Page 1
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast
Peter Anderson Simon Fraser University Prepared By: Simon Fraser University 8888 University Drive Burnaby, B.C. V5A 1S6 Associate Professor and Director, Telematics Research Lab, School of Communication Contractor's Document Number: Project Report (Tasks 6 and 7) Version 1.2 PWGSC Contract Number: W7714-145880 DRDC Project Number: CSSP-2013-TI-1033 Technical Authority: Philip Dawe, Portfolio Manager, DRDC – Centre for Security Science Disclaimer: The scientif ic or technical validity of this Contract Report is entirely the responsibility of the Contractor and the contents do not necessarily have the approval or endorsement of the Department of National Defence of Canada.
Contract Report DRDC-RDDC-2016-C174 March 2016
Page 2
© Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada, as represented by the Minister of National Defence, 2016
© Sa Majesté la Reine (en droit du Canada), telle que représentée par le ministre de la Défense nationale, 2016
Page 3
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast
Canadian Safety and Security Program
Project Number CSSP-2013-TI-1033
Project Report (Tasks 6 and 7) For period ending 31 March, 2016
Version 1.2
Page 4
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
ii
Record of Amendments
Version Number
Date Description Author
1.0 15 March, 2016 Initial version Peter Anderson
1.1 18 March, 2016 Small edits Peter Anderson
1.2 26 March, 2016 Inclusion of additional participant feedback
Peter Anderson
Page 5
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
iii
DocumentDescriptionThisdocumentprovidesfinalreportingforTasks6and7oftheImprovingEnd-To-EndTsunamiWarningforRiskReductiononCanada'sWestCoastProject(CSSP2013-TI-1033)fortheperiod1January,2016to31March,2016.ProjectOrganizationTechnicalAuthorityPhilipDawePortfolioManager–EmergencyManagement&DisasterResilienceDefenseResearchandDevelopmentCanada,CentreforSecurityScience222NepeanStreet,11thfloorOttawa,OntarioK1A0K2ProvinceofBritishColumbiaRepresentativeandProjectChampionRalphMohrmannSeniorRegionalManagerandAssistantDirectorofOperationsEmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaMinistryofJustice2261KeatingXRoadSaanichton,BCV8M2A5ResearchLeadPeterAndersonAssociateProfessorandDirector,TelematicsResearchLabSchoolofCommunicationSimonFraserUniversity8888UniversityDriveBurnaby,B.C.V5A1S6ResearchTeamPeterAnderson,Director,TelematicsResearchLab,SimonFraserUniversityStephenBraham,Director.PolyLAB,SchoolofCommunication,SimonFraserUniversityOlympiaKoziatek,DepartmentofGeography,SimonFraserUniversityAmandaOldring,SchoolofCommunication,SimonFraserUniversityAmandaOye,SchoolofCommunication,SimonFraserUniversityDawnUrsulak,SchoolofCommunication,SimonFraserUniversityMarcd’Aquino,HolisticEmergencyPreparednessandResponse
Page 6
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
iv
Table of Contents RecordofAmendments iiDocumentDescription iiiProjectOrganization iiiAcknowledgements viListofTables ixListofFigures ixListofAcronyms x1.0Introduction 12.0ImprovingEnd-To-EndTsunamiWarningforRiskReductiononCanada'sWestCoast:ProjectSummary 22.1ProjectObjectivesandScope 22.2StudyMethodology 22.2.1Phase1:Task3-ComprehensiveReviewofExistingCoastal
WarningandCommunicationNetworksandLast-mileSegments 2 2.2.1.1CreationofaNotificationMatrixandPlanningTool 3 2.2.1.2CommunitySurveying 3 2.2.1.3GISDataGatheringandMapping 4 2.2.1.4SocialMediaTwitterAnalysis 5 2.2.1.5SelectedRadioPropagationMapping 62.2.2Phase2:Task4-PilotingandEvaluatingNewTechniquesand
TechnologiesinCommunities 7 2.2.2.1NewMethodsforIdentificationofAdditionalCoastal
Populations-at-risk 7 2.2.2.2SelectionofProjectNotificationTechnologyPilots 8 2.2.2.3SelectionofCommunitiesandOtherParticipantsfor
PilotProjects 112.2.3Phase2:Task5-TsunamiNotificationToolKit 142.3ImpactonStatedProjectOutcomes 152.3.1IdentifyingMostVulnerablePopulations,HazardZones,and CommunityCapacities 152.3.2IncreasingCommunity-levelRiskAwarenessandEncouraging
AppropriatePreparednessandMitigationActivities 172.3.3BuildingSocialCapitalthroughFacilitatingConnectednessand CommunityBuilding 202.3.4OtherEngagement 202.3.5ReportsandPublications 212.4RelationshiptootherCSSPProjects 212.5RecommendationsForFurtherAdvancingTsunamiNotification 213.0LeveragingTsunamiNotificationPracticestoSupportB.C.All-HazardsNotification 223.1Background 223.1.1B.C.Geography 223.1.2HazardsinBritishColumbia 223.1.3BritishColumbiaEmergencyManagementResponsibilities 23
Page 7
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
v
3.1.4ComprehensiveEmergencyManagementPlan 233.1.5LocalAuthorityResponse 243.1.6ProvincialResponse 243.1.7TheDutytoNotify 253.2B.C.PublicNotificationArrangements 253.3CurrentNotificationChallenges 263.4LeveragingTsunamiNotificationArrangements 263.4.1Recommendations 29 3.4.1.1BackgroundStudies 29 3.4.1.2EnhancementsofCurrentProvincialNotification Systems 30 3.4.1.3EducationandTraining 304.0TheWayForward:TransitioningtoaSmartB.C.All-HazardsNotification System 324.1Recommendations 344.1.1EngagementandCollaboration 344.1.2GuidanceandCoordination 34
Page 8
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
vi
AcknowledgementsThisprojectwassupportedthroughtheCanadianSafetyandSecurityProgram,afederalprogramledbyDefenceResearchandDevelopmentCanada’sCentreforSecurityScience,inpartnershipwithPublicSafetyCanadaCSSP2013-TI-1033.Manypeoplecontributedtheirvaluabletimeandinformationtoenablethisprojecttobecarriedoutsuccessfully.Wehaveattemptedtoacknowledgebelowthosewhocontributedthroughoutthedurationoftheprojectandapologizeforanyomissions.GordonKirk,B.C.AmbulanceServiceCraigMcGowan,B.C.AmbulanceServiceRodSalem,B.C.AmbulanceServiceSolLancashire,B.C.HydroNickHeath,B.C.MarineTrailsNetworkAssociationJasonWood,B.C.MinistryofTransportationandInfrastructureSteveWaugh,BellaCoolaDaveRainnie,CanadianBroadcastingCorporationBrianBain,CanadianCoastGuard-WesternClayEvans,CanadianCoastGuard–WesternMikeMcCullagh,CanadianCoastGuard–WesternGlennOrmiston,CanadianCoastGuard–WesternSusanPickrell,CanadianCoastGuard-WesternIanWade,CCG,CanadianCoastGuard-WesternNathanWebb,CanadianCoastGuard-WesternDougAllport,CanadianPublicSafetyOperationsOrganizationBrentFalkins,DFO,CanadianHydrographicServices,InstituteofOceanSciencesDennySinnott,DFO,CanadianHydrographicServices,InstituteofOceanSciencesFredStephenson,DFO,CanadianHydrographicServices,InstituteofOceanSciencesAspaKotsopoulos,CanadianRadio-televisionandTelecommunicationsCommissionPeterEnsor,CapitalRegionalDistrictCherylWaugh,CentralCoastRegionalDistrictPhilipDawe,CentreforSystemsScience,DefenseResearchandDevelopmentCanadaSheldonDickie,CentreforSystemsScience,DefenseResearchandDevelopmentCanadaJackPagotto,CentreforSystemsScience,DefenseResearchandDevelopmentCanadaDaveSamson,CermacCanadaDirkdeJager,ChromaCommunicationsWendyMagnes,DestinationBritishColumbiaJohnTidbury,DistrictofPortHardyKarlaRobison,DistrictofUclueletMikeWebb,E-CommAndrewBryan,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaIanCunnings,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaChrisDuffy,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaClareFletcher,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaKathrynForge,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbia
Page 9
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
vii
MichaelHiggins,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaMaurieHurst,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaIanLighthouse,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaMichaelKnauff,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaRobertKennedy,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaKelliKryzanowski,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaSueLaunder,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaCameronLewis,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaChrisMah,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaRalphMohrmann,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaJohnOakley,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaPeterPrendergast,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaPatQuealey,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaToddSmith,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaRobertWhite,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaSoniaWoolford,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaJenniferMcLarty,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbia,SocialMediaUnitAshleySpilak,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbia,SocialMediaUnitArmelCastellan,EnvironmentCanadaMichaelGismondi,EnvironmentCanadaFredVoglmaier,EnvironmentCanadaCarolOgborne,GeoBCJoshuaChan,GeoBCPatriciaMcCourt,IndigenousAffairsandNorthernDevelopmentCanadaKimMikkelesen,IndustryCanadaMelodyMeyers,IndustryCanadaPawasVerma,IndustryCanadaWendyWu,IndustryCanadaMajorDavidProctor,MARPC/JointTaskForcePacificMontyCook,NAVCanadaWilfBangert,NetworkBC,OfficeoftheChiefInformationOfficerChrisHauff,NetworkBC,OfficeoftheChiefInformationOfficerJamesMcGrath,NetworkBC,OfficeoftheChiefInformationOfficerHowardRandell,NetworkBC,OfficeoftheChiefInformationOfficerJohnCarrick,NOAANationalTsunamiWarningCenterPaulHaung,NOAANationalTsunamiWarningCenterPaulWhitmore,NOAANationalTsunamiWarningCenterNathanBecker,NOAAPacificTsunamiWarningCenterStuartWeinstein,NOAAPacificTsunamiWarningCenterRandyZaleshuck,NorthIsland911GarryRogers,NRCAN,PacificGeoscienceCentreTeronMoore,OceanNetworksCanadaPeterClarkson,ParksCanadaChuckLok,PortMcNeilCindyJeromin,PortMetroVancouverWayneHirlehey,PublicSafetyCanada
Page 10
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
viii
DavidJones,Roadpost,Inc.GregFletcher,RegionalDistrictofMountWaddingtonGloriaLeGal,RegionalDistrictofMountWaddingtonGlennAlsaker,RogersWirelessClementCheung,RogersWirelessMichelleAlton,RCMPDennisCrowe,RCMPDebbieLetkemann,RCMPGregoryGoss,SierraSystemsFraserHacking,SierraSystemsJohnClague,EarthSciences,SimonFraserUniversityNickHedley,DepartmentofGeography,SimonFraserUniversityHowieSiemens,StrathconaRegionalDistrictandCityofCampbellRiverLaylaGuica,SurreySearchandRescueLuizaGuica,SurreySearchandRescueLucasBrown,TelusCommunicationsJenniferConner,TelusMobilityJeffHortobagyi,TelusCommunicationsMoutiWali,TelusMobilityTimWebb,TofinoRobinNeale,TransportCanadaMadelineMcDonald,VillageofPortAliceMikeAtchison,ZeballosFireDepartmentDougBrown,WuikinuxvNationWewouldespeciallyliketothankover90communities,regionaldistrictsandFirstNationsforenablingtheirlocalauthoritiestoparticipateinouron-linetsunaminotificationandAlertReadytestsurveysand/orcommunitypilotprojects.
