January 2011 Cover Story Outsource And Compete The jewellery retailer’s new mantra Special Report Impulse Buying – The Growing Sales Driver Focus Re-inventing The Shopping Experience For Jewellery Consumers Market Report Hot Trading, Shortages Keep Diamond Prices Strong magazine india retail COMPETE OUTSOURCE AND The jewellery retailer’s new mantra
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
January 2011
Cover StoryOutsource And CompeteThe jewellery retailer’s new mantra
Special ReportImpulse Buying – The Growing Sales Driver
FocusRe-inventing The Shopping Experience For Jewellery Consumers
RaMat gan 52130, ISRaEltEl: +972-3-575-7455, FaX: +972-3-7511203
IDEX Magazine - India Retail is published in India by Idex Online S.A.. Reprints of individual articles are obtainable on application to the editor. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or
transmitted in any form or by any means without the prior written permission of the Copyright owner.
PUBlISHED BY YaROn BaRzIlaY FOR IDEX OnlInE S.a
ISSn 0334-68382003 IDEX OnlInE S.a.
IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: EDItOR 3
From the Editor’s Desk
H aving remained unchanged for millennia, the Indian gem and jewellery retail industry has gone through a series of changes in the
last decade or so. Changes so profound, they have left many industry veterans uncomprehending and unable to cope. But understanding and adjusting to these changes is vital for any retailer wanting survive and thrive into the future.
The single biggest change is in assessing and defining the retailer’s role in the marketplace. With each passing day, it is becoming less relevant for the retailer to be many things rolled into one. Today, he would do well to stop trying to be both a bullion dealer as well as a manufacturer and concentrate instead on just one thing – understanding and servicing his customer to a level he has not before.
This is something many veteran retailers, who have succeeded in the Indian consumer market hitherto, find very difficult to accept. It takes a major leap of faith to appreciate that a specialist manufacturer also understands the tastes and demands of one’s customers and is able to come up with a product range that will cater to them. But as many retailers will tell you, letting go of manufacture is probably the best thing you could do.
In today’s fiercely competitive marketplace, those who understand their customers’ tastes and desires, provide the widest range of choices to cater to them and a whole raft of assurance programs that instill confidence in the product and its valuation, are going to be the survivors. Those who don’t will be history. It is literally as stark as that.
Today’s jewellery retailer is not just competing against other jewellery retailers. A whole range of other luxury products with a set of value propositions that resonate well with the desires and aspirations of today’s consumers are aggressively competing for a slice of the disposable income pie. The changes that we look at in this issue
reflect the jewellery retail industry’s organised response toward better countering these new threats.
And while the retail industry has changed, the retailer has to also appreciate the fact that the consumer and the drivers that impel jewellery buying have also changed. While they might not command as high unit prices as the more traditional bridal and festival market segments do, impulse purchases of jewellery have grown exponentially and for many retailers today, are one of the lifelines that sustain them in the many ups and downs of today’s unsteady economic situation.
Even if one adopts to the new methods of sourcing product and positioning it to cater to the new sales drivers, one needs to ensure that the product itself enjoys a rock solid confidence with the consumer. Assurance programs are an essential part of the retail game today. And this assurance increasingly has to come from independent third parties and not the retailers themselves.
The successful retailer today is one who offers his customer the widest possible range of choices in terms of product design and styling as well as options in price points, gets a third party to examine and certify the product and stands behind even after it has been sold. The push to meet all these criteria is what has triggered the many changes in the industry.
It stands to reason that embracing these changes is not an option at all but an imperative. This issue’s selection of articles is designed to help the industry both understand and better adopt these changes as well as giving some insight into the new impellers that drive jewellery sales today. ■
Coping With A Sea Change
Vinod KuriyanEditor
4 IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: MUMBaI DIaMOnD MaRKEt REPORt
Mumbai DIaMOnD MaRKEt REPORt
T he Mumbai polished diamond market saw very good activity all the way through to the end of December – much better than
what anybody expected. Demand was very good for all sizes and categories of diamonds. But goods were in short supply all around and buyers had very limited choices. Due to this, prices moved noticeably upward, with buyers unable to resist them any more (there had been strong resistance to price rises in November, just after Diwali). Today, buyers simply have to pay more for what they want, even though there is room for some negotiation and sellers don’t necessarily get whatever they ask for.
Strong domestic demand was the main driver for the market, though Christmas demand from
overseas buyers was also good. Due to the shortages, however, overseas buyers stayed longer than they expected in the city and finally bought something or the other before leaving. The shortages are expected to continue through to January, when new production is expected to come onto the market. It is going to remain a seller’s market until then.
Though not entirely favourable, the dollar-rupee exchange rate was nonetheless stable, with movements remaining within a 2 percent band up or down. This allowed trading to go ahead unfettered, unlike in previous months, when large swings kept a nervous market at low volumes. ■
Hot December Trading, Shortages Keep Prices Buoyant
5MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: MUMBaI DIaMOnD MaRKEt REPORt
Size in Ct. (Sieve) Comments Forward Call
▲ -0.01 (-2 ) Very good demand for SI+ goods.good demand for lower piqué goods. Overall very good demand across the board.
Shortages will continue in near future. Prices are on the rise, will go up by 2%-4%.
▲ -0.02 (+2-6.5) Very good demand for SI+ goods.good demand for lower piqué goods. Very hot category.
Shortages will be severe due to increasing demand. Prices will go up by 2%-4%.
▲ 0.03-0.07 (+6.5-11)
Very good demand for SI+ & lower piqué goods. +8 sieve is the most required sieve, demand improving for -8 sieve.
Overall demand will remain stable. Prices will go up by 2%-3%.
▲ 0.08-0.14 (+11-14) Very good demand for piqué goods.good demand for SI1+ goods.
Shortages will be felt. activity will remain stable.
▲ 0.15-0.17 (+14-15.5)
Very good demand for piqué goods.good demand for SI1+ goods.
activity will remain stable with shortages of goods.
▲ 0.18-0.22 (1/5) Fair demand for SI1+ goods. Overall low activity will be seen in this category.
▲ 0.23-0.29 (1/4) good demand for VS+ & piqué goods.Demand for VS+ goods is mainly for local market.
activity will remain stable.
▲ 0.30 (1/3) good demand for VS+ & piqué goods.Demand for VS+ goods mainly for domestic market. g-J colours in greater demand.
Demand & prices will remain stable.
▲ 0.40 (3/8) good demand for VS+/g-J col.Demand for this category is mainly for local market.
Demand & prices will remain stable.+0.45 carat will be difficult to find.
▲ 0.50 (1/2) good demand for I2+/J+ col. Overall good demand across the board.
Demand & prices will go up. Better demand can be seen for D&F col.
▲ 0.75 (3/4) good demand for I1/I2 & VS+ clarity. +0.80 carat in more demand.
Shortages will be seen for +0.90 carat.
▲ 1.00 (4/4) Overall very good activity across the board. Shortages seen in premium sizes.
Severe shortages will be seen for H lower col. Prices will go up by 2%-3%.
▲ +3.00 Fair demand for SI1+/ H-K col.Demand for VS/J-K col. increasing in +5 carat sizes.
Better demand & activity is expected.
M U M B a I D I a M O n D t R a D I n g I n D E C E M B E R
Special Report
8 IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: SPECIal REPORt
E ven in the 21st century, the vast majority of jewellery sales in India is driven by events — weddings, festivals, anniversaries and other
milestones. A major factor in the consumer’s assessment of jewellery is still its intrinsic value — even when one is looking at relatively low-cost product. Given the combination of event-driven purchase impellers and the need for the product to act as a storehouse of value, most jewellery purchases in India are carefully thought out, with the actual purchase decision taking a fair amount of time to be reached, say many industry insiders. According to them, a relatively small proportion of sales is driven by impulse — a purchase because a customer liked what he or she saw and wanted to have the product immediately.
Pratap Kamath, CEO of Abaran Jewellery in Bangalore, says, “I would estimate that more than 70 percent of jewellery sales in India are event driven. Events are such a strong impeller that even Rio Tinto, the diamond mining company, is looking at developing a sales model for their diamonds based on events. Also, it is natural that high-value purchase decisions will be taken only after a fair amount of thought. It follows then that most impulse purchases are therefore usually in the lower price ranges, mostly in the Rs.5,000 to Rs.15,000 range and rarely if ever crossing the Rs.50,000 mark.”
According to Kamath, impulse buying hasn’t increased dramatically over the last decade or so, though he does think it has nonetheless, established itself firmly
Impulse Buying – The Growing Sales Driver
By Vinod Kuriyan
naC JEwEllERS
Special Report
9IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: SPECIal REPORt
in the Indian market — an arena that had almost no impulse sales for millennia.
