Top Banner
Granulation, P Granulation, P - - Dynamics, and Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated for EBPR SBR operated for EBPR Ebru Dulekgurgen Ebru Dulekgurgen 08.06.04 (UIUC) 08.06.04 (UIUC) Background pictures: Unpublished data by E. Dulekgurgen (2004) Background pictures: Unpublished data by E. Dulekgurgen (2004)
15

Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

May 23, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

Granulation, PGranulation, P--Dynamics, and Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column Population Shifts in a Column

SBR operated for EBPR SBR operated for EBPR

Ebru DulekgurgenEbru Dulekgurgen08.06.04 (UIUC)08.06.04 (UIUC)Background pictures: Unpublished data by E. Dulekgurgen (2004)Background pictures: Unpublished data by E. Dulekgurgen (2004)

Page 2: Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

Column SBRColumn SBR

ColumnColumn--type SBR, H/D=74.4/7.2cmtype SBR, H/D=74.4/7.2cmVwVw = 3L = 3L ExchangeExchange =50%=50%QairQair = 150 L/hr= 150 L/hrPowerPoweraeraer =0.26 Watt =0.26 Watt GGaeraer = 208 sec= 208 sec--11

Influent: Influent: 400 mgCOD/L (acetate)400 mgCOD/L (acetate)17 mgPO17 mgPO44

--33--P/LP/LOperation:Operation:

2hr Anaerobic/ 3hr 44min Aerobic/12hr Anaerobic/ 3hr 44min Aerobic/1--5min settling5min settling

Page 3: Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

Column SBRColumn SBRInoculum (D01): Inoculum (D01):

EBPR biomass from CarlosEBPR biomass from Carlos’’s SBRs SBR

Granular Biomass (D99)Granular Biomass (D99)

Augmentation (D40Augmentation (D40--D47):D47):EBPR biomass from CarlosEBPR biomass from Carlos’’s SBRs SBR

Granulation strategy: Granulation strategy: High shear, low settling time (ts), High shear, low settling time (ts), slowslow--growers (PAOs)growers (PAOs)

Page 4: Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

Biomass/SettlingBiomass/Settling

ColSBR: SVI vs MLSS

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100

Time (days)

MLS

S (m

g/L)

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

SVI (

mL/

g)

MLSS (mg/L) SVI (mL/g)

ts5min

ts:1 min ts: 5min ts:1 min

Page 5: Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

ColSBR: Effluent SS

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100

Time (days)

Con

c. (m

g/L)

ts5min

ts:1 min ts: 5min ts:1 min

EffluentEffluent

Page 6: Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

CC--DynamicsDynamics

ColumnSBR: Carbon Removal

0

100

200

300

400

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100

Time (days)

Solu

ble

CO

D (m

g/L)

Effluent Anaerobic

Start-up

Augmentation1+2: Foaming and biofilm formation stoppped

ts5min

T:26oC 29oC 22oC 22oC 21oC

ts:1 min

Biomass washoutExtensive FOAMINGExtensive BIOFILM1st granulation

ts: 5min ts:1 min

After Augmentation:2nd granulationCycle profilesP-dynamics

Page 7: Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

POPO44--33--P DynamicsP Dynamics

ColumnSBR: PO4-3-P Removal

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100

Time (days)

PO4-3

-P (m

g/L)

Effluent Anaerobic

Start-up

Augmentation1+2: Foaming and biofilm formation stoppped

ts5min

T:26oC 29oC 22oC 22oC 21oC

ts:1 min

Biomass washoutExtensive FOAMINGExtensive BIOFILM1st granulation

ts: 5min ts:1 min

After Augmentation:2nd granulationCycle profilesP-dynamics

Page 8: Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

Column SBR: Extracellular Polysaccharides (ECP) and Extracellular Proteins (E Prot)

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

D01 D08 D39 C39 D56 D100Time (days)

Con

c. (m

g/L)

EPSac (mg glucose/L) EProt (mg BSA/L)

Extracellular polysaccharides and proteins per unit biomass

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

D01 D08 D39 C39 D56 D100Time (days)

Valu

es n

orm

aliz

ed to

MLV

SS

EPSac (mg glucose/mg MLVSS) EProt (mg BSA/mg MLVSS)

EPS EPS Extracellular polysaccharides and ProteinsExtracellular polysaccharides and Proteins

