Speed Post RTI MATTER F. NO.13/643/2013·TS Government of India Ministry of Urban Development Directorate of Estates Allotment Type Special-II Nirman Bhawan. New Delhi, / Sri Subhash Chandra Agrawal, 1775, Kucha Lattushah, Dariba Chandni Chowk, Delhi-110006 Subject: Order of First Appellate Authority dated 12.08.2013 regarding RTI application dated 27.05.2013. Sir. <,-.... In complianc17 with the order of the First Appellate Authority, I am to refer to your application on the subject cited above and to say that the original application had inadvertently got mixed up in the section with certain other papers amidst excessively heavy burden of work and hence the information could not be given in time. 2. However, on receipt of a copy of the same now along with the orders of the First Appellate Authority, the matter has been examined and seen that only item Nos. 2, 3, 4 & 7 of your application pertain to this Division. The requisite information on these items is furnished as under as per available records: SI. No. Replyllnfdrmation 2. List is attached at Annexure-I. The primary responsibility for allotment of accommodation to the Members of Parliament rests with the respective House Committee (Lok Sabhal Rajya Sabha Secretariat) concerned. As per the existing guidelines, the former Union Ministers who continue to be sitting Members of Parliament are allowed retention of their Ministerial accommodation till they are allotted their entitled category of accommodation from the respective Lok Sabha/ Rajya Sabha House Committee concerned. 3. 4. 7. Nil. Lok Sabhal Rajya Sabha Secretariats have been requested accordingly for allotment of accommodation in respect of former Union Ministers as per their entitlement. The required list of unauthorized occupants of Government houses is attached at Annexure-II. 3. If not satisfied, an appeal may be preferred with the Appellate within 30 days from the receipt of this letter. The name and address of the Appellate Authonty IS as under: Shri Munish Kumar Garg, Director of Estates. Ministry of Urban Development, Room No. 414. Q . Wing, Nirman Bhawan. New Delhi (Telefax: 23061189). ___ Dy. Director of Estates &CPIO. Copy for information to: 0 Ih' tOM No 1/273/2013/RTICI DE dated (i)AD (RTI Cell). Nirman Bhawan. Newel W.r.. ., . 12.08.2013. I. (i)DD. Policy Division. (ii)DD, Rent Division. [D.B. Kumbhare] Assistant Director of Estates
13
Embed
Here is complete documents of unauthorized occupation of government bungalows by former Union Ministers and others despite Supreme Court's verdict.
It refers to Union Ministry of Urban Development (MoUD) revealing list of unauthorised occupants of government-accommodations by persons of different categories including even many former Union Ministers. However list has wrongly mentioned names of Sushma Swaraj and Arun Jaitley as unauthorized occupants because both of these enjoy status of Union Minister in their capacity as leaders of opposition in two Houses of Parliament and as such entitled for ministerial-bungalows. MoUD has fixed responsibility on concerned committees of Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha for allotting former Union Ministers alternate government-accommodations in their capacity as Parliamentarians so that ministerial-palaces may got vacated. But MoUD is silent on those former Union Ministers who are not even Parliamentarians now. Apart from this, there are many others which are occupying government-accommodations despite some of them having lost entitlement even decades ago. MoUD is also silent on unauthorised occupation of government-bungalow number 6, Krishna Menon Marg (New Delhi) despite Supreme Court’s specific direction for not converting any government-bungalow in memorial. Chat Conversation End
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Speed Post RTI MATTER
F. NO.13/643/2013·TS Government of India
Ministry of Urban Development Directorate of Estates
Allotment Type Special-II Nirman Bhawan. New Delhi,
Subject: Order of First Appellate Authority dated 12.08.2013 regarding RTI application dated 27.05.2013.
Sir. <,-.... In complianc17 with the order of the First Appellate Authority, I am to refer to your
application on the subject cited above and to say that the original application had inadvertently got mixed up in the section with certain other papers amidst excessively heavy burden of work and hence the information could not be given in time.
2. However, on receipt of a copy of the same now along with the orders of the First Appellate Authority, the matter has been examined and seen that only item Nos. 2, 3, 4 & 7 of your application pertain to this Division. The requisite information on these items is furnished as under as per available records:
SI. No. Replyllnfdrmation 2. List is attached at Annexure-I. The primary responsibility for allotment of
accommodation to the Members of Parliament rests with the respective House Committee (Lok Sabhal Rajya Sabha Secretariat) concerned. As per the existing guidelines, the former Union Ministers who continue to be sitting Members of Parliament are allowed retention of their Ministerial accommodation till they are allotted their entitled category of accommodation from the respective Lok Sabha/ Rajya Sabha House Committee concerned.
3. 4.
7.
Nil. Lok Sabhal Rajya Sabha Secretariats have been requested accordingly for allotment of accommodation in respect of former Union Ministers as per their entitlement. The required list of unauthorized occupants of Government houses is attached at Annexure-II.
3. If not satisfied, an appeal may be preferred with the Appellate Aut~or!ty within 30 days from the receipt of this letter. The name and address of the Appellate Authonty IS as under:
Shri Munish Kumar Garg, Director of Estates. Ministry of Urban Development, Room No. 414. Q . Wing, Nirman Bhawan. New Delhi (Telefax: 23061189). ~ ___
[S.K.~ Dy. Director of Estates &CPIO.
Copy for information to: 0 Ih' tOM No 1/273/2013/RTICI DE dated (i)AD (RTI Cell). Nirman Bhawan. Newel W.r.. ., .
12.08.2013. I. (i)DD. Policy Division. (ii)DD, Rent Division. [D.B. Kumbhare]
Assistant Director of Estates
Annexure-I
List of former Union Ministers in occupation of government-accommodations as on 22.08.2013.