N. Anantha Padmanabhan of NAC Jewellers in Chennai, however, states emphatically that the reverse is true, that impulse sales are what keep jewellery outlets going every day. “We’re surviving on impulse sales,” he notes, adding, “without them, half the jewellery showrooms around the country would have shut down by now!” Padmanabhan estimates that impulse sales account for between 30- and 40 percent of his total sales.
“Impulse buying is something that has grown in almost every consumer sector,” Padmanabhan notes. “Some years ago, I too would normally go out to buy myself new clothes only at Diwali or some special occasion. But today, the variety of choices and the range of product have changed the way I think. I’m likely to go out and buy myself a new shirt at any time of the year, should I feel like it. This is exactly what is happening in the Indian jewellery market. The range and variety of product available today has nudged the Indian consumer away from being an occasion-driven buyer only to one who is liable to make a purchase at any time, should the urge to buy strike him or her.” He too notes, however, that impulse sales are usually in the lower price ranges, with the more expensive product being bought only after a fair amount of thought and planning.
IndIa Hooked on IntrInsIc ValueAbaran’s Kamath observes that like it or not, the Indian jewellery industry is hooked on the consumer’s demand for high intrinsic value in the product they buy. “The
Indian consumer’s demand for high intrinsic value is what gives the domestic jewellery industry such staggeringly high volumes,” he notes. “If we were to move away from this model where intrinsic value matters, to something like the models in western countries,” he notes, “we’d see a sharp drop in volumes and overall value.”
Kamath quotes the example of gold jewellery sales in Kerala. “Fully half of all the gold consumed in jewellery every year is recycled from older jewellery. This clearly indicates that jewellery still plays a major role as a storehouse of value and that it is held onto with a strong investment motive as well,” he observes.
This, Kamath says, is why he doesn’t think impulse sales are that big a factor in the overall sales mix. And this, he acknowledges, brings with it a major danger for the future. Tomorrow’s generation is less likely to seek high intrinsic value in jewellery and probably seek other attributes like a higher design quotient. “As an industry, we need to move on from simply depending on intrinsic value and generate a value proposition based on other factors like emotions. De Beers did this successfully with diamonds, making their perceived value lie in their ability to become the symbol of emotional commitment between men and women. Here is where impulse buying could gain importance.”
Even here, however, Kamath feels that event-based buying will still be the underlying framework on which the industry will still rest. “An emotional hook certainly
abaRan abaRan
10 IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: SPECIal REPORt
has the potential to add to sales, but even with it, the underlying factor will still be an event like an anniversary or a festival. An emotional impulse could however, be a major trigger for jewellery sales over these events.”
It is worth noting here that Valentine’s Day, a very western concept with no traditional grounding in India, was promoted as a jewellery-giving occasion only as recently as a few years ago, but is already one of the fastest-growing sales drivers for low-end, high design quotient jewellery. The emotional value of a beautifully designed Valentine’s Day jewellery gift, more than makes up for its low intrinsic value and has the potential to last much longer than the latter.
The CEO of a jewellery brand, who requested anonymity, observed that as a product category, jewellery is not something that is bought on impulse but a planned buy. “Jewellery is a destination,” he notes. “You walk into a jewellery showroom because you want to buy some, it isn’t like an iPod, which you could snap up on impulse while you were idly browsing through a retail outlet. As a retailer, you can create an environment that is conducive to more impulse-driven behaviour, but the product itself is not something people consider on impulse.”
Much of this difference in buying behaviour, he notes, is due to the fact that even low-priced jewellery is perceived as a ‘precious’ product. “You can walk into a clothing outlet and casually handle suits that retail for Rs.30,000, but a piece of jewellery that is worth just Rs.5,000 is always behind a glass wall in a counter. You are more likely to buy the 30,000-rupee suit on impulse than the 5,000-rupee piece of jewellery. The products themselves dictate buying behaviour.”
steady sellers already exIstMansukh Kothari of Vasupati Jewellers in Mumbai, thinks that while not exactly falling into the category of impulse sales, there are some jewellery product segments that have strong sales all year round, independent of festivals and events. “Chains and bangles are everyday items,” he says, “they sell all year round because they are an important part of a woman’s daily attire. These products sell well in a variety of price points though the most popular products around the country would be those that have have less than 30 grams of gold.”In addition to these steady sellers, India’s still nascent branded jewellery industry, especially the lower-price-point mass-market segment, has definitely made major strides in modifying consumers’ jewellery purchase
abaRan
11IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: SPECIal REPORt
behaviour. Mass-market brands by their very nature, exclude themselves from the traditional jewellery buying triggers in India. Positioning themselves in malls and mass-retail chains, with a more casual and immediate ambience, these brands have taken big steps away from the more ivory-towered feel that jewellery has traditionally generated.
“The mass-market brands,” said one high end retailer who declined to be identified, “have a product that is not in the same space as that of most other fine jewellery retailers. I haven’t come across a single customer of mine, who has bought anything at all from the mass-market brands.” At the same time, however, he acknowledges that the buying triggers for the branded mass-market product were much more in keeping with many other non-jewellery product categories that generate sales simply by attracting consumers who might not have come to a retail outlet with any specific intent to buy them. The unique sales proposition of most of these products was not plain utility or value for money, but rather their ability to generate a more diaphanous ‘must have’ feeling in the consumer. That ‘must have’ feeling, he acknowledged, has far better prospects in the long term than dependence on the perception of intrinsic value.
Abaran’s Kamath notes that the domestic jewellery retail industry could well see a change in consumer behaviour in the future where purchases driven by the investment motive are confined to only pure bullion – gold bars and biscuits – while jewellery sales might be impelled by a completely different set of drivers.
There are already signs of this in the marketplace. Observers note that with gold at today’s sky-high prices, there has been a sharp increase in the purchase of gold bars and biscuits, with consumer willing even to pay premiums for biscuits bought from banks in tamper-proof packaging, thus indicating a clear intent to hold the gold for investment. Even purchases from jewellery retailers are seeing some major changes. Where traditionally the jewellery buying decisions have been taken solely by the women in the family, with the elders playing a major role even in purchases for events like weddings, retailers have noted that increasingly, they are seeing the greater involvement of men in these purchases as high-priced gold calls for more hard-headed business decisions for investment.
Conversely, branded jewellery has seen a higher percentage of final buying decisions being taken by the wearer herself, even if she isn’t a family elder. Impulse buying has definitely established itself in the Indian market. ■
n. anantHa PaDManabHan: SavED by IMPulSE buyIng
naC JEwEllERS naC JEwEllERS
SpotlightRoland Lorie
14 IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: spOtlIght
“Thirteen years ago, there was absolutely no reason to open a diamond and gem-testing laboratory in India,” says Roland Lorie, global CEO of the International Gemological Institute (IGI). “None of the global players – including the biggest Indian diamond exporters – was interested in the Indian consuming market and Indian consumers didn’t know enough to either want or appreciate a gem-testing laboratory’s certificate.”
The situation changed when De Beers targeted the Indian consuming market with its umbrella promotion campaign along with the launch of branded diamond jewellery – a completely new concept in the Indian market at that time. “We jumped into the Indian market along with the De Beers campaign,” Lorie says, “and we certified the De Beers brands. But it took time to gain acceptance.”
Before it opened its gem-testing laboratory in India however, Lorie notes, the IGI realised that it needed to educate the domestic Indian gem and jewellery industry about the scientific basis for assessing and certifying diamonds. So the first thing it did on entering India was to open a gemological school. “It made sense to have an industry that was appreciative of the need for a gem-testing laboratory and certification before actually opening one,” Lorie says. The initiative caught on and IGI’s Indian foray was soon a success.
“But even now, with all the global education and testing majors running teaching institutions in India, the educational thrust in the country is nowhere near enough,” Lorie notes. “India is a huge market and you don’t see anywhere near as much jewellery on people as you do in this country. Yet the consuming public and – much more importantly – the jewellery retail industry know surprisingly little about diamonds.
“Indian consumers know a great deal about gold, its purity and value; but when it comes to diamonds, they are almost totally dependent on the retailer for information and valuation. And when you have a sales person who knows very little about diamonds himself or herself, the consumer ends up with very little confidence in diamonds. A retailer doesn’t need to know as much detail about diamonds as a manufacturer does, but he or she must be
able to clearly understand the product and transmit this understanding to the consumer.”
According to Lorie, this is why the IGI has launched a focussed initiative to educate and train the jewellery retail sales force around the country. “We have taken the initiative a step further with some simple but effective steps. In many retail outlets, we have set up microscopes and the retailer invites the customer to have a look at the diamond himself or herself. This gives the consumer a great deal of confidence and
“What’s The Price Of A Red Car?”Educating consumErs & instilling confidEncE in diamonds
By Vinod Kuriyan
ROlanD lORIE: EDucatIOn Is paRaMOunt
15IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: spOtlIght
that confidence results in a much higher percentage of store visits being converted into actual sales. Both consumers and retailers are very happy with this simple initiative.”
