".!$"9$!%2$;;4!0,&*(!4*/*4%!;A!%*+',4!

$,0,%%-*.&!&$*)!*+1*0"*.2*(!,%!1,0&!;A!&$*"0!*/*0)(,)!4"/*%=!H$*!:0"&*%!,@;'&!$;:!

9"04%!("%24;%*(!&$,&6!N@*".9!5"%%*(!,9,".%&!&$*"0!:"44!:,%!&$*!:;0%&!A;0-!;A!%*+',4!

$,0,%%-*.&6!0,&*(!-;0*!%*0";'%4)!&$,.!$*,0".9!@;)%B!2;--*.&%!,@;'&!&$*"0!@;("*%!

;0!0*2*"/".9!;&$*0!&)1*%!;A!'.:,.&*(!%*+',4!,&&*.&";.O!3W[7=!Q,&$*0!&$,.!("%-"%%".9!

%'2$!".&*0,2&";.%!('*!&;!&$*!:,)!&$*)!,0*!%"&',&*(!".!14,)6!#$;0.*!*+,-".*%!&$*!

:,)%!%*+',4"J*(!&$0*,&%!,0*!,!:*,1;.!A;0!9*.(*0*(!1;:*0!&$0;'9$;'&!*4*-*.&,0)!

%2$;;4!:$*0*!@;)%!:;'4(!&$0*,&*.!9"04%!:"&$!5"%%*%!;0!&0)!&;!N1".2$!&$*"0!@'&&%O!3iU7!

"A!&$*)!("(!.;&!(;!&$*"0!@"((".9=!!#$;0.*!1;%"&%!%'2$!,2&";.%!,%!10*(*2*%%;0%!A;0!,!

2'4&'0*!&$,&!-"."-"J*%!,(;4*%2*.&!,.(!,('4&!%*+',4!$,0,%%-*.&=!H$*!:0"&*%X!

!>.!&$*!2$,09*%!,.(!2;'.&*0!2$,09*%!&$,&!,&&*.(!%;-*!*1"%;(*%!;A!&,&&4".96!;.*!

1,0&)!-,)!(*A".*!&$*!%"&',&";.!,%!,!%*0";'%!/";4,&";.6!:$"4*!&$*!;&$*0!1,0&)!

".%"%&%!&$,&!&$*)!:*0*!oM'%&!14,)".9=B!#$"%!1,&&*0.!0*2'0%!".!&$*!:,5*!;A!

14,)90;'.(!"./,%";.%X!@;)%6!A,0!-;0*!;A&*.!&$*!"./,(*0%6!;A&*.!24,"-!,!14,)!

Page 152: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U[[!

!

A0,-*6!@'&!9"04%6!-;0*!;A&*.!&$*!&,09*&%!;A!"./,%";.6!0*A'%*!&;!,22*1&!&$,&!

(*A"."&";.=!#$*!,%)--*&0)!".20*,%*%!:"&$!,9*j!-,.)!A;'0&$E!,.(!A"A&$E90,(*!

9"04%!%**!-,4*!"./,%";.%!,%!,!14,)90;'.(!.'"%,.2*!&$,&!%"-14)!-,5*%!&$*-!

,.90)=!#$"%!1,&&*0.!0*%*-@4*%!&$*!0*%&0'2&'0".9!;A!%*+',4!$,0,%%-*.&=!#$*!

$,0,%%*06!.*,04)!,4:,)%!-,4*6!;A&*.!24,"-%!&$,&!/*0@,4!,.(!1$)%"2,4!".&0'%";.!

".&;!&$*!&,09*&B%!1*0%;.,4!%1,2*!,0*!o,44!".!A'.6B!:$"4*!&$*!&,09*&6!'%',44)!

A*-,4*6!%**%!"&!,%!'.:,.&*(!,.(!*/*.!2;*02"/*!,&&*.&";.=!T"*0,02$"*%!$*41!

(*&*0-".*!:$;%*!/*0%";.!;A!0*,4"&)!:"44!10*/,"4=!3ZV7!

h;02*(!5"%%".9!3,.(!&$*!&$0*,&!;A!"&7!".!8".(*09,0&*.!2$"4(0*.B%!14,)!*+"%&%!".!&$*!

4,09*0!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!".!:$"2$!A;02*(!%*+',4"J*(!2;.&,2&!"%!.;0-,4"J*(=!!

#$*!().,-"2%!,&!14,)!:"&$".!-)!A"*4(:;05!1;".&!&;!:,)%!&$*!0*20*,&";.!;A!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!1;:*0!-,)!@*!,(("&";.,44)!2;-14"2,&*(=!D%!10*/";'%4)!

-*.&";.*(6!C'.2,.!:,%!*+1*0"*.2".9!2;.A4"2&!('*!&;!A**4".9!N4"5*!,!9"04!".%"(*=O!b$,&!

(;*%!"&!-*,.6!&$*.6!&$,&!$*!,990*%%"/*4)!1*01*&',&*(!.;0-%!0*9,0(".9!-,%2'4"."&)!

,.(!1;:*0e!T,(!$*!,%%;2",&*(!%'2$!,2&";.%!:"&$!,!%'22*%%A'4!*.,2&-*.&!;A!

-,%2'4"."&)!".!:$"2$!$*!;&$*0:"%*!-"9$&!A,"4e!Q*9,0(4*%%!;A!&$*!0*,%;.%6!&$*!(,&,!

,@;/*!3,%!:*44!,%!&$*!(,&,!".!&$*!A;44;:".9!%*2&";.7!10;/"(*!,.!*+2*44*.&!*+,-14*!;A!

$;:!,.)!2$"4(6!*/*.!&$;%*!;AA!&$*!0,(,0!,%!N9*.(*0!.;.2;.A;0-".96O!-,)!@*!

.*9,&"/*4)!,AA*2&*(!@)6!:$"4*!%"-'4&,.*;'%4)!1*01*&',&".96!%)%&*-%!;A!(;-".,&";.!

,.(!%'@;0(".,&";.!*-@*((*(!".!*/*0)(,)!".%&"&'&";.,4"J*(!10,2&"2*%!;A!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!!#;!0*&'0.!&;!*+,-14*%!A0;-!-)!A"*4(.;&*%X!

Page 153: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U[]!

!

#$*!%&;0)!0*,(!@*A;0*!&$*!24,%%B%!,A&*0.;;.!0*2*%%!"%!4&.%3(#.,(@&$(-&.(

S7.$)*9!@)!R4"J,@*&$!?*0("25!,.(!I,0"*5,!T*".4*.=!I,09,0*&!,%5%!&$*!

%&'(*.&%!&;!1,)!,&&*.&";.!&;!&$*"0!@;("*%!,.(!%**!"A!&$*)!.;&"2*!2$,.9*%!:$*.!

&$*)!$*,0!&$*!$'0&A'4!:;0(%!@*".9!0*,(=!#$*)!9,%16!:$"-1*06!,.(!%$'((*0!

:$*.!&$*)!$*,0!&$*!$'0&A'4!:;0(%=!#$*)!10,2&"2*!%,)".9!&$*!:;0(%=!R/*0)!

&"-*!&$*!:;0(!N%&'1"(O!"%!%,"(6!%;-*!;A!&$*!2$"4(0*.!1'&!&$*"0!$,.(%!;/*0!&$*"0!

*,0%!,.(!9,%1=!#$*)!&,45!,@;'&!&$*!:;0(!N%&'1"(O!,.(!&$*!:;0(!N%;00)O!@*".9!

1;:*0A'4=!b$*.!&$*)!10,2&"2*!&*44".9!1*;14*!&$*)!(;.B&!4"5*!&$;%*!:;0(%!,.(!

:;0(%!,0*!.;&!A;0!$'0&".96!&$*!2$"4(0*.!1,0&"2"1,&*!&$;'9$&A'44)!,.(!2,44!;'&!

-,.)!%'99*%&";.%!,%!&;!$;:!&;!$,.(4*!$'0&A'4!%"&',&";.%=!!

!

DA&*0!&$*!%&;0)6!&$*!24,%%!$*,(%!;'&%"(*!&;!14,)=!`*&&"*!0'.%!,20;%%!&$*!A"*4(!,.(!

M'-1%!;.!,!1"*2*!;A!14,)90;'.(!*L'"1-*.&!:"&$!&:;!@;)%=!>&!"%!,!%1"..".9!0*(!

-*&,4!2"024*!&$,&!$,%!,!1;4*!:"&$!$,.(4*%!;.!"&=!C'.2,.!%&,0&%!9*&&".9!-,(!&$,&!

`*&&"*!$,%!9;&&*.!;AA!,.(!9;&&*.!@,25!;.!,.(!%;!"&!"%!.;!4;.9*0!$*0!&'0.=!T*!

%&,.(%!24;%*!*.;'9$!&;!&$*!*L'"1-*.&!&;!4;;-!;/*0!$*0!,.(!%,)%!

&$0*,&*.".94)6!N);'!2,.!9*&!;AA!.;:!;0!:*!2,.!A;02*!);'!;AAc!>%!&$,&!:$,&!);'!

:,.&e!C;!);'!:,.&!'%!&;!A;02*!);'eO!`*&&"*!"9.;0*%!$"-!,.(!$*!2;.&".'*%!&;!

*%2,4,&*!&$*!&$0*,&%6!%,)".9!&$,&!&$*)!2;'4(!1'%$!$*0!;AA!;0!(0,9!$*0!;AA6!"&!:,%!

$*0!N2$;"2*=O!T"%!-;/*-*.&%!@*2;-*!,9"&,&*(!,.(!,990*%%"/*=!H$*!(;*%.B&!

-;/*=!T*!%&,&*%6!N&$,&B%!"&6O!2;'.&%!(;:.!A0;-!A"/*!,.(!&'0.%!,0;'.(!)*44".96!

N;5,)6!1'%$".9cO!C)4,.6!:$;!"%!1$)%"2,44)!-'2$!%-,44*0!&$,.!@;&$!C'.2,.!

Page 154: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U[k!

!

,.(!`*&&"*6!M'-1%!@*&:**.!&$*-!:"&$!$"%!,0-%!;'&%&0*&2$*(!$;4(".9!$"%!$,.(%!

".!,!N%&;1O!1;%"&";.=!T"%!%$;'&%!:"&$!,.+";'%!2;.2*0.6!NC;.B&c!H&;1c!

Q*-*-@*0!&$*!@;;5e=O!#$*!".&*0/*.&";.!10;/*%!*AA*2&"/*6!,%!C'.2,.B%!

,990*%%"/*!@;()!4,.9',9*!(*E*%2,4,&*%!,.(!$*!%L'**J*%!;.!&$*!(*%"0*(!1"*2*!

;A!14,)90;'.(!*L'"1-*.&!:"&$!&$*!;&$*0!&$0**!2$"4(0*.=!#$*)!,44!%&,0&!M;5".9!

&;9*&$*0!,.(!4,'9$".9!,@;'&!1;;=!!

I*,.:$"4*6!A;'0!@;)%!1".!P,&,%$,!;.!&$*!90;'.(6!2$,.&".96!N.;!1;:*06!.;!

1;:*0=O!!P,&,%$,!"%!,-;.9!&$*!-;0*!1$)%"2,44)!,2&"/*!;A!&$*!2$"4(0*.=!H$*!

&,45%!,@;'&!@*".9!9;;(!,&!%1;0&%6!%$;:%!8,0,&*!-;/*%!A;0!%$;:!,.(!&*446!,.(!

*+10*%%*%!2;.A"(*.2*!".!$*0!@;()B%!%&0*.9&$!:$*.!.,/"9,&".9!14,)90;'.(!

*L'"1-*.&=!H$*!)*44%!@,256!N(;!>!.**(!&;!&*44eO!,.(!&$*)!%2,&&*0=fk!>!,-!%&0'25!

@)!&$*!'%*!;A!1$)%"2,4!A;02*!,.(!2,..;&!$*41!@'&!:;.(*0!$;:!"&!:;'4(!14,)!

;'&!".!,!24,%%0;;-!:"&$!4*%%!&*,2$*0!/,4"(,&";.!;A!2$"4(0*.B%!0"9$&%!&;!&$*"0!

;:.!@;'.(,0"*%!,.(!(*%"0*!&;!".%&"44!&$*!"-1;0&,.2*!;A!2;.%*.&=!>!:;.(*06!

&;;6!$;:!&$,&!,2&";.!:;'4(!14,)!;'&!:"&$!,!4*%%!,%%*0&"/*!9"046!:$,&!%$*!:;'4(!

@*!4*,0.".9!,@;'&!$*0%*4A!,.(!:$,&!&$*!@;)%!:;'4(!@*!4*,0.".9!,@;'&!

*.&"&4*-*.&!,.(!1;:*0!;/*0!;&$*0!1*;14*_*%1*2",44)!9"04%!,.(!:;-*.=!!

3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!Yk<V[<UY7=!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

fkF;&$!I,09,0*&!,.(!`,-*%!3&$*!H&'(*.&!H'11;0&!b;05*07!:*0*!10*%*.&!;'&%"(*!

:"&$!&$*!2$"4(0*.!('0".9!&$*%*!14,)&"-*%=!T;:*/*06!:"&$!&$*!.'-@*0!;A!A,%&!-;/".9!

,.(!4;'(!2$"4(0*.6!"&!:,%!*,%)!&;!-"%%!-,.)!".&*0,2&";.%=!h;0!*+,-14*6!&:;!;A!&$*!

2$"4(0*.!:;'4(!0*9'4,04)!20)!&;!&$*!1;".&!;A!.*,0E$)1*0/*.&"4,&";.=!b$*.!I,09,0*&!

:;'4(!@*!,&&*.(".9!&;!&$*!%,A*&)!&;!;.*!;A!&$;%*!2$"4(0*.!".!&$;%*!-;-*.&%6!;&$*0!

14,)!:;'4(!.;&!0*2*"/*!-'2$!".&*0/*.&";.=!!

Page 155: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U[i!

!

d.(*0%&;;(!".!&$*!2;.&*+&!;A!9*.(*0!().,-"2%!,.(!1;:*0!@*".9!4*,0.*(!

%"-'4&,.*;'%4)6!&$*%*!;22'00*.2*%!,0*!4".5*(!&;!:$,&!@*2;-*%!.;0-,&"/*!".!

".&*01*0%;.,4!".&*0,2&";.%=!b,44"%!,.(!?,.R/*0)!,((0*%%!:,)%!(;-".,.&!("%2;'0%*!

;A!2$"4($;;(!"..;2*.2*!2,.!-,%5!1;:*0!&$,&!"%!.,/"9,&*(!,.(!.;0-,4"J*(!".!

2$"4(0*.B%!14,)=!#$*!&$*;0"J,&";.!;A!&$*%*!%2$;4,0%!"%!1,0&"2'4,04)!0*4*/,.&!&;!&$*!

,990*%%"/*!,2&";.%!".!&$*!0*2*%%!14,)!(*%20"@*(!,@;/*=!#$*)!:0"&*6!N#$*!10,2&"2*%!

&$,&!-,".&,".!&$*!,11,0*.&!,%*+',4"&)!;A!10"-,0)!%2$;;4%!,4%;!0*".A;02*!9*.(*0*(!

1;:*0!0*4,&";.%$"1%=!F;)%!,0*!,44;:*(!&;!1;4"2*!&$*!@*$,/";'0!;A!9"04%!"A!&$*)!,0*!

o%$;:".9!&$*"0!5."25*0%=B!^,-*%!;A!5"%%E2$,%*!4,)!&$*!90;'.(:;05!A;0!&$*!".,@"4"&)!;A!

-*.!&;!$*,0!o.;B!,.(!&$*!A'&"4"&)!;A!:;-*.!%,)".9!"&uO!3[YV7=!!#$*%*!10,2&"2*%!(;!.;&!

*.(!;.!&$*!14,)90;'.(6!@'&!@*2;-*!1,0&!;A!".%&"&'&";.,44)!.;0-,4"J*(!%;2",4!

().,-"2%=!G,%2;*!;@%*0/*%!&$*!4".5!@*&:**.!9*.(*0!.;0-%!,.(!$*&*0;.;0-,&"/*!

%;2",4!0"&',4%!A;0!A4"0&".9X!ND&!Q"/*0!T"9$!-,%2'4"."&)!:,%!*%&,@4"%$*(!&$0;'9$!

9*.(*0*(!0"&',4%!;A!&;'2$!"./;4/".9!@;)B%!1$)%"2,4!(;-".,.2*!,.(!9"04%B!%'@-"%%";.O!

3Wk7=!!

C*.)".9!&$*!2;-14*+"&)!;A!1;:*0!".!2$"4(0*.B%!14,)!,44;:%!%'2$!1;:*0!

().,-"2%!&;!@*2;-*!*.&0*.2$*(!:"&$;'&!;AA*0".9!&;;4%!A;0!20"&"2,4!30*7&$".5".9!,.(!

0*%"%&,.2*=!>.!&$"%!:,)6!("%2;'0%*%!;A!"..;2*.2*!%*0/*!&;!0*".A;02*!&$*!%&,&'%!L';6!

0,&$*0!&$,.!10;&*2&".9!2$"4(0*.!A0;-!$,0-=!h".!S'44*.!,.(!a,'0,!H,.()!,09'*!&$,&6!

("%2'%%".9!%*+',4"&)!:"&$!2$"4(0*.!"%!A0,'9$&X!

vaw,09*4)!A0;-!&$*!0;-,.&"2!.;&";.!;A!&$*!"..;2*.&!,.(!.;.E%*+',4!2$"4(!,%!

20*,&*(!&$0;'9$!&$*!/,%&!:*,4&$!;A!("%2'%%";.!:"&$".!1'@4"2!4"A*!,@;'&!

Page 156: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U[Z!

!

2$"4(0*.!.**(".9!&;!@*!10;&*2&*(!A0;-!'.:,.&*(!%*+',4!,(/,.2*%!,.(!

(*%"0*%=!#$"%!/*0)!.;&";.!;A!,.!"..;2*.&6!.;.E%*+',4!2$"4(!9"/*%!0"%*!&;!,!

("%2;'0%*!;A!10;&*2&";.6!:$"2$!".!&'0.!0*".A;02*%!("%2;'0%*%!;A!"..;2*.2*=!

T;:*/*06!,%!F"25-;0*!,09'*%6!"&!"%!);'.9!2$"4(0*.B%!%"J*!".!,(("&";.!&;!&$*"0!

0*4,&"/*!4,25!;A!1;:*0!,.(!5.;:4*(9*6!0,&$*0!&$,.!o"..;2*.2*B6!:$"2$!A;0-%!

&$*!@,%"%!;A!2$"4(0*.B%!/'4.*0,@"4"&)=!#$"%!o4,25B6!%$*!,09'*%6!.*9,&*%!2$"4(0*.B%!

0"9$&%!&;!%*4AE(*&*0-".,&";.!".!&$*"0!&0,.%"&";.!&;!A'44!2"&"J*.%$"1=!3U[[7!

G0*/";'%4)6!>!,09'*(!&$,&!("%2;'0%*%!;A!"..;2*.2*!.,&'0,4"J*!"9.;0,.2*!;A!

L'**0.*%%!,.(!9*.(*0!.;.E2;.A;0-"&)6!:$"2$6!".!&'0.6!"%!'%*(!&;!%'11;0&!&$*!

2;.2*1&',4"J,&";.!;A!2$"4(0*.!,%!N&;;!"..;2*.&O!&;!'.(*0%&,.(!(*1,0&'0*%!A0;-!&$*!

$*&*0;<.;0-,&"/*!-,".%&0*,-=!I)!A"*4(:;05!;@%*0/,&";.%6!,.(!S'44*.!,.(!H,.()B%!

20"&"L'*%6!"44'-".,&*!,.!,(("&";.,4!2;.%*L'*.2*!;A!("%2;'0%*%!;A!"..;2*.2*!:$*0*@)!

2$"4(0*.!,0*!(*."*(!&$*!-*,.%!:"&$!:$"2$!&;!10;&*2&!&$*-%*4/*%=!b$*.!"..;2*.2*!"%!

2;.A4,&*(!:"&$!"9.;0,.2*6!*('2,&";.!,.(!&;;4%!A;0!%*4AE10;&*2&";.!,0*!*L',&*(!:"&$!

2;00'1&";.6!0,&$*0!&$,.!1*0%;.,4!1;:*0=!#$'%6!".!&$*!.,-*!;A!10;&*2&".9!2$"4(0*.6!

2$"4(0*.!,0*!".,(/*0&*.&4)!-,(*!-;0*!/'4.*0,@4*=!F)!%&0*%%".9!&$*!:,)!2$"4(0*.!

:*0*!.;&!"..;2*.&!".!&$*"0!14,)!;0!".!&$*!2;./*0%,&";.6!-)!A"*4(%&'()!,4%;!0*/*,4%!

1;".&%!;A!0*%"%&,.2*!&;!1;:*0!().,-"2%!%'2$!,%!C)4,.B%!".&*0/*.&";.!;.!C'.2,.B%!

'%*!;A!2;*02"/*!1;:*0!,.(!P,&,%$,B%!2;.A"(*.2*!".!$*0%*4A!,.(!$*0!1;:*0!&;!9,".!

I,09,0*&B%!%'11;0&!3.;&!&;!-*.&";.!I,09,0*&!".%&"44".9!&$"%!2;.A"(*.2*!&$0;'9$!$;:!

%$*!4"%&*.*(!&;!$*0!%&'(*.&%7=!!

Page 157: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U[W!

!

fCAE$fDFD$:C<>YFDB$#A9<BI+$

b$*.!>!@*9,.!&;!2;.('2&!&$*!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!A;2'%!90;'1%6!&$*!A"0%&!".!,!

0;'.(!;A!&$0**!A;2'%!90;'1%!:"&$!&$*!2$"4(0*.6!>!@*4"*/*(!&$*!90;'1%!:;'4(!"44'%&0,&*!

&,@;;%!,0;'.(!9*.(*0!,.(!?,4*.&".*%=!b$,&!*-*09*(!:,%!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!

*.9,9*-*.&!:"&$!4*,0.".9!&$*!N0'4*%O!;A!%;2",4!@*$,/";'0!".!&$*!24,%%=!h;0!*+,-14*6!

&$*)!0*1*,&*(4)!0*-".(*(!*,2$!;&$*0!;A!&$*!24,%%!0'4*!&$,&!"A!);'!9,/*!,!?,4*.&".*!&;!

;.*!1*0%;.6!);'!$,(!&;!9"/*!;.*!&;!*/*0);.*!".!&$*!24,%%=!#$"%!$,11*.*(!".!

2;.M'.2&";.!:"&$!2$"4(0*.!("%2'%%".9!%;2",4!@;'.(,0"*%!,.(!-*,.".9!-,5".9=!#$*)!

:;'4(!20*,&*!%2*.,0";%!&$,&!0*A4*2&*(!&$*"0!"(*,%!,0;'.(!9"A&!9"/".9!,.(!:"&$$;4(".96!

%'2$!,%!&$,&!".!&$*!2;./*0%,&";.!@*4;:X!

`*&&"*X!b*446!%;-*&"-*%!>u!%;-*&"-*%!>!9"/*!?,4*.&".*%!&;!-)!A0"*.(%!:$;!@*!

."2*!&;!-*!,.(!:$;!(;.B&!@*!."2*!&;!-*!>!(;.B&!9"/*!&$*-!?,4*.&".*!2,'%*!"A!>!

9"/*!&$*-!?,4*.&".*B%6!&$*)!(;.B&!9"/*!-*!?,4*.&".*B%!@,25!%;!>!(;.B&!9"/*!

&$*-!?,4*.&".*%!"A!&$*)B0*!@*".9!-*,.!&;!-*=!!

C)4,.X!d$6!`*&&"*u!

`*&&"*X!I$--e!

C)4,.X!>A!);'!9"/*!,!?,4*.&".*!&;!;.*!1*0%;.6!);'!$,/*!&;!9"/*!"&!&;!&$*!:$;4*!

24,%%=!

3?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1!U!U]<VY<UY7!

`*&&"*!$,(!9"/*.!?,4*.&".*%!&;!*/*0);.*!".!&$*!24,%%6!@'&!,11*,0*(!&;!@*!.,/"9,&".9!

$*0!;:.!@;'.(,0"*%!,0;'.(!:$*.!&;!9"/*!;0!.;&!9"/*!9"A&%=!!

Page 158: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U]V!

!

a,09*0!2'4&'0,4!.;0-%!0*9,0(".9!9"A&!9"/".9!,%!1,0&!;A!%;2",4!@*4;.9".9!:*0*!

,11,0*.&!".!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1%=!b$*.!,%5*(!:$,&!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!:,%!,@;'&6!&$*!

,.%:*0%!9*.*0,44)!1,"0*(!A;;(!,.(!,AA*2&";.6!%'2$!,%!N4;/*!,.(!2,.()cO!3?,4*.&".*B%!

C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1!Y!Uk<VY<UY7!,.(!NA0"*.(%$"1!,.(!2$;2;4,&*O3?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!h;2'%!

^0;'1!f!Uk<VY<UY7=!b$*.!,%5*(!:$)!&$*%*!&$".9%!:*.&!&;9*&$*06!2;./*0%,&";.%!

%'2$!,%!&$*!A;44;:".9!&;;5!14,2*X!

D@"9,"4X!1*;14*!9"/*!*,2$!;&$*0!2,.()!,.(!&$*.!&$*)!4;/*!*,2$!;&$*0=!!

8,&)X!b*446!"&B%!,!10*%*.&!&;!%$;:!&$*)!2,0*!,@;'&!1*;14*=!!

DX!Q"9$&=!K5,)=!

D@"9,"4X!g*,$6!"A!);'!(;.B&!9*&!2,.()!"&!-*,.%!&$,&!&$*)!(;.B&!2,0*!,@;'&!);'=!!

DX!K$e!b$,&!"A!%;-*;.*u!

D@"9,"4X!b*446!4"5*!3A0"*.(B%!.,-*7!("(.B&!9"/*!-*!2,.()!*/*.!&$;'9$!%$*!2,0*%!

,@;'&!-*u!M'%&!@*2,'%*u!

8,&)X!g;'!(;.B&!"#W,c!v%"2w!K.!-)!2,0(%!>!("(.B&!9"/*!1*;14*!2,.()!@*2,'%*!-)!

-;-!&$".5%!"&B%!9,0@,9*!A;;(=!!

!3)/)%7=!!!

P,&,%$,!,.(!`*&&"*!,4%;!("%2'%%*(!&$*!10;2*%%!;A!9"/".9!2,0(%!,%!,!:,)!&;!

0*('2*!%;2",4!A*,0!,.(!,.+"*&)X!

`*&&"*X!>A!%;-*@;()!"%!.*:!@'&!>!:,.&*(!&;!9"/*!$*0!,!?,4*.&".*!2,0(!@'&!"A!

%$*B%!.*:!&;!&$"%!%2$;;4!@'&!.;&!.*:!&;!&$"%!%2$;;4!@'&!.*:!&;!&$"%!1,0&!,.(!>!

:,%!&$*0*!,.(!>!:,%.B&!.*:!@'&!&$*.!>!:,.&*(!&;!9"/*!$*0!,!?,4*.&".*!,.(!>!

9*&!?,4*.&".*%!,.(!>!:,%!,!4"&&4*!@"&!.*0/;'%!&$*.!&;-;00;:!"A!>!:,%!&$*0*!,.(!

Page 159: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U]U!

!

"A!%$*!:,%!&$*0*!,.(!>!:,%!,!4"&&4*!@"&!.*0/;'%!&$*.!>!2;'4(!9;!,.(!%,)!N(;!);'!

:,.&!,!?,4*.&".*eO!,.(!%$*!2;'4(!%,)!)*%!;0!.;!,.(!&$*.!>!2;'4(!M'%&!,%5!$*0!

,.(!&$*.!"A!%$*!%,"(!)*%!,.(!>!2;'4(!M'%&!,%5!$*0!A0"*.(!,.(!"A!%$*!%,"(!)*%!&$*.!

&$,&!2;'4(!M'%&!$,11*.!3?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1![!Uk<VY<UY7=!

`*&&"*X!H,)!&$,&!D."5,!:,%!-)!A0"*.(!,.(!>!:,%!,!@"9!&**.,9*0c!3H&,.(%!'1!;.!

&$*!@*.2$!:"&$!$*0!$,.(%!;/*0!$*0!$*,(7!,.(!%$*!:,%!4"5*!,!4"&&4*!&**.,9*0!

,.(6!,.(!);'!:*0*!4"5*!,.(!);'!:*0*!4"5*!%2,0*(!;A!-*!,.(!10*&*.(!&$,&!

P,&,%$,6!:,%!0*,44)6!0*,44)!%-,44u!

P,&,%$,X!T*)c!>B-!@"99*0!&$,.!);'!,.(!>B-!0*,44)6!0*,44)!%-,44u!

DX!34,'9$".97!4*&B%!.;&!24"-@!;.!&$*!&,@4*!&$;'9$6!@*2,'%*!>!(;.B&!:,.&!&;!%**!

);'!9*&!$'0&u:*B44!"-,9".*!);'B0*!0*,44)!@"9=!!

`*&&"*X!H;!%$*!:,%!0*,44)6!0*,44)!%-,44=!

3Q*1*,&%=!P,&,%$,!20;'2$*%!(;:.7!

P,&,%$,X!T*44;c!3".!,!4"&&4*!/;"2*=7!

3Q*1*,&%!".&*0,2&";.!&:"2*=7!

`*&&"*X!,.(!>!:,%!0*,44)6!0*,44)!@"9!,.(!&$*.!%$*!:,%!0*,44)6!0*,44)!%-,44!,.(!

&$*.!>!:,%!4"5*!N$*44;O!,.(!&$*.!%$*!:,%!4"5*!%2,0*(!3&$*)!,2&!"&!;'&!,.(!9"994*!

:$"4*!`*&&"*!&,45%=7=!!D.(!&$*.!>B(!%,)!N$"O!,.(!&$*.!>B-!4"5*!N$"6O!3P,&,%$,!

-,5*%!%2,0*(!.;"%*%76!N(;!);'!4"5*!-)!/,4*.&".*eO!,.(!&$*.!%$*!0,.!,:,)!,.(!

&$*.!%$*!&;;5!"&=!!

DX!#$,.5!);'!A;0!&$,&!4"&&4*!14,)c!

3)/)%7=!!!

Page 160: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U]Y!

!

#$*!N4"&&4*!14,)O!(*-;.%&0,&*(!&$*!'%*!;A!9"A&!9"/".9!,%!,!:,)!&;!@0"(9*!A*,0!;A!

.*:!1*;14*!;0!@"99*0!1*;14*=fi!C'0".9!&$*!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!A;2'%!90;'1%6!&$*!2$"4(0*.!

(*-;.%&0,&*(!&$*"0!2;.%2";'%!*.9,9*-*.&!:"&$!%;2",4!@;'.(,0)!-,5".9=!#$*)!:*0*!

.;&!N"..;2*.&O!;A!%;2",4!-*,.".9!-,5".96!0,&$*0!&$*)!:*0*!(;".9!A;'.(,&";.,4!:;05!

&;!@'"4(!&$*"0!'.(*0%&,.(".9%!;A!:$,&!A0"*.(%!(;6!$;:!&;!-,.,9*!%$).*%%6!,.(!;&$*0!

2;-14"2,&*(!%;2",4!.;0-%=!#$"%!A;2'%!"%!1,0&"2'4,04)!-*,.".9A'4!".!&*0-%!;A!9*.(*0!

2'4&'0*!,%!&$"%!A;'.(,&";.,4!:;05!"./;4/*(!("%2*0.".9!:$;!:,%!".%"(*!,.(!:$;!:,%!

;'&%"(*!%;2",4!@*4;.9".9=!

#$*!".&*0,2&";.%!@*&:**.!&$*!2$"4(0*.!('0".9!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1%!:*0*!'%',44)!

-'2$!-;0*!&*44".9!;A!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!9*.(*0!&,@;;%6!&$,.!:$,&!:,%!*+14"2"&4)!%&,&*(=!

h;0!*+,-14*6!:$*.!,%5*(!,!L'*%&";.!,@;'&!20;%%".9!9*.(*0!.;0-%!3%**!,11*.("+76!

&$*!2$"4(0*.!:;'4(!0*4",@4)!0*%1;.(!:"&$!&$*!N0"9$&O!,.%:*0_&$,&!"&!:,%!,22*1&,@4*=!

h;0!*+,-14*6!@;)%!2;'4(!:*,0!(0*%%*%6!,.);.*!2;'4(!14,)!:"&$!,.)!&;)!3G".5!C,)!

h;2'%!^0;'1%!U6!Y6!pf6!U!I,02$!YVUY7=!!T;:*/*06!:$,&!:,%!(*-;.%&0,&*(!('0".9!

&$*"0!".&*0,2&";.%!:,%!&$*!%,-*!A;2'%!;.!%;2",4!".24'%";.6!*+24'%";.!,.(!@;'.(,0)!

-,5".9=!P;:$*0*!:,%!&$"%!-;0*!*+14"2"&!&$,.!,0;'.(!&$*!%'@M*2&!;A!@,&$0;;-%=!!

#$*!A;2'%!90;'1%!:*0*!4;2,&*(!".!&$*!;1*.!,0*,!,20;%%!A0;-!&$*!@;)%B!

:,%$0;;-=!b$"4*!`*&&"*!:,%!".!&$*!-"((4*!;A!&*44".9!,!%&;0)6!&$*!1,0&"2"1,.&%!.;&"2*(!

,!9*.(*0E,-@"9';'%!%&'(*.&!A0;-!,.;&$*0!24,%%!*.&*0!&$*!@,&$0;;-=!#$*!2$"4(0*.!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

fi!#$"%!-,)!@*!('*6!".!1,0&6!&;!&$*!@'(()!%)%&*-!:$*0*!*/*0);.*!".!8".(*09,0&*.!

$,(!,!@'(()!A0;-!,!^0,(*!H*/*.!24,%%=!>.!;'0!".&*0/"*:6!I,09,0*&!$,(!("%2'%%*(!&$,&!

1,0&!;A!&$*!1'01;%*!;A!&$"%!:,%!&;!$*41!&$*!8".(*09,0&*.!%&'(*.&%!.;&!@*!,A0,"(!;A!

2$"4(0*.!:$;!:*0*!@"99*0!&$,.!&$*)!,0*!,.(!&;!(*/*4;1!0*4,&";.%$"1%!,20;%%!,9*E

90;'1%=!

Page 161: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U]f!

!

%&;11*(!1,)".9!,&&*.&";.!:$"4*!`*&&"*!:,%!-"(E%*.&*.2*!,.(6!A;0!,!0,0*!-;-*.&6!&$*)!

:*0*!A;2'%*(!&;9*&$*0!;.!&$*!%,-*!2;./*0%,&";.=!>.!M**0".9!&;.*%6!&$*)!("%2'%%*(!

&$*!2$"4(!:,45".9!".&;!&$*!@;)B%!@,&$0;;-X!

D%$4*)X!b;:6!"%!&$,&!,!9"04!;0!"%!&$,&!,!@;)e!3%;-*;.*!:,45".9!".&;!,!

@,&$0;;-7!

C)4,.X!#$,&B%!,!9"04=!

#0"%&,.X!b$;e!

`*&&"*X!P;6!&$,&B%!,!@;)=!

#0"%&,.X!#$,&B%!,!@;)E9"04=!

Q),.X!#$,&B%!,!@;)E@;)E9"04=!

D%$4*)X!34,'9$".9!1;".&*(4)7!H;!"&B%!%&"44!,!@;)=!

Q),.X!b$;!"%!"&e!

#0"%&,.X!>!(;.B&!5.;:c!

3"@"(=7!

#$*!2$"4(0*.!4,'9$*(!,.(!1;".&*(!-;25".94)!,&!&$*!2$"4(!:$;!('25*(!".&;!&$*!

@,&$0;;-=!b$"4*!&$*!%&'(*.&%!:;'4(!%&,&*!&$,&!20;%%".9!9*.(*0*(!4".*%!"%!N;5,)O!

3G".5!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1%6!U6!Y6!p!f!f<Vf<YVUY76!&$*"0!".&*0,2&";.%!(*-;.%&0,&*(!,!

("AA*0*.&!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!%;2",4!@;'.(,0)!%*&&".9=!H;-*;.*!".(*&*0-".,&*4)!

9*.(*0*(!:,%!,!%;'02*!,.(!;@M*2&!;A!0"("2'4*=!>.!\7,,.)*9(F#$".&&23;(E,*%,.B(

I,G7#6)$=B(#*%($",(S=9),*)+(?2#9)*#$)&*6!H$*"4,!S,/,.,9$!,09'*%!&$,&!,.+"*&)!

N0*9,0(".9!9*.(*0!/,0",.2*!"%!5**.4)!A*4&!".!1'@4"2!:,%$0;;-%!,.(!;A&*.!10;M*2&*(!

;.&;!&0,.%!A;45O!3[7=!H$*!20*("&%!&$"%!,%!2;.2*0.".9!,!N1*02*"/*(!&$0*,&!&;!

Page 162: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U][!

!

$*&*0;.;0-,&"/"&)O!3]7=!I)!A"*4(%&'()!"44'%&0,&*(!$;:6!,&!,!);'.9!,9*6!&$*%*!

,.+"*&"*%!:*0*!,&!14,)!".!&$*!%;2",4!4"/*%!;A!&$*!2$"4(0*.!,%!:*44!,%!@*".9!

".%&"&'&";.,44)!*.(;0%*(!".!:,)%!&$,&!:*0*!-*,.".9A'4!A;0!&$*-=!!

F,&$0;;-!.;0-%!:*0*!%;!&,5*.!A;0E90,.&*(!&$,&!:$,&!:,%!:0;.9!:"&$!

20;%%".9!&$*-!:,%!(**-*(!&;!9;!:"&$;'&!%,)".9=!h;0!*+,-14*6!;.*!(,)6!,%!&$*!

%&'(*.&%!:*0*!4".*(!'1!&;!9;!@,25!".&;!24,%%6!>!,%5*(!K%2,0!$;:!$"%!0*2*%%!:,%!,.(!

$*!0*14"*(!&$,&!"&!:,%!@,(!@*2,'%*!;.*!@;)!:*.&!".&;!&$*!9"04%B!@,&$0;;-_;.!

1'01;%*=!>!,%5*(!:$)!&$,&!:,%!@,(!,.(!:,%!9"/*.!,!2;.A'%*(6!,4-;%&!2;.2*0.*(!

4;;5=!T*!,.%:*0*(6!N@*2,'%*!$*!"%!,!@;)!,.(!$*!:*.&!".!&$*!9"04%B!@,&$0;;-O!

3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!V]<V[<UY7=!>&!:,%!&;;!;@/";'%!&;!,%5=!b$"4*!I,09,0*&!,&&*-1&*(!

&;!9,&$*0!&$*!24,%%!".&;!,!2"024*6!K%2,0!,-1*(!'1!&$*!*.*09)!;A!&$*!*/*.&!@)!0*1*,&".9!

;/*0!,.(!;/*0!&$,&!&$*0*!:,%!,!@;)!".!&$*!9"04%B!@,&$0;;-!3)/)%7=!!

I,09,0*&!,4%;!("%2'%%*(!@,&$0;;-%!,%!1,0&!;A!2$"4(0*.B%!9*.(*0*(!

A0"*.(%$"1%!().,-"2%X!

D!A*:!)*,0%!,9;6!>!$,(6!'-6!,!);'.9!9"04!".!-)!24,%%!,.(6!'$6!%$*!4"5*(!&;!:*,0!

$*0!;4(*0!@0;&$*0B%!24;&$".9=!D.(6!'-6!%$*_);'!5.;:6!%$*!$,(!%$;0&*0!$,"0!

,.(!&$*!5"(%!'%',44)!,%%'-*!&$,&!"A!);'!$,/*!,!4;.9!$,"06!);'B0*!,!9"046!"A!);'!

$,/*!%$;0&!$,"06!);'B0*!,!@;)u,.):,)6!%$*!%'010"%*(!;.*!;A!$*0!1**0%!;.*!

(,)!@*2,'%*6!'-6!>!%*.(!'%',44)!@;)%!:"&$!,!1,0&.*0!:$;!"%!,4%;!,!@;)!&;!&$*!

@;)%B!:,%$0;;-!:$*.!&$*)!.**(!&;!9;6!,.(!9"04%!9;!:"&$!,!9"04!&;!&$*!

:,%$0;;-!:$*.!&$*)!.**(!&;!9;=!H;!&$"%!4"&&4*!@;)!1"25*(!$"%!A0"*.(6!&$".5".9!

&$,&!%$*!:,%!,4%;!,!@;)=!D.(!&$*.6!);'!5.;:6!&$*!9"04!&'0.*(!,.(!5".(!;A!

Page 163: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U]]!

!

90"..*(!,&!$"-6!4"5*6!o>!2,.B&=B!D.(!$*!:,%!%$;25*(=!g;'!2;'4(!%**!&$*!%$;25!".!

$"%!A,2*=!T*!5".(!;A!%&*11*(!@,256!$*!&'0.*(!1,4*6!$"%!-;'&$!5".(!;A!(0;11*(!

;1*.=!T*!:,%!M'%&6!4"5*6!og;'B0*!.;&!:$,&!>!&$;'9$&!);'!:*0*6B!,.(!&$,&!:,%!

%;0&!;A!&$*!,%1*2&!&$,&!$*!$,(!:"&$!$"%!@;()!4,.9',9*!:,%!/*0)6!/*0)!

".&*0*%&".9u!>!&$".5!$*!:,%!;.*!;A!&$;%*!4"&&4*!@;)%!:$;!%;0&!;A!"(*.&"A"*%!

$"-%*4A!,%!o>!(;.B&!14,)!:"&$!9"04%=B!v4,'9$w!D.(!&$,&!:,%!/*0)!-'2$!,!1,0&!;A!

$;:!$*!%,:!$"-%*4A=!D.(!%;!A".(".9!;'&!&$,&!&$"%!A0"*.(6!&$*.!:,%!,_,!9"04!

5".(!;A!&$0*:!$"-!A;0!,!4;;1u!$*!:,%!%;!%$,5*.!'1!"&!:,%!,4-;%&_"&!:,%!

,4-;%&!$'-;0;'%=!3Q;/*44,!U]<V]<UY7!

D%!2$"4(0*.!(*-;.%&0,&*(!&$*"0!*.9,9*-*.&!:"&$!4*,0.".9!0'4*%6!&$*!A'.2&";.!

;A!@,&$0;;-%!".!*%&,@4"%$".9!&,@;;%!0*9,0(".9!9*.(*0!,-@"9'"&)!"%!,!:;0&$:$"4*!%"&*!

;A!,.,4)%"%=!h0;-!&$*!A"0%&!-;-*.&%!,&!%2$;;46!"&!"%!*%&,@4"%$*(!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!-'%&!

("%2*0.!,.(!%*90*9,&*!@;)%!A0;-!9"04%=!#$"%!.;0-!"%!&$*.!0*"&*0,&*(!*/*0)!&"-*!&$*)!

.**(!&;!'%*!&$*!@,&$0;;-=!D%!"&!"%!*%&,@4"%$*(!&$,&!"&!"%!:0;.9!,.(!%'%1*2&!"A!&$"%!0'4*!

"%!20;%%*(6!"&!"%!.;!:;.(*0!&$,&!&$;%*!:$;!,0*!".("%2*0."@4*!,%!-,4*!;0!A*-,4*!,0*!

&$*.!'.(*0%&;;(!&;!@*!:0;.9!,.(!%'%1*2&!&$*-%*4/*%=!#$*!2'%&;-!;A!@,&$0;;-%!

.;0-,4"J*%!,!2'4&'0*!:$*0*".!&$;%*!:$;!(;!.;&!A"&!,!9*.(*0!@".,0)!,0*!,.!*/*.&6!

0,&$*0!&$,.!1,0&!;A!*/*0)(,)!4"A*=fZ!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

fZ!#$*!2'%&;-!;A!9;".9!&;!@,&$0;;-%!".!90;'1%!"%!0*4,&*(!&;!N%&0,.9*0!(,.9*0O!

("%2;'0%*!:$"2$!1;%"&*(!%2$;;4!@,&$0;;-%!,%!,!%"&*!;A!1;&*.&",4!2$"4(!,@'%*!,%!,('4&%!

:*0*!&$;'9$&!&;!$"(*!".!%&,44%!".!:,"&!A;0!2$"4(0*.=!H&0,.9*0!(,.9*0!:,%!1;1'4,0"J*(!

".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!".!S,.,(,!('0".9!&$*!S;4(!b,0!*0,!:"&$!"&%!A*,0!;A!&$*!&7$3)%,.=!

R4"%*!S$*."*0!;AA*0%!&$*!A;44;:".9!20"&"L'*!,%!&;!&$*!:,)%!%&0,.9*0!(,.9*0!0*".A;02*%!

Page 164: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U]k!

!

>."&",4!A".(".9%!A0;-!&$*!^*.(*0!S0*,&"/*!8"(%!3^S87!G0;M*2&!%$;:*(!

9*.(*0*(!@,&$0;;-!'%*!,%!;.*!;A!&$*!10"-,0)!"%%'*%!A,2".9!&0,.%9*.(*0!,.(!9*.(*0!

.;.2;.A;0-".9!%&'(*.&%!".!%2$;;4%=fW!#*,2$*0%!0*4,)*(!&$*!*+1*0"*.2*%!;A!%&'(*.&%!

".!8".(*09,0&*.!,.(!^0,(*!K.*!$,/".9!@**.!@'44"*(!%;!@,(4)!;/*0!@,&$0;;-!'%*!&$,&!

&$*)!.**(*(!&;!2$,.9*!%2$;;4%=!#:;!1,0&"2"1,.&%!:;05*(!".!,!%2$;;4!&$,&!$,(!

9*.(*0E.*'&0,4!@,&$0;;-%!,.(!("%2'%%*(!$;:!&$"%!20*,&*(!,.!*./"0;.-*.&!:"&$!4*%%!

1;4"2".9!;A!9*.(*0!.;0-%=!#:;!&0,.%9*.(*0!2$"4(0*.!$,(!&0,.%A*00*(!&;!&$*"0!%2$;;4!

%1*2"A"2,44)!@*2,'%*!&$*)!:;'4(!@*!,@4*!&;!'%*!&$*!:,%$0;;-!:"&$;'&!A*,0".9!

$,0,%%-*.&!3NR4*-*.&,0)!R('2,&;0%B!8.;:4*(9*!;A!,.(!R+1*0"*.2*%!:"&$!

#0,.%9*.(*0!,.(!^*.(*0!S0*,&"/*!8"(%X!D.!D2&";.!Q*%*,02$!G0;M*2&O7=!#$"%!-,5*%!,!

2;-1*44".9!,09'-*.&!A;0!0*E*+,-".".9!@,&$0;;-!.;0-%!".!%2$;;4%=!T;:*/*06!-,.)!

:;05".9!:"&$".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!:"44!.;&!$,/*!&$*!;1&";.!&;!20*,&*!,!.*'&0,4!

:,%$0;;-=!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

(;-".,.&!%;2",4!.;0-%!0,&$*0!&$,.!-,5".9!%'@%&,.&"/*!-;/*%!&;:,0(!*.(".9!

,@'%*%!;A!,2&',4!2$"4(0*.X!!

#$*!oo%&0,.9*0BB!".!%&0,.9*0!(,.9*0!,AA"0-%!&$*!:$"&*6!-"((4*E24,%%6!&0,("&";.,4!

39*.(*0*(!,.(!$"*0,02$"2,46!.'24*,0!,.(!$*&*0;%*+',47!A,-"4)!,%!&$*!%".9'4,0!

".%&"&'&";.!&$,&!10*%*0/*%6!10;&*2&%6!,.(!%*2'0*%!2$"4(0*.B%!1$)%"2,4!,.(!

*-;&";.,4!%,A*&)=!>&!.,&'0,4"%*%!,.(!"(*,4"%*%!-;(*0.!A,-"4)!4"A*6!,.(!".!&$*!

10;2*%%!%'@%'-*%!A,-"4)!/";4*.2*=!h,-"4"*%!2,.!@*!(,.9*0;'%!14,2*%!A;0!

2$"4(0*.6!@'&!&$*!%&0,.9*0!(,.9*0!.,00,&"/*!0*E,%%*0&%!&$*!A,-"4)!,%!&$*!

"(*,4"%*(!%"&*!A;0!&$*!10;('2&";.!,.(!0*10;('2&";.!;A!%;2",4!.;0-%6!,%!,.!

".2'@,&;0!A;0!10;2*%%*%!;A!.;0-,4"J,&";.=!3UZf7!fW!#$*!^*.(*0!S0*,&"/*!8"(%!3^S87!G0;M*2&!"%!,!0*%*,02$!90;'1!&$,&6!,-;.9!;&$*0!

10;M*2&%6!2;.('2&%!".&*0/"*:%!,20;%%!S,.,(,!:"&$!&*,2$*0%!0*9,0(".9!&$*"0!

*+1*0"*.2*%!:;05".9!:"&$!&0,.%9*.(*06!9*.(*0!.;.E2;.A;0-".96!,.(!9*.(*0!20*,&"/*!

%&'(*.&%=!>!:,%!*-14;)*(!:"&$!&$*!^S8!G0;M*2&!,%!&$*!?,.2;'/*0E@,%*(!Q*%*,02$!

D%%"%&,.&!".!YVUf=!

Page 165: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U]i!

!

^"/*.!&$*!:,)!C)4,.6!;.!&$*!14,)90;'.(6!"--*(",&*4)!'%*(!&;;4%!&;!".&*0/*.*!

".!().,-"2%!&$,&!:*0*!(**-*(!$'0&A'46!"&!"%!:;0&$!1;.(*0".9!&$*!1;&*.&",4!;A!

I,09,0*&B%!A;2'%!;.!20"&"2,4!&$".5".9!,.(!%*4AE,:,0*.*%%!&;!A'0&$*0!:;05!,9,".%&!

%;2",4!.;0-%!&$,&!N;&$*0O!2$"4(0*.!:$;!(;!.;&!A"&!&$*!@,&$0;;-!("2$;&;-)=!b$,&!"A6!

,4;.9!:"&$!*/*0)(,)!0*1*&"&";.!&$,&!%&'(*.&%!,0*!N@;)%O!,.(!N9"04%6O!&$*0*!:,%!,4%;!

0*1*&"&";.!&$,&!.;&!*/*0);.*!"%!;.*!9*.(*0!;0!,.;&$*0e!b$,&!"A!,!0,.9*!;A!9*.(*0%!

2;'4(!@*!(*1"2&*(!,%!1,0&!;A!*/*0)(,)!4"A*!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-e!b$"4*!&$*!".%&"&'&";.,4!

%&0'2&'0*!&$,&!%*90*9,&*%!@,&$0;;-%!A0;-!&$*!;.%*&!;A!2$"4(0*.B%!*('2,&";.,4!

*+1*0"*.2*%!-,)!1*0%"%&6!20"&"2,4!(",4;9'*!2;'4(!0*".A;02*!&$,&!%'2$!,.!".%&"&'&";.,4!

10,2&"2*!:"44!.;&!%'"&!*/*0);.*!".!&$,&!24,%%!;0!".!&$*!%2$;;4=!b*0*!"&!.;&!1;%%"@4*!&;!

".%&"&'&*!9*.(*0E.*'&0,4!:,%$0;;-%6!,&!&$*!/*0)!4*,%&!%&'(*.&%!,.(!,('4&%!2;'4(!

%&0,&*9"J*!:,)%!&;!%&,.(!'1!A;0!&$*-%*4/*%!,.(!*,2$!;&$*0!:$*.!.,/"9,&".9!&$"%!,.(!

;&$*0!.;0-%=!!

:?BZ>HJ<?B$

>&!"%!.;!:;.(*0!&$,&!%2$;4,0%!*+,-".".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!$,/*!

2"&*(!1;1'4,0!'.(*0%&,.(".9%!;A!2$"4($;;(!"..;2*.2*!,%!1,0&!;A!&$*!0*,%;.!:$)!&$*)!

:*0*!'.,@4*!&;!".24'(*!,2&',4!2$"4(0*.!".!&$*"0!%&'("*%!;A!$*&*0;.;0-,&"/"&)!,.(!

10"-,0)!%2$;;4!3S'44*.!,.(!H,.()6!S'00,.,6!S$",0;44"@6!,.(!G,44;&&,ES$",0;44"26!b,44"%!

,.(!?,.R/*0)7=!R+,-".".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4!0*L'"0*%!

.,/"9,&".9!("%2;'0%*%!;A!)**&+,*+,6!:$"2$!14,)!,.!".A4'*.&",4!,.(!2;-14"2,&*(!0;4*!".!

1;1'4,0!*('2,&";.,4!("%2;'0%*=!

Page 166: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U]Z!

!

R/*0)(,)!0*1*&"&";.!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!;22'0%!".!10,2&"2*%!A0;-!

