-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:385 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
12Strategic Human ResourceManagement ofInternational
Assignments
Dr Marie Waxin
Objectives
Throughout this chapter, the student will be exposed to:
The different approaches to staffing foreign operations The
reasons for using international assignments: position filling,
sharingand transferring knowledge, developing employees, and
controlling andcoordination of international activities
The different categories of international personnel: parent
country, hostcountry, and third country nationals, impatriates
The different types of international assignment for parent
countrynationals: expatriates, short-term assignees, international
commutersand frequent flyers, global managers, and high
potentials.
The different steps of the strategic management of
internationalassignments: strategic planning and job analysis,
recruitment, selec-tion, preparation to transfer, cross-cultural
adjustment and organiza-tional support, performance appraisal,
compensation, repatriation, andretention.
385
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:386 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
386 International Business
Opening Case
Imagine that you are Stephen Grant, marketing manager in a large
inter-
national company in London, United Kingdom. The following are
some
personal facts.
You are married to a financial analyst who works in a bank
located in
the same city. You have two childrena boy, aged 10, and a girl,
aged 8. You and your family are actively engaged in a variety of
volunteer activ-
ities sponsored by your church, which include environmental
activities
and providing food for the needy. You and your spouse enjoy
sports activities togetheryou jog, play ten-
nis, and golf on regular basis. You also enjoy cultural events
together,
such as concerts and plays.
You have just received the following letter from your
employer.
Dear Stephen,
We are pleased to inform you that you have been selected as a
candi-
date for an overseas position in our subsidiary in Kenya. Please
contact
M. Santerre, our international human resources manager, as soon
as possible
to discuss this opportunity further.
Best regards
Graham White, International Marketing.
Question: Individually, consider this situation and how you
would react
to it.
Identify your major concerns as well as reasons why you would
want to
accept or decline such an offer.
Source: Compiled by Marie Waxin.1
International managers constitute valuable resources that
organizations
do not always use to the best of their potential. Further,
senior managers
assigned to positions in foreign subsidiaries do not always live
up to their
bosses expectations. When they succeed in their international
assignments,
they often leave the organization upon returning to their
country of ori-
gin. Organizations can reverse this trend by encouraging
managers interna-
tional mobility, through better planning of assignments, better
recruitment
and selection practices for international assignments, better
pre-departure
preparation, better performance management, and better
management of
the return of their international managers.
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:387 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
Strategic Human Resource Management of International Assignments
387
The following challenges are associated with the strategic
managementof international assignments:
Assigning the right kind of international manager to the right
position,at the right time
Designing international HR practices for balancing generic and
localneeds on the one hand, and control, coordination, and autonomy
needson the other
Establishing balance between global competitiveness and
reactivenessto the local environments peculiarities
Identifying the needs for international personnel with a high
degree ofprecision
Strategic management of international assignments and of
internationalpersonnel at the lowest cost: what type of
international employee mustbe chosen, and to fulfill which
position? Which type of contract mustbe drafted?
In the following sections, we will first look at the different
approachesto international staffing, the reasons for using
international assignments,and the different types of international
employees. Then, we will proposea model for the strategic
management of international assignments. Finally,we will look at
the role played by women in the global arena.
The Different Approaches to International Staffing
The international HRM (iHRM) literature uses four terms to
describe MNEapproaches to managing and staffing their subsidiaries.
These terms comefrom Perlmutter2 who identified among international
executives three dif-ferent attitudesethnocentric, polycentric, and
geocentrictoward buildinga multinational enterprise. The
distinctions are based on top managementassumptions upon which
functional and geographical decisions about keyproducts are made.
Perlmutters distinction between these three differentapproaches was
later refined by Heenan and Perlmutter,3 who added a
fourthattitude: regiocentric. To describe these four attitudes, the
authors use theconcepts of complexity of organization, authority
and decision-making, eval-uation and control, rewards and
punishments, communication processes,geographical identification,
basic HRM strategy and state of international-ization (Exhibit
12.1). These distinctions, now widely accepted, have beenused in
various scholarly books on international human resource
manage-ment. Heenan and Perlmutters3 attitudes are presented in
Exhibit 12.1. Wewill see how these four attitudes influence the
degree of utilization of thedifferent categories of international
personnel.
-
........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
ElsevierUS
Jobcode:
KIB
Chapter:
Ch12-H7983
27-11-2006
8:26p.m.
Page:388
Trimsize:7.25in
10.25in
Fontsused:
Sabon&Frutiger
Margins:Top:36pt
Gutter:66pt
FontSize:11/14pt
TextWidth:30PC
Depth:43Lines
388
Intern
ationalBusin
ess
Exhibit 12.1
The Four Approaches to International Staffing
Ethnocentrism Polycentrism Regiocentrism Geocentrism
Complexity of
organization
Complex in home
country, simple in
subsidiaries
Varied and
independent
Highly interdependent on a
regional basis
Increasingly complex and
highly interdependent
on a worldwide basis
Authority and
decision-making
High in
headquarters (HQ)
Relatively low in
headquarters
High regional HQ and/or
high collaboration among
subsidiaries
Collaboration of HQ and
subsidiaries around the
world
Evaluation and
control
Home standards
applied for persons
and performance
Determined locally Determined regionally Standards which are
universal and local
Rewards and
punishments;
incentives
High in HQ; low in
subsidiaries
Wide variation; big
or small rewards
for subsidiary
performance
Rewards for contribution to
regional objectives
Rewards to international
and local executives for
reaching local and
worldwide objectives
-
........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
ElsevierUS
Jobcode:
KIB
Chapter:
Ch12-H7983
27-11-2006
8:26p.m.
Page:389
Trimsize:7.25in
10.25in
Fontsused:
Sabon&Frutiger
Margins:Top:36pt
Gutter:66pt
FontSize:11/14pt
TextWidth:30PC
Depth:43Lines
StrategicHuman
Reso
urce
Managem
entofIntern
ationalAssign
ments
389
Communication
and information
flow
High volume of
orders, commands,
advice to
subsidiaries
Little to and from
headquarters; little
among subsidiaries
Little to and from corporate
HQ, but may be high to and
from regional HQ and
among countries
Both ways and among
subsidiaries around the
world
Geographical
identification
Nationality of
owner
Nationality of host
country
Regional company Truly worldwide
company, but
identifying with national
interests
Basic HRM
strategy
People of home
country developed
for key positions
everywhere in the
world
People of local
nationality
developed for key
positions in their
own country
Regional people developed
for key positions anywhere
in the region
Best people everywhere
in the world developed
for key positions
everywhere in the world
State of inter-
nationalization
Early Middle Middle Late
Source: Heenan and Perlmutter.3
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:390 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
390 International Business
Ethnocentric Approach. Strategic decisions are made at
headquarters,and foreign subsidiaries have little autonomy. Key
jobs at both domesticand foreign operations are held by
headquarters management personnel andsubsidiaries are managed by
expatriates from the home country. Head officemanagers see
expatriation as a way to accelerate the progression of theircareer,
since the competence development of expatriates is preferred to
thatof local managers.
