1 Grade 6 Promotion Portfolio Manual 2010‐2011 NYC Department of Education May 2011
1
Grade 6
Promotion Portfolio Manual
2010‐2011
NYC Department of Education
May 2011
2
Table of Contents
PROMOTION PORTFOLIO OVERIVEW ............................................................................................. 3
PROCESS AND TIMELINE FOR GRADE 6 AUTOMATIC APPEALS ................................................... 4‐6
PROMOTION PORTFOLIO PROCESS OVERVIEW ................................................................................................ 4
AUTOMATIC APPEALS TIMELINE ...................................................................................................................... 5
WHO KEEPS THE PROMOTION PORTFOLIO? ..................................................................................................... 6
PROMOTION REVIEW SUMMARY SHEET ........................................................................................ 7
ELA PROMOTION PORTFOLIO .................................................................................................... 8‐25
LEVELED TEXT ................................................................................................................................................. 9
STANDARD READING PASSAGES ............................................................................................................... 10‐22
INDEPENDENT WRITING ACTIVITY ............................................................................................................ 23‐24
ELA CLASS WORK .......................................................................................................................................... 25
MATHEMATICS PROMOTION PORTFOLIO ............................................................................... 26‐40
MATHEMATICAL INVENTORY ................................................................................................................... 27‐34
STANDARD MATH PROBLEMS .................................................................................................................. 35‐39
MATHEMATICS CLASS WORK ........................................................................................................................ 40
EXAMPLES OF HIGH LEVEL 2 DESIGNATIONS ............................................................................... 41
AUGUST UPDATE: GRADE 6 PROMOTION REVIEW SUMMARY SHEET .................................... 42‐44
OVERVIEW ............................................................................................................................................... 42‐43
AUGUST UPDATE SHEET (FOR DUPLICATION) ........................................................................................... 43‐44
3
Promotion Portfolio Overview
Promotion Portfolio Overview
To be promoted, grade 6 students held to standard promotion criteria must:
Score Level 2 or higher on both the State English Language Arts (ELA) and Mathematics
assessments.
Students who do not meet the New York City Promotion Standard on the State ELA and/or Mathematics
tests are given the opportunity to demonstrate performance comparable to Level 2 through a
mandatory, automatic appeal in the form of a promotion portfolio. A promotion portfolio is a
standardized set of ELA or math activities that schools administer to students who do not meet their
promotion standard.
This Promotion Portfolio Manual is designed to provide information to grade 6 teachers and
administrators about the automatic appeals process for all students who did not meet
promotion standards on the grade 6 State ELA and/or Mathematics tests. This manual includes:
o The process and timeline for grade 6 promotion automatic appeals
o Step‐by‐step instructions for administering the promotion portfolio
o Criteria used to determine whether the student’s overall promotion portfolio
performance is comparable to Level 1, Level 2, or High Level 2 in ELA and mathematics
The accompanying Promotion Portfolio Blackline Masters contains all materials used by students
during the administration of the promotion portfolio as well as any sheets on which teachers
need to write. The Promotion Portfolio Blackline Masters should be duplicated for each student
as needed.
ELA Promotion Portfolio Components
Students who do not meet the New York City Promotion Standard on the State ELA test are
administered the ELA promotion portfolio, which has four components:
Leveled Text: Reading record for a Level T book (using Fountas and Pinnell levels) selected from
the classroom library
Standard Reading Passages: Evaluates reading comprehension using two of the standard
comprehension passages in this manual
Independent writing activity: Piece of student writing created for the promotion portfolio
Class work: One piece of ELA class work included to reflect the student’s current performance
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio Components
Students who do not meet the New York City Promotion Standard on the State Mathematics test are
administered the mathematics promotion portfolio, which has three components:
Mathematical Inventory: Evaluates mastery of mathematical and computational skills
Standard Math Problems: Evaluates basic math problem‐solving skills
Class work: One piece of mathematics class work included to reflect the student’s current
performance
4
Process and Timeline for Grade 6 Automatic Appeals
Process and Timeline for Grade 6 Automatic Appeals
Through an automatic appeals process, grade 6 students who do not meet the New York City Promotion
Standard on the State ELA and/or Mathematics test will be assessed using a promotion portfolio.
Promotion Portfolio Process Overview
June
In June, teachers will create a promotion portfolio and complete the “Grade 6 Promotion Summary
Sheet,” which schools must print from the PPSC screen in ATS, for grade 6 students who did not meet
promotion standards the State ELA and/or Mathematics test(s). Teachers will administer and score the
promotion portfolio using the guidelines outlined in this manual. Students who perform comparable to
High Level 2 on their promotion portfolio are eligible to be recommended for promotion in June; all
other students are encouraged to attend summer school.
August
For students who do not attain a Level 2 on the New York City Summer test(s) taken in August, the
principal reviews the promotion portfolio submitted in June. Summer school work and the summer
school teacher’s observations may be added to students’ portfolios using the “August Update: Grade 6
Promotion Review Summary Sheet” (included in this manual). If, in the principal’s judgment, a student
has attained performance comparable to Level 2, the principal submits a recommendation of promotion
to the community superintendent.
In addition, a student will not be promoted if the principal determines that the student is not ready for
seventh grade academic courses, based upon student work, teacher observation, and grades in sixth
grade academic courses.
For additional information about the New York City Promotion Policy, please visit the promotion page on the Principals’ Portal (http://intranet.nycboe.net/DOEPortal/Principals/) and refer to the 2010‐2011 Promotion Guide and Chancellor’s Regulation A‐501, Promotion Standards.
5
Process and Timeline for Grade 6 Automatic Appeals
Automatic Appeals Timeline
The timeline for the automatic appeals process is outlined in the table below:
Date Task/Activity Completed By:
By June 15 Promotion Portfolio Assembly: Schools print a “Promotion Portfolio
Summary Sheet” from the PPSC screen in ATS for all students at risk of
not meeting promotion standards on one or both State tests.
The teacher administers a promotion portfolio to these students and
determines whether students are performing comparable to High Level 2,
Level 2, or Level 1. The teacher submits the promotion portfolio to the
principal for every student who might not meet promotion standards.
Teachers
By June 15 Promotion Portfolio Review: The principal reviews the promotion
portfolios of all students who do not meet promotion standards on one
or both State tests and scans these students’ “Promotion Portfolio
Summary Sheets” into ATS to populate promotion portfolio results on the
UPSC screen in ATS. Principals may recommend promotion for only
students whose performance is comparable to High Level 2 and forward
only High Level 2 promotion portfolios to community superintendents.
Principals
By June 17 Final Promotion Decisions: The community superintendent reviews
promotion recommendations from principals and makes the final
promotion decision.
Community
superintendents
June 20 Parent Notification: After final promotion decisions are made, schools
mail promotion letters to notify parents that students have not met the
required promotion standards and are encouraged to attend summer
school.
Principals
By August 4 Summer School Evidence: Teachers complete the “August Update:
Promotion Review Summary Sheet” to include evidence of summer
school work in each student’s promotion portfolio.
Teachers
Math: August 8
ELA: August 9
Make‐up: August 10
New York City Summer Tests Administered: New York City Summer ELA
and Mathematics tests are administered to give students an additional
opportunity to meet their required promotion standards.
Summer school
staff
August 11‐12 Promotion Portfolio Review: For students not attaining Level 2 on the
required New York City Summer test(s) taken in August, the principal
reviews the previously submitted promotion portfolio, New York City
Summer test score(s), summer school work and the summer school
teacher’s observations. If, in the principal’s judgment, a student has
attained performance that is comparable to Level 2, the principal may
submit a recommendation of promotion to the community
superintendent.
Principals
By August 19 Final Promotion Decisions: The community superintendent reviews
promotion recommendations from principals and makes the final
promotion decision.
Community
superintendents
Week of August 22 Parent Notification: After final promotion decisions are made, parent
notification letters are mailed centrally to notify all parents of students
who did not meet the required promotion standards in June of their
child’s final promotion decision.
Central
6
Process and Timeline for Grade 6 Automatic Appeals
Note: Schools must keep promotion portfolios for their records and as evidence supporting promotion decisions.
Consequently, promotion portfolios should be kept at the school and should not be given to students’ families.
Who Keeps the Promotion Portfolio?
Numerous people will review the promotion portfolio during June and August promotion decision
periods. The table below outlines the processes of who should keep the promotion portfolio at any
given time. Following these processes will help ensure that students’ promotion portfolios are
always readily accessible when they are needed as evidence to support a promotion decision.
Note: Each superintendent will outline the logistics for delivering the portfolios to and from district
offices and between summer school and home school sites.
