GRID INTERCONNECTION OF RENEWABLEENERGY SOURCES AT THE
DISTRIBUTION LEVELWITH POWER-QUALITY IMPROVEMENT
FEATURESABSTRACTRenewable energy resources (RES) are being
increasingly connected in distribution systems utilizing power
electronic converters. This paper presents a novel control strategy
for achieving maximum benefits from these grid-interfacing
inverters when installed in 3-phase 4-wire distribution systems.
The inverter is controlled to perform as a multi-function device by
incorporating active power filter functionality. The inverter can
thus be utilized as: 1) power converter to inject power generated
from RES to the grid, and 2) shunt APF to compensate current
unbalance, load current harmonics, load reactive power demand and
load neutral current. All of these functions may be accomplished
either individually or simultaneously. With such a control, the
combination of grid-interfacing inverter and the 3-phase 4-wire
linear/non-linear unbalanced load at point of common coupling
appears as balanced linear load to the grid. This new control
concept is demonstrated with extensive MATLAB/Simulink simulation
studies and validated through digital signal processor-based
laboratory experimental results.
INTRODUCTIONELECTRIC utilities and end users of electric power
are becoming increasingly concerned about meeting the growing
energy demand. Seventy five percent of total global energy demand
is supplied by the burning of fossil fuels. But increasing air
pollution, global warming concerns, diminishing fossil fuels and
their increasing cost have made it necessary to look towards
renewable sources as a future energy solution. Since the past
decade, there has been an enormous interest in many countries on
renewable energy for power generation. The market liberalization
and governments incentives have further accelerated the renewable
energy sector growth.Renewable energy source (RES) integrated at
distribution level is termed as distributed generation (DG). The
utility is concerned due to the high penetration level of
intermittent RES in distribution systems as it may pose a threat to
network in terms of stability, voltage regulation and power-quality
(PQ) issues. Therefore, the DG systems are required to comply with
strict technical and regulatory frameworks to ensure safe, reliable
and efficient operation of overall network. With the advancement in
power electronics and digital control technology, the DG systems
can now be actively controlled to enhance the system operation with
improved PQ at PCC. However, the extensive use of power electronics
based equipment and non-linear loads at PCC generate harmonic
currents, which may deteriorate the quality of power. Generally,
current controlled voltage source inverters are used to interface
the intermittent RES in distributed system. Recently, a few control
strategies for grid connected inverters incorporating PQ solution
have been proposed. In an inverter operates as active inductor at a
certain frequency to absorb the harmonic current. But the exact
calculation of network inductance in real-time is difficult and may
deteriorate the control performance. A similar approach in which a
shunt active filter acts as active conductance to damp out the
harmonics in distribution network is proposed. A control strategy
for renewable interfacing inverter based on theory is proposed. In
this strategy both load and inverter current sensing is required to
compensate the load current harmonics. The non-linear load current
harmonics may result in voltage harmonics and can create a serious
PQ problem in the power system network. Active power filters (APF)
are extensively used to compensate the load current harmonics and
load unbalance at distribution level. This results in an additional
hardware cost. However, in this paper authors have incorporated the
features of APF in the, conventional inverter interfacing renewable
with the grid, without any additional hardware cost. Here, the main
idea is the maximum utilization of inverter rating which is most of
the time underutilized due to intermittent nature of RES. It is
shown in this paper that the grid-interfacing inverter can
effectively be utilized to perform following important functions:
1) transfer of active power harvested from the renewable resources
(wind, solar, etc.); 2) load reactive power demand support; 3)
current harmonics compensation at PCC; and 4) current unbalance and
neutral current compensation in case of 3-phase 4-wire system.
Moreover, with adequate control of grid-interfacing inverter, all
the four objectives can be accomplished either individually or
simultaneously. The PQ constraints at the PCC can therefore be
strictly maintained within the utility standards without additional
hardware cost.
DISTRIBUTED GENERATIONDistributed generation, also calledon-site
generation,dispersed generation,embedded generation, decentralized
generation, decentralized energy or distributed energy
enerateselectricityfrom many small energy sources. Currently,
industrial countries generate most of their electricity in large
centralized facilities, such asfossil fuel(coal,gas
powered)nuclearor hydropowerplants. These plants have excellent
economies of scale, but usually transmit electricity long distances
and negatively affect the environment.Most plants are built this
way due to a number ofeconomic,health&safety,logistical,
environmental,geographicalandgeologicalfactors. For example, coal
power plants are built away from cities to prevent their heavy air
pollution from affecting the populace. In addition, such plants are
often built nearcollieriesto minimize the cost of transporting
coal.Hydroelectricplants are by their nature limited to operating
at sites with sufficient water flow. Most power plants are often
considered to be too far away for their waste heat to be used for
heating buildings.Low pollution is a crucial advantage ofcombined
cycleplants that burnnatural gas. The low pollution permits the
plants to be near enough to a city to be used fordistrict
heatingand cooling. Distributed generation is another approach. It
reduces the amount of energy lost in transmitting electricity
because the electricity is generated very near where it is used,
perhaps even in the same building. This also reduces the size and
number of power lines that must be constructed. Typical distributed
power sources in aFeed-in Tariff(FIT) scheme have low maintenance,
low pollution and high efficiencies. In the past, these traits
required dedicated operating engineers and large complex plants to
reduce pollution. However, modernembedded systemscan provide these
traits with automated operation andrenewable, such as sunlight,
wind andgeothermal. This reduces the size of power plant that can
show a profit.Distributed energy resourceDistributed energy
resource (DER) systems are small-scale power generation
technologies (typically in the range of 3kW to 10,000kW) used to
provide an alternative to or an enhancement of the traditional
electric power system. The usual problems with distributed
generators are their high costs.One popular source issolar panelson
the roofs of buildings. The production cost is $0.99 to 2.00/W
(2007) plus installation and supporting equipment unless the
installation isDo it yourself(DIY) bringing the cost to $6.50 to
7.50 (2007).This is comparable to coal power plant costs of $0.582
to 0.906/W (1979),adjusting for inflation. Nuclear power is higher
at $2.2 to $6.00/W (2007).[4]Some solar cells ("thin-film" type)
also have waste disposal issues; since "thin-film" type solar cells
often contain heavy-metal electronic wastes, such asCadmium
telluride(CdTe) andCopper indium gallium selenide(CuInGaSe), and
need to be recycled. As opposed to silicon semi-conductor type
solar cells which is made from quartz. The plus side is that unlike
coal and nuclear, there are no fuel costs, pollution, mining safety
or operating safety issues. Solar also has a lowduty cycle,
producing peak power at local noon each day. Average duty cycle is
typically 20%.Another source is smallwind turbines. These have low
maintenance, and low pollution. Construction costs are higher
($0.80/W, 2007) per watt than large power plants, except in very
windy areas. Wind towers and generators have substantial insurable
liabilities caused by high winds, but good operating safety. In
some areas of the US there may also be Property Tax costs involved
with wind turbines that are not offset by incentives oraccelerated
depreciation. Wind also tends to be complementary to solar; on days
there is no sun there tends to be wind and vice versa.Many
distributed generation sites combine wind power and solar power
such asSlippery Rock University, which can bemonitored
online.Distributedcogenerationsources usenatural gas-firedmicro
turbinesorreciprocating enginesto turn generators. The hot exhaust
is then used for space or water heating, or to drive anabsorptive
chiller[6]forair-conditioning. The clean fuel has only low
pollution.Designscurrently have uneven reliability, with some makes
having excellent maintenance costs, and others being unacceptable.
Co generators are also more expensive per watt than central
generators. They find favor because most buildings already burn
fuels, and the cogeneration can extract more value from the
fuel.Some larger installations utilizecombined cyclegeneration.
Usually this consists of agas turbinewhose exhaust boilswaterfor
asteam turbinein aRankine cycle. The condenser of the steam cycle
provides the heat for space heating or an absorptive chiller.
Combined cycle plants with cogeneration have the highest known
thermal efficiencies, often exceeding 85%.In countries with high
pressure gas distribution, small turbines can be used to bring the
gas pressure to domestic levels whilst extracting useful energy. If
the UK were to implement this countrywide an additional 2-4GWe
would become available. (Note that the energy is already being
generated elsewhere to provide the high initial gas pressure - this
method simply distributes the energy via a different route.) Future
generations of electric vehicles will have the ability to deliver
power from the battery into the grid when needed. This could also
be an important distributed generation resource.
