Top Banner
I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY (E885) Stephen Kent (CD/EAG) FNAL Users Meeting June 10, 2002
57

I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Jan 01, 2016

Download

Documents

Rudolph Walton
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

I. Description/Status of survey

II. Science projects with SDSSGalaxies and Large Scale

StructureQuasarsMilky Way Structures

SLOAN DIGITALSKY SURVEY (E885)

Stephen Kent (CD/EAG)

FNAL Users MeetingJune 10, 2002

Page 2: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Partner InstitutionsFermi National Accelerator LaboratoryPrinceton UniversityUniversity of ChicagoInstitute for Advanced StudyJapanese Promotion GroupUS Naval ObservatoryUniversity of WashingtonJohns Hopkins UniversityMax Planck Institute for Astronomy, HeidelbergMax Planck Institute, GarchingNew Mexico State University(new) Los Alamos National Laboratory(new) University of Pittsburgh

Page 3: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

FNAL ROLE IN SDSS● Participants

● EAG (10 Scientists*, 5 CP, 0.4 staff)

● Other CD (1 CP, 1 FTE)

● TAG (3 scientists)

● PPD (5 eng/tech, 2.5 staff)

● BD (0.5 FTE)● Students

● 3 Thesis (U of Ch.)

● Responsibilities● DAQ system,

maintenance/upgrade

● Data processing HW, some SW, operations

● Data distribution

● Telescope & Systems engineering (APO)

*includes 1 ex-director

Page 4: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Sloan Digital Sky SurveyGoals:

1. Image ¼ of sky in 5 bands

(Scope is now reduced by 1/3)2. Obtain redshifts of 1 million galaxies and

quasars

Science:Measure large scale structure of

a) galaxies in 0.2% of the visible universeb) quasars in 100% of the visible universe

Astrophysics/Particle Physics Connection:Large scale structure today arose in universe from

processes occurring above T=1027 K (E=1014 Gev).

Page 5: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Detectors/Equipment

2.5 m Telescope

Mosaic Imaging Camera

640 Fiber Spectrograph “Photometric” telescope

Page 6: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

2. Identify Galaxies, Quasars

3. Design Plugplates 4. Obtain Spectra

Survey Operations

1. Image Sky

Page 7: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Sloan Digital Sky Survey(CD/EAG, PPD/TAG)

Current Status (Jun. 2002)

Percent Complete

44% as of Apr 15, 2002

29% as of Apr 15, 2002

63% as of Apr 15, 2002

IMAGING

SPECTROSCOPY

MT (calibrations)

Baseline

8452 sq. deg.

1688 tiles

1563 patches

Operations began: Apr 1, 2000

Operations end: Jun 30, 2005

Sloan Digital Sky Survey(CD/EAG, PPD/TAG)

Current Status (Jun. 2002)

Percent Complete

44% as of Apr 15, 2002

29% as of Apr 15, 2002

63% as of Apr 15, 2002

IMAGING

SPECTROSCOPY

MT (calibrations)

Baseline

8452 sq. deg.

1688 tiles

1563 patches

Operations began: Apr 1, 2000

Operations end: Jun 30, 2005

Page 8: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Research Results

● Publications● 173 total

● (103 in refereed journals)

● 13 additional based on SDSS data

● 28 Ph. D. Theses

● Topics● Hi Z Quasars

● Gravitational Lensing

● QSO & Galaxy Corr. Function

● Galaxy Clusters

● Galaxy Struct./Evol.

● Milky Way Halo

● Brown Dwarfs

● Asteroids

Page 9: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Early Data Release(Stoughton et al. 2002)

1. 462 Sq. Deg. (5% of total survey)2. Catalog of 14 million objects (stars, galaxies, quasars, ...)3. 54,000 spectra

Data are publicly available in online databases accesed via STScI

Page 10: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

What is Cosmology?

● Good old days

– H0, q

0

● Modern Times

– H0

– ΩTotal

= ΩΛ + Ω

Matter+ Ω

ν

– σ8, n, w, b

– Derived parameters: Γ

ΩBaryon

+ ΩCDM

SDSS will measure

SDSS will try tomeasure

Page 11: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Simulations of SDSS Performance

Power spectrum (Γ, σ8)Ω

M, w

Page 12: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Distribution of Galaxies around Sun to z=0.1

The clustering ofgalaxies that wesee today arosefrom quantumfluctuations laiddown at the end ofthe inflationaryepoch in the earlyuniverse.

