-
International Journal of Photonics and Optical Technology Vol.
3, Iss. 3, pp: 4-12, Sept. 2017
Copyright © IJPOT, All Rights Reserved Page 4
Fluorescent Bis(benzimidazolium) ethaneborontetrafluoride: A ppb
Level Sensor for Picric Acid Explosives Tandrima Chaudhuri1*,
Chhanda Mukhopadhyay2, Sabari Ghosh2, Animesh Karmakar1 1Department
of Chemistry, Dr. Bhupendranath Dutta Smriti Mahavidyalaya,
Burdwan-713407, India 2Department of Chemistry, University of
Calcutta, 92 APC Road, Kolkata-700009, India [email protected]
(Received 24th August, 2017; Revised 04th September 2017; Accepted
21st September, 2017; Published: 30th September, 2017) Abstract:
Highly photoluminescent white light emitting
Bis(benzimidazolium)ethaneborontetrafluoride (BBIM-ethane salt)
demonstrated as a selective sensory material for the trace
detection of (20 ppb) picric acid (here after N4) among the other
treated nitroaromatic and non-nitroaromatic compounds in
acetonitrile medium via energy transfer based fluorescence
quenching mechanism. 1H NMR study, Cyclic voltammetry, Monte Carlo
simulation and FMO as well as NBO calculation reveal that
nitroaromatic compounds (NACs) (N1 – N6, except N4) induce
formation of H-bonded adduct with the BBIM-ethane salt causing
fluorescence quenching of NAC. However, N4 can be recognized via
deprotonation of strongly acidic phenolic -OH proton followed by
anion exchange with the BBIM-ethane salt, giving a new emitting
species that emits in longer wavelength region. Keywords: Picric
acid sensor, ppb level, Monte Carlo, FMO, Explosive sensing. 1.
INTRODUCTION The colour change in naked eye or upon UV irradiation
due to strong H-bonding interaction or deprotonation followed by
H-bonding interaction among organic molecules is a promising mode
for the selective detection of various analytes [1].
Benzimidazolium salt based rotaxane or pseudo-rotaxane has a
profound background of forming molecular machine via H-bonding with
crown ether of appropriate cavity size [2]. Benzimidazolium salts
are also used as good fluorophore for sensing of transition metal
ions [3]. Picrate derivative of imidazole based fluorophores [4]
are known but imidazolium salt based sensors of nitro aromatic
compounds (NACs) especially of picric acid are scanty [5]. Picric
acid sensors are mainly of two types based on mode of interaction
with it through (a) the electron deficient phenyl ring [6] and (b)
the acidic hydroxyl group [7]. But the former type of probes favour
donor–acceptor complex formation for all nitro aromatics, thus lack
good selectivity when picric acid is part of a mixed analyte
containing other nitro aromatics. If those interfering entities do
not have an acidic hydroxyl group, the latter type shows high
selectivity for picric acid among nitro aromatic explosives. On the
other hand, if other sensitive acidic components are present in the
mixed analyte, their selectivity is severely affected. For example,
nitrobenzoic acid or degradation of picric acid leads to possible
acidic products,
such as dinitrophenol, nitrophenol, and phenol [8] which may
affect the selective detection of picric acid. Therefore, probes
that selectively identify picric acid from both electron deficient
nitro aromatics and other acidic components are certainly
advantageous. Fig. 1: Structure of BBIM-ethane salt and its
non-mirror symmetric absorption-emission spectra in acetonitrile
medium. Bis(benzimidazolium)ethaneborontetrafluoride (Figure 1) is
a white light emitting fluorophore soluble only in acetonitrile
medium form stable ground state isosbestic with six different NACs
(Fig. S1) viz. 4-Nitrophenol (N1), 2,4-Dinitrophenol (N2),
2,5-Dinitrophenol (N3), picric acid (N4), 2,4-Dinitrotoluene (N5),
3,5-Dinitrobenzoic acid (N6) and three non-nitro aromatic
compounds: 2-Iodo benzoic acid (7), 1-Bromo-4-chlorobenzene (8) and
3-Chloro-4-fluoro aniline (9) in this study. This BBIM-ethane salt
was synthesized following our reported procedures [9]. All six NACs
show massive quenching of fluorescence of BBIM-ethane while
non-NACs demonstrate nominal quenching. However, addition of N4 to
BBIM-ethane results in the appearance of a new peak in the longer
wavelength region. Relative peak intensity of new peak increases
with further addition of N4, though a quenching of fluorescence
results in both peaks. Ultimately, N4 addition reflects > 96%
fluorescence quenching of BBIM-ethane in acetonitrile. This dual
emission clearly indicates simultaneous existence of two
emitting
250 300 350 400 450 500
0.00.5
1.01.52.02.5
Normalised Fluorescence Inte
nsityWavelength (nm) 0
10002000300040005000
Normalised Absorbance
-
International Journal of Photonics and Optical Technology Vol.