June Teacher prepares
promotion portfolio
(May/June) and
principal reviews.
Summer
School
During summer school, all Level 1 and Level 2 promotion portfolios should be kept at the students’ summer school
site so that summer school teachers can review the promotion portfolios and add the August Update sheet to them.
August Summer school teacher
prepares August Update
and home school
principal reviews.
Superintendents keep promotion
portfolios until July 10 and then they
are given to the summer school site
where they are kept by summer
school site supervisor or designee.
Summer School Site (July 11)
Promotion portfolios go back
to students’ home school to
keep for school records.
Students’ Home School
Promotion portfolios go to the
summer school site where they
are kept by summer school site
supervisor or designee.
Summer School Site
Promotion portfolios go back
to students’ home school to
address parent appeals and
keep for school records and
instructional purposes.
Students’ Home School
(August 29)
At the end of summer school, all other
promotion portfolios go back to students’
home school principal to keep for school
records and instructional purposes.
Students’ Home School
Superintendent reviews
promotion portfolios for
students who scored
Level 1 on the NYC test.*
Superintendent
Superintendent
reviews promotion
portfolios.*
Superintendent
*Superintendents should receive promotion porfolios of only students recommended for promotion and review them for a final overall score decision.
7
Promotion Review Summary Sheet
Promotion Review Summary Sheet
To prepare the “Promotion Review Summary Sheet”:
1. Print “Promotion Review Summary Sheet.” This year, schools will use the PPSC screen in ATS to
generate the “Promotion Review Summary Sheet” for each student who is administered a
promotion portfolio.
2. Complete “Promotion Review Summary Sheet.” As teachers administer each component of the
promotion portfolio (see directions in the next two sections of this manual), they should complete
the corresponding component on the student’s “Promotion Review Summary Sheet” by filling in the
bubble next to the student’s score for that component. Please see below for a sample of a
completed “Promotion Review Summary Sheet.”
3. Scan “Promotion Review Summary Sheet” into ATS. After the “Promotion Review Summary Sheet”
is complete, schools should scan the sheet into ATS to populate promotion portfolio results on the
UPSC screen in ATS.
8
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Overview
ELA Promotion Portfolio
Overview
The table below summarizes the four components of the ELA promotion portfolio and the benchmarks
(highlighted in yellow) students must meet to demonstrate performance comparable to Level 2 in each
component:
Component Description of Component Areas Assessed Benchmarks Comparable to
Level 2 Performance
Leveled Text
Reading record on a Level T
book (using Fountas and
Pinnell levels).
Reading Accuracy
Read Level T books (using
Fountas and Pinnell levels) with
90% accuracy.
Standard Reading
Passages
(Select one of
two fiction and
one of two non‐
fiction passages)
Individually‐administered,
standard comprehension
passage and questions
(included in this manual);
students read passages
independently and verbally
answer comprehension
questions posed by teachers.
Reading
Comprehension
Student must read and answer
questions for one fiction
passage and one non‐fiction
passage. Student must achieve
a Medium on each type of
question – literal, inferential,
and critical – for BOTH
passages.
Independent
Writing Activity
Individually‐administered
writing activity; students may
self‐select a writing topic or
respond to one of the
suggested topics.
Writing Process/
Writing
Expression/
Writing Mechanics
Using the rubric provided in
this manual, students must
score a Medium and show
evidence of the writing process
(draft, revision, final piece).
ELA Class Work One piece of standards‐
based ELA class work.
English Language
Arts
Using the guidelines provided
in this manual, students must
score a Medium on their class
work.
The table below outlines how to determine the overall score for a student’s ELA promotion portfolio
based on the results of the four components summarized above:
Promotion Portfolio Level Required benchmark performance levels
High Level 2 At least meets benchmarks on the Leveled Text and Independent
Writing components
AND
Exceeds benchmarks on the Standard Reading Passage and ELA Class
Work components
Level 2 Meets all benchmarks
Level 1 Does not meet one or more benchmarks
9
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Leveled Text
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Leveled Text
Directions
Teachers should select a Level T book (using Fountas and Pinnell levels) from the classroom library for
students to read aloud. The selected Level T book should neither be familiar to the student nor have
been used during classroom instruction. While the student reads, the teacher should complete a reading
record and determine the student’s accuracy rate for the first 100 words of the text using the “Leveled
Text Scoring Sheet” in the Blackline Masters. Directions for completing a reading record appear below.
After determining the accuracy rate, the teacher should record the performance level on the student’s
“Promotion Portfolio Summary Sheet.”
Reading Leveled Books from Classroom Libraries: Coding the Reading Record
Follow these directions for recording a student’s reading:
Errors:
1. Misread word/substitution: Cross out the word and above the text, write the word the student
read incorrectly or substituted.
2. Omission: Circle the omitted word.
3. Insertion: Draw a caret ( ^ ) where the student inserts a word (s) and write the word above.
4. Punctuation ignored: Circle the ignored punctuation.
5. Teacher help: Write “T” above the word.
Repairs – Not Errors
1. Self‐correction: Write “SC” above the corrected word.
2. Pause: Write “P” above a word where the student pauses and works through decoding a
difficult word without help from the teacher.
3. Repetition: Draw an arrow backwards over the repeated word(s), starting with the last word
read. Remember: Repeated errors on the same (recurring) word are counted as one error only.
Formula for Calculating Accuracy Rate
(words) 100 ‐ (errors) ____ = (total) ____ ÷ (words) ____ x 100 = (Accuracy Rate) ____ %
(Use the first 100 words in the text for the reading record.)
Note: A list of Level T books can be found in The Fountas and Pinnell Leveled Book List K‐8+, 2010‐2012 Edition by Irene C. Fountas and Gay Su Pinnell. Copyright © 2009 by Irene C. Fountas and Gay Su Pinnell. Published by Heinemann, a Division of Reed Elsevier, Inc., Portsmouth, NH.
Scoring Guide
To demonstrate performance comparable to Level 2, students must read a Level T book with 90%
accuracy. The table below outlines the student performance levels for this component of the ELA
promotion portfolio:
Reading Record Accuracy Percentage Leveled Text Performance Level
91% or above Exceeds benchmark
90% Meets benchmark
89% or below Does not meet benchmark
Blackline
Masters
p. 5
10
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Standard Reading Passages
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Standard Reading Passages
Directions
Four reading passages, comprehension questions, and general rubrics to evaluate students’ responses
are included on the following pages in this manual. A summary of each of the passage appears in the
box below. Students must read one non‐fiction passage and one fiction passage.
Students should read the selected passages independently from the Blackline Masters. Then, using the
questions and sample answers listed in this manual that correspond to each passage, teachers should (1)
ask one question from each question category (literal, inferential, and critical), (2) score students’
responses, and (3) record the score for each question (high, medium, or low) on the “Promotion
Portfolio Summary Sheet.”
Fiction Passage #1: The Equal Trade
Sometimes things are not always what they seem to be. Read about how Justin befriends old
Mr. Myers and his mean old dog named Minus.
Fiction Passage #2: Welcome to the Grand Cineplex
Learning a new language and culture can be very difficult. Read to learn how Massoud’s
determination led him to learn to speak English.
Non‐fiction Passage #1: Elizabeth Blackwell, the First Woman Doctor
Elizabeth Blackwell became the first woman doctor. Read and discover what makes Elizabeth
Blackwell an inspiration to women in medicine.
Non‐fiction Passage #2: Jim Thorpe, An All‐Around Athlete
Jim Thorpe excelled at many sports. Read and discover what makes Jim Thorpe an exceptional
athlete.
Scoring Guide
To demonstrate performance comparable to Level 2, students must achieve a Medium on each type of
question – literal, inferential, critical – for BOTH passages. The table below outlines the student
performance levels for this component of the ELA promotion portfolio:
Response Level for Comprehension Questions Standard Reading Passages
Performance Level
Students must achieve at least a Medium on each type of question
– literal, inferential, critical – for BOTH passages AND a High for at
least one fiction question AND at least one non‐fiction question.
Exceeds benchmark
Students must achieve a Medium on each type of question –
literal, inferential, critical – for BOTH passages. Note: If students
achieve only one High answer, their performance level is “meets
benchmark.”
Meets benchmark
Student achieves Low on one or more questions. Does not meet benchmark
Blackline
Masters
p. 9‐15
11
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Standard Reading Passages
Assessment
Fiction Passage #1
The Equal Trade
Justin and his triumphant friends walked back towards home from the schoolyard. Justin had his
basketball under his arm, but his mind wasn’t on the game he’d just won. He was preoccupied with the
math homework he had to turn in tomorrow. He knew he would have to start it as soon as he got home,
and he wasn’t looking forward to it. Justin did alright in all his other subjects, but numbers just were not
Justin’s friends. He felt ashamed when other students in math class were able to solve equations in a
few seconds that took him ten minutes of struggle, and sometimes he still got the answer wrong. His
parents talked about hiring a tutor, but Justin knew that money was tight. Justin hated the idea of their
having to pay some stranger to teach him math.
