y P ^Fa IN THE SUPREME COURT OF OHIO IN RE SAMANTHA JOHNS PRO SE 75 Woods Drive Apt. 1 West Milton, Ohio 45383 (937)751-9893 * * * * * * * * * Supreme Court No Relator, V. THE HONORABLE MARY L. WISEMAN MONTGOMERY COUNTY COMMON PLEAS COURT 41 N. Perry Street Dayton, Ohio 45402 WARD BARRENTINE KARINA KOROSTYSHEVSKY HEATHERJANS MATTHEW T. CRAWFORD ASSISTANT PORSECUTING ATTORNEYS Dayton-Montgomery County Courts Bldg. P.O. Box 972, 301 W. Third Street Dayton, Ohio 45422 (937)225-5757 ALYSIA A. GOSS LAW OF PUBLIC DEFENDER 117 S. Main Street, Suite 400 Dayton, Ohio 45422 (937)225-4652 * PETITION FOR ALTERNATIVE WRIT * WRIT OF PROHIBITION OR * OTHER APPROPRATE RELIEF * * * * y * t {.i N ^;^^ %s j a^ ^`.s. * ------------------------------------------------------------------ BOBBYJOECOX ATTORNEY AT LAW 130 W. Second Street Suite 800 Dayton, Ohio 45402 (937)228-1975 RICHARD BUTCH BARNES J. ALLEN WILMES ATTORNEY AT LAW ATTORNEY AT LAW 41 E. Main Street 7821 N. Dixie Drive Enon, Ohio 45323 Dayton, Ohio 45414 (937)340-2226 (937)278-0652 Respondents,
159
Embed
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF OHIO Relator seeks an Alternative Writ as an emergency stay preventing Judge Wiseman from proceeding with the trial in this case below, until the Writ of Prohibition
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
C:ocen{y of [v*r^QA^ ......_ ..,.....( ^_ .. ..,. .
Sulxsor+t>e and swam to (as aft^rmed} }7etore
rne canrth-isjte<iay ,... .. ._..,.
prrn=ed to rae on the basis of satisfae.tor,,ev{denc.etcs be i3?e Personfs) who appearedbefore me.
THE HONORABLE MARY L. WISEMAN
MONTGOMERY COUNTY
COMMON PLEAS COURT
41 N. Perry Street
Dayton, Ohio 45402
WARD BARRENTINE
KARINA KOROSTYSHEVSKY
HEATHERJANS
MATTHEW T. CRAWFORD
ASSISTANT PORSECUTING ATTORNEYSDayton-Montgomery County Courts Bldg.
ALYSIA A. GOSS
LAW OF PUBLIC DEFENDER
117 S. Main Street, Suite 400
Dayton, Ohio 45422
(937)225-4652
RICHARD BUTCH BARNES
ATTORNEY AT LAW
41 E. Main StreetEnon, Ohio 45323
(937)340-2226
BOBBY JOE COXATTORNEY AT LAW130 W. Second Street Suite 800Dayton, Ohio 45402(937)228-1975
J. ALLEN WILMES
ATTORNEY AT LAW
7821 N. Dixie DriveDayton, Ohio 45414
(937)278-0652 Respondents,
AFFIDAVIT OF INDIGENCE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF OHIO
Affidavit of Indigence
do hereby. state that I amwithout the necessary funds to pay the costs of this action for the followingreason(s): [Note: S.Ct.Prac.R. 3.06 requires your affidavit of
indigence to state the reason(s) you are unable topay the docket fees andfor security deposit.Failure to state specific reasons that you are
unable to pay will result in your affidavit beingrejected for filing by the Clerk.]
Pursuant to Rule 3.06, of the Rules of Practice of the Supreme Court of Ohio, Iam requesting that the filing fee and secu it^ deposi^,a.if app(,^ ble, be waived.
^r-_
Affiant
Sworn to, or affirmed, and subscribed in my presence this '^ day of
^^^6' -, , 20 iI-S
Notary Public
My Commission Expires: 12011 2D11
T[Note: This affidavit must be executed not more than six months prior to beingfiled in the Supreme Court in order to comply with S.Ct.Prac.R. 3.06. Affidavits
not in compliance with that section will be rejected for filing by the Clerk.]
WEST SECOND STREET, DAYa ONa OH 45402 (PHON .a , ^ .. PAY.:. 937-224-r YO^ ^ILL BEEXC?aSED FROM AT" ="^H"°y11"^ ^ ^^ ^RM-41l) JURY H, Azoen ^ .
Y'ou are required to be and appear be¢ore Xhe DA'°?TON M O3c a ^OMERY
COU NT°^ COURTS BU9LD6NG, Lower Levei, 30'i West Third Street, Daytvn, Ohio A'-J 7 8w3" A.M. to 1esticy
as a witness on behalf of the State of Ohio T1ainfi'sff in the a.bov^. -en:iiied cpase` and 'o not °pa.,-t from 1;-ie COURT witholit
leave 3,arzder pcNALT" OF LAW
aV,N-7'e'•.f^aC- FL HECK,
P9'^sp-1cuaEYag Attorney
Ta i^n, i9'^^'A;;'6"sic, ry a''+3i.fe:aj; `'«'+hiv
tTO THE SHERIFF OF AMON^`GO%^ER`^' COUNTY, OHIO
8y: RraA E"'i^'`.^' E M m "i-N n h?E-',Lt3''
Assistant Prossewutirla Attorney(937) 225-5757
You are Comil•iarlded so SEat"flr7lor': thP, witness(es) whose f"laii^e(s) and addrQss(r:'s) a°1- Sei forth above to be and
C^1^.i arlc ^^..^It,llt^.l 4o ORDER saidapp..-.a;,^ be3or'UR-' this Court aS lhe `irE^e Carlf' place ^iLl forth above for said 4fJll^i\."s /SG's) Zo p." ^
^v.^.^:
^nritness(es) NOT depa^safd^Coaart wiittout leave UNDER ^ENA1-`i-^` OF ^AVJ., e^^^
^P1^Tr^ESU my 7ar^d and tne seai of the saiu Cc;ur a^ Dayton, O";o inin __„_ O^^,^:^x ^ '' ._.7('^^ A. 20112:
'^REEV'LA;,RY A„ BRUSH, C:...E-FK
P;ionfi6or;nery County Cour; of Cor°li-Tion Pieas
E^^,^. . - .-- •
D E ?'tJT':'
NiKIClO'7-26-12
' ^ki .^!-• . ' . . . .^ { 1
TJ^k,ION`^^^TMERY CO7'^Y CO1^^^^I^.^N PLEAS ^.'OURT^ ^; MONTGOMERY COUNTY, 0^O
i ' _ _'4t °'
`L. hc^
^OF^^^^
IN RE; ^l^VESTIGATION
x^^^ ^ I
ORDER AND e^^FURN{?>-11 ENT RY
WHEREAS, this matter came before the Court on the motion. of the Mortgomory County u:3er;ff's Office scr anorder compeiiinq the fol:o9rrinQ business or s:aitity to producm records or moreof its customers or subscribers;
I. The co^pany or entity in possession of said recor dstand or information being sow:gb'a is:
Chase BankCustodian of Records Legal i:'s-oca.ss Departnqe:itI Chase Manhattan PlazaNew York, Ne-w York 1 00i35
18. The records being sought pY€tain to the eoiAowina account:
Bank Records forAcco,snt No: 3033736509Baak Records for AccQubet No: 752075127
IRi. The pedod focwbich these records ase being .souo t is:
Date the account was open through the present.
IV. The records being sought are:
Aii account hofidaa- information indi.5ding address and aii otghor idorsrq€n^ informatso ^aa;i' nanries; addressesand phone numbers associated to the account. : o also =a?cRuda any int'i^rm atiun on dates of rrione;y depositsand witta drawismada to the account.
WHEREAS, there appeared persosaas9y baFore me oria QE?^QTiVL I. KELLAR and svsRorp to the faac"bs setforth in an Afiidavit on iida with the Cou' in this matter.
WHEREAS, based upo; s speoitic facts aaicuia;ted to the Cv'ur', in the a.ffidaton.;°<e Cotiq'E finds :^at ta'-sera arereasonabla grounds to believe that the records andior i nfoz mat:on sought is or are relsvarA and ma.fedai toanongoing investigation of a Violatbon of the Ohio Revised Code.
WHEREAS, it is accoordirsgiy ordered and adiudged that Chase Bank sbaiN produce to Deteutiva' Kellar ofthe Montgomery County SfiierifPs Office, Dayton, Ohio, the records andCor in¢ormiatio:ri dps&,b4d above.
WHEREAS, it is accordingly ordered and ad;udgod that pursuant te a, afiticxai cdminal io-v : stigation beingconducted by the ^i?^aa^tgoa^e€y Coas^at^o, Ohio Si?ar'i^s Q^^, you afe aot to disc9oso a cf thisrequest. Any such disclosure could impede the i s^sasti^at€^^ being co^d^ <ad an d t^ ^^^^:b^ ^a:aibrceodeazt'of the law. f3^^ ^^^^
Dated the 23rd day of October, 2012. wrtp,g d
^`^^^^-
MY hand a4d seag this^- ^.^^ ^^
4, e^^S^i :[.i •JI S S^dcAA.A^^!ty CAl^s.^ 5
^
"mrn"^ V7 4A{4,j ,
^^ +^SP
. i. _ .. ,} . . .
. t- ^ ` .. " . . ^
{ ^ .~ ^^^^^. , ,.• ^ ^v{ t^.3E' ^^ ^
.... ^^^ ^4 {." C..
g^0 r 'S_.ou Y.FOAd..^iA)t°
^, ^.^1^TTER OF T^ ^TAN^^...^ O^'f^ ^;Q!ii?}. O?^^.^r^... ^'o:r^p^„!zng ; 4e Kee:^e: of Redoxc^s forC,^ase Ba*-,...egai Wo^!epaa'i<.^ieut, s Chase Marhatcs,.a i'd2J>a, New York-,Ne^w 'r3 <a, 10005 td rvteaseeertain zz^a?a^a^^^to the ;'oj?o^Ting accca^ts: f^eco;aaa^€ _i^io: iu33'73 ;S^)9.,Aeeo^ant ^To '?52075 iL i ^"
S TA."I'E i' OHIO, MC3NTGE^IO-T-RY COL?N . x' SS:^ 2 C R 06013 ^ A.
Before me, the undersigned Judge, personally appeared Detective Isaiah Kelia.r, -^v:ao being frs^ duIycautioned a.ad sw®zmz on oath, deposes atad says:
L That in Y. ae City of Brookville, Montgomery County, Obio, the Lz4m.ina.! C.feu,e = rheft asdefined by Ohio Revised Code sewiiop, 2913.x 32, has oc,-;4-red.
IL That Detective Isaiah a5:ellar recuestw the issuance of a Co-a-, Order FaorupP -li:;.g tnQ reF::ase of-eezt.a.in iasformadon speei-5calI;{ listed in paraggrapia n T ofthe Couft Oxr-fer :,r's €:is Matter, Tuisinivrmaiiusa is reiewaraE and mater.-ai to an ongointr crihinai irriestigayion beir-g conducted bythe Montgomery County, t °b io Sbe:iTs Ofn-ce.
Ill. The iaformation being sought is in the possession or custody of Chase saodkl I (1-:taseManhattan Plaza, New YorY, New York, i^0015e
I'V. That the facts upon which the A€fiaza,t bases said be;je3.s are:
TL-e Afflant is a swo_T'Zl, police offi^.erwii.h the State c ^ O-hi :bs and is J.'"esenitiy emp.:.oye$7.with
fne Mcsuttgoinery County Sheriff s Offiee, assigned tsa the Sp4eiax Invesdgrdons TJdk. `? heAffiant has been a Sworn i'ezt.ee Officer since 1997, a^er-;uty Sioer-^' -wi-fla MontgomeryCojmt-y Sheriff s O'Lfiee since 2001, and has been aDetecFive since 20,08. 'i _e j-4-fdano- hasreeekyeci speeiaiized training i.n th;, investigations of Violbn,. al°mes, Sev-7aily0niesziedCrimes, iutem e^ Ciiines againsL Cbiidre.T.jzCAC-IT, CbOd Obscenity an^; Exp:a=tador,Undercover Peer 2 Peer invesLigatio-as, Forensic Interviewing of Cbiid:een;. Pr,opeAly Cx;,,^esaad Narcotics Related ^.'^=es,
QnAug-^st 27, 20i2, Montgomery Ce^^^-ty ChI;&en Serviees Casewue,-er ^e^- ssa 3^®^ar^ receivedan Ex Parte Court Order frcsrr^ ^/Iantgotnerf Ce^^^^ Juvenile Court for removal of ZacharyStringxeliow, Sainaze^ S^^ello^r and I^1a^b.eX,^r S<:^gfel^ie=^r fro^ their p;e^^`s,^vf a^^Stringfellow and Samantha. H&rr'isou-^oh-?as; custody at 516 Caleb St, Brookvilie; Ohio, 45309,due to possible medical child abuse.
Montgemery County Sheriffs Office Road Flatrog Dep-ataes; Deputr R Brown, Deputy J Caito andDeputy M Williams and BrookviIlv Police Depafament assigLtd T6.%ontgeme,z:y7 County Ch-1dren'sSerr-3iees w?taa the removal of the C^ffld&°exi. The h•o^ the residence andplaced ^ ^ontgoine^^ County Childsen. Servyees Custody.
Montgomery County Children Services began this investigation after bemg contx-,Ved by Dr. BobShapiro from Cincinnati Children's Hospitax. 'Dr. Bob Shapiro reported lklonwgomes: u CounlyChildren's Services that he was made aware of this case after sa,.^uei Nose,and Tbioat Specialist; Dr. Choo had e^ntaeted hi: with oe4eem-s about ^amnuel's, rnoyb:e4.Samantha Harrison-Johns. Dr. Choo repe.-ited Sauaantha -11-j^anisen-.^ohn's was being evasive andaanLraath-fuP with his medical practice regarding the medical history and medxeai.tre3tments ofSamuel Strin^eHow_ Dr. Shapiro eon-Lac$ed additional medical p-fovide<-s for Sarnue^S'Lri.ragfelle^ within 'Lhe C^°zeL^ati Cbild.rvja's Hospital Network to inves6gµte Dr. Choo'scomplaint fuitber. Dr. Shapiro reported atter speaking wRth additional medical p:rovzders forSainuel Staingfellow he was concerned because the subjecied ruediWall complaints made bySamantha.Hanison-John's were not substantiated by the clinical a-ad -meda ^^ ^^dings.
mvasi^e medical treatrner. vere r^^oomxz-acudc'd by the physaclans.
RDi1I'k^'ag'^f'3e c/.:i'"5e of tl3e investigation, o^gFS Mfianf ei^ information s"F^ ^had been opened f^s^u, Chase Ba.ak, Brookvxi;w,,> Ohio, to ass:^'L with the me^ica; forSamv.e1 Stz-,rig$'elicw, under the false Pre-tense 'a^ ^^nn.'e< vvas diagnos^-d with(1^F.^^ch£3F:d^-1alEa'1Cq€).uaxC'im--v43pa^llyy. This A ^'_fianne jaaS also received infsr^s'^aiz;;n that °r'?EiOi?SfundraaserS have been set up within ^^he MoF^tgomu rCo^^:-,,; Oh-do cormrnumkty; for donatz>zm s ofmedical equipment ne,ded for Saimuua Striu^,-^^How due to hi.s m°diwaA diagnoses.
FF.i?a.-aciai i11fOrmatiC1Y& is requested fi7oF.."^. -0he Chase baFsk acc^'S;.'sLitS of Sa7 Fli>°l ^^Aa'^^i r3^a a-r,dSa,..arAtha HarTison-JohnS, wb.^^h may ^onta,n. th-u do;nadipn;s ma.c.le to Samuel S` ingfex^^w f-or tiepurpast^ of paying for medical expenses und.°z a false medical d?a,"poses.
^
FuMrther.th&Affiant saith naught.
a. ^, ''• '?'V
IV9[`.
Eif
R Q
Y
{A^.
?^^-3''t _ ^..-^t ^^`?-&.c`°/^^. -
.,--rSwomtobefoge me and subscifb^^ ^^y-prespn05 - o;: or this d2..u3 /'v y 3L
On October 23, 2012, & met ^^^h Montgr^mr;^,ry QoL7ni; ^0 -^jmon ^'A^ Cc^^^, Hcno a, N^^ j^,^gA Saxb^:Aa Gc^r^^an;to receive approval on a cour'a order for ^^elfinepc¢a? ^^^^^^ of ^wrna;m;^a. H^^son-Johns and Samuel^^^ipgfei4o,Ws bank account is^^orrnatiOs^ th^^^^^i Chase ^ank. The bank a;6:>ou^t-c ^.yeree repc^^^^^^ s_'A up fordonations to purchase med^^l equipment for ^^^^eVs m_,ica^ issues.
Honorable Judge Barbara Gorman Pev4^we the court ^.3rlder end appro5.&dcsA!^;.^^ed ofs ^n C)Ctober 23; 2(3 2,1415 hours. The court order was sent to Chase ^^nk's, ^^^poeM:^ ^^ocaSs^rkg; 7610 'M Washington IstFloor, Indianapolis, In, 46231, to be ^^^^^^^ed by the begal de,^^rt imeqn..
Ow.ce, the financial information is received from Chase Ba,> k, ^^^ proper paperwork w,?.. i1 i^^ f^^^p^lefed.
^^^^^^ ^ ^^^ C A S 1q, F cD; .^^^^ ^ ^^^^01 A^ Ar ^ pm
If you a re rlot regts+ered to vote wtipr'c you rrvc itow,'„^ra! ^ou I;I<e to a€a it to v4hcra Y^^ay{^ YES, 1Vb ll? I91 ('qt`i4f to vote. [..,!fi J(> not vv^d ^i?ot'Gc7'ffiriO vCi^fS;
If yoti do iaot clieck a:$lher box, jrita yv;i Jbe coi sIdk:rcctd ho .,,R7<-doelc#ed €.oR to rog?sm€* ac vole ^:^: Ms ,tmm_.,....,.,,^., . , . ._.. . _
t" 3 K 3^omp€e'o this secFtron fQ, you or Por ^r ljcrscn ff^r <v:;cr ya cf rsp,alyfn{ . ^' ^ sf^
t^^e^ ^C[3E^^ Cl e° YrJ€1 i? ^iP^G ^^3 ^t^l ^J^IU'I $'pcuaw3G.^C ds^l, '^oc i;z or Yd oU:ci9i ^" Ms t I Noli eS, hoG" t ^ ^ U`'ll'tc'f^ ^.^
V
. ^:. . , :^_ _ . . .. ., . .Complele fh3s sec4oon for you or for 2ho persorr, for wrrwm you are app1y[u___ - ._,.....Sts&rsf ^^'cfress ; ? Chack hare If yO>~ arO siuMalOss
...._ ,. _.1€y Cacarfy
......Phon e N:sr^ue, Oesl Time io Cart Add, ona' Phone Ntaar,bDr F"l u,o A d ira: s
c^is^i^(Ptt 3^., 1 }3 ¢ ^^ - v4a t y^^`..i' f E1^'^., u.^3J. ...J b n'^„7V4^ . . ..._ .