Still, Lorie reiterates, knowledge about diamonds is woefully inadequate in the Indian consuming market. A huge number of Indian consumers still don’t know that there is no such thing as a generic price for a stone of a given size and that one needs to factor in colour, clarity and cut to determine the stone’s value. “When they learn who I am,” Lorie observes, “I have actually had some people ask me, ‘So how much does a one-carat diamond cost?’ I respond to that question with one of my own – ‘What’s the price of a red car?’ They get the joke and an appreciation of what goes into valuing a diamond.”
Education and consumer confidence, Lorie says, are of paramount importance in the Indian market today. “As an industry, we have to reach out to the consumer and make him or her confident of our product. Which is why we have taken the initiative of opening laboratories in consuming centres like Delhi, Kolkata, Chennai and Trichur. It is much easier to stay focussed on the trading centres – clients can easily give you 1,000 stones at a time. But retailers and consumers need us and our ability to boost confidence as an independent third-party certifying authority. Without the consumers who demand our product and the retailers who sell it to them, we won’t have a business in the trading centres either.”
Beautiful StorehouSe of ValueLorie thinks that in India, the diamond can successfully complement gold as another storehouse of value. “The diamond is one of very few products that are both a storehouse of value – something to consider investing in – and a luxury item at the same time. The fact that it is perceived as something of high value as well as a thing of beauty makes it special as a gift. Women like flowers because they have no utility at all , are beautiful and are given for no particular reason other than the intent of the person giving them to convey an emotion. It’s the same thing with diamonds.”
Lorie thinks the mystique and lure of diamonds has definitely caught on in India. “I see more advertising for diamonds in India than in any other country in the world,” he observes. And this advertising and promotion has a much greater depth than anywhere else in the
world. Typically, it will be the same top global brands that you see advertising and promoting their product internationally. In India, however, even the smaller retailers are involved in some form of advertising and promotion. That is great because competition down to this level creates a buzz in the consumer marketplace and generates a buying impulse. Today, retailers are willing to mix plain-gold and diamond jewellery in their store displays, a sign that diamond jewellery has gained equal acceptance with the consumer as the more traditional plain-gold variety.”
Lorie thinks the diamond manufacturing and retail industry need to develop an umbrella campaign in India to create and project a strong value proposition for diamonds to the consumer.
According to Lorie, the other issues the diamond manufacturing and retail industry needs to keep a watchful eye on include high pressure and high
IgI hYDERaBaD InItIatIVE
16 IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: spOtlIght
temperature (HPHT) treated diamonds and synthetics. “We’ve seen a greater number of both these categories coming through our laboratories worldwide,” he observes. “Both are a potential threat to the industry though synthetics are a real danger. For the moment though, I wouldn’t classify them as an imminent threat. Adhering to some simple safety rules should keep the natural diamond industry safe from the threat of undisclosed stones masquerading as the real thing.”
Even as a fully disclosed and inexpensive substitute for natural diamonds, Lorie feels, synthetics don’t pose a threat to the industry. In the end, the draw of the natural stone is its best value proposition. “Take the Swarovsky product,” he observes, “even though it is positioned as a unique product on its own, it is bought by those wanting a diamond look at considerably lower prices. The products are beautiful and generate repeat customers. But once you have the pleasure of owning a Swarovsky product, you start hankering for some real diamonds. In a sense, the Swarovsky product builds steps towards real diamonds. And because Swarovsky products are regularly given to young girls, we have a generation that starts wanting real diamonds much earlier than they would otherwise.”
Bright futureLorie is enthusiastic about the future of both the diamond as well as its accompanying certification industry in India. “With greater consumer education and awareness in India, there will be greater demand for diamonds – and a correspondingly greater demand for assurance programs like certification. Disclosure and certification will have to come from a laboratory and not from the retailer himself. Third party assurance is the norm today. You wouldn’t buy a Picasso painting just because you saw his signature on it. You’d ask an art expert to authenticate it. It’s the same with diamonds. And the more laboratories there are in the marketplace, the greater the consumer awareness and demand for certification will be.”
Lorie quotes the China retail market as an example of what could well develop in India. “Consumers go online to our website (we give consumers direct access) to confirm the specifications of a certificate they see at a retail store. They frequently call our helpline to clear up any discrepancies. The whole thing makes purchases that much easier and gives the consumer much greater confidence. It could all happen in India too.” ■
EQuIpMEnt tO InstIl cOnsuMER cOnFIDEncE
18 Idex MagazIne – IndIa RetaIl | nO 02: COVeR StORY
The jewellery retailer’s new mantra
OutsOurcecOmpete
And
By Vinod Kuriyan
19Idex MagazIne – IndIa RetaIl | nO 02: COVeR StORY
With the economic transformation of the country, the Indian jewellery retail industry has gone through a profound transformation in the last decade. Among the more profound changes has been the steady migration away from one of the retail industry’s oldest and most widely known role – that of jewellery designer and manufacturer.
For millennia, jewellery has played a multiple role in Indian society – the most obvious one of adornment, a symbol of status and most vitally in a society that had almost no options for the safeguard and investment of wealth, a storehouse of value that could be depended on to not only outpace inflation, but also provide instant cash in a crisis. Given all these roles, it has been essential that the retailer, who has played many roles in local society, including that of pawnbroker, have complete control of the raw material sourcing as well as jewellery manufacturing.
OutsOurcecOmpete
20 Idex MagazIne – IndIa RetaIl | nO 02: COVeR StORY
not any more. With a variety of investment options now available as well as a whole range of luxury products to choose from, the Indian consumer is increasingly
looking for a very different relationship with even the traditional family jewellery retailers. Primarily, they want a huge choice in the range of products on offer. In addition to that, they want guarantees of purity in the gold content, assurance about the quality and value of the diamonds and coloured gemstones used, as well as some warranty services in the form of assured repairs, cleaning etc. All the other luxury products offer this and more and the Indian consumer wants the same from the jewellery retail industry.
Retailers around the country now find it impossible to perform both their traditional roles as well as cater to the new demands from their customers. Increasingly, they have turned to specialist manufacturers and distributors to source their product, as being rid of this responsibility allows them to focus more on their customers and their specific needs.
With much stiffer competition in the market all round, the name of the game is segmentation and profiling, say industry analysts. As one put it, “There are three separate games – the brand, the product game and the retail – and the return on investment in each is different. If you are in branding, your focus is to maximise the perceived value of the brand; if you are a manufacturer, you will be focussed on simply satisfying the customer’s specific needs within the product range you have as your intent is to ensure that your manufactured product keeps moving. If you are primarily a retailer, however, it is all about catering to every single need of the customer – even those that he or she cannot articulate clearly. You then need the greatest variety and depth of product to offer the greatest range of choices.”
The analyst goes on to say, “It has happened in every other industry from automobiles to fast moving
consumer goods – organised retail is what drives organised manufacture and organised manufacture in turn triggers organised outsourcing. The Indian jewellery retail industry is on the same path that every other product category’s retail system has gone through. Organised outsourcing is inevitable.”
Specialist manufacturers take on a variety of headaches in the manufacturing process that require inordinately large amounts of time and skilled manpower to tackle. They take care of:
• Sourcing primary gold and hedging against the yellow metal’s increasingly volatile price swings. They deliver a product at a fixed price that the retailer knows is good for his customer base during a specific sales period.
• Ensure quality by taking care of hallmarking and providing laboratory certification of the diamonds and coloured gemstones used if this is required.
• Provide a huge range of product styles and options that no retailer could offer his customers on his own. These include the very latest in trends and fashions, that the younger customer base is increasingly demanding of the product they buy. This also allows the retailer in turn to increase the range of products he offers his customers.
• Stand behind their product by providing guarantees as well as repair and refurbishing services when needed.
Outsourcing Gives You A Wide ChoiceMansukh Kothari of Vasupati Jewellers in Mumbai, a firm that provides back-end design and manufacturing services for range of retailer clients around the country, says that the volume and value of the jewellery that
Specialist manufacturers take on a variety of headaches. They deliver a product at a fixed price that the retailer knows is good for his customer base during a specific sales period.
21Idex MagazIne – IndIa RetaIl | nO 02: COVeR StORY
is now outsourced around the country has more than doubled in the last five years. “One of the biggest reasons for this increase,” he notes, “is that outsourcing allows retailers to dramatically increase their stocks. Most retailers have doubled the stocks they hold in the past five years. They have to offer their customers the widest range of choices and options as competition – both from within the industry as well as from other luxury products – is becoming increasingly fierce every day.”
In Kothari’s opinion, outsourcing now accounts for up to 98 percent of the products offered by some retailers. “Many retailers only manufacture a very small percentage of their product to cater to very specialized orders,” he says.
