How can researchers inform and accelerate the shift to a Green Economy? Professor Stewart Elgie
How can researchers inform and accelerate the shift to a
Green Economy?
Professor Stewart Elgie
Canadian Context
• Green growth agenda stalled in Canada 2007-15 o Key barrier = economy. Highly partisan issue.
o Green growth seen as ‘threat’ (resource/carbon intensive)
• How can researchers help to change this?
• Built env-econ research network (2008+) – not enough
• Change the public debate – create safe space for new gov’t
• Break the env’t versus economy narrative
• Needed (a) credible economic experts - to build understanding / legitimacy on policies for green economy, and (b) prominent leaders (business, NGO, politics) to provide economic credibility and political cover
• Action: Create two major research and policy change initiatives (2013-15)
• Ex-leaders of all political parties
• CEOs of business and NGOs
Advisory
Council
• 11 top fiscal/economic experts
• All independent, highly credible Commissioners
• Coordinate and manage
• Research, writing, comms Secretariat
Goal: Build support for pollution pricing through blue chip economists plus
prominent national leaders (cut across politics and env - economy)
Who is on it? 2 tier structure:
Output and Impact:
• 3 major reports / year (re: pricing) Carbon pricing (main), roads, water, etc
10-15 events/ year
100+ media stories / year
• High impact on policy makers/shapers, and surprisingly big impact on political leaders Lead role in rehabilitating carbon pricing in Canada
Helped shape new government’s carbon pricing policy
Less impact on other pricing issues (so far)
Canada’s Ecofiscal Commish gears up for Green Taxapalooza
Terence Corcoran
What? 2 tier structure
1. SP Institute (research network / think tank hybrid) • Network: 80+ scholars – economy, policy, law (¾ Canadian, ¼ global)
• Expert staff: research, comms, events
• Global partners: e.g. GGKP, Grantham, OECD, RFF, Duke, UCL
• Focus: policies on (i) Clean Innovation; (ii) Resource Efficiency (Circular
Econ.); (iii) Price Pollution, and (iv) Conserve & Value Nature (Bio Econ)
2. SP Initiative (Leaders Group)
• 30+ prominent business CEOs (all sectors) and NGO leaders
• Work with nation’s top communications experts
• Release reports / letters / statements on clean growth
A powerful platform, builds on Institute’s research
Smart Prosperity
Goal: Drive clean growth policy change through (i) policy-relevant
research; (ii) connecting scholars with business, government and
NGO leaders, and (iii) broader communication. Ideas + Impact.
Smart Prosperity
Output and Impact:
• SP Research Institute 15-20 reports, briefs / year (research -> key policy issues)
15-20 events / year (research + policy, interactive)
High impact on policy-makers/shapers and ‘experts’
40-50 media stories / yr; 11,000 social media followers
• SP Initiative (Leaders) 2 major reports per year (built on research)
o Clean growth, innovation, bio-econ, etc
High profile statements by business/NGO CEOs
High impact on political leaders, public debate o Launch generated 500+ stories, trended on twitter, quoted in PM/Premiers speeches
o Letter by 100 CEOs built critical momentum for national climate & clean growth plan
Greenery in Canada We have a winner B.C. carbon tax woos sceptics
Business executives urge
‘bold leadership’ on climate
plan from Justin Trudeau,
premiers
60-plus signatories from a variety of industries including oil and gas, mining and aluminum ask ministers to press ahead with putting a price on carbon.
Lessons and Challenges: Broader
Challenges
• Alignment: academic system d/n reward policy impact
• Most academics aren’t policy change experts Knowledge translation, connection, communication are key
Need ‘intermediary’ skills (bodies)
• Hard to fund in university model Mix of foundations, gov’t, companies, research councils
• Individual universities wanting credit (impediment)
Lessons
• Academics can have real policy impact, with direction and support
• Creating incentives, training, support = hard, but possible
• Building a powerful platform helps (joint action, mobilization, ‘brand’)