If yGS, ,rorn what source?-- ._. ...__ ..... Y
tS .Ctr'a(s) k2r) u^;ls? to pre?^..<are ap^alS ^=_SL ¢S} c^ :^^3^ 3Y?;^v°% j yt, r ;^a...3I you urasv+PLS"ed "1"eS tt3 ho ii3si't7a^ ^ C d£ 4.atis, u}Fi^ Ehts ;2orSoaT0 ; sjai't tC, I-,scalSze at3od as$6statlct3
separadeIv f€'arn the Otrrer Poopir, aot., live V>,€h? !. yss No,:^__...-...._ __
. . _ ._ . .. .a
W6t yos., or the people Rn y^^u, hot,TD r'ocef 3 ia.c! n a ffiis mc ^ ^? l Ees N c ^ .. ^^
Inconne refers to aIE the money that you and the pea, r:. in your ^on^o rect)sve srlc,! ,,, 0nirtg4 from ernPloyrnsni,c^lE^dIS}7GtiSr.^^:`lT:^dlCi3^ SuEJ^7Qoi, d15i3`UI^I".Jf e)8E7C,'i)t'^, rA.,kar i:€i11;it ^}i;(1G(ii&, ^1}() k.C.'f;r ^{1PiT^^;d.aiTiln7r;, ^C7ct E? ^^.",q ,f;11rlt^`, SS#Jet^i^t,s Senefks, etc.
= ...f y3as,ptease cnipPate the kub€e tauiow-l:.. __.! __ ...^ # M ]f cu^t^ an^^rte ^ 3 c^ fSc a^s.0'ua4 I f
.._._.,^2^6Y^.._........ ......_. b^t7A3L`r6$'iiC4^GY7& ! f13.'3Pt^+^:^ f.^a ^ d A,;i^ ^l J^ t 3 1D:$1°u6,'tSr
.__^ .._ ._ _.,...,Jici ar'i;.tt;.da'' FI, 41'i'^i^r ^la^ri?S lC2ive a io^.l or :{ S^a u ,^wx' 4'Ti^n Y°^^e s.S° ^.^.^,! 3s utu e a _. .,.^ i L^11 VeS, who?
Yvt?r^tr^s'.sCfi? _.
(S aS'l"yftiTl2 irl VCt.BE` ho;pe oil stIf y+"s, wP?o;'
c-^ { ^,i q/4^4,! Ti"^i 8 C°^' '>.+ Na'^3. !^ a ^i! kE
{.^ jl63 or other ,.:e^Iai^t.^wziCfi^Ca)
Estimated arncr^rt paid per nT;n•rh: $
o 4i; a
^lGUTxo K ^ ^J M^ •_^ s
.k,^,y'..^.`. ^
^1^Tich experaaes do y^r ar-^d t}^e ^ ^. ;
iRrMEd(cc^l ig?$p?I1SeS ff? tat?ia0 ?s a'.s a b l eba or u,38 60 O fdpr. TEz ..ce a GS^ fYpc-r`asxv5 SulCh as a71saaGHbills, prescriptions, P;ealth tsssurance p, eniiurfls, or ctrTa.• meoicaI se;^iccs, i?c .,o, ;n r^!r<de an^y ,1,Ad;c.:^l s;,;pF,,.,r; ,^mentsyou enkere^f in Bhe check box above, ^stir^aatec arn^^ nt paid per r lasY^r pa
_.._.....__..._._...._..._._._ .. _.., _. _......L'O Rerit / Wt€rt-tgae e paynierais - _ ;Estimated amount paid per morti:: S
_.^.4§ p y. -.._....... . f ..._ ......,_ ._._..... _..__.. ... ^l^t iia.es -^j^as^ cneGk ;hauEliltleS yoL, pay mr be:aw
Do you pay for heaf3r,.g andPor wair corxciiiican:ng? ^^ ^septar,k ^ r:v,°er
^, ^,..,
JFS 0'20C (r.t^•4' '.
^ ._. -Ye°
77777_
v JEr 3 OI 4
Scanned by iv,ortgr rrsery Coun'tvJFS Angei Shepard 12:7/2014 11.U5;^.s3 ANA
t By signing thiis app€,caflon,
1 uf3der5taPid the C{uesllQrt`i orj 'ti31s fo,,`'1 and certify, ta7Ut .:L I<eP:p Q! 3ci^t!ty, t.l s, :R ,a o. i.o :.eAm s azL> CGrrsrri andcomplete to ih,°. best Of; 4ykliC}weQ0 lTlclla"og 2.n,iCtm<Nt11 ko ,<k siew d44 e€! aEy ^.^.i'r7.s'tn smW.'', of c:rGh hGU.aetlqiC.^
mernr`aer appiyingfor assistance,
i sia[eaMe: penalty o#per;ury hava Msdamd exl! un".;::s and o.her ^^,,.ftar Einonmai f9svi::s in Wiwh { andlGd i?3y
spc;asa have any inteast.
!I?1d£$`M-^u'slC§ and "ugl'c?e to pfUillta'^, ', dL1f;i11i1.'3r is ';C have
EJnCfusmnC1 a.RO''s`.SreeGt1Elt ML ±F'C"aji S nu'y'oCmaG't $I., a?£`CGssE4fV p'JU`! of
my P-ligibit_Py and level of assistance,
I ui:Qey`$ts'i. t2d that by s2y?Gilftu this ap3::lICPitiilii allfa i c:CC`.v.,: ;(,3hii1 WiC3 f'ifS•i, e a93i aSSW.'1#ng to t,il? E`s3;C', ui 4.Jhlt`3 i,S[?y
fl;i?1's to ^,hiiEsf7o136a.( SUppQrf tflot is owed :G ::1f3 i1{"t`t?, ifk?'t tiilnd)r Ci1f[(i:"{,''I; !(1 iilc'. Assma?'Me g:ul1G d(aMG Stli; Oltitk
V'a'ork;sFirsf eEiaibi4s't f period.
tJRders$arYdttla$ i3}1 SdCy`37?flg Mlf. saj:=,piicil'".!C}i1 and reC V 1!y Mf?ii1C ili{, ( iaia ?*Ss,aRiri,.^^ ia ii1^'.. State of r3h3Q any rights to,
r,ledicai SUppari and any rlhts to ,a aymeiiis by a 1iaWs f lsrci p=;'iy for medical issis{x+r7ce owe;; tc F; c dndl7r to ;;;eIili'rfm f'.hlWmn fi? thex.ss6stan CG a,'MUiJ during the ?!l.gIii6itty pei3'„+d.
the child support enM:cz.ner;t ac,zenuy f:nay reques! abd supaar's sMNs es byFo. a ati°,g th:^ JFS 07076 "App18catiDfifor Child ;aupport Se;vices."I UtB.^.'rstir$1d that f^ sci1+: Bi7s'ia7(eCEt €ma; be iSsWC; t,;!' r +t.?Isd:1'1% i.'.? the L,i,lJi"a`. to tr.ax' vAa%?'`uEv/'.i GoCloC.t'.a af6''
IN THE COMMON PLEAS CO'^^ OF t^^^^ ^ GOM.^^ ^ COUNTY3 ^^^^CRIMINAL .^I"V^^TON
STATE OF OHIO CASE NO. 2014 CR 00138
P ' tiff
VSm JUDGE MARY IM%E.AN
SAMANTHA HARRISON SUMMONS TO APPEARON INDICTED CH..^^^^^
Defendant
Surnmons is hereby issm', iri accordance with criminal rale 4 yD) :?dv?siil-9
SAMANTHA HA SON
516 CALEB DR.
BROOKVILLE, OH 45309
THAT SAMANTHA HARRISON has been andicte;^ by the Grand Ju^^ of Moritgo:sr^^ry County and thatthe person ^amed in the indictment is i:er^lby ordered to pel*sona.lay appear at 8:30 A.M. on. MAY 15,2014 before a Presiding Judge of the P^^ontgor^^^^ County Common Pleas Cu-uy'c, Coa:mra€^m A THYRDFLOOR, 41 North Pe^,= Street, Dayton, Ohio, and that FAILURE TO AI'PEr^.I^ WILL RESI_,T1:1- IN AWARRANT FOR ARREST, FORFEITURE OF BOUND,. IF ANY, OR ADDDI`I'IONAL CRIMINAI,CHARGES FOR. FAILURE TO APPEAR UNDER :^e--t^3n 2937.99, Os;.io Revised Code. I ^^er°tify tiiatthe attached indictrnent is a true copy ofthe original indictment or^ file in this officM. You have the rightto an attorney. If you are unable to hire an att€^rney; ^fl the Montgomery <ounty Pu.b^^^ ^^^ender°sO^°x^ at 2225 2 between the hours of 9.00 amnr and 4.00 pame t^ ^^^e,-i^^ if you qa^^^^^ forattorney services at no cost to voue I'^ ^ AS'E I?'RING THIS INDICTMENT TO COT-aT WITH YOU.
^^^^^ A. Brush,^^^^^^ Pleas Clerk of ^^urtsMontgomery County, Ohio
By: /s/ Gr^^^^ ^ hClerk of Couq
I ^xecut^. ihis Surn-m®ns by maiiiiig a copy oI'the within Lndictmes-it to t,b.e defendant(s) herein byCERTIFIED MAIL.
,°..a....,^ ^.d...^^,
'^-
I
^ ^.
^ ^)
^^
MDNTGOMERY COUNTY DEPT. OF JOB AlY.I} FAMILY SERVICES
lt is our goal to assist the MCDJFS client named above in preparing for his/her transition fromwelfare to work. This client states that he/she must serve as the primary caregiver for the patientnamed above and is therefore unable to participate as required. Please give careful considerationin completing this form. The information that you provide will be used to determine activitiesthis client may be able to parlicipate in and duties he/sh.e may be able to perform, even if thereare some limitations.
My signature below authorizes the release of medical data to the Montgomery County Dept. ofJob and Family Services.
Patient if
Medical Practitioner please comnlete the items below
18 years old):
tY1;}ockeo^^dr^al t^tiseas^ CmELAS -CQr,n^,1a K"^ r^c y r i^x seclzePat3entDlagnosis:kyrN e,n+:%.cL, 3leedrnt^^:,strd^r; ^^r,nr^^r^^^l+c^ ^liserde.r (c ysf
r-- ntOLr^^t^ Aork^e r^oci, ^rc`c:^c}^c^ ^t 1.n4-9,rvcLlsYndro^ne' l_c^c.k;c A c 'i c4os,5,
1. Does the Patient-require a relative to provide medically necessary, fufl-time care?q No.
^Yes. If yes, name of caregiver.Comments:
2. Does carang for the patient prevent caregiver from participating in the followzng:working, volunteering, training or attending school?
q No.
es. If yes, ple^se za cate anset o ilit3 a€ad foiha^t long f` participate ui tdie abc3veactsvittes ^ill last: Qnset^jV ^ - Dnration:. -. .. ^
3. If patient is :under the age_ of 6, can the patient attend a cliilldcare facaiiiy for af least 20 hours perweek?
0 No. Unable to attend months from this dateq Yes.V N/A
Practitioner Name (please print)Physician Signature
PhoneCiiy 1?Gc.lf ^1f'I State 8_ Zip CodePlease retwn this form to no later than
w^^ ,^937) *for ]b}- mail. 113onfgomen Cotan#t= Dep#, of Job andFHruitt sens-5ces 1 I I1 S. Fchs in C Moses Bh tL ^~-ton, QIl4 1^^"^ '-,i-' f^f^^.^ ':^.P^j•MCDJFS 10795 Rev. 9/2011
25"2 Ul
^`-N^r ^;° ..,^ ^
^'°^^ `^ti^^;
n^'?^ffi^,^z 'ao
THEFT ($1000) ;Bv Deception;i F5
A3^ ^^L
^4 . ^ mam. . . _.nr.^^xvrs+s.arrF+ ^^ ^
f (I^(4^7
^"j
Foreman of the Grand Jury
vLEu"TR^MCALLY F.^EDCOUR's," ^^^= '^ OM^^^^^ PLEASWet:nasdc t, .%Hpr s 30, 2014 2:24:04 PPe3';ASENUNNIBER; 2014 a,,^ 00 138 E_;ockei 0 : 19061148`°• R^o.a^...;^^d^<'a^°u tl_'^ . r ^': ^sRUS..CLERK Q.F s:..CURs S a Oh' e GOMERY COUNTY 0:IO
D€i'^^^T
THE S`^AT^ OF OH,10, ^^^^^ ^ GOME.^^^ ^^^^TY
2014 CR 00138THE COURT OF ^^^^^^^^^ ^^EAS
(January f`errrr in the year "NIVe Thousand and Fnu%feun)
MONTGOMERY COUNTY, ss.
THE GRAND JURORS of the Ccunity of Mointgv mPrjr in the r,arnR, and by the
authority of the State of Ohio, upon :„ ^ef^ oaths do fs^d and Presunt ^^^at. SA;0ANT HA
HARRsSON, befiween the dates ^^^^^^riber 1, 2011 through October 31, 2012 in the
U:;vnzy of Montgomery, aforesaird, and State ci` Ohio, vvr z`h PE,,rpose to ni prWe the owner,
to-wit: Montg^me;°y County Job & Family Ser,Juev of property or Service^.^, did knowingly
and by deception, obtain or exeE i control over said owner's Prope; ty or services, Ao-wfz:
Cash ^s.^. en^^'its and/or f^'r^d a5SlsianGE: hfa`3inu a value di One Thousand "Do6{a3"s (-'^ 1,000) or
more bu'L less than $7,500; ;c^n'Lrary IL-o the form of the statute (in ^,;;.o;.atiorl ;^ ^eeLion
,ri^ee^, an,' against291 3.02(A;(3} of the Ohio Revised %Codle; r such case made and pa (,
My name is Martin Stringfellow, I am the father of SamanthaHarrison's 3 children; Zachary Stringfellow, Samuel Stringfellow, andMatthew Stringfellow. I do not live with them at 516 Caleb Drive Brookville,Ohio. However, due to my name being on the house, I am allowing her andthe children to iive there, rent free. I will pay the house payment and allutilizes. I will also give her $150.00 a week to help take care of my boys. Ialso provide the primary medical insurance for the boys, but none for her. Ifyou have any questions, please feel free to call me. I do work 3rd shift, so Imay be a little hard to get a hold of. I will do my best to get back to you assoon as possible.
Sincerely,
,^• ^
Martin Stringfellow
^vbab MiA aMS* b NK s. ^,#ya df e's^r . #^
^l
-_i^>< -a
r
^^
^, ^.r.J L^°3^f 5d^1r-I_i YJ'^^ CiiL'u^ :;s.a,. .9_a+ -^ F
N W4st Fourth StTect, Suite 700$.7ax id:rr, Oi^io 45422
^AMiAINi i'^ ^^ ^IA:ZRiSON..! '. 4D i. A .i... i .J{O.
BROOrzVIL-LE, 01-; 453og9
Delki Samantha Harrssoji
COURT Si:;RVIi:'FSR€ 1t3(y1,07rii i=LOOfZ
4 i Notrth Pex'r'v Street
ko<,rn 103
i N;,ton, OII ia 45422-2 100
(937) ^^^-3481___,
::c;\ (07) 225-4925
51:ay 15, 2`k14.
i^^for t ^e^'tOn May hJ., 2014 j'U'L1 were scheduled fdr 'sPli'<tag:'tnL';3" in ('an ':'_clT*f''.P ! CR 00138 x^
(S 1000) (By Deceptionl, for which you ffirled;o, apFaear"
Your diC;`e4% Lxi.irt Ca3te has been 5t;he,r.L^EYd for ^,A:^^ 29, 2^ii^ , ?ik`. ?^:^±^'t ,^.1^^. at ig"^5: I"f^o',1t^?€^3?ti?"y County
Common ^ 7 ^ ^ ^^^ yo,i's Ohio 45421 ^ v ? ^ ^ tr / , ^-s 1-, Floor. n ^ 9 .e v n^i; a{)L^.i'f., ^-? N. Perry .`L3°C^.^`, ti'.^3.,}/.,, ':1fle '0~'.^3^1^"")"+;i.l,?, `^d^.^'^M ^^ sure W^.^ f ^ c`1S
ciEG°e^a" the d8spla2 imEAnhGFrs in the iobby for any changes in the cou'sbroQ)ni ok,Lye?ben FatP.:?:Ye to appear .Or
` .^ ^tle^iJL '1^ t3^^iGil.r.vao/^,KJn..ih1.5 3a'."a37; et13e31^: will "aCSt1ik: ilt a ^^8:iai:i kDel^i'_? 2.StE.:c^...; f^RN ^i..'^t?s: arrest U ^! i ^'.,'s _ k?",^G1yM1.^ rC'.^3L^f: in P t
.;%a,.^a . a^ ^'^' ,,, ^?.^2 a., ^^;ti.s« ^ ^.or legal elements of t1he bh&rges asserted .^^^^^ ^ the 2e^ ^^ not o^ .3xe 5, 2014
or provided ^^ Defendant ^th the ^^^^^^^ or ^^^ced:rb^ to be used :mehe defen;^^^ of the charges.