Recently interest in Distributed Energy Systems (DES) is
increasing, particularly onsite generation. This interest is
because larger power plants are economically unfeasible in many
regions due to increasing system and fuel costs, and more strict
environmental regulations. In addition, recent technological
advances in small generators, Power Electronics, and energy storage
devices have provided a new opportunity for distributed energy
resources at the distribution level, and especially, the incentive
laws to utilize renewable energies has also encouraged a more
decentralized approach to power delivery.There are many generation
sources for DES: conventional technologies (diesel or natural gas
engines), emerging technologies (micro turbines or fuel cells or
energy storage devices), and renewable technologies (small wind
turbines or solar/photovoltaics or small hydro turbines). These DES
are used for applications to a standalone, a standby, a
grid-interconnected, a cogeneration, peak shavings, etc. and have
many advantages such as environmental-friendly and modular electric
generation, increased reliability, high power quality,
uninterruptible service, cost savings, on-site generation,
expandability, etc. So many utility companies are trying to
construct small distribution stations combined with several DES
available at the regions, instead of large power plants. Basically,
these technologies are based on notably advanced Power Electronics
because all DES require Power Converters, interconnection
techniques, and electronic control units. That is, all power genera
ed by DES is generated as DC Power, and then all the power fed to
the DC distribution bus is again converted into an AC power with
fixed magnitude and frequency by control units using Digital Signal
Processor (DSP). So improved power electronic technologies that
permit grid interconnection of asynchronous generation sources are
definitely required to support distributed generation resourcesThe
research works in the recent papers about DES focus on being
utilized directly to a standalone AC system or fed back to the
utility mains. That is, when in normal operation or mainfailures,
DES directly supply loads with power (standalone mode or standby
mode), while, when DES have surplus power or need more power, this
system operates in parallel mode to the mains. Therefore, in order
to permit to connect more generators on the network in good
conditions, a good technique about interconnection with the grid
and voltage regulations should overcome the problems due to
parallel operation of Power Converter for applications to DES.
DISTRIBUTED ENERGY SYSTEMSToday, new advances in technology and
new directions in electricity regulation encourage a significant
increase of distributed generation resources around the world. As
shown in Fig. the currently competitive small generation units and
the incentive laws to use renewable energies force electric utility
companies to construct an increasing number of distributed
generation units on its distribution network, instead of large
central power plants. Moreover, DES can offer improved service
reliability, better economics and a reduced dependence on the local
utility. Distributed Generation Systems have mainly been used as a
standby power source for critical businesses. For example, most
hospitals and office buildings had stand-by diesel generation as an
emergency power source for use only during outages. However, the
diesel generators were not inherently cost-effective, and produce
noise and exhaust that would be objectionable on anything except
for an emergency basis.
Fig. A large central power plant and distributed energy
systems
Meanwhile, recently, the use of Distributed Energy Systems under
the 500 kW level is rapidly increasing due to recent technology
improvements in small generators, power electronics, and energy
storage devices. Efficient clean fossil fuels technologies such as
micro-turbines and fuel cells, and environmentally friendly
renewable energy technologies such as solar/photovoltaics, small
wind and hydro are increasingly used for new distributed generation
systems. These DES are applied to a standalone, a standby, a
grid-interconnected, a cogeneration, peak shavings, etc. and have a
lot of benefits such as environmental-friendly and modular electric
generation, increased reliability, high power quality,
uninterruptible service, cost savings, on-site generation,
expandability, etc. The major Distributed Generation technologies
that will be discussed in this section are as follows:
micro-turbines, fuel cells, solar/photovoltaic systems, and energy
storage devices.Micro-turbines, especially the small gas fired
micro turbines in the 25-100 kW that can be mass-produced at low
cost have been more attractive due to the competitive price of
natural gas, low installation and maintenance costs. It takes very
clever engineering and use of innovative design (e.g. air bearing,
recuperation) to achieve reasonable efficiency and costs in
machines of lower output, and a big advantage of these systems is
small because these mainly use high-speed turbines (50,000-90,000
RPM) with air foil bearings. Therefore, micro turbines hold the
most promise of any of the DES technologies today.Fuel cells are
also well used for distributed generation applications, and can
essentially be described as batteries which never become discharged
as long as hydrogen and oxygen are continuously provided. The
hydrogen can be supplied directly, or produced from natural gas, or
liquid fuels such as alcohols, or gasoline. Each unit ranges in
size from 3 250 kW or larger MW size. Even if they offer high
efficiency and low emissions, todays costs are high. Phosphoric
acid cell are commercially available in the range of the 200 kW,
while solid oxide and molten carbonate cell are in a pre-commercial
stage of development.The possibility of using gasoline as a fuel
for cells has resulted in a major development effort by the
automotive companies. The recent research work about fuel cells is
focused towards the polymer electrolyte membrane (PEM) fuel cells.
Fuel cells in sizes greater than 200 kW, hold promise beyond 2005,
but residential size fuel cells are unlikely to have any
significant market impact any time soon. Mixed micro-turbine and
fuel cell systems will also be available as a distributed
generation source. Recently, a solid oxide fuel cell has been
combined with a gas micro-turbine creating a combined cycle power
plant. It has expected electrical efficiency of greater than 70 %,
and the expected power levels range from 250 kW to 2.5 MW.
Solar/photovoltaic systems may be used in a variety of sizes, but
the installation of large numbers of photovoltaic systems is
undesirable due to high land costs and in many geographic areas
with poor intensity and reliability of sunlight. In general, almost
one acre of land would be needed to provide 150 kW of electricity,
so solar/photovoltaic systems will continue to have limited
applications in the future. Energy storage devices such as ultra
capacitors, batteries, and flywheels are one of the most critical
technologies for DES. In general, the electrochemical capacitor has
high power density as well as good energy density. In particular,
ultra capacitors have several benefits such as high pulse power
capacity, long lifetime, high power density, low ESR, and very thin
and tight. In contrast, batteries have higher energy density, but
lower power density and short lifetime relative to ultra-capacitor.
So hybrid Power System, a combination of ultra-capacitor and
battery, is strongly recommended to satisfy several requirements
and to optimize system performance. Recently storage systems are
much more efficient, cheaper, and longer than five years ago. In
particular, flywheel systems can generate 700 kW for 5 seconds,
while 28-cell ultra capacitors can provide up to 12.5 kW for a few
seconds.In the past, the electric utility industry did not offer
various options that were suited for a wide range of consumer
needs, and most utilities offered at best two or three combinations
of reliability-price. However, the types of modern DES give
commercial electric consumers various options in a wider range of
reliability-price combinations. For these reasons, DES will be very
likely to thrive in the next 20 years, and especially, distributed
generation technologies will have a much greater market potential
in areas with high electricity costs and low reliability such as in
developing countries.PROBLEM STATEMENTS
DES technologies have very different issues compared with
traditional centralized power sources. For example, they are
applied to the mains or the loads with voltage of 480 volts or
less; and require power converters and different strategies of
control and dispatch. All of these energy technologies provide a DC
output which requires power electronic interfaces with the
distribution power networks and its loads. In most cases the
conversion is performed by using a voltage source inverter (VSI)
with a possibility of pulse width modulation (PWM) that provides
fast regulation for voltage magnitude. Power electronic interfaces
introduce new control issues, but at the same time, new
possibilities. For example, a system which consists of
micro-generators and storage devices could be designed to operate
in both an autonomous mode and connected to the power grid. One
large class of problems is related to the fact that the power
sources such as micro turbines and fuel cell have slow response and
their inertia is much less. It must be remembered that the current
power systems have storage in generators inertia, and this may
result in a slight reduction in system frequency. As these
generators become more compact, the need to link them to lower
network voltage is significantly increasing. However, without any
medium voltage networks adaptation, this fast expansion can affect
the quality of supply as well as the public and equipment safety
because distribution networks have not been designed to connect a
significant amount of generation. Therefore, a new voltage control
system to facilitate the connection of distributed generation
resources to distribution networks should be developed. In many
cases there are also major technical barriers to operating
independently in a standalone AC system, or to connecting small
generation systems to the electrical distribution network with
lower voltage and the recent research issues includes:1. Control
strategy to facilitate the connection of distributed generation
resources to distribution networks.2. Efficient battery control.3.
Inverter control based on only local information.4. Synchronization
with the utility mains.5. Compensation of the reactive power and
higher harmonic components.6. Power Factor Correction.7. System
protection.8. Load sharing.9. Reliability of communication.10.
Requirements of the customer.DES offers significant research and
engineering challenges in solving these problems. Moreover, the
electrical and economic relationships between customers and the
distribution utility and among customers may take forms quite
distinct from those we know today. For example, rather than devices
being individually interconnected in parallel with the grid, they
may be grouped with loads in a semi-autonomous neighborhood that
could be termed a micro grid is a cluster of small sources, storage
systems, and loads which presents itself to the grid as a
legitimate single entity. Hence, future research work will focus on
solving the above issues so that DES with more advantages compared
with tradition large power plants can thrive in electric power
industry.
