IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,judgmenthck.kar.nic.in/judgments/bitstream/123456789/...2010/07/02 · : 1 : IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH Dated this the 7 th day of

: 1 :

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,

DHARWAD BENCH

Dated this the 7th day of October 2013

Before

THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE H.N.NAGAMOHAN DAS

Writ Petition No.46460/2002 C/w W.P.No.398/2000,W.P.No.528/2007, W.P.No.3508/2000,

W.P.No.4233/2000, W.P.No.8367/2000,W.P.No.9395/2000, W.P.No.9867/2000,W.P.No.11825/2000, W.P.No.21915/2000,W.P.No.22311/2000, W.P.No.32144/2000,W.P.No.3880/2000, W.P.No.433/2001,W.P.No.194/2002, W.P.No.13838/2002,

W.P.No.17712/2002, W.P.No.38334/2002,W.P.No.3621/2006, W.P.No.172/2007,W.P.No.435/2007, W.P.No.18602/2006,

W.P.No.3930/2005

In W.P.No.46460/2002

BETWEEN:

1. MR. B.MELLAREDDY,AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,S/O B RAMA REDDY,PROP MANJUNATHA CHEMICALSFERTILISERS, BELLARY.

2. MR. J.THIPPERUDRAPPA,AGE: 48 YEARS,S/O J SANNA BASAVANNA GOWDA,UMA MAHESHWARA AGRO AGENCIES,SHOP NO 2, EDIGA HOSTEL COMPLEX,DOUBLE ROAD, BELLARY-1.

: 2 :

3. SRI. C. CHANDRASHEKAR,AGE: 52 YEARS,S/O NARAYANAPPASRI MAHALAXMI AGRO AGENCIES,AMBEDKAR COMPLEX,STALL NO 10, DOUBLE ROAD,BELLARY-1.

4. G. RAMAKRISHNA REDDY,AGE: 35 YEARS,S/O G VEERA REDDYSRI. RENUKA AGRO TRADERS,STALL NO.11, AMBEDKAR COMPLEX,DOUBLE ROAD, BELLARY.

5. B. HARI S.BABU, AGE: 30 YEARS,S/O B.SUBBARAMAIAH,SEETHARAM AGENCIES,FERTILISERS AND PESTICIDES,SHOP NO 4, NEAR BUS STAND,BELLARY-1.

6. K.BALBIR REDDY, AGE: 40 YEARS,S/O SANKA REDDY,M/S. HALE BASAVESHWARA AGRO

CHEMICALS, STALL NO 5, ARYA EDIGA HOSTEL COMPLEX, DOUBLE ROAD, BELLARY-1.

7. D.SHESHADRI, S/O SUBBARALU,AGE: 46 YEARS,SRI. KANKADURGA AGRO CHEMICALS,NO 9, DOUBLE ROAD, BELLARY-1.

8. D.S.JYANAMURTHY, AGE: 62 YEARS,S/O SIDDARAPPA, AMARESHWARA & CO.,DEALERS IN FERTILISERS CHEMICALSSEEDS AND AGRICULTURAL COMPONENTS,BALAJI KALYANA MANTAP, STALL NO 485.

: 3 :

9. H. SRINIVASA REDDY, AGE: 39 YEARS,S/O H.HAMMA REDDY,VENKATESHWARA AGRO CHEMICALS,K.C. ROAD, BELLARY-1.

10. M.C.CHINNAPPA REDDY, AGE: 46, S/O HANUMANTHA REDDY MARUTHI AGRO AGENCIES, K.C. ROAD, BELLARY. …PETITIONERS

(BY SRI. B.N.SHIVANNA, V.ANJANE GOWDA &D.M.RENUKA MURTHY, ADVOCATES)

A N D :

1. JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,JOINT DIRECTORS OFFICE, BELLARY.BELLARY DISTRICT.

2. THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,SHESHADRI ROAD, BANGALORE-1.

3. ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,BELLARY TALUK, BELLARY.

4. JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,CHITRADURGA. ...RESPONDENTS

(BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADVOCATE)

THIS WP IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFTHE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA WITH A PRAYER TO QUASHTHE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED 12.01.2000 ISSUED BY R1VIDE ANNEXURE-A AND DIRECT R1 TO RENEW THELICENSE OF THE PETITIONERS 1 TO 10 BY TAKINGRS.30/-.

- - - - - - - - - -

: 4 :

In W.P.No.398/2000

BETWEEN

KISAN AGRO AGENCIES GUNJ AREA,GULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETOR,REVANASIDDAPPA,S/O BASAWANAPPA UDAMNALLI,AGE MAJOR, OCC: BUSINESS,R/O GULBARGA. ...PETITIONER

(BY SRI. N.P.VIVEKMEHTA, ADVOCATE)

AND

1. UNION OF INDIA,BY ITS SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OFAGRICULTURE AND CO-OPERATION,KRISHI BHAVAN, NEW DELHI.

2. DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,NEAR K.R.CIRCLE, BANGALORE. ...RESPONDENTS

(BY SHRI. C.SHASHIKANTHA, ACGSC & SRI. ASHOKHARANAHALLI, CGSC FOR R1; SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, AGA R2)

THIS WP IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF

CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DECLARE THAT

RULE 10(2)(a) OF THE INSECTICIDE (AMENDED) RULE

1999 AS UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND ARBITRARY.

- - - - - - - - - - - -

IN W.P.NO.528/2007

BETWEEN

M/S BHAVANI AGRO CHEMICALS,SHOP NO 30, PAL COMPLEX,

: 5 :

CITY BUS STAND, HEAD POST OFFICEROAD, SUPER MARKET,GULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETOR,SRI. PRAKASH,S/O CHENNABASSAYYA HIREMATH,AGE 39 YEARS. ...PETITIONER

(BY SRI. SHARANABASAPPA K BABSHETTY, ADVOCATE)

AND

1. UNION OF INDIA,BY ITS SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OFAGRICULTURE AND CO-OPERATION,(KRISHI BHAVAN),DR.RAJENDRA PRASAD ROAD,NEW DELHI.

2. THE COMMISSIONER AND DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE, GOVERNMENT OFKARNATAKA, SHESHADRI ROAD,BANGALORE.

3. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE, GULBARGA. ...RESPONDENTS

(BY SHRI. D.R.ANANDEESWARA, CGSC FOR R1 SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADV., FOR R2 & R3)

THIS W.P. IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF

CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DECLARE THAT

RULE 10(2)(a) OF THE INSECTICIDES (AMENDED) RULE

1999 AS UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND ARBITRARY, IN SO FAR

AS PETITIONER IS CONCERNED.

- - - - - - - - - -

: 6 :

IN W.P. NO.3508/2000

BETWEEN

1. S.SHIVAKUMAR, MAJOR,S/O LATE G.SHIVAPPA,PROPRIETOR,GURU CHEMICALS & FERTILISERS,NO.2, III MAIN ROAD,NEW THARAGUPET, BANGALORE-560002/

2. K.SUBRAMANYAM, MAJOR,S/O KALASA KRISHNA RAO,PROPRIETOR,KARNATAKA FARMS SUPPLIES,ST.JOHN AMBULANCE ASSOCIATIONBUILDING, SAMPANGIRAMANAGARA,BANGALORE-560002.

3. B.L.NAGENDRA GUPTA, MAJOR,S/O LATE B.S.LAKSHMINARAYANA SETTY,PROPRIETOR, NAGENDRA FERTILIZERS,NO.3, III MAIN ROAD, NEW THARAGUPET,BANGALORE-560002.

4. B.K.MUKTHAR PASHA, MAJOR,S/O ABDUL RAHIM,PROPRIETOR,KISSAN AGRO SERVICES,NO.1, III MAIN ROAD,NEW THARAGUPET,BANGALORE-560002.

5. M.V.SHANKARANARAYANA SETTY, MAJOR,S/O VENKATA NRAYANAPPA,PROPRIETOR,SHREE ADHISHEHSA FERTILISERS,NEAR K.S.R.T.C BUS STAND,NH 4, SIRA-572137.

: 7 :

6. S.PUTTALINGAIAH, MAJOR,S/O B.S.SUGURAPPA,PROPRIETOR,SRI SOMESHWARA FERTILISERS,N.H-4, SIRA-572137.

7. P.R.RAMU, MAJOR,S/O P.L.RANGAPPA, PROPRIETOR,SRI RANGA TRAERS,N.H.4, SIRA.

8. S.KARIAPPA, MAJORS/O SIDDALINGAPPA,PROPREITOR,SIDDALINGESWARA TRADERS,SIRA.

9. S.C.ASHWATHANARAYANA SETTY,MAJOR,S/O LATE S.CHELUMAIAH SETTY,PROPRIETOR, S.CHALUMAIAH & SONS, N.H.4, SIRA.

10. C.T.RAVIKUMAR, MAJOR,S/O THIMMEGOWDA, PROPRIETOR,BASAVESWARA FERTILISERS,N.S.ROAD, CHELUR.

11. N.LAXMIPARHY, MAJOR, S/O LATE NARASAPPA, PROPRIETOR, SRI. LAKSHMINARASIMHA TRADERS, J.C.K COMPLEX, B.H.ROAD GUBBI-572216.

12. MANJUNATHASWAMY, MAJOR,S/O K.S.SADHASHIVAIAH,PROPRIETOR,SRI SIDDALINGESWARA TRADERS,IN FRONT OF BUS STAND,(NEAR CHANNABASAVESHWARA

: 8 :

TALKIES) GUBBI.

13. H.R.NARASIMHAGUPTA, MAJOR,S/O H.N.RAMAIAH SETTY,PROPRIETOR,KARNATAKA AGRO SUPPLIES,2ND MAIN ROAD, NEW MANDIPET,TUMKUR-572101.

14. G.P.VEERANNA, MAJOR,S/O PEDDAPPA, PROPRIETORSWATHI TRADERS2ND MAIN RAOD, NEW MANDIPETTUMKUR-572101.

15. K.N.NATARAJU, MAJOR,S/O K.C.NAGARAJU, PROPRIETOR,NATARAJA FERTILIZERS,2ND MAIN ROAD,NEW MANIDI PET, TUMKUR-572101.

16. B.L.MANIKYRAJU, MAJOR,S/O LATE LAXMIPATHAIAH,PROPRIETORSRI PARSWANATHA TRADERS &FERTILISERS, MANDYA MERCHANTSAND COMMISSIONS AGENTS, 2ND MAINROAD, NEW MANDIPET, TUMKUR-1.

17. T.S.RAJENDRA, MAJOR,S/O T.S.SIDAPPA, PROPRIETOR,SPIC AGRO SERVICE CENTRE,C/O NIRAJAN TRADING COMPANYFERTILISERS, SEEDS AND PESTICIDESDEALER, KUNIGAL ROAD,HONNUDIKE HAND POST.TUMKUR 572 101.

18. T.S.NIRANJANA, MAJOR,

: 9 :

S/O T.S.SIDDAPPA, PROPRIETORNIRANJAN TRADING CO.,DEALERS IN FERTILISERS PESTISIDES& SEEDS, 2ND MAIN ROAD,NEW MANDIPET,TUMKUR 572 101. ...PETITIONERS

(BY SRI. N.G.PHADKE , MEERABAI, ADVOCATES)

AND

1. UNION OF INDIA,REPRESENTED BY JOINTSECRETARY, (PLANT PROTECTION)MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE &CO.OPERATION, KRISHI BHAVAN,NEW DELHI-110001.

2. STATE OF KARNTAKA,REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPALSECRETARY, AGRICULTURAL &HORTICULTURAL DEPT,VIDHANA SOUDHA,BANGALORE-560001. ...RESPONDENTS

(By SHRI. N. DEVHADASS, ASG FOR R1 SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADVOCATE FOR R2)

THIS WP FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TOCALL FOR THERECORDS FROM R1 RELATING TO IMPUGNEDNOTIFICATION DT. 20.5.99 IN SO FAR AS IT RELATES TOTHE AMENDMENT OF RULE 10(2) OF THE INSECTICIDESRULES, 1971, AND QUASH THE SAME AS ILLEGAL ANDWITHOUT JURISDICTION.