The Defendant zs indigent w^^ entidpei tz hand"Affig ;; the cha--ge:;^s asseried agx;.s3
her. T-he public dek^^^^m assigned to the ^ef^^darit's c^.. ^ hpnm . ^.^t hnquinf^-,d of the De&x^danz
concerning e"i^^^ facts re l ated to th^.' cha?'g'a,'^.s. have no6. GSaquf'.redl, ^'..'., dw „ za ^Lhe W::`na,ss°s
necessary for vi&! to 4^su, ^ ^ ` aes. e»fl.e^ ^. ,^fi ^.a, ^^- ^ ^^t c^^°s ^"..,.^tMn.P^ a 3s $ >s the ^s ar .z^,,r.z5.dams. ^ ^> ^"wa,^ ei^a ^`^^,Yk.^?^:, f ° ;;^ u a^°.^..^ ^
Vv^^.esses necessary ^^^ the trial of ths^ ^^aner. T^ e Defendant has 'been dertz.e,'
effective assistance of ^^unse° as neither >3oss, ^^^s x, Cux '^ave -a knowledge of
the basic a^^qua^eraen^ of the Ohio Rux^^ of Profe:,^^^nal Coxdu,,x,G as, tl^^ Defe:dama has not receive
*ie benefit of the public ^ef^^^^^ ^erno:^^^^^^^ the ability of ^e Publi; de:^^^^^^ to In.and3e tl,,e
Defendant's case as ne3d^c£' Goss, ,.''^fian "s. a.'. r ^.'^.,ox, have knquA2e4z. of ^.s.a° D.^'efe''F^dzmi Kh', [^crd^^ issues
regarding the charges ol- explained to ,Ah,^ De'gendeE''s'; ^'^e legal ^'rz:^enns of vle Q-'?^:^`ges^ A^,'o>ti3St `'s ie
Defendant.
b. Oh.a^ Rules of Professional ^^^^wo----- Rule L2
â9 4 n ^.^. ls''^'tsi^'yeY shal l abide b^' a client's -s'^^3:^2t^Eu^'s,^ c^,?;;e",--m angtae objectives and,
as required by Rule 1,4g shall consult 'vriQ^^^ dhe client z, tio dhe a^^anis b'f' ^-y are to be
ps.LN, u^',£d. A law;°^°s^ st^^ j ^?^^ such s'"sr^^k& ^^ ^ ^^ ^ â^;. ^ , ^ G^,^'y a ^ t•.. w ^e len } of the m. a.3.rin^g^^'s, .,3"^ ^ ^sacp^.^fl..^,.hai r^'M^.,,^%^i3^"'3^ ,^',<.3 ',+' ^^ ^
out the representation. A lawyer sha%^ abide by a client's decflsi:^.^^ wh.exhed I;, zN''s"^^^ a. maneR4 In a
a p^a^9."Y^..-0s"&^.n case, the lawyer shall E4P,e5kd'"' by t:.^w 06w'.^t'"s:5s diYb`,Rs?`;n,^ aftea om^^im.;Psc:;, with the Sari'^ye:"y as
4'^" ^i:S 9 5 tr nr,'^'p +` d ` p r", `.P^a a plea to be e^E2e g^,3s^, ^r e^a^eT to a^.ve a3, ^,-y ,^^^ and ^z ^,m^: eY ^h ^?a; a^ I>: n: ^ ^^t.:^^ the
period of ^^pres^^^^^^on. ney&.er Goss, ^^ ^^^ or e o;^^ lilmls^ ^onf^^:^d w^th, the in$
the objectives of representation or ffie means b;^ W'Plia:h a.he of Tek+rese;wu.<t3o,^ ^^^ to be
for May ^9, 2014 ^ '!9ncfigs t,}Q'"$@`^a^' ^.^.°•^F
;^a'^v^' dn.sa z.r °.` v^'y.,^y'. $},
l^a..^ ^.^ou`^ «3u ^s';•° ,^ Wa,, at k t^ 3^ y. a^i, and ^^i^'e^'^ t^
^dress,.. Fc"^r.3'luG"e to appear worth:ts :J.7?^,i"' ,Me:%l wi^^ ^^sul" 8.^:
whac`^'a ^^^^ result in incarceration.
As yoL^ can ima.gA:ne I was ve^^ al^ed .'^^^a this &ez^^en x got ^^ 'ibe County PRO
System and I ^^ntfi^ed I had a warr-f.r.3 a^suzed *ba r'n-Y -arest. ^:Rhz, als' ww the fact
that just two days prior to this I wn, fired s s5-rn cn, r" ?avi en<o rm;mec t x o tvo:;. F,,z- a pehs^ ^ officer
th^u&h my police department ^..^d gi ve^'i ne exp4^:^a^i^+°... e".^7. ^as ^f rf -, ^F o;^:w y'^ n.w 'i^ ^^^^^¢^^^ +^`"#,^. .
Onq June 5, 2'Sr`..^ ^ 4 E'.Sr^^ my ^C^a?^FgS..t°A'^4.^,^,.^?^q/- ^ I plead'^ t a^Y^' ^ '^^.L^J^.^.yx dA1`^r'C9 ^t'"rY, /"'^' 9-F^^r r i,.'3'&H^ ^^.L(.?:6`nw^KAriSM S.. .hn^:'^W^n ^s,.,^a,{ ^• ^^5,^ f1 ^f^^^.hd that^' g 4'^' wasry not
the time for r:"&^ to 'Ei's,er i:Ci.^° ple^., I ee+r,iiaib^e^n o-s.^^ k^^i^a. &a-. e ^Ja r.' 'a :»" ^0 ^'' "x h pR ead r9e'^ ^^^$^^`'sl^
because that -wher a den^n.dan€ ini&ns their Ple<^ th^.'^. starts the prwsea'3.xsa.^Ps tL :x.`.^ fo?' a Speedy Trial.
libe pu°^'ik Defender tried to -waim7e rr,?n.y dghas to `s °il! i.he tLme zzia^9 I s'+^;"^rs^:; her d a d her. to.^.aa.^^ .5 and
waive not one of rny ragb4si The on.^^^ ^^^^ I -wanv^^^ ^^as, the reainPT ofi:.^.^ ndfi€;^^e-w., and meivcd
^b:^e cof the 3ndi^;^eat ^d e^te^ ^^ ^e ^x of z^*b^;. ,.,y^,c^ i ls^ ^ .^^^ E^ a^:r'^.r^,^--^r, k,^ ¢. €^ 3copy ^C.; ^e^.^ plea ^ects kh-c€t, I
ofstood mute. ^is Co^..^ has also miss :-e "^^a.^y ^ e^F oa" ^^^^^^gs, by .^^^^^^g to provide the
m^' reason the hearing -w-a-c aelip5_7 hMld„ Like ;rdlher s ^.;^ c "rwR;€ ted and
., .n
.A^ Qu-^;'^_„`.`
also sdischarged. 1 ^^',^,%^,s.etTC•s took ;^a^`.^t^ !s
The ^ ^ '' ° 2^^ ^ ^ ,..^' ^, t_*p ^^^^: ^ ^;^^^±-^^.,, ^^:^^^r Sect ion t f' . j r e (G)(3) of ^.^^. ,_ ^^^ ^•..^.^ E.^^,. Y^ . de, K3;zi the Forerasic
Psychiatry Center for We5U,-r' i't Ohio ex'u'°saai33e th.? Defendant apd_a°,tu3:: a :.dn. iF"3eiiFig;, to ia'i° i.3vldt^, The i'e^3£)"-
i.s to i&""sdS.i.id+^ facts found by th e ^xc d??aa.esq'-'i. „ ts ^i";e.eaPons, and conclusions aa t^^ the De%enG'ias0.t`^
Ca'3i^petei?ea $t? stand "raa^ ai'^^ee present ^.iza?e. °:^:^.€i^^s,^c4 '° ep:i^s that `c;i,c ; ^e?^^;33dar.z: is pi'eSir^3^i^^
mcompeP+renty qA.^^e opinEorK should b,- IDiL ,^. '?'.i Qi' ule 'a:°f :?:hs ^aife..h.'P,-^tZ^ cor1^'t.ietvnt to stand
g y pY,rfiG;^
t^Ii'^i^. '^i5i^m. ^{ D 3^a'>c^L3' c:d Ad sf tN,}M .t^ +„'r" m;.'0.itGr°.ifly A a;C;.. . . . . -"^, '3 ^i£ the report 3.Se`^. ^ t,^o^ ' ^.!'>,
b €.' forwarded to the d eFe i'As n..', vsi1n :3^,'b Tn d. 3,P' t'a,'s. ;s.°'s^`y^4' iZ to r^%Ss wa.^ =^..^_
I.^'wNpoin:.men4.s set by v,na For^.^^''sn`^JE °v 'E' 4.}k Wvstei'u Jp$i p ^a- xjc., e:z noLed 4ii^v the
the Adult Probation Department is b.. b-z :s.-.;;rmea Anariedlatc€v. 37he F : can p-resan^^^^ be reached
^^SPOSIT iON DATE: 109./25f ^ 4 DUE TO 00UfZT : 09118,114
`^ ^.., _..®..^..^-,• ^""_..^. .^ _ ^.^
A.--
1
°LECYtaa^''aitaiOFw'. Y FiL?-D
C Os^R T ^s^^ C d?n 3:,^^ P L E A SFriday, Now 0:7, 2014 3:16:34 PMC rSE °'.,^ CR 00138 Docket 0; 1957GRE ^ s .i,LF-RK OF ^ ..`. -3MON3°^^^^^^Y COUNTY 0
Defezadar?t Samantha Harr?sen:s ordered to appear in. Cc .,: { o, t^retvf;:? c:- 20, 2014 at 4:.00pam. :-or a
hearing on a forensic report regarding ci'ii!a.'iei.e?1ce and Stix?e:"_'+tJ.fii'i, .
Defendarz'L is required to be present aT ±:ne date and tirre speei ied :n i'.f"Ie coa?-troor?n ofJudge MarY
Wiseman, C®UYtS'®odnn 8. MiC'titi,nt;me"'v County Ct",.<E3s`l.A`S^vi:,Se, 41 :''•i^viL: Perry S',;°ei., Da)i.o'I., Oi31.'3. 45422.
^.' O s.^i'RDE i ;L, D:
J: `D'.^3 E iVAR':r i,h,t;.SEEMAN
This document is eleetron;eally fiiad byusi7ngtrhe Clerk of Courts e-Filing system. Thesystem w^l', post a record of the filing to t;`4e, e-T?i3ng a;cS",^'.^ur.t "FNot1fac ^io°3.s" tab ^,?i'l.he following
This doCi.il.iAent is e;PctiC7i21"aflkj' :?4e`",s b 3 us i ng the Cl o f '^r..•w:?"?5 ^. ^:aing system. Thesys'Leia"1 Wi;.i'°a.,'sr'sa 2. rae..o°Y.°Li of"L`°A^.E fi"sxng to the e--Hfli g acr`ou:' ' ^:C :^:.•c; K{ r.^ raiiof :?i-- foll.?w4ng
case participants:
.i U.s,^iGE YP.t^' .. RY ^.'^3 G S Ei'"f .('., i'V
Hz,A:'HERJANSASSISTAN T ?RO^ECuf^!G ATTORNEYf93 ;1-225-5 /57
Attorrae-v for Plaintiff
UASENO., 204'4 : R00138
BOBBY JOE COXA'fT ORNEY AT i AV,%13O WvS, SECONF) S"RrEf SUITE 800DAYTON., OH 45402
(937)-228- : 975Attoney for Defenda-nt, Sarnantha Ha>-iser,
The Honorable Mary L. '0,!isemanMom,gomery `"loun:;^ Common Pleas I.-our=41 N, Perry StreetDayton, OH 45402
RE Samantha M. HasdmonCCN: 20149CRe00138
Dear judge Vifisemam
Attached, please find a report detailing h^ results ofk ;he <^^^^^^^,nc;; t^."u Stand Trial
°val:,?atd®n completed in the rC"e"°nG: d case. Rea;;.e d;z ;;s;ta"e to contact
me if yQlA have any q^.,^estIGB?s regarding fls'e „€tach°,^'a r£-',}:;ort'
We would be happy to make the examiner avaf;aNe for any upcor^^^^g hearings,should he/>h-- be subpoenaed to provide testimony. "{;vi'eVe"; vie 1ti%ouiv apprpCBaie :^i
if this pifice coijld be contacted during the scheduianN p;owess so r:^at, we can verifyfhe examiner's avaglabilrty.
Thank you fC)i` this r eferral. ^ hope ii Ea"', the attached re -pGY': i;, of a:,sl,^tar's.-I`e to ; oi.E.
Respectfully,
Kara E.A. Marciani, Psy.D., F^BPPLicensed PsychologistBoard Certified in Forer,sY^ PsychologyDirector of Forensic Serv€uea
KEAMii Ir
uC: File
^^NR'^^^^^^^AL
'F07RENSd C I--VA'-UATQN
NAIME: Samantha M. Harrison
DATE OF BgRTH: 9/1 2,`1969 (45 years)
"IO^^T CASE NO: 2014-CR-00'r 38
COUNTY. N`ion6gomerv
/; f ^-5 ^^VrYS4i.^t;T,."ii5 ;,.iar'...!'+nA. Be9gifjCln, Ph.D.
DATE OF 'EVALUA7 s u /'i 0/14
^4^P"^•$^''4 ^"+. r '-""' c^. *
^ ^ { ^ #^
JUDGE : 'e.^'aP-^^4 g >rfV^C_ e!l-PGn
^,"'. F^ ^{^ ^ p° y.."'
k.:,,,
a ^ '? y aY TO
„/ '^,. ,."'"+._.q he A^^ ^ ,ryq '•" "^' ^ .'^:G% . q ^ ^^ e^ p f ^^'b1 3 c"9 ^ G'^'2'M1' ^Ea^.v^' i 7^' '^" ^b,PlL*n^..e. ,Q^., ^G^".1 fvs v! ^S ?^ ^ i'sp,^^! C k^q` 9 w, )r4s?
October 2 9, /_ i' ", z
Ms. Harrison, a 45-year-o:d sinw^^ Caucasian feanaye, vras referred to the ForensicPsychiatry ;enier :'`or Western a " i:3 by -tse H:38 orabir ',?'iary L. ^lVisei;^an, judg° of the
^'^onigomery County t,c^^g^<o^ Plea--o^;^°'. ^,ursuar"^ to :; ^.^^. ?:34a.^7i0'3';),J^i'^'+A`
Competency to Stand Trial. ^^'95. fic.a^os p :s ;,s"ar»^,°^ 'ed ^?'1:^^^'°: one 'uo,.fi`-^'.,. a ^ t I' 1,0^ r,.'a0^ ?"`-'" ^fi ^
C^eC;v^s" tiC^?^1(F5) and is currently fii^'^ £::"! bond, awaiting ^^ic-,;^os^aix3" tni, xe- --usE'.
Mis. Harrison was wvaaua[ed at the officles oft4e Forensic ^syE, r-:ial.: yOhio on 10!110114 ^^^ approximately two ""OL,;r:.
T h^ evaluation consisted of an :r,tie Y;^tecn' ^^.,.,9n;;ca;^ ..Ikerv'Ievv, ,. Mentai Status
. ^ S-'r";: a n;^',u , c^. ^^ "+, t^r ;,^ a ^:and ^,, telephoneExamination, aa ^ '^'^".^,rrEpe":t'^.-'3"w ;!
corsultaaion w9th deserAse ;^^ ^sel on 9112i`14- and on ^10l10E141
(8/26/14).2. 8n d a; L m e n t (4 /3 F11'14}.`? r' `Z,u^3. Appo i n tment letter %'' ij r°'a^^^t t.! ^ °;^;. ^'.f, ^ rr i 1 ^^^^ro^^ ; 8! !2LJp I 1' ; 3'+^,^,t 9!",^r'4;.4. Mcantcornetlry CodaF n< ri^ 's O^ ' .;.,^r R_,^.;^,_F"^^^,^^*,, . and :^ t ,°,'/^;: R od ^ A. Brown^^ ^^^,"" ^,_^ ' ^,^^^x^ S
(8l2ff12).^°. 3$ (^y/y 'ry?[^^
^y Coun ty 1 ^3tr^{ ,e ^ /°/ r
fi ^;f'`0 (6? ^`'
^^qofy: Vard ^^^^'l!`s.k,i.3i,'^' .• *3 t/S. ^^p^9r^'^ii/^, Y
^lL ] iG1 e '0 Office^.w" ^ ;/,i' A . e3`^'^?.^I^;,."^'.^P:7Lk...-,,,7
(9/4/12).
c. Montgomery County Sher;fii'';, Off,ce Rupo: an'-14 NarracGv;; ^s&2h' VV. Kellar19041112, 9F7112, 9i14I12, 10/4/12. 10,241'12, 10129r`1^2, 1,%29/1'3, 2l^!-13, 2r1`x3113,2/26/13, 9i24113, 10/28/13, and r 1i's 4/ i •:3}.
7 . Montgomery County Sheriff ' s Office ^^po^^ zari' Nar;-afi;>re ' He;;^eq H. ThornWn(9/4/12).
COMPETENCY TO STAND TRJALSamantha M. ^^rftQnPage 2
8. Telephone contacts with defense c;aumsei.9. Mental Saatus Examination +1'>:sh, Ms. 'sa:'Pas^s"? s `=0l1N;` §41,
10. CScreen i ng i l te^. V -; e''^1 v i.lf^,i ^v^
P r i or to G 9Pf,i xn..%^ 1n:.fi^ , i^:11t?, the 3^r ' ^;.;s' ^..^ee^n„ , S ,^"'^l ''<' o3" ^_' ' '.s+.''sqst..:Qs''-r ^.BJf' aI:y.lC11 o^" ^^'(v pa rameters, ^'r ^._ and ,.^ ' .. of 4 S^«.
evaluation were eXQ.9ained to Ms. Hai i"9 ;Qti. She 'i sd<cat;^d Qomoi eh'a nsiQCo of the
information presented and indicated 10hat she w,'.s; Ed proceed .Ali'" i the evaluation,
bQQaL<SQ she was "th,^"ec` ,te3"3E..'d b4° the Ji,i'' .,a3Q." :^h''- sE^-,&: `h=s: zagenia?'s ^F`1fQ:"meCJ
Participation Statement following the explanation Qffe, Qd by the examiner and wrote
underneath her signaaut'e: In no way am € waiving ^r-iy feg;°;ts bv, siQnrn:, t: 6;:!"
BACKGROUND ^^FORPOAq ^ON
^^^^^^^^fiwl Circumstances
Ms. Harrison offered as hQr address a post office box 4n. :'SrQQ k'^^i^'Q, 01-'.o. 'si'b°hQn asked
'^aQG^% :Q; 4Uy" she has iP'J'- „Q ii , her E.;a:rr.^'Qi;. ^t lQ+^.?^iaQ she ;' ^ ^^ ^ '^i?^ she ff 3c^c . alone and
ha ...°' lived ?n her current residence ;^or one vv<;c:{. &he adf:'sed that whe re ss!-_ iives Es "nQt
^^ l '^ ^ ^si +^ YQ C? ^ ss^(C% ;.^: ^<. r about f ry^'i Q^' ^ ^ ^tsj vels ^ ' ^ ^^dAA.s, N^ ^n, ysQ; ^11,11as re luctantYins ^^'d?`^sE'a^r'.r^'. d ^ , i s ^F ^;s-^'s^ k ^T °.^. ^'^^; ..
'e'.,.¢
to provide any specific 4i'i'?Qi m',^,tt1:en. but sfa£Qd that sh e a'..a+„k i;`t ^'`^'. er, a previous ^?:;, ;^..^iQC'E
'sFoi nine months and that before living at that =:Qcatiib"', she had ;:ve'd at a different
location with her grandmother for some mo.rs'ths. NIs. Harrison ^ ^po; ^^^ that she wasborn and raised in the Dayton area.