Page 11
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
ix
ListofTablesTable1.ParticipatingCommunities 11Table2:LocalPlansandCapabilitiesforallLocalAuthorities 17
ListofFiguresFigure1:LocationsofSampled@EmergencyInfoBCTwitterFollowers 6Figure2:FlickrSourcedKayakingLocations 8Figure3:WestCoastTrailinReachGPSandTextMessageDeliveryTiming 12Figure4:CCGSBartlettIridiumGomessagingTestLocations 13Figure5.CCGSBartlettMSATEmergNetTestLocations 13Figure6:KayakingLocationswithMarginalTsunamiNotificationCoverage 16
Page 12
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
x
List of Acronyms 5G FifthGenerationMobileWirelessTechnologiesB.C. BritishColumbiaBCAS B.C.AmbulanceServiceBCERMS B.C.EmergencyResponseManagementSystemBCEAS BritishColumbiaEmergencyAlertingSystemCAP CommonAlertingProtocolCBRNE Chemical,Biological,Radiological,NuclearandExplosiveEventsCCG CanadianCoastGuardCEMP ComprehensiveEmergencyManagementPlanCRTC CanadianRadio-televisionandTelecommunicationsCommissionCSSP CanadianSafetyandSecurityProgramEC EnvironmentCanadaEMBC EmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaHSPA HighSpeedPacketAccessGIS GeographicalInformationSystemIOT InternetofThingsLMD LastMileDistributorLMR Land-MobileRadioLTE LongTermEvolutionMF MediumFrequencyNAADS NationalAlertAggregationandDisseminationSystemNOAA NationalOceanicandAtmosphericAdministrationNPAS NationalPublicAlertingSystemNRCAN NationalResourcesCanadaNTWC NationalTsunamiWarningCenterNWS NationalWeatherServicePTWC PacificTsunamiWarningCenterPECC ProvincialEmergencyCoordinationCentrePENS ProvincialEmergencyNotificationSystemPERCS ProvincialEmergencyRadioCommunicationsServicePREOC ProvincialRegionalEmergencyOperationsCentrePSBN PublicSafetyBroadbandNetworkPTWC PacificTsunamiWarningCenterRCMP RoyalCanadianMountedPoliceRSS ReallySimpleSyndicationorRichSiteSummarySEND SatelliteEmergencyNotificationDeviceSFU SimonFraserUniversitySMS ShortMessageServiceVGI VolunteerGeographyInformationVHF VeryHighFrequencyWPAS WirelessPublicAlertingService
Page 13
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
1
1.0 IntroductionThepurposeofthisdocumentistwo-fold:1)tosummarizethecurrentprojectactivitiesandkeyfindings(ImprovingEnd-To-EndTsunamiWarningforRiskReductiononCanada'sWestCoast)and2)tooutlineoptionsandpresentrecommendationsforaroadmaptoadvanceimplementationofaB.C.all-hazardsnotificationsystembased,inpart,onexperienceandknowledgederivedfromthecurrentproject.Thereportisdividedintofoursections:Section1(thissection)includesanintroduction;Section2providesasummaryofworkcarriedoutinthisproject,itsalignmentwithCSSPoutcomegoals,andrecommendationsforadvancingtsunaminotification;Section3containsaseriesofbackgroundprofilesofB.C.hazards,localandprovincialauthorityemergencymanagementrolesandresponsibilities,includingemergencynotification,aswellasabriefdescriptionofnotificationmethods;Section4discusseshowresultsofthisworkcanbeleveragedtosupportbroaderB.C.notificationeffortsandSection5makesrecommendationsforintegratingandtransitioningcurrentarrangementsintoafutureSmartB.C.All-HazardsNotificationSystem.Throughoutthereport,theterm“notification”isusedoftenandisintendedtoencompassthemeanstoalertpeoplethatahazardeventhasoccurred,towarnthemaboutthenatureofimpendingthreat,andtoprovidethemwiththenecessaryinformationandinstructionstoprotectthemselvesfromtheevent.Often,diversemeansandmethodsofcommunicationmaybeusedforthealertandfollowupinformationdissemination.
Page 14
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
2
2.0 ImprovingEnd-To-EndTsunamiWarningforRiskReductiononCanada'sWestCoast:ProjectSummary
Thissectionreviewstheworkundertakeninthisproject,underlyingmethodologies,results,andlessonslearned,alongwithrecommendationsforfurtheractions.Thestudytookintoaccountfindingsandaction-basedrecommendationsofpreviousB.C.tsunaminotificationstudiesandinitiativescarriedoutoverthepastdecade.
2.1 ProjectObjectivesandScope
Theprinciplestudyobjectiveswereto:• bringpractitionersandkeystakeholdergroupstogetherwithsubjectmatterexperts
toshareknowledgeandbuildrelationshipstosupportlong-termdevelopmentofsustainable,reliableandintegratedWestCoastCanadianend-to-endpublicalertingandemergencycommunicationsystemsandtocontributetostrengtheningthesetypesofsystemselsewhereinCanada;
• improveapplicationofthesesystems,throughselectedpilotprojects,tosupportremoteareatsunamialerting,and
• provideclearandaction-specificrecommendationstoadvanceimplementationofanall-hazardsalertingsystem.
Theprojectwascomposedoftwomajorphases:
• Phase1:(April–December,2014)Conductingastudytoinventoryandassessexistingcoastalwarningandcommunicationnetworksandlast-milesegments.
• Phase2:(January,2015–March,2016)Pilotingandevaluatingnewtechniquesandtechnologiesthatcansupportregion-wideandlocalizedneeds.ThisphaseincludedrevisingandexpandingtheSimonFraserUniversity(SFU)“TsunamiWarningMethodsPlanningToolKit”,aplanningguideoriginallypublishedin2006,andproducingrecommendationsforaroadmaptowardanall-hazardsnotificationsystemforBritishColumbia,basedonexperienceandknowledgederivedfromthecurrentproject.
2.2 StudyMethodology2.2.1 Phase1:Task3-ComprehensiveReviewofExistingCoastalWarning
andCommunicationNetworksandLast-mileSegmentsFromtheoutset,theprojectsetouttoaddressrecommendationsofpreviousinitiativesandcarryoutnewresearchbyestablishingaframeworkandstudymethodologythatwouldenableitsteamtosystematicallycaptureandstorestudydataconcerning:
• tsunamihazardzones;• populations-at-risk;• coastalsocio-economicactivities;• keynotificationprocessesandstakeholders;
Page 15
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
3
• currentandemergingnotificationmethodsandtheirunderpinningcommunicationinfrastructures,includingcoverage;
• currentnotificationmethodsusages,practicesandcapabilities,and• otherareacommunicationmethodsandsupportingtechnologynotcurrently
integratedintoexistingtsunaminotificationsystems.Theprincipledatagatheringmethodsemployedinthisstudyphaseincluded:semi-structuredinterviews,sitevisitsandemailcorrespondencewithkeyagencies;Internetandonlinejournalanddatabasesearchesforbackgrounddataandinformationconcerningwarningssystems,lessonslearnedandrecommendedgoodpractices,coastalpopulations,socio-economicactivities,communicationscoverageandcommunitytsunamihazardandpublicinformationprograms;downloadingspecialTwitterdatasetstoidentifyfollowersof@NWS_NTWCand@EmergencyInfoBC(thetwokeyaccountsusedtodisseminateofficialWestCoasttsunamibulletins);participationintheTsunamiNotificationNetworkingGroupandEmergencyManagementBritishColumbia(EMBC)planningmeetingsandactivities,andinterviewswithcommunicationserviceprovidersandvendors.Anumberofadditionalrequestsweremadetoselectedagenciesforspecializeddataconcerningnotificationprocesses,methods,supportinginfrastructuresandlocationsoffacilitiesandservicecoverage.
2.2.1.1CreationofaNotificationMatrixandPlanningTool
Throughoutthecollectionperiod,datawasreviewedandorganizedintocategories.Categorieswerethenconvertedtodatafieldsinasetofspreadsheetstoestablishaframeworkforsystematicallyrecordingandorganizingstudydata.Datafieldsinitiallyincluded:communityandothergeographiclocationsandcurrenttsunaminotificationzonesidentifiedintheBritishColumbiaTsunamiNotificationProcessPlan;variousotherjurisdictionalboundaries;typesofmethodsusedforreceivingofficialexternaltsunaminotifications,aswellasmethodsusedtodisseminatemessagestolocalpopulations.Thesefieldsweresupplementedbyaddinggeo-referencecodesandotherattributedatatoeachidentifiedlocation.Thisprocessresultedinthecreationofalargegeo-codedcommunitynotificationmatrixthatcouldbeusednotonlyfordatacollectionpurposes,butalsotosupportanalysisandinformtheselectionpilotprojectsandtheirparticipantsinPhase2.Mostimportantly,thematrixevolvedintoapracticalcommunity,regionalandprovincialplanningtoolthatcanbeusedtosupportall-hazardsnotificationplanning.
2.2.1.2CommunitySurveying
GiventhelimitedtimeframeforPhase1initialdatacollection(April-September2014),initiallyitwasunclearastohowfeasibleitwouldbetocollectdetaileddataforalllocationsalongtheB.C.coast,anditwasdecidedthatconcentratinginitiallyonacoastalsub-regionwouldprovideanopportunitytotestandvalidatethematrix.TwonorthernVancouverIslandregionaldistricts,MountWaddingtonRegionalDistrictandStrathconaRegionalDistrict,agreedtoparticipatebycontactingtheircommunities’emergencymanagementauthoritiesandassistingwithfillingintheappropriatedatafields.Asworkprogressed,itwassoonrealizedthatanon-lineversioncouldprovideameanstoquicklyexpanddatacollectionacrosstheentirecoastalregion.Coincidentally,thecompletiondeadlinefor
Page 16
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
4
Phase1wasextendedtoendofDecember,2014,makingthislatestcollectionmethodfeasible.
Consequently,anonlinequestionnairewascreatedthatimbeddedthesamedatacollectionfieldsfoundinthespreadsheet,butwasexpandedtoincludeadditionalquestionsconcerningnotificationpreferencesandcommunitycapacitiestoreceiveandlocallyre-distributetsunaminotifications.WiththeassistanceofEMBC’sregionalmanagers,invitationsweresentouttolocalauthorityrepresentativeswithintheirregions.Theseincludedrepresentativesfromincorporatedmunicipalities,regionaldistrictsandFirstNations.Acopyofthesurveyquestionnaireaccompaniedtheinvitationtoenableparticipantstoviewthequestionsandgathernecessaryinformationbeforegoingon-line.ForthosewithoutInternetaccess,anoptiontofaxtheresultswasprovided.Thesurveyproduced84responseswithasamplingofallcoastalareas,urbanandrural.41werefromauthoritiesrepresentingincorporatedmunicipalitiesandregionaldistricts,29werefromFirstNationsand14werefromunincorporatedlocations.Theresultswerethenincorporatedintothecommunitymatrixspreadsheets.ThesurveyprovedtobeaveryusefultoolforcommunitydatacollectionandcouldprovideatemplateforexpandedsurveyingaboutemergencynotificationpracticesinotherB.C.regions.
2.2.1.3GISDataGatheringandMapping
AveryuniquefeatureoftheprojectwastheuseofdatavisualizationthroughGISmapping.TwotypesofdatawereusedtosupportGISmapping:OriginalandDeriveddata.Originaldatareferstothedatathatwasdownloadedfromanexternalsource.Deriveddatareferstodatathatwascreatedfromoriginaldatasetsorcollectedthroughothermeans(e.g.,surveys).
Over100datasetswerecollectedand/orderivedfromanumberofsources.PrincipalOriginaldatasourcesinclude:DataB.C.(GeoBC),HectaresBC,Geobase,SpectrumDirectandspecialsetsfromagenciesandserviceproviders,includingcellular.Deriveddatasourcesinclude:Census,emailandSMSnotifications,Twitter,NetworkBCandprojectsurveys.
TwoofthemostsignificantsetsofDeriveddatacamefromthecommunitynotificationmatrixandlocalauthoritynotificationsurveysdescribedabove.Oncethedatawasplacedintotables,spatialjoinswereadministeredtoidentifythelatitudeandlongitudefieldsforeachrepresentativelocation.Thistechniqueworkedforoverhalfthelocations;therestweremanuallyentered.ThedatawasthenimportedintoArcGISandconvertedintoavectorformatfile.AspatialjoinwasalsoprocessedbetweenthesurveydataandthecensusdatatoidentifythepopulationoftheB.C.coastalregion.Usingthistechnique,aseriesofspecializedmapswascreatedbasedondataextractedfromthecommunitynotificationmatrix,surveyquestionsandotherdatasets.Examplesofotherdatasetsincludegeographicalfeaturesandnames,politicalandcensusboundaries,tourismlocationsbyactivity,landandmarinetransportationroutes,criticalinfrastructure,publicsafetyservices,economicactivities,andmostimportantly,communicationandemergencynotificationsystemscoverage.Essentially,everyeffortwasmadetogeocodeas
Page 17
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
5
muchcollecteddataaspossibleinordertoproduceacomprehensiveviewoftheentirecoastalregiontosupportidentificationofpopulations-at-riskandanalysisofavailablenotificationmethods.Thisapproachprovedtobeveryusefulinlaterphasesoftheproject,especiallyinplanning,executingandassessingpilotprojects.ThisGISinitiativealsohelpedtocreateanotherpotentiallyusefulplanningtoolthatcouldsupportsimilaranalyticalworkinotherhazarddomainsandregionsofB.C.2.2.1.4SocialMediaTwitterAnalysis
TheNTWCsendsoutautomatedshortenedWarning,Advisory,WatchandInformationmessagesonitsTwitteraccount,@NWS_NTWC.EMBCalsousesthe@EmergencInfoBCTwitteraccounttoalertBritishColumbianstotsunamithreatsbyamplifyingmessagesandverifiedinformationfromNTWCandEMBCofficials.Inourstudy,weundertooktoidentifyB.C.followersoftheU.S.NationalTsunamiWarningCenterandEmergencyManagementBritishColumbiaTwitterfeedsthroughcollectingasampleof9,999followersfromeachofthe@NWS_NTWCand@EmergencyInfoBCTwittersitesandanalyzingfollowerprofiledata.Oncethesampleswereimported,thenextstepwastosearchforeligibleusersandtieslocatedinthePacificWestCoastRegionandcheckandhand-codeeachB.C.followerforstatus,language,andlocation.