- - - - - - - - - - - -

: 10 :

IN W.P. NO.4233/2000

BETWEEN

1. SUN AGRO SEEDS,SHOP NO.3, SARASWATHI LODGEBUILDINGS, 3RD MAIN ROAD,GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BYSRI. S.N.CHANDRA RAJ GUPTA,S/O K.S.NARAYANA SHETTY,NO.26, 1ST MAIN ROAD,N.R.COLONY, BANGALORE-560019.

2. INDO AMERICAN SEEDS,AITHAL COMPLEX, NO.6, 2ND CROSS,GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BYSRI. K.S.SHIVA KUMAR,S/O K.S.SURYA NARAYANANO.53, 12TH MAIN, 3RD BLOCKJAYANAGAR, BANGALROE-560011.

3. NATIONAL AGRO AGENCIES,NO.6, SARASWATHI LODGE BUILDING2ND CROSS, GANDHINAGAR,BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BYSRI. B.R.ASHWATH NARAYAN,S/O B.R.RATHADAIAH NO.15, 5TH CROSS,SHANKARAPURAM, BANGALORE-560004.

4. YASHWASWI AGRO SEEDS,MAHAVEEN PLAZA, 2ND CROSS,GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BY A.R.HARISHS/O A.G.RAMAIAH SETTY,2ND CROSS, GANDHINAGAR,BANGALORE-560009.

: 11 :

5. AJAY AGRO SEEDS,NO.3, GIRISH COMPLEX,OPP: SYNDICATE BANK,2ND CROSS, GANDHINAGAR,BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BYSRI. D.N.RAMESH KUMAR,S/O D.NARAYANA SETTY,D.NO.54/2, M.M.V.ROAD,BASAVANAGUDI, BANGALORE-560004.

6. SHREE AGRO SEEDS,NO.4 & 5, GIRISH COMPLEX,2ND CROSS, GANDHINAGAR,BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BYSRI. K.SRINIVAS,S/O M.KRISHNAIAH SETY,NO.1262, 7TH CROSS, 27TH MAIN,1ST PHASE, J.P.NAGAR,BANGALORE-560078.

7. KARNATAKA AGRO SEEDS,NO.9 & 10, GIRISH COMPLEXOPP. SYNDICATE BANK, 2ND CROSS,GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BYSRI. PRABHAKAR GUPTA,S/O P.VENKATAPPA,NO.22, 5TH CROSS6TH MAIN, HANUMANTHANAGAR,BANGALORE-560019.

8. KISSAN SEEDS CORPORATION,NO.3, ARYA VIDYA SHALA BUILDING,5TH MAIN,GANDHINAGAR,BANGALORE-560009.REPRESENTED BY SRI G.GOPAL,S/O G.MUNISHAMAYYA,NO.84, 4TH MAIN,

: 12 :

AMAR JYOTHI LAYOUT,R.T.NAGAR, BANGALORE-560032.

9. SAMRUDHI AGRO SEEDS,NO.2, SAJJAN LODGE BUILDING6TH MAIN, GANDHINAGAR,BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BYSRI. B.L.RAMA KRISHNA PRASAD,S/O B.S.LAKSHMINARAYAN,NO.22, 6TH CROSS, 5TH MAIN,N.R.COLONY, BANGALORE-560019.

10. UNIVERSAL AGRO SEEDS,SAJJAN LODGE BUILDING,6TH MAIN ROAD, GANDHINAGAR,BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BYSRI. M.K.NARAYANA MURTHY,S/O M.K.KRISHNA MURTHY,S/O M.K.KRISHNA SETTYNO.54/4, 14TH MAIN ROAD,VIJAYANAGAR, BANGALORE-560040.

11. INTERNATIONAL AGRO SEEDS,NO.28, 6TH MAIN ROAD,SAJJAN LODGE BUILDING, GANDHINAGAR,BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BY SRI. D.N.MALLIKARJUN,S/O D.NARAYANA SETTY, NO.2,BARANI NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL,BANGALORE.

12. ALL INDIA AGRO KENDRA,5TH MAIN ROAD, GANDHINAGAR,BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BYSRI. P.V.BHAGVAN BABUS/O P.K.VENKATACHALAPATHY SETTYNO.25, YELLAPPA GANDEN,

: 13 :

10TH CROSS, MALLESWARAM,BANGALORE-560003

13. ALL INDIA AGRO SEEDS,NO.19, S.C.ROADANANDA RAO CIRCLE,BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BYSRI. P.K.RAMACHANDRA GUPTA,S/O P.KRISHNA SHETTY,D.NO.37/1, S.B.ROAD, 2ND FLOOR,V.V.PURAM, BANGALORE-560003.

14. PADMA AGRO SEEDS,G-3, BRIGADE PLAZA,S.C.ROAD, ANAND RAO CIRCLE,BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BYSRI. VENKATESH S.N.S/O S.V.NAGARAJA SHETTY,R.V.ROAD, D. NO.95,BASAWANAGUDI, BANGALORE-560004.

15. NEW KARNATAKA SEEDSNO.G-4, BRIGADE PLAZA, A.A.CIRCLES.C.ROAD, BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BYSRI. M.RAMACHANDRAPPA,S/O ALTE K.MUNISHAMAPAD.NO.521, 4TH CROSS, 2ND BLOCK,R.T.NAGAR, BANGALORE-560032.

16. SRINIVASA AGRO SEEDS,NO.2, TRINETRA MARKET,III MAIN ROAD, N.T.PET,BANGALORE-560002,REPRESENTED BYD.V.MANOHARA GUPTA,S/O ALTE D.V.S.GUPTANO.62, RAM IYENGAR ROAD,

: 14 :

V.V.PURAM, BANGALORE-560004.

17. SAMRUDHI AGRO CENTRE,NO.217/4, 3RD MAIN ROAD,N.T.PET, BANGALORE-560002,REPRESENTED BYSRI. B.L.MURALI KRISHNA,S/O LATE B.S.LAKSHMINARAYANA SETTY,NO.28, SAMRUDHIPUTTANNA ROAD, BASAVANAGUDI,BANGALORE-560004.

18. SRINIVASA AGRO CORPORATION,NO.2/11, TRINETRA MARKET,3RD MAIN ROAD, N.T.PETBANGALORE-560002.REPRESENTED BYP.USHA SATHYAN,W/O P.R.SATHYANARAYANA SETTY.

19. UNITED AGRO SEEDS,NO.3/4, 3RD MAIN ROAD,N.R.TPET, BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BY ITSL.C.RAVISHANAKR,NO.14, RANGA RAO ROAD,SHANKARAPURAM,BANGALORE-560004.

20. SRI. BALAJI AGRO SEEDS,NO.2/7, TRINETRA MARKET,3RD MAIN ROAD, N.T.PET.BANGALORE-560002,REPRESENTED BYSRI. K.NARAYANA GUPTA, NO.2/7TRINETRA MARKET, 3RD MAIN ROAD,N.T.PET, BANGALORE-560002.

: 15 :

21. ARUL AGRO CENTER,NO.88/1, I FLOOR,3RD MAIN ROAD, N.T.PET,BANGALORE-560002,REPRESENTED BYSRI. A.ANBALUGAN,NO.88/1, I FLOOR, 3RD MAIN ROAD,N.T.PET, BANGALORE-560002. ...PETITIONERS

(By SRI. S.K.V.CHALAPATHY & K.N.SRINIVASA, ADVS.,)

A N D :

1. UNION OF INDIA,REPRESENTED BY JOINT SECRETARY(PLANT PRODUCTION),MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTUREAND CO.OPERATION, KRISHI BHAVAN,NEW DELHI 110 001.

2. DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA, SHESHADRI ROAD, BANGALORE-01. ...RESPONDENTS

(BY SHRI. S.N.ASHWATHANARAYANA, CGSC FOR R1 SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADV., FOR R2)

THIS WP FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF

CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE

AMENDED RULE 10 UNDER ANN-A AND B IN SO FAR AS IT

RELATES TO PRESCRIBING THE FEES OF RS.500 FOR

EVERY INSECTICIDE FOR GRANT OR RENEWAL OF

LICENCE SUBJECT TO A MAXIMUM OF RS.7,500/-.

- - - - - - - - - -

: 16 :

IN W.P. NO.8367/2000

BETWEEN

1. SRI. NEW CHANNAVEERA AGROAGENCY, FILTERBED ROADGULBARGA.PROP: CHANNABASAPPAS/O: VEERANNA SIRGONDAGE: 26 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS

2. VIJAYA AGRO AGENCY,GUNJ ROAD, GULBARGAPROP: MADIVALAPPA S/O: NINGAPPAHENDI, AGE: 35 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS

3. LAXMI AGRO SUPPLIERS,GUNJ, BUS STAND, HBD ROAD,PROP: R V PRAKASH,S/O R V VENKATARAMAIAHAGE: 45 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS,

4. ANAND TRADING COMPANY,NEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGAPROP: GOPAL RAO,S/O NARAYANARAO KHAMITKARAGE:45 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS.

5. ANAND TRADERS,NEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGAPROP: MADHUSUDAN S/O GOPAL RAOKHAMITKAR,AGE: 23 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS

6. MRITYUNJAYA TRADERS,PROP: SOMASHEKAR G NADKATTIAGE: 55, OCC: BUSINESS

: 17 :

7. JAJEE AGRO AGENCY,KIRANA BAZAR, GULBARGA.PARTNER, VIJAYAKUMAR,S/O PRABHAKAR JAJEE,AGE: 45 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS,

8. PRABHUDEV AGRO AGENCY,GUNJ, GULBARGA.PROP: NAGARAJS/O SHANKARGOUDA PATILAGE: 25 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS,

9. KEDARNATH JAJEE,S/O KASHAPPA JAJEE,KIRANA BAZAR, GULBARGA, MNG. PT.,KEDARNATH JAJEE, AGE: 45 YEARS,OCC: BUSINESS

10. JAJEE PESTICIDES,RAGHUJI BUILDING, FILTERBED ROADGULBARGA, MNG. PT. K.K.JAJEE,AGE: 45 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS,

11. KRISHNA FERTILIZERS & PESTICIDES,GUNJ, GULBARGA, PROP: V AMARNATH,S/O A V PADMANABHA GUPTA,AGE: 42 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS

12. VEERABHADRESHWARA AGRO ASSOCIATES,GUNJ, GULBARGA, MNG. PT.,SANGANNA,S/O CHANDRASHEKHAR PATIL,AGE: 42, OCC: BUSINESS

13. M/S CLASSIC PESTICIDES,NEHRU GUNJ, OPP: SBH,GULBARGA, MNG. PARTNER,SIDDANNA S/O KASIRAYA BIRADAR,AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS

: 18 :

14. SRI. SAI NIDHI ENTERPRISES, GUNJ,OPP: SBH, GULBARGA,PROP: VEERANNA,S/O KASIRAYA BIRADAR,AGE: 37, OCC: BUSINESS

15. JYOTHI AGRO TRADERS,BIYANI COMPLEX, GUNJ,MAIN ROAD, GULBARGA,PROP: CHANDRASHEKHAR,S/O SIDRAMAPPA TALLALLI,AGE: 47 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS

ALL ARE RESIDENTS OF GULBARGATQ. & DIST: GULBARGA. ...PETITIONERS

(By SRI. N.P.VIVEKMEHTA, ADVOCATE)

AND

1. UNION OF INDIA,BY ITS SECRETARY,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE ANDCO.OPERATION, (KRISHI BHAVAN),DR RAJENDRAPRASAD ROAD.NEW DELHI.

2. DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,K.R.CIRCLE, BANGALORE. ...RESPONDENTS

(BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADVOCATE FOR R2)

THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DECLARE THATRULE 10(2)(a) OF THE INSECTICIDE (AMENDED) RULE,1999 AS UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND ARBITRARY.

- - - - - - - - - -

: 19 :

IN W.P. NO.9395/2000

BETWEEN

1. D.CHANDRASHEKHAR,DIBBADAHALLI AGRO SERVICESCHAMARAJPET, DAVANGERE 577 001

2. H P SHEETHAL PRASAD,PARSHWANATH AGRO AGENCIES,DISTRIBUTOR FOR SEEDS & PESTICIDES,BEHIND N.R.ROAD, JAIN TEMPLE,DAVANGERE 577 001.

3. K H KESHAVAMURTHY,MAJOR, PRESIDENT OF DAVANGERE DIST.PESTICIDE FERTILIZERS AND SEEDDEALER ASSOCIATION, DAVANGERE.

4. S V NELIVIGI,SHRUTHI AGRO AGENCIESDISTRIBUTORS:SANDOZ (I)LTD, BOMBAY, MAHAVEER ROADDAVANGERE.

5. B M GANESHAN,KANCHAN HYBRID SEED CO.,DISTRIBUTORS:SEED AND PESTICIDESMAHAVEER ROAD, DAVANGERE 577 001.

6. NARYAN C KULKARNISHAKTHI AGRO AGENCIES276/1, CHAMARAJPETBESIDE BALAGAVI COMPLEXDAVANGERE 577 001

7. PRATAPARUDRA,PROPRIETOR,SIDDALINGESHWARA AGRO AGENCIES181/2, NARASARAJA ROAD,

: 20 :

DAVANGERE 577 001.

8. G S PRAKASHCHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTORKALPATARU SEED PVT LTD.,206/6, MAHAVEER ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

9. G S PRAKASHPROPRIETORAGRO HYBRID SEEDS CORPORATIONDR.NAGANAGOWDA BUILDINGOLD HOSPITAL ROADDAVANGERE 577 001

10. G S PRAKASHCHAIRMAN & MANAGING DIRECTORAKSHAY AGRO SALES PVT LTD206/6, MAHAVEER ROADDAVANGERE 577 001

11. K P KRISHNAMURTHYVENKATAKRISHNA TADERS206/3A, MAHAVEER ROADDAVANGERE 577 001

12. G SHIVANNAKAAMADENU SEEDS AND AGROCHEMICAL CORPORATIONP.B.ROAD, DAVANGERE 577 001.

13. T M GIRISH, PRORPEITOR,GURU RENUKA AGRO CENTRE,NO.291/1, CHAMARAJPET,DAVANGGERE-577 001.

14. LION B H RAMESH BHAWAN,SAHANA AGRO AGENCY,179/13, N.R.ROAD,

: 21 :

DAVANGERE-577 001,

15. G M INDUMATHI, PROPIETOR,SREE MALLIKARJUNA SEEDS ANDAGRO CHEMICALS CORP. AUTHORISEDDEALER, E.I.D PARRY (INDIA) LTDMAHAVEER ROAD, DAVANGERE-577 001.

16. B O UDAYKUMAR, PROPRIETOR,HANUMANAHALLI AGRO AGENCIES169/C,NARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE-577 001.

17. B V VIJAYKUMAR, PROPRIETOR,VENKATESHWARA SEED CENTRE,NO.173/3, NARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE-577 001.

18. C KRISHNA, PROPRIETOR,VIKAS HYBRID SEEDS,6/202/1, NARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE.

19. PRADEEP N NEELGUND,PROPRIETOR,MANDARA AGRO NEEDS,179/11, NEXT TO KARUR VYSYA BANK,NARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE-577 001.

20. K JAGADEESHWAR,KAVALAHALLI AGRO AGENCIES,NEW BAMBOO BAZAR ROAD,DAVANGERE-577 001.

21. G B CHANDRASHEKHARA,PROPRIETOR,SREE KOTTURESHWARA AGRO AGENCIES,106/7B, R.M.C LINK ROAD,

: 22 :

DAVANGERE-577 001.

22. A GANGADHARAPPA,PROPRIETOR,SREE ANANBERU RANGANATH AGRO,AGENCIES, K.R.ROAD,SHYAMANUR SHIVAPPA COMPLEX,DAVANGERE-577 001.

23. T R DEVENDRAPPA,DEEPA AGRO CORPORATION,K.R.ROAD, DAVANGERE 577 001.

24. U S REVANASIDDAIAHPROPRIETORMALALKERE AGRO AGENCIESDAVANGERE 577 002

25. KAMALAKAR, VERNEKARENTERPRISES, MANDIPETDAVANGERE 577 001.

26. KAMALAKAR, VERNEKARAGRO FERTILIZERS, MANDIPET,DAVANGERE 577 001,

27. V G NAGARAJ, PROPRIETOR,MANJUNATHA AGRO AGENCIES,MANDIPET. DAVANGERE-577 001.

28. A P NAGARAJA, PROPRIETOR,ESWAR AGRO AGENCIES,NO.64, NARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

29. SIDDAPPA N KITTR, PROPRIETOR,205/3 BOMMAJJA BUILDING,NARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

: 23 :

30. N VIJAY KUMAR,PROPRIETOR,213/4, BEHIND JAIN TEMPLE,NARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

31. SHIVANNA B M, PROPRIETORVIJAYALAKSHMI TRADING CO.,NARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

32. H E MURTHY, PROPRIEOTR,MARULASIDDESHWAR FERTILIZERSK.R.ROAD, DAVANGERE 577 001,

33. RAJU Y G, PROPRIETOR,BHAGYASHREE SEED CENTRE,181/2, VYSYA BANK,NARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

34. H G LAKUSH, PROPRIETOR,SUNEEL FERTILIZERS,179/12, NEXT TO KARUR VYSYA BANK,NARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

35. P VIJAY KUMAR, PROPRIETOR,VIJAY AGRO CHEMICALS AND SEEDSNARASARAJ ROADDAVANGERE 577 001

36. D B RAGHUNANDAN, PROPRIETOR,SAMRUDHI AGRO CENTRE,173/4, NARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

37. H K RAVI,SHIVAKUMAR RAVI FERTILIZERS,

: 24 :

NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE 577 001.

38. C M JAYAPPA,GURUBASAVA AGRO AGENCY,NARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

39. G H SUKUMAR, PROPRIETORGUMMANUR SRI CHANNABASAVESHWARAAGRO AGENCIES, 219/10, NARASARA ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001,

40. M BANIDA,BETUR MARADI KRUSHI SAMPATHU,222/1, NARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

41. J B BHAKTAVATSALAM,PROPRIETOR,284/1, MAHAVEER ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

42. B M UVAYA KUMAR, PROPRIETOR,BALEHOLADA AGRO AGENCIES,219/13, NARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

43. GNENISH NAIK,SWASTIK SEEDS CO.,CHAMARAJENDRA, CIRCLE,MAHAVEER ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

44. G E MAHANTESH, PROPRIETOR,CHETANA SEEDS CENTREOLD HOSPITAL ROAD,(NEAR CHAMARAJENDRA CIRCLE)DAVANGERE 577 001.

: 25 :

45. K H KESHAVAMURTHY, PROPRIETOR,MARUTI AGRO FERTILIZERS,CHAMARAJPET, DAVANGERE 577 001.

46. S J SREEDHAR,SRINIDHI AGRO CHEMICALS,275/2C, BELAGAVI COMPLEX,CHAMARAJPET, DAVANGERE 577 001.

47. H A GIRISH, PROPRIETOR,BALAJI AGRO AGENCIES,378/1 CHAMARAJPET,DAVANGERE 577 001.

48. B A KOTRESHAPPA,PROPRIETOR,KOTTURESHWARA TRADERS,NARASARAJA ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

49. G K ARVIND KUMAR,PROPRIETOR,BANASHANKARI AGRO AGENCIES,688, NARASARAJA ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

50. K A VISHWANATH,KARNATAKA AGRO FERTILIZERS,689/2, VEERESH NILAYA,NEAR GANESHA TEMPLE,NARASARAJA ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

51. T S SANKAPPA, PROPRIETOR,PRASHANTH AGRO FERTILIZERS,N.R.ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

52. V BASAVARAJAPPA,VENKATESHWARA AGRO FERTILIZERS,

: 26 :

K.R.ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

53. B K KUBERAPPA,BHAVIHAL KALLESHWARA AGRO CENTRE,OPP. KSRTC BUS STAND,A-3, PB ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

54. G JAYAPRAKASH, PROPRIEOTRSRI RAGHAVENDRA TRADINGCOMPANY, DAVANGERE 577 001.

55. KUMAR AGRO AGENCIES,217/2, NARASARAJA ROAD,DAVANGERE 577001.

56. K V JAYADEVAPPA, PROPRIEOTRVEERABHADRESHWARA AGRO AGENCIES,211/A-3, NARASARAJA ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

57. PRORPIETOR,SREE BASAVESHWARA AGRO CENTRE,CHAMARAJAPET, DAVANGERE-577 001,

58. N G SWAMY, PROPRIETOR,VISHWABANDHU FERTILIZERS,K.R.ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

59. M SHADAKAPPA, PROPRIETOR,SREE NANDI AGRO FERTILIZERS,145/2E, K.R.ROAD,DAVANGERRE 577 001.

60. D J HALESHI,BASAVESHWARA AGRO AGENCIES,K.R.ROAD, DAVANGERE 577 001.

: 27 :

61. M SATYANARAYAN,DIVYABHIRAMI AGENCIES,NO.323/5, CHIGATERI COMPOUND,OLD HOSPITAL ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

62. H N SHIVAKUMAR, PROPRIETOR,SREE SIDDESWARA SEEDS CENTRE,133/1, K.R.ROAD, DAVANGERE 577 001

63. G LAXMIDEVI, PROPRIETOR,SINGRIHALLI AGRO FERTILIZERS,NARASARAJA ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

64. R G BADARINATHA, PROPRIETOR,SRIKAR AGENCIES,242/A, NEAR HASABAVI CIRCLE,CHAMARAJPET,DAVANGERE 577 001.

65. B CHIDANAND, PROPRIETOR,SEEDS CENTRE,MAHAVEER ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001.

66. K JAYACHANDRAPPA,DEEPA AGRO AGENCIES,K.R.ROAD, DAVANGERE 577 001. ...PETITIONERS

(BY SRI. B.N.SHIVANNA, ADVOCATE)

A N D

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,REPRESENTED BY ITS SECY,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE,M.S.BUILDING, BANGALORE-1

: 28 :

2. THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OFAGRICULTURE, SESHADRI ROADBANGALORE-1.

3. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE, THE LICENCING AUTHORITYOF INSECTICIDE PESTICIDE, RUNGICIDEAND SEEDS, SITTING IN CHITRADURGACOVERING ENTIRE DAVANGEREAND CHITRADURGA

4. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE, DAVANGERE TALUKDAVANGERE.

5. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE, DAVANGERE TALUKDAVANGERE DISTRICT. ...RESPONDENTS


THIS WP FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TOQUASH THEIMPUGNED ORDER VIDE ANN-A DT. 12.1.2000 BY R5UNDER THE DIRECTION BY R3; AND DIRECT R3 TORENEW THE PETITIONERS LICENCE PAYMENT OFRS.30.00.

