DELIVERING QUALITY SINCE 1952. Introduction to Rigid-Flex Materials & Constructions [10.26.12]
May 19, 2015
DELIVERING QUALITY SINCE 1952.
Introduction to Rigid-FlexMaterials & Constructions
[10.26.12]
2
Scope
Rigid-Flex Design Evolution
Rigid-Flex Reliability
Copper Clad Flex Laminate Constructions
Coverlay Constructions
Design Review / Quoting Process
Summary
Case Studies
3
Design Evolution
Significant Design Evolution In The Past Decades
“Older” Designs:– “Point to Point” interconnects & Simple Circuits
• PTH Connectors & Components• Low layer counts
4
Design Evolution
Significant Design Evolution In The Past Decades
Current Designs:– Rigid areas serve as fully capable “Rigid” boards– Push the same limits of complexity and density
• Fine lines / spacing• High aspect ratio sub 0.010” vias• Blind & Buried Vias• High Layer Counts• Higher Operating Temperatures• RoHS Assembly
5
Rigid-Flex Reliability
Advancing designs identified a Via reliability issue.– Formation of Copper plating cracks within Via holes
Root Cause:– Use of Flex circuit adhesives within Rigid areas– High Co-Efficient of Thermal Expansion of
Flex Adhesives (10 -20X of FR-4) place viasunder Z-Axis stress during thermal cycles.
– Thermal Cycle Sources:• RoHS Assembly • Multiple Assembly cycles• Higher System & Component
operating temperatures– Confirmed through failed Interconnect
Stress Testing (IST) and Scanning ElectronMicroscope Imaging (SEM)
6
Rigid-Flex Reliability
Potential Sources of Adhesive:– Adhesive based Copper Clad Flex Laminates
– Full coverage Coverlay constructions
– Rigid to Flex layer bonding with adhesives
Worst Case Construction: 6 Adhesive Layers
7
Rigid-Flex Reliability
VIA Reliability Solution:– Manufacturing, Material Suppliers and Industry Standards
Organizations worked together to develop the following elements to resolve the issue:
• Adhesiveless Copper Clad Flex laminates
• Selective Coverlay Constructions
• Rigid to Flex layer bonding with No- Flow FR-4 prepreg
8
Rigid-Flex Reliability
IPC 2223C - Sectional Design Standard forFlexible Printed Boards– Eliminate / Minimize use of adhesives within rigid areas
– Use of adhesiveless based substrates
– Use of Selective / Partial Coverlay Construction
– Secs. 4.1, 5.2.2.2., A2
9
Copper Clad Flex Laminate Constructions
Adhesive Based:– Copper bonded to Polyimide core with Acrylic or Modified Epoxy
adhesives
Adhesiveless:– Copper directly attached to Polyimide Core
10
Copper Clad Flex Laminate Constructions
Benefits and Drawbacks:
– Adhesiveless Copper Clad Laminates:
• Thinner constructions:– Up to 33% thinner per Flex laminate core
• More flexible & reliable designs
• Higher Operating Temperature rating
• Higher Copper peel strengths
• Reduced thermal expansion stress on vias
• Slight material cost increase
– Adhesive Based Copper Clad Flex Laminates:
• Lower Cost
• Limited to Flex Only applications:– Point to Point Interconnects– Limited Thermal Excursions
11
Coverlay Constructions
Full Coverage Coverlay Construction:– Coverlays extend throughout Rigid areas
• Vias & PTH holes drilled through Coverlay adhesive and exposed to excessive Z-Axis thermal expansion stress
Poor Construction Design: 2 Adhesive Layers
12
Coverlay Constructions
Selective Coverlay Construction:– Coverlays restricted to exposed flex areas only
– Up to 0.050” interface with Rigid areas
– PTH holes restricted within Coverlay to Rigid interface area
– Rigid layers bonded with High Temp No – Flow FR-4 Prepreg
IPC Specified Construction Design: 0 Adhesive Layers
13
Coverlay Constructions
Benefits and Drawbacks:
– Selective Coverlay Construction:
• Significantly reduced thermal expansion stress placed on vias
• Higher Operating Temperature rating
• Higher layer to layer bond strength
• Thinner Constructions
• Slight cost increase due to greater number of manufacturing process steps
– Full Coverage Coverlay Construction:
• Lower Cost
• Flex adhesive based Thermal stressreliability issues
14
Design Review / Quoting Process
Design Review:– Specifications
– Materials
– Construction
– Gerber Data DFM
– Application (electrical & mechanical requirements)
– Identify areas of opportunity
• Improved reliability, Improved functionality, Reduced Cost
– Communicate and resolve all technical items and potential areas of opportunity
Quoting:– Accurate quote
– Based on manufacturable, reliable, cost effective design
– Eliminates / Minimizes technical issues after PO is placed
15
Summary
Modern IPC specified Material and Construction methods have virtually eliminated Thermal Stress induced Via reliability issues
Many current Rigid-Flex designs do not adequately or correctly define modern IPC specified materials and constructions
16
Summary
Incorrect / Inadequate Designs May:
– Allow supplier(s) to utilize less expensive materials and constructions to gain a competitive pricing advantage at the expensive of future reliability issues
– Limits customers recourse in the event of reliability issues:• Parts made to print
– Complicates the quoting process• Proper materials and constructions require deviations from the supplied
specifications to be identified
– Deviations from print may not be understood resulting in rejection of viable quotes
– Quoting delays due to added technical communications
– Supplier(s) may not identify deviations on quote• Parts not built to print• Potential order rejection at in-coming inspection
17
Case Study: Rigid-Flex
Application:– Power Distribution Control Circuits
Customer Requirement:– Improve quality and supply chain reliability while maintaining existing price
targets Challenge:
– Supplied designs did not meet current IPC standards for materials and construction
18
Case Study: Rigid-Flex
Solution:– Epec revised designs to meet current standards and to utilize more cost
effective materials– Performed technical sessions with both end user and CM (customer) to inform
them of the benefits Summary:
– Epec awarded both PNs– End User to implement design revisions in to current and new part numbers
19
Case Study: Rigid-Flex
Application:– Medical Care Communication system
Customer Requirement:– Develop technical and supply chain partner to assist in product design and
production requirements Challenge:
– End Customer & Design House lacked experience in all areas of Rigid-Flex design (Gerber layout, material selection, Manu. Specs etc.)
20
Case Study: Rigid-Flex
Solution:– Epec worked closely with Design Team and CM to develop design and ensure
manufacturability– Utilized in-house capabilities for Gerber layout
(impedance controlled), provided complete materialsand specifications package
Summary:– Successful introduction,
passed all tests / qualifications– In volume production
(2 additional PN’s won)
21
Build To Print Electronics
We are a leading provider of printed circuit boards, flex and rigid-flex circuits, membrane switches, touch panels, silicone rubber keypads, graphic overlays, custom battery packs, and electronic fans & motors.
22
Thank You
If you require additional information please contact us with any questions or requests.
North American Headquarters174 Duchaine Blvd.New Bedford, MA 02745Tel: (508) 996-7400Fax: (508) 998-8694
Contact Us By Email:Sales [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
Visit Our Website For More Informationwww.epectec.com
Stay Connected with Epec Engineered TechnologiesJoin our Social Community and keep in touch with all our latest technology investments, current news, upcoming events, and promotions. Visit our Social Media Websites for more information.