^^^^^y Hastory I
^ey4 ^hel^. asked^'0'^ about her parents, lir ...^"+! s. S"`^^`%^' ^ ^"^;..d ..t^C.i^. ,`^.`.c f.C':S e :^'`,, °Z ez sdf ir ^'l^,.^i 9 1vv`^° stated r in ° ^...+'c.,:^^'
?ha$ her mother lives in t the Dayton area. She reported thal her priQa ;s" s dR".fQmQd whQ',"'s
ahP, was a ChilCi, but that she does not i€3Qw the Yea;aos, ': }`•`;e dl^N:!"i:e_ Fo?3s,rw!;"3g the
divorce, '^ r ar^"!;;Q^'? was in the.`sc;,euEQQ^p of sle', ;?"y, a„^: and st^s's"^a- had.5s.^a., V^v".^..^^ :J:, r.. some
QQe't(?.Qt with her noncustodial fal:heE•, bu' ,,h.at it was jo: ie-uxar. She s+csttQ; that her
mother rer nareieU wtl !.en, Mi..^.>. HS.i1i r£so,waiJ ani w?uu°t @, VvrtFen Chskl¢,.,.A. xais, i viaa4r`lshi,J^,r'
bQtNQQn her biological ^,,',areit}s whQn t"?e4' were to gether, she s e.:^^,'^ th,.,' they did 's'1Qt
`n h.'ux pase-ItS dur i ngget along. She c'?a"'s.,'Q.E^ that there was ,^" .QiiiQstE;.; ti;iok; oc^..' bQ ,v%e.
her childhood years.
At that pQ=ntin the interview, Ms, Harrison stated thaf .:he did inQt believe that any of thatinformation wouid have anything hQ do with her cQrn;:,e-ten:y to stand trial and declinedto proceed Wl'Lh the clinical interview. She ais:' added that "a"?t' S`a,^,e t=,i'so,uney General's
Office had `Qlr.,? her ?.''^a¢ M'Q ^,r'sx' +r,.^^ ? ^'t^ °V, v^(^..,Qe^,?.'^,9c..^i.3 ^^e:t!;`^ ^ Ft^ `'^' f e ^.^,°^ a^^^s^^.; r\r ^% order fo r ^ ana that3 tl s
Q\ialR°ats0o! of her CQ^pe'QV^iv` to saaf1.Q i;'FGi. 1 3f^s, s3 ; Csi ;F ^:Q,'`.^' '`wa`^; tihe was :';?` `f,dilsing
COMPETENCY TO STAND TMALSamantha M. HarrisonPage 3
^1AL
^-^;._.,^
to take the psych c,og ica l test tlh.at is ^ou°,+nei^ ^dminxste; ed , , fioFe::;^^c afuat;ons ;fiheMinnesota Mi,3ltepisaS€c Pe, so6°a?IT: 4 i`3ventos"y-2j.
COLLATERAL €^^^^MA^ ^^^
^,n?C°^sfi^,3a^^or's Reports
The same investigator an°sEesilgatev the current criminai case and the Fai"gatpons of child
abuse by lMunuhauaei: by Proxy in'vo€tf^;g obtaining med;CaE pT°oc :?^i:rea and medical
equipment by reporting sympforns of mediuaE p^^i^lem^ (which later We„e shown byi»EedicaE kes?s to not e?'ist). As a. resu5 of 'h;: ch:^^ abuse a°ie <;r,^'rns ^;z:e hiid Gn V41es"e
3 hom e ^'' P6^^^^^^ :' ^^ r care. The is ^a°es i^, ye`3df„^^ of thr^ i^^dei^Ww f d^^^^.5 from 1^^ii s^i^^ and have ^^^; : '^'+; .
offense indicated ap*scat;on ^`or benefits with no report c.,f':'rie f.,a'.her a ;-i;,ome - althoughthe parents had a J^oip^ bank account.
Consult With Attorney
Bobby Joe ^..''.ox, defense ci unsei, was consulted br'eli,' via, te?ep`';o:-e. He indicated
^,+s. t a^,^'ci.^1^:!;s J. ' ^.r^ G. i"^that Ms. Harrison liaz a hsMtoS"v of c°°^'^'^"`^l`s°^,'S',: i3"i t +.a 4 ° '^'^e1 t" J'..^L t^i'^i r` ^. bo "i in the
p('e,",er;t cas-^.-^ and i:n a pre`®ivl;s case d#R,s:)M;n^'up,. he^ d.:^h?sdren. F=e ha; eXpla3n:°'d zhe
purpose and process of a co;-r;p^^ency IL'o stand tria: pva!±a`:on and ts;.e reason that theraS'^e.^i'iSr^^4; '•^1d'^n ^i`^.e previouss5`ud^e ordered €t and Ms. Hariis'L°ii3 'v.'6'a: very hG;9^fl£?. He i^
attorneys. The second aztanney v4Fas apeempti,jg t1o discuss wi?l-^ Ms. ^-Earrison a pleabargain ^^^^^d by the Prosecutor -s wh9ch g,jaYa: ^^eed Pr^^aVor ^ and Ms. Harriso;^threate4^ed to sue him so he withdrew irom t€`^e case. T '.'e ti"s} a''ztemptev to
e,;pla;r, to 11-5er about an ofFer of Diversion ^ a-id Ms. Har: ;, tr,^siste^- on f a ^ria;. M.r. C.ox
sent a mi::t9()C; ^o the eXaF"i'?Enef' ''t'{ ia^ s11€s. ,--lat"i"3son had »5weg' ai°';; ^. ^a. -I thE,-' mot1on,
she accused ^,he (-'oui^ olf abuse of discretion because the judge ordered the
competency ev^luatiC'srn over IMa. ^'ca"'?uC;^n's, "ob,€ecvoz;.,, ih,";, '`^ros^'^`^,uu.^o''3 of supplying
<<a"su.^'a^ ^e i37po4'r'?aE^^"^,^ ,^ a'b"
^:'-^.. ^'i.fae he did not exercise ;i.a^; «.z'd the f^ef::C"i .i8JE'^, +^
attorneys of ineffective ass;stan; e of coumses (^^^ausc- 'the,: have not !;stened to hererpianatioris),
g^^^ ^ ^^ STATUS ^^^ANUNATr.ON
Ms. Harrison was a small, slender Caucasian female d"'^^^^d neatly in : asuaI clothing.
She was accompanied by a hafn'ssed German Shep€";ef^ ^er^f§^^ dog. 110s. Harrison
'In$G;racts d woth the exai"nEi ie'' in a suspicious, guarded ?"nar4ner uos itr'JiaeC$ 'Lh°
process of the evasi.cs'L€on by refusing "4o i:3ar-icipa"P ir, cOmmon piou^^^"'u"e:;a. The ^,^,YP9'a^^
effect was one of Qbstrd.dctio"Bism. She a,.stifiyd her 1bsti"Saw^tPo?:"1isi",''` u . ta^ii'.g ',.;?at ih^.'
.^t'corney General's office toFd her that such procedures (C,lir;:ca^nte;view andpsychol+?gi:a0 testing) were "no, necessary bo d8d;+.^.'m.n-e coif.putE;nGy ta stand trial."
^^^^^^^CY TO STAND 3^^ALSamantha M. ^^rnsodPage 4
V^ Ec ... , -, . . . , . . ..e Cl/y^
.... ffl-.
s^,^s. Harrison ap^;eared to be oriented, "i..!: ^ei awa r eness of ^;eC .e° rent si 7ua^ic^^;Cls^ p yY ._ `ud w^ ^ be distorted ^^'.l/'Y her ^e,^^y^ ^ }`'"' '^'^'^• She •,^!^,, ^a.^i ^, r ti.'^.3J^ `it9.F'%5 ^''4r6 lz:'•^i.J'r/R..'t1^^ N^i °^9
procedures that she uei"^•ao:`iaiEy dwemed necessary. S-: o,ror)^; ta'y^, contact and
displayed average activity le ue?. She appeared preoc.;;: ^.: :°.°?h vsew that she isbeing treated unfairly and that her ^^ghts are be=ng ;asoiate.-'. She app^^a;°ed to be unableto take ai NC?she8''s view in order to ,r deistsao?d the actions a" $ i e s !'son ; of her att orney
and the judge.
Although Ms. Harrison's view of Ehe current situation was di t^^^ed by her
sUsp'c9okisness, she expressed he, :'+.°k;?E;aN€-As s"n a ^o,^icaf, cow+^leni m40n"'"^r for the most
,t,^,art. There did not appear 'io be a s0i°i"?a! ':is;.:+ugh?` aa.so,,-;s t(„ e f.ius^':tns} or ., ",^`^3ssl
do.1VN tA43 i.eiA t! 1'4i5.l,gi :^4 pr"ali^'^Gsw. E^1 tS./kg; 89^ lf^+.ln°."•t 3!, ?i Y som e i,^^i . , e e3ss 'CP"XS.^ji.i odd ^ da8h. L1./4L §^s^.
er"'dp^oylng common p>m bedur^^ pr3ct?ce:, However , sil%c .i d.iu.qht C,.o? sa";"'^t ^,%k'as not
noted.
Mood appeared to be even and contm°'^d w;th ;r,s^^iv anxious affec' . -3.yed. T herewas no observation or 6-^por 6 of qmssF'w dEs?orte^.^. o^`;rceps, ri
ha9pucinateons).
Met;^or4 funcicons <^',G'uk^^ not be asses:sed, since Mls. Harr',.aori istioi,:Bd-1 i?--} participate in an
interview about he$ ^^^^^^^ound.
intellectual functioning was estirric:tei - b^'sed of s -c.,nis., .d obiv;"rat. ios"s of a^'`^^tral-t
thinking and manner oi +ferbai c£'im?'?r#uniCaS's^o4i - to be iC3the aveiaC,... :ange.
Judgment appears to be impaired by i'v1s. ? :a`s ' Svn 'a SU5QK.,s0US.ness and ''.:"iies that she
is being treated unfairly.
Mental Status Summar;l^
Present meE 6tr l status e'a" Bi3 3a4.so3 was ,C;;:oE c;::l^'i' ;i^ sr"a'ti ca € a ext c^i information was
s.^'3rss&ng d^'^'.'^.' to Ms. Harrison's ?"^l'usa' to fully cooperate we:s? the evaiua:`on". Thus, a
diagnostic formulation c;ou-Id not be :madle.
COMPETENCY ^^^^^^^^^ INTERV^Eu^^
Comprehension of Charges and Poss^^le, ^^^aREes
Ms. Harrison was abie to state the cha3 ae aga:nst ; s ;r as Jv FG au.d. A
feiony of the fifth de^"acee ;" VVhe?i asked as.;-oi,;t the 4s e:;:i'ce b^.'tAnre':'" a. f"^^od"'?i an^'' a
h"^ds §°>demeanoa , ^+fkS. Harrison ^u^,"..^ teu tha tc the differen ce r' is in +''and "`^, thedegree, i s. he
sentencing. She stated that $^lori3es u'oui."`,+. carry a. sPnteF,ce of Mjpriso„ment and the
sentence fnY a misdemeanor would be "a ^esser degree „
^°,^^^^PE9 ^^CY TO SIFAN^ ^RIIA:^^^^^^^^^^a M.Page 5 <
` ° ^ ^,.^^ of the^ charge ' " ^'f ;i^ inhere nt EsFaP'an .^^ 1^s;, asked about the ^E^^^iEiC^ ^ i?^ c "ii^a ; E^ •r^ ^i"^'.E. ^r€ ^:^^"S2f3n, Ms.
Harrison rc^^or-ted that the aCGusaEioc" is that st'.c obt?;n,,etii benefits io^rr her and her
child^^^ from Montgomery ^OUn*v Job and Family Serv^:(,-es by ^^^eptici-i, "A°her, askedwhy she was charged W3^^ the offense, Ms. ^^arr'sson. Ent:iaisy stated 'a'ai her attorney has
not explained anythi'ig about the case t'aa her. Hoi{:aevei, whe7^. -ior her
undes"standing of the current cs 9. -'1.s"ce, Ms. Harrison ^ ep;,e^.,^.`s: B'^^.cawse saying the
kids' fathEMs- flv®";; with. me when I app;'^ed for the ^enya^ts-.
.^^`::^" asked what c'^9,,ld happen if ^;s1.^.^. . convicted of :°?s-„ ,N"i^^i"g^;, . , a°s'^so 5t^^^^ a
that she has already had consequences , s;:s^e- - as scon as a warrant for he: arrestwas issued ^ the polic; department where she was work;n, ^ed he.M. ^zhe also add^^that if convicted of the charge, she '.rvo'S.'id n^.? €Ui3ger be able I; be a a::°?EiC;e off;4;er and
a conviction for the charge, Ms. H.a''c"€son said there cou''d '?e fines and ;ai^ ^ensei"€Ce,
but she was faot aware of the length of ,^.. p:'ssib@C, ;a!^ ^en`es;cE', She aiso ti'~^ted: "D°.,,',£.?
to ^bama's legislation, I wcauldn'k be ;^^^^^^--." 'V^i Een asked aboi 3; the meaning of a
Suspended Sentence, Ms. Harrison repfled: I'^ entai^; PrC) ;at:^v€°e. They suspend the
sentence in lieU of Probation. if you do uo"'P°thii;g el;.e. 's'3ey caE`' apply th,,e s°,,"ze'rce,;
^,., said:When asked for am exp5anaf.9e?i"G oi Viu concept of Pt'ob" i"€^. ^i;.; ^^;"; s^3rs:
have to be 2cco4antab1e "t'^'°i the Court and the laws. if you u;o `'s seV can, come
back and you wQuhLn be f^'^,ced wrEth the suspended senf^.rce "
^omprehe>^^^^^ of Various Possible ^^^^s
Ms. Harrison was able to s;l,tir.Eabn the Q=ffe;°e?'?ce bEa•?:wce;? .. G,..';E^'° .^ x: Not GuE?';.y1 plea.
Her ^.'XplG',i"+,a}iGi's of a pyer': of No C-or, l y '^ st 'M n L^p i°-s '•,$ m is gt.;EIE.. 3^lCi,"^r^' f Nor
are t19^ s ^ s
s.e"il {,'a. ,A Ar °U ' e ^li?i$^':G toA ,,,^y
s:,' r''^^-,^' gives+w you ^13.s,.^".. you're v not ^^ 3 ,.^`u^;^.14 E:E d t,^t%^
''^^.u?;.^^? of °?`^a^^s2^'^V,16o^°." ^%4I^t^'€? asked to ^x;^3aEs^ the i+eck"!€?.^ of a plea G ` "^^ol G^3r'''^, by
Ms. Harrison .Sa€d: "It rneai"HS it's a ty.,^"'ie of defense - by s'ea so? i of Msa;'s?;y." 101hen asked
to explain the tei m "bC?^an?ty " Ms. HaY"'si,Yi r .. 'a€d: `6ac mua"'sa ^,t^e Ce^elnd.a''C s^ incapafJ9e of
standSng trial rjr of c;ompi^er,end;ng the sit;.;ation."
When asked aboua hier €; yiei eded P!ea, Ms. Harrison waz, abR':., to s 1.;, "^ s^ Ds°ea. T'Ue?^ she
^'y
^ e^'^ sJJu^ .^
'*, a E E' e to E gX +.^''sl a;E^ ^^ i"'^` i i '.^.h^`. to °^':^ (^.ai ^^4E^ to enter and ^i ^E'^ 1^ ;^^«" c^i fa? c^ ^ +^6a•',31".^,F° E °.' io" the
intended plea. °AfheiE asked if her at±orrie" agrees 'flzEV;^^ her p6ea, -she rep';ied "?'ve notspoken 'C rn,y at'^oa n^,^ ^2'", 0 r°^^°,.3 ai'.r ^` "_ ' V'^C Pe s f3s re+..^^. .. .. ; ; b and her :;attoa ney have
d€s< assa d any other E ^ea, AAs. Hsx: ,' on srt es . ` 1-ie rse; • m:9 be ^^:, ,,, ^ cic into
court. He haan't- met with me ;sukside of ;'°,. 'ur`f:. He hasn 't Ki:ed an ;! mo4:uns. ? have
asked h im ,a i^s a nd for a ^ ,s;1 a^,:'r"e of ^ ,^ ^, C n ^ is^a"7^ to file a B ill of Pa rt i cu l a rs ^^^:^ s^w^.^- the ^^'^4being unreasonable or biased. a'i^^^e are seve ra^ i71o':€o^s ,.:a` ° , e wai",ted him to file,
but they're at home."
^^^^^PE^^^^^Y TO SRANID THA'..^^^^^^h"a M. ^arrisor:.,Page 6
T:.::...
When asked if she ^^^F^, aware of what coN?µh„^pp;n .fth>; Judge w^u,., find a ^^^eridantto be Not Gui^^^ by Reason of ^i3san?ty. Ms. Harrison stated that she has stud i ed ih^ law
;nt^,"^°i ^'r.tie a"i.tfii{{e's uus:ody &or Po s sqbFe ^d ^^p^P L^ ^:^6.^ '^^ a s9`'e?lt^ii
Wi i^^ ^^lked about the concept of a `=';ea Bai`gaiP :'vI,:. Hai: ^. ^; ;'"' define - ,, ^'-i -^": ,£^s Barg ai nu 7et^^ x,: i that the ^, offers^^ ^'^'v°.w^^'^^ ^. .^ ^) s^ p s;e ^,3..:f a ^sr^?i A ^..,d ^'i^^ . i^ i'^.'^^• ih., R z^"`Fas ^^.^ r''i"3"'^ '''.,.^^,' P^'^ or ^s^^t'^k;ed°i',^
e;^?stds::( ^:^,^°uid enter a ^^94;'^ )! ^''u,. .L^'r,; J She6nSZead of a maximum s. .,^sentence. ^ ','^k^
added: "Ther'ra not offering ^.o expunge r'` ^;: 4"u.,^.fd, ^,"'on't i"eme` n u'i the " ^^. r tha`F, ' f'^s" te
p0ose4.katof made. BU"" ;"aidY? s: do ?t a3,; ha"+le -.'^.-`./idenf.,,, that 9 dP'- i,^? ., .;c, ?a, so "''?"i not
going to accept a PEea BaYgain,,.