As they rounded the corner, Justin’s friends chuckled and pointed. “Better watch out!” “Here comes
double trouble!” Justin’s neighbor, old Mr. Myers, was hobbling up the sidewalk with his dog. Mr. Myers
was known for being grumpy and unfriendly, and his dog wasn’t much better. The dog snarled at anyone
who came too near, and Mr. Myers, though he did not exactly snarl, made it clear that he preferred to
be left alone. He had trouble walking, and each step looked painful. Justin thought this might be why he
was always in such a bad mood. Justin liked animals, and felt sad for Mr. Myers’ dog, with only a
grouchy old man for company. Justin lived in an apartment building that didn’t allow any pets.
“I dare you to go pet that dog,” teased Justin’s friend. “I’ll buy you pizza for a week.”
“I can buy my own pizza, and I’m not afraid of that dog,” countered Justin, with more courage than he
felt. As he approached Mr. Myers and the dog, he felt two sets of cold eyes on him. “Good afternoon,
Mr. Myers,” said Justin politely. “Can I say hi to your dog?”
“Watch out, he snaps,” grunted Mr. Myers. Justin held out his hand for the dog to sniff. To his surprise,
the dog nuzzled his hand as if asking for his head to be scratched. Justin squatted down to the dog’s
level and rubbed his ears. “Hmmph,” said Mr. Myers. “He usually doesn’t take like that to strangers.”
“What’s his name?” inquired Justin. “Minus,” answered Mr. Myers. “Hi Minus. Good boy,” murmured
Justin.
“Hey, Justin! Let’s go!” called his friends. Justin had almost forgotten about them. He stood up. He
thought the dog looked sorry to see him go.
Continued on the next page
12
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Standard Reading Passages
His friends slapped him on the back for his courage. “He wasn’t so intimidating,” said Justin. “His name
is Minus. What a weird name for a dog.” His friend spoke up.
“That’s because the old man used to be a math teacher. My older brother had him in high school. He
said he was mean then, too.” A math teacher! Justin had an idea.
The next day, he didn’t go with his friends after school. He waited on the street for Mr. Myers and
Minus. Sure enough, at around the same time, the pair made their way slowly up the street.
You again,” barked Mr. Myers, though Justin thought he saw an amused twinkle in his eye. Minus greeted him like an old friend. “Mr. Myers, I was wondering if you’d be interested in a trade,” said Justin. “What kind of trade?” “I’ll walk Minus for you, if you’ll tutor me in math. I can’t seem to get it in school.” Mr. Myers rubbed his chin and almost smiled. “Well, you must have some brains, to come up with an idea like this. Come and see me tomorrow.” Justin wrote down the address. Justin’s friends couldn’t believe it when they saw Justin walking Mr. Myers’ mean old dog. The only person more surprised was Justin’s math teacher at school. “You’ve really improved, Justin!” she exclaimed a few weeks later. “You must have studied a great deal.” “I made a great deal,” smiled Justin.
13
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Standard Reading Passages
Fiction Passage #1:
The Equal Trade High Medium Low
Benchmark
• shows signs of reflection and/or personal connection • sophisticated use of language • accurate/insightful/detailed The response is complete and uses supporting information from the passage.
• shows general grasp of the passage • mostly accurate/literal/ some details The response is accurate, but incomplete. It shows some understanding, but does not contain details.
• shows lack of understanding of what was read • misses point of the question • inaccurate/few details The response misses the point of the question and shows lack of understanding of the passage.
Literal
Q1. What did Justin’s
friends dare him to
do?
Mr. Myers was known for being gruff and unfriendly,
and his dog wasn’t much better. Justin’s friends dared
him to pet Mr. Myers’ dog, Minus.
Justin’s friends dared him to
pet the dog.
Justin’s friends are afraid of the
dog.
Q2. Why did Justin
wait for Mr. Myers
and Minus one day,
after school?
Justin waited for Mr. Myers because he wanted Mr.
Myers to tutor him in math, and in return Justin would
walk Mr. Meyers’ dog, Minus.
Justin waited for Mr. Myers
because he was wondering
if Mr. Myers would be
interested in a trade.
Justin waited for Mr. Myers
because he wanted to pet
Minus.
Inferential
Q3. What is the
connection between
the title, “The Equal
Trade,” and the
relationship between
Mr. Myers and
Justin?
Mr. Myers and Justin made an equal trade. Since Mr.
Myers was a former math teacher, he was able to
tutor Justin to improve his math skills. In return,
Justin walked Mr. Meyers’ dog, Minus, because it was
difficult for him to walk his own dog. Most
importantly, they formed a friendship because of this
equal trade.
Justin and Mr. Myers made
a deal. Mr. Myers gave
Justin math help, and in
return Justin walked the
dog.
They traded many things with
each other.
Q4. How does the
relationship between
Mr. Myers and Justin
change throughout
the story?
Justin is introduced to Mr. Myers as the unfriendly
neighbor who never speaks to anybody. Mr. Myers
spends most of his time with his dog, Minus who is
also unfriendly. When Justin is told that Mr. Myers is a
math teacher, he decides to use that information and
propose an equal trade. Justin walks Minus, and in
return, Mr. Meyers will help him with his math. As a
result, Mr. Myers is no longer the old, unfriendly
neighbor, and Justin is happy because he is doing
much better in math.
Mr. Myers and Justin form a
friendship because they
learn from each other.
Mr. Myers and Justin love
math.
Critical
Q5. What lesson
about responsibility
do you learn from
Justin’s actions?
Justin knew that he was having difficulties in his math
class. When his friends told him that Mr. Myers was a
math teacher, he decided to ask for help. Responsible
people take action. They don’t wait for someone to
give them the answers.
Justin demonstrated that he
was a responsible young
boy when he asked Mr.
Myers to tutor him in math.
Justin learned to make an equal
trade.
Q6. What qualities
make a good
friendship?
A good friendship is a balance between giving and
taking. In this story, Mr. Myers and Justin helped each
other. They gave each other something they did not
have in their lives. Everyone has special qualities that
others may not have. As a result, there is an equal
trade among friends who can balance each other.
A good friendship has a
balance of two helping each
other with their problems.
A good friendship is when two
people like each other.
14
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Standard Reading Passages
Assessment
Fiction Passage #2
Welcome to the Grand Cineplex
17‐year‐old Massoud smiled and greeted people as they entered the movie theater.
“Welcome to the Grand Cineplex. May I see your tickets, please?” He still had a strong Iranian accent,
but at least people understood him. They even smiled back.
It had not always been this way. Massoud had arrived in New York from the countryside of Iran six
months before. He had come to stay with his older brother for a year. Massoud’s brother had already
been in America for several years, but Massoud had never been out of Iran before. When he first saw
New York City, he was overwhelmed. The people, the noise, everything was different than back home.
Massoud’s brother enrolled him in the local high school. He also helped him get a part‐time job in a
movie theater, so Massoud could earn spending money. Massoud did not speak much English, and he
struggled to understand his teachers in school and his boss at the movie theater. Massoud’s job was to
sweep up the popcorn after the movie, because he could do it without having to speak to anyone. He
tried to make friends with the other young people who worked there, but all they wanted to talk about
was baseball, a game Massoud didn’t understand at all. He tried to tell them about soccer, but they had
trouble understanding him, and they weren’t interested, anyway. They treated him as if he wasn’t very
smart, just because he didn’t speak their language very well. Back in Iran, Massoud had been at the top
his class at his high school. Now Massoud felt frustrated and left out, and he didn’t like sweeping floors.
He felt like quitting his job, but he didn’t want to give up.
One day, while he was working, Massoud decided to watch the movie. He didn’t understand every word,
but he got some of it. The next day, he watched the same movie again. This time, he understood more.
Massoud was excited. He started writing down the words he didn’t understand, and he asked his co‐
workers what they meant. They were surprised, but they helped him. Soon, he was using many of the
same words and expressions that they did. Massoud’s co‐workers became friendlier, now that they
could understand him. They even invited him to go out for ice cream with them after work.
After Massoud had been working at the theater for about five months, he went to see his boss.
Massoud asked him to give him the job of greeting customers at the door. The manager wasn’t sure.
“Your English isn’t good enough yet,” his boss said.