Page 13: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Distribution of Quasars to z = 2

Page 14: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

GalaxyLuminosityFunction(Blanton et al. 2001)

Page 15: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Weak LensingMcKay, Sheldon, et al (2001, 2002)

Foreground Galaxy

Background galaxy (sheared)

Page 16: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Shear andmass Densityvs. Radius forensemble of31,000 galaxies

Page 17: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Weak Lensing Calibration of M/L

McKay + Blanton ==> Ω(matter) > 0.16

Page 18: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Galaxy-Galaxy2-pointCorrelationFunction(Zehavi et al.2002)

Galaxy Clustering

Page 19: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

3 Dimensional Power Spectrum Derived fromAngular Correlation Function (Dodelson et al. 2002)

Power Spectrum

Page 20: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Abell 1689 Galaxy Cluster

Cluster members have same “golden” color

Galaxy Clusters

Page 21: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

z = 0.06

z = 0.13

z = 0.20

Likelihood= -7.8

N=0 N=19 N=0

Likelihood= 1.9 Likelihood= -8.4

Page 22: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

The maxBcg Cluster Catalog

● The 200 sq-degrees currently analyzed gives a catalog of 4000 clusters

● Photometric redshift for each cluster good to 0.015

● Mass estimates from total galaxy light

● Plot shows all clusters from a wedge 90o wide and 3o high, out to redshifts of 0.7

Page 23: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Scaling Mass with N

σ (km/s)

log σ = 0.70 log N + 1.75

Weak Lensing

log M ~ 2.1 log N

Number & Mass Functions

Page 24: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Parameters of Interest

Black line is a fiducial model.

Red, orange, green, blue vary the parameter of interest.

Dotted lines are a different redshift.

Ωm σ8

fν n

Ωm= 0.27 .07 .1 σ8 = 1.04 .11 .1 fν = 0.30 .08 +0.1-0.2

(Work in Progress !!!)

Page 25: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

z=6.28 Quasar (r', i', z')

Page 26: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Lyman AlphaTrough vs.Redshift

Ly AlphaTrough

Page 27: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Optical Depth vs. Redshift

Page 28: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

End of theDark Ages

Page 29: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Debris in the Milky Way Halo(Yanny, Newberg, Ivesic, Grebel, ...)

Page 30: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.
Page 31: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.
Page 32: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

SagittariusNorth stream

SagittariusSouth Stream

NewStructure?

MonocerosStructure

F stars alongCelestialEquator

Page 33: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Conclusions

● SDSS is performing successfully● Producing leading edge science in a wide range

of disciplines● 40% of reduced scope survey now done.

Page 34: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Cryogenic Dark Matter Search(CDMS)Progress and Status

• S. Kent for the

• CDMS collaboration

FNAL Users MeetingJune 10, 2002

Page 35: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

CDMS CollaborationSanta Clara UniversityB.A. Young

Stanford UniversityL. Baudis, P.L. Brink, B. Cabrera, C. Chang, T. Saab

University of California, BerkeleyM.S. Armel, V. Mandic, P. Meunier, W. Rau, B. Sadoulet

University of California, Santa Barbara

D.A. Bauer, R. Bunker, D.O. Caldwell, C. Maloney,H. Nelson, J. Sander, S. Yellin

University of Colorado at DenverM. E. Huber

Case Western Reserve UniversityD.S. Akerib, A. Bolozdynya, D. Driscoll,S. Kamat, T.A. Perera, R.W. Schnee, G.Wang

Fermi National Accelerator LaboratoryM.B. Crisler, R. Dixon, D. Holmgren

Lawrence Berkeley National LaboratoryR.J. McDonald, R.R. Ross, A. Smith

National Institute of Standards and Technology

J. Martinis

Princeton UniversityT. Shutt

Brown UniversityR.J. Gaitskell

University of MinnesotaP. Cushman

Page 36: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

How it works½ mwimpv2 ~ 25 kev

Measure phonons and ionizations

CDMS I: Stanford Tunnel

Page 37: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

CDMS Background Discrimination

• Detectors provide near-perfect event-by-event discrimination against otherwise dominant bulk electron-recoil backgrounds, very good (>95%) against surface electron-recoil backgrounds

• Measure simultaneously the phonons and the ionization created by the interactions.

• High sensitivity• Discrimination• Ionization Yield (ionization energy per unit

recoil energy) depends strongly on type of recoil

• Most background sources (photons, electrons, alphas) produce electron recoils

• Electron recoils near detector surface result in reduced ionization yield

• WIMPs (and neutrons) produce nuclear recoils

616 Neutrons (external source)

1334 Photons (external source)

233 Electrons (tagged contamination)

Page 38: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

CDMS I Enlargement of Sample– Inner-Electrode– 12.4 kg-days for WIMPs (≠ 10.7 better efficiencies)

13 nuclear-recoil candidates > 10 keV4 multiples: They are not WIMPs but neutrons

NR Band (-3,+1.28) 90% efficient

all single-scattersnuclear recoil candidates

– Shared-Electrode– 4.6 kg-days for WIMPs – 10 nuclear-recoil candidates > 10 keV

NR Band (-3,+1.28) 90% eff.

