Group 5 Report-Appeals

8/18/2019 Group 5 Report-Appeals

1/46

APPEALSFOR CIVIL AND CRIMINAL CASES

Group 5


2/46

WHY SHOULD YOU LEARN APPEALS?

First

You won’t awa!" w#n

Second

Y ou $a! w#n% &ut t'( )u*+$(nt #"n’t a" ,a-ora&( a" !ou want #t to

&(


3/46

WHA. ARE .HE MODES OF APPEAL?

Ru( /0% S(1t#on 23 Modes of appeal

Ordinary appeal

Petition for review

Appeal by certiorari


4/46

WHA. FORMS WILL WE DISCUSS?

Not#1( o, App(a

App(a M($oran*u$

App(ant’" 4r#(,

App(((’" 4r#(,

R(p! 4r#(,

P(t#t#on ,or R(-#(w on C(rt#orar# Ru( /56


5/46

WHA. DO YOU APPEAL?

Cr#$#na

Ru( 022 S(1t#on 03 Who may appeal3

An! part! $a! app(a

Fro$ a )u*+$(nt or 7na or*(r

Un("" t'( a11u"(* w# &( pa1(* #n *ou&( )(opar*!3

C#-#

Ru( /8 Fro$ M.C6% Ru( /0 9 /2 Fro$ R.C6% Ru( /5 to SC6

.'( "u&)(1t o, app(a #" a )u*+$(nt or 7na or*(r o, t'( Court a quo

Rule of Thumb: Rule 41, Section 1. Subject of appeal3 : An app(a$a! &( ta;(n from a judgment or nal order that completelydisposes of the case, or of a particular matter therein w'(n*(1ar(* &! t'("( Ru(" to &( app(aa&(3


6/46

No app(a $a! &( ta;(n ,ro$< a6 An or*(r *(n!#n+ a $ot#on ,or n(w tr#a or r(1on"#*(rat#on=

&6 An or*(r *(n!#n+ a p(t#t#on ,or r(#(, or an! "#$#ar $ot#on"((;#n+ r(#(, ,ro$ )u*+$(nt=

16 An #nt(ro1utor! or*(r= *6 An or*(r *#"aow#n+ or *#"$#""#n+ an app(a=

(6 An or*(r *(n!#n+ a $ot#on to "(t a"#*( a )u*+$(nt &! 1on"(nt%1on,(""#on or 1o$pro$#"( on t'( +roun* o, ,rau*% $#"ta;( or *ur(""%or an! ot'(r +roun* -#t#at#n+ 1on"(nt=

,6 An or*(r o, (>(1ut#on=

+6 A )u*+$(nt or 7na or*(r ,or or a+a#n"t on( or $or( o, "(-(rapart#(" or #n "(parat( 1a#$"% 1ount(r1a#$"% 1ro""1a#$" an* t'#r*part! 1o$pa#nt"% w'#( t'( $a#n 1a"( #" p(n*#n+% un("" t'( 1ourtaow" an app(a t'(r(,ro$= an*

'6 An or*(r *#"$#""#n+ an a1t#on w#t'out pr()u*#1(3

PROHI4I.ED APPEALS


7/46

In a t'( a&o-( #n"tan1(" w'(r( t'( )u*+$(nt or 7naor*(r #" not app(aa&(% t'( a++r#(-(* part! $a! 7( anappropr#at( "p(1#a 1#-# a1t#on un*(r Ru( @53

PROHI4I.ED APPEALS


8/46

HOW APPEAL .AEN? CRIMINAL

Ru( 022 S(13 B ow appeal ta!en

M.C R.C

Not#1( o, app(a 7(* #n t'( M.C

R.C CA

R.C #n t'( (>(r1#"( o, #t" or#+#na )ur#"*#1t#on

Not#1( o, app(a 7(* #n t'( R.C

R.C CA

R.C #n t'( (>(r1#"( o, #t" app(at( )ur#"*#1t#on "tart(* ,ro$ M.C6

P(t#t#on ,or r(-#(w un*(r Ru( /2 7(* #n t'( CA

R.C SC

W'(r( t'( p(nat! #$po"(* #" 06 *(at' 26 reclusion perpetua B6 #,(#$pr#"on$(nt

Not#1( o, app(a 7(* #n t'( R.C


9/46

HOW APPEAL .AEN? CRIMINAL

CA SC

P(t#t#on ,or R(-#(w on C(rt#orar# un*(r Ru( /5

Sp(1#a ru("