PROBLEM DESCRIPTION
These new distributed generations interconnected to the low grid
voltage or low load voltage cause new problems which require
innovative approaches to managing and operating the distributed
resources. In the fields of Power Electronics, the recent papers
have focused on applications of a standby generation, a standalone
AC system, a combined heat and power (cogeneration) system, and
interconnection with the grid of distribution generations on the
distribution network, and have suggested technical solutions which
would permit to connect more generators on the network in good
conditions and to perform a good voltage regulation. Depending on
the load, generation level, and local connection conditions, each
generator can cause the problems described in the previous chapter.
The main goals which should be achieved will thus be: to increase
the network connection capacity by allowing more consumers and
producer customers connection without creating new reinforcement
costs, to enhance the reliability of the systems by the
protections, to improve the overall quality of supply with a best
voltage control.A. Configurations for DES
1) Case I: A Power Converter connected in a Standalone AC System
or in Parallel with the Utility Mains Fig. show a distributed power
system which is connected to directly load or in parallel with
utility mains, according to its mode. This system consists of a
generator, an input filter, an AC/AC power converter, an output
filter, an isolation transformer, output sensor (V, I, P), and a
DSP controller. In the Figures, a distributed generator may operate
as one of three modes: a standby, a peak shaving, and a standalone
power source. In a standby mode shown in Fig. a generator set
serves as a UPS system operating during mains failures. It is used
to increase the reliability of the energy supply and to enhance the
overall performance of the system. The static switch SW 1 is closed
in normal operation and SW 2 is open, while in case of mains
failures or excessive voltage drop detection SW 1 is open and SW 2
is simultaneously closed. In this case, control techniques of DES
are very similar to those of UPS. If a transient load increases,
the output voltage has relatively large drops due to the internal
impedance of the inverter and filter stage, which frequently result
in malfunction of sensitive load. Fig. can serves as a peak shaving
or interconnection with the grid to feed power back to mains. In
both modes, the generator is connected in parallel with the main
grids. In a peak shaving mode, this generator is running as few as
several hundred hours annually because the SW 1 is only closed
during the limited periods. Meanwhile, in an interconnection with
the grid, SW 1 is always closed and this system provides the grid
with continuous electric power. In addition, the converter
connected in parallel to the mains can serve also as a source of
reactive power and higher harmonic current components.In a
standalone AC system shown in Fig. the generator is directly
connected to the load lines without being connected to the mains
and it will operate independently. In this case, the operations of
this system are similar to a standby mode, and it serves
continuously unlike a standby mode and a peak shaving mode.
Fig. Block diagram of a standby mode
Fig. Block diagram of a peak shaving mode
Fig. Block diagram of a standalone mode
As shown in Fig. the output voltage of the generator is fed to a
DC/AC converter that converts a DC output of the generator to be
fixed voltage and frequency for utility mains or loads. The DSP
controller monitors multiple system variables on a real time basis
and executes control routines to optimize the operation of the
individual subsystems in response to measured variables. It also
provides all necessary functions to sense output voltages, current,
and power, to operate protections, and to give reference signals to
regulators. The output power of the converter is controlled
according to the reference signal of the control unit. As described
above, in order to compensate for reactive power and higher
harmonic components or to improve power factor, the active power
(P) and reactive power (Q) should be controlled independently.
Moreover, the above system needs over-dimensioning some parts of
the power converter in order to produce reactive power by the
converter at rated active power. Because a power converter
dimensioned for rated current can supply reactive power only if the
active component is less than rated. Therefore, a control strategy
easy to implement is required to ensure closed loop control of the
power factor and to provide a good power quality. In case that a
generator is used for distributed generation systems, the recent
research focuses are summarized as follows:1. Control strategy
which permits to connect more generators on the network2.
Compensation of the reactive power and higher harmonic components3.
An active power (P) and a reactive power control (Q)
independently4. Power factor correction5. Synchronization with the
utility mains6. System protections2) Case II: Power Converters
supplying power in a standalone mode or feeding it back to the
utility mains Fig. shows a block diagram of multiple power
converters for a standalone AC system or feeding generated powers
back to the utility mains. If all generators are directly connected
to the loads, the systems operate as a standalone AC system.
Meanwhile, if these are connected in parallel to the mains, these
provide the utility grids with an electric power. Each system
consists of a generator, an input filter, an AC/AC power converter,
an output filter, an isolation transformer, a control unit (DSP), a
static switch (SW 1) and output sensors (V, I, P). The function of
the static switch (SW 1) is to disrupt the energy flow between the
generator and mains or loads in the case of disturbances in the
mains voltage. As shown in Fig., this configuration is very similar
to parallel operation of multiple UPS systems except that the input
sources of inverters are independent generation systems such as
micro turbines, fuel cells, and photovoltaic, etc. instead of
utility mains.In case of parallel operation of UPS systems, a
recent critical research issue is to share linear and nonlinear
load properly by each unit. In general, the load sharing is mainly
influenced by non uniformity of the units, component tolerance, and
line impedance mismatches. Another issue is a proper control scheme
without any control interconnection wires among inverters because
these wires restrict the location of the inverter units as well as
these can act as a source of the noise and failure. Moreover, in
three-phase systems they could also cause unbalance and draw
excessive neutral currents. Even if conventionally passive L-C
filters were used to reduce harmonics and capacitors were employed
to improve the power factor of the ac loads, passive filters have
the demerits of fixed compensation, large size, and resonance.
Therefore, the injected harmonic, reactive power burden, unbalance,
and excessive neutral currents definitely cause low system
efficiency and poor power factor. In particular, a power factor can
be improved as AC/AC power converters function a complete active
filter for better power quality and the above problems should be
overcome by a good control technique to assure the DES to expand
increasingly around the world.
Fig. Block diagram of power converters connected in parallel
So the above issues can be applied to distributed power systems
similarly, and the recent research focuses are summarized as
follows:1. Standardized DES modeling using the software tools2.
Equal load sharing such as the real and reactive power, the load
harmonic current among the parallel connected inverters.3.
Connection capability of more DES to the utility mains in best
conditions4. Independent P, Q control of the inverters5. Power
factor correction6. Reduction of Total Harmonic Distortion
(THD).Distributed Generation (DG) is commonly defined as electric
power generation facilities that are not directly connected to a
bulk power transmission system. They cover a multitude of energy
sources, fuels, and conversion methods to produce electricity
through photovoltaic (PV) arrays, wind turbines, fuel cells, micro
turbines, liquid and gas-fueled reciprocating engines, etc. Given
the wide variety of sources, it is natural that specific impacts
associated with DG would vary with type and application. However,
there are many common threads on how DG benefits the customers they
serve and society at large. This is demonstrated in this paper
through several examples, giving testimonials of the positive
impact these installations have.
EXAMPLES
Case 1 Emergency/Temporary Power Application
In mid-November 2007, the town of Chester, California, was
preparing to undergo a 72-hour power shutdown. This was required to
improve the service reliability in Chester after past sustained
outages due to circuit configuration, condition and exposure. For
that reason, Pacific Gas and Electric (PG&E) would replace 41
power poles and their cross-arms on its Hamilton Branch
transmission line. This line serves the Chester community with
1,652 electric meters within, and accounting for a combined
electrical demand in the range of 1.9 MW to 2.4 MW. Given PG&Es
commitment to customer satisfaction, and to maintaining their
service uptime percentage as high as possible, a prolonged outage
was really not a viable option. The solution was a temporary DG
installation consisting of two 2 MW diesel generator sets operated
through a parallel configuration with the PG&E power supply
(see Fig. 1). With this configuration, only two brief electrical
clearances, totaling less than 30 seconds, were necessary. Over
2,378,880 outage minutes were avoided for PG&E customers.
Chesters lights remained on and the aging poles were replaced.
PG&E avoided the combination of lost power sales during any
outage, and the added expense and safety concerns of having to work
crews around the clock for 72 hours to replace all the poles.
