Halifax, 31 Oct – 3 Nov 2011ICT Accessibility For All ITS HIS – TIA T. Russell Shields Chair, Ygomi LLC Document No: GSC16-PLEN-81 Source: TIA Contact:

Halifax, 31 Oct – 3 Nov 2011 ICT Accessibility For All

ITS HIS – TIAITS HIS – TIA

T. Russell ShieldsT. Russell Shields

Chair, Ygomi LLCChair, Ygomi LLC

Document No:

GSC16-PLEN-81

Source: TIA

Contact: [email protected]

GSC Session:

PLENARY

Agenda Item:

6.6


GSC16-PLEN-81

2

Highlight of Current Activities (1)Highlight of Current Activities (1)• TIA supports Engineering Committee TR-48, Vehicular

Telematics– www.tiaonline.org/standards/committees/committee.cfm?comm=tr-48

• TR-48 members are interested in ITS – TR-48 used to follow the ITS work through ISO TC204 activities

• Many new TR-48 members are from the cellular industry– One area of interest is to link Commercial Mobile Services

(CMS) and other access, such as BlueTooth, with ITS as auxiliary accesses for non-emergency services

• During the MSTF #2 Meeting in Atlanta in September, TR-48’s chair met Steve Bayless, chair of ITS America– The objective is to start a project on ITS in 2012


GSC16-PLEN-81

3

Highlight of Current Activities (2)Highlight of Current Activities (2)

• ISO TC 204 WG16– There are currently 23 published standards

and 2 published technical reports– There are 23 active work items– WG 16 does not have the pool of experts to

do its work items properly– The U.S. is in the process of selecting a new

convenor for WG 16


GSC16-PLEN-81

4


• IEEE 1609 DSRC WG*– P1609.0: Approval planned end of 2012– P1609.1: Approval planned September 2012– P1609.2: Approval planned March 2012– 1609.3-2010: Approved and published

• P1609.3 Cor1: Approval planned March 2012

– 1609.4-2010, Approved and published– P1609.5: Project extended until December 2013– 1609.11-2010: Approved and published– P1609.12: In draft development

* Sponsor: IEEE Vehicular Technology Society


GSC16-PLEN-81

5

Highlight of Current Activities (4)Highlight of Current Activities (4)• IEEE 802.11p-2010, WAVE*

– 802.11s amendment for Mesh Networks approved• To be included in the 802.11mb roll-up

– 802.11mb publication scheduled for March 2012• Mainly due to the decision to include 802.11s amendment

– ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC6 negotiating to resolve issues surrounding WAPI NWI

• Final CRM on November 21• Next meeting scheduled for February 2012 in Guangzhou

– Smart Grid SC made progress• Goals incl. NIST recognition of IEEE 802 wireless stds.• Tutorial session proposed for November 2011

* Sponsor: IEEE LANMAN Standards Committee


GSC16-PLEN-81


• U.S. DOT Connected Vehicle Research Program (Formerly IntelliDrive SM*)http://www.its.dot.gov/connected_vehicle/connected_vehicle_research.htm

– Connected Vehicle Safety Pilot Progress• Six Safety Pilot Driver Clinics will run from August 2011 to

spring 2012: 100 drivers/clinic, evaluated by researchers• Safety Pilot Model Deployment: 3,000 vehicles, mix of

embedded and aftermarket devices using 5.9 GHz DSRC• Passenger and commercial vehicles included

6

Brooklyn, MIMinneapolis, MNOrlando, FL

Blacksburg, VADallas, TXSan Francisco, CA


GSC16-PLEN-81

Highlight of Current Activities (6)Highlight of Current Activities (6)• U.S. DOT Connected Vehicle Research

Program (Formerly IntelliDrive SM*)http://www.its.dot.gov/connected_vehicle/connected_vehicle_research.htm

– Other Initiatives• AERIS: data collection for eco-driving

• Dynamic mobility applications

• Core systems concept of operations meetings

• Harmonization of international standards and selected applications: Joint Declaration of Intent on Research Cooperation in Cooperative Systems with EC, joint action plan with EC DG INFSO

• Research program to develop human factors guidelines that help prevent distracted driving

7


GSC16-PLEN-81

8

Highlight of Current Activities (7)Highlight of Current Activities (7)• U.S. NHTSA V2V Roadmap Status