Polycentric Approach. In this case, expatriation is no longer at
the centerof the international development strategy. The MNC treats
each subsidiaryas a distinct national entity and empowers it with
some decision-makingautonomy. Subsidiaries are usually managed by
local nationals (HCNs), whoare seldom promoted to positions at
headquarters. With this approach, theMNC avoids the difficulties
associated with expatriation and cross-culturaladjustment. The
control exercised by the head office is weak, and the diver-sity of
the situations in which the subsidiaries find themselves
complicatesthe process of integrating the organizations
international activities.
Geocentric Approach. With this approach, the MNC designs its
strategyfrom an international standpoint right from the beginning.
The organiza-tion favors ability and experience over nationality.
Parent country nation-als (PCNs), third country nationals (TCNs),
and host country nationals(HCNs) are thus equally mobile
internationally. In order to be successful,this approach to
staffing without regard to nationality must be accompaniedby a
worldwide, integrated business strategy.
Regiocentric Approach. The MNC that favors a regiocentric
approachadopts uniform practices for all managers within the same
geographicalzone. Like the MNC that functions with a geocentric
approach, it utilizes awider pool of managers but in a limited,
regional way. Personnel may moveoutside of their countries, but
only within their particular geographic region.For instance,
European managers are mobile solely within Europe. Regionalmanagers
may not be promoted to headquarters positions but they
enjoyconsiderable regional autonomy in decision-making (see Exhibit
12.1).
Functions of International Assignments
Why use international employees? Reasons vary
fromonemultinational orga-nization to theother,butananalysisof the
literature suggests that internationalemployees fulfill five major
roles. The first three roles are tactical in nature:fulfilling a
need for a certain type of personnel that is not available in the
hostcountry, sharing and transferring information, and developing
the capacitiesand level of implication of managers within the
organization. The other tworoles are strategic in nature:
controlling and coordinating activities.
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:391 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
Strategic Human Resource Management of International Assignments
391
Fulfilling a Specific Need for Personnel andKnow-how
The first role of international assignments is to fulfill the
insufficient technicaland managerial competencies in certain
countries where the market structureis often characterized by a
shortage of engineers, senior technicians, andtrained managers.
Sharing and Transferring Knowledge
Another reason for using international assignments is to share
and exchangeinformation. A multinational organization can send an
expatriate employeein order to better understand a subsidiarys
activities in a particular context,to share knowledge regarding a
new type of equipment or a specific tool, orto communicate elements
of its organizational culture, processes, or compe-tencies.
Expatriation allows for a rapid and efficient transfer of
know-how.The need for such an assignment can arise, for instance,
when setting upan activity that does not exist in the host country.
Expatriation then playsa role in the training of the local
personnel, until the subsidiaries enter agrowing phase, who then
replace the expatriate employees in managementand supervision
positions. It is important to note that the knowledge trans-fer
does not only flow from the head office to the subsidiaries, but
alsobetween the subsidiaries and from the subsidiaries toward the
head office.According to Black et al.,4 there are two unique
aspects to expatriationwith regard to information exchange. First,
the duration of the assignments,between one and five years, allows
the collection and transfer of com-plex information. Secondly, the
information exchange takes place not onlyduring the expatriation,
but also afterward. The organization can benefitfrom the
expatriates acquired knowledge concerning the foreign
subsidiariesand integrate that knowledge in the strategic planning
and decision-makingprocesses.
The Development of Managers and theirImplication Toward the
Organization
International assignments constitute a proven method for
developing globalmanagers. Most senior managers have extensive
international experience.When the expatriates role comprises
supervision functions, expatriationcan play a prominent role in
developing managerial competencies and infostering loyalty toward
the organization. Indeed, expatriation allows juniormanagers or
high-potential employees to face new situations, to develop new
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:392 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
392 International Business
competencies, especially when it comes to acting autonomously
and takingrisks, thus facilitating the development of abilities
required for becominga senior manager. The managers various
international experiences help indeveloping a global understanding
of the organization. Moreover, interna-tional transfers develop the
individuals commitment toward the organiza-tion, his orher feeling
of belonging and his loyalty. Organizations that useexpatriation to
improve their managers competencies, either formally ornot,
associate expatriation with promotions. Organizations that use
expatri-ation to improve their managers abilities associate
international assignmentsmore or less formally with a promotion.
This practice gets the messagethrough to expatriates that their
international experience will be valued as anasset.
Control of Activities. From an organizational standpoint,
managers are gen-erally expatriated in the early phase of the
internalization process, in orderto control the subsidiaries
activities. In an international context, the transferof managers
constitutes an informal control mechanism, which can comple-ment or
replace more formal control measures such as the elaboration
ofnorms and procedures common to all subsidiaries. Expatriate
employees arealso used to reduce the uncertainty stemming from the
environment (polit-ical risk, cultural distance, legal environment,
competition), which is alsoa form of control. As these uncertainty
factors increase in importance, therole of the expatriate becomes
increasingly managerial in nature. Similarly,the higher the
interdependence between the head office and the subsidiariesand the
more complex the activities, the more the expatriates function
willbe control oriented.
Coordination of Activities. Expatriates as well as impatriates
play an essen-tial part in the coordination of subsidiaries
activities. Through complexdialectic processes (local/global,
individual/collective), international assign-ments are aimed at
reinforcing the integration of individual and organiza-tional
dynamics which contribute to the cohesion of the firm.
Internationalassignments indeed allow for the creation and
development of internationalnetworks that reinforce the integration
of activities. According to Janssensand Brett,5 the coordination of
a global organization relies on three elements:centralization
(decision-making by a core of senior managers),
formalization(decision-making following established rules and
procedures), and socializa-tion (decision-making following shared
norms and values).
The various functions of international assignments demand
different typesof international employees, with different profiles.
For instance, if the mainpurpose of an assignment is managerial
development, the organization willselect a junior manager or a
high-potential employee. If, on the other hand,the main purpose of
an assignment is to control a subsidiarys activities,
theorganization will select an experienced manager who is familiar
with the
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:393 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
Strategic Human Resource Management of International Assignments
393
head offices values and managerial procedures. Finally, it must
be noted thatthe five functions of international assignments are
not mutually exclusiveand can be combined.
Types of International Personnel
In this section, we will look at the main categories of
international employ-ees, discuss their respective advantages and
disadvantages, and present thevarious types of assignments for
employees from the organizations countryof origin.
The Different Categories of International Personnel
In the literature, four categories of international personnel
have been iden-tified, based on their country of origin and the
location of their assignment.These categories are parent PCNs,
HCNs, TCNs, and impatriates.
The PCNs are employees from the multinationals head-office
(expatri-ate employees). For instance, a Japanese manager working
in a Japanesemultinationals French subsidiary is an expatriate, or
a PCN.