- - - - - - - - - - - -

IN W.P.NO.9867/2000

BETWEEN

1. LAKSHMI TRADING CO.,NO.10, 3RD CROSS,S.C.ROAD, BANGALORE-560009,REPRESENTED BY SRI. SHEKAR BABU.

: 29 :

2. KOMANNA SEEDS,CARNATGON ROAD,BANGARPET,REPRESENTED BYSRI. M.PERUMAL.

3. SREE MANJUNATHA ENTERPRISES,KADUGODI MAIN ROAD,BANGALORE-560067.REPRESENTED BY SRI. M.R.NATARAM.

4. AKSHAYA AGRO SEEDS PVT LTD.,NO.7, POOJA COMPLEX,3RD MAIN, CHAMARAJPET,BANGALORE-560018.REPRESENTED BYSRI. S.C.MURTHY.

5. INDIAN HYBRID SEEDS CONO.72, KALASIPALYAM MAIN ROADBANGALORE-560002,REPRESENTED BYSYED REHAMATHULLA

6. SRI VINAYAKA AGRO TRADERS,NO.2/9, TRINETRA MARKET,3RD MAIN, N.T.PET,BANGALORE-560002.REPRESENTED BYSRI. S.V.MURALIDHAR

7. INDUSTRIES AND CHEMICALSNO.2/1, TRINETRA COMPLEX3RD MAIN, N.T.PET,BANGALORE-560002REPRESENTED BYSRI S.V.MURALIDHAR

8. MAHESHWARA ENTERPRISESNO.4/1, 3RD MIAN ROAD

: 30 :

N.T.PET, BANGALORE-560002,REPRESENTED BYSRI. N.MALLIKARJUN

9. S.R.AGRO SALES,NO.36/1, NARASIMHARAJA ROAD,OOSMARIA BUILDING,BANGALORE.REPRESENTED BY SHAHTAJ BEGUM.

10. A.R.SHARIFF AND SONS,NO.15, NARASIMHARAJA ROAD,BANGALORE.REPRESENTED BYBASHEER AHMED SHARIFF.

11. SRINIVASA AGRO AGENCIES,NO.18, N.R.ROAD,BANGALORE-2,REPRESENTED BYSRI. S.S.SHESHADRI.

12. MERUT AGRO CHEMICALSNO.18, N.R.ROADBANGALORE-560002.REPRESENTED BYSRI VENKATESH

13. KARNATAKA PESTICIDESAND AGENCIES,NO.18, N.R.ROADBANGALORE-560002.REPRESENTED BY GAYATHRI

14. SRI RAMA AGENCIES,NO.18, N.R.ROAD,BANGALORE-560002,REPRESENTED BYSRI. S.SHESHADRI

: 31 :

15. SRINIVASA FERTILIZERS,CHELUR ROAD,CHINTAMANI 563 125,REPRESENTED BYSRI. N.NAGIREDDY

16. SHANKAR FERTILIZERS,FERTILIZE DEALER,CHELUR RAOD,CHINTAMANI-563125.REPRESENTED BYSRI. D.GOPALA REDDY.

17. S.L.V. TRADERS,CHELUR ROAD,CHINTAMANI-563125.REPRESENTED BYSRI. R.D.KRISHNA

18. SREE MAHANANDI SEEDS ANDPESTICIDES,NO.2, A.P.M.C COMPLEX,2ND WARD, CHELUR ROAD,CHINTAMANI, KOLAR DISTRICT.REPRESENTED BYSRI. N.NARAYANA SWAMY

19. SRI VANI TRADERS,CHELUR ROAD, A.P.M.C YARD,CHINTAMANI-563125,REPRESENTED BYSRI. V.NARAYANASWAMY

20. I.N.R. SEEDS & PESTICIDES,CHELUR ROAD,CHINTAMANI-563125,REPRESENTED BYSRI. N.SRINIVASA REDDY.

: 32 :

21. RAITHABANDHU TRADERS,CHELUR ROAD,CHINTAMANI-563125.REPRESENTED. BYSRI. K.R.SRINIVASA REDDY

22. RAJANI TRADERS,NEAR WOOD LANDS, M.G.ROAD,CHINTAMAI-563125.REPRESENTED BYSRI. K.S.AUJAPPA

23. MARUTHI FERTILIZERS,CHELUR ROAD,CHINTAMANI,REPRESENTED BYSRI. B.K.CHANDRA MOHAN

24. SRI. VIJAY AGRO TRADERS,GAJANANA CIRCLE, M.G.ROAD,CHINTAMANI-563125,REPRESENTED BYSRI. R.RAMESH BABU.

25. Y.C.A. TRADERS,FERTILIZER TRADERS,M.G.ROAD,CHINTAMANI-563 125.REPRESENTED BYSRI. Y.L.ADINARAYANA SETTY.

26. RAGHURAM SEEDS AND FERTILIZERS,CHELUR,CHINTAMANI-563125,REPRESENTED BYSRI. VENKATA RAMANA SETTY

27. LAKSHMI TRADERS,NO.14, STADIUM COMPLEX,

: 33 :

DOUBLE ROAD, CHINTAMANI.REPRESENTED BYSRI. C.SHIVANNA

28. VIJAYA LAKSHMI SEEDS,OPP. BUS STAND,CHINTAMANI,REPRESENTED BYSRI. GOVINDA REDDY

29. KALPRARUKSHA TRADERS,CHELUR ROAD, CHINTAMANI.REPRESENTED BYSRI. D.S.MALLIKARJUN

30. C.NAGARAJ,DEALERS IN FERTILIZERSPESTICIDES & SEEDS,OLD BUS STAND,DODDABALLAPUR-561203.REPRESENTED BYSRI. C.NAGARAJ.

31. G GOVINDARAJDEALERS IN FERTILIZERSSEEDS AND AGRO CHEMICALSOLD BUS STANDDODDABALLAPUR-561203.REPRESENTED BYSRI. G.GOVINDARAJU

32. SAPTAGIRI TRADERS,PADMA COMPLEX,OPP. POST OFFICE,B.B.ROAD, YELAHANKA-560064.REPRESENTED BYSRI. H.G.SRINVASA. ...PETITIONERS

(BY SRI. S.K.V. CHALAPATHY & K.N.SREENIVAS, ADVS.,)

: 34 :

A N D :

1. UNIOIN OF INDIA,REPRESENTED BY JT SECRETARY(PLANT PRODUCTION)MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTUREAND CO.OPERATION,KRISHI BHAVAN, NEW DELHI 110 001

2. THE DIRECTOR,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE,GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA,SESHADRI ROAD, BANGALORE. ...RESPONDENTS

(BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADV., FOR R2)

THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THEAMENDED RULE 10 UNDER ANX.A AND B IN SO FAR AS ITRELATES TO PRESCRIBING THE FEES OF RS.500 FOREVERY INSECTICIDE FOR GRANT OR RENEWAL OFLICENSCE SUBJECT TO A MAXIMUM OF RS.7,500/-.

- - - - - - - - - - -

IN W.P. NO.11825/2000

BETWEEN

1. KARNATAKA STATE FERTILISERSSEEDS & PESTICIDES DEALERS'ASSOCIATION, NO.2, II FLOORIII MAIN ROAD, NEW THARAGUPET,BANGALORE-560002,BY ITS HONORARY SECYSRI. S.SHIVAKUMAR

2. SRI. G GURUSIDDAIAH, MAJOR,

: 35 :

S/O G.GURUBASAVAIAHM/S EESHA AGTEC &M/S DHAANYA GREEN TECH16 & 16/1, 9TH A MAIN, 36TH CROSS,5TH BLOCK, JAYANAGAR,BANGALORE-560041.

3. SRI PARSWANATH, MAJOR,S/O R J ANANTHARAJAIAHPROP: OMKAR AGENCIESI MAIN ROAD, NEW MANDIPETTUMKUR-572101.

4. SRI. D.NARAYANA, MAJOR,S/O D.VENKATARAJAIAHPROP: SRI POONAM ASSICIATESNO.93, 3RD MAIN, NEW THARAGUPET,BANGALORE-560002.

5. SRI VASANTHA A,MAJOR, S/O C K ASWATHA SETTYPROP: KUNCHAM TRADERSII MAIN ROAD, NEW MANDIPETTUMKUR

6. SRI CHANDRA BABU G.A.,MAJOR, S/O G.AYYANNAPROP: MANJU AGENCIESI MAIN ROAD, NEW MANDIPET,TUMKUR.

7. SRI SIDDAGANGAPPAMAJOR, S/O B.RUDRAPPAPROP: SRI MANJUNATHA FERTILISERSI MAIN ROAD, NEW MANDIPETTUMKUR-572101.

8. SMT MANJULA L.,MAJOR, W/O G P MUDALAGIRIPROP: M/S SRINIDHI FERTILISERS

: 36 :

SIDDIVINAYAKA VEGETABLE MARKETTUMKUR-572101.

9. SMT B S SUSHEELAMAJOR, W/O CHANDRAPPA PROP:M/S SWAMY AYYAPPA FERTILISERSI MAIN, MANDIPETTUMKUR

10. SMT NALINI NAGESH MAJOR, W/O S R NAGESH PROP: GARDEN CITY AGRICULTURAL AGENCIES, NO.292, KANAKAPURAMAIN ROAD, JAYANAGAR VII BLOCK

BANGALORE-560 082. ...PETITIONERS

(BY SRI. N.G.PHADKE & MEERA BAI, ADVOCATES)

A N D :

1. UNION OF INDIA,REPRESENTED BY JOINT SECRETARY(PLANT PROTECTION)MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE,DEPT OF AGRICULTURE & COOPERATION,KRISHI BHAVAN. NEW DELHI-110001.

2. STATE OF KARNATAKA,REPRESENTED BY ITSPRINCIPAL SECRETARY,AGRICULTURAL & HORTICULTURAL DEPT.VIDHANA SOUDHA,

BANGALORE-560001. ...RESPONDENTS

(BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADV., FOR R2)

THIS W.P. IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TOQUASH THEIMPUGNED NOTIFICATION IN G.S.R.NO.371 (E) DT. 20.5.99

: 37 :

IN SO FAR AS IT RELATES TO THE AMENDMENT OF RULE10(2) OF THE INSECTICIDES RULES, 1971.

- - - - - - - - - - - -

IN W.P.NO.21915/2000

BETWEEN

1. J M KOTRESHPROPRIETORM/S SRIGURU AGRO AGENCIESDEALER IN PESTICIDES227/1, MAHAVEER NILAYANEAR DELUXE ROADLINESNARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE 577 001

2. N G RAMAKRISHNAGENERAL MANAGERJAGANMATHA AGRO SALES PVT. LTDDEALER IN PESTICIDES323-1 0. SRI BALAJI BUILDINGBINNY COMPANY ROADDAVANGERE 577 001

3. THIPPESWAMYSUNEEL FERTILIZERSDALER IN PESTICIDES179/12, NEXT TO KARUR VYSYA BANKNARASARAJ ROADDAVANGERE

4. M S BASAVARJAPPAPROPRIETOR, BHADRA HYBRID SEEDSCOMPANY, DEALER IN PESTICIDESAGRO COMPLEX, SHOP NO.2P.B.ROAD, DAVANGERE -2

5. M K CHANDRASHEKARAPPAPROPRIETOR

: 38 :

MULLEKATTE SHIVALINGAPPA & CO.DEALER IN PESTICIDES240/1, BEHIND CHAMARAJPETDAVANGERE 577 001

6. M K CHANDRSHEKARAPPAPROPRIETORSHEKAR AGRO SERVICE CENTREDEALER IN PESTICIDESNO.240, CHAMARAJPETDAVANGERE 577 001

7. G.KRISHNAMURTHYPROPRIETORMAHALAXMI AGRO AGENCIESDEALER IN PESTICIDES173/2A, NARASARAJ ROADDAVANGERE-1

8. G.N.PATEL, PROPRIETORM/S PATEELA AGENCIESDEALER IN PESTICIDES162/2, NARASARAJ ROADDAVANGERE-1

9. V.D.LAXMESHWARPROPRIETORM/S SHRIRAM AGRO AGENCIESDEALER IN PESTICIDES221/6, ALUR BASAPPA BUILDINGNARASARAJ ROADDAVANGERE-1

10. K.H.RAMESH, PROPRIETORMARUTHI AGRO INPUTSDEALER IN PESTICIDES280/3, R.G.N. BUILDING,MAHAVEER ROAD (CHAMARAJENDRACIRCLE), DAVANGERE-1

: 39 :

11. N.B.BHUMA, PROPRIETORMYSORE SEEDS CORPORATIONDEALER IN PESTICIDES227/3, NARASARAJ ROADDAVANGERE-1.

12. R.G.MANJUNATH, PROPRIETORBASAVESWARA AGRO CENTREDEALER IN PESTICIDESCHAMARAJPET, DAVANGERE-1

13. G.THIMMAPPA, PROPRIETORG.VEERABASAOOA & CO.,DELAER IN PESTICIDESHADADI ROADDAVANGERE-1

14. K.PRASAD, PROPRIETORSREE VENAKTESHWARA AGRO FERTILISERSDEALER IN PESTICIDESDOOR NO.281/D, CHAMARAJ CIRCLEMAHAVEER ROADDAVANGERE-1

15. T.N.UMESH, PROPRIETORSRI KALLESHWARA AGRO CORPORATIONDEALER IN PESTICIDES249/2, CHAMARAJPETDAVANGERE-1

16. PRAGATI AGRO FERTILIZERSDEALER IN PESTICIDESNARASARAJ ROADDAVANGERE-1.

17. B.VIRUPAKSHA, PROPRIETORASHWINI AGRO AGENCIESDELAER IN PESTICIDES231/4,, NARASARAJ ROAD

: 40 :

DAVANGERE-1.

