Top Banner
Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico April 20, 2002 Frans Pretorius UBC http://laplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/fransp/
14

Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico.

Dec 19, 2015

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico.

Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry

Collaborators:Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC

Eric Hircshmann, BYUSteve Liebling, LIU

APS MeetingAlbuquerque, New Mexico

April 20, 2002

Frans Pretorius UBC

http://laplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/fransp/

Page 2: Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico.

2

Outline

• Motivation

• Overview of the physical system

• Adaptive Mesh Refinement (AMR) in our numerical code

• Critical phenomena in axisymmetry

• Conclusion: “near” future extensions

Page 3: Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico.

3

Motivation

• Our immediate goal is to study critical behavior in axisymmetry:– massless, real scalar field– Brill waves– introduce angular momentum via a complex scalar

field

• Long term goals are to explore a wide range axisymmetric phenomena:– head-on black hole collisions– black hole - matter interactions– incorporate a variety of matter models, including

fluids and electromagnetism

Page 4: Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico.

4

and are the conjugates to and ,respectively

• Geometry:

• Matter: a minimally-coupled, massless scalar field

• All variables are functions of

• Kinematical variables:

• Dynamical variables:

Physical System

),,( zt

])(

)[(2222

24222

dedtdz

dtddtdsz

),,( z

),,,,(

Page 5: Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico.

5

Adaptive Mesh Refinement

• Our technique is based upon the Berger & Oliger algorithm

– Replace the single mesh with a hierarchy of meshes

– Recursive time stepping algorithm• Efficient use of resources in both space and time• Geared to the solution of hyperbolic-type equations• Use a combination of extrapolation and delayed solution for

elliptic equations

– Dynamical regridding via local truncation error estimates (calculated using a self-shadow hierarchy)

– Clustering algorithms:• The signature-line method of Berger and Rigoutsos (using a

routine written by R. Guenther, M. Huq and D. Choi) • Smallest, non-overlapping rectangular bounding boxes

Page 6: Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico.

6

2D Critical Collapse example• Initial data that is anti-symmetric about z=0:

Initial scalar field profile and grid hierarchy (2:1 coarsened in figure)

z

),,(),,( tztz

Page 7: Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico.

7

Anti-symmetric SF collapse

Scalar field

Weak field evolution

z

Page 8: Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico.

8

Anti-symmetric SF collapse

Scalar field

Near critical evolution

z

Page 9: Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico.

9

AMR grid hierarchy

17(+1), 2:1 refined levels

(2:1 coarsened in figure)

z

magnification factor = 1

Page 10: Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico.

10

17(+1), 2:1 refined levels

(2:1 coarsened in figure)

z

AMR grid hierarchy

magnification factor ~ 17

Page 11: Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico.

11

17(+1), 2:1 refined levels

(2:1 coarsened in figure)

z

AMR grid hierarchy

magnification factor ~ 130

Page 12: Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico.

12

17(+1), 2:1 refined levels

(2:1 coarsened in figure)

z

AMR grid hierarchy

magnification factor ~ 330

Page 13: Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico.

13

Page 14: Gravitational Collapse in Axisymmetry Collaborators: Matthew Choptuik, CIAR/UBC Eric Hircshmann, BYU Steve Liebling, LIU APS Meeting Albuquerque, New Mexico.

14

Conclusion

• “Near” future work

– More thorough study of scalar field critical parameter space

– Improve the robustness of the multigrid solver, to study Brill wave critical phenomena

– Include the effects of angular momentum

– Incorporate excision into the AMR code

– Add additional matter sources, including a complex scalar field and the electromagnetic field