I, t'( R.C #$po"(" t'( *(at' p(nat!% no not#1( o, app(a #"n(1(""ar! an* t'( "a$( #" auto$at#1a! r(-#(w(* &! t'( Supr($(

Court


10/46

HOW APPEAL .AEN? CIVIL

M.C R.C

Ru( /8 S(13 B Not#1( o, app(a 7(* #n t'( M.C

R.C CA

R.C #n t'( (>(r1#"( o, #t" or#+#na )ur#"*#1t#on

Ru( /0 S(13 2 Not#1( o, app(a 7(* #n t'( R.C R.C CA

R.C #n t'( (>(r1#"( o, #t" app(at( )ur#"*#1t#on "tart(* ,ro$ M.C6

Ru( /2 S(130 P(t#t#on ,or r(-#(w un*(r Ru( /2 7(* #n t'( CA

R.C SC

W'(r( on! u("t#on" o, aw ar( ra#"(* or #n-o-(* Ru( /5 S(13 0 P(t#t#on(r ,or R(-#(w on C(rt#orar# 7(* #n t'( SC


11/46

HOW APPEAL .AEN? CIVIL

CA SC

Ru( /5 S(13 0 P(t#t#on ,or R(-#(w on C(rt#orar# 7(* #n t'( SC


12/46

WHEN .O APPEAL? CRIMINAL

For a Court"

Ru( 022 S(13 @3 When appeal to be ta!en3

F#,t((n 056 *a!"

Fro$ pro$u+at#on o, t'( )u*+$(nt or ,ro$ not#1( o, t'( 7na or*(rapp(a(* ,ro$3


13/46

WHEN .O APPEAL? CIVIL

Fro$ M.C to R.C

Ru( /8 S(13 2

05 *a!" a,t(r not#1( to t'( app(ant o, t'( )u*+$(nt or 7na app(a(* ,ro$3

B8 *a!" #n 1a"( a r(1or* o, app(a #" r(u#r(*3

Fro$ R.C to CA

Ru( /0 S(13 B R.C 'a" or#+#na )ur#"*#1t#on6

05 *a!" ,ro$ not#1( o, t'( )u*+$(nt or 7na or*(r app(a(* ,ro$

B8 *a!" #n 1a"( a r(1or* o, app(a #" r(u#r(*

Ru( /2 S(13 0 R.C 'a" app(at( )ur#"*#1t#on6

05 *a!" ,ro$ not#1( o, t'( *(1#"#on "ou+'t to &( r(-#(w(* or o, t'( *(n#a o,

p(t#t#on(r’" $ot#on ,or n(w tr#a or r(1on"#*(rat#on 7(* #n *u( t#$( a,t(r )u*+$(nt3


14/46

WHEN .O APPEAL? CIVIL

Fro$ R.C or CA to SC

Ru( /5 S(13 2

05 *a!" ,ro$ not#1( o, t'( )u*+$(nt or 7na or*(r or r("out#on app(a(*,ro$% or o, t'( *(n#a o, t'( p(t#t#on(r’" $ot#on ,or n(w tr#a orr(1on"#*(rat#on 7(* #n *u( t#$( a,t(r not#1( o, t'( )u*+$(nt3

Not(< t'( 7,t((n 056 *a! p(r#o* #" "u"p(n*(* Fro$ t'( t#$( a $ot#on ,or n(w tr#a or r(1on"#*(rat#on #" 7(* unt# not#1(

o, t'( or*(r o-(rru#n+ t'( $ot#on "'a 'a-( &((n "(r-(* upon t'(a11u"(* or '#" 1oun"( at w'#1' t#$( t'( &aan1( o, t'( p(r#o* &(+#n" torun3

Not(< a11or*#n+ to t'( "eypes ru#n+% t'( ,r("' p(r#o* ru(

app#(" to &ot' 1r#$#na an* 1#-# 1a"(" w'(n MR an* MN. ar(7(*3


15/46

APPEAL .O R.C


16/46

APPEAL .O R.C< NO.ICE OF APPEAL

Ru( /8 S(13 B

.'( not#1( o, app(a "'a #n*#1at(<

.'( part#(" to t'( app(a%

.'( )u*+$(nt or 7na or*(r or part t'(r(o, app(a(* ,ro$% an* "tat(

.'( $at(r#a *at(" "'ow#n+ t'( t#$(#n("" o, t'( app(a3

A**#t#on r(u#r($(nt un*(r Ru( /0 S(13 5

Sp(1#,! t'( 1ourt to w'#1' t'( app(a #" &(#n+ ta;(n


17/46

APPEAL .O R.C< NO.ICE OF APPEAL

W'at ar( t'( t'r(( #$portant t'#n+" t'at n((* to &("tat(* #n t'( not#1( o, app(a?