CE:^^prehenslon of the Ada^er^ar s^ PD,f?icess
Ms. Har'oison i'epi.i'lted i."'Eai ther-- was a .'<r`JS'^ran$ fo9 her aTr°s$ ...ww;t:d ,.^ir, 4i29r'14.
n rs °'a ^-'.,,,^'r^ 'r.' ' -..'` ^' ^rih, i.«^°::,d Y a^;b <^ ^€^^^ she ^ ^ c ^ ^^^d r had not ^.C^ s ., ^^ G! i, .. .^ ^ ;^'. ? ^& ^1 f ^ ^ ' a-L she
en sh.`. w• .D her Chief^G E E6Pylv JtS.BViA L the w:...?t rCld ps, uui. B;.Ebcu'. l YLehdid 4 3o pti
of '^^^i^c who "^^^^ her that she was S^^ '^1 :a'1k.,; 'sio.. ^ei`: ^?e: 'if;^;"iv and o€^i'}? iii1.a^'
she wo°;.i:d i'eceive "u ^ett::". She stated ^u'., .a did ge«. a :e%fei' from^°'"_ , ^ :; ^'f''P_s'^.'` ah^r'1s a
"^5Court y
after she was fired. The letter i..dica$a,i tr¢a : she had i"zo',; appeared for a court date and
as there oQu ^ ^ be a `eJ^ '^ ^ s^ i^ . She ss.^,.e, 'if t,^,M G she .C;gg'"+..ed .stv^i.., ^,^sbn'^^o"i^Pey'
Couzisy system and Pourid a warran,. ;';cco. d,na to k1s. she ro a€ied C=ey k'sOffice and ;f1fa5 told that she ccf €4C appear t 'u4 . She .; . . ; i t^?at ^Eti; went to Judge
^'Co€;nell's courti°oo:^ and said that s:-!e . . ^i^'/ to ^ ^ r f° ':,a; ^t }^'° . d tta,,.,'r'fn a fs'^i'^ t^:' +u3..9F ^,, ^^'.+ .t...^.k'^..1 ^' .
Harrison, this occurred on 5/5/14. She u4 K:^r SN'?e, was `°booKed M. az Frd booked out"and was given an OR bond.
According to Ms. Harrison, when first . aLoYi'1e`+,' 4c, E,'k . -c:,'nC} out t'^"'''sa'.
X '^'' ^r ^' '^',^-M {; Not ' tt^^ and $'^es t'^^ to -ri, P .3ia ff ^'' ^` - e^^€^ had p l ed ^^^^in# ^r^^s ^,. go ^e; .^., ^ ^,.,?.,; ; ¢^°^ ^^; ^ s ,-.:^^ k^ ^^^; F^ ^M ^ r^t6 ^s'%.ds. %.^a, ,st:^. s .'es: -'d wi`ii^t t:l?e i...^Cius'.'^the ^se, beccause t^'?a atb^''r^'i^9^^ e^ ^ ;;doe^Y^``^,.at f" „ ' ?;3'0,^"." s ^^,
"+.. i', a second '^ .i'^i^! i ^ the i:. ^' :^a'"i^' a;. ^`17',.!'v+^Y^e:^, 7,'' ca , ^`^i"ric a: also^ii^b.i^1yi^ .a^'^ „F^ ^: ^ ' ^:^.' ^.i,, F_.^6 has
removed himsels,ror;i'^^^ case an^ she ha> a .h, ; a..ornt.:y, ^^bby .;c: Cox. Ho'YrreveP° >
she ss:ate£^ ^^at :re has "fi$; G'i. a `rru`'oc i ;; o e
'sNhei4 a5^^d. how many times she has met 4•1,^.i : ef pae`bc:n'; atto,`."e°f s`he stated 'tha¢
she hi:as 31ad a telephone cC94"dv:'r;aa`oi~i ^iim as'°'sG e?as r',.e1 w'.rt .s;r whiF'n st1e haa
gone to court. °VViieda asked how i ;f?g he hc3.s, uec'F3;,, her ^^to6'n^esl, P'.:,.. Harrison stated
ihei'Fsh:V does noP, i"eCa^a how long 'l..i`'sa;^ been fai"sd her notes vtl^';s^^: F.'l ;^so ti-^.
Ms. Harrison was able to P;"o4'ide ?.icv'.,Js ".:^.c:r^ ,^^., ;-^;9i° ^ `" i3^. ^ ^'^'' roles "^;1 ; .,^^.i^iK°i^J.s^'*., 9, s .!",? functions of
Defe nse Atiorney, Judge, ^, r^,}9^c,"+;'.m "^^ the F'.^ r^ . ;^ ^`T was ..xi,. ,. ^ ... ^a^ '^^...f exp la i n thec.^',.''^' ^^b^^, ^ ^f: ., .^.^^ ^ ,,t,purpose of sa ti-'sal and w^.s able to `;aieaci'G+N:e si,cc S.:GtiV` What b ckPpess at ;t i%:sl.
C0^PETENCY TO STAND TMAa^^^aretlia FA. HarrisonFtge 7
^ ..,
7 'z^'"hen asked if there woudd b'^.' any wfli. eeises aga.r:st i'ie!, Harrison saad: "May:;+e thede's`,eu'c'.ve." ViffaeE^ asked what, she thinks the d£ ee.r';9!.re ! €v it say R ' "-.Fs te' eif :or§4'- sh^',,^r'a^ C}°^r^ : `^^ have c, ^ of She then.a€ ,€^'. 94riz^,:^. f €R^^^^?'^ seen any ^: ^. -,^ E<''.,^t;C9id^;. ^^ he"` ''^d that sheJ ,. .
has .`'a'ven a por`ct: s"`-p^s^,oi:. 'wh"scis referenced her ' fo; .,i''Nb a^.2and ^er^ i ^'.' `'.>?o9
benehts for 2011 to 201Z ShEt Wso added that .i,°'. ^ ^ ^^: ^sC. i,.°" a. ^,:i.^.#,^. ? re1.: i. c'` "..r! ! a^r 4Sst:7ren'ta
case with CSB." t1 :%hp"r asked w#"Eti.s she , iyht AonE her attorney tc MaA as a w€tI'^es`.a oni
her behalf, Ms. Hara €^on said: I don't ^^ow..,
Ms. Ha€"'$sCr, was aware tat she could ?"'sot. be i„:C?mpeR;':;^ to ans'tPPe" quesi.iwns at her
own trial because of the Fifth Am^^^^^nt She a'so, =;aas a'o?ar^ ^^nat !yang under oathconstitutes the crime of Pee il.€ty. ,rVhen a?led whaf, w'^'.. v,' ouicl dio if she thought one of
the other witnesses %ms i;'°k 2g or making a 9"s"Yl.."g':ake in their testimony, € e",,,^,^^a ,^o ^? .a^^ was^as
(1° would convey it to the attorR:e;'.'
lMs. Ha."; Eson was able to g ive an r'3ccu; „ t: aepla..,"' i`scn y'f ;Ne concept , f
to Elaa 8d T€"Faa° and was We to spec:uiate as to m..at t .,u,.. ;? ..nce CMLP.#u . endi:.a a ^;., ^ ^';^^ ^"^, ^^ ^.
to be ft"1GoN•mpw'te'4a'. 'o stand triai. lB^ acJdto€ , she a! C,,:;`::;3re^1 stated tha t d,?e j5..:&" ge could
a person to a "."Y?, f°'^$^^ F^ %.:osend ^^ ^i'^., ^a ""`v t ^" '+s":Ci ^^ '^ r .s f frv' `3^^^... ^'1 t o {`. be
3^a R^;t'.?; q'€:^^
pef^;^r;s a
ss^^^ trial.
3Sr^'^'^ eR ,^v asked ^ she ha s ^ ever a^.vY 9 Pe3°B ^:•...^^»¢^ }_i e L,' €:rB ^^ r a,a^ ^^f ^, '"â, a, ^srsi'^ ^^ s4er.:^^^ ^^ d that she€ €^9 i R ^ / ^^n^ ;.^r ^"., et^ i . ;. ^:_ ^`,e
was a federal employee in a G.h'^° past c.nG'' was ':`+Z3'i;;,^ted :^' ';1z to 7 years ago ,r..,'k €o" to
^et;.ed'i,,.. the iob. She aus: stated that ah: ei i.es eu the Po°€*"e A°:adep" 1f .n 2000 and was
evW:,°ed°d as part of the application. Add€'.'fo: ia.€jr`, Pv's. - 3 ;,rr;s^.'°; sxa<;eC,,,at she had a
u^^^^^^ogta€ evW^abmi about 9 years auo ddF fng 7, 7 - ^endencj, cF arvth tier `5-^'?`e+r24^r'6l3SA i7V i. R.dC.i'a. stated that she does r6'4 L ^em4s1: En.'er . 5y- 3?ng .,H6-- w u,..ti .%t evWuabL'sn.
She then s stated that the sheri^^^^ off; ;e has tr ;e report the e'iak^at"?n which was
.,o€^^^^^^^ 9 years ago. She s ,bed that =rhe Chi`s.^^en SeC;.r Fwar„ „en-. the repc;^„s^^^^eHy" to D^^^ct^^e Ka&Gaq who had younger c€:dren
^ ^, ^ i-' ^and ads+'^ 4^;^' s?o was €i"'°^t?.^a^^s''^c^.€E"?; ^:,^`^e .>,.?^^±€'^^r§; c^^`., ag^.^.^^.. her. ."hwn asb,^iedl how she
^k^ievv that Dexects5,ie Ke;?aP $^aci the r^^^^rt s€:e said xha, he made that s.ata€^^enn: on thewlbn n.^.o'is s6£slh.d,
Relationship w.^,"i Attorney ^Abi;ity ip C^ wn^ell,,
During the B^'^'°sent el^c l;..ic^f€',.^, , ^^;'.s. F-,a ^. °°iis^'.i? ^i^:3m^:a^is^c^ v'C,i^ rE^.. ^ k^ E.".5^, express `"^6'^ ^
,s Rg' a,^{6
verbally in an effen%^€°^fe manner. She 'u'41v3, -^',^e to<-. 6 „^'-^a€o 3^^?^'use^.,, ^nsfocused ^";.: was able^'''4 >.^,r ^ ^ o
con,cent;a6c on th e ips o" ^ ti^.3n at e .c, -^s.t e; :a`ci al a ^. i ?^'we ^?.F- J^^^'^^r; i^.,. ,^ ehU"'',ld€S `^^.!', a^ ^ ^ : ~^ ior was
appr^pMate.
However, during the present evalua t ion, ^',,/i.;, Hat"s€s:n res:>i:ted to engage in ;^r€°oc^.'t.^^'Ei"?s
which a3''^,°' common to any psa1C'hr ogica, evaluai;on, A Cibn€ca^ lrn#:ed°'",e'vv (in oi de€° to
provide background P^formalt€om; and p:ayclr-.oRog:cal testing (to ;myi^ de :,3fo'r, iatifan about^; clear :^ ., ^.^pr.ych;^^o&al aurictto^."^€^;;a. She ^.' ..,^^ ts.^',^ide;^ ^. it'n ^;,.x^.,'^.nr e "'^ €:^ .^ f ",^-^ e rea,^ c^ra ^'
^OM^^ ^^^^ TO STAND TRJALSamantha M. ^arrisonPage 8
that the ex-:mirer needed 14he :;;T^ra..to, N,^^at would be prus?d^d "by ;;Fod,edures)in order to render an opinion "n 1ega„";3 %o competency to stand 4 :,. €`"ov4ev;',€', .'he
i4 ststed that 3 ^ A^^r y ^ s '^^ e r^ ,A e r ?^s^ : , f r° re ?:^s e^ 4^^..^^^ ^.^a^s ^a'^' ^ , ^^, ^ ^ 's'^. ^;^ ^ a^. not d 2^,cessat yto d;lerm?ne competency to stand tr;aE,'
Ms. Harrison's reactions to attorneys who have represented her at various points in 'Lhpcurrrtint case (as described by her current ar.`{or ney; P uv-= been 6 qu r w u,usuar and evenseif-defeating, (Le. refus;ng D3lpers;on, and ahreatenano to sue h^ atto;ney whopresented her with the Prosecutor's PiAe'v2 Bargain bdffp9 of "qF.a:Jnveud PrSJ2.{ab64FiC."l!
Threatening to sue the attorney who presented laer w,t;, a v+rr'^ten stae^.:";^en., regardingthe offered Plea Barga:n, appears to be Mf: <^^^^^-,na' M,500;nse. ..,in:;: attor;Se^J ^ offeradvice and
* a ^..
;4^:^ ^ ;r has .i^•^^^^_.^ -.-^' Y^'^ ..`^i ^`",..A ^t•^" 3eY i. 3tl s. ? ^.r? cs^.a ^ ^ ' to c 4..^u ,s;e. ^^^^;^ ..d ith hostilitywhen he e,Y 4aI'9^,'i^ to °s?f;r e^:essits! of ci s"i'i°^'"1 y^:g `^;1^'st+^''the ^ : ^.:§^ ^ "^ for the^ the i° ^ ^i ^ ^ ^ , a,^r ,^r ^compete€^c^p evaluation.
SUMMARY AND DISCUSSiON
Present ^^^luatiQr.. i9-id6uates that N11s. Harrison appears :o regard commo n, reasonable-rprocedures em?lUyeC a f pE ose5si` ; ^^ls !i:vv ^jed in ti^i^. a; i€l ?? !j1?i great
o cio ' lac e s GIF.p : r i^^a=P'f ^f^s a ti3 i.'ti .^ ^' ^3se sfr' . ^ f ; ^ ^ ,- g. v ^ ^ "`.^^^^7 4^ and ""Et. ;'+p t^sarrf^ - ^ ^,r^;^ ^l 'niuaeher in some way. As a. result, she refuses to cooperate. T .f•a`, he r and needto protect herself °,nhib;' professicna.°;^ ^rors' ^s.^^i; eXcc.^ ing 4.";ei^ fu"'.c`...o€ : r,, 'the process,which has ground to a halt.
: ^ the cas^,. ca. ^case of `h-C^ c^9 r ^^'^'"'t c ^'?^,mp^.,^^^. f`^r{"^'^"6"',^yf ao s '.a, r" ^ ^sr ' r i ::,zF'G ej a l7ir. r t ,.; a,r soy^;^ . ..,, :^ ^ ^^ ,^ `^ ..^ h asobstructionistic f if'^f is f°- ,^'.^ n, `"'is£^.n ^. '^!eti^'. f'a3'..' :at t.:"f^ of behavior€^^v f which ^+i thatexhibited obseru .€'rt'oni.^'.t.t^ 4.+
. S-sv<` s `i'T.`^ t and 1(" s ^ th e (^'^..f^.^ E t..A 0v. 4'e.^JI >^^btd^`i^ aA. .,.- ! .'k .t 5 9A+.+ . C. . ifl b.^^,
^ Y ^'f-:^ rr ^ ° ' beC? th e 6".,C^sen` Pvc°^Ei.%atis^^', sh^':F^ `^'J: s • some fa cto rs ti"9a^ ca me to (i,^, s i' - ^^d^"i„^`r c ouldin'Lerpreted as sian.^ of a ^enta'd.^^^^er - such as .av:^^; Pa post office box in a Itlownwhere she does not reside, i nsisting that he.; c?"9,,;d ,:as a de..^'sp"ste
medical evidence to the contd ary, implying that she was °:".ror rk;ng a s a ^ ^^ officer evenepilepsy^though sh^,. has a s-ensice O'o T, ^ (due to - a^.`or"C^s"°' told,q °^;ss-,e t.her
attorney), and reacting To reasonable expectations as ' V.ne}' vve!`e ne"u s.'"s.`s.;a. From the
standpoint of a psychologist, suo^h lf;;acao;v cannot be 'el3aao.tiy § , er;.,.etied without a
°vontei'+.f.^. (whi& is o8"oY9faed by a C't6n':e,..?l %iit°rvie':P+l) ::ind/o; w .no%..; ^rmaG'.3- p rovided
by resu lts of psVch^iogEcaf gestl +:^. Othe r c.,s°.^^^s" i rr;? .^r;^',4;^ "^^,% have
been s c deY3tIfie i;f theie i?a•,''F'. ^ees°"+. Pa. +,..s'inIC;ai s"i".'<..i"'a:'+ibf.
^.q,,^ r^'ra! f£"^y.+i 0. ^.^^ ° r^..^'^^'^' i r^nt ^'\fal~ric"$^:(°^°i, '£^ 1^..' undersigned e^,cai`4`?i: e°' e.^ p:c^ned to Ms. H arr.s s;'n how
sC?ps'9e of the ab. '.eVe-";"?en"tlQned factors cx)'<.dld reflect i.:;r^',^;"at^4?,.,. HowE:ve v^l;L1"1ouf further
context provided by C;inical :i^^^rv;ew and results a'f psrchosogioai te:;fi,^g, a diagnosticformulation r-oudd not b-, made. She was Pcov;dec„ a;; exp'anafio; of ^^e I^elevarce of adiagnosis aQ a competency to stand :a; evaluation. The e;am;ner a€:^ ^^^^essed to
COMPET ENCY TO STAND J €^^^ ^^^^^ni-ha M. ^^^^^^or,Foge 9
^^her the 6dE'a that the difference beibm^.'en her s^''^°;`!4' '^` i the ,^^, .^':°; ^ s^ ':a pi o^^e s wi °^5 cas.p:.
- .
te'+Pri of the situation forms *he bc ts of te question as.^^+^.-$ thei" C ;'?'"4p`a"c'.,^ r,a nc°y •
However, Ms. Harrison remained steadfas: in her relsa' to co^.;^pe;°a9`e fi:,;^y with^^^^^^api procedures for the ^^mphton of t&e compexano:'J to s ^ aia_aatzo'^;cr r^ ^.°'sf s`^.
°F"8 c,^f.ndE °.s^."''in, although no U`.eTsn,°s'.;`+fe diefg"`:os;s can be Ma"r?^.%'-^E : . - ^as^ ds.Y'g Ms. ;-^^'a; ='isoT^3';^.
psychapatric men tai status, it was ev„,."ynt thR'oug ; t ;"it,:i"acacso'; o.'ish i v's that she is 3'^o',,.. .^^^^3s.i^J^'l^yr' impc^i!"ed. Also -".,,..'itideC`dce from the ^.^^`pe;^;^a;^y ^.;ys"e.'-'^^[^g ^3,;rti?^'r„%'s.?:°i is ts'''^ Y , tha t
Harrison has both a faa:.ia± anc} a rational us^^^e rstandrng, of Ahi^ legas process inwhich she is involved.
Ii`4 at i"dtoR what was etdpnM1 toni the Sgese5"st eva€uaton 'an.'ca;^ that M& Ha, r?soi`; has notexhibited G?`?e capacity to work with a4'3 attorney in order to Ci;'VES°:3'Y) a defense cw Ea
resoiuption to the criminal charge. Vpdhat was not MhNf;d by the evak1at;;^n wasthe question of whekes due to a munta^ sxInMss she is . o`_, ap:ibse of with her
K^'..a^i^ a ? x ^ r `atoi^Z'ie°y' andfC3r is not $ U ;, ^ of s..z^^;;^.13.^a^ii g in the :e'^^„'" ^,^t '^ ,.;^.,^ ia s a `^''ecs`#'^ii^ ,su°W
manner.