“It will become better if I talk to the people,” reasoned Massoud.
Continued on the next page
15
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Standard Reading Passages
The boss agreed, because he saw how determined Massoud was.
Now, just a month later, Massoud smiled proudly as he took people’s tickets. He got along with
everyone at the theater. His boss was even talking about promoting him to be assistant manager!
Massoud was glad he had not given up.
16
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Standard Reading Passages
Fiction Passage #2:
The Grand Cineplex High Medium Low
Benchmark
• shows signs of reflection and/or personal connection • sophisticated use of language • accurate/insightful/detailed The response is complete and uses supporting information from the passage.
• shows general grasp of the passage • mostly accurate/literal/ some details The response is accurate, but incomplete. It shows some understanding, but does not contain details.
• shows lack of understanding of what was read • misses point of the question • inaccurate/few details The response misses the point of the question and shows lack of understanding of the passage.
Literal
Q1. Why did Massoud
view the same movie
multiple times during
work?
Massoud viewed the same movie multiple
times during work so that he could build an
English vocabulary. He started writing
down the words he didn’t understand. He
asked his co‐workers to help him
understand what the words meant.
Massoud started to use the words in his
daily language and began to incorporate
the words into his conversations.
Massoud watched the
movie many times at work
so that he could have more
conversations with his co‐
workers.
Massoud watched the movie
at work so that he could
entertain himself.
Q2. What new job
assignment did
Massoud request of
his boss?
Massoud asked his boss to give him the job
of greeting customers at the door and
taking their tickets. He wanted to practice
speaking English by greeting customers at
the front door.
He asked his boss if he
could take tickets at the
door from customers.
He asked if he could work with
his co‐workers behind the
food stand.
Inferential
Q3. How did
Massoud’s co‐
workers feel about
him?
At first, his co‐workers did not understand
him and they were not interested in getting
to know him. They treated him as if he
wasn’t very smart because he didn’t speak
the English language very well. As Massoud
begins to develop a better speaking
vocabulary, his co‐workers become
friendlier and begin to invite him out with
them. Massoud and his co‐workers feel
much better about being able to
communicate with one another.
At first, the co‐workers
were uncomfortable with
communicating with
Massoud. They didn’t know
how to treat him.
The‐co‐workers did not accept
Massoud even though he
started to learn the new
language.
Q4. How did
Massoud’s hard work
and determination
pay off?
Massoud’s hard work and determination
paid off because he is now able to
communicate with his co‐workers and
other New Yorkers. He has developed new
friendships, gained confidence, and was
promoted to a better job because he
believed in his capabilities.
His hard work and
determination helped him
to be promoted to a new
job.
His hard work and
determination leads to more
frustration at work because he
still sees himself as an
outsider.
17
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Standard Reading Passages
Fiction Passage #2:
The Grand Cineplex High Medium Low
Benchmark
• shows signs of reflection and/or personal connection • sophisticated use of language • accurate/insightful/detailed The response is complete and uses supporting information from the passage.
• shows general grasp of the passage • mostly accurate/literal/ some details The response is accurate, but incomplete. It shows some understanding, but does not contain details.
• shows lack of understanding of what was read • misses point of the question • inaccurate/few details The response misses the point of the question and shows lack of understanding of the passage.
Critical
Q5. What lesson does
the author want the
readers to learn from
Massoud’s story?
The author wants us to learn that being
dedicated and determined will help you
achieve your goals. In the story, Massoud
works really hard at learning a new
language. He knows how important it is for
him to communicate with others. Not only
does he learn new words from watching
movies, but he also observes others while
listening to their conversations. He finds
new ways of learning and understanding
the English language. The author wants us
to dedicate ourselves to our goals and give
everything we have in order to achieve
success.
The author wants us to
learn that Massoud’s belief
in himself led to his success.
The author wants us to also
believe in ourselves so that
we can be successful.
Even if don’t know the
language, you can still
communicate with other
people.
Q6. What kinds of
struggles do you think
immigrants face
when they move to
another country?
I think many immigrants struggle with their
communication skills. In the story,
Massoud was very frustrated and struggled
because he didn’t have the right words to
communicate with his peers. Even though
Massoud was determined to speak English,
his co‐workers and customers rejected his
attempts to communicate. Similarly,
immigrants have trouble establishing new
friendships and seeking employment
because they don’t have the right words to
communicate their feelings and thoughts.
Immigrants have trouble
making new friends
because they don’t know
English.
Immigrants have trouble
understanding the words in
movies, just like Massoud did.
18
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Standard Reading Passages
Assessment
Non‐fiction Passage #1
Elizabeth Blackwell, the First Woman Doctor
Until about 160 years ago, medical doctors were all men. This was true not only in America, but everywhere in the
world. That was before Elizabeth Blackwell became the first woman anywhere to go to medical school. She later
became the first woman doctor.
The road to her goal was not easy. Elizabeth Blackwell was born in England in 1821. Her family moved to America
when she was a baby. When Elizabeth was a young woman, her family had very little money. Elizabeth helped
support the family by becoming a teacher. Teaching was one of the only jobs outside the home women were
allowed to do at the time. Elizabeth was frustrated. She didn’t really like teaching. She wanted the chance do more
difficult work.
Then a friend of Elizabeth’s became sick. Elizabeth took care of her. The friend told Elizabeth that she was smart
enough to be a doctor. Elizabeth was excited. However, most people at the time did not believe that women
should be doctors. No woman had ever tried to become one before. This did not stop Elizabeth. She studied
medicine secretly in her spare time. She even rented a room in the home of a doctor, so that she would be able to
read his medical books. She also helped the doctor in his work. She learned a lot about medicine that way.
In 1847, when Elizabeth was 26, she decided to go to medical school. But no school would admit her, because she
was a woman. One doctor suggested that she disguise herself as a man to trick a school into accepting her!
A medical school in New York finally accepted Elizabeth by accident. The men in charge of the school asked the
other students to vote on admitting a female student. The other students all thought it was a joke. They “played
along” and voted to admit her. The young men were surprised when Elizabeth Blackwell arrived for first day of
school. However, they were not allowed to change their minds. Elizabeth was there to stay.
Elizabeth did her schoolwork, but she had trouble fitting in. Strangers came to the school to stare at Elizabeth
studying in a roomful of men. When she went into town, people stayed away from her. They treated her as though
she had done something wrong. Still, she stuck with her studies. Elizabeth did so well that the professors and other
students came to admire her. She graduated at the top of her class!
However, her struggles were not over. Many hospitals and patients did not accept the idea of a woman doctor. She
had trouble finding a place to work. Finally, Elizabeth Blackwell opened her own clinic. Now no one could stop her
from using her skills as a doctor. She also gave other women a chance to work in medicine.
Elizabeth Blackwell’s courage opened the door for all women doctors who came after her. Today, medical schools
in America admit as many female students as males.
19
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Standard Reading Passages
Non‐fiction Passage #1:
Elizabeth Blackwell High Medium Low
Benchmark
• shows signs of reflection and/or personal connection • sophisticated use of language • accurate/insightful/detailed The response is complete and uses supporting information from the passage.
• shows general grasp of the passage • mostly accurate/literal/ some details The response is accurate, but incomplete. It shows some understanding, but does not contain details.
• shows lack of understanding of what was read • misses point of the question • inaccurate/few details The response misses the point of the question and shows lack of understanding of the passage.
Literal
Q1. Why did
Elizabeth rent a
room in the home
of a doctor?
Elizabeth rented a room in the home of a doctor
because she was able to read his medical books
and help the doctor in his work. She learned a lot
about medicine that way.
Elizabeth rented a room in
the home of a doctor
because she wanted to learn
about medicine.
Elizabeth rented a room in the
home of a doctor because she
could not afford an
apartment.
Q2. Why did
Elizabeth open her
own clinic?
Elizabeth opened her own clinic because she was
unable to find work at hospitals. Many patients
also rejected the idea of a woman doctor. She had
trouble finding a place to work.
Elizabeth could not find
work at hospitals.
Elizabeth loved to work at
clinics.
Inferential
Q3. Why was
Elizabeth a
successful doctor?
Elizabeth Blackwell was a successful doctor
because she never gave up her dream of becoming
a doctor. She graduated at the top of her class,
but many hospitals refused to hire a woman
doctor. She opened her own clinic, and used her
skills as a doctor. She also gave other women a
chance to work in medicine.
Elizabeth was a successful
doctor because opened the
doors for women doctors.
Elizabeth was successful because she was a doctor.
Q4. Why was
Elizabeth Blackwell
a courageous
woman?
