Hearing Timetable: Version 2 (19 August 2016) Melbourne ...- Dean Griggs of City of Melbourne in social and community impacts. - Barry Fox of City of Melbourne in surface water, ground

Hearing Timetable: Version 2 (19 August 2016)

Melbourne Metro Rail Project – EES Inquiry and Advisory Committee (IAC)

Hearing Venue: Mercure Treasury Gardens, 13 Spring Street, Melbourne

Page 1

Day 1: Monday 22 August 2016

Government agencies, MMRA

Time Party Allocated

10.00am – 10.30am IAC - Preliminary matters 30 mins

10.30am – 10.45am Minister for Planning, represented by Adrian

Finanzio SC, with Emma Peppler (Submission No. 88)

15 mins

10.45am – 11.00am EPA Victoria, represented by German Ferrando-

Miguel and Madhvi Betigeri (291)

15 mins

11.00am – 11.15am Tea break

11.15am – 1.00pm Melbourne Metro Rail Authority (MMRA),

represented by Michelle Quigley QC, Chris

Townshend QC, Marita Foley and Barnaby Chessell of

Counsel, instructed by Tim Power of Herbert Smith

Freehills, (280) and calling various experts as noted in

following Days 2 – 9 and Day 19, with closing

submissions on Day 33

9.5 days

1.00pm – 2.00pm Lunch Break

2.00pm – 4.30pm MMRA, continued

Day 2: Tuesday 23 August 2016

MMRA



10.15am – 12.15pm Public Transport Victoria (Part 1), represented by

Stuart Morris QC, instructed by Ashurst Lawyers, with

Part 2 scheduled for Day 21 (275)

2 hours

12.15pm – 1.30pm Lunch

1.30pm – 4.30pm MMRA, continued, evidence from:

- Rob Milner of 10 Consulting Group in land

use planning

9.5 days

Melbourne Metro Rail Project: Inquiry and Advisory Committee | Hearing Timetable Version 2 (19/08/2016)

Page 2

Day 3: Wednesday 24 August 2016

MMRA



10.15am – 1.00pm MMRA, continued, evidence from:

- Peter Lovell of Lovell Chen in heritage

- David Galway of Tree Dimensions in

arboriculture

- John Patrick of John Patrick in arboriculture

9.5 days



Day 4: Thursday 25 August 2016

MMRA


9.15am - 10.00am Confidential submission (restricted entry to hearing

room)

45 mins



- Ron Jones of Jones and Whitehead in urban

design

- John McCrann of AJMJV in surface water

- Hugh Middlemis of Hydrogeologic in

groundwater

9.5 days



Day 5: Friday 26 August 2016

MMRA




- Shane Lakmaker of AJMJV in air quality

- David Coutts of AJMJV in contaminated land

9.5 days



3.00pm End of day


Page 3

Day 6: Monday 29 August 2016

MMRA



10.15am – 10.45am Metropolitan Planning Authority, represented by

Kate Alder (376)

30 mins

10.45am – 1.00pm

MMRA, continued, evidence from:

- Sean Smedley of Smedley Technical and

Strategic in transport

- Rose McArthur of AJMJV in transport

9.5 days



Day 7: Tuesday 30 August 2016

MMRA




- Dave Anderson of Acoustic Studio in

airbourne and operational vibration

- John Heilig of Heilig and Partners in

construction vibration

9.5 days



Day 8: Wednesday 31 August 2016

MMRA




- Anthony Bennett of AJMJV in ground

movement and future development loading

9.5 days




Page 4

Day 9: Thursday 1 September 2016

MMRA




- Terry Rawnsley of SGS Economics and

Planning in business impact assessment

- Owen Boushel of AJMJV in social impacts

- Tim Offer of Pax Republic in social impacts

9.5 days



3.30pm End of Day


Page 5

Day 10: Monday 5 September 2016

Councils



10.15am – 1.00pm Melbourne City Council, represented by Matthew

Townsend of Counsel (365), and calling evidence

from:

- Haig Poulson of City of Melbourne in

engineering

- Richard Smithers of City of Melbourne in

transport

- Graham Porteous of City of Melbourne in

social and community impacts

- Alison Duncan of City of Melbourne in social

and community impacts

- Dean Griggs of City of Melbourne in social and

community impacts.

- Barry Fox of City of Melbourne in surface

water, ground water and stormwater.

- Peter Fearnside of Marshall Day Acoustics in

noise and vibration management.