SI.No. Name Address Type 1. K. Chandra Shekhar Rao 23, Tughlak Road VIII 2. Dayanidhi Maran 6, Akbar Road VIII 3. Subodh Kant Sahay 11, Akbar Road VIII 4. Saifuddin Soz 12, Akbar Road VIII 5. Ambika Soni 22, Akbar Road VIII 6. Pawan Kumar Bansal 6, Ashoka Road VIII 7. Raghuvansh Prasad Singh 8, Ashoka Road VIII 8. Arun Jaitly 9, Ashoka Road vru 9. Meneka Gandhi 14, Ashoka Road Vlll 10. C.P. Joshi IS, Ashoka Road VlIl
-'11. Ashwini Kumar 18, Ashoka Road VIl~
12. M. Venkaiah Naidu 30, Aurangazeb Road VlH
13. Agatha K. Sangma 34, Aurangazeb Road Villi
14. Mukul Wasnik 36, Aurangazeb Road villi 15. M. K. Alagiri 1, Dupleix Road VJII\
16. Yashwant Sinha 6, Kushak Road VIIIi
17. Sudip Bandopadhyay I-B, Maulana Azad Road Villi
18. Vilas Muttenwar 1, Motilal Nehru Marg VIII
19. L. K. Advani 30, Prithwi Raj Road VIII
20. M. M. Joshi 6, Raisina Road VIII
21. T. R. Balu 10, Raisina Road VIII
22. B. K. Handique 2, Tughlak Road VIn
23. Sharad Yadav 7, Tughlak Road VIII
24. S. M. Krishna 1, Tyagaraj Marg VIII
25. M.S. Gill 12, Willingdom Crescent VIII
26. Dinesh Trivedi 4, Lodhi Estate VII
27. Rao Inderjit Singh 6, Lodhi Estate VII
Suagata Ray 58, Lodhi Estate VlI 28.
C.M. Jatua 59, Lodhi Estate VII 29.
2-A, MLN Marg VII 30. A. Raja
]0, Pandit Pant Marg VII 31. AjayMaken
8, Safdarjung Lane ViI 32. Sushma Swaraj
21, Wellington Crescent VII 33. Ravi Shankar Prasad vn 34. Dr. Karan Singh
24, Wellington Crescent VIE
35. Vincent H. Pala 21, B. R. Mehta Lane
VIE Mahadev Singh Khandela
52, Lodhi Estate 36.
Pool GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP OP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP GP I
GP GP GP
Annexure-II
Unauthorized occupants of Government Accommodation as on 22.08.2013
Type-VII
Sl.No. File No.lFlat No. Name of the allottee Date of Retention Date of reference to Cancellation allowed up Litigation Division
22.08.201331.07.201301.04.2013Md. Haleem Khan 35, New Moti Bagh
4.
Type-6B
Date of reference to RetentionDate ofName ofthe allotteeFile No.lFlat No. Sl.No. Litigation Division allowed upCancellation for eviction to proceedingsl Remarks 06.06.2013-19-03-2013Shri P.K. Rastogi 9/1901/20011.
17. Shri Savitur Prasad 011/3, Pt. Pant Marg 16.9.2011 -18. Sh ri Y o~end ra Ga rg 01l/B-6, Tilak Lane 27.2.2013 19. Shri R.C. Pandit, 011/0-6, Tilal< Lane 16.10.2001
Journalist 20. Shri B. Anand 011/97, Kaka Na~ar 16.5.2013
NIRMAN BHAWAN, NEW DELHI, DATED THE 19TH OCTOBER, 2013
To, /cV ?hri Subhash Chandra Agrawal,
House No.1775, Kucha lattushah, Dariba, Chandni Chowk, Delhi - 110006
Subject: Information under the RTI Act - 2005 regarding.
Please refer to your letter dated 05/07/2013 addressed to CPIO, M/o-UD and AD (RTI/PG) Dte. of Estates dated 06/08/2013 on the above cited subject.
The information against SI. No. 1 to 5 and 81. No. 7 to 11 do not pertains to' Type A (A&B) Section.
The information against SI. No. 6 for government accommodations in Delhi/New Delhi presently as unauthorized occupations under Type-I quarters is concerned, a detailed list may be provided to the applicant.
If you are not satisfied with this information, you can appeal to the following Appellate Officer within 30 days from the date of issue of this letter.
Shri Krishna Dutt, Director of Estates - II, Room No. 439-C, Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi - 110011.
~ ( SHOBHANA MATHEW)
PIO &DY. DIRECTOR (A-II)
Copy to : The Assistant Director (RTIIPG), Directorate of Estates, Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi.
/ PIO &DY. DIRECTOR (A-II) \
Government of India Directorate of Estates Type A(A&B) Section
*****
List of unauthorized occupants till date
House No. Name Office address of the Date of Death/ Date from which No.
lSI. S/ShrIlSmt. allottee Retlrementl vacation is
I Transfer requiredI 1. N/3/332/Andrewz DIWAN PURl, BIFR, S.O. (Admn.), M/o 31.05.2027 11.09.2009
Ganj! Finance, Byapar Bhawan, NO.
2. 4/13/C/DIZ area SHIV Deptt. Of ORO, EE. ParI. 30.09.2021 19.10.2006 NARESH, Works Division-53,
CPWD I.P. Bhawan, NO. 3. 4/68/C/DIZ area K.C.CHATELA Min. of Commerce. 31.07.2012 01.12.2010
P&AO, 'Deptt. of Commerce, Udyog Bhawan, NO
4. 4/8/AtDIZ area RAVINDER Deptt. Of Defence 28.02.2011 01.07.2011 SHARMA, Research &