Elizabeth Blackwell was a courageous woman
because her hard work opened the doors for other
woman to practice medicine. She also gave other
women a chance to work in medicine. Today,
medical schools admit both men and women.
Elizabeth was a courageous
woman because she also
gave other women a chance
to work in medicine.
Elizabeth worked in a
dangerous clinic.
Critical
Q5. If you were to
meet Elizabeth
Blackwell today,
what words of
inspiration might
she share with
you?
If I were to meet Elizabeth Blackwell today, she
most likely would insist that I follow my dreams.
She always wanted to become a doctor, yet people
told her women couldn’t do the job. She
graduated from the top of her class, yet could not
find a job at a hospital. Eventually, she opened her
own clinic and was able to show her patients and
the rest of the world that she was a great doctor.
Elizabeth Blackwell would
insist that women are
capable of doing the same
type of work as men.
If I were to meet Elizabeth
Blackwell today, she would
insist that I open up a clinic
first.
Q6. What would
life be like if
Elizabeth Blackwell
had never achieved
her goals?
If Elizabeth Blackwell had never achieved her goals,
it would have definitely taken women a lot longer
to become doctors. Elizabeth’s courage opened
the door for all the women doctors who came after
her.
If Elizabeth never achieved
her goals, she would not
have been able to
encourage women to
practice medicine.
Elizabeth would have been a
teacher.
20
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Standard Reading Passages
Assessment Non‐fiction Passage #2
Jim Thorpe: An All‐Around Athlete
Many professional athletes become famous for being very good at one sport. However, in the early 1900s, a
man named Jim Thorpe excelled at many sports. That made him one of the most famous athletes of the 20th
century.
Jim Thorpe’s Native American name was Wa‐Ho‐Thuk, which means “Bright Path”. He was born on a
reservation in Oklahoma in 1888. Both his parents were of partial Native American ancestry. When he was
about 16, Thorpe went to a school for Native Americans in Pennsylvania. At school, he discovered his love
and talent for sports. He joined the football team, and quickly became one of its star players. He led his team
twice to the college championship. He also competed in baseball, track and field events and even ballroom
dancing!
When he was only 24, Jim Thorpe boarded a ship with the American Olympic team. They sailed to Europe to
compete in the 1912 Olympic Games. Jim Thorpe worked out constantly on the ship during the journey
across the ocean. In the Olympics, Thorpe set new world records in many sports. He won the pentathlon, a
series of five sports events. Pentathlon events include swimming, running and horseback riding. Thorpe also
won the decathlon, a combination of ten different sports. Some decathlon sports are hurdle racing, javelin
throwing and the long jump. King Gustave of Sweden gave Thorpe his gold medals. The King was so
impressed with Thorpe’s accomplishments, he said, “Sir, you are the greatest athlete in the world!”
Thorpe replied simply, “Thanks King."
Jim Thorpe returned to America to a hero’s welcome. He marched down Broadway in New York City in a big
parade in his honor.
Now Thorpe turned to professional sports. He played baseball with the New York Giants, and toured around
the world. He later returned to playing football. He even tried basketball for a short time.
After all of Thorpe’s sports careers were finished, he started yet another new one. This time he did athletics
in the movies. Thorpe worked as a stunt double for movie actors. He performed athletic moves that were too
dangerous or difficult for the actors. On film, in looked as if the actors were doing the stunts, but it was really
Jim Thorpe.
Jim Thorpe endured hardships during his career. For example, the Olympic committee stripped him of his
gold medals. The committee claimed that Thorpe had broken Olympic rules by playing professional baseball
before the Games. They returned the medals to his family many years later, after his death. Jim Thorpe also
struggled to support his family late in his life. At that time, professional athletes were not as highly paid as
they are today. Despite these setbacks, Jim Thorpe remains one of the most admired American athletes in
history.
21
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Standard Reading Passages
Non‐fiction Passage #2:
Jim Thorpe High Medium Low
Benchmark
• shows signs of reflection and/or personal connection • sophisticated use of language • accurate/insightful/detailed The response is complete and uses supporting information from the passage.
• shows general grasp of the passage • mostly accurate/literal/ some details The response is accurate, but incomplete. It shows some understanding, but does not contain details.
• shows lack of understanding of what was read • misses point of the question • inaccurate/few details The response misses the point of the question and shows lack of understanding of the passage.
Literal
Q1. What did Jim
Thorpe discover at
school in
Pennsylvania?
Jim Thorpe discovered his love and talent
for sports at school in Pennsylvania. He
joined many sports team and competed
within many events.
Jim discovered that he loved
sports.
Jim discovered that he could
join a football and basketball
team.
Q2. What was one
problem Thorpe
experienced during
his career?
Jim Thorpe had many problems during
his career. One problem Jim had was
that he struggled to support his family.
Although he was great at sports and
loved to play, he was not highly paid.
This caused many hardships for him and
his family.
One problem Jim Thorpe had
was the Olympic committee
took away his gold medals.
Jim Thorpe was very upset
because he was not getting
paid for all of the sports
activities he was participating
in.
Inferential
Q3. Why is Jim
Thorpe considered
as America’s most
admired athlete?
According to the author, Jim Thorpe is
considered one of the most admired
American athletes in history. Although
he had many obstacles and problems in
his career, he continued to play sports
and try new careers, such as becoming a
stunt double in the film industry. His
determination to practice and develop
new skills led him to set new world
records.
Jim Thorpe was admired in
America because he played
many sports. He practiced
becoming a better athlete.
Jim Thorpe is an admired
athlete because he is good at
what he did.
Q4. How did Jim
Thorpe’s obstacles
and problems affect
him?
Jim Thorpe’s obstacles influenced him to
try harder to become the best athlete.
He believed in himself and did not allow
his problems to stand in his way.
Although he struggled to support his
family, he continued to try new jobs.
After his sports career as an athlete, he
started a new career in stunt doubling
for movie actors. On film, he proved that
he was able to perform dangerous and
difficult stunts. Through practice and
determination, Jim was honored with a
hero’s welcome in New York City in a big
parade.
Jim Thorpe’s problems made
him a better athlete. He
played many sports and
practiced to make himself
better. He even tried
becoming a stunt double in
films.
Jim Thorpe’s obstacles made
him upset because the
Olympic committee took away
all of his gold medals because
he did not play by the rules
during the games.
22
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Standard Reading Passages
Non‐fiction Passage #2:
Jim Thorpe High Medium Low
Benchmark
• shows signs of reflection and/or personal connection • sophisticated use of language • accurate/insightful/detailed The response is complete and uses supporting information from the passage.
• shows general grasp of the passage • mostly accurate/literal/ some details The response is accurate, but incomplete. It shows some understanding, but does not contain details.
• shows lack of understanding of what was read • misses point of the question • inaccurate/few details The response misses the point of the question and shows lack of understanding of the passage.
Critical
Q5. What makes a
successful athlete?
Hard work and determination makes a
successful athlete. Jim Thorpe continued
to improve his skills throughout his
career by playing new sports and even
trying new career opportunities.
Although he was not paid highly, the love
of the game and his passion led him to
be recognized as an admirable and
inspirational person.
A successful athlete is
competitive. He or she will
try playing the sport many
times until they get it.
A successful athlete wins
during every competition.
Q6. The author says that Jim Thorpe is “one of the most admired American athletes in history.” Do you agree? Why or why not?
I believe that Jim Thorpe is one of the
most admired athletes of all time. He
never gave up on his dreams and love of
sports. He was inspired at a young age
and continued to follow his dreams
throughout his career. He set world
records during the Olympics,
participating in a variety of events, such
as the decathlon and the pentathlon. He
inspired and entertained people
throughout the world
Jim Thorpe is an admired
athlete. Many people in
America loved and
supported him. They even
thought of him as a hero and
watched him march during a
New York City parade.
Many people considered Jim
Thorpe to be a good athlete.
He won many awards
23
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Independent Writing Activity
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Independent Writing Activity
Directions
Students should complete one independent writing activity and record their response on Blackline
Masters “Independent Writing Activity” sheet. Suggested topics are listed below. Students may respond
in a question/answer format, essay or as a letter writing activity. Teachers should score the writing
activity using the rubric found on the following page and record the performance level on the student’s
“Promotion Portfolio Summary Sheet.”
Suggested
Topics
Question/Answer: Answer the questions
completely that are provided with the
suggested topic.
Letter Writing: Write a letter to the person who
is indicated with the suggested topic. Be sure to
include all the information that is listed with the
suggested topic.
If I Could Change the
World
Think about one problem in today’s world that you
feel strongly about and would like to fix. How does
this problem affect you, other people, and the
environment? Describe some strategies you would
use to solve this problem and explain why the
world would be a better place if you accomplished
your goal. Be sure to use details and write a
complete answer.