– Rulemaking and Research Priority Plan issued March 2011(http://www.nhtsa.gov/staticfiles/rulemaking/pdf/2011-2013_Vehicle_Safety-Fuel_Economy_Rulemaking-Research_Priority_Plan.pdf)

– NHTSA has included FCW and lane departure warning in NCAP data for model year 2011 vehicles

– Agency decisions planned for 2013 on issues including vehicle communication, blind spot detection, pedestrian detection, AACN

• NHTSA is developing a strategic motor vehicle safety plan for 2014-2020

• Voluntary guidelines on visual manual distraction planned to be published in 2011

– Not released as of October 26, 2011


GSC16-PLEN-81

9

Highlight of Current Activities (8)Highlight of Current Activities (8)• ITU-T has established a task force on driver

distraction– This is a major concern in the U.S.

• ITU has proposed a Collaboration on ITS Communications

• All GSC PSOs are invited to become members of the management committee


GSC16-PLEN-81

10

Strategic Direction (1)Strategic Direction (1)

• TR-48 will start a project on ITS• TC204 WG16 will continue to work on its open work

items• IEEE 1609 WG will continue expert-level liaison with ISO

TC204, ISO TC204 WG1, and WG16; ETSI TC-ITS, WGs 1-5; and SAE J2735

• IEEE 802.11p-2010 to be included in P802.11mb roll-up• IEEE 802 working toward agreement on LANMAN

security and other issues, sending 802 drafts to ISO/IEC JTC 1 SC6 for “coordination,” and pursue recognition of IEEE 802 wireless standards as viable in smart grids


GSC16-PLEN-81

11

Strategic Direction (2)Strategic Direction (2)

• U.S. DOT will continue research on V2V and V2I safety communication systems, as well as AERIS, dynamic mobility applications, and the core system concept– Continuing work with Crash Avoidance Metrics Partnership

(CAMP)– Safety Pilot Driver Clinics– Safety Pilot Model Deployment

• NHTSA continues to work toward a 2013 regulatory decision. Possible outcomes include– Future regulatory action– Inclusion in the New Car Assessment Program (NCAP)– Further research and development


GSC16-PLEN-81

12

Challenges (1)Challenges (1)

• Resolution of issues in ISO/IEC JTC 1 SC6 over security requirements and withdrawal of obsolescent 8802 standards– 802.11 Ad Hoc for JTC 1 topics now an 802

SC

• LTE will continue to require work for ITS– The proximity work in 3GPP is relevant


GSC16-PLEN-81

13

Next Steps / Actions (1)Next Steps / Actions (1)• IEEE Standard 802.11p-2010. Continue to

monitor the roll-up of all of the amendments approved since IEEE Standard 802.11-2007 was published

• IEEE P1609.2, .3 Cor1. Guide through balloting steps

• IEEE P1609.0, .1, .12. Work on documents for balloting in 2012

• IEEE P1609.5. Refine proposals and identify content.


GSC16-PLEN-81

14

Supplementary SlidesSupplementary Slides


GSC16-PLEN-81

15

IEEE P1609 (1)IEEE P1609 (1)• IEEE P1609.0™, Guide for Wireless Access in Vehicular Environments (WAVE) – Architecture

– Draft development in progress, use case contributions completed and pending and including relationship to the ITS Core Systems Architecture and the “Here-I-Am” device used in the Safety Net Pilot project. Plan sponsor ballot in mid-2012, approval end of 2012

• IEEE P1609.1, Standard for Wireless Access in Vehicular Environments (WAVE) - Resource Manager

– Draft rewrite will baseline remote management around use of SNMP via IP based on results of analysis of IP/SNMP survey responses from microprocessor manufacturers, planned for sponsor ballot in 2012, planned approval September 2012

• IEEE P1609.2, Standard for Wireless Access in Vehicular Environments - Security Services for Applications and Management Messages

– Completed first round of IEEE VTS/ITS sponsor ballot with 75% plus approval, with 322 comments, comment resolution and rewrite in progress, plan recirculation following comment resolution, plan for approval in March 2012

• IEEE 1609.3-2010, Standard for Wireless Access in Vehicular Environments (WAVE)—Networking Services

– Approved and published

• IEEE P1609.3 Cor1, Standard for Wireless Access in Vehicular Environments (WAVE) - Networking Services - Corrigendum 1: Corrections to Annex G Packet format examples

– Approved project to make changes to published standard, pending outcome of mandatory editorial review before initiating sponsor ballot. Planned approval in March 2012