Fig. - Cat XQ2000 Power Modules in Chester
Case 2 Open-Market Price Hedging
The volatility in the energy market was greatly affecting the
power department budget in the city of Hurricane, Utah. Its
population surged from 8,250 in 2000 to 12,084 in 2006 an increase
of 46.5 percent. That growth put stress on the municipal power
system, operated by Hurricane City Power, especially in the summer
when temperatures can exceed 110F. This demand, coupled with high
prices on the energy market, forced the city to dip into budgetary
reserves to pay for power a few years in a row .In order to
diversify its electric supply options, Hurricane turned to natural
gas generator sets. The citys new generator sets would have to meet
Hurricanes needs load following, summer peaking and open market
price-hedging strategies. Hurricane also needed to boost
end-of-line voltage and frequency for distribution system
enhancement over a period of three years, six Cat G3520C natural
gas generator sets with Cat Oxidation Catalysts were installed (see
Fig. 2). The catalysts lower emissions of carbon monoxide by 93%
and decrease hydrocarbons by more than 40%, greatly reducing the
generator sets environmental impact. One of these units serves the
nearby city of Washington and is used when supplemental power is
needed there. The generator sets are rated at 1,940 ekW at 1800
rpm, in 115F temperature and at an elevation of 3,000 feet. They
operate together with paralleling switchgear at 12,470 V. This
power is connected directly to the adjacent substations
distribution buss. The reliability and cost-effectiveness of this
power solution earned Hurricane City Power and Washington City
Power a joint award in 2007 for the Most Improved System of the
Year from the Utah Associated Municipal Power Systems (UAMPS). The
city has been able to save as much as $10,000 to $12,000 a day
because of their ability to react to market prices quickly, and run
their generators instead of buying power on the market when the
cost is high. In addition to cost savings for the city, the gensets
provide peak power production support and backup power in case of a
citywide blackout. Three area blackouts have occurred in the three
years since this system has been in place, and the gensets have
provided the power needed to get the city up and running with no
outside power available.
Fig. - DG in Hurricane City Power Plant
Case 3 Combined CHP and Standby Power for Hospital
A cost effective combined heat and power (CHP) and standby power
generation package was required for the Norfolk and Norwich
Hospital being built by Octagon Healthcare in the United Kingdom.
In addition, tariff quality metering was necessary to qualify the
CHP as eligible for payment under the Climate Change Levy Good
Quality CHP scheme. Rather than the usual basement plant room, a
stand-alone energy center was built to give better access for
servicing and supplies. The CHP system prime mover is a Cat G3516
lean burn gas engine. Heat is recovered from the engine exhaust,
jacket water and oil cooler circuits, to provide 1314 kW. It is
used heat the returning medium-pressure hot water before it
re-enters the boiler, so the CHP acts as lead boiler. When thermal
demand is low excess heat is dumped to a remote radiator. A Cat SR4
generator directly linked to the engine provides 400 volts at 50
Hz. This feeds a synchronizing circuit breaker inside a control
panel, in turn connected to the hospitals HV line via a step-up
transformer. The complete system is displayed on a graphical
overview; a simple touch of the screen is all that is required for
an operator to interact with the system.The standby generation
system comprises four 2250 kVA (1800 kW) Caterpillar 3616B diesel
generator sets guarding against utility failures. Generators work
in an n+1 configuration so that full coverage of the hospital power
requirements continues if one set is unavailable; say due to
servicing at the time of power failure. The generators are
connected to the hospital heating and ventilation power feed via a
HV switchboard. Like the CHP system, the master control panel
provides a graphical overview of the system. Restoration to utility
power, once service has been deemed to be back to normal, is fully
automatic. The system is tested monthly with a real disconnection
from the utility supply. Case 4 Landfill
ApplicationsLandfill-gas-to-energy embodies the ideal solution to
an environmental problem: it turns nuisance waste into a product
with a practical use and economic value. It is an important and
growing component of North Americas power generation mix.
Generation from municipal solid waste and landfill gas is projected
to increase to about 31 billion kilowatt-hours by 2025. Although
the U.S. leads in this category, landfill gas is globally available
as the chart below illustrates.
Fig. - Estimated Global Landfill Methane Emissions
Landfill gas (LFG) is produced naturally as organic waste
decomposes in landfills. LFG is composed of about 50 percent
methane, about 50 percent carbon dioxide and small amounts of
non-methane organic compounds. At most municipal solid-waste
landfills, the methane and carbon dioxide are destroyed in a gas
collection and control system or utility flare. However, to use LFG
as an alternative fuel, the gas is extracted from landfills using a
series of wells and a vacuum system. Pipes are inserted deep into
the landfill to provide a point of release for the landfill gases.
A slight vacuum is then applied in the pipe to draw the gases into
and through it to a central point, where it can be processed and
treated for use in generating electricity, replacing the need for
conventional fossil fuels. Here are a few examples from around the
world of how LFG is used to produce electric power through engine
generator sets in landfill configurations.
Fig. Landfill Gas Engine Generator Set
Seneca Meadows Landfill, Seneca Falls, New York This energy
system, owned by Innovative Energy Systems of Oakfield, NY, began
operation in 1996 and has been expanded three times to its current
11.2 MW capacity. The system (see Fig.) uses fourteen Cat G3516
generator sets that have been modified for landfill use. Overall
energy plant NOx emissions are compliant with local air-quality
standards.
Fig. - Seneca Meadows Landfill, Seneca Falls, NY
Hartland Landfill in Victoria, British Columbia, Canada The
landfill receives municipal solid waste from a population of
roughly 400,000. Until the power generating system went online, the
landfill gas had been flared. Independent power producer Maxim
Power Corporation of Calgary, Alberta, installed the
land-fill-gas-to-energy system (see Fig. 6). The electric energy
output (continuous duty at 1.6 MW) is being sold to BC Hydro for
that companys Green Power program.
Fig. Harland Landfill, Victoria, BC, Canada
South East New Territories Landfill, Hong Kong This site
operated by Green Valley Landfill Ltd., installed two Cat G3516
landfill generator sets in 1997. Each unit is rated at 970 kW,
providing 1.9 MW of continuous power for the landfill
infrastructure and an on-site wastewater treatment plant (see Fig.
7). The units operate in parallel with the local utility, exporting
excess power to the grid. The generator sets have oversized
radiators to compensate for tropical heat and humidity.
Fig. - South East New Territories Landfill, Hong Kong
Case 5 Biogas Applications
Biogas is produced through the natural anaerobic decomposition
or fermentation of organic waste, such as manure, municipal solid
waste, biodegradable waste or any other biodegradable feedstock
within an anaerobic environment. Biogas consists primarily of
methane (50-80 percent) and carbon dioxide (20-50 percent). Biogas
can be extracted for commercial use from almost any of its sources.
For example, some livestock farms or large feeder operations use a
lagoon to store the manure generated by their livestock. Instead of
releasing the methane and carbon dioxide generated by the
decomposition of this manure into the atmosphere, the methane can
be extracted and burned at the farm in biogas-fueled boilers,
heaters or other gas consuming devices, including gas engines. In
addition to livestock farms, other agricultural operations afford
opportunities for biogas productions. For example,
cassava-processing plants, which produce starch, are common in
China, India and Indonesia and may utilize biogas for electric
power. By tapping their biogas resources, these plants not only
avoid the cost of purchasing heavy fuel oil and electricity but
also reclaim valuable land that would otherwise have to be used to
purify the factorys wastewater, and virtually eliminating odor and
pest issues caused by large-scale decomposition of organic
material.As an example of this type of DG application, let us
consider the Nong Rai Farm, in Rayong, Thailand. The farm partners
with the CP Group, one of the largest food suppliers in Thailand,
and runs a feeder operation for more than 30,000 hogs. Nong Rai
Farms consumes approximately 200 kW of power for blowers, drying
systems and other auxiliary needs associated with its operations.
The manure produced by its hogs is piped into a digester pond (see
Fig. 8), where it generates biogas that is used to fuel the
generator sets, which produce sufficient power for all of Nong Rai
Farms electric power requirements.
Fig. - Buffer Tank and Digestion Process in Thailand
Case 6 Coal Mine Methane (CMM) Gas Applications
The anthropogenic release of methane (CH4) into the environment
and its global warming potential continues to draw attention
globally. Methane can be released into the atmosphere through
sources where it naturally occurs: landfill decomposition,
agriculture, gas and oil extraction systems, and coal mining
activities. About 8% of total anthropogenic methane emissions come
from coal mines. Globally, coal mines emit approximately 400
million metric tons or 28 billion cubic meters of carbon dioxide
equivalent annually. This amount is equivalent to consumption of
818 million barrels of oil or the carbon dioxide emissions of 64
million passenger cars. Between 1994 and 2005, a U.S. Emission
decreased by over 20%, in large part due to the coal mining
industrys increased recovery and utilization of drained gas. China
leads the world in coal mine methane with about 14 billion cubic
meters of CO2 emitted annually a 2004 measurement estimated nearly
200 million metric tons were emitted that year. Aside from the U.S.
and China, other leading emitters include Ukraine, Australia,
Russia and India. Once methane is released into the atmosphere it
remains in it for approximately 15 years. It is a greenhouse gas
with an estimated global warming potential of 21. This means that
emissions of methane have an estimated effect on global warming
equal to 21 times the effect of carbon dioxide. Implementing
methods to use CMM instead of emitting it to the atmosphere will
help mitigate global warming, improve mine safety, and productivity
and generate revenues and cost savings.There are several options
currently available for CMM mitigation, including reciprocating gas
engines, gas turbines, industrial boilers and furnaces, and
chemical processing. Other technologies like catalytic systems and
fuel cells are also being developed. Two examples of this type of
DG application are described next, where CMM is sequestered and
used as an alternative fuel for reciprocating gas engine generator
sets. This is a mature and proven technology highly effective for
greenhouse gas.