- John Briggs of John Briggs Architects in

heritage

- Rob Moore of City of Melbourne in urban

design

- Ian Shears of City of Melbourne in

arboriculture, parks and open space

- Melanie Oke of City of Melbourne in waste

management

- Dr Nicholas Williams of the University of

Melbourne in biodiversity

- Steve Nagle of City of Melbourne in business

and tourism

2.5 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm Melbourne City Council, continued


Page 6

Day 11: Tuesday 6 September 2016

Councils



10.15am – 1.00pm Melbourne City Council, continued 2.5 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm Melbourne City Council, continued

Note: remaining time is scheduled for Day 27

Day 12: Wednesday 7 September 2016

Councils



10.15am – 12.15pm Port Phillip City Council, represented by Claire Ferres

Miles (133)

2 hours


1.00pm – 4.30pm Stonnington City Council, represented by Peter

O’Farrell of Counsel, instructed by Kim Piskuric of

Harwood Andrews (257), and calling evidence from:

- Steve Schutt of Hansen in landscape and open

space

- Tim Marks of Marshall Day in acoustics

- William McDougall in transport planning

- Stephen Hunt of Cardno in traffic

1.5 days


Councils



10.15am – 1.00pm Stonnington City Council, continued 1.5 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm Stonnington City Council, continued


Page 7

Day 14: Friday 9 September 2016

Education



10.15am – 10.25am Trevor Jensen (209) 10 mins

10.25am – 1.00pm The Graduate Union of the University of Melbourne,

represented by Chris Wren QC (100) and calling

evidence from:

- Eli Giannini of MGS Architects in architecture

- Stephen Payne of Bonacci Group in engineering

- Daniel Soussan of Tract Consultants in town

planning

- Dr Kerry Bennett of The Graduate Union

1 day


2.00pm – 4.30pm The Graduate Union of the University of Melbourne,

continued


Education


10.00am – 10.15am IAC – Preliminary matters 15 mins

10.15am – 10.35am Jonathan Forbes (266) 20 mins

10.35am – 10.45am Robin Vowels (364) 10 mins

10.45am – 1.00pm RMIT University, represented by Maria Marshall and

Barnaby McIlrath of Maddocks, (180) and calling

evidence from:

- Tim Marks of Marshall Day in acoustics and

vibration

- Hugh Smyth of SJB Planning in planning

- Amelio Russo of Meinhardt in environmental

management

1.5 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm RMIT University, continued


Page 8


Education



10.15am – 1.00pm RMIT University, continued 1.5 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm Melbourne Anglican Trust Corporation, represented

by Lisa Riddle of Planisphere and Revd Dr Andreas

Lowe (274), and calling evidence from:

- Ross Leo of Marshall Day Acoustics in acoustics

2.5 hours


Education



10.15am – 1.00pm The University of Melbourne, represented by Susan

Brennan SC and Paul Chiappi of Counsel, instructed by

Rigby Cooke Lawyers (318), and calling evidence from:

- Rob McGauran of MGS Architects in architecture

- Professor James McCluskey of Melbourne

University in research

- Professor Glyn Davis, Vice-Chancellor of

Melbourne University

- Jason Sellars of GTA in traffic

- Matthew Stead of Resonate Acoustics in acoustics

2.5 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm The University of Melbourne, continued


Education



10.15am – 1.00pm The University of Melbourne, continued 2.5 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm The University of Melbourne, continued


Page 9


Education and others



10.15am – 10.25am Peter James Anderson (204) 10 mins

10.25am – 10.40am Christ Church South Yarra, represented by Revd Dr

Richard Treloar (159)

15 mins

10.40am – 1.00pm The University of Melbourne, continued 2.5 days


2.00pm – 4.00pm MMRA – additional submissions (if required). 2 hours


Culture and Heritage



10.15am – 11.15am National Trust of Victoria, represented by Anna Foley

(332)

60 mins


11.30am – 12.30pm The Hallmark Owners Corporation 501271A,

represented by George Swinburne (283) and for

himself (289)

60 mins

12.30pm – 1.00pm Melbourne Heritage Action Group, represented by

Rohan Storey (335)

30 mins

1.00pm – 1.15pm Australia Institute of Landscape Architects,

representation tbc (255)

15 mins


2.00pm – 2.30pm Naturelinks Landscape Management, represented by

Patrick Deasey (227)

30 mins

2.30pm – 2.50pm Australia Visitors Centres, represented by Soho

Lawyers (121)