^^^^^^N
On the basis of F s£,' ps"u:ser' tievc,.aua$9on' the offered 'ft ath:i i'°a
able degree of ^syvhologicas ^..'erl:ai;"t, :
1. Ms. Harrison p4esenty appears not to be a ` menluidlv a.Gg:vda^d ,nd^viduai, as^. 1specified in O.R.C. 2;^'5. .^7^i;;^^;;,^;
2. No definitive diagnostic sts: ^%;ern^'a '^t 'a v '^sY. ^':a^ s ^ .,ay. ' ,.3"^., made^'3^.r reg ardi ng ^< ^,^~p"^,^'sets^r 9 sv,>> as
r ee by O.R.C. 2945.3ea, ,);`..,
^^edi i;
3. Pre,^'aqG1tIV, Ms. Harrison is ! wpab^>' of :js^aG`ers"^G w&'g lt ^e "^"r•Y' w ad, s','rioi:isT?es5
5. Presently, Ms. Har^ison iias n. w exNbRed the ^apW6, to 'J^, 3 .i, k'^^^^ an attorney,but an opinion cannot be rendered regarding whether she is rl. , +. ^^^^aNe due to a^^^tt iNness.
6. PmE.'senty, an opinion cannot be rendered as to Ms. `'azi'is"'J:t'a capacity toparticipate I"? ^, M"'seai'6ing3'ui manne r in'i±iF' w'ega's pCc-G-£,-'„L.
COMPETENCY TO STAND ^PiALSamantha M. HaFrizonPage 10
in Gonclusion, b^Cai.B:F' Ms. Haids;n ef;.:;aed to paFtlcipar`;^ fuiiy ?s; tq`':^ evaiuation
process, . there can be no C?p.^,;:l'C^'^ Yek3;`.?3"e^ -° 't^^raQ „"ai,. a '^`^';^s^ti`rs ,r,^.' '4e degree ^'rif. . ,^?s^(chol,^tgi^:al ie^`ta3n'?; - as tio whether she does or tao3,s s'";; w , eet :n, Ohio Gaw to
be adjudicated as clsmpe'^en6 to stand "€.i";"^"'i,^.
&^^^J^^^9^E . ^ ,^ ,^ a^3 ^ a ^^,.^'°s.^^ a, ,. n.2^^xdx^,S^^^ ^:. ^.t'^tu^, .^..:^, t:.stl"#^^S^ix ^ 4i,aS:?aTl
fv^I''ral'^'' who i`'^^` curdenLLv 45 yra:.s of .i°l1s _xV tv^ par-r:X^?^^'3'te 't^3. this
°" 7sinc'^i' she is ^. f^ b ST'tJ^a ^i^A^r2^° ^ ^ 1 4^^spi6 Y 4'" of^l k.+ 1 :.` K''.^.g,. ^'1^'is .s
app^`.'ar.>°.nC.°e ar?,^''d, hygiene were a^lPK"oa^x'^.at^" v."..;^ ^ ^«ls. '^.si'aS.'^^ ;.s^,?a'P "'Er t,A:] y.`"%+-'',Jtv^ r.,eA9^ ,Y/ - Sa]eabCv p. iA-ry 0&Ad^ t
he ¢LS^A ofY yr1°hW od
our r3"it£:Tv:€ew, She rel9tx;.^.^. ?n stiTi a,iaa, and poli;.^ n"^'^ ,^. a
.'".':^'^^3 was able to^r
; `..^,ntaa ^
3"espe^'xd all i^^ip-st3t?T:?S; and 3h^e was abl^= to ;^e-,'-c^,t f"°eces :, a`ld: rviuh f::zan±y. MI30Ha^. -r4&un, rqrQrted, tlh.tt^ she has neY^^.^ ^, s ^'3+_.Ai s,,z i ^ ¢ ^ ^ ^^ _ v: S'!'Pils.^' l2 .fhi^1 ^' '3Itf^4 17 such as
dexiwsions, or thoi)^ f suicide , ' ^iC ^.^v^ra^ no^:^ry*^ J^ also ^ [^ af,^,soWe'Ra3S ^'o ;^.-ft J.;tancr z;er Thes^^f-,'s^dant ack..7Rowled,^ed, IuIUM she is .at'heA• depress^'', a.:d. s1he WIdYba:e. .h^^ To custody ofar'+^iu k^''L'_`ee a?'ouriQesF: Mm HsazshsoG a,s'4:1 b-IHUVG:s I+?3e fI'-Ut"1. ",'''uM^: formn ofPz..SD,»
refou1ng to wtn,ess s"„k'.,.JV.;e'i,.•h, b^-,ca'w3f„ f <^ n . of 3,^,,s'u";^- .r^sr. t'aa,^ tA f a, -.c^^ ^.^ '.'t< 5!^"3 ^'4-^^'^" Li'^. f ol' herAeraCa'^^..Edin-n. Ms. Flaw"r%5un :'"epcxE^d uhai bu
^;. aY7dr, ^a'l^,+Tk^, } '^T e .7. ;,.rf,.ck P y 5^^el^$'^.'d t^'' :3.eA
hosp.^^^izayto.^ as havi^g by^zi "not a pz.,nyc." IN4S. 3art-ison app°a-cs to 'u~r. oj' ^mt ..ea^^ averageintelligence, if not ioxnoYVh2bt 'SA "+»ei al G" ^gh r'. .^ a was not f3yp t2 ll^ X^,^^ r vssess-d , Wk^^^ ^^,,ked4 Y^
s.11v ^.^?mig^a she had be'^^ ho;SpRaia^ed ),.ciSr . e: e..a.rd .Asµ, c: Ya:;t7atio,. . i 'v. .iYI:,3.f.E JVdl. J^.Y^^:, N^ rr,T, p a Y p/ ^;
^hY.a^.^5^k3
ttTAI+..j'6.3dg^.' oed$r'r^,.'d a Qorn^etwZ;.4::y'' {4,^ st^.'d,n- d trial evah,>."''i.t<{`J':,k. The ''ErS£ `v°i.?e iUas^x't satisfactory." As
Social ^^^^ory, I%.s. Httrrison r^poo;^^^ that she ttivm bo;'a ixe D^^°on, ^`,^e Yf^^' ^hger ;•°lwf childrenR3''a her family oF.^or:.g"rs^ ti`^eF lvreM`°e.;; dls ,To;'^^,-d jI,2en she was 8 y'^?.:ti vx they ,,^^^5 : t,,^p^^'Y :^^
grarzdpxm.:2ts ^vs'^o 1'xolped ru^ her, 7vh;^^n qu .stion^ya aESow lvfls smted that herr *r.' y^,^father disciplined her hars-bly 9 and this was &;.^^ , d s av ^'^ b c,.9 z tTe. After 9 lik. n ^ ^'^i ^. ? o«r`^1'elt£i'',1d^%^
^^nisC}.3 reported that ^s`1- was :^^' Qa'.t:i.,o."`u'.z ,T f ^.3R?'ls.tis'.4',^"` ~^ Y.^. r ..Ps ^c f r's`1i 'Pts, ^. s ^.a,. ...
"'"..,.^ b ^^ii3{Bd
^onter around family vacairtonS. ra.s toz vvh?t :h.f.^ ;..:^^ tO -,;JhTng-e aivouk her c,oalildhood, iMs,H~rison wishes sh4 had s:^t more1^^ x „^T.Cl f ^.^. 3° ^ txse.. ° ^ ^, ^.^^; .'i^v •r'J . ^. ^ )d3+r++xr'^ ^,!?.ses ?a-,d dCIgs; Thedefendant vXxas, reas'".ed; ?rt the *a..''a:jptY.St fa.ti i rcriN o"«3'xo;?,tzyr ^^^axMt c rb as Word of
i azth,
^:^'^i^.rdl ^^g her ed^^.?da^„t^? 9 $ ^ t ,Ms. Harrison d" "?s.Dt ^ ^.,U i^3"vi N^'a^ ^rSi,^'^^ r ^ w r r;io> K ^ v1 +^ . ^ ^^^^^^^c^^ HighSchool iF?' 2 98"', She i^^.^.^p,'t'.rted that `:h` ,.,uxfe.`..:d ^;^DS:1 ^^v5!''.^,.h_E^. a:.a+^ '^aV'.s gi'uz'F` y in ^ :'3i3^,ft ^y *; d'i' ^ . b.^.K ;. p^P.. a.S.m.^,4 ^
^la,'.:ses ''ti^tti^.1 her 3^nioF` year. At flh,"',t ^I3,e vr'ts.7'C3iled iri a k'as. H°uF'ri5(3i1
jokin,glyT °^''^^es^''iri-b'^.°-d .n,^°r3elf as ha+/i.'.'t'`',' sba,- sa'r,'w'?a.. ^.;r?' 1^'^f:.;^'^ r - nn^, {.e ^ that 3i. .A c,.^ af4a i s'^4,°.^''.1
from, Srliczakr Commumsty Coilego, 0-he rep;r:e^: trsa^ she r^^y the of a 10achelor^sdeg=feo, pramaY'3lv coAAsa'.st;.ng of ;oi.^..^:'ties ::r? _ a^.^i^^'3., and s^°:^ ^_ ^.sse^i^,.^ ^u's cz^r. ° .^ ^^"' .^ et 1ncriminai justice ir^i 2006. Ms. R^' °riso:^ -mc o _rF^eX=oLfied that she a.rs in fae &a^^^^^Y ^'' y s )'u ^ ^library at thoU^iversity of Dayton.
^r
1^-1 ' 14 12; 3c FROM- ; -'23 ?0005/0Jo8 °s=-753
;.." tenms of ^^^^^ynnent, lAs, ]Harmisvn, a'qcosi^^ ^^^^ ^ p- has wrjr-k-ed in em,-^Dzce^^^-^ as ap{3r^kv+^- officer and ^.^.^bt^^ ^+' : She re^'^^'31rCd ^<Ni she p?e4;1z4'^5!^i ^d?'odk^"...^ ?^.^'^^.,^..L;'.^ s..:i r^?"n 7ik; °.^1aia^'3..dtf but
^ disGha:'gl^d ^,T'u:-- Lo y:3eI' 17,-armt Oa aTge. Mts. H.?tmii ; n Z;vpa.Led fiTa=; she o4r``JPs l3„l^a o;r3JFI
conSLsucw3oIk'^omap-..^' .ny, t'T..id Lb^ ^^lz-'s.^lT;p i r, s, 1"'iumSo i i%5%an%s to .'?"..ov':-' ,1u -sh"o "`epoi°'Ced
S?^,`,,r't y^r
0r , t, fr ^. r e^etkk'C3t Jhe has a 4ocat1on'L-,q r`.'^•.'`.. a 'S b^.^ i.a:. € .•. i£3a v^ =.^.'r ^^^ she ^^oyss MS,3'
: F ^ f^" w1`^aj-:I.S'oES. l'ekev to Lraib dr+,x°gs. T::-Iv .+,s d^f_!^.Ae.t^i r „•iy^u__C5t..C,.,.
coaAl.!erzidy^ UB.'N, Had?.isc^,^ ^G4^^%^ b^a.•r.^!. r r^'^^-,.^ ^, ^^;Trd^3^g .3 .ki' sA .:^a.. / 'a.vrx^_ Tz '4 4^ u ^f ^c^i.her? 2aL for Z3^^: of her ^io^S a.Cs: ^.ibt:n tL;.uL ^z ^^ =3. ^ ^^ ^s.Ta?l + r 3'^ 3^.;Cr 7^`3.c'. . 3
w,-,a"e taught to ?a?2°x'i by his m.,ofl'„v:i'.
Leg.ll Nkakwry; 11'49° rv:t'E t^.ssysi.ck?'i.
-n- 'aLo^'s ^^fi.-^. q?::es,;;,o^'F:^3^^ a.^'^Du ra ^u %v^ 9 c'v^ky-'^"^.,_,. ±`/^^. :^£a^.So a?_ z "§1 a"LS d L^3^L she has
a seizure disorder and also s^'Ys'-iers -fr:}l diabetes. S11.0 r°i ti...'`0 i,t,, 'i e^s!•+`%, r- °^ dog z. s^^d+^ 'i^. 4'J` x ^,. JZs;-.H og SY.no can
p^'b^;e$^J`^' "i^".^i?.^in she is F±s^.lrdti; to h^'e'^N a sci^:`t^'^. 3'f::^e ^x^.Y'i-ss^v'3? is ^.^a ^:^ ^a°S^^AU^^ ^^T^^^i&^.
Review of her chars ^. . ^
^?^ tiz f^...^'^^ Lbu; ;Y._u. 1"._ :^,v:3 a:'das .".'^:;; :""e;= %;:^edr=^al !'^z3.Ge^°^:u of^.^z "h.sa,!.'_.^.I:mPzoAna ^ pafP.2s°a1v:4.,'I3S, '^.' fsL; ° _^^% '^g °a.^e.r..r''r''p 1..1.,r_«" s y ° ."'^n-'^e?/' v'^"^ic' C},'.,. 2s%',9,
pro^.'^lvms and the local S;hi-We:''> ^,,-svt: :t^e.Y, ^;?e^.uc, ..` ^^.e a C 4.a`s, .i `^'^'l .^_ ^ ^^^^^:^i^. what shQ r^fe.^-e^. ¢^ as ^''^^^^sty{a^
PdS. ^Farr3.,,€'i7}sS cs..?u'l's-l of -ffeaL.mex?w .^i.,i: S."^'s^.t'. reV'4..'-0.^^'r Li:as`, She has r;,o4 ^xhib:a.y^'' ^rrs".o4.3„g symptoms
of ^^^'^"^^Ri ili3e+,u, Nt'erif's.e'.^..^5y Y^'E"+x^'^?i.^^vn* itr. z "" ...' .6'ir^^.^"'^,c^ ^3 .^eT' e "1 er^^.'r ^ -'^= ^, ^s, ^sz i ^. 'a, , 'E^. saZ^ has not
displ^.yed any ;^^sycax;^LS^: s^^p#o^^ss a..^d ^:he iv ^oj p^mcejv^Pd °> ^=^_j.T z' QT^.>;^, d ^, pT e;;seda.e^xio^+, r'.,,r'q Rather, ?`^ tiE:. 31^' x^ ^F .^i: ^ax.i%TS ...n ^ ^ri ,^^,s<," .4^^..^, f`i' f-'-a3. ^',5`+-^E r^^ , ; `^^7 ^s.".:rr , ^s^i^43^. . x 4 t, ^,,,e. s;^ch's'es aY
^'
/. v4+rcis+)3,wfdy ?YAt. %ona?^oy 9.l4soGdeE Os. .'L:o..LC.,-.'.li.b- DA.:1Of dv,., hA, . ...^.^dTh).5"SSihas aisc been
t -enp s^%Cei'Ied by Sosate z3Ee t^d^ets of . A ^1 :k:^as
11-1 0-' 14 12 36 FROM- T-223 P0008/0008 F-753
.^isc^r^^r. 1A: .^a^; .soa_ :^°'^ :a ^, PsNrc^aol ogist,to administer v ^ $ r ^i ^.:^'"i ^ .^.... C c•..t^.T.:4"f-,^ to ^^,•^'.'3. _:.L:n A^o-f
s°zw.Goyy an.^i°. pleads rny side of +'.,^v^',se. I ^.k^>d a :,4Ao^a+',^?° to ^^_,e ^^k^^. ° /'^C.+ ^'- ' y2
r± my1 the y^ ro+,.^.w ^4}.^J.^L`Y^
^9 ^"c^s, .c^'A^^''/4.n then `¢f.^l.fi^'wa
the
1t , ,'^v s `^ `u5. s.,'^^y'r x ^^,N fAs^"'.^'z . o&
c.4.^ec pro ^ r '5 ^ p^ °^'^Ga _:.. t 1 , ^,^ '6' Y d 1^z^ ^ ^+^.,.^ ^`or ^1`t° xV[S.Hairfso%'x ddP1nl.1fi^^'a t^^.' 'xrob,-' of .:ae Proq_^_-^.,asa.zg Asto_.ney ^:a`u GF^'',^ pr^,.?v,, ,. .,"^e ^'xd prove A^eg'SJi^"+w;^.sa She sta¢p'^. t^?h; the J: i^;" cti'.siuSa.s 'fo +^^r^3i : ..adew ._ *'.s^ '^ r 'vi,-'^ a ,A. ^^ : a ,v v, sr hfti, Ha d3o:kkcn.ew there aA e, ty^.^A^''i°dt''..&.Ay fw°-3it•J,. t.^is.,aviduFZU °vJn:. a .:ua`°+ ia:%'.&a :':r both :7ird`°:i and64rddda,Jn a jU'edg1SALfSt,•9 3a".3$^.^la .= ^ ^,l^.l.:si"lj^ a5wFb8:lew ^w^...k4, a ^'?'yk e 's v " , ^^~4 s.^A ,^5M i:7^. ^u^f., ^ ^•.: ia ^x,. t,: vr..^.ia.i' for the^ ^y e
S=y:ose^v'^i.ryr.i(3^Y or %.E;^ dkfd:^'^+^ %a She 7^s^..AadA^^t^',.^.4. n;'.:,i.]T ;v x:hQ
u;1de^'^aid5ri`y' of the I'-o Ci?ntiet.., -P c:i:a w °a'.d, J{ ...a ^noa. ^ ,ng to rp^^ad" gWl^a^^y o^
innooent. B,^.szoall..- ask the co^^:^. to decide svh:k x`4: ^S' ^ ^o,7i "a^^ ^m .^',^ ,. v+:^na^` cg;. to indicate t-haZ sheLind.^ti'I"stoCYd piev'id,'.Ftg fl^.^i' clorL?Sti iS bcs°.s:a adaa:ssson of the faots ::?th4 ,.sO; lyls, Har4'is5:31
yixe iNy1u't .^3'uiRy by R,F9aS'`Jr; `^..^.f :y;i ailteJ' P iew as "Yo.a. a? ^ m;.o' ri right Ms.nd 'gi t1he*Ldme of a+x.^'v ^°^,.«^i ^c^i.id1.S.x^-} ^.^^^A3^+^+^3's^ of ^ a .... _.+^^^^Vn ^' i^>°g.3, ^^s^ +'`°i3HaiTisd,.^. +'At^'+r. ,+;^ ^ ^-1 a ^. stated,
"Something 11-ie Pnoseuraor ^omes up MA4 ? to gx'te y o'u', s'at.%^+ e C/ sys,3^..'^s ,;' ^ s 4PP'a ^p 9^ak^ wFf
n.hl^d 4^'ih2^i^g^"i's, e a plea^ to it, ^ln4.^. 4^a^'l. +r.^''i ^I'a= '^ti+i a ';^ehd. ^ -"x ^
..
