Top Banner
Half-baked Methane Higher Value and Lower Emissions through Pyrolysis Marc von Keitz, Ph.D. Program Director February 28, 2017
17

Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

Jul 30, 2018

Download

Documents

duonglien
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

Half-baked MethaneHigher Value and Lower Emissions through Pyrolysis

Marc von Keitz, Ph.D.Program Director

February 28, 2017

Page 2: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

How can we maximize the benefits from U.S. gas wealth?

February 28, 2017 Half-baked Methane, MvK 1

Page 3: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

Existing ARPA-E Nat Gas programs

‣New Idea: GTGAS (Gas-to-Gas-and-Solid)

2Half-baked Methane, MvKFebruary 28, 2017

MOVE

Natural gas fueled residential Combined Heat & Power – CHP

Gas storage tanks and at-home refueling stationsfor passenger cars

biological Gas-to-Liquid –bioGTL

REMOTE

GENSETS

Page 4: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

Methane as a hydrogen repository

CH4

Hydrogen represents

¼ of the weight, but

½ of the energy

Half-baked Methane, MvK 3February 28, 2017

Page 5: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

Hydrogen in fuel cells provides very efficient electricity…

4Half-baked Methane, MvKFebruary 28, 2017

…for mobile…

… and stationary applications

Page 6: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

We already make Hydrogen from methane at large scale for…

5Half-baked Methane, MvKFebruary 28, 2017

Steam Methane Reforming (SMR) Ammonia Production (Haber-Bosch)

Petroleum Refining

GTL

Challenges: economical only at large scale & CO2 emissions

Page 7: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

Alternative Approach: Thermal Cracking of Methane

2 H2 C (s)CH4

Gaseous hydrogen Solid carbon

+

+

1200 -1400°C

Half-baked Methane, MvKFebruary 28, 2017 6

Page 8: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

CO2 vs Solid Carbon from 1 Quad of Hydrogen

SMR – CO2

7Half-baked Methane, MvKFebruary 28, 2017

Methane Cracking – Solid Carbon

22.3 million MT~ 45 million m3

Image: dpa

70 million MT @1,200 psi117 million m3

Image: pbs

Page 9: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

What’s the better value proposition: CO2 or solid Carbon?

8Half-baked Methane, MvKFebruary 28, 2017

Solid Carbon

Metallurgical coal: $100/MT

Carbon black: $500-$2,500/MT

Carbon nanotubes: $1,000,000/MT

CO2

Baseline: $0 per ton

Enhanced Oil Recovery: ~ $40/ton

Carbon Capture & Storage: negative $

Page 10: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

What’s the better value proposition: CO2 or solid Carbon?

9Half-baked Methane, MvKFebruary 28, 2017

Solid Carbon

Metallurgical coal: $100/MT

Carbon black: $500-$2,500/MT

Carbon nanotubes: $1,000,000/MT

>$2,000 per karat (>$10,000,000/MT)

CO2

Baseline: $0 per ton

Enhanced Oil Recovery: ~ $40/ton

Carbon Capture & Storage: negative $

Page 11: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

Not just $$$, but also market size

Total world market:‣ Carbon Black: 12 million MT/yr‣ Copper: 19 million MT/yr‣ Cotton: 24 million MT/yr‣ Aluminum: 49 million MT/yr‣ Polyolefins: 120 million MT/yr‣ Steel: 1,600 million MT/yr‣ Concrete: ~20,000 million MT/yr

Remember:1 Quad H2 ~ 22.3 million MT C

…but, it’s hard to compete with dirt.

Half-baked Methane, MvKFebruary 28, 2017 10

Page 12: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

Carbon materials could enable low-cost composite buildings

11Half-baked Methane, MvKFebruary 28, 2017

Wing House, Asymptote Architecture

Carbon to building products can be alternative to CO2 sequestration

Page 13: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

One possible path: Methane to CNTs to Carbon Fiber

12Half-baked Methane, MvKFebruary 28, 2017

FibersCNT Fiber spinningCNT Solution

Page 14: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

No matter what exact product, the process needs to …

13Half-baked Methane, MvKFebruary 28, 2017

…deliver required product performance targets,…

…provide sufficient yield, and…

…be scalable.

Page 15: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

Enabling Technology Developments

14Half-baked Methane, MvKFebruary 28, 2017

Molten Metal Reactor

Plasma Arc Reactor

Computational Fluid Dynamics

Photo: Georgia Tech

Photo:Pyrogenesis

Molecular ModelingImage:PRETechnologies

Page 16: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

Workshop intended for early Summer ’17…

‣ …will bringing together experts in:– catalysis– process engineering– material science, and – product/application development

‣ …to better define the most promising research and development opportunities to advance methane cracking towards a commercially relevant technology.

‣ If you are interested, in this topic area, please see me here at the summit orsend me an email: [email protected]

Half-baked Methane, MvKFebruary 28, 2017 15

Page 17: Half-baked Methane - ARPA-E · Half-baked Methane Higher Value and ... at-home refueling stations. for passenger cars ... Plasma Arc Reactor Computational Fluid Dynamics. Photo: Georgia

Thank you!

February 28, 2017 Half-baked Methane, MvK 16