Informal is Global Benjamin de la Peña for Agile City Partners | June 25, 2021
Paratransit?Informal Transportation?
Intermediate Public Transportation?Indigenous Transportation?Artisanal Transportation?Popular Transportation?
Pop-Transport?
Pet
roza
vods
k tra
ffic
mic
robu
s G
AZe
lle, b
y M
aSii
A ta
p ta
p bu
s in
Hai
ti
http
s://b
roke
lyn.
com
/a-h
ail-o
f-a-r
ide-
a-bk
-dol
lar-
van-
map
/
clas
sic
"sho
rt sn
out"
1969
MB
LO
1112
col
ectiv
o at
the
Mer
cede
s-B
enz
Mus
eum
in
Stu
ttgar
t, by
Moe
bius
uibe
om-e
n
Son
gtha
ew in
Udo
n Th
ani,
Isaa
n P
rovi
nce,
Tha
iland
, by
Phi
lipp
L. W
esch
e.
A je
epne
y in
Intra
mur
os, M
anila
, by
Bah
nfre
nd
A m
atat
u c.
201
5, b
y Jo
ciku
A re
d P
ublic
Lig
ht B
us, b
y H
im9
小巴
LV37
05的照片
JEEPNEY SONG-THAEW MATATU VAN
JÁI
COLECTIVO TAP TAP MARSHRUTKA DOLLAR
VANS
BENJIE’s slide
From
http
s://w
ww
.thai
land
disc
over
y.in
fo/b
angk
ok-th
aila
nd-tu
k-tu
ks/
Baj
aj a
uto-
ricks
haw
nex
t to
the
Gal
le F
ort i
n S
ri La
nka,
by
Mr.
Cho
pper
s
CN
G-p
ower
ed a
uto
ricks
haw
in N
ew D
elhi
, nea
r the
Ras
htra
pati
Bha
wan
on
Raj
Pat
h,
by W
arre
n A
pel
Chi
ngch
ee (Q
uing
qi) i
n P
akis
tan.
Wik
iped
iaPAKISTAN SRI LANKA THAILAND INDIA
Mar
iord
o (M
ario
Rob
erto
Dur
án O
rtiz)
- O
wn
wor
k. B
ajaj
m
otot
axi i
n E
l Sal
vado
r
Ban
aue,
Phi
lippi
nes:
Loc
al T
axi S
tand
in B
anau
e M
unic
ipal
Tow
n, b
y C
Eph
oto,
Uw
e A
rana
s
EL SALVADOR PHILIPPINES
Nat
ural
Gas
-fuel
led
Baj
aj a
utor
icks
haw
on
Jaka
rta
stre
et, B
Y G
unaw
an K
arta
pran
ata INDONESIA
Pho
to ©
Leo
pard
i fro
m
http
s://w
ww
.sty
lepa
rk.c
om/e
n/ne
ws/
tuk-
tuks
-dal
adal
as-a
nd-s
uper
-hig
hway
s
NIGERIA
BENJIE’s slide
Oje
ks (m
otor
cycl
e ta
xis)
in In
done
sia,
by
Ser
enity
Oka
das
in L
agos
, Nig
eria
, by
Aki
niel
o
Tran
spor
t cou
rant
à T
abat
inga
et L
etic
ia G
oele
tte.C
arda
bela
BODABODAS, OJEKS, OKADAS, MOTOR SAI, MOTO TAXI, XE-OMS, ETC.
BENJIE’s slide
Informal transportation comes by many names: matatus, trotros, camionetas, colectivos, jeepneys, auto rickshaws, trisikads, minibuses, mega taxis, boda bodas, tuk tuks, okadas, ojeks, —two wheels, three wheels, or four; human powered or engine powered—informal transportation very likely moves and employs more people than all the city trains, buses, and taxis around the world. They dominate the cities of the Global South. They provide affordable mobility for the poor and middle-class and livelihoods for mostly low-income households.
BENJIE’s slide
“...formal mass transit routes (red) only cover a relatively limited urban area, whereas informal routes (blue) reach far more people and are often the only access to motorised transport for low-income urban dwellers. Small, privately operated minibuses are one of the most important informal modes: In Nairobi, 70% of commuters rely on privately run ‘matatus’ to get to work, while 74% of all public transport trips in Mexico City are completed on ‘colectivos.’ In addition to the vital role these services play in getting people to work, informal transit is itself an important employer. In Kenya, the informal transport sector and associated services are estimated to employ nearly half a million people.”
from Mobility for the Masses: The essential role of informal transport in the COVID-19 recovery
by Talia Calnek-Sugin and Catarina HeecktLondon School of Economics
BENJIE’s slide
Golde
n Pha
ntom
Matat
u serv
ing th
e Ong
ata ro
ute in
Nairo
bi. Ph
oto fro
m Na
ibuzz.
com.