The HCNs are employees from the host country (the subsidiarys).
Forinstance, a French manager working in a Japanese multinationals
Frenchsubsidiary is an HCN.
The TCNs are employees from countries other than that of the
multina-tionals head office and that of the subsidiary. For
instance, a Belgian man-ager working in a Japanese multinationals
French subsidiary is a TCN. Anexample of a multinational using
these three types of international employ-ees is Honda: working in
Hondas subsidiary in Dubai are one Japanesemanager, an expatriate
from Honda JAPAN, the international head office,one French
expatriate from the European head office, and 35 HCNs (Indiansand
Philippinos).
Impatriates (as opposed to expatriates) are HCNs sent to the
headoffice. The reasons most frequently cited to justify hiring
HCNs for transferat the head office have to do with competence
development of managers,knowledge transfer, and subsidiary
integration. Moreover, generating a flowof impatriates toward the
head office is an excellent way to trigger the processof
socializing NPHs. Through impatriation, HCNs develop a sense of
belong-ing to the global organization. The reasons for using
impatriation determinethe selection criteria for future
impatriates. When the main goal is knowl-edge transfer and
subsidiary integration, for example, communication skillsin the
multinationals official language as well as in the subsidiarys
languageare important criteria. Finally, it is worth noting that
the duration of impa-triations is generally shorter than that of
expatriations. Many organizationsuse impatriates in order to
reduce, in the end, the number of expatriates.
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:394 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
394 International Business
When a specific position needs to be filled, how should
organizationschoose between the different categories of
international employees? Usually,the choice is partly determined by
three elements: the general staffing policyon key positions in
headquarters and subsidiaries (ethnocentrism, polycen-trism,
geocentrism, and regiocentrism), the constraints imposed by the
hostgovernments on hiring policies, and staff availabilities.
Beyond these consid-erations, the advantages and disadvantages
associated with PCNs, HCNs,and TCNs, presented below, are
considered.
Six criteria seem relevant to discuss the respective advantages
anddisadvantages of these three categories of international
employees.
1. Cost2. Knowledge of the organization (products,
organizational culture)3. Cultural proximity4. Knowledge of the
local environment5. Attitude of the foreign government6.
Promotability of local employees.
With regard to costs for the organization, hiring a PCN always
costsmore than hiring an HCN. On average, an expatriates salary is
two totwo and a half times that of a local employee or of a TCN.
These costsincrease if the expatriate fails in his assignment. The
high cost of expatriationsometimes leads the organization to opt
for other solutions, such as short-term assignments.
The PCNs, however, present two advantages compared to the
othercategories of international managers. First, their technical
and managerialcompetencies have been put to test in their previous
positions, in the par-ent country, and have been recognized by the
head office. Secondly, theypossess extensive knowledge of the
organization: its products, its managers,and the organizational
culture. These two characteristics allow for efficientcommunication
with the head office.
As far as cultural proximity and knowledge of the local
environment areconcerned, HCNs are obviously at an advantage. All
things being equal,a local employee who speaks the local language,
understands the politicalsystem and, often enough, is a member of
the local elite, should proveto be more efficient than a foreign
manager. For local personnel, culturaladjustment is not an issue.
Training HCNs also seems simpler, from ashort-term point of view,
than selecting high-potential employees from theorganizations
country of origin and spending resources in order for themto adjust
to the host country. Well-trained local managers thus
constitutefirst-rate candidates for organizations. On the other
hand, local managersare not familiar with the organization and with
its culture. In addition, localmanagers might be too deeply
involved in the local community and have a
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:395 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
Strategic Human Resource Management of International Assignments
395
hard time understanding the parent companys global strategy, and
few ofthem might truly identify with the organization and its
goals.
Local governments sometimes exert explicit or implicit pressure
on multi-national companies so that they develop and promote local
managers to keypositions in order to nationalize the management or
foreign subsidiaries.Local legislation concerning working visas
partly determines the subsidiaryscapacity to hire TCNs. In some
countries, such as Canada, companies mayhire TCNs only if they can
prove that available local candidates were notsuitable for the
position.
Finally, the constitution of a pool of international managers
takes placeat the expense of the recruitment and promotion of local
managers and viceversa. Third country nationals can be closer to
the country of origins culturethan HCNs, but they hinder local
managers chances to get promoted. Thechoice to hire TCNs must thus
be made taking all these considerations intoaccount.
Selection between the three classic categories of managers will
be influ-enced, beyond the vast differences in terms of advantages
and disadvantagesof each, by the degree of internationalization of
the company, its internation-alization strategy, its iHRM approach,
its international assignment policy,and the specific needs of its
subsidiaries. The more the head office wishes toimpose its
nationalistic views (ethnocentric approach), the more it resorts
toexpatriation, and the more the head office wishes to expose its
geocentricside without trying to impose the control methods used at
the head-office,the more it will select based on competence rather
than nationality.
Exhibit 12.2 summarizes the advantages and disadvantages of the
variouscategories of international managers.
The Different Types of International Assignmentfor PCNs
Within organizations, many types of assignments can be found for
PCNs.The duration of assignments distinguishes between
expatriations and differ-ent kinds of short-term assignments. In
addition, the role of internationalassignments in an employees
career distinguishes between global managers,expatriates, and
international junior managers.
Long-term Assignments, or Expatriations. An expatriation is an
assignmentabroad, for a duration of one to five years, but
generally three. The employeeand his family are relocated to the
host country. At the end of his initialcontract, if the employee
wishes to remain with the subsidiary, it will beunder a local
contract. According to Harris,6 expatriations are mostly usedfor
strategic missions, and meet the needs of the control function (a
functionthat was mentioned by 62 percent of companies using
expatriate employees),knowledge transfer function (74%), and
professional development function
-
........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
ElsevierUS
Jobcode:
KIB
Chapter:
Ch12-H7983
27-11-2006
8:26p.m.
Page:396
Trimsize:7.25in
10.25in
Fontsused:
Sabon&Frutiger
Margins:Top:36pt
Gutter:66pt
FontSize:11/14pt
TextWidth:30PC
Depth:43Lines
396
Intern
ationalBusin
ess
Exhibit 12.2
The Advantages and Disadvantages of the Various Categories of
International Managers
Type of international
manager
Advantages Disadvantages
Parent country
nationals (PCNs)
Control over the subsidiaries
Share a common culture and
educational background
Facilitate communication
and coordination with corporate
headquarters
Lack of knowledge regarding countrys economic
development, culture, legal system, and political
process
Very expensive to both relocate and maintain
(expatriatespeople working and residing in their
non-native countries)
Legal restrictions imposed by many countries as to the
number of foreign employees that can be employed
Host country nationals
(HCNs)
Understand and know local laws,
culture, and economic conditions
Cost is much lower
Opportunity for development and
source of motivation
Legal regulation of employment
Cultural difficulties hindering recruitment and
training activities
Lack of knowledge concerning the organization,
its products, and its services
Communication problems with the head office
May not be as familiar with the business culture and
practices
Control and coordination of headquarters may be
impeded
Third country nationals
(TCNs)
Costs are lower than those of PCNs
Knowledge of the organization, of its
practices, of its management policies
Culture close to that of the head office
Legal restrictions imposed by many countries as to the
number of foreign employees that can be employed
Hinders local employees chances to get promoted
Lack of loyalty towards the organization
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:397 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
Strategic Human Resource Management of International Assignments
397
(60%). Expatriations, however, are costly for companies. The
main difficul-
ties related to expatriate management concern dual career
couples, lack of
candidates for assignments in less-attractive areas and
repatriation. Organi-
zations first concern is, however, the high cost associated with
expatriations.