.'at t'( not#1( 'a" &((n 7(* w#t'#n t'( r(+($(ntar! p(r#o*

.'at t'( ,((" 'a-( &((n pa#*% an* t'at t'( r(1(#pt t'(r(o, #"atta1'(* to t'( not#1(

.'at t'( )u*+$(nt app(a(* ,ro$ #" (#t'(r 1ontrar! to aw or to t'(,a1t" o, t'( 1a"( Purpo"( o, t'( app(a6


18/46

DOCE. FEES

Ru( /0 S(13 / W#t'#n t'( p(r#o* ,or ta;#n+ an app(a% t'(appellant shall pay to the clerk of the court hich renderedthe judgment or nal order appealed from, the full amountof the appellate court docket and other laful fees. Proo, o,pa!$(nt o, "a#* ,((" "'a &( tran"$#tt(* to t'( app(at( 1ourtto+(t'(r w#t' t'( or#+#na r(1or* or t'( r(1or* on app(a3

.'( pa!$(nt o, t'( *o1;(t ,(( w#t'#n t'( p(r#o* #" $an*ator! top(r,(1t t'( app(a3 W#t'out pa!$(nt% t'( app(at( 1ourt wou*n’t&( a&( to a1t on t'( "u&)(1t $att(r o, t'( a1t#on an* t'( *(1#"#on&(1o$(" 7na an* (>(1utor!3 t'#" #" &(1au"( t'( app(at( 1ourt

*o(" not a1u#r( )ur#"*#1t#on o-(r t'( app(a3 :Enr#u( -3Enr#u(% G3R3 No3 0BB8B


19/46

DU.IES OF .HE CLER OF COUR.

Ru( /8% S(1t#on @

W#t'#n 7,t((n 056 *a!" ,ro$ t'( p(r,(1t#on o, t'( app(a% t'( 1(r;o, 1ourt o, t'( ow(r 1ourt "'a tran"$#t t'( or#+#na r(1or* or t'(r(1or* on app(a% to+(t'(r w#t' t'( tran"1r#pt" an* (>'#t"% w'#1''( "'a 1(rt#,! a" 1o$p(t(% to t'( prop(r R(+#ona .r#a Court3

A 1op! o, '#" (tt(r o, tran"$#tta o, t'( r(1or*" to t'( app(at(1ourt "'a &( ,urn#"'(* t'( part#("3

Ru( /8% S(1t#on

Upon r(1(#pt o, t'( 1o$p(t( r(1or* or t'( r(1or* on app(a% t'(1(r; o, 1ourt o, t'( R.C "'a not#,! t'( part#(" o, "u1' ,a1t3


20/46

APPEAL .O R.C< CRIMINAL

Ru( 022 S(13 3 Appeal to the #e$ional %rial &ourts3

W#t'#n 7,t((n 056 *a!"

Fro$ r(1(#pt o, not#1( t'at R.C 'a" 1o$p(t( r(1or*" o, t'( 1a"(%tran"1r#pt"% an* (>'#t"

.'( part#(" $a! "u&$#t memoranda or briefs% or $a! &( r(u#r(*&! t'( R(+#ona .r#a Court to *o "o3


21/46

APPEAL .O R.C< CIVIL

Ru( /8 S(13

W#t'#n 05 *a!" ,ro$ "u1' not#1( &! t'( C(r; o, Court o, t'( R.C

It "'a &( t'( *ut! o, t'( app(ant to "u&$#t a $($oran*u$ w'#1' "'a

&r#(J! *#"1u"" t'( (rror" #$put(* to t'( ow(r 1ourt% a 1op! o, w'#1'"'a &( ,urn#"'(* &! '#$ to t'( a*-(r"( part!

W#t'#n 05 *a!" ,ro$ r(1(#pt o, t'( app(ant’" $($oran*u$ .'( app((( $a! 7( '#" $($oran*u$3

!ailure of the appellant to le a memorandum shall be a groundfor dismissal of the appeal


22/46

APPEAL .O CA


23/46

APPELLAN.’S 4RIEF< CRIMINAL

Ru( 02/ S(1 B3 When brief for appellant to be 'led3

W#t'#n t'#rt! B86 *a!"

