Good Morning!!! 1.NVC 2.HOT ROC: Reviewing Critical Thinking 3.The Trial of Sacco and Vanzetti Essential Question: Should Sacco and Vanzetti receive clemency?

Good Morning!!!

1. NVC

2. HOT ROC: Reviewing Critical Thinking

3. The Trial of Sacco and Vanzetti

Essential Question: Should Sacco and Vanzetti receive clemency?

Homework: Research and Prepare for Trial on Friday

Equal Opportunity Schools Survey

• https://eos.co1.qualtrics.com/SE/?SID=SV_8GQyAIVtGatCfeB

HOT ROC: Critical Thinking

• Use the Critical Thinking Rubric to evaluate the three responses from the Sedition Act activity question “Is Schenck patriotic or anti-American? Explain.”– “He is anti-American b/c of all the things he says America is doing

wrong.”– “Schenck is very much patriotic. He opposes the sending of

America’s young men overseas because he cares for their rights and, ultimately, security. He is looking out for the American people, hoping to re-instill the Constitutional ideals which have seemingly been lost throughout this angry process of war.”

– “I think he is in the grey area. He loves his country and doesn’t want it to suffer yet he wants to harm it by spreading these pamphlets.”

Sacco & Vanzetti Trial

Overview

• At 3:00 P.M. on April 15,1920, a paymaster and his guard were carrying a factory payroll of $15,776 through the main street of South Braintree, Massachusetts, a small industrial town south of Boston.

• Two men standing by a fence suddenly pulled out guns and fired on them. The gunmen snatched up the cash boxes dropped by the mortally wounded pair and jumped into a waiting automobile. The bandit gang, numbering four or five in all, sped away, eluding their pursuers.

• At first this brutal murder and robbery, not uncommon in post-World War I America, aroused only local interest.

Background

Background

• Three weeks later, on the evening of May 5, 1920, two Italians, Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti, fell into a police trap that had been set for a suspect in the Braintree crime.

• Although originally not under suspicion, both men were carrying guns at the time of their arrest and when questioned by the authorities they lied. As a result they were held and eventually indicted for the South Braintree crimes.

• Vanzetti was also charged with an earlier holdup attempt that had taken place on December 24, 1919, in the nearby town of Bridgewater.

• After a hard-fought trial of six weeks, during which the themes of patriotism and radicalism were often sharply contrasted by the prosecution and the defense, the jury found Sacco and Vanzetti guilty of robbery and murder on July 14,1921.

• This verdict marked, however, only the beginning of a lengthy legal struggle to save the two men. It extended until 1927, during which time the defense made many separate motions, appeals, and petitions to both state and federal courts in an attempt to gain a new trial.

Background

• Overview:– The governor of Massachusetts has summoned you to testify in

a clemency hearing for two convicted death row murderers. Governors convene these hearings when they are considering granting clemency, a pardon or lessening of a penalty.

• Objective:– Should Sacco and Vanzetti receive clemency?

• Directions:– Each student will be assigned to a pair/group to play a role. You

are to prepare for the trial according to the instructions provided. Remember you want to be able to both defend your position and attack and undermine those who oppose you using evidence from the book and any other sources you would like.

Clemency Hearing

• Each group will have someone present a brief (1 minute) opening statement that explains who you are and you will share how you feel regarding the clemency of Sacco and Vanzetti.

• When everyone has spoken there will be time for a brief debate of ideas and for the Lowell Committee to ask questions to each of the groups.– If time allows, groups may also question each other.

• The jury may also ask questions of Sacco and Vanzetti. – If time allows, groups may also question Sacco and Vanzetti

• Sacco and Vanzetti will give their closing statements at the end.• After the presentation of statements and questions, the Lowell Committee

will deliberate a verdict. The deliberations will be open and take place in front of the class, as a fish bowl. Each member of the Committee is required to present an argument during deliberations. Then a vote will be taken and a verdict reached.

• After the verdict has been reached, Governor Fuller will choose to either support the Lowell Committee’s decision or overrule it and make his own decision.

