James Greyson 1 Last chance at the last minute? Making global whole systems change visible and possible ASSYST Florence mee4ng on 'Exploring the future in complex systems for decision‐making’ 13 th Feb 2012 If we do not change direc4on, we may end up where we are heading. Lao Tzu
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
o Thepuzzle:everythingisconnectedtoeverythingelse.
o Usethisconnectednesstoleveragechange.
o Seekleverage‘whereasmallshisinonethingcanproducebigchangesineverything’.DonellaMeadows,LeveragePoints,1999
JamesGreyson 10
Leversarebuiltintosystems
o Pa_ernsofconnectednessshapeoutcomesevenifwedon’tseethem.
o Newpa_ernsofconnectednessofferpoten4alevolu4onsofsystems,evenifwedon’tusethem.
o “Systemscanbeunderstoodbylookingforpa_ernswithintheircomplexity,pa_ernsthatdescribepoten4alevolu4onsofthesystem.”Dooley,K.(1996),“ANominalDefini4onofComplexAdap4veSystems,”TheChaosNetwork,8(1):2‐3.h_p://www.public.asu.edu/~kdooley/papers/casdef.PDF
JamesGreyson 11
Wholesystemlevers
o Leverslinktoreal‐worldoutcomes.o Leversareconnected,asinalock,so
o BasedonNATO‐publishedresearchfromtwoAdvancedResearchWorkshops.o Interna4onalacademicpeer‐review.Read>5k4mes.Discussion>3kcomments.Webthinktank>550people.o Policyswitchesareleversforglobalwholesystemchange.o Allareneededtosolveanymajorproblem.
JamesGreyson 14
Fromhoppingtorunning;afuturethatdoesn’tfallover
o Subsystemandwholesystemmethodsarelikefeet.Useboth.
o ‘Inthebroaderperspec4veofthesystemsapproachnoproblemcanbesolvedsimplyonitsownbasis.Everyproblemhasanenvironment,towhichitisinextricablyunited.’CWestChurchman
o Everysubsystemhasaglobalwholesystemtowhichitisinextricablylinked.
o Foodsecurityinvolvessolu4onsbothwithinandbeyondthefoodsubsystem.o Possibletoendhungerwithoutregenera4ngsoils,ecosystems,economies…?
o Na4onalsecurityinvolvessolu4onsbothwithinandbeyondthedefensesubsystem.o Possibletoachievesecurityanywherewithoutglobalsecurity?o Risingdefensespending=fallingsecurity.
JamesGreyson 16
TheGuardianJune25th1988
o Climateinstabilityisasystemicproblemwithsubsystemresponses.o Runawaychangecouldprecedeaneffec4veresponse.o ResponsessofarcomefromZoneA.‘Let’sfocusoncarbon.’‘Let’saimforwhatseemsrealis4c.’o TheZoneBsystemicresponseisyettobegin.
JamesGreyson 17
Day1ofaneffec4veresponse:frametheproblem
o ZoneAfocusoncuyngconcentra4onsnotjustemissions.Reverselossofsinks.
o ZoneBfocusonclimateassymptomofmul4‐issuedynamic.Fixthewhole.
o Egreshapetheglobaleconomy:h_p://climatecolab.org/web/guest/plans/‐/plans/contestId/4/planId/15101
o EgRevivesoils,ecosystems,climateandeconomiesbyreversinglinearcarbonflows:h_p://climatecolab.org/web/guest/plans/‐/plans/contestId/4/planId/14637
Climateisanout‐of‐the‐boxproblem
JamesGreyson 18
References
o ‘Weneedtoadvanceinamanagedway.Wetakeoneblockata4me.Otherwisewewillproducechaos.’h_p://www.environmentalgovernance.org/video/2010/05/quest‐for‐leadership/videoat12:45mins
o ‘Togethertheswitchesdefineaprac4calstrategyforglobalsecurity,foraseriousa_emptatrevivalofco‐opera4on,ecosystemsandprosperity.’Greyson2010,SevenPolicySwitchesforGlobalSecurity.NATOScienceProgramme.ISBN9048195675h_p://bit.ly/7switches
o ‘Energysecurity,climatestability,sustainabledevelopment,economicgrowthandna4onalsecurityarecodependentgoals;eitherallwillbeachievedornone.’Greyson2008,SystemicEconomicInstrumentsforEnergy,ClimateandGlobalSecurity.NATOScienceProgramme.ISBN9781402084928h_p://bit.ly/systemic
o ‘AnOutOfParadigmSpace(OOPS)todiscussop4onsthathaven’tbeenconsideredsimplybecausetheydidn’tfitintheprevailingsharedmentalmodels.’EarthSystemsGovernanceOp‐Ed.h_p://www.ieg.earthsystemgovernance.org/news/2011‐08‐19/interna4onal‐environmental‐governance‐paradigm‐governance
JamesGreyson 19
Thankyou!
o Endoftalko Remainingslidesoutlinethe7policyswitches
“The view that negative impacts are an inevitable consequence of development has blinded us to the obvious. We could design development to increase the size, health and resilience of natural systems, while improving human health and life quality.”
Prof Janis Birkeland
Positive Development. Earthscan 2008 My proposed economic tool is on page 339
o Curiosityisamissingingredientinbotheduca4onandpolicy‐making.
o “Whatwewanttoseeisthechildinpursuitofknowledgeandnotknowledgeinpursuitofthechild.”GeorgeBernardShaw
o Joined‐uplearningenablesjoined‐upengagedgroups/communi4es/society.
JamesGreyson 22
“Our enormously productive economy demands that we make consumption our way of life, that we convert the buying and use of goods into rituals, that we seek our spiritual satisfaction in consumption patterns. We need things consumed, burned up, replaced and discarded at an ever accelerating rate.”
Victor Lebow ‘Price Competition in 1955’, Journal of Retailing. USA, Spring 1955. Page 7
o Waste,toxics,pollu4onandGHGshouldnolongerbe‘managed’attheendofthepipe,whenit’stoolate.Everyphysicalproductthatissoldshouldbeinsuredtoaccountfortheriskofaddingtowastelevelsinecosystems.
o ‘Precyclingpremiums’forallproducts,largeandsmall,couldquicklyphaseoutwaste‐dependenceeverywhere.Arevivaloftheeconomy,ecosystemsandco‐opera4onwouldbecomeviable.
o Premiumswouldbepaidaccordingto‘wasterisk’.Premiumswouldbeinvestedtocutwasteriskbysuppor4ngprecycling,buildingtechnical,socialandecologicalcapacity.
o Producerscouldchoosehowtohandletheirresponsibility.Theycouldcuttheirpremiumsbyprecyclingornotbotherandpaymoretosupportprecyclingelsewhere.Customersandinvestorscouldchoose.