In order to avoid those costs and the difficulties associated
with manag-
ing expatriates, more and more companies reduce the number of
expatriate
employees, propose shorter-term assignments, localize their
expatriates, offer
less generous compensation packages, and hire more local
employees.
Avayas strategies to reduce the number of career expatriates
Avaya Inc., a provider of communication systems in Basking
Ridge, New Jersey,with 15,000 employees, keeps its number of
expatriates low (currently at 15,down from 90 two years ago) by
using three strategies:
First, Avaya started sending more employees on short-term
assignments in2002. The short-term assignment, generally six months
long, is treated more likea business trip. The employee stays in a
hotel or company apartment and is reim-bursed for meals and trips
to home every other month, eliminating the need topay pricey
housing allowances and costs related to moving the employees
fam-ily. The company is now tightening its policies for short-term
assignments. Wewant to treat employees on a fair and equitable
basis rather than basing it oneach persons negotiating power or
each managers willingness to say yes or no.
Second, Avaya controls costs by hiring third country nationals.
Avaya cur-rently has 365 foreign nationals, about twice as many as
it had two and ahalf years ago. By hiring foreign nationals, the
company saves because benefitssuch as tax assistance, education for
dependents and housing allowances areoffered only for a limited
time. Also, foreign nationals arent paid a
cost-of-livingadjustment, a hardship allowance or an expatriate
premium. Foreign nationalsalso typically dont need as much time to
acclimate because they dont face thecultural barriers that an
American might. Theres no language problem and thatperson is also
in tune with the business style of the region.
And third, Avaya started localizing some of the expats. Once
expatriatesare localized, Avaya phases out housing and schooling
allowances after a year,pays employees in the local currency,
switches them to local health benefits anddoesnt have to pay income
tax in both countries. For an expatriate who earnsa salary of
$100,000, the dual income taxes alone cost $140,000.
Source: Leslie Gross Klaff.7
Short-term Assignments (112 months). Employees sent on
short-term
assignments stay in the host country between one and twelve
months. Tech-
nically, the employee might be hired by the subsidiary, and
receive a mobility
bonus. The employees family may go along but, in practice, this
rarely
happens. Career management takes place at the head office and
performance
evaluation is often shared between the head office and the host
country.
According to Harris,6 short-term assignments can be used to
compensate
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:398 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
398 International Business
for the lack of mobility of dual-career couples. This type of
assignment isused mainly for knowledge transfer (69%) and for
managerial development(39%). Short-term assignments may prove
stressful for employees. Indeed,it becomes difficult to maintain a
proper balance between work and privatelife, because of the long
work hours in the host country and because ofthe distance between
the employee and his social and family environments.Organizations
have a hard time establishing consistent policies and practices,and
managing taxation and compensation issues.
In addition, Harris6 identifies two other sub-categories of
short-termassignment: the international commuters and the frequent
flyers. Inter-national commuters travel between their country of
origin and the hostcountry once or twice per week, while their
family remains in the countryof origin. Frequent flyers travel
frequently for business, for periods ofthirty-one days or less,
while remaining based in the country of origin. Usu-ally, business
trip and per diem policies apply to those trips. According
toHarris,6 international commuters and frequent flyers are used to
carryout operational assignments, but are also adequate for control
and knowl-edge transfer functions, as well as replacement of local
competencies andcoordination. These assignments often lead to
problems with work/familybalance and excessive fatigue among
employees. In addition, the impact ofcultural differences is often
underestimated in these assignments and cross-cultural training is
generally nonexistent. Finally, organizations often lackconsistent
policies regarding these assignments.
According to Harris,6 organizations are not monitoring these
alternativesto long-term expatriation closely enough, often having
little idea of theirnumber, how much they cost them, and how
cost-effective they might be.
Global Managers. As opposed to the expatriate manager, who
spendsbetween one and five years abroad and then returns to the
head office, theglobal manager strings together multiple
expatriations for the duration ofhis or her career. Global managers
have an international career, have showntheir ability to survive
and work efficiently in various cultures, have greatcommunication
skills, and an open mind. The international life style is atrue
motivation for them, and the management of their career is
centralizedat the head office.7
International Junior Managers. International junior managers are
sentabroad to develop their managerial abilities. They are young
managers,mostly high-potential employees.
In conclusion, organizations use global managers and
expatriatesfor strategic assignments, short-term assignments for
tactical missions,commuters and frequent flyers for operational
missions, and internationaljunior managers for managerial
development. These distinctions between thevarious types of
international assignments for PCNs give organizations the
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:399 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
Strategic Human Resource Management of International Assignments
399
flexibility to react to the different problems they encounter at
the lowest pos-sible cost. In expatriation policies, specific
sections can be found concerningthe different types of
contracts.
Strategic Management of International Assignments
Many companies are sending employees and managers abroad to
imple-ment their global strategies and to control or coordinate
their far-flungsubsidiaries.9 But sending managers abroad is very
expensive. Black andGregersen10 showed that expatriates cost two to
three times what theywould in an equivalent position back home.
Moreover, between 10 and20 percent of the expatriates come back
before the end of their contractbecause they could not adjust to
the job or to the country. Among thosewho stay in their position
abroad, one-third do not perform up to theirsupervisors
expectations.10 International managers constitute a crucial
andcompetitive resource for multinationals, a resource that needs
to be man-aged and developed. Value created by international
assignments dependson the way they are planned and managed. Basing
themselves on the lit-erature and on interviews with international
HR managers, Waxin et al.11
propose a model for the strategic management of international
assignments.This model comprises eight steps: (1) strategic
planning and job analysis, (2)recruitment, (3) selection, (4)
preparation for the transfer, (5) adjustmentand organizational
support, (6) evaluation and performance management,(7) Compensation
and (8) repatriation and retention (Exhibit 12.3).
Strategic Planning and Job Analysis
According to Waxin et al.,11 the first step consists in
establishing, for eachinternational assignment (1) the goals, (2)
the job description, (3) the jobspecification and (4) the ownership
for the responsibility of managing thefull
expatriation/repatriation cycle.