e'ss Ci:.3i^ _-,- 1a41v, m aa...:. E ^:Jxt the3:-i pm °.^r °a bded
a good .`r'xid^'fap ; 'v o1. 'wtil..of rv"^.'^,s+^iii... ^,' ". ^J:,x^v " s„ ,^`>, s y,^,A:f,>,] 7^, °'a;^.t.:v^nt ,/ls.^9^y^j Ma.s. ^., ,^r. '^°1 ,.^',^^•,!,.?^„y ^s._ bafvY?u'
°=1'Ihed ^^ you have t'^''+ '^^-.' piFn H a.6^'i a ^.1^ ^3 si+^;,v.o:..r, :"7 d^ u't'^ e. ^ i ti.rr ,r oc ^'^-^,R.^.: 5'^` E^.. .L ^,''r' y.,iP.y . . ^ ^ . . arve toit '^'^^',^ 9:w^
.^ostAktl.^..i^,tion_ Thej/ watch t b1P -yC3"t,e° ' _C4^'tJ^, to s . " _qk ,. ^.^. ..k^_^ ^ ? a^J "U n^ ^P._^ ., C:^.^3^"l^^sotibs ofpxobw^on= "
^i!3. Yh)zriSoi ^`^.^ows to be,eav, 'n a d r^a*^•s;^i 4^r4. •. a ^ .^J,FBE.^R'^v-* Y. ^1 . .d..+y^â L-^ '^^-,-,J e Li%'^T
-(^
mcU.^^^ ^. [
.SS is alB^^^:iYV
/e to^} 4 5 ^.uei^ry+
Spo'G^a.k rzk iCo-'Us°°t "Whi,^'.Z's KrS^aS^:.`t"'e ..^},S^x?^tis or ..?^.f'af:;i^ ?sai> to ..d^^x " ifs ^.'^^ ^ "C3i?rt 3",^+.4:^"?y. r. E`^S;i'a7'aC3^`3^1
^^eA.^. ok^feT^'a„ in °^.^...^Sla".1.^£, e^ iYis, ^^-a _,e?JCT^ Le''a'rr," aa Y s..II„e: 9.h.: i "4i r Qr, k^ 6i> ,:` ;3I.°.e fl^^.'^E. .^ .. ' } ^ a•^ •.^i'. x
thva?gA
^.i .^^3i' a ^'^:om e^.k ^•S"^ added, .wS^'T?3 ^ t4{^ y.JS'^.e to tell ^+ ; ^f 5 a .r l.y,,Ae ti9
^xy ., qyp21.`tF^4}riV speak
:^ ^^ ^^V[`^^^ ^ ^ ^tJ w ! ^1r ^yri&d`e
b y A a.
up NP^ ^,, ^ h4 h "Y^p for yotiw," ,^.^^5, .^"^^aten"k h. ,.;Nt.^'^^;`^.y^ to x:s^' ax^ft n.'^o,?^aeyl ^°ru, -,•,:sy .;w,,dgy wq;lG`'fi notallow ihiS, As ^'€•U'E{,,i.^ ^bcwe3 sxyv'". is g lan^.^.,,ng r 'a. b.^£' :^exi h;aa,S3;,g, Whenqwsfio.^ed do^^^ ^-, -wo? s; ^^enazk) rega€°dii;ka ;.^:" a..3cb^.F. :zx^sr^ ;^,^^d wf H ,^r x^ t; ,, S`z^tubd t.,^ °^ ,^. . ..,. ^^she is.A^3 planning file for W
;'^d"♦ >
<yqxy ^a'+.ISl.L^x^^`;,'^ ^
'^ -^41aa ^ , if vJi,llL '' r y 'J'^7^'r ^'^ to i:ik'b '^: `^:^S^S+/ w.i%" ^.^.^tNr $!^ se
hc-r 6:aree^. She ^^ew?fl.Qs,°'.t. t!'°ae most fa,bt rd.bl",t, fJ.if'('.v.'nex.. axw bc"i;wqg .(i, gtn3, it 's':u-au €.'.^^.^.^snai.v,id
has exhibited a"Ao o°^,'^^rt sdqnpi.f'"ns of no^ow:%s d,-,AAq wesC',
4
11-10-' 14 12; 37 E ROM- i 22„ P0007/0008 €--753
-mi'' ed S1hL''it rti'+n'^A^,`0, may f?-^:^i^^ b' .vvAa, 4`y'.irTetss.^Sg s^J°;9:.e x`.>..e-:.( t`s:31Aur'.''4^ p^i'^ ^ tM6,1:..: v a,^-" +^ ca^>ai',^r^ y
bwas
,C. A the but*
this YYs°'^a.,^t to be 'ibu ^,z f%E.^'Jre to -.1.5..-, u:n.s,f rlcf 'axA active nni'my.T%x:_ flu"n e`..s.3, C43n.r6i:.f^V Wvre
also ^a^..^eted tffia:`, Fvj'v: Fgaxr.isun e12a^? ^.3' 1;3.f N. Y of :sx.i
pardcPp3le itt a"3.ig.abe7°k+em«E'+wb.o.$i, e'.n'('S.?'e.°<,i..i:^^ an amoyna°s',' ..ss dek^r^'w: 's') M; ^.'.^u'^".... T-^e d '^f `y" ^ .„7 -:r ::a'A^S.ds,.....''^r
f'epir3^,{a that Sh° has b'vors ^--d in yzaiSm.Wsmeaz w:xd as an, NTI, 1 il. j F . also '^orted that^(-2(+^ pd . Y T
chooses to do so. AN Ela::.,v^.an is ,,.v'wxe of dm hnk,. of va. ^^. ^ ,^°'^, ° a.s ^^$a includingAtiea t.^3 ..a^ .,3^u^.,^" ^^u ^3°^< v
th;, aS,E-v^.-?'saCZ2l nature of si As. H".r Ji:$osr. c; <s ^3 ?, G va;.-AM p^.':i'?%''?mi4
-mows :s"^')garry^rizg the %l;a%gv: M:.1s°: She is ? ;:.`_? 4+,.s;..if ..cb4,sarlly au'.-?d p ' e3 S' eA
bS7hnwssts'..^'i. The defePkdar i:3 s'l.hi+. ^:. :vonk ir', :. an G,.c "''wy 'x ^d ^ -t, 3d3 ws . ,. N ,., She 1 i able r• to
'^a'Fkdfus¢axDC .' ins$f"^+.G%iC:a^'Ati and eV t saxom^^^b D a ,c^:. ;:`^^M,. ^.^,a. v.z, ^• d'.y'^^^r; ^,^„' ei^ ;-' ;.'^^;33: is d:lGtz'd':;:,., _Qf a :^ii1,..,.:`bi'^^,^
p.^^^ei^dzn,g3 against her;4. Ms. HaaF"s5f3TZ is ^^urr,^Tltiy Yc,; afrx" of ^..vu..:^^'in,^ .^i ^..> ^:,.. ^ ^ ..e.^ ^n f^F4"k^cs^1ofs^•r=^ to^ ,' ^.u! x. 4 ^ ss ^ ^5 o
do so as w1his is ^.and^r hek ^^^^ i tr ^;4.^ ° z^a ,. , vs an.' , :3.ot al 'Pna.ss;andY -
^. ^-u^. ^".yk^;^ad'x.a i raiY'e^^iy` ^.osvTi^':P^. ^.,;'`T `v syal:(, tr,,.a^,
C ^^,^^^s L^C, E^ %^^y^,hoxog;wt
^
ti7 ^
,i
J. ALLEN ^^^^^^^ATTOR^^^ AT LAW
7821 NORTH ^^^^^ DRIVEDA^ON, OHIO 45414e4694
-----------------
(937) 278-0652
November 25, 2014
Ms,Saa^antha Harrison
?n re: State vs. Harrison
DearMse Harrison:
As you know, e have been appoan'ced as your ^^^rth. a1b.^^^ey^n theabav€^: matter. 9 would be happy tomeet with you -to discuss facts and strategies for defending you ^ r, ffio5 matter, :f you wis€ caIl andschedule an appointment to mee witVi me at my office.
w ,. ud ^. +. '.3^6 ^i ca.s'1ixoti s"G3^'^.^^.,' your ^'vy^.e^" ^lq^,.`^`"^,'s.*. (in '13^^ .:s, F:va<),`^:s i n:-r. aV3x.,ssr y'?^. rPGa^;:4Zt^' ;^;^k: ^ as I have
not heard ^xu;rE.^s yoa.'t sEkflce the 112;ut- OU^_e
Enclosed please fin^. copies oi ^°^^ zi ^k i1cx k,^ :.iw^^'^'1.. ^% :n(...«: mo'¢.xon in i1imine),
;3^' `+ihâc:^. I have filed on ^'4^dA., ' case. I °^^/o.^f ^. ;.:.k^' x,^^? discuss t^.t^^. - cl'?^M^'^'xr . s as f Ve;.l as strategies
of d^,'Zeiise with you at your earliest s tjx?>1'eEii?:'cce.
75(l) WOODS DR^W E ,a ^1AIM$ T 0 N C) <-r 4-53' 83
_ Harrison^r ^x^S d^i. a3 4.4'1.a.^ ^.^..
^^^^' / ry Rw ^ ^
Dear Sar4^.ant.ha,
P
^'.^i^'fosed a.^ N•^:i e,;`±% 1"_F.,y b f% _^P^ ^^'^.awe. As
you c^.?a ."^,^e, +.^?^s is .^^.'^^ ^"^5.^,'^.s `^?, .°% `r^a^'n- , ^ .^_:,n+.^ ^,,'° ^ s ^.-^;a" `''^° 'i ^^..i,ri ^'" are ^^3cZ^E Si. n^. ..^ .. ...4, I^. 4 . ^o,..,'...^ ^.n^^^ ^
ySJ•eA'A-^
Y5CGL/+3Q,i+^,
l of ^,'^f,^/f
a1KJE. 1 6, 2 iy14 S.Lr^9e
4^..1.^tl^
: . ,^i^z ,
As d i ^a^6 n have1 V _1d U.'',; ^l !^ f.^..x. a f. ,na ...:rk^^^ence set ' 'r March 5^ 20,14 at
4 00d^,"'m, It waSi:.ld b':, adv..sabsc _6 r yo.n. s:. ^ ^tx: a F: o •e_ . . ^A9 to ,n.. ;^:t with
-.m.° a3?d to ^r"^^cu,^s defenses and 'L"a.al SE,<ate ^e.^°Fa ; as sat'^:? 'ti: 11.aMi'^.^le.
j_ fya:.
at Law
T .k
% '^-.^ .^ ^°i7 . -,}'1
1'F^ _:^. ^ ^ _ ; .:v1 ^r'a u' f
7821 IT-ti DIXIE DR
D1°L. C b^`''^^, g ^'^ .^3 . ;.Z fe,l^g ^r1 dk d'^` ^'^^`:^^+^^ .^.^ .,^ ad ^ "-2
.^93 `'^ ^
.fr!
^r,^^ Ra^'^^ ?
^ ,
J%az'^h 4.: ^...)
SAMANT".-' .tA HARR ; S Oi,j >^ OHNS.75 (:.)"WOODS DRIVEWEST ^^IL5'ON, 011 45383
i:'_ rea
' , ai e t ` "T v Q . 14- CR° 1 3 8
^^ai- Samantha:
k^+J^ s ing final ly nn ^a^^ 73 el, wF7^' c^ wZ^'es -yA ,.^.', av ^r ^a; ? % s'j 'r' v^.^^^ ^::aa•rr jIG.>> r ^"v ^ .. ?x prosecution of%
your dufeiise 9 1 h^a.v^ ^orne concerns ^.,. C'iou.: . l 5Y ..^,r, and the Yaj r .,,U,=^o n «. se.: F , -- ^ your , ;^r' u ^.k..a_ f .,, f. i s,a+1eno
p.^6?^til^:^f making TMs2ot'^^.?^.;.s to t^e ^,o^. '^ .^^:^':^.>s ; .:.:.t ._? ; %^^ a ?aj ^y% ^sii db ^^^i
ind:ctz'"2ent affte?' the grand iury v< t.,,d a:"3,' PJ ^^ basi, s , ; ," 17011j,. :. ., s;,.b on withr%t^ ai. ^g^a'-^ rthe ag^,.
i^& e^k' bill of particulars. Ht^vlP;i"'er, as I advised -,.s u, ^ arn, a ' C Q - vti. „ a s` "^ ^`'kaa.^«._ ^b^S ^6^,.
success on those motions.
YC)^,+T do have a right to remain s3ient but st '."'^.a.y be a ch^,°;.re ts? be =n.ade alltex 'yoas hear
What the Sta,^e witnesses l°Aa:Ie to say a-bou; you al'idi whet:l-e:- you ha^^ a response --- especiallysince you have no cr;nnana' ;^^oru,
My b^.^°^^',^'ii concern s'.^'i the ai^^'°+ of Yl:l"«a'4.^.''ss^-:? you ^,^'^v.:. i^.^,n.i..a. at`°'^_a^.. ^' F ,F„ /^ ^ , t^^1 a^, e., ..,. ^F ,. + v s " r^^^^ ^^^^ h t
.
^n ^o r ;a c x„o ^^ v F' ^^ ^ Mti^
,.._ _^ ^V^ ` ^._ '^'^IZ i Y e.. £ / t` ...v': @^.^;i.. to " v ^¢
.,...,. a v S: ^^: 3: ^ a S z" rauf..^ ^u c ^tiv
bacs{a reS. FurAteY, calling m u?t3pic doc;.ozs to _e,,^^if^ to 'hs :gs you!s%4ia r s.d `i?eis about Rr ho^de^ ^.^? "^,,,AS..^. ^. J' !n 4.a :F*i{° ^l ^s ^^i"^S you rsa^; ar.'^ C.^' and j ^,s^ in^.''^^:ssi .^;.y a . z.^so ^ith<^_ ^.iv 7°es ;eU^^,>^, ; '^p ro^essio:^a:
services and schedules. %"r^3^.i;''', `iz7;; :ii2.^'a ^Io f1{ ;eR? hard ^,.f .ze'_c^S°a:e ?^^e y^.^s::"ges 4:^^^inst you so as to^
keep out P^a,n^^ of your -hYs"or;f v"',th c,..flldre;^^^ ^^i-vycy3 of your _,o4ata^^^^ ^ffraudraising charitable monies. Ivkeda.caF vAit,:.essPJ mr..y ,°;en doors .oJ JHow r. :.^ay is.,=;:e;'> 1'r-
Likew8se, I strongly you ;o; .ry.xz,g to '.?o'si% _i county d eputxeS to show your
huSband'S absence 'a^^ ^^frou^^^^^ousia; ^^po3 6i-2g :.%pm to the _.;. . visioz: s.^.w^o.ls foi ^el-I p:ay and
J. ALLEN WILMESATTORNEVAT LAMi'
7821 NORTH DIXIE DRIVE. ^^ ^^^ ^ ^ ^ ^^ 45414
(937) ^^^^^^^^
^^^c-b: 4, 2 0 15
SAMANTHA HA I SO^T ^ OHNIS'75 (I) WOODS DRIVEWEST MILTON, OH ^^ ^^^
In re: State vs. 1-larrison
CaseNo.. A ^-CRm 138
Dear Ms. Johns:
E-ncls^^^^ please find the list oI°px^^ecutorial witnesses -,xhicch. you ::`ace next week. Itis my understanding what the State will introduce statements fh,3t aroF,s. ^i.ave signed ;'.a^^^^^ noinccsme. Then, they will produce proof $hat Marty, Strzri^^^^^ow3s was deposite: directly_^^^^ your account. `I'I-^ey may also i.ntrod-:a.ce y0a:^^ credit caxd' records to show that you were^^^endsng money I'rora soriie scsurce^
Since you declan-e to testify, after the Cou^'a, ove^^^^^ zqfl of my motions to excludeevidence, I do ii®t see any reb-attal or response to the Stage'^ ch.a;-ges. I-^convxyted, you may iaotreceive prisor, b^^^ would receive a felony on ;^^ij-r record ^.^d have ^^ sulbn`air t^ the nales ofprobation.
Even now, the prosecutor and the Court ,vould consider you eligible for (ILC)Intervention I.n Lieu OI'^^nvaction (and Canyel the t^. °ial) if you ad,..-nat to :ailalbg ro report income.II'^ou are willing to do this ^-nd ^e assessed for possible treaf^^.eriM a^^ therapy you may o^^taii, adismissal of your case and iio crArninal record in this nnatten°
Ir- my opinion, the option ddswrgresq^oux serious consideration sinceih: evidence againstyou appears strong and yo-ar position t^izat za:j.^s evidence °'v3ol^. ^;es ; o';^x Coffss.at 1?onal rights" and
^-nust be suppressed or excluded is uzi^^elv To be s usEa=sned by tb.e Court.
S xrl 0 c re ty,
J. A^^^n WilmesA.q,- on4 o v a t a.,cw
-^-^---^-^.-
^ a ^ _ ^.-^
^ ^fl`^ ^'
2\ C
:`" P^...Se.`'-.. 7 R ..iK . -d.,Y F' "
^O IIRT C - D:'; -^.AS
3 s :^^a 3t ." 24:04 P11038 Doeke#:D; 19861617
a , 0 r :: MONTGOMERY COUNi4° OFM
S^^ THE COMMON PLEAS^`afa, iaOy ^^ ^" OF C1q3 d,C^"^'^a.. ' g ';^ e''+.,dsu '^)°....il',..1&.9 a s t.,a < L. . ^e.e L . p"s,dt
c R, E %0 2 f°•,^.A%n S..d 7 V t+.'°. 1 0 ^ 'v°.
STATE OF OH9C)
P4aint6ff,
-v_q.,
SAMAa^ ^ ^^^ ^ARRa^ON
d^^^ndant.
^^^ ^x^ r+.^CA^^ s^'+. '.,°, 2014 R 138
^ ^ 4 m^`°
a ^° :.^ G E s.'E s^^;` E J. LA '^ s:.;^^^
STATE C` '.,^^QP^w:
VVRiTTE ",°.T
Comes no^a the SLate of0,.^;^. ery :^ounty Ohio,and ^^re'^^^^^ ^^rn9shesa ;€st of va?it^"?esx ,. . . ^ . . <. ;^ .a . . a: am^nded.