• IEEE P1609.5, Standard for Wireless Access in Vehicular Environments (WAVE) - Communication Manager

– Approved project, no definitive content identified, proposals discussed during September 2011 meeting, plan to request extension of PAR for a two year period until December 2013


GSC16-PLEN-81

16

IEEE P1609 (2)IEEE P1609 (2)• IEEE 1609.11-2010, IEEE Standard for Wireless Access in Vehicular Environments (WAVE)—

Over-the-Air Electronic Payment Data Exchange Protocol for Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS)

– Approved and published

• IEEE P1609.12, Standard for Wireless Access in Vehicular Environment (WAVE) - Identifier Allocations

– In draft development that includes agreement through expert coordination with ISO TC204 WG16 and ETSI TC/ITS WG2 on ITS identifiers, initiated IEEE VTS/ITS sponsor ballot in October 2011, approval and publication June 2012. Expectation is that a similar document will be developed in ISO TC204 WG16 and ETSI TC-ITS WG2 needed for global coordination and harmonization of identifiers

– Continued expert level liaison with ISO TC204, ISO TC204 WG1, Architecture and Data Dictionaries, and WG16, Communications Access for Land Mobiles (CALM); ETSI TC-ITS, WGs 1-5, and SAE J2735, DSRC Message Sets and Data Dictionary

– International expert participants are from six different countries

• IEEE P1609.2 Project Editor is participating in security-related activities for 5.9GHz security requirements in ISO TC204 WG16.7 and ETSI TC-ITS WG5. ETSI TC-ITS WG5 has developed a security profile for 5.9GHz band for safety message sets based on a draft of IEEE P1609.2

– ETSI TC-ITS had developed a 5.9GHz WAVE profile based on IEEE 1609.11p amendment, applicable to the EU.


GSC16-PLEN-81

Most current doc shaded

green

TG Published or Draft Baseline DocumentsSource MEC

Style Guide Editor

Snapshot Date

Published

s mb ae aa ad af ac ah ai

s Y Frame 8.0 Yes 2009 Kazuyuki Sakoda 19-Jul

mb Y 10.1 Frame 9.0 Yes 2009 Adrian Stephens 21-Sep

ae Y 12.0 9.0 5.0 OpenOffice 3.2

Yes 2009 Henry Ptasinski 19-Jul

aa Y 11.0 9.0 3.0 6.0 Word Yes 2009 Alex Ashley 19-Jul

ad Y 10.0 5.0 6.0 5.0 Word Yes 2009 Carlos Cordero 21-Sep

af Y 10.0 5.0 6.0 4.0 1.03 Frame 9.0 No 2009 Peter Ecclesine 22-Sep

ac Y 12.0 9.0 4.0 5.0 3.0 1.0 1.0 Frame 9.0 No 2009 Robert Stacey 19-Jul

ah No 2009 Minyoung Park 19-Jul

ai Frame 10.0

No 2009 Tom Siep 22-Sep

IEEE 802.11 Draft Development Snapshot*IEEE 802.11 Draft Development Snapshot*

17

* As of September 2011


GSC16-PLEN-81

18

IEEE 802.11 (2)IEEE 802.11 (2)

• 802.11ai™, Amendment- Fast Initial Link Setup

• 802.11ai is related to the 802.11p, WAVE, in that the specification for fast initial link setup is in the context of a base service set (BSS) where a set of stations (STAs) that have successfully synchronized using the JOIN service primitives and one STA that has used the START primitive; whereas in the 802.11p, it is outside the context of a BSS. 802.11p Task Group Chair is a member of Task Group 802.11ai is a member of this task group.

• 802.11mb™, Standard for Information Technology—Telecommunications and information exchange between systems—Local and Metropolitan Area networks—Specific requirements—Part 11: Wireless LAN Medium Access Control (MAC) and Physical Layer (PHY) specifications—Amendment: Accumulated maintenance changes