3, Iss. 3, pp: 4-12, Sept. 2017
Copyright © IJPOT, All Rights Reserved Page 5
species those interact with picric acid. Relative peak ratio
also indicates that the newly generated emitting species still
exists after complete quenching of emission of BBIM-ethane. Thus
BBIM-ethane can specifically as well selectively sense picric acid
(N4) differentiating from other nitro aromatic and non-nitro
aromatic compounds on the basis of deprotonation of strongly acidic
phenolic -OH group followed by anion exchange from benzimidazolium
salt to form picrate-adduct via RET based quenching. However, all
other NACs interact with BBIM-ethane in same 1:2 ratio simply via
H-bonding between oxygen centres of NO2-group with N-H protons of
benzimidazolium unit. Thus picric acid can be recognized
photophysically by this BBIM-ethane salt due to RET based
fluorescence quenching as well as formation picrate adduct as new
emitting species in acetonitrile. However, 1H NMR study, cyclic
voltammetry, Monte Carlo simulation and NBO as well as FMO
calculation divulge this fluorescence off is due to formation of
multiple H-bonds between BBIM-ethane and other NACs but formation
of simultaneously emitting picrate-BBIM-ethane adduct that emits in
the longer wavelength region for N4. 2. EXPERIMENTAL A. MATERIALS
AND METHODS Acetonitrile used as solvent was of HPLC grade. The six
well known nitroaromatic compounds (NAC): 4-Nitrophenol (N1),
2,4-Dinitrophenol (N2), 2,5-Dinitrophenol (N3), Picric acid (N4),
2,4-Dinitrotoluene (N5), 3,5-Dinitrobenzoic acid (N6), and two
non-nitro aromatic compounds: 2-Iodio benzoic acid (7),
1-Bromo-4-chlorobenzene (8) and 3-Chloro-4-fluoro-aniline (9) were
purchased from Aldrich. The concentration of
Bis(benzimidazolium)ethane salt (BBIM-ethane) was made in the range
10−4 M to10−5 M in all the spectral measurements. The concentration
of NACs and non-NACs were of the order of ~10−4 M. B. INSTRUMENTS
USED The absorption (UV-Vis) spectral measurements were performed
with a Shimadzu UV 1800 spectrophotometer fitted with an electronic
temperature controller unit (TCC –240 A). The steady state
fluorescence emission and excitation spectra were recorded with a
Hitachi F-4500 spectrofluorometer equipped with a temperature
controlled cell holder. Temperature was controlled within ± 0.1 K
by circulating water from a constant temperature bath (Heto Holten,
Denmark). 1H NMR spectra were recorded on Bruker 300 MHz
spectrometer at 298 K in CD3CN. The cyclic voltammograms were
recorded with an electrochemical workstation of CH Instrument Inc.
model CHI600D using a three electrode system. A platinum
microelectrode was used as the working electrode. An Ag/AgCl
(acetonitrile) was used as the reference electrode along with a
platinum wire served as the counter electrode and as an electrolyte
0.1M TBA(HSO4) was used. C. MONTE CARLO SIMULATIONS Simulations
were performed using Spartan’14 molecular modelling software from
Wavefuntion Inc. (Irvine, CA, USA). Using Monte Carlo simulation
[13b], global minima search for
all the optimized complexes neglecting solvent were performed
using Merck molecular force-field calculations (MMFF). FMO and
Wiberg NBO calculations were done in DFT/MPWPW91/6-31G single point
calculation using the software Gaussian'09 Linax version. D.
SYNTHESIS OF BBIM-ETHANE SALT The synthesis of bis-benzimidazole
compounds have been previously reported by our group [9]. The salts
were obtained directly from these bis-benzimidazoles by adding an
equimolar amount of the corresponding aqueous fluoroboric acid and
crystallization from acetonitrile-diethyl ether [2b]. 1H NMR
(CD3CN): δ 7.87-7.83 (m, 4H, Ar H), 7.67-7.63 (m, 4H, Ar H) and
3.76 (s, 4H, CH2). 13C NMR (CD3CN): δ 150.6, 130.6, 126.8, 114.1
and 23.8. FT-IR (cmˉ1): 3309.1, 1628.0, 1572.9, 1462.8, 1377.2,
1301.5, 1263.9, 1226.3, 1091.6, 765.3, 670.4, 621.7 and 447.4.
Anal. calcd. for C16H16B2F8N4 : C: 43.88; H: 3.68; N: 12.79 and
found C: 43.88; H: 3.66; N: 12.80. GC-MS (EI+): 438, 399. Melting
point (CH3CN-Et2O): 276 °C. Yield: 90 % (394 mg, colourless
crystals). 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS A. PHOTOPHYSICAL STUDIES
BBIM-ethane containing borontetrafluoride as counter anion (Fig.1)
shows a non-mirror symmetric absorption-emission spectrum in
acetonitrile. BBIM-ethane emits sharply at 300 nm with a broad hump
centred at 375 nm on exciting at 260 nm. Thus the wavelength range
covered under the emission spectra enters into visible region upto
500 nm. The interaction of NAC with BBIM-ethane is investigated
photophysically. Incremental addition of BBIM-ethane upon all six
NACs (N1 to N6) and non-NACs (7 to 9) form well established
absorption isosbestic on interacting with low concentration of
BBIM-ethane in acetonitrile [Table 1, Fig. 2(A-C)]. Table 1. Ground
state photophysical parameters and excited state binding constants.
Compounds interacting with BBIM-ethane Absorption isosbestic point
at wavelength (nm) Binding constant (k) Binding sites(n) in NAC N1
224.2, 232.6, 280.6 1.17×105 1.21 N2 268.27, 280.1 2.13×107 1.67 N3
213.8, 232.1, 245.2 3.41×107 1.75 N4 267.5, 273.2, 274.1, 280.1
3.37×109 2.02 N5 274.4, 280.2 3.51×107 1.72 N6 213.1, 260.4, 284.8
1.61×107 1.68 7 208.3, 248.4, 282.4 - - 8 235, 218.5 9 282.8, 250.9
- -
-
International Journal of Photonics and Optical Technology Vol.