One of the reasons for this huge increase in outsourcing, he observes is that the specialist manufacturers, due to the scale of their operations, are able to study the different geographic markets around India and provide product to retailers in those markets that is specifically tailored to local tastes. “we study each market,” he says, “and we know what each geographic area wants. To give you a very generic example, if we’re making earrings, we know that they have to be big and bold for the northern markets, while the southern markets demand earrings that are smaller and more delicate. We know what product to offer which retailer,” he says, adding, “chains and bangles are the most widespread of jewellery products in India – they’re everyday items and the staple of the industry in every geographic market. Once you’ve got a manufacturing line with these products going, it is relatively an easy matter to start tweaking the design and styling for individual markets. You can offer the retailer a huge range of product because the volumes and varieties in this segment are gigantic.”
“Outsourcing design and product manufacture has definitely taken off,” says Pratap Kamath, CEO of Abaran Jewellery in Bangalore. “Everyone realises the need for a varied product mix today,” he notes, adding, “ a limited
naC JewelleRS
22 Idex MagazIne – IndIa RetaIl | nO 02: COVeR StORY
“Branded jewellery as in the big specific brands, is relatively small segment of the total market, though one can’t dismiss brands. Look at Tanishq and how they’ve changed the jewellery retail landscape!”
or select product offering is a big negative for customers today.” Kamath attributes a lot of today’s changes to the fact that disposable incomes have increased and that people have travelled a lot more and have been exposed to cultures, tastes and styles outside India. “These people come back from their travels and realise the importance of design and styling.” He notes that the trend towards a greater variety of styles and designs is also impelled by a strong component of economic necessity. The sky-high price of gold, he notes, has made people buy less jewellery now for occasions and very choosy about what do they buy. “Earlier, when the price of gold was 5,000 for 10 grams, people would buy perhaps five bangles and some three necklaces for a wedding. Now the number of those purchases has been scaled back sharply – perhaps just two or three bangles and just a single necklace, perhaps two. And they will spend a lot of time choosing those two or three pieces that they do buy. The retailer needs to have a really wide selection on offer to cater to this demand. So the trend towards outsourcing manufacture is based on actual consumer demand and this in turn is a need-based imperative. At the end of the day, the retailer can’t fight something the consumer demands.”
Trust Issues Resolved“Earlier,” Kamath observes, “there were many barriers to outsourcing, not the least of which was trust and dependability. Now with the hallmarking of gold and the certification of diamonds and coloured gemstones, outsourcing is on a solid basis in terms of dependability. That crucial trust element has been taken care of. Outsourcing your product line-up something of a huge leap into the unknown.” He goes on to say, “What the outsourcing does, is take away some 75 percent of the retailers headaches, allowing him to focus on his core competence – selling to the consumer. He can work on developing aggressive sales programs and spend more time in training his sales force to better service
his customers. This makes him better at what he does and thus better able to compete even with other luxury products.”
Kamath notes that outsourcing product design manufacture doesn’t mean that the retailer will lose his identity in any way. “We have our own in-store ‘branded’ collections at Abaran,” he notes, emphasizing that his customer base is content knowing that his retail outlet stands behind the product as a brand of its own. “Branded jewellery as in the big specific brands, is relatively small segment of the total market,” Kamath says, adding with a laugh, “though one can’t dismiss brands. Look at Tanishq and how they’ve changed the jewellery retail landscape!”
Emphatically endorsing the statement that outsourcing is now the norm, N. Anantha Padmanabhan of NAC
ManSUKH KOtHaRI: OUtSOURCIng HaS MORe tHan dOUBled
23Idex MagazIne – IndIa RetaIl | nO 02: COVeR StORY
Jewellers in Chennai, says, “Except for a few individual retailers here or there, I would say that 75 percent of all jewellery in retail showrooms today is outsourced. The sheer variety of product available from specialist manufacturers today is terrific. Every retailer needs to know what is happening in the market – the new trends, styles and colours. The specialist manufacturers spend a lot of time and money on researching the market, designing and developing the product. The retailer gets a snapshot of the entire market when he is offered the product range of a specialist manufacturer.”
Citing a personal example, Padmanabhan notes, “Until last year, I designed and manufactured all my product in-house – could source my diamonds cheaper and keep a close eye on quality issues. But I found that I didn’t know what was happening in the market and I was missing out on offering the best product range to a large segment of my clientele that wanted the latest in trends and styles to choose from. Also, designing and manufacturing one’s own product is a major headache. I started outsourcing a major chunk of my product offering and I’m happy doing it.”
Padmanabhan observes, however, that there is one segment he just will not outsource – the high-end and exclusive product that he makes for a select customer base. “When all is said and done, I still think the best product can only emerge when you design and manufacture it yourself. You can meticulously source your diamonds and coloured gemstones, keep a close eye on quality and assure you high end customers completely when you have designed and manufactured the product yourself. And because it has all come from you, the product on offer can be exclusive and not available anywhere else. So for jewellery that costs Rs. 5 lakhs and upwards, we do all the designing and manufacturing in-house. For product that retails at up to Rs.3 lakhs or so, we outsource design and manufacture. This way, we have the best of both worlds.” VaSUpatI JewelleRS
24 Idex MagazIne – IndIa RetaIl | nO 02: COVeR StORY
In a tight market, all the retailer has to do is to adjust his own margin slightly, without having to worry about the fluctuations in the price of gold and the availability of other raw material like diamonds and coloured gemstones
Everybody is keeping a close eye on the market and everybody wants a bigger slice of the consumer’s wallet. The fierce competition that he is talking about, Kothari of Vasupati notes, is actually threatening the future of the small and medium jewellery retailer. “You could run a successful retail operation with a range of jewellery that would account for some 30 or 40 kilograms of gold,” he observes, “but not any more. You need much more on hand to offer your customer a choice. In five years’ time, I think you’ll need a minimum stock that accounts for some 100 kilograms of gold. The bigger operators and those with multiple branches are going to be the only ones able to cope with demands like this. And they are not going to be tied down with having to source gold,
design product, manufacture it and then look at issues like quality control. They want ready product with all of this taken care of.”
Artisan Workforce Unlikely To LastThe traditional role of the retailer is also threatened by a social issue. The karigar is no longer a widespread and dependable entity. Many of these traditional artisans, who have gone into jewellery manufacture because their families have been in the trade for generations, no longer want to continue with a job that demands long hours in poor working conditions and absolutely no security of income. Most of them want their children to move into
pRatap KaMatH: eVeRYOne RealISeS need FOR VaRIed pROdUCt OFFeRIng
25Idex MagazIne – IndIa RetaIl | nO 02: COVeR StORY
other fields. The ones that are still in business would much rather work in factory conditions for a specialist manufacturer, chain retailer with its own manufacturing or at the very least a retailer with multiple branches and therefore the scope and volume of production demands that will enable it to offer the same working conditions and salaries that the others can. The small retailer with low and sporadic demand, will no longer have a manufacturing resource to depend on.
According to Kothari, the karigar is being increasingly given a service role in carrying out the minor repairs and refurbishments that customers demand from retailers everywhere. Rather than ship a product back to a third-party manufacturer somewhere else in India – a costly affair in both time and logistics – it makes more sense to have repair services offered locally by karigars he says. “Only if there are major repairs or technical issues beyond the karigars’ scope, is the piece sent back to the manufacturer,” Kothari adds.
Kamath echoes this. “Services like repairs and refurbishment are taken care of locally, primarily because the consumer is not willing to wait for a long period of time while the piece is shipped back to the manufacturer. They want an instant response.”
Just the sheer convenience of having someone else look after the entire design and manufacture process, Kothari notes, is continuing to drive the process to expansion. “Normally, the retailer just adds on our cost to the sticker price of the product and we then pay our way through the process,” he says. In a tight market, all the retailer has to do is to adjust his own margin slightly, without having to worry about the fluctuations in the price of gold and the availability of other raw material like diamonds and coloured gemstones.
The future, according to some industry insiders will see retailers who manufacture their own jewellery becoming highly specialized niche operators in an increasingly exclusive market segment.
aBaRan JewelleRY
30 IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: REtaIl Et CEtERa
Et Cetera
Tres, Tres ChiC!there’s nobody like the French when it comes to fashion. no matter what the rest of the world is doing, the French do it just that much more chicly. these jewelry and watch pieces from France show just why the country deserves its reputation for style.
JEwElRy by bEllOn CRéatEuR
Down To The LineThe Blue Line range from Bellon Créateur has a contemporary style imprinted on a classic look, combining white or yellow gold with oval or cushion gems. Despite the name, the rings and pendants are also available set with amethysts, citrines and smoky quartz, as well as with blue topaz and blue sapphires.
31IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: REtaIl Et CEtERa
work of ArTIn homage to the impressionist painter Claude Monet, Mathon Paris has re-launched its Nymphéas collection, created in 2005 and now enriched with new color harmonies and a modernised design. The line is based around orange and yellow – yellow sapphires, spessarite garnets and diamonds – to evoke the atmosphere
of Monet’s lush field of poppies.
GrAPhiC DesiGnCacharel’s Argent Générique line encompasses what the company calls “graphic-chic.” The necklace, ring and bracelet are made of silver, lacquer and cubic zirconia to provide an art deco look in contemporary colors for affordable fashion jewelry. The open-worked, crafted bubble jewelry in the Bulles (bubbles) collection is made of rhodium-plated sterling silver and zirconia.
JEwElRy by CaChaREl
JEwElRy by MathOn PaRIs
Bon VoyAGeHow can you not fail to be “charmed” by these travel-themed charms from Commelin? The Voyages collection takes wearers all over the world through a variety of 18 karat yellow and white gold charms. Providing inspiration for places not yet visited, as well as mementos of special places, these charms are irresistible.
JurA JeweLsisabelle Langlois comes from a long line of lapidaries from the Jura region of France. She has lived among gems since her childhood, which is evident from her stunning designs. She uses an extensive range of gems, including pink and green tourmalines, Ceylon sapphires, tsavorites, citrines and amethysts. Her “French-style” is easy to wear and very decorative, just like real bouquets of flowers.
worLD TrAVeLer Artist-jeweler Philippe Tournaire is renowned for his architectural creations. Now he has taken his creativity a stage further with rings based on some of the world’s most important cities. London, Dubai, Moscow, New York and Paris, rendered in multi-colored gold and artfully placed diamonds, are his first world offerings, though other cities are planned to follow.
JEwElRy by IsabEllE langlOIs
JEwElRy by PhIlIPPE tOuRnaIRE
JEwElRy by COMMElIn
32 IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: REtaIl Et CEtERa
no frèresFounded in 1835, Gay frères is renowned as a manufacturer and supplier to some of the best-known European jewelry brands. The Endless Love collection, one of about 40 produced by the company, represents the power of love. The necklaces, rings, earrings and bracelets come in pink or yellow gold, or white gold with diamonds.
PreCious heArTsIn its Sceau de Coeurs collection,
Poiray reveals a new line of poetic, fun and technical jewelry. Two
interchangeable rings, one in precious metal, the other in ceramic, are interlaced. The rings are available in 18 karat white, pink or yellow gold, semi-pavéd or entirely pavéd in diamonds.
JEwElRy by gay FRèREs
JEwElRy by POIRay
33IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: REtaIl Et CEtERa
TiMe ChAnGeThese Obi watches from kenzo are available for both men and women. The watches feature reversible straps, allowing wearers to match them with double the number of outfits that a single timepiece would allow. Now you need never worry about clashing with your clothes ever again!
GAy PArisThe Rêviere Parisienne collection of watches from opex takes its inspiration from famous Parisian people and places. These muses include the writer Colette, the singer Edith Piaf and the famous Café de Flore on Boulevard Saint Germain where artists and writers would meet. While the inspiration may come from the Paris of yesterday, the designs are as modern and forward-looking as they come.
watChEs by OPEX
watChEs by kEnzO
34 IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: REtaIl Et CEtERa
This price list reflects suggested retail prices for polished diamonds. Diamonds may, and should, sell at discounts compared to this list. For more education on prices and discounts please visit www.diamondSRP.com. Copyright 2009 by WFDB and IDEX Online S.A. All rights reserved.
Prices are in Rupees Per Carat Powered by www.idexonline.com
DRAFT – JANUARY 1st 201136
the DIAmonD RetAIl benchmARk - InDIADIAmonD RetAIl benchmARk FoR PolISheD DIAmonDS
DRAFT – JANUARY 1st 2011
Disclaimer: This Diamond Retail Benchmark India (DRB™) is an informational and educational tool for diamond consumers. Organized around the “the 4C’s” - Carat, Cut, Color & Clarity - the DRB India is based on market data from the diamond trading centers Worldwide and market research assessment of customary retail mark-ups. Endorsed by the All India Gem & Jewelry Trade Federation (GJF), as well as the World Federation of Diamond Bourses (WFDB) The DRB™ should be used as background information only. Actual diamond sale prices may be differ compared to this benchmark, depending on demand and supply at time of transaction; source of the diamond certificate; fluorescence; cut specifications; payment and other terms of business; foreign exchange rates; special stones and other business considerations. This is published jointly by The All
India Gems and Jewellery Trade Federation (GJF), a trade body headquartered in Mumbai, and IDEX, a diamond research house headquartered in Tel Aviv Israel, with a view of unbiased service to the consumer
Prices are in Rupees Per Carat Powered by www.idexonline.com
the DIAmonD RetAIl benchmARk - InDIADIAmonD RetAIl benchmARk FoR PolISheD DIAmonDS
DRAFT – JANUARY 1st 2011
Disclaimer: This Diamond Retail Benchmark India (DRB™) is an informational and educational tool for diamond consumers. Organized around the “the 4C’s” - Carat, Cut, Color & Clarity - the DRB India is based on market data from the diamond trading centers Worldwide and market research assessment of customary retail mark-ups. Endorsed by the All India Gem & Jewelry Trade Federation (GJF), as well as the World Federation of Diamond Bourses (WFDB) The DRB™ should be used as background information only. Actual diamond sale prices may be differ compared to this benchmark, depending on demand and supply at time of transaction; source of the diamond certificate; fluorescence; cut specifications; payment and other terms of business; foreign exchange rates; special stones and other business considerations. This is published jointly by The All
India Gems and Jewellery Trade Federation (GJF), a trade body headquartered in Mumbai, and IDEX, a diamond research house headquartered in Tel Aviv Israel, with a view of unbiased service to the consumer
IF VVS1 VVS2 VS1 VS2 SI1 SI2 SI3 I1 I2 I3
D 590389396597356036338009310968 274914 229846 189285 144217 99149 63095
e 396597356036342516328996301955 261394 220833 184778 139710 94643 58588
Prices are in Rupees Per Carat Powered by www.idexonline.com
Disclaimer: This Diamond Retail Benchmark India (DRB™) is an informational and educational tool for diamond consumers. Organized around the “the 4C’s” - Carat, Cut, Color & Clarity - the DRB India is based on market data from the diamond trading centers Worldwide and market research assessment of customary retail mark-ups. Endorsed by the All India Gem & Jewelry Trade Federation (GJF), as well as the World Federation of Diamond Bourses (WFDB) The DRB™ should be used as background information only. Actual diamond sale prices may be differ compared to this benchmark, depending on demand and supply at time of transaction; source of the diamond certificate; fluorescence; cut specifications; payment and other terms of business; foreign exchange rates; special stones and other business considerations. This is published jointly by The All
India Gems and Jewellery Trade Federation (GJF), a trade body headquartered in Mumbai, and IDEX, a diamond research house headquartered in Tel Aviv Israel, with a view of unbiased service to the consumer
DRAFT – JANUARY 1st 201138
the DIAmonD RetAIl benchmARk - InDIADIAmonD RetAIl benchmARk FoR PolISheD DIAmonDS
DRAFT – JANUARY 1st 2011
Prices are in Rupees Per Carat Powered by www.idexonline.com
DRAFT – JANUARY 1st 2011 39
IF VVS1 VVS2 VS1 VS2 SI1 SI2 SI3 I1 I2 I3
D 590389396597356036338009310968 274914 229846 189285 144217 99149 63095
e 396597356036342516328996301955 261394 220833 184778 139710 94643 58588
Disclaimer: This Diamond Retail Benchmark India (DRB™) is an informational and educational tool for diamond consumers. Organized around the “the 4C’s” - Carat, Cut, Color & Clarity - the DRB India is based on market data from the diamond trading centers Worldwide and market research assessment of customary retail mark-ups. Endorsed by the All India Gem & Jewelry Trade Federation (GJF), as well as the World Federation of Diamond Bourses (WFDB) The DRB™ should be used as background information only. Actual diamond sale prices may be differ compared to this benchmark, depending on demand and supply at time of transaction; source of the diamond certificate; fluorescence; cut specifications; payment and other terms of business; foreign exchange rates; special stones and other business considerations. This is published jointly by The All
India Gems and Jewellery Trade Federation (GJF), a trade body headquartered in Mumbai, and IDEX, a diamond research house headquartered in Tel Aviv Israel, with a view of unbiased service to the consumer
the DIAmonD RetAIl benchmARk - InDIADIAmonD RetAIl benchmARk FoR PolISheD DIAmonDS
DRAFT – JANUARY 1st 2011
IDEX ONLINE 3GS
Mobile technology May be the next big trend, but Many retailers and business owners have been slow to Meet this new advertising, Marketing and sales streaM head on.