%*90*9,&*(!@,&$0;;-%6!&;!2'00"2'4'-6!1"2&'0*!@;;5%6!$,44:,)!2;./*0%,&";.%6!,.(!

2$"4(0*.B%!14,)=!b$*.!4;;5".9!,&!:$,&!2$"4(0*.!,2&',44)!(;!,.(!%,)6!0,&$*0!&$,.!:$,&!

"%!%,"(!,@;'&!&$*"0!"..;2*.2*6!"&!"%!24*,0!&$,&!&$*"0!(*%"0*%!A;0!1;:*06!,AA*2&";.6!,.(!

A0"*.(%$"1!&,5*!-,.)!A;0-%!,.(!&$,&!&$*)!*+1*0"*.2*!&$*"0!;:.!9*.(*0%!".!,!

-'4&"14"2"&)!;A!:,)%=!I)!%&'()!%'99*%&%!&$,&!2$"4(0*.6!4"5*!,('4&%6!.,/"9,&*!,!

2;.%&*44,&";.!;A!&$*"0!;:.!".&*0*%&%6!A,-"4)!().,-"2%6!2'4&'0,4!0*10*%*.&,&";.%6!,.(!

*+1*2&,&";.%6!".!;0(*0!&;!-,5*!%*.%*!,.(!-*,.".9!;'&!;A!&$*"0!"(*.&"&"*%!,.(!%;2",4!

:;04(%=!#$*%*!%;2",4!:;04(%!-,)!"./;4/*!A0"*.(%$"1%!:"&$!,&&0,2&";.%!&;!%;-*!

2$"4(0*.!,.(!.;&!A;0!;&$*0%=!#$*)!:"44!"./;4/*!.*9;&",&".9!%;2",4!().,-"2%6!1;:*06!

,.(!@;'.(,0"*%=!>.!,(("&";.6!,%!%;-*!2$"4(0*.!$,/*!&$*"0!;:.!,&&0,2&";.%6!*/*.!

2$"4(0*.!:$;!(;!.;&!A".(!&$"%!&;!@*!1,0&!;A!&$*"0!".&*0*%&%!2;'4(!@*.*A"&!A0;-!$,/".9!

,22*%%!&;!%5"44%!:"&$!:$"2$!&;!.,/"9,&*!&$*!".&*0*%&%!;A!;&$*0%=!D25.;:4*(9".9!&$,&!

2$"4(0*.!,0*!&$".5".9!,@;'&!&$*"0!;:.!%*4/*%!,.(!&$*"0!1**0%!".!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!

.;0-,&"/*!2'4&'0*!,AA;0(%!0;;-!&;!0*A0,-*!$;:!("%2'%%";.%!;A!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)!

,0*!2;.2*1&',4"J*(=!Q,&$*0!&$,.!".&0;('2".9!&;1"2%!&$,&!2;00'1&!2$"4(0*.!:$;!,0*!

;&$*0:"%*!'.,:,0*6!%'2$!("%2'%%";.%!2,.!@*!A0,-*(!,%!0*-;/".9!&,@;;%!&$,&!5**1!

.;0-,&"/*!4"A*!14,)".9!;'&!".!&$*"0!2'00*.&4)!/";4,&;0)6!0*10*%%"/*6!;0!"%;4,&".9!:,)%=!

!

!

Page 167: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

U]W!

!

:CA=EDF$;<PD,$WHDDFBDJJ$AJ$A$#=DZ<A>$/PDBE,$/[A@<B<BI$!4<__DFDBZD-$4<JZ?HFJD$

"BEF?YHZE<?B$

>.!YVVi6!,&!S*.&0,4!8".9%!Q'0,4!T"9$!".!P;/,!H2;&",6!,!^0,(*!P".*!@;)!:;0*!,!

1".5!1;4;!%$"0&!;.!$"%!A"0%&!(,)!;A!%2$;;4=!T*!:,%!@,(4)!$,0,%%*(6!2,44*(!,!A,96!,.(!

@*,&*.!'1=!!d1;.!$*,0".9!,@;'&!&$"%6!&:;!^0,(*!#:*4/*!%&'(*.&%6!C,/"(!H$*1$*0(!

,.(!#0,/"%!G0"2*6!:*.&!&;!,!4;2,4!("%2;'.&!%&;0*!:$*0*!&$*)!@;'9$&!A"A&)!1".5!%$"0&%!

,.(!%10*,(!&$*!:;0(!;.4".*!A;0!,%!-,.)!%&'(*.&%!,%!1;%%"@4*!&;!2;-*!&;!%2$;;4!&$*!

.*+&!(,)!".!1".5=!#$"%!0*%'4&*(!".!,!%2$;;4E:"(*!1".5!N%*,!;A!%'11;0&O!A;0!&$*!%&'(*.&!

:$;!:,%!$,0-*(=!#$*"0!2,44!&;!,2&";.!,9,".%&!%'2$!@'44)".9!0*2*"/*(!".&*0.,&";.,4!

,&&*.&";.=!#$*!^0,(*!#:*4/*!%&'(*.&%!:*0*!".&*0/"*:*(!".!-)0",(!%*&&".9%!A0;-!

.*:%1,1*0%!&;!&,45!%$;:%!3NF'44"*(!H&'(*.&!#"254*(!G".5!@)!H2$;;4-,&*%O7=!#;!

2;--*-;0,&*!&$"%!*/*.&!,.(!2,1"&,4"J*!;.!&$*!;11;0&'."&)!&;!&,45!,@;'&!@'44)".96!

%2$;;4%!,20;%%!&$*!2;'.&0)!,(;1&*(!G".5!C,)6!,!(,)!:$*0*!*/*0);.*!"%!,%5*(!&;!:*,0!

1".5!&;!N&,5*!,!%&,.(!,9,".%&!@'44)".9O!3)/)%7=!!

#$*!.*+&!)*,06!YVVZ6!:$*.!&$*!A"0%&!G".5!C,)!:,%!$*4(!".!%2$;;4%!.,&";.:"(*6!

>!:,%!:;05".9!".!,!8".(*09,0&*.!24,%%0;;-!,&!,.!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4=!>!0*-*-@*0!

.;&"2".9!$;:!1;:*0A'44)!&$*!(,)!'.*,0&$*(!&$*!*+&*.&!&;!:$"2$!9*.(*0!&,@;;%!:*0*!

,&!14,)!".!&$*!%2$;;4!,.(!&$*!,.+"*&)!-,.)!);'.9!@;)%!$,(!;/*0!@*".9!,%%;2",&*(!

:"&$!L',4"&"*%!(**-*(!A*-".".*=!I,.)!;A!&$*!@;)%!2,-*!&;!%2$;;4!4;;5".9!&*00"A"*(=!

K.*!@;)!,00"/*(!,&!$"%!8".(*09,0&*.!24,%%!:"&$!$"%!$,.(%!24,%1*(!;/*0!,!1".5!24;&$!

&,1*(!&;!$"%!%$"0&!3$*!("(.B&!$,/*!,.)!1".5!24;&$*%76!4;;5".9!A'0&"/*4)!,0;'.(!&$*!

0;;-=!!T*!%,&!,:,)!A0;-!&$*!;&$*0!2$"4(0*.!&$,&!-;0.".96!$"%!%*.%*!;A!(0*,(!,2'&*=!>&!

Page 168: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UkV!

!

%&0'25!-*!&$,&!&$"%!2$"4(!:,%!*.,2&".9!$"%!;:.!%;2",4!*+24'%";.!:$*.!1".5!:,%!

,&&,2$*(!&;!$"%!1*0%;.=!S4*,04)!&$"%!:,%!,!4;,(*(!(,)!:;0&$)!;A!A'0&$*0!"./*%&"9,&";.!

".&;!$;:!*,04)!2$"4($;;(!*('2,&";.!"%!*.&:".*(!:"&$!%)%&*-"2!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-,&"/*!10,2&"2*%=!!

>.!&$*!10*/";'%!2$,1&*06!>!*+14;0*(!&$*!.;0-,4"J".9!0;4*%!;A!("%2;'0%*%!;A!

)**&+,*+,!:$*0*@)!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!"%!.,&'0,4"J*(!,.(!.;&!(**-*(!&;!@*!

,@;'&!%*+',4"&)6!,.(!2$"4(0*.!,0*!'.(*0%&;;(!&;!@*!"..;2*.&!;A!,.)&$".9!;'&%"(*!;A!

:$,&!"%!.,&'0,4"J*(=!D%!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4!.;0-%!,0*!&$*.!,40*,()!:*44!*%&,@4"%$*(6!

L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%6!"A!,((0*%%*(!,&!,446!,0*!0*4*9,&*(!&;!&$*!0*,4-!

;A!N@*".9!("AA*0*.&=O!#$"%!2$,1&*0!*+14;0*%!:,)%!("%2;'0%*%!;A!("AA*0*.2*!:*0*!&,5*.!

'1!('0".9!-)!A"*4(:;05!,.(!"&%!"-14"2,&";.%!A;0!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4=!!

\'**0.*%%!:,%!;.4)!*+14"2"&4)!("%2'%%*(!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!;.!G".5!C,)=!b$"4*!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!:,%!10*%*.&!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!*/*0)(,)6!L'**0.*%%!:,%!

1,0&!;A!,!%1*2",4!*/*.&!,.(!;.4)!-*.&";.*(!".!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!@'44)".9=!!b"&$".!

?,.2;'/*0!%2$;;4%6!,.&"E$;-;1$;@",!*('2,&";.!;A&*.!&,5*%!&$*!A;0-!;A!%1*2",4!

*/*.&%X!,!9'*%&!%1*,5*06!,!:;05%$;1!".!0*%1;.%*!&;!,.&"E9,)!@'44)".96!,!A"4-=!a;0"!

I,2>.&;%$!20"&"L'*%!&$*%*!,110;,2$*%!,%!".,(*L',&*6!@,.(E,"(!%;4'&";.%!&;!"%%'*%!;A!

%*+',4"&)!,.(!9*.(*0!("/*0%"&)!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!!#$*!@,.(E,"(!%&0,&*9"*%!2,00)!&$*!

*+1*2&,&";.!&$,&!,!4"&&4*!*('2,&";.!:"44!$,/*!10;A;'.(6!4,%&".9!"-1,2&=!I;0*;/*06!

L'**0.*%%!,.(!9*.(*0!.;.2;.A;0-"&)!,0*!2;.A4,&*(!:"&$!,!("%20"-".,&*(!%'@M*2&!

1;%"&";.6!.;0-,4"J".9!&$*!A"9'0*!;A!&$*!@'44"*(!L'**0=!D%!%'2$6!("AA*0*.2*!("%2;'0%*!

2,.!A'.2&";.!,%!,.!;&$*0".9!10,2&"2*=!S$,.(0,!I;$,.&)!A0,-*%!&$"%!,%!N-,.,9".9!

Page 169: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UkU!

!

("/*0%"&)O!3UWW76!:$"2$!%$*!1;%"&%!,%!,!10,2&"2*!;A!;09,."J".96!0,&$*0!&$,.!

%'@%&,.&",44)!2$,44*.9".9!&$*!%&,&'%!L';=!

>.!&$"%!2$,1&*06!>!*+,-".*!:,)%!&$,&!("AA*0*.2*!:,%!;09,."J*(!,.(!"&%!

1;&*.&",4!&;!@;&$!2$,44*.9*!,.(!0*".A;02*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!#$*!("%2;'0%*!

:,%!-;%&!,11,0*.&!&$0;'9$!&$*!%1*2",4!*/*.&%!A;0!G".5!C,)6!:$"2$!,0*!9"/*.!10"-,2)!

:"&$".!&$"%!2$,1&*0=!#$*%*!%1*2",4!*/*.&%!&,5*!14,2*!".!,!4,09*0!2'4&'0,4!2;.&*+&!;A!&$*!

%2$;;4j!".&*0/"*:%!:"&$!&$*!%'11;0&!:;05*06!24,%%0;;-!&*,2$*06!,.(!%2$;;4!10".2"1,4!

,44!"44'-".,&*!2$,44*.9*%!*('2,&;0%!A,2*!:$*.!:;05".9!&;!'10;;&!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-,&"/"&)=!>!&$*.!,.,4)J*!&$*!&:;!G".5!C,)!,%%*-@4"*%!,.(!I,09,0*&!Q;/*44,B%!

24,%%0;;-!&,45!;.!$;-;1$;@",!A;0!&$*"0!2;.&0,%&".9!,110;,2$*%!&;!("AA*0*.2*!

("%2;'0%*=!#$*!2$"4(0*.B%!-*-;0"*%!;A!G".5!C,)6!,%!0*2;'.&*(!".!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1%6!

,4%;!"44'%&0,&*!&$*!"-14"2,&";.%!&$,&!("AA*0*.2*!("%2;'0%*6!;0!%1*2",4!*/*.&!L'**0.*%%6!

$,%!A;0!*%&,@4"%$".9!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*=!$

:H>EHFA>$:><@AED$

#$*!?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!F;,0(B%!1;4"2)!&;!@*!".24'%"/*!;A!,!:"(*!0,.9*!;A!

9*.(*0%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%6!:,%!(*-;.%&0,&*(!,&!H;'&$!H"(*!R4*-*.&,0)!H2$;;4!&$0;'9$!

@0".9".9!".!9'*%&!%1*,5*0%!,.(!,&&*-1&".9!&;!1'&!,!%&;1!&;!$;-;1$;@"2!&,45=!D&!&$"%!

4*/*4!;A!".&*0/*.&";.!,9,".%&!$;-;1$;@",6!&*,2$*0%!,.(!,(-"."%&0,&";.!A,2*(!%*/*0,4!

;@%&,24*%X!A*,0!;A!10*%%!3@0;'9$&!,@;'&!@)!1,0*.&,4!2;.2*0.76!4,25!;A!A'.(%6!,.(!

$;-;1$;@"2!2'4&'0*!,-;.9%&!A,2'4&)=!!

C'0".9!;'0!".&*0/"*:6!&$*!10".2"1,46!S,0;4".*!P*4%;.6!("%2'%%*(!$*0!(*%"0*!&;!

$,/*!%,-*E%*+!0*4,&";.%$"1%!%1;5*.!,@;'&!".!,!0*%1*2&A'4!:,)=!H$*!,.(!I,09,0*&!

Page 170: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UkY!

!

(*%20"@*(!&$*!%2$;;4!$,/".9!*+1*0"*.2*(!,.!N;'&@0*,5O!;A!2$"4(0*.!'%".9!&$*!1$0,%*!

N&$,&B%!%;!9,)O!,%!,.!".%'4&!,.(!$;:!&$*!%2$;;4!$,(!@0;'9$&!".!&$*!("%&0"2&!D.&"E

$;-;1$;@",!I*.&;06!H&*/*!I'44"9,.6!&;!&,45!&;!&$*!:$;4*!%2$;;4!,%!:*44!,%!".("/"(',4!

24,%%*%!,@;'&!9,)!1*;14*!,.(!4"/*(!*+1*0"*.2*%!;A!$;-;1$;@",=!S,0;4".*!%1;5*!;A!

$*0!;:.!".&*0/*.&";.%!:$*.!%$*!:;'4(!$*,0!$;-;1$;@"2!%1**2$!".!&$*!$,44%X!

>!%,)!&$,&!>!$,/*!,('4&!2$"4(0*.!:$;!,0*!9,)u:$)!:;'4(!&$,&!@*!,.!".%'4&e===!

b$*.!&$*)B0*!);'.96!:*!&,45!,@;'&6!oT;:!(;_(;!);'!5.;:!:$;!);'B0*!9;".9!

&;!-,00)e!>!("(.B&!5.;:!:$;!>!:,%!9;".9!&;!-,00)!:$*.!>!:,%!%"+=B!g;'!5.;:6!

);'!&0)!&;!(*,4!:"&$!"&!,&!&$*"0!4,.9',9*=!D.(!&$*.!&$*0*B%!"%%'*%!:"&$!:$,&!

5"(%!$*,0!,&!$;-*6!&;;=!H;!"&B%!10*&&)!$,0(!&;!%,)6!og;'0!(,(()B%!,!A;;4=B!g;'!

5.;:e!F'&!>!(;!%,)6!og*,$6!:*44!&$,&B%!.;&!&0'*=!D.(!&$,&B%!.;&!&0'*!,&!;'0!

%2$;;46!,.(!&$,&B%!.;&!$.7,6B!);'!5.;:=!d-_>!A**4!10*&&)!2;.A"(*.&!,@;'&!

@*".9!A;02*A'4!,@;'&!&$;%*!&$".9%=!g;'!5.;:6!$,/*.B&!@**.!;.!&$*!2;/*0!;A!#$*!

G0;/".2*!)*&6!@'&_"&B%!.;&!;/*0!)*&!3P*4%;.!YV<V[<UY7=!

S,0;4".*B%!0*%1;.%*%!&;!$;-;1$;@"2!2;--*.&%!:;05!,9,".%&!%;2",4!;&$*0".9!

".!&:;!0*%1*2&%X!&$*)!(;!.;&!10*%'-*!,!'."/*0%,4"J*(!A'&'0*!$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!A;0!,44!

2$"4(0*.!,.(!&$*)!(0,:!,2&',4!9,)!1*;14*!".&;!&$*!1"2&'0*!,%!1,0&!;A!N'%O!0,&$*0!&$,.!

,!("AA*0*.&!&$",.(:$;!,!10"/"4*9*(!N'%O!%$;'4(!.;&!@'44)=!!

T*0!A*,0!;A!10*%%!2;/*0,9*!"44'%&0,&*%!$;:!&$*!4,09*0!2'4&'0,4!24"-,&*!2,.!

".A4'*.2*!%2$;;4E@,%*(!:;05!,9,".%&!$;-;1$;@",=!h;0!*+,-14*6!$*0!*AA;0&%!9*.*0,44)!

A*44!,4;.9!&$*!4".*%!;A!0'..".9!0*1,"0%6!;0!0*%1;.(".9!&;!$;-;1$;@",6!,%!&$"%!*.,@4*(!

,!%"&*!;A!M'%&"A"2,&";.!A;0!$*0!".&*0/*.&";._:*0*!1,0*.&,4!("%%*.&!&;!@0".9!'.:,.&*(!

Page 171: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Ukf!

!

,&&*.&";.!&;!&$*!%2$;;46!%$*!%&,&*(!&$,&!%$*!:;'4(!@*!,@4*!&;!0*A*0!&;!10*/";'%!

2;.20*&*!*+,-14*%!;A!'.%,A*!,.(!'.:*42;-".9!@*$,/";'0!&$,&!.**(*(!&;!@*!

,((0*%%*(!".!;0(*0!A;0!&$*!%2$;;4!&;!4"/*!'1!&;!("%&0"2&!2;--"&-*.&%=!S,0;4".*B%!

("%2'%%";.!;A!.,/"9,&".9!2'4&'0,4!.;0-%!:"&$!,!(*%"0*!&;!0*('2*!$;-;1$;@",!

"44'%&0,&*%!@;&$!&$*!1;:*0!,.(!4"-"&,&";.%!;A!1;4"2)=!>.24'%";.!1;4"2"*%!9,/*!,!14,2*!

A0;-!:$"2$!&;!-,.,9*!("%%*.&!".!&$*!A,2*!;A!$;-;1$;@"2!&,456!@'&!&$*!&$0*,&!;A!

("%%*.&!,.(!,&&*.&";.!%&"44!$,(!&$*!1;:*0!&;!4"-"&!&$*!".&*90,&";.!;A!L'**0.*%%!&;!

@,.(E,"(!".&*0/*.&";.!,9,".%&!$,&*A'4!;0!$'0&A'4!%1**2$6!0,&$*0!&$,.!@0".9".9!,@;'&!

"&%!".24'%";.!,%!1,0&!;A!*/*0)(,)!4"A*=!C"%2;'0%*%!;A!"..;2*.2*!-,)!,4%;!@*!,&!14,)!".!

%$,1".9!,!2'4&'0,4!24"-,&*!".!&$"%!0*%1*2&6!,%!*('2,&;0%!2,.!@*!,22'%*(!;A!".&0;('2".9!

,!%'@M*2&!&$,&!2;00'1&%!2$"4(0*.!"A!&$*)!&,45!,@;'&!L'**0.*%%!;'&%"(*!;A!&$*!2;.&*+&!;A!

@'44)".9=!!

S,0;4".*!*+10*%%*(!2;.2*0.!,@;'&!2$"4(0*.!;.4)!$*,0".9!,@;'&!$;-;1$;@",!

A0;-!&*,2$*0%=!H$*!("(!.;&!@*4"*/*!&$*!".&*.(*(!-*%%,9*!%&'25!:"&$!%&'(*.&%6!,%!"&!

4,25*(!&$*!1;:*0!&;!2,&2$!&$*"0!,&&*.&";.=!#;!2;.&0,%&6!%$*!0*2,44*(!,!%1*2",4!*/*.&!

%$*!$,(!2;;0(".,&*(!&$*!)*,0!@*A;0*!:$*0*!,!-,.!1*0A;0-*(!,!.,00,&"/*!14,)!,%!

1,0&!;A!,.!,%%*-@4)X!

b*!$,(!,!:;.(*0A'4!1*0%;.!2;-*!:$;!*+14,".*(!$"%!*+1*0"*.2*!,%!,.!

,(;1&*(6!@4,256!9,)!-,.!".!&$*!10,"0"*%!".!&$*!%*/*.&"*%=!D.(!$*!("(!,!

:;.(*0A'4!;.*E-,.!%$;:!&$,&!:,%!%;!,110;10",&*!,.(!M'%&!,@;'&!$;:_

@*2,'%*!$*!2$;%*!&$*!1".5!%5"11".9!0;1*6!$;:!$"%!4"A*!:,%!$*44=!D.(!$,(!90*,&!

2;./*0%,&";.%6!,.(!&$*!5"(%!:*0*!%;!*+2"&*(6!,.(!&$*)!,44!:,.&*(!&;!&,45!&;!

Page 172: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Uk[!

!

$"-!,A&*0:,0(%6!,.(!"&!:,%!0*,44)!1;:*0A'4u!>&!2,'9$&!&$*-=!D.(!%;-*&"-*%!

:*6!'-_5"(%!2,.!%**!&$".9%!:$*.!"&B%!;'&!&$*0*=!#$*)!2,.B&!%**!"&!:$*.!

&$*)B0*!(;".9!"&!&$*-%*4/*%6!%;!1,0&!;A!&$,&!"%!&;!10;/"(*!&$;%*!;11;0&'."&"*%!

&;!*+&*0.,4"J*!&$,&6!,.(!&$*.!$;1*A'44)!&$*)!&,5*!,:,)!%;-*&$".9!A0;-!

"&u3)/)%7=!

H$*!&;4(!-*!$;:!%$*!$,(!*-,"4*(!*/*0)!,(-"."%&0,&;0!%$*!5.*:!&;!'09*!&$*-!&;!

@;;5!&$*!%$;:!".!&$*"0!%2$;;4%=!!

K/*0!&$*!1,%&!A*:!)*,0%6!&$*!?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!F;,0(!$,%!A,2*(!%"9."A"2,.&!

@'(9*&!2'&%6!-,5".9!*/*.&%!%'2$!,%!&$*!14,)!("%2'%%*(!,@;/*!".20*,%".94)!

".,22*%%"@4*!A;0!-,.)!%2$;;4%=!S,0;4".*!%&,&*(!&$,&!:$"4*!"%%'*%!;A!%;2",4!$"*0,02$"*%!

:*0*!"-1;0&,.&6!@'(9*&,0)!2;.%&0,".&%!1"&&*(!%;2",4!4*,0.".9!,9,".%&!,2,(*-"2!

4*,0.".9=!S,0;4".*!%&,&*(6!N&$*!&*,2$*0!"%!%&"44!9;".9!&;!9*&6!'-6!,$6!);'!5.;:6!;/*0!&$*!

@,00*4!"A!&$*!5"(B%!.;&!0*,(".9!,&!90,(*!4*/*4===!>&B%!M'%&!&$*0*B%!.;&!*.;'9$!$;'0%!".!&$*!

(,)6!,.(!%;-*&$".9!9*&%!(0;11*(!,.(!);'!M'%&!$;1*!"&B%!.;&!,!20'2",4!1"*2*O!3)/)%7=!D%!

>!(*%20"@*(!*,04"*06!&$*!)*,0!;A!-)!A"*4(%&'()!:,%!,4%;!&$*!)*,0!".!:$"2$!&*,2$*0%!

:*0*!*.9,9*(!".!,!M;@!,2&";.!&;!10;&*%&!F"44!SEYY!&$,&!".20*,%*(!24,%%!%"J*%!:$"4*!

0*%&0"2&".9!90;:&$!".!&*,2$*0%B!1,)=!S,0;4".*!*+14,".*(!&$,&!"&!$,(!@**.!$,0(*0!&;!

@0".9!".!%1*,5*0%!,.(!$;4(!;&$*0!%1*2",4!*/*.&%!('0".9!&$*!M;@!,2&";.=!!

#$*!2'4&'0,4!.;0-%!,0;'.(!"..;2*.2*!2,.!4"-"&!*/*.!&$*!"(*,!&$,&!*/*0)(,)!

&,45!,@;'&!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!2;'4(!@*!,!1,0&!;A!24,%%0;;-!4"A*=!

F*2,'%*!;A!&$"%6!%1*2",4!*/*.&%!,0*!;A&*.!:$,&!%&,.(!@*&:**.!2;-14*&*!,@%*.2*!;A!

.;.E.;0-,&"/*!9*.(*0%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%!,.(!%;-*!10*%*.2*=!H'2$!".&*0/*.&";.%!&$*.!

Page 173: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Uk]!

!

14,)!,.!"-1;0&,.&!0;4*!".!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*6!-,5".9!A'.(".9!2'&%!,!1;:*0A'4!1,0&!;A!

2;;0(".,&".9!%;2",4!4"/*%!".!%2$;;4%=!#$"%!-,)!@*!1,0&"2'4,04)!%;6!9"/*.!&*%&,-*.&%!;A!

%&,AA!$;-;1$;@",!("%2'%%*(!('0".9!-)!%&'()=!!

#$*!H&'(*.&!H'11;0&!b;05*06!`,-*%!T'9$*%6!("%2'%%*(!A**4".9!1$)%"2,44)!

'.%,A*!".!;.*!;A!&$*!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4%!$*!$,(!:;05*(!,&6!('*!&;!,!24"-,&*!;A!,2'&*!

1,0*.&,4!$;-;1$;@",=!T*!%&,&*(!&$,&!$*!$,(!.;&!&0'%&*(!$"%!2;44*,9'*%!;0!

,(-"."%&0,&";.!&;!".&*0/*.*!:*0*!&$*0*!&;!@*!2;.A0;.&,&";.=!b$"4*!$*!(*%20"@*(!

H;'&$!H"(*!R4*-*.&,0)!H2$;;4!,%!.;&!.*,04)!,%!*+&0*-*!".!&$*!2,%*!;A!%&,AA!

$;-;1$;@",6!$*!0*2;'.&*(!0*2*"/".9!2;--*.&%!A0;-6!,.(!A,2".9!*+24'%";.!@)6!%&,AA!

:$*.!$*!:,%!1*02*"/*(!,%!;'&%"(*!9*.(*0!.;0-%6!$;:*/*0!%4"9$&4)6!A;0!*+,-14*!

:$*.!$*!:;0*!1'014*!%'.94,%%*%!3T'9$*%!UZ<V]<UY7=!!I,09,0*&!,4%;!("%2'%%*(!,!

2;44*,9'*!,&!&$*!%2$;;4!:"&$!:$;-!%$*!$,(!@0"*A4)!:;05*(!:$;!$,(!("%2'%%*(!$;:6!

:$"4*!I,09,0*&!$,(!&$*!10"/"4*9*!&;!&,45!,@;'&!$*0!$'%@,.(!".!&$*!%&,AA!0;;-6!$*!("(!

.;&!A**4!$*!$,(!&$*!A0**(;-!&;!&,45!,@;'&!$"%!$'%@,.(!:"&$;'&!@*".9!%;2",44)!

;%&0,2"J*(=!!

#$*!%&,AA!24"-,&*!:,%!.;&!"%;4,&*(!&;!&$*!%&,AA0;;-=!I,09,0*&!(*%20"@*(!$;:!

$*0!2$,44*.9*!&;!%*&!'1!,!%,A*!%1,2*!A;0!2$"4(0*.!&;!*+14;0*!&$*"0!"(*.&"&"*%!:"&$;'&!

A**4".9!2;.%&0,".*(!@)!9*.(*0!.;0-%!:,%!;A&*.!,&!;((%!:"&$!$*0!2;44*,9'*%=!H$*!

0*2,44*(X!!

#$*0*!:,%!;.*!&*,2$*0!:$;!%,"(!&;!&:;!@;)%!:$;!5"%%*(!*,2$!;&$*0!".!&$*!

4".*!'1!@*2,'%*!&$*)!:*0*!A0"*.(%6!N@;)%!(;.B&!5"%%!@;)%=O!D.(!M'%&!);'!5.;:6!

10;@,@4)!M'%&!-*,.".96!);'!5.;:6!4*&B%!.;&!5"%%!;'0!A0"*.(%!2,'%*!:*B0*!9;".9!

Page 174: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Ukk!

!

&;!%10*,(!9*0-%6!@'&!,2&',44)!2$;%*!&;!%,)6!N@;)%!(;.B&!5"%%!@;)%=O!D.(!&$,&!

%*.(%!,!/*0)!%&0;.9!-*%%,9*!&;!,44!&$*!2$"4(0*.!:$;!$*,0(!&$,&u!3Q;/*44,!

YV<VY<UY7=!

H$*!%&,&*(!&$,&!@*2,'%*!;A!%&,AA!,&&"&'(*%6!"&!$,(!&,5*.!,:$"4*!A;0!$*0!&;!$,/*!

2;.A"(*.2*!&;!,110;,2$!&*,2$".9!,22;0(".9!&;!$*0!;:.!/,4'*%=!H$*!(*%20"@*(!$;:6!

:$*.!%$*!A"0%&!2,-*!&;!&$*!%2$;;46!%$*!$,(!.;&!@**.!A,-"4",0!:"&$!&$*!.*"9$@;'0$;;(!

,.(!:,%!%&"44!.*:!&;!&*,2$".9=!!D%!&$*!%2$;;4!$,(!-,.)!2;.%*0/,&"/*!&*,2$*0%6!%$*!

%,"(!%$*!:,%!.;&!%'0*!$;:!&;!,110;,2$!%;2",4!M'%&"2*!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!H$*!

0*2;'.&*(X!

>!A*4&!/*0)!".&"-"(,&*(!@)!&$*%*!5.;:4*(9*,@4*6!;4(*0!*('2,&;0%u!"&B%!0*,44)!

;.4)!$;.*%&4)!@**.!".!&$*!4,%&!A*:!)*,0%!:$*.!>!5".(!;A!A*4&!4"5*6!N);'!5.;:!

:$,&e!>&!(;*%.B&!-,&&*0!:$,&!;&$*0!1*;14*!(;!;0!;&$*0!1*;14*!&$".56!>B-!,!

9;;(!&*,2$*06!>B-!&0)".9!-)!@*%&6!)*%!>B-!&0)".9!&;!-**&!2'00"2'4'-!9;,4%!@'&!

>!,4%;!$,/*!&$"%!%;2",4!1"*2*!&$,&!>!0*,44)!A**4!.**(%!&;!$,11*.6!,.(!$;:!2,.!>!

-,5*!&$,&!$,11*.!".!-)!24,%%0;;-e!H;!>!M'%&!&0)!&;!5**1!&$*!1,0*.&%!,%!

".A;0-*(!,%!1;%%"@4*!3)/)%7=!

D%!("%2'%%*(!".!&$*!10*/";'%!2$,1&*06!5**1".9!1,0*.&%!".A;0-*(!("(!.;&!9;!:"&$;'&!

2$,44*.9*=!#$*!,@;/*!*+,-14*%!%'99*%&!$;:!,!/,0"*&)!;A!A,2&;0%!:;05!&;9*&$*0!&;!

2;;0(".,&*!&$*!1;%"&";.!;A!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!1*;14*!,%!N;&$*0%O!:"&$".!

*/*0)(,)!4"A*!".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4=!!

b$"4*!>!:,%!2;.('2&".9!-)!A"*4(:;056!>!("(!.;&!$*,0!-,.)!;'&@'0%&%!;A!N&$,&B%!

%;!9,)O!'%*(!,%!,.!".%'4&!;0!;&$*0!4;'(6!*+14"2"&4)!$;-;1$;@"2!%1**2$=!#$"%!-,)!$,/*!

Page 175: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Uki!

!

@**.!1,0&4)!('*!&;!,(-"."%&0,&"/*!*AA;0&%!,.(!%1*2",4!*/*.&%=[V!T;:*/*06!"&!"%!.;&!M'%&!

&$*!10*%*.2*!;A!*+14"2"&!".%'4&%!&$,&!0*A4*2&%!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*%!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-,&"/"&)=!>.&*0-*(",&*!%&'(*.&%!3^0,(*%!h;'0EH*/*.7!2;'4(!;A&*.!@*!$*,0(!

4,'9$".9!:$*.!,!@;)!%,"(!%;-*&$".9!1;%"&"/*!,@;'&!,.;&$*0!@;)B%!,11*,0,.2*!3&$,&!

2;'4(!@*!".&*010*&*(!$;-;*0;&"2,44)76!;0!&,45".9!,@;'&!$;:!@;)%!%$;'4(!,2&!,.(!$;:!

9"04%!%$;'4(!,2&!".!(*A"."&"/*4)!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!&*0-%!3*=9=6!:$;!%$;'4(!

-,5*!&$*!A"0%&!-;/*!".!(,&".9!%2*.,0";%7=!H'2$!.;0-,4"J".9!%1**2$!:,%!

2;--;.14,2*!".!*/*0)(,)!0*2*%%!,.(!4'.2$!$;'0!&,456!0*A4*2&".9!1**0!2'4&'0*%!&$,&!

%&"44!0*.(*0!L'**0!;0!&0,.%9*.(*0!%&'(*.&%!,%!;'&%"(*0%=!!

>.!&$*!.,&";.:"(*!%&'()!2;.('2&*(!@)!R9,4*!S,.,(,!T'-,.!Q"9$&%!#0'%&!3%**!

>.&0;('2&";.76!0*%*,02$*0%!A;'.(!&$,&!1;4"2"*%!,9,".%&!("%20"-".,&";.!@,%*(!;.!

9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4!;0"*.&,&";.!0*%'4&*(!".!%&'(*.&%!*+1*0"*.2".9!4*%%6!@'&!%&"44!

%"9."A"2,.&!$,0,%%-*.&=!!#$*!().,-"2%!,&!14,)!:"&$".!-)!A"*4(%&'()!%$*(!,(("&";.,4!

".%"9$&!;.!*/*0)(,)!.;0-,4"J".9!10,2&"2*%!".!:$"2$!$"9$!%2$;;4!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*%!

@*2;-*!".$;%1"&,@4*!A;0!a^F#!);'&$=!!>&!"%!.;&!M'%&!:$*&$*0!;0!.;&!,.&"E9,)!

%*.&"-*.&%!,0*!*+10*%%*(X!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!"%!%$,1*(!@)!*/*0)(,)!,@%*.2*%=!^"/*.!&$*!

:"(*%10*,(!,@%*.2*%6!&$*!%1*2",4!*/*.&%!2,00)!,!90*,&!(*,4!;A!:*"9$&!,.(!,0*!,%5*(!

&;!(;!-'2$!".!&$*!:,)!;A!%;2",4!2$,.9*_!&$*!"-1;%%"@4*!2$,44*.9*!"%!&;!".&0;('2*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[V!D&!,!%2$;;4!:$*0*!>!$,(!10*/";'%4)!:;05*(6!%&'(*.&%!$,(!4*,0.*(!&$,&!,('4&%!

:;'4(!&*44!&$*-!.;&!&;!'%*!9,)!,%!,.!".%'4&!,.(!:;'4(!.;&!-,5*!%'2$!2;--*.&%!".!

A0;.&!;A!-*=!T;:*/*06!>!("(!$*,0!:"(*%10*,(!'%*!;A!$;-;1$;@"2!".%'4&%!:$*.!

%&'(*.&%!("(!.;&!&$".5!>!:,%!10*%*.&=!>&!"%!,4%;!1;%%"@4*!&$,&!>!:"&.*%%*(!%&'(*.&%!

2*.%;0".9!&$*-%*4/*%!".!A0;.&!;A!,.!,('4&=!!

Page 176: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UkZ!

!

&$*!2;.2*1&!;A!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%6!".&0;('2*!&$*!2;.2*1&!;A!

$;-;1$;@",6!,.(!*%&,@4"%$!,!4,%&".9!,.&"E$;-;1$;@"2!2'4&'0*=!

V<BT$4A9$/PDBEJ$

R/*0)!:**56!&$*!24,%%!,&&*.(*(!,!%2$;;4E:"(*!%".9E,E4;.9!2;.%"%&".9!4,09*4)!;A!

;4(!A;45!%;.9%=!D&!&$*!*.(!;A!&$*!%".9E,E4;.9!;.!h*@0',0)!U]&$6!,!&*,2$*0!".&0;('2*(!

G".5!C,)!,.(!,%5*(!%&'(*.&%!:$,&!&$*)!5.*:!,@;'&!&$*!*/*.&=!!D!%&'(*.&!

%'--,0"J*(!&$*!*/*.&!,%!@*".9!,@;'&!,!@;)!:$;!9;&!@'44"*(!A;0!:*,0".9!,!1".5!%$"0&=!

#$*!&*,2$*0!,%5*(!"A!"&!:,%!;5,)!&;!@'44)!1*;14*!A;0!@*".9!("AA*0*.&!,.(!*/*0);.*!

%,"(!.;=!#$*!&*,2$*0!&$*.!&,45*(!,@;'&!,44!;A!'%!@*".9!("AA*0*.&_!$,/".9!("AA*0*.&!

2;4;'0%!;A!%5".6!%1*,5".9!("AA*0*.&!4,.9',9*%6!,.(!%&,&*(!&$,&!.;&!;.4)!"%!&$,&!;5,)j!

"&B%!9;;(=!T*!,%5*(!"A!"&!:,%!;5,)!&;!@'44)!,.(!*/*0);.*!2$"-*(!".!N.;=O!T*!,%5*(!"A!

&$*)!:*0*!9;".9!&;!@'44)!,.(!,9,".6!*/*0);.*!2,44*(!;'&!N.;cO!T*!%&,&*(6!N&$,&B%!:$,&!

G".5!C,)!"%!,@;'&O!,.(!".A;0-*(!&$*!%&'(*.&%!&$,&!&$*0*!:;'4(!@*!,.!,%%*-@4)!

3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%6!U]<VY<UY7=!>&!:,%!%&0"5".9!&$,&!&$*!"--*(",&*!1;0&0,),4!;A!,!@;)!

:*,0".9!1".5!:,%!&$,&!$*!:,%!N("AA*0*.&6O!&$'%!0*".A;02".9!,!9*.(*0!.;0-!A0;-!

:$"2$!3&2,!2$"4(0*.!:;'4(!@*!%)--,.,*$=!H"-'4&,.*;'%4)6!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!

%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!:*0*!"-14"*(!@'&!-'&*(6!.;&!,((0*%%*(!("0*2&4)=!#$*!,@%*.2*6!:$"4*!

%&,&".9!o,22*1&,.2*6B!-;(*4%!&,@;;!3-;0*!;.!&$"%!%$;0&4)7=!!!

C"%2;'0%*%!;A!("AA*0*.2*!-,)!%'99*%&!&$,&!&$*!%;4'&";.!&;!("%20"-".,&";.!"%!&;!

&*,2$!&$,&!("AA*0*.2*!"%!;5,)=!T;:*/*06!&$*!,%%'-1&";.%!*-@*((*(!".!"&!,0*!-;0*!

4;,(*(=!#$,&!&$*!(;-".,.&!90;'1!:"44!%**!("AA*0*.2*!".!,!-,09".,4"J*(!90;'1!,.(!

,'&;-,&"2,44)!A*,06!;0!;&$*06!&$*-6!A'0&$*0!0*".A;02*%!&$*!(;-".,.&!90;'1B%!10"/"4*9*=!

Page 177: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UkW!

!

Q*%1;.%*%!&;!("AA*0*.2*!,4%;!"./;4/*!*./)6!*-'4,&";.6!".&*0*%&6!;0!".("AA*0*.2*=!#$,&!

&$*%*!,0*!10*E*-1&"/*4)!:0"&&*.!;'&!;A!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!*+*-14"A"*%!:,)%!&$,&!&$*!

(;-".,.&!90;'1B%!2;.2*1&',4"J,&";.!;A!"&%*4A!,%!(*%"0,@4*!"%!.;0-,4"J*(=!!b$"4*!

-,09".,4"J*(!90;'1%!,0*!1;%"&";.*(!,%!;&$*0%!&$,&!&$*!10"/"4*9*(!%$;'4(!&0*,&!:*446!

&$*!(;-".,.&!90;'16!".!&$"%!A0,-*:;056!0*&,".%!&$*!1;:*0!&;!(*4".*,&*!:$;!:"44!;0!

:"44!.;&!@*!&0*,&*(!:*44=!>&!"%!&$"%!2,1,2"&)!A;0!0*".A;02".9!%'2$!1;:*0!%&0'2&'0*%!&$,&!

:"44!@*!,.,4)J*(!".!-)!("%2'%%";.!;A!&$*!;AA"2",4!("%2;'0%*%!;A!("AA*0*.2*!,&!14,)!".!

&$*!*/*.&%!;A!G".5!C,)=!!

#$*!h*@0',0)!U]&$!,%%*-@4)!0*-".(*(!-*!;A!&$*!G".5!C,)!*/*.&%!>B(!,&&*.(*(!

,%!,!?HF!*-14;)**=!D&!&$0**!("AA*0*.&!%2$;;4%6!&$*)!("%2'%%*(!$;:!5"(%!:*0*!-*,.!&;!

&$*!@;)!:$;!:;0*!1".5!,.(!%,"(!"7.$-76($")*93=!>%%'*%!;A!%*+"%-!,.(!$;-;1$;@",!".!

&$*!@'44)".9!:*0*!-,%5*(6!:$"4*!%&'(*.&%!,.(!*('2,&;0%!A;2'%*(!;.!$;:!@;)%!2;'4(!

:*,0!1".5!:"&$;'&!"&!2,#*)*9(#*=$")*9=!>!@*9,.!&;!:;.(*0!:$,&!&$"%!-*,.".9!2;'4(!

@*_"-14"*(!$;-;%*+',4"&)e!D!4,25!;A!-,%2'4"."&)e!^*.(*0!20;%%".9!,%!,.!"(*.&"&)e!>!

:,%!2;.2*0.*(!&$,&!%&0*%%".9!,!4,25!;A!-*,.".9!A'0&$*0!".20*,%*(!&$*!&,@;;!,@;'&!

:$,&!&$*%*!-*,.".9%!-"9$&!@*!,.(!$;:!&$"%!;&$*0*(!@;)%!:$;!-,)!*+1*0"*.2*!

&$*-%*4/*%!,%!9,)6!,%!A*-".".*6!9*.(*0!.;.E2;.A;0-".96!;0!&0,.%9*.(*0=!!

I,09,0*&!0*1*,&*(4)!*+10*%%*(!$*0!(*("2,&";.!&;!'%".9!G".5!C,)!,%!,.!

;11;0&'."&)!&;!,((0*%%!%*+"%-!,.(!$;-;1$;@",=!!H$*!$*4(!,!%&0;.9!(*%"0*!&;!

10;-;&*!%;2",4!2$,.9*!,.(!-,5*!&$*!;22,%";.!,@;'&!-;0*!&$,.!1".5!@*".9!,!N90*,&!

2;4;'0O!3Q;/*44,!YV<VY<UY7!@)!,((0*%%".9!&$*!%;2",4!-*,.".9%!;A!&$*!(,)!".!,!:,)!

&$,&!$*0!%&'(*.&%!:;'4(!@*!,@4*!&;!'.(*0%&,.(=!#$0;'9$;'&!&$*!:**56!I,09,0*&!'%*(!

Page 178: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UiV!

!

%&;0)!&"-*%6!9,-*%6!,.(!("%2'%%";.%!".!24,%%!&;!A,2"4"&,&*!%&'(*.&!*.9,9*-*.&!:"&$!

'.(*0%&,.(".9!&$*-%*4/*%!,%!$,/".9!&$*!1;:*0!&;!%&,.(!'1!A;0!&$*-%*4/*%!,.(!

;&$*0%6!-,5*!2$;"2*%6!,.(!&$".5!,@;'&!9*.(*0!.;0-%=!#$*!A;44;:".9!0*2;'.&%!&$*!

G".5!C,)!,%%*-@4)!,.(!I,09,0*&B%!(*@0"*A".9!;A!"&!:"&$!$*0!24,%%6!,%!:*44!,%!&$*!

*+14"2"&!4*%%;.!;.!$;-;1$;@",!9"/*.!,%!1,0&!;A!$*0!*AA;0&%!&;!*.%'0*!&$,&!"%%'*%!;A!

9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)!:*0*!@;&$!.,-*(!,.(!("%2'%%*(=!!

D&!&$*!G".5!C,)!D%%*-@4)6!$*4(!;.!h*@0',0)!YZ&$!!3&$*!(,)!@*A;0*!&$*!,2&',4!

G".5!C,)76!>!:,45*(!".&;!&$*!9)-!&;!,!@,00,9*!;A!.;"%*=!#$*0*!:,%!,!24,%%!;.!%&,9*!

%*&&".9!'1!A;0!&$*!1*0A;0-,.2*%=!D!1",.;!:,%!%*&!@)!&$*!%&,9*!:"&$!,!10;M*2&;0!,.(!

%;'.(!%)%&*-!".!&$*!-"((4*=!I,09,0*&B%!24,%%!:,%!%;-*:$,&!*.&0,.2*(!@)!&$*!N2;;4O!

9'"&,0!&$,&!:,%!,4%;!14'99*(!".!@)!&$*!%&,9*!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!YZ<VY<UY7=!#$*!*/*.&%!

;1*.*(!:"&$!;.*!24,%%B!%*0"*%!;A!:;0(4*%%!%5"&%!%*&!&;!-'%"26!0*E*.,2&".9!&$*!*/*.&%!

;A!G".5!C,)=!D.;&$*0!24,%%!&$*.!1*0A;0-*(!,!%*0"*%!;A!%5"&%!:$*0*!1*;14*!9;&!@'44"*(!

A;0!("AA*0*.&!&$".9%!3*,&".9!A;;(!%;-*!1*;14*!A;'.(!N%-*44)6O!.;&!@*".9!,@4*!&;!A".(!

&$*"0!14,2*!".!&$*!-'%"2!('0".9!,!2$;"0!10,2&"2*76!,.(!,!%*0"*%!;A!*/*.&%!&$,&!*.,@4*(!

&$*!@'44"*%!&;!2$,.9*!&$*"0!@*$,/";0=!D!A*:!-;0*!24,%%*%!$,(!10*1,0*(!%&,&*-*.&%!

%'2$!,%!N*/*0);.*!2,.!:*,0!1".5!,.)!(,)O!,.(!&$,&!1*;14*!,0*!N&0*,&*(!:*44!".!

S,.,(,6!&$*0*!"%!.;!@'44)".9!".!S,.,(,O!3)/)%7=[U!T'9*!1,1*0%!:*0*!$'.9!,..;'.2".9X!

NF*!%&0;.96!%1*,5!'16!&,5*!,2&";.O!,.(!N#,5*!,!%&,.(!,9,".%&!@'44)".9O!3)/)%7=!#$*!4"/*!

1*0A;0-,.2*%!:*0*!A;44;:*(!@)!,!/"(*;!;A!,!90;'1!;A!$"9$!%2$;;4!%&'(*.&%!:$;!$,(!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[U!>!:,%!.;&!".!&$*!1;%"&";.!&;!,%5!:$*0*!&$*!%&,&*-*.&!&$,&!&$*0*!:,%!.;!@'44)".9!".!

S,.,(,!2,-*!A0;-=!>!("(!:;.(*0!$;:!$"%&;0"2,4!,.(!2'00*.&!*/*.&%!:*0*!@*".9!

&,'9$&6!;0!.;&!&,'9$&6!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!".!;0(*0!A;0!%'2$!,.!,%%*0&";.!&;!@*!-,(*=!!

Page 179: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UiU!

!

1*0A;0-*(!,!(,.2*!.'-@*0!".!&$*!-"((4*!;A!,!4;2,4!-,44!('0".9!G".5!C,)!&$*!)*,0!

@*A;0*=!!

b$*.!:*!0*&'0.*(!&;!&$*!24,%%0;;-6!I,09,0*&!$,(!*/*0);.*!%"&!;.!&$*!2,01*&!

,.(!%$*!,%5*(!&$*!%&'(*.&%!:$,&!&$*!,%%*-@4)!:,%!,@;'&!,.(!:$,&!&$*)!

0*-*-@*0*(=!#$*!-;%&!10*/,4*.&!-*-;0)!0*2;'.&*(!:,%!&$*!(,.2*!,&!K,50"(9*!

I,446!,A&*0!:$"2$!,44!&$*!%&'(*.&%!:,.&*(!&;!%,)!:$*.!&$*)B(!@**.!&;!K,50"(9*=!

I,09,0*&!0*-".(*(!&$*-!,@;'&!&$*!%5"&!:$*0*!1*;14*!:*0*!*,&".9!4'.2$!,.(!,!

90;'1!4*,.*(!,:,)6!:,/".9!&$*"0!$,.(%!;/*0!&$*"0!.;%*%=!H$*!,%5*(!&$*!%&'(*.&%!

$;:!&$*!1*0%;.!-"9$&!$,/*!A*4&!:$*.!&$,&!$,11*.*(=!!H$*!'%*(!&$"%!,%!,!4*,(!".!&;!

%,)!&$,&!N;.*!1*0%;.!-,(*!,!2$;"2*O!3)/)%7!&;!&0)!&$*!%.,25!,.(!,A&*0!&$,&!&$*!90;'1!

".!&$*!%5"&!%$,0*(!A;;(!&;9*&$*0=!I,09,0*&!&,45*(!,@;'&!$;:!&$*!9"04!:"&$!&$*!%.,25!

%,&!'1!&,44!,A&*0!$*0!1**0%!%$,0*(!$*0!%.,256!%$*!,%5*(!&$*!%&'(*.&%!&;!0*2,44!:$,&!&$*!

9"04B%!@;()!4;;5*(!4"5*!,.(!,%5*(!&$*-!:$,&!&$,&!&;4(!&$*-!,@;'&!$;:!&$*!9"04!A*4&!

,A&*0!$*0!A0"*.(!-,(*!&$*!2$;"2*!&;!%$,0*!A;;(=!D&!A"0%&!&$*0*!:*0*!2;--*.&%!&$,&!

%$*!%$;'4(.B&!$,/*!@**.!*,&".9!%;-*;.*B%!%.,25!3"&!"%!,9,".%&!&$*!0'4*%!&;!%$,0*!

%.,25%!".!8".(*09,0&*.!('*!&;!A;;(!%*.%"&"/"&"*%!,.(!,44*09"*%7=!>&!&;;5!,!A*:!-".'&*%!

@*A;0*!&$*!%&'(*.&%!,11*,0*(!&;!'.(*0%&,.(!&$*!"%%'*!;A!*+24'%";.!&$,&!:,%!,&!14,)!

".!&$*!%5"&!,.(!2;./*0%,&";.=[Y!I,09,0*&!;/*0/"*:*(!&$*!G".5!C,)!%&;0)6!,%5".9!$;:!

&$*)!:;'4(!A**4!"A!%;-*;.*!1;".&*(!,.(!4,'9$*(!,&!&$*-!@*2,'%*!;A!:$,&!&$*)!2$;%*!

&;!:*,06!,.(!*.2;'0,9*(!&$*-!&;!&$".5!,@;'&!&$*"0!0*%1;.%*%!,.(!A**4".9%!".!&$*"0!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Y!#$*!"%%'*!;A!%&'(*.&%!@*".9!%;2",44)!;%&0,2"J*(!A;0!N%-*44)O!A;;(!"%!@,%*(!".!

0,2",4"J*(!.;0-%=!#$"%!:,%!,4%;!.;&!,((0*%%*(!("0*2&4)!".!&$*!,%%*-@4"*%!;0!

24,%%0;;-=!!

Page 180: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UiY!

!

N;:.!@0,".%O!3)/)%7!@*A;0*!%$,0".9!:"&$!&$*!24,%%=!D&!&$*!*.(!;A!&$*!("%2'%%";.!8,&)!

,%5*(!"A!&$*!%&;0)!I,09,0*&!&;4(!,@;'&!&$*!@;)!:,%!&$*!A"0%&!1".5!(,)=!b$*.!%$*!