3, Iss. 3, pp: 4-12, Sept. 2017
Copyright © IJPOT, All Rights Reserved Page 6
With the decreasing absorbance of N1 (at 308.0 nm), absorption
maxima of BBIM-ethane (at 269.5 nm) increases monotonously giving
rise to a set of isosbestic at the juncture (Fig. 2A). Similarly
for N6, absorbance at 228.5 nm decreases with increasing that of
BBIM-ethane (shown in Fig. 2B inset). But on reversing the
titration i.e., when analyte (any NACs or non-NACs) is added to
BBIM-ethane solution a monotonous increment of absorbance
throughout the range of BBIM-ethane was observed (Fig. 2[D] and
Fig. S3a). On addition of N4, as it absorbs in visible region
(400-500nm), colourless BBIM-ethane solution became yellow in
colour (Fig. 2D inset). But this may be the colour of N4 itself. No
other NAC addition to BBIM-ethane cause any visible colour change
(Fig. S3b). Job’s plot (Fig. 2E) determined the mole ratio of
BBIM-ethane/NAC adduct is 1:2 in the ground state.
Fig. 2: Absorption isosbestic of the NACs and non-NACs with
BBIM-ethane in Acetonitrile. Concentration of BBIM-ethane (µM):
0.00, 2.71, 5.18, 7.43, 9.50, 11.4, 13.1, 14.8, 16.3, 17.7, 19.0,
20.2, 21.4 and 22.45 at a fixed concentration of [A] N1 (166µM),
[B] N6 (144.5µM) and [C] compound 7 (137µM) solution in
Acetonitrile. [D] Ground state titration of BBIM-ethane (110µM)
with N4 in acetonitrile. Concentration of N4 (µM): 0, 19, 38, 57,
75, 92 in acetonitrile. Inset is the colour change just after
addition of excess equivalents of N4 to BBIM-ethane (1mM) in
acetonitrile medium. [E] Job’s plot of BBIM-ethane/N5 system at 300
nm. Significant effects have been observed in the excited state
interaction of N4 with BBIM-ethane. Enhancement of emission
intensity at 300 nm (emission maxima of BBIM-ethane) was observed
(in Fig. S4a) on addition of very low concentration (~ 10-8
mol.dm-3) of N4 to BBIM-ethane (~ 10-5 mol.dm-3). But for addition
of same concentration of N5, nominal quenching of BBIM-ethane
emission was observed (Fig. S4b). The fluorescence enhancement on
addition of 10-8 mol.dm-3 N4 solution, clearly indicate formation
of new adduct with BBIM-ethane in case of N4. Limit of detection
[6f, 7d, 7g] of N4 by BBIM-ethane in excited state was 20 ppb
(Fig.3a). The result indicates that the benzimidazolium-type
compound BBIM-ethane has better sensitivity than most of the small
organic functional compounds for picric acid (N4) reported till
date [4,7, 10]. Excited state interaction of all six NACs (N) and
non-NACs (7 to 9) with BBIM-ethane were studied at almost equimolar
concentration range (~ 10-5mol.dm-3) also. Here also N4 interacts
with BBIM-ethane salt in totally different way. BBIM-ethane reveals
rapid quenching of fluorescence with all six NACs (One of which is
shown in Fig. 3b). Picric acid (N4) among the six NACs diminishes
the fluorescence of BBIM-ethane with highest efficiency (almost 97%
for addition of same 13 equivalent NAC in 11µM BBIM-ethane)
[A] 0.00µM 22.45µM BBIM-ethane
[C] 0.00µM 22.45µM BBIM-ethane
[B] 0.0 5.0µ 10.0µ 15.0µ 20.0µ 25.0µ 30.0µ0.150.20
0.250.300.350.400.450.50
A 269.5 nm/A 228.5 nm
[BBIM-ethane] M
0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.90.140.160.18
0.200.220.240.260.280.30
Absorbance
at 300 nmMole Ratio of (BBIM-ethane/N5) [E]
[D] BBIM-ethane BBIM-ethane/
N4 92 µM 0.0 µM N4
-
International Journal of Photonics and Optical Technology Vol.
3, Iss. 3, pp: 4-12, Sept. 2017
Copyright © IJPOT, All Rights Reserved Page 7
(Fig.3c). N5 shows ~90% quenching efficiency while non-NACs show
negligible quenching (Fig. 3c). Thus the three non-NACs (7 to 9)
used in this study show nominal quenching effect in excited state
interaction though all of them contain heavy atoms. Among the all
six NACs picric acid (N4) shows a profound highest quenching
efficiency and highest excited state binding constant (3.37×109)
(table-1, Fig. 3d). Beside that addition of picric acid (N4) upon
BBIM-ethane, nature of emission spectra was totally changed. A dual
emission peak of almost equal intensity appeared at 300 and 386 nm.
The slightly most intense new peak at 386 nm regularly decreases
along with that of 300 nm peak after each addition of N4 and shows
a regular red shift. Ultimately with addition of large excess N4,
emission peak at 300 nm is almost vanished and the red shifted
longer wavelength peak appeared at 397nm. The relative fluorescence
intensity ratio at 397 nm to 300 nm with increasing N4
concentration also increases (Fig. 3e inset). This may be due to
formation of a new emitting species at the cost of interaction of
BBIM-ethane with N4. Being most acidic among the NACs used in this
study, picric acid easily forms picrate in presence of
borontetrafluoride ion in medium. Consequently it is the picrate
that interacts with BBIM-ethane salt. Thus BBIM-ethane can
specifically and selectively sense N4 among all other treated NACs
in acetonitrile via formation of longer wavelength emitting picrate
derivative of BBIM-ethane.