Firstly, the goals of each international assignment must be
specified,and their strategic value must be determined with regard
to the organiza-tions strategic objectives. What are the
assignments goals? (increase theorganizational performance, train
local employees, transfer the head officesorganizational culture
toward a subsidiary, solve a technical problem, launcha new
product, etc.). Which of these objectives are directly linked
withthe organizations strategic objectives? Dowling and Welch12
distinguishbetween hard, soft and contextual job goals. Hard goals
are objective, quan-tifiable, and can be directly measured (e.g.,
return on investment, or marketshare). Soft goals tend to be
relationship- or traitbased, like leadership
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:400 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
400 International Business
Exhibit 12.3
A Model for the Strategic Management of International
Assignments
Strategicplanning andjob analysis
Recruitment
Selection
Preparation
Adjustment
Performanceappraisal
Repatriationand retention
Compensation
Source: Waxin et al.11
style or interpersonal skills. Contextual goals attempt to take
into consider-
ation factors that result from the situation in which
performance occurs, like
arbitrary transfer pricing or other financial tools for
transactions between
subsidiaries to minimize foreign risk exposure. Job goals will
be translated
later on into performance appraisal criteria so specificity and
measurability
are essential. However, there are considerable differences in
the way the
goal-setting process is handled in different countries.
Tahvanainen13 found
that in Sweden and Germany, for example, it is normal for
managers to
participate in the setting of job goals, whereas setting job
goals is the priority
of senior managers in the USA.
The job analysis, which comprises of the job description and the
compe-
tency profile, must then be carried out. The job description
contains general
information on the position, the goals to be met, a list of
tasks in order
of importance, the particular conditions, the context of the
position, the
duration of the contract, the date of review, and the date of
approval. In the
context of an international assignment, the jobs context must be
described
in great detail; the main characteristics of the subsidiarys
organizational
culture must be identified, as well as those of the host
country. Harvey14
suggests that job analysis must generate criteria that
adequately capture the
nature of international work as opposed to the domestic context,
in order
to provide valid appraisal information.
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:401 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
Strategic Human Resource Management of International Assignments
401
The job specification states the required knowledge, abilities
(know-how)and experience, and personal characteristics for the job.
The profile must beobjective and realistic. In order for such a
profile to be drawn, the competen-cies required to complete each
task of the job description must be identifiedand weighed. In the
context of an international assignment, it is importantto include
in the profile cultural competencies and personal
characteristics,such as a social orientation, cultural flexibility,
stress resistance, and so onthat are required.15 Ideally, the job
specification will be used again as a basisfor the choice of the
evaluation criteria.
Finally, ownership for the responsibility of the management of
the fullexpatriation/repatriation cycle must be determined. Will
the expatriate referto their home- or host-country HR manager
during their assignment? Thisis where collaboration between home
and host HR and line management isessential. Confusion will only
make communication between the expatriateand HR more difficult, and
will make the expatriate feel less supported.
This first step helps determine the ideal type of international
managerfor the position (PCN, TCN, HCN, other type of international
employee).The objectives of the position, the job description and
specification, andthe details about the management of the
expatriation/repatriation processesshould be explained to the
candidate by the end of the selection process. Inany case, the
expatriate should know the exact purposes of his assignmentbefore
the beginning of his assignment.
Recruitment of International Employees
The main objectives of international recruitment are (1)
elaborating waysand techniques which will allow the organization to
attract a sufficientnumber of motivated and qualified international
candidates, (2) identifyingcandidates susceptible to filling
foreign positions at the lowest possible cost,and (3) increasing
the pool of international candidates at the lowest possiblecost,
anticipating for the organizations future needs in personnel. The
majordecisions at this step regard the sources and the methods of
recruitment.
Recruitment Sources. The first decision to be made is whether to
recruit inter-nally or externally. In spite of the external
recruitment possibility, it is welldocumented that the majority of
firms depend almost exclusively on internalrecruitment for foreign
positions, especially for their expatriates positions.This
preferred recruitment option can be found even in local markets
wherethere is plenty of skilled labor. Why is there not a greater
emphasis onexternal recruitment? The answer has to do with the
strategic value of theinternational assignment. Internal
recruitment is justified if the strategic pur-pose of the
assignment is coordination or control of operations. However,in the
case of learning units, for example when the subsidiary acquires
and
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:402 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
402 International Business
develops new resources that may be later exported to other parts
of the
organization, recruiting from the external market can be more
appropriate.
Recruitment Methods. The second decision to be made regards the
choice of
the recruitment methods. The major internal recruitment methods
for inter-
national positions are (international) job posting and
utilization of internal
databases. To enable the company to identify suitable internal
expatriates
candidates, HR departments need to build global databases that
include data
on potential candidates, their work experience, performance,
skills, avail-
ability, and their preferences regarding a potential
international assignment:
where he or she would be interested in working, in what
capacity, and on
what sort of projects.16 For example, Tetra pack developed their
Manage-
ment Planning and Development centralized database which
contains the
profile of over thousands high potential employees and which is
updated
once a year. This database is consultable by the HR directors
community
and can be used to support the expatriates recruitment
process.8
The Danone Groups Career recruitment site, for internaland
external recruitment
The Danone Group has opted for daily posting all vacant
positions on theDanone Career website, which is accessible from the
outside as well as frominside the company. To apply, candidates
must find positions that correspond totheir profile. The site is
the fastest and most efficient way to obtain informationregarding
vacant positions within the Group, from anywhere in the world.
Toapply for a position, candidates must:
1 Conduct a search, specifying their level of experience
(studentseeking an internship, junior (12 years of experience),
senior(2 years+of experience), or director/executive), their field
of spe-cialization and the geographical area where they wish to
work.
2 Select a job offer within the search results3 Study the job
descriptions and apply.
After having filled out his or her personal information on a
form, the can-didate can attach his or her CV and cover letter.
Within 72 hours of applying,the candidate will get a receipt
notification.
The English language is preferred throughout the recruitment
process. TheGroup searches for candidates with an international
profile, and proficiency inEnglish is highly valued. The candidate
may, however, use the language of hisor her choice in the free-text
fields or in the attached documents.
The progressive opening of the Careers website to foreigners
will help facil-itate the internationalization of the recruitment
process. Fifteen countries cur-rently use the website, and the
international development continues.
Source: Danone.fr
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:403 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
Strategic Human Resource Management of International Assignments
403
When suitable candidates cannot be found internally, companies
turn tothe external market. External recruitment methods for
international posi-tions include using the Internet, launching
campaigns in international media,using the services of recruitment
agencies and/or international head-hunters,and establishing
relationships with learning institutions.
Selection of International Employees
The main objectives of the selection process are (1) enabling
the companyand the employee to determine whether the candidate
possesses the compe-tencies and motivation to successfully
accomplish his or her internationalassignment, (2) minimizing the
risk of assignment failure and the relatedcosts, and (3) assigning
candidates to suitable positions, thus maximizingthe organizations
and the candidates benefit. Because of the specificity
andimplications of the task the expatriate will have to perform,
multinationalcompanies should ensure that they have an appropriate
selection process forinternational assignments. We will now take a
closer look at the selectioncriteria, the choice of the evaluators
and the selection methods.