• Draft 9.1 includes amendments:– Revision of IEEE Std 802.11™-2007, as amended by:– IEEE Std 802.11k™-2008, Radio Resource Measurement of Wireless LANs– IEEE Std 802.11r™-2008, Fast Basic Service Set (BSS) Transition– IEEE Std 802.11y™-2008, 3650–3700 MHz Operation in USA– IEEE Std 802.11w™-2009, Protected Management Frames– IEEE Std 802.11n™-2009, Enhancements for Higher Throughput– IEEE Std 802.11p™-2010, Wireless Access in Vehicular Environments– IEEE Std 802.11z™-2010, Extensions to Direct-Link Setup (DLS)– IEEE Std 802.11v™-2011, IEEE 802.11 Wireless Network Management– IEEE Std 802.11u™-2011, Interworking with External Networks– IEEE Std 802.11s™-2011, Mesh Networking


GSC16-PLEN-81

IEEE 802.11 Regulatory Summary – IEEE 802.11 Regulatory Summary – North AmericaNorth America

• US– FCC 5 GHz rules changes update – industry input for NPRM– OMB approved spending for Part 15 Subpart H

• Establishment of database(s) only remaining hurdle

– Forty-five-day geo-location database trial begun September 19– US House of Representatives looking to auction ALL spectrum

• Canada– TVWS Consultation: 802.18 prepared a response (18-11/75r3)

• SMSE-012-11 Consultation on a Policy and Technical Framework for the Use of Non-Broadcasting Applications in the Television Broadcasting Bands Below 698 MHz

– Radio Advisory Board of Canada (RABC) meetings to discuss TVWS

19


GSC16-PLEN-81

IEEE 802.11 Regulatory IEEE 802.11 Regulatory Summary – EUSummary – EU

• Ofcom – Geo-location database planning– Results of consultation on “Implementing Geolocation”– Next steps

• Consult on and publish Statutory Instrument (SI) to license-exempt TVBDs

• Cooperate with industry partners to enable information on licensed services

• Continue engagement with industry and EU regulatory and standards groups to developed harmonized approach

– Trials running in three locations in the UK

20


GSC16-PLEN-81

IEEE 802.11 Regulatory IEEE 802.11 Regulatory Summary – AsiaSummary – Asia

• UHT/EUHT Standards in China– UHT = Ultra-High Throughput (802.11n equivalent)– EUHT = Enhanced Ultra-High Throughput (802.11ac

equivalent)– CCSA approval then application for ISO recognition– Claim to coexist with Wi-Fi– EUHT is LTE-like (TDD)

21


GSC16-PLEN-81ISO TC 204 WG16 Current Work ProgramISO TC 204 WG16 Current Work Program (1)(1)ISO Work

ItemTitle Current

StageTarget Dates Started

Current Stage

Project Leader Project Control

TR 11766 Lawful Interception in ITS and CALM

60.60 2010-03-29 S Cadzow [email protected]

Published standard

TR 11769 Data retention for law enforcement in ITS and CALM

60.60 2010-09-21 S Cadzow [email protected]

Published standard

PWI 13181-1 CALM Security Part 1: Framework

00.00 No target dates yet

2008-11-14 S Cadzow [email protected]

Item registered by ISO CS 11 December 2008. Form4 should be retransmitted to ISO CS

PWI 13181-2 CALM Security Part 2: Threat Vulnerability and Risk Analysis




PWI 13181-3 CALM Security Part 3: Objectives and Requirements




PWI 13181-4 CALM Security Part 4: Countermeasures




DIS 13183 CALM receiving public broadcast communications

40.99 FDIS: 2012-10-06IS: 2013-04-06

2011-08-23 R [email protected]

Publication bundle submitted to ISO CS on 22 August 2011. ISO CS requests modifications.

IS 15628 DSRC Application Layer

90.93 2010-07-15 S [email protected]

SR ballot ended on 15 June 2010. CR meeting in Jeju

NP 15628 DSRC Application Layer Rev. 1

10.99 CD: 2012-02-03DIS: 2012-08-03FDIS: 2013-08-03IS: 2014-02-03

2011-02-03 S [email protected]

New project approved on 3 February 2011



ItemTitle Current


Current Stage


IS 15662 TICS Wide Area Communication Message Management Information

90.93 2009-05-15 H Wakayama [email protected]

ISO CS extended the life time of the standard

PWI 16444 CALM Geo-routing 00.20 2010-05-27 HJ [email protected]

ISO CS registered the WI as PWI on 19 July 2010

PWI 16445 CALM Handover mechanisms

00.20 2010-05-27 HJ [email protected]


PWI 16460 CALM WAVE 00.20 2010-05-27 HJ [email protected]


PWI 16461 Criteria for Privacy and Integrity protection in Probe Vehicle Information System