Page 39: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Results (to be send soon to PRD)

● Tests of various assumptions– • Our story is stable

● Small statistics fluctuations– • Still strong disagreement– with DAMA– • Still best at low mass– • We temporarily– lost the “lead”– at high mass– <= CDMSII focus

● Enlarged sample– Close to expected sensitivity– (we have that we were lucky– with the first sample– because of anomalously– high number of multiples)

Page 40: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

CDMS I->II● Go deep underground (Soudan Mine)● Athermal phonon technology

– Even better rejection of background● Increase the mass -> 7kg● Approved in January 2000

Page 41: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

CDMS II and other efforts

Page 42: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Soudan Installation

● Takes much longer than we would like– Historically two obstacles: Institutional– Fridge commissioning problems

● 1) Institutional– How to build enclosures in a university laboratory, without direct participation from

within?– Bureaucratic nightmare ( Building code, DOE)– Difficulties subcontracting through University of Minnesota– Some interference with MINOS construction

– Needed enclosures are essentially finished but nearly one year after our initial hope. However, our major accomplishment was learning to work around these difficulties. They did not have much impact on our schedule.

Page 43: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

New Scenario 2-4-7

UCB/Case T2

T1-4

Full Science Running

T1-7

T1-2 Soudan

4 Twrs 60%BeginScience

T1 SUF

BeginSoudan2 Twrs 30%

T3-4

T5-7

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005

T3

T5

T1

Page 44: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Conclusions● CDMS I remains the most sensitive WIMP search at low mass

● CDMS II well under way– Soudan tower 1 exceeds specifications.– Our measured background level* rejection shows that we should reach the

sensitivity we claim.– Impressive validation of our ZIP concept and our fabrication/testing techniques – We are systematically addressing detector yield issues– All other systems are in line– Enclosures at Soudan are ready and we will move electronics in the Spring

– We are aggressively addressing our “slow” temperature physics problem

● First dark this summer!– The sensitivity gains in the first month should be spectacular– We should decisively enter the Supersymmetry domain

Page 45: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

The Pierre Auger ProjectStephen Kent, for the Auger Collaboration

• A Study of

• The Highest Energy Cosmic Rays

• 1019 - 1021 eV• Energy Spectrum - Direction - Composition

• Two Large Air Shower Detectors

• Mendoza Province, Argentina (under construction)• Utah, USAFNAL Users Meeting

June 10, 2002

Page 46: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Cosmic Ray Spectrum

Energy (eV)

Flu

x (

m2 s

r s e

V)-

1

Page 47: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Possible Sources• Conventional – Bottoms-Up• Hot spots in radio galaxy lobes?• Accretion shocks in active galactic nuclei?• Colliding galaxies?• Associated with gamma ray bursts?• Exotic – Top-Down• Annihilation of topological defects?• Wimpzillas – heavy dark matter• Evaporation of mini black holes?• New astrophysics?• New physics?

• The highest energy cosmic rays should point back to possible sources (D < 50 Mpc)

Supernova~1015 eV

Page 48: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

A look at Air Showers

Shower Max

Depth in the Atmosphere

N

Sea level

1011 Particles at surface

Shower frontShower corehard muons

EM shower

Page 49: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Pierre Auger Observatory

Combines strengths of

Surface Detector Arrayand Fluorescence Detectors• Hybrid detector:

• Independent measurement techniques allow cross calibration and control of systematics

• More reliable energy and angle measurement

• Primary mass measured in complementary ways

• Uniform sky coverage

Page 50: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Auger Southern

Site

Page 51: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Auger Surface Array

1600 Detector Stations1.5 Km spacing7000 km2 str~40 events/yr > 1020 eV

Page 52: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

The Auger Surface Detector

Three 8” PM Tubes

Plastic tank

White light diffusing liner

12 m2 of de-ionized water

Solar panel and electronic box

Commantenna

GPSantenna

Battery box

Page 53: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Auger Fluorescence Detector

33 telescope units3.4 meter dia. Mirrors440 PMTs per camera

Page 54: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Construction Plan

• Years 2000 & 2001 (Engineering Array)• Install ~40 surface detector station array.• Install two fluorescence telescopes.• Install communications and data acquisition.• Complete Auger Campus.

• Year 2002 - 2004• Full production and deployment• Transition to data taking

Page 55: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Auger Center Building

Page 56: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Event Display of a hybrid event Surface Array

Page 57: I. Description/Status of survey II. Science projects with SDSS Galaxies and Large Scale Structure Quasars Milky Way Structures SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY.

Summary

• We have some exciting science.• Strong collaboration organized.• We have completed the Engineering Array.• We have passed our major review.• Construction of the full Auger southern site is

underway. Deployment well underway by end of 2002