Selection Criteria. In theory, the choice of selection criteria
for internationalemployees is based on an analysis of the
characteristics of the multinational,those of the subsidiary, the
host country, and the position to fill.11
Depending on the results of this analysis, the ideal candidates
profilevaries from one international assignment to the other
(Exhibit 12.4).17
Given the considerable diversity of potential positions and host
coun-tries, it is not possible to draw a list of key competencies
for expatriates.18
Unfortunately, organizations tend, when selecting expatriates,
not to lookfar beyond technical expertise and previous performance
in the countryof origin. However, in the context of an
international assignment, criteriarelated to the cross-cultural
competencies and individual characteristics ofthe candidate, such
as social orientation, will to communicate, good stressresistance,
and open-mindedness, should be considered.15 Studies show
thatindividuals who seek challenges, new experiences, and who enjoy
learningare more likely to approach an international assignment in
a positive andcreative way, and are also more likely to succeed as
expatriates. If the jobanalysis has been done properly, the
selection criteria will be based on theinternational assignments
competency profile.
Choice of Evaluators. Black et al.4 recommend forming an
expatriate selec-tion team which includes managers from the country
of origin and managersfrom the host country, as well as a
representative from the iHRM depart-ment. Harris and Brewster16
note, however, that most of the time, the iHRMspecialists role is
limited to that of an advisor, while the actual decision is
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:404 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
404 International Business
Exhibit 12.4
Determinants of the Selection Criteria for International
Employees
Subsidiarys characteristicsLegal form/ownership
modeLocalization
Positions characteristicsFunction of the international
assignmentJob description and specificationContract
durationHardness of communication
Stage of internationalizationIndustrial sectorBusiness
strategyHRM orientationiHRM policiesOrganizational culture
Multinationals characteristics
Selection criteria- Type of international manager- Education-
Experience- Professional competencies- Personal characteristics-
Cultural competencies
Host countrys characteristicsNational cultureLabor laws and
regulations
Source: Waxin et al.11
taken by the managers alone. Marchon8 states that when the
expatriationis requested by a subsidiary, the selection process is
more transparent: thesubsidiary, responsible for the selection,
will make a final selection amongseveral candidates it has chosen.
However, when the expatriation is deemednecessary by the head
office, the subsidiarys role is often limited to approv-ing or
rejecting the final choice of the candidate.
Selection Methods. Several methods are available, like
interviews, psycho-logical tests, assessment centers, work
simulations or role plays, references,biographical and background
data and so on.
According to Linehan et al.,19 the interview is the most used
and is stillregarded as the most effective method to select
overseas assignees. It providesa forum to understand the
expectations and motivations of the candidateand to inform him/her
about the job.
The use of formal testing like psychological or relational tests
is very lim-ited in the practice but according to Harvey20 they are
becoming used morefrequently. Finn and Morley21 cite that cultural
awareness and adaptabilitytests are almost never used because they
are expensive, difficult to constructand interpret, and their
reliability is questioned. Forster and Johnsen22 men-tion that in
an international context there are some enormous problems withboth
suitability and comparability of tests for different national
groups and
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:405 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
Strategic Human Resource Management of International Assignments
405
cultures. Finally, the same authors note that the introduction
of these testsencounters resistance from the selectors because this
could undermine theirpower and prestige in terms of
decision-making.
Assessment centers are considered costly and time-consuming, but
theyregroup all the methods of evaluation in a single place within
a few days.They allow the assessment of the communication skills
and the adaptabilityof the candidates as well as their strategic
competencies.
References, and biographical and background data are principally
usedto ensure that the applicant has the necessary technical
expertise to do thejob, and are so less decisive in the selection
of an expatriate, even if they canbe useful to spot a particular
candidate. According to the authors in iHRM,the best thing to
assess a candidate correctly is the use of several
differenttechniques and sources of data.
Expatriates selection process in a global fast-food
multinational company
Tricon Restaurants International, based in Dallas, Texas, is the
franchiser forover 10,000 overseas Kentucky Fried Chicken, Pizza
Hut, and Taco Bell Restau-rants. The company has 100 expatriates;
20 are Americans working overseas.
Tricon has established a very formal selection process to staff
its overseaspositions.
Selection Criteria. Rather than choosing candidates who are
merely excitedabout overseas assignment and who have the technical
skills to perform thejob, Tricon is taking a closer look at whether
the candidates have the necessarypersonality characteristics, such
as their empathy, their ability to adapt to dif-ferent situations,
their ability to interact with others (sociability), and the
familysupport needed to succeed in overseas assignments.
Selection Methods:
(1) To select candidates for overseas assignments, Tricon
interviewscandidates about the positions, the countrys culture, and
itsmarketplace.
(2) If there is any doubt whether the candidate can make the
adjust-ment, a consulting firm is hired to further assess whether
thecandidate has the personality needed to succeed in an
overseasassignment.
(3) If candidates pass the interview, a 360-degree feedback
survey,which asks peers and their managers about their strengths
andweaknesses, is used to evaluate their skills.
(4) If the evaluation is positive, candidates and their families
aresent overseas for a one-week look-see trip. During the visit,
local
(continued)
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:406 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
406 International Business
managers evaluate the candidate while the family evaluates
thecommunity. The family spends time touring local schools
andpotential housing locations, and meeting with other
expatriatesin the country who help them understand the local
culture andenvironment.
(5) If the local managers find the candidate acceptable, the
can-didate, with input from family, can accept or reject
theposition.
Source: Based on C. Patton.23
Harris and Brewster16 propose a typology of selection methods
for inter-national managers, which comprises four categories,
placing the variousselection methods on two axes: open/closed
procedure and formal/informalprocedure.
First, the selection process can be open or closed. In an open
system, allvacancies are advertised and anyone with appropriate
qualification and expe-rience may apply. All the candidates are
interviewed with greater or lesserdegrees of formalized testing.
Selection decisions are taken by consensusamongst selectors. In
contrast, in a closed system, selectors at corporate head-quarter
choose or nominate through line managers the suitable
candidates.These candidates are informed only once agreement about
acceptability hasbeen reached between headquarter personnel and the
line manager. Theselection interview consists of a negotiation
about the terms and conditionsof the assignment.
Then, the selection process can be formal or informal. In formal
systems,vacancies are advertised internally, selection criteria are
made explicit andare business focused, and directly related to the
job description and jobspecification. Psychometric testing is
likely to be used, and selectors need toagree among themselves
about candidate match. In informal systems, thereis a lack of
specificity between competencies and job description, criteriaare
often not specified. Selectors assume that personality
characteristics arealready known, and give a great importance to
networking, reputation, andteam fit. There is an increasing
likelihood that individual preferences ofselectors can predominate
(Exhibit 12.5).