You have been given the opportunity to voice your
opinion about changing one problem that affects
today’s youth. President Obama recognizes the
importance of listening to American youth and would
like to hear from you. Write a letter to President
Obama addressing one problem that is of great
concern to you. Be sure to include two
recommendations to remedy this problem. Remember
to use descriptive details and write a complete letter.
Who Am I? Who are you? Reflect on the following questions
when you are thinking about your answer. What is
your best quality or talent? What makes you so
special? How has your family and/or friends shaped
your personality? How do others view you? What
are your likes and dislikes? What is your favorite
way of learning new information or skills? What are
some of your short term and long term goals? Be
sure to use details and write a complete answer.
It is important that next year’s teachers get to know
you before school starts so they can gain a better
understanding of who you are and what they can do to
help you succeed in school. Write a letter to one of
your teachers describing yourself. Consider the
following questions when writing your answer. What
are your best qualities and talents? What makes you
so special? How has your family and/or friends shaped
your personality? How do others view you? What are
your likes and dislikes? What is your favorite way of
learning new information or skills? What are some of
your short term and long term goals? Be sure to use
descriptive details and write a complete letter.
My Most
Memorable
Moment
What is one of the most important memorable
moments you have experienced? As you describe
this memorable moment, use the following
questions to guide you: Why is this moment so
memorable and what makes it so significant? How
has this experience changed you? What have you
learned from it? How does it make you feel? Be
sure to use details and write a complete answer.
Write a letter to someone special in your life, sharing
the most memorable moment you experienced in their
company. Be sure to describe the significance and
specific details of this experience. Try to include how
this moment affected your relationship with them.
Use descriptive details and write a complete letter.
Blackline
Masters
p. 17‐18
24
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Independent Writing Activity
Scoring Guide
To demonstrate performance comparable to Level 2, students must achieve a Medium using the
writing rubric below AND show evidence of the writing process (draft, revision and final piece).
Students’ scores should be based on their final writing sample. The table below outlines the student
performance levels for this component of the ELA promotion portfolio:
Independent Writing Activity Score Independent Writing Activity Performance Level
High rubric score AND shows evidence of the
writing process (draft, revision and final piece)
Exceeds benchmark
Medium rubric score AND shows evidence of the
writing process (draft, revision and final piece)
Meets benchmark
Low rubric score OR does not show evidence of the
writing process (draft, revision and final piece)
Does not meet benchmark
Scoring Rubric for Writing Expression/Writing Mechanics
High Medium Low
Writing Expression
Main idea or topic with supporting details
Main idea or topic with some supporting details
Unclear main idea or topic with few supporting details
Uses varied sentence structure and challenging vocabulary
Uses only simple sentences and basic vocabulary
Uses minimal vocabulary
Answers are very easy to understand
Answers may be a little confusing
Answers are confusing
Establishes and maintains a clear focus
May attempt to establish focus
May focus on minor details or lack focus
Clear sequence and appropriate transitions
Some sequence and transitions
No logical sequence or transitions
Fluent with vivid language, engagement and voice
Readable with some sense of engagement and voice
Repetitive with little or no sense of engagement or voice
Ideas are developed fully through elaboration
Ideas are brief with little elaboration but are adequately developed to answer questions
May include a few accurate details
Writing Mechanics
Grammar, syntax,
capitalization, punctuation ,
spelling and use of
paragraphs are essentially
correct.
Some errors in grammar and
syntax; however, capitalization,
punctuation, spelling of grade
appropriate words, and use of
paragraphs are mostly correct.
There are many errors in
grammar, syntax, capitalization,
and spelling. These errors
interfere with comprehension.
Control of conventions of
English
Minimal control of conventions
of written English
Lack of control of the
conventions of written English
25
ELA Promotion Portfolio: Class Work
ELA Promotion Portfolio: ELA Class Work
Directions
Please include one piece of student writing produced in the classroom during a unit of study in ELA,
social studies or science and given a score by the teacher.
Form: The piece of writing can be a narrative, report, essay or opinion piece. For example: a personal
narrative or fictional story; report on a topic of interest within a science or social studies unit; a book
review/recommendation; formal argument in essay form; feature article; persuasive essay or letter.
Components: The writing piece must include four elements to be considered when evaluating a student
for promotion:
1. The assigned task
2. Draft with editing and/or revisions evident
3. Final product
4. Tool (rubric, checklist, etc.) used to score this piece of writing or teacher evaluation based on
specific criteria
All four of these ELA class work elements must be included in promotion portfolios submitted to the
principal and community superintendent.
Workbook pages, ditto sheets, etc. should not be submitted as a piece of student work.
Based on the scoring guide below, teachers should record the performance level on the student’s “Promotion Portfolio Summary Sheet.”
Scoring Guide
To demonstrate performance comparable to Level 2, students must achieve a Medium on the ELA
class work submitted for their promotion portfolio. The table below outlines the student performance
levels for this component of the ELA promotion portfolio:
School Rubric Score Class Work Performance Level
(for promotion portfolio)
Exceeds school’s Level 2 standard* High/Exceeds benchmark
Meets school’s Level 2 standard* Medium/Meets benchmark
Below school’s Level 2 standard* Class work that does not meet school’s Level 2
standard should not be submitted as evidence
for the promotion portfolio.
*School’s Level 2 standard is evidenced by the scoring tool submitted along with the ELA class work.
26
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio: Overview
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio
Overview
The table below summarizes the three components of the mathematics promotion portfolio and the
benchmarks (highlighted in yellow) students must meet to demonstrate performance comparable to
Level 2 in each component:
Component Description of
Component
Areas Assessed Benchmarks Comparable
To Level 2 Performance
Mathematical
Inventory
Individually‐administered
problems assessing
computation and problem‐
solving skills (included in
this manual).
Mathematical
Development
Master 12 out of 20
computation skills and
provide evidence of basic
problem solving.
Standard
Math
Problems
Individually‐administered
standard math problems
(included in this manual).
Mathematical
Development
Answer 4 out of 5 standard
math questions correctly.
Math
Class Work
One piece of standards‐
based mathematics class
work.
Mathematics Using the guidelines provided
in this manual, students must
score a Medium on their class
work.
The table below outlines how to determine the overall score for a student’s mathematics promotion
portfolio based on the results of the three components listed above:
Promotion Portfolio Level Required benchmark performance levels
High Level 2 At least meets benchmarks on the Mathematical Inventory and
the Standard Math Problems components and exceeds the
benchmark on at least one of these two components
AND
Exceeds benchmark on the Mathematics Class Work component
Level 2 Meets all benchmarks
Level 1 Does not meet one or more benchmarks
27
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio:Mathematical Inventory
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio: Mathematical Inventory
Directions
The Mathematical Inventory assesses 20 key mathematical skills. These skills and their corresponding
performance indicators are listed below. Teachers should ask students the questions in the Assessment
section in this manual, and students should follow along and record their answers as appropriate on the
corresponding “Mathematical Inventory: Student Sheet” found in the Blackline Masters. Students may
explain/justify their answers orally. Teachers should use the “Mathematical Inventory Scoring Sheet,”
found in the Blackline Masters, to record if students have mastered each skill and then record the final
performance level on the student’s “Promotion Portfolio Summary Sheet.” The Answer Key section
provides sample answers for teachers’ reference.