2;.A"0-*(!&$,&!"&!:,%6!&:;!9"04%!&'0.*(!&;!*,2$!;&$*0!,.(!%,"(!N:$;,cO!,%!"A!$*,0".9!

,@;'&!&$*!@*9"..".9!;A!,.!,.2"*.&!4*9*.(!3)/)%7=!!

#$*!2$"4(0*.!24,-;'0*(!*+2"&*(4)!".&;!&$*!0;;-!;.!G".5!C,)=!R/*0)!%".94*!9"04!

:,%!:*,0".9!1".5!,%!:*44!,%!-;%&!;A!&$*!@;)%=!8"*0;.6!:$;!'%',44)!$,(!,!0*(!%&0*,5!

()*(!".!$"%!$,"06!$,(!,!1".5!%&0*,5!".%&*,(!,.(!*+24,"-*(6!N>!9*&!&;!5**1!"&!A;0!

,:$"4*cO!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!YW<VY<UY7!K%2,06!#0"%&,.6!,.(!C)4,.!:;0*!1'014*6!N2,'%*!

"&B%!,4-;%&!1".5cO!3)/)%7=!C)4,.!$,(!,!2'&!;'&!;A!,!1".5!%$"0&!1"..*(!&;!$"%!%$"0&!:"&$!

Nh*@0',0)!YW!G".5!H$"0&!C,)O!:0"&&*.!;.!"&!3)/)%7=!C'.2,.!:;0*!,!1".5!%$"0&!:"&$!,!

@4,25!%5'44!:*,0".9!$*,(1$;.*%!;.!"&6!,.(!8)'.9!:;0*!,!1".5!%1;0&%!/*%&!:"&$!

N@'44(;9O!:0"&&*.!,20;%%!&$*!A0;.&!,.(!@,25=!I;%&!;A!&$*!9"04%!$,(!%&0"1*%!,.(!

%*L'".%j!`*&&"*B%!%$"0&!$,(!N%-"4*O!:0"&&*.!,20;%%!&$*!A0;.&!3)/)%7=!S;..*06!:$;!&$*!

(,)!@*A;0*!$,(!(;.*!,!$,11)!(,.2*!,20;%%!&$*!24,%%0;;-!".!,.&"2"1,&";.!;A!:*,0".9!

1".5!&$*!.*+&!(,)6!:;0*!,!1".5!%$"0&!:"&$!N(,.2*O!:0"&&*.!,20;%%!&$*!A0;.&!3)/)%7=!

#$;'9$!$*!(,.2*(!:$*.!$*!:;0*!"&6!>!("(!.;&!%**!$"-!:*,0!&$*!%$"0&!;.!,.)!;&$*0!

(,)!('0".9!-)!A"*4(:;05=!

#$,&!,A&*0.;;.6!I,09,0*&!2,44*(!&$*!24,%%!&;!&$*!2,01*&=!#$*)!%,&!A,2".9!,!

1,1*0!A4"1!2$,0&!;.!,!@0"9$&!;0,.9*!*,%*4=!!D!1;%&*0!:"&$!&$*!$*,(".9!NT;-;1$;@",!

h0**!s;.*O!:,%!&,1*(!&;!&$*!-"((4*!;A!&$*!A4"1!2$,0&!:"&$!&$*!:;0(!NT;-;1$;@",O!

:0"&&*.!".!4,09*!4*&&*0%!;/*0!"&=!!

Page 181: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Uif!

!

K.!-)!A"0%&!(,)!,&!&$*!A"*4(:;05!14,2*-*.&6!>!$,(!.;&"2*(!&$*!NT;-;1$;@",!

h0**!s;.*O!1;%&*0!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!F*4;:!&$*!&"&4*!:,%!&$*!1$,%*!N#$,&B%!H;!^,)cO!

:"&$!,!@,.!%"9.!;/*0!"&=!!

d.(*0.*,&$!:,%!:0"&&*.X!!

T;-;1$;@"2!%4'0%!4"5*!&$"%!;.*!:"44!PK#!@*!&;4*0,&*(!$*0*!

#$*)!,0*!M'%&!,%!$,&*A'4!,%!0,2"%-_`!

F'44)".9!2,.!$,11*.!&;!DPgKPRc!

3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!Uf<VY<UY7=(

#$*%*!1;%&*0%!:*0*!("%&0"@'&*(!&;!%2$;;4%!&$0;'9$;'&!&$*!?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!

F;,0(!,%!1,0&!;A!,!10;M*2&!:"&$!^,)!,.(!a*%@",.!R('2,&;0%!3^DaR7!FS!3.;:!G0"(*!

R('2,&";.!P*&:;057!".!YVV[!,.(6!:$"4*!&$*)!,0*!%&"44!".!%2$;;4%6!&$*)!,0*!.;!4;.9*0!

@*".9!"%%'*(=!D%!,.!*-14;)**6!>!.;&"2*(!&$*-!".!-,.)!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4!2;--;.!

,0*,%!,.(!24,%%0;;-%6!&$;'9$!,%!,!9*.*0,4!0'4*!&$*)!:*0*!4;2,&*(!%4"9$&4)!,@;/*!-)!

$*,(=!#$"%!24,%%0;;-B%!1;%&*0!14,2*-*.&!:,%!2;.%"%&*.&!:"&$!&$"%!&0*.(=!>&!:,%!

1;%&*(!.*+&!&;!&$*!(;;0=!>!%&,.(!]BiO!,.(!&$*!1;%&*0!:,%!,@;/*!-)!*)*!4*/*4=!D9,".6!

&$"%!%*.(%!,.!".&*0*%&".9!-*%%,9*!,@;'&!%*+',4"&)!,.(!;&$*0.*%%_"&!"%!10*%*.&!@'&!

;'&!;A!%"9$&=!#$*!'%',4!14,2*-*.&!;A!&$*!1;%&*0!-,(*!"&%!2$,.9*!".!4;2,&";.!

%"9."A"2,.&!,.(!-,05*(!&$*!2;./*0%,&";.!,%!1,0&!;A!,!%1*2",4!;22,%";.=!T;:*/*06!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[f!#$"%!%&,&*-*.&!%**-%!&;!"-14)!&$,&!&$*!$,0-%!;A!0,2"%-!:*0*!'."/*0%,44)6!

".%&"&'&";.,44)!,25.;:4*(9*(!,.(!&$,&!$;-;1$;@",!;'9$&!&;!@*!0*2;9."J*(!;.!1,0!

:"&$!&$*!0*2;9."&";.!;A!0,2"%-=!H'2$!,!%&,&*-*.&!*0,%*%!&$*!10;A;'.(!0,2"%-%!%&"44!,&!

14,)!:"&$".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!,.(!4,09*0!(;-".,.&!2'4&'0*!".!F0"&"%$!S;4'-@",=!!!

Page 182: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Ui[!

!

*/*0)!*AA;0&!:,%!-,(*!&;!2;./*)!(;:.E&;E*,0&$6!"-1,2&A'4!".A;0-,&";.!:"&$!:$"2$!

%&'(*.&%!:;'4(!2;..*2&=!!

I,09,0*&!@*9,.6!N>B-!9;".9!&;!&*44!);'!,!%&;0)!,@;'&!%;-*&$".9!>!'%*(!&;!$*,0!

:$*.!>!:,%!".!%2$;;4=!H;-*&$".9!&$,&!-,(*!-*!A**4!@,(!".%"(*O!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!

YW<VY<UY7=!H$*!10;2**(*(!&;!&*44!,!%&;0)!,@;'&!:$*.!%$*!:,%!".!,.!*4*-*.&,0)!

%2$;;4!9)-!24,%%!,.(!,!@;)!&'0.*(!&;!,.;&$*0!@;)!,.(!%,"(6!N);'!0'.!4"5*!,!9"04=O!H$*!

&;4(!&$*-!%".2*0*4)6!N>&!:,%.B&!%,"(!".!,!."2*!:,)=!T*!("(.B&!-*,.!);'!0'.!4"5*!,!9"046!

$*!-*,.&6!);'!(;.B&!0'.!/*0)!:*44=!>&!-,(*!-*!A**46!,%!,!9"046!-,)@*!>!("(.B&!0'.!:*446!

;0!&$,&!-,)@*!9"04%!(;.B&!0'.!,%!:*44!,%!@;)%!;0!&$,&!>!("(.B&!0'.!:*44O!a)/)%L'(#$*!

2$"4(0*.!4"%&*.*(!".&*.&4)!,%!%$*!%,"(!&$,&!A;0!$*0!:$;4*!4"A*!%$*!0*-*-@*0*(!$;:!

@,(!"&!-,(*!$*0!A**4=!H$*!0*1*,&*(!%4;:4)6!N);'!0'.!4"5*!,!9"04O!3)/)%7=!Q,&$*0!&$,.!

,%%*0&".9!&$,&!@;)%!:*,0".9!1".5!("(.B&!-*,.!,.)&$".96!I,09,0*&!-,(*!*+14"2"&!&$*!

&0*.(!:$*0*@)!@;)%!4;%*!%&,&'%!:$*.!&$*)!(;!&$".9%!&$,&!,0*!2,&*9;0"J*(!,%!6)P,(

9).63b,(&0*.(!*-@*((*(!".!%*+"%&!,.(!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!10"/"4*9".9=!

I,09,0*&!("(!.;&!94;%%!;/*0!"%%'*%!;A!$;-;1$;@",!&$,&!:*0*!1,0&!;A!&$*!"."&",4!

*/*.&%!&$,&!@*9,.!G".5!C,)=!DA&*0!&*44".9!$*0!%&;0)!;A!N);'!0'.!4"5*!,!9"046O!%$*!&;;5!

(;:.!&$*!%"9.!&$,&!0*,(6!N&$,&B%!%;!9,)6O!,%5".9!"A!&$*!%&'(*.&%!5.*:!:$,&!N9,)O!

-*,.&=!P,&,%$,!%,"(!N.;6O!,.(!,%5*(!A;0!,.!,.%:*0!3)/)%7=!C)4,.!,4%;!%&,&*(!&$,&!$*!

("(.B&!5.;:=!8"*0;.!%&;;(!'1!,.(!10;'(4)!,..;'.2*(!&$,&!$*!5.*:!:$,&!"&!-*,.&X!

N:$*.!,!@;)!4"5*%!,.;&$*0!@;)!,.(!&$*)!9*&!-,00"*(=!#$*!%,-*!:"&$!9"04%6O!&;!:$"2$!

%*/*0,4!2$"4(0*.!-'0-'0*(!N;$!)*,$O!3)/)%7=!I,09,0*&!2;.A"0-*(!&$,&!8"*0;.B%!

,.%:*0!:,%!0"9$&!,.(!A;44;:*(!:"&$!,%5".96!N"%!&$*0*!,.)&$".9!:0;.9!:"&$!&$,&eO!

Page 183: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Ui]!

!

3)/)%7=!!#$*!24,%%!%,"(6!N.;O!".!'."%;.=!I,09,0*&!%&0*%%*(!&$,&!@*".9!9,)!"%!N;5,)!,.(!

A".*O!3)/)%7!,.(!0*,(!&$*!%"9.!;.!&$*!1;%&*0!;'&!4;'(=!!H$*!*+14,".*(!&$,&!:$*.!1*;14*!

%,)6!N&$,&B%!%;!9,)6O!&$*)!-*,.!N&$,&B%!%;!%&'1"(6O!,.(!,%5*(!$;:!1*;14*!:$;!,0*!9,)!

:;'4(!A**4!:$*.!&$*)!$*,0!&$,&=!#$*!24,%%!0*14"*(!".!'."%;.!,9,".6!N@,(=O!b"&$".!&$"%!

&,456!%*+"%-!,.(!$;-;1$;@",!:*0*!-,(*!*+14"2"&=!F*".9!9,)!:,%!.,-*(6!0,&$*0!&$,.!

;22'1)".9!,!%"&*!;A!-'&*(!,/;"(,.2*!3&$,&!"&B%!;5,)!A;0!@;)%!&;!:*,0!1".5!@*2,'%*!"&!

(;*%.B&!2,#*(#*=$")*96!"-14)".9!&$,&!&$*0*!*+"%&%!,!-*,.".9A'4!&$".9!;.*!%$;'4(!

,/;"(7=!!

I,09,0*&!1;%*(!&$*!L'*%&";.6!N:$,&!"A!"&!v&$*!%"9.w!%,"(!o&$,&B%!%;!4"5*!,!@;)eB!

G*;14*!:;'4(!&$".5!&$,&!I0%=!Q;/*44,!&$".5%!&$*0*B%!%;-*&$".9!:0;.9!:"&$!@*".9!,!

@;)=O!H$*!&$*.!,%5*(6!N:$,&!"A!"&!%,"(!&$,&B%!%;!S$".*%*eO!3)/)%7=!!H*/*0,4!5"(%!

0*%1;.(*(!&;!&$"%!@)!%&,&".96!N>B-!.;&!S$".*%*O!3-;0*!;.!&$*%*!0*%1;.%*%!@*4;:7=!

8"*0;.!M'-1*(!".!*+24,"-".9!&$,&!"&!:;'4(!@*!4"5*!%,)".9!N&$,&B%!%;!P,&"/*cO!3)/)%7=!!

T*!%,"(!&$,&!$*!$;1*(!&$,&!$*!,.(!C'.2,.!$,(!&$*"0!P,&"/*!90;'1!&$,&!(,)=!#$*)!

*,2$!%,:!I"2$*44*!R/*0*&&!,@;'&!;.2*!,!-;.&$!A;0!A"A&**.!-".'&*%!,%!:*44!,%!

;22,%";.,46!4;.9*0!90;'1!%*%%";.%!,.(!A"*4(!&0"1%=!H$*!:,%.B&!&$*0*!('0".9!&$*!4,%&!

%2$*('4*(!&"-*!('*!&;!"44.*%%!,.(!&$*0*!:,%!.;!0*14,2*-*.&=!Q*9,0(4*%%!;A!&$*!

@0*/"&)6!$*!&,45*(!,@;'&!"&!*+2"&*(4)!,.(!@0;'9$&!&$*!%&,&*-*.&6!NC'.2,.!,.(!>!,0*!

P,&"/*O!3)/)%7!".&;!&$*!2;./*0%,&";.!".!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!$;:!.*9,&"/*!%&,&*-*.&%!

,@;'&!@*".9!N9,)O!,.(!@*".9!NP,&"/*O!:*0*!.;&!;5,)=!I,09,0*&!0*A4*2&*(!&$,&!@*".9!

P,&"/*!:,%!1,0&!;A!$"%!2'4&'0*!,.(!"-1;0&,.&!&;!$"-=!H$*!%&,&*(!&$,&!,44!;A!&$;%*!

Page 184: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Uik!

!

%&,&*-*.&%!,0*!("AA*0*.&!@'&!&$*)!,0*!,4%;!%"-"4,0!,.(!&$,&!.;.*!;A!&$*-!,0*!;5,)=!

8"*0;.!,(,-,.&4)!2,44*(!;'&!N)*,$cO!3)/)%7=!

DA&*0!&$*!&,45!,@;'&!&$*!1;%&*06!I,09,0*&!".&0;('2*(!&$*!:;0(!$;-;1$;@",=!

I;%&!;A!&$*!2$"4(0*.!$,(!.;&!$*,0(!"&!@*A;0*=!I,09,0*&!%&,&*(!&$,&6!NR.94"%$!$,%!

90*,&6!90*,&!90,.(1,0*.&%6!M'%&!4"5*!);'!$,/*!90*,&6!90*,&!90,.(1,0*.&%O!3)/)%7=!!>!

:;'4(!$,/*!,.&"2"1,&*(!&$*!2$"4(0*.!4;%".9!".&*0*%&!,%!%$*!&,45*(!,@;'&!^0**5!

-*,.".9%!;A!&$*!:;0(%!$;-;!,.(!1$;@",6!@'&!&$*)!9,/*!$*0!&$*"0!0,1&!,&&*.&";.!:"&$!

*+2"&*(!N;$O!,.(!N,$O!:$*.!$*,0".9!,@;'&!$;:!N$;-;!0*A*0%!&;!$;-;%*+',46!,.;&$*0!

:;0(!A;0!9,)O!3)/)%7!,.(!&$,&!1$;@",!0*A*00*(!&;!@*".9!,A0,"(=!H$*!&$*.!0*1*,&*(6!

,9,".6!:$,&!9,)!-*,.%!,.(!$;:!"&!0*A*0%!&;!N&$*!5".(!;A!4;/*!:$*0*!);'B(!:,.&!&;!9*&!

-,00"*(!;0!:$*0*!);'B(!:,.&!&;!@*!@;)A0"*.(!;0!9"04A0"*.(O!3)/)%7=!!#$*!%&'(*.&%!

,11*,0*(!&;!'.(*0%&,.(!,.(!A;44;:6!.;((".9!&$*"0!$*,(%!,%!%$*!*+14,".*(!&$,&!

$;-;1$;@",!0*A*0%!&;!1*;14*!@*".9!,A0,"(!;A!1*;14*!@*".9!9,)=!H$*!,%5*(6!Nb$,&!

(;*%!"&!-*,.!:$*.!1*;14*!,0*!,A0,"(!;A!1*;14*!@*".9!("AA*0*.&e!>%!"&!;5,)!&;!@'44)!

&$*-eO!3)/)%7=!!D9,".6!&$*!24,%%!0*1*,&*(6!N.;6O!".!'."%;.=!8,&)!%&,&*(!L'"*&4)!&$,&!"&!"%!

.;&!;5,)!&;!*/*0!@'44)!,.);.*=!b$"4*!@*".9!9,)!:,%!(*A".*(!".!1;%"&"/*!&*0-%6!"&!:,%!

"--*(",&*4)!1;%"&";.*(!,%!("AA*0*.&6!,%!&$",.=!!

I,09,0*&!A;44;:*(!&$*!("%2'%%";.!;A!$;-;1$;@",!:"&$!&"-*!%1*.&!0*/"*:".9!

&$*!G".5!C,)!%&;0)=!#$*!%&'(*.&%!:*0*!".&*.%*4)!*.9,9*(!:"&$!&$*!%&;0)6!1'.2&',&".9!

"&!:"&$!%$;25*(!9,%1%!,.(!%$'((*0%6!*%1*2",44)!:$*.!I,09,0*&!%&,&*(!&$,&!&$*!@'44"*%!

%,"(!N&$,&B%!%;!9,)O!&;!&$*!@;)!:$;!:;0*!,!1".5!%$"0&!3&$*0*!:*0*!.;!%'2$!*+&0*-*!

0*,2&";.%!&;!&$*!G".5!C,)!%&;0)!:$*.!"&!$,(!@**.!&;4(!&$*!(,)!@*A;0*7=!H$*!A0,-*(!

Page 185: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Uii!

!

&$*!^0,(*!#:*4/*!%&'(*.&B%!0*%1;.%*!,%!N%;-*&$".9!,-,J".9O!&$,&!$,11*.*(!:$*.!

&$*!%&'(*.&%!-,(*!,!1;:*0A'4!2$;"2*!3)/)%7=!

!#$*!&,45!2;.24'(*(!:"&$!,.!*+14,.,&";.!,%!&;!:$,&!"&!-*,.&!&;!$,/*!,!@,.!

%"9.!&$0;'9$!&$*!1$0,%*6!N#$,&B%!H;!^,)6O!;.!&$*!1;%&*0=!I,09,0*&!%&,&*(!N".!&$"%!

24,%%0;;-6!&$"%!%1,2*6!"&!"%!.;&!;5,)!&;!@*!$;-;1$;@"2O!3)/)%7=!!H$*!*4,@;0,&*(6!N&$"%!

,114"*%!&;!*/*0)&$".9X!"&!"%!.;&!;5,)!&;!%,)!%;-*&$".9!"%!4"5*!,!@;)6!;0!&;!%,)!@,(!

&$".9%!,@;'&!@*".9!S$".*%*6!;0!&$,&!9"04%!(;.B&!&"*!&$*"0!%$;*%!:*446O!3)/)%7!,.(!

2;.&".'*(!:"&$!%"-"4,0!*+,-14*%=!H$*!,%5*(!&$*!2$"4(0*.!"A!&$*)!:,.&*(!&;!,((!

,.)&$".9!,.(!%;-*!2$"4(0*.!&,45*(!,@;'&!$;:!&$*)B(!%**.!&$*!1;%&*0!@*A;0*!,.(!

:;.(*0*(!:$,&!"&!-*,.&=!

8"*0;.!-,(*!,!%"9."A"2,.&!2;.&0"@'&";.!&;!&$*!2;./*0%,&";.6!(0,:".9!A0;-!$"%!

2'4&'0,4!@,2590;'.(!,.(!%1*,5".9!:"&$!10"(*!,@;'&!"&=!>&!"%!.;&*:;0&$)!&$,&!$*!:,%!

&$*!A"0%&!%&'(*.&!&;!%&,&*!&$,&!$*!5.*:!:$,&!9,)!-*,.&!,.(!&;!@*!2;-A;0&,@4*!&,45".9!

,@;'&!"&!".!24,%%=!h;0!8"*0;.6!&$*!("%2'%%";.!0*9,0(".9!N&$,&B%!%;!9,)O!&;;5!14,2*!".!,!

2;.&*+&!".!:$"2$!1*;14*!@*".9!9,)!:,%!,40*,()!,!2;--;.14,2*!;22'00*.2*!A;0!:$"2$!

&$*0*!:,%!4,.9',9*=!h0;-!%&;0"*%!8"*0;.!&;4(!;A!A,-"4)!9,&$*0".9%6!"&!,11*,0*(!&$*)!

:*0*!2;..*2&*(!&;6!,.(!10;'(!;A!&$*"0!$"%&;0)6!,.(!,4%;!("%2'%%*(!("%20"-".,&";.!

:"&$!$"-=!>.!,(("&";.6!$*!:,%!1,0&!;A!,!90;'1!&$,&!&,45*(!,@;'&!,.(!1,0&"2"1,&*(!".!

,2&"/"&"*%!,0;'.(!D@;0"9".,4"&)!:"&$".!&$*!%2$;;4=!T"%!@,2590;'.(6!".!&$"%!2;.&*+&6!

$,(!,!14,2*!&;!@*!,0&"2'4,&*(!:"&$".!$"%!".%&"&'&";.=!#$;'9$!&$*!&"-*!%1*.&!:"&$!&$*!

D@;0"9".,4!R.$,.2*-*.&!b;05*0!:,%!@0"*A6!,.(!%*90*9,&*(!A0;-!&$*!0*%&!;A!&$*!(,)E

&;E(,)!;A!24,%%!4"A*6!"&!&;;5!14,2*!:"&$!;&$*0!1**0%!,.(!:,%!,!1;".&!;A!*+2"&*-*.&!,.(!

Page 186: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UiZ!

!

10"(*!:$*.*/*0!$*!%1;5*!;A!"&=!b$*.!>!%1;5*!&;!I"2$*44*!R/*0*&&6!%$*!%&0*%%*(!:,)%!

%$*!A;2'%*(!;.!2$"4(0*.!@*".9!,@4*!&;!'.(*0%&,.(!&$*"0!D@;0"9".,4!@,2590;'.(%!,%!

("%&".2&!@'&!,4%;!1,0&!;A!,!4,09*0!.*&:;05!;A!2'4&'0*%!3R/*0*&&!Uk<V]<UY7=!>.!&$"%!:,)6!

8"*0;.B%!*&$."2"&)!:,%!.;&!-*.&";.*(!,&!%2$;;4!%;4*4)!".!&$*!2;.&*+&!;A!

("%20"-".,&";.!;0!&$",.)*96!,.(!$*!$,(!&$"%!'.(*0%&,.(".9!&;!(0,:!A0;-!".!&$*!

2;./*0%,&";.!0*9,0(".9!$;-;1$;@",=!$

#$*!2$"4(0*.B%!0*%1;.%*!&;!I,09,0*&B%!2;-1,0"%;.!;A!N&$,&B%!%;!9,)O!:"&$!

N&$,&B%!%;!S$".*%*O!"%!,4%;!:;0&$!"./*%&"9,&".9=!D!A*:!2$"4(0*.!%&,&*(!&$,&!&$*)!:*0*!

.;&!S$".*%*6!:$*0*,%!:$*.!10"/"4*9*(!"(*.&"&"*%!3*=9=!%;-*&$".9!@*".9!N4"5*!,!@;)O7!

:*0*!(0,:.!;.6!.;!%'2$!%&,&*-*.&%!:*0*!-,(*=!C*%1"&*!,!:"(*!0,.9*!;A!*&$."2!

@,2590;'.(%!:"&$".!&$*!24,%%6!&$*%*!,%%*0&";.%!".("2,&*!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!:*0*!*.9,9*(!

".!-,5".9!-*,.".9!;'&!;A!0,2",4"J*(!%;2",4!4;2,&";.%=!#$*!%&,&*-*.&!&$,&!

("%20"-".,&";.!"%!.;&!;5,)!&,5*%!14,2*!".!,!2;.&*+&!".!:$"2$!&$*!10"/"4*9".9!;A!:$"&*6!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)6!%&"44!10*/,"4%=!!

>.!;'0!G".5!C,)!".&*0/"*:6!>!,%5*(!I,09,0*&!,@;'&!,((0*%%".9!("AA*0*.&!

2'4&'0*%!:"&$".!&$*!24,%%=!H$*!0*%1;.(*(6!N>&B%!,4-;%&!,%!"A!&$*!2'4&'0*%!(;.B&!

*+"%&u:*!,44!,0*!&;9*&$*0!,.(!;'0!2'4&'0*!"%!8".(*09,0&*.u!>!$,/*.B&!0*,44)!

*.2;'0,9*(!&$*!5"(%!&;!(*4/*!".&;!&$*!A,2&6!:*446!%;E,.(E%;!"%!S$".*%*uO!3Q;/*44,!

VY<Vf<UY7=!#$"%!"%!&$*!0"%5!8'-,%$"0;!("%2'%%*%!".!0*9,0(%!&;!%;4*4)!*-14;)".9!,.!

N*('2,&";.!A;0!&$*!;&$*0O!3fi7!,110;,2$!&;!%;2",4!M'%&"2*!:"&$".!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!>A!.;!

;.*!"%!@'44"*(!A;0!&$*"0!*&$."2"&"*%6!&$*.!".24'%";.!2,.!@*!10*%'-*(!&;!$,/*!@**.!

,22;-14"%$*(=!T;:*/*06!".("/"(',4!2$"4(0*.B%!2'4&'0*%!:*0*!%&"44!%'@%'-*(!@)!

Page 187: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UiW!

!

(;-".,.&6!(*A,'4&!2'4&'0*%=[[!h;0!*+,-14*6!('0".9!-)!A"*4(:;056!R,%&*0!,.(!

?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!,.(!;&$*0!b*%&*0."J*(!$;4"(,)%!:*0*!-,(*!".&;!;22,%";.%!".!&$*!

24,%%0;;-!,.(!:*0*!.*'&0,4"J*(!,%!@*".9!,@;'&!2'4&'0*=!!

b$"4*!I,09,0*&!$,(!@**.!,(,-,.&!&$,&!"&!:,%!.;&!;5,)!&;!%,)6!N&$,&B%!%;!9,)O!

@*2,'%*!"&!:,%!.;&!;5,)!&;!%,)!@,(!&$".9%!,@;'&!9,)!1*;14*6!.;.*!;A!&$*!2$"4(0*.!

0*2,44*(!&$"%!-*%%,9*=!C'0".9!A;2'%!90;'1%!:"&$!&$*!%&'(*.&%!&$*!(,)!,A&*0!G".5!C,)6!

&$*!2$"4(0*.!(*-;.%&0,&*(!"-14"2,&";.%!;A!&$*!%;4*!-*.&";.!;A!N9,)O!&,5".9!14,2*!

%"-'4&,.*;'%4)!:"&$!$;-;1$;@",=!#$*!A;44;:".9!A;2'%!90;'1!*+2*01&!"%!*-@4*-,&"2!

;A!%&'(*.&!("%2'%%";.%!;.!:$,&!&$*)!0*-*-@*0*(!I,09,0*&B%!&,45!,%!$,/".9!@**.!

,@;'&X!

D@"9,"4X!d$6!>!(;.B&!5.;:=!!

DX!K5,)=!#$,&B%!,40"9$&=!C;!);'!0*-*-@*0!:$,&!%$*!&,45*(!,@;'&!:"&$!&$,&!

v&$*!1;%&*0we!

D%$4*)X!d$$$$$6!(;.B&!%,)!&$,&!:;0(c!

DX!C;!);'!0*-*-@*0!:$)!.;&!&;!%,)!&$,&!:;0(e!!

D%$4*)X!S,'%*!"&B%!,!-*,.!:;0(=!!

DX!b$,&!:;0(!"%!-*,.e!!

D%$4*)X!#$,&B%!%;!9,)c!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[[!I,09,0*&!,4%;!%&,&*(!&$,&!%$*!:,.&*(!&;!".24'(*!,!/,0"*&)!;A!2'4&'0*%!".!$*0!

&*,2$".9!10,2&"2*!@'&!A*,0*(!@*".9!,110;10",&"/*6!,.(!&$"%!A*,0!%;-*&"-*%!%&"A4*(!$*0!

,&&*-1&%!&;!-;0*!,2&"/*4)!,((0*%%!L'**0!,.(!.;.E(;-".,.&!*&$."2!2'4&'0*%!:"&$".!

$*0!*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%!3Q;/*44,!VY<Vf<UY7=!#$"%!A*,0!10;/"(*%!,.;&$*0!*+,-14*!,%!

&$*!.**(!A;0!*+1,.(*(!10;A*%%";.,4!(*/*4;1-*.&!0*9,0(".9!%;2",4!M'%&"2*!1*(,9;9"*%!

&$,&!:;'4(!%&0,&*9"J*!:,)%!&;!(*E2*.&0*!2'4&'0*!.;0-%!".!24,%%0;;-%!:"&$;'&!

2'4&'0,4!,110;10",&";.=!

Page 188: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UZV!

!

DX!>&B%!,!-*,.!&$".9!&;!%,)e!b$)!"%!&$,&!-*,.e!b$,&B%!-*,.!,@;'&!"&e!!

D%$4*)X!K06!;06!'.4*%%!);'!%,)!N);'!0'.!4"5*!,!9"04=O!

DX!b$,&!"A!%;-*;.*!%,)%6!N>B-!9,)6O!"%!&$,&!-*,.e!!

D@"9,"4!,.(!D%$4*)X!P;c!!

D%$4*)X!S,'%*!&$*)B0*!%,)".9!"&!&;!&$*"0%*4/*%c!v%"2w!

DX!F*2,'%*!&$*)B0*!%,)".9!"&!&;!&$*-%*4/*%=!D.(!:$,&!(;*%!&$,&!-*,.!:$*.!

&$*)!%,)!"&e!!

D@"9,"4X!#$*)B0*!%,)".9!"&!&;!&$*-%*4/*%c!

D%$4*)X!H;!&$,&!);'!(;.B&!$,/*!&;!%,)!&$,&6!14*,%*!%&;1=!D.(!);'!%,)6!N14*,%*!

%&;1!(;!&$,&!%*4AcO!v%"2w!

D@"9,"4X!D.(!"A!>!%,)6!N>!%;!9,)6O!,.(!"A!>!%,)!N>!%;6O!N>B-!%;!9,)O!&;!-)%*4A6!&$,&!

-*,.%!>!A**4!4"5*!%,)".9!"&!@'&!>!(;.B&!:,.&6!@'&!>!5.;:!.;&!&;!%,)!"&!&;!;&$*0!

1*;14*6!%;!>!%,)!"&!&;!-)%*4A=!!

3G".5!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1!Y!U<Vf<UY7!

>.!qD9,".%&!Q*1*&"&";.X!D((0*%%".9!Q*%"%&,.2*!&;!D.&"EK110*%%"/*!S$,.9*!".!

&$*!G0,2&"2*%!;A!a*,0.".96!#*,2$".96!H'1*0/"%".96!,.(!Q*%*,02$".96O!8*/".!

8'-,%$"0;!("%2'%%*%!$;:!;.*!;A!&$*!;@%&,24*%!&;!&$*!"-14*-*.&,&";.!;A!,.&"E

;110*%%"/*!*('2,&";.!"%!&$,&!@;&$!2$"4(0*.!,.(!,('4&%!$,/*!,!&*.(*.2)!&;!%'@%'-*!

".A;0-,&";.!".&;!&$*"0!-;%&!A,-"4",0!A0,-*:;05=!#$*!2$"4(0*.!:*0*!-;0*!A,-"4",0!

:"&$!,!A0,-*:;05!:$"2$!".%&0'2&%!&$*-!.;&!&;!2,44!.,-*%!&$,&!$'0&!A**4".9%6!&$,.!

&$*)!:*0*!,:,0*!;A!&$*!2;.2*1&!&$,&!);'!2;'4(!2,44!%;-*;.*!%;-*&$".9!,%!,.!".%'4&6!

:$*.!&$,&!:;0(!%$;'4(!.;&!@*!'%*(!,%!,.!".%'4&=!#$"%!-,(*!"&!*,%"*0!A;0!&$*-!&;!

Page 189: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UZU!

!

".&*010*&!&$*!-*%%,9*!;A!&$*!(,)!,%!N9,)!"%!,!@,(!:;0(O!&$,.!"&!:,%!&;!'.(*0%&,.(!

N9,)!"%!.;&!@,(!@'&!2,44".9!%;-*;.*!&$,&!,%!,.!".%'4&!"%=O!#$"%!:,%!*+,2*0@,&*(!@)!&$*!

A,2&!&$,&!%;-*!%&'(*.&%!%"-'4&,.*;'%4)!4*,0.*(!&$*!(*A"."&";.!;A!9,)6!&$*!(*A"."&";.!

;A!$;-;1$;@",6!,.(!*+,-14*%!;A!$;-;1$;@"2!@'44)".9=!!

C*%1"&*!I,09,0*&B%!".%"%&*.2*!&$,&!9,)!"%!;5,)!,.(!&$,&!$;-;1$;@",!:,%!.;&!

;5,)6!&$*!%1*2",4.*%%!;A!&$*!&;1"2!,.(!"&%!%*90*9,&";.!A0;-!*/*0)(,)!&,45!0*%'4&*(!".!

&$*!2;.A4,&";.!;A!@*".9!9,)!:"&$!@*".9!@'44"*(=!T;:!:;'4(!2$"4(0*.!:$;!:*0*!,:,0*!

;A!&$*"0!;:.!.;.E.;0-,&"/*!(*%"0*%!;0!"(*.&"&"*%!*+1*0"*.2*!&$"%!-*%%,9*e!Q,&$*0!

&$,.!@*".9!,@4*!&;!A"&!".&;!*/*0)(,)!4"A*6!:$"2$!"%!0*10*%*.&*(!".!,!0,.9*!;A!&;1"2%!

:"&$!,!0,.9*!;A!2;./*0%,&";.%!,.(!"-,9*%6!;.*B%!1;&*.&",4!"(*.&"&)!"%!-,09".,4"J*(!&;!

,!%1*2",4!&;1"2_"&!"%!,!&$".9!);'!2;'4(!@*!@'44"*(!A;06!@'&!%$;'4(.B&!@*=!!

:?BZ>HJ<?B$

#$*!1'01;%*!:$"2$!%1*2",4!*/*.&%!,0*!,%5*(!&;!%*0/*!$,%!@**.!20"&"L'*(!@)!

a",.!F*/*0"(9*!".6!N`'%&!a"5*!R/*0);.*!R4%*X!#$*!8.;:4*(9*<>9.;0,.2*!F".,0)!".!

S*.%;0%$"1!,.(!^,)!,.(!a*%@",.!G"2&'0*!F;;5%6O!".!:$"2$!%$*!("%2'%%*%!%;-*!

2;--;.,4"&"*%!@*&:**.!("%2;'0%*%!A;0!,.(!,9,".%&!&$*!'%*!;A!&$*!9,)!,.(!4*%@",.!

1"2&'0*!@;;5%!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!F;&$!N%"(*%O!2;.2*1&',4"J*(!,.)!".A;0-,&";.!

2$"4(0*.!:*0*!9"/*.!,@;'&!%*+',4"&)!,%!@;&$!W,.=(J&!,.-76(3"&!2;'4(!2,'%*!&$*!

(;:.A,44!;A!S$0"%&",."&)!;0!&'0.!2$"4(0*.!".&;!9;;(!2"&"J*.%7!,.(!/*0)!%&"25)_,!/*0)!

4"&&4*!@"&!;A!".A;0-,&";.!3%'2$!,%!0*,(".9!;.*!1"2&'0*!@;;5!:"&$!2$,0,2&*0%!".!,!%,-*E

%*+!0*4,&";.%$"17!:;'4(!4*,(!&;!4,%&".9!2$,.9*(!;1".";.%6!4"/*%6!,.(!-'2$!-;0*!

".A;0-,&";.!0*9,0(".9!%*+',4"&)!3ZYEZf7=!D%!"%!&$*!2,%*!:"&$!F*/*0"(9*B%!&$*;0"J".96!

Page 190: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UZY!

!

&$"%!%&'()!2,44%!".&;!L'*%&";.!&$*!1;:*0!;A!,!%".94*6!%1*2",4!;22,%";.!&;!'10;;&!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!

b"&$".!-)!A"*4(!%&'()6!-'4&"14*!2'4&'0,4!A,2&;0%!0*4*9,&*(!L'**0!,.(!

&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!&;!%1*2",4!*/*.&!(,)%!('0".9!:$"2$!&$*)!:*0*!"-14"*(!".!

%;-*!2,%*%6!,.(!-*.&";.*(!("0*2&4)!".!;.*=!T;:*/*06!('*!&;!&$*!4,25!;A!".&*90,&";.!

;A!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!1*;14*!".!*/*0)(,)!4"A*6!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!1*;14*!

:*0*!2;.%&0'2&*(!%;4*4)!,%!%'@M*2&%!;A!@'44)".96!$,0,%%-*.&6!/";4*.2*6!;0!("AA*0*.2*=!

I;0*;/*06!&$*!:,)!%'2$!("AA*0*.2*!"%!-,."A*%&*(!"%!,.!".&*0*%&".9!%"&*!A;0!,.,4)%"%=!

D%!"&!"%!,%%'-*(!&$,&!&$*!(;-".,.&!90;'1!-'%&!'.4*,0.!A*,0!,.(!$,&0*(!;A!&$*!

;&$*0*(!90;'1B%!("AA*0*.2*6!&$*!(;-".,.&!90;'1B%!,%%'-*(!10"/"4*9*!"%!0*".A;02*(=!

#$0;'9$;'&!-)!0*%*,02$6!(;-".,.&!2;.2*1&',4"J,&";.%!;A!.,&'0*6!"..;2*.2*6!,.(!

("AA*0*.2*!:;05*(!&;9*&$*0!&;!.;0-,4"J*!&$*!%&,&'%!L';!,.(!;09,."J*!;&$*0.*%%=!

#$"%!%,"(6!I,09,0*&B%!&,45!;.!G".5!C,)!10;/"(*(!,!1;:*0A'4!*+,-14*!;A!:,)%!%*+"%-!

,.(!$;-;1$;@",!2,.!@*!("0*2&4)!,((0*%%*(!".!,!8".(*09,0&*.!%*&&".9=!T,(!

L'**0.*%%6!9*.(*0E.;.2;.A;0-"&)6!,.(!("/*0%*!*&$."2!@,2590;'.(%!@**.!&;1"2%!;A!

*/*0)(,)!("%2'%%";.!&$0;'9$;'&!&$*!)*,06!&$*.!&$*!10;@4*-,&"2!:,)!:$"2$!2$"4(0*.!

'.(*0%&;;(!&$*!G".5!C,)!4*%%;.!&$,&!2;.A4,&*(!9,)!:"&$!$;-;1$;@"2!@'44)".9!:;'4(!

4"5*4)!$,/*!14,)*(!;'&!("AA*0*.&4)=!

! !

Page 191: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UZf!

!

:CA=EDF$#<[,$4?I$:C<>YFDB$ABY$2DBYDF$:F?JJ<BI$

"BEF?YHZE<?B$

#$*!1,%&!&:;!2$,1&*0%!$,/*!"(*.&"A"*(!&:;!;/*0,02$".9!&$*-*%!&$,&!

2;.&0"@'&*!&;!10;('2".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!#$*!A"0%&!

2;.%&0'2&%!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!,%!0*L'"0".9!-;0*!-,&'0"&)!&;!

'.(*0%&,.(!&$,.!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!0*L'"0*=!#$"%!2;.%&0'2&";.!

"%!*-@*((*(!".!("%2;'0%*%!;A!"..;2*.2*!&$,&!*L',&*!@*".9!,!+")6%!:"&$!@*".9!

'.,:,0*!;A!(*%"0*%!;'&%"(*!@;'.(,0"*%!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!#$*!%*2;.(6!

("%2;'0%*%!;A!("AA*0*.2*6!"%!;A&*.!A0,-*(!".!&$*!0$*&;0"2!;A!*-@0,2".9!("/*0%"&)=!

T;:*/*06!@)!2;.A4,&".9!)%,*$)$),3(3@*".9!L'**0!;0!&0,.%9*.(*07!:"&$!-,09".,4"J*(!

%'@M*2&!1;%"&";.%!3"%%'*%!;A!$;-;1$;@"2!,.(!&0,.%1$;@"2!@'44)".976!("AA*0*.2*!

("%2;'0%*!2,.!:;05!&;!*%&,@4"%$!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!,%!&$",.=!

G0*/";'%!2$,1&*0%!A;2'%*(!;.!$;:!%)%&*-"2!10,2&"2*%!0*".A;02*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-,&"/"&)_A0;-!9*.(*0!("/"(*(!@,&$0;;-%6!4,25!;A!0*%;'02*%!,.(!&0,".".96!&;!

%;2",4!;&$*0".9!;A!%&,AA!:$;!A,"4!&;!4"/*!'1!&;!&$*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!:"&$".!&$*!

%2$;;4=!H'2$!-'4&"E&"*0*(!A,2&;0%!%$,1*!,!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!%2$;;4!24"-,&*6!

*/*.!:"&$".!,!N10;90*%%"/*O!("%&0"2&!,.(!(*-;.%&0,&*!;@%&,24*%!A,2*(!@)!&$;%*!

:;05".9!&;!20*,&*!A,0E0*,2$".9!2$,.9*=!T;:*/*06!-)!A"*4(:;05!,4%;!*+*-14"A"*(!

:,)%!&;!(*1,0&!A0;-!%'2$!10;@4*-,&"2!.;0-%=!!

#$"%!2$,1&*0!"%!(*("2,&*(!&;!(*1"2&".9!%;4'&";.EA;2'%*(!;22'00*.2*%!A0;-!-)!

A"*4(:;05=!b$"4*!-,.)!1;%"&"/*!".&*0,2&";.%!&;;5!14,2*!;/*0!&$*!2;'0%*!;A!-)!

%&'("*%6!&$*!&$0**!.,00,&"/*%!9"/*.!10"-,2)!".!&$"%!2$,1&*0!$,/*!("0*2&!"-14"2,&";.%!

Page 192: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UZ[!

!

A;0!2;'.&*0".9!"%%'*%!,%%;2",&*(!:"&$!("%2;'0%*%!;A!"..;2*.2*!,.(!("AA*0*.2*!,%!

"(*.&"A"*(!".!&$*!10*/";'%!&:;!2$,1&*0%=!>!:"44!A"0%&!2;/*0!I,09,0*&B%!*/*0)(,)!:;05!

&;!20*,&*!,!2$"4(E2*.&*0*(!24,%%0;;-!".!:$"2$!2$"4(0*.!:*0*!*.2;'0,9*(!&;!4"%&*.!&;!

&$*"0!@;("*%!,.(!$,(!,!0;4*!".!2$,.9".9!24,%%0;;-!10,2&"2*%!@,%*(!;.!&$*"0!

,:,0*.*%%!;A!&$*"0!;:.!.**(%=!>!*+14;0*!&$"%!1*(,9;9)!A;0!"&%!1;&*.&",4!&;!,-*4";0,&*!

1;%%"@4*!9*.(*0*(!1"&A,44%!".!1'@4"2!*('2,&";.=!#$"%!:,%!(*-;.%&0,&*(!:"&$!

1,0&"2'4,0!24,0"&)!&$0;'9$!I,09,0*&B%!:;05!:"&$!C'.2,.6!:$;%*!*%2,4,&".9!,2&".9!;'&!

".!24,%%!2;'4(!*,%"4)!@*!'.(*0%&;;(!,%!10;&;&)1"2,4!N@;)O!@*$,/";'0=!T;:*/*06!

C'.2,.B%!A0'%&0,&";.!%&*--*(!A0;-!A**4".96!,%!$*!1'&!"&6!N4"5*!,!9"04!".%"(*6O!,.(!.;&!

*+1*0"*.2".9!&$*!A0**(;-!&;!*+10*%%!&$"%!1,0&!;A!$"-%*4A=!!

b$"4*!I,09,0*&!*+1*0"*.2*(!10*%%'0*!A0;-!2;44*,9'*%!&;!&,5*!'1!,!@".,0)6!

9*.(*0E("AA*0*.2*!,110;,2$!&;!&*,2$".96!$*0!0*%"%&,.2*!&;!&$"%!,110;,2$!*.,@4*(!$*0!

&;!@*!,&&'.*(!&;!&$"%!2$"4(!,%!,.!".("/"(',46!,.(!A,2"4"&,&*!$"%!2;-".9!&;!,!90*,&*0!

'.(*0%&,.(".9!,@;'&!&$*!%;'02*!;A!$"%!("%&0*%%6!:$"2$!:,%!10;-1&".9!$"%!*%2,4,&".9!

A0'%&0,&";.!,.(!,990*%%";.=!T;:*/*06!,4&$;'9$!I,09,0*&B%!1*(,9;9"2,4!,110;,2$!

/,4"(,&*(!&$*!2$"4(!:$;!:,%!L'*%&";.".9!$"%!9*.(*0!,.(!(**-*(!$"-!2;-1*&*.&!&;!

5.;:!:$;!$*!:,%6!&$*!2$"4(B%!"%;4,&";.!A0;-!1**0%!%&"44!".20*,%*(!;/*0!&$*!-;.&$%!;A!

-)!%&'()=!#$"%!4*,(%!;.*!&;!,%5X!$;:!2;'4(!*/*0)(,)!.;0-%!0*9,0(".9!9*.(*0!,.(!

%*+',4"&)!@*!&,5*.!'1!("AA*0*.&4)!&;!0*('2*!&$*!".*/"&,@"4"&)!;A!".&*0.,4!2;.A4"2&!,.(!

"%;4,&";.!;A!&$;%*!:$;!(;!.;&!A".(!&$*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!"(*,4%!2;.90'*.&!:"&$!&$*"0!

%*.%*%!;A!%*4/*%e!!

Page 193: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UZ]!

!

#;!10;/"(*!,.!'.'%',4!-;(*46!&$*!A;44;:".9!%*2&";.!;A!&$"%!2$,1&*0!(0,:%!

10"-,0"4)!A0;-!&$*!%&;0)!;A!,!9"04!:$;!".%"%&*(!&$,&!%$*!:,%6!".!A,2&6!1,0&!(;9=!T*0!

20*,&"/*!,.(!*+'@*0,.&!.,/"9,&";.!@*&:**.!(;9!,.(!$'-,.!:;04(%!10;/"(*%!,.!

,4&*0.,&*!,110;,2$!&;!("%2'%%".9!%*4AE,:,0*.*%%!,.(!("AA*0*.2*!:"&$".!,!

8".(*09,0&*.!2;.&*+&!&$,&6!>!,09'*6!;AA*0%!,!9*.*0,&"/*!2$,44*.9*!&;!$;:!L'**0!,.(!

&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!,0*!9*.*0,44)!,((0*%%*(!3;0!&$*!0,&";.,4"J,&";.!,%!&;!:$)!

&$*)!%$;'4(!.;&!@*!,((0*%%*(7=!!

>!2;.24'(*!&$*!2$,1&*0!@)!(0,:".9!A0;-!,!1;:*0A'4!*+,-14*!;A!&$*!%&'(*.&%!

;09,."J".9!,!2,-1,"9.!&;!%&;1!;&$*0!%&'(*.&%!A0;-!&$0;:".9!:;;(!2$"1%!(;:.!&$*!

(0,".%!".!&$*!14,)90;'.(=!#$;'9$!&$*"0!:;05!:,%!.;&!A;2'%*(!;.!9*.(*06!&$*!

0*%1;.%*%!&;!&$*!%&'(*.&%B!2;.2*0.%!9,/*!,.!*+,-14*!;A!:,)%!:;05!A;0!%;2",4!2$,.9*!

2,.!@*!4*(!@)!%&'(*.&%!,.(!A,2"4"&,&*(!@)!*('2,&;0%!".!,!24,%%0;;-=!#$"%!%&;0)!"%!

".24'(*(!".!&$*!2$,1&*0!;.!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!,%!"&!(*1"2&%!8".(*09,0&*.!%&'(*.&%!,%!,2&"/*!

,9*.&%!".!%$,1".9!&$*"0!%2$;;46!&$*!0*2;9."&";.!;A!:$"2$!"%!0*L'"0*(!:$*.!/,4'".9!

);'.9!1*;14*B%!,@"4"&"*%!&;!0*20*,&*!;0!0*%"%&!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%=!

5?YD><BI$0DJ=DZE$

I,09,0*&!(*("2,&*(!-'2$!&"-*!&;!&$".5".9!,@;'&!:,)%!&;!-,5*!,!1;%"&"/*!

24,%%0;;-!2;--'."&)!".!:$"2$!2$"4(0*.!:;'4(!A**4!N*-1;:*0*(O!&;!%1*,5!&$*"0!

-".(%=!#$"%!A;2'%!0*%'4&*(!".!%;-*!("%0'1&";.!;A!.;0-,&"/*!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*=!R/*0)!

-;0.".9!&$*!24,%%!9,&$*0*(!".!,!2"024*!,.(!1,%%*(!,!N%1*,5".9!%&;.*O!,0;'.(!&$*!

0;;-!,4;.9!:"&$!,!4"&&4*!90,1$!:$*0*!&$*!2$"4(0*.!2;'4(!%*&!,.!,00;:!".!&$*!%1,2*!

&$,&!@*%&!(*%20"@*(!$;:!&$*)!A*4&!&$,&!(,)X!N&;;!A,%&6O!N&;;!%4;:6O!;0!NM'%&!0"9$&=O!#$*!

Page 194: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UZk!

!

%&'(*.&%!,.(!*('2,&;0%!:;'4(!2$*25!".!,%!&;!:$)!&$*)!:*0*!A**4".9!&$*!:,)%!&$*)!

:*0*!&$,&!-;0.".9X!*+2"&*-*.&!;/*0!,!@"0&$(,)!-"9$&!@*!,!0*,%;.!A;0!&$*!N&;;!A,%&O!

%*&&".96!,!A"9$&!:"&$!,!%"@4".9!;0!1,0*.&!:*0*!,-;.9!&$*!0*,%;.%!A;0!A**4".9!&;;!%4;:6!

$,/".9!,!9;;(!%4**1!:,%!,&!&"-*%!-*.&";.*(!,%!:$)!&$*)!:*0*!M'%&!0"9$&6!,-;.9!

;&$*0%=!#$*0*!:,%!,4%;!,!2$*25E".!,&!&$*!*.(!;A!&$*!(,)=!>.!&$*!-;0.".96!,A&*0!0*2*%%6!

,.(!,A&*0!4'.2$6!&$*!%&'(*.&%!:;'4(!(;!,!N-".(E'1O!*+*02"%*!&$,&!"./;4/*(!1,)".9!

,&&*.&";.!&;!:$*0*!&$*"0!@;("*%!:*0*!".!&$,&!-;-*.&!,.(!N-".(A'44)O!.;&"2".9!&$*"0!

@0*,&$=!#$"%!A;2'%!:,%!&;!$*41!&$*!2$"4(0*.!4*,0.!&;!4"%&*.!&;!&$*"0!@;("*%!,.(!

0*9'4,&*!&$*-%*4/*%6!A;0!&$*-%*4/*%6!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!*./"0;.-*.&=!!

#$"%!,110;,2$!:,%!".&*90,&*(!&$0;'9$;'&!I,09,0*&B%!&*,2$".9=!b$*.!

%&'(*.&%!:;'4(!9*&!&;;!0;:()!&;!4"%&*.!&;!*,2$!;&$*0!".!,!90;'1!("%2'%%";.6!0,&$*0!

&$,.!,(-;."%$".9!&$*-!%$*!:;'4(!%'99*%&!&$,&!&$*)!&,5*!,!%*2;.(!&;!2$*25E".!:"&$!

&$*"0!;:.!@;("*%!,.(!&;!%**!:$,&!&$*)!.**(*(!&;!(;!&;!@*!,@4*!&;!4"%&*.!0*%1*2&A'44)!