Fro$ r(1(#pt &! t'( app(ant or '#" 1oun"( o, t'( not#1( ,ro$ t'(1(r; o, 1ourt o, t'( Court o, App(a" t'at t'( (-#*(n1(% ora an**o1u$(ntar!% #" ar(a*! atta1'(* to t'( r(1or*%

.'( app(ant "'a 7( "(-(n 6 1op#(" o, '#" &r#(, w#t' t'( 1(r; o,1ourt

W'#1' "'a &( a11o$pan#(* &! proo, o, "(r-#1( o, two 26 1op#("t'(r(o, upon t'( app(((3


24/46

WHA. HAPPENS IF YOU FAIL .O FILE ANAPPELLAN.’S 4RIEF IN CRIMINAL CASES?

Ru( 02/ S(13 K3 (ismissal of appeal for abandonment orfailure to prosecute3

.'( Court o, App(a" $a!% upon $ot#on o, t'( app((( or motu proprio an* w#t' not#1( to t'( app(ant #n (#t'(r 1a"(%

D#"$#"" t'( app(a #, t'( app(ant ,a#" to 7( '#" &r#(, w#t'#n t'(

t#$( pr("1r#&(* &! t'#" Ru(% (>1(pt w'(r( t'( app(ant #"r(pr("(nt(* &! a 1oun"( de o'cio3


25/46

APPELLAN.’S 4RIEF< CIVIL

Ru( // S(1 3

It "'a &( t'( *ut! o, t'( app(ant to 7( w#t' t'( 1ourt

W#t'#n /5 *a!" ,ro$ r(1(#pt o, t'( not#1( o, t'( 1(r; t'at a(-#*(n1(% ora an* *o1u$(ntar!% ar( atta1'(* to t'( r(1or*

1op#(" o, '#" app(ant’" &r#(,

W#t' proo, o, "(r-#1( o, 2 1op#(" t'(r(o, upon t'( app(((3


26/46

CON.EN.S OF APPELLAN.’S 4RIEF

Ru( // S(13 0B3 &ontents of appellant)s brief* : .'( app(ant" &r#(, "'a 1onta#n% #n t'( or*(r'(r(#n #n*#1at(*% t'( ,oow#n+<

A "u&)(1t #n*(> o, t'( $att(r #n t'( &r#(, W#t' a *#+("t o, t'( ar+u$(nt" an* pa+(

r(,(r(n1("% an*

A ta&( o, 1a"(" ap'a&(t#1a! arran+(*% t(>t&oo;"an* "tatut(" 1#t(* w#t' r(,(r(n1(" to t'( pa+("

w'(r( t'(! ar( 1#t(*= An a""#+n$(nt o, (rror" #nt(n*(* to &(

ur+(*% w'#1' (rror" "'a &( "(parat(!%*#"t#n1t! an* 1on1#"(! "tat(* w#t'outr(p(t#t#on an* nu$&(r(* 1on"(1ut#-(!=


27/46


Un*(r t'( '(a*#n+ Stat($(nt o, t'( Ca"(% A 1(ar an* 1on1#"( "tat($(nt o, t'( natur( o, t'( a1t#on%

A "u$$ar! o, t'( pro1((*#n+"%

.'( app(a(* ru#n+" an* or*(r" o, t'( 1ourt% t'( natur( o, t'( )u*+$(nt an*

An! ot'(r $att(r" n(1(""ar! to an un*(r"tan*#n+ o, t'( natur( o,t'( 1ontro-(r"! w#t' pa+( r(,(r(n1(" to t'( r(1or*=

Un*(r t'( '(a*#n+ Stat($(nt o, Fa1t"% A 1(ar an* 1on1#"( "tat($(nt #n a narrat#-( ,or$ o, t'( ,a1t"

a*$#tt(* &! &ot' part#(" an* o, t'o"( #n 1ontro-(r"!%

.o+(t'(r w#t' t'( "u&"tan1( o, t'( proo, r(at#n+ t'(r(to #n "u1#(nt

*(ta# to $a;( #t 1(ar! #nt(#+#&(% w#t' pa+( r(,(r(n1(" to t'(r(1or*=


28/46


A 1(ar an* 1on1#"( "tat($(nt o, t'( #""u(" o, ,a1t or aw to &("u&$#tt(*% to t'( 1ourt ,or #t" )u*+$(nt=