D01D01 : Inoculum: InoculumD08D08 : Before ts decreased to 1 min: Before ts decreased to 1 minD39D39 : Before augmentation: Before augmentationC39C39 : Biomass for augmentation (Carlos: Biomass for augmentation (Carlos’’s SBR)s SBR)D56D56 : Before ts decreased to 1 min: Before ts decreased to 1 minD100D100 : Granular biomass: Granular biomass

Page 9: Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

EPS EPS Extracellular polysaccharides and ProteinsExtracellular polysaccharides and Proteins

x8x8 x8x8 x10x10 x6x6

EPSac / EProt (mg glucose/mg BSA)57.0% 55.8%

39.5%41.9%

44.5%

38.7%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

D01 D08 D39 C39 D56 D100Time (days)

ECP/

E Pr

ot

Page 10: Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

TRFLP to Monitor the PopulationsTRFLP to Monitor the Populations

TRFLP? TRFLP? Terminal Restriction Fragment Length PolimorphismTerminal Restriction Fragment Length Polimorphism

Extract genomic DNAExtract genomic DNAAmplify region on SSU rDNA (PCR)Amplify region on SSU rDNA (PCR)Use FluoUse Fluo--labeled primer (PCR: *Eub338 and Univ1392a)labeled primer (PCR: *Eub338 and Univ1392a)Digest amplicons w/ restriction enzymesDigest amplicons w/ restriction enzymesElectrophore the digets Electrophore the digets

Page 11: Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

TRFLP to Monitor the PopulationsTRFLP to Monitor the Populations

ElectophorogramsElectophorograms

GoodGood

LowLow

Monomorphic!!Monomorphic!!

Polymorphic but;Polymorphic but;

Page 12: Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

TRFLP to Monitor the PopulationsTRFLP to Monitor the Populations

In silico TRFLP: Results of amplification and DigestionIn silico TRFLP: Results of amplification and Digestion

HaeIII-diversity

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

0 250 500 750 1000 1250 1500 1750 2000 2250 2500 2750 3000 3250 3500 3750 4000 4250 4500 4750 5000 5250 5500 5750 6000 6250 6500 6750 7000 7250 7500 7750 8000 8250 8500 8750 9000

Seq. Order

Frag

men

t Len

gth

Page 13: Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

TRFLP to Monitor the PopulationsTRFLP to Monitor the Populations

Electrophorogram for PAO population Electrophorogram for PAO population in the Column SBR (Day1in the Column SBR (Day1--18)18)

D1D1

D4D4

D8D8

D13D13

D18D18

Page 14: Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

Preliminary TRFLP ResultsPreliminary TRFLP Results

Significant Results for Significant Results for PAOs PAOs andand GAOsGAOs

PAOsPAOs

GAOsGAOs

130

1.37% 2.45%0 0

2.52%

15.99%

40.48%40.20%42.90%

4.05%

23.07%

16.21%

0 0 1.20% 0 0 1.51%0%5%

10%15%20%25%30%35%40%45%50%

D01 D04 D08 D13 D18 D20 D29 D34 D40 C40 D43 D45 D47 D50 D62 D70 D84 D98

Time (days)

% P

eak

Are

a

410+415

53.40%

35.81%41.93%

38.35%

1.33% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%

29.18%

18.56%

30.32%

45.83%

24.45%

43.24%

62.54%

54.75%

21.20%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

D01 D04 D08 D13 D18 D20 D29 D34 D40 C40 D43 D45 D47 D50 D62 D70 D84 D98

Time (days)

% P

eak

Are

a

Page 15: Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR …dulekgurgen/uiucppp.pdf · 2005-11-10 · Granulation, P-Dynamics, and Population Shifts in a Column SBR operated

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Eberhard Eberhard MORGENROTH, MORGENROTH, Lut Lut RASKIN, RASKIN, Julie Julie ZILLESZILLESRocky BARIONES, Dominic FRIGON, Adam Rocky BARIONES, Dominic FRIGON, Adam KLEIN, Carlos LOPEZ, Sudini PADMASIRI, Rob KLEIN, Carlos LOPEZ, Sudini PADMASIRI, Rob SANFORD, Chuanwu XISANFORD, Chuanwu XI..........and all the members of the ..........and all the members of the

MORGENROTH Group and RASKIN Group MORGENROTH Group and RASKIN Group

Nazik ARTAN, Derin ORHONNazik ARTAN, Derin ORHON