IDEX MAGAZINE – INDIA RETAIL | NO 02: GOING MOBILE40
According to a Shop.org survey released last year, while nearly three-quarters of retailers were exploring mobile strategies as an additional sales channel, the number of retailers who had begun implementing their mobile technology plan was much smaller. The survey revealed that 62 percent of retailers had either not yet begun or were only in the early stages of planning their mobile strategy.
The fact that they are planning at all is good news, but with technology moving so quickly and so rapidly in so many different directions, it is imperative that businesses take the mobile plunge, diamantaires and jewelers among them. “Retailers who ignore mobile retailing risk being ignored in return by current and future generations of shoppers,” stated a white paper sponsored by the National Retail Federation (NRF).
The “Mobile Retail Initiative” white paper succinctly summed up the importance of this new sales channel, and went so far as to say it was changing the way retailers conduct business. “Because [mobile phones] are always with us – and always on – they connect retailers to current and potential customers regardless of location or time of day,” the report said.
The numbers are worth considering. In 2015, shoppers are expected to use mobile phones to purchase goods and services worth close to $120 billion, which is in the region of 8 percent of the total e-commerce market. The white paper estimated that payment for goods and services and
money transfers initiated from mobile phones will leap to $630 million by 2014, up from $70 million last year. “Mobile retail represents both a new way to shop and a new payment paradigm,” said the NRF.
While there is a big difference between buying an item of jewelry and buying a coffee, those interested in how to use a mobile phone as a means of payment should follow the latest development from Starbucks.
The coffee behemoth launched its mobile payment test via the Starbucks Card Mobile App in fall 2009 in 16 stores in Seattle and Northern California and at more than 1,000 Starbucks in U.S. Target stores. In October 2010, the company expanded its mobile payment test to nearly 300 company-operated stores in New York City and Nassau and Suffolk counties on Long Island.
“Mobile technology is part of our customers’ daily routine and with the expansion of mobile payment in our test cities, we’re seeing more and more customers using their smartphones as their mobile wallets,” said Brady Brewer, vice president Starbucks Card and Loyalty. “We’ve heard from our customers on My Starbucks Idea that they want a faster, more convenient way to pay… Mobile is just one of the ways we continue to innovate and enhance the experience for our customers.”
To pay for their beverages using their smartphones, customers must first download the free Starbucks
13 : 42Tuesday, 11 January
IDEX MAGAZINE – INDIA RETAIL | NO 02: GOING MOBILE 41
Card Mobile App onto their supported BlackBerry smartphone, iPhone or iPod touch. This gives them a barcode on their screen that they hold in front of a scanner on the counter to pay for their purchase, which is pretty nifty.
In addition to the mobile payment feature, the app allows customers to manage their card account, reload their card balance directly from their smartphone with a major credit card, check their My Starbucks Rewards status or find nearby Starbucks stores.
“With the expansion of mobile payment to New York City, we expect to see more and more customers trading their plastic Starbucks Cards for the digital version on their mobile phone,” said Brewer. “Expanding our mobile footprint gives our customers a new way to connect with Starbucks on the go and transforms the way customers experience their Starbucks Card through the mobile app.”
In the UK, the smartphone as payment device is being taken even further. CreditCall, a specialist payment services provider and transaction gateway with global recognition for innovation in credit card acceptance, has embarked on a “Smartphone Payment Acceptance Trial” that allows companies to accept Chip and PIN credit and debit card payments with their smartphone.
According to a press release from CreditCall, “Businesses operating outside the ‘normal’ retail environment who need to accept payments on the go, such as trades people, mobile retailers, beauticians, delivery services and exhibitors, can
now accept Chip and PIN payments on their mobile phone, without the hassle of checks or cash. Provided they have a mobile signal or Wi-Fi connection, a smartphone, and the special Chip and PIN pad, card payments can be taken anywhere, anytime.” If it’s successful, who knows where it will end. Ultimately, it could spell the end of credit and debit cards, as well as the hassle of carrying cash.
Those who are hesitant to embark on a full mobile marketing campaign should at the very least embrace social networking, a strategy that has been written about many times in these pages. While setting up a Facebook page or launching a Twitter account is not going to revolutionize a company’s business, with young consumers spending more and more time on these sites, it provides important exposure. “Social networks are the fastest growing engagement point between brands and customers and will grow more quickly than any other form of interactive marketing,” NRF estimated in its white paper. “A social media strategy and a mobile strategy will be at the forefront of a successful retail market strategy in years to come,” it continued.
Estimates of the number of active users of mobile social networking sites, according to the NRF, is expected to rise from 55 million in 2010 to nearly 730 million in 2013. “With people now spending more time on Facebook than Google, social media optimization strategies have become the new black,” said a recent report from L2, an NYU Stern organization driving digital innovation. Clearly, if you are not online and actively engaging current and potential consumers, you are missing out on a large and vibrant audience.
IDEX ONLINE 3GS GOING MObILE
GoinG Mobile
IDEX MAGAZINE – INDIA RETAIL | NO 02: GOING MOBILE42
1
Customers are expecting a rich experience, so retailers need to figure out how to deliver.
So, how can you begin to think about
your mobile marketing strategy? At the
NRF’s Mobile Boot Camp, which was
held last year, one session dealt with
just that subject. Listed on the NRF’s
blog are seven tips from Sitemini’s Marci
Troutman and the expert panelists
from Wet Seal, Netbiscuits, Digby, and
Zumobi to help attendees get started on
their mobile journey. (See http://blog.
nrf.com/ or http://tinyurl.com/34e86fr
for a direct link to the full post).
2
3
4
5
6
7
MAke the experience frictionless – minimize the clicks, give them a buy button and make checkout simple. keeping it simple, easy, and fast will improve conversions.
Prioritize what things you want to accomplish, because you can’t get them all done. For example, if you want to sell, make sure you are tracking conversion rates. Alternatively, if you are optimizing the in-store experience, focus on making product information easily accessible.
CoNSiDeR all platforms. You might miss out on most of your customers if you focus only on delivering to high-end devices.
kNoW where your customers are going on your site and make it easy. Whether it’s a store locator or a specific category of items, help your customers get there quickly.kNoW your customers.
Wet Seal knew that their customers were fashion focused, and so focused on imagery and featuring products.
DoN’T check “mobile strategy” off your list and walk away. Never stop working to make it more effective.
13 : 58Tuesday, 11 January
IDEX MAGAZINE – INDIA RETAIL | NO 02: GOING MOBILE 43
Global Polished Diamond Prices
44 IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: POlISHED
W orldwide polished diamond prices rose significantly in
November, according to the IDEX Online Global Polished Price Index. At the beginning of the month, the IDEX Online Index stood at 117.1. By the end of the month, it had reached 118.5, a rise of 1.2 percent. This would equate to an annualized 14 percent price increase.
Several factors drove higher prices, including the following:
October jewelry sales in the U.S. •showed a solid recovery from lackluster demand in the late summer period. An improving stock market and a bottoming real estate market were responsible for a rising consumer wealth factor.
When consumers feel wealthy, they increase their discretionary spending.
U.S. consumers began their •holiday shopping earlier in 2010.
While the economic recovery has been slow, the economy is clearly improving. As a result, consumers appear to have breathed a sigh of relief and loosened their purse strings.
The holidays in the Indian market •are over, and traders were buying goods.
The overall mood has improved in •the diamond industry throughout the entire distribution pipeline. Emboldened diamantaires have begun to raise polished diamond prices.
The IDEX Online Global Polished Price Index averaged 117.9 for the month of November, barely up from an average of 117.8 for October. However, the “average” obscureddaily trends, as graph 1 illustrates. The IDEX Online Index reached 118.5 in early September (peak at left on graph 1), then fell for the balance of September and October, and began rising in early November,
as this three-month daily price summary shows. OutlOOk MOre rOsyLast month, IDEX Online Research was bearish on diamond prices, especially after weak September jewelry sales in the U.S. market.
It now appears that consumers were in the malls, and that holiday selling season saleswill be up– thoughmodestly–from2009.Further,earlyindicators suggest that jewelry was onconsumers’shoppinglists. Capitalism sets prices based on supply and demand. Now that demandfor jewelry–andperhapsdiamondjewelry–isstrengthening,diamond prices will likely trend higher.
However, it is clear that we are still in the recovery phase of the current economic cycle. As a result, demand will be choppy for the next several months. Thus, we could see short-term swings in demand that might obscure the long-term potential for higher diamond prices.