Fig. 3: Excited state interaction of different NACs with
BBIM-ethane in Acetonitrile medium. (a) Fluorescence intensity of
BBIM-ethane (11µM) at 300nm as a function of N4 concentration.
Inset: showing the calculation of detection limit of N4. (b)
Concentration of N5 (µM): 0.00, 17, 33.5, 49.6, 65.4, 80.8, 95.8,
110.5,125, 139, 152.5 and 166 at a fixed concentration (11µM) of
the BBIM-ethane solution in Acetonitrile. (c) Quenching efficiency
bar diagram comparing all six NACs and three non-NACs for fixed
concentration of BBIM-ethane (11µM) and 13 equiv. analyte in each
case at λem = 300nm, λex = 260 nm. (d) Stern-Volmer plot of
BBIM-ethane/N4 system. Inset: Binding constant plot. (e) Addition
of N4 (legend shows the concentration) at a fixed concentration
(11µM) of the BBIM-ethane solution in Acetonitrile. λex = 260
nm.
0.0000 0.0005 0.0010 0.0015 0.0020 0.0025 0.0030 0.00353300
36003900420045004800 I 300n
m
N4 concentration in equivalents
(a) DL= 1.1×10-5 mol. L-1 ×0.0018 equiv. = 0.00198×10-5 mol. L-1
= 1.98×10-8 mol. L-1 = 20ppb
300 350 400 450 50005001000
150020002500300035004000
Fluorescence intensity
Wavelength (nm)
(b) [N5] 0.00µM 166µM
BBIM-ethane
N1 N2 N3 N4 N5 N6 7 8 90.00.1
0.20.30.40.5
(F o- F)/F 0 Analytes
(c)
0 25 50 75 100 125 150 175 20001020
304050607080
F 0 /F[N4] µM
(d) -4.6 -4.4 -4.2 -4.0 -3.8 -3.60.00.51.01.52.0
log [(F 0-F)/F] log[N4](e)
300 350 400 450 50001000
2000300040005000
Fluorescence intensity
Wavelength (nm)
11µM BBIM-ethane +19µM N4 +38µM N4 +57µM N4 +75µM N4 +92µM N4
+110µM N4 +126µM N4 +143µM N4 +159µM N4 +175µM N4 +190µM N4375 397
0 25 50 75 100 125 150 175 20001
23456
F 397nm /F 300 nm [N4] µM300
-
Copyright © IJPOT, All Rights Reserved
Fig. 4: (a) Spectral overlap of the absorption spectra of N4
emission spectrum of BBIM-ethane (blue line). (b) Fluoresof
BBIM-ethane for N4 under different λex. (c) Visual color upon
subjecting a 1mM BBIM-ethane solution in acetonitri20 equiv of six
different NACs (N1 to N6) in acetonitrile in roand under UV
irradiation of 366nm (bottom). B. FLUORESCENCE QUENCHING
MECHANISThe good selectivity and high sensitivity of for the
detection of N4 may be related to the quenching mechanism. The
observed fluorescencfor N4 is attributed to the energy transfer
from pπ-electron rich BBIM-ethane to ground-sta
(a)
200 220 240 260 280020
406080100
Quenching efficiency (%)
Excitation wavelength (nm)(b)
(c) BBIM- N4 N5 N6 N1 N2 N3 BBIM- N4 N5 N6 N1 N2 N3
International Journal of Photonics andVol. 3, Iss. 3,
(red line) with the luorescence quenching color change observed
tonitrile to addition of le in room light (upper) NISM. y of
BBIM-ethane to the fluorescence rescence quenching from photo
excited state electron-
deficient N4, which is further confirmoverlap of the emission
spectrum ofabsorption spectrum of N4 in the range4a). Notably, the
fluorescence titratiethane by addition of 13 equiv of wavelengths
(200−280 nm) are investigThe quenching efficiency value ofchange
(Fig 4b). This means that the dintensity of BBIM-ethane is not due
tenergy transfer mechanism proposed aresults. Because there is no
spectral overlap of N5 and the emission of BBIM-ethmain quenching
mechanism for N5 shdue to H-bonding based equilibrium foThis is
confirmed by the result of UV tiBBIM-ethane salt solution as
wmeasurement at different concentrationwell-known that the energy
transfer is a11]. N4 can interact with the BBIsurrounding it and
forming a picrate deBBIM-ethane and its picrate
derivativsimultaneously giving dual emission (NACs only can quench
the emission ointeracting with it. Thus, compared to selective as
well as specific to quench ethane. C. VISUAL DETECTION OF PA IN
SLIGHT. The visual detection of picric acid UV light is carried out
and shown in Fthe solution of fluorophore BBIMchanges significantly
on addition of NACs is added, the fluorescence completely quenched.
But for N4, thei.e. almost nothing is emitted, whichabove results.
For the highly selective detection oonly a few reports about the DL
valuesame detection level as reported hereand the sensitivity here
is better than t[4, 5, 7, 10] Therefore, acetonitrile BBIM-ethane
can be used to visuallyof picric acid with high sensitivity. D. 1H
NMR STUDY Further, to investigate the interactiowith NACs and
non-NACs, we dimentional 1H NMR studies of BBIMethane/7 adducts
(1:2) in CD3CN. Roy1H NMR shift of a tris-imidazoliuminteracting
with picric acid (N4) wheinstead of picric acid. But as
fluorophowater soluble wet N4 cannot be usedhas to be stored always
under water)mode of interaction of NACs with BB(very similar to N4
and also soluble in The 1H NMR spectrum of BBIM-ethwell separated
peaks for different pro
(a.u.) 280
N3 N3
tonics and Optical Technology l. 3, Iss. 3, pp: 4-12, Sept.
