Project: Colossal Collisions
ChallengeA very large asteroid (called Etiam) that is capable of
destroying most life on Earth is headed our way. You and your team
are going to work together on preventing the impending collision of
Etiam with Earth. There are many different solutions to this
problem—each one has its own challenges and benefits. How you
decide to protect the Earth will depend on decisions that your
group makes using the information and concepts you develop over the
course of this project. Once your group makes a decision on what
your solution to save Earth is, your group will create a video news
segment that describes how you plan to prevent this impending
collision.
Background Data on EtiamShape: Etiam has been described as
having an irregular bone-shape.Length at longest point: 78 kmWidth
at thickest point: 20 km Width at thinnest point: 12 km
Mass:6,890,000,000,000,000 or 6.89 x 1015 kg
Speed: Etiam is travelling at 103,450 km/h.This speed is
relative to the Earth.
Location:Etiam is 104.7 million km from Earth and about 84
million km from the edge of the asteroid belt.
Day 1: Research historical evidence of asteroid impacts,
effects, and solutions:It is largely believed that about 65 million
years ago, a large asteroid collided with Earth, causing a huge
explosion and a cascade of worldwide effects – the most well-known
effect being the extinction of dinosaurs from our planet. Let’s
take a look at some of the evidence that scientists have
studied.
I. The fossil recordThe picture to the right shows layers of the
Earth, containing different fossils.
1) Compare the layers above and below the red line. How are they
different?
2) What do you think the red line represents?
II. Soil and fossil dataIridium, a common component of
asteroids, can be found in the 65 million year old soil layer at
many points around the world. You can see it to the right as the
lighter-colored rock layer.
The same soil layer contains grains of quartz (a type of rock)
that were deformed by high shock pressures, as would occur in a
giant explosion.
The same soil layer contains enough soot to correspond to
burning down all of the forests of the world. This suggests that
massive fires were touched off at the time of impact.
1. What soil evidence do scientists give for an asteroid
collision?
III. Analyzing Biodiversity over time
As scientists analyzed the fossil record, they took all the data
they gathered on marine organisms and created the graph below. It
shows the number of different kinds of marine organisms
(biodiversity) over time.
1.Does the number of different kinds of marine organisms stay
stable over time?
2.What do the red arrows represent?
3. What do you think are some possible causes for these dips in
biodiversity?
IV. Other historical asteroid impacts and their effects
Go online and research major asteroid impacts throughout
history. List some of them in the space below:
Go online and research the effects of asteroid impacts. List
some of them in the space below:
V. Possible solutions for an asteroid headed towards EarthGo
online and research. Then discuss with your group possible ways to
prevent an asteroid from hitting the Earth. List your ideas in the
space below:
Day 2 & 3: ExperimentsI. Determine how “asteroids” with
different masses impact “Earth”
# pennies knocked over in each trial
Type of marble
Trial 1
Trial 2
Trial 3
Trial 4
Trial 5
Average # of pennies knocked over (add 5 trials, then divide by
5)
Small
Medium
Large
1. What kind of energy does the marble have while in motion?
2. What are all the different forces acting on the pennies?
3. Where do we see Newton’s 1st law happening?
4. Where do we see Newton’s 3rd law happening?
II. Study the relationship between gravity, force, and crater
size
Directions: Drop each of the 3 marbles into the tray of sand
from a height of 50 cm. Measure the crater diameter (cm). Do 3
drops for each marble. Be sure to level the sand between drops.
Crater diameter (cm)
Type of marble
Drop 1
Drop 2
Drop 3
Average (add 3 drops, then divide by 3)
small
medium
large
1. Based on your data, which marble fell with the greatest
force? Do your results agree with Newton’s 2nd law which states
that Force = mass x acceleration?
2. What caused the marble to accelerate after you released
it?
Directions: Using only the medium sized marble, drop the marble
from a height of 25 cm, 75 cm, and 100 cm. Measure the crater
diameter (cm). Do 3 drops at each height.
Crater diameter (cm)
Height of drop
Drop 1
Drop 2
Drop 3
Average (add 3 drops, then divide by 3)
25 cm
75 cm
100 cm
3. What do you think caused the crater diameters to be different
at different heights?
III. Explore how the trajectory of an object can be affected by
the gravity of other objects
The plastic sheet represents a large area in space and the
marble represents an asteroid. Place the marble at the starting
point, release it, and watch it roll down the plastic sheet. Record
where the marble crosses the number line in the data table.
If objects in space get close to each other, the gravity of the
objects will affect each other’s trajectories. Let’s explore how
objects of different mass affect the trajectory of the asteroid
(marble). Block #1 represents a low mass object and block #2
represents a high mass object. Place block #1 at the “X”. Place the
marble at the starting point, release it, and watch it roll down
the plastic sheet. Record where the marble crosses the number line
at the bottom. Then repeat using block #2 at the “X” and record
results.
Now let’s see what happens when 2 high mass objects are near the
path of the asteroid (marble). Place block #2 at “X” and block #3
at “Y”. Place the marble at the starting point, release it, and
watch it roll down the plastic sheet. Record where the marble
crosses the number line at the bottom or if something else
happens.
Scenario
Crossed number line at…..
No other objects nearby
Block #1 (low mass) at “X”
Block #2 (high mass) at “X”
Block #2 (high mass) at “X” and Block #3 (high mass) at “Y”
1. Describe how low mass and high mass objects can affect the
trajectory of an asteroid differently.
2. Some astronomers refer to Jupiter as the “Defender of the
Solar System”. What do you think that means?
Day 4: Record a video news segment
It is highly recommended that you use iMovie on your iPad to
make your video. If you’re unfamiliar with iMovie, learn the basics
in a YouTube video such as one of these:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZSWD4-RekI&https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a7sjT_BySf8
Submit your completed video through Schoology (only 1 person
from each group need to submit).
Your news segment should:□ Explain the situation to the
public
□ Propose a solution □ How does your group plan to prevent a
collision between Etiam and the Earth? □ Show in a diagram and/or
video (possibly use pictures/video from the 3 experiments) □
Explain the science concepts you used to help create your plan □
Why did your group decide on this strategy instead of other
strategies? □ What are problems/concerns with your solution?
□ Have High Video News Segment Quality □ Includes a visual model
that shows how your solution works □ Is organized logically □ Is
interesting to the audience □ Practices good oral presentation
skills