20 mins

2.50pm – 3.05pm Tea break

3.05pm – 3.25pm Burke and Wills Historical Society, represented by

David Dodd (269)

20 mins

3.25pm – 3.55pm National Boer War Memorial Association,

represented by William Woolmore (375)

30 mins

3.55pm – 4.10pm National Gallery of Victoria, represented by Tony

Ellwood (166)

15 mins

4.10pm – 4.30pm Arts Centre Victoria, tbc (321) 20 mins


Page 10


Public Transport Victoria and business



10.15am – 1.00pm Public Transport Victoria (Part 2), represented by

Stuart Morris QC, instructed by Ashurst Lawyers (275)

3 hours


2.00pm – 4.00pm

Legend Properties Pty Ltd, represented by Paul

Chiappi of Counsel, instructed by Phillip Leamann of

Tisher Liner Law (372) and calling evidence from:

- Neil Huybregts of Marshall Day in acoustics

2 hours


4.15pm – 6.15pm Hobsons Pty Ltd and Karaoke Pty Ltd, represented by

Paul Chiappi of Counsel, instructed by Phillip Leamann

of Tisher Liner (261)

2 hours


Page 11


Owners Corporations



10.15am – 1.00pm Owners Corporation 348427V of 400 St Kilda Road

Melbourne ‘The Botanica’, represented by Nick

Sutton, Planning and Property Partners (240) and

calling evidence from:

- Neville Goddard of Watson Moss Growcott in

acoustic and vibration

- Terry Bellair of Environmental Science Associates

in air quality

- John Kiriakidis of GTA Consultatnts in traffic and

transport

3 hours


2.00pm – 3.00pm G12+ Group of Owners Corporations represented by

Cameron Gentle, Hansen Partnership (370 and 356)

60 mins


3.15pm – 5.15pm The Domain Owners Corporation, represented by

Cameron Gentle, Hansen Partnership (190), and


- Simon McHugh of Marshall Day Acoustics

2 hours


Page 12


Owners Corporations and property owners



9.30am – 10.30am City Wide North Melbourne Asphalt, represented by

Paul Chiappi of Counsel, instructed by Planning and

Property Partners (277)

2 hours

10.30am – 12.30pm City Wide Service Solutions, represented by Paul

Chiappi of Counsel, instructed by Planning and

Property Partners (170), calling evidence from:

- John Kiriakides of GTA Consultants in traffic

engineering

60 mins


St Kilda Road property owners

1.30pm – 1.40pm Linda Bardo Nicholls AO (81) 10 mins

1.40pm – 1.45pm Royal Domain Plaza Owners Corporation PS419703E,


5 mins

1.45pm – 2.00pm John Tabart (306) 15 mins

2.00pm – 2.20pm Karina Reynolds (313) 20 mins

2.20pm – 2.25pm Mike Planinc (94) 5 mins

2.25pm – 2.35pm Promenade/City Condos/Princeton Residents Group,

represented by James Hayton (319)

10 mins

2.35pm – 2.45pm Promenade/City Condos/Princeton Residents Group,

represented by Timothy Fitton (349)

10 mins

2.45pm – 2.55pm Timothy Fitton (89) 10 mins


3.10pm – 3.20pm Christopher Fellows (108) 10 mins

3.20pm – 3.35pm Fiona Reed (343) 15 mins

3.35pm – 3.45pm James Hayton (265) 10 mins

3.45pm – 3.50pm Stephanie Anderson (267) 5 mins

3.50pm – 4.00pm Winston Chong (104) 10 mins

4.00pm – 4.10pm Tennessee Leeuwenburg (325) 10 mins

4.10pm – 4.20pm Fiona Reed (333) 10 mins

4.20pm – 4.35pm William Melville (04) 15 mins


Page 13


Owners Corporations and property owners



10.45am – 11.45am Domain Hill Owners Corporation represented by

Richard St John (226)

60 mins

11.45am – 12noon Tea break

12noon – 12.05pm Helen Kent (196) 5 mins

12.05pm – 12.20pm Tedd Warden (312) 15 mins

12.20pm – 1.00pm Residents of Albert Tower, represented by Lou Raunik

(268)