18. P.S.LAXMINARAYANAPROPRIETORSRI VASAVI SEEDS CENTREDEALER IN PESTICIDES283, MAHAVEER ROADDAVANGERE-1

19. S.VENAKTESH, PROPRIEOTRSRI THIRUMALA AGRO AGENCIESDEALER IN PESTICIDESCHURCH COMPLEX, K.R.ROADDAVANGERE-1

20. G.S.PRAKASH, PROPRIETORAGRO HYBRID SEEDS CORPORATIONDEALER IN PESTICIDESDR.NAGANAGOWDA BUILDINGOLD HOSPITAL ROADDAVANGERE-1

21. Y.DEVANDRAPPA, PROPRIETORVINAYAKA AGRO KENDRADEALER IN PESTICIDES201/2, NARASARAJ ROADDAVANGERE-1

22. S.V.SUBHASH, PROPRIETORSHRIRAKSHA AGRO AGENCIESDEALER IN PESTICIDES288/1-B, I FLOORCHAMARAJPETDAVANGERE-1

23. NIRMALAMMAPROPRIETOR, ADITYA AGRO AGNECIESDEALER IN PESTICIDES211/3, NARASARAJ ROADOPP. KARUR VYSYA BANK

: 41 :

DAVANGERE-1

24. K.H.NAGARAJ, PROPRIETORSRI. RENUKA AGRO AGENCIESDEALER IN PESTICIDESAPMC DEPOT NO.6OPP. NEW BUS STAND, P.B.ROADDAVANGERE-2

25. D.E.DEVENDRAPPA, PROPRIETORSRINIDHI SEEDS CENTREDEALER IN PESTICIDES284, MAHAVEER RAODDAVANGERE-1

26. M.H.NIJANANANDA, PROPRIEOTRAGRO INDUSTRIAL CORP.,DEALER IN PESTICIDESPSOT BOX NO.85MANDIPET, DAVANGERE-1

27. B.R.SRINIVAS, PROPRIETORGOVARDHAN AGRO AGENCIESDEALER IN PESTICIDES195/1, NARASARAJ ROADDAVANGERE-1 ...PETITIONERS


AND

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE,M.S.BUILDING, BANGALORE-560001.

2. THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OF

: 42 :

AGRICLTURE, SESHADRI ROAD,BANGALORE-560001.

3. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE, THE LICENCINGAUTHORITY OF INSECTICIDE, PESTICIDEFUNGICIDE AND SEEDSSITTING IN CHITRADURGA COVERINGENTIRE DAVANGERE ANDCHITRADURGA DISTRICTS.

4. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE,DAVANGERE TALUK,DAVANGERE DISTRICT.

5. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OFAGRICUTLURE,DAVANGERE TALUK,DAVANGERE DISTRICT. ...RESPONDENTS


THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DIRECT THE R3 TORENEW THE LICENCE BY TAKING RS. 30/- TO CARRY ALLCOMPANIES INSECTICIDE BUSINESS AND QUASH VIDEANX. A DT. 12.1.2000 ISSUED BY THE R5 UNDER THEDIRECTION BY R3.

- - - - - - - - -

IN W.P. NO.22311/2000

BETWEEN

1. K SRINIVASALU, PROPRIETORABHILASH AGRO SEEDSDELAER IN PESTICIDESMUNICIPAL STALL NO.9

: 43 :

DOUBLE ROADBELLARY 583 101

2. D S MALLIKARJUNA, PROPRIETORANUPAMA AGENCIESDEALER IN PESTICIDESOPP:KSRTC BUS STANDDOUBLE ROADBELLARY 583 101

3. K RAMAPPA, PROPRIETORUSHA AGRO SEEDSDEALER IN PESTICIDESMUNICIPAL STAL NO.3DOUBLE ROADBELLARY 583 101

4. D HANUMANTHARAO, PROPRIETORSRI. VIJAYALAKSHMI AGRO SEEDS,DEALERS IN PESTICIDESMUNICIPAL STALL NO.14,DOUBLE ROAD,BELLARY 583 101

5. B V MUKKANAN, PROPRIETORASHOK AGRO SEED SUPPLIESDEALERS IN PESTICIDESK.C.ROAD, BELLARY 583 101

6. E R MOHAN, PROPRIETORANANDATHA HYBRID SEEDSDEALERS IN PESTICIDES2-A, K.C.ROADBELLARY 583 101

7. D BALIREDDI, PROPRIETORSHREE SIDDESHWARA AGENCIESDEALERS IN PESTICIDESMEENAKSHI COMPLEXSHOP NO.1, K.C.ROAD

: 44 :

BELLARY 583 101

8. T NAGESHWARRAO, PROPRIETORSARITHA AGRO SEEDSDEALERS IN PESTICIDESMEENAKSHI LODGE STALL,STALL NO.7, K.C.ROADBELLARY 583 101 ...PETITIONERS


AND

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,REPRESENTED BY ITS SECY,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE,M.S.BUILDING, BANGALORE-560001.

2. THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OFAGRICULTURE, SESHADRI ROADBANGALORE-560001.

3. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE THE LICENCING AUTHORITYOF INSECTICIDE, PESTICIDE, FUNGICIDEAND SEEDS, SITTING IN BELLARYCOVERING ENTIREBELARY DISTRICT.

4. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, BELLARY TALUK, BELLARY DISTRICT.

5. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, BELLARY TALUK, BELLARY DISTRICT. ...RESPONDENTS

(By SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADVOCATE)

: 45 :

THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDERVIDE ANNEX.A. DT. ISSUED BY R5 UNDER THEDIRECTION BY THE R3; AND DIRECT R3 TO RENEW THELICENSE OF PETITIONER NO.1 TO 8 BY TAKING RS. 30/-.

- - - - - - - - -

IN W.P. NO.32144/2000

BETWEEN

CHINTAMANI TALUK AGRICULTURALMARKETING CO-OP SOCIETY LTD,CHINTAMANI, KOLAR DISTRICT,BY ITS SERCRETARY,SRI. K.V.NARASIMHA MURTHY,S/O VENKATARAYAPPA, MAJOR. ...PETITIONER

(BY SRI Y.R.SADASIVA REDDY, ADVOCATE)

AND

1. UNION OF INDIA,REPRESENTED BY ITSJOINT SECRETARY (PLANT PRODUCTION),MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE &COOPERATION, KRISHI BHAVAN,NEW DELHI-110001.

2. THE DIRECTOR,DEPARTMEN TOF AGRICULTURE,GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA,SESHADRIPURAM,BANGALORE-560020. ...RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. ASHOK HARANAHALLI, ADVOCATE FOR R1

: 46 :

SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADV., FOR R2)

THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH VIDE ANX.A AND B IN SO FAR AS IT RELATES TO PRESCRIBING THEFEES OF RS.500 FOR EVERY INSECTICIDES FOR GRANTOR RENEWAL OF LICENCE SUBJECT TO A MAXIMUM OFRS.7,500/-.

- - - - - - - - - -

IN W.P. NO.3880/2000

BETWEEN

K H KESHAVAMURTHY,MAJOR, PRESIDENT OFDAVANGERE DISTRICTPESTICIDE FERTILISERS AND SEEDDEALERS ASSOCIATION,DAVANGERE. ...PETITIONER


AND

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE,M.S.BUILDING, BANGALORE 560 001

2. THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OFAGRICULTURE, SESHADRIPURAMROAD, BANGALORE-1

3. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF

: 47 :

AGRICULTURE, DAVANGERE TALUK,DISTRICT: DAVANGERE.

4. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE, DAVANGERE TALUK,DISTRICT: DAVANGERE.

5. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOROF AGRICULTURE, DAVANGERE,TALUK: DAVANGERE,DISTRICT: DAVANGERE. ...RESPONDENTS


THIS WP FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THEIMPUGNED ORDER VIDE ANN-A DT. 12.1.2000 BY R5.

- - - - - - - - - - -

IN W.P. NO.433/2001

BETWEEN

1. K SUBBA RAO, PROP:SRI GURUDATTA ENTERPRISESCHAMARAJPET, DAVANAGERE

2. R P M GOVARDAN, PROP:M/S SREE RAMANJANEYA FARM SUPPLIESDEALERS IN FERTILISERS & INSECTICIDES32/1, BANGALORE ROAD,BELLARY-583 101.

3. B V VALLABAI PATEL, PROP:M/S SRI MANJUNATHA AGRO SEEDSUPPLIES, NO.105/2, 16TH WARDBANGALORE ROADBELLARY-583 101

: 48 :

4. B VALLABAI PATEL, PROP:M/S SRI MANJUNATHA AGRO SEEDSUPPLIES, NO.16/2, 9TH WARDBANGALORE ROADBELLARY-583 101

5. B KANAKA REDDY, PROP:M/S SRI VENKATADRI ENTERPRISESSTALL NO.15,OPP: NATARAJA THEATREDOUBLE ROAD, BELLARY

6. S D CHANNEGOWDA, PROP:M/S AMARESHWARA AGRO AGENCIES108/XVI, KRISHNACHARI ROADBELLARY-583101.

7. SHANTHI TRADING CO.,KHANIS COMPLEX, NEARPROP: TALED, RADHAKRISHNA ROADBELLARY, VIJAYAKUAMR TALEDBELLARY

8. SRI MANJUNATH AGRO CENNTREPANCHAJANYA COMPLEX101/B, K.R.ROADDAVANAGERE.

9. SRI. TARALABALU AGRO SERVICE,DOOR NO.101/B, K R ROAD,DAVANAGERE-1.

10. NATIONAL CHEMICALS & FERTILIZERS, NO.306, III MAIN, N T PET, BANGALORE-2.

11. DHANDDEVI TRADERS, PROP: DHANRAJ JAIN, PESTICIDES DEALERS MAIN ROAD, GANGAVATHI

: 49 :

KOPPAL.

12. SREELAKHA AGENCIES, PROP: M BALAIAH, K.C.ROAD, BELLARY. ...PETITIONERS

(BY SRI. B.N.SHIVANNA, C.C.NARAYANA, ADVOCATES)

AND

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE,M.S.BUILDING, BANGALORE-1.

2. THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OFAGRICULTURE, SESHADRI ROAD,BANGALORE-9.

3. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE THE LICENSING AUTHORITYOF INSECTICIDE, PESTICIDE, FUNGICIDEAND SEEDS, SITTING IN BELLARY.COVERING ENTIRE BELLARY DISTRICT

4. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE BANGALORE RURAL& URBAN DIST THE LICENSING AUTHORITYOF INSECTICIDES, PESTICIDES,BANGALORE.

5. JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,BANGALORE RURAL AND URBAN DIST.

6. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE, DAVANAGERE TALUK,DAVANAGERE DISTRICT.

7. THE ASST DIRECTOR OF

: 50 :

AGRICULTUREBELLARY DIST., BELLARY. ...RESPONDENTS


THIS WP FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DIRECT THE R3 TORENEW THE PETITIONER LICENCE BY TAKING RS.30/-;AND QUASH THE IMPUGNED ORDER VIDE ANN-A ISSUEDBY R3.

- - - - - - - - -

IN W.P. No.194/2002

BETWEEN

1. DAVULURI RADHAKRISHNA MURTHYPROPRIETOR,SRINIVASA AGRO CHEMICALSD.NO. 97/4, (L) WARD XVIKRISHNAMACHARI RAODBELLARY 583 101

2. K MANIKYAM, PROPRIEOTRM/S. ASHWINI AGRO CHEMICALSD.NO. 212/3, COMMING ROADOPP PANDURANGA TEMPLEBELLARY 583 101

3. P BASAVANA GOUDA, PROPRIETORSREE GURU KATTE BASAWESHWARAFERTILISERS AND CHEMICALSCAR STREET NEARKANEEKAL BUSSTANDBELLARY 583 101

4. BASAVANAGOUDA SPROPRIETORSAGAR AGRO AGENCIES

: 51 :

STALL N.2 G.S. COMPLEX,K.C. ROADBELLARY 583 101

5. H SHIVA KUMAR, PROPRIETORGANGADHAR AGENCIESD.NO. 90, WARD NO. XIVK.C. ROAD BELLARY 588 101

6. G INATHAREDDY, PROPRIETORSREE KRISHNA TRADING COHAVINAHAL SHARANAPAP COMPELXBALAJIRAO ROADBELLARY 583 101

7. P HANUMANTHA REDDYPROPRIETORLAKSHMIVENKATESHWARA TRADERSOPP ADB BANKNEAR KSRTC BUS STANDBELLARY 583 101

8. Y ESWARA RAO PROPRIETORANNAPURA AGRO AGENCIESK.C. ROADBELLARY 583 101. ...PETITIONERS

(BY SRI B.N.SHIVANNA & C.C.NARAYANA, ADVOCATES)

AND

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE,M.S. BUILDING,BANGALORE-560001.

2. THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OF

: 52 :

AGRICULTURE, SESHADRI ROAD,BANGALORE-560001.

3. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,THE LICENSING AUTHORITY OFINSECTICIDE, PESTICIDE FUNGICIDEAND SEEDS, SITTING IN BELLARYCOVERING ENTIRE, BELLARY DISTRICT.

4. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF AGRILBELLARY TALUK, BELLARY DISTRICT.

5. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE, BELLARY TALUK,BELLARY DISTRICT. ...RESPONDENTS


THIS WP FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THEIMPUGNED ORDER VIDE ANN-A DT. IN NO. ISSUED BYTHE FIFTH RESPONDENT UNDER THE DIRECTION BY R3;AND DIRECT R3 TO RENEW THE LICENSE OF PETITIONERNO.1 TO 8 BY TAKING RS.30/-.

- - - - - - - - - - -

IN W.P. NO.13838/2002

BETWEEN

1. PRAKASH AGRO AGENCIESFILTER BED ROAD UDNOOR COMPLEXNEHRU GUNJ GULBARGABY ITS PROPRIETORPRAKASH K SUTARAGE:32 YEARS

2. M/S. NAGARAJ AGRO AGENCYFILTERBED ROAD

: 53 :

GULBARGA BY ITS PROPRIETORSRI. NAGENDRAPPA TADKALAGE:40 YEARS

3. MAHAVEER AGRO SERVICE CENTRENEHRU GUNJ GULBARGABY ITS PROPRIETORPADMARAJ VARDHAMANAGE:32 YEARS. ...PETITIONERS

(BY SRI. SHARANABASSAPPA K.BABSHETTY, ADVOCATE)

AND

1. UNION OF INDIA,BY ITS SECRETARY,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE,AND CO.OPERATION (KRISHI BHAVAN)DR. RAJENDRA PRASAD ROAD,NEW DELHI.

2. DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,K.R.CIRCLE, BANGALORE. ...RESPONDENTS

(BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADV., FOR R2)(R1-SD)

THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DECLARE THATRULE 10(2) (a) OF THE INTECTICIDE (AMENDED) RULES,1999 AS UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND ARBITRARY.

: 54 :

In W.P. No.17712/2002

BETWEEN

1. SRI.S M BASAVARAJAPROPRIETOR, AGE: 42 YEARS,M/S. ANNAPURANA AGRO AGENCIES,SHOP NO.01, S LINGANNA COMPLEX,CAR STREET, BELLARY – 583 101

2. SRI.A KRISHNAPROPRIETOR, AGE: 38 YEARS,M/s. SREE LAKSHMI VENKATESHWARA TRADERS,59/1, 11TH WARD CAR – STREET,BELLARY – 583 101.

3. SRI.J HARINATHAGE: 44 YEARSS/O J BHEEMAPPA SHETTY,PROPRIETOR,M/s.HARI CHEMICALS AND FERTILISERS,D.NO.32, WARD NO.7TH,

OPP.NAGARESWARA TEMPLE,BANGALORE ROAD,BELLARY – 583 101.

4. SRI. M M ULLAGADDIPROPRIETOR, AGE: 49 YEARS,M/s.VISHWARADYA AGRO SUPPLIESD NO.48, WARD NO.11,DODDABASAVESWARA COMPLEX,CAR – STREET, BELLARY – 583 101.

5. SRI.RAJASHEKAR GOWDAPROPRIETOR, AGE: 35 YEARS,M/s.SREE VIRUPAKSHESWARA SWAMYAGRO CHEMICALS,NEAR OLD RAYADURGA BUS - STANDBANGALORE ROAD, BELLARY – 583 101.

: 55 :

6. SRI.N T ASWATH NARAYANAAGE: 29 YEARS,S/O N T HANUMANTHA RAYADUPROPRIETORMs.N T HANUMANTH RAYUDUOLD RAYADURGA BUS – STAND,BANGALORE ROAD,BELLARY – 583 101.

7. SRI.S WADIYARPROPRIETOR, AGE 46 YEARS,M/s.SWATHI ENTERPRISESSREE LAKSHMI NARASIMHA COMPLEXK C ROAD, BELLARY – 583 101.

8. SRI.V ANJINAYALU,AGE: 32 YEARS,S/O VERAIAH, PROPRIETORM/s.VIGNESHWARA ENTERPRISESSHOP NO.02 S LINGANNA COMPLEXKANEKAL BUS STAND, CAR STREET,BELLARY – 583 101.

9. SRI.SRIMANNARAYANAAGE: 33 YEARS,S/O MASTAN RAOM/s.VIGNESHWARA CHEMICALS& PESTICIDESS LINGANNA COMPLEXSHOP NO 6KANEKAL BUS STAND, CAR STREETBELLARY – 583 101.

10. SRI. P CHENNAKESHVALUAGE: 40 YEARS,S/O RAJEVAIAH, PROPRIETORM/s.VIJAYA LAKSHMI AGRO AGENCIESNEAR KANEKAL BUS STANDCAR STREET, BELLARY – 583 101.

: 56 :

11. SRI.P MALLIKARJUNA REDDYPROPRIETOR, AGE: 49 YEARS,M/s.MARUTHI CHEMICALS AND FERTILISERSK C ROAD OPP CHAMBER OF COMMERCEBELLARY – 583 101.

12. SMT.P KOTESHWARIW/O P SAMBA SHIVA RAOAGE: 31 YEARSM/s.VIJAYALAKSHMI AGRO TRADERSBALAJI RAO ROADBELLARY – 583 101.

13. SRI.P RAMAKOTAGE: 48 YEARSS/O VENKATA RAMAIAHPROPRIETORM/s. KRISHNA AGRO CHEMICALSDURGAPPA COMPLEX, K C ROADBELLARY – 583 101.

... PETITIONERS(By Sri.N J BALIGA, Adv.,)

AND

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,REP. BY ITS SECRETARY,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE,M S BUILDING,BANGALORE – 560 001

2. THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OFAGRICULTURE, SESHADRI ROADBANGALORE – 560 001

3. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURETHE LICENSING AUTHORITY IN INSECTICIDE,PESTICIDE FUNGICIDE AND SEEDS

: 57 :

SITING IN BELLARY COVERING ENTIREBELLARY DIST

4. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTUREBELLARY - TALUK, BELLARY DIST.

5. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE, BELLARY TALUK,BELLARY DIST. ...RESPONDENTS

(By Smt.K.VIDYAVATHI, AGA)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES

226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA QUASHANNEXURE-C DATED 12/1/2000 PASSED BY THE 3RD

RESPONDENT.

In W.P.No.38334/2002

BETWEEN

1. SMT.L MEENA KUMARI,W/O SRI.B MURALI KRISHNA,AGE: 38 YEARS,M/S “SIRI AGRO TECH”, SHOP No.2,SIRI COMPLEX, 4TH CROSS, PATELNAGAR,BELLARY.

2. SRI.B MURALI KRISHNAS/O SRI.B RAMAIAH SETTY AGE: 43 YEARS,M/S “SIRI AGRO MARKETERS”SHOP No.25/29, 1ST CROSS,PATELNAGAR, BELLARY.

3. SRI.TEDDY JOSE THEKKEKARAS/O T J JOSE,AGE: 33 YEARS,"BABA ENTEPRISES', 10TH WARD, 100/1ADHI SHAKTHI COMPLEX,

: 58 :

CAR STEET, BELLARY

4. SRI.VIJAYA KUMAR GUPTHAS/O SUBHASH KUMAR GUPHATAGE: 47 YEARS,M/S “PARMOUNT PESTICIDES PVT LTD”SRI DODDA BASAVESHWARA COMPLEX,No49, 11TH WARD, CAR STREET,BELLARY.

5. SRI.K SHASHI KRISHNAS/O K KRISHNA MOHANAGE : 29 YEARS,M/S “SREE LAXMI VENKATESHWARA AGRODISTRIBUTERS”, MUDLUR ANGINAPA COMPOUND,MILLARPET, BOMMANL ROAD,BELLARY.

6. SRI.P K MISHRAS/O R K MISHRAAGE: 50 YEARS,M/S SHIPONCHEMICAL PVT LTD.,7/7, MUNDLUR ANJINAPPA COMPOUND,RUPANGADI ROAD, MILLARPET, BELLARY.

7. SRI.G SATHYANARAYANA S/O G APPA RAOAGE: 42 YEARS,M/S HINDUSTAN PEST CONTROL,303/A, RAGHAVA KRISHNA COMPLEX,K C ROAD, BELLARY.

8. SRI.DORAI RAJ KUPPURANGAMS/O KUPPARANGAMAGE: 56 YEARS,M/S GREEN CROP INTERNATIONAL PVT., LTD.,RAGHVA KRISHNA COMPLEX,C-7, BLOCK, K C ROAD, BELLARY

... PETITIONERS

(By Sri. N J BALIGA : K VENKATA, ADV’S.,)

: 59 :

AND

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKAREPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE,M S BUILDING, BANGALORE – 560 001.

2. THE DIRECTOR OF AGICULTURE,OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OF AGRICULTURE,SESHADRI ROAD, BANGALORE – 560 001.

3. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE,THE LICENSING AUTHORITY OF INSECTICIDE,PESTICIDE, FUNGICIDE AND SEEDSSITING IN BELLARY COVERING ENTIREBELLARY DIST.

4. THE DY DIECTOR OF AGRICULTUREBELLARY TQBELLARY DIST

5. THE ASST DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTUREBELLARY TQBELLARY DIST

... RESPONDENT(S)

(By Smt.K.VIDYAVATHI, AGA)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226& 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASHVIDE ANNEXURE-C DATED 12.01.2000 BY R3.