Graph 2 illustrates that diamond prices are recovering, even though there may be daily or weekly swings that are unfavorable. ■
the IDeX OnlIne DIaMOnD PrIce InDeXThe IDEX Online Diamond Price Index is a real-time index derived from actual asking prices in the global diamond industry. The IDEX Online Diamond Price Index objectively reflects price trends as they happen. The Diamond Index and Diamond Drivers were formulated following comprehensive research and analysis of the IDEX inventory database, aggregated since 2001. Research and development were conducted in cooperation with Dr. Avi Wohl, senior lecturer of Finance at the Faculty of Management, Tel Aviv University, Israel.
Further information is available from IDEX Online Research, contact [email protected]
The full analysis of The polished diamond prices is available To ideX online research subscribers
and ideX online members.
For more inFormation on how to subscribe or to become a member, contact [email protected]
Source: IDEX Online Research By Month
2008 2009 2010
gRaPH 2
IDEX Online Polished Diamond Price Index24 Months
a S 0 nD J M a M J J a S O n D J FF M a M J J
Peak august 2008 = 128.9november 2010 = 117.8
average april–november 2009108+
46 IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: U.S. MaRKEt WInDOW
U.S. Market Window
U.S. jewelry sales trends for the third quarter of 2010 were encouraging. Total jewelry sales rose, and specialty jewelers, whose sales represent just under half of all U.S. jewelry sales, posted revenue and profit gains.
The table below summarizes quarterly jewelry sales trends in the U.S. market for both the calendar third quarter and the fiscal third quarter, since some companies are on a fiscal third quarter ending on the last day of October.
The following trends were reported by a majority of jewelers in the third quarter:
• Jewelry sales trends by month were mixed. Sales were relatively strong in July, but weakened in August and September. In October, sales strengthened significantly, as the table below illustrates.
• The average jewelry ticket was up, generally in the mid-to-high single digit range.
• Most specialty jewelers reported an increase in customer traffic.
• The number of transactions rose, though it was inconsistent. This is good news, since it means that jewelers’ conversion ratio – browsers to buyers – is increasing.
• Unit sales were up for most specialty jewelers.
• Sales growth was the greatest for big-ticket statement jewelry.
• Demand for designer name jewelry was strong. Demand for one-of-a-kind jewelry was solid.
• Bridal demand was particularly strong.
• Proprietary branded jewelry sold well.
• Pandora demand continues to be exceptionally strong.
Third Quarter U.S. Jewelry Sales Trends Positive
Month Total Sales Jewelry & Watches
Total Sales Specialty Jewelers
July +8.0% +7.6%
august +5.9% +2.9%
September +5.1% (1.3%)
October +7.0% +7.3%
U.S. Jewelry Sales TrendsMonthly Sales 2010 vs 2009Percent Change Year-to-Year
Calendar third quarter = July, August, SeptemberFiscal third quarter = August, September, October
U.S. Jewelry Sales Trendsthird Quarter 2010 vs third Quarter 2009
Percent Change Year-to-Year
Source: Department of Commerce
Source: Department of Commerce
47IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: U.S. MaRKEt WInDOW
• Jewelers’ credit sales mix rose marginally. This is a hopeful sign, since lack of consumer credit has hurt jewelers’ sales.
• Sales per store continue to rise. This helps to absorb relatively fixed overhead costs more efficiently.
• Jewelers who sell warranty and insurance plans for jewelry say that this business has been strong.
• Most jewelers reported an increase in their gross margins, though greater sales of higher ticket goods – with an inherently lower margin – had a negative impact on their margins.
• New product introductions seem to be well received.
• Sales of colored diamonds and leather accessories were solid.
• Watch sales seem to have improved notably. The LGI Network Watch Tracker service reported that lower-priced (under $500) fine watch sales and very high-end fine watch sales (over $1,500) were stronger than watches priced in the mid-range of $500 to $1,500.
OutlOOk ImprOvesMost of the publicly held companies reported a brightened outlook. • Management of publicly held companies guided Wall
Street analysts toward higher sales and profits than previous forecasts, especially for the fourth quarter of 2010.
• Many jewelers are stepping up their new store openings in 2011 and beyond. Real estate is cheap and available.
• Several jewelers mentioned that they will increase new proprietary product introductions 2011.
Preliminary results for the all-important holiday selling season of November-December suggest that jewelry sales will be stronger than expected.
The following table summarizes sales performance for the major publicly held specialty jewelers for their U.S. stores. All specialty jewelers on the table above gained market share in the third quarter except Zale (stores), Movado, Sterling’s regional brands, and Tiffany’s New York Flagship store. ■
Approx. Total Stores $ Millions Total Sales % Chg Y/Y Total Sales % Chg Y/Y Total Sales
High-End Jewelers Inflation Index Same-StoreHarry Winston US 8 $80.2 75.6% Salestiffany US * 81 $298.6 9.0% 5.0%
new York Flagship 1 n/a (3.0%) n/aUS Branches 80 n/a n/a 8.0% Online/Catalog n/a n/a 7.0% n/a
Jared (Sterling) *** 180 $164.4 16.9% 14.3% Mayors US ** 29 $24.0 n/a 2.0%
notes:* tiffany's sales for the americas (Canada, US, Mexico, Central & South america) were $331.8 million. U.S. sales were an estimated 90% of reported americas sales.** Mayors US sales estimated; same-store sales are for six-month period ended September.*** Sterling's store counts are estimates, but are within 5 stores of the actual number.**** zale stores include zale's, zale's Outlet, gordons, Peoples, & Mappins.***** zale kiosks include Piercing Pagoda, Plumb gold, and Silver & gold Connections.
Source: Company Reports
Third Quarter 2010 Sales Trends
M ost diamonds found in nature have some “birthmarks” or inclusions that influence their value or grade. Cutters can remove some of the clarity characteristics so they
don’t detract from appearance or durability with innovative cutting process, but some require more than that. The early 1970s brought many advances in diamond clarity treatments.
People have experimented with many ways to change and modify diamond’s appearance.
LASER DRILLINGDiamond manufacturers have used lasers to drill tiny tunnels – thinner than a human hair — into diamonds to remove or reduce dark inclusions since the early 1970s. The laser drill-hole makes it possible to vaporize the inclusion with laser, bleach it, or etch it out with acid. This lightens a dark inclusion and can make the diamond more marketable.
In spite of the fact that it disguises an existing inclusion, laser drilling often doesn’t improve the clarity grade. In fact, the drill-hole itself becomes a clarity characteristic.
DETECTIONYou can detect a laser drill-hole with careful examination under 10X magnification, although higher magnification is sometimes necessary. A laser drill-hole can be very difficult to detect if it is very small, short or covered u n d e r the prong during setting.
Once drilled, the hole is a permanent characteristic of the diamond, so all major gem labs, like the GIA Laboratory, will grade laser-drilled stones. They report the drill-hole as a clarity characteristic.
ADVE
RTO
RIA
L
Clarity Treatments
A variation on laser drilling is called internal laser drilling (ILD), a technique that uses a laser to expand an existing cleavage or create a new cleavage between an inclusion and the surface. This allows the introduction of a bleaching solution, which results in the lightening of a dark inclusion, making it less visible.
The cleavage created by this procedure is more natural-looking than a traditional laser drill-hole. When you examine a diamond treated with ILD under the microscope, you see a step-like series of tiny cleavages. These wormhole-like channels are definite signs of ILD treatment.
There’s industry wide agreement that laser-drilled diamonds should be clearly disclosed all the way from wholesaler to consumer.
FRACTURE FILLINGThe first fracture filling treatment for diamonds was introduced in 1980s and many manufacturers of filling materials have emerged since. The exact composition of filler varies from manufacturer to manufacture, but they are primarily molten glass.
The refractive index (RI) of diamond makes light behave in a predictable way. When a diamond has a fracture that reaches the surface, the air in the fracture (with its lower RI) interrupts light’s path through the diamond and makes the fracture reflective and easier to see.
The filling has an RI closer to diamond than the air it replaces, so it makes the filled fracture almost invisible to the casual observer.
MAgAzInE – InDIA RETAIL | nO 02: gIA48
If a fracture doesn’t reach the surface, a laser drill-hole provides a route
for the filling.
Fracture filling has become a fact of life in the diamond industry — many more diamonds
are subjected to this treatment than to irradiation, coating, heat,
or pressure.
Diamonds that once were considered unsuitable for gem use can be treated and made attractive and affordable to a wider range of consumers.
Diamonds as small as melee have been filled, but because of the cost of the treatment, most filled diamonds weigh more than one carat. The marketability of larger stones takes a higher leap with an apparent clarity improvement.
Fracture filling has its advantages — it makes a diamond look better — but it also has some disadvantages. For one thing, the filler sometimes lowers a diamond’s colour slightly.
Fracture filling can last for years with proper care, but it’s important to know that the fillers can sometimes be damaged by common jewellery repair procedures, such as the high temperatures created during recutting or repolishing and the torch heat generated during retipping or repair.