MODELING AND CONTROL OF INVERTER INTERFACED DG UNITS
Basically each DG unit may have DC type or rectified generation
unit (Fuel cell, solar cell, wind turbine, micro turbine), storage
devices, DC-DC converter, DC-AC inverter, filter, and transformer
for connecting to loads or utility in order to exchange power.
Model and dynamic of each of this part may have influence in system
operation. But here for simplification it is considered that DC
side of the units has sufficient storage and considered as a
constant DC source. Hence only DC-AC inverter modeling and control
investigated in this paper.A circuit model of a three-phase DC to
AC inverter with LC output filter is further described in Figure As
shown in the figure, the system consists of a DC voltage source
(Vdc), a three- phase PWM inverter, an output filter (Lf and C with
considering parasitic resistance of filter- Rf). Sometimes a
transformer may be used for stepping up the output voltage and
hence Lf can be transformer inductance.
Figure PWM inverter diagram
There are two ways for controlling an inverter in a distributed
generation system
A. PQ Inverter Control
This type of control is adopted when the DG unit system is
connected to an external grid or to an island of loads and more
generators. In this situation, the variables controlled by the
inverter are the active and reactive power injected into the grid,
which have to follow the set points Pref and Qref, respectively.
These set points can be chosen by the customer or by a central
controller. The PQ control of an inverter can be performed using a
current control technique in qd reference frame which the inverter
current is controlled in amplitude and phase to meet the desired
set-points of active and reactive power.With the aim of Park
transform and equations between inverter input and output, the
inverter controller block diagram for supplying reference value of
Pref and Qref is as figures. For the current controller, two
Proportional-Integral (PI) regulators have been chosen in order to
meet the requirements of stability of the system and to make the
steady state error be zero. With this control scheme, it is
possible to control the inverter in such way that injects reference
value of Pref, Qref into other part of stand-alone network. When
the output voltage is needed to be regulated, the PV control scheme
that is similar to PQ mode with feedback of voltage used to adjust
Qref.
Figure : PQ control scheme of inverter
B. Vf Inverter ControlThis controller has to act on the inverter
whenever the system is in stand-alone mode of operation. In fact in
this case it must regulate the voltage value at a reference bus bar
and the frequency of the whole grid. A regulators work in order to
keep the measured voltages upon the set points. Moreover the
frequency is imposed through the modulating signals of the inverter
PWM control by mean of an oscillator. A simple PI controller can
regulate bus voltage in reference value with getting feedback of
real bus voltage. Figure outlines this control strategy. In this
case it is obvious that the DG unit should have storage device in
order to regulate the power and voltage.
Figure: Vf control scheme of inverter
POWER QUALITYThe contemporary container crane industry, like
many other industry segments, is often enamored by the bells and
whistles, colorful diagnostic displays, high speed performance, and
levels of automation that can be achieved. Although these features
and their indirectly related computer based enhancements are key
issues to an efficient terminal operation, we must not forget the
foundation upon which we are building. Power quality is the mortar
which bonds the foundation blocks. Power quality also affects
terminal operating economics, crane reliability, our environment,
and initial investment in power distribution systems to support new
crane installations. To quote the utility company newsletter which
accompanied the last monthly issue of my home utility billing:
Using electricity wisely is a good environmental and business
practice which saves you money, reduces emissions from generating
plants, and conserves our natural resources. As we are all aware,
container crane performance requirements continue to increase at an
astounding rate. Next generation container cranes, already in the
bidding process, will require average power demands of 1500 to 2000
kW almost double the total average demand three years ago. The
rapid increase in power demand levels, an increase in container
crane population, SCR converter crane drive retrofits and the large
AC and DC drives needed to power and control these cranes will
increase awareness of the power quality issue in the very near
future.POWER QUALITY PROBLEMSFor the purpose of this article, we
shall define power quality problems as:Any power problem that
results in failure or misoperation of customer equipment manifests
itself as an economic burden to the user, or produces negative
impacts on the environment.When applied to the container crane
industry, the power issues which degrade power quality include:
Power Factor Harmonic Distortion Voltage Transients Voltage Sags or
Dips Voltage SwellsThe AC and DC variable speed drives utilized on
board container cranes are significant contributors to total
harmonic current and voltage distortion. Whereas SCR phase control
creates the desirable average power factor, DC SCR drives operate
at less than this. In addition, line notching occurs when SCRs
commutate, creating transient peak recovery voltages that can be 3
to 4 times the nominal line voltage depending upon the system
impedance and the size of the drives. The frequency and severity of
these power system disturbances varies with the speed of the drive.
Harmonic current injection by AC and DC drives will be highest when
the drives are operating at slow speeds. Power factor will be
lowest when DC drives are operating at slow speeds or during
initial acceleration and deceleration periods, increasing to its
maximum value when the SCRs are phased on to produce rated or base
speed. Above base speed, the power factor essentially remains
constant. Unfortunately, container cranes can spend considerable
time at low speeds as the operator attempts to spot and land
containers. Poor power factor places a greater kVA demand burden on
the utility or engine-alternator power source. Low power factor
loads can also affect the voltage stability which can ultimately
result in detrimental effects on the life of sensitive electronic
equipment or even intermittent malfunction. Voltage transients
created by DC drive SCR line notching, AC drive voltage chopping,
and high frequency harmonic voltages and currents are all
significant sources of noise and disturbance to sensitive
electronic equipmentIt has been our experience that end users often
do not associate power quality problems with Container cranes,
either because they are totally unaware of such issues or there was
no economic Consequence if power quality was not addressed. Before
the advent of solid-state power supplies, Power factor was
reasonable, and harmonic current injection was minimal. Not until
the crane Population multiplied, power demands per crane increased,
and static power conversion became the way of life, did power
quality issues begin to emerge. Even as harmonic distortion and
power Factor issues surfaced, no one was really prepared. Even
today, crane builders and electrical drive System vendors avoid the
issue during competitive bidding for new cranes. Rather than focus
on Awareness and understanding of the potential issues, the power
quality issue is intentionally or unintentionally ignored. Power
quality problem solutions are available. Although the solutions are
not free, in most cases, they do represent a good return on
investment. However, if power quality is not specified, it most
likely will not be delivered.
Power quality can be improved through: Power factor correction,
Harmonic filtering, Special line notch filtering, Transient voltage
surge suppression, Proper earthing systems.In most cases, the
person specifying and/or buying a container crane may not be fully
aware of the potential power quality issues. If this article
accomplishes nothing else, we would hope to provide that
awareness.In many cases, those involved with specification and
procurement of container cranes may not be cognizant of such
issues, do not pay the utility billings, or consider it someone
elses concern. As a result, container crane specifications may not
include definitive power quality criteria such as power factor
correction and/or harmonic filtering. Also, many of those
specifications which do require power quality equipment do not
properly define the criteria. Early in the process of preparing the
crane specification: Consult with the utility company to determine
regulatory or contract requirements that must be satisfied, if any.
Consult with the electrical drive suppliers and determine the power
quality profiles that can be expected based on the drive sizes and
technologies proposed for the specific project. Evaluate the
economics of power quality correction not only on the present
situation, but consider the impact of future utility deregulation
and the future development plans for the terminalTHE BENEFITS OF
POWER QUALITYPower quality in the container terminal environment
impacts the economics of the terminal operation, affects
reliability of the terminal equipment, and affects other consumers
served by the same utility service. Each of these concerns is
explored in the following paragraphs.1. Economic ImpactThe economic
impact of power quality is the foremost incentive to container
terminal operators. Economic impact can be significant and manifest
itself in several ways:
a. Power Factor PenaltiesMany utility companies invoke penalties
for low power factor on monthly billings. There is no industry
standard followed by utility companies. Methods of metering and
calculating power factor penalties vary from one utility company to
the next. Some utility companies actually meter kVAR usage and
establish a fixed rate times the number of kVAR-hours consumed.