In W.P.No.3621/2006

BETWEEN

1. M/S VIJAYA AGRO AGENCIESSHOP NO 8-11-22, NEAR MARGAMMA TEMPLEGUNJ ROAD GULBARGA

: 60 :

BY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI MADIVALAPPAS/O NINGAPPA HENDOLIAGED 43 YEARS

2. M/S GANGADHAR TRADING COSHOP NO 8-1129, ASHOK CHOWKFITTER BED ROAD, GULBARGABY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI SATISH V RANGAAGED : 31 YEARS

3. M/S GANGA AGRO TRADERSSHOP NO 8-1223 FILTER BED ROAD,GULBARGA BY ITSPROPRIETORSRI LAXMIKANTH S/O AMBARAYAPAGADI AGED: 40 YEARS

4. M/S KISSAN AGRO AGENCIESSHOP NO 8-4-12, FILTER BED ROAD,GULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETORSRI REVANSIDDAPPA S/O BASAWANAPPAUDAMNALLI AGE: 46 YEARS

5. M/S MALLIKARJUNA SALES CORPORATIONSHOP NO D 5, INDUSTRIAL ESTATE,GULBARGA BY ITS PROPRIETORSRI U.B. CHANDRASHEKARAGE: 48 YEARS

6. M/S MAHANTESHWAR KRISHI BHANDARSHOP NO 8-1246/3 FILTER BED ROADGULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETORSMT SIDDAMMA W/O SHIVAKUMAR PATILAGE: 34 YEARS

7. M/S SHUBHAM AGRO SUPPLIESSHOP NO 8-1434 10 SALI COMPLEX,NEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGA BY ITS PROPRIETORSRI SHIVAKARANA S/O CHANDRA SHETTYNIGGUDAGI

: 61 :

AGE: 49 YEARS

8. M/S GANESH AGRO CHEMICALSSHOP NO 8-143/7, UDNOOR COMPLEX,NEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGA BY ITSPARTNER SRI PRASHANT PAUL S/O DEVENDRAKUMAR PAUL AGE: 29 YEARS

9. M/S NARIBOLI AGRO SALESSHOP NO 7, COTTON MARKET GUNJGULBARGA BY ITS PARTNER SIMADIVALAPPA NINGAPPAHUNDI, AGE: 43 YEARS

10. M/S SURAJ AGRO AGENCIESSHOP NO 7-1202/27/A3-3, BEHINDCENTRAL WARE HOUSE, NEHRU GUNJGULBARGABY ITS PROPRIETOR SMT GEETAW/O SHIVAPPA ANGADI AGE: 44 YEARS

11. M/S BHUVANESHWARI KRISHI KENDRASHOP NO CMC-8-1419, HANUMANT TEMPLECOMPLEX GUNJ GULBARGA BY ITS PARNTERSRI PRASAD KUMAR S/O SHIVASHARNAPPADEGAON AGE: 22 YEAS

12. M/S PEDDI AGRO TECHSHOP NO 8-1015 NETAJI CHOWK GULBARGABY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI AMARNATHS/O RAJASHEKHAR PADDIAGE: 23 YEARS

13. M/S NAGARAJ AGRO AGENCIESSHOP NO 6-979 NETAJI CHOWK GUNJ ROADGULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETORSRI NAGENDRAPPA S/O ANNARAO TADKALAGE: 44 YEARS

: 62 :

14. M/S DANESHWARI AGRO SALESSHOP NO 3, BEHIND HANUMAN TEMPLENEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGA, BY ITS PARTNERSRI VIJAYKUMAR S/O REVANASIDDAPPAINGINSHETTY AGE: 34 YEARS

15. M/S SURAJ AGENCIES PESTICIDE DEALERSHOP NO 7-1202/27/A/3-2, BEHINDCENTRAL WARE HOUSE, NEHRU GUNJGULBARGA BY IS H.U.F. KARTHA SRISHIVAPPA S/O SHIVALINGAPPA ANGADIAGE: 54 YEAS

16. M/S SAINATH FERTILIZERSSHOP NO 8-1443/4 RAGHOJI BUILDINGNEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETORSRI SUSHILKUMAR S/O MALSHETTAPPA MAMDYAGE:35 YEARS

17. M/S ZUARI INDUSTRIES LTDC AND F AGENT M/S. SAINATH FERTILIZERSRAGHOJI BUILDING, NEHRU GUNJ, GUULBARGABY ITS PROPRIETOR, SRI SUSHILKUMARS/O MALSHETTAPPA MAMDYAGE: 35 YEAS

18. M/S DEVI AGENCIES UDNOOR COMPLEXFILTER BED ROAD NEHRU GUNJGULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETORSRI SUSHILKUMAR,S/O MALSHETTAPPA MANDYAGE: 35 YEARS. ...PETITIONERS


A N D :

1. UNION OF INDIA,

: 63 :

BY ITS SECRETARY,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE ANDCO-OPERATION (KRISHI BHAVAN),DR RAJENDRA PRASAD ROAD,NEW DELHI.

2. THE COMMISSIONER AND DIRECTOROF AGRICUTURE,GOVT OF KARNATAKA,SHESHADRI ROAD,BANGALORE.


(BY SRI. D.R.ANANDEESWARA, CGSC FOR R1 SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADV., FOR R2 & R3)

THIS WP FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DECLARE THATRULE 10(2)(a) OF THE INSECICIDES (AMENDED) RUELS1999 AS UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND ARBITRARY IN SO FARAS PETITONERS IS CONCERNED.

In W.P.No.172/2007

BETWEEN

1. MR MRUTHUNJAYA PRASADAGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,PARTNER, M/S MRUTHYUNJAYAAGRO KENDRA, KAVALI BLDNG,NEW COTTON MARKETHUBLI

2. MR NEELAPPA S KENDURAGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,PARTNER

: 64 :

M/S UNITED AGRO SERVICESNEW COTTON MARKET,HUBLI

3. MR NEELESHAGED ABOUT 44 YEARS,SABERO ORGANICS GURARAT LTDM V HUBLI BLDNGNEW COTTON MARKETHUBLI

4. MR SHASHIKANT BASAPPA BALIKGARAGED ABOUT 43 YEARS,PROPRIETOR, SHREE SOMESHWAR AGRO KENDRAMADHURA CHAITANYA COMPLEXNEELIGIN RD, HUBLI

5. RUDRAGOUDA SHETTAPPA HANNIAGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,DESAI ENTERPRISES, # 4, KAVALI BLDNGNEW COTTON MARKETHUBLI

6. SHANTESH S HAVERISHETTARAGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,M/S C M HAVERISHETTAR# 43, KAVALI BLDNG, NEW COTTON MARKETHUBLI

7. SUHAS S HAVERISHETTARAGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,PARTNER, SANGAMESH AGRO CENTREMORRUSAVIRMATH COMPLEXNEAR OLD BUS-STANDHUBLI

8. SUHAS S.HAVERISHETTAR, AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,

PARTNER, SANGAMESH AGRO AGENCIES,MOORUSAVIRMATH COMPLEX,

: 65 :

NEAR OLD-BUS STAND, HUBLI.

9. SHIVARDURAPPA N PVATANNAVARAGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,SIDDESHWAR RAITALYA, HDMC COMPLEXOLD GRASS MARKET,DHARWAD

10. SHIDDARAM GANGAPPA NADAKATTIAGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,PROPRIETOR, MRUTYUNJAYA SEEDS CORPORATINOLD DALAL MARKET, DHARWAD

11. MURUGEPPA F KOTURAGED ABOUT 65 YEARS,PARTNER, KOTURU SHETKI BHANDARAMARKET, DHARWAD

12. GANGADHAR SHIDDAYYA ADAVIMATHAGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,PROPRIETORM/S ADVIMATH & COMPANYGANDHI MARKET, BELLARY GALLIHUBLI

13. NINGAPPA NEELAKANTHAPPA MADLIAGED ABOUT 29 YEARS,PROPRIETORSRI SIDDAROODHA AGRO AGENCIESMADHURA CHAITANYA COMPLEXNEELIGN RD, HUBLI

14. SHIVAPPA NINGAPPA KARIKATTIAGED ABOUT 44 YEARS,PROPRIETOR, M/S KARNATAKA TRADERSSTALL # 8, KURAHATTI BLDNGNAVANAGAR, HUBLI

: 66 :

15. C B KADARAMANDALAGIAGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,, MANAGERHYDERABAD CHEMICALS LTDBEHIND KAHADAR GARAGE, DESHPANDE NAGARNEW COTTON MARKET, HUBLI

16. VISHWANATH S NAYAKAGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,PARTNER, M/S SUJIRKAR BUSINESS ENTERPRISPVT LTD, MADIMAN COMPLEXNEELIGIN RD, HUBLI

17. ASHA JITENDRA NAYAKAGED ABOUT 30 YEARS,PARTNER, M/S SUJIRKAR MARKEITNG PVT LTD# 12, MADIMAN COMPLEXNEELIGIN RDHUBLI

18. S G DEVAGIRIAGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,DEVI DAYAL SEEDS LTD12TH MADIMAN COMPLEX, NEELIGIN RDHUBLI

19. VIJAYANAND S LAXMESHWARAGED ABOUT 38 YEARS,PARTNER, M/S LAXMESHWAR HATTIKAL & COSAUNDATTI RDDHARWAD

20. SRI P V HURKADLIAGED ABOUT 50 YEARSSRI MAHANTESH AGRO AGENCEIS# 4, SHRINATH COMPLEX, IST FLOORNEW COTTON MARKET, HUBLI-580029KARNATAKA. ...PETITIONERS


: 67 :

AND

1. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE THE LICENSINGAUTHORITY OF INSECTICIDESPESTICIDES, FUNGICIDES & SEEDSSITTING IN DHARWAD COVERINGENTIRE DHARWAD DIST. ...RESPONDENT


THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THEIMPUGNED ORDER DT. 12.1.2000 ISSUED BY THERESPONDENT VIDE ANNEX.A AND DIRECT THERESPONDENT TO RENEW THE LICENSE OFTHEPETITIONERS TAKING RS.2,500/-.

In W.P.No.435/2007

BETWEEN

1. M/S VISHWARADHYA AGRO AGENCIESSARDA COMPLEX, NEHRU GUNJGULBARGA BY ITS PROPRIETORSRI SHARANABASAPPAS/O GURULINGAPPA KANNIAGE 34 YEARS

2. M/S CHANDRIKA AGRO SYNDICATENO.8-1368/2, NEHRU COMPLEX, NEAR HANUMANTEMPLE, NEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGABY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI BASAVARAJR/O CHANDRAKANTH MANGALGIAGE 32 YEARS

3. M/S SRI GURUSHAMB AGRO NEEDSJADHAV COMPLEX, SHOP NO.8-1434/4,

: 68 :

FILTERBED ROAD, GULBARGA BY ITSPROPRIETOR, SRI CHANDRAKANT R DIGGIKARAGE 34 YEARS

4. M/S GANGA AGRO CHEMICALSSHOP NO.3 AND 4, SUNRISE COMPEXBESIDE AVINASH PETROL PUMPGUNJ ROAD, GULBARGA.BY ITS PROPRIETORSRI.CHANNABASSAPPA S/O SHIVASHARNAPPARAYANAD, AGE 45 YEARS

5. M/S GANGA AGRO SALESNO.6-952, NETAJI CHOWK, GUNJ ROADGULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETORSRI.LINGABASAPPA S/O SHIVASHARNAPPARAYANAD, AGE 32 YEARS

6. M/S NANDI BASAVESHWAR AGRO AGENCYSHOP NO.1434/8, SALI COMPLEXBAMBU BAZAR, NEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGABY ITS PROPRIETORSRI.SHIVANAND S/O HANMANTRAO INDIAGE 30 YEARS

7. M/S BASAWA AGRO AGENCIESSHOP NO.7-1190/4, GUNJ BUS STANDHUMNABAD ROAD, GULBARGA, BY ITSPROPRIETOR, SRI NAGARAJS/O SHANGLINGAPPA DUKANDARAGE 38 YEARS

8. M/S BASAWA AGRO AGENCIES(BRANCH)SHOP NO.8-1277/A/2, BEHIND HANUMANTEMPLE, NEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGA BY ITSPROPRIETOR, SRI NAGARAJS/O SHANTLINGAPPA DUKANDARAGE 38 YEARS

9. M/S BHAGYA AGRO CHEMICALSGOWLI BUILDING, BAMBU BAZAR

: 69 :

NEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGA BY ITSPROPRIETOR, SRI.SIDDAPPAS/O SHARNAPPA PATILAGE 52 YEARS

10. M/S AMARESHWAR KRISHI KENDRAHANUMAN TEMPLE ROADNEHRU GUNJGULBARGA.BY ITS PROPRIETORSRI AMARAPPA S/O BASALINGAPPAHARKERI, AGE 41 YEARS

11. M/S NATIONAL AGRO NEEDSKIRAN BAZARGULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETORSRI.MOHD YOUSUFS/O SHAIK AHMEDAGE 50 YEARS. ...PETITIONERS


AND

1. UNION OF INDIA,BY ITS SECRETARY,DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE ANDCO-OPERATION (KRISHI BHAVAN),DR.RAJENDRA PRASAD ROAD,NEW DELHI.