&;!&$*"0!1**0!:$;!:,%!%1*,5".9=!#$*!2$"4(0*.!9*.*0,44)!0*%1;.(*(!@)!%$"A&".9!".!

&$*"0!%1;&%6!@0*,&$".9!(**14)!,.(!,(M'%&".9!&$*"0!,&&*.&";.!&;!&$*!%1*,5*0=!!

I,09,0*&!(*,4&!:"&$!2$"4(0*.B%!0*%"%&,.2*!&;!2'00"2'4'-!:"&$!%"-"4,04)!

0*%1*2&A'4!2$*25".9!".=!h;0!*+,-14*6!%$*!:;'4(!4*,(!,!%$;0&!%*0"*%!;A!%&0*&2$*%!,A&*0!

-;0.".9!2"024*6!@*A;0*!-;/".9!&;!&$*!.*+&!,2&"/"&)=!C'0".9!&$"%!&"-*6!&$*!24,%%!:;'4(!

0'.!,0;'.(!,.(!*/*.!4*,/*!&$*!0;;-!('0".9!&$*!%&0*&2$*%=!I,09,0*&!0*%1;.(*(!@)!

,%5".9!&$*!%&'(*.&%!&;!2;-*!%"&!(;:.=!>.!,!.*'&0,4!&;.*!%$*!%,"(!&$,&!%$*!.;&"2*(!&$,&!

&$"%!:,%!$,11*.".96!,%5*(!:$)6!,.(!%&,&*(!&$,&!%$*!:,.&*(!&$*"0!".1'&!,@;'&!:$,&!

2;'4(!@*!(;.*!,@;'&!"&!%".2*!"&!:,%.B&!%,A*!&;!0'.!;'&%"(*=!#$*!%&'(*.&%!%,"(!&$,&!&$*)!

Page 195: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UZi!

!

("(.B&!4"5*!&$*!*+*02"%*%!@*2,'%*!&$*)!:*0*!,4:,)%!&$*!%,-*=!#;9*&$*0!&$*)!

@0,".%&;0-*(!;&$*0!:,)%!&;!2;.('2&!&$"%!,2&"/"&)!,.(!"&!:,%!(*2"(*(!&$,&!&$*!

%&'(*.&%!:;'4(!&,5*!&'0.%!4*,(".9!%&0*&2$*%=!I,09,0*&!&$,.5*(!&$*-!A;0!&$*"0!

2;.&0"@'&";.!,.(!,A&*0!&$"%6!&$*!0'..".9!,:,)!%&;11*(!,.(!&$"%!@*2,-*!,!A,/;'0*(!

,2&"/"&)!A;0!,44!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!YV<VY<UY7=!!

b$*.!,!&0*.(!@*9,.!&;!90;:!('0".9!-;0.".9!2"024*!:$*0*@)!%&'(*.&%!:;'4(!

-;/*!A0;-!&$*!A4;;0!&;!&$*"0!(*%5%6!I,09,0*&!%,&!(;:.!&;!&,45!,@;'&!&$"%!,.(!%*/*0,4!

2$"4(0*.!0*%1;.(*(!&$,&!%;-*&"-*%!&$*)!:*0*!.;&!2;-A;0&,@4*!".!&$*!2"024*!,.(!

.**(*(!&$*"0!;:.!%1,2*=!b$*.!I,09,0*&!%'99*%&*(!&$,&!&$*)!&;!&0)!&;!.;&"2*!$;:!

&$*)!:*0*!A**4".96!,.(!%"&!:"&$!"&6!%&,)".9!".!&$*!2"024*!&;!%$;:!0*%1*2&!A;0!&$*"0!1**0%!

:$;!:*0*!%1*,5".96!8,&)!%&,&*(!%&0;.94)!&$,&!&$"%!:,%!%;-*&"-*%!N.;&!2;-A;0&,@4*O!

A;0!$*0!,.(!%$*!.**(*(!&;!9*&!'1!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!Yf<VY<UY7=!8,&)!&$*.!,((*(!&$,&!

%$*!2;'4(!&'0.!$*0%*4A!&;:,0(!&$*!1*0%;.!%1*,5".9!,.(!4"%&*.!0*%1*2&A'44)!A0;-!$*0!

(*%5=!I,09,0*&!,90**(!&$,&!&$"%!:,%!:$,&!8,&)!:,%!(;".9!,.(!%'99*%&*(!&$,&!;&$*0!

%&'(*.&%!(*-;.%&0,&*!&$"%!5".(!;A!0*%1*2&!"A!&$*)!&;;!.**(*(!&;!9*&!'1=!a,&*06!".!&$*!

%&,AA0;;-6!I,09,0*&!*+10*%%*(!$*0!,110*2",&";.!A;0!8,&)B%!%*4AE,:,0*.*%%!,.(!

,@"4"&)!&;!".%"%&!;.!$*0!.**(%!:$"4*!@*".9!0*%1*2&A'4!&;!&$*!90;'1=!!

I,09,0*&!("(!.;&!A0,-*!&$"%!,%1*2&!;A!$*0!:;05!,%!%1*2"A"2,44)!0*4,&*(!&;!

2$,44*.9".9!9*.(*0!.;0-%j!$;:*/*06!A0;-!&$*!*+,-14*%!,@;/*6!8,&)!3,4;.9!:"&$!&$*!

;&$*0!2$"4(0*.7!("(!.;&!,11*,0!&;!@*!4*,0.".9!&;!1,%%"/*4)!*.9,9*!".!;0(*0!&;!14*,%*!

&$*"0!&*,2$*0=!Q,&$*06!&$*!%&'(*.&%!$,(!%'11;0&!".!5.;:".9!,.(!,(/;2,&".9!A;0!&$*"0!

;:.!@;'.(,0"*%=!>.!;'0!".&*0/"*:%6!I,09,0*&!,.(!>!%1;5*!,@;'&!A,2&;0%!&$,&!$,(!

Page 196: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UZZ!

!

".A4'*.2*(!$*0!&*,2$".9=!H$*!(*%20"@*(!10*%%'0*!%$*!$,(!A*4&!A0;-!2;44*,9'*%!&;!

".2;01;0,&*!,!@".,0)6!9*.(*0E("AA*0*.2*!,110;,2$!".&;!$*0!&*,2$".9!,.(!$*0!

$*%"&,&";.!&;!(;!&$"%6!,%!%$*!("(!.;&!:,.&!&;!*.9,9*!".!9*.(*0!%&*0*;&)1".9=!b$"4*!

%$*!%&,&*(!&$,&!%$*!("(!;@%*0/*!%;-*!9*.(*0*(!&0*.(%6!%$*!A*,0*(!&$,&!&*,2$".9!A;0!

@;)%!,.(!A;0!9"04%!:;'4(!4*,/*!;'&!2$"4(0*.!:$;!(*1,0&*(!A0;-!&$*-=!H$*!("%2'%%*(!

&$*!A;44;:".9X!

>B/*!%**.!-;0*!;A!,_,!0,44)".9!A;0!oC;.B&!A;09*&!,@;'&!&$*!@;)%=B!D.(!);'!

5.;:6!&$*_&$*!:;05!;A!I"2$,*4!^'0",.!&$,&!:,%!0*2;--*.(*(!&;!-*6!'-6!,!

A*:!)*,0%!,9;!@)!%;-*;.*=!>!0*,(!1,0&!;A!&$*!@;;56!.;&!,44!;A!"&6!@'&!"&B%!

@,%"2,44)!0*".A;02".9!)*%6!@;)%B!@0,".%!,0*!("AA*0*.&!,.(!&$,&B%!;5,)6!,.(!,44;:!

&$*-!&;!@*!("AA*0*.&=!D.(!@;)%!-"9$&!4"5*!&;6!'-_);'!5.;:6!&$*)!4"5*!&;!

@;.(!/*0)!1$)%"2,44)!:"&$!*,2$!;&$*06!%;!&$,&!&'%%4".9!&$,&!$,11*.%6!&$,&!%;0&!

;A!2;44"(".9!;A!@;("*%!&$,&!$,11*.%!&$,&!:*!;A&*.!%&;1!@*2,'%*!"&B%!&;;!/";4*.&!

;0!.;&!9*.&4*!*.;'9$6!,44;:!&$,&!&;!$,11*.!@*2,'%*6!'-6!&$,&B%!$;:!@;)%!

(*/*4;1!@;.(%!:"&$!*,2$!;&$*06!"%!&$0;'9$!&$,&!1$)%"2,4!".&*0,2&";.=!D.(!9"04%!

4"5*!&;!@*!-;0*!/*0@,46!,.(!5.;:!&$,&B%!;5,)!,.(!&$,&!:$*.!9"04%!A"0%&!2;-*!&;!

%2$;;46!&$*)_&$*!/*0@,4!1,0&!;A!&$*"0!@0,".!"%!-;0*!(*/*4;1*(!&$,.!"&!"%!".!&$*!

@;)%B!1,0&!;A!&$*!@0,".6!%;!&$*)B0*!9;".9!&;!*+2*4!,&!&,%5%!&$,&6!);'!5.;:6!

0*L'"0*!4"%&*.".9!%5"44%!;0!%1*,5".9!%5"44%!;0!:0"&".9!%5"44%!,.(!2;-10*$*.%";.=!

d-6!,.(!&$*!@;)%6!);'!5.;:6!9"/*!&$*-!-;0*!&"-*!&;!14,)!,2&"/*4)!:"&$!%&'AA=!

a*&!&$*-!&,5*!&$".9%!,1,0&6!1'&!&$*-!@,25!&;9*&$*06!A".(!;'&!$;:!&$*)!:;05=!

D.(!&$,&B%_,.(!>!:,%!0*,(".9!&$"%!,.(!>B-!&$".5".96!&$,&B%!.;&!0*%;.,&".9!

Page 197: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UZW!

!

:*44!:"&$!-*!%;-*$;:u!>B/*!%**.!A0;-!&$*!5"(%!&$,&!>!&*,2$!&$,&!&$,&B%!.;&!

,4:,)%!&0'*u!D.(!>B-!&$".5".9!0,&$*0!&$,.!&*,2$".9!A;0!,!9*.(*0!@,%*6!>B-!

&*,2$".9!".("/"(',4!1*;14*=!H;!%;-*&"-*%!A;0!-*6!&$*!9*.(*0!,09'-*.&!M'%&!

9*&%!,!4"&&4*!&"0*%;-*!*%1*2",44)!:$*.!"&B%6!);'!5.;:6!1'01;0&".9!&$*!

("AA*0*.2*%!;A!;.*!;/*0!&$*!;&$*0u!>B-!9;".9!&;!M'%&!&*,2$!&;!&$"%!2$"4(6!0,&$*0!

&$,.!&$*!A,2&!&$,&!$*B%!,!@;)!;0!%$*B%!9"04=!!oS,'%*!A;0!-*6!"&!%**-%!&$,&B%!-;0*!

;A!,.!"%%'*!0,&$*0!&$,.!,!9*.(*0!"%%'*6!&$,&!&$*0*!,0*!%;-*!2$"4(0*.!&$,&!,0*!

/*0)!1$)%"2,44)!,%%*0&"/*6!,.(!&$*)!4;/*!&$,&!1$)%"2,4!2;.&,2&!:"&$!*,2$!;&$*06!

,.(!)*,$6!&$*)!:,.&!&;!&'-@4*!,0;'.(!,.(!:0*%&4*!,.(!"&B%!.;&!,4:,)%!&$*!

@;)%=!h0;-!:$,&!>B/*!%**.6!-;0*!;A&*.!"&!"%6!@'&!*/*0)!.;:!,.(!&$*.!);'!9*&!,!

9"04!:$;!2;-*%!".!,.(!M'%&6!);'!5.;:6!4"5*6!:,.&%!&;!M'%&_>!(;.B&!5.;:6!

14;'9$!".&;!%;-*@;()!,.(!:0*%&4*!&$*-!&;!&$*!90;'.(!,.(_%;!>!,4:,)%!%,)6!

;5,)6!&$,&B%!.;&!;5,)!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-6!M'%&!0*9,0(4*%%!;A!:$;!);'!,0*6!4"5*6!

.;X!N&$,&B%!&;;!0;'9$!A;0u=!9*.&4*!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-cO!3Q;/*44,!U]<V]<UY7=!

#$0;'9$!I,09,0*&B%!&$;'9$&A'4!90,114".9!,%!&;!$;:!&;!-,5*!0;;-!A;0!("AA*0*.&!

4*,0.".9!%&)4*%!,.(!1*0%;.,4"&"*%!:"&$".!$*0!24,%%*%6!%$*!2$,44*.9*(!&$*!.;&";.!&$,&!

;.*!-'%&!,%20"@*!(*A"."&"/*6!*%%*.&",4"%&!-*,.".9%!&;!9*.(*0*(!&0*.(%!".!;0(*0!&;!

A,2"4"&,&*!24,%%0;;-%!&$,&!2,&*0!&;!,!/,0"*&)!;A!4*,0.*0%=!!

S$"4(0*.B%!%*4AE,(/;2,2)!:,%!&,5*.!,%!,110;10",&*!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!,.(!,%!

&$*!&*,2$*0!%$*6!".!&'0.6!:;'4(!2$,.9*!&$*!24,%%0;;-!*./"0;.-*.&!@,%*(!;.!%&'(*.&!

2;.2*0.%=!I,09,0*&B%!A;2'%!;.!0*%1*2&!A;0!*,2$!2$"4(B%!.**(%!,.(!&$*"0!%*.%*!;A!%*4A!

A,2"4"&,&*(!2$"4(0*.!$,/".9!&;;4%!&;!0*%"%&!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!;.!-;0*!&$,.!

Page 198: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UWV!

!

;.*!%"9."A"2,.&!;22,%";.=!#$*!"-14"2,&";.!&$,&!-,.)!9*.(*0%!-,)!@*!N%$'&!(;:.O!

&$0;'9$!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!"%!,.!".&*0*%&".9!1;".&!A;0!,.,4)%"%_&$*!"-14"2,&";.%!

;A!:$"2$!,0*!:*44!"44'%&0,&*(!&$0;'9$!&$*!2$"4(!:$;!A*4&!N4"5*!,!9"04!".%"(*=O!

;DD><BI$&<TD$A$2<F>$"BJ<YD$

I,09,0*&B%!0*A'%,4!&;!("/"(*!4*,0.".9!%&)4*%!,.(!@*$,/";'0%!,4;.9!@;)<9"04!

4".*%!%*0/*(!&$*!%&'(*.&%!:*44!('0".9!&$*!2;'0%*!;A!-)!%&'()=!K.*!%&'(*.&!".!

1,0&"2'4,06!C'.2,.6!(*-;.%&0,&*(!L'".&*%%*.&",4!@*$,/";'0!,.(!,&&"&'(*%!(*%20"@*(!

@)!&$;%*!2;.2*0.*(!:"&$!$;:!%2$;;4%!-,)!@*!A,"4".9!@;)%X!$*!:,%!4;'(6!1$)%"2,44)!

,990*%%"/*6!("(.B&!N&,5*!10"(*O!".!$"%!:;056!,.(!:,%!;A&*.!("%0'1&"/*!".!24,%%=!!

C'0".9!&$*!A"0%&!:**5!;A!-)!%&'()!C'.2,.!:,%!,:,)=!#$*!H&'(*.&!H'11;0&!

b;05*06!`,-*%!T'9$*%6!".A;0-*(!-*!&$,&!&$*!24,%%0;;-!().,-"2!:;'4(!2$,.9*!

(0,%&"2,44)!:$*.!C'.2,.!9;&!@,25!@*2,'%*!$*6!-;0*!&$,.!,.)!;&$*0!%&'(*.&6!:,%!

/*0)!2;.2*0.*(!:"&$!9*.(*0!.;0-%=!`,-*%!&;4(!-*!&$,&!C'.2,.!:,%!&$*!A"0%&!&;!&*44!

%;-*;.*!&$,&!&$*!1"2&'0*!&$*)!:*0*!(0,:".9!2;'4(.B&!@*!,!@;)!"A!&$*)!:;0*!1".56!;0!

*,00".9%6!;0!$,(!;&$*0!L',4"&"*%!&$,&!("(.B&!NA"&=O!`,-*%!.;&*(!&$,&!;'&!;A!,44!&$*!@;)%!

".!&$*!24,%%6!C'.2,.!:,%!2;-A;0&,@4*!-;/".9!@*&:**.!,.)!%;2",4!90;'1=!`,-*%!

%'--,0"J*(6!Nb*446!$*B%!5".(!;A!,.!,41$,O!3T'9$*%!YY<VY<UY7=[]!

K.!C'.2,.B%!A"0%&!(,)!@,256!>!2$,&&*(!:"&$!$"%!A,&$*0!:$;!,%5*(!,!@"&!,@;'&!

-)!0*%*,02$=!T*!&;4(!-*!&$,&!C'.2,.!:,%!,!0*,4!N9')B%!9')6O!*/*.!-;0*!&$,.!$*!:,%!

$"-%*4A=!!T*!("%2'%%*(!&$"%!".!&$*!2;.&*+&!;A!10;/".9!&$*!N.,&'0,4.*%%O!;A!,!9*.(*0!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[]!`,-*%!T'9$*%!("(!.;&!10;/"(*!;.*!&;!;.*!%'11;0&!A;0!C'.2,.6!@'&!:,%!1,0&!;A!&$*!

24,%%!('*!&;!$"%!:;05!:"&$!,.;&$*0!%&'(*.&=!!

Page 199: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UWU!

!

@".,0)!".!:$"2$!@;)%!0*,44)!,0*!("AA*0*.&!A0;-!9"04%=!T*!&,45*(!,@;'&!$;:!$"%!&:;!

(,'9$&*0%!:*0*!N0*,4!9"04)E9"04%O!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!U[<VY<UY76!@'&!.;&!$"%!%;.=!T*B(!

%$,5*.!$"%!$*,(6!%&,&".9!&$,&!$*!("(.B&!*/*.!5.;:!A0;-!:$*0*!C'.2,.!9;&!$"%!4*/*4!

;A!-,%2'4"."&)!3)/)%7=!C'.2,.!4"/*(!'1!&;!$"%!0*1'&,&";.=!!G$)%"2,44)!4,09*0!&$,.!$"%!

1**0%6!$*!:,%!/*0)!2;-A;0&,@4*!'%".9!$"%!%"J*!&;!,%%*0&!(;-".,.2*=!!T"%!$"9$4)!

9*.(*0*(!14,)!:;'4(!-;25!:$,&!$*!(**-*(!A*-".".*!3N;;;6!(;44%cO7!,.(!94;0"A)!

:$,&!:,%!&$;'9$&!&;!@*!-,%2'4".*!30,44)".9!&$*!@;)%!&;!-,5*!1,1*0!N-,,,,.!

-;'%&,2$*%cO7!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!YU<VY<UY7=!!

D%!-)!9;,4!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!:,%!&;!@*!,.!,AA"0-,&"/*!10*%*.2*6!>!:;'4(!

9*.*0,44)!%-"4*!,.(!0*A4*2&!:$,&!&$*!2$"4(0*.!:*0*!&*44".9!-*!".!,!:,)!&$,&!:;'4(!

(0,:!-*!".&;!&$*"0!%;2",4!:;04(%=!H'2$!14,)!;A&*.!"./;4/*(!%2*.,0";%!".!:$"2$!

2$"4(0*.!:;'4(!%$;:!,.(!&*44!-*!%;-*&$".9!,@;'&!&$*"0!"-,9".,&";.!9,-*%=!b$*.!

&:;!2$"4(0*.!:;'4(!&*44!-*!&$*)!:*0*!-,5".9!"-,9".,0)!1;12;0.!3&$"%!:,%!,!

A,/;'0"&*!9,-*!;A!&:;!2$"4(0*.!A;0!;/*0!,!-;.&$76!>!:;'4(!&$,.5!A;0!&$*-!A;0!&*44".9!

-*!,@;'&!"&=!S$"4(0*.!:;'4(!0'.!'1!&;!-*!:"&$!,!%&'AA*(!,."-,4!,.(!&*44!-*!,@;'&!&$*!

:;04(!"&!:,%!1,0&!;A6!&;!:$"2$!>!:;'4(!%-"4*!,.(!0*1*,&!:$,&!:,%!%,"(!3*=9=!N;$6!"&!$,%!

&;!*%2,1*!A0;-!&$*!(0,9;.%cO7=!D&!&"-*%!>!%&0'994*(!&;!0*%"%&!".&*0A*0".9!:"&$!&$*"0!

14,)6!1,0&"2'4,04)!:$*.!C'.2,.!:;'4(!-;25!&$*!&;)%!&$*!9"04%!:*0*!14,)".9!:"&$!;0!

-;25!&$*!9"04%!&$*-%*4/*%=!!

K.!&$*!;22,%";.!:$*.!C'.2,.!0,44"*(!&$*!@;)%!".&;!-,5".9!N-,.!

-;'%&,2$*%O!;'&!;A!%&0*,-*0%6!%;-*!;A!&$*!9"04%!M;".*(6!-,5".9!*4,@;0,&*!&,"4%6!

*)*@0;:%6!,.(!-;'%&,2$*%!;'&!;A!%&0*,-*0%=!#$*!2$"4(0*.!@*2,-*!,."-,4%6!1"0,&*%6!

Page 200: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UWY!

!

,.(!N@,(!9')%=O!C'0".9!&$"%!&"-*6!C'.2,.!0*1*,&*(4)!$*4(!'1!&$*!%&0*,-*0%!&;!@*!,!

-;25!@0,!,.(!("(!,!1,0,(*!;A!*+,99*0,&*(!NA*-"."."&)6O!&;!&$*!*+2"&*(6!&,@;;!

4,'9$&*0!;A!&$*!@;)%=!D&!&$*%*!&"-*%6!C'.2,.!&'0.*(!&;!-*6!,%%*%%".9!-)!0*%1;.%*=!>!

A;'.(!%'2$!%2*.,0";%!("AA"2'4&=!>!:,%!,A0,"(!&$,&!-)!4,25!;A!("%0'1&";.!:;'4(!"-14)!

&,2"&!,110;/,46!;0!.;0-,4"J*!&$*!-;25".9!;A!1,0&"2'4,0!@;("*%=!C*%1"&*!-)!

("%2;-A;0&6!>!("(!.;&!:,.&!&;!*%&,@4"%$!-)%*4A!,%!,!M'(9-*.&,4!10*%*.2*!".!&$*"0!14,)!

,.(!:;05*(!&;!0*-,".!,&!4*,%&!'.0*%1;.%"/*!".!&$*%*!-;-*.&%=!!!

#$*!@;)%!0*9,0(*(!NA*-".".*O!14,)!("AA*0*.&4)!&$,.!&$*!9"04%!0*9,0(*(!

N-,%2'4".*O!14,)=!#$"%!"%!.;&!&;!%,)!&$,&!&$*0*!:*0*!.;!&,@;;%!,0;'.(!9*.(*0!

20;%%".9!A;0!&$*!9"04%6!@'&!0,&$*06!-,%2'4"."&)!:,%!("AA*0*.&4)!1;4"2*(=!`'("&$!

T,4@*0%&,-!$,%!("%2'%%*(!("AA*0*.&",4!9*.(*0!1;4"2".9!".!2$"4(0*.!:$*0*".!9"04%!-,)!

*+10*%%!10"(*!".!9*.(*0!20;%%".96!;0!&;-@;)6!@*$,/";'0%!3YVV[6!UWi7!@'&!9*.(*0!

20;%%".9!"%!("AA*0*.&4)!%$,-*(!".!@;)%=!D44!9*.(*0!1;4"2".9!&,5*%!14,2*!".!,!4,09*0!

2'4&'0,4!2;.&*+&!;A!-,4*!1;:*0!,.(!10"/"4*9*=!T,4@*0%&,-!:0"&*%X!

F*2,'%*!-,%2'4"."&)!"%!,!%"9.!;A!10"/"4*9*!".!;'0!%;2"*&)6!"&!"%!-'2$!-;0*!

$*,/"4)!9',0(*(!&$,.!A*-"."."&)=!!g;'.9!@;)%!:$;!*+$"@"&!A*-".".*!@*$,/";0!

,0*!1'."%$*(6!.;&!&;!10;&*2&!A*-"."."&)!A0;-!-,4*!".2'0%";.%!@'&!&;!

*.2;'0,9*!-,%2'4"."&)!".!-,4*!@;("*%j!);'.9!9"04%!:$;!*+$"@"&!-,%2'4".*!

@*$,/";06!;.!&$*!;&$*0!$,.(6!,0*!1'."%$*(!.;&!;.4)!@*2,'%*!&$*"0!A*-"."."&)!

"%!".!M*;1,0()!@'&!,4%;!@*2,'%*!-,%2'4"."&)!$,%!@**.!0*%*0/*(!*+24'%"/*4)!A;0!

-,4*!@;("*%=!3YVV[6!YVU7!

Page 201: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UWf!

!

H"-"4,0!%*.&"-*.&%!,0*!*+10*%%*(!".!Q;+,..*!T*.5".B%!4"&O3(?*W)$,%($&(I"#.,Y(83)*9(

D)$,.#+=($&(0,#+"(-&.(Rc7)$=(#*%(I&+)#6(:73$)+,'!H$*!("%2'%%*%!14,)90;'.(!().,-"2%!".!

:$"2$!N&$*!:;0%&!&$".9!);'!2,.!2,44!,!@;)!"%!,!9"04=O!b$"4*!%"&',&".9!&$"%!,%!

.;0-,4"J".9!(;-".,.&!2'4&'0,4!%*+"%-6!%$*!'09*%!*('2,&;0%!&;!NR+,-".*!:$)!&$*!

:;0%&!&$".9!);'!2,.!2,44!,!@;)!"%!,!9"04=!b$,&!(;*%!&$"%!(;!&;!,!9"04B%!%*4AE*%&**-e!

b$,&!(;*%!"&!(;!&;!@;)%!:$;!4"5*!9"04%eO!3[f7=!>!,((6!!"#$(%&,3($")3(%&($&(2#6,(

#33)9*,%(+")6%.,*(!"&()%,*$)-=(!)$"(&.(#3(9).63e!!

b"&$".!-)!0*%*,02$6!&$*!2'4&'0,4!("%1,0,9*-*.&!;A!A*-"."."&)!("(!.;&!;.4)!

,AA*2&!&$*!9"04%!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!b$"4*!C'.2,.!".%&"9,&*(!-'2$!;A!&$*!

("%1,0,9*-*.&!;A!A*-"."."&)6!$*!:,%!90*,&4)!,AA*2&*(!@;&$!@)!9*.(*0!@".,0"*%!,.(!

&$*"0!$"*0,02$"*%=!D%!&$*!-;.&$%!10;90*%%*(6!C'.2,.B%!,990*%%"/*!@*$,/";'0!@*2,-*!

,.!".20*,%".9!10;@4*-=!T*!@*9,.!&;!$,/*!0*9'4,0!N-*4&(;:.%6O!4,%$".9!;'&6!&$0;:".9!

;@M*2&%!,&!%&'(*.&%6!)*44".96!,.(!0'..".9!,:,)=!!

I,09,0*&!0*%1*2&A'44)!A,2"4"&,&*(!&"-*!,.(!%1,2*!A;0!C'.2,.!&;!9,".!%5"44%!".!

*+10*%%".9!N%&0;.9!A**4".9%O!,.(!-,.,9".9!$"%!*-;&";.%!".!%,A*!:,)%!A;0!$"-%*4A!,.(!

&$;%*!,0;'.(!$"-=!H$*!@*9,.!&,5".9!&"-*!&;!%"&!(;:.!:"&$!$"-!;.*!&;!;.*=!D&!&$*!

@*9"..".9!;A!&$*"0!&"-*!&;9*&$*06!$*!2;'4(!(0,:!,.)&$".9!$*!:,.&*(!,.(!%$*!:;'4(!

&,45!:"&$!$"-!,@;'&!&$*!1"2&'0*!A;0!,%!4;.9!,%!$*!:"%$*(!&;=!b$*.!&$*!A"0%&!1"2&'0*!

:,%!A"."%$*(!%$*!:;'4(!,%5!$"-!&;!(0,:!,!1"2&'0*!;A!$"-%*4A!:$*.!$*!:,%!$,/".9!

%&0;.9!A**4".9%!,.(!&$*)!:;'4(!&$*.!&,45!,@;'&!&$,&!1"2&'0*!@*A;0*!-;/".9!".&;!,!

("%2'%%";.!%&0,&*9"J".9!$;:!$*!:;'4(!4"5*!&;!$,.(4*!&$*%*!A**4".9%!:$*.!$*!:,%!".!

&$*!24,%%0;;-!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!VY<V]<UY7=!#$*"0!%;4'&";.%!/,0"*(!A0;-!%*%%";.!&;!

Page 202: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UW[!

!

%*%%";.=!C'0".9!&$*!A"0%&!%*%%";.!&$*)!$,(!&;9*&$*06!C'.2,.!,.(!I,09,0*&!(*/*4;1*(!

,!%,A*&)!14,.!".!:$"2$!$*!:;'4(!,@4*!&;!9;!$"(*!".!&$*!2'@@"*%=!#$*)!2,-*!'1!:"&$!,!

2;(*!:$*0*!,.!,('4&!:;'4(!%,)6!NC'.2,.6!:$,&!(;!);'!.**(eO!,.(!$*!:;'4(!0*14)!

*"&$*06!N.;&$".9O!;0!N>!.**(!%1,2*=O!#$*!,('4&!:;'4(!&$*.!&*44!$"-!&$,&!$*!2;'4(!2;-*!

,.(!&,45!"A!$*!.**(*(!&;!,A&*0!$*B(!$,(!%1,2*=!C'.2,.!$,(!,%5*(!I,09,0*&!&;!&*44!-*!

,.(!&$*!;&$*0!*('2,&;0%!,@;'&!&$"%!N%,A*&)!14,.6O!:$"2$!%$*!10;2**(*(!&;!(;!

3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!YU<V[<UY7=!#$*!1;0&0,"&%!:"&$!&$*"0!&0,.%20"@*(!%,A*&)!14,.%!:*0*!

1;%&*(!;.!,!@'44*&".!@;,0(!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-6!:$"2$!$*!:;'4(!9;!,.(!4;;5!,&!

0*9'4,04)6!90"..".9!10;'(4)=!!

G*0$,1%!,!0*%'4&!;A!I,09,0*&B%!%5"44!,%!,!&*,2$*0!,.(!$*0!;1*..*%%!&;!,%%"%&!

2$"4(0*.!".!@*".9!,@4*!&;!4"%&*.!&;!,.(!%1*,5!A;0!&$*-%*4/*%6!&$*%*!%*%%";.%!-,(*!

0;;-!A;0!C'.2,.!&;!%$,0*!-;0*!;A!:$,&!$,(!@**.!$,11*.".9!A;0!$"-!&$,&!".%&"9,&*(!

%;-*!;A!$"%!".&*.%"&)=!!D&!4'.2$!;.!D10"4!Yk&$6!I,09,0*&!&;4(!-*!&$,&!C'.2,.!$,(!

@*9'.!&;!&,45!,@;'&!A**4".9!N4"5*!,!9"04!".%"(*=O!D&!&$,&!(,&*6!$*!$,(!-*.&";.*(!&$"%!&;!

$*0!*/*0)(,)!A;0!&$*!1,%&!A"/*!(,)%!,.(!,&&0"@'&*(!&$*!A0'%&0,&";.!$*!$,(!;/*0!

.**(".9!&;!N%L'"%$!(;:.O!&$*!9"04!1,0&!;A!$"-%*4A!&;!:$)!$*!:,%!$,/".9!&0;'@4*!:"&$!

$"%!A**4".9%!,.(!%'@%*L'*.&4)!,2&".9!;'&!".!24,%%=!T*!$,(!0*1;0&*(!:,.&".9!&;!$,/*!

4;.9!$,"0!,.(!(0*%%*%6!,.(!$,(!@*9'.!&;!(0,:!$"-%*4A!,%!,!9"04!".!$"%!1;0&0,"&!

(0,:".9!%*%%";.%=!T*!&;4(!I,09,0*&!&$,&!$*!:,.&*(!&;!@*!Q,1'.J*4=!K.*!;A!&$*!

1"2&'0*%!;.!&$*!24,%%0;;-!2;05@;,0(!@;,%&*(!,!%-"4".9!2$,0,2&*0!".!,!(0*%%!:"&$!

$,"0!&$,&!A4*:!,0;'.(!&$*!*.&"0*!1,9*=!!

Page 203: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UW]!

!

F,25!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-6!>!:,&2$*(!C'.2,.!0'.!,0;'.(!".!$"%!90**.!14,"(!1,.&%6!

,!@4'*!%$"0&!:"&$!2,0&;;.!*+14;%";.%6!,.(!0*(!,.(!@4,25!0'..".9!%$;*%=!K.!&$*!:,)!&;!

&$*!4"@0,0)6!&$*!@;)!".!A0;.&!;A!C'.2,.!5"25*(!$"-!,.(!C'.2,.!$"&!$"-!@,25=!D&!&$*!

&;1!;A!&$*!%&,"0%6!$*!*+2$,.9*(!N$"9$EA"/*%O!:"&$!,.!;4(*0!@;)!,.(!2;.&".'*(!&;!

*+10*%%!$"-%*4A!".!,!:,)!&$,&!-,.)!;'&%"(*!;@%*0/*0%!-,)!$,/*!4,@*4*(!&)1"2,4!

N@;)O!@*$,/";'0=!>!1;'0*(!;/*0!&$*!9*.(*0*(!24,%%0;;-!%2*.,0";%!".!:$"2$!$*B(!

@**.!,!1,0&6!%&0'25!@)!&$*!"-14"2,&";.%!$"%!1;&*.&",4!".&*0.,4!10;2*%%!$,(!A;0!&$*!

:,)%!".!:$"2$!>!2;'4(!30*7".&*010*&!%'2$!".&*0,2&";.%=!b$,&!"A!1,0&!;A!$"%!-;25".9!

A*-"."."&)!:,%!9,'9".9!-)!0*%1;.%*!&;!,.!,%1*2&!;A!$"-%*4A!$*!:,.&*(!&;!@*!,@4*!&;!

*+10*%%e!T,(!>!*+10*%%*(!-)!("%,110;/,46!$*!2;'4(!$,/*!'.(*0%&;;(!"&!,%!A0;:.".9!

;.!$"%!*+14;0,&";.6!0,&$*0!&$,.!,%!("%2;'0,9".9!&$*!-;25".9!1*0A;0-,.2*!;A!

A*-".".*!2,0"2,&'0*=!

D%!C'.2,.!:,%!;.*!;A!&$*!&:;!2$"4(0*.!A0;-!I,09,0*&B%!24,%%!:$;!

;22,%";.,44)!%,:!&$*!D@;0"9".,4!R.$,.2*-*.&!b;05*06!I,09,0*&!%1;5*!&;!I"2$*44*!

R/*0*&&!,@;'&!C'.2,.!".!$;1*%!;A!A".(".9!@;&$!2'4&'0,44)!0*4*/,.&!%'11;0&!,.(!&;!

,%%*%%!:$,&!C'.2,.B%!A,-"4)!%"&',&";.!:,%!4"5*!@*A;0*!(*2"(".9!:$*&$*0!;0!.;&!&;!

%$,0*!C'.2,.B%!("%24;%'0*!:"&$!&$*-=!D%!I"2$*44*!5.*:!C'.2,.B%!A,-"4)6!%$*!A*4&!

2;-A;0&,@4*!("%2'%%".9!$"%!9*.(*0!:"&$!&$*-!,.(!&$;'9$&!A,-"4",4!,:,0*.*%%!;A!&$"%!

:;'4(!4"5*4)!@*.*A"&!$"-=!H$*!0*2;'.&*(!&;!-*X!

v>w.!D@;0"9".,4!2'4&'0*6!'-6!&$*!:$;4*!0*,4-!;A!&:;E%1"0"&*(.*%%!,.(!

2;..*2&*(.*%%!:"&$!&$*!&:;E%1"0"&%!,.(!&:;E%1"0"&*(!1*;14*6!$,%!%&,0&*(!&;!

@*2;-*!,22*1&*(!,9,".!B2,'%*!&$"%!"%!,!/*0)!,.2"*.&!2;.2*1&=!H;!>B/*!&;4(6!);'!

Page 204: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UWk!

!

5.;:6!$"%!-'-!,.(!&$*!&*,2$*0!&$,&6!&$"%!"%!:$*0*!>B-!2;-".9!A0;-!:"&$!"&6!%;!

"A!"&!*.(%!'1!@*".9!%;-*&$".9!&;!(;!:"&$!9*.(*06!>B-!;1*.!,.(!>B-!;5,)!,.(!"A!

$*!:,.&%!&;!&,45!&;!-*!;0!"A!>!2,.!4*.(!,.)!%'11;0&!&$,&!:,)u!>B-!-;0*!&$,.!

$,11)!&;=!3R/*0*&&!Uk<V]<YVUY7!

I,09,0*&!9;&!".A;0-,&";.!A0;-!I"2$*44*!,@;'&!&:;E%1"0"&*(.*%%=!D&!&$*!*.(!;A!

-)!A"*4(:;056!%$*!:,%!%&"44!&0)".9!&;!-,5*!&"-*!A;0!I"2$*44*!&;!%1*,5!:"&$!&$*!24,%%!

,@;'&!D@;0"9".,4!2'4&'0*6!@'&!('*!&;!&"-*!2;.%&0,".&%!A0;-!4,25!;A!A'.(".9!A;0!

,(*L',&*!DRb!%'11;0&6!%$*!$,(!.;&!@**.!,@4*!&;=!T;:*/*06!C'.2,.B%!A**4".9%!,@;'&!

9*.(*0!:*0*!("%2'%%*(!@)!,!10;A*%%";.,4!:$;!,40*,()!$,(!2'4&'0,4!0,11;0&!:"&$!$"%!

A,-"4)6!:$"2$!-,)!$,/*!,"(*(!".!&$*!;1*..*%%!&$,&!I"2$*44*!,&&*%&*(!&;!$,/".9!

0*2*"/*(!A0;-!&$*-!:$*.!%$*!@0;,2$*(!&$*!%'@M*2&!;A!9*.(*0=!!

DA&*0!,!A*:!:**5%!;A!&,45".9!:"&$!I,09,0*&!,.(!0*2*"/".9!%'11;0&!A0;-!

I"2$*44*6!C'.2,.B%!9*.(*0*(!@*$,/";'0!@*9,.!&;!4;%*!%;-*!;A!"&%!M**0".9!*(9*=!h;0!

*+,-14*6!;.!D10"4!fV6!$*!1'&!;.!,!A,.2)!&,AA*&,!20;:.6!:,45*(!'1!&;!-*!,.(!

,..;'.2*(6!N>B-!&$*!L'**.!;A!&$*!%$"1O!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!fV<V[<UY7=!b"&$;'&!

-;25".9!2,0"2,&'0*6!$*!:,45*(!,0;'.(!A;0!,:$"4*!,.(!&$*.!".24'(*(!-*!".!&$*!%$"1!

-,5*E@*4"*/*=!D%!&$*!L'**.6!$*!,%5*(!-*!:$,&!>B(!,22;-14"%$*(!;.!&$*!%$"1=!

T;:*/*06!('0".9!&$"%!&"-*6!$"%!"%;4,&";.!A0;-!$"%!1**0%!90*:=!T*!@*9,.!4,99".9!

@*$".(!,&!0*2*%%!,.(!4'.2$6!(*-;.%&0,&".9!,!0*4'2&,.2*!&;!4*,/*!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!T*!

%1*.&!-'2$!&"-*!,&!$"%!(*%5!:$*.!&$*!;&$*0%!%,&!;.!&$*!A4;;0=!I,09,0*&!0*%1*2&*(!$"%!

.**(!A;0!%1,2*!,.(!%;-*!;A!$"%!,990*%%"/*!,.(!A0'%&0,&*(!@*$,/";'0%!(*20*,%*(=!!

Page 205: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UWi!

!

#$*!&"-".9!;A!C'.2,.B%!9*.(*0*(!%&,&*-*.&%!,.(!$"%!:"&$(0,:,4!:,%!

.;&*:;0&$)=!>!:,%!0*-".(*(!;A!-)!:;05!,%!,!H&'(*.&!H'11;0&!b;05*0!&$,&!>!

(*%20"@*(!".!&$*!>.&0;('2&";.!&;!-)!0*%*,02$=!#$;'9$!&$*!2$"4(!>!$,(!:;05*(!:"&$!

("(!.;&!0*,(!,%!9*.(*0E.;.2;.A;0-".9!&;!&$*"0!1**0%!,.(!*('2,&;0%6!&$*)!&;;!

*+1*0"*.2*(!"%;4,&";.!:$*.!&$*)!A;'.(!&$*-%*4/*%!2$,A".9!,9,".%&!&$*!9*.(*0!

.;0-%!".!&$*"0!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*=!>&!"%!%&0"5".9!$;:!&$;0;'9$4)!'.(*&*2&,@4*!&$"%!2$,A".9!

2,.!@*=!b"&$!@;&$!2$"4(0*.6!&$*"0!20;%%".9%!@;'.(,0"*%!@*&:**.!@;)!,.(!9"04!:*0*!

%;'02*%!;A!%;2",4!"%;4,&";.!,.(!("%&0*%%6!0*9,0(4*%%!;A!&$*!1;&*.&",4!A;0!20*,&"/*!%*4AE

(*&*0-".,&";.!@;&$!*+10*%%*(6!%'2$!,%!N#$*!H*20*&!F;)!P,-*!C,.2*O!,.(!@*2;-".9!

&$*!\'**.!;A!&$*!H$"1=!>!2;.&0,%&!&$"%!:"&$!&$*!%*.%*!;A!M;)!,.(!%;2",4!2;..*2&";.!;.*!

2$"4(!".!-)!A"*4(:;05!(*-;.%&0,&*(!:$*.!*+1*0"*.2".9!$*0%*4A!,%!20;%%".9!&$*!

@;'.(,0)!@*&:**.!,."-,4!,.(!$'-,.=!#$*!A;44;:".9!%*2&";.!;A!&$"%!2$,1&*0!

*+14;0*%!&$"%!("%20*1,.2)!,%!:*44!,%!1;%"&".9!,4&*0.,&*!:,)%!;A!2;.2*1&',4"J".9!

(*1,0&'0*%!A0;-!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!#$"%!1;%%"@"4"&)!(*1,0&%!A0;-!

("%2;'0%*%!&$,&!.;0-,4"J*!4*,/".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!,%!0*L'"0".9!,!1,".A'4!

1*0%;.,4!10;2*%%!;A!@*2;-".9!&$",.=!

!%C?JD$fC?$;DD>$%CD9$'FD$4?IJ-$

D@"9,"46!8,&)6!a"4)6!8)'.96!,.(!>!%,&!,&!;.*!;A!&$*!&$0**!4'.2$!&,@4*%!:"&$!

,&&,2$*(!@*.2$*%!".!&$*!;1*.!4'.2$!,0*,!.*,0*%&!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!#$*!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!

A;2'%!90;'1!-*,.(*0*(!".&;!&,45!,@;'&!%"@4".9%j!D@"9,"4!:,.&*(!&;!-,5*!;.*!&$".9!

24*,0_$*0!(;9!0*,44)!:,%!$*0!%"%&*0!@*2,'%*!D@"9,"4!"%!,2&',44)!,!(;9=!>!:;'4(!%,)!

&$,&!$*0!1**0%!@*4"*/*(!$*06!@'&!&$,&!:;'4(!"-14)!&$,&!&$*)!A;'.(!&$*0*!&;!@*!

Page 206: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UWZ!

!

%;-*&$".9!&;!@*4"*/*!;0!("%@*4"*/*=!Q,&$*06!&$*)!*+2"&*(4)!*4,@;0,&*(!;.!$*0!(,"4)!

.,/"9,&";.!@*&:**.!@*".9!,!(;9!,.(!,!$'-,.=!K.*!%'2$!".&*0,2&";.!14,)*(!;'&!,%!

A;44;:%X!

D@"9,"4X!>!$,/*!,!%"%&*0!(;9!o2,'%*!>!,2&',44)!,-!,!0*,4!(;9=!

DX!g;'!$,/*!,!%"%&*0!(;9e!

D@"9,"4X!g*,$6!,.(!>!,-!,!0*,4!(;9=!R+2*1&c!>!2,.!&'0.!@,25!".&;!,!$'-,.=!!

8,&)X!D@"9,"4c!D@"9,"4c!!>!%**!:$*0*!);'u!

D@"9,"4X!vuw!#$*.!$'-,.6!&$*.!(;96!&$*.!$'-,.6!&$*.!(;9u!

8,&)X!D@"9,"46!>!%**!&$,&!);'!$,/*!,!@"&!;A!$,"0!*/*0):$*0*6!2,'%*!);'B0*!,!(;9=!

D.(!>!%**!&$,&!);'!$,/*!4"&&4*!*,0%=!

D@"9,"4X!R+2*1&!&$,&!>B-!$,4A!1*0%;.!%;!>B/*!M'%&!9;&!4"&&4*!&**.)E:**.)E:**.)E

:**.)!*,0%!0"9$&!.;:u!

8,&)X!D.(!$,"0!&$,&!.;!;.*!2,.!%**=!

D@"9,"4X!g*,$c!R,0%!'.(*0!-)!$,"0c!>B-!M'%&!,!:$;4*!1;;(4*!o2,'%*!>!,2&',44)!

$,/*!,!1;;(4*!:$"2$!"%!$;:!v".("%2*0."@4*w!

DX!H;!);'!%;-*&"-*%!&'0.!".&;!,!(;9!&$,&B%!,!$,4AE1*0%;.6!$,4AE(;9!,.(!$,/*!

4"&&4*!*,0%e!

D@"9,"4X!g*,$6!%;6!>!,4:,)%!:,45!;.!-)!&"11)E&;*%6!>!.*/*0!:,45!;.!-)!:$;4*!

A**&=!oS,'%*!-)!:$;4*!A**&!,0*!M'%&!A;0!%"&&".9!(;:.uH;-*&"-*%!>!9;!4"5*!&$"%!

:$*.!>B-!,!(;9!3(;*%!%;-*&$".9!:"&$!$*0!A**&!'.(*0!&$*!&,@4*7=!

8,&)X!b,"&c!3G**0%!'.(*0!&$*!&,@4*=7!D,,,$c!g*,$c!g;'!#.,!;.!);'0!&"11)E&;*%=!

3h;2'%!^0;'1!f6!Uk<VY<UY7=!

Page 207: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

UWW!

!

#$,&!%$*!2;'4(!'.(*0%&,.(!$*0!@;()!,%!1,0&!(;9!:,%!@*);.(!0*10;,2$6!.;&!

M'%&!".!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1%6!@'&!&$0;'9$;'&!-)!A"*4(:;05!;@%*0/,&";.%=!>&!:,%!%;!

.;0-,4"J*(!:"&$".!$*0!%;2",4!4"A*!&$,&!>!A;'.(!$*0!o(;9.*%%B!@*2,-*!1,0&!;A!

*/*0);.*B%!".&*0,2&";.%!:"&$!$*0=!h;0!*+,-14*6!%$*!:;'4(!@*!,%5*(!"A!%$*!:,%!,!(;96!

,!(;9E1*0%;.6!;0!,!1*0%;.E1*0%;.=!T*0!,.%:*0%!/,0"*(=!K.*!0*2*%%!%$*!0*14"*(6!N,!

1*0%;.E1*0%;.=!#$*!(;9%!,0*!4*,0.".9!A0;-!&$*!$;0%*%O!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!V]<V[<UY7=!!

b$"4*!&$*0*!:*0*!.;!(;9%!;0!$;0%*%!/"%"@4*6!2$"4(0*.!,.(!*('2,&;0%!%-"4*(!,.(!

2,00"*(!;.!,%!"A!&$*0*!:,%!.;&$".9!;'&E;AE&$*E;0(".,0)!".!&$*!*+2$,.9*6!A;0!".(**(6!

&$*0*!:,%.B&=!!

#$*!*('2,&;0%!&0*,&*(!&$"%!,%!,!20*,&"/*!:,)!&$,&!%$*!'.(*0%&;;(!$*0%*4A!,.(!

:,%!@'"4(".9!$*0!%;2",4!*+1*0"*.2*%=!#,45!@*&:**.!&$*-!,25.;:4*(9*(!&$,&!D@"9,"4!

:;'4(!4"5*4)!.;&!$,/*!&$"%!1*02*1&";.!;A!$*0%*4A!&$0;'9$;'&!$*0!4"A*&"-*=!T;:*/*06!

.;!;.*!%,:!,!.**(!&;!("%2;'0,9*!$*0!2;.2*1&',4"J,&";.!;A!$*0%*4A=!Q,&$*06!$*0!

*+10*%%";.!:,%!A0,-*(!,%!$*0!%*.%*!;A!1;%%"@"4"&)6!,!%*.%*!&$*!*('2,&;0%!$;1*(!&$,&!

%$*!:;'4(!".2;01;0,&*!".&;!$*0!90;:".9!'1=!#$'%6!&$*!%*.%*!;A!1;%%"@"4"&)!,.(!,@"4"&)!

&;!5.;:!,.(!*+1*0"*.2*!$*0%*4A!;.!$*0!;:.!&*0-%!:,%!0*2;9."J*(=!!

D@"9,"4B%!(;9!"(*.&"A"2,&";.!:,%!10*%*.&!".!(,"4)!0;'&".*%!%'2$!,%!H$;:!,.(!

#*44=!!#;:,0(!&$*!*.(!;A!I,02$6!D@"9,"4!@*9,.!&;!&*44!%&;0"*%!,&!$*0!H$;:!,.(!#*44!

&"-*6!0,&$*0!&$,.!@0".9".9!,.!;@M*2&!A0;-!$;-*=!#$*!A"0%&!&"-*6!%$*!,..;'.2*(!&$,&!

*/*0);.*!:;'4(!@*!"./"&*(!&;!$*0!(;9!%4*((".9!1,0&)!,.(!&$,&!1*;14*!:$;!("(.B&!

:,.&!&;!M;".!2;'4(!:,&2$=!I,09,0*&!2$*25*(!".!:"&$!$*0!&;!%**!:$,&!&$*!(;9!%4*((".9!

1,0&)!:,%!,.(!D@"9,"4!*4,@;0,&*(!&$,&!"&!:;'4(!@*!,&!$*0!$;'%*!@'&!"&!2;'4(!,4%;!

Page 208: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YVV!

!

$,11*.!,&!%2$;;4!,.(!:,%!,.!*/*.&!".!:$"2$!1*;14*!2;'4(!&,5*!&'0.%!%&,.(".9!;.!,!

2$,"0!,.(!N&$;%*!:$;!A**4!&$*)!,0*!(;9%O!:;'4(!&,5*!&'0.%!1'44".9!&$*-!3h"*4(:;05!

.;&*%!Yi<Vf<UY7=!K/*0!&$*!.*+&!-;.&$6!&$"%!:,%!,!%'@M*2&!;A!-'2$!*+2"&*-*.&=!

D@"9,"4!2,-*!,4"/*!:$"4*!&,45".9!,@;'&!&$"%6!9,44;1".9!:"4(4)!:$"4*!0*2;'.&".9!(*&,"4%X!

>A!.;!5"(%!:,.&*(!&;!@*!1*;14*!,.(!&$*)!,44!:,.&*(!&;!@*!(;9%6!&$*.!,('4&%!2;'4(!@*!

1'44*(6!2$"4(0*.!,.(!,('4&%!,0*!"./"&*(6!-;%&!,('4&%!:"44!10;@,@4)!:,&2$6!@'&!&$*)!2,.!

1,0&"2"1,&*!-;0*!"A!&$*)!:,.&!&;6!,.(!2$"4(0*.!2,.!:,&2$!"A!&$*)!(;.B&!:,.&!&;!1'44!;0!

@*!1'44*(=!!

>!,%5*(!$*0!$;:!&$*)!:;'4(!(*2"(*!:$;!:;'4(!1'44!,.(!:$;!:;'4(!@*!1'44*(!

,.(!%$*!,.%:*0*(!%*0";'%4)!&$,&!*/*0);.*!2;'4(!&$".5!,@;'&!"&!".!&$*"0!;:.!$*,(%!

3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!V]<V[<UY7=!#$"%!'&"4"J*(!&$*!4,.9',9*!I,09,0*&!*-14;)*(!&;!$*41!

%&'(*.&%!&,5*!,!-;-*.&!&;!&$".5!,@;'&!&$*"0!0*%1;.%*%!A;0!&$*-%*4/*%!,%!%$*B(!

.;&"2*(!&$,&!&$*!2$"4(0*.!:*0*!N-,&2$".9O!&$*"0!,.%:*0%!&;!&$*"0!1**0%=!d1;.!

.;&"2".9!&$*!-,&2$".9!,%!,!&0*.(6!I,09,0*&!*.2;'0,9*(!%&'(*.&%!&;!&,5*!,!-".'&*!&;!