Asmightbeexpected,theseresultscorrelatewithpopulationdensitiesandcommunicationinfrastructureavailability.Thevastmajorityoffollowersarelocatedinthelargercentres,mostofwhicharealsolocatedinlowertsunamiriskzones.Thelackoflargernumbersoffollowersinthehigherriskandmoreremotecoastalsub-regionsalsoappearstocorrelatewithlackofmobilephoneand/orbroadbandInternetservice.
Inspiteofthis,interestinsocialmediacontinuestogrow,andasconnectivityimprovesthroughoutB.C.,socialmediaapplicationswillplayanincreasinglyimportantroleinemergencynotification.Further,EMBC‘[email protected] ’sofficialTwitterchannelforallprovincial-levelandlarge-scaleemergencyalertsandnotifications.Assuch,ourstudymethodologycanbeausefultoolforidentifyingall@EmergencyInfoBCfollowersandreachofEMBCTwittermessagingacrosstheprovince.Moreover,asshowninFigure1,theinitialmappingoffollowersfortsunaminotificationshelpedtosupportthisprovincialanalysis,sinceallfollowersreceivetsunamiaswellasothernotifications.Ofcourse,theresultsaretimesensitiveanddatacollectionandanalysiswouldneedtobecarriedoutmoreregularlytoretaincurrentperspectives.Theprocesscouldalsobemademoreefficientthroughadditionalautomationandstandardizationofdatacollectionandcoding.
Page 18
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
6
Figure1:LocationsofSampled@EmergencyInfoBCTwitterFollowers
2.2.1.5SelectedRadioPropagationMappingInordertoidentifyandmapcoverageavailabilityofexistingCoastalradiofrequency-basednotificationsystems,twomethodswereemployed:1)obtainingGIScoveragedatadirectlyfromsystemprovidersandIndustryCanada,theradiolicensingauthorityand2)generatingourownmapsbaseduponcreatingalgorithmsandprogramcodingtoautomaticallysearchandfilterdatafromIndustryCanada’sSpectrumDirectlicensingdatabaseandtostreamlinepropagationmapping.Duetoitsvastdiversity,takingintoaccountcoastalterrainfeaturesiscriticaltoplottingcorrectline-of-sightcoveragetoensurethatareaswithpoorornoservicearenoted,particularlyfornotificationtotransientpopulations.Inourproject,wewereabletomapthekeywirelessnetworksthatareusedfortsunaminotification.TheseincludeCanadianCoastGuardVHFandMFradio,EnvironmentCanadaWeatheradio,mobilecellularservice,andover-the-airAM,FMandtelevisionservices.Asaproof-of-concept,generatingourownmaps,usingdatafromIndustryCanada’sradiolicensingdatabase,provedespeciallyusefulforidentifyinghiddencommunicationresources,suchasotherpublicagencyandprivatesectorradiosystemsthatarenotcurrentlyincorporatedintocommunityandregionalnotificationsystems,butcouldsignificantlyimprovereachofwarningstopopulations-at-risk,especiallyagencyemployeesandotherradiosystemusers.Bothmethodsofradiopropagationmappinghave
Page 19
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
7
widespreadapplicationinall-hazardsnotificationcoverageanalysisforanyregionofB.C.
2.2.2 Phase2:Task4-PilotingandEvaluatingNewTechniquesandTechnologiesinCommunities
2.2.2.1NewMethodsforIdentificationofAdditionalCoastalPopulations-at-risk
Whilewewereabletonotelocationsformanyofthesettledpopulationsthatarepotentially-at-riskfromtsunamis,wediscoveredanumberofothercoastalpopulationgroupsthatarenotwelldocumented.Thesearetransientpopulationsthatresidetemporarilyinoraretraversingthroughcoastalareas.Therearemanyvarietieswhosenumbersvaryaccordingtoeconomic,socio-cultural,seasonalandotherfactors.Examplesincludelogging,commercialfishingandaquacultureworkers,recreationallandandmarinepopulations,tourists,etc.and,fromourmapping,wehavebeenabletoconfirmthattheytravelthroughoutallofB.C’ssub-regions,includingthemostremotelocationswherecommunicationservicesaremarginalatbest.Further,ourresearchandconsultationswithU.S.andCanadiannotificationauthorities,emergencyplannersandcoastalindustryofficialsrevealthatmanyofthesepopulationsarenotfullyintegratedintoexistingtsunaminotificationarrangementsallalongtheWestCoastofNorthAmerica,asmostconventionalarrangementsfocusonmorepermanentsettlementsandadjacentareas.Consequently,astimeandresourcespermitted,wecontinuedtoresearchandgathercoastalpopulationdata,includingB.C.ParksandParksCanadavisitorattendancerecordsAmongthemoreinnovativetechniqueswepilotedwastheuseofaformofcrowdsourcingthatengagesprivatecitizensassensorsoftheenvironmenttoprovideinformationwhichistermed“VolunteeredGeographicInformation”(VGI).Withthecurrentuseofsmartphones,othermobiledevicesandsocialmedia,usersareconstantlyuploadingpictures,changingstatuses,sendingmessages,etc.Theseactionsalsogeneratemetadatafilesthatoftenincludelocationaldata.AnexampleofthisVGIapplicationisFlickr,awebsitethatallowsuserstouploadtheirimagesfromanywhereandincludetitles,descriptions,date,usernameandlocationintheformoflatitudeandlongitude.AnapplicationnamedBulkrallowsuserstosearchkeytermsanddownloadlargequantitiesofimageswiththecorrespondingmetadata.ThelocationaldatacanbebroughtintoaGeographicInformationSystem,representedaspointlocationsofwhereimagesweretakenwiththetimeanddayoftheyear.VGIhassomeinherentlimitationsanduncertaintiesthatmustbeaddressed.First,withusingcitizensasagentsofdatacollecting,theyarenotrequiredtoprovideaccuratelocationtextdescriptionsthatareessentialinthefilteringprocess.Second,GPSaccuracymayvarybyphoneandtopography,whichmayoffsetthesiteaccuracyofthetakenimagebyseveralmetresormore.Third,datacollectedmaynotincludeafullsetofassociatedlocationsforspecifickeywords.Despitetheselimitations,VGIisausefulformofauxiliarydatabecauseitprovidesactualcitizenreportedlocationsthatcanrevealinsightintotransientpopulationbehaviour.VGIdatasetsarealsodynamicinthattheyare
Page 20
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
8
continuouslyupdated.Fromthesesets,generalpatternscanbeobservedaboutwhenandwherecertainactivitiesoccur.Forinstance,astaticcampsitepointdatasetpublishedbyanestablishedorganizationoftenwillnotbeupdatedregularly.Mostlikely,itwillalsonotcontainspecifictimesofhighandlowusage,unlessfurthersupplementedfromotherdatasets.VGIdoesnothavethislimitationbecauseusersarenotrestrainedbytimeanddateofwhentheycantakeanduploadpictures.Inthecaseofcampsites,VGIdatasetscanshowatrendofhigherandlowercampingactivityinwarmandcoolseasonsrespectively.Asapilottobetterdocumentseasonaltransientpopulationtrendsandassociatedtsunaminotificationlocations,wesearchedFlickrtofollowandrecordcoastalkayakers.Thedatawasusedtosupplementexistingstudysetsandtoaddmoretemporaldimensionstoguidetheselectionoflocationsforfuturepilotprojects,asshowninFigure2.Assuch,thisformofcrowdsourcinganalysiscouldbeanotherusefultoolforidentifyingtransientpopulationsacrossavarietyofactivities,seasonsandlocationsthroughoutB.C.,especiallyinregionswherenoattendancerecordsareavailable.
Figure2:FlickrSourcedKayakingLocations
2.2.2.2SelectionofProjectNotificationTechnologyPilotsBaseduponanalysisofdatacollectedinPhase1andfeedbackfromstakeholders,asetofpilotstoevaluatenewtechniquesandtechnologieswereidentifiedthat,whencombined,
Page 21
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
9
wouldcatertobothfixedandtransientpopulationsinurban,ruralandremotecoastalsub-regions.Specialattentionwasgiventoassessingtheirsuitabilityinsub-regionsthatarepoorlyservedfromacommunicationsperspective.Thepilotsandresultsarebrieflysummarizedbelow,butdescribedindetailintheCSSPTask4report.Selectedpilotscentredon:
1. Testingandassessingsuitabilityoftwo-wayportableandmobilesatellitebasedtechnologiestoalertandcommunicatewithtransientpopulations,especiallyincoastalsub-regionsthatlackconventionalcommunicationinfrastructures;
2. InvestigationofexpandedusageofMSATEmergNetsatellitetwo-wayradiosystemtoenhancecoastalemergencyinteragencycommunicationinteroperabilityandreliability,and
3. TheAlertReadyrolloutinBritishColumbia–assessingimplicationsofNAADSforenhancingtsunamiwarningandadvisorynotification,especiallyinremotecoastalsub-regions.
Consultationswereundertakenwithabroadrangeofstakeholderstosolicittheirinput,andparticipationintheseactivitiesandpilotprojectswereinitiatedinearlySummer2015ascoastalactivitiespickedupandswungintofullseason.InterestedpartiesincludedCanadianCoastGuard,ParksCanada,coastalindustries,adventurerecreationalgroups,FirstNations,localauthoritiesandEMBC.Two-wayPortableandMobileSatellite-basedNotificationOneofthemostsignificantWestCoastnotificationchallengesiscommunicatingeffectivelywithpopulationson-the-movebothonlandandwater.OurPhase1assessmentrevealedthatthereisnoubiquitousmeansofreachingthesetransientpopulations.Currentcoastalmobilenotificationislimitedtoover-the-airAMandFMradiobroadcast,cellular,WeatheradioandCanadianCoastGuardVHFcoverage,allofwhichremainsincompletealongthecoast.Evenwhereradioandmobilesatellitecommunicationsystemsareemployed,accesstoandreliabilityofservicecanbesignificantlyinfluencedbyline-of-sightcoverageissuesduetomountainousterrainandotherobstructions.Notwithstandingthesechallenges,overthepastdecadeanumberofmobilesatellitesystemsandserviceshaveemergedthatcouldhelptoexpandmobilenotification.TheseincludeShortMessageSystem(SMS)enabledmobilesatellitephones,mobileIPbasedsatellitedevicesandtwo-waySatelliteEmergencyNotificationDevices(SENDs).Thesedevicesoperateondifferentplatforms,employingbothlowearthandgeostationaryorbitalsatellitesystemsandsupportvariousformsofmessaging.Afteraseriesofinitialtestsofsixdifferentvariationsthatcouldbepiloted,wedecidedtofocusonthemostmobile,accessibleandlikelyaffordablesystemsthatabroadrangeofcoastalpopulationsmightuseandthatwecouldtestinasmanycoastalareasaspossiblefrombothlandandmarineperspectives.Twosystemswechosewerethetwo-waySatelliteEmergencyNotificationDevices(SENDs)andShortMessageSystem(SMS)enabledmobilesatellitephones.SpecificserviceschosentoexemplifyeachweretheDelormeinReachandIridiumGoservices.Eachsupportsitsownmobilehandsetstoprovideshortmessaging
Page 22
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
10
andGPStracking,butthroughdifferentsoftwareapplicationsanduserfeatures.Botharecommerciallyavailableand,inparticular,theinReachdevicesarenowwidelysoldthroughoutdoor,sportingandelectronicsoutletsandareincreasinglybeingusedtosupportawidevarietyofrecreationalandoutdoorworksafeactivities.Thesedevicesweretestedinawidevarietyoflocations,andresultsweremappedtoverifyhowwelltheyperformedindifferentterrainsandenvironments.MSATEmergNetMSAT,NorthAmerica’slongestrunninggeostationarymobilesatelliteservice,offersbothatelephoneandatwo-wayvoice-radiocapability(calleddispatchradio).Thetwo-wayradiofunctionsmuchlikeaterrestrialtrunkingradiosystem,andofferstalk-groupsthatcanbepre-configuredfordifferentgroupsofagencies.Becausethesystemissatellite-based,otherthanrequiringuseofalocalDCpowersource,itcanoperatewithoutrelyingonlocalterrestrialinfrastructureandcanbeusedovervastgeographicareas.Thisserviceprovedtobemorereliableforacquiringandmaintaininganetworkconnectionthanmobileservicesthatrelyuponlowearthorbitsatelliteservices,particularlyinthemountainousBCcoastalregion.InB.C.,aspecialservicepackageconfiguredspecificallyforemergencypreparednessandresponseagencieshasbeendevelopedcalled“EmergNet”.Thisservicepackageincludestworadiotalk-groups(generalandprivateone-to-one),aswellasvoicetelephonecapability.EMBChasEmergNetterminalsinstalledatitsEmergencyCoordinationCentreandatallofitsProvincialRegionalEmergencyOperationsCentres.Anumberofcoastalemergencymanagement,healthandpublicsafetyagencies,includinglocalauthoritiesalsohavejoinedEmergNet.Despitethesedevelopments,EmergNetstillremainsunderutilizedfromanoperationalperspectiveand,inconsultationwithexistingsubscribersandadditionalkeystakeholders,wechosetoundertakesomesmallpilotingtoencourageexpandedusageofMSATEmergNettoenhanceemergencyPSTNandcoastalemergencyinteragencycommunicationinteroperability,includingassessingthefeasibilityofestablishingaspecialcoastalsub-network.Theseactivitieswereintegratedintomostofthecommunityandcoastalmarinepilots.AlertReadyInearly2015,EMBCbeganplanningaseriesofAlertReadypilottests,withapriorityfocusontsunaminotificationinB.C.coastalareas.Toassistintheseefforts,ourprojectteambeganworkingwithEMBCandprovidedaninitialseriesofbroadcastcoveragemaps,alongwithotherexistingcommunicationscoverageinformationfromtheproject’sGISdatabasetohelpidentifythepotentialreachofAlertReady.OneofourkeygoalswastousetheteststoverifywhichcoastalregionscanactuallyreceivealertsviaAlertReady.ThisvalidationisimportantbecauseAlertReadymayserveasoneofthefirstubiquitoustsunaminotificationdeliverysystemsforallcoastalpopulationsresidingatfixedlocations,urbanorremote.