Mathematical Skill
1. Define and identify the commutative and associative properties of addition and multiplication. (6.N.2)
2. Express equivalent ratios as a proportion. (6.N.7)
3. Define absolute value and determine the absolute value of rational numbers (including positive and negative).
(6.N.13)
4. Add and subtract fractions with unlike denominators. (6.N.16)
5. Add, subtract, multiply and divide mixed numbers with unlike denominators. (6.N.18)
6. Find multiple representations of rational numbers (fractions, decimals, and percents 0 to 100). (6.N.2)
7. Evaluate numerical expressions using order of operations (may include exponents of two and three). (6.N.22)
8. Translate simple verbal expressions into algebraic expressions. (5.A.2)
9. Substitute assigned values into variable expressions and evaluate using order of operations. (5.A.3)
10. Translate two‐step verbal expressions into algebraic expressions. (6.A.1)
11. Use substitution to evaluate algebraic expressions (may include exponents of one, two and three) (6.A.2).
12. Evaluate formulas for given input values (circumference, area, volume, distance, temperature, interest, etc.).
(6.A.6)
13. Calculate perimeter of basic geometric shapes drawn on a coordinate plane (rectangles and shapes composed
of rectangles having sides with integer lengths and parallel to the axes). (5.G.14)
14. Determine the volume of rectangular prisms by counting cubes and develop the formula. (6.G.4)
15. Understand the relationship between the diameter and radius of a circle. (6.G.6)
16. Identify equivalent customary units of capacity (cups to pints, pints to quarts, and quarts to gallons). (6.M.3)
17. Identify equivalent metric units of capacity (milliliter to liter and liter to milliliter). (6.M.5)
18. Record experiment results using fractions/ratios. (5.S.6)
19. Determine the mean, mode, and median for a given set of data. (6.S.5)
20. Determine the range for a given set of data. (6.S.6)
Blackline
Masters
p. 19‐ 23
p. 6
28
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio:Mathematical Inventory
Scoring Guide
To demonstrate performance comparable to Level 2, students must demonstrate mastery of 12 out of
20 Mathematical Inventory skills. Students must answer all parts of each question correctly to achieve
mastery for that skill. The table below outlines the student performance levels for this component of the
Mathematics promotion portfolio:
Number of Skills Mastered Mathematical Inventory Performance Level
13 or more Exceeds benchmark
12 Meets benchmark
10 or fewer Does not meet benchmark
Assessment – Mathematical Inventory
Students must answer all parts of each question correctly to be considered as mastery.
1. Define and identify the commutative and associative properties of addition and multiplication.
Name the property shown in the equation below.
9 + (4 + 7) = (9 + 4) + 7
2. Express equivalent ratios as a proportion.
Pick out the statement which is a proportion and explain why you eliminated the others.
a. = b. = c. = 3. Define absolute value and determine the absolute value of rational numbers (including positive
and negative).
Write the absolute value for each of the following:
a. |‐7| b. |+3| c. |0| d. |‐6|
4. Add and subtract fractions with unlike denominators.
Tanya bought 1/5 pound of flour and 3/4 pound of rice. What was the total weight of her
purchase? Show your work.
29
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio:Mathematical Inventory
5. Add, subtract, multiply and divide mixed numbers with unlike denominators.
Ellen had 2 1 4 yards of ribbon. If she used ⅓ of this piece, how many yards did she use?
Show your work. 6. Find multiple representations of rational numbers (fractions, decimals, and percents 0 to 100).
A 60‐pound container is filled with 12 pounds of sand. Represent the amount of sand that fills the container as a:
a. fraction b. decimal c. percent
7. Evaluate numerical expressions using order of operations (may include exponents of two and three).
Simplify the following expression. Show your work.
52 × 3 + 22 × 4
8. Translate simple verbal expressions into algebraic expressions.
Mary is x years old now. Represent her age 5 years ago.
9. Substitute assigned values into variable expressions and evaluate using order of operations.
Find the value of the following expression when x = 6.
20 – 3x ÷ 2
10. Translate two‐step verbal expressions into algebraic expressions.
Write an algebraic expression for 4 less than the product of 3 and a number. Use n to represent
a number.
11. Use substitution to evaluate algebraic expressions (may include exponents of one, two and three).
Cheryl wrote the expression below:
2n2 × 5
If n equals 4, what is the value of the expression? Show your work.
30
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio:Mathematical Inventory
12. Evaluate formulas for given input values (circumference, area, volume, distance, temperature,
interest, etc.).
The width of a table is 3 feet and the length is 4 times the width. What is the area of the table in
square feet?
A = lw
13. Calculate perimeter of basic geometric shapes drawn on a coordinate plane (rectangles and shapes
composed of rectangles having sides with integer lengths and parallel to the axes). Show your work.
On the grid below, Adam drew a diagram of a rectangular dance floor. What is the perimeter in
units of the rectangular dance floor?
14. Determine the volume of rectangular prisms by counting cubes and develop the formula. Show your
work.
What is the volume of the rectangular prism shown below?
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1 x
y
(not drawn to scale)
KEY
= 1 cubic inch
31
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio:Mathematical Inventory
15. Understand the relationship between the diameter and radius of a circle.
If the radius of a circle is 13.5 inches, what is the diameter of the circle in inches? Explain how you were able to figure out the diameter.
16. Identify equivalent customary units of capacity (cups to pints, pints to quarts, and quarts to gallons).
How many quarts are there in 3 ½ gallons of milk? Show your work.
1 gallon = 4 quarts.
17. Identify equivalent metric units of capacity (milliliter to liter and liter to milliliter).
Aileen has 3 liters of water. She uses 950 milliliters to water her plants. How many milliliters of
water does Aileen have left? Show your work.
1 liter = 1000 milliliters
18. Record experiment results using fractions/ratios.
A box contains only 4 red marbles, 6 yellow marbles and 7 green marbles. Write as a fraction
the probability of picking a green marble.
19. Determine the mean, mode, and median for a given set of data.
Find the mean of the following group of numbers:
28, 36, 26, 38, 22
Show your work.
20. Determine the range for a given set of data.
Steve received the following grades on his 5 math tests.
75, 80, 95, 75, 70
What is the range of these test scores? Show your work.
32
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio:Mathematical Inventory
Answer Key – Mathematical Inventory
1. Associative property of addition
2. Answer: C. Sample responses may include but are not limited to: “Eliminated the other two
because the cross products aren’t equal.”
3. a. 7 b. 3 c . 0 d. 6
4. Answer: Work: = = + =
5. Answer: ¾ yd
2 ¼ x ⅓
9/4 x ⅓ (Students may do cancelling)
9/12
¾ yd.
6. Answers: fraction = 1/5, decimal = .2 or .20, percent = 20%
7. Answer: 91
52 × 3 + 22 × 4
25 × 3 + 4 × 4
75 + 16
91
8. x – 5
9. Answer: 11
20 – 3x ÷ 2
20 – (3 × 6) ÷ 2
20 – 18 ÷2
20 – 9
11
33
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio:Mathematical Inventory
10. 3n –4
11. Answer: 160
2n2 x 5
2 × 42 × 5
2 × 16 × 5
32 × 5
160
12. Answer: 36 square feet
w = 3 and l = 4 × 3(width)
l = 12 feet
A = lw
A = 12 × 3
A = 36 square feet
13. Answer: 22 units
Width = 5, length = 6 5 + 5 + 6 + 6 = 22
14. Answer: 96 cubic inches
L = 6
W = 4
H = 4
V = lwh
V = 6 × 4 × 4
V = 96 cubic inches
15. Answer: 27 inches.
The diameter is twice the size of the radius, therefore you need to double the radius
34
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio:Mathematical Inventory
16. Answer: 14 quarts
1 gallon = 4 quarts
3½ × 4
7/2 × 4/1 (Students may do cancelling)
28/2
14 quarts
17. Answer: 2050 milliliters 1 liter = 1000 milliliters
3× 1000 = 3000 milliliters 3000 – 950 = 2050 milliliters
18. Answer: 7 17 19. Answer: 30
28 + 36 + 26 + 38 + 22 = 150 150 ÷ 5 = 30
20. Answer: 25
95 – 70 = 25
Students may explain that they subtracted the lowest number from the highest number.
35
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio: Standard Math Problems
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio: Standard Math Problems
Directions
Students should independently complete the standard math problems that appear in the “Standard
Math Problems: Student Sheet” in the Blackline Masters. Students are not required to use traditional
algorithms, but rather, are encouraged to use the strategies with which they are most comfortable. The
standard math problems and the answer key are listed in this manual for teachers’ reference. After
students complete the standard math problems, teachers should use the “Standard Math Problems
Scoring Sheet,” found in the Blackline Masters, to record which questions the student answered
correctly and then record the final performance level on the student’s “Promotion Portfolio Summary
Sheet.”
Scoring Guide
To demonstrate performance comparable to Level 2, students must answer 4 out of 5 standard math
problems correctly. Use the answer key to determine if students should receive credit for their answer.
The table below outlines the student performance levels for this component of the Mathematics
promotion portfolio:
Number of Questions Correct Mathematical Inventory Performance Level
5 Exceeds benchmark
4 Meets benchmark
3 or fewer Does not meet benchmark
Assessment – Standard Math Problems
1. Anna is going grocery shopping and has $150 to spend. At the store, Anna spends 30% of her money
on dairy products and vegetables.
Part A: How much money did she spend? Show your work.
Answer: $_________________
Part B: If Anna spends $60 dollars out of the $150 dollars for meats and poultry, what percent
of her money does this represent? Show your work.
Answer: __________________%
Blackline
Masters
p. 24‐27
Blackline
Masters
p. 7
36
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio: Standard Math Problems
2. Find the value of the following expression when a = 5. Show your work.
42 + 6a
Answer: _______________
3. Mr. Smith wants to tile his kitchen floor. How many square feet of tile will he need if his room
measurements are as shown in the illustration below.