&$".5!,@;'&!&$*"0!0*%1;.%*%!".!&$*"0!N;:.!$*,(%O!@*A;0*!%$,0".9!:"&$!&$;%*!%"&&".9!

.*+&!&;!&$*-!;0!:"&$!&$*!*.&"0*!24,%%=!D@"9,"4!24*,04)!1'&!-'2$!&$;'9$&!,.(!*AA;0&!

".&;!&$*!1,0&)6!(0,:".9!A0;-!,.(!*4,@;0,&".9!".&*01*0%;.,4!%5"44%!&$*!&*,2$*0!$,(!

A,2"4"&,&*(=!!

D@"9,"4B%!L'"05)!:,)%!;A!'.(*0%&,.(".9!$*0%*4A!("(!.;&!0*-;/*!$*0!A0;-!

0*4,&";.%$"1%!:"&$!$*0!1**0%=!K.!&$*!2;.&0,0)6!"&!9,/*!$*0!".20*,%*(!,0*.,%!A;0!

2;..*2&";.=!D&!0*2*%%!&$*)!:;'4(!&,45!,@;'&!:$;!A*4&!4"5*!&$*0*!:*0*!(;9%!,.(6!9"/*.!

,!2$;"2*6!:;'4(!10,2&"2*!A;0!&$*!(;9!%4*((".9!1,0&)!@)!0'..".9!:"&$!,!%*0"*%!;A!

Page 209: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YVU!

!

/,0";'%4)!,%%*-@4*(!$'4,E$;;1%!,.(!M'-1!0;1*%=!>.!&$"%!:,)6!%$*!*.9,9*(!".!,!

10;2*%%!@)!:$"2$!1*;14*!$,(!,!2$;"2*!0*9,0(".9!%;2",4!0;4*%6!2$;"2*%!&$,&!*,%"4)!

*+1,.(*(!,%!%$*!0*,4"J*(!&$,&!-;0*!;1&";.%!-"9$&!@*!0*L'"0*(!&;!,22;--;(,&*!

*/*0);.*B%!.**(%=!>.("/"(',4%!:*0*!1;%"&";.*(!,%!2;-1*&*.&!&;!5.;:6!A;0!

&$*-%*4/*%6!&$*!,2&"/"&"*%!&$*)!:;'4(!4"5*!&;!*.9,9*!".!,.(!"(*.&"A"2,&";.%!&$*)!

:;'4(!4"5*!&;!$,/*=!#$0;'9$;'&!-)!A"*4(:;056!.;&!;.4)!("(!D@"9,"4B%!("AA*0*.&!

0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!$*0!%;2",4!:;04(!(0,:!2;..*2&";.%!@*&:**.!$*0%*4A!,.(!$*0!1**0%6!"&!

;1*.*(!'1!;11;0&'."&)!A;0!$*0!1**0%!&;!&$".5!,@;'&!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!A;0!&$*-%*4/*%!,%!

:*44=!T;:*/*06!&$"%!A0,-*:;05!,4;.9!:"&$!&$*"0!%;2",4!&;;4%6!("(!.;&!,114)!&;!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!!!

K.!h*@0',0)!Yi&$!3&$*!(,)!@*A;0*!G".5!C,)76!I,09,0*&!0*,(!&$*!@;;5!4,(

I"#.,(RW,.=$")*9\6!@)!Q;@*0&!I'.%2$!,.(!I"2$,*4!I,0&2$*.5;6!,!0$)&$-"2,4!%&;0)!

,@;'&!,!@;)!,.(!,!9"04!;.!&$*"0!A"0%&!(,)!;A!8".(*09,0&*.=!D%!&$*)!-;/*!&$0;'9$!&$*"0!

(,)6!&$*)!A"9$&!;/*0!&;)%!,.(!%'114"*%!;.4)!&;!@*!-*&!:"&$!&$*!%'9,0)!".%&0'2&";.%!

A0;-!&$*!8".(*09,0&*.!&*,2$*0!&$,&!N".!8".(*09,0&*.!:*!%$,0*6!:*!%$,0*!

*/*0)&$".9cO!3'.1,9".,&*(7=!#$*!&*,2$*06!;A&*.!(*1"2&*(!:"&$!$*,0&%6!A4;:*0%6!,.(!

*/*.!@"0(%!%'00;'.(".9!$*0!('0".9!$*0!("0*2&";.%6!"%!%$;25*(!:$*.!&$*!@;)!,.(!9"04!

(*2"(*!&$,&!"A!&$*)!%$;'4(!%$,0*6!&$*)!:"44!%$,0*!&$*"0!24;&$*%!,.(!10;-1&4)!&0,(*!

&$*-=!#$*!&*,2$*0B%!&;.*!2$,.9*%!(0,-,&"2,44)!A0;-!$,0-;.";'%!%:**&.*%%!:"&$!$*0!

("%-,)!&$,&!&$*!@;)!"%!:*,0".9!1".5!24;&$*%=!!I,09,0*&!1,'%*(!".!&$*!%&;0)!&;!".L'"0*!

:$,&!&$*!%&'(*.&%!&$;'9$&!,@;'&!&$*!&*,2$*0B%!2$;"2*!&;!9*&!'1%*&=!H$*!,%5*(6!N"A!);'!

:*0*!&$*!&*,2$*06!:$,&!:;'4(!);'!(;eO!3Yi<VY<UY7=!!

Page 210: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YVY!

!

C*%1"&*!,!.'-@*0!;A!2$"4(0*.!("%,90**".9!:"&$!&$*!&*,2$*0B%!2$;"2*6!D@"9,"4!

%&,&*(!&$,&!"A!%$*!:*0*!&$*!&*,2$*0!%$*!&;;!:;'4(!&*44!&$*!@;)!.;&!&;!:*,0!1".5!,.(!

&$,&!N"&B%!.;&!;5,)6!@*2,'%*!-;%&!@;)%!(;.B&!4"5*!1".5O!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!Yi<VY<UY7=!

b$*.!*+14;0".9!*/*0)(,)!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!".!8".(*09,0&*.6!"&!"%!/*0)!&*44".9!&$,&!:$"4*!

;.*!2;'4(!@*!2;.%"(*0*(!2;-1*&*.&!&;!5.;:!A;0!&$*-%*4/*%!"A!&$*)!:*0*!,!1*0%;.E

1*0%;.6!;0!,!(;9E1*0%;._;.*!2;'4(!.;&6!,22;0(".9!&;!D@"9,"46!@*!,!@;)!:$;!4"5*(!

%;-*&$".9!-;%&!@;)%!("(!.;&!4"5*!34*&!,4;.*!@*!,!2$"4(!:$;!:,%!,%%"9.*(!&$*!4,@*4!

N@;)O!@'&!:$;!"(*.&"A"*(!,%!,!N9"046O!;0!:$;!"(*.&"A"*(!,%!@;&$!;0!.*"&$*0!;A!&$;%*!&:;!

9*.(*0%7=!b$"4*!"&!:,%!.;&!1;%%"@4*!&;!5.;:!;.*%*4A!&;!@*!@;&$!@;)!,.(!9"04!

3I;&$*0B%!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1!f6!U[!I,)!YVUY76!&$,&!D@"9,"4!2;'4(!5.;:!$*0%*4A!,20;%%!

(;9E$'-,.!4".*%!:,%!.;&!;.4)!1;%%"@4*!&;!$*0!1**0%6!"&!:,%!".&*0*%&".9!,.(!*+2"&".9!

,.(!20*,&*(!,(("&";.,4!;11;0&'."&"*%!A;0!&$*-!,.(!&$*"0!14,)=!K.*!2;'4(!,09'*!&$,&!

@*".9!,!(;9!:,%!24*,04)!.;&!0*,4!,.(!&$*0*A;0*!.;&!&,@;;=!>!-,5*!.;!10*&*.%*_&$"%!"%!

%;-*:$,&!A,.&,%&"2,4!,.(!$'-;'0;'%=!T;:*/*06!&;!&$*!%&'(*.&%6!&$"%!*+1*0"*.2*!

:,%!0*,4!,.(!&$*!("AA*0*.&",4!&0*,&-*.&!@*&:**.!20;%%".9!9*.(*0!.;0-%!,.(!20;%%".9!

;&$*0!.;0-%!@*,0%!*+,-".".9=!!

>.!&*0-%!;A!9*.(*06!A0;-!".%&"&'&";.,4!".A0,%&0'2&'0*!%'2$!,%!9*.(*0E

%*90*9,&*(!:,%$0;;-%!&;!*/*0)(,)!&,45!@*&:**.!%'1*0/"%";.E,"(*%!,.(!&*,2$*0%6!

9*.(*0!,-@"9'"&)!:,%!1;%"&";.*(!,%!2;.A'%".9!;0!%'%1*2&=!>.!;.*!".&*0/"*:6!

I,09,0*&!&;4(!&$*!%&;0)!;A!,!%&'(*.&!:$;!$,(!4;.9!$,"0!,&!&$*!@*9"..".9!;A!&$*!%2$;;4!

)*,0=!H$*!&;4(!;A!*('2,&;0%!2;.%"%&*.&4)!2,44".9!$"-!,!9"046!*/*.!&$;'9$!$*!24,0"A"*(!

&$,&!$*!:,%.B&=!I,09,0*&!0*2;'.&*(X!

Page 211: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YVf!

!

DA&*0!$*B(!@**.!,&!%2$;;4!A;06!>!9'*%%6!&:;!;0!&$0**!:**5%6!$*!2,-*!;.*!(,)!

,.(!$"%!$,"0!:,%!&;&,44)!%$;0&=!D.(6!'$6!:$*.!:*!("(!;'0!4"&&4*!1,%%".9!&$*!

%&;.*!,0;'.(!&$*!2"024*6!o>B-!".!&$*!90**.!J;.*!&;(,)!@*2,'%*!>!9;&!-)!$,"0!2'&!

,.(!.;:!>!4;;5!4"5*!,!@;)=B!D.(!$*!:,%!L'"&*!/;2,4!A;0!,!A*:!(,)%!,@;'&!$;:!

$*!("(.B&!4"5*!@*".9!2,44*(!,!9"04!,.(!&$,&B%!:$)!$*!9;&!$"%!$,"0!2'&=!D.(!,!4;&!;A!

&$*!,('4&%!".!&$*!%2$;;4!0*".A;02*(!&$,&!B2,'%*!&$*)!2,-*!&;!$"-!,.(!%,"(6!oK$6!

);'!4;;5!%;!-'2$!@*&&*0=!>!4"5*!);'0!$,"02'&=!g;'_B2,'%*6!);'!5.;:6!&$*!4;.9!

$,"0!2;.A'%*(B_&$*0*!:,%!%;-*;.*!:$;!,2&',44)!%,"(6!o#$*!4;.9!$,"0!

2;.A'%*(!-*=!>!&$;'9$&!);'!:*0*!,!9"04=B!D.!,('4&!%,"(!&;!&$,&!$"-=!H;!&$"%!"%!

:$,&!&$*%*!5"(%!,0*!'1!,9,".%&=!b*B0*!,&!,!%2$;;4!:$*0*!:*B0*!&0)".9!&;!&*,2$!

("/*0%"&)!,.(!)*&!&$*0*!,0*!%&"44!-*-@*0%!;A!%&,AA!:$;!%,@;&,9*!&$,&!,.(!

%,@;&,9*!%&'(*.&%B!"(*,%!;A!&$*"0!;:.!"(*.&"&)!3Q;/*44,!U]<V]<UY7=!

H'2$!".&*0,2&";.%!,.(!".A0,%&0'2&'0*!:;05*(!&;!(*4".*,&*!&$;%*!:$;!

@*4;.9*(!,.(!&$;%*!:$;!:*0*!;'&%"(*0%=!#$0;'9$;'&!-)!0*%*,02$6!>!$,/*!*+14;0*(!

:,)%!%;2",4!"%;4,&";.!,.(!*+24'%";.!,0*!-,(*!2;--;.14,2*!A;0!2$"4(0*.!:$;!(;!.;&!

*+1*0"*.2*!&$*-%*4/*%!:"&$".!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!&*0-%=!>.!&$"%!:,)6!&$*!

%*.%*!;A!1;%%"@"4"&)!&$,&!&$*!24,%%0;;-!*('2,&;0%!.;&*(!1*;14*!;A&*.!4;%*6!$,(!

,40*,()!@**.!4;%&!".!D@"9,"4B%!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!9*.(*0!.;0-%_2$;"2*!:,%!,40*,()!

%'%1*2&!,.(!A0**(;-!,40*,()!2'0&,"4*(=!

#$*!(;9E9"04!%&;0)6!:$"4*!$"9$4)!"-,9".,&"/*6!$,%!"-14"2,&";.%!A;0!-,.)!;A!&$*!

5*)!&$*-*%!&$,&!>!$,/*!*+14;0*(!&$0;'9$;'&!-)!0*%*,02$X!%'2$!,%6!$;:()**&+,*+,("%!

2;.%&0'2&*(!,.(!&$*!1;%"&";.!;A!L'**0.*%%!,%!%)--,.,*+,!:"&$".!(;-".,.&!1;:*0!

Page 212: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YV[!

!

%&0'2&'0*%=!D@"9,"4!1,0&"2"1,&*(!".!1;4"2".9!9*.(*0!.;0-%6!&$;'9$!".!;&$*0!0*%1*2&%!

%$*!$,(!,!.',.2*(!'.(*0%&,.(".9!;A!:,)%!".("/"(',4%!2;'4(!(*2"(*!$;:!&$*)!%,:!

&$*-%*4/*%!,.(!:,)%!&$,&!:;05*(!A;0!&$*-!:$*.!1,0&"2"1,&".9!".!%;2",4!4"A*=!S4*,04)!

.;.*!;A!&$*!2$"4(0*.!:*0*!,2&',44)!(;9%6!@'&!:$"4*!&$*0*!:*0*!.;!%;2",4!

2;.%*L'*.2*%!&;!20;%%".9!,!(;9E$'-,.!("/"(*!".!&*0-%!;A!;.*B%!"(*.&"A"2,&";.6!&$"%!

:,%!.;&!&0'*!;A!9*.(*0!.;0-%!30"9$&!(;:.!&;!&$*!2;4;'0!1".57=!T,/".9!,.!

"-,9".,&"/*!:,)!&;!*.9,9*!:"&$!$*0!%*.%*!;A!%*4A!:,%!.;&!0*,(!,%!".!,.)!:,)!0*4,&*(!

&;!,!10*%*.2*!;0!,@%*.2*!;A!)**&+,*+,6!%$*!:,%!%"-14)!*+14;0".9!:$;!%$*!:,%!,.(!

A".(".9!:,)%!;A!0*4,&".9!&;!$*0!:;04(=!h".,44)6!&$;'9$!24*,04)!@*".9!,!(;9E1*0%;.!:,%!

%)--,.,*$!A0;-!&$*!.;0-6!&$"%!("AA*0*.2*!:,%!.;&!%;-*&$".9!&$,&!0*L'"0*(!&$*!

,%%*0&";.!&$,&!("AA*0*.2*!:,%!N;5,)O!,.(!.;&!&;!@'44)!$*0j!0,&$*06!$*0!1**0%!2;'4(!

&$".5!A;0!&$*-%*4/*%!,.(!(*2"(*!:$,&!"(*.&"A"2,&";.!%'"&*(!&$*-=!!

I,09,0*&B%!A;2'%!;.!2$"4(0*.!5.;:".9!&$*-%*4/*%!,.(!,(/;2,&".9!;.!@*$,4A!

;A!&$*"0!.**(%!10;/"(*(!,.!*+2*44*.&!&*-14,&*!&;!%'11;0&!C'.2,.B%!%$"A&!A0;-!

-;25".9!&;!*-@0,2".9!&0,"&%!(**-*(!NA*-".".*6O!:$*.!&$"%!%*4AE1*01*&',&*(!

0*1'(",&";.!:,%!2,'%".9!("%&0*%%=!T;:*/*06!&$*!(*1,0&'0*!A0;-!9*.(*0!.;0-%!,.(!

$"%!("%&0*%%!:,%!,!%1*2",4!"%%'*!,.(!C'.2,.!%&"44!*+1*0"*.2*(!%'@%*L'*.&!"%;4,&";._

.*"&$*0!;A!:$"2$!10;A;'.(4)!10;-;&*(!4,09*0!2$,.9*!:"&$".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!,.(!

%2$;;4=!D@"9,"4B%!20*,&"/*!(*14;)-*.&!;A!%*4AE(*&*0-".*(!"(*.&"&)!10;/"(*%!,.!

*+,-14*!;A!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!A;0!&,5".9!'1!("/*09".9!%*4AE*+10*%%";.%!&$,&!,0*!.;&!@,%*(!

;.!A*,0!;0!4;,&$".9=!>.!&$"%!%*2&";.6!>!$,/*!"./"&*(!&$*!L'*%&";.X!:$,&!"&!:;'4(!4;;5!

4"5*!A;0$L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!&;!@*!".&*90,&*(!".&;!*/*0)(,)!4"A*!:"&$!

Page 213: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YV]!

!

&$*!%,-*!".24'%"/*!%*.%*!;A!*+2"&*-*.&e!#$"%!L'*%&";.!'09*%!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!

%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!&;!@*!0*A0,-*(!,%!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!0,&$*0!&$,.!N"%%'*%=O!!

>.!;'0!".&*0/"*:6!S,0;4".*!P*4%;.!("%2'%%*(!,!/,0"*&)!;A!,2&"/"&"*%!&$*!%2$;;4!

$,(!%1*,0$*,(*(!;/*0!&$*!1,%&!)*,06!%'2$!,%!A'.(0,"%".9!A;0!2,.2*0!,.(!0*4"*A!:;05!

".!&$*!:,5*!;A!.,&'0,4!("%,%&*0%=!b,.(*0".9!&$*!90;'.(%!;A!&$*!%2$;;46!;&$*0!10;M*2&%!

:*0*!*/"(*.&=!K.*!24,%%!$,(!@'"4&!,!2;-1;%&!1"&!,%!1,0&!;A!,%%"%&".9!&$*!%2$;;4!:"&$!

:,%&*!0*('2&";.j!&$*!D@;0"9".,4!90;'1!$,(!%&,0&*(!,!.,&"/*!14,.&!(*-;.%&0,&";.!

9,0(*.=!b$"4*!%;-*!;A!&$*%*!10;M*2&%!-,)!$,/*!*.9,9*(!".!;&$*0".9!("%2;'0%*6!"&!"%!

*L',44)!4"5*4)!&$,&!;&$*0%!:*0*!,!(*-;.%&0,&";.!;A!90;'1%!*AA*2&".9!2$,.9*!".!&$*"0!

%2$;;4%!,.(!4,09*0!2'4&'0*%_&$'%!&*,2$".9!4*9,2"*%!;A!,2&"/"%-!,.(!%&0,&*9"*%!&;!

20*,&*!2$,.9*=!

>A!,!/,0"*&)!;A!9*.(*0%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%!:*0*!1,0&!;A!*/*0)(,)!&,456!".&*90,&*(!

".&;!*/*0)(,)!24,%%0;;-!4"A*6!"%%'*%!;A!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!&0,.%1$;@",!:;'4(!%&"44!*+"%&!

:"&$".!&$*!4,09*0!2'4&'0*=!T;:*/*06!1'@4"2!*('2,&";.!".%&"&'&";.%!:;'4(!&$*.!@*!".!

&$*!1;%"&";.!&;!,((0*%%!%'2$!"%%'*%!,%!%*1,0,&*!A0;-!&$*!"(*.&"&"*%!&$*-%*4/*%=!b$"4*!

.;&!*+14"2"&4)!0*4,&*(!&;!9*.(*06!&$*!A;44;:".9!%&;0)!A0;-!-)!*&$.;90,1$"2!

;@%*0/,&";.%!10;/"(*%!,!%;4"(!*+,-14*!;A!2$"4(E(0"/*.!,2&"/"%-!".!:$"2$!*('2,&;0%!

0*%1;.(*(!@)!*.2;'0,9".9!%&'(*.&%B!2;--'."2,&";.!,.(!%*.%*%!;A!1;:*0_@;&$!;A!

:$"2$!:;'4(!@*!*,%"4)!,114"2,@4*!&;!;&$*0!%;2",4!M'%&"2*!&;1"2%=!!

0A>>9<BI$ABY$f??Y$:C<=J$

b$"4*!>!$,/*!;/*0/"*:*(!10;@4*-,&"2!("%2;'0%*%!:"&$".!-)!A"*4(%&'()!,%!

&$*)!0*4,&*(!&;!9*.(*0%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%6!".!;&$*0!0*%1*2&%6!&$*0*!:*0*!*('2,&;0%!,&!

Page 214: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YVk!

!

&$*!%2$;;4!:$;!(*-;.%&0,&*(!90*,&!0*%1*2&!A;0!);'.9!1*;14*B%!%;2",4!2;-1*&*.2)=!

K.*!%&0"5".9!*+,-14*!;A!%&'(*.&%!&,5".9!'1!%;2",4!"%%'*%!$,11*.*(!".!0*%1;.%*!&;!

:;;(!2$"1%!@*".9!&$0;:.!(;:.!&$*!(0,".=!D@"9,"4B%!*+'@*0,.&6!0*4,&";.%$"1!@'"4(".9!

,110;,2$!&;!$*0!%*4AE24,"-*(!"(*.&"&)!;AA*0%!,!.*:!1;&*.&",4!-;(*4!A;0!:$,&!

".("/"(',4%B!0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!2;'4(!4;;5!4"5*=!

#$*!b;;(!S$"1!.,00,&"/*%!;AA*0!,.!*+,-14*!;A!2;44,@;0,&"/*!:;05!@*&:**.!

*('2,&;0%!,.(!%&'(*.&%!&$,&!10;/"(*!".%"9$&!A;0!;&$*0!,0*.,%!;A!A,2"4"&,&".9!%;2",4!

2$,.9*!".!%2$;;4%=!#,5*.!&;9*&$*06!&$*)!10;/"(*!,!94"-1%*!;A!,110;,2$*%!&;!"(*.&"&)!

,.(!%;2",4!"%%'*%!,%!%*1,0,&*!A0;-!&$*!,@;/*E-*.&";.*(!10;@4*-,&"2!("%2;'0%*%=!!

K.!I,)![&$6!>!2,-*!,20;%%!,!1"2&'0*!&$,&!,!%-,44!90;'1!;A!%&'(*.&%!$,(!(0,:.!

;A!&:;!2$"4(0*.!1'&&".9!:;;(!2$"1%!".!&$*!:,&*0!(0,".!.*+&!&;!&$*!14,)90;'.(!:$"4*!

&:;!;&$*0!2$"4(0*.!%&;;(!4;;5".9!%$;25*(=!d.(*0!&$*!1"2&'0*!D@"9,"4!$,(!:0"&&*.6!

NIDS!D!PKC>H!hKQ!I"s!P>aHdP!DFKb#!#$*!bK#Q!H>SaK=!>!DI!HRQR>HcO!>!,%5*(!

:$,&!"&!%,"(!%$*B(!0*,(!:"&$!10"(*6!NI,5*!,!.;&"2*!A;0!I%=!P*4%;.!,@;'&!&$*!:,&*0!

2)24*=!>!,-!%*0";'%cO!I,09,0*&!;/*0$*,0(!&$"%!,.(!&;4(!D@"9,"4!&$,&!"A!%$*!@0;'9$&!&$*!

.;&*!&;!I%=!P*4%;.6!%$*!@*4"*/*(!&$,&!I%=!P*4%;.!:;'4(!'.(*0%&,.(!$;:!%*0";'%!&$*!

"%%'*!:,%=!D@"9,"4!,.(!$*0!%'00;'.(".9!1**0%!:*0*!/*0)!*+2"&*(!@)!&$"%!,.(!

*.2;'0,9*(!I,09,0*&!&;!%$;:!&$*!1"2&'0*!&;!&$*!10".2"1,4=!DA&*06!I,09,0*&!9;&!&*,0%!

".!$*0!*)*%!,.(!&,45*(!,@;'&!$;:!&$"%!0*10*%*.&*(!*/*0)&$".9!%$*!:;05%!A;0=!H$*!

:,.&*(!&;!%$;:!"&!&;!1,0*.&%!".!&$*!'12;-".9!1,0*.&<&*,2$*0!-**&".9%!&;!-;(*4!&$*!

9;,4!;A!:0"&".9!".!8".(*09,0&*._&$,&!2$"4(0*.!'.(*0%&,.(!4"&*0,2)!.;&!M'%&!,%!

,%%"9.-*.&%!@'&!,%!,!&;;4!&$*)!2,.!'%*!".!;0(*0!&;!*+10*%%!&$*-%*4/*%=!!

Page 215: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YVi!

!

#$*!A;44;:".9!I;.(,)6!I,09,0*&!$,(!,.!,A&*0.;;.!-**&".9!%2$*('4*(!&:;!;A!

&$*!2$"4(0*.!&;!-**&!:"&$!S,0;4".*!P*4%;.!3>!,%5*(!&$*-!"A!&$*)!:;'4(!@*!;5,)!:"&$!

-*!2;-".9!:"&$!&$*-!,.(!&$*)!@*,-*(!,.(!%,"(6!Ng*%cO7=!#$*"0!*+2"&*-*.&!:,%!

'.2;.&,".*(!;.!&$*"0!:,)!'1!&$*!%&,"0%=!#$*)!%L'*,4*(6!&$*"0!$,.(%!".!A"%&%6!*)*%!

:"(*6!90"..".9!,.(!*+14;(".9!:"&$6!N*****cO!N#$"%!"%!%;!*+2"&".9cO!,.(!N2,.!);'!

@*4"*/*!&$"%!"%!0*,44)!$,11*.".9eO!K.2*!".!&$*!;AA"2*6!&$*"0!@;()!4,.9',9*!2$,.9*(!

,@0'1&4)=!#$*)!%*0";'%4)!".A;0-*(!&$*!%*20*&,0)!&$,&!&$*)!:;'4(!4"5*!&;!%1*,5!&;!I%=!

P*4%;.!,.(!*2$;!I,09,0*&!&*44".9!$*0!&$,&6!N%$*!"%!*+1*2&".9!'%=O!#$*)!:*0*!/*0)!

2;-1;%*(!,.(!10;A*%%";.,46!@'&!0*4,1%*(!".&;!A"%&!:,/".9!,.(!*+14;%"/*!90".%!

:$*.*/*0!&$*!;&$*0!,('4&%!&'0.*(!&$*"0!@,25%=!!

S,0;4".*!P*4%;.!:*42;-*(!&$*-!".&;!$*0!;AA"2*!,.(!%&,&*(!&$,&!%$*!

'.(*0%&;;(!&$,&!&$*)!$,(!,!2;.2*0.=!H$*!&0*,&*(!&$*-!,%!>!@*4"*/*!%$*!:;'4(!,.)!

1,0*.&6!0*%*,02$*06!;0!*-14;)**!:$;!-"9$&!2;-*!&;!*+10*%%!2;.2*0.%=!H$*!&;;5!

.;&*%!,.(!2;.A"0-*(!&$,&!&$0;:".9!&$".9%!(;:.!&$*!(0,".!:,%!,!%*0";'%!10;@4*-=!

H$*!&;4(!&$*-!&$,&!&$*!)*,0!@*A;0*!&$*!%2$;;4!$,(!$"0*(!%;-*;.*!&;!%'2&";.!,44!;A!&$*!

:;;(!2$"1%!,.(!9,0@,9*!;'&!;A!&$*!(0,".!,.(!&$,&!"&!:,%!/*0)!*+1*.%"/*=!#$*!

2$"4(0*.!%-"4*(!,.(!.;((*(6!2;.A*00".9!%*0";'%4)=!S,0;4".*!,%5*(!:$,&!&$*)!:;'4(!

4"5*!$*0!&;!(;=!!D@"9,"4!%&,&*(!&$,&!&$*)!:;'4(!4"5*!&;!-,5*!,.!,..;'.2*-*.&!,.(!&$*!

&$0**!;A!&$*-!A"44*(!;'&!,.!,..;'.2*-*.&!A;0-!&;9*&$*0=!b$"4*!S,0;4".*!:,%!;'&!;A!

&$*!;AA"2*!9*&&".9!&$*!A;0-6!&$*!2$"4(0*.!&,45*(!,@;'&!.;&!@*".9!,@4*!&;!@*4"*/*!&$,&!

N&$"%!:,%!0*,44)!1;%%"@4*O!,.(!,%5*(!*,2$!;&$*0!N$;:!-,.)!5"(%O!$,(!%;-*&$".9!&$"%!

,-,J".9!$,11*.!3&$*!,-,J".9!*/*.&!%**-*(!&;!@*!9*&&".9!&;!&,5*!&$*"0!2;.2*0.%!&;!

Page 216: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YVZ!

!

&$*!10".2"1,47=!D@"9,"4!%&,&*(6!&$,&!&$*)!:*0*!N4'25)!5"(%O!3h"*4(:;05!.;&*%!]!I,)!

YVUY7=!S,0;4".*!%*.&!,!2;1)!;A!&$*!.;&"2*!,.(!,!&$,.5!);'!.;&*!A;0!I,09,0*&!&$,&!,4%;!

"./"&*(!$*0!24,%%!&;!-,5*!-;0*!1;%&*0%!&$,&!2;'4(!@*!1'&!,0;'.(!&$*!%2$;;4=!K.!&$*!

:,)!(;:.%&,"0%!&$*)!(,.2*(!,.(!%,.9!,!%;.9!,@;'&!N4"%&*.".9!&;!&$*!

,..;'.2*-*.&%=O!F,25!".!24,%%6!>!,%5*(!&$*!2$"4(0*.!$;:!&$*)!5.*:!&$,&!1'&&".9!

:;;(!2$"1%!(;:.!&$*!(0,".!:;'4(!@*!,!10;@4*-=!#$*)!&,45*(!,@;'&!$;:!&$*!:;;(!

2$"1%!("(!.;&!@*4;.9!".!&$*!;2*,.6!,.(!2;'4(!$'0&!&$*!A"%$=!D!24'%&*0!;A!2$"4(0*.!

2;.&".'*(!&;!&,45!,@;'&!"%%'*%!;A!:,&*0!1;44'&";.!,.(!A"%$6!(*-;.%&0,&".9!@;&$!

*./"0;.-*.&,4!*('2,&";.!,.(!(*('2&"/*!0*,%;.".9!&$*)!'%*(!".!A"9'0".9!;'&!,!

1;&*.&",4!10;@4*-=!!

#$*!.*+&!-;0.".96!&$*!24,%%!:,%!$'--".9!:"&$!*+2"&*-*.&=!DA&*0!&$*!

-;0.".9!,..;'.2*-*.&%6!&$*!%&'(*.&%!M'-1*(!'1!,.(!(;:.!,.(!-,.)!$'99*(!*,2$!

;&$*06!,11*,0".9!&;!@*4"*/*!&$,&!$,(!,2$"*/*(!2*4*@0"&)!%&,&'%!,A&*0!$*,0".9!.,-*%!;A!

24,%%-,&*%!0*,(!;/*0!&$*!-;0.".9!,..;'.2*-*.&%=!C'0".9!&$*!A"0%&!S*.&0*!&"-*!;A!

&$*!(,)6!,&!4*,%&!&*.!2$"4(0*.!0,44"*(!&;!-,5*!-;0*!1;%&*0%!&;!1'&!'1!,0;'.(!&$*!

%2$;;46!'09".9!&$*"0!1**0%!.;&!&;!&$0;:!:;;(!2$"1%!(;:.!&$*!(0,".=!#$*"0!&,45!

20*,&*(!,!2;E4*,0.".9!*./"0;.-*.&!,%!&$*)!%'11;0&*(!*,2$!;&$*0B%!:;05!;.!&$*!

1;%&*0%=!#$*!A;44;:".9!:,%!&,5*.!A0;-!-)!A"*4(:;05!.;&*%X!

D@"9,"4!2'04*(!$*0!A".9*0%!,0;'.(!@)!$*0!-;'&$!,.(!,..;'.2*%!&$,&!-;0*!

1*;14*!2,.!M;".!".!&$*!1;%&*0!-,5".9=!>!:;.(*0!"A!%$*!$,%!%**.!,.);.*!;09,."J*!,!

2,-1,"9.!@*A;0*=!!

K%2,0X!b$,&!"%!"&!2,44*(!,9,".e!

Page 217: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YVW!

!

D@"9,"4X!b,&*0!2)))24*c!C0,,"".=!

8,&)X!P;6!"&B%!,2&',44)!2,44*(!,!9'&&*0c!P;&!,!:,&*0!2)24*=!>&!"%=!!

`*&&"*!:,45%!'1!:"&$!,!0*,44)!@"9!%&,25!;A!1,1*0=!#$*)!$,/*!,!4;&!;A!&,45!,@;'&!

:$*0*!&;!1'&!&$*!1;%&*0%6!".24'(".9!.*+&!&;!&$*!(0,".=!8,&)!*+2"&*(4)!%,)%!&$,&!

&$*.!1*;14*!:"44!%**!"&!,.(!5.;:!.;&!&;!1'&!&$*-!&$*0*=!!

#$*)!%&,0&!2$,.&".96!".!,!%".9E%;.9!2$;0'%X!

P;!D%$4*)6!.;&!".!&$*!(0,".!

P;!D@"9,"46!.;&!".!&$*!(0,".uO!!

#$*)!2;.&".'*!&$*!2$,.&".96!%,)".9!,44!&$*"0!.,-*%!,.(!(,.2".9!:$"4*!&$*)!

-,5*!1;%&*0%=!!

`*&&"*X!^')%6!:*B0*!0*,44)!9;".9!&;!:;05!;.!&$"%!0*,44)!9;;(=!

R/*0);.*X!g*,$c!

3)/)%7!

I,09,0*&!1'&!-*&,4!0".9%!".!&$*!1"2&'0*%!,.(!4,-".,&*(!&$*-=!H$*!,4%;!

%'11;0&*(!&$0**!2$"4(0*.!".!9;".9!,0;'.(!&;!(*4"/*0!&$*!1;%&*0%!&;!("AA*0*.&!24,%%*%!

:$*0*!&$*)!:*0*!"./"&*(!".!&;!&*44!*,2$!&*,2$*0!,.(!%&'(*.&%!,@;'&!&$*!"%%'*=!D%!&$*!

90;'1!9;&!-;0*!2;-A;0&,@4*!-;/".9!A0;-!24,%%!&;!24,%%6!I,09,0*&!$'.9!@,25!-;0*!

,.(!-;0*6!,AA;0(".9!&$*"0!".20*,%*(!".(*1*.(*.2*!:$*.!-,5".9!0;'.(%!&$0;'9$!&$*!

24,%%*%!;A!;4(*0!2$"4(0*.=!!b$"4*!&$*"0!&,5*!;.!&$*!"%%'*_&$,&!:;;(!2$"1%!9;!".&;!&$*!

;2*,.!,.(!A"%$!*,&!&$*-!,.(!&$*)!("*_-,)!$,/*!.;&!:"&$%&;;(!%2"*.&"A"2!%20'&".)6!

&$*!"-1,2&!&$"%!-;(*4!$,(!;.!%&'(*.&!4*,0.".9!,.(!,2&"/"%-!"%!:;0&$!A'0&$*0!

,.,4)%"%=!!

Page 218: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YUV!

!

b$*.!,.!"%%'*!:,%!"(*.&"A"*(6!%1,2*!,.(!0*%1*2&!:,%!9"/*.6!,.(!&;;4%!:*0*!

10;/"(*(!A;0!%&'(*.&%!&;!2$,.9*!&$*"0!*./"0;.-*.&%=!D%!>!:,&2$*(!&$*!24,%%!@;.(!

;/*0!1;%&*0!-,5".9!,.(!9,".!2;'0,9*!&;!-,5*!,..;'.2*-*.&%6!>!2;'4(!.;&!$*41!@'&!

1;.(*0!:$,&!%'2$!,2&"/"%-!:;'4(!4;;5!4"5*!".!&*0-%!;A!9*.(*0%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%!:*0*!

%'2$!&;1"2%!1,0&!;A!*/*0)(,)!%2$;;4!4"A*!,.(!0*-;/*(!A0;-!&$*!0*,4-!;A!-;0,4!

M'(9-*.&=!>.!,!24,%%0;;-!*./"0;.-*.&!".!:$"2$!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!

%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!:*0*!,%!2;--;.14,2*!,.(!M'@"4,.&4)!*+10*%%*(!,%!D@"9,"4B%!%*4AE

10;24,"-*(!"(*.&"&)6!:;'4(!&$*0*!@*!);'.9!1*;14*!:$;!:;'4(!@*2;-*!(0"/*.!&;!

,2&"/"%-!:$*.!4*,0.".9!,@;'&!(;-".,.&!2'4&'0,4!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!&0,.%1$;@",e!

b$,&!2$,.9*!:;'4(!@*!-,(*!1;%%"@4*!&$0;'9$!&$*!0*14"2,&";.!;A!S,0;4".*!,.(!

I,09,0*&B%!-;(*4%!;A!/,4'".9!2$"4(0*.B%!4"&*0,2)6!%*.%*%!;A!M'%&"2*6!,.(!20*,&"/"&)e!!

:?BZ>HJ<?B$

K/*0!&$"%!2$,1&*06!>!$,/*!A;2'%*(!,&&*.&";.!;.!&$0**!0*2;0(%!A0;-!-)!

A"*4(:;05!&$,&!(*1"2&!1;&*.&",4!,110;,2$*%!&;!%;2",4!2$,.9*!".!4"9$&!;A!;@%&,24*%!&;!

2$,44*.9".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!".!10"-,0)!90,(*%=!#$*%*!0*2;0(%!2;.&0,%&!

("%2;'0%*%!0*9,0(".9!2$"4(0*.!&$,&!(*A".*!&$*-!,%!"..;2*.&!,.(!".2,1,@4*!;A!

'.(*0%&,.(".9!,.(!.*9;&",&".9!&$*"0!;:.!,.(!&$*"0!1**0%B!"(*.&"&"*%!".!&*0-%!;A!

9*.(*0%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%=!#$*!%&;0"*%!".!&$"%!2$,1&*06!2;./*0%*4)6!10;/"(*!*+,-14*%!;AX!

• ^*.(*0*(!"-14"2,&";.%!;A!*.2;'0,9".9!2$"4(0*.!&;!4"%&*.!&;!&$*-%*4/*%!,.(!

&,5".9!2$"4(0*.B%!".%"9$&%!,.(!%*4AE,:,0*.*%%!%*0";'%4)!

• D!8".(*09,0&*.!2$"4(!(*-;.%&0,&".9!&$,&!&$*)!:*0*!24*,04)!.,/"9,&".9!&$*"0!

;:.!9*.(*0!"(*.&"&)!,.(!*+1*0"*.2".9!("%&0*%%!A0;-!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-%!!

Page 219: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YUU!

!

• D.!,4&*0.,&*!*.9,9*-*.&!:"&$!N("AA*0*.2*O!&$,&!"%!.;&!@,%*(!;.!;&$*0".9!,.(!

(;*%!.;&!4*,(!&;!%;2",4!"%;4,&";.!!

• S$"4(0*.!(*-;.%&0,&".9!&$*"0!,9*.2)!,.(!,@"4"&)!&;!:;05!A;0!2$,.9*6!,4;.9!

:"&$!-;(*4%!;A!,('4&!%'11;0&!A;0!&$"%!2$,.9*=!!

#$*!2$"4(0*.!("%2'%%*(!".!&$"%!2$,1&*0!,44!(*-;.%&0,&*(!2;-1*&*.2"*%!3,.(!

2;.&0,("2&";.%7!:$*.!.,/"9,&".9!2;-14*+!"(*.&"&"*%!,.(<;0!%;2",4!.;0-%=!#$*!

*('2,&;0%B!(*2"%";.%!".!&$"%!2$,1&*0!("(!%"9."A"2,.&!:;05!&;!A,2"4"&,&*!&$*!2$"4(0*.B%!

*+1,.%";.!;A!&$*"0!"(*.&"&"*%6!0,&$*0!&$,.!%$'&&".9!(;:.!1;%%"@"4"&"*%=!#$*%*!A;2"!

10;/"(*!"-1;0&,.&!,4&*0.,&"/*%!&;!0*%*,02$!:$"2$!0*.(*0!2$"4(0*.!1,%%"/*!0*2"1"*.&%!

;A!2'4&'0*=!S;-@".*(!:"&$!&$*!10*/";'%4)!'.(*0E&$*;0"J*(!A;2'%!&$"%!0*%*,02$!@0".9%!

&;!("%2'%%".9!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!".!8".(*09,0&*.6!%'2$!A".(".9%!

;AA*0!10,2&"2,4!".%"9$&!A;0!&$;%*!2;.2*0.*(!:"&$!2$"4(0*.!,.(!9*.(*0!M'%&"2*!".!1'@4"2!

%2$;;4%=!!

!

! !

Page 220: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YUY!

!

:?BZ>HJ<?B$

b$*.!>!:,%!,!?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!F;,0(!*-14;)**6!>!$,(!,!4*.9&$)!

2;./*0%,&";.!,@;'&!,.&"E$;-;1$;@",!:"&$!,!2;44*,9'*=!#$"%!&*,2$*0!%".2*0*4)!

:,.&*(!&;!-,5*!%2$;;4%!%,A*0!,.(!-;0*!1;%"&"/*!*./"0;.-*.&%!A;0!L'**0!);'&$=!

K/*0!&$*!2;'0%*!;A!;'0!2;./*0%,&";.6!%$*!,%5*(!"A!>!$,(!2$"4(0*.6!,.(!%&,&*(!&$,&!

(*%1"&*!%'11;0&".9!L'**0!);'&$6!%$*!:;'4(!%&"44!@*!%,(!,.(!2;.2*0.*(!"A!$*0!&**.,9*!

(,'9$&*0!:,%!9,)=!D%!:*!%1;5*6!>!0*,4"J*(!&$,&!%$*!$,(!,%%'-*(!>!:,%!$*&*0;%*+',4!

,.(!&$,&!>!:;'4(!,4%;!@*!%,(!&;!$,/*!,!2$"4(!&$,&!:,%!;&$*0:"%*=!!

b$*.!%$*!1;%*(!$*0!L'*%&";.6!>!@*9,.!&;!"-,9".*!:$,&!-)!4"A*!:;'4(!$,/*!

@**.!4"5*!$,(!>!.;&!@**.!L'**0=!>!&;4(!$*0!,@;'&!$;:!90,&*A'4!>!:,%!&;!$,/*!$,(!,!

2;'.&*0E2'4&'0*!&$0;'9$!-)!&:*.&"*%!&$,&!:,%!*,%"4)!,22*%%"@4*!&;!-*6!:$"2$!/,4'*(!

2$;%*.!A,-"4)!".!&$*!:,)!&$,&!-)!L'**0!2;--'."&"*%!("(=!>!%1;5*!;A!$;:6!:$*.!

-;/".9!A0;-!;.*!2"&)!&;!,.;&$*06!>!:,%!,@4*!&;!A".(!1*;14*!:$;6!4"5*!-*6!:;05*(!&;!

-,5*!0;;-!A;0!,!:"(*0!0,.9*!;A!9*.(*0!*+10*%%";.%!,.(!$;:!&$"%!$,(!$*41*(!-*!&;!

:;05!,9,".%&!".&*0.,4"J".9!(;-".,.&!2'4&'0,4!@*,'&)!.;0-%!,.(!&;!,/;"(!@*".9!

2;.A".*(!@)!(;-".,.&!2'4&'0,4!*+1*2&,&";.%!,.(!4"-"&,&";.%!;A!9*.(*0=!H$*!:,%!

14*,%*(!&;!$*,0!&$"%!,.(!,4%;!/*0)!%'010"%*(X!"&!$,(!.*/*0!;22'00*(!&;!$*0!&;!/"*:!

L'**0.*%%!,%!,!1;&*.&",44)!1;%"&"/*!*+1*0"*.2*!".!%;-*;.*B%!4"A*=[k!#$,&!-;-*.&!

"44'%&0,&*(!&;!-*!,!%"9."A"2,.&!@,00"*0!&;!20*,&".9!%;2",4!2$,.9*!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!>A!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[k!>!0*,4"J*!&$,&!-)!*+1*0"*.2*%!,0*!2'4&'0,44)!%"&',&*(=!T;:*/*06!&$"%!*('2,&;0!,.(!>!

@;&$!4"/*(!".!&$*!%,-*!'0@,.!2*.&0*!:"&$!0"2$!2;'.&*0E2'4&'0*%=!#$*!%1*2"A"2%!;A!-)!

*+1*0"*.2*!2;'4(!/*0)!:*44!$,/*!,114"*(!&;!$*0!(,'9$&*06!$,(!$*0!(,'9$&*0!@**.!

L'**0=!

Page 221: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YUf!

!

*('2,&;0%!:;05".9!&;!0*('2*!$;-;1$;@",!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!2,..;&!"-,9".*!1;%"&"/*!

1;%%"@"4"&"*%!A;0!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!4"/*%!,.(!A'&'0*%6!"&!"%!.;!:;.(*0!&$,&6!

2$"4(0*.!,.(!);'&$!,4%;!A,2*!%'2$!,.!;@%&,24*_1,0&"2'4,04)!9"/*.!&$*!10*/,4*.2*!;A!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!;&$*0".9!,.(!;%&0,2"%-!&$,&!&,5*%!14,2*!A0;-!&$*!

@*9"..".9!;A!,!%&'(*.&B%!1'@4"2!*('2,&";.=!$

0DJDAFZC$;<BY<BIJ$

H2$;;4!2'4&'0*%!%$,1*(!@)!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!(;!.;&!$,11*.!

".2"(*.&,44)=!#$*)!,0*!0*".A;02*(!3;0!0*%"%&*(7!(,"4)!&$0;'9$!;0(".,0)!*/*.&%!".!

1'@4"2!*('2,&";.,4!4"A*=!I)!%&'()!%*&!;'&!&;!*+14;0*!&$*!L'*%&";.%X!!

• b$,&!".A;0-,4!10,2&"2*%!3*=9=!*/*0)(,)!&,456!%&;0)&*44".96!2;--*.&%!;.!&$*!

%&'(*.&B%!14,)7!&,5*!14,2*!@*&:**.!%&'(*.&%!,.(!@*&:**.!*('2,&;0%!,.(!

%&'(*.&%!&$,&!0*A*0!&;!,&&0,2&";.6!2;'14".96!%*+',4"&)6!,.(!9*.(*0e!!

• b$,&!10,2&"2*%!3*=9=!&,456!14,)7!(*-;.%&0,&*!%&'(*.&%B!0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)e!!

b$"4*!&$*!10*/";'%!2$,1&*0%!*+14;0*(!(*&,"4%!;A!-)!0*%*,02$!A".(".9%6!>!:"44!.;:!

0*2,1!,!A*:!;A!&$*!A".(".9%!%1*2"A"2,44)!".!0*4,&";.!&;!-)!0*%*,02$!L'*%&";.%=!

T*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!0*4,&";.%$"1%!:*0*!10*/,4*.&!".!1"2&'0*!@;;5%6!

@;&$!A"2&";.!,.(!.;.EA"2&";.6!0*%'4&".9!".!-'4&"14*!(*1"2&";.%!;A!$*&*0;%*+',4!

0*4,&";.%$"1%6!4"/*%6!,.(!A'&'0*!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!A;0!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!".("/"(',4%!

:"&$".!&$*!2'00"2'4'-6!0*9,0(4*%%!;A!&$*!%'@M*2&!-,&&*0=!T*&*0;%*+',4!A,-"4"*%!,.(!

1,0&.*0%$"1%!:*0*!("%2'%%*(!*/*0)(,)!@)!&$*!2$"4(0*.6!*('2,&;0%6!,.(!1,0*.&%=!#$*!

("%2'%%";.%!:*0*!.*/*0!A0,-*(!,%!%*+',4!;0!,@;'&!%*+',4"&)=!F)!2;.&0,%&6!@*".9!9,)!

Page 222: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YU[!

!

:,%!-*.&";.*(!;.4)!;.2*!".!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!&$*!0"%5!;A!/";4*.2*!3%&0*%%".9!&$,&!;.*!

%$;'4(.B&!@'44)!1*;14*!:$;!:*0*!("AA*0*.&7=!D%!%'2$6!@*".9!N9,)O!:,%!,!%;2",4!"%%'*6!

0,&$*0!&$,.!1,0&!;A!*/*0)(,)!4"A*=!T;:*/*06!'.4"5*!-,.)!%2$;;4%!&$,&!>!:;05*(!".!,%!,!

?HF!*-14;)**6!I,09,0*&!.,-*(!&$*!$;-;1$;@",!,.(!%*+"%-!*-@*((*(!".!&$*!

*/*.&%!&$,&!@0;'9$&!,@;'&!G".5!C,)6!0,&$*0!&$,.!;@%2'0".9!&$*!-*%%,9*!".!

%*.&"-*.&%!&$,&!@;)%!:*,0".9!1".5!("(.B&!2,#*(#*=$")*9=!#$'%6!&$*!"%%'*%!:*0*!.;&!

0*.(*0*(!'.-*.&";.,@4)!&,@;;=!!

b$"4*!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!:*0*!.*/*0!("%2'%%*(!".!&$*!2'00"2'4'-6!

*/*0)(,)!.;0-%!0*".A;02*(!.;&!;.4)!&$*!&:;E9*.(*0!%)%&*-6!@'&!&$,&!&;!@*!

'.".&*44"9"@4)!9*.(*0*(!:,%!%'%1*2&!,.(!'.,22*1&,@4*!3@,&$0;;-%6!2$"4(0*.B%!

0*%1;.%*%!&;!2$"4(0*.B%!@;;5!2$,0,2&*0%7=!#$*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!&$,&!:,%!

(*-;.%&0,&*(!".!-)!A"*4(:;05!"44'%&0,&*(!$;:!-,4*!10"/"4*9*!2,.!,4%;!@*2;-*!

.;0-,4"J*(=!b"&$".!&$*!2'00"2'4'-6!10;&,9;."%&%!;A!1"2&'0*!@;;5%!:*0*!,4-;%&!

*+24'%"/*4)!-,4*=!S$"4(0*.!;A!,44!9*.(*0%!(*A,'4&*(!&;!-,4*!10;.;'.%!:$*.!&,45".9!

,@;'&!2$,0,2&*0%6!,."-,4%6!,.(!&;)%=!b$"4*!>!;@%*0/*(!@;)%!&$0*,&*.!&;!;/*01;:*0!

9"04%!;0!'%*!'.:,.&*(!1$)%"2,4!;0!%*+',4!2;.&,2&!3*=9=!5"%%".97!,%!,!&$0*,&j!&$*0*!:*0*!

,4%;!".%&,.2*%!;A!0*%"%&,.2*!&$*%*!".&*0,2&";.%=!#$*!0*%"%&,.2*!:,%!,"(*(!@)!

I,09,0*&B%!*-1$,%"%!;.!*.2;'0,9".9!20"&"2,4!&$".5".9!".!0*%1;.%*%!&;!%&;0"*%!,.(!

;&$*0!2'00"2'4'-6!*/*.!:$*.!&$,&!-*,.&!0*,(M'%&".9!$*0!;:.!4*%%;.!14,.%=!!

I'2$!0;;-!:,%!-,(*!:"&$".!&$*!24,%%!A;0!("AA*0*.&!:,)%!;A!10;2*%%".9!

".A;0-,&";.!,.(!("AA*0*.&!4*,0.".9!%&)4*%=!C"%,@"4"&)!:,%!("%2'%%*(!:"&$;'&!;&$*0".96!

@'&!0,&$*0!&;!*.2;'0,9*!*,2$!2$"4(!&;!@*&&*0!'.(*0%&,.(!&$*-%*4/*%!,.(!&$*"0!;:.!

Page 223: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YU]!

!

.**(%!".!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!&$*"0!1**0%=!I,09,0*&!,4%;!("%2'%%*(!%&'(*.&%B!$;-*!4"/*%!".!

,!:,)!&$,&!:,%!-".(A'4!;A!1;&*.&",4!24,%%!("AA*0*.2*%!@*&:**.!%&'(*.&%=!#$*%*!

,110;,2$*%!:*0*!2;.%"%&*.&!:"&$!$*0!(*%"0*!&;!$,/*!$*0!24,%%0;;-!@*!,!%,A*!,.(!

10;('2&"/*!%1,2*!".!:$"2$!$*0!%&'(*.&%!2;'4(!4*,0.=!

b"&$".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!2'4&'0*6!%*2'4,0"J*(!b*%&*0.!.;0-%!:*0*!(;-".,.&=!

Q,2*!,.(!0,2"%-!:*0*!9*.*0,44)!.;&!("%2'%%*(=!b$"4*!>!;@%*0/*(!&$*!10*/,4*.2*!;A!