Page 23
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
11
2.2.2.3SelectionofCommunitiesandOtherParticipantsforPilotProjects
Takingintoaccountthediversityandrangeanddistributionofnotificationarrangementsthatisrequiredfornotifyingallcoastalpopulations,weattemptedtochooseapilotprojectstrategythatwouldbeasinclusiveaspossible,bothinpopulationandlocationrepresentation,whilealsotakingintoaccountrelativelylimitedtimeframes,projectresources(staff,equipmentandtravel),availabilityofparticipantsandlogisticalchallengesofundertakingprojectsinmoreruralandremoteprojectareas.
Further,whileallcoastallocationspossesssomedegreeoftsunamirisk,ourownanalysisindicatesthatthosemostatimmediatephysicalriskfromtsunamisalsoappeartobemostatriskfromacommunicationcapabilityperspective.TheseareasincludeB.C.TsunamiNotificationZonesA,BandCand,morespecifically,thewesternareasofHaidaGwaii,(ZoneA),CentralCoast(ZoneB)andNorthernandWesterncoastalregionsofVancouverIsland(ZoneC).
Takingthesefactorsintoaccount,weattemptedto:• beculturallyandjurisdictionallydiverse;• includeasbroadacoastalarearepresentationaspractical;• includearangeofemergencyauthorities;• includecommunicationoptionsforbothfixedandtransientpopulations,and• giveprioritytoremoteregionswithlimitedaccessandcommunication.
Akeyobjectivewastousethesepilotsasameanstosampleandtogainmoreinsighttopotentialmethodsthatcanbemorefullyarticulatedinthenextprojectphase,revisingthetsunamiwarning’toolkit’.
Table1.ParticipatingCommunitiesCommunity/Region Tsunami
NotificationZone(s)
TsunamiRunupPlanningLevels(m)
Remoteness CommunicationAvailabilityRange
Gitga'atNation(HartleyBay)
B 6 Remote Medium
WuikiunxvNation B 6 Remote LowPortAlice C 9 Semi-remote Medium
Ehattesaht/ChinehkintFirstNation
C 9 Semi-remote Low
Zeballos C 9 Semi-remote LowUcluelet C 9 Rural High
TseshahtFirstNation C 9 Rural HighRegionalDistrictofMount
WaddingtonCandD 9/4.1 Urbanto
remoteHightoLow
StrathconaRegionalDistrict
CandD 9/4.1 Urbantoremote
HightoLow
Inall,localauthoritiesinsevencommunitiesandtworegionaldistrictsparticipateddirectlyintestsanddemonstrationsofdifferentcombinationsoftheselectedtechnologies(inReach,IridiumGoandMSAT).FourofthesewereFirstNationcommunities.Twoother
Page 24
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
12
regionaldistrictsdidnotdirectlyparticipateinthepilotsduetotiming.ThesewereCapitalRegionalDistrictandCentralCoastRegionalDistrict.However,wedidundertaketocarryoutsomeinitialtestingofmobiletechnologiesinthoseareas.Threeagencieswithspecificemergencyresponseresponsibilitiesalsoparticipatedinpilots.ThesewereEmergencyManagementBritishColumbia,CanadianCoastGuardandParksCanada.Atthecommunitylevels,theselectedpilottechnologieswereusedprimarilytoverifythereliabilityofcommunicationalongevacuationroutesandatassemblysites,EOCsandcommunitysupportfacilities,aswellasatotherstrategiclocations,suchasdocks,helicopterlandingsites,airstrips,etc.Communityparticipantsweregivenhands-onopportunitiestotestandcomparethemwithexistingarrangements.Inanumberofcommunitieswewereabletocombinecommunicationsdemonstrations,testingandassessmentsaspartoflocalemergencyplanningandtrainingactivities.Tosupporttestingofout-of-areacommunication,projectteammemberswereabletoparticipateinsendingandreceivingmessageswithcommunitymembers.Throughtheseprocesseswewereabletoassistinvalidatingormodifyingcurrentarrangements,determinecommunicationsissuesatproposedsafelocationsand/orevenhelptofindmoresuitablelocations,based,inpart,oncommunicationscoverage.Thisground-truthingprovedtobeinvaluableaswellasinstructiveforparticipants.Inothercases,smallertestsanddemoswereconductedasinitialproofs-of-conceptinhopesofstimulatinggreatercollaborationinthenearfuture.Inordertovisualizetestresults,datalogswereextractedfromtheinReachserver,thatrecordedGPStrackmessagestransmittedbythedevicesandwereabletobesynchronizedandcombinedwithinternallogsstoredonthedevicestoproduceacomprehensiverecordofthetravelroute.ThroughaspecialrequestmadetoinReachCanada,wewerealsoabletoobtainmoredetailedlogsthatalsoincludedthetimestampsofwhentextandGPSmessagesfromdeviceswerereceivedbytheserverandwheninboundmessageswerereceivedbydevices,allowingforacalculationofmessagingtiminganddelays.Normalwasconsideredtobewithin5minutes,Moderatelatencytobebetween5and10minutesandHighlatencygreaterthantenminutes.Bycombiningandintegratingalloftheselogsandattributes,wewereabletoplotthedataasaseriesofmapoverlaysandtoidentifycoastalsub-regionsand,morespecifically,localareaswhereterrainsaffectline-of-sitevisibilitywithsatellites.Figure2isanexampleofmessagingalongtheWestCoastTrail.MSATandIridiumdonotprovideextensiveloggingofgeocodedtracks,butsinceallofthepilottechnologieswereco-locatedduringpilots,therecordedinReachtrackswereabletobelatersynchronizedwithtimestampsfromMSATandIridiumtestsinordertoproducemapoverlaysandidentifyareaswheregeographicalobstructionsaffectedsatellitecommunication,asillustratedinFigures3and4.
Page 25
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
13
Figure3:WestCoastTrailinReachGPSandTextMessageDeliveryTiming
Figure4:CCGSBartlettIridiumGomessaging
TestLocationsFigure:5.CCGSBartlettMSATEmergNetTest
Locations
Page 26
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
14
Inadditiontocollectingandanalyzingassociatedtechnicaldata,wealsoexaminedarangeofotherfactorsandissuesthataffectthefunctionalityandusabilityofthetestedsystems.Examplesinclude:suitability;complexityofsetup,configurationanduseofdevices;batterypowermanagement;documentation;trainingandongoingusersupport;dataloggingandexportforplanning,responseandrecoveryoperations,andmulti-purposeuseoftechnology.Theresultswereincorporatedintothetsunaminotificationtoolkitdocument.Further,thismethodofengagingcommunitiesandagenciesinground-truthingworkedwellincommunitiesandisverytransferabletootherregionsofB.C.Infact,asafollowup,wehavealreadybegunusingitinseveralnon-coastalFirstNationcommunities.AlertReadyWewereabletoparticipateintheSeptember,2015EMBCAlertReadytestbyhelpingtosetupashorton-linefeedbacksurveytosolicitconfirmationfromcoastalcommunityemergencyauthoritiesabouttheirreceptionofthealertbroadcast.Afewdaysbeforethetest,anoticewassentfromEMBCRegionalManagerstocoastalemergencyauthorities,informingthemoftheupcomingtest,invitingthemtoobservethetestandthenfilloutouron-linefeedbacksurvey.At13:58HrsonSeptember16th,theAlertReadysystemwastestedbyissuingabroadcastintrusivealertonradioandTVstationanddistributionsystemsthroughoutB.C.Eventhoughtherewaslimitedadvancenoticeaboutthetest,27localcoastalauthoritiesresponded.Whilethemajorityofrespondentswerelocatedinthemoreurbancoastalsub-regionsofB.C.,ofparticularnotewereresponsesfromremotecoastalauthoritieswhosecommunitiesarelocatedinsub-regionsthatareinthemostunderservedfromacommunicationperspective.Althoughverypreliminaryatthisstage,thedataindicatesthat,barringline-of-sitetoreceivedsignals(terrestrialand/orsatellite),eventhemostremotecoastallocationsarenowwithinthecoverageoftheAlertReadysystem.WeintendtoassistEMBCinconductingsurveysduringfutureteststoverifyreceptionofmessagesthroughoutB.C.2.2.3 Phase2:Task5-TsunamiNotificationToolKit
ThefinaloutcomeofTask5wastheproductionofaBritishColumbiaTsunamiMethodsToolKitforCommunityPlanning.Themainpurposeofthetoolkitistoprovidecommunityandothercoastalauthoritieswithinformationaboutvariouswarningmethodsandprocedurestoassistthemwithplanninganddevelopingtsunamiwarningmethodsandproceduresfortheirownareas.
Thedocument,inpart,isbasedonapreviousdocumentproducedbytheSFUTelematicsResearchLabin2005,withextensiverevisionsandupdatestoreflectcontemporarynotificationpracticesandunderpinninginfrastructures.Asubstantialamountofbackgroundinformationwasincorporatedfrompreviousphasesoftheproject.
Severalothermethodswereusedtogatheradditionalinformation.AseriesofInternetandonlinejournalsearcheswereconductedconcerningwarningssystems,lessonslearnedandrecommendedgoodpractices.Provincialandfederalprogramswerereviewedandinformationwasgatheredfromotherjurisdictionsthroughinterviewsandotherpersonalcontact,avisittotheU.S.NationalOceanicandAtmosphericAssociation’sNationalTsunamiWarningCenterandparticipationintheU.S.NationalTsunamiMitigation
Page 27
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
15
Program.AdditionalinformationwasgatheredthroughparticipationinEMBC,regionalandlocalworkshops,planningmeetingsandexercises(especiallyTsunamiNotificationNetworkingGroupandrural/remotecoastalcommunity),andinterviewswithcommunicationserviceproviders,vendorsandothersupplyorganizations.Otherinformationwasderivedfromdatacollectedandanalyzedduringtheconductingofpilotprojectsandmappingandvisualizationofcompiledcoastaldatasets.
ThedocumentalsohighlightstherapidchangesoccurringintheCanadiancommunicationsenvironmentresultingfromthetransitionfromanalogtoInternetProtocol-basedfixedandmobileterrestrialandsatellitesystems.Inparticular,oneofthemostsignificantparadigmshiftsistherapidmovementawayfromtheuseoffixedsinglemodetechnologies(suchaslandlinetelephoneandover-theairbroadcasting)towardspersonalizedandgloballyconnectedmobilecommunicationtechnologies(suchaswirelesssmartdevices)whichcombinealloftheattributesoftraditionalmassandpersonalizedserviceswithnewformsofsocialcommunicationandnetworking.Consequently,toremainrelevant,tsunamiandotheremergencynotificationarrangementsnowmustdrawuponandintegrateabroadmixtureoftraditionalandcontemporarysystemstosupporttimelycommunicationwithallpotentiallyaffectedpopulations(fixedandtransient).Manyofthetoolkit’ssectionscontaininformationandstrategiesthatcanbeappliedgenericallytoall-hazardsnotification,includingbasicsofpublicwarningsystems,considerationsforeffectivewarning,aswellasmostofthenotificationmethodsexamined.