2017
Page 8
firmed by a large spectral m of BBIM-ethane with the range of
270 to 500 nm (Fig. titrations of 11µM BBIM- of N4 at various
excitation vestigated. lue of N4 has no significant t the decrease
in fluorescence t due to masking by N4. The osed above is proved by
the verlap between the absorption ethane (Figure S4c), the should
be static and that um formation in ground state. UV titration of N5
toward. as well as by life time tration of N5 (Fig. S4D). It is fer
is a long-range process [7, BBIM-ethane fluorophore derivative.
Then both free erivative emit in the medium ssion (Fig. 3e). But
all other sion of BBIM-ethane salt on ed to other NACs, N4 is more
uench the emission of BBIM-IN SOLUTION UNDER UV c acid (N4) in
solution under n in Figure 4c. The colour of BIM-ethane in
acetonitrile n of N4. When 20 equiv of cence of BBIM-ethane is ,
the solution become black which is consistent with the ction of
picric acid, there are L value around 20 ppb. The here is
unparallel [4, 7, 10] than that reported previously itrile solution
of compound sually detect instant presence eraction of the
BBIM-ethane we carried out the one-BIM-ethane/N5 and BBIM-. Roy et
al [5] demonstrated olium based fluorophore on where N4 exists as
picrate rophore BBIM-ethane is not used for this NMR study (N4
water), rather to identify the BBIM-ethane, N5 system ble in
acetonitrile) is selected. ethane showed clean and nt protons (Fig.
5 and S6a).
-
International Journal of Photonics and Optical Technology Vol.
3, Iss. 3, pp: 4-12, Sept. 2017
Copyright © IJPOT, All Rights Reserved Page 9
The methyl group of N5 shifted downfield from δ 2.69 to δ 2.7.
Two aromatic protons of N5 shifted from δ 7.71 to δ 7.714 and from
δ 8.41- δ 8.38 to δ 8.42 - δ 8.39 (shown in Fig. S6b and S6c) while
the aromatic proton between the two nitro groups remained constant
at δ 8.75. All protons of the bis-benzimidazolium salt
(BBIM-ethane) remain fixed at δ 7.87-7.83, δ 7.67-7.63 and δ 3.76
on interacting with N5. Only the peak for CH2-protons at δ 3.76 get
splitted (Fig. 5 inset) on interacting with N5 indicating definite
interactions between BBIM-ethane and N5. It seems that the two
methylene protons of the CH2 group lie in two different
environments leading to such splitting in adduct. After interaction
of compound 7 and the bis-benzimidazolium salt (BBIM-ethane) all
the aromatic protons of 7 shifts upfield (shown in Figure S6d and
S6e). The protons of the BBIM-ethane at δ 7.87-7.83, δ 7.67-7.63
shifted upfield to δ 7.86-7.81, δ 7.66-7.62 and the methylene
protons at δ 3.76 remain unchanged at δ 3.76 in presence of
compound 7. Fig. 5: 1H NMR spectra of BBIM-ethane, merged with
BBIM-ethane/N5 (1:2) adduct in CD3CN at 298K. The behaviour of
BBIM-ethane/N5 system varies considerably from the BBIM-ethane/7
system as observed from their 1H NMR behaviour. The former system
gets most of the protons to shift downfield while the opposite
happens when compound 7 is present. The presence of three sets of
lone pairs of electrons on the iodine atom in compound 7 makes a
very different set of environment as compared to N5. In these
systems, charge transfer complexes do not occur since the
BBIM-ethane system is an electron deficient species as also N5.
However, N5 is also electron deficient due to the presence of two
nitro groups. E. CYCLIC VOLTAMOMETRY The electrochemical studies
using cyclic voltammetric technique were performed to evaluate the
redox potentials of the NAC, N3, BBIM-ethane and their adduct in
acetonitrile containing 0.1M TBA(HSO4) as electrolyte. The data is
used to verify the possibility of change in reduction potential of
NAC on interacting with BBIM-ethane in the mixture. The
current-potential curve for BBIM-ethane and N3 are shown in Fig.
S7a and S7b respectively.