Clemency Hearing

Roles & OverviewRoles 1st Period

Sacco (Desk 12) Tessa

Vanzetti (Desk 17) MichaelGovernor Fuller (Desk 4) Anthony

Lowell Committee (Desk 9, 14, 14, 19)

Alex Malo, Daniel, Rocio, Hannah Robinson, Allen

American Civil Liberties Union (Desk 1, 2,5,3,6)

Katy, Kshitiz, Hiba, Makayla, Jamin

Nativists (Desk 27, 30,33)

Alex Penfold, Bella, Ally, Rushil

Industrial Workers of the World (Desk 28, 31, 34)

Lara, Hannah Athey, Matt, Amanda

Plymouth Cordage Company (Desk 10, 15, 20, 25)

Jennifer, Tiffany, Angel, Emily

East Boston Anarchists Organization (Desk 29, 32, 35)

Will, Michelle, Jamaila, Edi, Baylee

Officials in the Palmer Raids (Desk 11, 16, 26, 21)

Yimei, Hanna Yoshida, Jimmy, Alejandro

• Use the information packet to prepare for the clemency hearing.– Tasks:

• Read 26.1 (pg. 331) and then ONLY the first paragraph of 26.2-26.5 (pg. 332-338)

• Read about your group• Answer questions for your

group• Prepare statements for the

hearing– Friday

• Clemency Hearing• Starts at the beginning of

class, no work time.

Roles & OverviewRoles 3rd Period

Sacco (Desk 12) Roshan

Vanzetti (Desk 17) JoeyGovernor Fuller (Desk 4) Kelly

Lowell Committee (Desk 9, 14, 14, 19)

Dylan, Jackie, Evan, Alyssa, Marie

American Civil Liberties Union (Desk 1, 2,5,3,6)

Charlotte, Elena, Lizeth, Ryan

Nativists (Desk 27, 30,33)

Meghan, Lucas, Jonathan, Janet

Industrial Workers of the World (Desk 28, 31, 34)

Kyla, Casey, Brandon, Angelica

Plymouth Cordage Company (Desk 10, 15, 20, 25)

Lizzy, Andrew, Cindy, Camila

East Boston Anarchists Organization (Desk 29, 32, 35)

Kevin, Juan, Ricardo, Hansol

Officials in the Palmer Raids (Desk 11, 16, 26, 21)

Anne, Molly, Kaylan, Punu

• Use the information packet to prepare for the clemency hearing.– Tasks:

• Read 26.1 (pg. 331) and then ONLY the first paragraph of 26.2-26.5 (pg. 332-338)

• Read about your group• Answer questions for your

group• Prepare statements for the

hearing– Friday

• Clemency Hearing• Starts at the beginning of

class, no work time.

Roles & OverviewRoles 2nd Period

Sacco (Desk 12) Tara

Vanzetti (Desk 17) KimikoGovernor Fuller (Desk 4) Erik

Lowell Committee (Desk 9, 14, 14, 19)

Jeanette, Carly, Sasha, Andres, Wendy

American Civil Liberties Union (Desk 2,5,3,6)

Marisa, Michelle, Jennifer Palacios, Suleyma

Nativists (Desk 27, 30,33) Jose, Jorge, JoselynIndustrial Workers of the World (Desk 28, 31, 34)

Nick, Jennifer Geranen, Jeffrey

Plymouth Cordage Company (Desk 10, 15, 20, 25)

Aria, Bronte, Breanna, Jonathan

East Boston Anarchists Organization (Desk 29, 32, 35) Sarah, Oswaldo, CarolinaOfficials in the Palmer Raids (Desk 11, 16, 26, 21)

Erin, Lucas, Jeremiah, Melissa

• Use the information packet to prepare for the clemency hearing.– Tasks:

• Read 26.1 (pg. 331) and then ONLY the first paragraph of 26.2-26.5 (pg. 332-338)

• Read about your group• Answer questions for your

group• Prepare statements for the

hearing– Friday

• Clemency Hearing• Starts at the beginning of

class, no work time.