KEEPER OF RECO;'aEDS, sV'90.'*. ;?0r,4E.R•"r.• AND FMkLy
P..^^.E R V iC E: S; 111 " S. E ? . 1 .°^ °: C. M+,.1Ss,:..S B, L V,..y. D, A Y , 4s^N, `>.^..^4"F!0, 45 4 2 2
DEPUTY ROD R-ROWN, : ; "a SH6^'...r...F F', 'S OFFiCE, 345 W
^^^ ST. DA`Y"'ON, OH'^O 45422
DEP;R;T`f M. W'.7 IAIMS3_^ 45vv2 ND ST. DAYTOi'a, OH'^^^ 45422
tl 1 Y.... G'^-.,:,^,.'0°° P` EAS
2015 3:3 ?e27 PM
J 'a MONTGOMERY COUNTY Cj€-^
1 N TT".iE C-0 Rv9.Mm>'' ?. ^A^v .^?: T Lt . ^ P f K ^_ 0::1 T't , 01-d^^^d 9
CR;. !?r`;. a N^`; L D.kV I:^ ^ ON
^^
f: $
^
^
^
0
M
STATE OF OHIO,
-vs-
SAMANTHA ^ARRiSO1'.,
; A S ti, i i 0.. l 0`1 4 R 0 E : 3 S
',f Ar.Y ::_`'+;EP,4AN
Ai
^^_^ . . 3 IAa
^ j ''4ii .s,f^ P^,°,_ ^ F. .!-d^ 4^
... , . . - J r ^RULING IN PART
'{AF G%X17"^ Of.^ON IN LI?kIINE
Th-C.,' C43LflT-i grants Dw'fe%3da-:?t'5 a'ry0603"3 +"4 .,T'"i.Fi'?e as is, ,Ja:4'Z•.<i'3s vo ',^e ey:isoP that Defendant lost
^m'::i'p34°,M2P'.y or peit?anent c'e.i: `;?d.f of her dh=^die,"s e^:3a3ms. i.31' ?:lY.,ot3yPoa9:i 3f cg:Ylds"e^ being harT3,_a. e^''. by
medical abuse or MuZ3a;a2haEx6^m's by pi•:)xy; a'2G, i."E ; use r vr ^ c1 '^ or firauduIe;ti claims in 1id ;dfu'.,SiiA6.
f.ri/ financial d^.'^ a or informa!?o9i, x't)vweetei iVfl: `3G: a>',^ : _:ile.
' 0 0 `''.^+5"_r'E ^'wE D:
'.JDG;`, t'?laAR ": WISEMAN
This c^^current is electro,,n;.svalny ;. Iex^ blv 9 s.ng te ^^edk :;' coe F Fgie:g system. Thesv^^^m, wii^ a record .^."i.^^P filing the e- F'GS^^ r^. c .;te,. i ^.z^-..^<^,t f c:^^ ,. ' ^post ^, °^^. a^^ . k^?^'^:n tai e,
The presence v f ds^'ie Ps";diwi'^ ^ '.^i'?t3 ^E,e.: c ZA^. T Sl } ` + s ^3 y to the3 ^ ^ . «... .. i:k4.iC 'i^^rt.+..I^.. a ^J .^G4.La^ai Sk^S..leY^..^ii^'^^^.^'E ^L!fair
znd orderly adm?,snSti^acio-n. 1^0' 0r"c^, . ^ r ^ ^d ^ ` k^ F,x ^^ s, ." 3%1:. _,^ a. . .. ,_ ^l.i asvJ practices. 's^ , Siv ev e ?i
that the service daoye^'x[uS uu.i2 v;'"^:^,-.3.^,.r-..iu.. a_7^'t(.^s .. . r. t ° °v ^^^ y.^..?wF..6:.P, ^..c fi4+..ji9i'y, iSeco1:"3^.'S a
distraction °ii^v S^^ ^k`3..'â'aei2t^., to tE3e z%.xi 2^i"i?: o3v.A%'^^' ^:c'a,:.t;:"(iSti"A?i.^,e°' Zâ "p+."^iG*^, ^.?^i i"s,9;'^S°e,z9tS a 8dgf:>Licu:+
(aett'1 â'nenti ti 52i^rn.y and aei:urii,v, f.°3C; C;tii,.^' 'Js/iuj be id..i:iived i'ff;sa`mn the il;iarS.roor"i" OR.f<^'.i'4diI14^ canine
conduct includeM but ... -ov$ .:msfed, te, exC°6,.iSi`«Je '?o-Vern, ,. ^ "`s';' ei^;.. .I::..1.,^_ excessivey.>,.^..r. -t'^i S°.^:vn of
3it3iSe (inJhintI3' ^T^C3°^i'3 :<a ^ f^^.C",ik^,.;, i)a"3R 'lig, , iM ) Also, in ` v ' , t ^an +F^^; b' ^, ?.s`"^w , 3 ;=Y^ _ 6^: ^ cannot ^a^ seated .^^e tO
prospective ,tkrvi'Sbe..ng or at.e1;?rK to a' .^'of?,s, .wI.' z..,, .::o, ;/ ^"".• , t^,..ov. from.'.,:? ` IR t'f'te courtroom and- c
alternative accommodations Pa. ap1.c9-y'°','. !s: any $i:Chl. ax.:!f.?,_tivC; %:c, 1mi:iQd°c1t1s?S25 will be
provided to Defendant.
i'irst, Defendarx, mayv rRma r. ,^7 r r .:^i^ .,^"a. s.he dGg. b,%"st have ¢a.he Cio- present i t2 ohi
hallway or other p1.Pjii11:w: space :)_,,.s;.u.e of vva°` :,.76'^I'3?, °rSFj::dtid- 4.^ , v;/ ,y's responsible adult "r3.S to whom thF'
dog VV1z: o-buy b: hav3?orar cornr:;ards 'i a.3£'J,s a; : f^., pub.kc U3.;^r, Defie':d,.'?t 2?"1ay interact with the dog on
^ ^^^^ TGv^z'EPY^OUN: `'` rjHiO'I N 4. 9F^ !^ C d"A^^'R`bL'^^,g^ y^ ^ ^ PL:sr"^' ' F^.s"^ac^^" ^'^ t r^^,'s^'As(a9?'",^T r1-1 .' f" r^y^.^^2^,.^ 3
5^•
STATE OF ^^^^
vs
SAMANTHA H.^^ RRMON
Nr'-_CER A', N, G. . ^ -, ^.^JJA^-^^g^^ g^^.3c"^''7.../&^.,.,., k` E
;:.;. T;. `^i^ U.
STATE OF OHIO, ^05JNTY OFTO T^^^ CLERK:
C AS;^ P 201^' CR 00138^^'u W- RY WISEMAN
^ ^^J F5 ^"^E N .^
The undersSgned. Prosecuting Aft°Jrnt:Sd^.^.) e38; iJe"c.-F of ; 5 of ^,^,^'^°^3, ^"'e:u%^i^ ^.;, ._ ^ `?^ sauc^^^e af the fo9lo4lf6CEs^Subpoena for the hered^. bedaw .^^^^d w^tnes5 4'-0 a z?a.^ea5 ;hi_ ;,^ua at the t^m: as set
Mlarty St€'&ng@e4iow CaiebX, B rookv.^^e;.'.rhso 45309,^^
You are required to be and appear tc^,o n ii Ae„ D'^^SV, tNl t`.rmc. Cv rZnnis.'iaE P$^^s Court, 4tl°d Hoa3',^+. gn.^ay rr,^a3,* eb'6. ^V19'6 x/r^i'nxy
r .#8 , &^'8
q^ ryv^ ^,^2,d^F! G
M
GA,9
{ y
^Y79
^
ERAyY1°al'p^
b°^"'^f G„7N`
( + p ^^ ^ ^
ET^N '^s' e^R1^2 '^ _^ 4; N!')r^,t^a ^^Yfi+. t i, i, 6 °i> £.5:.^ ; i i^ the 1^^^?^'4, u9^^oa^da^ f RFc^^^ ^ ^1^ a^ 9e00 A.M. 'tn te^t^;f a. : 'i^ ^ . ^ ^. ba "f ^f ^ : N^: y ^ ,^ (,r'aii r^`.^ i 4 the abave-en;^^^^^
^^^^^ and do not der,C3aEl from th^.' CGuE';' §A{;$'oF+, g'.^F.a'+le under P"ti.' ALTY OF i 41R'`r
Please call 937-225 -6757 ;30 a ' m. ^^ Q-cdaeduwed to appear; ^^ ^^^do not need to appear, a :-:,a41 so ^.^^%.^Psen '.,aye '.y M C 25-5757 be^sy- -er ^ ^^ ^.^,and 4.30 p.mn and ask for aha prwse;utos.
`
+3i:zi7o '
`^^ THE ^^^^^FF OF lRdION°^^ON, IER°^ ^OVINTY,You are coPnmc'1nded to su 'nmon ncr"'Ea a : ; . ^ set '^°ar"'2 abc';"e to be and appear before
1nis Court at fiho- t:me and place set forth above t; said rvitness:^^ ^ppp-^ , rto-ae,' said witness not depart saidCourt without Ieavb UNDER .^^NAL "( 01= ,'LA.a,/a.
WITNESS rnhand and the sea6 of t^ : sc^lC ^'£^i,i t at ' . ^ ^ ^ ,^".1 ^,sar."^k'.1^ r, 4 F6.^ 'c3,., 5 1'^'.4.» 20 1 5 .J . e11^t""'1"u, .IC$,.E,^+.) ..2:2l . ''.;re
^^ THE COMMON PLEA,$ '`.^^^PT 0FfA0 g u g GOMIE ^ ' ^' ..^
STATE OF 0HIO
vs
SAMANTHA H^RRBON
T ,° .r^'^r*.d
VVIT;'^ YOU.
STATE OF OHI^^, COUN`^°' CaR ! ^° `TO Ta^^ CLERK:
^ 2 3 .. . 20,14CR00?38; y 9^^^^^^^AN'
^^'Uut&n
^ ^... . . ^^^ ^ ^g^BPC^ENA
The ^ndersigned, Prosecuting A.so,ney's} or, behaff uf the St.^'e of O'hio, , e,ebU rec"J-'s.:: the issuance of the followingSubpoena foethe hermEr, below ra, t ied witness appear in nis Court at the time azz^ ;e^ ^amh:
^^y
^,mn^r RecoC"ds; ^^i ^r: .^d.. ^ . . . .^ iAir <d. . ^.w ^a E4, .,1^' lu .', y p7 e, Ct C'Ey ^ v d 4L
ppeaa before tUhe CRHMBNA cr N the -i3 ". o"t Pleas Court, 4th Fl€3or,Courtroom #8, MONTGOMERY COUNTY COURTS BUsLs.a{NG, 41 Ss.rees. ^a;smn, Ohio during the week a,IVlonc^^ , ^a^^ ^^, 2015 at ^? ^ ^ ^ fir of ;r.,m^ Ge^^d A z, id^ ^tc'^f^`'t a s a ^?rE &^t^ss on ^3es a^` of ^a^' {& k : ;:153 ,^i^i;^^3'Fr in the r^^'is^sty^°^54^iCEc^case) and dN not depart firom se.afry z,.nda., ,F^IE INWLTs OF ._,WV
Piease ca^^ 937-225-5757 be•^^^en 4-30 p.m, and,3,30 a.m, th,- ya ^.;^^ ^^^a-d:^^^d to appear; if youdo not need to appear„ a rew^rdMg wyfll so aj,r^se. I ^^^a^= z{??ve any a.' oa s, 2Z5 -37^7 be^^^;^a-9 ^;^0 ^.^a.and 4^30 p.m. and ask for ^he, assg^dled po" svc,tor.
'?, 9 ^'^g ^ ^ ^•`F&G°as'^^
pp^ '^Y
. . - -... - ..^,.
Y0,087317
TO THE SHERIFF OF MARION COUNTY, OH:Yfil,d are commanded to sta"nmo; he wit^^s zs whose 'ia ne and add, re< are : ''tf ab^3.le 3:?? be and auyd3ec'3Y''E.3C?sore
'thi^ Court at i de time and p6ace sa"'Cs?"I' above Tr.)r Said W€in°,^aS c,, ` s .'rt"`' jtafR3ess not depart : saidCcaurt x^Athout leave UNDER PENALTY OF L,
VVffNE"vvS my5' hand and 'E:he se^i 'l7:the a:ar" 9sJ r +s+. i''" a ^e ..J'^">" S'E C? s. ,^`cF"^,^J ^'1 ^ , 20 1,.1'.
'Gregyr o-'y A . Birush,
f1srpr,':er^ `uixmti4t oe Ccdn6f or Pleas
KS ?!6t2-G15
/y^^^'^^^ ,^^ A4 ^
'.e.""d ^ ^ _s ^-°`-"--=-a=m.®.>^
.^^!'
..
o-^^ ^^ -^_,. ^,m^.^....,^„w`"",..- ,'
'^.,.^..®,-""" 'r . '.^'' _ ,.. ^ .^
3g
^'._ 0`°4^
f ,.^,,^^ ^
^^i ^
ELECTRONICALLY F1LEC?COURT OF COMMON PLEASFriday, March 06, 2015 2:54:21 PMCASE AiUi^^ER: 2094 CR 00138 Docket ID: 1SGREGORY A BRUSF!CLERK OF COURTS MONTGOMERY COUNTY
IN THE COMMON PLEAS COLrRT OF MONTGOMERY COUNTY, OHIOCRIMINAL DIVISION
0^
U)
G?
GL
0
E 0
0 .5
ar00^
^E0L39.^.+C0m
STATE OF OHIO,
Plaintiff,
CASE NO.: 2014 CR 00138
JUDGE MARY WISEMAN
-vs-
SAMANTHA HARRISON,
Defendant.ORDER AND ENTRY SETTINGTIME LIMITS FOR TRIAL
This matter will be tried to conclusion during March 16, 17, 18, 2015. For purposes of court
economy and efficiency in the management of the court's docket, the following maximum time limits and
resulting approximated schedule is established.
Monday March 16, 2015 Trial Day 1
8:45 a.m. - 9:00 a.m. Conference/Record made if needed of pretrial matters
9:05 a.m. - 9:40 a.m. Voir Dire by Court
9:45 a.m. - 11:00 a.m. Voir Dire by State
11:00 a.m. - 12:15 p.m. Voir Dire by Defense
12:15 p.m. - 12:40 p.m. Jury Selection in Chambers
12:45 p.m. - 1:00 p.m. Jury Swom and Juror Orientation
2:15 p.m. - 2:45 p.m.
2:15 p.m. - 3:15 p.m.
3:30 p.m. - 5:00 p.m.
State Opening Statement
Defense Opening Statement
State's Evidence
Conclude Day 1
Tuesday March 17, 2015 Trial Day 2
8:45 a.m. - 9:00 a.m. Conference/Record made if needed of trial/evidence issues
3:45 p.m. - 4:15 p.m. State's Closing (Time Includes Rebuttal)
4:15 p.m. - 4:45 p.m. Defendant's Closing
4:45 p.m. - 5:00 p.m. Jury Instructions
In summary, each side is provided the following maximum time allotments:
Voir Dire 1.25 hours each
Openings .50 hour each
State's Case 6.25 hours
Defendant's Case 6.25 hours(if any)
Closing Arguments .50 hours each
Unused time cannot be reserved by a party. The court may use or allot unused time as it deems
appropriate and fair. Unused time likely will inure to the benefit of breaks and getting to jury deliberations
2
earlier. The Court reserves the right to modify the time limits as needed for the fair and efficient
management of the trial. The time limits apply even if Defendant opts to proceed p ro se. The time limits and
approximated start and end times may be adjusted as needed to accommodate unforeseen circumstances.
The court may adjust the time limits to account for cross-examination exceeding a reasonable length,
objections, side bars, and other activities.
SO ORDERED:
JUDGE MARY WISEMAN
This document is electronically filed by using the Clerk of Courts e-Filing system. Thesystem will post a record of the filing to the e-Filing account "Notifications" tab of the followingcase participants:
WARD BARRENTINEKARINA KOROSTYSHEVSKYASSISTANT PROSECUTING ATTORNEYS(937)-225-5757Attorneys for Plaintiff
J ALLEN WILMESATTORNEY AT LAW(937)-278-0652Attorney for Defendant, Samantha Harrison
ELECTRONICALLY FILEDCOURT OF COMMON PLEASWednesday, March 11, 2015 3:10:24 PMCASE NUMBER: 2014 CR 00138 Docket ID: 19875151GREGORY A BRUSHCLERK OF COURTS MONTGOMERY COUNTY OHIO
IN THE COMMON PLEAS COURT OF MONTGOMERY COUNTY, OHIOCRIMINAL DIVISION
STATE OF OHIO
Plaintiff,
-vs-
SAMANTHA HARRISON
Defendant.
CASE NO. 2014 CR 00138
JUDGE MARY WISEMAN
First Amended STATE OF OHIO'SWRITTEN LISTOF WITNESSES
Comes now the State of Ohio, by the Prosecuting Attorney of Montgomery County,Ohio, and herewith furnishes a list of witnesses, in accordance with Local Rule 3.03 IIf Aas amended.
2.
3.
4.
5.6.
8.
9.
10
1112
MIRACHEL FIELDS, Montgomery County Job and Family Services, 1111South Edwin C. Moses Blvd., Dayton, Ohio 45422;KEEPER OF RECORDS, Montgomery County Job and Family Services,1111 South Edwin C. Moses Blvd., Dayton, Ohio 45422;KEEPER OF RECORDS, JP Morgan and Chase National, 7610 WashingtonSt. Indianapolis, IN 46231;KEEPER OF RECORDS, Clay Township Police Department, 8207 ArlingtonRd., Brookville, Ohio 45005;MARTY STRINGFELLOW, 516 Caleb Dr., Brookville, Ohio 45309;ROBYN TRAYWICK, 45 West Franklin St., Bellbrook, Ohio 45305;DET. ISAIAH KELLER, Montgomery County Sheriffs Office, 330 WestSecond Street, Dayton, OH 45402;DEP. CAITO, Montgomery County Sheriffs Office, 330 West Second Street,Dayton, OH 45402;DEP. WILLIAMS, Montgomery County Sheriffs Office, 330 West SecondStreet, Dayton, OH 45402;DEP. ROD BROWN, Montgomery County Sheriffs Office, 330 West SecondStreet, Dayton, OH 45402.MELISSA LOWE, Care House, 410 Valley Street, Dayton, Ohio 45404VIKKI CARTER, Montgomery County Children Services, 3304 N. MainStreet. Dayton, Ohio 45405
In addition to the above, the State reserves the right to call all persons required toestablish chain of custody of the evidence and any witness listed in the discovery providedto the Defendant.
Respectfully submitted,
MATHIAS H. HECK, JR.Prosecuting Attorney
By: /s/ Karina KorostyshevskyWARD BARRENTINE 0074366E,KARINA KOROSTYSHEVSKY 0087317EAssistant Prosecuting AttorneyDayton-Montgomery County Courts Bldg.P. O. Box 972, 301 W. Third StreetDayton, Ohio 45422(937) 225-5757
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned hereby certifies that on March 11 , 2015 I electronically filed theforegoing with the Clerk of Court using the Electronic Criminal Filing system, which willsend notification of such filing to the following: J ALLEN WILMES, Attorney for Defendant.