2.3 ImpactonStatedProjectOutcomes
ThisprojectcontributedtotheCSSPIntermediateOutcome6:Alertandresilientcommunitiesandthefollowingrelatedimmediateoutcomes:
• 6b:Community-basedbestpracticesenhanceresilienceandprovidecommunitieswithtoolstodevelopandimplementresilienceroadmaps,and
• 6d:Newtechnologicalcapabilitiesavailabletothepublicareimplementedandenhancecommunityresilience.
Takingthesebroadoutcomegoalsintoaccount,theprojectwasgearedtowardstheimprovementoftsunamiwarningtohelpbuildstrongcommunitiesandenableconnectedpractitioners,thusincreasingresiliencetodisastersby:
1. Identifyingmostvulnerablepopulations,hazardzonesandcommunitycapacities;2. Increasingcommunity-levelriskawarenessandencouragingappropriate
preparednessandmitigationactivities,and3. Buildingsocialcapitalthroughfacilitatingconnectednessandcommunitybuilding.
2.3.1 IdentifyingMostVulnerablePopulations,HazardZones,andCommunity
CapacitiesTheprojectenabledustocarryoutaverycomprehensivereviewanddocumentationoflocationsofcoastalpopulations-at-risk,aswellasgaininsighttotheircharacteristics,levelsofpreparednessandcurrentnotificationcapabilities.
Page 28
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
16
Asdiscussedabove,awidevarietyofmethodologieswasusedtocollect,recordandintegratethisdata.ThroughtheuseofGIS,eachdatasetwasconvertedtoalayerthathelpedtocreatecompositeviewsoftheentirecoast,aswellasspecificsub-regionsorlocations.BoththecommunitymatrixandderivedGISdatabasesenabledthedatatobesorted,filteredandvisualizedbyvirtuallyanycommonfield,includinggeographical,jurisdictional,methodofcommunicationavailable,communityattribute,etc.Thecorrelationofhumanpopulationlocationandactivitywithareageographicfeatures,tsunamihazardwarningzones,andcommunicationscoveragedatahelpedustoidentifyandvisualizetherangeofnotificationoptionsatanygivenlocationwhich,inmanycases,canserveasanimportantdeterminantoftechnicalwarningcapacity.Throughthisprocess,itwaspossibletoidentifyregionsthatareeasiertonotifythanothers,andbywhichmethods.Conversely,andperhapsmoreimportantly,throughthissameprocess,weareabletoconductgapanalysestoidentifylocationsthathavethepooresttechnicalcoverageorlowlocaluptake.Thiswasparticularlyimportantforunderstandinghowtransientpopulationscouldbeorcouldnotbenotifiedthroughconventionalmethods(suchasCoastGuardRadio,Weatheradio,cellularapps,includingSMS,Twitter,etc,),asFigure5illustratesforkayakers.Theresultsalsoallowedustoidentifycommunitiesandregionsthatwouldbesuitableforpilotingofyet-to-beadoptedconventionaland/ornewmethods,andtousein-fieldtestingtoverifyourcommunicationscoverageprojections.Theresultsweresharedwidelywithstakeholdersandotherinterestedparties.
Figure6:KayakingLocationswithMarginalTsunamiNotificationCoverage
Page 29
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
17
Anotherderivedbenefitwastheidentificationandmappingofanumberof“hidden”resourcesthatcanhelplocalandregionalemergencymanagersextendoramplifyNTWCandEMBCtsunamiwarnings.Examplesincludepagingoffiredepartmentofficialsinremotecommunitiesthroughcentralizeddispatchservices,notificationof51RCMPcoastaldetachmentofficesthroughRCMP’sOperationalCommunicationsCentres,andnotificationof51coastalambulancestationsbyBCAmbulanceService’sEmergencyResponseManagementSystem,allthreeofwhichdisseminateNTWCandEMBCTsunamiWarning,Advisory,WatchandCancellationmessages.2.3.2 IncreasingCommunity-levelRiskAwarenessandEncouraging
AppropriatePreparednessandMitigationActivitiesThroughasurveyof86coastalcommunities,wewereabletogainsomeinsightsaboutcurrentlevelsoflocaltsunamiactionplanning,warningmessagereceptionandlocaldisseminationcapabilities,aswellaseducationandawarenessactivities.AsTable2indicates,localnotificationandawarenessengagementprocessesremainunderdevelopedamongthemajorityofcommunitiessurveyed,andmoreattentionneedstobegiventoassistingcommunitiesandtheirresidentsforreducingtheirexposuretotsunamisthroughincreasedpreparednessandmitigationactivities.
Table2:LocalPlansandCapabilitiesforallLocalAuthoritiesPlansandCapabilities Sum %Total
Emergencycommunicationsplan 51 61%
Tsunamiactionplan 44 52%
Meanstoreceiveexternaltsunaminotificationsandcarryoutnecessaryactionsona24hourperday
basis 44 52%
Meanstodisseminatelocaltsunamimessagesona24hourperdaybasis 34 40%
Tsunamieducation/awarenessprogram 34 40%
Thisprojectcontributedtothiscapacitybuildinginseveralways:
• Assistingcommunitiesandregionswithassessingtheiremergencycommunicationandnotificationneedsandcapabilities;
• Providinglocalmeanstotestandvalidatenewnotificationtechniquestoassesstheirappropriatenessandreliability,and
• Incorporatingtheresultsintocommunityemergencynotificationplansandpractices.
Page 30
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
18
Muchofthisworkwascarriedoutthroughthepilotprojectsand,onanumberofoccasions,especiallyinFirstNations,inconjunctionwithlocalemergencyplanningandtrainingworkshopsfacilitatedbyMarcd’Aquino(oneoftheprojectcontributors).Thefollowingshortnarrativesdescribesomeoftheprojectoutcomesthathaveledtoimprovedpreparednessandmitigation.Communitytestingofsatellitebasedtwo-wayvoiceandtextmessagingsystems.Aboriginalgovernmentandotherlocalauthoritieshadanopportunitytotestandassesssatellitecommunicationsequipmentand,then,determinetheirsuitabilityandapplication.Initially,virtuallyallparticipantsatthestartofthesesessionsfeltsomewhatintimidatedwhentheywerefirstgivenseveraldifferentdevicestotryout.Butbytheendofthesessions,theywereexcitedabouttheexperiencesandnewknowledgegained.Testswereperformedwithkeypersonnelfromeachcommunity,whereweloggedlocationsandqualityorperformanceofequipment.Theseresultswereshared,andthemostsignificantoutcomeforthecommunitieswasfindingoutwhatworkedthebestbasedonneedsandlocationviability.Technologyvalidation.Therearemanyexamplesofhowcommunitytestinghelpedtoidentifygapsandweaknessesthatcouldnegativelyimpactlocalwarningandresponsearrangements,aswellasrevealandvalidatenewopportunitiesforfillinggaps.OneexampleconcernsacommunitythathadjustpurchasedanumberofnewWeatheradioreceiversbut,throughthetestingwithus,discoveredthattheradioswerenotequippedtoreceivethecorrectlocalbroadcastfrequency,andwereabletochangetoadifferentmodelwiththecorrectconfiguration,potentiallyavertingafutureemergencynotificationfailure,aswellasanimmediateandunnecessaryfinancialburden.Asecondexampleconcernsacommunitythatwasfinalizingplanstodevelopanewcommunitytsunamievacuationsite.Throughconductingcommunicationtestsatthesite,wewereabletodeterminethatitwasvirtuallyacompletecommunicationsdeadzoneduetoitsproximitytoanearbymountain.Fortunately,throughadditionalareatesting,anewlocationwasfound,whichhadbettercommunicationcoverageandwasonlyashortdistancefromtheoriginalproposedsite.Athirdexampleconcernstheuseofpilotedtechnologytoinitiateandsuccessfullyfacilitateanunplannedactualemergencyresponseoperation.DuringthepilotingofinReachdevicesalongtheWestCoastTrail,ourprojectmemberswereapproachedbyagroupofhikerstoassistinamedicalemergency.Byinitiatingthepre-configuredemergencycontactfeaturesonthedevice,ourmemberswereabletocontactourexternalprojectteam,theParksCanadaJasperOperationsCentreandParksManager,allofwhoimmediatelyknewtheincidentlocationthroughimbeddedgeolocationdatainthemessages.DuringtheensuingactionsourprojectteammembershelpedtocoordinatetheinformationexchangeandtheJasperCentrewasabletoreceiveadditionalinformationabouttheconditionoftheinjuredperson,localtreatmentgivenandestablisharescueplanwiththehikers.Withinlessthanfourhoursoftheoriginalnotification,theinjuredhikerwasevacuatedbyboat.
Page 31
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
19
Finally,fortheCanadianCoastGuard,theteststhattookplaceontheCGGSBartlettwereconsideredasignificantfootstepintothefuture.Themobilesatellitetwo-waymessagingtechnologiesused,demonstratedthatessentialcommunicationscanbeestablishedevenwhenVHFandcellcommunicationsaredownorotherwiseunavailable.Operationallythisallowsoperationscentres(CCGRegionalOperationsCentre,JointRescueCoordinationCentreandotherEOCs)toknowwheretheirresponseunitsarewithouthavingtocontactthemandwaitforareply.ThisgreatlyimprovestheSituationalAwarenessofanincident,providinginstantinformationforplannersandcommanders.IncorporatingtheresultsintocommunityandagencyemergencyplansandpracticesThecommunityvisitsandpilotsresultedinseveralcommunitiesacquiringorplanningtoacquirenewsystems.Bytheendofthepilotproject,threecommunitieshadpurchasedMSATEmergNetsystems,andseveralothersareplanningtodosointhenearfutureforprimarycommunitycommunicationback-upandmobilecommunicationpurposes.Forimprovedtwo-waytextmessagingandtracking,oneoftheparticipatingcommunity’sEmergencyServicesDepartmenthasbudgetedforsixoftheinReachdevicestobepurchasedin2017.ThedeviceswillbeallocatedtotheDistrict'sEmergencyManagementTeamandwillbeincorporatedintoeachmanager’semergencyresponsekits.Anexampleofwherethedevicesmaybepracticableforthecommunityisduringtsunamievacuationevents.Inthecommunity,therearesixdesignatedcommunitysafe(high)zonesallocatedforvisitorsandresidentsfortheirsafetyduringpotentialtsunamiincidents.EachEmergencyManagerhasbeengivenresponsibilityforaspecificcommunitysafezonebasedontheneighbourhoodstheyresidein.ThesecommunitysafezoneshavethepotentialtobecomeisolatedduringaCascadiaSubductionZoneevent.TheinReachdevicescouldprovetobecriticaltoolsforrelayingmessagesamongtheEmergencyManagers,thelocalEmergencyOperationCentre,andexternalpartnerswhencellphoneandothercommunicationsystemsaredown.CanadianCoastGuardhasproposednewprojectstoprovidesomeofitssurfaceresponseunitswithtabletsandsatellitetwo-waymessagingdevicesforalongerdurationtrialperiodforcommunicatingwithitsoperationscentresduringoperations.ThenewtrialswouldtoincludeGPStracking,email,SMStext,pictures,andsatellitevoicephonecommunications.ForParksCanada,inremotesettingssuchastheWestCoastTrail,itsabilitytocommunicatedirectlywithhikersduringanemergencyhasbeenverylimited.Asaresult,emergencyrespondersaretypicallydealingwithverylimitedinformationregardingtheurgencyandlocationoftheincident.Thishasoftenresultedinrespondersputtingthemselvesatgreaterriskthanwaslaterdeterminedtobenecessary.Operationallythroughthepilotproject,wewereabletoconfirmwithParksCanadathatinReachtechnologyisgenerallyeffectivealongtheWestCoastTrail.Furtherissuesremainregardingopportunitiestorepowerthedevicesduringtheremotemulti-dayhike,aswellasadoptionofthedevicesbyallhikers.ParksCanadahasexpressedinterestincontinuingthisworktoenhanceitsabilitytocommunicatewithparkusersinremotesettings.