-,.)!(;-".,.&!.;0-%!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-6!I,09,0*&!,4%;!@0;'9$&!A;0:,0(!,/*.'*%!A;0!

20"&"2,4!*.9,9*-*.&=!H$*!A;2'%*(!;.!%&'(*.&%!9,".".9!,!%*.%*!;A!%*4AE,:,0*.*%%!,.(!

,AA"0-*(!&$*!"(*,%!,.(!*+1*0"*.2*%!&$*)!*+10*%%*(!&;!$*0=!#$*0*A;0*6!%&'(*.&%!:;'4(!

$,/*!$*0!'.:,/*0".9!%'11;0&!"A!&$*)!,40*,()!5.*:!$;:!&;!,0&"2'4,&*!"%%'*%!;A!0,2"%-!

;0!:*0*!,:,0*!&$,&!&$*)!$,(!(*1,0&*(!A0;-!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!>.!4"9$&!;A!

&$*!,@;/*!;/*0/"*:6!"&!"%!24*,0!&$,&!-)!A"*4(%&'()!;AA*0%!".%"9$&!".&;!A,2&;0%!&$,&!

*.&0*.2$!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!,%!:*44!,%!*+,-14*%!;A!&;;4%!&$,&!2;'4(!,%%"%&!".!

0*:;05".9!%,"(!.;0-%=!!

"@=><ZAE<?BJ$?_$0DJDAFZC$;<BY<BIJ$

I)!%&'()!'.(*0%2;0*%!%;-*!;A!&$*!".%&"&'&";.,4!.;0-%!,.(!*/*0)(,)!

10,2&"2*%!&$,&!2;;0(".,&*!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*!".!8".(*09,0&*.!@,%*(!;.!;@%*0/,&";.%6!

A;2'%!90;'1%!,.(!".&*0/"*:%!".!,!%2$;;4!".!?,.2;'/*06!FS!".!YVUY=!F*2,'%*!-)!%&'()!

(;*%!.;&!,%%'-*!,!'."/*0%,4!2"%9*.(*0!,.(!$*&*0;%*+',4!A'&'0*!A;0!,44!);'.9!1*;14*6!

>!:,%!:,0.*(!&$,&!"&!:;'4(!("AA"2'4&6!"A!.;&!"-1;%%"@4*6!&;!2;.('2&!"&!:"&$".!2'00*.&!

S,.,(",.!2'4&'0,4!24"-,&*!;A!1'@4"2!*('2,&";.=!>!$,/*!("%2'%%*(!$;:!&$*!2;.%&0'2&";.!

;A!2$"4($;;(!"..;2*.2*!@*2;-*%!,!%*4AE1*01*&',&".9!("%2;'0%*X!"&!"%!,09'*(!&$,&!

Page 224: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YUk!

!

2$"4(0*.!,0*!"..;2*.&6!"..;2*.2*!"%!2;.A4,&*(!:"&$!"9.;0,.2*!;A!L'**0!,.(!

&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&!1;%"&";.%6!&$*0*A;0*!&$*%*!%'@M*2&!1;%"&";.%!,0*!.;&!("%2'%%*(!".!

*/*0)(,)!4"A*=!b$*.!&$*0*!,0*!2$"4(0*.!:$;!,0*!&$*.!'.,:,0*!;A!"(*.&"&"*%!;'&%"(*!

&$*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!-,".%&0*,-6!&$"%!"%!'%*(!,%!*/"(*.2*!;A!&$*"0!

"..;2*.2*!,.(!,!0*,%;.!:$)!&$*)!-'%&!0*-,".!"9.;0,.&!;A!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!

1*;14*=!!

>!$,/*!20"&"2,44)!,.,4)%*(!,110;,2$*%!&;!,.&"E$;-;1$;@",!*('2,&";.!,.(!$;:!

&$*)!2,.!0*".A;02*!&$*!;&$*0".9!&$*)!1'01;0&!&;!,((0*%%=!F,.(E,"(!,110;,2$*%!&;!

$;-;1$;@",!2,.!$,/*!&$*!*AA*2&!;A!*L',&".9!L'**0.*%%!:"&$!$;-;1$;@",!;06!,%!a**!

D"0&;.!:0"&*%!".!Na*,/*!o#$;%*!8"(%B!D4;.*6O!NL'**0.*%%!@*2;-*%!"&2&J"&/)#d!3Uf7=!

#$*!*AA*2&%!;A!&$"%!:*0*!(*-;.%&0,&*(!".!-)!A"*4(:;05!:$*.!@*".9!9,)!:,%!(*A".*(!

%"-'4&,.*;'%4)!:"&$!$;-;1$;@",=!\'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!,%!1*0%;.,4!

*+10*%%";.%6!,%!1,0&!;A!0"2$!2;'.&*0E2'4&'0*%6!;0!,%!2,00)".9!1;:*0A'4!$"%&;0"*%!:*0*!

&$*.!4;%&!,%!L'**0.*%%!/,+#2,($;-;1$;@",!,.(!&$*!$;-;1$;@"2!".&*0/*.&";.!

1;%"&";.*(!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!1*;14*!,%!;&$*0=!!

\'**0.*%%!:,%!4,@*4*(!,%!N("AA*0*.&O!,.(!&$"%!("AA*0*.2*!:,%!,'&;-,&"2,44)!

1,"0*(!:"&$!A*,0!,.(!&$*!&$0*,&!;A!/";4*.2*!32;.&0,%&*(!&;!D@"9,"4B%!1;%"&";.".9!@*".9!

("AA*0*.&!".!20*,&"/*!:,)%!&$,&!:*0*!M;)A'4!,.(!@0;'9$&!A0"*.(%$"176!&$'%!A'0&$*0!

*.&0*.2$".9!&$*!10"/"4*9*(!90;'1B%!1;:*0!&;!(*2"(*!$;:!&$*!;&$*0!:,%!&0*,&*(=!#;!

10*%*.&!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!%;4*4)!".!&$*!2;.&*+&!;A!@'44)".9!

2;.%&0'2&%!&$*!@'44"*(!L'**0!;0!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&=!S;.%*L'*.&4)6!%'2$!,.&"E

@'44)".9!("%2;'0%*!2,.!A,2"4"&,&*!$;-;1$;@"2!,.(!&0,.%1$;@"2!;&$*0".9!,.(!4*,/*!

Page 225: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YUi!

!

(;-".,.&!1;:*0!$"*0,02$"*%!".&,2&=!!H'2$!$"*0,02$"*%!.;0-,4"J*!N2;-".9!;'&O!,%!,!

1,".A'46!%;2",44)!"%;4,&".9!*+1*0"*.2*6!&$'%!'.(*0-".".9!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!A;0!L'**0!;0!

&0,.%9*.(*0!"(*.&"A"2,&";.%!&;!@*!24,"-*(!,%!20*,&"/*!%*4AE*+10*%%";.!;0!*/*.!,.!

;0(".,0)!1,0&!;A!%*4AE,:,0*.*%%=!!

#$*0*!*+"%&!,4&*0.,&*!-;(*4%!A;0!2;.2*1&',4"J".9!2$"4(0*.B%!,9*.2)!,.(!

.*9;&",&";.!;A!"(*.&"&)!,.(!2$,.9*=!#$*0*!:*0*!*('2,&;0%!".!-)!A"*4(%&'()!:$;!

:;05*(!&;!A,2"4"&,&*!%1,2*!A;06!,.(!/,4"(,&*!2$"4(0*.!,%6!2;-1*&*.&!,.(!

5.;:4*(9*,@4*=!#$"%!A;2'%6!:*0*!"&!2;-@".*(!:"&$!".&*90,&".9!L'**0!,.(!

&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!".&;!&$*!*/*0)(,)!".%&"&'&";.,4!4"A*6!$;4(%!&$*!1;&*.&",4!A;0!

10;A;'.(!%;2",4!2$,.9*=!!

#HIIDJE<?BJ$_?F$:CABID$$

I)!0*%*,02$!*+*-14"A"*%!$;:!*,04)!2$"4($;;(!*('2,&";.!"-,9".*%!"&%*4A!,%!

.*'&0,4!3;0!(*/;"(!;A!%*+',4"&)7!:$"4*!"&!,2&"/*4)!2;.%&0'2&%!9*.(*0!2;.A;0-".96!

$*&*0;%*+',4"&)!,%!&$*!;.4)!:,)!&;!,2$"*/*!%;2",4!@*4;.9".9!,.(!4"/*!,!4"A*!:;0&$!

4"/".9=!F0".9".9!,@;'&!%;2",4!2$,.9*!0*9,0(".9!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!

0*L'"0*%!,!%$"A&!".!$;:!*,04)!2$"4($;;(!*('2,&";.!*./"%";.%!"&%*4A=!

#$*!A;44;:".9!%*2&";.!10;1;%*%!$;:!*/*0)(,)!4"A*!".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4%!2;'4(!

14,)!;'&!".!:,)%!&$,&!,44;:!0;;-!A;0!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!2$"4(0*.=!#$*%*!

0*2;--*.(,&";.%!(*1*.(!;.!10,2&"2,4!,.(!2;.2*1&',4!:;05!A;0!2'4&'0,4!2$,.9*=!h;0!

*+,-14*6!:$"4*!10*%*.&".9!10;.;'.!2$;"2*%!:"&$".!.;0-,&"/*!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*%!-,)!

@*!@;&$!/,4',@4*!,.(!10,2&"2,46!:"&$;'&!:;05!&;!%$"A&!&$*!2;.2*1&',4!-*,.".9%!-,(*!

,0;'.(!9*.(*0!20;%%".9!;0!&$*!%*2;.(,0)!%&,&'%!;A!:$,&!"%!(**-*(!A*-".".*6!%'2$!

Page 226: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YUZ!

!

2$;"2*%!:;'4(!%&"44!@*!A0,'9$&=!!h;0!&$*!1'01;%*!;A!2;.2"%";.6!>!$,/*!;09,."J*(!

0*2;--*.(,&";.%!A;0!2$,.9*!".&;!&$*!A;44;:".9!A;'0!2,&*9;0"*%X!1$"4;%;1$)j!

%&0'2&'0,4!2$,.9*j!1*(,9;9)!,.(!2'00"2'4'-j!,.(!10;A*%%";.,4!(*/*4;1-*.&=!!!

VC<>?J?=C9,$:CA>>DBI<BI$ECD$4?H8>D$#EABYAFY$ABY$0DZ?IB<c<BI$

:C<>YFDBdJ$'IDBZ9$$

I)!;@%*0/,&";.%!,.(!A;2'%!90;'1%!10;/"(*(!-,.)!*+,-14*%!;A!:,)%!

8".(*09,0&*.!2$"4(0*.!,0*!&$".5".9!,@;'&!&$*!9*.(*0*(!"-14"2,&";.%!;A!0*4,&";.%$"1%!

,.(!&$*"0!;:.!"(*.&"&"*%=!K.*!%"-14*6!)*&!10;A;'.(6!,110;,2$!&;!%;2",4!2$,.9*!"%!&;!

,25.;:4*(9*!&$,&!%&'(*.&%!,0*!(*,4".9!:"&$!2;-14"2,&*(!0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!,&&0,2&";.6!

1;:*06!,.(!"(*.&"&)!A0;-!,!);'.9!,9*=!F*2,'%*!2$"4(0*.!,0*!&$".5".9!,@;'&!,.(!

".&*0,2&".9!:"&$!"(*,%!0*9,0(".9!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4"&)6!,25.;:4*(9".9!,.(!&,45".9!

,@;'&!,!0,.9*!;A!9*.(*0%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%!,%!1,0&!;A!*/*0)(,)!4"A*!@*2;-*%!,!20"&"2,4!

%&*1!&;:,0(!*.(".9!&$*!(;'@4*!%&,.(,0(!:$"2$!".24'(*%!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!

,%!,.!,22*1&,@4*!1,0&!;A!*/*0)(,)!2'00"2'4'-6!@'&!2,&*9;0"J*%!L'**0!,.(!

&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!,%!%*+',44)!".,110;10",&*=!#$*!0*2;9."&";.!;A!&$*!

2;-14*+"&)!;A!2$"4(0*.B%!%;2",4!4"/*%!,4%;!%"&',&*%!2$"4(0*.!,%!%;2",4!,2&;0%!:$;!2,.!

9*.*0,&*!20*,&"/*!,.(!20"&"2,4!,110;,2$*%!&;!,((0*%%".9!%;2",4!10;@4*-%!,.(!

,110;,2$*%!&;!%;2",4!2$,.9*=!!

#EFHZEHFA>$:CABIDJ,$(AECF??@J$ABY$VF?B?HBJ$

b;05".9!,9,".%&!&$*!(;'@4*E%&,.(,0(!0*L'"0*%!2$,.9*!".!*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%6!

%;-*!;A!:$"2$!,0*!*,%"*0!&;!%$"A&!&$,.!;&$*0%!(*1*.(".9!;.!&$*!4*/*4!;A!%&0'2&'0,4!

,.(!".%&"&'&";.,4!@,00"*0%!A,2*(!@)!".("/"(',4%!:;05".9!A;0!2$,.9*=!H&'(*.&%!$*,0!"&!

Page 227: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YUW!

!

0*1*,&*(!*/*0)(,)!&$,&!&$*)!,0*!N@;)%O!,.(!N9"04%=O!R('2,&".9!,9,".%&!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-,&"/"&)!0*L'"0*%!%"-"4,0!0*1*&"&";.!&$,&!.;&!*/*0);.*!"%!;.*!;0!&$*!;&$*0=!>!

0*2;--*.(!&$*!"-14*-*.&,&";.!;A!24,%%0;;-!("%2'%%";.%!&$,&!".&0;('2*!&$*!"(*,!

&$,&!".("/"(',4%!2,.!(*2"(*!A;0!&$*-%*4/*%!"A!&$*)!,0*!@;)%6!9"04%6!@;&$6!;0!.*"&$*0!,.(!

:$"2$!,44;:!".("/"(',4%!&;!2$;%*!&$*"0!10*A*00*(!10;.;'.%=!I,.)!2'4&'0*%!0*2;9."J*!

-;0*!&$,.!&:;!9*.(*0%=!#;!2$,44*.9*!&$*!(;-".,.2*!;A!b*%&*0.!2'4&'0,4!

'.(*0%&,.(".9%!0*9,0(".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)6!>!,(/;2,&*!&$,&!*('2,&;0%!

(0,:!A0;-!&$*!*+1*0&"%*!;A!".("/"(',4%!A0;-!0,.9*!;A!2'4&'0,4!@,2590;'.(%!:$;!2,.!

%1*,5!&;!/,0"*(!2'4&'0,4!,110;,2$*%!&;!9*.(*0!("/*0%"&)=!!

R/*0)(,)!2;./*0%,&";.%!,@;'&6!,.(!*+,-14*%!;A6!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!

%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!A;0-!,.!"-1;0&,.&!@,%"%!A0;-!:$"2$!&;!("%2'%%!".%&"&'&";.,4!.;0-%6!

%'2$!,%!9*.(*0!%*90*9,&*(!:,%$0;;-%=!#$*!-*%%,9*!&$,&!%;-*&$".9!"%!:0;.9!:$*.!

,!1*0%;.!(;*%!.;&!,11*,0!("%2*0.,@4)!9*.(*0*(!,%!-,4*!;0!A*-,4*!-,)!@*!90*,&4)!

0*('2*(!&$0;'9$!"-14*-*.&".9!9*.(*0E.*'&0,4!:,%$0;;-%=!#$*!".%&"&'&";.,4!

%&0'2&'0*%!&$,&!%*90*9,&*!@,&$0;;-%!A0;-!&$*!;.%*&!;A!2$"4(0*.B%!*('2,&";.,4!

*+1*0"*.2*%!-,)!1*0%"%&!:"&$".!%;-*!".%&"&'&";.%=!>.!%'2$!2,%*%6!20"&"2,4!(",4;9'*!"%!

.*2*%%,0)!&;!2;-*!'1!:"&$!20*,&"/*!%;4'&";.%!;0!,2&"/"%&!0*%1;.%*%!&;!&$*!:,)!&$"%!

".A0,%&0'2&'0*!"%!5.;:.!&;!$,/*!(*&0"-*.&,4!*AA*2&%!;.!,!/,0";'%!1*;14*B%!4"/*%=!!

VDYAI?I9$ABY$:HFF<ZH>H@$

G"2&'0*@;;5%!;A&*.!A;0-!&$*!@'45!;A!%&0'2&'0*(!2'00"2'4'-!".!8".(*09,0&*.=!#$*!

2$"4(0*.!10;M*2&*(!&$*-%*4/*%!".&;!&$*!%&;0"*%6!1,0&"2'4,04)!:$*.!&$*!10;&,9;."%&!

$,(!,!9*.(*0!:"&$!:$"2$!&$*)!&$*-%*4/*%!"(*.&"A)=!#$'%6!(0,:".9!A0;-!,!:"(*!0,.9*!

Page 228: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YYV!

!

;A!10;&,9;."%&%B!(*1"2&";.%!;A!9*.(*0%!,.(!%*+',4"&"*%!A,2"4"&,&*%!,!:"(*0!0,.9*!;A!

2$"4(0*.B%!,@"4"&"*%!&;!"-,9".*!&$*-%*4/*%!".&;!%&;0"*%!,.(!&$'%!20*,&"/*4)!&$".5!

,@;'&!&$*"0!4"/*%!,.(!1;&*.&",4!A'&'0*%=!I,09,0*&B%!-;(*4!;A!,%5".9!20"&"2,4!L'*%&";.%!

:$*.!0*,(".9!1"2&'0*!@;;5%!,AA;0(*(!0;;-!A;0!24,%%0;;-!("%2'%%";.%!&$,&!

2$,44*.9*(!%;-*!1;&*.&",44)!%'@&4*!-*%%,9*%!*-@*((*(!".!&$*!%&;0"*%=!D9,".6!>!

,(/;2,&*!'&"4"J".9!&$"%!-;(*4!&;!*+14"2"&4)!2$,44*.9*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)=!

#$*!4,09*0!24,%%0;;-!%1,2*!:,%!A"44*(!:"&$!&;)%6!9,-*%6!,.(!4*,0.".9!,2&"/"&"*%=!

C'0".9!*/*0)(,)!".&*0,2&";.%!,0;'.(!&$*!24,%%0;;-6!I,09,0*&B%!:;05!A;2'%*(!;.!

&*,2$".9!A;0!".("/"(',4%6!0,&$*0!&$,.!&*,2$".9!A;0!9*.(*0*(!%&*0*;&)1*%X!*=9=6!%$*!("(!

.;&!@0*,5!&$*!%&'(*.&%!'1!".&;!90;'1%!;A!@;)%!/*0%'%!9"04%6!%$*!%&0*%%*(!&$,&!,44!&$*!

&;)%!,.(!@;;5%!:*0*!A;0!*/*0);.*6!,.(!*.2;'0,9*(!2$"4(0*.!&;!"./"&*!("AA*0*.&!

24,%%-,&*%!&;!14,)!:"&$!&;)%!&$,&!&$*)!("(.B&!'%',44)!14,)!:"&$=!H'2$!*AA;0&%!$*41!".!

20*,&".9!%1,2*!:$*0*!2$"4(0*.!2,.!@*!("AA*0*.&!A0;-!*,2$!;&$*0!,.(!.;&!$,/*!&$*"0!

".&*0*%&%!,.(!%5"44!(*/*4;1-*.&!0*%&0"2&*(!@)!10*2;.2*"/*(!.;&";.%!;A!:$,&!&$*)!:"44!

4"5*!,.(!$;:!&$*)!:"44!4*,0.=!

VF?_DJJ<?BA>$4DPD>?=@DBE$ABY$VAFDBEA>$/YHZAE<?B$

>.!;0(*0!&;!-,5*!"&!1;%%"@4*!&;!2$,44*.9*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)6!

*('2,&;0%!.**(!&;!@*!*L'"11*(!&;!".2;01;0,&*!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!

".&;!*/*0)(,)!2'00"2'4'-!,.(!24,%%0;;-!2;./*0%,&";.%=!RL'"11".9!&*,2$*0%!&$'%!

0*L'"0*%!2$,.9*%!&;!&*,2$*0!,.(!,(-"."%&0,&;0!*('2,&";.!10;90,-%!,.(!10;A*%%";.,4!

(*/*4;1-*.&!:;05%$;1%=!H'2$!&*,2$".9!,.(!,(-"."%&0,&";.!*('2,&";.!10;90,-%!

2;'4(!&$*.!@'"4(!,:,0*.*%%!;A!$;:!%*+',4"&)!,.(!9*.(*0!,0*!&,5*.!'1!".!*/*0)(,)!

Page 229: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YYU!

!

4"A*!".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4!,.(!$;:!&$*%*!.;0-%!1*01*&',&*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!

%2$;;4!2'4&'0*%=!>!0*2;--*.(!&$,&!%'2$!2;'0%*:;05!,4%;!@'"4(!&$*!%&'(*.&%B!%5"44%!".!

'%".9!.;.!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!4,.9',9*!,.(!10;/"(*!0*%;'02*%!&;!,%%"%&!".!

4*,0.".9!:,)%!&;!("%2'%%!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!4"/*%6!$"%&;0"*%6!,.(!2;'.&*0E

2'4&'0*%=!>!,(/;2,&*!&$,&!%'2$!2;'0%*:;05!,.(!10;A*%%";.,4!(*/*4;1-*.&!"./;4/*!

@'"4(".9!,:,0*.*%%!:"&$!1,0*.&%6!9',0(",.%6!,.(!&$*!4,09*0!2;--'."&)=!H2$;;4!

("%&0"2&%!:"&$!10;90*%%"/*!1;4"2"*%!,0*!:*44E1;%"&";.*(!&;!10;/"(*!*('2,&";.!;A!&$*!

,2&',4!:;05!0*L'"0*(!&;!@0".9!".24'%";.!,.(!*L'"&)!1;4"2"*%!A0;-!&$*"0!*+"%&*.2*%!

;.4)!,%!:0"&&*.!(;2'-*.&%!&;!*AA*2&".9!2$,.9*!;.!&$*!90;'.(!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%=!

G,0*.&,4!*('2,&";.!"%!&,.&,-;'.&!".!;0(*0!&;!-;@"4"J*!1;4"2)!%;!&$,&!"&!(;*%!.;&!M'%&!

&,5*!14,2*!".!0*4,&";.%$"1!&;!/";4*.2*6!;0!".!4,&*0!90,(*%6!@'&!".%&*,(!A,2"4"&,&*%!

@'"4(".9!%,A*0!*('2,&";.,4!".%&"&'&";.%!A0;-!&$*!;.%*&!;A!1'@4"2!%2$;;4!4"A*=!!

'FDAJ$_?F$;HFECDF$0DJDAFZC$

Q*%*,02$!0*9,0(".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!".!*,04)!10"-,0)!%2$;;4!"%!,.!

*-*09".9!,0*.,!;A!%2$;4,0%$"1=!D4&$;'9$!&$"%!%&'()!-,5*%!,.!"-1;0&,.&!

2;.&0"@'&";.!&;!&$*!4"&*0,&'0*6!&$*0*!"%!-'2$!0;;-!A;0!A'0&$*0!0*%*,02$=!#$*!

A;44;:".9!*+,-14*%!,0*!@'&!,!A*:!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!;A!:$"2$!&$*0*!,0*!-,.)!;&$*0%=!#$*!

A"*4(!:;'4(!@*!:*44!%*0/*(!@)X!!

• 0*%*,02$!2;.('2&*(!@)!%2$;4,0%!:$;!,0*!.;&!:$"&*!,.(!:$;!,0*!.;&!

2"%9*.(*0j!

• 0*%*,02$!".&;!@,00"*0%!20*,&*(!@)!0,2"%-!;.!&$*!1,0&!;A!:$"&*!L'**0!,.(!

&0,.%9*.(*0!,2&"/"%&%!,.(!:;05!&;!2$,44*.9*!@;&$!&$*!@,00"*0%!,.(!0,2"%-%j!

Page 230: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YYY!

!

• 0*%*,02$!&$,&!"./*%&"9,&*%!A'0&$*0!"-14"2,&";.%!;A!("%2;'0%*%!;A!"..;2*.2*!!

• 0*%*,02$!&$,&!(;2'-*.&%!&$*!"-14*-*.&,&";.!;A!%'99*%&";.%!A;0!2$,.9*!

@0;'9$&!A;0:,0(!".!&$"%!%&'()j!

• 0*%*,02$!&$,&!A;2'%*%!;.!&$*!0*4,&";.%$"1%!@*&:**.!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*%!,.(!4,09*0!

2'4&'0,4!2;.&*+&%!3*=9=!A,-"4"*%6!14,2*%!;A!:;0%$"16!,.(!%;!;.7!

D%!>!$,/*!%&,&*(6!-)!%"&',&*(.*%%!4"5*4)!0*%'4&*(!".!("AA*0*.&!0*%*,02$!0*%'4&%!

A0;-!&$;%*!A;'.(!,.(!,0&"2'4,&*(!@)!%;-*;.*!:"&$!,!("AA*0*.&!$"%&;0)=!#$*!

%*4*2&";.%!A0;-!-)!(,&,!A;0!".24'%";.!$*0*".!A*44!&;!-)!M'(9-*.&!,%!,!0*%*,02$*0=!

#$*!;/*0:$*4-".9!-,M;0"&)!;A!%2$;4,0%!".!&$"%!A"*4(!,0*!:$"&*!,.(!&$*0*A;0*!4,25!

".&"-,&*!5.;:4*(9*!;A!A,-"4)!A;0-,&";.!,.(!2'4&'0,4!10,2&"2*%!5.;:.!@)!&$;%*!;A!

-)0",(!;&$*0!*&$."2"&"*%!10*%*.&!".!?,.2;'/*0!%2$;;4%=!>&!"%!;A&*.!*,%)!A;0!:$"&*!

%2$;4,0%!,.(!,2&"/"%&%!&;!@*!'.,:,0*!;A!2'4&'0,44)!,110;10",&*!,.(!-*,.".9A'4!:,)%!

&;!2$,44*.9*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!!)$")*!,.(!-&.!("AA*0".9!2'4&'0*%=!S'00*.&4)6!

&$*0*!"%!,4%;!,!(*,0&$!;A!0*%*,02$!0*9,0(".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!".!1'@4"2!

%2$;;4%!2;.('2&*(!@)!&0,.%9*.(*0!".("/"(',4%=!#$*%*!&*.(*.2"*%!%1*,5!&;!%)%&*-"2!

@,00"*0%!A,2*(!@)!&0,.%9*.(*0!1*;14*!,.(!1*;14*!;A!2;4;'0!:"&$".!*('2,&";.,4!

".%&"&'&";.%=!I;0*;/*06!&$"%!4,25!10"/"4*9*%!&$*!:;05!;A!&$;%*!:"&$!-;0*!1;:*0!&;!

%1*,5!;.!@*$,4A!;A!&$;%*!-,09".,4"J*(!:"&$".!(;-".,.&!9*.(*0*(!,.(!0,2",4"J*(!

$"*0,02$"*%=!!

>.!,2&"/"%-!&;!2$,44*.9*!$;-;1$;@",!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%6!&$*0*!"%!,!&*.(*.2)!A;0!

:$"&*!(;-".,&*(6!L'**0!10*%%!&;!0,2",4"J*!,.&"E9,)!1;4"&"2%=!#$"%!&0*.(!:,%!

1,0&"2'4,04)!*/"(*.&!".!&$*!YVUU!2,%*!;A!F'0.,@)!H2$;;4!F;,0(B%!,(;1&";.!;A!,.&"E

Page 231: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YYf!

!

$;-;1$;@",!,.(!,.&"E$*&*0;%*+"%-!1;4"2)=!#$;%*!;11;%".9!&$*!1;4"2)!:*0*!;A&*.!

0,2",4"J*(!".!.*:%!0*1;0&".9!,%!N-;%&4)!D%",.6O!:$"4*!&$*!10*%*.2*!;A!10;E9,)!1*;14*!

;A!2;4;'0!:*.&!'.0*1;0&*(=[i!!b$"4*!&$"%!:,%!.;&!,!-,."A*%&,&";.!;A!0,2"%-!&$,&!:,%!

*/"(*.2*(!".!-)!A"*4(:;056!A'0&$*0!%&'("*%!&$,&!%1*2"A"2,44)!*+14;0*!2$,44*.9*%!&;!

%'2$!0,2",4"J,&";.!:;'4(!@*!@*.*A"2",4=!H"-"4,04)6!*('2,&;0%!".&*0/"*:*(!".!&$*!

^*.(*0!S0*,&"/*!8"(%!G0;M*2&!"(*.&"A"*(!&$*!(;-".,.2*!;A!:$"&*!%&'(*.&%!".!^,)E

H&0,"9$&!D44",.2*%=!#$*!:$"&*!".&*0/"*:**%!"(*.&"A"*(!&$"%!,%!('*!&;!".20*,%*(!

$;-;1$;@",!".!N"--"90,.&O!1;1'4,&";.%!3I*)*07=!>.!,(("&";.!&;!&$*!10;@4*-,&"2!

2;.A4,&";.!;A!.;.E:$"&*!1;1'4,&";.%!,%!N"--"90,.&%O!,.(!:$"&*!1;1'4,&";.%!,%!

2"&"J*.%6!&$"%!A0,-".9!(;*%!4"&&4*!&;!"./*%&"9,&*!$;:!0,2"%-!,-;.9%&!:$"&*!^HD!

-*-@*0%!2;'4(!A;0-!,!@,00"*0!A;0!.;.E:$"&*!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%&'(*.&%=!b,)%!

&;!@'"4(!%&0;.9*0!,.&"E0,2"%&!,110;,2$*%!&;!2$,44*.9".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!

".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!0*-,".%!,.!"-1;0&,.&!%"&*!A;0!A'0&$*0!%2$;4,0%$"1!,.(!,2&";.=!!

^"/*.!&$*!*-*09".9!.,&'0*!;A!&$"%!,0*.,!;A!%&'()6!?3(?$(I$)66(#(F&=Y(,"-%!&;!24,0"A)!

A,2&;0%!&$,&!*%&,@4"%$!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!2'4&'0*!".!*,04)!10"-,0)!%2$;;4=!H'2$!

'.(*0%&,.(".9!10;/"(*%!'%*A'4!4,.9',9*!A;0!&$;%*!%**5".9!&;!2;'.&*0!.;&";.%!&$,&!

L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!2;00'1&!2$"4(0*.!,.(!2$"4($;;(=!!

#$*!2;.2*1&',4"J,&";.!;A!2$"4($;;(!"..;2*.2*!$,(!%"9."A"2,.&!A;2'%!:"&$".!

-)!0*%*,02$=!#$"%!A;2'%!2*.&*0*(!;.!&$*!(;'@4*E%&,.(,0(!@*&:**.!:$,&!"%!%**.!,%!

"..;2*.&!,.(!,%*+',4!,.(!:$,&!"%!%*+',4"J*(!,.(!%**.!,%!2;00'1&".9!&$"%!"..;2*.2*=!>!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[i$&&1X<<:::=+&0,=2,<1'@4"2<?,.2;'/*0<K11;.*.&%n1,25nF'0.,@)n%2$;;4n@;,0(n

-**&".9EUVViZ=,%1+!

Page 232: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YY[!

!

$,/*!&,5*.!'1!&$"%!1,0&"2'4,0!2;.%&0'2&";.!;A!"..;2*.2*6!@,%*(!;.!$;:!"&!-,."A*%&*(!

".!-)!0*%*,02$=!b"&$".!-)!%&'()!&$"%!(;'@4*E%&,.(,0(!0*".A;02*(!@;&$!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!@)!*0,%".9!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!A0;-!

*/*0)(,)!4"A*!,.(!@)!0*".A;02".9!(;-".,.&!9*.(*0!1;:*0!().,-"2%!".!&*0-%!;A!-,4*!

1$)%"2,4!1;:*0!,.(!2;.&0;4=!h'0&$*0!0*%*,02$!2;'4(!'.*,0&$!;&$*0!9*.(*0*(!,.(!

0,2",4"J*(!"-14"2,&";.%!*-@*((*(!".!2;.%&0'2&";.%!;A!2$"4($;;(!"..;2*.2*=[Z!#$"%!

2;'4(!".24'(*!&,@;;%!,0;'.(!2$"4(0*.B%!*+10*%%";.%!;A!%*+',4"&)!3*=9=!-,%&'0@,&";.7!

,.(!,4%;!9*.(*0*(!("2$;&;-"*%!@*&:**.!10;-"%2'"&)!,.(!"..;2*.2*!".!);'.9!

2$"4(0*.=!h;0!*+,-14*6!A'0&$*0!0*%*,02$!2;'4(!*+14;0*!:,)%!9"04%!(**-*(!

10;-"%2';'%!,0*!2;.%&0'2&*(!,%!,!&$0*,&!&;!@;)%!,.(!&*,2$*0%=!T;:!9"04%!:$;!$,/*!

N4;%&O!&$*"0!"..;2*.2*!2,.!%'@%*L'*.&4)!@*!$*4(!0*%1;.%"@4*!A;0!%*+',4!,%%,'4&!"%!,.!

,0*.,!&$,&!:;'4(!@*.*A"&!A0;-!A'0&$*0!"./*%&"9,&";.!,&!,!10"-,0)!%2$;;4!4*/*4=[W!!

#$*!A;2'%!:"&$".!-)!0*%*,02$!:,%!@,%*(!;.!:$,&!:,%!,2&',44)!$,11*.".9!

:"&$".!-)!A"*4(%&'()=!D%!,.!"."&",4!%&'()!;A!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!".!&$*!

8".(*09,0&*.6!-)!%&'()!A;2'%*(!;.!&$*!*/*.&%!,%!&$*)!&;;5!14,2*!:"&$".!&$*!%2$;;4!

"&%*4A=!b$,&!:,%!$,11*.".9!:"&$".!&$*!%2$;;4!("(!.;&!&,5*!14,2*!".!"%;4,&";.!A0;-!

;&$*0!2'4&'0,4!.;0-%=!R,2$!2$"4(!".!&$*!24,%%!:,%!1,0&!;A!A,-"4"*%!:"&$!&$*"0!;:.!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Z!Q;@".!F*0%&*".!A0'"&A'44)!*+14;0*%!&$*!$"%&;0"2,4!0,2",4!"-14"2,&";.%!2;.%&0'2&";.%!

;A!2$"4($;;(!"..;2*.2*!".!,.!D-*0"2,.!2;.&*+&!".!$*0!:;056!5#+)#6)Q,%(?**&+,*+,;(

A,.-&.2)*9(<2,.)+#*(>")6%"&&%(-.&2(I6#W,.=($&(>)W)6(5)9"$3'(![WH2$;4,0%!%'2$!,%!I*4,."*!Q*.(*44!,.(!a"%*!^;&*44!*+,-".*!$;:!4*9,4!10;2*%%*%!

2;.%&0'2&!N"(*,46O!;0!@*4"*/,@4*6!A*-,4*!,%%,'4&!/"2&"-%!,%!"..;2*.&!:$"4*!:;-*.!

:$;!,0*!2;.%&0'2&*(!,%!;&$*0:"%*!N10;-"%2';'%O!,0*!(**-*(!(*%*0/".9!;A!,.(!

0*%1;.%"@4*!A;0!&$*"0!,%%,'4&%=!b$"4*!&$*!%'@M*2&!;A!A*-"."%&!2;.2*0.6!-;0*!0*%*,02$!

2;'4(!*+14;0*!:,)%!10"-,0)!%2$;;4!("%2;'0%*%!;A!"..;2*.2*!1,0&"2"1,&*%!".!

0*%1;.%"@"4"J".9!9"04%!A;0!,%%,'4&=!!

Page 233: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YY]!

!

-*(",!2;.%'-1&";.6!14,2*%!;A!:;0%$"16!1;4"&"2,4!;0"*.&,&";.%6!,.(!;&$*0!2'4&'0,4!

A,2&;0%!&$,&!".A4'*.2*(!&$*!*/*.&%!>!;@%*0/*(=!D!@*.*A"2",4!,0*,!A;0!A'0&$*0!0*%*,02$!

:;'4(!*+14;0*!*/*0)(,)!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!2'4&'0*!".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4!:"&$!,.!

".20*,%*(!A;2'%!;.!%&'(*.&%B!A,-"4",4!,.(!%;2";E2'4&'0,4!4"/*%=!!

b"&$".!&$*!%2;1*!;A!&$"%!%&'()6!&$*0*!:,%!,-14*!(,&,!&;!"44'%&0,&*!*/*0)(,)!

10,2&"2*%!&$,&!0;'&"."J*!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!,.(!;&$*0*(!L'**0!,.(!

&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%=!h0;-!&$*!,.,4)%"%!10*%*.&*(!:"&$".!&$"%!%&'()6!>!$,/*!

10;/"(*(!;/*0/"*:%!;A!1;%%"@4*!&0,M*2&;0"*%!A;0!%;2",4!2$,.9*=!F,%*(!;.!&$"%6!A'&'0*!

0*%*,02$!2;'4(!1"4;&!10;M*2&%!&;!"-14*-*.&!2$,.9*%!,.(!,%%*%%!&$*"0!*AA"2,2)!A;0!

0*('2".9!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!".!*/*0)(,)!4"A*!".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4!24,%%0;;-%=!

#$"%!2;'4(!".24'(*!2'00"2'4'-!&$,&!".&*.&";.,44)!:;/*!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!

%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!".&;!("/*0%*!%'@M*2&!,0*,%!10*%*.&*(!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!>&!2;'4(!,4%;!

".24'(*!1"4;&".9!2;'0%*%!".!&*,2$*0!*('2,&";.!10;90,-%!&$,&!A;2'%!;.!%'2$!

".&*90,&";.!".!10"-,0)!&*,2$*0B%!*/*0)(,)!:;05!,.(!&$*"0!*AA*2&!;.!&*,2$".9!

10,2&"2*%!,.(!24,%%0;;-%=!I)!%&'()!10;/"(*%!*/"(*.2*!;A!&$*!10*%*.2*!;A!

$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!".!8".(*09,0&*.=!>.!,(("&";.6!-)!;@%*0/,&";.%!;A!:$,&!

2$"4(0*.!,0*!(;".9!,.(!%,)".9!".!&$*"0!*/*0)(,)!4"/*%!:"&$".!&$*!%2$;;4!2;.&*+&!

%'99*%&!1;%%"@4*!*AA*2&%!;A!%'2$!.;0-%=!D%!%'2$6!&$"%!%&'()!10;/"(*%!90;'.(:;05!&$,&!

*.,@4*%!%;-*!;A!&$*!,@;/*!,0*,%!;A!A'0&$*0!0*%*,02$=!!

;<BA>$%C?HICEJ$

D%!>!:0"&*!&$"%6!D(,-!Q;@*0&%6!,!9,)!&**.!".!P*:!F0'.%:"256!"%!,&&*-1&".9!&;!

9,".!("%&0"2&!,.(!9;/*0.-*.&,4!%'11;0&!&;!$*41!$"-!*.(!$;-;1$;@",!".!$"%!%2$;;4=!

Page 234: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YYk!

!

F)!$"%!,22;'.&%6!$"%!(,)E&;E(,)!4"A*!".!%2$;;4!"%!'.@*,0,@4*!,.(!4*(!&;!$"%!%'"2"(*!

,&&*-1&%=!#$*!.*:%!,.2$;06!C,/"(!F*446!0*1;0&*(!&$,&!D(,-!Q;@*0&%!$,(!@**.!

'.,@4*!&;!N%**!,!A'&'0*!:"&$!$"-%*4A!".!"&O!3Y!I,)!YVUf7=!!#$"%!%'22".2&!%*.&"-*.&!

%1*,5%!&;!$;:!1;:*0A'44)!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/"&)!2,.!4"-"&!".("/"(',4%B!,@"4"&"*%!

&;!"-,9".*!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!A;0!&$*"0!;:.!4"/*%=!b$*.!*+,-".".9!&$*!0*%'4&%!;A!-)!

A"*4(%&'()6!"&!"%!.;&!$,0(!&;!%**!$;:!&$"%!2,.!@*!&$*!2,%*=!C'0".9!-)!;@%*0/,&";.%6!

2$"4(0*.!:$;!2;'4(!10;M*2&!&$*-%*4/*%!".&;!,!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!.;0-,&"/*!A'&'0*!%,:!

(,"4)!0*A4*2&";.%!;A!1;%%"@"4"&"*%!;A!4"/*%!;A!4;/*6!A,-"4)6!,(/*.&'0*%6!,.(!

0*4,&";.%$"1%j!:$*0*,%6!&$;%*!:$;!-"9$&!'.(*0%&,.(!&$*-%*4/*%!&;!@*!L'**0!;0!

&0,.%9*.(*0!;.4)!*.2;'.&*0*(!;.*!0*A*0*.2*!&;!&$*"0!%'@M*2&!1;%"&";.%!,.(!&$,&!:,%!

".!0*A*0*.2*!&;!1;&*.&",44)!*+1*0"*.2".9!/";4*.2*=!#$*!?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!F;,0(!$,%!

$,(!10;90*%%"/*!1;4"2"*%!".!14,2*!0*9,0(".9!9*.(*0!,.(!%*+',4!("/*0%"&)!%".2*!UWWi=!

T;:*/*06!&$0;'9$!,!&,1*%&0)!;A!2'4&'0,4!.;0-%6!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!%'@M*2&"/"&"*%!

,0*!0*4*9,&*(!&;!@*".9!&$*!%'@M*2&%!;A!@'44)".96!0,&$*0!&$,.!@*".9!".&*90,&*(!".&;!

*/*0)(,)!4"A*!,.(!%'@%*L'*.&4)!".&;!1;%"&";.%!A0;-!:$"2$!&;!@'"4(!,!4"A*=!

h;0&'.,&*4)6!(*1"2&".9!L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!4"/*%!,%!@4*,5!,.(!A'44!;A!

@'44)".9!(;*%!.;&!.**(!&;!2;.&".'*=!S;.2*1&',4"J,&";.%!;A!2$"4($;;(!"..;2*.2*!,.(!

%*+',4!("AA*0*.2*!$,/*!@**.!1,0&!;A!&$*!-*2$,."%-%!&$,&!.,&'0,4"J*!2;-".9!;'&!,%!,!

1,".A'4!,.(!"%;4,&".9!*+1*0"*.2*=!T;:*/*06!&$*!%&0'2&'0*%!&$,&!0*".A;02*!;&$*0".9!

L'**0!,.(!&0,.%9*.(*0!1*;14*!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!$,/*!$"%&;0"*%!&$,&!".("/"(',4!,.(!

2;44,@;0,&"/*!*AA;0&%!2,.!&0,2*6!'.0,/*46!,.(!0*%"%&=!`'%&!,%!$*&*0;<9*.(*0!

.;0-,&"/"&)!"%!0*10;('2*(!&$0;'9$!*/*0)(,)!10,2&"2*%6!&$*!9*.(*0!2'4&'0*%!"&!

Page 235: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YYi!

!

0*".A;02*%!,0*!2$,.9*(!&$0;'9$!*/*0)(,)!0*%"%&,.2*=!D%!$,%!@**.!(*-;.%&0,&*(!

&$0;'9$;'&!?3()$(I$)66(#(F&=YB!&$*0*!*+"%&!-,.)!20*,&"/*6!1;:*0A'4!,110;,2$*%!&;!

0*%"%&,.2*j!1;:*0A'46!,.(!-;%&!"-1;0&,.&4)6!(;,@4*=!!

$

( (

Page 236: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YYZ!

!

(<8><?IFA=C9$

D"0&;.6!a**=!Na*,/*!o#$;%*!8"(%B!D4;.*X!K.!&$*!S;.A4,&";.!;A!H2$;;4!T;-;1$;@",!,.(!

H'AA*0".9!\'**0%=O!vd.1'@4"%$*(!-,.'%20"1&=w!

ND@;0"9".,4!H;2",4!b;05*0%!;.!H&0"5*!".!FS=O!P,&";.,4!d.";.!;A!G'@4"2!,.(!^*.*0,4!

R-14;)**%=!Y!C*2*-@*0!YVUY=!b*@!YV!H*1&*-@*0!YVUf=!!

D%&6!C,/"(!*&!,4=!NS$,44*.9".9!T;-;1$;@",!,.(!T*&*0;%*+"%-X!D!8EUY!S'00"2'4'-!

Q*%;'02*!^'"(*=O!0&.&*$&(;(0TIF(Rc7)$#/6,(#*%(?*+673)W,(I+"&&63B(NZMM'(

!ND!#"-*4".*!;A!Q*%"(*.&",4!H2$;;4%6!&$*!#0'&$!,.(!Q*2;.2"4",&";.!S;--"%";.=O!>F>(

@,!3=!UU!`'.*!YVUU=!b*@!YW!H*1&=!YVUf=!!

F,"4*)6!8,0*.!Q=!N#$*!^"04%!,0*!&$*!K.*%!:"&$!&$*!G;".&)!P,"4%X!D.!R+14;0,&";.!;A!

S$"4(0*.B%!S;.2*1&";.%!;A!^*.(*0=!a;.(;.X!0",(<6$"&73,(A.,336!UWWf=!!

F,0%;&&"6!P,&,%$,=!NF'0.,@)6!#:;!g*,0%!a,&*0=O!]$.#\(E#=(#*%(D,3/)#*(@,!3=!f!`'.*!

YVUf=!b*@=!Y]!`'.*!YVUf=!!

FS!I*&"%!h*(*0,&";.=!ND@;0"9".,4!R('2,&";.!R.$,.2*-*.&!b;05*0EH2$;;4!C"%&0"2&!

yfW=O!UU!`,.',0)!YVUY=!b*@=!Yk!`'.*!YVUf=!!

FS#h!>.A;0-,&";.!H*0/"2*%!,.(!Q*%*,02$!C*1,0&-*.&%6!NYVUY!FS!R('2,&";.!h,2&%6O!

F.)$)3"(>&672/)#(0,#+",.O3(1,%,.#$)&*=!D'9'%&!YVUY=!b*@=!U]!I,)!YVUf=!!

F*446!C,/"(=!N^,)!P*:!F0'.%:"25!#**.!G4*,(%!A;0!F'44)".9!&;!H&;1=O!>0e=!f!I,)!YVUf=!

b*@=!UY!I,)!YVUf=!!

F*0.%&*".6!Q;@".=!5#+)#6)Q,%(?**&+,*+,;(A,.-&.2)*9(<2,.)+#*(>")6%"&&%(-.&2(I6#W,.=(

$&(>)W)6(5)9"$3'(P*:!g;05X!P*:!g;05!d."/*0%"&)!G0*%%6!YVUU=!

Page 237: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YYW!

!

F*/*0"(9*6!a",.=!N`'%&!a"5*!R/*0);.*!R4%*X!#$*!8.;:4*(9*<>9.;0,.2*!F".,0)!".!

S*.%;0%$"1!,.(!a*%@",.!,.(!^,)!G"2&'0*@;;5%=O$C"%%=!d."/*0%"&)!;A!F0"&"%$!

S;4'-@",6!YVUY=!!

NF"44!UZX!#$*!G'@4"2!H2$;;4%!D--*.(-*.&!D2&!3H,A*!,.(!>.24'%"/*!H2$;;4%7=O!

C#*)$&/#(D,9)36#$7.,=!YVUY=!b*@=!f!K2&=!YVUf=!!

NF"44!YY!T'0&%!H&'(*.&%!,.(!D&&,25%!#*,2$*0%B!Q"9$&%6O!FS!#*,2$*0B%!h*(*0,&";.=!

$&&1X<<@2&A=2,<F,09,".".9D.(S;.&0,2&%=,%1+e"(mY]WiZ=!U]!I,)!YVUf=!!

F4;,'.&6!`,25"*=!h"&!&;!#*,2$X!H,-*E%*+!C*%"0*6!^*.(*06!,.(!H;2",4!b;05!".!&$*!

#:*.&"*&$!S*.&'0)=!D4@,.)X!H&,&*!d."/*0%"&)!;A!P*:!g;05!G0*%%6!YVV]=!!

F;0.%&*".6!8,&*=!^*.(*0!K'&4,:X!K.!I*.6!b;-*.!,.(!&$*!Q*%&!;A!d%=!P*:!g;05X!

Q;'&4*(9*6!UWW[=!!

F0'$-6!H&*/*.!,.(!P,&,%$,!T'04*)=!N>.&0;('2&";.=O!>7.)&73,.;(X*($",(K7,,.*,33(&-(

>")6%.,*'!F0'$-!,.(!T'04*)6!*(%=!I"..*,1;4"%X!d=!;A!I"..*%;&,!G0*%%6!YVV[=!

"+E+++/"""=!

NF'44"*(!H&'(*.&!#"254*(!G".5!@)!H2$;;4-,&*%l!#E%$"0&!2,-1,"9.=O!SFS!P*:%=!UZ!

H*1&*-@*0!YVVi=!b*@=!U]!D'9'%&!YVUY=!!

F'05*6!D%$4*)=!N^,)!K&&,:,!#**.!:$;!8"44*(!T"-%*4A!:,%!F'44"*(X!`,-"*!T'@4*)!:,%!

,!h"9'0*!H5,&*0!,.(!&$*!K.4)!K1*.4)!^,)!F;)!".!T"%!H2$;;4=O!>F>(@,!3'!UZ!

K2&;@*0!YVUU=!b*@=![!P;/*-@*0!YVUU=!

F'&4*06!`'("&$=!^*.(*0!#0;'@4*X!h*-"."%-!,.(!&$*!H'@/*0%";.!;A!>(*.&"&)=!!Y.(!*(=!

P*:!g;05X!Q;'&4*(9*6!UWWW=!!

Page 238: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YfV!

!

EEE=!F;("*%!#$,&!I,&&*0X!K.!&$*!C"%2'0%"/*!a"-"&%!;A!NH*+=O!!P*:!g;05X!Q;'&4*(9*6!

UWWf=!!!

S,-*0;.6!I"2$*44*!=!N#:;EH1"0"&*(!D@;0"9".,4!G*;14*X!S;.&".'".9!S'4&'0,4!

D110;10",&";.!@)!P;.ED@;0"9".,4!H;2"*&)=O!>#*#%)#*(4&2#*(I$7%),3(Y[=Y<f!

3YVV]7X!YYfEYYi=!!

S,/,.,9$6!H$*"4,=!Nh*-,4*E#*,2$*0!^*.(*0!,.(!H*+',4"&)!".!#:*.&"*&$ES*.&'0)!

K.&,0";6!S,.,(,=O!S)3$&.=(&-(R%7+#$)&*(K7#.$,.6=![]=Y!3YVV]7X!Y[iEYif=!

EEE=!I,G)*9($",(0,#+",.;(I+"&&6(I+#*%#63(#*%(K7,,.(A,%#9&9),3=!?,.2;'/*0X!d."/*0%"&)!

;A!F0"&"%$!S;4'-@",!G0*%%6!YVVi=!!

S$*."*06!R4"%*=!N#$*!P,&'0,4!K0(*0!;A!C"%;0(*0X!G*(;1$"4",6!H&0,.9*0!C,.9*0!,.(!&$*!

P;0-,4"%".9!h,-"4)=O!I,G7#6)$=(f(>76$7.,!!Uk!3YVUY7X!UiY{UZk=!

S$0"%16!`"44=!N#$*!P*9;&",&";.!;A!C"/*09*.&!C*-,.(%!b$*.!S;--'."&)!Q*%*,02$!"%!

a;2,&*(!".!&$*!D2,(*-)X!#$*!I;&$*0ED(;4*%2*.&!H;.!G0;M*2&=O!0.#W,66)*9(

>&2J#*)&*3;(1,2)*)32B(0,#+")*9B(#*%(<+$)&*(5,3,#.+"'!R(=!I,0)!F0)(;.E

I"44*06!G,&0"2",!I,9'"0*6!,.(!D4"2*!I2>.&)0*=!b*%&1;0&X!^0**.:;;(!

G'@4"%$".96!YVV[=!iWEW]=!

S;44".%6!G,&0"2",!T"44=!F6#+P(1,2)*)3$(0"&79"$;(^*&!6,%9,B(>&*3+)&73*,33(#*%($",(

A&6)$)+3(&-(R2J&!,.2,*$=!P*:!g;05X!Q;'&4*(9*6!YVVV=!!

S'44*.6!h".!,.(!a,'0,!H,.()=!Na*%@",.!S".(*0*44,!,.(!K&$*0!H&;0"*%X!#*44".9!#,4*%!,.(!

Q*%*,02$".9!H*+',4"&"*%!RL',4"&"*%!".!G0"-,0)!H2$;;4=O!I,G(R%7+#$)&*;(

I,G7#6)$=B(I&+),$=(#*%(D,#.*)*9(W=Y!3YVVW7!U[UEU][=!!

Page 239: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YfU!

!

C,/"*%6!F0;.:).!,.(!Q;-!T,00*=!NG;%"&";.".9X!#$*!C"%2'0%"/*!G0;('2&";.!;A!H*4/*%=O!