In practice, however, the majority of organizations operate
predominantlyclosed and informal selection systems, which are not
that different fromthe systems used for domestic assignments.
Stahl24 states that 81 percent ofthe 116 expatriates sampled in his
study were recruited through an opaqueselection system, on the
basis of nonstructured interviews. Only 19 percent ofthe candidates
went through a structured interview. None of the candidateshad had
to pass a test, and in no case, at any moment during the
selectionprocess, was the life-partner taken into account (Exhibit
12.6).
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:407 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
Strategic Human Resource Management of International Assignments
407
Exhibit 12.5
Typology of Expatriates Selection Processes
Clearly defined criteria Clearly defined measures Training for
selectors Open advertising of vacancy
(Internal/external) Panel discussions
Clearly defined criteria Clearly defined measures Training for
selectors Panel discussions Nominations only
(networking/reputation)
Less defined criteria Less defined measures Limited training for
selectors No panel discussions Open advertising of vacancy
Recommendations
Selectors individual preferencesdetermine criteria and
measures
No panel discussions Nominations only
(networking/reputation)
Open
Closed
Formal Informal
Source: Harris and Brewster.16
Exhibit 12.6
The Expatriates Selection Methods
81%
19%
N = 116 expatriates
0% 0% 0%0%
10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%
UnstructuredInterview
StructuredInterview
PsychologicalTests
AssessmentCenter
Inclusion ofPartner
Source: Stahl.24
Closed and informal selection systems present at least three
majordisadvantages.16 First, they limit the degree to which
interpersonal andintercultural skills are taken into account when
selecting international man-agers. Secondly, they restrict the pool
of potential candidates to the candi-dates who are appreciated by
the selectors. This is particularly problematicfor women, given the
fact that between 80 and 95 percent of internationalmanagers are
men. Within such an imbalanced selection context, it is allthe more
important to ensure that an open/formal selection system
preventspotential discriminatory biases on the part of selectors.
An open formal
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:408 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
408 International Business
The expatriates selection processes in five Swiss multinational
companies(Credit Suisse, Nestle, Holcim, Tetra Pak, Novartis)
In each case the task of the selection falls to the host
company, either throughthe line manager or through the HR., with
sometimes a possible involvement ofa central department. These
persons have generally no particular internationalexperience and
therefore do not emphasize the cultural dimension
throughoutexperience and therefore do not emphasize the cultural
dimension throughoutthe selection process. The selection criteria
mainly used by these five companiesare based on technical and
professional competencies, when the literature rec-ommends relying
firstly on crosscultural skills, without of course forgetting
theprofessional skills. For all five companies, the selection
methods employed toevaluate the competencies of the candidates are
the references, the backgroundof the employee and an interview. The
informal selection procedure mainlyleans on the personal contacts
and the network of the selectors. An interviewis normally used to
confirm the selection choice. None of the companies usesany kind of
formal testing to assess the cross cultural or relational skills of
thecandidate. However, three out of the five companies say they are
willing toimprove their selection processes in the near future by
introducing some morestructured selection tools in the selection
process.
Source: Marchon8.
selection system forces the selectors to continually question
their assump-tions about womens or other minorities suitability and
their acceptabilityin international management positions. Thirdly,
they prevent the organiza-tion from managing international
assignments strategically. The role of theHR manager is limited to
dealing with the financial, physical, and socialaspects of
international selection, instead of having an input into which
kindof international manager is needed and what kind of assignment
could beoptimal for that international manager.
In conclusion, although the researchers are unanimous about the
sig-nificance of an effective selection system, there is a big gap
between theirsuggestions and the organizations practices. As we
will see, the work accom-plished during the selection is also
useful for determining the preparationneeded by the selected
candidate.
Preparation to Transfer
When an appropriate candidate has been selected for an
international assign-ment, he or she must get prepared to face the
challenges of the new position.The purpose of the preparation step
is to provide the expatriates with allthe necessary elements that
will help them succeed during the international
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:409 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
Strategic Human Resource Management of International Assignments
409
assignment by facilitating their adjustment in the host country
and allow-
ing them to work efficiently throughout the duration of their
contract. The
options company can use include organizing preliminary visits,
providing
practical assistance to the international employees, providing
language and
cross-cultural training.
Preliminary Visits or Look-see Visits. This is a trip to the
host country offered
to the assignee so that he or she can assess by himself the
situation he or she
will have to face. This option is sometimes used at the end of
the selection
process so that the candidate can confirm his or her acceptance
of the
position. During this trip the expatriate will finalize the
contract and settle
some issues like finding an accommodation or a school for the
children. The
expatriate will also get an idea about the new work environment.
Usually,
a preliminary visit includes the spouse, sometimes the
children.
Practical Assistance. This aspect of the preparation is to make
everything
ready for the transfer of the expatriate and his family in order
to facilitate
the settling in. This consists in arranging for the visas, for
the transporta-
tion, finding a new accommodation for the family, new schools
for the
children, if it has not been done during the look-see trip, and
so on. Many
multinationals now use the services of relocation specialists to
provide this
practical assistance. Informing the expatriate on how the
transfer will occur
and how life in the host country will be will reduce the stress
related to the
uncertainty of the foreign assignment and facilitate the
adjustment in the
new environment. The organization should give adequate notice of
the new
posting given the professional and personal arrangements that
the employee
will need to make before he leaves his home organization and
country.
Language Training. The assignee is taught the language of the
region where
he or she will be sent. According to Ashamalla,25 language
ability facilitates
the adjustment in the local environment and enhances
effectiveness in dealing
with foreign counterparts groups including government officials,
bankers,
labor organizations, suppliers, and customers. The rigor of the
training
should depend on the relational aspect of the expatriates
job.
Cross-cultural Training. The objective of cross-cultural
training is to teach
membersofone culture to interact effectivelywithmembersof
another culture,
andtopredispose themtoarapidadjustment to theirnewpositions.
26Brislin,27
a cross-cultural psychologist, identifies three methods of
cross-cultural train-
ing: cognitive, affective, and behavioral. The cognitive method
corresponds
to a diffusion of information, using conferences or
nonparticipative sessions,
in a foreign cultural environment. The affective method aims at
provoking
individual reactions so the subject can learn to deal with
critical cultural inci-
dents. The behavioral method aims at improving participants
capacity to
adapt to their communication style and to establish positive
relationships
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:410 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
410 International Business
with members of another culture. Management science researchers
haveused Brislins model and have added to it the situational
(hardness of theculture and hardness of the communication, function
and role of the man-ager, planned duration of expatriation) and
individual variables (personallearning objectives, degree of active
participation). Tung28 suggests that thetraining method should be
chosen according to the type of assignment andshould be contingent
to two determinant factors: the degree of similaritybetween the
culture of origin and the host culture (which is a synonym
ofcultural distance) and the degree of interpersonal interaction
between themanager and the host countrys inhabitants, which would
be linked, accord-ing to Black et al.,4 to the role and function of
the manager. In conclusion,the different models of cross-cultural
training and their content are builtaround three fundamental
variables: the cultural distance between the coun-try of origin and
the host country, the managers level of integration with
hisenvironment, and the duration of the overseas assignment
(Exhibit 12.7).