Other utility companies monitor kVAR demands and calculate power
factor. If the power factor falls below a fixed limit value over a
demand period, a penalty is billed in the form of an adjustment to
the peak demand charges. A number of utility companies servicing
container terminal equipment do not yet invoke power factor
penalties. However, their service contract with the Port may still
require that a minimum power factor over a defined demand period be
met. The utility company may not continuously monitor power factor
or kVAR usage and reflect them in the monthly utility billings;
however, they do reserve the right to monitor the Port service at
any time. If the power factor criteria set forth in the service
contract are not met, the user may be penalized, or required to
take corrective actions at the users expense. One utility company,
which supplies power service to several east coast container
terminals in the USA, does not reflect power factor penalties in
their monthly billings, however, their service contract with the
terminal reads as follows:The average power factor under operating
conditions of customers load at the point where service is metered
shall be not less than 85%. If below 85%, the customer may be
required to furnish, install and maintain at its expense corrective
apparatus which will increase thePower factor of the entire
installation to not less than 85%. The customer shall ensure that
no excessive harmonics or transients are introduced on to the
[utility] system. This may require special power conditioning
equipment or filters.The Port or terminal operations personnel, who
are responsible for maintaining container cranes, or specifying new
container crane equipment, should be aware of these requirements.
Utility deregulation will most likely force utilities to enforce
requirements such as the example above.Terminal operators who do
not deal with penalty issues today may be faced with some rather
severe penalties in the future. A sound, future terminal growth
plan should include contingencies for addressing the possible
economic impact of utility deregulation.b. System LossesHarmonic
currents and low power factor created by nonlinear loads, not only
result in possible power factor penalties, but also increase the
power losses in the distribution system. These losses are not
visible as a separate item on your monthly utility billing, but you
pay for them each month. Container cranes are significant
contributors to harmonic currents and low power factor. Based on
the typical demands of todays high speed container cranes,
correction of power factor alone on a typical state of the art quay
crane can result in a reduction of system losses that converts to a
6 to 10% reduction in the monthly utility billing. For most of the
larger terminals, this is a significant annual saving in the cost
of operation.C. Power Service Initial Capital InvestmentsThe power
distribution system design and installation for new terminals, as
well as modification of systems for terminal capacity upgrades,
involves high cost, specialized, high and medium voltage equipment.
Transformers, switchgear, feeder cables, cable reel trailing
cables, collector bars, etc. must be sized based on the kVA demand.
Thus cost of the equipment is directly related to the total kVA
demand. As the relationship above indicates, kVA demand is
inversely proportional to the overall power factor, i.e. a lower
power factor demands higher kVA for the same kW load. Container
cranes are one of the most significant users of power in the
terminal. Since container cranes with DC, 6 pulse, SCR drives
operate at relatively low power factor, the total kVA demand is
significantly larger than would be the case if power factor
correction equipment were supplied on board each crane or at some
common bus location in the terminal. In the absence of power
quality corrective equipment, transformers are larger, switchgear
current ratings must be higher, feeder cable copper sizes are
larger, collector system and cable reel cables must be larger, etc.
Consequently, the cost of the initial power distribution system
equipment for a system which does not address power quality will
most likely be higher than the same system which includes power
quality equipment. 2. Equipment ReliabilityPoor power quality can
affect machine or equipment reliability and reduce the life of
components. Harmonics, voltage transients, and voltage system sags
and swells are all power quality problems and are all
interdependent. Harmonics affect power factor, voltage transients
can induce harmonics, the same phenomena which create harmonic
current injection in DC SCR variable speed drives are responsible
for poor power factor, and dynamically varying power factor of the
same drives can create voltage sags and swells. The effects of
harmonic distortion, harmonic currents, and line notch ringing can
be mitigated using specially designed filters.3. Power System
AdequacyWhen considering the installation of additional cranes to
an existing power distribution system, a power system analysis
should be completed to determine the adequacy of the system to
support additional crane loads. Power quality corrective actions
may be dictated due to inadequacy of existing power distribution
systems to which new or relocated cranes are to be connected. In
other words, addition of power quality equipment may render a
workable scenario on an existing power distribution system, which
would otherwise be inadequate to support additional cranes without
high risk of problems.4. EnvironmentNo issue might be as important
as the effect of power quality on our environment. Reduction in
system losses and lower demands equate to a reduction in the
consumption of our natural nm resources and reduction in power
plant emissions. It is our responsibility as occupants of this
planet to encourage conservation of our natural resources and
support measures which improve our air quality.
ACTIVE POWER FILTERSActive Filters are commonly used for
providing harmonic compensation to a system by controlling current
harmonics in supply networks at the low to medium voltage
distribution level or for reactive power or voltage control at high
voltage distribution level. These functions may be combined in a
single circuit to achieve the various functions mentioned above or
in separate active filters which can attack each aspect
individually. The block diagram presented in section shows the
basic sequence of operation for the active filter. This diagram
shows various sections of the filter each responding to its own
classification. Classification of active filters The block diagram
shown in figure represents the key components of a typical active
power filter along with their interconnections. The reference
signal estimator monitors the harmonic current from the nonlinear
load along with information about other system variables. The
reference signal from the current estimator, as well as other
signals, drives the overall system controller. This in turn
provides the control for the PWM switching pattern generator. The
output of the PWM pattern generator controls the power circuit
through a suitable interface. The power circuit in the generalized
block diagram can be connected in parallel, series or
parallel/series configurations, depending on the transformer
used.
Active power filters according to can be classified based on the
following criteria: 1. Power rating and speed of response required
in compensated systems; 2. Power-circuit configuration and
connections; 3. System parameters to be compensated; 4. Control
techniques employed; and 5. Technique used for estimating the
reference current/voltage. Classification according to power rating
and speed of response in compensated system The block diagram shown
in figure shows the classification based on this criterion. The
size of nonlinear loads play a major role in deciding the way
different control methods are implemented. The filter required for
compensation must be practical for the load and this decision
affects the speed of response. In general a reciprocal relationship
exists between the cost of a particular system to the required
speed of response.
Low power applications Low power applications govern
applications with a power rating below 100kVA. Applications of
these sizes are generally associated with residential areas,
commercial buildings, hospitals and for a wide range of medium
sized factory loads and motor drive systems. Active filters chosen
for this power range employ sophisticated techniques catering with
high pulse number PWM voltage or current source inverters. The
response time for smaller applications is relatively much faster
than other sizes ranging from ten microseconds to ten milliseconds.
This type comprises the following two categories. Single-phase
systems Low power rating loads generally require single phase
active filters. They are generally most employed in commercial
buildings with a large number of computers. This application means
that current harmonics can be treated at the point of common
coupling (PCC). It is often economical and practical to install
single phase active filters on distribution based sites of reduced
size capacity than a larger rated filter installed upstream. This
is due to the large number of the single-phase loads within one
building and the harmful consequences associated with the presence
of large amounts of harmonic in the neutral line. This allows for
more selective compensation as the operating conditions vary. Due
to the load capacity drawn from residential loads, it is rare for a
high concentration of harmonics, and thus the impacts on the
neutral lines are not significant. Residential customers tend not
invest in purchasing active filters because there are no compulsory
harmonic regulations however, the main advantage of such an
installation are that operating frequencies can be increased moving
to improved performance since only low ratings are employed.
Three-phase systems The installation of three-phase filters is used
for three-phase applications. Different filter configurations can
be tested and installed based upon whether the loads are balanced
or unbalanced. At levels below 100kVA, a three phase filter can be
reconfigured to compensate for three individual single phases in
one unit or for a single three-phase supply. When nonlinear loads
are balanced, meaning all three phased impedances are equal, a
single three-phase-inverter configuration is employed. This choice
of inverter is used when the objective is to eliminate as many
current harmonics as possible, assuming that the magnitudes and
respective phase angles in each phase are the same. In the
situation when nonlinear loads are unbalanced, or supply voltages
are unsymmetrical, three single phase inverter circuits are used.
Medium power applications Power systems ranging between 100kVA to
10MVA fit the class of a medium power application. Due to the fact
that phase unbalances are reduced on this sized system, the major
objective is to eliminate current harmonics. In general, capacitive
and Inductive static compensators, line-commutated thyristor
converters, synchronous condensers and cascaded multilevel-inverter
VAR compensators, are often more economic as reactive power
compensation using active filters often is not viable. This is due
to the high voltage as well as problems with isolation and
series/parallel connection of switches. The speed of response
expected in this range is of the order of tens of milliseconds.
High power applications At high power ratings, the use of active
filters becomes very uneconomical. This is because of the lack of
high switching frequency power devices that can control the current
flow. Thus, this is a major disadvantage for such systems. In
addition, even the latest advances in semiconductor technology
still fall short as extra high voltages of a few hundred kilovolts
cannot be tolerated. The series-parallel combination is possible
however; implementation is difficult and also cost-ineffective.