During the cathodic excursion of the potential, one reduction
within the accessible potential window of the solvent is observed
for N3. The reduction is found to be irreversible [12] as
peak-to-peak separation, ∆Epp = 1560 mV and the cathodic-to-anodic
peak current ratio, ipc/ipa is not unity (Fig. S7b). BBIM-ethane is
also electron deficient having reduction potential -0.97 V (Figure
S6a). Now the adduct BBIM-ethane/N3 is also an electron seeking
complex and having smaller reduction potential of – 0.82 V (Figure
S7c), compared to that both of N3 (-0.87 V, Figure S7b) and of
BBIM-ethane (-0.97 V, Figure S7a). F. Monte Carlo Simulation A
rigorous Monte Carlo (MC) conformational search protocol [13] is
employed for better understanding of these associated complexes
[1b, 2a]. Fig. 6 gives the MC simulated global minimum conformers
of the three complexes. All six NAC compounds (N) except picric
acid (N4) interact with BBIM-ethane salt in a similar fashion is
giving 12 conformers each. The global minimum conformers of
BBIM-ethane/N in each case form four H-bonds with four
benzimidazolium protons of BBIM-ethane salt and oxygen centres
nitro groups of N (shown in Fig. 6A – 6B). H-bond distances are
within (1.69 to 1.84) Å in all six cases of NAC adduct of
BBIM-ethane (Fig. S7). 2-Iodio benzoic acid (compound 7) interacts
with the BBIM-ethane salt in a totally different way. Here
BBIM-ethane salt gets folded completely and is also forming four
H-bonds between carbonyl oxygen (of compound 7) and benimidazolium
protons (of BBIM-ethane) of length (1.62 – 1.66) Å. BBIM-ethane/7
adduct has 24 conformers in gas phase and the global minimum one is
shown in Fig. 6[C]. As observed from Monte Carlo simulation
H-bonding interactions take place in the BBIM-ethane/N5 system
while some lone-pair interactions coupled with H-bonding is
probably present in the BBIM-ethane/7 system, so 1H NMR shift show
entirely opposite effects for N5 and compound 7 to interact with
BBIM-ethane salt in CD3CN. The global minimum conformer of
picrate-BBIM-ethane adduct shown in Fig.6[D] was more stable
compared to the corresponding picric acid (N4) adduct in respect to
H-bond distances as well as calculated values of Wiberg NBO bond
indices (Table 2). Values of H-bond indices are in well agreement
with the calculated H–bond distances of the picric acid-BBIM-ethane
adduct and picrate adduct. The reasonable high value of H-bond
indexes of picrate adduct compared to all other NAC adducts was
found. Thus picrate-BBIM-ethane has greater H-bond indexes,
indicating stronger H-bonding interaction as compared to
N4-BBIM-ethane adduct. The frontier molecular orbital energy
profile diagram in Figure 6E indicates that the ground-state charge
transfer occurs from picrate anions to the positively charged
sensor molecules in the gas phase as evident from the DFT
calculations. The DFT studies revealed that the energy of the
highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) of the free sensor
BBIM-ethane is −13.47 eV and the lowest occupied molecular orbital
(LUMO) is -8.47 eV, while the energies of HOMO and LUMO of picrate
anion are −3.13 eV and +0.63 eV, respectively. Hence, the
ground-state electronic charge transfer takes place from the HOMO
of picrate anion to the LUMO of sensor BBIM-ethane
BBIM-ethane BBIM-ethane/N5
-
International Journal of Photonics and Optical Technology Vol.
3, Iss. 3, pp: 4-12, Sept. 2017
Copyright © IJPOT, All Rights Reserved Page 10
Fig. 6: Wireframe structure of Monte Carlo global minimum
onformers of [A] BBIM-ethane/N4 adducts, [B] BBIM- ethane/N5
adduct, [C] BBIM-ethane/7 adduct and [D] BBIM-ethane-picrate adduct
in gas phase. [E] Energy profile diagram of FMOs of N4,
BBIM-ethane, picrate and BBIM-ethane-picrate adduct describing
charge transfer phenomena.
N4 BBIM-ethane Picrate Picrate adduct-14-12-10
-8-6-4-202
FMO energy (eV)
3.65eV 5.24eV
[E]
[A]
[B]
[C]
[D]
-
International Journal of Photonics and Optical Technology Vol.
3, Iss. 3, pp: 4-12, Sept. 2017
Copyright © IJPOT, All Rights Reserved Page 11
Table 2. Wiberg NBO indexes and distances of H-bonds of the MC
global minimum conformers of NAC adducts. BBIM-ethane adduct H-bond
distances (Å) Wiberg NBO H-bond index NO2(O)... H-N NO2(O)... H-N
NO2(O)... H-N NO2(O)... H-N N1 1.706 1.996 0.1860 -0.0672 N2 1.701
1.750 0.1171 0.0653 N4 1.704 1.764 0.1332 0.0620 N5 1.707 1.713
0.1291 0.0700 N6 1.696 1.808 0.1256 0.0660 Picrate NO2(O)... H-N
Ph-O-... H-N NO2(O)... H-N Ph-O-... H-N 1.593 1.618 0.1518 0.1251
cause quenching. Band gap of BBIM-ethane salt (5.24eV, Fig. 6E) on
forming picrate-adduct was decreased to 3.65eV, resulting a longer
wavelength emission compared to that of free BBIM-ethane. Though N4
and N5 have similar reduction potentials (RNO2/RNO2- = -0.39V for
Picric acid and -0.40V for 2,4-DNT) [14], selectivity and
specificity of picric acid among all other NACs can be attributed
to deprotonation of strongly acidic phenolic -OH group followed by
anion exchange to interact with the sensor molecule. Ray et. al [5]
reported water soluble tris imidazolium based picric acid sensor of
DL 354 ppb, but there also N4 exists as picrate. However as that
sensor does not has any imidazolium proton in it so no chance of
H-bonding was there. Consequently, simple quenching is observed. In
this study picrate form stable differently emitting adduct with
acetonitrile soluble bis-benzimidazolium based sensor BBIM-ethane
having DL 20 ppb. 4. CONCLUSION In summary, a new simple
bis-benzimidazolium based salt was designed for detection of picric
acid on the basis of long-range energy transfer mechanism.
BBIM-ethane salt shows good selectivity and high sensitivity of
picric acid, the DL is 20 ppb and binding constant is 3.39×109 M-1.
The fluorescence turn off based visual detection is developed in
acetonitrile medium. Thus, simple bis-benzimidazolium salts can
also be viewed as a suitable class of compounds in the development
of efficient sensor for the trace detection of picric acid. The
recognition can be done as picrate derivative in solution by a
noteworthy colour change for the first time. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Author TC acknowledges the grant received from UGC funded Major
project, F.42-390/2013(SR)/dated 25/03/2013. REFERENCES [1] (a) X.
He et al., “Oxidized bis (indolyl) methane: a simple and efficient
chromogenic-sensing molecule based on the proton transfer
signalling mode,” Org. Lett., vol. 8, pp. 333-336, 2006. (b) A.