:&7.*#6(-&.($",(0",&.=(&-(I&+)#6(F,"#W)&7.!YV=U!3UWWV7X![fEkf!

C,/"%6!D-)=!G*0%;.,4!>.&*0/"*:=!UY!I,)!YVUY=!!

C*!S,%&*446!H'J,..*!,.(!I,0)!F0)%;.=!N\'**0!R&$.;90,1$)X!>(*.&"&)6!D'&$;0"&)6!

P,00,&"/"&)!,.(!,!^*;1;4"&"2%!;A!#*+&=O!?*3)%,($",(<+#%,2=(#*%(X7$;(

D,3/)#*VE#=VK7,,.(I$7%),3(#*%(I&+)#6(<+$)&*'(R(=!`,."2*!a=!Q"%&;25!,.(!

S,&$*0".*!^=!#,)4;0=!#;0;.&;X!#;0;.&;!d."/*0%"&)!G0*%%6!UWWZ=!WiEUUV=!

C*?,'4&6!I,0M;0"*!a=!,.(!a"J,!I2S;)=!N>.%&"&'&";.,4!R&$.;90,1$)X!d%".9!>.&*0/"*:%!

&;!>./*%&"9,&*!Q'4".9!Q*4,&";.%=O!?*3$)$7$)&*#6(R$"*&9.#J"=(#3(A.#+$)+,'!R(=!

C;0;&$)!R=!H-"&$=!a,.$,-X!Q;:-,.!,.(!a"&&4*A"*4(6!YVVk=!U]E[[=!

C*4$"6!8,0"=!N#$*)!Q'4*!@)!H)-1,&$)X!#$*!h*-"."J,&";.!;A!G*(,9;9)=O!0",(>#*#%)#*(

:&7.*#6(&-(I&+)&6&9=(V(>#"),.3(+#*#%),*3(%,(3&+)&6&9),'(UW=Y!3UWW[7X!UW]EYUk=!

C',6!R.,5%$"!,.(!D.9*4,!Q;@*0&%;.=!I+.#$+")*9($",(I7.-#+,;(>#*#%)#*(<*$)H5#+)3$(

1,2)*)3$(0"&79"$'!#;0;.&;X!b;-*.B%!G0*%%6!UWWW=!!

C'5*6!#$;-,%!H2;&&=!!Nb;05".9!:"&$!a^F#\!g;'&$!:"&$!C"%,@"4"&"*%X!T;:!H1*2",4!

R('2,&;0%!S,.!Q*2;.2*1&',4"J*!SRS!H&,.(,0(%=O!!F,=&*%(A.&9.,33(#*%((

C#.9)*#6)Q#$)&*;(DEF0K(U&7$"()*(R%7+#$)&*#6(>&*$,G$3=!!S;00".*!S=!F*0&0,-6!I!

H'*!S0;:4*)!,.(!H*,.!^=!I,%%*)!R(%=!P*:!g;056!PgX!G*&*0!a,.9!G'@4"%$".96!

YVUV=!!!

Page 240: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YfY!

!

R1%&*".6!C*@@"*6!*&!,4=!NH2$;;4@;)!h0"2&";.%X!h*-"."%-!,.(!oh,"4".9B!F;)%=O!1#)6)*9(

F&=3Y(?337,3()*(E,*%,.(#*%(<+"),W,2,*$=!C*@@"*!R1%&*".!*&!,46!*(%=!

F'25".9$,-X!K1*.!d."/*0%"&)!G0*%%6!UWWZ=!

R/*0*&&6!I"2$*44*=!G*0%;.,4!".&*0/"*:=!Uk!I,)!YVUY=!F;%&;.X!F*,2;.!G0*%%6!UWWZ=!

h,0.%:;0&$6!`;$.!,.(!F0;.:).!F;;.=!!ND.,4)%".9!^0;'1!C).,-"2%!b"&$".!&$*!h;2'%!

^0;'1=O!K7#6)$#$)W,(5,3,#.+"(UV=]!3YVUV7X!kV]EkY[=!

h,'%&;EH&*04".96!D..*=!H*+".9!&$*!F;()X!^*.(*0!G;4"&"2%!,.(!&$*!S;.%&0'2&";.!;A!!

((((((((((I,G7#6)$==!!P*:!g;05X!F,%"2!F;;5%6!YVVV=!

h**6!D.9"*=!Nb$;!G'&!&$*!oT*&*0;B!".!H*+',4"&)e!0.#*3(E,*%,.(?%,*$)$),3;(0&!#.%(#(

I&+)#6(<*#6=3)3(&-(E,*%,.(T)W,.3)$='(H,44)!T".*%!,.(!#,-!H,.9*06!*(%=!YViEYY[=!

P*:!g;05X!Q;'&4*(9*6!YVUV=!YViEYY[=!

h;'2,'4&6!I"2$*4=!NY]!`,.',0)!UWiZ=O!I,+7.)$=B(0,..)$&.=B(A&J76#$)&*;(D,+$7.,3(#$($",(

>&66g9,(%,(1.#*+,B(M[hhiM[hj'(#0,.%=!^0,$,-!F'02$*44=!R(=!I"2$*4!H*.*44,0&6!

*&!,4=!F,%".9%&;5*X!G,490,/*!I,2-"44,.6!YVVi=!]]EZk=!

EEE=!C"%2"14".*!,.(!G'."%$X!#$*!F"0&$!;A!&$*!G0"%;.=!!#0,.%=!D4,.!H$*0"(,.=!P*:!g;05X!!

?".&,9*!F;;5%6!UWii=!!

h0,.56!F4)*6!*&!,4=!D!#,.94*!;A!#0;'@4*X!F;)%6!I,%2'4"."&)!,.(!H2$;;4".9_h'&'0*!

C"0*2&";.%=O!R%7+#$)&*#6(5,W),!!]]=Y!3YVVf7X!UUWEUff=(

h0*(6!Q,.()=!Nh;0*:;0(=O!5,3)3$#*+,(#*%(5,*,!#6;(I7.W)W)*9($",(?*%)#*(5,3)%,*$)#6(

I+"&&6=!?,.2;'/*0X!D0%*.,4!G'41!G0*%%6!UWWZ=!S*4",!T,"9EF0;:.=!?,.2;'/*0X!

D0%*.,4!G'41!G0*%%6!UWWZ=!U]EY]=!(

Page 241: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Yff!

!

h0*'(6!H"9-'.(=!N#$0**!R%%,)%!;.!&$*!#$*;0)!;A!H*+',4"&)=O!1.,7%(X*(4&2,*=!

R4"J,@*&$!g;'.9!F0'*$46!*(=!1.,7%(X*(4&2,*;(<(5,#%,.'!!P*:!g;05X!b=b=!

P;0&;.!p!S;-1,.)6!UWWV=!1=!ZWEU[k=!

h0"%@)6!b*.()6!G,&0"2",!I,9'"0*6!,.(!S;44**.!Q*"(=!N#$*!ohB!b;0(!T,%!R/*0)&$".9!&;!

C;!b"&$!>&X!T;:!h*-"."%&!#$*;0"*%!>.A;0-!D2&";.!Q*%*,02$=O!<+$)&*(5,3,#.+"!

i=U!3YVVW7X!UfEYW=!

^,4".,6!D4@*0&;!I*.(;J,=!N?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!F;,0(!b0*%&4*%!:"&$!D114)".9!D.&"E

T;-;1$;@",!G;4"2)=O!0"7*%,./).%'+#'(UZ!P;/=!YVUU=!b*@=!U!K2&=!YVUf=!!

^,44,2$*06!a*%4*)ED..*!,.(!I"2$,*4!^,44,9$*0=!NI*&$;(;4;9"2,4!>--,&'0"&)!".!

S$"4($;;(!Q*%*,02$eX!#$".5".9!#$0;'9$!G,0&"2"1,&;0)!I*&$;(%=!>")6%"&&%!

U]=[!3YVVZ7X![WWE]Uk=!!

^,44,9$*06!I"2$,*4=!NoG;:*0!"%!P;&!,.!R/"4X!Q*&$".5".9!G;:*0!".!G,0&"2"1,&;0)!

I*&$;(%=O!>")6%.,*O3(E,&9.#J"),3!k=Y!3YVVZ7X!UfiEU]V=!!

^*.;/*%*6!I,((,4*.,6!C,/".,!Q;'%*446!,.(!#$*!#:;!H1"0"&!S"024*!;A!R(-;.&;.!

H;2"*&)=!!I+"&&63(-&.(0!&(IJ).)$(U&7$";(<(97)%,(-&.($,#+",.3(#*%(3$7%,*$3'(

R(-;.&;.X!#$*!H;2"*&)!A;0!H,A*!,.(!S,0".9!H2$;;4%!p!S;--'."&"*%6!YVUU=!!

^*;09*6!I;44)=!N#*,2$".9!h;2'%!^0;'1!>.&*0/"*:".9X!F*.*A"&%!,.(!S$,44*.9*%=O!

0,#+")*9(I&+)&6&9=$[U=f!3YVUf7X!Y]iEYiV=$

^"44-;06!C;.=!U7+P\(<(D&W,(I$&.==!>44'%=!I,0"*Ea;'"%*!^,)=!I,05$,-X!h"&J$*.0)!p!

b$"&*%"(*6!YVVU=!!

Page 242: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Yf[!

!

^4*,%;.6!I;.,!,.(!`*,.!F,0-,.=!N>.&0;('2&";.=O!>")6%.,*B(0,#+",.3(#*%(I+"&&63;(?*(

$",(S)3$&.=(&-(F.)$)3"(>&672/)#'(I;.,!^4*,%;.!,.(!`*,.!F,0-,.6!*(%=!

R(-;.&;.X!F0'%$!R('2,&";.6!YVVf=!WEUf=!

^;&*446!a"%*=!NQ*&$".5".9!DAA"0-,&"/*!S;.%*.&!".!S,.,(",.!H*+',4!D%%,'4&!a,:X!

P*;4"@*0,4!H*+',4!H'@M*2&%!,.(!Q"%5)!b;-*.=O!<.P&*(D#!(5,W),!![U=f!

3YVVZ7X!Zk]EZWZ=!!

^0,)6!Q;@".=!N?"%',4"J".9!G*(,9;9)!,.(!G;:*0!:"&$!d0@,.!P,&"/*!g;'&$X!R+1;%".9!

&$*!a*9,2)!;A!&$*!>.(",.!Q*%"(*.&",4!H2$;;4!H)%&*-=O!>#*#%)#*(:&7.*#6(&-(

@#$)W,(R%7+#$)&*!f[=U!3YVUU7X!WEYi=!

^0*"96!S$0"%&;1$*0=!NI,%2'4"."&"*%6!Q*,(".9!,.(!&$*!oF;)!G0;@4*-BX!D!S0"&"L'*!;A!

K.&,0";!G;4"2"*%=!<R1(:&7.*#6!Ui=U!3YVVf7X!ffE]k=!!

^0*%$,-6!8"05=!Nh0;-!K.*!b$"&*!^,)!I,4*!&;!D.;&$*0X!S,44".9!;'&!&$*!>-14"2"&!

Q,2"%-!".!C,.!H,/,9*l%!oa"@*0,4B!G;4"&"2%!p!&$*!o>&!9*&%!@*&&*0B!S,-1,"9.=q!0",(

1,2)*)3$(4).,=!YZ$h*@0',0)!YVUY=!b*@!Uf!D'9'%&!YVUf=!!

^'"4(A;0(6!`,.*&=!NoH*1,0,&*!H1$*0*%BX!#$*!h*-"."J,&";.!;A!G'@4"2!H2$;;4!#*,2$".9!".!

P;/,!H2;&",6!UZfZEUZZV=O!<+#%),*3)3(YY=U!3UWWY7X![[Ek[=!

^'0",.6!I"2$,*4=!F&=3(#*%(E).63(D,#.*(T)--,.,*$6=\(<(E7)%,(-&.(0,#+",.3(#*%(A#.,*$3=!

H,.!h0,.2"%2;X!`;%%*)EF,%%6!YVVU=!

T,"9EF0;:.6!S*4",=!Q*%"%&,.2*!,.(!Q*.*:,4X!H'0/"/".9!&$*!>.(",.!Q*%"(*.&",4!H2$;;4=!

?,.2;'/*0X!D0%*.,4!G'41!G0*%%6!UWWZ=!

T,4@*0%&,-6!`'("&$=!1,2#6,(C#3+76)*)$),3=!C'0$,-X!C'5*!d."/*0%"&)!G0*%%6!UWWZ=!

Page 243: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Yf]!

!

EEE=!NK$!F;.(,9*!d1!g;'0%c!h*-,4*!I,%2'4"."&)!,.(!#$*!#;-@;)=O!>7.)&73,.;(X*($",(

K7,,.*,33(&-(>")6%.,*'!F0'$-!,.(!T'04*)6!*(%==!I"..*,1;4"%X!d."/*0%"&)!;A!

I"..*%;&,!G0*%%6!YVV[=!UWUEYU[=!

T,%5*446!Q*@*22,!,.(!F0",.!F'0&2$=!!E,$($"#$(1.,#P;(S&2&J"&/)#(#*%(0.#*3J"&/)#()*(

S)9"(I+"&&63=!!T,4"A,+6!PHX!h*0.:;;(!G'@4"%$".96!YVUV=!!!

T,01*06!H&*/*.=!NG0"-*!I"."%&*0!H&*1$*.!T,01*0l%!H&,&*-*.&!;A!D1;4;9)=O!>F>(@,!3'!

UU!`'.*!YVVZ=!b*@=!Uk!D'9'%&!YVUf=!!

T*.5".6!Q;+,..*=!4"&O3(?*W)$,%($&(I"#.,Y(83)*9(D)$,.#+=($&(0,#+"(-&.(Rc7)$=(#*%(

I&+)#6(:73$)+,'!G;0&%-;'&$X!T*".*-,..6!UWWZ=!

T"0%2$A*4(6!I,9.'%=!NH*4*2&";.%!A0;-X!#$*!#0,.%/*%&"&*%X!#$*!R0;&"2!C0"/*!&;!S0;%%E!

T.,33'd(0",(0.#*39,*%,.(I$7%),3(5,#%,.=!R(=!H'%,.!H&0)5*0!,.(!H&*1$*.!b$"&&4*=!!P*:!

g;05X!Q;'&4*(9*6!YVVk=!YZEfW=!

$;;5%6!@*44=!NS$;;%".9!&$*!I,09".%!,%!,!H1,2*!;A!Q,("2,4!;1*..*%%=O!!U,#.*)*9;(5#+,B(

E,*%,.B(#*%(>76$7.#6(A&6)$)+3'((U[]EU]]=!!S,-@0"(9*X!H;'&$!R.(!G0*%%6!UWWV=!

NT;'%".9!G0"2*%!T"9$*0!".!I;%&!S,.,(",.!I,05*&%!".!R,04)!YVUfX!Q*1;0&=O!0",(E6&/,(

#*%(C#)6=!W!D10"4!YVUf=!b*@=!U]!I,)!YVUf=!!

T'-*6!`,-*%=!NI;0,4!#0,".".9!".!G'@4"2!H2$;;4%=O!X*$#.)&(R%7+#$)&*(<33&+)#$)&*(

A.&+,,%)*93!3UZWZ7X!YffEYf[=!!

`,2;@%6!F*/*04*)=!NQ*%1;.%*!&;!S,.,(,l%!D1;4;9)!&;!Q*%"(*.&",4!H2$;;4!H'0/"/;0%=O!

>#*#%)#*(4&2#*(I$7%),3!Yk=f<[!3YVVZ7X!YYfEYY]=!

T'9$*%6!`,-*%=!G*0%;.,4!".&*0/"*:=!YY!h*@=!YVUY=!!

T'9$*%6!`,-*%=!G*0%;.,4!".&*0/"*:=!Vi!I,02$!YVUY=!

Page 244: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Yfk!

!

T'9$*%6!`,-*%=!G*0%;.,4!".&*0/"*:=!UZ!I,)!YVUY=!

`,-"46!K-,0!F=!,.(!^,0)!b=!T,01*0=!!NH2$;;4!A;0!&$*!HRhX!R+,-".".9!&$*!Q;4*!;A!

R('2,&";.,4!H*&&".9%!".!>(*.&"&)!C*/*4;1-*.&!,-;.9!^,)6!F"%*+',46!,.(!

\'*%&";.".9!I,4*!g;'&$!;A!S;4;0=O!F,=&*%(A.&9.,33(#*%(C#.9)*#6)Q#$)&*;(

DEF0K(U&7$"()*(R%7+#$)&*#6(>&*$,G$3=!!S;00".*!S=!F*0&0,-6!I!H'*!S0;:4*)!,.(!

H*,.!^=!I,%%*)!R(%=!P*:!g;05X!G*&*0!a,.96!YVUV=!!!

`;:*&&6!I,(*4*".*!,.(!KB#;;4*6!^"44=!Nh;2'%".9!Q*%*,02$*0%B!I".(%X!S;.&0,%&".9!

R+1*0"*.2*%!;A!d%".9!h;2'%!^0;'1%!".!h*-"."%&!\',4"&,&"/*!Q*%*,02$=O!

\',4"&,&"/*!Q*%*,02$!k=[!3YVVk7X![]f{iY=!

8*$4*06!I"2$,*4=!Nb$;!:"44!oH,/*!&$*!F;)%Be!3Q*7R+,-".".9!,!G,."2!A;0!

d.(*0,2$"*/".9!F;)%=O!<%&6,3+,*$(D)$,.#+),3(#*%($",(E,*%,.,%(I,6-;(a5,L(

>&*3$.7+$)*9(?%,*$)$),3($".&79"(C76$)2&%,6(D)$,.#+=(A.#+$)+,3=!F,0@,0,!`=!

^'J*&&"!,.(!#$;-,%!b=!F*,.6!*(%=!P*:!g;05X!Q;'&4*(9*6!YVUf=!UYUEUfU=!

8*4-6!I,0)ER44*.=!>&6&*)Q)*9(F&%),3;(</&.)9)*#6(S,#6$"(#*%(S,#6)*9()*(F.)$)3"(

>&672/)#'(?,.2;'/*0X!d."/*0%"&)!;A!F0"&"%$!S;4'-@",!G0*%%6!UWWZ=!

8"--*46!I"2$,*4=!N#$*!b,0!D9,".%&!F;)%eO!T)33,*$!]f=![!3YVVk7X!k]EiV=!

8"&J".9*06!`*..)=!N#$*!I*&$;(;4;9)!;A!h;2'%!^0;'1%X!#$*!>-1;0&,.2*!;A!>.&*0,2&";.!

F*&:**.!Q*%*,02$!G,0&"2"1,.&%=O!I&+)&6&9=(&-(S,#6$"(f(?66*,33!Uk=U!3UWW[7X!

UVf{UYU=!

80,AA&ER@".96!Q"2$,0(!/;.=!!NH*4*2&";.%!A0;-;(A3=+"&J#$")#(I,G7#6)3(!)$"(IJ,+)#6((

Page 245: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Yfi!

!

Q*A*0*.2*!&;!S;.&0,0)!H*+',4!>.%&".2&X!D!I*("2;Ea*9,4!H&'()=O!#$*!#0,.%9*.(*0!

H&'("*%!Q*,(*0=!R(=!H'%,.!H&0)5*0!,.(!H&*1$*.!b$"&&4*=!P*:!g;05X!Q;'&4*(9*6!

YVVk=!YUEYZ=!

8'-,%$"0;6!8*/".!8=!!qD9,".%&!Q*1*&"&";.X!D((0*%%".9!Q*%"%&,.2*!&;!D.&"EK110*%%"/*!

S$,.9*!".!&$*!G0,2&"2*%!;A!a*,0.".96!#*,2$".96!H'1*0/"%".96!,.(!Q*%*,02$".9=q!!

S#.W#.%(R%7+#$)&*#6(5,W),!!iY=Y!3YVVY7X!kiEWY=!!!

a,.(6!?"2&;0",!,.(!S*4",!8"&J".9*0=!NH1*,5".9!,%!,!a*%@",.X!S;00*2&".9!&$*!

T*&*0;%*+"%&!G0*%'-1&";.=O!5,3,#.+"(&*(D#*97#9,(#*%(I&+)#6(?*$,.#+$)&*!fZ=[!

3YVV]7X!fiUE[Uk=!!!

a*/*06!`,.*&=!NH*+!C"AA*0*.2*%!".!&$*!^,-*%!S$"4(0*.!G4,)eO!I&+)#6(A.&/6,23!Yf=[!

3UWki7X![iZE[ZZ=!

a*/)6!T"4,0)=!Nob$"2$!K.*!>%!g;'0%eBX!S$"4(0*.!,.(!R&$.;90,1$)=O!K7#6)$#$)W,(

I&+)&6&9=!fY=f!3YVVW7X!fUU{ffU=!

a4*:*44).6!80"%&".,=!N>.!&$*!P,-*!;A!C*-;20,2)X!#$*!b;05!;A!b;-*.!#*,2$*0%!".!

K.&,0";!,.(!?,.2;'/*06!UW[]EUWkV=O!C"%%=!d."/*0%"&)!;A!F0"&"%$!S;4'-@",6!

YVVk=!!

a*:"%6!H$,'.,=!NI,."&;@,!#*,2$*0%l!d.";.!G,%%*%!S'00"2'4'-!Q*%;4'&";.=O!]$.#\(E#=(

#*%(D,3/)#*(@,!3=!Yf!I,)!YVUf=!!b*@=!Y]!`'.*!YVUf=!!

a;0@*06!`'("&$=!A#.#%&G,3(&-(E,*%,.'!a;.(;.X!g,4*!d."/*0%"&)!G0*%%6!UWW]=!!

a;'&J*.$*"%*06!a"%,!b=!NS,.!b*!a*,0.!\'**04)e!P;0-,&"/"&)!,.(!H;2",4!`'%&"2*!

G*(,9;9"*%=O!I&+)#6(:73$)+,(A,%#9&9=(<+.&33($",(>7..)+7672;(0",(A.#+$)+,(&-(

Page 246: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YfZ!

!

1.,,%&2=!R(=!#$,.(*5,!8=!S$,1-,.!,.(!P"5;4,!T;@@*4=!P*:!g;05X!Q;'&4*(9*6!

YVUV=!UYUEU[f=!!

I,2^"44"/0,)6!a,'0"*!,.(!D.,!I,0"&J,!I,0&".*J=!NG0".2*%%*%!:$;!S;--"&!H'"2"(*X!

G0"-,0)!S$"4(0*.!b0"&".9!b"&$".!,.(!D9,".%&!^*.(*0!%&*0*;&)1*%=O!:&7.*#6(&-(

D)$,.#+=(5,3,#.+"(fV=U!3UWWZ7X!]fEZ[=!!

I,2>.&;%$6!a;0"=!NC;*%!D.);.*!T,/*!,!F,.(ED"(eX!D.&"ET;-;1$;@",!C"%2;'0%*%!,.(!

G*(,9;9"2,4!>-1;%%"@"4"&"*%=O!R%7+#$)&*#6(I$7%),3![U=U!3YVVi7X!ffE[f=!

Ix.%%;.6!D.."5,=!NF*2;-".9!,!G0*%2$;;4!S$"4(X!H'@M*2&"A"2,&";.!".!#;((4*0%!C'0".9!

&$*"0!>.&0;('2&";.!&;!G0*%2$;;46!A0;-!,!^*.(*0!G*0%1*2&"/*=O!?*$,.*#$)&*#6(

:&7.*#6(&-(R#.6=(>")6%"&&%B(_`!3YVUU7X!iEYY=!

I,0&".6!`,.*=!Nb$,&!H$;'4(!b*!C;!:"&$!,!T"((*.!S'00"2'4'-!b$*.!b*!h".(!K.*eO!

>7..)+7672(I$7%),3!k=Y!3UWik7X!Uf]EU]U=!!

I,0&".6!8,0*.=!NF*2;-".9!,!^*.(*0*(!F;()X!G0,2&"2*%!;A!G0*%2$;;4%=O!<2,.)+#*(

I&+)&6&9)+#6(5,W),!(kf=[!3UWWZ7X![W[E]UU=!

I,0&".;6!b,).*!`;$.=!NI,4*!#*,2$*0%!,%!Q;4*!I;(*4%X!D((0*%%".9!>%%'*%!;A!

I,%2'4"."&)6!G*(,9;9)!,.(!&$*!Q*EI,%2'4"."J,&";.!;A!H2$;;4".9=!>7..)+7672(

?*c7).=!fZ=Y!3YVVZ7X!UZWEYYf=!

I,'0;6!R44*.=!NK&&,:,!#**.!C*&,"4%!h".,4!H'"2"(,4!#$;'9$&%!;.!F4;9=O!>0e(@,!3=!Ui!

K2&=!YVUU=!

I2S'44;2$6!#$;-,%=!0",(@#$7.,(#*%(83,3(&-(#(D)/,.#6(R%7+#$)&*=!T,4"A,+X!UZUW=!fEYY=!

I*02*06!Q"25=!NQ"25B%!Q,.&X!I,5*!"&!F*&&*0!P;:=O!5?>^(CR5>R5=>XC'!!Yk!P;/*-@*0!

YVUU=!b*@!Uf!D'9'%&!YVUf=!!

Page 247: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YfW!

!

I*)*06!R4"J,@*&$=!NR4*-*.&,0)!R('2,&;0%B!8.;:4*(9*!;A!,.(!R+1*0"*.2*%!:"&$!

#0,.%9*.(*0!,.(!^*.(*0!S0*,&"/*!8"(%X!D.!D2&";.!Q*%*,02$!G0;M*2&=O!G,1*0!

10*%*.&*(!,&!&$*!>&*9.,33(-&.($",(1,%,.#$)&*(&-(I&+)#6(I+),*+,3(#*%(

S72#*)$),3=!?"2&;0",X!d."/*0%"&)!;A!?"2&;0",6!YVUf=!!

I"44;)6!`;$.=!<(@#$)&*#6(>.)2,;(0",(>#*#%)#*(E&W,.*2,*$(#*%($",(5,3)%,*$)#6(I+"&&6(

I=3$,2B(Mjh[HM[jk=!b".."1*9X!d."/*0%"&)!;A!I,."&;@,!G0*%%6!UWWW=!!

I"."%&0)!;A!R('2,&";.=!D@;0"9".,4!R('2,&";.!R.$,.2*-*.&!D90**-*.&=!W!`'.*!YVVW=!

b*@!Yk!`'.*!YVUf=!!

EEE=!^)*%,.9#.$,*!>7..)+7672(A#+P#9,'!H*1&*-@*0!YVUV=!b*@=!U!D'9'%&!YVUY=!!

EEE=!H;2",4!`'%&"2*!UY!#*,2$*0!^'"(*X!>.%&0'2&";.!,.(!D%%*%%-*.&!H'11;0&=!YVVZ=!b*@=!

Y]!`'.*!YVUf=!

I;$,.&)6!S$,.(0,!#,41,(*=!K.!Q,2*!,.(!?;"2*X!S$,44*.9*%!A;0!a"@*0,4!R('2,&";.!".!

&$*!UWWV%=!S'4&'0,4!S0"&"L'*!U[=U!3UWZWEUWWV7X!UiWEYVZ=$

I;%@)6!>,.=!ND(-"."%&*0".9!S;4;.",4!H2"*.2*X!P'&0"&";.!Q*%*,02$!,.(!T'-,.!

F";-*("2,4!R+1*0"-*.&,&";.!".!D@;0"9".,4!S;--'."&"*%!,.(!Q*%"(*.&",4!

H2$;;4%6!UW[YEUW]Y=O!S)3$&).,(I&+)#6,V3&+)#6(")3$&.=![k=WU!3YVUf7X!U[]EUiY=$

I;&$*0B%!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1!U=!U[!I,)!YVUY=!

I;&$*0B%!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1!Y=!U[!I,)!YVUY=!

I;&$*0B%!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1!f=!U[!I,)!YVUY=!

I'.%2$6!Q;@*0&=!>44=!I"2$,*4!I,0&2$*.5;=!4,(I"#.,(RW,.=$")*9\!I,05$,-X!H2$;4,%&"2!

S,.,(,6!UWWW=!

Page 248: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y[V!

!

I'00,)6!H'%,.=!qob*!D44!a;/*!S$,04*%BX!I*.!".!S$"4(!S,0*!,.(!&$*!H;2",4!S;.%&0'2&";.!

;A!^*.(*0=O!E,*%,.(#*%(I&+),$=!UV=[!3UWWk7X!fkZEfZ]=!

P,-,%&*6!?"/",.*!8=!>./"%"@4*!a"/*%X!#$*!R0,%'0*!;A!#0,.%%*+',4!,.(!#0,.%9*.(*0*(!!

A,&J6,=!#$*!d."/*0%"&)!;A!S$"2,9;!G0*%%X!S$"2,9;6!YVVV=!!

P,14*%6!P,.2)!D=!h*-"."%-!,.(!I*&$;(X!R&$.;90,1$)6!C"%2;'0%*!D.,4)%"%6!,.(!

D2&"/"%&!Q*%*,02$=!P*:!g;05X!Q;'&4*(9*6!YVVf=!

P*4%;.6!S,0;4".*=!G*0%;.,4!".&*0/"*:=!YV!D10"4!YVUY=!!

P,&";.,4!G;%&!H&,AA=!!ND.!D1;4;9)!A0;-!P,&";.,4!G;%&=O!@#$)&*#6(A&3$=!fV!H*1&*-@*0!

YVUU=!b*@=![!K2&;@*0!YVUU=!!

!

P;@4*6!F;@@)=!C#3+76)*)$),3(4)$"&7$(C,*Y((1,2#6,(C#3+76)*)$),3()*(0!,*$),$"(>,*$7.=(

1)+$)&*3=!!dFS!G0*%%X!F0"&"%$!S;4'-@",6!YVV[=!

G,%2;*6!S=`=!C'(*6!U&7O.,(#(1#9;(C#3+76)*)$=(#*%(I,G7#6)$=()*(S)9"(I+"&&6=!F*05*4*)X!

d."/*0%"&)!;A!S,4"A;0.",!G0*%%6!YVVi=!

G,'46!a"%%,=!5,#%)*9(X$",.(4#=3=!G;0&%-;'&$X!F;).&;.<S;;5!G'@4"%$*0%6!UWWZ=!!

G*&*0%;.6!a,&;),=!Nb$*0*!"%!&$*!G0;;A!&$,&!>&!^*&%!F*&&*0e!\'**0!GKS!,.(!&$*!

H;4"(,0"&)!^,1=O!5#+)#6)+)&73=!UW!K2&;@*0!YVUV=!b*@!Uf!D'9'%&!YVUf=!!

NG*&"&";.!A;0!T;-;1$;@",!G;4"2)=O!>1:>(0e;(^#26&&J3(e,.=(X!*=!!]!`'.*!YVUf=!b*@=!

Y]!`'.*!YVUf=!!

G".5!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1!U=!U!I,02$!YVUY=!!

G".5!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1!Y=!U!I,02$!YVUY=!!

G".5!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1!f=!U!I,02$!YVUY=!!

Page 249: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y[U!

!

A&6)+=(C#*7#6;(D,3/)#*B(E#=B(F)3,G7#6B(0.#*39,*%,.B(0!&HIJ).)$B(K7,3$)&*)*9=!

?,.2;'/*0X!?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!F;,0(=!Uk!h*@0',0)!YVV[=!b*@=![!P;/*-@*0!

YVUU=!

G0;%%*06!`,)=!!H*2;.(!H5".%X!#$*!F;()!P,00,&"/*%!;A!#0,.%%*+',4"&)=!!P*:!g;05X!!

S;4'-@",!d."/*0%"&)!G0*%%6!UWWZ=!

Q,-,J,.;94'6!S,0;4".*!,.(!`,.*&!T;44,.(=!!1,2)*)3$(C,$"&%&6&9=;(>"#66,*9,3(#*%(

>"&)+,3'!!a;.(;.X!H,9*6!YVVY=!!!

Q,-*&6!H,@0".,!G*&0,=!N>.&0;('2&";.=O!E,*%,.(5,W,.3#63(#*%(E,*%,.(>76$7.,3;(

<*$".&J&6&9)+#6(#*%(S)3$&.)+#6(A,.3J,+$)W,3=!P*:!g;05X!Q;'&4*(9*6!UWWk=!!

Q,.(*446!I*4,."*=!NH*+',4!D%%,'4&!a,:6!S0*("@"4"&)6!,.(!o>(*,4!?"2&"-%XB!S;.%*.&6!

Q*%"%&,.2*6!,.(!?"2&"-!F4,-".9=!>#*#%)#*(:&7.*#6(&-(4&2,*(#*%($",(D#!!YY=Y!

3YVUV7X!fWiE[f[=!!

NQSIG!".!/"(*;!&*44!9,)!);'&$!l>&!^*&%!F*&&*0Xl!?"(*;!;.!g;'#'@*!A*,&'0*%!".&*0/"*:%!

:"&$!F=S=!I;'.&"*%!%$,0".9!);'&$!%&0'994*%=O!>F>(@,!3=!k!P;/*-@*0!YVUY=!

b*@!Uf!D'9'%&!YVUf=!!

NQ*.&,4!D1,0&-*.&!?,2,.2"*%!d1O!>#*#%)#*(F.&#%+#3$)*9(>&.J&.#$)&*=!Uf!C*2*-@*0!

YVUY=!b*@=!U]!I,)!YVUf=!!

Q*).;4(%6!H$*"4,=!NH'00*)!T;1*%!&;!S4;%*!&$*!F;;5!;.!T;-;1$;@",=O!I7..=(@&.$"(

T,6$#(D,#%,.'(YU!`'.*!YVUf=!b*@=!`'.*!Y]6!YVUf=!!

Q9,%1,0=!Q*%1;.%*!&;!ND.!D1;4;9)!A0;-!&$*!P,&";.,4!G;%&=O!0",(@#$)&*#6(A&3$=!fV!

H*1&!YVUU=!b*@!fV!D10"4!YVUf=!!

Page 250: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y[Y!

!

Q"2$6!D(0"*..*=!NS;-1'4%;0)!T*&*0;%*+',4"&)!,.(!a*%@",.!R+"%&*.2*!3UWZV7=O!

:&7.*#6(&-(4&2,*O3(S)3$&.=!U]=f!3YVVf7X!UUE[Z=!!!

Q"/*0%6!S,0)4!,.(!Q;%,4".(!F,0.*&&=!0",(0.7$"(</&7$(E).63(#*%(F&=3;(>"#66,*9)*9(0&G)+(

I$,.,&$=J,3(</&7$(X7.(>")6%.,*=!b*%&!H'%%*+X!S;4'-@",!d."/*0%"&)!G0*%%6!

YVUU=!

Q;@".%;.6!8*00)=!No\'**0)".9!^*.(*0X!T*&*0;.;0-,&"/"&)!".!R,04)!2$"4($;;(!

R('2,&";.=!<73$.#6)#*(:&7.*#6(&-(R#.6=(>")6%"&&%!fV=Y!3YVV]7!UWEYZ=!

Q;-,.6!a*%4"*!^=!NC;'@4*!R+1;%'0*X!#$*!G;4"&"2%!;A!h*-"."%&!I,&*0",4"%&!

R&$.;90,1$)=O!R%7+#$)&*#6(0",&.=![f=f!3UWWf7X!YiWEfVZ=!

Q;/*44,6!I,09,0*&=!G*0%;.,4!".&*0/"*:=!YV!h*@=!YVUY=!

Q;/*44,6!I,09,0*&=!G*0%;.,4!".&*0/"*:=!VY!I,02$!YVUY=!

Q;/*44,6!I,09,0*&=!G*0%;.,4!".&*0/"*:=!U]!I,)!YVUY=!

Q'"&*.@*096!S4,'(",=!NC"%2;'0%*6!#$*,&0"2,4!G*0A;0-,.2*6!D9*.2)X!#$*!D.,4)&"2!h;02*!

;A!oG*0A;0-,&"/"&)B!".!R('2,&";.=O!A")6&3&J"=(&-(R%7+#$)&*'!F,0@,0,!H&*.9*46!

*(=!d0@,.,6!>aX!G$"4;%;1$)!;A!R('2,&";.!H;2"*&)6!YVVi=!YkVEYkZ=!

H,+6!a*;.,0(=!F&=3(<%.)-$;(0",(1)W,(1#+$&.3(T.)W)*9($",(RJ)%,2)+(&-(8*2&$)W#$,%(F&=3(

#*%(8*%,.#+"),W)*9(U&7*9(C,*=!P*:!g;05X!F,%"2!F;;5%6!YVVW=!!

H,(5*06!I)0,!,.(!C,/"(!H,(5*0=!N#$*!I"%*('2,&";.!;A!F;)%=O!0",(:&33,=HF#33(5,#%,.(

&*(E,*%,.()*(R%7+#$)&*'(H,.!h0,.2"%2;X!`;%%*)EF,%%X!D!b"4*)!S;-1,.)6!YVVY=!

UZYEYVf=!

NH,4,0)!^0"(%=O!FS!#*,2$*0B%!h*(*0,&";.=!

$&&1%X<<@2&A=2,<'14;,(*(A"4*%<H,4,0)^0"(%<C"%&fW=1(A!b*@=!U]!I,)!YVUf=!!

Page 251: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y[f!

!

H,4*0.;6!Q;@=!NP,&";.,4!G;%&!D1;4;9"J*%!A;0!Q'..".9!#0,.%1$;@"2!D(X!D2&"/"%&%!

S,44*(!A;0!D2&";.!".!Q*%1;.%*!&;!lH&;1!S;00'1&".9!S$"4(0*.l!S,-1,"9.=O!]$.#\(

E#=(#*%(D,3/)#*(@,!3=!YW!H*1&*-@*0!YVUU=!b*@=!YW!K2&;@*0!YVUU=!!

H,.9*06!#,-=!NF*);.(!^*.(*0!,.(!H*+',4"&)!F".,0"*%!".!H;2";4;9"2,4!#$*;0)X!#$*!

S,%*!A;0!#0,.%9*.(*0!>.24'%";.=!0.#*3(E,*%,.(?%,*$)$),3;(0&!#.%(#(I&+)#6(

<*#6=3)3(&-(E,*%,.(T)W,.3)$='!H,44)!T".*%!,.(!#,-!H,.9*06!*(%=!YViEYY[=!P*:!

g;05X!Q;'&4*(9*6!YVUV=!Y]WEYii=!

H*,0%6!`,-*%=!N>.&*00;9,&".9!&$*!H'@M*2&X!\'**0".9!R4*-*.&,0)!R('2,&";.6!UV!g*,0%!

K.=O!I,G(R%7+#$)&*;(I,G7#6)$=B(I&+),$=(#*%(D,#.*)*9(W=Y!3YVVW7!UWfEYVV=!

H*(9:"256!R/*!8;%;A%5)=!!RJ)3$,2&6&9=(&-($",(>6&3,$=!!F*05*4*)X!d."/*0%"&)!;A!

S,4"A;0.",!G0*%%6!UWWV=!

H$*44*)6!S$0"%&;1$*0!D=!#0,.%1*;14*X!Q*1'(",&";.6!#0,'-,6!T*,4".9=!!#;0;.&;X!!

d."/*0%"&)!;A!#;0;.&;!G0*%%6!YVVZ=!

H"4/*0%&*".6!H$*4=!0",(E)W)*9(0.,,=!P*:!g;05X!T,01*0!,.(!Q;:6!UWk[=!

H-"&$6!C;0;&$)!R=!>.%&"&'&";.,4!R&$.;90,1$)X!D!H;2";4;9)!A;0!G*;14*=!#;0;.&;X!

D4&,-"0,6!YVV]=!!

H-"&$6!a".(,!#'$":,"=!NK.!#0"25)!^0;'.(X!Q*%*,02$".9!&$*!P,&"/*!".!&$*!D9*!;A!

d.2*0&,".&)=O!0",(D#*%3+#J,(&-(K7#6)$#$)W,(5,3,#.+"'!R(=!P;0-,.!8=!C*.J".!

,.(!g/;..,!H=!a".2;.=!a;.(;.X!H,9*6!YVVZ=!UUfEU[f=!

H&,2*)6!`'("&$=!NS,.!#$*0*!F*!,!h*-"."%&!R&$.;90,1$)eO!4&2,*O3(I$7%),3(

?*$,.*#$)&*#6(1&.72!UU=U!3UWZZ7=!YUEYi=!!

Page 252: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y[[!

!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!!NF*);.(!P;0-,4"J,&";.X!D.!D.,4)%"%!;A!T*&*0;.;0-,&"/"&)!".!

S$"4(0*.B%!G"2&'0*!F;;5%=O!!Q,2$*4!R1%&*".!*(=!4"&O3(U&7.(T#%%=Y(<*%(X$",.(

4.)$)*93(&*!K7,,.(A#.,*$)*9=!!#;0;.&;X!H'-,2$!G0*%%6!YVVW=!1=!UkWEUZV=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!Uf!h*@=!YVUY!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!U[!h*@=!UY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!U]!h*@=!YVUY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!YV!h*@=!YVUY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!YU!h*@=!YVUY!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!Yf!h*@=!YVUY!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!Yi!h*@=!YVUY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!YZ!h*@=!YVUY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!YW!h*@=!YVUY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!YV!I,02$!YVUY!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!Yk!I,02$!YVUY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!V]!D10"4!YVUY!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!UV!D10"4!YVUY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!YU!D10"4!YVUY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!Yk!D10"4!YVUY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!Yi!D10"4!YVUY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!fV!D10"4!YVUY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!Y!I,)!YVUY!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=![!I,)!YVUY=!

Page 253: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y[]!

!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!UV!I,)!YVUY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!UU!I,)!YVUY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!UY!I,)!YVUY!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!U[!I,)!YVUY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!U]!I,)!YVUY!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!Uk!I,)!YVUY=!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!Ui!I,)!YVUY!

H&,AA;0(6!D."5,=!h"*4(:;05!.;&*%=!YV!I,)!YVUY=!

H&;25&;.6!8,&$0).!F;.(=!#$*!\'**0!S$"4(X!K0!^0;:".9!H"(*:,)%!".!&$*!#:*.&"*&$!

S*.&'0)=!C'0$,-!,.(!a;.(;.X!C'5*!dG6!YVVW=!

H&0)5*06!H'%,.=!N3C*7H'@M'9,&*(!8.;:4*(9*%X!D.!>.&0;('2&";.!&;!#0,.%9*.(*0!

H&'("*%=O!0",(0.#*39,*%,.(I$7%),3(5,#%,.=!H'%,.!H&0)5*0!,.(!H&*1$,."*!

b$"&&4*6!*(%==!P*:!g;05X!Q;'&4*(9*6!YVVk=!UEUW=!!

H'44"/,.6!I,0",..*!*&!,4=!NQ*%*,02$*0!,.(!Q*%*,02$*(ES;--'."&)!G*0%1*2&"/*%X!

#;:,0(!F0"(9".9!&$*!^,1=O!S,#6$"(R%7+#$)&*(#*%(F,"#W)&.!YZ=Y!3YVVU7!UfVE

U[W=!

#,)4;06!S,&$*0".*6!*&!,4=!g;'&$!H1*,5!d1!,@;'&!T;-;1$;@",!,.(!#0,.%1$;@",X!#$*!

h"0%&!P,&";.,4!S4"-,&*!H'0/*)!;.!T;-;1$;@",!".!S,.,(",.!H2$;;4%=!h".,4!

Q*1;0&=!#;0;.&;X!R9,4*!S,.,(,!T'-,.!Q"9$&%!#0'%&6!YVUU=!!

#nA0;9=!Q*%1;.%*!&;!ND.!D1;4;9)!A0;-!&$*!P,&";.,4!G;%&=O!0",(@#$)&*#6(A&3$=!fV!H*1&!

YVUU=!b*@!fV!D10"4!YVUf=!!

Page 254: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y[k!

!

#$;0.*6!F,00"*=!!E,*%,.(A6#=;(E).63(#*%(F&=3()*(I+"&&6=!!P*:!`*0%*)X!Q'&9*0%!

d."/*0%"&)!G0*%%6!UWWf=!!

?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1!U=!U]!h*@=!YVUY=!

?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1!Y=!Uk!h*@=!YVUY=!

?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1!f=!Uk!h*@=!YVUY=!

?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!h;2'%!^0;'1![=!U]!h*@=!YVUY=!

?,44,.2*6!R4"J,@*&$=!NT"(".9!&$*!$"((*.!2'00"2'4'-X!D.!".&*010*&,&";.!;A!&$*!

4,.9',9*!;A!M'%&"A"2,&";.!".!.".*&**.&$E2*.&'0)!*('2,&";.,4!0*A;0-=O!

>7..)+7672(0",&.=(@,$!&.P([=U!3UWif7X!]EYU=!

?*0("256!R4"J,@*&$=!4&.%3(#.,(@&$(-&.(S7.$)*9=!>44'%=!I,0"*5,!T*".4".=!I"..*,1;4"%X!

h0**!H1"0"&!G'@4"%$".96!YVV[=!!

b,45*0(".*6!?,4*0"*=!!NF*);.(!C*/*4;1-*.&,4"%-=O!0",&.=(#*%(A3=+"&6&9=(f=[!

3UWWf7X![]UE[kW=!

b,45*0EH&*/*.%;.6!^0,2*=!N\'**0!>.&*0%*2&";.%!p!D44"*%X!b$*.!C;*%!>&!^*&!F*&&*0eO!

8*+&22&*(0"&79"$(:&7.*#6;(<*#6=3)3(&-(>.)$)+#6(?337,3(&-(&7.(0)2,3=!YZ!`'.*!

YVUf=!b*@!Uf!D'9'%&!YVUf=!!

b,44"%6!D-)!,.(!`;!?,.R/*0)=!NH*+',4"&)!".!&$*!G0"-,0)!H2$;;4=O!I,G7#6)$),3(f=[!

3YVVV7![VWE[Yf=!

b*%&6!S,.(,2*!,.(!C;.!s"--*0-,.=!T&)*9(E,*%,.=!E,*%,.(#*%(I&+),$=!U=Y!3UWZi7X!

UY]EU]U=!!

Page 255: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y[i!

!

b$"&*6!8*/".!*&!,4=!NR('2,&;0%B!G*0%1*2&"/*%!,@;'&!,!G'@4"2!H2$;;4!C"%&0"2&B%!

D@;0"9".,4!R('2,&";.!R.$,.2*-*.&!D90**-*.&!".!F0"&"%$!S;4'-@",=O!

>#*#%)#*(:&7.*#6(&-(@#$)W,(R%7+#$)&*(f=U!3YVUY7X![YEk]=!!

b"45".%;.6!a".(%,)!,.(!`*.."A*0!G*,0%;.=!!NH2$;;4!S'4&'0*!,.(!&$*!b*44EF*".9!;A!

H,-*EH*+!D&&0,2&*(!g;'&$=!!E,*%,.(#*%(I&+),$==!!Yf!3[76!YVVW=!!G=!][YE]kZ=!!!

b"45".%;.6!H'*=!!Nh;2'%!^0;'1%X!D!h*-"."%&!I*&$;(=O!1,2)*)3$(A,.3J,+$)W,3(&*(I&+)#6(

5,3,#.+"'!R(=!H$,04*.*!P,9)!T*%%*EF"@*0!,.(!I"2$*44*!a=!g,"%*0=!P*:!g;05X!

K+A;0(!d."/*0%"&)!G0*%%6!YVV[=!YiUEYW]=!

b"44*-%6!I;=!>!,-!>./"&*(!&;!,!G,0&)c!P*:!g;05X!C"%.*)ET)1*0";.6!YVVi=!!

b"4%;.6!D4*+=!NT;:!b*!h".(!K'0%*4/*%X!>(*.&"&)!C*/*4;1-*.&!,.(!#:;EH1"0"&!

G*;14*=O!S#.W#.%(R%7+#$)&*#6(5,W),!(kk=Y!3UWWk7X!fVfEfUi=!!

g'*g;'.96!I,99"*!a'=!N?,.2;'/*0X!P;0&$!D-*0"2,B%!I;%&!R+1*.%"/*!S"&)=O!0",(

e#*+&7W,.(I7*=!U]!h*@0',0)!YVUY=!b*@!U]!I,)!YVUf=!!

!

! !

Page 256: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y[Z!

!

'==DBY<[$',$;?ZHJ$2F?H=$#EAFEDF$WHDJE<?BJ$

"B<E<A>$;?ZHJ$2F?H=$#EAFEDF$WHDJE<?BJ$

6A>DBE<BDdJ$4A9$#A@=>D$gHDJE<?BJ$

• C;*%!);'0!24,%%!(;!&$".9%!&;!2*4*@0,&*!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)e!!!

• b$,&!5".(!;A!,2&"/"&"*%!(;!);'!(;e!

• b$,&!,0*!%;-*!;A!&$*!&$".9%!);'!4"5*<("%4"5*!,@;'&!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)e!

• C;!);'!9"/*!/,4*.&".*%!&;!1*;14*e!

• b$;!(;!);'!9"/*!&$*-!&;e!

• b;'4(!);'!9"/*!/,4*.&".*%!&;u3%'99*%&!;1&";.%!;&$*0!&$,.!&$;%*!%,"(_&;!

@;)%6!&;!9"04%6!&;!*/*0);.*6!&;!;.4)!;.*e7!

• C;*%!,.);.*!9"/*!/,4*.&".*%!&;u3N!O7e!

• b$,&!:;'4(!$,11*.!"A!%;-*;.*!9,/*!/,4*.&".*%!&;u3N!O7e!

• b$,&!"A!%;-*;.*!"%!;4(*0!,.(u3N!O7e!!

• b$,&!"A!%;-*;.*!"%!);'.9*0!3N!O7e!

• C;!);'!$,/*!,!%&;0)!,@;'&!,!0*,44)!9;;(6!@,(6!A'..)u?,4*.&".*B%!C,)e!

• >%!&$*0*!,.)&$".9!"-1;0&,.&!>!%$;'4(!5.;:!,@;'&!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)e!b$,&!,0*!

&$*)e!

• >A!);'!'%*(!&;!9;!&;!%2$;;4%!&$,&!("(.B&!&,45!,@;'&!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)6!:*0*!&$*0*!

;&$*0!:,)%!);'!&,45*(!,@;'&!A0"*.(%$"1e!b$,&!:;'4(!);'!4"5*!&;!&*44!-*!

,@;'&!&$*-e!!

! !

Page 257: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y[W!

!

'BE<h(H>>9<BI$4A9$#A@=>D$WHDJE<?BJ$

• S,.!);'!&*44!-*!,!@"&!,@;'&!D.&"EF'44)".9!C,)e!b$,&!$,11*.%!&;(,)e!

• b$)!(;!:*!:*,0!1".5!%$"0&%e!

• C;!);'!'%',44)!:*,0!1".5!%$"0&%e!!b$)e!!b$)!.;&e!!b$,&!,0*!);'0!A,/;'0"&*!

2;4;'0%e!

• b$,&!:;'4(!$,11*.!"A!);'!:;0*!,!1".5!%$"0&!;.!,!(,)!&$,&!:,%.B&!1".5!%$"0&!

(,)e!!

o D%5!A'0&$*0!L'*%&";.%!"A!&$*0*!"%!&,45!,@;'&!,.)&$".9!@,(!$,11*.".9_

&*,%".9!,.(!%;!;.=!!\'*%&";.%!:"44!,%5!:$)!&$,&!$,11*.%6!:$,&!&$*)!

:;'4(!(;!,@;'&!"&!"A!"&!:*0*!$,11*.".9!&;!&$*-e!#;!%;-*;.*!*4%*e!

• b$,&!5".(%!;A!@'44)".9!$,11*.!,&!);'0!%2$;;4e!!b$,&!(;!);'0!&*,2$*0%!(;e!!

b$,&!(;!);'!(;e!!

• b$,&!,0*!&$*!0*,%;.%!1*;14*!,0*!@'44"*(e!b$,&!(;!);'!&$".5!,@;'&!&$"%e!

! !

Page 258: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y]V!

!

5?ECDFdJ$4A9$#A@=>D$WHDJE<?BJ$

• C;!);'!2*4*@0,&*!I;&$*0B%!C,)e!!b$,&!(;!);'!4"5*!&;!(;!A;0!I;&$*0B%!C,)e$

• b$,&!(;*%!);'0!24,%%!(;!;.!I;&$*0B%!(,)e!$

• b$,&!(;*%!);'0!24,%%!(;!A;0!h,&$*0B%!C,)!3"A!".!^0,(*!K.*7e$

• b$,&!"A!%;-*;.*B%!-;-!:;'4(!0,&$*0!$,/*!&$*!h,&$*0B%!C,)!10*%*.&!;0!