Gertsen30 proposes a typology of training methods encompassing
fourcategories. First, she identifies two kinds of training:
conventional train-ing, where the information is transmitted
through a unidirectional commu-nication, as is the case in schools
and universities, and experimental train-ing, where the trainer
gets the trainees to participate by simulating real-lifesituations.
Then, she identifies two possible orientations: either the
training
Exhibit 12.7
Cross-Cultural Training Model
Level ofdifficulty Cross-cultural training method and
content
12 months
14weeks
Low
High
Less than1 week
Cognitive approachConferencesFilms/booksLanguage (basic
level)
Affective approachRole playsCase studiesCritical incidentsStress
reductionLanguage(intermediate level)
Intensive approach, or immersionEvaluation centreField
experiencesSimulationsLanguage(advanced level)
Lengthof training
Low High
1 month or less 13 years212 months
Level ofintegration
Length ofexpatriation
Moderate
Moderate
Source: Adapted from Mendenhall, Dunbar and Oddou.29
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:411 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
Strategic Human Resource Management of International Assignments
411
Exhibit 12.8
Types of Training Methods
Experimentaltraining
Generalexperimental
training
Specificexperimental
trainingGeneralculture
Specificculture
Generalconventional
training
Specificconventional
training
Conventionaltraining
Source: Gertsens typology of cross-cultural training.30
focuses on the notion of culture in general and aims at
sensitizing partici-pants to the notion of culture, or it focuses
on one specific culture and aimsat making participants more
competent in that particular culture. Accordingto Gertsen,30 the
combination of these two dimensions reveals four types oftraining,
as represented in Exhibit 12.8. In our research, we use these
fourtypes of training.
Pre-departure Cross-cultural TrainingEffectiveness
Studies in the fields of cross-cultural psychology and
management demon-strate the beneficial impact of cross-cultural
training on expatriatescross-cultural adjustment.31 Their findings
can be summarized in threeconclusions: cross-cultural training is
associated with (1) feelings of well-being and self-confidence, (2)
development of appropriate behaviors in thecontext of the foreign
culture, and (3) improvement of the relationshipswith host countrys
inhabitants. In 2005, Waxin and Panaccio32 studied theimpact of the
four types of pre-departure cross-cultural training identified
byGertsen30 on the three facets of cross-cultural adjustment (work
adjustment,interaction adjustment, and general adjustment) for
French, German, Scan-dinavian, and Korean expatriates working in
India. In summary, the findingsof their research confirm the view
expressed by researchers over the lasttwenty years that pre-move
cultural training has a positive effect on adap-tation to
international assignments. The authors further contribute to
theliterature in three different ways. First, their study shows
that experimental
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:412 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
412 International Business
types of training are the most effective ones. Secondly, their
results show
that the larger the cultural distance between the country of
origin and the
host country, the more pronounced are the effects of
cross-cultural training.
Thirdly, the authors show that efficacy of inter-cultural
training is clearly
influenced by the magnitude of expatriates prior international
experience.
Cross-cultural trainings effectiveness is indeed stronger for
managers with
less international experience.
Pre-departure preparation thus appears to be an important factor
for
adjustment. However, in most multinationals, cross-cultural
preparation for
expatriates is superficial, incomplete or simply nonexistent.32
The fact that
decision-makers often have no international experience might,
among other
reasons, explain this state of affairs (see Box below).
Pre-departure preparation at Novartis, Switzerland
Before formally accepting the overseas position, expatriates at
Novartis areoffered a look-see trip to the host country.
English courses may be offered to the expatriate if needed,
English being theofficial language of the company. Furthermore, if
it is considered as essential thatthe assignee and his spouse have
basic knowledge of the host country language,the company can pay
for such a language tuition.
Novartis invites then the assignee and the spouse to a
pre-assignment briefingto coordinate the arrangements for the
transfer, to explain the compensationpackage and to answer any
question about the host country.
Moreover, a cross cultural training is offered, consisting of a
country briefingand a course about managing in the host country,
communication and negoti-ation skills useful for the country of
assignment. This training is provided by anative of the host
country. Even if it lasts only 2 days, this preparation allows
abetter adjustment and expatriates are globally satisfied with it.
A pre assignmentcheck list is also given to the expatriate in order
for him/her not to forget anyimportant issue before leaving.
Source: Marchon.8
As an alternative to pre-departure training, cross-cultural
training in the
host country could also be envisaged.33 Mendenhall and Stahl34
mention
in-country real-time training as one of the three new tendencies
that are
emerging for HRmanagers who work in the international HR area,
alongside
with global mindset training and CD-ROM/Internet-based training.
Further,
corporations should provide cross-cultural training to
expatriates spouses,
since a lack of adjustment on their part could have negative
repercussions
on the adjustment of the expatriate himself. Finally, Harris35
notes that
corporations would benefit from using their former expatriates
as trainers
for the new expatriates. Indeed, usage of the newly acquired
competencies
-
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................
Elsevier US Job code: KIB Chapter: Ch12-H7983 27-11-2006
8:26p.m. Page:413 Trimsize:7.25in10.25in
Fonts used: Sabon & Frutiger Margins:Top:36pt Gutter:66pt
Font Size:11/14pt Text Width:30PC Depth:43 Lines
Strategic Human Resource Management of International Assignments
413
of expatriates is often neglected, and cross-cultural training
constitutes anarea where those competencies could easily be put to
contribution.
Adjustment of the Expatriate Manager:Organization Support upon
Arrival and duringthe Assignment
Once the expatriate lands in the location of assignment, he or
she needsfurther support from the company to adjust as quickly and
smoothly aspossible in the new job and in the new environment.
Also, since the expatriateis supposed to come back to the home
country after the realization ofhis mission, the company must also
keep links with the expatriate so thatthe employee does not suffer
from the out-of-sight, out-of-mind syndrome.Furthermore, maybe even
more than the expatriate, the spouse needs alsosupport. First, we
will define the notion of adjustment and present theadjustment
model and the expatriates adjustment factors. We will then seehow
the organization can support the expatriate employee, upon arrival
andthroughout the assignment.
The Process of Cross-cultural Adjustment
Expatriates adjustment to their new role and environment is of
great sig-nificance, both to the organization and to the managers
themselves. Fromthe organizations perspective, expatriates degree
of adjustment partiallypredicts performance and completion of the
mission.36 From the managersperspective, adjustment is a factor of
job satisfaction and psychologicalwell-being.37 As a result, there
has been a burgeoning ac