Harmonic pollution upstream affecting high power ranges above 10MVA
is not such a problem compared against low power systems. The
implementation of single and three phase filters downstream at the
low voltage system provides suitable compensation such that
significant harmonic pollution upstream is minimal. The static-VAR
compensation is then the major concern and is usually compensated
for by using traditional static power conditioners/filters as well
as several sets of synchronous condensers connected in parallel and
cascaded multilevel-inverter VAR compensators. The required
response time for such cases is in the range of tens of seconds,
which is sufficient for contactors and circuit breakers to operate
after taking the optimal-switching decision. Power fluctuations in
the range of a few seconds are, on the other hand, treated by the
generating stations' ancillary devices. Classification according to
power circuit, configurations and connections The choice of power
circuit chosen for the active filter greatly influences its
efficiency and accuracy in providing true compensation. It is
therefore important that the correct circuit configuration is
chosen. Figure 3.3 classes three major types of filter structures
along with the relevant power circuit.
Shunt active filters Shunt active filters are by far the most
widely accept and dominant filter of choice in most industrial
processes. Figures show the system configuration of the shunt
design. The active filter is connected in parallel at the PCC and
is fed from the main power circuit. The objective of the shunt
active filter is to supply opposing harmonic current to the
nonlinear load effectively resulting in a net harmonic current.
This means that the supply signals remain purely fundamental. Shunt
filters also have the additional benefit of contributing to
reactive power compensation and balancing of three-phase currents.
Since the active filter is connected in parallel to the PCC, only
the compensation current plus a small amount of active fundamental
current is carried in the unit. For an increased range of power
ratings, several shunt active filters can be combined together to
withstand higher currents. This configuration consists of four
distinct categories of circuit, namely inverter configurations,
switched-capacitor circuits, lattice-structured filters and
voltage-regulator-type
Series active filters The objective of the series active filter
is to maintain a pure sinusoidal voltage waveform across the load.
This is achieved by producing a PWM voltage waveform which is added
or subtracted against the supply voltage waveform. The choice of
power circuit used in most cases is the voltage-fed PWM inverter
without a current minor loop. The active filter acts as a voltage
source and thus it is often a preferred solution of harmonic
producing loads such as large capacity diode rectifiers with
capacitive loads. In general, series active filters are less
commonly used against the shunt design. Unlike the shunt filter
which carries mainly compensation current, the series circuit has
to handle high load currents. This causes an increased rating of
the filter suitable to carry the increased current. Series filters
offer the main advantage over the shunt configuration of achieving
ac voltage regulation by eliminating voltage-waveform harmonics.
This means the load contains a pure sinusoidal waveform.
Other combinations In some cases, the combinations of shunt and
series active filters provide a greater effectiveness in
eliminating harmonic pollution from the system. Combination of both
shunt and series active filters The diagram shown in figure shows
the combination of both parallel and series active filters. This
system combines both the benefits of the shunt and series and is
often used to achieve the demanding power system requirements. The
control of active filters can be complex. A combination of the two
provides an even greater complexity. The higher cost involved in a
more complex design has shown a reduced demand for the combined
structure. As a result of the increased cost and complexity, this
combination has received less attention than other configurations.
Flexible AC transmission systems, commonly abbreviated as FACTS
regularly make use of the arrangement. Combination of series active
and shunt passive filters The combination of the active parallel
and active series filters in 3.4.3.1 was seen to be very complex in
control yielding a high cost. One method of reducing these problems
was to replace the parallel active filter with a passive structure.
The series active filter, which constitutes high impedance for
high-frequency harmonics, is accompanied by a parallel passive
filter to provide a path for the harmonic currents of the load.
This combination, represented by figure, permits an improvement
over the characteristics of plain series active filters and the
extension of their capabilities to include current- harmonic
reduction and voltage- harmonic elimination. Passive filters are
often easier and simple to implement and do not require any control
circuit. This, this deserves to be most beneficial.
Combination of shunt active and passive filters Shunt active
filters are best suitable to compensate for lower order harmonics
thus only requiring low power rating which serves most economical.
This configuration makes use of a passive filter which serves to
compensate for the high order load current harmonics. This
combination, represented by figure presents this important
configuration. Combinations such as this can be designed to
compensate for higher powers without excessive costs for high-power
switching. The major disadvantage of this configuration is the fact
that passive filters can only be tuned for a specific predefined
harmonic and thus cannot be easily changed for loads which have
varying harmonics.
Active filter in series with shunt passive filters The
combination of an active filter in series with a shunt passive
filter is considered a significant design configuration for medium
and high voltage applications. The passive filter is designed to
reduce the voltage stress applied to the switches in the active
filter. This design is in its infancy of development however,
further research is still needed to assess the effectiveness of the
configuration.
Classification according to compensated variable Active filters
are designed to provide suitable compensation for a particular
variable or a multiple of sorts in cases of combination structures.
Figure shows the variety of compensated variable that active
filters can provide for.
Reactive power compensation The shunt active filter does provide
reactive power compensation however; they rarely treat the problem
of power-factor correction on its own owing to the fact that other
quasidynamic, cheaper and slower-in-response reactive-power
compensators are available in the market. When this technique is
applied, lower power applications are more suited since the
currents needed for reactive-power compensation are of the same
order of magnitude as the rated current of the load. It would be a
waste of sophisticated equipment to tackle them without the use of
other power factor-correction devices, such as thyristor-controlled
reactors and capacitors; especially in single-phase systems, where
in certain specific applications the requirement is for accurate
compensation without harmonics generation.Harmonic compensation
Within the system, active filters can be used to provide suitable
harmonic compensation for voltage harmonics and current harmonics.
These harmonic are the most important variable requiring
compensation. Compensation of voltage harmonics In general, the
concern for compensating voltage harmonics is not high due to the
fact that power supplies usually have low impedance. Generally, at
the point of common coupling, ridged standards are implemented to
ensure a correct level of total harmonic distortion (THD) and
voltage regulation is maintained. The problem of compensating for
voltage harmonics is to ensure the supply to be purely sinusoidal.
This is important for harmonic voltage sensitive devices such as
power system protection devices and superconducting magnetic energy
storage. Voltage harmonics are related to current harmonics by the
impedance of the line. Although compensation of voltage harmonics
helps to provide a reduction in current harmonics, this however,
does not negate the necessity to current harmonic compensation.
Compensation of current harmonics Current harmonic compensation
strategies are exceptionally important. Current harmonics are
greatly reduced by the compensation of voltage harmonics at the
consumers point of common coupling. The reduction in current
harmonics is not only important for reasons such as device heating
and reduction in life of devices but also in design of power system
equipment. One of the major design criteria covers the magnitude of
the current and its waveform. This is to reduce cable and feeder
losses. Since the root mean square (RMS) of the load current
incorporates the sum of squares of individual harmonics, true
current harmonic compensation will aid system designers for better
approached power rating equipment. Balancing of three phase systems
In most low and medium voltage distribution systems, it is frequent
to find situations where the currents and voltages in the three
phases are not balanced and are not evenly distributed by 120
degrees. Balancing of mains voltage in three phase systems Voltage
imbalance is a situation where each phase voltage is unequal in
magnitude and is not displaced by 120 degrees. This is a direct
result of current imbalances and the severity of the system
imbalances is governed by the magnitude of the supply impedance.
The solution to this problem is to add or subtract the
corresponding amount of instantaneous voltage to force it to follow
the reference sinusoidal waveform. On high voltage systems, the
supply impedance does not impact severely on system performance and
thus the problem of mains voltage unbalances are primarily related
to low rating systems. Balancing of mains current in three phase
systems In low power applications such as compensating for
residential loads, the magnitude of currents supplied to the grid
depends entirely upon the level of imbalance in the system. In most
cases, the compensator would be forced to supply rated current.
This places a limitation on the power handling capability.Multiple
compensationTo target a variety of variables requiring
compensation, often it is usual to combine different combinations
to improve the effectiveness of the filter. The following are the
most frequently used combinations. Harmonic current with reactive
power compensation One very common filter design makes use of
combining aspects of reactive power compensation together with
harmonic current elimination. This ensures the supply current
remains purely fundamental free from distributing harmonics whilst
making certain the current is in phase with the supply voltage.