2. THE COMMISSIONER AND DIRECTOROF AGRICULTURE, GOVT.OF KARNATAKA,SHESHADRI ROAD, BANGALORE.


(BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADV., FOR R2 & R3)THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF

CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DECLARE THAT,

: 70 :

RULE 10(2)(a) OF THE INSECTICIDES (AMENDED)RULE1999 AS UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND ARBITRARY, IN SO FARAS PETITIONER IS CONCERNED.

In W.P.No.18602/2006

BETWEEN

1. M/S KANIKAPARAMESHWARI AGRO CHEMICALS(REP BY ITS PARTNER)RAMESH VENKATAPPA BANAGERID/NO.15/16, 1ST FLOORSHINDE COMPLEXNEELIGIRI ROADHUBLI-580029

2. SRI GAURISHANKAR AGRO INPUTS PVT LTD(REP BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR)RAMESH VENKATAPPA BANAGERID/NO.15/16, 1ST FLOORSHINDE COMPLEXNEELIGIRI ROADHUBLI 580029. ...PETITIONERS

(By SRI. B.N.SHIVANNA, ADVOCATE)

A N D:

THE JOINT DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE THE LICENSING AUTHORITYOF INSECTICIDES, PESTICIDES,FUNGICIDES AND SEEDS:SITTING IN DHARWAD COVERINGENTIRE DHARWAD DISTRICTS ...RESPONDENT


THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH IMPUGNED

: 71 :

ORDER DT. 12.1.2000 ISSUED BY THE RESPONDENT VIDEANX-A AND DIRECT THE RESPONDENT BY ISSUING WRITOF MANDAMUS TO RENEW THE LICENSE OF THEPETITIONERS TAKING RS.30/-.

In W.P.No.3930/2005

BETWEEN

1. BHIMANAGOUDA FHAKIRAGOWDA PATILAGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,PROP V S PATIL AND SONSDISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES AND INSECTICENO 11,12 SRINATH COMPLEXNEW COTTON MARKET, HUBLI

2. BASALINGAYYA REVAYYA BANNIGIDADMATHAGED ABOUT 55PROP AGRO DISTRIBUTORSDISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES AND INSECTICENEELIGIN ROAD,HUBLI

3. ULLAS S TALEBAILKAR SHRIPADAGED ABOUT 40PROP SAMARTH AGRO CHEMICALSDISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES AND INSECTICECHIKKAVEERAYYANAVAR COMPLEXNEELIGIN ROAD, HUBLI

4. S M SURESH S/O S MALLAPPAAGED ABOUT 42PROP SHREE GANESH AGROSERVICE CENRE, DISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDEAND INSECTICIDE D 205, 207, 210SHINDE COMPLEX, NEELIGIN ROADHUBLI

5. MALLIKARJUN M GUJANEGALAGED ABOUT 44

: 72 :

PROP SHRI UMESHWAR AGENCYDISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES ANDINSECTICIDE, NO 106, MADHURA CHAITANYACOMPLEX, NEELIGIN ROAD, HUBLI

6. RAJU SIVANAGOWDA PATILAGED ABOUTPROP M/S PATIL ENTERPRISESDISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES ANDINSECTICIDE, C/O A NAGAPPA AND CO BUILDGOPP TRAFFIC POLICE STATIONNEW COTTON MARKET, HUBLI

7. B K NANJUNDA GOWDAAGED ABOUTPROP M/S TIRUMALA AGENCIESDISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES ANDINSECTICIDE, CHIKKAVEERAYANAVAR COMPLEXGNEELIGIN ROAD, HUBLI

8. SHEKHARAPPA MALLAPPA NARAGUNDAGED ABOUTPROP M/S SHANTALA ENTERPRISDISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES ANDNO 168, C BLOCK, SHINDE COMPLEX COMPLEXGNEELIGIN ROAD, HUBLI

9. SAGIRAPPA ANDANAPPA LAXMESHWARAGED ABOUTPROP SRI SAI AGRO SYNDICATEDISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES ANDD 138, SHINDE COMPLEX, NELIGIN ROADHUBLI

10. VIJAY L KULKARNIAGED ABOUTPROP M/S AISHWARYA COMMERCIDISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES ANDNO 34, KAMITHARTHA, 1 CROSS,ARJUN VIHAR, GOKUL ROAD

: 73 :

HUBLI

11. VIJAY LAXMAN RAO KULKARNIAGED ABOUTPROP M/S HUBLI AGRO AGENCIEP LTD, DBTR FOR PESTICIDES ANDG 6, SRINATH COMPLEXNEW COTTON MARKET, HUBLIHUBLI

12. VIJAY LAXMAN RAO KULKARNIAGED ABOUT YEARSPROPRIETOR, M/S ASSOCIATES AGROSDRISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES ANDINSECTICIDE, NO 6, SRINATH COMPLEXNEW COTTON MARKETHUBLI-29

13. PARAPPA MALLAPPA VENKATAPURAGED ABOUT YEARSPROPRIETOR, M/S SHREE GAJANAN SEEDSDRISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES ANDINSECTICIDE, HEGDE COMPLEX, OLD DALALMARKETDHARWAD-01

14. PRANESH RAMACHARYA GANDAMALIAGED ABOUT YEARSPROPRIETOR, M/S RAMESH AGRO MARKETERSDRISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES ANDINSECTICIDE, NO 12, MADIMAN BUILDINGNEELIGIN ROADHUBLI-29

15. SURESH AGARWAL S/O PANNALALAGED ABOUT 30 YEARSPROPRIETOR, M/S AGARWAL AGRO AGENCIESDRISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES ANDINSECTICIDE, NO 19, SHINDE COMPLEXNELIGIN ROAD

: 74 :

HUBLI

16. BANTY SURESH AGARAWALAGED ABOUT 25 YEARSPROPRIETOR, M/S AGARWAL SALES CORPORATINDRISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES ANDINSECTICIDE, C.V COMPOUND, NEELIGIRIROAD, HUBLI

17. SHUSHI CHANAGOWD PATILAGED ABOUT 45 YEARSPROPRIETOR, M/S ALLAMAPRABHU ASSOCIATESDRISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES ANDINSECTICIDE, KORVI BUILDING, NEW COTTONMARKET, HUBLI-29

18. MURALIKSIRHNA B K S/O BASANNAAGED ABOUT 32 YEARSPROPRIETOR, M/S THIRUMALA AGENCIESDRISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES ANDINSECTICIDE, NO 9, KAVALI COMPLEXNEW COTTON MARKET, HUBLI-29

19. PRAKASH V BETAGERI S/O VEERAPPA BETAGERIAGED ABOUT 37 YEARSPROPRIETOR, M/S CHANNABASAVESHWARA AGNCSDRISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES ANDINSECTICIDE, NO 8, SHRINATH COMPLEXNEW COTTON MARKET, HUBLI-29

20. P KANNADASANAGED ABOUT YEARSPROPRIETOR, M/S SHRI TEJASWINI AGRIASSOCIATES, DISTRICUTOR FOR PESTICIDESAND INECTCIDE, NO 4, I.F. PATIL BUILDINGNEAR CHETANA WEIGH, NEW COTTON MARKETHUBLI-29

21. F S NEELGUND FAKKIRGOWDA S/OSHIVANNAGOWDANEELGUND

: 75 :

AGED ABOUT 50 YEARSPROPRIETOR, M/S SUMANGALA AGRO CENTREDISTRICUTOR FOR PESTICIDESAND INECTCIDE, NEELIGIN ROAD, LAXMICOMPLEX NO L-6, HUBLI-29

22. SHIVAYOGI KALYANAPPA MURKHANDI S/OKALYANAPPAAGED 45 YEARSPROPRIETORM/S MAHANTESH AGRO SERVICES,DISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES, & INSECTCIDENO 4, SHRINATH COMPLEX, NEW COTTON MARKTHUBLI-29

23. SHASHIDHAR CHANAGOWD PATIL S/OCHANNAGOWDAAGED 45 YEARSPROPRIETORM/S BASAVESHWAR AGRO AGENCIESDISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES, & INSECTCIDECHAKKAVEERAYYANAVAR COMPLEX, NEELIGIN RDHUBLI-29

24. SOMNATH BHIMANGOWDA PATILAGED ABOUTS/O. BHIMANAGOWDA PATILPROP, M/S. PATIL AND CO.,DISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIEDS ANDINSECTICIDENO.13 & 14, SRINATH COMPLEX,NEW COTTON MARKET, HUBLI - 580 029

25. K MANJUNATHAAGED ABOUTM/S. SAPTHAMI AGRO PRODUCTS PVT LTDDISTRIBUTOR FOR PESTICIDES ANDINSECTICIDE, NO.B-132,

SHINDE COMPLEX, NEELIGIN ROAD,HUBLI - 580 029. ... PETITIONERS

: 76 :

(BY SRI. B.N.SHIVANNA & RENUKAMURTHY, ADVOCATES)

A N D

THE JOINT DIRECTOR OFAGRICULTURE, THE LICENSING AUTHORITYOF INSECTICIDE, PESTICIDE, FUNGICIDEAND SEEDS, SITTING IN DHARWADCOVERING ENTIREDHARWAD DISTRICTS. ...RESPONDENT

(BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADVOCATE )

THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OFCONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DIRECT THERESPONDENT TO RENEW THE LICENSE OF THEPETITIONERS ON PAYMENT OF RS. 30.00.

These petitions coming on for Hearing this day,the Court made the following:

ORDER

Smt. K.Vidyavathi, learned Additional Government

Advocate, submits that in identical matter, this Court in

W.P.No.81112/2010 and connected matters vide order

dated 27th March 2013 dismissed the writ petitions and

the same reads as under:

: 77 :

“ This court in Writ Petition

No.17654/2008 and other connected matters

are upheld to amend Rule 10(2) of

Insecticides rules 1971, wherein enhanced

the licence free from Rs.22,500/-. This court

has held amendment does not violate the

provisions of Constitution to uphold the

legality. In this petition, the legality of the

amendment is challenged and the notification

is issued directing to pay as per the

amendment is in challenge. Since rules

amended is upheld, the notification would be

a valid in law and it does not suffer any

illegality.

In that view of the matter, the writ

petitions are dismissed.”

Accordingly and for the reasons stated above, these writ

petitions are hereby disposed of.

SD/-

JUDGE

Kms

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,judgmenthck.kar.nic.in/judgments/bitstream/123456789/...2010/07/02 · : 1 : IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH Dated this the 7 th day of

Documents