Over time, repeated cleaning can also harm fillers, especially when the method involves steam, acid, or ultrasonics. Prolonged exposure to UV radiation — even sunlight — can discolour filler and make it look cloudy over time.
It’s possible to replace the filler if it melts and leaks out, but if it turns dark, there’s no way to make it colourless again. The only solution is to remove it and replace it with new material.
Many major manufacturers of fracture fillings offer lifetime guarantees on their treatments for just this reason.
DETECTIONThe ability to identify filled diamonds is always essential, especially if you have to take jewellery in for repair and cleaning procedures that can damage a treated stone.
ADVE
RTO
RIA
L
The most obvious evidence of fracture filling is called the flash effect, which is a flash of changing colour that shows up with proper lighting under magnification. The flash effect results because glass fillers don’t precisely match diamond’s RI for all wavelengths of light.
To see it, you must look parallel to the fracture and rock the diamond back and forth. The colour of the flash will change as the stone is shifted and the background moves from dark to a light.
Other signs of fracture filling include gas bubbles trapped in the fracture or in the filler itself. The injected filler can also have a crackled texture. When you see these features under magnification, it’s obvious that they’re not part of the diamond’s original internal structure.
Always make sure you examine the diamond from many different angles. Fibre-optic illumination
makes the flash effect more evident.
Because fracture fillings can be semi-permanent, most gemmological laboratories, including the
GIA Laboratory, don’t grade filled diamonds. (They do, however, report the presence of fracture
filling.) Its only function is to make a diamond more marketable by disguising its inclusions.
If you’re ever unsure about the presence of fracture filling in a diamond, send it to a gemmological laboratory for identification.
To be absolutely sure – take it to the GIA India Laboratory Like all GIA laboratories worldwide, GIA India tests every diamond it grades for laser drilling, fracture filling, irradiation, high pressure/high temperature (HPHT) and chemical vapour deposition (CVD) to detect known treatments and to separate natural diamonds from synthetics. Grading reports are not issued for diamonds that have undergone unstable treatments such as coating or fracture filling. And, while grading reports may be issued for diamonds that have been laser drilled, irradiated or HPHT processed, these treatments are prominently disclosed on a GIA Report.
Want to learn more?About GIA Lab Services, email us at [email protected] and for GIA India’s training programmes email us at [email protected]. You can also visit GIA India at www.giaindia.in.
MAgAzInE – InDIA RETAIL | nO 02: gIA 49
FocusBailey Banks & Biddle
50 IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: FOCUS
T his is a story of how success was crafted
from failure. The story of a once successful
company that stumbled and went under
financially and how the vision and determination of a
group of managers enabled a small but viable part of
the company to rise phoenix-like from the ashes of
the first failure. It is also the story of re-invention and
how the internet can be used to give the consumer a
previously unimaginable range of choices and options
and deliver a custom solution with economy of scale
that bulk manufacture offers.
Bailey Banks & Biddle was part of a larger company
named Finlay, that operated a larger number (between
500 and 700 outlets) of leased jewelry departments in US
Departments stores such as Macy’s and Bloomingdales.
And though Finlay was a successful company, things
went wrong financially. Basically, their expenses
exceeded their gross margin dollars and the result
was a financial failure.
As the post-failure process got under way, with
assets being disposed of to try and recover as much
Re-inventing The Shopping Experience For Jewellery Consumers
Combining briCks-and-mortar with the internet helps firm rise from ashes
BBB’S vaRIED pRODUCt OFFERIng
51IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: FOCUS
of its debt as possible, a group of BBB employees
concluded that a core part of the company was
essentially healthy and could definitely be turned
around and that they had the necessary expertise
to do so. They believed that the brand itself has
a tremendous amount of consumer awareness, as
well as a storied history dating back to 1832. In
addition, current CEO and president Paul Leonard
had previously led the successful consolidation,
repositioning, and turnaround of Bailey Banks and
Biddle in the mid 1990’s as its then parent company,
Zale Corp., emerged from bankruptcy.
Market data also indicated that the time was ripe for a
fundamental change in the whole jewellery shopping
experience for consumers. A completely new approach
to how jewellery was retailed was called for. US
customers are generally dissatisfied with the overall
shopping experience and the value of offerings in
traditional jewellery stores. Saddled with the highest
cost structures in retail, traditional brick-and-mortar
jewellery stores have lost sales to online jewelry retailers
at twice the rate of the total retail industry. The new
management team evolved a strategy that recognizes
and embraces the change in consumer attitudes and
behaviour by becoming the first jewelry retailer to
bridge the gap between online and in-
store shopping.
The centerpiece of the new Bailey Banks
and Biddle is “Bailey’s Design Studio,”
which puts the customer in charge, whether
online or in-store. Customers can select
a favourite mounting from hundreds of
high quality design samples. Then, if in-
store, they can settle into a comfortable
leather chair and surf the Bailey Banks and
Biddle website for a diamond (over 25,000
are available via IDEX’s virtual inventory
and online purchasing tools specially
customized for BBB’s requirements) on
one of several 55-inch flat-screen monitors.
The external website will be launched this
spring, so customers will then be able to
purchase from home. This hybrid online/
in-store experience was inspired by the
unique interactive experience Apple, the creator of the
Mac computer, the iPod, iPhone and iPad as well as the
on-line iTunes music store, evolved to attract customers
and deliver value. The new Bailey Banks and Biddle
tagline is “Online Pricing…In-Store Service”.
The current management team includes a number
of key executives who were part of the successful
turnaround in the 1990s, in addition to store managers
from recent years. The knowledge base of the group
was instrumental in determining the group’s strategy to
reinvent the company. Since the company had ceased
operating at the end of 2009, with the closing of all
stores, the new Bailey Banks and Biddle is really a
start-up rather than a turn-around. However, the group
was able to acquire rights to the brand and negotiate
favourable leases for five former BBB stores. The stores
are located in Austin, Dallas, Houston, St. Louis and
Philadelphia.
As a virtual start-up, the new company was a clean
slate and the management team clearly recognized the
need to reinvent BBB in order to be successful. They
evolved an innovative economic model that significantly
reduces inventory costs with design samples consisting
of silver and cubic zirconia, which serves as a “virtual
BBB’S vaRIED pRODUCt OFFERIng
52 IDEX MagazInE – InDIa REtaIl | nO 02: FOCUS
inventory.” In addition, Bailey’s Design Studio’s offers
more than 25,000 diamonds from around the world
at prices below those at traditional jewellery retailers.
The value-oriented emphasis of the new BBB business
model has the potential to appeal to a much broader
base, especially the increasingly price-conscious affluent
customer and younger tech-savvy customers who have
gravitated to online jewellery offerings. In addition, the
new BBB carries a wide assortment of finished jewellery.
Consistent with its heritage, all merchandise is made
with the finest diamonds, gemstones, and precious
metals.
But the turnaround didn’t go like clockwork and it
wasn’t all smooth sailing for the new management team.
Basically, as with all start-ups, nothing was in place at
the beginning. The new managers secured an office
building and furnished it, including the installation
of a vault. They had to establish relationships with
banks, utilities, phone-, and cable companies. And
while the core group of eight executives was in place
at the outset in May, the group had to hire a central
organization and selling staff for the five stores. In
addition, they negotiated with landlords for many
of the closed BBB stores before selecting five and
remodelling them to incorporate the new Bailey’s
Design Studio.
One of the key changes that the
new team made was to combine the
traditional sourcing and stocking model
with a cutting-edge digital one. As with
most other brick-and-mortar jewellery
stores, the current BBB uses traditional
channels for “live” merchandise. But by
combining it with online sourcing the
new company can provide the consumer
access to a much larger inventory of
diamonds. The new BBB uses the
IDEX online Guaranteed Diamond
TransactionsTM virtual inventory
and purchasing system to provide
its customers with the widest choice
possible with prices that are competitive
compared to the online-only players.
The biggest advantage to the online
model, is the ability to reach a much wider audience
without the expense of a large number of stores and
a large inventory. The new company plans to grow
to about 50 stores within five years, which will once
again give it a national footprint in brick-and-mortar
terms. However, the company believes that the customer
will increasingly research online, even if they decide
to make their purchase in a store, and the fact that it
will have a store in most cities, the management team
believes, will give it a competitive advantage compared
to online-only retailers. The fact that the company is
pricing solitaires competitively with online retailers
gives it a competitive advantage against traditional
jewellery stores.
Assessing its prospects for the future, the new Bailey
Banks & Biddle believes that its opportunity lies
with being the first jewellery retailer to embrace the
hybrid online/in-store model. It realises, however,
that this alone will not be enough to carry it forward
successfully. The challenge will be learning how to
compete successfully against established retailers in each
channel simultaneously. The new company is confident
that it will meet the challenge and looks forward to
a future where it is the master of a completely new
and memorable shopping experience for the jewellery