Page 32
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
20
2.3.3 BuildingSocialCapitalthroughFacilitatingConnectednessandCommunityBuilding
Becausetheprojectfollowedaparticipatoryresearchmodel,itprovidednumerousopportunitiesforcollaborationandlocalinteractiontoenhancebothtechnicalandsocialconnectivity,aswellastechnologyandknowledgetransfer.Somekeyoutcomeswereintroducingnewmethodologiesforsupportinglocalnotificationresearchandplanning(communitynotificationmatrixtoolandGISmapping)andenablingcommunityandagencyparticipantstolearnaboutnewtechnologiesandtestandevaluatethemwithintheirownlocalgeographicalandculturalcontexts.Theprojectalsohelpedtoincreaseregionalemergencycoordinationandcontactwithresidentsinmoreremotesareas,particularlyFirstNations.Fromapracticalperspective,thecommunicationground-truthingexercisesgreatlyassistedcommunitieswithoptimizingtheselectionofevacuationlocationsbyensuringcommunicationsavailabilityandregionaldistrictsconfirming"low"and"nocontact"areaswithintheirregions,particularlymarinelocations.2.3.4 OtherEngagementDuringtheprojectperiod,over16presentationsweregiven,primarilybyPeterAnderson,including:
• April9,2014 TsunamiNotificationNetworkingGroup,Victoria• May13,2014 MountWaddingtonRegionalDistrict,PortMcNeil• July3,2014 TsunamiNotificationNetworkingGroup,Victoria• November6,2014 TsunamiNotificationNetworkingGroup,Victoria• November4,2014 Mid-IslandEmergencyManagersMeeting
(viateleconference)• December2,2014 U.S.NationalTsunamiWarningCenter,Palmer,Alaska• January23,2015 CascadiaRegionEarthquakeWorkgroup,Victoria• January28,2015 CSSPTsunamiWarningProjectReviewCommittee (viateleconference)• February10,2015 NationalTsunamiHazardMitigationProgram,Portland,
Oregon• February17,2015 NationalPublicAlertingSummit,Edmonton• February24,2015 EMBCRegionalManagersProjectBriefing
(viateleconference)• March2,2015 TsunamiNotificationNetworkingGroup,Victoria• August12,2015 EhattesahtFirstNationandVillageofZeballos• August14,2015 MountWaddingtonRegionalDistrict,PortMcNeil• November9,2015 TsunamiNotificationNetworkingGroup,Victoria• January22,2016 TsunamiNotificationNetworkingGroup,Victoria
(viateleconference)
Page 33
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
21
TheprojectalsocontributedtograduateresearchintotheuseofTwitterfortsunaminotificationandtheteachingoftwoSFUseniorundergraduatecoursesconcerningtheroleofcommunicationinmitigatingdisasters.2.3.5 ReportsandPublicationsInadditiontothisreport,fourotherprojectreportswereprepared:
1. ImprovingEnd-To-EndTsunamiWarningforRiskReductiononCanada'sWestCoast:CSSP-2013-TI-1033Task3Report,Revision1.2,12January,2015.
2. ImprovingEnd-To-EndTsunamiWarningforRiskReductiononCanada'sWestCoast:CSSP-2013-TI-1033Task4.1Report,31March,2015.
3. ImprovingEnd-To-EndTsunamiWarningforRiskReductiononCanada'sWestCoast:CSSP-2013-TI-1033Task4FullReport,Revision1.1,30November,2015.
4. BritishColumbiaTsunamiNotificationMethods:AToolkitCommunityPlanning”.ImprovingEnd-To-EndTsunamiWarningforRiskReductiononCanada'sWestCoast:CSSP-2013-TI-1033Task5Report,Revision1.2,12January,2015.
2.4 RelationshiptootherCSSPProjectsThisprojectcloselyalignswithtwootherCSSPProjects:
1. FieldOperationalTestFacilityForNext-GenerationInteroperableMission-CriticalCommunicationsand
2. WirelessPublicAlertingService(WPAS)DevelopmentandDemonstrationInitiative.
2.5 RecommendationsForFurtherAdvancingTsunamiNotification
1. Annuallyupdatethecommunitynotificationmatrixthroughanonlinesurvey;2. GISmapping.Continueidentifyingcoastaldatasourcestofurthersupportspatial
analysisofresources,vulnerabilityandmitigation;3. Continueworkingwithorganizationstogatherinformationabouttransient
populations,includingtourismguides,touroperators,accommodationproviders,industrysectors,regionaldistricts,parksmanagers;
4. Establishaspecialtsunamiawarenessandpreparednessinitiativeformaritimeandtransientpopulations;
5. Increaseawarenessthroughspecialeventssuchasoutdoorrecreationshows;6. Continueworkingwithcommunitiesinenhancingemergencyplanningand
responsearrangementsthroughlocaltestingandground-truthingofcommunicationandnotificationtechnologiesandon-sitetraining,and
7. Improveintegrationofexistingnotificationtechniquesatalljurisdictionallevels(discussedinmoredetailinSections3and4).
Page 34
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
22
3.0 LeveragingTsunamiNotificationPracticestoSupportB.C.All-HazardsNotification
3.1 Background3.1.1 B.C.GeographyAsof2011,thepopulationofBritishColumbiawas4.4millionpeople.ThemajorpopulationcentresareMetroVancouver(pop.2.4million)andtheCapitalRegionalDistrict(pop.370,000).Otherpopulationcentresinclude:Kelowna,Kamloops,Nanaimo,ChilliwackandPrinceGeorge.Thereare27regionaldistricts,160municipalities,198FirstNationsbandsandsixtreatyFirstNationscommunitiesinB.C.BritishColumbiaisethnicallyandculturallydiverse.Accordingtothe2001census,thetoptenlanguagesintheprovinceareEnglish,Chinese,Punjabi,German,French,Tagalog,Spanish,Italian,KoreanandDutch.Eachyearover40,000immigrantsarrivefromaroundtheworld.BritishColumbiaisborderedby:
• TheNorthwestandYukonterritoriestothenorth;• Alaskatothenorthwest;• Albertatotheeast;• PacificOceantothewest,and• WashingtonState,IdahoandMontanatothesouth;
BritishColumbia’secologyisvariedwithcoastal,mountainous,plateauanddesertterrains,aswellasextensiveriverandlakesystems.B.C.’stotallandandfreshwaterareais95millionhectares,occupyingabouttenpercentofCanada'slandsurface.BritishColumbiahasnearly1,000provincialparksandprotectedareas,attractingabout20millionvisitorseachyear.
3.1.2 HazardsinBritishColumbia
ThediversityofBritishColumbia’sclimate,geography,settlementandlandusepatternsandeconomicactivitiescreatesaverydiverseprovincialhazardprofile.Over50naturalandhuman-inducedhazardshavebeenidentifiedwithinB.C.,andcontinuedurbanizationandclimatechangeareexpectedtodirectlyinfluencethenumber,typesandseverityofdisastersfacedbyindividuals,communitiesandalllevelsofgovernmentinthecomingdecades.High-riskhazardsaredetailedasfollows:
• Seismic-Earthquakes• Tsunami
Page 35
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
23
• VolcanicEruption• Wildfire• Flood• Drought• Hazardousmaterialsevent• OilSpills• Dambreaches• Pandemics• Terrorism,includingChemical,Biological,Radiological,NuclearandExplosiveEvents
(CBRNE)3.1.3 BritishColumbiaEmergencyManagementResponsibilities
TheB.C.EmergencyProgramActanditsregulationssetoutthebroadresponsibilitiesforemergencymanagementwithintheprovince.UndertheauthorityoftheAct,EMBCisdesignatedastheleadcoordinatingagencyintheprovincialgovernmentforallemergencymanagementactivities.EMBCprovidesexecutivecoordination,strategicplanningandmulti-agencyfacilitation,andstrivestodevelopeffectiveworkingrelationshipsinanincreasinglycomplexemergencymanagementenvironment.EMBCworkswithlocalgovernments,FirstNations,federaldepartments,industry,non-governmentorganizationsandvolunteerstosupporttheemergencymanagementphasesofmitigation,prevention,preparedness,responseandrecovery.Additionally,EMBCengagesprovincial,nationalandinternationalpartnerstoenhancecollectiveemergencypreparedness.TheEmergencyProgramActandtheLocalAuthorityEmergencyManagementRegulationestablishtheresponsibilityofB.C.localauthoritiestodevelopemergencyplansbasedonthehazardsandvulnerabilitiesintheircommunities.Localauthoritiesrangefromsmallisolatedcommunitieswithlimitedresourcesandveryspecificrisks,tolargemetropolitanareaswithcomplexriskprofilesandextensiveresourcecapabilitiestomeetresponseandcoordinationchallenges.Basedonhazard,riskandvulnerabilityassessments,emergencyplansneedtobedevelopedtoalevelrequiredtomeetcommunityneedsandaddressassociatedriskprofiles.3.1.4 ComprehensiveEmergencyManagementPlanTheComprehensiveEmergencyManagementPlan(CEMP)shapesEMBC'semergencyplanningstructure.CEMP’sfoundationisbasedontheB.C.All-HazardPlanthatoutlinestheprovincialconceptofoperations,aswellastherolesandresponsibilitiesthatareapplicableinallemergenciesordisasters.TheAll-HazardPlandoesnotoverridelocalauthorityplans,exceptwherealocalauthorityisunderaprovincialstateofemergency.
Page 36
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
24
Duringeventsthatrequiretheactivationoftheprovincialemergencymanagementsystem,boththelocalauthorityplanandtheAll-HazardPlanmaybeactivated.Emergenciesvaryinscopeandintensity,fromsmall,localizedincidentswithminimaldamage,tomulti-jurisdictionaldisastersresultinginextensivedevastationandlossoflife.Forplanningpurposes,emergenciesanddisastersarethoseeventsthatcanresultin:
• Fatalities;• Casualties;• Displacedpeople;• Interruptionofessentialpublicservices;• Propertydamageorloss;• Economicimpacts;• Damagetobasicinfrastructure,and• Significantharmtotheenvironment.
Thereare“no-notice”and“notice”events.“No-notice”eventsarerapidonsetemergencyeventssuchasflashfloodsandlandslidesthatoccurwithlittleornowarning,andcancauseanextremeemergencyconditioninanyareaoftheprovince.Duringa“notice”slower-onsetemergencyevent,priorwarningmaycomefromlocalprogramsoroutsideorganizationsthathaveaccesstoscientificmethodsforpredictinghazardssuchastsunamis,floods,forestfiresandsevereweather.Wherereliablepredictionispossible,actioncanbetakenbeforetheonsetofanemergency.3.1.5 LocalAuthorityResponseTheEmergencyProgramActestablishesthatalocalauthorityisatalltimesresponsibleforthedirectionandcontrolofthelocalauthority'semergencyresponse.TheLocalAuthorityEmergencyManagementRegulationfurtherrequiresthateverylocalauthorityinBritishColumbiaestablishanemergencymanagementorganization,developandmaintainacurrentlocalemergencyplanandestablishprocedurestoimplementtheplan.Duringactivations,localauthoritieswillinitiateactionstosavelivesandpropertyinsupportoftheincidentsitecommand,usingjurisdictionalresources,aswellasresourcesavailablethroughmutualaid/assistanceagreements.However,ifthesituationescalatesbeyondlocalcapacity,theprovincialemergencymanagementstructurewillbeactivated.3.1.6 ProvincialResponseAttheprovincialgovernmentlevel,EMBCprovidescoordinationwithprovincialministriesandcrowncorporationsinsupportoflocalgovernmentresponse.Provincialemergencyresponseassistanceisintendedtosupplementnotsubstitutecommunityresources.EmergencyresponseandrecoveryiscarriedoutinaccordancewiththeB.C.EmergencyResponseManagementSystem(BCERMS).EMBCcanactivate,onshortnotice,oneormoreofitssixProvincialRegionalEmergencyOperationsCentres(PREOCs)and/orthe
Page 37
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
25
ProvincialEmergencyCoordinationCentre(PECC)tocoordinateprovincialresponseandrecovery,monitoremergencyeventsandassistimpactedcommunitiesinemergencyresponseandrecovery.Ifseveralministriesareinvolvedinanintegratedprovincialresponse,EMBCwillcoordinateintegratedprovincialemergencymanagementthroughthePREOCsandPECC.3.1.7 TheDutytoNotify
ThedutytonotifyisestablishedundertheauthorityoftheB.C.EmergencyProgramActanditsregulations.Asindicatedearlier,thelocalauthorityis“atalltimesresponsibleforthedirectionandcontrolofthelocalauthority’semergencyresponse”,and,aspartofthelocalemergencyplan,must“establishproceduresbywhichthosepersonswhomaybeharmedorwhomaysufferlossarenotifiedofanemergencyorimpendingdisaster”.
Provincially,accordingtotheAct,theministermay“conductpublicinformationprogramsrelatingtoemergencypreparedness”andmust“provideadviceandassistancetolocalauthoritiesinthedevelopmentoflocalemergencymanagementorganizationsandlocalemergencyprograms”,and“coordinateorassistincoordinatingthegovernment'sresponsetoemergenciesanddisasters”.
TheProvincemustalso“assistlocalauthoritieswithresponsetoorrecoveryfromemergenciesordisastersthatareofsuchmagnitudethatthelocalauthoritiesareincapableofeffectivelyrespondingorrecoveringfromthem.”
Thisassistancemayincludebothamplifyinglocalemergencynotificationsthroughitsprovincialchannels(e.g.,email,websitesandsocialmedia),aswellassupportingwideareanotificationthatisbeyondthecapacityoflocalauthorities,suchastsunamiwarning.