Un*(r t'( '(a*#n+ Ar+u$(nt% .'( app(ant" ar+u$(nt" on (a1' a""#+n$(nt o, (rror w#t' pa+(

r(,(r(n1(" to t'( r(1or*3

.'( aut'or#t#(" r(#(* upon "'a &( 1#t(* &! t'( pa+( o, t'( r(port atw'#1' t'( 1a"( &(+#n" an* t'( pa+( o, t'( r(port on w'#1' t'( 1#tat#on #",oun*=

Un*(r t'( '(a*#n+ R(#(,% A "p(1#71at#on o, t'( or*(r or )u*+$(nt w'#1' t'( app(ant "((;"= an*

In 1a"(" not &rou+'t up &! r(1or* on app(a% t'( app(ant"

&r#(, "'a 1onta#n% a" an app(n*#>% a 1op! o, t'( )u*+$(nt or7na or*(r app(a(* ,ro$3


29/46

APPELLEE’S 4RIEF< CRIMINAL

Ru( 02/ S(13 /3 When brief for appellee to be 'led= replybrief of the appellant 3

W#t'#n t'#rt! B86 *a!"

Fro$ t'( r(1(#pt o, t'( &r#(, o, t'( app(ant%

.'( app((( "'a 7( "(-(n 6 1op#(" o, t'( &r#(, o, t'( app(((w#t' t'( 1(r; o, 1ourt

W'#1' "'a &( a11o$pan#(* &! proo, o, "(r-#1( o, two 26 1op#("t'(r(o, upon t'( app(ant3


30/46

APPELLEE’S 4RIEF< CIVIL

Ru( // S(13 K3 Appellee+s brief

W#t'#n /5 *a!"

Fro$ r(1(#pt o, t'( app(ant’" &r#(,

.'( app((( "'a 7( w#t' t'( 1ourt 1op#(" o, '#" &r#(,

W#t' proo, o, "(r-#1( o, 2 1op#(" t'(r(o, upon t'( app(ant3


31/46

CON.EN.S OF APPELLEE’S 4RIEF

Ru( // S(13 0/3 &ontents of appellee)s brief* : .'(app(((" &r#(, "'a 1onta#n% #n t'( or*(r '(r(#n#n*#1at(* t'( ,oow#n+<

A "u&)(1t #n*(> o, t'( $att(r #n t'( &r#(, w#t'

A *#+("t o, t'( ar+u$(nt" an* pa+( r(,(r(n1("% an*

A ta&( o, 1a"(" ap'a&(t#1a! arran+(*% t(>t&oo;" an* "tatut(" 1#t(*w#t' r(,(r(n1(" to t'( pa+(" w'(r( t'(! ar( 1#t(*=


32/46

CON.EN.S OF APPELLEE’S 4RIEF

Un*(r t'( '(a*#n+ Stat($(nt o, Fa1t"%

.'( app((( "'a "tat( t'at '( a11(pt" t'( "tat($(nt o, ,a1t" #n t'(app(ant" &r#(,% or un*(r t'( '(a*#n+ Count(rStat($(nt o, Fa1t"% '("'a po#nt out "u1' #n"u1#(n1#(" or #na11ura1#(" a" '( &(#(-(" (>#"t #nt'( app(ant" "tat($(nt o, ,a1t" w#t' r(,(r(n1(" to t'( pa+(" o, t'(r(1or* #n "upport t'(r(o,% &ut

W#t'out r(p(t#t#on o, $att(r" #n t'( app(ant" "tat($(nt o, ,a1t"= an* Un*(r t'( '(a*#n+ Ar+u$(nt%

.'( app((( "'a "(t ,ort' '#" ar+u$(nt" #n t'( 1a"( on (a1'a""#+n$(nt o, (rror w#t' pa+( r(,(r(n1(" to t'( r(1or*3

.'( aut'or#t#(" r(#(* on "'a &( 1#t(* &! t'( pa+( o, t'( r(port at w'#1't'( 1a"( &(+#n" an* t'( pa+( o, t'( r(port on w'#1' t'( 1#tat#on #"

,oun*3


33/46

REPLY 4RIEF< CRIMINAL

Ru( 02/ S(13 /

W#t'#n tw(nt! 286 *a!"