00.20 2010-05-27 M [email protected]


PWI 16788 IPv6 Networking Security

00.00 2010-11-17 T Ernst [email protected]

ISO CS registered the WI as PWI on 17 November 2010

PWI 16789 IPv6 Networking Optimisation

00.00 2010-11-17 T Ernst [email protected]

ISO CS registered the WI as PWI on 17 November 2010

PWI 17515 LTE cellular system

00.00 2011-06-14 H Cho ISO CS registered the WI as PWI on 14 June 2011

23



ItemTitle Current


Current Stage


PRF 21210 CALM IPv6 Networking

50.00 IS: 2011-06-27 2011-09-07 H Wakayama [email protected]

TC204 has sent the publication bundle to ISO CS on 9 March 2011. ISO CS requested modification. The modified document was submitted to ISO CS on 22 August 2011. The expected date of proof is 26 November.

IS 21212 CALM using 2G Cellular Systems

60.60 2008-10-22 R [email protected]

Published standard

IS 21213 CALM using 3G Cellular Systems


Published standard

IS 21214 CALM IR 90.92 2008-04-11 R [email protected]

Standard is under revision

DIS 21214 CALM IR Rev.1 40.99 FDIS: 2013-01-13IS: 2013-07-13

2011-08-30 R [email protected]

DIS ballot ended on 23 August 2011. Results: Yes 17, yes with comments 2, no 0, abstention 7

IS 21215 CALM M5 60.60 2010-11-05 K Evensen [email protected]

Published standard

IS 21216 CALM Millimetre, Air interface


Standard is under minor revision

DIS 21216 CALM Millimetre, Air interface

40.99 FDIS: 2013-10-26 IS: 2014-04-26

2011-04-26 M [email protected]

Draft was submitted to TC204 on 22 August 2011

IS 21217 CALM Architecture 60.60 2010-04-01 K [email protected]

Published standard



ItemTitle Current


Current Stage


IS 21218 CALM Networking - Lower Layer SAPs

90.20 2011-07-15 HJ [email protected]

Standard is under periodic review

IS 22837 Vehicle Probe Data for Wide Area Communication


Standard is under revision

NP 22837 Vehicle Probe Data for Wide Area Communication Rev. 1


ISO CS registered the WI as NP on 26 April 2011

IS 24100 Basic Principles for personal data protection in probe vehicle information systems


Standard under revision

NP 24100 Basic Principles for personal data protection in probe vehicle information systems Rev. 1



IS 24101-1 CALM Application Management


Standard’s periodical review closed, results: confirmed 14, no vote 0 and abstained 9 members.

IS 24101-2 CALM Application Management – Conformance Test


Published standard

25



ItemTitle Current


Current Stage


IS 24102 CALM ITS Station Management

60.60 2010-11-13 K [email protected]

Published standard

IS 24103 CALM MAIL 60.60 2009-05-26 K [email protected]

Published standard

IS 24978 ITS Safety and Emergency Notifications using any Available Wireless Media - Data Registry


Published standard

IS 25111 CALM ITS using Public Wireless Networks - General requirement

60.60 2009-10-30 H [email protected]

Published standard

IS 25112 CALM MWB using IEEE 802.16

60.60 2009-11-10 H [email protected]

Published standard

IS 25113 CALM MWB using HC-SDMA

60.60 2009-11-10 K [email protected]

Published standard

TS 25114 Probe Data Reporting Management


Standard under revision

NP TS 25114 Probe Data Reporting Management Rev. 1





ItemTitle Current


Current Stage


IS 29281 CALM non-IP Networking

60.60 2011-04-24 T [email protected]

Published standard

IS 29282 CALM Applications using Satellite


Published standard

IS 29283 CALM Applications using 802.20

60.60 FDIS: 2011-03-02IS: 2011-09-02

2011-01-26 K [email protected]

Published standard

DTS 29284 Event based Probe Vehicle Data

30.99 FDIS: 2012-03-12IS: 2012-09-12

2010-07-19 M [email protected]

Typo check done, proposed modifications are being implemented.

27

Halifax, 31 Oct – 3 Nov 2011ICT Accessibility For All ITS HIS – TIA T. Russell Shields Chair, Ygomi LLC Document No: GSC16-PLEN-81 Source: TIA Contact:

Documents

ict accessibility

published p1609

ca slide

new tr

published standards

iso tc204 activities

engineering committee

dsrc wg