Minib
us in
Karac
hi. Ph
oto fro
m ww
w.brec
order.
com
INGENUITY + ARTISTRY
HISTORY AND SOCIETY● History, racism, colonial experience, exclusion
ECONOMIC POLICY ● Market primacy, investment in cities, investment in transportation
INFRASTRUCTURE ● Automobile-centric infrastructure, primacy of roads
URBAN POLICY AND FORM● Density and sprawl of residential areas,
distance from work and commerce + urban growth
VEHICLES
● Availability of and affordability of adaptable vehicles
BUSINESS MODEL
● Transportation as micro-enterprises, hypercompetitionMOBILITY POLICIES AND REGS
● Primacy of traffic management over commuter needs LOCAL CULTURE
● Celebration of “make do” ingenuity, music, songs, art, self-expression
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
● Ride hail and payment apps, digital mapping, and journey planning apps
HISTORY AND SOCIETY
ECONOMIC POLICY
INFRASTRUCTURE
URBAN POLICY AND FORM
VEHICLES
BUSINESS MODEL
MOBILITY POLICIES AND REGS
LOCAL CULTURE
● Incentivizing self-assembled “kit of parts” approaches to vehicles
● Paying for transit through specific taxes or levies
● Service contracting, fleet management services
● Prioritizing people movement
● Local arts and design awardsINFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
● Cashless Fare Collection, VLS, Digital Real Time Route Permits
Informal transportation is a truly global phenomena and yet, it always seems to be treated as a local problem.
Emphasis on “problem” rather than asset.
BENJIEs slide
1. is innovative and resilient;2. is ubiquitous in the global south; 3. is ignored in policy and investments; 4. is despised in planning; and, 5. represents a powerful lever to decarbonizing the
transportation sector through a Just Transition.
Informal transportation: BENJIE’s slide
Our Mission
Work hand-in-hand with informal urban transportation systems of the Global South to advance innovation, improve services, and change business models. By leveraging new technology and innovative policies, we believe these informal networks can confront climate change and make our cities work for everyone.
ANDREA’s slide
The Global Encyclopedia ofInformal Transportation Vehicles
A project of the Global Partnership for Informal Transportation
“The aspiration to such uniformity and order alerts us to the fact that modern statecraft is largely a project of internal colonization, often glossed, as it is in its imperial rhetoric, as a 'civilizing mission'.”
― from Seeing Like a State by James C. Scott
Electric Jeepney (eJeepney) plying on the streets of metro ManilaVice President Binay used this green electronic jeepney (e-Jeepney) that was labeled "B-Jeep" during the inaugural rites on June 30, 2011. Carmela Lapeña
The e-jeepney project from ICSC.NGO
What did digitalization do?
KEY FINDING #4
“Subsidizes big business especially large real estate developers and IT firms. The Bhoomi program is facilitating very large land developers catering to a global IT Market. Earlier, these firms would have to compete with smaller land developers who often would provide a better price to land owners. Also, the public land acquisition process uses eminent domain via the Industrial acts (KIADB) to notify large consolidated land parcels in favor of big business that in effect disadvantages smaller firms with less capital and far less lobbying powers. Thus, what would have been illegal in previous times was from 1998 onwards, facilitated legally!“
Bhoomi: ‘E-Governance’, or an Anti-Politics Machine Necessary to Globalize Bangalore? ( January 2006)Dr. Solomon Benjamin, R Bhuvaneswari, P. Rajan, Manjunatha
https://casumm.files.wordpress.com/2008/09/bhoomi-e-governance.pdf
Informal Transportation
“Problems”
“To be solved”
“To be controlled”
“Disorganized”
“Old and decrepit”
Technology
“Solutions”
“To be deployed”
“To be adapted”
“Optimization”
“Innovative and new”
vs
Aggregating information also aggregates power.
What are the existing power relationships? How will they shift?When we make a system legible,
who gets better vision?
Credit: Peter Macdiarmid/Getty Images AsiaPac/Getty Images
“We believe informal urban transportation systems can be powerful engines for economic mobility
and for creating more sustainable and inclusive cities.”
BENJIE’s slide
www.gpitransportation.orggpitransportation.substack.com
@GlobalInformalmakeshiftmobility.substack.com
agilecity.co