Fro$ r(1(#pt o, t'( &r#(, o, t'( app(((

.'( app(ant $a! 7( a r(p! &r#(, tra-(r"#n+ $att(r" ra#"(* #n t'( ,or$(r&ut not 1o-(r(* #n t'( &r#(, o, t'( app(ant3


34/46

REPLY 4RIEF< CIVIL

Ru( // S(13 App(ant’" r(p! &r#(,

W#t'#n tw(nt! 286 *a!"

Fro$ r(1(#pt o, t'( app(((’" &r#(,

.'( app(ant $a! 7( a r(p! &r#(, an"w(r#n+ po#nt" #n t'( app(((’" &r#(,not 1o-(r(* #n '#" $a#n &r#(,3


35/46

WHA. IS AN APPELLAN.’S REPLY 4RIEF?

.'( app(ant’" r(p! &r#(, #" a *o1u$(nt an"w(r#n+ po#nt" #n t'(

app(((" &r#(, NO. 1o-(r(* #n app(ant’" $a#n &r#(,

It 1onta#n" t'( an"w(r o, t'( app(ant to t'( a(+at#on" ra#"(* #nt'( app(((’" &r#(,

L(+a

Fa1tua

It r(#t(rat(" t'( ar+u$(nt" ra#"(* #n t'( app(ant’" &r#(,

4r#n+" t'( ,o1u" &a1; to t'( ar+u$(nt" #n t'( app(ant’" op(n#n+ &r#(,

4oo"t" t'( 1r(*##t! &! 1#t#n+ aut'or#t#(" t'at "upport t'( "tan*o, t'( app(ant

U"(" t'( ar+u$(nt" o, t'( app((( to *#"1u"" #""u(" #n t'(op(n#n+ &r#(,


36/46

WHA. NO. .O PU. IN .HE APPELLAN.’SREPLY 4RIEF

N(w ar$at#-( #""u("

Goo* r(a"on" ,or not ra#"#n+ #t &(,or(

R('a"' o, Stat($(nt o, Ca"( an* Fa1t"


37/46

E.ENSION OF .IME

For &ot' Cr#$#na Ru( 02/ S(13 536 an* C#-# Ru( //S(13 026 E>t(n"#on o, t#$( ,or t'( 7#n+ o, &r#(," w# not&( aow(*

E>1(pt ,or<

Goo* an* "u1#(nt 1au"( an*< On! #, t'( $ot#on ,or (>t(n"#on #" 7(* &(,or( t'( (>p#rat#on o, t'(

t#$( "ou+'t to &( (>t(n*(*3


38/46

FOR SPECIAL CASES

Ru( // S(13 08 %ime of 'lin$ memoranda in specialcases

In 1(rt#orar#% pro'#t#on% $an*a$u"% quo warranto an* habeascorpus 1a"("

.'( part#(" "'a 7( #n #(u o, &r#(,"

.'(#r r("p(1t#-( $($oran*a

W#t'#n a non(>t(n*#&( p(r#o* o, B8 *a!"

Fro$ r(1(#pt o, t'( not#1( #""u(* &! t'( 1(r; t'at a t'( (-#*(n1(%ora% an* *o1u$(ntar!% #" ar(a*! atta1'(* to t'( r(1or*3


39/46

APPEAL .O SC


40/46

PE.I.ION FOR REVIEW ON CER.IORARI

Ru( /5 S(13 03 Filin$ of petition with Supreme &ourt 3

Fro$ a )u*+$(nt or 7na or*(r or r("out#on o, t'( CA% t'(San*#+an&a!an% t'( R.C or ot'(r 1ourt"

Ma! #n1u*( an app#1at#on ,or a wr#t o, pr(#$#nar! #n)un1t#on orot'(r pro-#"#ona r($(*#("

App#1a&( on &ot' 1#-# an* 1r#$#na 1a"("% (>1(pt #n 1r#$#na 1a"("w'(r( t'( p(nat! #" *(at'% r(1u"#on p(rp(tua% or #,( #$pr#"on$(nt