Karmakar et al., “Quinone–Bodipy H-bonding interaction over
π-stacking in toluene,” Photochem. Photobiol. Sci., vol. 14, pp.
1207- 1212, 2015. (c) A. Karmakar et al., “Recognition of steric
factor in external association of xanthenocrown-5 and
bis-napthalenocrown-6 with
bis(benzimidazolium)propane borontetrafluoride,” Spectrochim.
Acta. A., vol. 159, pp. 141- 145, 2016. [2] (a) S. Ghosh, T.
Chaudhuri, C. Mukhopadhyay, “The new threading system 2-benzyl-5,
6-dimethyl-1H-benzo[d]imidazolium – dibenzo-24-crown-8: a model for
Monte Carlo calculations incorporating an anion for the first time
in threaded structures,” RSC, Adv.4, pp. 18835- 18841, 2014. (b) S.
Ghosh et al., “Anomalous behaviour of the
bis(benzimidazolium)butane[2]pseudorotaxanes of
dibenzo-24-crown-8:a comparative study of methane, ethane, propane
and butane bis(benzimidazolium)alkane]dibenzo-24-crown-8 systems
with variable spacers,” J. Incl. Phenom Macrocycl Chem., vol. 81,
pp. 321-340, 2015. (c) T. Chaudhuri et al., “Molecular recognition
of 4-Nitrobenzo-15-crown-5 by
bis(benzimidazolium)propaneborontetrafluoride in acetonitrile,” J.
Lumin., vol. 16, pp. 164-173, 2015. (d) S. Ghosh, T. Chaudhuri, E.
Padmanaban, C. Mukhopadhyay, “The idiosyncrasies of (BBIM-alkane)
DB30C10 MIMs,” J. Mol. Struc., vol. 1097, pp. 6-14, 2015. [3] A. K.
Lal, M. D. Milton, “Synthesis of new benzimidazolium salts with
tunable emission intensities and their application as fluorescent
probes for Fe3+ in pure aqueous media.“ Tet. Lett., vol. 55, pp.
1810-1814, 2014. [4] (a) J.-F. Xiong et al., “Benzimidazole
Derivatives: Selective Flourescent Chemosensors for the Picogram
Detection of Picric acid,” J.Org. Chem., vol. 79, pp. 11619-11630,
2014. (b) K. M. Priyadarshini, A. Chandramohan, “Synthesis, Growth,
Crystal structure and Characterisation of anorganic salt single
crystal: Diimidazolium dipicratemonohydrate,” The Experiment, vol.
25, pp. 1759-1774, 2014. [5] B. Roy, A. K. Bar, B. Gole, P. S.
Mukherjee, “Flourescent Tris-Imidazolium Sensors for Picric acid
Explosive,” J. Org. Chem., vol. 78, pp. 1306-1310, 2013. [6] (a) H.
Sohn, M. J. Sailor, D. Magde, W. C. Trogler, “Detection of
Nitroaromatic Explosives Based on photoluminescent Polymer
Containing Metalloles,” J. Am. Chem. Soc., vol. 125, pp. 3821-3830,
2003. (b) J. Liu, et al., “Hyperbranched Conjugated Polysiloles:
Synthesis,Structure, Aggregation-Enhanced Emission, Multicolor
Flourescent Photopatterning, and Superamplified Detection of
Explosives,” Macromolecules, vol. 43 pp. 4921-4936, 2010. (c) S.
Shanmugaraju, S. A. Joshi, P. S. Mukherjee, “Flourescence and
visual sensing of nitroaromatic explosive using electron rich
discrete flouophores,” J. Mater. Chem., vol. 21, pp. 9130-9138,
2011. (d) Y. Peng, A.-J. Zhang, M. Dong, Y.-W. Wang, “A
Colorimetric and fluorescent chemosensor for the detection of an
explosive -2, 4, 6-trinitrophenol (TNP),” Chem. Commun., vol. 47,
pp. 4505-4507, 2011. (e) W. Shu, C. Guan, W. Guo, C. Wang, Y. Shen,
“Conjugated poly (aryleneethynylenesiloles) and their application
in detecting explosives,” J. Mater. Chem., vol. 22, pp.
-
International Journal of Photonics and Optical Technology Vol.
3, Iss. 3, pp: 4-12, Sept. 2017
Copyright © IJPOT, All Rights Reserved Page 12
3075-3081, 2012. (f) V. Bhalla, A. Gupta, M. Kumar, “Flourescent
Nanoaggregates of pentacenequinone Derivative for selective Sensing
of Picric acid in Aqueous Media,” Org. Lett., vol. 14, pp.
3112-3115, 2012. (g) N. Venkatramaiah, S. Kumar, S. Patil,
“Fluoranthene based fluorescent chemosensor for detection of
explosive nitroaromatics,” Chem. Commun., vol. 48, pp. 5007-5009,
2012. (h) N. Venkatramaiah, S. Kumar, S. Patil, “Femtogram
Detection of Explosive Nitroaromatics: Fluoranthene‐Based
Fluorescent Chemosensors,” Chemistry–A European J., vol. 18, pp.
14745-14751, 2012. (i) S. Kumar, N. Venkatramaiah, S. Patil,
“Fluoranthene based derivatives for detection of trace explosive
nitroaromatics,” The J. Phys. Chem C., vol. 117, pp. 7236-7245,
2013. (j) V. Bhalla, A. Gupta, M. Kumar, D. S. Rao, S. K. Prasad,
“Self-assembled pentacenequinone derivative for trace detection of
picric acid,” ACS appl. mater. interfaces, vol. 5, pp. 672-679,
2013. (k) Y. Dong et al., “Endowing hexaphenylsilole with chemical
sensory and biological probing properties by attaching amino
pendants to the silolyl core,” Chem. Phys. Lett., vol. 446, pp.