3.2 B.C.PublicNotificationArrangements
AcrossBritishColumbia,awidevarietyofemergencynotificationsystemsareusedtosupportall-hazardswarning.Asdiscussedabove,generally,localauthoritiesareresponsibleforissuingwarningsabouthazardsthatposerisktopopulationsresidingwithintheirjurisdictions,andwarningsareparticularlyimportantwhenprotectiveactionsarerequired,suchasevacuationorshelteringinplace.
However,localauthoritiesarenotalwaystheoriginatorsofinitialwarnings,especiallythosethatspreadbeyondanylocaljurisdictionorrequiretheinputandguidanceofhazarddomainspecialists.Inmanyofthesesituations,otheragenciesmaybedelegatedresponsibilityforissuinginitialwarningsforhazards.Examplesare:EnvironmentCanadaforextremeweatherandairquality;theB.C.RiverForecastCentreforflood,andAvalancheCanadaforavalanches.Industryalsousesawidevarietyofotherwarningsystemstoreachpeopleatriskaroundcriticalfacilitiessuchchemicalplantsanddams.Anevenmorecomplexarrangementinvolvestsunaminotification,inwhichEMBCservesastheofficialCanadianWestCoastreceivingpointforU.S.NationalTsunamiWarningCenter(NTWC)messagesthatconstitutethetriggersforissuingB.C.tsunamiwarnings.In
Page 38
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
26
caseswhereNTWCissuesatsunamiWarning,AdvisoryandWatch,EMBC’senhancednotificationprocesswillbeimmediatelyinitiated,usingsocialmedia,EmergencyCoordinationCentreemail,PENS(theProvincialEmergencyNotificationSystem,anautomatedemail,texttovoicetelephoneandfaxsystem),theEmergencyInfoBCwebsiteandAlertReady.However,ifNTWCissuesanearthquakenotificationthatdoesnotresultinanytsunamithreat,EMBCmaynotissueanotificationtoitsgreateraudienceorviasocialmedia.EMBC’sinitialmessagingtargetsareemergencyandpublicsafetyauthorities,criticalinfrastructureandserviceprovidersandthemedia,althoughthepubliccanalsobenotifiedviaEMBCinitiatedsocialmediaandAlertReady.And,eventhoughthepublicmayreceiveNTWCandEMBCtsunamiwarningsorotherinformationthroughthesechannels,localauthoritiesarestillrequiredtodirectlycommunicatethethreattoasmanyoftheiraffectedpopulationsaspossible.
3.3 CurrentNotificationChallenges
Establishinganintegratedall-hazardsB.C.approachtopublicwarningisacomplexprocessinwhichanumberofchallengesmustbeaddressed,includingthefollowing:
• Manyofthehazardspecificnotificationarrangementshaveevolvedindependentlyamongdifferentorganizationsandjurisdictionswithdifferentmandatesandgovernancestructures;
• Warningsfromdifferentsourcesoftenusedifferentterminologytoexpressthesameissuesofriskandrecommendedaction;
• Thereareveryfewcommonstandards,protocols,orproceduresfordevelopingandissuingwarningmessages;
• Thereisnocentralizedcoordinationorsetofcommontechnicalstandardsforallhazarddomains;
• Fewlocalemergencymanagersorfirstrespondershaveeffectivewaystoinputinformationandwarningsintomanyofthesesystems;
• Therearedifferentsystemaccessarrangementsforpublicengagement(somehavevoluntaryopt-inwhileothershavenoopt-outprovisions);
• Notificationsystemsusedifferenttechnologiesandhavedifferentpublicreach;• Manyofthesystemsarenotinteroperable,and• Manysystemsarebecomingobsoleteordonottakeintoaccountrapidlychanging
publicusagepatterns.
3.4 LeveragingTsunamiNotificationArrangements
Tsunaminotificationisaparticularlyusefulmodelasacontributortoall-hazardsnotificationasitconstitutesBritishColumbia’smostintegratedend-to-endsystemofsystemsandtakesintoaccountadiversityofpopulationsandlocalitiestobeserved,rangingfromheavilypopulatedurbancentrestotinysettlementsanddestinationspotslocatedinsomeoftheworld’smostruggedandaccessibilitychallengedterrains.Nosinglenotificationmethodcanreachallpopulations-at-risk,andauthoritiesarerequiredto
Page 39
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
27
employawiderangeoflegacyandcontemporarycommunicationtechnologiesandstrategies.Thespecificmethodsandtechnologiesusedlargelydependupontherequirementsandcapacitiesofthelocalcommunitiesinvolved.Regardlessofthemethod,additionalcriticalconsiderationsareconsistencyinapplicationandmessaging,timeliness,aswellasensuringwidespreadpublicknowledgeofthenatureoftherisks,methodsofnotificationandexpectedactions.Muchcanbelearnedfromtheseeffortstoprovideeffectiveintegratedandconsistentnotificationinthecoastalregion,assimilargeo-politicalfeaturesandnotificationchallengesexistinotherregionsofBritishColumbia.ThechoicesofmethodsemployedeverywhereintheProvinceareheavilyinfluencedbythephysicallocationandnatureofthepopulation(e.g.residentsvs.non-residents),availablesupportinginfrastructures,institutionalandjurisdictionalarrangements,localcustomsandeconomicandsocialactivities.InmanyB.C.ruralandremoteregions,communicationwithpopulations-at-riskremainchallengedbecauseoflimitedmodesoftransportationandwidelydispersedpopulationsthatvaryaccordingtoseasonalfluctuationsandeconomiccircumstances.Fromanelectroniccommunicationperspective,particularlyinruralareas,therearewidelyvaryinglevelsofaccesstoservices(especiallybasiclandlineandcellulartelephone,Internetandlocalbroadcastingservices)duetohigherinfrastructurecosts,smallersupportingpopulationsandgreaterdistancesfromlargercentres.Evenwheretwo-wayradioandsatellitecommunicationsystemsareemployed,accesstoandreliabilityofservicecanbeaffectedbyline-of-sightcoverageissuesduetomountainousterrain.Inrecognizingthesechallenges,theProvincehasembarkedonseveralinitiativestobringaffordablebroadbandservicestoallBritishColumbians,including:
• ConnectingBritishColumbiaAgreementtoincreaseaccesstoInternetservicesinruralandremoteareasandexpandaccesstocellularservicesalongunconnectedsegmentsofprovincialhighways;
• BCBroadbandSatelliteInitiativetohelpmakeaccesstosatellite-basedhigh-speedInternetmoreaffordableforcitizensandsmallbusinessesinremoteareasthatcurrently,andfortheforeseeablefuture,havenootherbroadbandInternetsolutions,and
• PathwaystoTechnologyProgramledbyFirstNationsorganizationswiththegoalofconnectingorenhancingconnectivitytoall203ofB.C.'sFirstNationscommunities.
Currently,high-speedInternetservicesareavailableto94%ofBritishColumbianhouseholds.BritishColumbiahasagoalof100%ofitsresidentshavingaccesstohigh-speedInternetservicesby2021.ThesedevelopmentswilllaythefoundationsforcreatingarangeofnewoptionsforintegratingandstandardizingemergencynotificationarrangementssupportedthroughInternetProtocol-basedfixedandmobileterrestrialandsatellitesystems.Thesesystemsaremoreaddressable,becomingmoreaffordableandwidespreadinuse,includingnewdataexchangeschemes,suchastheCommonAlertingProtocol(CAP),andofferopportunitiestobettermanage,integrateandtargetwarning
Page 40
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
28
messagessimultaneouslyacrossawidevarietyoffixedandmobiledisseminationsystems,withexponentially-growingcommunicationcapacity.Nationally,effortsareunderwaytocapitalizeonthesedevelopmentsthroughtheestablishmentofaNationalPublicAlertingSystem(NPAS).TheseeffortsbuildontheworkofCanadianfederal,provincialandterritorialgovernmentsandtheCanadianRadio-televisionandTelecommunicationsCommission(CRTC).NPASembodiesanall-channelcommunicationsapproachtoenablealertingauthoritiestotransferasinglealertingelectronicinformationfiletoacentralcollectionpointforpublicdistributionthroughavarietyofestablishedcommunicationsmedia.ThesedigitalalertmessagesmayalsoberedistributedthroughmultiplemethodsbyotherLastMileDistributors(LMDs)andthepublic.Presently,emergencyalertsarebeingdistributedthroughtheuseofasingleNationalAggregationandDisseminationSystem(NAADS)thatisoperatedbyPelmorexCommunicationsInc.(TheWeatherNetwork).SincetheNAADSystembecameavailablein2010,EnvironmentCanadaandall13provinces/territorieshavecompleteduseragreementstoissueoracceptemergencyalertsviatheirEmergencyManagementOrganizationsthroughtheNAADSystem.ThefirstnationalpublicalertinitiativetouseNAADSisAlertReady,whichlinkstoCanadianlicensedover-the-airtransmittersandbroadcastingdistributionandvideo-on-demandundertakingstoenableauthorizedemergencyorganizationstoprovidewarningmessagesdirectlytolistenersandviewers.Asthesystemexpands,itwillincludetheparticipationofcellphonecompanies,socialmediawebsitesandotherInternetandmultimediadistributors.Onthepublicsafetycommunicationsfront,newopportunitiesareemergingtoimproveinteragencyemergencynotificationandsituationalawarenessthroughanewpublicsafetybroadbandnetworkinitiative.WhilethesechangesholdpromisefordramaticallyexpandingthereachofpublicemergencymessagedisseminationacrossCanada,anumberofadditionalstepsneedtobetakentointegratethesearrangementswithexistingnotificationmethods,andensureadoptionbytheemergencymanagementorganizationsandthepublic.Beginningin2015,andcontinuingthrough2016,EmergencyManagementBritishColumbia(EMBC)hascommencedaseriesofprovince-widepilottestsoftheBritishColumbiaEmergencyAlertingSystem(BCEAS)componentofAlertReadytoenhancetsunaminotificationinB.C.coastalareas.Whiletsunamiwarningisthekeyinitialfocus,theenvisionedgoalisfortheBCEAStoeventuallyencompassallhazardsandallregions.Simultaneously,aspartofitsStrategicPlan,EMBChasembarkedonaprogramtointegrateandreplaceitslegacynotificationsystems,whichrequiremanualmanagementofcontactinformationforwarningdissemination,withahostedmulti-channelsolution.Drawinguponexperiencefromthecurrentproject,thefollowingobservationsandrecommendationsareofferedtofurthertheseefforts.Anumberofthemethodsusedintsunaminotificationwarningcanserveasfoundationalelementsforanall-hazardssystem.AmongthesearetheProvincialEmergencyNotificationSystem,AlertReadyandsocialmediaservicessuchasTwitterandEmergencyInfoBCwebsite.Presently,thesesystemsarenotfullyintegratedandrequiremanualinputtingof
Page 41
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
29
messageinformation.Further,theintendedmessagerecipientsandrequirementsforscalingandgeo-targetinghavenotbeenfullyidentifiedonaprovince-widebasis.3.4.1Recommendations3.4.1.1BackgroundStudies
1. ConductacomprehensivestudytoidentifyandanalyzewhatexistinghazardeventnotificationsystemsareavailabletothepublicthroughoutBritishColumbia,including:
o Theunderpinningtechnologies;o Coverage;o Interoperability;o Easeofintegrationwithothersystems;o Howwellmessagingcanbegeographicallytargetedinassociationwiththe
areasatrisk,ando Governanceandotherinstitutionalarrangements.
2. Usingexistingtsunaminotificationmethodsaspotentialfoundationalcomponentsforall-hazardsnotification,conductastudytoassesstheirprovince-wideavailabilityandsuitabilityforeachformofhazardnotification.
3. ExtendcurrentmappingofcoastalcommunicationscoveragetoincludeallofB.C.,andinclude:
o AM,FMandTV;o CableandSatelliteTV;o MobilecellularHSPAandLTE;o Fixedbroadband;o Weatheradiobeyondimmediatecoastalareas,ando Otheragencyradiosystems.
4. Identifyanddocumenttheuniquefeaturesofunderpinningcommunicationsnetworkingarrangements.Forexample,manybroadcastingstationsusenetworkedrebroadcastingtransmitterstoextendcoveragetoadjacentareasortosupportregionalnetworking.ForAlertReadypurposes,CRTCregulationsrequireallprogramoriginatingstationsandassociatedrebroadcastingstationstobeincludedwhenalertmessagesareissued.However,inBritishColumbia,thesenetworkscanstretchintoareaswellbeyondtheimpactsofalocalhazardevent.Assuch,itisimportanttounderstandthepotentialforoverwarning.
5. Carryouton-linesurveyswithlocalemergencymanagersandthepublicduringanAlertReadyprovincialtesttoconfirmreceiptofmessages,effectivenessandfunctioningoftheoverallsystem.
6. MonitorcommunicationtrendsinB.C.toensurethatallusergroupsandtheircommunicationcustomsareproperlyidentifiedandtakenintoaccount.