14 ft.
Formulas: A = lw
P = 2l + 2w 12 ft.
Answer: ____________________ square feet 4. Mike has a bag that contains 80 marbles. Half of the marbles are blue and the other half of the
marbles consist of the following colors: 10 green, 20 red and 10 yellow.
Part A. If Mike randomly takes a marble out of the bag, what is the probability that the marble will be red?
Answer: ___________
Part B. If Mike randomly takes a marble out of the bag, what is the probability that the marble will be blue or yellow?
Answer: ____________
Explain your answer.
37
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio: Standard Math Problems
5. John puts his baseball cards in a box like the one shown below.
3 in.
4i44in4i44 4 in.
12 in. (not drawn to scale)
Part A: What is the volume of the box? Use the formula V = lwh. Show your work. Answer: __________________cubic inches
Part B. If the width of the box is doubled, what will be the volume of the new box? Answer: ___________________cubic inches
Explain how you found your answer.
38
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio: Standard Math Problems
Answer Key – Standard Math Problems
Question 1: Students must answer both part A and part B correctly. Work must be shown in both parts.
Part A: Answer: $45 or $45.00
30% = .3 or .30 or 1/3
.30 ×150 = 45.00
1/3 × 150/1 = 45/1
= $45
Part B: Answer: 40%
60/150 = 2/5
2/5 = 40%
Students can show this by division or by multiplying by 100/1
Question 2: Students must answer the question correctly. Work must be shown.
Substitute the value of a = 5 into the expression: 42 + 6a 42 + 6 × 5 16 + 6 × 5 16 + 30 46 Answer: 46
Question 3: Students must be able to answer the question correctly and be able to explain how they
solved the problem.
Answer: 168 square feet Accept reasonable explanations from the student stating that the length is 14 feet and that the width is 12 feet and that they knew to use the Area formula to multiply the two numbers.
Question 4: Students must answer both part A and part B correctly. Students must be able to explain
how they got their answer for Part B.
Part A: Answer: 20/80 or 2/8 or ¼ Part B: Answer: 50/80 or 5/8
Sample responses may include but are not limited to: “I added together the 40 blue marbles
and 10 yellow marbles to get 50 and placed that number over the total of 80 marbles.”
39
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio: Standard Math Problems
Question 5: Students must answer both part A and part B correctly. Work must be shown in Part A and
an explanation must be given for the answer for Part B.
Part A: Answer: 144 cubic inches V = lwh V = 12 × 3 × 4 V = 144 cubic inches
Part B: Answer: 288 cubic inches
Sample responses may include but are not limited to: “I doubled the width 3 inches to 6
inches and then used the formula for volume to multiply the three numbers.”
40
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio: Class Work
Mathematics Promotion Portfolio: Mathematics Class Work
Directions
Please include one piece of student work produced in the mathematics classroom and given a score by
the teacher. This work sample should be aligned with an appropriate grade level task or problem within
one of the appropriate strands for the grade.
Components: The work must include four elements to be considered when evaluating a student for
promotion:
1. The assigned task
2. Evidence of the process used to produce answer (drawing, writing, explanation, computations,
diagrams or a combination of such evidence)
3. The correct answer
4. Tool (rubric, checklist, etc.) used to score this piece of mathematical work or teacher evaluation
based on specific criteria
All four of these mathematics class work elements must be included in promotion portfolios submitted to
the principal and community superintendent.
The student’s mathematical thinking and problem solving abilities should be clearly evidenced in the
piece of work that is chosen.
Workbook pages, ditto sheets, etc. and other pieces of class work that do not require the
student to show mathematical thinking and/or problem solving abilities should not be
submitted as a piece of student work.
Based on the scoring guide below, teachers should record the performance level on the student’s
“Promotion Portfolio Summary Sheet.”
Scoring Guide
To demonstrate performance comparable to Level 2, students must achieve a Medium on the
mathematics class work submitted for their promotion portfolio. The table below outlines the student
performance levels for this component of the mathematics promotion portfolio:
School Rubric Score Class Work Performance Level
(for promotion portfolio)
Exceeds school’s Level 2 standard* High/Exceeds benchmark
Meets school’s Level 2 standard* Medium/Meets benchmark
Below school’s Level 2 standard* Class work that does not meet school’s Level 2
standard should not be submitted as evidence for
the promotion portfolio.
*School’s Level 2 standard is evidenced by the scoring tool submitted along with the mathematics class
work.
41
Examples of High Level 2 Designations
Examples of High Level 2 Designations
For High Level 2 Designation in ELA
To perform comparable to a High Level 2 in ELA, a student must:
at least meet benchmarks on the Leveled Text and Independent Writing components
AND
exceed benchmarks on the Standard Reading Passage and ELA Class Work components
For High Level 2 Designation in Mathematics
To perform comparable to High Level 2 in mathematics, a student must:
at least meet benchmarks on the Mathematical Inventory and the Standard Math Problems
components and exceed the benchmark on at least one of these two components
AND
exceed benchmark on the Mathematics Class Work component
Sample High Level 2 Performance – ELA Promotion Portfolio
Component/Results Performance Level
Leveled text: 90% accuracy on Level T book Meets benchmark
Standard Reading Passage: Received one Medium and two Highs on fiction
passage questions and two Mediums and one High for the non‐fiction
passage questions.
Exceeds benchmark
Independent Writing Activity: Medium AND showed evidence of the writing
process
Meets benchmark
Class Work: Demonstrates Level 3 on school’s scoring system (high) Exceeds benchmark
This student met the benchmarks on all selected ELA components and exceeded the benchmarks
for the Standard Reading Passage and ELA Class Work.
Sample High Level 2 Performance – Mathematics Promotion Portfolio
Component/Results Performance Level
Mathematical Inventory: Mastered 17 out of 20 skills Exceeds benchmark
Standard Math Problems: Answered 4 out of 5 problems correctly Meets benchmark
Class Work: Demonstrates Level 3 on school’s scoring system (high) Exceeds benchmark
This student at least met the benchmarks for all math components and exceeded the benchmarks
for the Mathematical Inventory and Math Class Work.
42
August Update: Grade 6 Promotion Review Summary Sheet
August Update: Grade 6 Promotion Review Summary Sheet
Overview
Summer school teachers should include an update about each student’s performance in summer school
using the “August Update: Grade 6 Promotion Review Summary Sheet.” This sheet is found on the last
page of this manual and should be duplicated for each summer school student who was administered a
promotion portfolio in June.
The “August Update” sheet should include observations about the student’s performance in:
ELA: reading accuracy, reading comprehension, and independent writing for ELA
Mathematics: grade‐level, standards‐based performance in mathematics strands. (While the
Mathematics portfolio provides specific problems to assess skills in these mathematics strands,
teachers may use evidence from the classroom to assess students’ performance in these strands
for the August update.)
Teachers should also include only one piece of evidence per portfolio component or mathematics strand
outlined above (up to three pieces of evidence for ELA and five for math) to demonstrate student
performance comparable to Level 2. This evidence should be student work (as outlined in the Class
Work components of the promotion portfolio) or assessments; ditto sheets and work books should not
be submitted. Please see the next page for a sample completed “August Update” sheet.
43
August Update: Grade 6 Promotion Review Summary Sheet
Sample “August Update” Sheet
August Update: Grade 6 Promotion Review Summary Sheet
44
Student Name: Student ID:
Borough: District: School: Summer Teacher: Principal:
Subject(s) to be assessed: ELA Math Date: __________________
Promotion Portfolio Scores: August Update
ELA Promotion Portfolio
Score: August
Student is performing comparable to Level 2 in ELA.
Student is performing comparable to Level 1 in ELA.
Mathematics Promotion
Portfolio Score: August
Student is performing comparable to Level 2 in mathematics.
Student is performing comparable to Level 1 in mathematics.
Principal: __________________________________________ Date: _______
Community superintendent: Date:
Types of Evidence Is student performance
comparable to Level 2?
Comments (Description of evidence submitted,
notes about performance, etc.)
ELA Summer Class W
ork
Reading Accuracy
Yes – Level 2 No – below Level 2
Reading Comprehension Yes – Level 2 No – below Level 2
Independent Writing Yes – Level 2 No – below Level 2
Math Summer Class W
ork
Number sense &
operations
Yes – Level 2 No – below Level 2
Algebra
Yes – Level 2 No – below Level 2
Geometry
Yes – Level 2 No – below Level 2
Measurement
Yes – Level 2 No – below Level 2
Statistics and Probability
Yes – Level 2 No – below Level 2