124-127, 2007. [7] (a) Z. F. An et al., “Exceptional Blueshifted
and Enhanced Aggregation‐Induced Emission of Conjugated Asymmetric
Triazines and Their Applications in Superamplified Detection of
Explosives,” Chem.A Euro. J., vol. 18, pp. 15655-15661, 2012. (b)
M. Kumar, S. I. Reja, V. Bhalla, “A charge transfer amplified
fluorescent Hg2+ complex for detection of picric acid and
construction of logic functions,” Org. Lett., vol. 14, pp.
6084-6087, 2012. (c) Q. Niu, K. Gao, Z. Lin, W. Wu, “Amine-capped
carbon dots as a nanosensor for sensitive and selective detection
of picric acid in aqueous solution via electrostatic interaction,”
Anal. Methods, vol. 5, pp. 6228-6233, 2013. (d) S. Pramanik, V.
Bhalla, M. Kumar, “Mercury assisted fluorescent supramolecular
assembly of hexaphenylbenzene derivative for femtogram detection of
picric acid,” Anal. chim. acta., vol. 793, pp. 99-106, 2013. (e) X.
H. Zhou et al., “A flexible Eu (III)-based metal–organic framework:
turn-off luminescent sensor for the detection of Fe (III) and
picric acid,” Dalton Transactions, vol. 42, pp. 12403-12409, 2013.
(f) V. Bhalla, S. Kaur, V. Vij, M. Kumar, “Mercury-modulated
supramolecular assembly of a hexaphenylbenzene derivative for
selective detection of picric acid,” Inorg. chem., vol. 52, pp.
4860-4865, 2013. (g) V. Vij, V. Bhalla, M. Kumar, “Attogram
detection of picric acid by hexa-peri-hexabenzocoronene-based
chemosensors by controlled aggregation-induced emission
enhancement,” ACS appl. mater. interfaces, vol. 5, pp. 5373-5380,
2013. (h) M. Dong, Y. W. Wang, A. J. Zhang, Y. Peng,
“Colorimetric and Fluorescent Chemosensors for the Detection of
2, 4, 6‐Trinitrophenol and Investigation of their Co‐Crystal
Structures,” Chem. Asian J., vol. 8, pp. 1321-1330, 2013. (i) Y. Xu
et al., “ICT-not-quenching near infrared ratiometric fluorescent
detection of picric acid in aqueous media,” Chem. Commun., vol. 49,
pp. 4764-4766, 2013. [8] (a) K. S. Ju, R.E. Parales, “Nitroaromatic
compounds, from synthesis to biodegradation,” Microbiol. mol. bio.
rev., vol. 74, pp. 250-272, 2010. (b) M. Nipper, R.S. Carr, J. M.
Biedenbach, R. L. Hooten, K. Miller, “Fate and effects of picric
acid and 2, 6-DNT in marine environments: Toxicity of degradation
products,” Marine pollution bulletin, vol. 50, pp. 1205-1217, 2005.
(c) M. Nipper, Y. Qian, R. S. Carr, K. Miller, “Degradation of
picric acid and 2, 6-DNT in marine sediments and waters: the role
of microbial activity and ultra-violet exposure,” Chemosphere, vol.
56, pp. 519-530, 2004. [9] C. Mukhopadhyay, S. Ghosh, R. J.
Butcher, “An efficient and versatile synthesis of
2,2’-(alkanediyl)-bis- 1H-benzimidazoles employinf aqueous
flouroboric acid as catalyst:density functional theory calculations
and fluorescence studies,” Arkivoc, vol. 9, pp. 75-96, 2010. [10]
(a) M. Kumar, S. I. Reja, V. Bhalla, “A charge transfer amplified
fluorescent Hg2+ complex for detection of picric acid and
construction of logic functions,” Org. Lett., vol. 14, pp.
6084-6087, 2012. (b) X. H. Zhou et al., “A flexible Eu (III)-based
metal–organic framework: turn-off luminescent sensor for the
detection of Fe (III) and picric acid,” Dalton Transactions, vol.
42, pp. 12403-12409, 2013. [11] (a) B. Valeur, M. N.
Berberan-Santos, Molecular fluorescence: principles and
applications. John Wiley & Sons. 2012. (b) J. Wang et al.,
“Hyperbranched polytriazoles with high molecular compressibility:
aggregation-induced emission and superamplified explosive
detection,” J. Mater. Chem., vol. 21, pp. 4056-4059, 2011. [12] A.
J. Bard, L. R. Faulkner, Electrochemical Methods: Fundamentals and
Applications, second ed., John Wiley, New York, 2001. [13] (a) J.
Kong et al., “Q‐Chem 2.0: a high‐performance ab initio electronic
structure program package,” J. Comput. Chem., vol. 21, pp.
1532-1548, 2000. (b) G. Chang, W.C. Guida, W.C. Still, “An
internal-coordinate Monte Carlo method for searching conformational
space,” J. Am. Chem. Soc., vol. 111, pp. 4379-4386, 1989. [14] M.
Uchimiya, L. Gorb, O. Isayev, M. M. Qasim, J. Leszczynski,
“One-electron standard reduction potentials of nitroaromatic and
cyclic nitramine explosives,” Environmental Pollution, vol. 158,
pp. 3048-3053, 2010.