Page 42
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
30
3.4.1.2EnhancementsofCurrentProvincialNotificationSystems
1. BeginningwithPENSandAlertReadyfortsunamiwarning,developanautomatedprocessforimportingNTWCmessagedata(NTWCCAPfeeds)intotemplatesthatcanbeeasilyandquicklyeditedbyEMBCdutymanagerstoaddressB.C.specificrequirements.
2. DevelopanautomatedprocessusingopensourcetoolstoexportallPENSmessagesinCAP-CP,RSS,email,Twitterandotherstandardizedformatstoimprovetimeliness,consistencyandaccuracyinmessagingcontentandnotification.
3. Reviewandincorporate,whereappropriate,bestpracticesandexperienceofothernotificationproviderssuchasNTWC,EnvironmentCanadaandAlbertaEmergencyAlert.
4. Developamobileappfortsunamiwarningthatcouldserveasapilotforanall-hazardsapp,similartoEMBC’suseof@EmergencyinfoBC.
5. Investigatestandardsandprotocolsforautomatedmessagedeliverytoanddisplayonnetworkedelectronicsigns,includingapilotforprovincialroadsigns,aswellasautomaticupdatingoftheEmergencyInfoBCandotherwebsitessuchasDriveBC.
6. UsetheproposedPENSenhancementsasapilottodefineandconductproof-of-conceptassessmentsforahostedall-hazardsProvincialhub,basedonopenstandards,andintegratedwithnationalNPAS,Multi-agencySituationalAwarenessSystem(MASAS),andotherthird-partyemergencyapplications.
3.4.1.3EducationandTraining
1. Throughpartnerships,establishaprovincialframeworkforimprovingpublicwarningeducationandtraining,includingestablishingcriteriaforcertification.
Toprovideforeffectiveuseofpublicwarning,everywarningauthorityshouldhaveaplanforhow,inaimingtobenefitthepublic,itusesnotificationsystemsthatincorporateexistingandemergingnotificationsystems.Toprepareaneffectiveplan,anauthorityfirstmusthaveafullunderstandingoftheenvironmentinwhichtheauthorityoperates.Everycommunityisdifferentintermsofneedsandthreats.Thecurrentsituationwillneedtobeexplored,suchasanticipatedthreats,populationsat-risk(includinglocations),capabilities,andauthority.Goalsandobjectivesneedtobedefined,andaplanpreparedthatincludesdetailsofrolesandresponsibilities.
EspeciallyasAlertReadyandothernewservicesrollout,allusersmustunderstandthesystemsandprocedures,whichcanbeaccomplishedthroughinitialandrecurringtrainingandexercises.Whilethecurrenttsunaminotificationsystemcannotserveallnotificationpurposes,manyofitsunderlyingprinciples,whichhavebeenoutlinedinpreviousprojectreports,especiallyTask3andTask5(ToolKit),arecommonandcanbeincorporatedintoall-hazardnotificationpractices.Integratingnotificationsystemsintoregularoperationsalsohasbenefits;itbuildsfamiliaritywithsystems,enablesbetterthinkingskills,andprovidesbetter
Page 43
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
31
responsetoemergencies,includingrespondersafety.Useshouldincludeoperationofthetechnology,aswellasformingmessagesanddeterminingdistributionchannels,allofwhichwillbuildskills.
Whileusersrequireactualtrainingonalertandnotificationsystems,thepublicshouldalsobe“trained.”Educatingthepublicwillincreasethelikelihoodthatthepublicwilltakeactionstoprotectthemselveswhenanactualeventoccurs.Thecurrentprovince-widetestingofAlertReadycanserveasavaluableinputtothisprocess.
Page 44
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
32
4.0 TheWayForward:TransitioningtoaSmartB.C.All-HazardsNotificationSystem
Section3.4outlinedprovisionsforinitiatinganintegratedProvincialall-hazardspublicnotificationsystembyusinganenhancedProvincialEmergencyNotificationSystemasafoundationforahostedmulti-channelpublicnotificationsolution.SuchaninitiativeisalsoinalignmentwithB.C.residents’andvisitors’useofmoderntechnologyandcommunicationexpectations.
Theworldisrapidlychangingasthepublicandindustrymovetonewsmartphoneandbroadbandcellularcommunicationstechnologies.ThePublicalsoneedstohaveaccesstotoolsforprovidingandreceivinghazardeventinformationandhelpinginanemergency,andthatarecompatiblewithamodern,mobile,smartphone-dominatedworld.Internet-enabledmobiletechnology,especiallysmartphonesandbroadbandmobilewireless,isparticularlycriticaltopublicsafetybecauseitcanprovideforrapidtargetedalertingandenhancedsituationalawarenesssimultaneouslythroughmultiplechannelsandapplications.
MobileandInternet-connectedtechnologiesarebecomingdominant,leadingtotheemergingInternetofThings(IoT)ofhighlyconnectedpeople,computersandsensors.Asdemonstratedinourpilotprojects,eventhemostremoteB.C.regionscannowbeconnectedthroughIPenabledmobilesatellitesystems.Theresultisthatlegacytechnologies,previouslyusedinemergencyresponseandpubliccommunication,suchasagencyLand-MobileRadio(LMR),landlinetelephone,facsimile,broadcastradiotechnologies(manydatingbacktothe1930’swithlittlechange)arenowinanexponentialdeclineinrelativecapability,availabilityandrelevancetoapublicthatisincreasinglyconnectedtoandbyweb-basedandsocialmediaresources.Thisdeclineisrapidlyreachingacriticalpointwhereatransitionofagenciestomoderntechnologyisrequired,whilealsoensuringthatmembersofthepublichavethesmarttools,includingsmartphones,cellularcommunicationnetworks,apps,instantmessagingandsocialmediatoolsthattheyneedtobepreparedandsafeinemergenciesandmajordisasters.
Recognizingthislife-criticaltransition,inadditiontoinitiativessuchasNPAS,NAADS,includingAlertReadyandWirelessPublicAlertingService,Canadaisinthebeginningstagesofpreparingforanadvancedbroadbandcellularcommunications-basedPublicSafetyBroadbandNetwork(PSBN)andhasauniqueopportunitytoachieveacomprehensivevisionforenhancingthesafetyandsecurityofallCanadians.Asimilartransitionisinprocessthrougharangeofhighly-fundednationalandinternationalinitiativesaroundtheworld,includingintheUSandEurope,andB.C.mustnotbeleftbehind;carefulplanningandstrongcommitmentcancreateacutting-edgepublicsafetycommunicationssystemtoallowfirstrespondersanywhereinthecountrytocommunicatewitheachother,sendingandreceivingcriticalvoice,videoanddatatosavelives,reduceinjuries,andimpactstopropertyandtheenvironment.Broadbandfixedandmobilenetworkscanalsodisseminatevitalinformation(inmultipleformatsandlanguages)tothepublicduringemergencies.However,thesenewprocessesandtoolsmustinterfacetothe
Page 45
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
33
publicandmustbecompatiblewiththerichandubiquitouscommunicationstoolsthatthepublicisusing.
BothCanadaandtheU.S.haveadoptedLongTermEvolution(LTE)asthetechnicalstandardfor700MHzwirelessPSBNtosupport“smartphone”technology,withsoftwareapplications,messagingandvoicecommunicationsanywhere,anytime.LTEisthesamestandardadoptedforcommercialcellularusebut,forPSBN,willrequirehigherstandardsofreliability,resiliencyandsecurity.Inaddition,thecommercialcommunicationsindustryisinitiatingthetransitionfrom4thGenerationtechnologiessuchasLTEtonew5thGeneration(5G)technologies,andthisprocessmustalsobeaddressedbytheEmergencyManagementcommunitywhileadoptingsmarttechnologies.
Whilemanyrespondersandemergencymanagershaveexperienceinusinginformationandcommunicationtechnologiesinanofficeenvironment,extendingthistofield-leveloperationscanbeanewexperienceand/orbelimitedtouseofavailablecommercialservicesthathavenotbeendesignedorscaledforemergencyuse.Majoron-demandcriticaloperationsrequirespecialin-fieldinteroperabilitysolutionsthatoftendifferfromday-to-dayurbansolutions.Further,Canada,andespeciallyBritishColumbia,alsohascomplexterrainsandmanyareasoflowpopulationdensityforwhichextensionofemergingfixedPSBNsystemsisimpractical.Intheseareas,PSBNwillneedtobedeployedonanas-neededbasis.DeployablesystemswillalsobeneededinruralandurbanareasthatdonothaveenoughPSBNcapacityorwhenmajoremergenciesoverwhelmexistingcapacity.
Toaddresstheseneeds,anotherCSSPsupportedprojected,ledbySimonFraserUniversity’sTelematicsResearchLab,hasrecentlyestablishedCanada’sfirstnationalin-fieldPSBNwirelesstestingandvalidatingcapability,specificallyfocusedondeployableLTEsystemstosupportdisasterresponsesituationswhereconventionalcommunicationinfrastructuresaredamagedornon-existent.Thisuniqueandinnovativefield-basedPSBNfacilityistestingdifferentbackhaultechniquesconnectedtoemergingbroadbandsystemsandcontributingtothedevelopmentofnewprotocolsandstrategiestoovercomeconnectivityandinteroperabilityproblems.TwocorefieldtestlocationshavealreadybeenestablishedintheMetroVancouverandtheInteriorregionsofBritishColumbia.
Similarly,membersofthepublicandcommunityleadersneedtohaveaccesstonewtoolsovercommercialInternetandsmartphonenetworking,andbeawareandcomfortablewiththesetools,beforeamajoremergencyordisasterofthescalethatcanstrikeinBritishColumbiaoccurssuchas:earthquakes,tsunamis,landslides,floods,avalanches,andwildfires,plusemergingnewrisks,suchasriots,terrorismandmajorcriminalactivities.BecausetheSFUin-fieldPSBNwirelesstestingfacilityusesthesametechnologybaseascommercialsystems,itcanalsoserveasaproto-typingfacilityfornext-generationemergencynotification.
Inadditiontoaidingthetransitionofresponderagenciesandthepublictosmarttechnology-enabledemergencymanagement,awarenessandnotificationsystems,itisalsoimportanttosupportthetransitionofcriticalB.C.industriestomodernappropriatetools,toallowsupportofinfrastructure,businesscontinuity,andforindustrysupportof
Page 46
Improving End-To-End Tsunami Warning for Risk Reduction on Canada's West Coast (CSSP-2013-TI-1033)
34
governmentandrespondersduringmajoremergenciesanddisasters.Furthermore,B.C.possessesmanybusinessesthatbuildsmarttechnologytoolsforemergencymanagement,andmanythatcanenterthemarket.ItisimportanttohaveanenvironmentinwhichthesebusinessescangrowwhilesupportingthesavingoflivesandtheenvironmentinourProvince,compatiblewiththe2016#BCTECHStrategy.
Consequently,thereareimportantsynergiesandbenefitstobegainedfromthesecombineddevelopments.
4.1 Recommendations
4.1.1 EngagementandCollaboration
1. Supportthetransitiontomodern,mobilesmartphone-enabledemergencycommunicationsandoperationsforagencies,communitiesandthepublic,inmajoremergenciesanddisastersthroughpartnershipsandnewinitiativesthatenableemergencymanagementpractitionerstoworkwithtechnologists,academia,governmentandindustrypartnerstoexploreandtestoptionstosolvepublicsafetycommunicationandinteroperabilityproblemsinpublicalerting,SAR,flood,wildfire,seismic,tsunamiandotheremergencyresponse.
2. EnhanceandexpandexistingSFUCSSP-fundedPublicSafetybroadbandfacilitiestosupportextensiveurbanandlong-rangerural,remoteandcommunity-deployedtestsofawiderangeofconsumerandgovernmentsmarttechnologies,onland,onwaterandintheair,and
3. Supportcontinuousoutreachtoagenciesandcommunities,through:o Workshopsandtraining;o Community/agencyprojects;o Communityandagencyvisitsanddemonstrationsforbothunderstanding
requirements,anddiscussinganddemonstratingmodernsmartandmobileemergencymanagementtechnology,and
o Exercisesandspecialevents.
4.1.2 GuidanceandCoordination
1. Inalignmentwithnationallyadoptedapproaches,establishaProvincialPublicAlertingWorkingGrouptobuildconsensusaroundandacceptanceof:
o Provincialpublicalertingprinciples,guidelinesandoperatingprocedures;o Technicalprotocolsandstandards;o Proceduresandprotocolsforcoordinatingwarningsthatimpactmultiple
jurisdictions;o Commonterminologyforall-hazardnotification;o Standardmessageprotocolsandtemplates;o Pilotprojectstotestconceptsandapproaches;o Trainingandcertificationstandards,ando Educationandoutreachcampaigns.