This approach is very cost effective because only one device is
used for all aspects rather than including multiple circuits for
each individual objective. The active filter used here however,
suffers from poor power switching limits and thus can only serve as
a compensator for low powered applications. Harmonic voltages with
reactive power compensation This combination, however rare, takes
place in certain configurations for controlling the voltage
harmonics, which would normally affect indirectly (using suitable
feedback) the reactive-power compensation. This compensation system
is only suitable for low-power applications. Harmonic current and
voltages To compensate for both current and voltage system
harmonics, a shunt and series active filter configuration must be
used respectively. Integrating this filter serves to eliminate load
harmonics whilst ensuring the supply remains fundamental. This type
of design contains very complex control algorithms and is normally
used only for very sensitive devices such as
power-system-protection equipment and superconducting
magnetic-energy storage systems. Harmonic current and voltages with
reactive power compensation This filter design incorporates all
three compensating variables into one unit. It controls all
harmonics and reactive power within the system. This is achieved by
implementing of a parallel/series active filter combination. The
control for this design is very complex and difficult to maintain
and thus is not often employed.
Classification based upon control technique Figure presents the
basic control structure for active power system filters. The two
main techniques are open look control and closed loop control.
Open loop systems Open-loop systems sense the load current and
the harmonics it contains. They inject a fixed amount of power in
the form of current (mainly reactive) into the system, which may
compensate for most of the harmonics and/or reactive power
available. Since there is no feedback loop on this system, there is
no reference to check the performance and accuracy of the filter.
This is a traditional technique and in present day is not often
used. Closed loop systems Closed loop control systems incorporate a
feedback loop providing greater accuracy of current injection for
harmonic compensation as well as reactive power reduction well over
the open loop design. This feature enables true sensing of the
required variables under consideration. Almost all new techniques
in use are of this type.
Constant capacitor voltage technique In this technique, the DC
link contains a capacitor and once charged, this capacitor voltage
is the voltage source which controls the current waveform by PWM
techniques. The voltage across the terminals of the capacitor often
fluctuates due to the fact that energy is either supplied or
expelled. To regulate and maintain terminal voltage levels, a
reference voltage is chosen. The difference between the actual
capacitor voltage and the predefined reference voltage determines
the active component of power required to compensate for losses in
the filter. This error difference is added to the
current-controller error signal to determine the overall system
error to be processed by the current controller. This technique is
widely accepted and is very popular. Constant inductor current
technique The control replaces the use of the capacitor in the DC
link with an inductor. The system operates much the same as
mentioned in 3.6.2.1 however; the capacitor voltage is replaced
with the inductor current. This is achieved in two ways: (i)
current pulse-width modulation where like in the PWM provides the
required pulses to represent the average current signal and (ii)
current pulse amplitude modulation which is a new control method
provides the active filter with a basis for amplitude modulation
rather than solely the width. Optimization technique The
optimization procedure for switched-capacitor and lattice-filter
circuits is the same. The rate of rise of the current and the
amplitude depend mainly on the size of the capacitors and the
initial voltages on them. These factors are functions of the
switching patterns, and they provide considerable flexibility in
shaping the waveform of the current drawn by the filter. The key to
controlling these filter configurations is to determine the
appropriate switching function for the switches. The main task of
the system controller is to minimize a predetermined number of
individual load-current harmonics, in addition minimizing either
the THD or the fundamental component of the filter current.
However, this is not performed instantaneously. A time delay exists
between the detection of a change in the harmonic current and the
application of the new set of switching angles obtained from the
optimization procedure. This system is mainly suitable for constant
or slowly varying loads. Linear voltage control technique Series
active filters incorporating the additional benefit of voltage
regulation can be controlled using the linear voltage control
technique. Through regularly charging and discharging the capacitor
through linear control, the capacitor voltage can be regulated. The
reference capacitor voltage can be determined based upon the
harmonic reference. The charge in the supply loop of the circuit
and thus switching frequency can be controlled by the regular
variations of the capacitor voltage in contrast to the abrupt
changes in inverter voltage waveforms. This technique ensures that
the supply side receives no abrupt variation of voltage and this
reduces the amount of high-frequency harmonics injected into the
supply due to the presence of the PWM inverter. Other techniques
Other control techniques exist that simply provide small changes to
the aforementioned techniques, providing simply newer or better
performance over their predecessors. These techniques may include
the use of state of the art adaptive, predictive and sliding-mode
controllers, which are normally difficult to implement without the
use of Digital Signal Processing (DSP). These techniques can be
implemented in either the time domain or the frequency domain.
Active filters harmonic detection and extraction A shunt active
filter acts as a controllable harmonic current source. In
principle, harmonic compensation is achieved when the current
source is commanded to inject harmonic currents of the same
magnitude but opposite phase to the load harmonic currents. Before
the inverter can subtly inject opposing harmonic currents into the
power system, appropriate harmonic detection strategies must be
implemented to efficiently sense and determine the harmonic current
from the nonlinear load. Types of harmonic detection strategies
There are 3 different types of harmonic detection strategies used
to determine the current reference for the active filter. These are
1. Measuring the load harmonic current to be compensated and using
this as a reference command; 2. Measuring source harmonic current
and controlling the filter to minimize it; and 3. Measuring
harmonic voltage at the active filter point of common coupling
(PCC) and controlling the filter to minimize the voltage
distortion.
Load current sensing This method involves measurement of the
load current and subsequent extraction of its harmonic content
using a high pass filter scheme. The harmonic components, so
extracted, are adjusted for polarity and used as reference commands
for the current controller. This is explained with the help of
equation 3.1 and figure 3.14. Denoting the harmonic components of
the load current by, the describing equation for this strategy is
lhi
Source current sensing In this strategy, the source current is
measured and its harmonic component extracted. This is scaled by a
suitable controller, generally of the proportional type. The output
of the proportional controller is provided as a reference to the
current controller. This is schematically represented in figure and
analytically expressed by equation. Denoting the harmonic
components of the source current by shi, the describing equation
for this strategy is
Point of Common Coupling (PCC) voltage sensing This method
requires measurement of the harmonic component of the Point of
Common Coupling (PCC) voltage, e(t). The harmonic component is then
used to generate the current reference, after passing it through a
proportional controller. Schematically, it is represented in figure
and analytically expressed by equation Denoting the harmonic
components of the PCC voltage by, the describing equation for this
strategy is
Load current sensing and supply current sensing are suitable for
shunt active filters installed in the vicinity of one or more
harmonic producing loads by individual high-powered consumers. PCC
voltage sensing is suitable for shunt active filters, which will be
installed on distribution systems by utilities. Supply current
detection is the most basic harmonic detection method for series
active filters acting as a voltage source. Classification based
upon current/voltage reference estimation technique There are
numerous techniques each sub classified in figure which propose
methods to calculate and determine the appropriate compensating
reference current used for the active filter to pass to the PWM
inverter.
Current/voltage reference synthesis (continuous time-domain) In
this method, an analogue signal filter is applied at the supply
side to determine the current harmonics from the supply. This
technique is very simple and easy to implement however introduces
major amounts of magnitude and phase errors. High pass filter
method This method uses a high pass filter to pass high ordered
frequencies effectively removing low order components in the load
current signal. The filtered frequencies constitute the reference
portion. This technique however, is susceptible to noise as this is
undesired.Low pass filter method This method is favored in terms of
reference synthesis because unlike the high pass filter method, the
effects of noise in the filtered portion are suppressed. The
desired reference value is the harmonic component found in the load
current. This is determined by subtracting the low order frequency
component found from implementing a low pass filter from the total
load current. This presents the harmonic portion from the load
current waveform. This technique however, introduces large
magnitude and phase errors. Current/voltage reference calculation
(discrete time or frequency domain) The techniques mentioned have
many disadvantages to their use namely, phase and magnitude errors
as well as the effects of noise. The calculation of harmonics
therefore provides the most appropriate alternative. Two major
techniques are classified in either time domain or frequency
domain.
Time domain approaches The following seven subdivisions of
time-domain approaches are mainly used for three-phase systems
except for the fictitious-power-compensation technique which can be
adopted for single- or three-phase systems. The time-domain methods
are mainly used to gain more speed or fewer calculations compared
to the frequency-domain methods. Instantaneous reactive power
algorithm Instantaneous power theory determines the harmonic
distortion from the instantaneous power calculation in a
three-phase system, which is the multiplication of the
instantaneous values of the currents and voltages .
The values of the instantaneous power p and q, which are the
real and respective imaginary powers, contain dc and ac components
depending on the existing active, reactive and distorted powers in
the system. The dc components of p and q represent the active and
reactive powers and must be removed with high-pass filters to
retain only the ac signals. The ac components converted by an
inverse transformation matrix to the abc-frame represent the
harmonic distortion, which is given as the reference for the
current controller. These processes are depicted in figure.
This operation takes place only under the assumption that the
three-phase system is balanced and that the voltage waveforms are
purely sinusoidal. If, on the other hand, this technique is applied
to contaminated supplies, the resulting performance is proven to be
poor. Synchronous detection algorithm This technique relies in the
fact that the three phase currents are balanced. The average power
is calculated and divided equally between the three phases. The
signal is t