41/46


.'( p(t#t#on "'a ra#"( on! u("t#on" o, aw w'#1' $u"t &( *#"t#n1t! "(t,ort'3 E>1(pt<

w'(n t'( 1on1u"#on #" a 7n*#n+ +roun*(* (nt#r(! on "p(1uat#on% "ur$#"( an*1on)(1tur(=

w'(n t'( #n,(r(n1( $a*( #" $an#,("t! $#"ta;(n=

w'(n t'(r( #" a +ra-( a&u"( o, *#"1r(t#on=

w'(n t'( )u*+$(nt #" &a"(* on a $#"appr('(n"#on o, ,a1t"=

w'(n t'( 7n*#n+" o, ,a1t ar( 1onJ#1t#n+=

w'(n t'( Court o, App(a" w(nt &(!on* t'( #""u(" o, t'( 1a"( an* #t" 7n*#n+"ar( 1ontrar! to t'( a*$#""#on" o, &ot' app(ant an* app(((=

w'(n t'( 7n*#n+" o, ,a1t o, t'( Court o, App(a" ar( 1ontrar! to t'o"( o, t'( tr#a

1ourt=

w'(n "a#* 7n*#n+" o, ,a1t ar( 1on1u"#on" w#t'out 1#tat#on o, "p(1#71 (-#*(n1( onw'#1' t'(! ar( &a"(*=


42/46


w'(n t'( ,a1t" "(t ,ort' #n t'( p(t#t#on a" w( a" #n t'( p(t#t#on(r’" $a#n an*r(p! &r#(," ar( not *#"put(* &! t'( r("pon*(nt"= an*

w'(n t'( 7n*#n+" o, ,a1t o, t'( Court o, App(a" ar( pr($#"(* on t'(

"uppo"(* a&"(n1( o, (-#*(n1( an* 1ontra*#1t(* &! t'( (-#*(n1( on r(1or*3&irte! ,mployees -abor .nion/Federation of Free Wor!ers v* &irte!

,lectronics0 1nc*0 2*#* "o* 3456360 7une 580 95330 865 SA 8680 8856


43/46

CON.EN.S OF PE.I.ION

Ru( /5 S(13 /3 &ontents of petition3

.'( p(t#t#on "'a &( 7(* #n (#+'t((n 0K6 1op#(" w#t' t'( or#+#na1op! #nt(n*(* ,or t'( 1ourt &(#n+ #n*#1at(* a" "u1' &! t'( p(t#t#on(ran* "'a

Stat( t'( ,u na$( o, t'( app(a#n+ part! a" t'( p(t#t#on(r an* t'(

a*-(r"( part! a" r("pon*(nt% w#t'out #$p(a*#n+ t'( ow(r 1ourt" or )u*+(" t'(r(o, (#t'(r a" p(t#t#on(r" or r("pon*(nt"=

In*#1at( t'( $at(r#a *at(" "'ow#n+<

w'(n not#1( o, t'( )u*+$(nt or 7na or*(r or r("out#on "u&)(1tt'(r(o, wa" r(1(#-(*%

w'(n a $ot#on ,or n(w tr#a or r(1on"#*(rat#on% #, an!% wa" 7(* an*

w'(n not#1( o, t'( *(n#a t'(r(o, wa" r(1(#-(*=


44/46

CON.EN.S OF PE.I.ION

S(t ,ort' 1on1#"(! a "tat($(nt o, t'( $att(r" #n-o-(*% an* t'(r(a"on" or ar+u$(nt" r(#(* on ,or t'( aowan1( o, t'( p(t#t#on=

4( a11o$pan#(* &! a 1(ar! (+#&( *up#1at( or#+#na% or a 1(rt#7(*tru( 1op! o, t'( )u*+$(nt or 7na or*(r or r("out#on 1(rt#7(* &! t'(1(r; o, 1ourt o, t'( 1ourt a quo an* t'( r(u#"#t( nu$&(r o, pa#n1op#(" t'(r(o,% an* "u1' $at(r#a port#on" o, t'( r(1or* a" wou*

"upport t'( p(t#t#on= an*

Conta#n a "worn 1(rt#71at#on a+a#n"t ,oru$ "'opp#n+ a" pro-#*(* #nt'( a"t para+rap' o, "(1t#on 2% Ru( /23


45/46

DISMISSAL OF PE.I.ION

Ru( /5 S(13 53 (ismissal or denial of petition3

.'( ,a#ur( o, t'( p(t#t#on(r to 1o$p! w#t' t'( r(u#r($(nt"r(+ar*#n+ t'( 1ont(nt" o, t'( *o1u$(nt" w'#1' "'ou* a11o$pan!t'( p(t#t#on "'a &( "u1#(nt +roun* ,or t'( *#"$#""a t'(r(o,3


46/46

END

.'an; !ou ,or #"t(n#n+

Group 5 Report-Appeals

Documents