%;-*;.*B%!(,(!:;'4(!0,&$*0!$,/*!&$*!I;&$*0B%!C,)!10*%*.&e!$

o D%5!A;0!24,0"A"2,&";.%!,.(!*4,@;0,&";.%$

• b$;!,0*!&$*!1*;14*!".!);'0!A,-"4)e!b$,&!;&$*0!5".(%!;A!A,-"4"*%!,0*!&$*0*e$

• b$,&!:;'4(!%;-*!;A!&$;%*!A,-"4"*%!(;!A;0!hC<ICe$

!

! !

Page 259: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y]U!

!

'>EDFBAED$;?ZHJ$2F?H=$#EAFEDF$WHDJE<?BJ$

6A>DBE<BDdJ$4A9$

• b$,&!"%!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)!,@;'&e!

• b$,&!("(!);'!(;!;.!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)e!!

• b$,&!9;;(!&$".9%!$,11*.*(e!

• C"(!,.)&$".9!$,11*.!&$,&!:,%.B&!9;;(e!

• C;!);'!5.;:!,.)!&**.,9*0%e!b$;!(;!&$*)!9"/*!?,4*.&".*B%!&;e!!

• C;!90;:.E'1%!9"/*!?,4*.&".*B%e!b$;!(;!&$*)!9"/*!&$*-!&;e!

• b"44!);'!9"/*!?,4*.&".*B%!:$*.!);'!90;:!'1e!b$;!:"44!);'!9"/*!&$*-!&;e!P;&!

9"/*!&$*-!&;e!!

V<BT$4A9$

• b$,&!"%!G".5!C,)!,@;'&e$

• b$*.!$,%!@'44)".9!$,11*.*(!,&!);'0!%2$;;4e$

• b$,&!("(!);'!:*,0!A;0!G".5!C,)e!S,.!);'!&*44!-*!,@;'&!&$,&!2$;"2*e$

• C;!);'!:*,0!1".5!;&$*0!(,)%e!b$)e!b$)!.;&e$

! D0*!&$*0*!&$".9%!;.4)!@;)%!%$;'4(!(;e!K.4)!9"04%!%$;'4(!(;e!

• b$,&!(;!);'!0*-*-@*0!,@;'&!&$*!G".5!C,)!,%%*-@4)e!

• b$,&!(;!);'!0*-*-@*0!,@;'&!:$,&!I0%=!Q;/*44,!%,"(!,@;'&!G".5!C,)e!!

! C;!);'!0*-*-@*0!&$*!1;%&*0!%$*!%$;:*(!);'e!!

! b$,&!(;!);'!0*-*-@*0!,@;'&!"&e!

! !

Page 260: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y]Y!

!

5?ECDFdJ$4A9$

• C;!);'!2*4*@0,&*!I;&$*0B%!C,)e$

• b$,&!("(!);'!(;e$

• b$;B%!".!);'0!A,-"4)e$

• C;!,44!A,-"4"*%!$,/*!nne!b$;B%!".!;&$*0!A,-"4"*%e$

• C;!);'!2*4*@0,&*!h,&$*0B%!C,)e$

• b$,&!$,/*!);'!(;.*!A;0!h,&$*0B%!C,)e$

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! !

Page 261: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y]f!

!

'==DBY<[$(,$#A@=>D$"BEDFP<D`$#EAFEDF$WHDJE<?BJ$

%DAZCDF$ABY$#EHYDBE$#H==?FE$f?FTDF$#EAFEDF$WHDJE<?BJ$

• S,.!);'!&*44!-*!,!@"&!,@;'&!);'0!&$;'9$&%!0*9,0(".9!&$*!*/*.&%!;A!&$*!(,)_

$;:!);'!A**4!"&!:*.&e!#$".9%!);'!.;&"2*(e!g;'0!&$;'9$&%!;.!".&*0,2&";.%!&$,&!

&;;5!14,2*!('0".9!&$*!,2&"/"&"*%e!!

• >!.;&"2*(!|!3%;-*&$".9!>!.;&"2*(!('0".9!&$*!%1*2",4!;22,%";.76!:$,&!,0*!);'0!

&$;'9$&%!;.!&$,&!|!32;--*.&6!".&*0,2&";.6!0*,2&";.7e!!

o >%!&$"%!,!2;--;.!;22'00*.2*e!S,.!);'!&*44!-*!,@;'&!;&$*0!&"-*%!

);'B/*!.;&"2*(!&$"%e!

• S,.!);'!&*44!-*!,@;'&!2;.%"(*0,&";.%!&$,&!-,)!$,/*!".A4'*.2*(!);'0!14,..".9!

;A!|e!b*0*!&$*0*!;&$*0!:,)%!);'!-"9$&!$,/*!0*%1;.(*(<&$".9%!);'!-"9$&!

$,/*!14,..*(!"A!2"02'-%&,.2*%!:*0*!("AA*0*.&e!3#$"%!-,)!".24'(*!A,2&;0%!%'2$!

,%!2;.2*0.%!*+10*%%*(!@)!1,0*.&%!;.!,!9"/*.!"%%'*6!%2$;;4!1;4"2"*%!,.(!

("%2'%%";.%6!,.(!%;!;.=!!>!-,)!(0,:!A0;-!%;-*&$".9!&$,&!&,5*%!14,2*!:$"4*!>!

,-!,&!&$*!%2$;;4!,%!,.!*+,-14*=7!

• >!5.;:!&$*0*!,0*!%;!-,.)!2;.%"(*0,&";.%!&$,&!9;!".&;!*/*0)!,%1*2&!;A!

&*,2$".9=!>B-!".&*0*%&*(!".!&$*!14,..".9!10;2*%%!A;0!&$"%!(,)_:$,&!A,2&;0%!

:*0*!,&!14,)!:$*.!14,..".9!&$*!*/*.&%e!!

>!("%2'%%*(!&$*!A"0%&!&:;!L'*%&";.%!:"&$!&$*!HHb6!@'&!.;&!&$*!%*2;.(6!,%!&$*)!(;!.;&!

14,.!24,%%0;;-!,2&"/"&"*%=!!

! !

Page 262: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y][!

!

#A@=>D$'8?F<I<BA>$/BCABZD@DBE$f?FTDF$"BEDFP<D`$#EAFEDF$WHDJE<?BJ$

• b$,&!"%!);'0!2'00*.&!0;4*!".!&$*!?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!F;,0(!,.(!&$"%!%2$;;4e!

• b$,&!"%!&$*!$"%&;0)!;A!&$"%!1;%"&";._:$*.!,.(!$;:!("(!"&!@*9".e!!

• S;'4(!);'!&*44!-*!,!@"&!,@;'&!&$*!1;1'4,&";.!&$,&!);'!:;05!:"&$!,&!&$"%!

%2$;;4e!!

• S,.!);'!(*%20"@*!%;-*!;A!&$*!%-,44!90;'1!,.(!".("/"(',4!,2&"/"&"*%!);'!0'.!

:"&$!%&'(*.&%!".!);'0!2,%*4;,(e!!

• b$,&!5".(%!;A!9*.(*0!".&*0,2&";.%!$,/*!);'!.;&"2*(!@*&:**.!%&'(*.&%!&$,&!

);'!:;05!:"&$e!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! !

Page 263: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y]]!

!

#A@=>D$'Y@<B<JEFAE<?B$"BEDFP<D`$#EAFEDF$WHDJE<?BJ$

• S;'4(!);'!&*44!-*!,!@"&!,@;'&!&$*!%2$;;4!,.(!"&%!$"%&;0)e!!

• >B(!4"5*!&;!9*&!,!%*.%*!;A!&$*!9*.*0,4!2'4&'0*!;A!&$*!%2$;;4!,.(!"&B%!

(*-;90,1$"2%=!S;'4(!);'!("%2'%%!&$*!.*"9$@;'0$;;(!,.(!&$*!%&'(*.&%!,.(!

A,-"4"*%!$*0*e!!

• b$,&!5".(%!;A!1,0*.&!"./;4/*-*.&!&,5*!14,2*!,&!&$*!%2$;;4e!>%!&$*0*!,.)&$".9!

&$"%!%2$;;4!"%!:*44E5.;:.!A;0!&$,&!);'!:;'4(!%,)!"%!1,0&!;A!:$,&!&$*!%2$;;4!"%!

,@;'&e!

• S;'4(!);'!&,45!,@;'&!&$*!%2$;;4B%!0;4*!".!&$*!2;--'."&)e!!

• b$,&!$,%!@**.!&$*!%2$;;4B%!0*4,&";.%$"1!:"&$!%&,.(,0("J*(!&*%&".9e!T;:!$,/*!

&*,2$*0%!,.(!A,-"4"*%!0*%1;.(*(!&;!.*:!"-14*-*.&,&";.!;A!%&,.(,0("J*(!

&*%&%e!

• T;:!:;'4(!);'!(*%20"@*!&$*!%2$;;4!,.(!"&%!&*,2$*0B%!,110;,2$*%!&;!,2,(*-"2!

4*,0.".9e!!

• C'0".9!);'0!&"-*!$*0*6!:$,&!"%%'*%!$,/*!);'!%**.!@0;'9$&!A;0:,0(!A;0!,.&"E

@'44)".9!2,-1,"9.%!;0!("/*0%"&)!,:,0*.*%%!*('2,&";.e!

!

!

!

!

Page 264: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y]k!

!

'==DBY<[$:,$#A@=>D$:?BJDBE$;?F@J$

VAFDBEA>$:?BJDBE$;?F@$

/[=>?F<BI$/PDF9YA9$2DBYDF$:H>EHFD$<B$A$6ABZ?HPDF$VF<@AF9$:>AJJF??@$

#EHY9$4DJZF<=E<?B$

#$"%!0*%*,02$!"%!@*".9!2;.('2&*(!,%!1,0&!;A!,!G$C!("%%*0&,&";.=!>&!"./;4/*%!,!

&$0**E-;.&$!A"*4(!%&'()!,&!,.!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4=!#$*!%&'()!A;2'%*%!;.!*/*0)(,)!

".&*0,2&";.%!&$,&!2;.&0"@'&*!&;!2$"4(0*.l%!'.(*0%&,.(".9!;A!9*.(*0=!

#$*!9;,4!;A!&$*!10;M*2&!"%!&;!4*,0.!-;0*!,@;'&!$;:!9*.(*0!.;0-%!,0*!

*%&,@4"%$*(!".!*,04)!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4=!D!24,%%0;;-!".!&$"%!%2$;;4!"%!;A!".&*0*%&!('*!

&;!&$*!"-1;0&,.&!%&*1%!&;:,0(!*L'"&,@4*!,.(!%,A*!4*,0.".9!*./"0;.-*.&%!&$,&!$,/*!

,40*,()!@*9'.!".!&$"%!%2$;;4!,.(!".!&$*!?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!F;,0(=!

)8JDFPAE<?BJ$

>!:"44!@*!%"&&".9!".!;.!);'0!2$"4(B%!24,%%!('0".9!24,%%!&"-*6!".!&$*!4'.2$0;;-6!

,.(!;.!&$*!14,)90;'.(6!@*&:**.!h*@0',0)!iEI,)!UZ6!YVUY=!!>!:"44!,&&*.(!24,%%![E]!

(,)%!,!:**5!;/*0!&$"%!&"-*=!#$*0*!:"44!.;&!@*!,(("&";.,4!&"-*!0*L'"0*(!;A!&$*!

%&'(*.&%!A;0!&$"%!1;0&";.!;A!&$*!%&'()=!

#$*!24,%%0;;-6!14,)90;'.(6!,.(!4'.2$!;@%*0/,&";.%!:"44!A;2'%!;.X!

} b$,&!".A;0-,4!10,2&"2*%!&,5*!14,2*!@*&:**.!%&,AA!-*-@*0%!,.(!%&'(*.&%!&$,&!

0*A*0!&;!9*.(*0e!

} b$,&!,2&";.%!(*-;.%&0,&*!%&'(*.&%B!0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!9*.(*0!.;0-%e!

!

Page 265: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y]i!

!

#$"%!0*%*,02$!:"44!2;.%"(*0!0;4*!;A!9*.(*0!.;0-%!".!2;;0(".,&".9!%;2",4!

".24'%";.!,.(!*+24'%";.!".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4!24,%%0;;-%=!H'2$!,!10;M*2&!:"44!10;/"(*!

'%*A'4!".%"9$&!A;0!*('2,&;0%!:;05".9!&;!20*,&*!%,A*!%2$;;4%=!!!

D%!,!A;0-*0!?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!F;,0(!*-14;)**6!>!,-!,:,0*!;A!&$*!.**(!A;0!

-"."-,4!("%0'1&";.!;A!*/*0)(,)!%2$;;4!4"A*=!I)!9;,4!"%!&;!@*2;-*!,!A,-"4",06!A0"*.(4)6!

,.(!'.;@&0'%"/*!1,0&!;A!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!H&'(*.&%!-,)!$,/*!*.2;'.&*0*(!;&$*0!

1*;14*!:$;!@*$,/*!%"-"4,04)!:"&$".!&$*"0!24,%%0;;-%6!%'2$!,%!%&'(*.&!&*,2$*0%!".!

&$*"0!A"0%&!14,2*-*.&%6!:$;!:;'4(!@*!10*%*.&!,.(!-,5".9!;@%*0/,&";.%!".!&$*!

24,%%0;;-%!:"&$;'&!&*,2$".9!;0!@*2;-".9!("0*2&4)!"./;4/*(=!!!

>!,-!$,11)!&;!10;/"(*!0*A*0*.2*%!A0;-!&$;%*!,&!%2$;;4%!>!$,/*!:;05*(!".!:$;!

2,.!,&&*%&!&;!-)!10;A*%%";.,4!2;.('2&6!.;.EM'(9-*.&,4!,110;,2$6!24*,0!@;'.(,0"*%6!

,.(!%;!;.=!>A!,%5*(!,@;'&!-)!10*%*.2*6!>!:"44!4*&!%&'(*.&%!5.;:!>!,-!A0;-!&$*!

d."/*0%"&)!;A!F0"&"%$!S;4'-@",!,.(!,-!".&*0*%&*(!".!:$,&!"&B%!4"5*!&;!@*!".!

*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4!;0!10;/"(*!%"-"4,0!,.%:*0%!&$,&!:"44!,%%"%&!".!*%&,@4"%$".9!-)!

10*%*.2*!,%!,.!;0(".,0)!1,0&!;A!%2$;;4!4"A*=!#$"%!0*%*,02$!"%!.;&!A'.(*(!@)!,.)!

,9*.2"*%=!

>A!);'!(;!.;&!:,.&!);'0!2$"4(!&;!@*!"./;4/*(!".!&$*!;@%*0/,&";.%6!>!:"44!.;&!

&,5*!.;&*%!;.!&$*-!;0!".&*0,2&";.%!".!:$"2$!&$*)!1,0&"2"1,&*=!

;?ZHJ$2F?H=J$

>.!,(("&";.!&;!*/*0)(,)!;@%*0/,&";.%6!>!:"44!,4%;!$;4(!%-,44!A;2'%!90;'1%!:"&$!

&$*!2$"4(0*.!;.!&$0**!%*4*2&!(,)%_?,4*.&".*B%!C,)6!D.&"EF'44)".9!31".5!%$"0&7!C,)6!

,.(!I;&$*0B%!C,)=!#$*!A;2'%!90;'1!(,)%!:*0*!2$;%*.!&;!,((0*%%!&$0**!&0*.(%!:"&$".!

Page 266: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y]Z!

!

%2$;4,0%$"1!;.!9*.(*0!,.(!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%X!A0"*.(%$"16!A,-"4)6!,.(!39*.(*0*(7!

0*,%;.%!A;0!@'44)".9=!DA&*0!*,2$!%1*2",4!;22,%";.!(,)6!>!:"44!$;4(!,!@0"*A!".&*0/"*:!

:"&$!&$*!24,%%0;;-!&*,2$*0!,.(!HHb!3"A!,114"2,@4*7!,%!&;!:$,&!&$*)!.;&"2*(!,.(!

0*A4*2&*(!;.!".!&*0-%!;A!&$*!24,%%0;;-!,2&"/"&"*%!,.(!:$,&!&;;5!14,2*!;/*0!&$*!(,)!

32;1"*%!;A!&$*!%,-14*!A;2'%!90;'1!,.(!".&*0/"*:!L'*%&";.%!,0*!,/,"4,@4*!'1;.!

0*L'*%&7=!

>!:"44!&*44!%&'(*.&%!0*4*/,.&6!@'&!.;&!(*&,"4*(6!".A;0-,&";.!,@;'&!&$*!0*%*,02$=!

b$*.!2;.('2&".9!A;2'%!90;'1%6!&$*)!:"44!5.;:!&$,&!>B-!".&*0*%&*(!".!:$,&!&$*)!(;!

;.6!A;0!*+,-14*6!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)6!,.(!:$,&!&$*)!&$".5!,@;'&!&$*!$;4"(,)=!

#$*!A;2'%!90;'1%!:"44!,44;:!%&'(*.&%B!%&;0"*%!&;!@*!9"/*.!A;2'%!".!-)!,.,4)%"%!

;A!&$*!%2$;;4!2'4&'0*=!R,2$!A;2'%!90;'1!:"44!$,/*!;A!A;'0!;0!A"/*!%&'(*.&%_*.;'9$!

2$"4(0*.!&$,&!&$*)!2,.!("%2'%%!&$*!L'*%&";.%!:"&$!*,2$!;&$*06!@'&!.;&!%;!-,.)!&$,&!

&$*!L'"*&*0!2$"4(0*.!4,25!;11;0&'."&"*%!&;!%1*,5!;0!:"44!$,/*!,!%*.%*!;A!%1*,5".9!".!

A0;.&!;A!,44!&$*"0!1**0%=!!R,2$!A;2'%!90;'1!:"44!@*!,110;+"-,&*4)!U!$;'0=!>A!,!%&'(*.&!

1,0&"2"1,&*%!".!&$*!90;'1!&$*)!:"44!4"5*4)!%1*.(!f!$;'0%!;'&%"(*!;A!".A;0-,4!24,%%!

,2&"/"&"*%!%'2$!,%!L'"*&!0*,(".9!,.(!14,)!2*.&0*!&"-*!;/*0!&$*!2;'0%*!;A!f!-;.&$%=!

H&'(*.&%!:$;!,0*!.;&!1,0&"2"1,&".9!".!&$"%!%&'()!:"44!.;&!M;".!&$*!A;2'%!

90;'1%=!D%!&$*!90;'1%!:"44!0;&,&*6!&$*!-,M;0"&)!;A!&$*!24,%%!:"44!@*!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!

:$"4*!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1%!&,5*!14,2*!%;!&$*)!:"44!.;&!%&,.(!;'&=!H&'(*.&%!:"44!,4:,)%!

$,/*!&$*!2$;"2*!,%!&;!:$*&$*0!;0!.;&!&;!1,0&"2"1,&*6!&$*)!:"44!@*!0*-".(*(!,&!&$*!

@*9"..".9!;A!*/*0)!90;'1!&$,&!&$*)!2,.!(;!.;&!$,/*!&;!,.%:*0!,.)!L'*%&";.%!&$*)!(;!

.;&!:,.&!&;!,.%:*0=!

Page 267: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Y]W!

!

%FDAE@DBE$?_$4AEA$

F;&$!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1%!,.(!".&*0/"*:%!:"44!@*!,'(";!0*2;0(*(=!D44!.;&*%!:"44!@*!

5*1&!;.!-)!;:.!2;-1'&*0!&$,&!$,%!1,%%:;0(!*.20)1&";.!%;4*4)!A;0!-)!'%*=!G0".&*(!

(;2'-*.&%!,.(!&$*!,'(";!0*2;0(".9!:"44!@*!5*1&!".!,!4;25*(!A"4".9!2,@".*&!:"&$!C0=!

I;.,!^4*,%;.!3,.(!(*%&0;)*(!,A&*0!]!)*,0%7=!

#$*!;'&2;-*%!;A!&$"%!%&'()!:"44!@*!("%2'%%*(!".!,!G$C!("%%*0&,&";.!,.(!-,)!

@*!1'@4"%$*(!,%!,!@;;5!;0!,%!,0&"24*%!".!M;'0.,4%!,.(!,.&$;4;9"*%!;.!*('2,&";.!,.(!

%;2",4!M'%&"2*!"%%'*%=!>A!);'!:;'4(!4"5*!&;!%**!&$*!0*%'4&%!;A!&$"%!%&'()6!);'!,0*!

:*42;-*!&;!4*,/*!);'0!-,"4".9!,((0*%%!;.!&$"%!2;.%*.&!A;0-!,.(!,!2;1)!:"44!@*!%*.&!

&;!);'!'1;.!&$*!2;-14*&";.!;A!&$*!10;M*2&=!

.?`$`<>>$0<JTJ$?_$ECD$#EHY9$8D$'YYFDJJDY+$

D%!>!:"44!.;&!@*!".&*0,2&".9!("0*2&4)!:"&$!&$*!2$"4(0*.!('0".9!&$*!;@%*0/,&";.%6!

&$*0*!,0*!.;!A;0*%**,@4*!0"%5%=!

C'0".9!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1%6!,%!".!,.)!2;./*0%,&";.6!"&!"%!1;%%"@4*!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!

-"9$&!$,/*!%;-*!'.14*,%,.&!A**4".9%=!>!:"44!-,5*!%'0*!2$"4(0*.!,0*!,:,0*!;A!

0*%;'02*%!,&!&$*"0!%2$;;4%!32;'.%*4;06!&*,2$*06!;0!,(-"."%&0,&";.!,/,"4,@"4"&)7!"A!&$*)!

.**(!A'0&$*0!%'11;0&=!#$*!90;'1%!:"44!@*!$*4(!".!,.!;1*.!%*&&".9!34"@0,0)6!0*%;'02*!

0;;-7!,.(!%&0'2&'0*(!&;!-"-"2!("%2'%%";.!90;'1%!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!:"44!$,/*!

*.2;'.&*0*(!('0".9!10;M*2&%!:"&$!&*,2$*0E4"@0,0",.%6!%2$;;4!2;'.%*4".9!90;'1%6!,.(!

;&$*0!%*&&".9%!:$*0*!&$*)!$,/*!("%2'%%";.%!:"&$!,!A,-"4",0!,('4&!:$;!"%!.;&!&$*"0!

&*,2$*0=!!>.!&$"%!:,)6!&$*!%&0'2&'0*!:"44!.;&!@*!;'&!;A!&$*!;0(".,0)!A;0!&$*!2$"4(0*.!

,.(!:"44!$*41!A,2"4"&,&*!,!2;-A;0&,@4*6!4;:!0"%5!*./"0;.-*.&=!#$*!L'*%&";.%!,%5*(!,0*!

Page 268: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YkV!

!

9*,0*(!&;!@*!;1*.!*.(*(!%;!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!:"44!@*!,@4*!&;!".A4'*.2*!&$*!("0*2&";.!;A!

&$*!("%2'%%";.=!!#$"%!,110;,2$!:"44!$"9$4"9$&!:$,&!"%!"-1;0&,.&!&;!&$*-!,.(!&;!

*.%'0*!&$*)!,0*!.;&!10*%%'0*(!&;!("%2'%%!,.)&$".9!&$,&!:"44!@*!;'&%"(*!&$*"0!2;-A;0&!

J;.*=!D&!&$*!@*9"..".9!;A!*/*0)!A;2'%!90;'1!&$*!%&'(*.&%!:"44!@*!0*-".(*(!&$,&!&$*)!

,0*!A0**!&;!.;&!,.%:*0!,.)!L'*%&";.!&$*)!(;!.;&!:"%$!&;!,.%:*0=!

V?EDBE<A>$(DBD_<EJ$?_$ECD$#EHY9$

b$"4*!&$*!%&'()!:"44!.;&!.*2*%%,0"4)!$,/*!("0*2&!@*.*A"&!A;0!%&'(*.&%!;0!

&*,2$*0%6!&$*!%&'(*.&%!-,)!*.M;)!&$*!("%2'%%";.%!,.(!A".(!&$*-!".&*0*%&".9=!

.?`$f<>>$:?B_<YDBE<A><E9$(D$5A<BEA<BDY+$

I)!.;&*!&,5".9!:"44!@*!(;.*!;.!-)!1,%%:;0(E10;&*2&*(!4,1&;1=!D%!>!:"44!&,5*!

.;&*%!;.!-'4&"14*!2$"4(0*.!3:"&$;'&!'%".9!&$*"0!0*,4!.,-*%76!>!:"44!.;&!%$;:!-)!

.;&*%!&;!&$*!%&'(*.&%!%$;'4(!&$*)!0*L'*%&!&;!%**!&$*-6!,%!&$"%!2;'4(!@*!,!

2;.A"(*.&",4"&)!"%%'*!:"&$!".A;0-,&";.!0*9,0(".9!&$*"0!1**0%=!b*0*!>!&;!@*!,%5*(6!>!

:"44!&*44!&$*-!&$,&!-)!2;-1'&*0!"%!M'%&!A;0!-*!&;!'%*=!

G,0&"2"1,.&%!:"44!@*!9"/*.!,!1%*'(;.)-!:"&$!:$"2$!&$*)!:"44!@*!0*A*00*(!

&$0;'9$;'&!&$*!(,&,!2;44*2&";.!10;2*%%!,.(!1;%%"@4*!A'&'0*!1'@4"2,&";.%=!K&$*0!

"(*.&"A)".9!(*&,"4%!3*=9=!&$*!.,-*!;A!&$*!%2$;;47!:"44!,4%;!@*!2$,.9*(=!

h;2'%!90;'1!1,0&"2"1,.&%!:"44!@*!*.2;'0,9*(!&;!0*%1*2&!*,2$!;&$*0B%!10"/,2)j!

$;:*/*06!,%!:"&$!,.)!("%2'%%";.!&$,&!&,5*%!14,2*!".!&$*!%2$;;46!:*!2,..;&!2;.&0;4!

:$,&!&$*!2$"4(0*.!0*1*,&!;'&%"(*!;A!&$*!90;'1%=!>A!,@'%*!;0!.*94*2&!;A!,!2$"4(!"%!

0*/*,4*(6!&$*!0*%*,02$*0!3,%!:"&$!1'@4"2!%2$;;4!*-14;)**%7!-'%&!0*1;0&!&$*!

".A;0-,&";.!&;!,110;10",&*!,'&$;0"&"*%=!

Page 269: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YkU!

!

VA9@DBE$

#$*0*!"%!.;!1,)!"./;4/*(!".!&$"%!%&'()=!#$*!%&'()!:"44!,4%;!0*L'"0*!-"."-,4!

&"-*!,.(!.;!2;%&%!&;!&$*!1,0&"2"1,.&%=!

fC?$:AB$*?H$:?BEAZE$<_$*?H$.APD$WHDJE<?BJ$'8?HE$EC<J$#EHY9+$

>A!);'!$,/*!,.)!L'*%&";.%!;0!2;.2*0.%!,@;'&!:$,&!:*!,0*!,%5".9!;A!);'6!

14*,%*!2;.&,2&!C0=!I;.,!^4*,%;.!;0!D."5,!H&,AA;0(=!#$*!.,-*%!,.(!&*4*1$;.*!

.'-@*0%!,0*!4"%&*(!,&!&$*!&;1!;A!&$*!A"0%&!1,9*!;A!&$"%!A;0-=!

fC?$:AB$*?H$:?BEAZE$<_$*?H$.APD$:?@=>A<BEJ$'8?HE$EC<J$#EHY9+$

>A!);'!$,/*!,.)!2;.2*0.%!,@;'&!);'0!0"9$&%!,%!,!0*%*,02$!%'@M*2&!,.(<;0!);'0!

*+1*0"*.2*%!:$"4*!1,0&"2"1,&".9!".!&$"%!%&'()6!);'!-,)!2;.&,2&!&$*!Q*%*,02$!H'@M*2&!

>.A;0-,&";.!a".*!".!&$*!dFS!KAA"2*!;A!Q*%*,02$!H*0/"2*%!,&!kV[EZYYEZ]WZ!;0!"A!4;.9!

("%&,.2*!*E-,"4!QH>a~;0%='@2=2,!;0!2,44!&;44!A0**!UEZiiEZYYEZ]WZ=!

!>!2;.%*.&<>!(;!.;&!2;.%*.&!32"024*!;.*7!&;!-)!2$"4(B%!1,0&"2"1,&";.!".!&$"%!

%&'()=!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn!H'@M*2&!H"9.,&'0*! C,&*!

3G,0*.&!;0!^',0(",.!H"9.,&'0*7!

nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn!G0".&*(!P,-*!;A!G,0*.&!;0!

^',0(",.!H"9.".9!D@;/*!

nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn!G0".&*(!P,-*!;A!S$"4(=!

#$*!%"9.,&'0*!@*4;:!,25.;:4*(9*%!&$,&!>!$,/*!0*2*"/*(!,!2;1)!;A!&$"%!4*&&*0=!

nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn!H'@M*2&!H"9.,&'0*! C,&*!

3G,0*.&!;0!^',0(",.!H"9.,&'0*7!

Page 270: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YkY!

!

%DAZCDF$:?BJDBE$;?F@$

/[=>?F<BI$/PDF9YA9$2DBYDF$:H>EHFD$<B$A$6ABZ?HPDF$VF<@AF9$:>AJJF??@$

#EHY9$4DJZF<=E<?B$

#$"%!0*%*,02$!"%!@*".9!2;.('2&*(!,%!1,0&!;A!,!G$C!("%%*0&,&";.=!>&!"./;4/*%!,!

&$0**E-;.&$!A"*4(!%&'()!,&!,.!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4=!#$*!%&'()!A;2'%*%!;.!*/*0)(,)!

".&*0,2&";.%!&$,&!2;.&0"@'&*!&;!2$"4(0*.B%!'.(*0%&,.(".9%!;A!9*.(*0=!

#$*!9;,4!;A!&$*!10;M*2&!"%!&;!4*,0.!-;0*!,@;'&!$;:!9*.(*0!.;0-%!,0*!

*%&,@4"%$*(!".!*,04)!*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4=!D!24,%%0;;-!".!&$"%!%2$;;4!"%!;A!".&*0*%&!('*!

&;!&$*!"-1;0&,.&!%&*1%!&;:,0(!*L'"&,@4*!,.(!%,A*!4*,0.".9!*./"0;.-*.&%!&$,&!$,/*!

,40*,()!@*9'.!".!&$"%!%2$;;4!,.(!".!&$*!?,.2;'/*0!H2$;;4!F;,0(=!

VF?ZDYHFDJ$

#$"%!10;M*2&!"%!,!-'4&"E-*&$;(6!L',4"&,&"/*!%&'()!@,%*(!*-1"0"2,44)!".!

;@%*0/,&";.%6!A;2'%!90;'1%6!,.(!".&*0/"*:%=!!!

)8JDFPAE<?BJ$

>A!);'!,90**!&;!1,0&"2"1,&*!".!&$"%!%&'()6!>!:"44!%"&!".!;.!24,%%E&"-*!,.(!;@%*0/*!

".&*0,2&";.%!".!&$*!4'.2$0;;-!,.(!;.!&$*!14,)90;'.(!@*&:**.!h*@0',0)!iEI,)!UZ6!

YVUY=!>!:"44!,&&*.(!24,%%*%![E]!(,)%!,!:**5!;/*0!&$"%!1*0";(=!#$*0*!:"44!.;&!@*!,.)!

,(("&";.,4!&"-*!0*L'"0*(!@)!%&'(*.&%!;0!*('2,&;0%!A;0!&$"%!1;0&";.!;A!&$*!%&'()=!

#$*!24,%%0;;-6!14,)90;'.(6!,.(!4'.2$!;@%*0/,&";.%!:"44!A;2'%!;.X!

} b$,&!".A;0-,4!10,2&"2*%!&,5*!14,2*!@*&:**.!%&,AA!-*-@*0%!,.(!%&'(*.&%!&$,&!

0*A*0!&;!9*.(*0e!

} b$,&!,2&";.%!(*-;.%&0,&*!%&'(*.&%B!0*4,&";.%$"1%!&;!9*.(*0!.;0-%e!

Page 271: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Ykf!

!

#$"%!0*%*,02$!:"44!2;.%"(*0!0;4*!;A!9*.(*0!.;0-%!".!2;;0(".,&".9!%;2",4!

".24'%";.!,.(!*+24'%";.!".!10"-,0)!%2$;;4!24,%%0;;-%=!H'2$!,!10;M*2&!:"44!10;/"(*!

'%*A'4!".%"9$&!A;0!*('2,&;0%!:;05".9!&;!20*,&*!%,A*!%2$;;4%=!!!

D%!,!A;0-*0!?HF!*-14;)**6!>!,-!,:,0*!;A!&$*!.**(!A;0!-"."-,4!("%0'1&";.!;A!

*/*0)(,)!%2$;;4!4"A*=!I)!9;,4!"%!&;!@*2;-*!,!A,-"4",06!A0"*.(4)6!,.(!'.;@&0'%"/*!1,0&!

;A!&$*!24,%%0;;-=!H&'(*.&%!-,)!$,/*!*.2;'.&*0*(!;&$*0!1*;14*!:$;!@*$,/*!

%"-"4,04)!:"&$".!&$*"0!24,%%0;;-%6!%'2$!,%!%&'(*.&!&*,2$*0%!".!&$*"0!A"0%&!14,2*-*.&%6!

:$;!:;'4(!@*!10*%*.&!,.(!-,5".9!;@%*0/,&";.%!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-%!:"&$;'&!&*,2$".9!

;0!@*2;-".9!("0*2&4)!"./;4/*(=!

>!,-!$,11)!&;!10;/"(*!0*A*0*.2*%!A0;-!&$;%*!,&!%2$;;4%!>!$,/*!:;05*(!".!:$;!

2,.!,&&*%&!&;!-)!10;A*%%";.,4!2;.('2&6!.;.EM'(9-*.&,4!,110;,2$6!24*,0!@;'.(,0"*%6!

,.(!%;!;.=!>A!,%5*(!,@;'&!-)!10*%*.2*6!>!:"44!4*&!%&'(*.&%!5.;:!>!,-!A0;-!&$*!

d."/*0%"&)!;A!F0"&"%$!S;4'-@",!,.(!,-!".&*0*%&*(!".!:$,&!"&B%!4"5*!&;!@*!".!

*4*-*.&,0)!%2$;;4!;0!;AA*0!%"-"4,0!,.%:*0%!&$,&!:"44!,%%"%&!".!*%&,@4"%$".9!-)!

10*%*.2*!,%!,.!;0(".,0)!1,0&!;A!%2$;;4!4"A*=!#$"%!0*%*,02$!"%!.;&!A'.(*(!@)!,.)!

,9*.2"*%=!

>A!,!1,0*.&!(;*%!.;&!:"%$!&$*"0!2$"4(!&;!@*!"./;4/*(!".!&$*!;@%*0/,&";.%6!>!:"44!

.;&!&,5*!.;&*%!;.!&$,&!2$"4(!;0!&$*!".&*0,2&";.%!".!:$"2$!&$*)!1,0&"2"1,&*=!

;?ZHJ$2F?H=J$

>.!,(("&";.!&;!*/*0)(,)!;@%*0/,&";.%6!>!:"44!,4%;!$;4(!%-,44!A;2'%!90;'1%!:"&$!

&$*!2$"4(0*.!;.!&$0**!%*4*2&!(,)%_?,4*.&".*B%!C,)6!D.&"EF'44)".9!31".5!%$"0&7!C,)6!

,.(!I;&$*0B%!C,)=!#$*!A;2'%!90;'1!(,)%!:*0*!2$;%*.!&;!,((0*%%!&$0**!&0*.(%!:"&$".!

Page 272: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Yk[!

!

%2$;4,0%$"1!;.!9*.(*0!,.(!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%X!A0"*.(%$"16!A,-"4)6!,.(!39*.(*0*(7!

0*,%;.%!A;0!@'44)".9=!DA&*0!*,2$!%1*2",4!;22,%";.!(,)6!>!:"44!$;4(!,!@0"*A!".&*0/"*:!

:"&$!&$*!24,%%0;;-!&*,2$*0!,.(!HHb!3"A!,114"2,@4*7!,%!&;!:$,&!&$*)!.;&"2*(!,.(!

0*A4*2&*(!;.!".!&*0-%!;A!&$*!24,%%0;;-!,2&"/"&"*%!,.(!:$,&!&;;5!14,2*!;/*0!&$*!(,)!

32;1"*%!;A!&$*!%,-14*!A;2'%!90;'1!,.(!".&*0/"*:!L'*%&";.%!,0*!,/,"4,@4*!'1;.!

0*L'*%&7=!

>!:"44!&*44!%&'(*.&%!0*4*/,.&6!@'&!.;&!(*&,"4*(6!".A;0-,&";.!,@;'&!&$*!0*%*,02$=!

b$*.!2;.('2&".9!A;2'%!90;'1%6!&$*)!:"44!5.;:!&$,&!>B-!".&*0*%&*(!".!:$,&!&$*)!(;!

;.6!A;0!*+,-14*6!?,4*.&".*B%!C,)6!,.(!:$,&!&$*)!&$".5!,@;'&!&$*!;22,%";.=!#$*!A;2'%!

90;'1%!:"44!,44;:!%&'(*.&%B!".%"9$&!&;!$,/*!".20*,%*(!10"-,2)!".!-)!,.,4)%"%!;A!&$*!

%2$;;4!2'4&'0*=!R,2$!A;2'%!90;'1!:"44!$,/*![!;0!]!%&'(*.&%_*.;'9$!2$"4(0*.!&$,&!

&$*)!2,.!("%2'%%!&$*!L'*%&";.%!:"&$!*,2$!;&$*06!@'&!.;&!%;!-,.)!&$,&!&$*!L'"*&*0!

2$"4(0*.!4,25!;11;0&'."&"*%!&;!%1*,5!;0!:"44!$,/*!,!%*.%*!;A!%1*,5".9!".!A0;.&!;A!,44!

&$*"0!1**0%=!R,2$!A;2'%!90;'1!:"44!@*!,110;+"-,&*4)!;.*!$;'0=!>A!,!%&'(*.&!

1,0&"2"1,&*%!".!&$*!90;'1!&$*)!:"44!4"5*4)!%1*.(!f!$;'0%!;'&%"(*!;A!".A;0-,4!24,%%!

,2&"/"&"*%!%'2$!,%!L'"*&!0*,(".9!,.(!14,)!2*.&0*!&"-*!;/*0!&$*!2;'0%*!;A!f!-;.&$%=!

H&'(*.&%!:$;!,0*!.;&!1,0&"2"1,&".9!".!&$"%!%&'()!:"44!.;&!M;".!&$*!A;2'%!

90;'1%=!D%!&$*!90;'1%!:"44!0;&,&*6!&$*!-,M;0"&)!;A!&$*!24,%%!:"44!@*!".!&$*!24,%%0;;-!

:$"4*!*,2$!A;2'%!90;'1%!&,5*%!14,2*!%;!&$*)!:"44!.;&!%&,.(!;'&=!H&'(*.&%!:"44!,4:,)%!

$,/*!&$*!2$;"2*!,%!&;!:$*&$*0!;0!.;&!&;!1,0&"2"1,&*6!,.(!&$*)!:"44!@*!0*-".(*(!,&!&$*!

@*9"..".9!;A!*/*0)!90;'1!&$,&!&$*)!2,.!(;!.;&!$,/*!&;!,.%:*0!,.)!L'*%&";.%!&$*)!(;!

.;&!:,.&!&;!,.%:*0=!

Page 273: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Yk]!

!

"BEDFP<D`J$

DA&*0!*,2$!%1*2",4!;22,%";.!(,)6!>!:"44!$;4(!,!@0"*A!".&*0/"*:!:"&$!);'!

0*9,0(".9!14,..".9!&$*!*/*.&%!;A!&$,&!(,)!,.(!5*)!-;-*.&%!);'!.;&"2*(=!#$"%!"%!".!

;0(*0!&;!-,5*!%'0*!&*,2$*0!*+1*0&"%*!"%!0*A4*2&*(!".!&$*!,.,4)%"%!;A!&$*!(,)=!#$*0*!

:"44!@*!&$0**!".&*0/"*:%!".!&;&,46!*,2$!,110;+"-,&*4)!$,4A!,.!$;'06!&$;'9$!);'!2,.!

(*&*0-".*!"A!);'!:;'4(!4"5*!&$*!".&*0/"*:!&;!0'.!,!4;.9*0!;0!%$;0&*0!&"-*!9"/*.!&$*!

,-;'.&!;A!".A;0-,&";.!);'!:"%$!&;!%$,0*=!

>!,-!$,11)!&;!9"/*!);'!,!2;1)!;A!&$*!&0,.%20"1&%!,.(!:0"&*E'1%!;A!&$*%*!

".&*0/"*:%!,.(!:;'4(!:*42;-*!2;00*2&";.!:*0*!,.)!,0*,%!&;!0*,(!,%!,.!".,22'0,&*!

0*10*%*.&,&";.!;A!);'0!/"*:%=!

%FDAE@DBE$?_$4AEA$

F;&$!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1%!,.(!".&*0/"*:%!:"44!@*!,'(";!0*2;0(*(=!D44!.;&*%!:"44!@*!

5*1&!;.!-)!;:.!2;-1'&*0!&$,&!$,%!1,%%:;0(!*.20)1&";.!%;4*4)!A;0!-)!'%*=!G0".&*(!

(;2'-*.&%!,.(!&$*!,'(";!0*2;0(".9!:"44!@*!5*1&!".!,!4;25*(!A"4".9!2,@".*&!:"&$!C0=!

I;.,!^4*,%;.!3,.(!(*%&0;)*(!,A&*0!]!)*,0%7=!

#$*!;'&2;-*%!;A!&$"%!%&'()!:"44!@*!("%2'%%*(!".!,!G$C!("%%*0&,&";.!,.(!-,)!

@*!1'@4"%$*(!,%!,!@;;5!;0!,%!,0&"24*%!".!M;'0.,4%!,.(!,.&$;4;9"*%!;.!*('2,&";.!,.(!

%;2",4!M'%&"2*!"%%'*%=!

>A!);'!:;'4(!4"5*!&;!%**!&$*!0*%'4&%!;A!&$"%!%&'()6!);'!,0*!:*42;-*!&;!4*,/*!

);'0!-,"4".9!,((0*%%!;.!&$"%!2;.%*.&!A;0-!,.(!2;1)!:"44!@*!%*.&!&;!);'!'1;.!&$*!

2;-14*&";.!;A!&$*!10;M*2&=!

!

Page 274: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Ykk!

!

.?`$`<>>$V?EDBE<A>$0<JTJ$?_$ECD$#EHY9$(D$'YYFDJJDY+$

D%!>!:"44!.;&!@*!".&*0,2&".9!("0*2&4)!:"&$!&$*!2$"4(0*.!('0".9!&$*!;@%*0/,&";.%6!

&$*0*!,0*!.;!A;0*%**,@4*!0"%5%=!

C'0".9!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1%6!,%!".!,.)!2;./*0%,&";.6!"&!"%!1;%%"@4*!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!

-"9$&!$,/*!%;-*!'.14*,%,.&!A**4".9%=!>!:"44!-,5*!%'0*!2$"4(0*.!,0*!,:,0*!;A!

0*%;'02*%!,&!&$*"0!%2$;;4%!32;'.%*4;06!&*,2$*06!;0!,(-"."%&0,&";.!,/,"4,@"4"&)7!"A!&$*)!

.**(!A'0&$*0!%'11;0&=!#$*!90;'1%!:"44!@*!$*4(!".!,.!;1*.!%*&&".9!34"@0,0)6!0*%;'02*!

0;;-7!,.(!%&0'2&'0*(!&;!-"-"2!("%2'%%";.!90;'1%!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!:"44!$,/*!

*.2;'.&*0*(!('0".9!10;M*2&%!:"&$!&*,2$*0E4"@0,0",.%6!%2$;;4!2;'.%*4".9!90;'1%6!,.(!

;&$*0!%*&&".9%!:$*0*!&$*)!$,/*!("%2'%%";.%!:"&$!,!A,-"4",0!,('4&!:$;!"%!.;&!&$*"0!

&*,2$*0=!!>.!&$"%!:,)6!&$*!%&0'2&'0*!:"44!.;&!@*!;'&!;A!&$*!;0(".,0)!A;0!&$*!2$"4(0*.!

,.(!:"44!$*41!A,2"4"&,&*!,!2;-A;0&,@4*6!4;:!0"%5!*./"0;.-*.&=!#$*!L'*%&";.%!,%5*(!,0*!

9*,0*(!&;!@*!;1*.!*.(*(!%;!&$,&!2$"4(0*.!:"44!@*!,@4*!&;!".A4'*.2*!&$*!("0*2&";.!;A!

&$*!("%2'%%";.=!!#$"%!,110;,2$!:"44!$"9$4"9$&!:$,&!"%!"-1;0&,.&!&;!&$*-!,.(!&;!$*41!

*.%'0*!&$*)!,0*!.;&!10*%%'0*(!&;!("%2'%%!,.)&$".9!&$,&!:"44!@*!;'&%"(*!&$*"0!2;-A;0&!

J;.*=!D&!&$*!@*9"..".9!;A!*/*0)!A;2'%!90;'1!&$*!%&'(*.&%!:"44!@*!0*-".(*(!&$,&!&$*)!

,0*!A0**!&;!.;&!,.%:*0!,.)!L'*%&";.!&$*)!(;!.;&!:"%$!&;!,.%:*0=!

#$*!".&*0/"*:%!:"&$!&$*!*('2,&;0!;0!*('2,&;0%!:"44!@*!".A;0-,4!,.(!);'!,0*!

:*42;-*!&;!%&**0!&$*!("%2'%%";.!".!,4&*0.,&*!("0*2&";.%!"A!&$*!L'*%&";.%!,%5*(!(;!.;&!

2;/*0!&$*!".A;0-,&";.!);'!:"%$!&;!"-1,0&=!g;'!:"44!@*!,@4*!&;!&*0-".,&*!&$*!

".&*0/"*:!,&!,.)!&"-*!;0!2$;;%*!.;&!&;!,.%:*0!,.)!L'*%&";.=!

Page 275: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

Yki!

!

#$*!0*%*,02$!"%!".(*1*.(*.&!A0;-!,.)!A'.(".96!,(-"."%&0,&"/*6!;0!,.)!;&$*0!

,9*.2)!&$,&!2;'4(!".A4'*.2*!);'0!1,)!;0!*-14;)-*.&=!

V?EDBE<A>$(DBD_<EJ$?_$ECD$#EHY9$

b$"4*!&$*!%&'()!:"44!.;&!.*2*%%,0"4)!$,/*!,!("0*2&!@*.*A"&!&;!%&'(*.&%!;0!

*('2,&;0%6!&$*!%&'(*.&%!-,)!*.M;)!&$*!A;2'%!90;'1!("%2'%%";.%!,.(!A".(!&$*-!

".&*0*%&".9=!R('2,&;0%!-,)!*.M;)!2;.&0"@'&".9!&;!*('2,&";.,4!%2$;4,0%$"1!:"&$!&$*!

9;,4!;A!0*('2".9!("%20"-".,&";.!".!1'@4"2!%2$;;4%!,%!&$*!%&'()!-,)!2;.&0"@'&*!&;!

1;4"2"*%!,.(!10,2&"2*%!&$,&!A'0&$*0!:;05!&;:,0(!%,A*0!%2$;;4%=!

.?`$f<>>$:?B_<YDBE<A><E9$(D$5A<BEA<BDY+$

I)!.;&*!&,5".9!:"44!@*!(;.*!;.!-)!1,%%:;0(E10;&*2&*(!4,1&;1=!D%!>!:"44!&,5*!

.;&*%!;.!-'4&"14*!2$"4(0*.!3:"&$;'&!'%".9!&$*"0!0*,4!.,-*%76!>!:"44!.;&!%$;:!-)!

.;&*%!&;!&$*!%&'(*.&%!%$;'4(!&$*)!0*L'*%&!&;!%**!&$*-6!,%!&$"%!2;'4(!@*!,!

2;.A"(*.&",4"&)!"%%'*!:"&$!".A;0-,&";.!0*9,0(".9!&$*"0!1**0%=!b*0*!>!&;!@*!,%5*(6!>!

:"44!&*44!&$*-!&$,&!-)!2;-1'&*0!"%!M'%&!A;0!-*!&;!'%*=$

G,0&"2"1,.&%!:"44!@*!9"/*.!,!1%*'(;.)-!:"&$!:$"2$!&$*)!:"44!@*!0*A*00*(!

&$0;'9$;'&!&$*!(,&,!2;44*2&";.!10;2*%%!,.(!1;%%"@4*!A'&'0*!1'@4"2,&";.%=!K&$*0!

"(*.&"A)".9!(*&,"4%!3*=9=!&$*!.,-*!;A!&$*!%2$;;47!:"44!,4%;!@*!2$,.9*(=!g;'!:"44!@*!,@4*!

&;!2$;;%*!,!1%*'(;.)-!&$,&!:"44!@*!'%*(!".!&0,.%20"1&";.%!,.(!1'@4"2,&";.=!

h;2'%!90;'1!1,0&"2"1,.&%!:"44!@*!*.2;'0,9*(!&;!0*%1*2&!*,2$!;&$*0B%!10"/,2)j!

$;:*/*06!,%!:"&$!,.)!("%2'%%";.!&$,&!&,5*%!14,2*!".!&$*!%2$;;46!:*!2,..;&!2;.&0;4!

:$,&!&$*!2$"4(0*.!0*1*,&!;'&%"(*!;A!&$*!90;'1%=!

Page 276: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YkZ!

!

>A!,@'%*!;0!.*94*2&!;A!,!2$"4(!"%!0*/*,4*(6!&$*!0*%*,02$*0!3,%!:"&$!1'@4"2!%2$;;4!

*-14;)**%7!-'%&!0*1;0&!&$*!".A;0-,&";.!&;!,110;10",&*!,'&$;0"&"*%=!

VA9@DBE$

#$*0*!"%!.;!1,)!"./;4/*(!".!&$"%!%&'()=!#$*!%&'()!:"44!,4%;!0*L'"0*!-"."-,4!

&"-*!,.(!.;!2;%&!&;!&$*!1,0&"2"1,.&%=!

fC?$:AB$*?H$:?BEAZE$<_$*?H$.APD$WHDJE<?BJ$'8?HE$EC<J$#EHY9+$

>A!);'!$,/*!,.)!L'*%&";.%!;0!2;.2*0.%!,@;'&!:$,&!:*!,0*!,%5".9!;A!);'6!

14*,%*!2;.&,2&!C0=!I;.,!^4*,%;.!;0!D."5,!H&,AA;0(=!#$*!.,-*%!,.(!&*4*1$;.*!

.'-@*0%!,0*!4"%&*(!,&!&$*!&;1!;A!&$*!A"0%&!1,9*!;A!&$"%!A;0-=!

fC?$:AB$*?H$:?BEAZE$<_$*?H$.APD$:?@=>A<BEJ$'8?HE$EC<J$#EHY9+$

>A!);'!$,/*!,.)!2;.2*0.%!,@;'&!);'0!0"9$&%!,%!,!0*%*,02$!%'@M*2&!,.(<;0!);'0!

*+1*0"*.2*%!:$"4*!1,0&"2"1,&".9!".!&$"%!%&'()6!);'!-,)!2;.&,2&!&$*!Q*%*,02$!H'@M*2&!

>.A;0-,&";.!a".*!".!&$*!dFS!KAA"2*!;A!Q*%*,02$!H*0/"2*%!,&!kV[EZYYEZ]WZ!;0!"A!4;.9!

("%&,.2*!*E-,"4!QH>a~;0%='@2=2,!;0!2,44!&;44!A0**!UEZiiEZYYEZ]WZ=!

#,5".9!1,0&!".!&$"%!%&'()!"%!*.&"0*4)!/;4'.&,0)=!g;'!$,/*!&$*!0"9$&!&;!0*A'%*!&;!

1,0&"2"1,&*=!>A!);'!(*2"(*!&;!&,5*!1,0&6!);'!-,)!2$;;%*!&;!1'44!;'&!;A!&$*!%&'()!,&!,.)!

&"-*!:"&$;'&!9"/".9!,!0*,%;.!,.(!:"&$;'&!.*9,&"/*!0*2;'0%*!".!&*0-%!;A!);'0!

*-14;)-*.&!;0!2,0**0=!

! !

Page 277: Is it Still a Boy? Hetero/gender Normativity in Kindergarten

YkW!

!

g;'0!%"9.,&'0*!".("2,&*%!&$,&!);'!2;.%*.&!&;!1,0&"2"1,&*!".!&$"%!%&'()=!!!

nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn!

G,0&"2"1,.&!H"9.,&'0*! ! ! ! ! C,&*!

nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn!

G0".&*(!P,-*!;A!&$*!G,0&"2"1,.&!%"9.".9!,@;/*!

g;'0!%"9.,&'0*!@*4;:!".("2,&*%!&$,&!);'!$,/*!0*2*"/*(!,!2;1)!;A!&$"%!2;.%*.&!A;0-!

A;0!);'0!;:.!0*2;0(%=!

!