40 mins


South Yarra area

2.00pm – 2.40pm Ronald and Nola Hutchins (352) 40 mins

2.40pm – 2.50pm James Robinson (44) 10 mins

2.50pm - 3.00pm Pratap Acharya (348) 10 mins


3.15pm – 3.30pm Nicolas Thomas (354) 15 mins

3.30pm – 3.45pm Roger and Wendy Allgood (12) 15 mins

3.45pm – 4.00pm Thomas Howgate (19) 15 mins

4.00pm – 4.10pm Peter and Sharon Robertson (164) 10 mins

4.10pm – 4.15pm Joseph Ayres (264) 5 mins


Page 14


Owners Corporations, community associations and property owners



Fawkner Park area

10.15am – 10.35am Fawkner Park Children’s Centre, represented by

Hayden Rattray (278)

20 mins

10.35am – 10.40am Owners Corporation OCSP444 563B 2-14 Hope Street,

represented by Basil Jenkins (141)

5 mins

10.40am – 10.50am Malcolm and Darcy Cameron (213, 214) 10 mins

10.50am – 11.00am Maurice Eisenbruch (296) 10 mins

11.00am – 11.20am Thomas Harley and Sarah Kennedy (322) 20 mins


Kensington area

11.35am – 12.05pm Group of South Kensington Residents, represented by

Mathew Hammond (238)

30 mins

12.05pm – 12.10pm Kensington Association, represented by Rilke Muir

(124)

5 mins

12.10pm – 12.20pm Vincent Ryan (210) 10 mins

12.20pm – 12.25pm Bronwen Jefferson (230) 5 mins

12.25pm – 12.35pm Charles McHugh (243) 10 mins

12.35pm – 12.40pm Peter Giudice (340) 5 mins

12.40pm – 12.50pm Dennis Kennedy (83) 10 mins

12.50pm – 12.55pm Therese Fitzgerald (11) 5 mins

12.55pm – 1.05pm Adam Murchie (101) 10 mins


North Melbourne area

2.00pm – 2.40pm North Melbourne Community Group, represented by

Rina Mordaunt (228)

40 mins

2.40pm – 3.00pm Michael and Rina Mordaunt (203) 20 mins

3.00pm – 3.30pm Angela Williams (207) 30 mins


3.45pm – 3.55pm Ross Miller (134) 10 mins

3.55pm – 4.00pm Quang Dang To (350) 5 mins

4.00pm – 4.15pm Mihaljo Dusanovic and family (250) 15 mins

4.15pm – 4.30pm Geoff Leach (327) 15 mins


Page 15

4.30pm – 4.45pm Timothy Brooks (49) 15 mins

4.45pm – 5.00pm CJ Scott, represented by Charles James Scott (233) 15 mins


Individuals and community



10.15am – 10.20am David Macgowan (218) 5 mins

10.20am – 10.30am Justin Marden (225) 10 mins

10.30am – 10.35am Michael Younes (18) 5 mins

10.35am – 10.45am Tony Smith (73) 10 mins

10.45am – 10.55am Alexander Kahn (105) 10 mins

10.55am – 11.05am Dr Russell Keays (219) 10 mins

11.05am – 11.20am Metropolitan Transport Forum, represented by Cr

Tom Melican (328)

15 mins

11.20am – 11.35am Steven Unthank (329) 15 mins


11.50am – 12.10pm Parkville Association, represented by Helen Weston

(294)

20 mins

12.10pm – 12.40pm The Mac.Robertson Girls High, represented by Dr

Toni Meath (61)

30 mins


2.00pm – 4.30pm Melbourne City Council continued, represented by

Matthew Townsend of Counsel (365), and calling

evidence from:

- Alison Duncan of City of Melbourne in community

services

2.5 hours


Page 16


Vacated day


The Westin



10.15am – 10.25am Mark and Zoe Cassar (142) 10 mins

10.25am – 10.30am Rydges on Swanston, represented by Emma Barnes

(287)

5 mins

10.30am – 12.30pm Newmark Capital Ltd represented by John Cicero,

Best Hooper Solicitors (362)

2 hours


1.30pm – 5.30pm Owners Corporation PS 428405M and the owners of

the Westin residential apartments (The Westin)

represented by John Cicero, Best Hooper (310), with

evidence from:

- Matthew Shields of Acoustic Logic in acoustics and

vibration

- David Doolan of 4D Workshop in building design

and engineering

4 hours


Page 17

Day 29: Monday 3 October 2016

Business



10.15am - 11.15am Tabcorp Holdings Limited, represented by Jane Sharp

of Counsel instructed by Meg Lee of Gadens (368) and


- Simon Duck, General Manager, IT Delivery

Tabcorp Holdings Limited

60 mins


11.30am – 1.00pm George Weston Foods, represented by Chris Schulz of

Allens Solicitors (357), calling evidence from:

- Chris Coath of GTA consultants in traffic

1.5 hours


1.50pm – 2.10pm Nick Theodossi Prestige Cars, represented by Peter

Bazzani and Matthew Liston (84)

20 mins

2.10pm – 2.30pm Irwin Stock Feeds (163) 20 mins

2.30pm – 2.45pm Federation Square (178) 15 mins

2.45pm End of day


Page 18

Day 30: Tuesday 4 October 2016

Businesses



10.15am - 10.45am COMFORTiD.com Pty Ltd, represented by Erwin

Boermans, with Klaas Visser (360)

30 mins

10.45am – 11.05am Ross House Association, represented by Nazzareno

Marchionda (182)

20 mins

11.05am – 11.35am Allard Shelton Pty Ltd, represented by Rob Bradley of

Aitken Partners (186)

30 mins


11.50am - 12.35pm Oscard Pty Ltd represented by Mark Bartley, HWL

Ebsworth (379)

45 mins

12.35pm – 1.05pm McDonald’s Australia Limited and North-West

Investments Pty Ltd, represented by Michelle

Blackburn, Corrs Chambers Westgarth (195)

30 mins


2.00pm – 2.30pm ALE/ALH Group represented by Chris Schulz, Allens

Solicitors (326)

30 mins

2.30pm – 3.00pm Slater and Gordon, represented by Manisha Blencowe

(371)

30 mins

3.00pm – 3.45pm PDG Corporation (272) and Zagame Group (273),

representation tbc

45 mins


4.00pm – 4.20pm ALDI Stores, represented by Ratio Consultants (263) 20 mins

4.20pm – 4.40pm GPT Group, represented by William Kwong (231) 20 mins

4.40pm – 5.00pm Robert Brunner (311) 20 mins


Page 19

Day 31: Wednesday 5 October 2016

Businesses



10.15am – 10.25am Dev Kevat (281) 10 mins

10.25am – 10.30am Lisa Whiffen (270) 5 mins

10.30am – 10.45am Mirko Angele (03) 15 mins


11.00am – 1.00pm Opportunity for Melbourne City Council, Stonnington

City Council and Port Phillip City Council to make

closing comments if required

2 hours


Flinders Lane and Swanston Street landowners

2.00pm – 2.10pm Lai Lee Tan (147) 10 mins

2.10pm – 2.20pm Margaret Bray (235), 10 mins

2.20pm – 2.30pm Simon Pockley (236) 10 mins

2.30pm – 2.50pm Rita Kumar, Dajaanu Pty Ltd T/a City Square Motel

(338)

20 mins


3.05pm – 3.20pm Alexander McDonald (262) 15 mins

3.20pm – 3.50pm Melbourne Health, represented by Sally Campbell

(308)

30 mins

3.50pm – 4.05pm Walter and Eliza Hall Institute of Medical Research,


15 mins

4.05pm – 4.25pm Ramsay Health Care, representation tbc (295) 20 mins


Page 20

Day 32: Thursday 6 October 2016

Education, Businesses



10.15am – 10.25am Melbourne Girls Grammar, represented by Christian

Lawless (358)

10 mins

10.25am – 1.00pm Melbourne Grammar School, represented by Ian Pitt

QC (367) and calling evidence from:

- James Hargreaves of Meinhardt in engineering

- Andrew Mitchell of Cogent Acoustics in acoustics

- Brett Young of Ratio in traffic

1 day


2.00pm – 4.30pm Melbourne Grammar School, continued


4.45pm – 5.45pm HRG Investments Pty Ltd, represented by Ian Pitt QC

(13)

60 mins

Day 33: Friday 7 October 2016

MMRA closing submissions



10.15am – 1.00pm MMRA – closing submissions 1 day


2.00pm – 4.30pm MMRA – closing submissions

4.30pm END OF HEARING

Hearing Timetable Notes:

1. This timetable may be amended without notice.

2. Please arrive at least 15 minutes before your scheduled time of commencement. If you are

unable to be present at your scheduled time, please contact Planning Panels Victoria as soon

as practicable.

3. Where tea breaks are not specified, these will be taken at an appropriate break in

proceedings.

4. Any queries regarding this timetable should be made to Julia Thomson, Senior Project Officer

of Planning Panels Victoria on 8392 6744.

Hearing Timetable: Version 2 (19 August 2016) Melbourne ...- Dean Griggs of City of Melbourne in social and community impacts. - Barry Fox of City of Melbourne in surface water, ground

Documents